A Hiding to Nothing AN ANIMAL AID INVESTIGATION March 2004

Use of the Whip Data Tables Researched & Compiled By Dene Stansall Report Scope, Terms and Criteria

This examination into the Use of the Whip in British was undertaken during October and November 2003.

Data was collected from 161 races run on 20 racecourses.

Three British horse racing disciplines were covered: All Weather Racing - AW Flat Racing - Flat National Hunt Racing - NH

The National Hunt discipline included: Hurdling, Chasing and NH Flat racing.

The 20 racecourses were selected to give a balanced representation of the varied conditions encountered by horse and rider: i.e. Left Handed L-H course; Right Handed R-H course; Figure 8 course; undulating surface; sharp/tight track; a galloping surface.

AW Lingfield • AW Southwell • AW Wolverhampton • Flat Ayr • Flat Brighton • Flat Catterick • Flat Newmarket • Flat Redcar • Flat Windsor • Flat Yarmouth • NH Lingfield • NH Haydock • NH Huntingdon • NH Ludlow • NH Market Rasen • NH Newton Abbot • NH Plumpton • NH Uttoxeter • NH Warwick • NH Wetherby

The Ground Conditions at the racecourses included: Firm; Good to Firm; Good; Good to Soft; Standard Fibresand; Standard Polytrack (although the artificial surfaces varied in their give and holding).

Races studied included all Classes: A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H. And they included: Sellers; Claimers; Conditional / Apprentice Jockeys; Amateur Jockeys; Maidens; Nurseries; Handicaps; Novice; Classified Stakes; Listed; Groups 3, 2 and 1.

Race distances (approximate) miles and furlongs - m f - included: AW: 5f; 6f; 7f; 1m; 1m 2f; 1m 4f; 1m 7f. Flat: 5f; 6f; 7f; 1m; 1m 1f; 1m 2f; 1m 3f; 1m 4f; 1m 6f; 2m. NH Hurdles: 2m; 2m 1f; 2m 2f; 2m 4f, 2m 5f; 2m 6f; 2m 7f; 3m; 3m 1f; 3m 2f. NH Brush Hurdles: 2m. NH Chases: 2m; 2m 1f; 2m 2f; 2m 4f; 2m 6f; 3m; 3m 1f; 3m 2f. NH Flat: 2m; 2m 1f; 2m 2f. NH AW Flat: 2m.

The 161 races covered featured 2 to 19 runners.

Horses' age range in years covered: 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14.

A total of 285 jockeys were studied. AW: 120 Flat: 116 NH: 135 86 riders were included in both AW and Flat.

1,500 horses and thus rides were examined.

Races were split into three sectors for the study: Start (s), Middle (m) and Finish (f). Examples: 6f race = start 0 to 2f; middle 2f to 4f; finish 4f (2 out) to winning post 6f. 2m Chase 13 fences = start: 0 to 3rd fence +; middle: 4th fence to 11th fence; finish: 3 fences out to the line. Individual race data was proportioned to the three sectors and viewed as a whole, and also as part of an overall compilation. Use of the Whip Data

Key to Layout and Abbreviations used in the Use of the Whip tables.

Layout

Date Racecourse •Race Time •Class of Race •Race Conditions •Distance Ran •Discipline •Going •No. of Runners

Horse •Jockey •Trainer •Finishing Position in Race •When Whipped •Number of Times Whipped •If Shown Whip •Sectional Totals of When Whipped •Whipping Totals •Shown Whip Totals

Researchers' Comments upon viewing the race

Abbreviations

Race Conditions: Con. = Conditional Jockeys; Ap. = Apprentice Jockeys; Am. = Amateur Riders; Hand. = Handicap; Maid. = Maiden; Nov. = Novice; Juv. = Juvenile; Nur. = Nursery; F & M = Fillies & Mares; Sell. = Selling; Claim. = Claiming; Au. = Auction; St/Stk = Stakes; List. = Listed; Grp/G = Group

Race Distance: m = mile; f = furlong; i.e. 1 mile 4 furlongs/1m 4f

Finish Ps: Finishing Position of the horse in the race as in the official form record

When Wh: The stage of the race where the horse was whipped: s = start of the race; m = middle of the race; f = finish of the race

NB not to be confused with race distance in miles and furlongs i.e. 1m 2f Further details on this can be found in the Scope, Terms and Criteria section.

No. Whips: Number of whip strikes to the horse that were counted At the base of the No. Whips column, three figures are given The first is for the number of horses whipped, the second for number of times they were all whipped, the third for the number of runners in the race, i.e. 10//29//13 ten horses were whipped, 29 times, from 13 runners.

Sho/Whip: If the horse was shown the whip during the race, the data is displayed as: sw. If the horse was not shown the whip a blank space is left. Shown the whip is also interpreted as a tap down the shoulder/neck hands on the reins. It is to be noted that, although a horse is shown the whip, the horse may not have necessarily been shown the whip before being hit for the first time.

At the base of the Sho/Whip column a total is given for the number of horses shown the whip to the number of runners in the race, i.e. 9//13 nine horses shown the whip from thirteen runners. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Lingfield 2.45pm Class E 3y+ Hand. 1m AW Stan.Poly 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. Whips Sho/Whip

Mallard M Fenton JG Given 1 f 8 sw JR Stevenson SW Kelly Wigham 2 f 3 sw Free Option Dane O'Neill B Hanbury 3 f 3 sw Gryngolette E Ahern G Butler 4 f 4 sw Stateroom Lisa Jones (3) JAR Toller 5 0 Labrett S Drowne Kelleway 6 f 3 sw Indian Welcome JF Egan Morrison 7 mf 7 sw Scottish River G Hannon M Usher 8 mf 6 sw College Delinquent C Catlin K Bell 9 0 Bathwick Bruce G Baker B Millman 10 mf 5 sw Star Of Normandie A McCarthy Margarson 11 m 2 sw One Last Time R Hughes R Hannon 12 mf 5 sw

5m 9f 10//46//12 10//12

Comments: McCarthy dropped hit whip in the process of hitting Star Of Normandie, he continued to hit the horse with his hand. Labrett was hit in the face with a whip by another jockey, which stopped his run through this probably lost Labrett - the favourite - the race. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Lingfield 3.20pm Class F 3y+Claim. 7f AW Stan.Poly 15 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. Whips Sho/Whip

Majhool RL Moore GL Moore 1 f 10 sw Point Of Dispute S Sanders PJ Makin 2 f 2 sw Dixie Dancing S Whitworth CA Cyzer 3 f 6 sw Compton Banker E Ahern G Butler 4 f 4 sw Hawk Dane O'Neill Chamings 5 f 4 sw Legal Set Darren Williams KR Burke 6 f 3 sw Yorker FP Ferris (3) J Eustace 7 f 4 sw Dancing Forest I Mongan DK Ivory 8 f 3 sw Zarzu N Callan KR Burke 9 f 2 sw Genial Genie D Sweeney R Hollinsh. 10 f 2 sw Chateau Nicol R Hughes B Powell 11 0 sw Forzacurity A Daly J Spearing 12 0 Travel Tardia D Nolan (5) IA Wood 13 0 Janes Valentine JP Spencer JR Boyle 14 m 4 sw Top Son C Catlin AP Jones 15 0

1m 10f 11//44//15 12//15 Wednesday 15th October 2003 Lingfield 3.55pm Class D 2yStakes 6f AW Stan.Poly 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. Whips Sho/Whip

Doohulla E Ahern G Butler 1 f 5 sw Khabfair Dane O'Neill A Perrett 2 f 3 sw Petardias Magic J Carroll EJ O'Neill 3 f 4 sw Oro Verde R Hughes R Hannon 4 f 5 sw Kafuwain JP Spencer J Noseda 5 f 5 sw Trotters Bottom S Sanders A Reid 6 0 sw Princess Kai FP Ferris (3) R Ingram 7 f 1 sw

6f 6//23//7 7//7

Comments: Hughes hit his horse down the neck. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Lingfield 5.05pm Class E 3y Hand. 1m 2f AW Stan.Poly 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. Whips Sho/Whip

Golano R Mullen CF Wall 1 f 7 sw Remembrance J Tate Eustace 2 f 9 sw Nuzzle Martin Dwyer M Quinn 3 f 6 sw Captain Darling A Quinn (5) R Cowell 4 f 4 sw Carrowdore R Hughes R Hannon 5 f 8 sw Vanbrugh Lisa Jones (3) D McHale 6 f 5 sw Madamoiselle Jones Dane O'Neill HS Howe 7 mf 2 sw Gunnhildr S Sanders PJ Makin 8 f 1 sw Toro Bravo S Drowne R Beckett 9 mf 7 sw Phred S Carson John.Houg 10 m 1 sw Red Hot Polka RL Moore P Mitchell 11 0 Duescals L Dettori J Gosden 12 m 1 sw

4m 9f 11//51//12 11//12

Comments: Hughes hit his horse down the neck hand off the reins. Tate constantly hit Remembrance and the horse hung badly away from the whip, this must have lost him the race as he was only beaten by a head. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Lingfield 5.35pm Class D 2y Maiden 1m AW Stan.Poly 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. Whips Sho/Whip

Cimyla R Mullen CF Wall 1 f 2 sw Cutting View N Callan PW Harris 2 f 3 sw Master Theo TE Durcan Collingrid. 3 f 6 sw Waziri M Fenton Morrison 4 f 4 sw Turn 'N Burn S Whitworth CA Cyzer 5 f 2 sw Rendoro R Hughes R Hannon 6 f 1 sw Turner L Dettori J Gosden 7 0 Worcester Lodge S Drowne R Charlton 8 f 1 sw Borodin E Ahern G Butler 9 0 sw House Of Blues JP Spencer J Osborne 10 m 5 sw Mix It Up M Tebbutt R Beckett 11 0 sw Bakhtyar S Sanders R Charlton 12 m 3 sw

2m 7f 9//27//12 11//12

Comments: Sanders, Spencer and Durcan all hit their horses down the neck. Two of the horses where having their first race. Thursday 16th October 2003 Southwell 1.20pm Class D 2yMaiden 6f AW Stan.Fibre 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.No. Whipswhips Sho/Whip

Foxies Future D Allan (3) J Weymes 1 f 11 sw Contagious A Culhane W Haggas 2 f 6 sw Bookiesindexdotcom SW Kelly J Jenkins 3 smf 9 sw Pure Folly G Duffield Prescott 4 0 sw Sir Jasper D Mernagh TD Barron 5 smf 8 sw El Magnifico S Carson P Cundell 6 0 Lupine Howl G Gibbons McMahon 7 mf 4 sw Lord Arthur T Lucas M Easterb. 8 0 Desert Light F Norton D Shaw 9 0 sw Mr Moon B Doyle Hammond 10 0

2s 3m 4f 5//38//10 7//10

Comments: Kelly and Mernagh were hitting their two year olds at all stages of the race. Sir Jasper having his first race will remember the poor experience. Bookiesindexdotcom's experience should not have been an excuse to hit her. Gibbons hit his horse down the neck. Allan struck his filly eleven times in the straight. Thursday 16th October 2003 Southwell 1.55pm Class D 2yMaiden 6f AW Stan.Fibre 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.No. Whipswhips Sho/Whip

Vilamoura A Culhane W Haggas 1 f 11 sw College Time D Nolan (5) P Blockley 2 f 12 sw Lizhar L Fletcher (3) Polglase 3 f 7 sw Sharplaw F Norton W Haggas 4 f 3 Iffy S Carson P Cundell 5 0 Sparling Clear B Doyle R Cowell 6 f 3 sw Quincannon D Mernagh TD Barron 7 f 2 sw Penthesilea G Duffield Prescott 8 0 Sam The Sorcerer J Bramhill JR Norton 9 f 3 sw Jesse Samuel SW Kelly J Jenkins 10 mf 4 sw

1m 8f 8//45//10 7//10

Comments: 30 strikes of the whip on the first three is too much for such young horses. These came from Culhane, Nolan and Fletcher. Nolan also hit his horse down the neck twice, hand off the reins, Fletcher hit his once hand off, Norton three times and Bramhill once. Thursday 16th October 2003 Southwell 2.25pm Class F 3y+Stakes1m AW Stan.Fibre 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.No. Whipswhips Sho/Whip

Shotacross The Bow F Norton Blanshard 1 mf 15 sw Merdiff G Baker Brisbourne 2 f 10 sw Danny Leahy M Fenton JG Given 3 mf 13 sw Pharoah's Gold T Hamilton (5) D Shaw 4 f 5 sw Sky Dome B Doyle Tompkins 5 f 7 sw Emperor's Well P Mulrennan (5) M Easterb. 6 m 3 sw Yorkshire Blue G Duffield Whitaker 7 mf 13 sw Mister Mal D Swift (7) R Fahey 8 mf 3 sw Queensberry D Allan (3) J O'Reilly 9 0 Yalla A Culhane W Haggas 10 m 4 sw Zhitomir SW Kelly M Dods 11 0 Nite-Owl Fizz JD O'Reilly (7) J O'Reilly 12 m 2 sw Original Sin R Miles (5) Fanshawe 13 m 2 sw Legality M Tebbutt P Mitchell 14 0 Castaigne J Mackay BW Duke 15 mf 5 Bontadini D McGaffin (3) D Morris 16 m 2 sw

10m 8f 13//84//16 12//16

Comments: 38 strikes on the first three is far too much. Mackay hit his horse down the neck, hand off the reins and without showing the horse the whip first. Duffield, Norton and Hamilton all hit their horses down the neck, hand off the reins. Thursday 16th October 2003 Southwell 3.00pm Class D 3y+ Hand. 7f AW Stan.Fibre 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.No. Whipswhips Sho/Whip

Flowerdrum A Culhane W Haggas 1 0 Etoile Solitaire M Henry MA Jarvis 2 f 7 sw St Petersburg G Duffield Tompkins 3 f 7 sw Jacaranda SW Kelly B Meehan 4 mf 5 sw Strong Hand P Mulrennan (5) M Easterb 5 0 Majestic Times P Doe T Easterb. 6 f 4 sw Blonde En Blonde G Gibbons Littmoden 7 f 4 sw Barzak J Bramhill S Bowring 8 f 1 sw Prince Of Gold Steph. Hollinshead(7)R Hollinsh. 9 f 5 sw Elidore D Kinsella (3) B Palling 10 m 1 sw Young Mr Grace D Allan (3) T Easterb. 11 m 1 sw Silver Chime J Tate J Eustace 12 mf 4 sw Hov S Hitchcott (3) JJ Quinn 13 0 sw Effective R Miles (5) AP Jarvis 14 m 3 sw Lakelands Lady P Makin (7) S Bowring 15 m 1 sw Aventura L Fletcher (3) Polglase 16 0

6m 8f 12//43//16 13//16

Comments: Duffield hit his horse down the neck, hand off the reins. Culhane never resorted to the whip to win this competitive race. Thursday 16th October 2003 Southwell 3.35pm Class F 3y+Hand. 5f AW Stan.Fibre 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.No. Whipswhips Sho/Whip

Count Cougar Laura-Jayne Crawford(7)TD Barron 1 0 sw Laurel Dawn F Norton A Berry 2 f 9 sw Soaked A Culhane D Chapm. 3 0 Empress Josephine SW Kelly J Jenkins 4 f 7 sw Teyaar P McCabe Macauley 5 mf 21 sw Geronimo S Righton Kelleway 6 f 2 sw Mr Spliffy L Enstone (3) KR Burke 7 f 4 sw Mount Hillaby T Lucas M Easterb 8 m 2 sw Patientes Virtis D Kinsella (3) Kelleway 9 f 6 sw Heathyardsblessing G Duffield R Hollinsh. 10 f 1 sw Mister Benji M Fenton B Baugh 11 f 5 sw Henry Tun J Edmunds J Balding 12 mf 4 sw Brioso FP Ferris (3) Eustace 13 mf 4 sw Somethingabouther B Doyle DK Ivory 14 f 1 sw Stand By R Miles (5) McCarthy 15 f 4 sw Mikasa L Fletcher (3) RF Fisher 16 0

4m 12f 13//70//16 14//16

Comments: Kelly had a high arm action in his whipping, whilst Edmunds, Norton and McCabe all hit their horses down the neck. However, what stands out in this race is the whipping of Teyaar by McCabe. His 21 strikes in this five furlong race is totally unacceptable and should have seen action from the stewards. The winner was not whipped and claimer Laura-Jayne Crawford takes the credit. Thursday 16th October 2003 Southwell 4.10pm Class G 2y Selling 1m AW Stan.Fibre 14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.No. Whipswhips Sho/Whip

Countrywide Flyer J Carroll A Berry 1 f 5 sw Maybe Someday N Chalmers (5) HJ Cyzer 2 mf 8 sw Doctored M Tebbutt B Meehan 3 mf 18 sw Absolute Pleasure L Fletcher (3) G Bravery 4 mf 7 sw Lady Predominant S Hitchcott (3) Channon 5 mf 5 sw Mind Play FP Ferris (3) JG Given 6 mf 2 sw Zarneeta G Duffield IA Wood 7 sm 4 sw Ace Maite P Makin (7) S Bowring 8 f 1 sw Peace Treaty J Bramhill S Bowring 9 0 sw Major Project Rory Moore (7) P Haslam 10 m 2 sw Cerezo P McCabe Keightley 11 m 7 sw Rowan Pursuit J Mackay Tompkins 12 m 1 sw Dash Of Ginger M Fenton JG Given 13 m 2 sw Back In Fashion A Nicholls J Mackie 14 0 sw

1s 10m 7f 12//62//14 14//14

Comments: The winner was clear when Carroll whipped him. McCabe and Tebbutt both hit their horses down the neck, with hand off the reins. 18 strikes from Tebbutt was excessive and should have been dealt with by the stewards. Thursday 16th October 2003 Southwell 4.45pm Class E 3y Hand. 6f AW Stan.Fibre 15 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.No. Whipswhips Sho/Whip

Queen Of Night D Mernagh TD Barron 1 f 13 sw B A Highflyer S Hitchcott (3) Channon 2 f 8 sw Mac's Talisman F Norton O'Gorman 3 f 13 sw Maddie's A Jem SW Kelly J Jenkins 4 f 11 sw Wainwright FP Ferris (3) P Blockley 5 f 6 sw Polish Emperor D Kinsella (3) PW Harris 6 f 5 sw St Ivian P McCabe Macauley 7 f 11 sw Park Star Dawn Watson (7) D Shaw 8 mf 4 sw Percy Douglas L Enstone (3) A Stokell 9 f 6 sw Brantwood G Gibbons McMahon 10 f 3 sw Foolish Thought D Swift (7) RA Fahey 11 0 sw Voluptuous A Culhane T Caldwell 12 0 Cayman Breeze J Carroll E Dunlop 13 f 1 sw Patandon Girl A Nicholls Channon 14 0 Great Game M Fenton B Rothwell 15 f 2 sw

1m 12f 12//83//15 13//15

Comments: Whipping from Mernagh, Norton, Kelly and McCabe added up to 48 strikes. Far too many on these three year olds. Norton hit down the neck with hand off the reins. Maddie's A Jem edged right when hit and Kelly did not stop hitting her. Monday 20th October 2003 Wolverhampton 2.25 Class F 3yAuMaid 6f AW Stan.Fibre 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Miss Poppets Dane O'Neill Elsworth 1 f 2 sw Wainwright FP Ferris (3) Blockley 2 f 4 sw Cloudless M Henry JW Unett 3 f 7 sw Largs J Edmunds J Balding 4 f 4 sw Estrella Levante RL Moore GL Moore 5 f 3 sw Distant Light C Catlin Saunders 6 f 1 sw Kallista's Pride SW Kelly Osbourne 7 0 Monte Mayor Lad A Clark Haydn Jo. 8 0 Precious Freedom P Fitzsimons J Balding 9 0 Calendar Girl D Sweeney PJ Makin 10 f 2 sw Blue Circle Kirsty Mullineaux (7) Mullineau. 11 m 4 sw Abellabrig P Bradley (5) A Berry 12 m 5 sw

2m 7f 9//32//12 9//12 Monday 20th October 2003 Wolverhampton 2.55 Class G 2y Selling 7f AW Stan.Fibre 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Maybe Someday N Chalmers (5) HJ Cyzer 1 f 4 sw City General LP Keniry (3) JS Moore 2 f 6 sw Timely Twist C Catlin S Kirk 3 f 2 sw Another Expletive A Daly J White 4 mf 6 sw Secret Bloom V Halliday JR Norton 5 mf 5 sw Kilcullen Lass N Callan PD Evans 6 m 2 sw Maybe A Lady Dean Williams (7) G Chung 7 mf 7 sw Ocean Dream SW Kelly Newcomb 8 f 1 sw Red Lancer P McCabe Keightley 9 f 5 sw Oh Frigate Dane O'Neill H Candy 10 f 3 sw Shanghai Surprise L Fletcher (3) IA Wood 11 mf 5 sw

5m 10f 11//46//11 11//11

Comments: All of these young horses were whipped during this race. Fletcher appeared to hit his horse down the neck and Chalmers when twelve lenghts clear struck his horse inside the final furlong which was on no account necessary. Monday 20th October 2003 Wolverhampton 3.25 Class F 3y+Stake 1m 4f AW Stan.Fibre 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Vin Du Pays N Callan Blanshard 1 smf 11 sw Queensberry JD O'Reilly J O'Reilly 2 mf 7 sw Pay The Silver D Sweeney IA Wood 3 mf 10 sw Itcanbedone Again C Catlin I Williams 4 f 1 sw Ersaal RL Moore J Jay 5 mf 9 sw Prince Prospect Kristin Stubbs (7) L Stubbs 6 f 5 sw Red Forest FP Ferris (3) J Mackie 7 m 1 sw Our Destiny J Bramhill D Burchell 8 0 Reno Dane O'Neill Thornton 9 m 1 sw Elheba R Miles (5) Wigham 10 m 2 sw Saxe-Coburg G Carter GA Ham 11 0 Ornellaia D Kinsella (3) P Phelan 12 m 1 sw

