Marxist Logic and Modern Sciences
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Galileo Galilei Alvin Goldman Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling Georg Wilhelm FriedrichLouis Hegel AlthusserMario Rossi Pierre Naville Lodovico Geymonat Friedrich Engels Maurice Godelier Galvano Della Volpe Herbert Marcuse Aristotle György Lukács Immanuel KantFrancis Bacon Warren Sturgis McCulloch Max Wertheimer Leon Trotsky Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Marxist Logic and Modern SciencesRoger Garaudy Bertrand Russell François Jacob Paul Fraisse Karl Marx George Novack Friedrich Adolf Trandelenburg Jean-PaulRobert Harding Sartre Whitaker Evert Willem BethHenri Lefebvre John Dewey Johann Gottlieb Fichte Plato René Descartes Nahuel Moreno Nicolas Bourbaki Ludwig Feuerbach Henri BergsonClaude Lévi StraussJean Piaget CEHuS Centro de Estudios Humanos y Sociales Nahuel Moreno Marxist Logic and Modern Sciences This work was first published as a preface to the Spanish edition of the book Introduction to the Logic of Marxism by George Novack, Editorial Pluma, Buenos Aires, 1973 English translation: Daniel Iglesias Cover and interior design: Daniel Iglesias www.nahuelmoreno.org www.uit-ci.org www.izquierdasocialista.org.ar Copyright by CEHuS , Centro de Estudios Humanos y Sociales Buenos Aires, 2018 [email protected] CEHuS Centro de Estudios Humanos y Sociales Index Marxist Logic and Modern Sciences Introduction .......................................................................................................................................................1 Chapter I Piaget’s epistemology ........................................................................................................................................3 1. The subject and the object in human knowledge ...............................................................................................................................3 2. The definition of thought and knowledge ..............................................................................................................................................4 3. The classification of sciences ...........................................................................................................................................................................5 Chapter II The Della Volpe school ......................................................................................................................................6 1. Confusion of Marxism with experimental empiricism .....................................................................................................................6 2. The determinate abstraction according to Della Volpe and according to modern epistemology ...........................8 3. The concrete-abstract-concrete circle .......................................................................................................................................................9 4.-The new hypothetical-deductive logic ...................................................................................................................................................10 5. The contradiction in Della Volpe and in Hegel-Marx ....................................................................................................................11 6. Tell me who you are with and it will tell you who you are ..........................................................................................................12 Chapter III Sartre and Della Volpe against Engels ..........................................................................................................14 1. A total coincidence ...........................................................................................................................................................................................14 2. Engels is not the only one ignored by dramatist Sartre .................................................................................................................15 3. Modern epistemology confirms Engels ..................................................................................................................................................16 4. The reasons for a curious agreement .......................................................................................................................................................16 Chapter IV Structuralism ....................................................................................................................................................18 1. The static structuralism of Lévi-Straus ....................................................................................................................................................19 2. Marx, discoverer of the relationship between the diachronic and synchronic laws .....................................................20 3. The attempt to unify structuralism with modern genetics ........................................................................................................21 4. Matter-movement; structure-genesis .....................................................................................................................................................21 5. Increased probability and necessity .........................................................................................................................................................22 Chapter V The law of uneven and combined development .........................................................................................24 1. Marx ...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................25 2. Trotsky ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................26 3. Piaget .........................................................................................................................................................................................................................26 4. The new according to Piaget ........................................................................................................................................................................27 5. A popularisation pamphlet that is much more than that ...........................................................................................................28 Chapter VI A new approach to the history of logic ........................................................................................................30 1. Aristotelian logic and epistemology.........................................................................................................................................................32 2. Experimental logic .............................................................................................................................................................................................33 3. German idealism .................................................................................................................................................................................................34 4. Hegel’s discovery .................................................................................................................................................................................................35 Chapter VII Marxist Logic ....................................................................................................................................................40 1. The anti-Hegelian interpretations of Marxism and modern epistemology........................................................................41 2. Pro-Hegelian Marxism .....................................................................................................................................................................................42 3. Marx as an interpreter of Hegel ..................................................................................................................................................................42 4. Marxist logic ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................43 5. Marxist logic and formal sciences .............................................................................................................................................................45 6. A good example of cuvrrent Marxist logic ...........................................................................................................................................46 7. Towards a logic of revolutionary politics...............................................................................................................................................47 Introduction This book adds, fortunately, to two others published this year in our language, dealing with the same subject: Dialectical Materialism by Henri Lefebvre and Critique of Contemporary Ideology by Galvano Della Volpe. Of this last author, we already knew Rousseau and Marx, and his and his disciples’ contribution to the polemics over the concrete—abstract—concrete circle.1 Unfortunately, two important works of this school have not yet been translated, such as the book