DOCSLIB.ORG

Firmus Energy (Distribution) Limited V Northern Ireland Authority for Utility Regulation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Firmus Energy (Distribution) Limited V Northern Ireland Authority for Utility Regulation Firmus Energy (Distribution) Limited v Northern Ireland Authority for Utility Regulation Final determination 26 June 2017 © Crown copyright 2017 You may reuse this information (not including logos) free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence, visit www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open–government– licence/ or write to the Information Policy Team, The National Archives, Kew, London TW9 4DU, or email: [email protected]. Website: www.gov.uk/cma Members of the Competition and Markets Authority who conducted this appeal Phil Evans Roger Finbow Jon Stern Acting Chief Executive of the Competition and Markets Authority Andrea Coscelli The Competition and Markets Authority has excluded from this published version of the report information which the inquiry group considers should be excluded having regard to the three considerations set out in section 244 of the Enterprise Act 2002 (specified information: considerations relevant to disclosure). The omissions are indicated by []. Some numbers have been replaced by a range. These are shown in square brackets. Non-sensitive wording is also indicated in square brackets. Contents Page 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................... 4 Conduct of the appeal ........................................................................................... 5 Permission to appeal ....................................................................................... 6 Submissions from the Parties .......................................................................... 6 CMA provisional determination and responses ............................................... 6 Site visit and hearings ..................................................................................... 7 Transparency ................................................................................................... 7 2. Background to the appeal ..................................................................................... 8 The gas supply chain in NI .................................................................................... 8 The GDNs ............................................................................................................. 8 FE .................................................................................................................... 9 PNGL ............................................................................................................... 9 SGN ................................................................................................................. 9 The regulation of GDNs’ revenues ........................................................................ 9 The decision under appeal – GD17 .................................................................... 10 3. The legal framework for the appeal ..................................................................... 12 The decision under appeal .................................................................................. 12 The UR’s principal objective, powers and duties ................................................ 12 The principal objective ................................................................................... 12 Powers of the UR .......................................................................................... 12 Duties of the UR ............................................................................................ 13 Test on appeal .................................................................................................... 13 Standard of review .............................................................................................. 14 Materiality ........................................................................................................... 18 4. Ground 1: Opex allowance ................................................................................. 20 Introduction ......................................................................................................... 20 FE’s grounds of appeal on Ground 1 .................................................................. 20 Background on setting an Opex allowance ......................................................... 22 Ground 1B: ‘The Maintenance Sparsity Error’ .................................................... 23 Summary of grounds of appeal...................................................................... 23 The UR’s Decision ......................................................................................... 24 FE’s submissions ........................................................................................... 25 The UR’s submissions ................................................................................... 29 Our assessment ............................................................................................ 30 Our conclusion on Ground 1B ....................................................................... 33 Ground 1C: ‘The GIS Oversight Error’ ................................................................ 33 Summary of grounds of appeal...................................................................... 34 The UR’s Decision ......................................................................................... 34 FE’s submissions ........................................................................................... 37 The UR’s submissions ................................................................................... 38 Our assessment ............................................................................................ 39 Our conclusion on Ground 1C ....................................................................... 43 Observations on the GD17 process ............................................................... 44 Ground 1D: ‘The Manpower Scale Error’ ............................................................ 44 Summary of grounds of appeal...................................................................... 44 The UR’s Decision ......................................................................................... 45 FE’s submissions ........................................................................................... 46 The UR’s submissions ................................................................................... 