1s 8m 6f 10//48//12 10//12

Comments: Callan was whipping his horse from the start of the race to the end. O'Reilly was also noted for his unattractive whip use. Monday 20th October 2003 Wolverhampton 3.55 Class D 3y Hand. 7f AW Stan.Fibre 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Spark Up M Henry JW Unett 1 mf 10 sw Tourmalet R Miles (5) A Berry 2 f 5 sw Blonde En Blonde J Bramhill Littmoden 3 f 8 sw Cape St Vincent RL Moore Morrison 4 f 13 sw And Toto Too N Callan PD Evans 5 mf 7 sw Heidelburg P Fitzsimons S Kirk 6 f 2 sw Bi Polar Dane O'Neill Elsworth 7 mf 6 sw Mandarin Spirit R Mullen G Chung 8 f 3 sw Craic Sa Ceili C Catlin Saunders 9 m 1 sw Blakeshall Quest G Gibbons Brotherton 10 m 3 sw Livy R Smith S Kirk 11 0 Ymlaen D Kinsella (3) B Palling 12 f 2 sw

5m 9f 11//60//12 11//12

Comments: Henry struck his horse 8 times in the last two furlongs. Monday 20th October 2003 Wolverhampton 4.25 Class E 3y+ Hand. 1m 7f AW Stan.Fibre 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

High Policy Steph Hollinshead (7) Hollinshea 1 f 2 sw Ambersong S Whitworth A Carroll 2 f 10 sw Nightwatchman R Mullen WR Muir 3 f 11 sw Aleron LP Keniry (3) JJ Quinn 4 f 3 sw Charnwood Street JF McDonald (5) D Shaw 5 m 1 sw Smoothie D Sweeney I Williams 6 0 Golfagent J Bramhill K Marks 7 m 3 sw Galandora D Kinsella (5) J Naylor 8 m 2 sw Fortunate Dave C Catlin I Williams 9 0 Bolshoi Ballet N Callan J Mackie 10 m 3 sw Bluegrass Beau RL Moore B Powell 11 0 Donegal Shore N Chalmers (5) J Candlish 12 m 5 sw 5m 4f 9//40//12 9//12

Comments: Mullen hit his horse 11 times in the final two furlongs and Whitworth 10 times. Monday 20th October 2003 Wolverhampton 4.55 Class E 3y Hand. 1m 1.5f AW Stan.Fibre 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Ofaraby P Robinson MA Jarvis 1 f 8 sw Sheriff's Deputy J-P Guillambert (5) JW Unett 2 f 3 sw Miss Champers N Callan PD Evans 3 f 8 sw Goodbye Mr Bond D Sweeney EJ Alston 4 f 14 sw Zouche D Kinsella (3) Brisbourne 5 mf 8 sw Proud Victor JF McDonald (5) D Shaw 6 m 4 sw Blue Trojan Dane O'Neill S Kirk 7 m 3 sw Retail Therapy D Fox (5) M Buckley 8 mf 6 sw Mount Benger M Tebbutt R Beckett 9 m 4 sw Inch Island LP Keniry (3) JJ Quinn 10 mf 3 sw Magenta Rising J Bramhill D Burchell 11 0

6m 7f 10//61//11 10//11

Comments: The winning horse veered from the whip. Sweeney hit his horse 14 times in the final two furlongs including once down the neck. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Southwell 1.40pm Class E 3y+ Hand. 6f AW Stan.Fibre 15 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Mufreh S Whitworth Newcomb. 1 f 11 sw Jan Brueghel D Mernagh TD Barron 2 f 11 sw Super S Drowne PW Harris 3 mf 11 sw Branston Tiger M Fenton JG Given 4 f 7 sw Soba Jones J Edmunds J Balding 5 m 1 sw Jonny Ebeneezer A Quinn (5) R Cowell 6 f 3 sw If By Chance Dale Gibson R Craggs 7 f 4 sw Headland A Culhane D Chapm. 8 0 Bint Royal P Doe V Haigh 9 0 sw Danielle's Lad D Sweeney B Palling 10 f 1 sw Gone 'N' Dunnett Darren Williams C Dunnett 11 mf 6 sw Czar Wars L Fletcher (3) J Balding 12 m 1 Quiet Times P Hanagan KA Ryan 13 mf 5 sw Noble Locks J-P Guillambert (5) JW Unett 14 0 Certa Cito D Allen (3) T Easterb. 15 0

5m 9f 11//61//15 11//15

Comments: The first three in the race were hit a total of thirty-three times - almost all within the final two furlongs. Fletcher hit his horse down the neck. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Southwell 2.10pm Class F 2yAuMaid 6f AW Stan.Fibre 15 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Lizhar L Fletcher (3) Polglase 1 f 7 sw Bookiesindexdotcom SW Kelly J Jenkins 2 smf 9 sw Ever Cheerful A Quinn (5) W Turner 3 mf 4 sw Charlieismydarling J Fanning J Osborne 4 0 sw Sir Jasper D Mernagh T Barron 5 mf 8 sw Designer City F Norton A Berry 6 smf 6 sw Masafi J Mackay Prescott 7 0 Bajan Storm S Drowne Blanshard 8 m 5 sw Darcie Mia D Allan (3) J Weymes 9 m 3 sw Indian Rum P Mulrennan (5) M Easterb 10 0 Imperial Princess Paul Eddery Hay.Jones 11 smf 8 sw La Vigna S Yourston (7) Featherst. 12 mf 3 sw Miss Judgement R Mullen WR Muir 13 m 3 sw Dunnett Again Joanna Badger C Dunnett 14 m 4 sw Desert Light Darren Williams D Shaw 15 f 1 sw

3s 10m 8f 12//61//15 13//15

Comments: Mernagh was harsh on Sir Jasper, having only his second run, with eight strikes of the whip coming much too late. Kelly struck his horse nine times with whips throughout this six furlong race. Fletcher struck his horse seven times, including twice down the neck.

For a two year old race a high number of whips were given. What is more, they came out very early on in the race and continued throughout. This will not help any horse's confidence for future races. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Southwell 2.40pm Class F 2yAuMaid 6f AW Stan.Fibre 13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Alinda M Fenton PW Harris 1 f 3 sw Pick Of The Crop SW Kelly J Jenkins 2 f 9 sw Bond Brooklyn R Ffrench B Smart 3 f 6 sw Atlantic Breeze L Enstone (3) Macauley 4 mf 7 sw Considine J Tate J Eustace 5 m 1 sw Cherokee Nation Paul Eddery P d'Arcy 6 0 sw Miss Porcia D Allan (3) M Quinlan 7 m 3 sw Sky Cove Dale Gibson M Easterb 8 0 Bishop To Actress L Fletcher (3) Polglase 9 mf 3 sw Jinksonthehouse Joanna Badger MDI Usher 10 f 6 sw Jocks Boy Dean McKeown PR Wood 11 f 1 sw Romeo Tias F Norton A Berry 12 m 2 Lezara J Bramhill M Buckley 13 0 sw

5m 7f 10//41//13 11//13

Comments: Ffrench hit his horse down the neck, with hands off the reins. Enstone and Norton also hit their horses down the neck. Kelly hit his horse nine times in the final two furlongs also using a high arm action. Enstone's horse was having her first run on a racecourse under rules and saw plenty of the whip with seven strikes. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Southwell 3.10pm Class F 3y+ Hand. 1m AW Stan.Fibre 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. WhipsSho/Whip

Ellen Mooney R Ffrench B Smart 1 f 9 sw Pharoah's Gold Darren Williams D Shaw 2 f 7 sw Sangiovese S Drowne Morrison 3 f 5 sw Magic Mamma's Too D Mernagh TD Barron 4 f 9 sw Cryfield Kim Tinkler N Tinkler 5 f 2 sw Waxwing J-P Guillambert (5) A Carroll 6 mf 4 sw Coronado Forest FP Ferris (3) MR Hoad 7 f 5 sw Maggies Pet LP Keniry (3) K Bell 8 mf 7 sw Neven Gemma Anderson (7)TD Barron 9 mf 5 sw Sudra JD O'Reilly (7) J O'Reilly 10 mf 5 sw Red Delirium L Fletcher (3) Brotherton 11 m 2 sw Sambucan Daze J Fanning JD Bethell 12 m 3 sw Due Diligence A Culhane Fairhurst 13 0 Poppyline R Mullen WR Muir 14 0 sw Smart Minister P Hanagan JJ Quinn 15 m 4 sw Emmervale PJ Scallan R Cowell 16 m 2 sw

8m 10f 14//69//16 15//16

Comments: A high number of whips in the final two furlongs. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Southwell 4.40pm Class F 2yAuMaid 7f AW Stan.Fibre 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. WhipsSho/Whip

Freddie Freccles M Fenton JG Given 1 mf 9 sw She's Our Lass R Fitzpatrick D Carroll 2 f 10 sw Restart P Dineley (7) P Haslam 3 0 Lord Greystoke S Whitworth C Morlock 4 mf 6 sw Capetown Girl Darren Williams KR Burke 5 f 5 sw Intikraft S Drowne S Liddiard 6 mf 9 sw Young J Mackay E Lavelle 7 f 4 sw Nordic Dancer M Henry R Cowell 8 mf 2 sw Bold Blade R Ffrench B Smart 9 sm 2 sw He's A Rocket N Chalmers (5) C Dunnett 10 mf 5 sw Mystic Promise Joanna Badger Macauley 11 m 3 sw Indian Sapphire F Norton A Berry 12 0 sw

1s 7m 8f 10//55//12 11//12

Comments: The front two, Fenton and Fitzpatrick, hit their two year old horses nineteen times between them. Freddie Freccles was having his first race. Fitzpatrick, Williams and Mackay all hit their horses down the neck. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 12.20pm Class D 2yMaiden 1m AW Stan.Poly 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Rendezvous Point L Dettori J Gosden 1 f 5 sw Pergolacha Dane O'Neill L Cumani 2 f 10 sw Pukka K Dalgleish L Cumani 3 mf 6 sw Resonance W Ryan A Perrett 4 f 2 sw La Landonne J-P Guillambert (3) P Phelan 5 f 3 sw Evaluator A Clark TG Mills 6 0 Land Of Nod SW Kelly G Butler 7 f 1 sw Just Filly G Hannon AP Jones 8 f 1 sw Donastrela M Fenton A Balding 9 f 2 Wake Up Henry S Drowne R Charlton 10 mf 2 sw Burlington Place JF Egan S Kirk 11 m 1 sw Skelthwaite J Fanning Tompkins 12 0 sw

3m 9f 10//33//12 10//12

Comments: Fenton hit his horse down the neck hand off the reins and didn't show the whip. Dalgleish also hit his horse twice down the neck hand off the reins. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 12.50pm Class E 3y+ Hand. 7f AW Stan.Poly 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Compton Banker SW Kelly G Butler 1 mf 7 sw Sir Laughalot A Culhane E Lavelle 2 f 4 sw Dorchester L Dettori W Musson 3 f 10 sw Foolish Thought S Hitchcott (3) R Fahey 4 f 4 sw Zak Facta C Cogan D McHale 5 f 6 sw Jagged Darren Williams KR Burke 6 mf 5 sw Duo Leoni M Tebbutt R Beckett 7 0 sw Majhool I Mongan GL Moore 8 f 1 sw Mistral Sky S Drowne S Liddiard 9 0 Peyto Princess Lisa Jones (3) M Buckley 10 mf 4 sw Teyaar P McCabe Macauley 11 f 9 sw Ripple Effect B Reilly (5) CA Dwyer 12 f 4 sw Its Ecco Boy D Kinsella P Howling 13 mf 4 sw Azreme M Fenton P d'Arcy 14 f 4 sw Toppling P Fitzsimons J Bradley 15 f 3 sw Fire Dome J-P Guillambert (3) A Reid 16 m 1 sw

5m 13f 14//66//16 15//16

Comments: Kelly had a high arm action in his whipping as did Williams. Jones hit her horse hand off the reins. Zak Facta veered away from the whip and hampered many horses. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 1.20pm Class D 2yMaiden 1m AW Stan.Poly 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Red Spell Dane O'Neill R Hannon 1 f 5 sw Bienvenue A Daly Tregoning 2 f 2 sw Impartial J Fanning PFI Cole 3 f 3 sw Waziri M Fenton Morrison 4 f 4 sw Inchpast L Dettori Tompkins 5 m 2 sw Polar Dancer W Ryan A Perrett 6 f 1 sw Ameyrah A Culhane Channon 7 0 Cora SW Kelly L Cumani 8 mf 3 sw Nuts For You S Drowne R Charlton 9 0 Crackleando J-P Guillambert (3) Littmoden 10 0 sw Solo Sole K Dalgleish L Cumani 11 0 sw

2m 6f 7//20//11 9//11

Comments: Fanning hit his horse down the neck hand off the reins. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 1.50pm Class E 3y+ Hand. 7f AW Stan.Poly 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Mr Bountiful SW Kelly M Dods 1 mf 9 sw Just One Smile JF Egan T Easterby 2 f 9 sw Trousers L Dettori A Reid 3 f 7 sw Blakeshall Boy Dean McKeown R Lee 4 f 2 sw George Stubbs J-P Guillambert (3) Littmoden 5 f 2 sw Heidelburg A Culhane S Kirk 6 f 2 sw Kilmeena Lad LP Keniry (3) JC Fox 7 f 2 sw Goodenough Mover Dane O'Neill JS King 8 f 5 sw Fearby Cross Lisa Jones (3) Musson 9 f 4 sw Inistrahull Island J Fanning Tompkins 10 0 sw King David R Price D Birchell 11 f 5 sw Jonny Ebeneezer S Drowne R Cowell 12 f 2 sw Sestina P Doe S Dow 13 0 sw Tuscan Treaty JF McDonald (5) T Clement 14 f 1 sw Dunedin Rascal S Carson E Wheeler 15 m 2 sw Fulvio I Mongan J Poulton 16 0

2m 12f 13//52//16 15//16

Comments: Jones hit her horse down the neck hand off the reins. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 2.20pm Class D 3y+Maid. 6f AW Stan.Poly 14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Phrenologist Dane O'Neill Fanshawe 1 f 6 sw Salon Prive L Dettori C Cyzer 2 f 9 sw Monte Mayor Lad S Drowne Hay.Jones 3 f 5 sw Mynd Dean McKeown Whitaker 4 f 6 sw Tatweer Darren Williams D Shaw 5 f 4 sw Inching M Henry R Cowell 6 f 8 sw Calusa Lady A Clark G Balding 7 0 sw Montana R Smith R Hannon 8 f 2 sw Go Go Girl LP Keniry (3) L Cottrell 9 f 9 sw Arran M Tebbutt Collingrid. 10 0 Beneking N Callan Gallagher 11 f 2 sw Nathan D Sweeney PJ Makin 12 f 2 sw Easy Breeze P Fitzsimons J Bradley 13 mf 4 sw Sargents Dream A Daly J Gilbert 14 f 4 sw

1m 12f 12//61//14 13//14

Comments: Sargents Dream was sweating badly, probably nervous, therefore should not have had the whip used. This was also her first race. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 2.50pm Class E 3-5yClaim. 1m 4f AW Stan.Poly 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Compton Eclaire JF McDonald (5) G Butler 1 0 sw Landescent M Fenton M Quinn 2 f 7 sw Rasid Dane O'Neill CA Dwyer 3 f 9 sw Khuzdar S Hitchcott (3) Channon 4 f 5 sw Water Of Life R Miles (5) JR Boyle 5 f 7 sw Dark Dolores D Sweeney JR Boyle 6 f 4 sw Route Barree P Doe S Dow 7 m 1 sw Elheba Lisa Jones (3) Wigham 8 f 1 sw Appleacre I Mongan B Johnson 9 f 2 sw Onya JF Egan JW Hills 10 m 1 sw

2m 7f 9//37//10 10//10

Comments: Miles hit his horse down the neck hand off the reins. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 3.20pm Class G 2y Selling 6f AW Stan.Poly 13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Fools Entire A Culhane Channon 1 f 8 sw Lady Predominant D Corby (3) Channon 2 f 8 sw Princess Kai N Day R Imgram 3 f 8 sw Emaradia N Callan PD Evans 4 f 8 sw City General LP Keniry (3) JS Moore 5 f 5 sw Jaolins R Smith R Hannon 6 f 3 sw Joint Destiny S Whitworth GL Moore 7 f 3 sw Costa Del Sol R Miles (5) JJ Bridger 8 f 3 sw Stamford Blue JD Smith JS Moore 9 f 1 sw Lady Mo D Kinsella A Reid 10 f 4 sw Introduction M Fenton Musson 11 0 He's A Rocket N Chalmers (5) C Dunnett 12 f 2 sw La Fonteyne J Fanning C Booth 13 0 sw

11f 11//53//13 12//13

Comments:Plenty of whip shown to the first four, and indeed, many of the other two year olds. Day hit his horse twice down the neck hand off the reins. Thursday 13th November 2003 Lingfield 3.50pm Class F 3y+A.Hand1m 1m 2f 2f AW Stan.Poly 13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Dower House D Corby A Turnell 1 f 6 sw Retirement Saleem Golam (7) Tompkins 2 f 6 sw JR Steveson Lisa Jones Wigham 3 f 2 sw Alrafid A Quinn (3) GL Moore 4 f 3 sw Most-Saucy D Nolan (3) IA Wood 5 f 4 sw Ofaraby D Fox (3) MA Jarvis 6 f 6 sw Liberty Royal L McVicar (7) PJ Makin 7 f 1 sw Classic Role S Hitchcott R Ingram 8 f 1 sw Night Warrior PP Mathers (5) D Flood 9 f 3 sw Cruise Director A Rutter (7) Wmusson 10 0 Tropical Coral JF McDonald (3) Lidderdale 11 f 2 sw The Gaikwar M Savage (5) NE Berry 12 mf 3 sw Indian Welcome LP Keniry Morrison 13 m 2 sw

2m 11f 12//39//13 12//13 Tuesday 18th November 2003 Lingfield 12.20pm Class D 2y Maiden 6f AW Stan.Poly 7 of 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Aesculus W Ryan L Cumani 1 f 3 sw Muktasb R Hills Tregoning 2 f 6 sw Halabaloo JF Egan G Wragg 3 f 5 sw Rockley Bay D Sweeney PJ Makin 4 f 6 sw Get To The Point Paul Eddery P d'Arcy 5 f 3 sw Beresford Boy I Mongan D Ivory 6 f 2 sw Eugenie Dane O'Neill R Hannon 7 mf 4 sw Ragged Jack SW Kelly G Butler U Took no part / unseated rider at the start

1m 7f 7//29//7 7//7

Comments: All of these young horses were hit. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Lingfield 1.20pm Class D 2y Maiden 6f AW Stan.Poly 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Kabreet S Drowne E Dunlop 1 0 Burlington Place JF Egan S Kirk 2 f 11 sw Comeraincomeshine R Miles (5) TG Mills 3 f 3 sw Foot Fault W Ryan Callaghan 4 f 3 sw Locator J Tate J Eustace 5 f 2 sw Emilys Dawn A Nicholls DK Ivory 6 f 3 sw Sabrina Brown S Carson G Balding 7 0 Charlieismydarling J Fanning J Osborne 8 0 sw Science Academy Dane O'Neill PFI Cole 9 f 1 sw Miss Millietant C Cogan Monta.Hall 10 0 Evening Fragrance M Fenton G Chung 11 0

6f 6//23//11 7//11

Comments: Egan gave his horse 11 strikes of the whip, too many for a young horse. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Lingfield 2.50pm Class D 2yNursHa. 1m AW Stan.Poly 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Freak Occurance S Drowne E Lavelle 1 f 8 sw Chubbes J Fanning MC Pipe 2 f 4 sw Keep On Movin' R Miles (5) TG Mills 3 f 2 sw Amwell Brave M Fenton J Jenkins 4 mf 10 sw Bold Joe G Gibbons P Mitchell 5 mf 9 sw Wizard Looking Dane O'Neill R Hannon 6 f 7 sw Abington Angel LP Keniry (3) B Meehan 7 f 2 sw St Savarin N Pollard JR Best 8 m 1 sw Darn Good P Gallagher (7) R Hannon 9 f 2 sw Sachin SW Kelly G Butler 10 m 7 sw Uncle John JF Egan S Kirk 11 m 5 sw

5m 8f 11//57//11 11//11

Comments: Every one of these two year olds was hit with the whip. More experienced than their contemporaries in the earlier races, this was no excuse to see these hit more frequently. Fanning, O'Neill and Gibbons hit their horse down the neck, hand off the reins and Drowne's eight strikes and Fenton's ten added to this race's poor show from many of the jockeys. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Lingfield 3.50pm Class F 3y+AmHa.1m 4f AW Stan.Poly 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Cold Turkey Mr E Dehdashti (5) GL Moore 1 f 10 sw Misson To Mars Mr S Walker P Hedger 2 f 4 sw Reminiscent Ms C Williams John-Houg 3 mf 7 sw King Revo Mr B Haslam (5) P Haslam 4 f 2 sw Most-Saucy Mr G Bartley (7) IA Wood 5 f 3 sw Gingko Mr J King (7) P Webber 6 f 4 sw Mandoob Miss F Guillambert (7)B Johnson 7 m 1 sw Silver Prophet Mrs S Bosley M Bosley 8 m 3 sw Starry Mary Mrs S Moore (3) EL James 9 0 sw Chevronne Mr L Jefford L Cottrell 10 m 3 sw Paso Doble Mr J Millman (7) B Millman 11 0 Peppershot Mr J Pemberton (7) G Enright 12 m 1

5m 6f 10//38//12 10//12

Comments: Prolific winner Cold Turkey did not require ten strikes of the whip to get home first, but was given them by amateur Dehdashti. Amateur Pemberton hit Peppershot totally out of the blue for no reason. He appeared to take his glove off and hit the horse down the neck, hand off the reins, without first showing the horse the whip or trying to push along with hands and heels. The Stewards should have taken action on this. Monday 13th October 2003 Windsor 1.40pm Class D 2y Maiden 6f Flat G/F 13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Fiddle Me Blue S Drowne Morrison Fav 1 0 Speedbird F Norton G Wragg 2 0 sw Chigorin J Tate J Eustace 3 0 Chara S Whitworth J Jenkins 4 f 1 Anchor RL Moore J Bradley 5 f 1 sw Your Just Lovely Martin Dwyer A Balding 6 f 2 Stella Marais O Urbina Chamings 7 0 Epaminondas D O'Neill R Hannon 8 mf 4 sw Apollo Gee LP Keniry B Meehan 9 f 4 Charlie Bear R Mullen E Dunlop 10 0 Cobalt Blue R Price W Haggas 11 f 1 sw Crispin Girl L Fletcher J Spearing 12 mf 6 sw Choristar C Catlin Muir 13 0

2m 7f 7/19/13 5//13

Comments:: KeniryWith this Not being Easy; a two year old race horses would need not to be knockedknocked about about' the two aprentices Keniry and Fletcher were not easy on their mounts the geldingding Apollo Apollo Gee and the filly Crispin Girl. Fletcheralso had hada high a high whip whip action. action. Monday 13th October 2003 Windsor 2.10pm Class D 2y Maiden 6f Flat G/F 14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Momtic Martin Dwyer W Jarvis 1 f 10 sw Sion Hill M Stoute 2 f 5 sw Presto Shinko P Dobbs R Hannon 3 f 6 sw Malvern Light R Price W Haggas 4 0 Archerfield RL Moore JW Hills 5 0 Intriguing Glimpse D Kinsella B Sanders 6 0 Typhonic S Drowne R Charlton 7 f 3 Dreaming Waters S Carson John/Houg 8 0 Maxi's Princess C Catlin PJ Makin 9 0 Mr Independent R Mullen E Dunlop 10 f 1 Ligne D'Eau N Callan PD Evans 11 0 All The More S Whitworth P Duffield 12 0 American Duke Paul Eddery B Meehan 13 0 Angel Maid D O'Neill G Balding 14 0

5f 5/22/14 3//14

Comments: :With this being a two year old race horses would need not to be 'knocked about' the riding from Dwyer was hard with the whip, high action and 10 strikestrikes withinfrom around the the two furlong pole to the finish Dobbs also showed a high action use of the whip. Monday 13th October 2003 Windsor 2.40pm Class F 2y Seller 1m 1/2f Flat G/F 18 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Chubbes S Drowne R Charlton 1 0 Doctored Pat Eddery B Meenan 2 mf 10 sw Peka Bou N Callan DJ Wintle 3 f 8 sw She Legged It Dane O'Neill R Hannon 4 f 7 sw Timely Twist P Dobbs S Kirk 5 f 4 Diamond Dreamer SW Kelly M Quinan 6 f 3 sw Garston Star LP Keniry JS Moore 7 f 7 sw Shanghai Surprise L Fletcher IA Wood 8 f 1 sw Delcienne A McCarthy Margarson 9 f 7 sw Bold Shout S Carson John/Houg 10 mf 5 sw Grigoriev S Whitworth JW Hills 11 mf 4 sw Monash Girl R Smith B Johnson 12 f 2 sw Mind Play I Mongan JG Given 13 mf 2 sw Tell The Trees R Mullen R Beckett 14 0 Lady Mo Lisa Jones (3) A Reid 15 f 2 sw Emmeffaich RL Moore J Portman 16 0 sw Eves Wood Martin Dwyer J Portman 17 0 Oakley Prince C Catlin Madgwick 18 0

4m 13f 13/62/18 13//18

Comments: 2 year old horses see a lot of the whip in this seller. Callan used his whip eight times in the last two furlongs and Pat Eddery and Dane O'Neill appeared to hit their horses down the neck. A poor display and disappointing to see young horses treated thisthis wayway. by many of the jockeys. Monday 13th October 2003 Windsor 3.10pm Class C 3y+ hand 1m 2f Flat G/F 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Desert Quest Pat Eddery M Stoute 1 f 8 sw Alrafid RL Moore GL Moore 2 f 13 sw Climate R Smith R Hannon 3 f 3 sw Brooklyn's Gold C Catlin I Williams 4 0 Cuddles Martin Dwyer C Brittain 5 f 6 sw Ace Of Hearts S Drowne C F Wall 6 f 4 sw Shenley Charm L Fletcher (3) Morrison 7 mf 4 sw Gallant Boy N Callan PD Evans 8 f 6 sw Den's-Joy Lisa Jones (3) D McHale 9 f 7 sw York Cliff P Dobbs J Gosden 10 f 1 sw Jubilee Treat F Norton G Wragg 11 f 2 sw Golden A Daly R Hannon 12 f 2 sw Gingko D Corby (3) P Webber 13 f 6 sw The Glen I Mongan Tompkins 14 m 1 sw Thihn A Beech (3) J Spearing 15 mf 2 sw Silver City Dane O'Neill AJ Perrett 16 m 2 sw

4m 13f 15/67/16 15//16

Comments: Every horse apart from one was hit. Pat Eddery hit his horse eight times in the last furlong. Moore hit his horse 13 times in the final two furlongs, 6 between 2f & 1F and 7 times between 1f & the finishing post. Monday 13th October 2003 Windsor 3.40pm Class D 2yNursery 1m 1/2f Flat G/F 17 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Foley Prince D Fox (5) D Flood 1 mf 13 sw Kingdom Come Dane O'Neill S Kirk 2 f 8 sw Almond Willow RL Moore J Noseda 3 f 4 sw Monte Bianco SW Kelly L Cumani 4 mf 7 sw Darn Good P Dobbs R Hannon 5 f 4 sw Fine Silver S Drowne PFI Cole 6 mf 6 sw Oddsmaker Joanna Badger PD Evans 7 mf 7 sw Baleric Star G Baker B Millman 8 mf 5 sw Nahane F Norton M Stoute 9 m 1 sw Anuvasteel P Keniry (3) Callaghan 10 mf 4 sw Woody Valentine Martin Dwyer Johnston 11 0 sw Coventina Pat Eddery JL Dunlop 12 f 2 sw Seeking Answers R Mullen A Stewart 13 mf 4 sw Imperial Royal C Catlin Channon 14 0 Saipan R Smith R Hannon 15 m 1 sw Cloudingswell D Kinsella (3) IA Wood 16 m 3 sw Avesomeofthat S Whitworth P Duffield 17 m 4 sw

10m 11f 15/73/17 16//17

Comments: A two year old nursery where 15 of the 17 were hit. The first two jockeys whipped in what would appear to be a harsh manner, with claimer Fox using his 13 times, of which nine strikes were in the last two furlongs. O'Neill struck his horse eight times in the final two furlongs, of which one was down the neck. Havlin also struck his horse down the neck. A poor race seeing whips used to their maximum on two year olds. Monday 13th October 2003 Windor 4.10pm Class D 3y+ Maid. 1m 1/2f Flat G/F 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Janayen P Dobbs Tregoning 1 f 1 sw Perfect Night S Drowne R Charlton 2 f 3 sw Ballinger Ridge Martin Dwyer A Balding 3 f 5 sw Many Thanks R Mullen E Dunlop 4 mf 6 sw Adantino G Baker B Millman 5 mf 7 sw High Cane Pat Eddery J Noseda 6 f 4 sw Tom From Bounty A McCarthy B Millman 7 mf 7 sw Blue Quiver Paul Eddery C Horgan 8 f 1 sw Dame Edna D Corby(3) She West 9 m 3 sw Nassau Street C Catlin ffrenchDav 10 0

4m 8f 9/37/10 9//10 Monday 13th October 2003 Windsor 4.40pm Class E 3y+ hand 6f Flat G/F 18 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Full Spate RL Moore J Bradley 1 f 8 sw Yomalo Pat Eddery R Guest 2 f 13 sw Its Ecco Boy Lisa Jones (3) P Howling 3 mf 12 sw A Woman In Love S Drowne B Sanders 4 f 5 sw Super Canyon N Callan PW Harris 5 mf 9 sw A Teen D Kinsella (3) P Howling 6 f 3 sw Desert Arc Martin Dwyer A Balding 7 f 5 sw High Ridge LP Keniry (3) J Bradley 8 f 6 sw Calusa Lady S Carson G Balding 9 f 1 sw Scythian Dane O'Neill R Hannon 10 f 6 sw B A Highflyer C Catlin Channon 11 f 3 sw Jagged G Baker KR Burke 12 f 4 sw Tender A McCarthy DJ Daly 13 mf 5 sw Siraj I Mongan N Graham 14 m 1 sw Toppling P Fitzsimons J Bradley 15 f 4 sw Twentytwosilver SW Kelly J Osborne 16 0 Flaran R Mullen A Stewart 17 m 1 sw Beyond Calculation CJ Davies (7) J Bradley 18 m 1 sw

6m 14f 17/87/18 17//18

Comments: The first three jockeys whipped out a finish in the final two furlongs hitting their horses - Eddery 13, Jones 10, and Moore 8 in the last furlong. Jones also hit her horse down the neck once and Fitzsimons hit his horse three times down the neck. A poor riding display by many jockeys. Monday 13th October 2003 Windsor 5.10pm Class D 3y+ Maid 1m 1/2f Flat G/F 9 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Baltic Blazer I Mongan PW Harris 1 mf 8 sw Margery Daw Martin Dwyer Tregoning 2 f 3 sw Amnesty Dane O'Neill H Candy 3 f 10 sw Saada One SW Kelly L Cumani 4 f 5 sw Grumpyintmorning A Daly Townsley 5 f 4 sw Maid For Life N Callan Wallace 6 0 Assignation S Drowne B Millman 7 f 6 sw Royale Pearl N Day R Ingram 8 f 4 sw If Lisa Jones (3) B Millman 9 m 2

2m 7f 8/42/9 7//9

Comments: Ian Mongan hit his horse twice down the neck. A Daly hit his once down the neck. Dane O'Neill hit his horse ten times during the last two furlongs. Monday 13th October 2003 Ayr 1.50pm Class D 2y Maiden 7f Flat G/S (Soft) 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Makfool A Culhane Channon 1 f 1 sw Devil's Bite L Dettori BW Hills 2 mf 8 sw Salamba P Robinson Thompkin 3 f 7 sw Asiatic J Fanning M Johnsn 4 f 3 sw Schapiro K Darley Gosden 5 0 sw Late Opposition W Supple E Dunlop 6 f 2 sw Dante's Devine M Fenton A Bailey 7 f 3 sw Son Of Thunder T Hamilton M Dods 8 f 1 Rhetorical G Duffield Prescott 9 f 2 Lapdancing T Eaves LA Perratt 10 s 1

1s 1m 8f 9/28/10 7//10

Comments: Both Dettori and Robinson were hard on their two year olds. Duffield appeared to hit Rhetorical downdown thethe neckneck withwith hishis handshands offoff thethe reins.reins. Monday 13th October 2003 Ayr 2.20pm Class D 2y Maiden 7f Flat G/S (Soft) 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Tabadul W Supple E Dunlop 1 f 6 sw Divine Gift P Robinson MA Jarvis 2 mf 6 sw Mystical Girl J Fanning M Johnsn 3 f 2 sw Neap Tide L Dettori Gosden 4 f 1 sw Glencairn Star P Hanagan JS Goldie 5 0 Trilemma G Duffield Prescott 6 0 Tytheknot R Winston O'Keeffe 7 0 sw Joe Charlie J Carroll KA Ryan 8 m 2 sw Blades Edge M Fenton A Bailey 9 0 Rusty Boy R Ffrench A Crook 10 m 1 sw

3m 4f 6/18/10 7//10

Comments: With this being a two year old race Supple and Robinson both hit their horses six times, Supple with a high action this was Tabadul's first race not a good introduction Monday 13th October 2003 Ayr 2.50pm Class E 3y Claim 1m 3f Flat G/S (Soft) 13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Pequenita M Fenton JG Given 1 f 2 sw Mr Mischief P Dineley (7) P Haslam 2 m 4 sw Lucayan Dancer L Dettori JS Goldie 3 mf 4 sw Lord Temuchin K Darley M Wallace 4 mf 3 sw Staff Nurse Kim Tinkler N Tinkler 5 mf 5 sw Maunby Rocker L Enstone (3) P Haslam 6 m 1 sw Culcabock P Fessey P Monteith 7 m 3 sw Sherwood Forest A Culhane LA Perratt 8 0 Commitment Lecture A Nicholls M Dods 9 m 2 sw Blue Myst J Fanning Swinbank 10 0 Feizor S Righton RF Fisher 11 m 2 Lady Past Times W Supple EJ Alston 12 m 3 sw Ryans Mistake R Winston Swinbank Pulled Up 0

9m 4f 9//28//10 9//13

Comments: Ryans Mistake broke down. Kim Tinkler appeared harsh on her horse, hitting her when clearly beaten and with no chance of a place position. Monday 13th October 2003 Ayr 3.50pm Class C 3y Condits1m Flat G/S (Soft) 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh No. Whips Sho/Whip

Makhlab W Supple BW Hills 1 f 8 sw Babodana P Robinson Tompkins 2 f 12 sw Blazing Thunder K Darley J Gosden 3 f 1 sw Millagros D McGaffin (3) I Semple 4 f 6 sw Majestic Horizon L Dettori Bin Suroor 5 f 1 sw Caught Out P Bradley (5) A Berry 6 0

5f 5//28//6 5//6

Comments: The first and second saw plenty of the whip with Supple striking his horse 8 times in the last two furlongs and Robinson striking 12 times in the last two furlongs. Tuesday 14th October 2003 Ayr 2.20pm Class D 2y Maid Fillies 1m Flat G/S (Soft) 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Mekuria K Dalgleish Johnston 1 f 7 sw Mommkin A Culhane Channon 2 f 3 sw Appetina M Fenton JG Given 3 f 6 sw New Morning P Robinson MA Jarvis 4 f 4 sw Beacon Blue R Ffrench Johnston 5 f 3 sw Shadowy G Duffield John/Houg 6 sf 2 sw Clog Dance K Darley J Gosden 7 0 sw Sand And Stars C Catlin Tompkins 8 0 Power Map Kim Tinkler N Tinkler 9 m 1 Anicaflash T Hamilton (5) M Dods 10 m 3 sw

1s 2m 6f 8//29//10 8//10

Comments: Two year old maiden fillies race where eight of the ten were hit. Hamilton looked particularly hard on his horse - making only her second appearance on a racecourse - a strike down the neck, whether with hands on reins or not, was especially disturbing. The horse could well be soured from this. Tuesday 14th October 2003 Ayr 2.50pm Class D 2yNursery 1m Flat G/S (Soft) 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Mutafanen W Supple E Dunlop 1 f 8 sw Red Damson G Duffield Prescott 2 f 12 sw Toparudi P Robinson Tompkins 3 f 8 sw Royal Distant K Darley J Gosden 4 f 9 sw Always Flying R Ffrench Johnston 5 mf 5 sw Rutters Rebel R Winston Swinbank 6 mf 3 sw Hathlen A Culhane Channon 7 m 3 sw Kentmere M Fenton Johnston 8 mf 9 sw Futoo D Mernagh G Moore 9 f 3 sw Kings Rock P Fessey KA Ryan 10 mf 11 sw Less Of A Mystery K Dalgleish Johnston 11 f 2 sw Soap Watcher P Hanagan RA Fahey 12 m 4 sw Showtime Annie F Norton A Bailey 13 m 1 sw Velocity Belle J Mackay MLW Bell 14 m 2 sw Washbrook C Catlin A Turnell 15 0 Ceasar J Jeffrey (7) P Haslam 16 0

8m 10f 14//80//16 14//16

Comments: A two year old race over a mile on this ground means they will become very tired. The jockeys used far too much whip on these young horses - especially the first four. Fenton and Fessey were also keen with the whip and could have desisted when beaten. Kentmere swished his tail each time he was hit. Tuesday 14th October 2003 Ayr 4.20pm Class D 3y+ Maid 1m 2f Flat G/S (Soft) 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Shouette A Culhane BW Hills 1 f 6 sw Allied Victory W Supple EJ Alston 2 mf 9 sw Artistic Style T Hamilton (5) B Ellison 3 mf 7 sw Shredded K Darley J Gosden 4 f 2 sw Silent Thunder SW Kelly J Noseda 5 mf 9 sw Prince Of The Wood F Norton A Bailey 6 0 sw Felidae M Lawson (7) M Brittain 7 mf 3 sw Essex R Winston M Stoute 8 0 Stellite N Mackay (5) JS Goldie 9 0 Cantemerle G Duffield Brisbourne 10 mf 3 sw Tropical Son Darren Williams D Shaw 11 m 2 sw Burghmuir D McGaffin (3) I Semple 12 0 sw

6m 7f 8/41/12 10//12 Thursday 16th October 2003 Newmarket 1.40pm Class D 2y Maiden 6f Flat Good/Firm12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Phantom Wind R Hughes J Gosden 1 f 2 sw Great Fox JF Egan P Gilligan 2 f 3 sw Emtilaak R Hills B Hanbury 3 f 3 sw Wyatt Earp S Sanders J Toller 4 mf 5 sw Elusive Kitty C Catlin G Butler 5 0 Mrs Shilling JP Spencer Fanshawe 6 0 Muktasb W Supple Tregoning 7 0 Royal Pavillion Pat Eddery Musson 8 0 Hezaam TE Durcan J Dunlop 9 0 Star Welcome R Mullen Musson 10 0 Genuinely A Rutter (7) Musson 11 0 Lord Wishingwell T Eaves (5) Wainwrig. 12 0

1m 4f 4//13//12 4//12

Comments: Sanders hit his two year old down the neck, hand off the reins. It was pleasing to see none of the newcomers to racing were whipped. Thursday 16th October 2003 Newmarket 2.15pm Class B 3y+ Hand. 1m 4f Flat Good/Firm9 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Dawn Invasion R Hughes A Perrett 1 f 11 sw Trust Rule M Hills BW Hills 2 f 5 sw Contraband JP Spencer W Haggas 3 f 3 sw Muhareb L Dettori C Brittain 4 f 11 sw Treculiar C Catlin G Butler 5 f 2 sw Robe Chinoise S Sanders J Dunlop 6 mf 6 sw Mamcazma N Callan D Morris 7 m 1 sw Flight Of Esteem D Holland PW Harris 8 m 2 sw Lesath Martin Dwyer Fanshawe 9 m 1 sw

4m 6f 9//42//9 9//9

Comments: Sanders and Spencer both hit their horses down the neck, hand off the reins. Thursday 16th October 2003 Newmarket 2.50pm Class A 3y+F&M List.1m 2f Flat Good/Firm14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Al Ihtithar W Supple BW Hills 1 f 6 sw Tadris R Hills Tregoning 2 f 6 sw Miss Corniche D Holland G Wragg 3 f 7 sw Weecando G Carter CN Allen 4 f 3 sw Silence Is Golden R Winston B Meehan 5 f 5 sw Wondrous Joy R Hughes E Dunlop 6 f 4 sw Rachel Dane O'Neill A Perrett 7 f 6 sw Ice Palace JP Spencer Fanshawe 8 f 3 sw Rainbow End Martin Dwyer Elsworth 9 0 sw La Dolfina S Drowne Morrison 10 f 4 sw In A Silent Way P Robinson MA Jarvis 11 0 Beneventa S Sanders J Dunlop 12 0 Silent Heir K Darley J Noseda 13 0 Santa Sophia Pat Eddery J Dunlop 14 0

9f 9//44//14 10//14 Thursday 16th October 2003 Newmarket 4.00pm Class A 3y+F&M List.6f Flat Good/Firm13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Frizzante JP Spencer Fanshawe 1 0 sw Goldeva N Callan R Hollins. 2 f 7 sw Fanny's Fancy S Sanders CF Wall 3 f 5 sw Ringmoor Down Dane O'Neill Arbuthnot 4 0 sw Khulood R Hills J Dunlop 5 f 6 sw Enchanted A McCarthy Margarson 6 f 1 Presto Vento R Hughes R Hannon 7 f 6 sw Proud Boast W Supple GS Rees 8 f 4 sw Medeena TE Durcan J Dunlop 9 f 3 sw Duty Paid Martin Dwyer Elsworth 10 0 Olivia Grace K Darley L Cumani 11 f 2 sw Fancy Lady M Hills BW Hills 12 f 3 sw Dragon Flyer S Drowne M Quinn 13 m 4 sw

1m 9f 10//41//13 11//13

Comments: Hughes, McCarthy, Supple, Durcan and Sanders all hit their horses down the neck. Fanny's Fancy was hit in the face with a whip in action from another jockey; it stopped her run. Thursday 16th October 2003 Newmarket 4.35pm Class D 2yNursery 1m Flat Good/Firm11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Top Spec Pat Eddery R Hannon 1 f 9 sw Sanbonah N Mackay (5) Callaghan 2 f 9 sw Lyca Ballerina P Hanagan BW Hills 3 f 5 sw State Dilemma M Hills BW Hills 4 f 8 sw Here To Me R Smith R Hannon 5 f 6 sw Le Tiss TE Durcan Channon 6 f 7 sw Poppys Footprint N Callan KA Ryan 7 f 4 sw Goblin RL Moore R Hannon 8 0 Boule D'Or N Day R Ingram 9 f 7 sw Lucayan Beauty K Darley M Wallace 10 m 1 sw Alqaayid Martin Dwyer Tregoning 11 0