52 1 Our assessment ............................................................................................ 54 Our conclusion on Ground 1D ....................................................................... 56 Ground 1E: ‘The Omission Error’ ........................................................................ 56 Summary of grounds of appeal...................................................................... 56 The UR’s Decision ......................................................................................... 57 FE’s submissions ........................................................................................... 59 The UR’s submissions ................................................................................... 60 Our assessment ............................................................................................ 62 Our conclusion on Ground 1E ....................................................................... 66 Ground 1A: ‘the Benchmarking Error’ ................................................................. 67 Summary of grounds of appeal...................................................................... 67 The UR’s Decision ......................................................................................... 67 FE’s submissions ........................................................................................... 70 The UR’s submissions ................................................................................... 74 Our assessment ............................................................................................ 76 Our conclusion on Ground 1A ....................................................................... 79 Observations on the GD17 process ............................................................... 80 Conclusion on Ground 1 ..................................................................................... 81 5. Ground 2: Connection incentive .......................................................................... 82 Introduction ......................................................................................................... 82 FE’s grounds of appeal on Ground 2 .................................................................. 82 Background on setting the connection incentive ................................................. 83 Ground 2A – ‘The Connection Target Error’ ....................................................... 84 The UR’s Decision ......................................................................................... 85 FE’s submissions ........................................................................................... 86 The UR’s submissions ................................................................................... 89 Third party submissions ................................................................................. 93 Our assessment ............................................................................................ 93 Our conclusion on Ground 2A ....................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Great Britain and Northern Ireland Regulatory Authorities Reports 2018
    Great Britain and Northern Ireland Regulatory Authorities Reports 2018 Regulatory Authorities Report pursuant to section 5ZA of the Utilities Act 2000 and section 6A of the Energy (Northern Ireland) Order 2003 Ofgem 10 South Colonnade, Canary Wharf London E14 4PU www.ofgem.gov.uk Great Britain and Northern Ireland Regulatory Authorities Reports 2018 Ofgem 2018 National Report to the European Commission Overview The Great Britain (GB) report covers: Developments in the GB energy markets in the calendar year 2017 and the first six months of 2018. In some cases, data is only available for a subset of this period (i.e. the 2017 calendar year only). Where this is the case, it is clearly stated. The regulation and performance of the GB electricity and gas markets in reference to network regulation, promoting competition, and security of supply. Our compliance with the Electricity and Gas Directives on consumer protection and dispute settlement. Since GB energy markets have been fully liberalised and the regulatory structures in place for a number of years, this report is intended as an updated version of the submissions made since 2007. Finally, for further information on Ofgem’s wider activities, please consult our Annual Report. The 2017-18 Ofgem Annual Report is available at the link below.1 Legal Basis All National Regulatory Authorities (NRAs) are obliged to report annually to the European Commission, in accordance with Directives 2009/72/EC (Electricity Directive) and 2009/73/EC (Gas Directive). The structure of the report is agreed at the Council of European Energy Regulators (CEER). Ofgem is the GB Office of Gas and Electricity Markets.
    [Show full text]
  • Policy and Players Shaping Investment
    www.davy.ie Bloomberg: DAVY<GO> Research: +353 1 6148997 Institutional Equity Sales: +353 1 6792816 Davy Research August 16, 2012 Davy Research Research Report: Sector update Caren Crowley Ireland's Electricity Future [email protected] / +353 1 6148997 Barry Dixon [email protected] / +353 1 6148997 Policy and players shaping David McNamara [email protected] / +353 1 6148997 investment 2020 EU climate change commitments to drive growth Table of contents • Despite overcapacity in conventional power generation, the Republic of Executive summary 2 Ireland and Northern Ireland are committed to generating 40% of electricity requirements from renewable resources by 2020 to meet The Single Electricity Market (SEM) – an binding EU climate change targets. all-island wholesale electricity market 4 Some €5bn of capital investment will be required to construct an • additional 3–3.5GW of onshore wind by 2020. SEM generation capacity and fuel mix 8 • Government schemes to support this investment have been implemented in both jurisdictions. Growth in generation capacity 10 Larger industry players to deliver renewable investment Renewable energy incentives 13 • Certain technical challenges and the constrained financing environment Challenges in delivering SEM 2020 renewable mean that scarce capital is more likely to be channelled into projects via energy targets 16 the utilities and larger, more experienced project developers. • The four integrated energy utilities that currently dominate the all- A changing SEM 18 island electricity market – ESB, Bord Gáis Energy, SSE Ireland and Viridian – are best placed to support continued delivery of onshore Retail electricity markets supported by the wind capacity. SEM 21 • Larger project developers such as Bord na Móna, Coillte, Mainstream and Element Power will also feature.