1m 8f 9//56//11 9//11

Comments: These young horses saw plenty of the whip. Day hit his horse three times down the neck hand off the reins. Thursday 16th October 2003 Newmarket 5.10pm Class B 3y+ Hand. 5f Flat Good/Firm16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Smart Predator R Winston JJ Quinn 1 f 8 sw Caribbean Coral S Sanders CF Wall 2 f 3 sw Fruit Of Glory D Holland J Jenkins 3 f 1 Bali Royal Dane O'Neill Saunders 4 f 5 sw Peruvian Chief I Mongan Littmoden 5 f 8 sw Connect P Robinson Tompkins 6 f 4 sw Speed Cop Martin Dwyer A Balding 7 f 4 sw Absent Friends R Hughes J Balding 8 f 1 sw Bond Boy L Dettori B Smart 9 f 2 sw Beyond The Clouds T Eaves (5) Wainwright 10 f 1 sw Budelli D Corby (3) Channon 11 0 sw My American Beauty J Fanning T Easterby 12 0 sw Mazepa N Mackay (5) Callaghan 13 f 1 sw Rushcutter Bay JF Egan P Gilligan 14 f 4 sw Good Girl K Darley T Easterby 15 0 Trinculo Lisa Jones (3) Littmoden 16 f 4 sw

13f 13//46//16 14//16

Comments: Hughes, Mongan, Winston, Holland and Sanders all hit their horses down the neck. Saturday 18th October 2003 Newmarket 1.40pm Class A 3y+Grp3 2m Flat G/F (F) 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Persian Punch Martin Dwyer Elsworth 1 mf 11 sw Pat Eddery JL Dunlop 2 f 3 sw Kasthari JP Murtagh M Stoute 3 mf 12 sw Tholjanah R Hills Tregoning 4 mf 3 sw Savannah Bay PJ Smullen B Meehan 5 f 4 sw Porsa System R Hughes F Poulsen 6 m 4 sw

4m 5f 6//37//6 6//6

Comments: All horses were hit during this race. Kasthari received eight strikes in the last two furlongs. Saturday 18th October 2003 Newmarket 2.10pm Class A 3y+StkG2 7f Flat G/F (F) 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Just James Pat Eddery J Noseda 1 f 6 sw Nayyir JP Spencer GA Butler 2 f 3 sw Arakan K Fallon M Stoute 3 f 3 sw Membership P Robinson C Brittain 4 0 Trade Fair R Hughes R Charlton 5 f 5 sw Rimrod Martin Dwyer A Balding 6 f 4 sw M Hills BW Hills 7 0 Baron's Pit L Dettori R Hannon 8 f 2 sw Tillerman MJ Kinane A Perrett 9 f 1 sw Twilight Blues PJ Smullen B Meehan 10 f 4 sw Patsy's Double F Norton Blanshard 11 f 1

9f 9//29//11 8//11

Comments: An appalling race. When the horses bunched going into the dip and were squeezed for room, Eddery, Norton, Smullen, Dwyer and Fallon all struck their horses down the neck with hand off the reins - Norton once; Eddery at least once; Smullen three times; Dwyer twice and Fallon twice. The latter also struck with a high arm action. Robinson and Michael Hills clearly kept to the rules and lost the race. The stewards needed to look into this race. Saturday 18th October 2003 Newmarket 3.25pm Class A 2y C/F G1 7f Flat G/F (F) 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Milk It Mick D Holland J Osborne 1 f 6 sw Three Valleys R Hughes R Charlton 2 f 8 sw R Hills BW Hills 3 f 7 sw S Sanders JAR Toller 4 f 2 sw Troubadour JP Spencer A O'Brien 5 f 8 sw Imperial Stride K Fallon M Stoute 6 f 3 sw Pat Eddery J Noseda 7 f 3 sw Cape Fear PJ Smullen B Meehan 8 0 sw Snow Ridge Martin Dwyer Tregoning 9 f 3 sw Duke Of Venice L Dettori Johnston 10 f 4 sw Antonius Pius MJ Kinane A O'Brien 11 f 3 sw Tashkil W Supple J Gosden 12 0 sw

10f 10//47//12 12//12

Comments: Fallon for the second time at today's meeting hit his horse down the neck. Dettori also hit his horse down the neck. Hughes and Spencer hit their horses eight times in the final two furlongs. This top two year old race saw plenty of use of the whip for a prestigious prize, only Smullen and Supple refrained from picking up the whip. Saturday 18th October 2003 Newmarket 4.00pm Class A 3y+StkG1 1m 2f Flat G/F (F) 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Rakti P Robinson MA Jarvis 1 f 9 sw Carnival Dancer D Holland A Perrett 2 f 7 sw Indian Creek Dane O'Neill Elsworth 3 f 5 sw Imperial Dancer TE Durcan Channon 4 f 6 sw K Fallon M Stoute 5 f 3 sw JP Murtagh JM Oxx 6 m 6 sw Kaieteur Pat Eddery B Meehan 7 f 1 R Hills Tregoning 8 mf 7 sw Middlemarch MJ Kinane A O'Brien 9 f 3 sw Dano-Mast JP Spencer F Poulsen 10 mf 6 sw JF Egan P d'Arcy 11 m 3 sw Vespone L Dettori SB Suroor 12 0 sw

4m 9f 11//56//12 11//12

Comments: The whip saw plenty of use with Robinson leading the way with nine strokes in the final two furlongs. Saturday 18th October 2003 Newmarket 4.40pm Class A 2yf StkG2 7f Flat G/F (F) 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Cairns TE Durcan Channon 1 f 8 sw Snow Goose Pat Eddery JL Dunlop 2 f 3 sw Kelucia R Ffrench JS Goldie 3 f 8 sw Gracefully JF Egan S Kirk 4 f 11 sw Withorwithoutyou W Supple McMahon 5 f 7 sw Surf The Net L Dettori R Hannon 6 f 2 sw Bay Tree M Hills BW Hills 7 f 3 sw Tarot Card R Hughes BW Hills 8 0 sw Noyac Dane O'Neill R Hannon 9 mf 3 sw Perle D'Or K Fallon W Haggas 10 0

1m 8f 8//45//10 9//10

Comments:Egan hit his horse eleven times in the last two furlongs and Duracan hit his eight times. Kelucia clearly did not like being whipped as she swished her tail when struck. Saturday 18th October 2003 Newmarket 5.15pm Class A 3y+StkG3 1m 1f Flat G/F (F) 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Far Lane R Hughes BW Hills 1 mf 17 sw Pawn Broker Dane O'Neill Elsworth 2 f 9 sw Checkit TE Durcan Channon 3 f 6 sw Muqbil R Hills JL Dunlop 4 f 7 sw Naheef L Dettori SB Suroor 5 f 6 sw Lundy's Lane D Holland C Brittain 6 mf 10 sw Putra Pekan P Robinson MA Jarvis 7 mf 12 sw Right Approach K Fallon M Stoute 8 f 2 sw Al Jadeed W Supple A Gosden 9 0 sw Tuning Fork W Ryan HRA Cecil 10 0 Macadamia JP Spencer Fanshawe 11 0

3m 8f 8//69//11 9//11

Comments: Most of these horses saw plenty of the whip. Hughes struck his horse 17 times, of which 12 were in the last two furlongs and three strikes were down the neck with hand off the reins. Holland also hit his horse down the neck hand off the reins and made eight strikes in the final two furlongs. Robinson struck his horse nine times in the last two furlongs. Saturday 18th October 2003 Catterick 2.00pm Class D 2y Nov.St. 5f Flat G/F (F) 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Spliff D Sweeney H Candy 1 f 8 sw Handsome Cross L Enstone (3) IA Wood 2 f 12 sw Compton's Eleven A Culhane Channon 3 f 5 sw Innstyle R Winston B Meehan 4 f 3 sw Smart Starprincess FP Ferris (3) Blockley 5 f 5 sw Shank On Fourteen Darren Williams KR Burke 6 f 1 sw Saristar C Catlin PFI Cole 7 0 Birikina P Bradley (5) A Berry 8 sm 2 sw

1s 1m 6f 7//36//8 7//8

Comments: The whips were out for these nursery two year olds. Catlin setting an example of care when his horse came under pressure. Sadly Sweeney and Enstone resorted strongly to the whip, with eight and 12 strikes respectively in the last two furlongs. Saturday 18th October 2003 Catterick 2.35pm Class F 3y+Claim. 1m 4f Flat G/F (F) 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Cheeky Girl D Allan T Easterb. 1 mf 8 sw Blackthorn D Swift (7) RA Fahey 2 f 4 sw Rousing Thunder D McGaffin W Storey 3 mf 17 sw Mama Jaffa PJ Scallan KR Burke 4 mf 7 sw Cantoris T Eaves (3) Johnston 5 mf 5 sw Behan D Nolan (3) A Crook 6 mf 5 sw Aveiro Hayley Turner (5) B Powell 7 f 2 sw Lost Spirit Natalia Gemelova (5) PW Hiatt 8 mf 6 sw Grand Lass L Estone T Barron 9 f 3 sw Turftanzer Janice Webster (7) DE Incisa 10 mf 5 sw

7m 10f 10//62//10 10//10

Comments: An appalling apprentice race with a disturbing use of the whip from these young jockeys. Every horse was hit. McGaffin was particularly excessive, with 17 strikes, including one down the neck with hands off the reins. His horse also received a strike across the face from Turner as she went to use her whip on her mount. These jockeys require tuition on correct use of the whip and should not be allowed to strike their horses in this manner. Racing's ruling body should look at this and act for the welfare of horses who have to endure such beatings. Saturday 18th October 2003 Catterick 3.10pm Class D 2yNursery 7f Flat G/F (F) 8 Ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Granston C Catlin J Bethell 1 f 1 sw Cotosol G Gibbons McMahon 2 f 7 sw Passion Fruit J Bramhill Fairhurst 3 f 10 sw Senor Bond PJ Scallan B Smart 4 f 4 sw Emperor Cat FP Ferris (3) Blockley 5 f 3 sw Midnight Prince Dale Gibson M Easterb 6 0 sw One 'N' Only P Fessey L Perratt 7 mf 4 sw Rabitatit D Sweeney J O'Shea 8 m 2 sw

2m 6f 7//31//8 8//8

Comments: Bramhill hit his two year old 10 times in the last two furlongs. Fessey appeared to hit his horse down the neck. Saturday 18th October 2003 Catterick 3.45pm Class E 2yMaid. 7f Flat G/F (F) 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Chase The Rainbow J Fanning Johnston 1 0 Miskina A Culhane Channon 2 f 5 sw Simons Wood T Eaves (5) G Moore 3 f 4 sw Nocatee P Dineley (7) P Haslam 4 0 sw Smart Danny R Winston JJ Quinn 5 0

2f 2//9//5 3//5

Comments: Fanning rode a whip free race and Dineley and Winston never resorted to the whip when their young horses came under pressure. Saturday 18th October 2003 Catterick 4.20pm Class D 3y+Hand. 5f Flat G/F (F) 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Strensall R Fitzpatrick RE Barr 1 f 5 sw Mr Spliffy Darren Williams KR Burke 2 f 5 sw Grasslandik D Fox (5) A Stokell 3 mf 11 sw College Queen PJ Scallan S Gollings 4 f 6 sw Rare Destiny J Fanning A Berry 5 f 4 sw Polar Force D Corby (3) Channon 6 f 6 sw Sir Sandrovitch D Swift (7) RA Fahey 7 f 3 sw Twice Upon A Time A Culhane B Smart 8 0 sw African Spur FP Ferris (3) Blockley 9 f 2 sw Sholto D Allan (3) J O'Reilly 10 0 Vision Of Dreams R Winston B Meehan 11 0 Brantwood G Gibbons McMahon 12 mf 3 sw

2m 9f 9//45//12 10//12

Comments: Conditional jockey Fox hit his horse 11 times, nine in the last two furlongs and, it appeared, once down the neck with hands off the reins, Fanning also appeared to hit his horse down the neck in a similar manner. Saturday 18th October 2003 Catterick 4.55pm Class F 3y+Stake 1m 6f Flat G/F (F) 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Tass Heel A Culhane Channon 1 f 10 sw Chaka Zulu T Eaves (5) Whillans 2 mf 8 sw Lazzaz D Allan (3) PW Hiatt 3 mf 9 sw Colway Ritz J Bramhill W Storey 4 f 7 sw Tom Bell D Sweeney J O'Shea 5 f 3 sw Field Spark R Winston J Glover 6 f 2 sw Red River Rebel Darren Williams J Norton 7 m 1 sw Colonnade J Carroll C Grant 8 0

3m 6f 7//40//8 7//8

Comments: Only Carroll refrained from the whip, whereas the leaders received more than enough strikes. Bramhill appeared to hit his horse down the neck with hands off the reign. Culhane hit his horse ten times during the final two furlongs. Saturday 18th October 2003 Catterick 5.25pm Class E 3y+ Hand. 7f Flat G/F (F) 13 of 14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Compton Arrow A Nicholls D Nicholls 1 f 2 sw Sarraaf R Winston I Semple 2 f 2 sw Prix Star J Fanning Fairhurst 3 f 4 sw Mr Bountiful C Catlin M Dods 4 f 3 sw Smith N Allan Oils PJ Scallan M Dods 5 f 2 sw Bulawayo G Gibbons McMahon 6 f 5 sw Tantric JD O'Reilly (7) J O'Reilly 7 f 1 sw Beauteous J Carroll A Berry 8 f 4 sw The Old Soldier A Beech (3) Dickman 9 f 1 sw Lord Of The East T Eaves (5) D Nicholls 10 0 Hurricane Coast D Allan (3) T Easterb. 11 0 Three Days In May A Culhane Channon 12 f 2 sw Phantom Flame K Dalgleish Johnston 13 m 2 sw Time To Remember J Bramhill D Nicholls L Took no part / Blindfold left on.

1m 10f 11//28//13 11//13

Comments: Conditionals Eaves and Allan did not resort to the whip when their horses were under pressure. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Yarmouth 2.20pm Class D 3y Maiden 7f Flat G/F (Firm) 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

In The Pink S Hitchcott (3) Channon 1 f 7 sw Exzilarating S Carson John.Houg 2 f 11 sw Able Mind M Hills W Haggas 3 f 8 sw Frieda Kahlo E Ahern G Wragg 4 f 5 sw Top Spot S Sanders C Brittain 5 f 8 sw Mutamared R Hills SB Suroor 6 mf 7 sw Central Command Dane O'Neill DJ Daly 7 mf 4 sw

2m 7f 7//50//7 7//7

Comments: Carson hit his horse eleven times in the final two furlongs. Plenty of whip shown to these maiden horses.

Tuesday 21st October 2003 Yarmouth 2.50pm Class D 2yNovStk. 7f Flat G/F (Firm) 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Ouija Board JP Spencer E Dunlop 1 0 sw Rydal E Ahern GA Butler 2 f 2 Naaddey S Hitchcott (3) Channon 3 f 2 sw Ticero S Sanders C Brittain 4 0 Stanley Crane R Hills B Hanbury 5 f 2 Go Yellow N Callan PD Evans 6 f 2 sw

4f 4//8//6 3//6

Comments: Ahern hit his horse without showing the whip, Rydal veered right and nearly brought down Naaddey. Ahern hit his horse again and again he veered right. No whip show from Hills. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Yarmouth 3.20pm Class D 3y+Hand. 1m 2f Flat G/F (Firm) 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Sky Quest S Sanders PW Harris 1 f 7 sw Clarisse Dane O'Neill H Candy 2 f 7 sw International Guest S Hitchcott (3) Margarson 3 f 5 sw Astrocharm M Hills Tompkins 4 mf 11 sw Persian Pearl Steph. Hollinshead(7) Collingridg 5 0 Skehana D Kinsella (3) J Nicol 6 mf 3 sw Itchington A Daly Tregonning 7 f 1 sw Oopsie Daisy JP Spencer Fanshaw 8 f 1 sw Water Of Life Lisa Jones (3) JR Boyle 9 mf 4 sw Super Cannes R Hills G Wragg 10 m 3 sw

4m 8f 9//42//10 9//10

Comments: Sanders was hard upon his horse as Sky Quest went clear and was still hit. O'Neill hit his horse down the neck. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Yarmouth 4.20pm Class C 2yCondSk 6f Flat G/F (Firm) 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Rum Shot Dane O'Neill H Candy 1 0 sw Swinbrook Lisa Jones (3) JAR Toller 2 f 7 sw Compton's Eleven S Hitchcott (3) Channon 3 f 3 sw Convince JP Spencer M Stoute 4 f 3 sw Scotch N' Dry D Corby (3) Channon 5 f 4 sw Waterline Blue N Callan PD Evans 6 f 1 sw

5f 5//18//6 6//6

Comments: Lisa Jones hit her horse down the neck. Tuesday 21st October 2003 Yarmouth 4.50pm Class E 2yNursery 1m Flat G/F (Firm) 9 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Oddsmaker D Kinsella (3) PD Evans 1 f 5 sw Le Tiss S Hitchcott (3) Channon 2 f 2 sw Chariot E Ahern BW Hills 3 f 2 sw Bettys Tribute Lisa Jones (3) CA Dwyer 4 f 5 sw Sanbonah W Ryan Callaghan 5 f 2 sw Look No More PM Quinn W Turner 6 f 3 sw Bold Joe RL Moore P Mitchell 7 f 1 sw Badbh S Righton G Bravery 8 mf 4 sw His Wang Mu G Bardwell G Bravery 9 m 6 sw

2m 8f 9//30//9 9//9

Comments: All of these 2 year olds were whipped. Lisa Jones hit her horse down the neck as in the previous race. Bardwell was particularly hard upon his horse with high action strokes. Thursday 23rd October 2003 Brighton 2.20pm Class E 2yMaidAu 7f Flat Firm (G/F) 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Queenstown S Sanders B Meehan 1 f 3 sw Averlline D Kinsella (3) B de Haan 2 f 3 sw Disengage E Ahern GA Butler 3 f 5 sw Farriers Charm Martin Dwyer D Coakley 4 0

3f 3//11//4 3//4

Comments: Sanders did not need to hit his horse the final time as he was clear. Ahern hit his horse down the neck. Thursday 23rd October 2003 Brighton 2.50pm Class D 2yMaiden 1m Flat Firm (G/F) 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Billiard S Drowne R Charlton 1 f 9 sw Hathlen TE Durcan Channon 2 f 13 sw Concert Hall Dane O'Neill A Perrett 3 f 8 sw Dance Solo B Doyle M Stoute 4 f 7 sw Stanhope Forbes S Sanders Littmoden 5 f 6 sw Zalda D Sweeney R Charlton 6 0 Romeo's Day C Catlin Channon 7 0

5f 5//43//7 5//7

Comments: A two year old race where the first five saw plenty of the whip, most of which was from two furlongs out to the line. Thursday 23rd October 2003 Brighton 3.55pm Class C 3y+ Hand. 6f Flat Firm (G/F) 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Madrasse R Miles (5) Montg.Hall 1 f 7 sw Border Edge G Baker J Bridger 2 f 11 sw Esatto Dean McKeown P Blockley 3 f 12 sw Landing Strip FP Ferris (3) J Eustace 4 f 5 sw Alpen Wolf Martin Dwyer WR Muir 5 f 5 sw Jayanjay S Sanders B Sanders 6 f 6 sw Budelli D Corby (3) Channon 7 f 5 sw Byo S Whitworth M Quinn 8 f 1 sw Inch By Inch G Bardwell PJ Makin 9 f 6 sw Idle Power E Ahern JR Boyle 10 f 5 sw Sir Edwin Landseer S Drowne PFI Cole 11 f 6 sw Semenovskii JF Egan P d'Arcy 12 0

11f 11//69//12 11//12

Comments: Extensive use of the whip in this sprint race. Ferris had a high arm action. Thursday 23rd October 2003 Brighton 4.30pm Class E 3y+Stakes 1m Flat Firm (G/F) 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Deeper In Debt G Carter Akehurst 1 f 9 sw A Woman In Love S Drowne B Sanders 2 f 10 sw Temper Tantrum J-P Guillambert (5) A Reid 3 f 3 sw Grumpyintmorning P Dobbs Townsley 4 f 7 sw Second Of May M Fenton Charmings 5 f 2 sw Anemos R Miles (5) P d'Arcy 6 m 2 sw Copperfields Lass L Treadwell (7) W Turner 7 m 3 sw Shirley Oaks S Hitchcott (3) Z Davison 8 mf 3 sw Martin's Sunset R Mullen WR Muir 9 smf 3 sw Abuelos C Catlin S Dow 10 0 sw Geespot JF McDonald (5) ffrenchDav. 11 m 1 sw That’s Enough Martin Dwyer S Williams 12 0

1s 5m 7f 10//43//12 11//12 Thursday 23rd October 2003 Brighton 5.00pm Class F 3y+Ahand 1m 4f Flat Firm (G/F) 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Coup De Chance D Nolan P Blockley 1 0 Short Change Hayley Turner (3) A Carroll 2 f 11 sw Desert Island Disc R Miles J Bridger 3 f 3 sw Khuzdar B O'Neill (5) Channon 4 f 2 sw Gabor A Quinn GL Moore 5 f 4 sw Western M Coumbe (5) Akehurst 6 f 1 sw Scottish River N Chalmers MDI Usher 7 f 4 sw Lord Temuchin J-P Guillambert M Wallace 8 f 3 sw

7f 7//28//8 7//8

Comments: Eleven strikes of the whip from Turner. Strikes down the neck hands off the reins from Coumbe and O'Neill. Thursday 23rd October 2003 Brighton 5.30pm Class E 2yNursery 7f Flat Firm (G/F) 12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Russian Ruby D Fox (5) Callaghan 1 f 6 sw Nick's Grey Dane O'Neill R Hannon 2 f 9 sw City Affair S Sanders Prescott 3 f 11 sw Princess Ismene M Fenton J Jay 4 mf 5 sw Lady Mo D Kinsella (3) A Reid 5 f 6 sw Cloudingswell D Nolan (5) IA Wood 6 mf 7 sw Sinora Wood SD Sweeney N Dutfield 7 f 3 sw Mustang Ali JF Egan S Kirk 8 mf 7 sw Turnberry S Whitworth JW Hills 9 f 2 sw Head Boy P Doe S Dow 10 mf 3 sw Regulated E Ahern Osborne 11 mf 5 sw Maysie C Catlin B Powell 12 0

5m 11f 11//64//12 11//12 Monday 3rd November 2003 Redcar 1.10pm Class D 2yMaiden 7f Flat G/S 15 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Go Padero R Winston Johnston 1 f 1 sw Honest Injun M Hills BW Hills 2 f 6 sw Pergolacha E Ahern L Cumani 3 f 4 sw Pukka C Catlin L Cumani 4 f 1 sw Fossgate P Robinson J Bethell 5 f 6 sw Catalini A Culhane Channon 6 f 5 sw Charmatic F Norton JA Glover 7 0 sw Stiletto Lady M Fenton JG Given 8 f 4 sw Verasi S Drowne R Charlton 9 0 Elusive Dream S Sanders Prescott 10 m 3 sw Book Matched R Ffrench B Smart 11 mf 2 sw Salut Saint Cloud L Fletcher (3) V Haigh 12 mf 3 sw Ablaj K Fallon E Dunlop 13 m 2 sw Lawgiver J Carroll T Fitzgera. 14 f 1 sw Bein Good A Nicholls D Nicholls 15 m 2 sw

5m 10f 13//40//15 14//15

Comments: Down the neck strikes on these two year old newcomers came from Nicholls, Ffrench & Sanders. Sanders' strike was early in the race with hands off the reins. Not a very good example for Elusive Dream's introduction to racing. Monday 3rd November 2003 Redcar 1.40pm Class E 2yNursey 1m Flat G/S 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Freak Occurrence S Drowne E Lavelle 1 f 15 sw Bethanys Boy R Winston B Ellison 2 f 6 sw Zakfree J-P Guillambert Littmoden 3 f 4 sw Cartronageeraghlad K Fallon J Osborne 4 f 5 sw Beacon Blue P Robinson Johnston 5 mf 6 sw Almond Willow SW Kelly J Noseda 6 f 9 sw Eboracum D Allen (3) T Easterby 7 f 7 sw Classic Event E Ahern T Easterby 8 mf 4 sw Blue Empire L Enstone (3) P Haslam 9 mf 2 sw Riley Boys M Fenton JG Given 10 f 5 sw Infidelity A Culhane A Bailey 11 0 Carte Noire R Ffrench J Portman 12 m 1 sw Billiard R Hughes R Charlton 13 0 Hearthstead Dream M Hills Johnston 14 m 3 sw Glendale J Carroll CA Dwyer 15 m 1 Stanhope Forbes S Sanders Littmoden 16 m 1 sw

7m 10f 14//69//16 13//16

Comments: Far too much whipping of these young horses. Carroll hit Glendale down the neck hand off the reins without showing the horse the whip. Drowne and Kelly 24 strikes between them. Monday 3rd November 2003 Redcar 2.10pm Class D 3yMaiden 1m 2f Flat G/S 13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Grooms Affection M Fenton PW Harris 1 f 7 sw Fine Palette W Ryan HRA Cecil 2 f 4 sw Sentry R Hughes J Gosden 3 mf 9 sw Allied Victory E Ahern EJ Alston 4 f 9 sw Calonnog Paul Eddery HRA Cecil 5 mf 3 sw So Vital R Price L Pearce 6 mf 8 sw Suerte S Sanders JG Given 7 mf 5 sw Star M Hills BW Hills 8 m 3 sw Silent Comfort A Culhane BW Hills 9 m 1 sw Crystal Choir S Drowne R Charlton 10 0 Dombeya F Norton J Gosden 11 0 Wentbridge Boy V Halliday J O'Reilly 12 m 4 sw Blue Maeve R Winston Hetherton 13 0

7m 7f 10//53//13 10//13

Comments: Hughes hit his horse down the neck. Halliday hit his horse four times. The horse was totally out of contention, when he struck Wentbridge Boy twice down the neck, with hand off the reins. This incedent should have seen action taken by the stewards against the shocking riding of Halliday. An extremely poor ride where a tired horse was whipped after he had led and been prominent until 3f out and was tiring rapidly, on what was only his second racecourse appearance. Monday 3rd November 2003 Redcar 2.40pm Class C 3y+Hand. 6f Flat G/S 15 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

CD Europe N Callan KA Ryan 1 f 3 sw Steel Blue A Culhane Whitaker 2 f 6 sw Million Percent K Fallon KR Burke 3 f 6 sw Watching S Sanders D Nicholls 4 f 15 sw Najeebon S Hitchcott (3) Channon 5 f 4 sw Consensus T Williams M Brittain 6 f 10 sw Cretan Gift TG McLaughlin Littmoden 7 f 11 sw Queens Rhapsody C Catlin A Bailey 8 0 Abbajabba R Hughes Fairhurst 9 f 3 sw Sundried Tomato L Fletcher (3) PW Hiatt 10 f 3 sw Lincoln Dancer A Nicholls D Nicholls 11 f 4 sw Matty Tun J Bramhill J Balding 12 0 sw Secret Pride M Hills BW Hills 13 f 2 sw Bond Playboy R Ffrench B Smart 14 m 2 sw Viewforth R Winston I Semple 15 0

1m 11f 12//69//15 13//15

Comments: Fletcher hit his horse down the neck hand off the reins. Sanders gave Watching a beating with the whip. 15 times the horse was whipped. A frantic action gave the horse no time to respond between whips. On no account should the stewards have let Sanders go unpunished for his brutal assault upon Watching. Monday 3rd November 2003 Redcar 3.10pm Class D 3y+Stake 5f Flat G/S 19 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Maktavish D McGaffin (3) I Semple 1 f 7 sw Soba Jones J Edmunds J Balding 2 f 7 sw Artie K Fallon T Easterby 3 f 6 sw Strensall R Fitzpatrick RE Barr 4 f 6 sw Regal Song R Winston Etheringt. 5 f 4 sw Catch The Cat T Eaves (5) Wainwrig. 6 f 2 sw Paddywack A Culhane D Chapm. 7 0 sw Piccled D Allan (3) EJ Alston 8 f 6 sw Dancing Mystery S Carson E Wheeler 9 f 2 sw Obe One F Norton A Berry 10 m 1 sw Shouting The Odds M Fenton JG Given 11 mf 8 sw The Fisio Martin Dwyer A Balding 12 f 3 sw Safranine PP Mathers (7) A Stokell 13 f 1 sw Park Star JF McDonald (5) D Shaw 14 m 2 sw Nemo Fugat A Nicholls D Nicholls 15 m 2 sw Bollin Janet S Sanders T Easterby 16 m 2 sw Prince Of Blues Kirsty Mullineaux (7) Mullineaux 17 mf 2 sw Tick Tock Lisa Jones (3) Mullineaux 18 mf 3 sw Awake J Carroll D Nicholls 19 0

7m 13f 17//64//19 18//19

Comments: Plenty of whip used in this sprint race with 17 of the 19 runners being hit. Edmunds and Fitzpatrick hit their horses down the neck. Monday 3rd November 2003 Redcar 3.40pm Class E 3y+Hand. 1m 2f Flat G/S 16 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Talldark'N'Andsome TG McLaughlin Littmoden 1 mf 20 sw Hiawatha D McGaffin (3) I Semple 2 f 15 sw Traveller's Tale M Fenton PW Harris 3 f 14 sw Intricate Web D Allan (3) EJ Alston 4 mf 10 sw True Companion J-P Guillambert Littmoden 5 mf 4 sw Konker P Aspell (5) M Reveley 6 f 1 sw Archie Babe LP Keniry (3) JJ Quinn 7 mf 8 sw Rotuma R Winston M Dods 8 f 1 sw Classic Role D Sweeney R Ingram 9 mf 4 sw Edmo Yewkay K Fallon T Easterby 10 m 2 sw Ovigo D Nolan (5) P Blockley 11 f 3 sw Ruby Legend A Culhane M Reveley 12 0 Cuddles S Sanders C Brittain 13 m 1 sw Graft Dale Gibson M Easterb. 14 0 Ceol Na Sraide T Eaves(5) B Rothwell 15 0 Kincob S Drowne J Nicol 16 m 3 sw

8m 10f 13//86//16 13//16

Comments: A shocking 59 strikes of the whip on the first four by McLaughlin, McGaffin, Fenton and Allan which should have seen them in front of the stewards. Handicappers would seem to receive an excessive amount of whipping that should not be be tolerated by racing's ruling body. Monday 3rd November 2003 Redcar 4.10pm Class D 2yMaiden 7f Flat G/S 14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Zeitgeist E Ahern L Cumani 1 f 8 sw Tenny's Gold M Hills BW Hills 2 f 7 sw Messe De Minuit S Drowne R Charlton 3 mf 3 sw Baboushka P Robinson CG Cox 4 f 2 sw Bakhtyar S Sanders R Charlton 5 f 1 sw Duncanbil S Righton RF Fisher 6 f 3 sw Ctesiphon M Fenton JG Given 7 f 1 sw Saratoga Splendour R Ffrench J O'Keeffe 8 f 3 sw Royal Nite Owl V Halliday J O'Reilly 9 mf 4 sw Quintillion J McAuley Etheringt. 10 f 1 sw Scots Guard W Ryan JG Given 11 f 1 sw Smart Danny R Winston JJ Quinn 12 0 Willhego N Pollard JR Best 13 0 Sheliak J Bramhill B Rothwell 14 mf 2 sw

3m 12f 12//36//14 12//14

Comments: Young horses with very few runs between them. Much use of the whip was made particularly by Ahern. Whilst Ffrench and Halliday hit their horses down the neck, hand off the reins. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Uttoxeter 2.00pm Class E 5y+NovCh 3m 2f NH Chase G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Punchy AP McCoy MC Pipe 1 f 8 sw Benrajah A Dobbin Todhunter 2 mf 7 sw Cyanara J Mogford Pritchard 3 sm 4 sw Reasonable Reserve TJ Murphy BG Powell U 0 sw

1s 2m 2f 3//19//4 4//4

Comments: McCoy hit his mount eight times between the last two fences. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Uttoxeter 2.35pm Class E 4-6yNovHu2m NH Hurdle G/F 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Gigs Bounty TJ Murphy M Pitman 1 f 8 sw Wyn Dixie AP McCoy MC Pipe 2 f 3 sw Kindle Ball Mr S Thomas (7) V 3 f 3 sw Daisy Dale R Greene K Bishop 4 0 Oh So Posh W Hutchinson (3) A Thorpe P 0 Master Jackson R Walford (3) T Walford P 0

3f 3//14//6 3//6 Wednesday 15th October 2003 Uttoxeter 3.10pm Class D 4y+HcHur 2m NH Hurdle G/F 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Red Sun AP McCoy J Mackie 1 0 Waterspray H Oliver J Spearing 2 m 2 Spandau F Keniry JC Tuck 3 m 4

2m 2//6//3 0//3

Comments: Neither Oliver or Keniry showed their horses the whip before hitting them. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Uttoxeter 3.45pm Class G 4-7CJSell 2m4.5f NH Hurdle G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Doucer Des Songes JE Moore (3) MC Pipe 1 mf 20 sw Cliquey D Kozak (8) O Sherwo. 2 f 1 sw Lord Brex James Davies J O'Shea 3 m 2 sw Amaraku S Crawford (3) A Forbes 4 0

2m 2f 3//23//4 3//3

Comments: Moore hit his horse 20 times in this conditional jockeys race. He did not set a good example, with ten hits from the last two fences. Earlier in the race he hit the horse with his right whip hand and the horse moved left and hit the rail. Moore hit the horse again with the whip in his right hand a couple of strides later. This is alarming to say the least. The horse jinked away from the whip significantly on the run-in. The mare clearly did not respond to being hit and looked distressed when whipped. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Uttoxeter 4.20pm Class E 5y+NovHc 2m 4f NH Chase G/F 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Mister Club Royal G Lee D McCain 1 f 9 sw Grouse Hall A Ross Todhunter 2 f 11 sw Shafts Chance A Tinkler (5) C Egerton F m 1 sw Serious Position T Doyle Stoddart P 0 Sorely Missed B Hitchcott R Dickin P sm 3 sw

1s 2m 2f 4//24//5 4//5

Comments: Hitchcott appeared to hit his horse down the neck with his hands off the reins. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Uttoxeter 4.55pm Class H 4-6yNHFt 2m NH Flat G/F 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Lancier D'Estruval J Mogford JC Tuck 1 mf 10 sw Tails I Win Mr J Mead (5) J Mullins 2 0 Springbrook Girl R Greene AG Hobbs 3 mf 7 sw Earls Rock DR Dennis Cresswell 4 mf 8 sw Alleged Affair R Hobson (5) BD Leavy 5 m 2 sw Just Lambrini G Lee D McCain 6 mf 4 sw Double Emblem M Bradburne BR Foster 7 m 1 sw

6m 4f 6//32//7 6//7

Comments: Many of these horses were having their first race under rules. Mogford was keen with the whip on his newcomer. Bradburne clearly hit his mare down the neck hands off. Only Mr Mead, riding his own horse, did not resort to the whip. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Uttoxeter 5.25pm Class E 5y+HcCh 2m NH Chase G/F 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Nick The Jewel P Hide JS King 1 0 sw Minster York K Renwick Hammond 2 mf 13 sw River Styx G Lee D McCain 3 f 5 sw

1m 2f 2//18//3 3//3

Comments: Renwick appeared to hit his horse down the neck with his hands off the reins. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Wetherby 2.20pm Class D 3yJuv Nov. 2m NH Hurdle Firm (G/F) 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Mezereon Antony Evans (3) D Carroll 1 f 5 sw Red Wizard L Cooper JJ O'Neill 2 f 6 sw Banningham Blaze R Thornton CR Dore 3 f 7 sw Chemicalreaction P Whelan (3) RA Fahey 4 f 6 Hollywest B Harding Sowersby 5 m 2 Regal Vintage R McGrath C Grant P 0

1m 4f 5//26//6 3//6

Comments: Neither Whelan or Harding showed their horses the whip before hitting them. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Wetherby 2.55pm Class D 4y+ Maid. 2m NH Hurdle Firm (G/F) 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Blushing Prince B Fenton L Stubbs 1 f 4 sw Scippit DC Costello (7) N Waggott 2 f 5 sw Analyze JP McNamara B Powell 3 0 Santiburi Lad DN Russell N Wilson 4 0 Kittylee A Thornton Buckley 5 0

2f 2//9//5 2//5 Wednesday 15th October 2003 Wetherby 3.30pm Class B 4y+Hand. 2m NH Hurdle Firm (G/F) 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Gimmick L Cooper 1 f 8 sw Rigmarole N Carter (7) 2 f 6 sw First Ballot Mr O Nelmes (7) 3 f 5 sw Ei Ei G Berridge (7) 4 f 5 sw Virgin Soldier JP McNamara 5 0 sw Domenico R Johnson 6 f 3 sw Mister Chisum P Aspell (3) 7 0

5f 5//27//7 6//7

Comments: Cooper gave his horse eight strikes of the whip from the last fence to the line. He was particularly vigorous with a high arm action and hard hitting in his strikes, Gimmick had little time to respond between strokes. The stewards should have looked into Cooper's riding. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Wetherby 4.05pm Class D 4y+Hand. 2m 4.5f NH Hurdle Firm G/F 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Mantilla WA Worthington (7) I Williams 1 0 Nip On D O'Meara (3) JR Turner 2 0 sw Gabla R Spate (10) RC Guest 3 f 1 sw

1f 1//1//3 2//3

Comments: All conditional jockeys and a minimum use of the whip. Despite Nip On being tailed off for most of the race and Gabla barely getting the trip, the whip was not used as a threatening tool to get the most out of these horses. The jockeys' peers could learn from this. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Wetherby 4.40pm Class D 4y+Nov.H 2m 4.5f NH Hurdle Firm G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Nandoo R Johnson Hammond 1 0 El Cordobes D Flavin (5) J Buckley 2 f 7 sw Schoolhouse Walk B Harding Sowersby 3 f 2 sw Thoralby R McGrath M Dods 4 mf 7 sw

1m 3f 3//16//4 3//4

Comments: Thoralby having his first run over hurdles and 688 days off the course could have done with more careful handling to boost his confidence. A green horse running against seasoned opposition swished his tail when hit. Wednesday 15th October 2003 Wetherby 5.15pm Class F 3y+ Nov. 3m 1f NH Hurdle Firm (G/F) 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Bolton Barrie R Spate (10) RC Guest 1 f 1 sw Hurricane Bay A Dobbin PD Niven 2 mf 12 sw Lucky Nomad R McGrath R Ford 3 f 10 sw Impero M Nicolls (7) W Clay 4 f 4 sw

1m 4f 4//27//4 4//4

Comments: Dobbin clearly hit his horse down the neck with his hands off the reins. This happened in front of the stands and in view of the stewards. He also hit Hurricane Bay eight times from the last two hurdles, as did McGrath on his horse. Hurricane Bay was tongue tied. Conditional jockey Spate held his horse together, showing a skill lacking amongst many professionals. The stewards at Wetherby should have looked into Dobbin's use of the whip, and failed in their duty, yet again, to enforce the rules of racing. Saturday 18th October 2003 Market Rasen 1.50pm Class G 4y+Hand. 2m 1.5f NH Hurdle G/F 9 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Cork Harbour TJ Murphy P Bowen 1 0 Lone Soldier VT Keane (3) SB Clark 2 f 4 sw Master Gatemaker James Davies (5) F Murtagh 3 0 sw Invitado G Lee TJ FitzGe. 4 f 1 sw Amber Lilly B Hitchcott ST Lewis 5 f 9 sw Bachelors Pad T Burrows (10) SJ Wilton 6 mf 5 sw Magic Box DN Russell K Milligan 7 0 sw Maunby Roller D Harold (10) K Morgan 8 m 1 sw Fryup Booster A Dempsey P Midgley F 0

2m 4f 5//20//9 7//9

Comments: Hitchcott was hard on Amber Lilly a horse that had been off the course for 476 days. He hit the horse down the neck with his hands off the reins. Saturday 18th October 2003 Market Rasen 2.25pm Class D 4y+Hand. 2m 6f NH Hurdle G/F 2 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Val De Fleurie T Doyle J O'Shea 1 0 Jamaican Flight A Dempsey Lamyman 2 mf 13 sw

1m 1f 1//13//2 1//2

Comments: Dempsey rode a very poor race hitting his horse 13 times, of which a number were down the neck and clearly seen. Saturday 18th October 2003 Market Rasen 3.00pm Class C 4y+Nov. 2m 1.5f NH Chase G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Atum Re T Doyle P Webber 1 0 Golly Mr J Diment (7) D William 2 0 sw Papua James Davies (5) J White 3 0 Polish Pilot R Hobson (5) J Cornwall 4 0 sw

0//0//4 2//4

Comments: It appeared that no horses were whipped during this race. Saturday 18th October 2003 Market Rasen 3.35pm Class C 5y+Hand. 3m 1f NH Chase G/F 2 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Virgin Soldier JP McNamara Swinbank 1 0 Divet Hill Mr D Jewett (7) Hamilton 2 0 sw

0//0//2 1//2

Comments: Sensible riding with no whipping. Saturday 18th October 2003 Market Rasen 4.10pm Class E 4y+Maid. 2m 3.5f NH Hurdle G/F 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Araglin N Fehily SJ Wilton 1 f 1 sw Lady Laureate B Fenton G Bravery 2 f 3 sw Roppongi Dancer A Dempsey Macauley 3 mf 11 sw Cliquey JE Moore (5) O Sherwd. 4 mf 7 sw Courtyard A Pogson (7) Featherst. Pm 2 sw

3m 4f 5//24//5 5//5

Comments: Demspey hit his horse more than once down the neck with his hands off the reins. The horse clearly did not like being hit and changed his legs because of this. Roppongi Dancer was also tongue tied. Saturday 18th October 2003 Market Rasen 4.45pm Class E 5y+Hand. 2m 6.5f NH Chase G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Step Quick TJ Murphy 1 0 Mr Laggan DN Russell 2 0 Bella Mary A Pogson (10) 3 f 1 sw The Hearty Joker James Davies (5) 4 0 sw

1f 1//1//4 2//4

Comments: Sensible riding given to these horses who required a confidence boost from their previous races. Saturday 18th October 2003 Market Rasen 5.20pm Class H 4-6yMaid. 2m 1.5f NH Flat G/F 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Marsh Run G Carenza (5) M Easterb 1 0 sw Society Affair Mr KE Power (7) JJ O'Neill 2 f 1 sw County Classic R Garritty T Easterb. 3 0 Willywont He VT Keane (3) P Midgley 4 f 1 sw Thixendale D Elsworth M Easterb 5 f 1 sw Queensland Bay D O'Meara (3) T Easterb. 6 m 1 sw Fizzy Pop MH Naughton (3) Cunningh. 7 m 1 sw Scolt Head Mr T Greenall (7) M Easterb 8 m 1 sw