    [Show full text]
  • Gas to the West Section 2
    Innovation and Technology Transfer Table of Contents INNOVATION AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER .................................................................................................................... 2 11.1 ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY .................................................................................................................................... 2 11.2 EFFICIENCY IN THE USE OF GAS AND THE USE OF NEW SOURCES OF GAS .................................................................................... 7 11.3 COST EFFICIENCY ........................................................................................................................................................ 11 11.4 DEVELOPMENT OF A GAS NETWORK UNDER THE LICENCE TO MORE REMOTE GEOGRAPHICAL AREAS ............................................. 14 11.5 HISTORY OF INNOVATION ............................................................................................................................................. 15 11.6 ABILITY TO SECURE FUNDING FROM OTHER GOVERNMENTAL OR REGULATORY AUTHORITIES ....................................................... 20 11.7 PROPOSALS TO TRANSFER ANY INNOVATION INTO NORTHERN IRELAND ................................................................................. 22 11.8 EXISTING SKILLS AND EXPERIENCE ................................................................................................................................... 22 Innovation and Technology Transfer Proven track record of bringing innovation and technology
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Definitions and Interpretation
    General Terms and Conditions for the supply Alfred Street, Belfast, BT2 8EN (contactable Ireland) Order 2003, relevant European of natural gas by Firmus Energy (Supply) by calling 02890 251 600, emailing info@ directives and/or regulations, the Network Code Limited (trading as “firmus energy”) to any consumercouncil.org.uk, visiting www. and the Licence (each as may be amended or customer (both domestic and non-domestic) consumercouncil.org.uk, or visiting its re-enacted from time to time); registered office); who uses up to 732,000 kilowatt hours of “Energy Act” means the Energy Act (Northern gas per year (“General Conditions”). “Conversion Works” means such works as Ireland) 2011; “Codes of Practice” means the codes required may be required to convert the Appliances at The following are the standard terms and in accordance with our Licence governing (i) the Supply Address to operate on Gas; “Equipment” means the Meter and associated conditions for the supply of Gas by firmus the Efficient Use of Natural Gas, (ii) Provision equipment and installations installed or to be energy for any Customer using up to 732,000 of Services for persons who are of Pensionable “Customer”, “you”, “your” means: (i) any installed at the Supply Address to allow for the kWh of Gas per year. These General Conditions Age, Disabled or Chronically Sick, (iii) Marketing, person or company who enters into the supply of Gas to the property at the Supply apply to any Customer who is supplied up to (iv) Payment of Bills (v) Services for Prepayment Agreement with the Company for the supply Address, including but not limited to associated 732,000 kWh of Gas under a Deemed Contract.
    [Show full text]
  • All Council Areas in Northern Ireland
    All council areas in Northern Ireland A few statistics in relation to firmus energy’s activity within all council areas: REDUCTION OF INVESTED 220,921 £140.7m CONNECTED TONNES OF SINCE 2005, 49,596 FROM THE £5.6m CUSTOMERS TO DATE 2 ATMOSPHERE PLANNED FOR 2020 CO EACH YEAR (INCLUDING OWNER-OCCUPIER PROPERTIES, NIHE, DOMESTIC (BASED ON 2019 FIGURES £ £ £ £ £ £ NEW BUILD AND INDUSTRIAL WHEN COMPARED TO OIL) AND COMMERICAL) IF ALL THESE REMAINING PROPERTIES CONNECTED TO GAS GAS THE ADDITIONAL C02 SAVINGS WOULD EQUATE TO IS AVAILABLE FOR 307,901 TONNES 104,884 GIVING A TOTAL REDUCTION OF FUTURE CUSTOMERS TONNES TO CONNECT 528,825 EVERY YEAR August 2020 About firmus energy Since 2005 firmus energy has been responsible The company employs over 100 direct staff, as well as for installing and maintaining over 1,600km of pipeline 300 indirectly in the construction, installation and service across 35 cities, towns