3m 3f 6//6//8 7//8

Comments: Once beaten in the race, the use of the whip was withheld. However, Naughton did appear to hit his horse down the neck with his hands off the reins earlier in the race. Monday 20th October 2003 Plumpton 2.05pm Class F 4y+Claim. 2m NH Hurdle G/F 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Double Blade James Davies (5) N Wilson 1 0 sw Blue Streak AP McCoy GL Moore 2 mf 5 sw L'Etang Bleu JE Moore (5) MC Pipe 3 m 4 sw Karakum Mr. S Thomas (7) Chamberl. 4 m 1 sw Brady Boys MA FitzGerald J O'Shea 5 m 3 sw

4m 1f 4//13//5 5//5 Monday 20th October 2003 Plumpton 2.35pm Class D 4y+ Hand. 3m 1.5f NH Hurdle G/F 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Maidstone Monument S Durak A Thorpe 1 f 4 sw Bush Park A Thornton RH Alner 2 mf 4 sw General Claremont J Tizzard P Nicholls 3 m 4 sw

2m 2f 3//12//3 3//3 Monday 20th October 2003 Plumpton 3.05pm Class E 3y+Novice 2m NH Hurdle G/F 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Jewel Of India R Johnson PJ Hobbs 1 f 5 sw Figaro Du Rocher AP McCoy MC Pipe 2 mf 9 sw My Ace R Thornton H Dalton 3 m 1 sw Jayed W Hutchinson (3) Bradstock 4 m 1 sw Chapel Royale MA FitzGerald E William. 5 m 2 sw

4m 2f 5//18//5 5//5 Monday 20th October 2003 Plumpton 3.35pm Class E 4y+Novice 2m 5f NH Hurdle G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Comply Or Die AP McCoy MC Pipe 1 f 1 sw Kaparolo L Aspell A Perrett 2 f 1 sw Teorban N Fehily M Pitman 3 m 4 sw French Direction B Fenton R Rowe 4 m 3 sw

2m 2f 4//9//4 4//4 Monday 20th October 2003 Plumpton 4.05pm Class D 4y+NovHa 2m 1f NH Chase G/F 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Dunkerron R Johnson PJ Hobbs 1 f 7 sw Genuine Article S Durak M Pitman 2 f 2 sw Ambience Lady R Young (5) J Mullins 3 m 1 sw

1m 2f 3//10//3 3//3 Monday 20th October 2003 Plumpton 4.35pm Class H 4-6y Maid 2m 2f NH Flat G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Time To Reflect AP McCoy MC Pipe 1 f 2 sw Celtic Ruffian B Fenton R Rowe 2 f 1 Herecomesstanley M Nicholls (7) MF Harris 3 f 1 sw Sean At The Ivy J Tizzard P Nicholls 4 m 1

1m 3f 4//5//4 2//4

Comments: Fenton hit his horse down the neck with hands off reins. Monday 20th October 2003 Plumpton 5.05pm Class D 5y+Hand. 3m 2f NH Chase G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Misty Future AP McCoy V William. 1 0 sw Dirk Cove B Fenton R Rowe 2 0 sw Gigs Gambit N Fehily M Pitman 3 m 1 sw Valigan DR Dennis NB King 4 m 3 sw

2m 2//4//4 4//4 Thursday 23rd October 2003 Haydock 2.35pm Class E 4y+ConHa2m NH Hurdle G/F 10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsSho/Whip

Celebration Town P Robson (3) N Richards 1 0 sw Sun King P Aspell (3) M Reveley 2 f 5 sw Young Owen James Davies L Normile 3 f 5 sw Gargoyle Girl G Berridge (3) JS Goldie 4 mf 4 sw Dinofelis Antony Evans Brisbourne 5 f 4 sw Lady Stratagem DC Costello (5) EW Tuer 6 f 2 sw Protocol A Tinkler Lamyman 7 f 1 sw Greenacres Boy S Crawford (3) Mullineaux 8 f 3 sw Risky Way D Elsworth B Rothwell 9 f 1 sw Wise Tale P Whelan PD Niven 10 m 5 sw

2m 8f 9//30//10 10//10 Thursday 23rd October 2003 Haydock 3.05pm Class E 4y+MsNov2m 4f NH Hurdle G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsSho/Whip

Ragu DN Russell F Murphy 1 0 Cashel Dancer AP McCoy Brooksha. 2 f 5 sw Kansas City D McPhail MF Harris 3 f 5 sw Severn Belle P Madden (10) SJ Smith 4 f 1 sw

3f 3//11//4 3//4 Thursday 23rd October 2003 Haydock 3.40pm Class D 5y+Hand. 2m 6f NH Chase G/F 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsSho/Whip

Cassia Heights TJ Murphy Brooksha. 1 f 6 sw Left Bank A Dempsey M Reveley 2 mf 14 sw Keen To The Last W Marston SJ Smith 3 f 11 sw Business Class Mr O Nelmes (7) M Reveley 4 f 1 sw

1m 4f 4//32//4 4//4

Comments: Extensive use of the whip by Marston and Dempsey. Dempsey hitting his horse down the neck a number of times. Thursday 23rd October 2003 Haydock 4.10pm Class D 4y+Hand. 2m 7.5f NH Hurdle G/F 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Fishki's Lad B Harding EW Tuer 1 f 6 sw Sadler's Secret J Culloty AJ Deakin 2 f 7 sw Amberleigh House G Lee D McCain 3 f 6 sw Derring Bridge R Johnson SM John. 4 0 Random Harvest DC Costello (10) M Reveley 5 f 1 sw Excellent Vibes C Llewellyn Twist-Dav. 6 f 5 sw Vicars Destiny T Siddall (3) Lamyman 7 m 1 sw Star Councel A Ross B Rothwell 8 m 3 sw

2m 5f 7//29//8 7//8 Thursday 23rd October 2003 Haydock 4.45pm Class E 5y+Novice 2m NH Chase G/F 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Another Joker JM Maguire Needham 1 f 7 sw Seaquill DN Russell F Murphy 2 f 4 sw Old King Coal R McGrath R Ford 3 0 sw Son Of A Gun R Thornton Polglase 4 mf 3 sw Father Mulcahy G Lee D McCain 5 smf 9 sw Bentyheath Lane A Thornton Mullineaux 6 0 sw

1s 2m 4f 4//23//6 6//6

Comments: Lee hit his horse at all stages of the race. Thursday 23rd October 2003 Haydock 5.15pm Class D 4-7yNovice2m NHFBHurdleG/F G/F 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Rival Bidder D Elsworth SJ Smith 1 0 sw Atticus Finch R Walford (3) M Stirk 2 0 sw Pollensa Bay S Durack Brooksha. 3 f 2 sw

1f 1//2//3 3//3 Monday 3rd November 2003 Plumpton 1.00pm Class F 4y+CoJoHand. 2m5f NH Hurdle Good(G/S)13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Circle Of Wolves Brian Murphy M Gingell 1 f 7 sw Sloane Street JE Moore Scudamor. 2 mf 13 sw Diorama D Laverty (7) LA Dace 3 mf 11 sw Kroisis D Cosgrave (5) R Curtis 4 mf 5 sw Moss Run N Carter (5) A Jessop 5 smf 8 sw No Mercy C Murray (3) B Pearce 6 m 4 sw Oudalmuteena PJ Brennan CJ Gray 7 m 5 sw Aliabad G Richards (3) J O'Shea 8 m 2 sw Malbec A Day (3) Newton-S 9 0 Almanoso D Crosse R Curtis Pm 2 sw Walcot Lad C Bolger A Ennis Pm 3 sw Charnwood Street James Davies D Shaw Pm 4 sw Jardin Fleuri R Walford MC Pipe U 0

1s 10m 5f 11//64//13 11//13

Comments: Carter hit his horse early on down the neck. Moore and Laverty had twenty-four strikes between them with no chance of winning. Monday 3rd November 2003 Plumpton 1.30pm Class E 4y+Novice2m 5f NH Hurdle Good(G/S)11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Gigs Bounty TJ Murphy M Pitman 1 f 3 sw The Grey Butler D Cosgrave (10) B de Haan 2 f 2 sw Intymcginty S Durack N Chance 3 mf 2 sw East Hill T Best (5) G Balding 4 m 1 sw Bell Tor T Doyle Gandolfo 5 0 sw Gray's Eulogy M Foley Gandolfo 6 f 1 sw Coombe Gold L Aspell N Gifford 7 0 sw Jollyshau C Bolger (5) Newton-S 8 m 1 sw Itchintogo M Batchelor LA Dace 9 0 sw Collective Dream BJ Crowley R Curtis 10 m 2 sw Dervalloc P Hide Winkworth 11 m 4 sw

5m 4f 8//16//11 11//11 Monday 3rd November 2003 Plumpton 2.00pm Class D 5y+ Hand. 2m 4f NH Chase Good(G/S)5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

The Newsman L Aspell Wareham 1 0 sw Bush Park A Thornton RH Alner 2 m 2 sw Falcon Du Coteau N Fehily CJ Mann 3 m 5 sw Canadiane AP McCoy MC Pipe 4 m 8 sw Noble Justice MA FitzGerald R Hodges Pm 4 sw

4m 4//19//5 5//5 Monday 3rd November 2003 Plumpton 2.30pm Class F 4y+Claim. 2m NH Hurdle Good(G/S)10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Greensmith Lane Miss E Jones (3) Llewellyn 1 f 6 sw My Sharp Grey AP McCoy MC Pipe 2 f 2 sw Fortune Point L Aspell A Carroll 3 f 4 sw Cliquey JA McCarthy Sherwood 4 mf 3 sw Mulabee J Mogford R Philips 5 0 sw Ressource JE Moore (5) G Moore 6 mf 8 sw Hazy Morn R Walford (3) R Hodges F 0 Sharp Spice Mr J Diment (7) D Williams P 0 Violent J Goldstein Newton-S P 0 Faraway John C Bolger (5) G Enright P 0

2m 5f 5//23//10 6//10

Comment: Moore hit his horse down the neck and McCarthy had a high arm action when whipping. Monday 3rd November 2003 Plumpton 3.00pm Class D 5y+NovHan. 3m 2f NH Chase Good(G/S)5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Radcliffe T Doyle V Williams 1 0 Colonial Sunset A Thornton A Whiting 2 0 sw Lost In Normandy P Flynn L William. 3 mf 10 sw Cush Jewel G Richards (5) J O'Shea F 0 Mr Nemo AP McCoy E Williams Pm 2 sw

2m 1f 2//12//5 3//5

Comment: Flynn's whipping had no relevance to the outcome of the race. Monday 3rd November 2003 Plumpton 3.30pm Class E 5y+ Hand. 2m 4f NH Chase Good(G/S)4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Reach The Clouds P Flynn J Upson 1 0 sw Harik JE Moore (5) G Moore 2 mf 14 sw Deich An Dorais MA FitzGerald Henderson 3 f 4 sw Renaloo B Fenton R Rowe Pm 1 sw

2m 2f 3//19//4 4//4

Comments: Fourteen strikes from Moore is unacceptable. Monday 3rd November 2003 Plumpton 4.00pm Class H 4-6yMaid. 2m 2f NH Flat Good(G/S)12 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Bramlynn Brook BJ Crowley V Williams 1 f 6 sw Celtic Major L Cooper JJ O'Neill 2 f 6 sw Northaw Lad MA FitzGerald Lidderdale 3 f 1 sw Gin And Terimonic L Aspell Winkworth 4 f 1 sw Little Ed T Doyle P Webber 5 mf 4 sw L'Archer L Barber (7) A Jessop 6 0 sw Semi Precious N Fehily D Keane 7 f 2 sw Victory Bell A Thornton AP Jones 8 m 1 sw Ballofasop JE Moore (5) A Whiting 9 0 sw Empress Of China C Bolger (5) SuzySmith 10 m 4 sw Major Bob P Hide G Enright 11 0 Trooper Kit M Bradburne L Richards F 0 sw

3m 6f 8//25//12 11//12 Monday 3rd November 2003 Warwick 1.20pm Class E 5y+ Hand. 2m 0.5f NH Chase G/F(Firm) 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Newick Park B Hitchcott R Dickin 1 f 6 sw Sharp Steel DR Dennis S Wilton 2 f 6 sw Wot No Cash M Nicolls (7) R Harper 3 f 5 sw Dunkerron R Johnson PJ Hobbs 4 mf 5 sw How Ran On T Scudamore L William. 5 f 6 sw Sacrifice Mr G Barfoot-Saunt(5)K Bishop 6 0 Son Of A Gun R Thornton Polglase P 0 Baron Aron R Greene B Pollock Pm 1 sw

2m 5f 6//29//8 6//8

Comments: Hitchcott hit his horse down the neck, hand off the reins. Monday 3rd November 2003 Warwick 1.50pm Class E 3y Novice 2m NH Hurdle G/F(Firm) 9 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Caroubier P Moloney I Williams 1 0 La Rose R Thornton JW Unett 2 mf 9 sw Door Of Knowledge M Nicolls (7) MF Harris 3 mf 5 sw Coctail Lady R Johnson BW Duke 4 0 sw Ziet D'Alsace J Culloty A Carroll 5 mf 4 sw Mytton's Quest D Gater (10) L William. 6 0 sw Roches Fleuries A Tinkler (5) A Turnell 7 m 2 sw Chandelier S Curran Saunders P 0 Inca Moon W Marston Brotherton Pm 1 sw

5m 3f 5//21//9 7//9 Monday 3rd November 2003 Warwick 2.20pm Class C 4y Novice 2m 0.5f NH Chase G/F(Firm) 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Look Collonges Jacques Ricou G Macaire 1 f 1 sw Saint Esteben J Tizzard P Nicholls 2 f 3 sw Bude JM Maguire Brookshaw 3 s 2 sw

1s 2f 3//6//3 3//3 Monday 3rd November 2003 Warwick 2.50pm Class E 4y+ Hand. 2m NH Hurdle G/F(Firm) 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Short Change R Johnson A Carroll 1 f 3 sw French Mannequin A Tinkler (5) H.-Fairley 2 mf 3 sw Ridapour W Marston D Wintle 3 mf 4 sw Afadan J Culloty J Jenkins 4 0 Three Lions R Hobson (5) Brookshaw 5 m 2 sw

3m 3f 4//12//5 4//5 Monday 3rd November 2003 Warwick 3.20pm Class E 4y+Novice 3m 1f NH Hurdle G/F(Firm) 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Petite Margot C Llewellyn Tw.-Davies 1 0 sw Manhunter W Marston P Bowen 2 mf 10 sw Farmer Josh J Pritchard (7) LV Davis 3 m 2 sw Spider Boy R Lucy-Butler (7) Z Davison 4 0

2m 1f 2//12//4 3//4 Monday 3rd November 2003 Warwick 3.50pm Class F 5y+Am.Hand.3m2f NH Chase G/F(Firm) 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Channahrlie Mr S Thomas (5) R Dickin 1 f 2 sw Pangeran Miss P Gundry NB King 2 f 4 sw Blazing Batman Dr P Pritchard DrPritchar. 3 mf 6 sw Sidewinder Mr TJ Malone (5) MC Pipe 4 m 5 sw River Styx Mr N Williams (5) D McCain 5 0 sw Miners Dance Mr C Studd (7) B Powell 6 0 sw

2m 3f 4//17//6 6//6 Monday 3rd November 2003 Warwick 4.20pm Class H 4-6y 2m NH Flat G/F(Firm) 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Zaffre R Lucey-Butler (7) Z Davison 1 0 sw Colnside Brook Mr G Baines (7) B Powell 2 f 6 sw Firstflor Mr P Cowley (7) F Jordan 3 f 8 sw Astral Affair Mr T Greenway (7) PA Pritch. 4 f 2 sw Freydis S Karnicnik (10) S Gollings 5 mf 6 sw Blow Me Down Mr J Owen F Jordan 6 mf 8 sw Mounts Bay Mr James White (7) R Hodges 7 f 5 sw Miss Quickly J Culloty HC Knight 8 m 2 sw Langcourt Jester R Thornton S Gilmore 9 m 1 sw Ellabury B Hitchcott R Dickin 10 m 4 sw Regal Empress T Scudamore CJ Price 11 m 2 sw

6m 6f 10//44//11 11//11 Tuesday 11th November 2003 Lingfield 1.00pm Class E 4y+Novice2m 7f NH Hurdle Good 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Classic China R Young (5) J Mullins 1 0 sw Rose Tea A Thornton N Graham 2 f 1 sw Julia's Choice R Johnson J Jenkins 3 mf 7 sw Eau Pure C Murray (7) B Pearce 4 f 7 sw Violent C Bolger (5) Newton-S 5 f 2 sw DD's Glenalla C Llewellyn Twis-Davie 6 m 2 sw Suzy Spitfire James Davies (5) B Powell Pm 2 sw

3m 4f 6//21//7 7//7

Comments: Murray hit his horse down the neck, hands off the reins. Young never resorted to the whip where others may have done. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Lingfield 1.30pm Class E 5y+Novice3m NH Chase Good(G/F)4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Stormy Skye JE Moore (5) GL Moore 1 f 7 sw Jongleur Collonges A Thornton RH Alner 2 f 3 sw Billy Ballbreaker J Tizzard C Tizzard 3 0 sw Pembroke Square F Keniry E Lavelle S 0

2f 2//10//4 3//4

Comments: Pembroke Square slipped up early on in the race. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Lingfield 2.00pm Class D 4-6y Nov. 2m 3.5f NH Hurdle Good 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Eric's Charm AP McCoy Sherwood 1 f 1 sw Unlocked R Johnson PJ Hobbs 2 f 2 sw A Glass In Thyne R Greene B Pollock 3 0 sw Tom's Gone Grey A Thornton RH Alner 4 0 sw Hurricane Dipper C Bolger (5) Newton-S 5 m 3 sw Ay Carumba C Murray (7) J Panvert Pm 3 sw

2m 2f 4//9//6 6//6

Comments: Murray hit his horse down the neck, hands off the reins, for the second time today. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Lingfield 2.30pm Class C 5y+ Hand. 2m NH Chase Good(G/F)6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Spring Grove A Thornton RH Alner 1 f 1 sw Selberry W Marston EL James 2 f 1 sw Toi Express R Johnson PJ Hobbs 3 f 8 sw Harik JE Moore (5) GL Moore 4 mf 5 sw Batswing AP McCoy B Ellison Pm 3 sw Jarro BJ Crowley V William. Um 3 sw

3m 4f 6//21//6 6//6

Comments: Johnson was by far the hardest in his use of the whip, including striking the horse down the neck. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Lingfield 3.00pm Class F 5y+Amat. 2m 4.5f NH Chase Good(G/F)3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Channahrlie Mr S Thomas (5) R Dickin 1 0 Mister Pickwick Mr S McHugh (7) GL Moore 2 m 4 sw Red Emperor Mr O Dayman (7) Pritchard 3 m 3 sw

2m 2//7//3 2//3 Tuesday 11th November 2003 Lingfield 3.30pm Class D 4y+ Hand. 2m 7f NH Hurdle Good 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

His Nibbs BJ Crowley V William. 1 mf 9 sw Joshua's Bay R Johnson J Jenkins 2 f 4 sw Igloo D'Estruval A Thornton L Taylor 3 0 sw Romero F Keniry Chamings 4 m 2 sw River Reine B Hitchcott R Buckley 5 mf 3 sw Renaloo James Davies (5) R Rowe 6 m 2 sw Commache General C Murray (7) J Panvert P 0

4m 3f 5//20//7 6//7 Tuesday 11th November 2003 Lingfield 4.00pm Class H 4-6yOpen 2m AWNHFlatStan.Poly.11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.WhipsNo. WhipsSho/Whip

Doca Vida R Johnson A King 1 f 3 sw Stanway C Llewellyn M Hambro 2 f 3 sw Viciana AP McCoy JW Payne 3 f 7 sw Petwick M Batchelor P Murphy 4 f 2 sw Master McNair G Richards (5) P Cundell 5 mf 3 sw The Wooden Spoon Mr JJ King (7) L Wells 6 f 5 sw Zaffre R Lucey-Butler (7) Z Davison 7 f 6 sw Unusual Suspect TJ Murphy M Pitman 8 sf 4 sw Jubba's Jester James Davies (5) B Powell 9 m 3 sw Spirit Of The Green Mr J Morgan (7) L Wells 10 f 6 sw Farewell Child C Bolger (5) SzySmith 11 f 2 sw

1s 2m 10f 11//44//11 11//11

Comments: An unusual NH Flat race run on an All Weather track. The majority of these horses were seeing a course for the first time. An appalling race where all of these young horses were hit. Johnson hit his horse down the neck twice with hands off the reins and Murphy hit his horse down the neck early on in the race. Morgan hit his horse when he was clearly out of contention on the turn into the straight and to the line. A word from the stewards should have been given. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Huntingdon 1.10pm Class E 4y+Novice2m 0.5f NH Hurdle G/F(Good)14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Dancer Life L Cooper JJ O'Neill 1 f 7 sw Zonergem L Aspell LadyHerri. 2 f 5 sw Gan Eagla A O'Keeffe (3) V William. 3 f 3 sw Danakil MA FitzGerald S Dow 4 m 3 sw Flaming Creek C Honour (7) Blackmor. 5 f 4 sw Anna Walhaan DR Dennis I Williams 6 0 sw Ripcord P Hide LadyHerri. 7 f 1 sw Wake Up Smiling B Fenton E Lavelle 8 m 1 sw Brilliantrio L Vickers (3) M Chapm. 9 0 sw Touch Of Spirit RCG Harris (10) J Jenkins 10 m 5 sw Bid Spotter JP McNamara Featherst. 11 0 sw Tareno P Moloney BJ Curley F 0 Diversity T Siddall(3) JJ O'Neill Pm 2 sw Istanbul N Fehily CJ Mann R 0

4m 5f 9//31//14 12//14

Comments: Tareno was sweating up. He took the lead early and was many lengths clear when he collapsed and died. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Huntingdon 1.40pm Class E 5y+Hand. 3m NH Chase G/F(Good)6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Supreme Arrow B Fenton E Lavelle 1 f 5 sw Strong Magic JA McCarthy J Cornwall 2 f 6 sw Flora Muck J Goldstein Twist-Davi. 3 f 3 sw Lord Broadway M Bradburne Babbage 4 f 1 sw Cromwell L Vickers (3) M Chapm. 5 m 7 sw Backscratcher P Flynn JR Upson 6 m 2 sw

2m 4f 6//24//6 6//6

Comments: Vickers hit his horse down the neck once. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Huntingdon 2.10pm Class D 3yJuvNov. 2m 0.5f NH Hurdle G/F(Good)8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No.Whips Sho/Whip

Dear Sir P Holley P Dutfield 1 f 3 sw Six Star Mr Ashley Price (7) BW Duke 2 mf 17 sw Niembro P Hide L Pearce 3 mf 7 sw Stokesies Boy P Flynn J Spearing 4 f 4 sw Stolen Song MA FitzGerald MJ Ryan 5 mf 5 sw April Miss L Aspell Wadham 6 m 2 sw Imperative R Thornton JW Unett 7 m 3 sw Williemind JP McNamara Featherst. Pm 1 sw

6m 5f 8//42//8 8//8

Comments: An appalling race where all the horses were whipped. Many of these were new to hurdling and only three years old. Dear Sir, the winner, was whipped by Holley when clear. Six Star, the runner up, was beaten in a shocking manner by Mr Ashley Price from the final fence to the line - 17 times in total, 15 from the last. The stewards should have certainly looked at his whip use. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Huntingdon 2.40pm Class C 5y+Hand. 2m 4.5f NH Chase G/F(Good) 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Poly Amanshaa J Culloty MC Banks 1 f 4 sw Rainbows Aglitter T Doyle Gandolfo 2 f 2 sw Top Buck JP McNamara KC Bailey 3 0 sw Mighty Montefalco L Cooper JJ O'Neill 4 0 sw

2f 2//6//4 4//4 Tuesday 11th November 2003 Huntingdon 3.10pm Class D 5y+Novice 2m 4.5f NH Chase G/F(Good) 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Palua B Fenton E Lavelle 1 f 1 sw Alvino J Culloty H Knight 2 f 2 sw Be My Friend R Thornton H Dalton F 0

2f 2//3//3 2//3

Comments: Fenton hit his horse down the neck. Tuesday 11th November 2003 Huntingdon 3.40pm Class D 4y+Hand. 2m 0.5f NH Hurdle G/F(Good) 8 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No.Whips Sho/Whip

Gabor P Hide GL Moore 1 f 3 sw Angels Venture RCG Harris (10) J Jenkins 2 f 8 sw Whaleef T Doyle P Webber 3 f 6 sw Castle River JP McNamara B Powell 4 f 1 sw Meltonian S Curran Clutterbuc. 5 f 1 sw Khaysar L Aspell Wadham 6 0 sw Agitando R Flavin (3) B de Hann F 0 sw Roppongi Dancer Miss EJ Jones (3) Macauley P 0 sw

5f 5//19//8 8//8 Thursday 13th November 2003 Ludlow 1.00pm Class G 4y+Selling 2m NH Hurdle G/F(Firm) 11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Saafend Rocket JP Byrne (3) HD Daly 1 0 sw Forzacurity JE Moore J Spearing 2 f 10 sw Karakum W Hutchinson Chamberl. 3 f 2 sw Batchelors Pad T Burrows (10) SJ Wilton 4 f 3 sw Oro Street S Peltell (7) Bridgewa. 5 0 sw Prayerful N Carter (5) BN Doran 6 mf 9 sw Magical Day PJ Brennan W Turner 7 f 4 sw Midnight Jazz G Richards J Harriman 8 m 6 sw Coq De Mirande A Tinkler K Marks R s 2 sw Springbok Attitude TJ Phelan Llewellyn P m 1 sw What A Racket A O'Keeffe DA Hamer P 0

1s 3m 5f 8//37//11 10//11

Comments: Claimer Byrne never hit his horse, yet Moore resorted to ten strikes for no benefit over the winner. Coq De Mirande refused to race, the whip proved pointless in trying to get him running. Thursday 13th November 2003 Ludlow 1.30pm Class E 5y+Novice 2m 4f NH Chase Firm(G/F) 7 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Medelai O McPhail AG Juckes 1 0 sw See More Snow PJ Brennan (5) W Turner 2 mf 7 sw Boxer's Double S Curran GA Ham 3 mf 4 sw Brady Boys G Richards (5) J O'Shea 4 0 sw Althrey R Hobson (5) Brisbourne F 0 sw Lime Stone Lass Matthew Smith (7) M Appleby P 0 Greenacres Boy RI Mackenzie (7) Mullineaux U 0

2m 2f 2//11//7 5//7

Comments: Brennan hit See More Snow down the neck twice with hand off the reins. Thursday 13th November 2003 Ludlow 2.00pm Class D 4-6y Nov. 2m NH Hurdle G/F(Firm) 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

My Ace R Thornton H Dalton 1 f 13 sw She's Our Native R Johnson PJ Hobbs 2 f 9 sw Beau Torero R Greene B Pollock 3 f 4 sw Lovers Tale S Fox Kavanagh 4 0 sw Just Lambrini JM Maguire D McCain P m 3 sw

1m 3f 4//29//5 5//5

Comments: Far too many strikes of the whip from Robert Thornton. Thursday 13th November 2003 Ludlow 2.30pm Class D 5y+ Hand. 3m NH Chase Firm(G/F) 5 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Tino PJ Brennan (5) JS King 1 f 7 sw Lord Seamus D Flavin (5) KC Bailey 2 f 5 sw Spread The Word R Walford (3) JG Cann 3 0 Dante's Battle A Tinkler (5) K Marks 4 0 sw Lord Youky R Johnson I Williams 5 f 1 sw

3f 3//13//5 4//5 Thursday 13th November 2003 Ludlow 3.00pm Class E 4y+ Maid. 2m 5f NH Hurdle G/F(Firm) 6 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Sunny Native R Thornton H Dalton 1 mf 15 sw Aliabad G Richards (5) J O'Shea 2 mf 14 sw Indian Beat R Walford (3) C Popham 3 f 1 sw Penalta Antony Evans (3) Brisbourne 4 mf 9 sw Pop Gun A Tinkler (5) K Marks P 0 sw Lancashire Lass PJ Brennan (5) JS King U mf 3 sw

4m 5f 5//42//6 6//6

Comments: Brennan hit his horse down the neck hand off the reins. Thornton and Richards showed their horses far too much whip. Thornton was still hitting Sunny Native when the horse was well clear of the others. Thursday 13th November 2003 Ludlow 3.30pm Class D 5y+NovHand.2m 2m NH Chase Firm(G/F) 3 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Lypharita's Risk J Mogford M Evans 1 0 sw Occam B Fenton A Bailey F 0 sw Sharp Steel N Fehily SJ Wilton F 0

0//0//3 2//3

Comments: No whipping but a tragic outcome for Occam and Sharp Steel, they fell at the last two fences and died. Thursday 13th November 2003 Ludlow 4.00pm Class H 4-6yInter 2m NH Flat G/F(Firm) 4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Spike Jones E Cooper (10) JJ O'Neill 1 0 sw Rye Brook A Honeyball (5) P Nicholls 2 m 5 sw Welsh Crystal R Hobson (5) L William. 3 m 4 sw Frightening Fred Antony Evans (3) Brisbourne 4 m 1 sw

3m 3//10//4 4//4

Comments: Hobson's whips were pointless as Welsh Crystal was isolated between horses. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Newton Abbot 1.00pm Class E 5y+NovHa.3m 2.5f NH Chase Good(G/S)11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Helixir Du Theil A Thornton R Buckler 1 f 3 sw See You Around R Young (5) JW Mullins 2 f 4 sw Jazz Duke PJ Brennan (3) Weeden 3 mf 6 sw Kittenkat Sophie Mitchell (3) N Mitchell 4 m 3 sw Big Max R Johnson K George 5 mf 5 sw Billy Ballbreaker J Tizzard C Tizzard 6 m 1 sw Tim's The Man N Fehily CJ Mann 7 0 No Sam No P Flynn Burrough F 0 Indoux R Thornton R Hodges F m 1 Little Herman M Bradburne JAB Old Pm 2 sw Onassis AP McCoy Sherwood Pm 1 sw

7m 4f 9//26//11 8//11

Comments: Robert Thornton didn't show Indoux the whip before hitting him. The horse fell shortly after at the next fence. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Newton Abbot 1.30pm Class EE 4-6yNovice2m 1f NH Hurdle Good(G/S)10 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Control Man AP McCoy MC Pipe 1 f 3 sw Il De Paris R Johnson PJ Hobbs 2 f 2 sw Blue Americo R Walsh P Nicholls 3 f 2 sw Bowleaze A Thornton RH Alner 4 0 sw Kildee Lass C Honour (7) JD Frost 5 f 1 sw Gaye Trigger J Culloty HC Knight 6 0 Percipient MA FitzGerald Gandolfo 7 0 Dante Citizen Mr P Callaghan (7) T George 8 m 1 sw Corrib Lad PJ Brennan (3) PJ Hobbs 9 m 1 sw Salliemak J Mogford A Wilson 10 m 1 sw

3m 4f 7//11//10 8//10

Comments: McCoy won this race by 12l. The use of the whip had little contribution to this win. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Newton Abbot 2.00pm Class DE 5y+Novice2m 5.5f NH Chase Good(G/S)9 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Strong Flow R Walsh P Nicholls 1 0 Kings Castle MA FitzGerald R Hodges 2 m 1 sw Dun An Doras R Flavin (3) JD Frost 3 0 sw Alcatras P Hide B Ryall 4 0 Polar Scout N Fehily CJ Mann 5 0 Kaluga P Flynn Burrough 6 m 2 sw New Leader M Bradburne L Richards 7 0 sw Caribbean Cove J Culloty HC Knight F 0 sw Billywill A Thornton J Mullins P 0

2m 2//3//9 5//9

Comments: All of these horses were strung out at the finish. 16l, 1l, dist, 11l, 22l, 22l. The whip was only used in the middle of the race. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Newton Abbot 2.30pm Class DD 4y+Hand. 2m 6f NH Hurdle Good(G/S)11 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Master Billyboy C Llewellyn S Williams 1 f 3 sw Tango Royal AP McCoy MC Pipe 2 f 8 sw Achilles Wings S Durak K George 3 f 7 sw Turtle Soup JM Maguire T George 4 f 2 sw D'Argent R Thornton A King 5 mf 13 sw Tesor Preziniere R Johnson PJ Hobbs 6 mf 4 sw Audiostreetdotcom T Best (5) G Balding 7 f 1 sw Howdydoody R Walsh P Nicholls 8 smf 11 sw Kattegat R Young (5) M Bridges 9 0 sw Maninga P Hide L Richards 10 m 1 sw Central Committee J Mogford R Phillips 11 0 sw

1s 4m 8f 9//50//11 11//11

Comments: Ruby Walsh gave Howdydoody far too much whip. Raising his arm high above his shoulder, he struck the horse six times down the neck with his hands off the reins. He was at the horse from the fourth until the end of the race. His arm action on his backhand strokes was over the shoulder. From an experienced jockey, at the fore in his profession, this was severe treatment of an animal who gives him his living. In our view, the stewards should have punished him severely. During the study, this was one of the worst cases recorded. What is more, the horse had not been out for 244 days. He was clearly under pressure and whipping down the shoulder could get no response. Why was this done? The whole of the race comes into question with, not only Walsh, but McCoy and Durak on the run-in and Robert Thornton with 13 strikes during the race, plus Johnson after the final bend, when his tired horse was hanging his tongue out, he was whipped with full force. Just because these horses are experienced handicappers, there should be no excuse to beat them to the line when the handicapper has done a good job in assessing their abilities. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Newton Abbot 3.00pm ClassClass DD 5y+Hand. 3m 2.5f NH Chase Good(G/S)4 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Master Of Illusion R Thornton R Lee 1 mf 37 sw Nativetrial N Fehily CJ Mann 2 mf 9 sw Commache Jim A Thornton RH Alner 3 mf 5 sw Possible Pardon R Johnson PJ Hobbs 4 mf 6 sw

4m 4f 4//57//4 4//4

Comments: Robert Thornton hit his horse a total of 37 times through the race. This number is unacceptable and should have been punished by the stewards who have failed, yet again, at this meeting to act on the rules of racing. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Newton Abbot 3.30pm Class E 4y+Hand. 2m 1f NH Hurdle Good(G/S)13 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh.No. Whips Sho/Whip

Celtic Star J Culloty N Williams 1 0 Ososhot M Batchelor AJ Wilson 2 f 2 sw Iambe De La See MA FitzGerald Henderson 3 0 Saby R Johnson PJ Hobbs 4 f 5 sw Bekstar S Durak JC Tuck 5 0 Fruit Defendu R Walsh P Nicholls 6 mf 4 sw Welcome To Unos AP McCoy MC Pipe 7 m 1 sw Mutadarra Miss RA Green (7) JW Mullins 8 mf 2 sw The Gene Genie J Tizzard RJ Hodges 9 0 sw Lord Fernando M Bradburne G Balding 10 m 2 sw Premier Generation J Mogford Pritchard Pm 2 sw Ifrane Balima F Keniry JC Tuck Pm 1 sw Polish Legend C Llewellyn B Millman F f 3 sw

6m 5f 9//22//13 10//13

Comments: Walsh high arm action and Green hit the horse down the neck, with hand off the reins. Polish Legend fell at the last hurdle, having been hit with the whip just before he looked to be shying from the whip, which was stuck out at a right angle to his head. His eye was clearly off the hurdle and on the whip, this must have contributed to the fall. Tuesday 18th November 2003 Newton Abbot 4.00pm Class H 4-6yOpen 2m 1f NH Flat Good(G/S)14 ran Horse Jockey Trainer Finish Ps. When Wh. No. Whips Sho/Whip

Accipiter T Best (5) G Balding 1 f 3 sw Roofing Spirit N Fehily DP Keane 2 mf 7 sw Wrags To Riches C Honour (7) JD Frost 3 mf 4 sw Trade Off AP McCoy MC Pipe 4 mf 15 sw Regal Bandit J Culloty HC Knight 5 0 sw Essex Bird C Llewellyn S Williams 6 0 sw Jacks Jewel J Tizzrad CJ Down 7 f 1 sw On Les Aura R Walford (3) RH Alner 8 mf 2 sw Pitminster Mr N Williams (7) P Nicholls 9 f 2 sw Alf Lauren W Hutchinson A King 10 0 sw Vito Andolini P Hide J Galpin 11 m 1 sw Lord Code A Thornton RH Alner 12 0 Miss Lewis MA FitzGerald CJ Down 13 0 sw Mr Don S Durak AM Thorpe 14 m 1 sw

6m 7f 9//36//14 13//14

Comments: Many of these were seeing the racecourse for the first time, and McCoy's horse Trade Off was one of those. He was particularly harsh with 15 strikes of the whip when the horse was clearly beaten and under pressure. Roofing Spirit swished his tail every time he was hit with the whip by Fehily and Hide hit his horse down the neck with his hand off the reins. Jockeys’ Record Data

Key to Layout and Abbreviations used in the Jockeys' Record tables.

Layout

Discipline • Tally of Jockeys • Jockey's Name • NHR • NHW • TNW • NHSW • M/NHR • M/NHW

Abbreviations

©: Jockey is an Apprentice, Conditional or Amateur NHR: Number of horses ridden NHW: Number of horses whipped TNW: Total number of whips NHSW: Number of horses shown the whip M/NHR: Mathematical mean whips for the number of horses ridden This is given only for those jockeys with four or more rides recorded M/NHW: Mathematical mean whips for the number of horses whipped Given only for those jockeys with four or more rides recorded Use of the Whip Jockeys' Record AW NHR NHW TNW NHSW M/NHR M/NHW

1 M Tebbutt 6 2 22 4 3.7 11 2 P McCabe 5 5 53 5 10.6 10.6 3 RL Moore 6 4 35 4 5.8 8.8 4 D Mernagh 6 6 51 6 8.5 8.5 5 F Norton 8 6 48 6 6 8 6 M Henry 5 5 34 5 6.8 6.8 7 S Whitworth 6 6 38 6 6.3 6.3 8 G Duffield 6 4 25 5 4.2 6.3 9 SW Kelly 16 14 85 14 5.3 6.1 10 A Culhane 12 6 35 6 2.9 5.8 11 M Fenton 16 14 80 13 5 5.7 12 L Dettori 7 6 34 6 4.9 5.7 13 JF Egan 7 7 39 7 5.6 5.6 14 D Sweeney 9 8 41 8 4.6 5.3 15 S Drowne 14 11 58 11 4.1 5.3 16 R Mullen 6 5 26 6 4.3 5.2 17 N Callan 9 9 46 9 5.1 5.1 18 R Hughes 5 4 19 5 3.8 4.8 19 G Gibbons 5 5 23 5 4.6 4.6 20 S Hitchcott © 6 5 23 6 3.8 4.6 21 L Fletcher © 9 7 32 6 3.6 4.6 22 D Allan © 6 4 18 4 3 4.5 23 Dane O'Neill 17 17 74 17 4.4 4.4 24 Darren Williams 7 7 31 7 4.4 4.4 25 LP Keniry © 9 9 39 9 4.3 4.3 26 E Ahern 4 3 13 4 3.3 4.3 27 J Tate 4 4 16 4 4 4 28 A Daly 4 3 12 3 3 4 29 J Bramhill 8 4 15 6 1.9 3.8 30 D Kinsella © 9 9 33 9 3.7 3.7 31 B Doyle 4 3 11 3 2.8 3.7 32 A Quinn © 4 4 14 4 3.5 3.5 33 FP Ferris © 8 8 27 8 3.4 3.4 34 R Miles © 9 9 31 9 3.4 3.4 35 J Mackay 4 3 10 2 2.5 3.3 36 J Fanning 8 3 10 8 1.3 3.3 37 Lisa Jones © 6 5 16 5 2.7 3.2 38 P Fitzsimons 4 3 9 3 2.3 3 39 J-P Guillambert © 7 5 13 6 1.9 2.6 40 P Doe 4 2 5 4 1.3 2.5 41 W Ryan 4 4 9 4 2.3 2.3 42 JF McDonald © 5 4 8 5 1.6 2 43 I Mongan 5 4 8 4 1.6 2 44 S Sanders 4 3 6 4 1.5 2 45 S Carson 5 2 3 2 0.6 1.5 46 C Catlin 7 4 5 4 0.7 1.3 47 D Nolan © 3 2 16 2 48 L Enstone © 3 3 17 3 49 R Ffrench 3 3 17 3 50 Paul Eddery 3 2 11 3 51 N Chalmers © 3 3 15 3 52 JD O'Reilly © 3 3 14 3 53 JP Spencer 3 3 14 3 54 Joanna Badger 3 3 13 3 55 J Carroll 3 3 10 3 56 A Nicholls 3 1 3 2 57 J Edmunds 3 3 9 3 58 Dean McKeown 3 3 9 3 59 P Mulrennan © 3 1 3 1 60 R Smith 3 2 5 2 61 A Clark 3 0 0 1 62 G Baker 2 2 15 2 63 D Corby © 2 2 14 2 64 K Dalgleish 2 1 6 2 65 D Fox © 2 2 12 2 66 C Cogan 2 1 6 1 67 N Chalmers © 2 2 9 2 68 P Hanagan 2 2 9 2 69 Dale Gibson 2 1 4 1 70 G Hannon 2 2 7 2 71 Steph. Hollinshead © 2 2 7 2 72 D Swift © 2 1 3 2 73 T Lucas 2 1 2 1 74 P Makin © 2 2 2 2 75 Mr E Dehdashti © 1 1 10 1 76 R Fitzpatrick 1 1 10 1 77 N Day 1 1 8 1 78 P Robinson 1 1 8 1 79 Ms C Williams © 1 1 7 1 80 Dean Williams © 1 1 7 1 81 TE Durcan 1 1 6 1 82 Martin Dwyer 1 1 6 1 83 R Hills 1 1 6 1 84 Saleem Golam © 1 1 6 1 85 Gemma Anderson © 1 1 5 1 86 P Bradley © 1 1 5 1 87 V Halliday 1 1 5 1 88 T Hamilton © 1 1 5 1 89 R Price 1 1 5 1 90 Kristin Stubbs© 1 1 5 1 91 Mr J King © 1 1 4 1 92 Kirsty Mullineaux © 1 1 4 1 93 B Reilly © 1 1 4 1 94 Mr S Walker © 1 1 4 1 95 Dawn Watson © 1 1 4 1 96 Mr G Bartley © 1 1 3 1 97 Mrs S Bosley © 1 1 3 1 98 Mr L Jefford © 1 1 3 1 99 PP Mathers © 1 1 3 1 100 M Savage © 1 1 3 1 101 S Yourston © 1 1 3 1 102 P Gallagher © 1 1 2 1 103 Mr B Haslam © 1 1 2 1 104 A McCarthy 1 1 2 1 105 D McGaffin © 1 1 2 1 106 Rory Moore © 1 1 2 1 107 S Righton 1 1 2 1 108 PJ Scallan 1 1 2 1 109 Kim Tinkler 1 1 2 1 110 Mr J Pemberton © 1 1 1 0 111 Miss F Guillambert © 1 1 1 1 112 L McVicar © 1 1 1 1 113 N Pollard 1 1 1 1 114 JD Smith 1 1 1 1 115 Laura-Jayne Crawford© 1 0 0 1 116 Mrs S Moore © 1 0 0 1 117 G Carter 1 0 0 0 118 P Dineley © 1 0 0 0 119 Mr J Millman © 1 0 0 0 120 A Rutter © 1 0 0 0