and villages in Northern Ireland. support industries. firmus energy prides itself on achieving This natural gas network extends through the central strip and maintaining Investors in People - gold status and of Northern Ireland from Newry, through Antrim (our HQ) takes part each year in Business in the Community’s and on to Derry / Londonderry. firmus energy also has Environmental Benchmarking Survey which assesses the a supply business which purchases and sells natural environmental performance of organisations. In 2019, in gas to over 100,000 domestic and Industrial recognition of our ongoing work in this area, firmus customers throughout Northern Ireland. energy was awarded gold status. The Northern Ireland Gas Industry - £1bn network Environmental investment to date Benefits Northern Ireland benefits from having one of the most Energy users switching from home heating oil to natural modern and efficient natural gas networks in the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Grupy Kapitałowe W Krajach Europejskiego Obszaru Gospodarczego Ze Szczególnym Uwzględnieniem Sektora Energetycznego
    Grzegorz Królikowski Grupy kapitałowe w krajach Europejskiego Obszaru Gospodarczego ze szczególnym uwzględnieniem sektora energetycznego K RAKÓW 2013 SPIS TREŚCI Rozdział 1 ................................................................................................................................... 5 Miejsce grup kapitałowych wśród dużych jednostek gospodarczych ........................................ 5 1.1. Typologia dużych jednostek gospodarczych .................................................................... 5 1.2 Rola korporacji w gospodarce światowej ...................................................................... 15 1.3. Korporacje transnarodowe z udziałami państwowymi ................................................. 20 1.4. Uregulowania prawne obecne w różnych krajach europejskich .................................... 21 Rozdział 2 ................................................................................................................................. 33 Europejskie grupy kapitałowe w świetle analizy najważniejszych indeksów giełd europejskich ................................................................................................................................................... 33 2.1. Giełdy europejskie i ich zróżnicowanie ....................................................................... 33 2.2. Giełdy europejskie na tle świata .................................................................................... 39 2.3. Metodyka badania .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Great Britain and Northern Ireland Regulatory Authorities Reports 2018
    Great Britain and Northern Ireland Regulatory Authorities Reports 2018 Regulatory Authorities Report pursuant to section 5ZA of the Utilities Act 2000 and section 6A of the Energy (Northern Ireland) Order 2003 Ofgem 10 South Colonnade, Canary Wharf London E14 4PU www.ofgem.gov.uk Great Britain and Northern Ireland Regulatory Authorities Reports 2018 Ofgem 2018 National Report to the European Commission Overview The Great Britain (GB) report covers: Developments in the GB energy markets in the calendar year 2017 and the first six months of 2018. In some cases, data is only available for a subset of this period (i.e. the 2017 calendar year only). Where this is the case, it is clearly stated. The regulation and performance of the GB electricity and gas markets in reference to network regulation, promoting competition, and security of supply. Our compliance with the Electricity and Gas Directives on consumer protection and dispute settlement. Since GB energy markets have been fully liberalised and the regulatory structures in place for a number of years, this report is intended as an updated version of the submissions made since 2007. Finally, for further information on Ofgem’s wider activities, please consult our Annual Report. The 2017-18 Ofgem Annual Report is available at the link below.1 Legal Basis All National Regulatory Authorities (NRAs) are obliged to report annually to the European Commission, in accordance with Directives 2009/72/EC (Electricity Directive) and 2009/73/EC (Gas Directive). The structure of the report is agreed at the Council of European Energy Regulators (CEER). Ofgem is the GB Office of Gas and Electricity Markets.