Total & Mean 442 361 1698 383 3.8 4.7 Use of the Whip Jockeys' Record Flat NHR NHW TNW NHSW M/NHR M/NHW

1 D McGaffin © 5 4 45 5 9 11.3 2 D Allan © 7 5 40 5 5.8 8 3 TE Durcan 7 6 43 6 6.1 7.2 4 P Robinson 13 11 76 11 5.8 6.9 5 G Baker 4 4 27 4 6.8 6.8 6 SW Kelly 6 5 33 5 5.5 6.6 7 R Hughes 13 11 70 12 5.4 6.4 8 J Bramhill 4 3 19 4 4.8 6.3 9 Dane O'Neill 18 15 93 17 5.2 6.2 10 W Supple 12 9 53 11 4.4 5.9 11 LP Keniry © 5 5 29 4 5.8 5.8 12 S Drowne 18 14 81 13 4.5 5.8 13 Pat Eddery 14 12 67 11 4.8 5.6 14 JF Egan 6 5 28 5 4.7 5.6 15 D Holland 6 6 33 5 5.5 5.5 16 M Fenton 13 12 66 12 5.1 5.5 17 M Hills 12 11 59 11 4.9 5.4 18 RL Moore 8 5 27 6 3.4 5.4 19 R Hills 10 10 51 9 5.1 5.1 20 Lisa Jones © 9 9 46 8 5.1 5.1 21 A McCarthy 4 4 20 3 5 5 22 S Sanders 20 18 90 18 4.5 5 23 D Nolan © 4 3 15 3 3.8 5 24 E Ahern 10 10 49 9 4.9 4.9 25 PJ Scallan 4 4 19 4 4.8 4.8 26 D Corby © 6 5 24 6 4 4.8 27 G Duffield 5 4 19 3 3.8 4.8 28 S Carson 5 4 19 4 3.8 4.8 29 Martin Dwyer 20 13 62 14 3.1 4.8 30 L Enstone © 4 4 18 4 4.5 4.5 31 N Callan 11 9 40 9 3.6 4.4 32 A Culhane 16 11 47 13 2.9 4.3 33 L Dettori 11 10 41 11 3.7 4.1 34 I Mongan 5 5 20 5 4 4 35 D Sweeney 6 5 20 5 3.3 4 36 JP Spencer 11 7 27 9 2.5 3.9 37 P Dobbs 6 6 23 5 3.8 3.8 38 FP Ferris © 4 4 15 4 3.8 3.8 39 D Kinsella © 7 6 23 6 3.3 3.8 40 S Hitchcott © 7 7 26 7 3.7 3.7 41 K Fallon 10 9 32 9 3.2 3.6 42 J-P Guillambert © 4 4 14 4 3.5 3.5 43 T Eaves © 9 6 21 5 2.3 3.5 44 R Winston 18 10 35 11 1.9 3.5 45 L Fletcher © 5 5 17 5 3.4 3.4 46 J Fanning 7 4 13 5 1.9 3.3 47 R Ffrench 8 8 25 8 3.1 3.1 48 R Smith 4 4 12 4 3 3 49 R Mullen 8 5 15 4 1.9 3 50 K Darley 10 6 18 8 1.8 3 51 A Nicholls 5 5 12 5 2.4 2.4 52 S Whitworth 6 5 12 4 2 2.4 53 Darren Williams 4 4 9 4 2.3 2.3 54 W Ryan 4 3 7 3 1.8 2.3 55 J Carroll 6 4 8 3 1.3 2 56 C Catlin 19 5 10 6 0.5 2 57 F Norton 9 5 6 7 0.7 1.2 58 D Fox © 3 3 30 3 59 P Fessey 3 3 18 3 60 G Gibbons 3 3 15 3 61 N Mackay © 3 2 10 2 62 P Hanagan 3 2 9 2 63 R Price 3 2 9 2 64 R Miles © 3 3 12 3 65 PJ Smullen 3 2 8 3 66 K Dalgleish 3 3 11 3 67 T Hamilton © 3 3 11 2 68 MJ Kinane 3 3 7 3 69 S Righton 3 3 9 2 70 A Daly 3 3 7 3 71 Paul Eddery 3 2 4 2 72 TG McLaughlin 2 2 31 2 73 JP Murtaugh 2 2 18 2 74 Hayley Turner © 2 2 13 2 75 G Bardwell 2 2 12 2 76 G Carter 2 2 12 2 77 R Fitzpatrick 2 2 11 2 78 N Day 2 2 11 2 79 V Halliday 2 2 8 2 80 P Dineley © 2 1 4 2 81 D Swift © 2 2 7 2 82 Kim Tinkler 2 2 6 1 83 P Bradley © 2 1 2 1 84 A Beech © 2 2 3 2 85 JF McDonald © 2 2 3 2 86 Dale Gibson 2 0 0 1 87 Dean McKeown 1 1 12 1 88 T Williams 1 1 10 1 89 Joanna Badger 1 1 7 1 90 B Doyle 1 1 7 1 91 J Edmunds 1 1 7 1 92 Natalia Gemelova © 1 1 6 1 93 Janice Webster © 1 1 5 1 94 N Chalmers © 1 1 4 1 95 P Fitzsimons 1 1 4 1 96 A Quinn © 1 1 4 1 97 P Doe 1 1 3 1 98 M Lawson © 1 1 3 1 99 D Mernagh 1 1 3 1 100 PM Quinn 1 1 3 1 101 L Treadwell © 1 1 3 1 102 J Mackay 1 1 2 1 103 Kirsty Mullineaux © 1 1 2 1 104 B O'Neill © 1 1 2 1 105 P Aspell © 1 1 1 1 106 M Coumbe © 1 1 1 1 107 CJ Davies © 1 1 1 1 108 PP Mathers © 1 1 1 1 109 J McAuley 1 1 1 1 110 JD O'Reilly © 1 1 1 1 111 Steph. Hollinshead © 1 0 0 0 112 J Jeffrey © 1 0 0 0 113 N Pollard 1 0 0 0 114 A Rutter © 1 0 0 0 115 J Tate 1 0 0 0 116 O Urbina 1 0 0 0

Total & Mean 594 480 2263 488 3.8 4.7 Use of the Whip Jockeys' Record NH NHR NHW TNW NHSW M/NHR M/NHW

1 A Dempsey 4 3 38 3 9.5 12.7 2 JE Moore © 10 9 88 10 8.8 9.8 3 R Thornton 13 11 103 10 7.9 9.4 4 R McGrath 4 2 17 3 4.3 8.5 5 L Cooper 5 4 27 5 5.4 6.8 6 G Richards © 6 4 25 5 4.2 6.3 7 G Lee 6 6 34 6 5.7 5.7 8 DR Dennis 4 3 17 4 4.3 5.7 9 R Walsh 4 3 17 3 4.3 5.7 10 W Marston 5 5 27 5 5.4 5.4 11 TJ Murphy 7 4 21 5 3 5.3 12 BJ Crowley 4 4 20 4 5 5 13 B Hitchcott 5 5 25 5 5 5 14 AP McCoy 20 18 86 19 4.3 4.8 15 Antony Evans © 4 4 19 4 4.8 4.8 16 PJ Brennan © 7 7 33 7 4.7 4.7 17 C Murray © 4 3 14 3 3.5 4.7 18 R Johnson 20 17 79 18 4 4.6 19 P Flynn 6 4 18 5 3 4.5 20 J Mogford 7 4 17 7 2.4 4.3 21 N Fehily 11 7 29 7 2.6 4.1 22 R Greene 5 3 12 4 2.4 4 23 T Doyle 8 3 12 4 1.5 4 24 DN Russell 5 1 4 2 0.8 4 25 M Nicolls © 4 4 15 4 3.8 3.8 26 J Culloty 10 5 19 7 1.9 3.8 27 JM Maguire 4 4 14 4 3.5 3.5 28 C Llewellyn 7 5 16 7 2.3 3.2 29 S Durak 7 6 18 6 2.6 3 30 James Davies © 10 6 18 9 1.8 3 31 L Aspell 7 4 12 7 1.7 3 32 MA FitzGerald 11 8 23 9 2.1 2.9 33 C Bolger © 7 6 15 6 2.1 2.5 34 A Thornton 16 8 20 13 1.3 2.5 35 R Young © 4 2 5 4 1.3 2.5 36 P Hide 9 6 17 7 1.9 2.8 37 R Hobson © 5 3 8 5 1.6 2.7 38 B Fenton 10 8 19 9 1.9 2.4 39 F Keniry 4 3 7 2 1.8 2.3 40 Mr S Thomas © 4 3 6 3 1.5 2 41 J Tizzard 7 5 10 6 1.4 2 42 A Tinkler © 7 5 9 7 1.3 1.8 43 M Bradburne 6 4 6 6 1 1.5 44 W Hutchinson © 4 2 3 3 0.8 1.5 45 R Walford © 7 2 3 3 0.4 1.5 46 JP McNamara 7 2 2 5 0.3 1 47 N Carter © 3 3 23 3 48 R Lucy-Butler © 3 1 6 2 49 B Harding 3 3 10 2 50 C Honour © 3 3 9 3 51 P Aspell © 3 2 6 2 52 DC Costello © 3 3 8 3 53 S Curran 3 2 5 2 54 M Batchelor 3 2 4 3 55 T Best © 3 3 5 3 56 D Elsworth 3 2 2 3 57 A Dobbin 2 2 19 2 58 A Ross 2 2 14 2 59 RCG Harris © 2 2 13 2 60 D Flavin © 2 2 12 2 61 P Whelan © 2 2 11 1 62 JA McCarthy 2 2 9 2 63 T Burrows © 2 2 8 2 64 T Scudamore 2 2 8 2 65 D Cosgrave © 2 2 7 2 66 Mr O Nelmes 2 2 6 2 67 VT Keane © 2 2 5 2 68 A Pogson © 2 2 3 2 69 T Siddall © 2 2 3 2 70 R Spate © 2 2 2 2 71 L Vickers © 2 1 7 2 72 Miss EJ Jones © 2 1 6 2 73 S Crawford © 2 1 3 1 74 J Goldstein 2 1 3 1 75 A O'Keeffe © 2 1 3 1 76 Mr N Williams © 2 1 2 2 77 D O'Meara© 2 1 1 2 78 R Flavin © 2 0 0 2 79 Mr J Diment © 2 0 0 1 80 P Moloney 2 0 0 0 81 Mr A Price © 1 1 17 1 82 K Renwick 1 1 13 1 83 D Laverty © 1 1 11 1 84 Mr P Cowley © 1 1 8 1 85 Mr J Owen © 1 1 8 1 86 Brian Murphy © 1 1 7 1 87 Mr G Baines © 1 1 6 1 88 S Karnicnik © 1 1 6 1 89 Dr P Pritchard © 1 1 6 1 90 Mr J Morgan © 1 1 6 1 91 G Berridge 1 1 5 1 92 A Honeyball © 1 1 5 1 93 Mr JJ King © 1 1 5 1 94 Mr TJ Malone © 1 1 5 1 95 D McPhail 1 1 5 1 96 Mr James White © 1 1 5 1 97 G Berridge © 1 1 4 1 98 Miss P Gundry © 1 1 4 1 99 Mr S McHugh © 1 1 4 1 100 Mr O Dayman © 1 1 3 1 101 P Holley 1 1 3 1 102 Sophie Mitchell © 1 1 3 1 103 H Oliver 1 1 2 0 104 D Crosse © 1 1 2 1 105 Miss RA Green © 1 1 2 1 106 Mr T Greenway © 1 1 2 1 107 J Pritchard © 1 1 2 1 108 Mr P Callaghan © 1 1 1 1 109 M Foley 1 1 1 1 110 Mr T Greenall © 1 1 1 1 111 D Harold © 1 1 1 1 112 O Kozak © 1 1 1 1 113 P Madden © 1 1 1 1 114 MH Naughton © 1 1 1 1 115 Mr KE Power © 1 1 1 1 116 TJ Phelan © 1 1 1 1 117 Jacques Ricou 1 1 1 1 118 L Barber © 1 0 0 1 119 JP Byrne © 1 0 0 1 120 G Carenza © 1 0 0 1 121 E Cooper © 1 0 0 1 122 S Fox 1 0 0 1 123 D Gater © 1 0 0 1 124 Mr D Jewett © 1 0 0 1 125 O McPhail 1 0 0 1 126 S Peltell © 1 0 0 1 127 P Robson © 1 0 0 1 128 Mr C Studd © 1 0 0 1 129 Mr G Barfoot-Saunt© 1 0 0 0 130 A Day © 1 0 0 0 131 R Garrity 1 0 0 0 132 RI Mackenzie © 1 0 0 0 133 Mr J Mead © 1 0 0 0 134 Matthew Smith © 1 0 0 0 135 WA Worthington 1 0 0 0

Total & Mean 3.1 4.3 Stage Of Race Where A Horse Is Whipped Data

Data covers the Three Disciplines and a Total of the Three Disciplines Stage Of Race Where A Horse Is Whipped AW

Stage of No.Horses Winning No. Races race when Whipped Horses whipped

Start s 8 1 35 Middle m 141 6 35 Finish f 293 31 35

Not Whipped 4 35

NB A horse can be whipped in any stage of a race i.e. at the start, in the middle, or at the finish. Therefore, a horse could feature in one or more columns, and, if he won, would appear in "winning horses" twice. This could not apply to horses not whipped that won.

The table below focuses on the 1st and 2nd finishing positioned horses in a race, and compares the number of times each was whipped, or not. The horse whipped the least is given as won, the horse whipped the most is given as lost. A draw is an equal amount of whips, or if neither are whipped.

Least Whip. Most Whip. Equal Whip. Races Of 35 Race Winners 1st Horse 17 won 14 lost 4 drawn 35 Of 35 Race Seconds 2nd Horse 14 won 17 lost 4 drawn 35 Stage Of Race Where A Horse Is Whipped Flat

Stage of No.Horses Winning No. Races race when Whipped Horses whipped

Start s 4 0 52 Middle m 152 6 52 Finish f 418 45 52

Not Whipped 7 52

NB A horse can be whipped in any stage of a race i.e. at the start, in the middle, or at the finish. Therefore, a horse could feature in one or more columns, and, if he won, would appear in "winning horses" twice. This could not apply to horses not whipped that won.

The table below focuses on the 1st and 2nd finishing positioned horses in a race, and compares the number of times each was whipped, or not. The horse whipped the least is given as won, the horse whipped the most is given as lost. A draw is an equal amount of whips, or if neither are whipped.

Least Whip. Most Whip. Equal Whip. Races Of 52 Race Winners 1st Horse 25 won 18 lost 9 drawn 52 Of 52 Race Seconds 2nd Horse 18 won 25 lost 9 drawn 52 Stage Of Race Where A Horse Is Whipped National Hunt NH

Stage of No.Horses Winning No. Races race when Whipped Horses whipped

Start s 8 0 74 Middle m 171 5 74 Finish f 227 44 74

Not Whipped 29 74

NB A horse can be whipped in any stage of a race i.e. at the start, in the middle, or at the finish. Therefore, a horse could feature in one or more columns, and, if he won, would appear in "winning horses" twice. This could not apply to horses not whipped that won.

The table below focuses on the 1st and 2nd finishing positioned horses in a race, and compares the number of times each was whipped, or not. The horse whipped the least is given as won, the horse whipped the most is given as lost, a draw is an equal amount of whips, or if neither are whipped.

Least Whip. Most Whip. Equal Whip. Races Of 74 Race Winners 1st Horse 40 won 19 lost 15 draw 74 Of 74 Race Seconds 2nd Horse 19 won 40 lost 15 draw 74 Stage Of Race Where A Horse Is Whipped Total of AW, Flat & NH

Stage of No.Horses Winning No. Races race when Whipped Horses whipped

Start s 20 1 161 Middle m 464 17 161 Finish f 938 120 161

Not Whipped 40 161

NB A horse can be whipped in any stage of a race i.e. at the start, in the middle, or at the finish. Therefore, a horse could feature in one or more columns, and, if he won, would appear in "winning horses" twice. This could not apply to horses not whipped that won. the table below focuses on the 1st and 2nd finishing positioned horses in a race, and compares the number of times each was whipped, or not. The horse whipped the least is given as won, the horse whipped the most is given as lost. A draw is an equal amount of whips, or if neither are whipped.

Least Whip. Most Whip. Equal Whip. Races Of 161 Race Winners 1st Horse 82 won 51 lost 28 drawn 161 races Of 161 Race Seconds2nd Horse 51 lost 82 lost 28 drawn 161 races Whip Use in Relation to Distance Ran Data

Data covers the Three Disciplines and a Total of the Three Disciplines Whip Use In Relation To Distance Ran AW

A B C D E F Distance No. Races No.Horses No. Whip No.Horses No.Horses Ratio C/D Ratio E/D Whipped Strikes Ran Shown Whip strikes/horsestrikes/horse

5f 1 13 70 16 14 5.4 4.4 6f 12 109 550 142 117 5 3.9 7f 7 82 366 98 88 4.5 3.8 1m 8 86 398 104 92 4.6 3.8 1m 2f 3 33 151 36 33 4.6 4.2 1m 4f 3 29 123 34 30 4.2 3.6 1m 7f 1 9 40 12 9 4.4 3.3

Total & 35 361 1698 442 383 4.7 3.8 Ratio Mean

Mean/Race 1 10.3 48.5 12.6 10.9 4.7 3.8 Whip Use In Relation To Distance Ran Flat

A B C D E F Distance No. Races No.Horses No. Whip No.Horses No.Horses Ratio C/D Ratio E/D Whipped Strikes Ran Shown Whip strikes/horsestrikes/horse

5f 4 46 191 55 49 4.2 3.5 6f 8 71 341 103 70 4.8 3.3 7f 14 112 444 137 115 3.9 3.2 1m 12 119 591 141 119 4.9 4.2 1m 1f 1 8 69 11 9 8.6 6.3 1m 2f 7 75 389 93 78 5.2 4.2 1m 3f 1 10 29 13 9 2.9 2.2 1m 4f 3 26 132 27 26 5.1 4.9 1m 6f 1 7 40 8 7 5.7 5 2m 1 6 37 6 6 6.2 6.2

Total & 52 480 2263 594 488 4.7 3.8 Ratio Mean

Mean/Race 1 9.2 43.5 11.4 9.4 4.7 3.8 Whip Use In Relation To Distance Ran National Hunt NH

A B C D E F Distance No. Races No.Horses No. Whip No.Horses No.Horses Ratio C/D Ratio E/D Whipped Strikes Ran Shown Whip strikes/horsestrikes/horse NH Hurdle 2m 17 83 358 120 97 4.3 3 2m 1f 2 16 33 23 18 2 1.4 2m 2f 1 5 20 9 7 4 2.2 2m 4f 3 12 44 15 14 3.7 2.9 2m 5f 7 35 171 45 40 4.9 3.8 2m 6f 2 10 63 13 12 6.3 4.8 2m 7f 2 11 41 14 13 3.7 2.9 3m 1 7 29 8 7 4.1 3.6 3m 1f 2 6 39 8 7 6.5 4.9 3m 2f 1 3 12 3 3 4 4

Total & 38 188 810 258 218 4.3 3.1 Ratio Mean

A B C D E F Distance No. Races No.Horses No. Whip No.Horses No.Horses Ratio C/D Ratio E/D Whipped Strikes Ran Shown Whip strikes/horsestrikes/horse NH Chase 2m 4 12 65 18 17 5.4 3.6 2m 1f 3 12 45 14 12 3.8 3.2 2m 2f 1 0 0 4 2 0 0 2m 4f 7 20 89 31 26 4.5 2.9 2m 6f 3 7 36 17 11 5.1 2.1 3m 3 11 47 15 13 4.3 3.1 3m 1f 1 0 0 2 1 0 0 3m 2f 6 24 135 34 29 5.6 4

Total & 28 86 417 135 111 4.8 3.1 Ratio Mean

A B C D E F Distance No. Races No.Horses No. Whip No.Horses No.Horses Ratio C/D Ratio E/D Whipped Strikes Ran Shown Whip strikes/horsestrikes/horse NH Flat 2m 4 30 130 33 32 4.3 3.9 2m 1f 1 9 36 14 13 4 2.6 2m 2f 3 18 36 24 20 2 1.5

Total & 8 57 202 71 65 3.5 2.8 Ratio Mean

Total NH & 74 331 1429 464 394 4.3 3 Ratio Mean Mean/Race 1 4.5 19.3 6.3 5.3 4.3 3 Use Of The Whip Across All Disciplines: AW; Flat; NH. Total Numbers & Mean

A B C D E F Discipline No. Races No.Horses No. Whip No.Horses No.Horses Ratio C/D Ratio E/D Whipped Strikes Ran Shown Whip strikes/horsestrikes/horse

AW/Flat/NH 161 1172 5390 1500 1263 4.6 3.6

Mean / Race 1 7.3 33.5 9.3 7.8 4.6 3.6