    [Show full text]
  • Conclusion of the Utility Regulator's Review of the Firmus Energy
    Conclusion of the Utility Regulator’s Review of the firmus energy (Supply) Ltd Maximum Average Price in the Ten Towns area March 2017 About the Utility Regulator The Utility Regulator is the independent non-ministerial government department responsible for regulating Northern Ireland’s electricity, gas, water and sewerage industries, to promote the short and long-term interests of consumers. We are not a policy-making department of government, but we make sure that the energy and water utility industries in Northern Ireland are regulated and developed within ministerial policy as set out in our statutory duties. We are governed by a Board of Directors and are accountable to the Northern Ireland Assembly through financial and annual reporting obligations. We are based at Queens House in the centre of Belfast. The Chief Executive leads a management team of directors representing each of the key functional areas in the organisation: Corporate Affairs; Electricity; Gas; Retail and Social; and Water. The staff team includes economists, engineers, accountants, utility specialists, legal advisors and administration professionals. Our Mission Value and sustainability in energy and water. We will make a difference for consumers by Our Vision listening, innovating and leading. Our Values Be a best practice regulator: transparent, consistent, proportional, accountable, and targeted. Be a united team. Be collaborative and co-operative. Be professional. Listen and explain. Make a difference. Act with integrity. Abstract Protecting customers is at the heart of the Utility Regulator’s role and ensuring that customers pay the correct price for energy from the price regulated supplier firmus energy Supply Ltd (feSL) is a core part of our work.
    [Show full text]
  • KRA Submission on GA0003 and DA0003 to A.Wps
    Kilcolgan Residents Telephone: +353-87-2804474 Association Email: [email protected] c/o Island View Web: www.safetybeforelng.com Convent Street Listowel Kilcolgan Residents Association County Kerry Safety before LNG 7 October 2008 Protecting the Shannon Estuary and KILCOLGAN RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION & SAFETY BEFORE LNG Submission on proposed Shannon LNG Natural Gas Pipeline and proposed compulsory acquisition of lands thereon from Kilcolgan, County Kerry to Foynes, County Limerick 7 October 2008 An Bord Pleanála, 64 Marlborough Street, Dublin 1. By Email only to: bord@Pleanála.ie Re: GA0003 - Gas pipeline to connect Shannon LNG Terminal at Ralappane, Co. Kerry to existing natural gas network at Leahys, Co. Limerick and DA0003 - Application for an acquisition order for the Shannon LNG Terminal at Tarbert, Co. Kerry to the Bord G áis Eireann Network at Foynes, County Limerick Dear Sir / Madam, The Kicolgan Residents Association represents nearby residents of the proposed LNG regasification terminal and people with close family and economic ties to the area. The ‘Safety Before LNG’ group represents people from both Kilcolgan and the wider community and is advocating responsible strategic siting of LNG terminals in areas which do not put people’s health and safety in danger. See attached signed submissions by Ms. Kathy Sinnott M.E.P1 and Mr. Tony Lowes for “Friends of the Irish Environment”2 on whose behalf this submission is also, therefore, being made. We are hereby formally objecting to the proposed Shannon LNG Natural Gas pipeline and compulsory acquisition order, referenced above, in their entirety, on health, safety, environmental and strategic planning grounds. In May 2006 Shannon LNG, a subsidiary of the American Hess Corporation, announced an option to purchase, subject to planning, the lands at Kilcolgan owned by Shannon Development, of which Councillor John Brassil was a director, to construct an LNG terminal for a price believed by us to be in the region of 28.1 million euros3.
    [Show full text]
  • Page 1 © Firmus Energy
    © firmus energy page 1 Natural Gas © firmus energy page 2 Natural gas in NI natural gas is established in Great Britain • 1966 – rolled out using ‘towns’ gas network natural gas is ‘new’ to Northern Ireland • 1996 – greater Belfast and Larne • 2005 – Ten Towns The natural gas industry in Northern Ireland is new for most consumers and strictly regulated . Natural gas prices and practices are stringently monitored by the Utility Regulator. © firmus energy page 3 Homes using natural gas – GB vs. NI 2011 2014 25% 91% NIAUR Transparency Report Aug 2014 NISRA NI Housing Statistics October 2014 © firmus energy page 4 Why Natural Gas? • Cleaner - When burned to heat homes or for industrial uses, natural gas releases almost 30% less Carbon Dioxide (CO 2) than oil and just under 45% less CO 2 than coal • Tackling Fuel Poverty - There is a strong correlation between the number of homes using natural gas and the reduced incidence of fuel poverty. Northern Ireland has the highest proportion of fuel poverty in the UK at 44% (302,300 households) compared with 33% in Scotland, 26% in Wales and 21% in England • Secure and abundant - Global gas reserves have more than doubled since 1980, reaching 190 trillion cubic metres at the beginning of 2010 © firmus energy page 5 Natural Gas in Northern Ireland © firmus energy page 6 Northern Ireland Natural Gas Networks 1. Derry / Londonderry firmus energy 2. Limavady network 3. Coleraine 4. Portstewert 5. Bushmills 6. Ballymoney 7. Cullybackey 8. Ahoghill 9. Ballymena 10. Broughshane 11.Doagh Greater 12.Ballyclare
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2011
    Scottish and Southern Energy plc For further information In producing this report we have chosen production methods which aim to minimise the impact on our about SSE, please contact: environment. The papers used – Revive 50:50 Silk and Kaskad – are manufactured from sustainable sources. Scottish and Southern Energy plc Revive 50:50 Silk also contains 50% recovered waste. Both the paper mills and printer involved in this production are Scottish and Southern Energy plc Corporate Affairs environmentally accredited with ISO 14001. The printer Annual Report 2011 Inveralmond House is also registered as a Carbon Neutral company. 200 Dunkeld Road Perth PH1 3AQ UK T: +44 (0)1738 456000 E: [email protected] www.sse.com Annual Report 2011 Follow the latest news from SSE on Twitter at: www.twitter.com/sse Registered in Scotland No. 117119 STOCK CODE 008235 Contents Financial statements 78 Independent auditors’ report Overview 79 Consolidated income statement 80 Statement of comprehensive income 01 Introduction 81 Balance sheets 02 The energy sector in Great Britain 82 Statement of changes in equity 05 The energy sector in Ireland 84 Cash flow statements 06 SSE – a balanced range of 86 Notes on the financial statements energy businesses 86 1. Significant accounting policies 08 Chairman and Chief Executive 95 2. Reclassification of comparative Questions and answers The stunning photograph amounts used on the cover of this year’s 96 3. Segmental information Strategy 99 4. Other operating income and expense Annual Report was taken at 10 Why invest in SSE? 100 5. Exceptional items and certain SSE’s Drumderg wind farm in remeasurements Perthshire by award-winning Group performance 101 6.
    [Show full text]
  • John Ellis Mobile 085 834 8936 Email: [email protected]
    Examining Energy Market Developments October 2010 Developments in the Wholesale Gas Market David Strahan Managing Director, Phoenix Energy Ltd Examining Energy Market Developments October 2010 Agenda _ About Phoenix Energy Ltd _ Wholesale Gas Market Developments _ Unconventional Gas Examining Energy Market Developments October 2010 About Phoenix Energy _ Part of Phoenix Energy Holdings Ltd Group of companies _ Phoenix Natural Gas is the largest distribution network owner in Northern Ireland _ Phoenix Supply is the largest natural gas supplier in Northern Ireland _ Owned by Terra Firma Examining Energy Market Developments October 2010 Customers Supplied on the island of Ireland _ In customer number terms, Phoenix is Number of natural gas customers supplied the second largest natural gas supplier on the island of Ireland (June 2010) on the island of Ireland _ Phoenix has 135,000 customers Customer numbers based on Commission for Energy Regulation Gas Market Update – 2010 (Q2) (CER/10/133) and NIAUR consultation on the options for co-ordinating the relinquishing of firmus energy’s supply exclusivity in the ten towns area Examining Energy Market Developments October 2010 Gas Supplied on the island of Ireland _ In volume terms, Phoenix is the third Volume of natural gas supplied on the island largest natural gas supplier on the of Ireland (January 2010 - June 2010) island of Ireland (excluding power generation) _ Phoenix is growing by around 8,000 new customers each year Volume supplied based on Commission for Energy Regulation Gas Market Updates
    [Show full text]