BOARD BOARD
ORIGINAL ORIGINAL
IN IN
Others Others
Nanniyode Nanniyode
EL EL
& &
Vazhapara Vazhapara
TRIUUNAL, TRIUUNAL,
NS
ENVlRONMENTAL ENVlRONMENTAL
CONTROL CONTROL
Kcrala Kcrala
COU
DELHI DELHI
Paluvally, Paluvally,
of of
GREEN GREEN
A A
Chantharan Chantharan
NEW NEW
No.508/2019 No.508/2019
State State
Usha Usha
Pacha, Pacha,
Pachayilkonam, Pachayilkonam,
C/o C/o
POLLUTION POLLUTION
H, H,
ASSISTANT ASSISTANT
JogyScaria JogyScaria
C
.. ..
STANDING STANDING
NATIONAL NATIONAL
Adv Adv
DEN
Tl-IE Tl-IE
~ ~
STATE STATE
s s
Applicution Applicution
TI-IIRUVANATHAPURAM TI-IIRUVANATHAPURAM
V
508/2019 508/2019
BY BY
IPAL IPAL
C
NO NO
IION'BLI
ADDITIONAL ADDITIONAL
Originul Originul
KERALA KERALA
PRIN
OFFICE, OFFICE,
FILED FILED
Tltlo: Tltlo:
: :
FOtU
~
pondcnt(s) pondcnt(s)
A1>plicunt A1>plicunt
s
Bl
REPORT REPORT
DISTRICT DISTRICT
ENGINEER, ENGINEER,
APPLICATION APPLICATION Rc
7 7
to to
Others Others
1 1
Pages Pages
Nanniyode Nanniyode
& &
Vazhapara Vazhapara
TRIBUNAL, TRIBUNAL,
Control Control
Kerala Kerala
DELHI DELHI
GREEN GREEN
Paluvally, Paluvally,
of of
A A
Chantharan Chantharan
Environmental Environmental
NEW NEW
No.508/2019 No.508/2019
State State
Usha Usha
Pollution Pollution
Pachayilkonam, Pachayilkonam,
C/o C/o
Pacha, Pacha,
Thiruvanathapuram Thiruvanathapuram
Index Index
Assistant Assistant
State State
NATIONAL NATIONAL
2020. 2020.
BENCH, BENCH,
VOLUMEl VOLUMEl
the the
office, office,
Application Application
Vs Vs
by by
Kerala Kerala
filed filed
September September
District District
HON'BLE HON'BLE
Original Original
of of
PRINCIPAL PRINCIPAL
Counsel Counsel
THE THE
day day
Description Description
Engineer, Engineer,
Report Report
Board, Board,
th th
8
Advocate Advocate
Standing Standing
the the
Applicant Applicant
BEFORE BEFORE
this this
1 1
SL.NO SL.NO
Respondent(s) Respondent(s)
Dated Dated
Additional Additional JogyScaria JogyScaria
I I
-6 -6
7 7
2
Pngcs Pngcs
-
. .
-
9 9
-
01
Others Others
2
Nnnniyodt' Nnnniyodt'
& &
V11d111pnrn V11d111pnrn
TIUUIINAI., TIUUIINAI.,
19 19
0/11/
N N 019-
2
;
1
r
20
/2
:
: :
d d
c
Kcrnln Kcrnln
08.
1>10:1.111 1>10:1.111
No
Pnluvnlly, Pnluvnlly, Dut
(;1u
of of
A A
No:06
22/06/2020 22/06/2020
25.
ce ce
W W
:
1
d d
. .
Chnnthnrnn Chnnthnrnn
hu hu
e
0
Nl
No.~0H/201'> No.~0H/201'>
Noti
2
ls
No: No:
lo lo
Sh1te Sh1te
l
0
s s
Dat
Dated Dated
P11ch11yllkon11m, P11ch11yllkon11m,
L/2019 L/2019
Pnchn, Pnchn,
C dex dex
II, II,
2
Permit Permit
se se
'
ription ription
r r
In
M M
g g
14 14
au
e
/
N(
esc
014 014
C
~
D
/2
/20
NATIONAi. NATIONAi.
llli
N
: :
N
l l
E
e
A1,plk11fion A1,plk11fion
Show Show
G
Quarryin
Septemb
/GE
/
33/00T 33/00T
Vs Vs
-
uns
-
l}-Proceeding
ll'AL ll'AL
14
of of
'
/ /
e e
Co
t
QP
day day
IION'IILl1
ca
/
Ori~innl Ori~innl
th th
8
PUIN(
GBS
e e
B/HO/fVM
Advo
/
TIU: TIU:
Standing Standing
C
th 0
: :
Annexurc(I)
PCB/HO/fVM
Anncxurc(ll Anncxurc(ll
2
Anncxurc(JI) Anncxurc(JI)
P
this this
01u
'
.. ..
I I
: :
2 2
3 3
Applifnnf Applifnnf
1u
SL.NO SL.NO
Dated Dated
Additional Additional
JogyScaria JogyScaria Respondent(s) Respondent(s)
I I
'/ '/
/ /
· ·
,. ,.
/, /,
'
, ,
r r 2. 2.
·
-
~fl\ ~fl\
, ,
C C
' '
-;,
. .
,
,
\ \
~ ~
t,
0
ro!".10:• ro!".10:•
'• '•
0 0
\ \
-
' '
;O
n ' '
1
c
~
_,,Q
\o
ri
3
\ t
~
,'
i
1
s
•
9
i
~
w
.-e:=-
D
~
rtliru
• •
, ,
~ ~
I I
d d
0 0
e e
d d
..!!'
~ ~
,e:;:
to to
2
e
in in
~ ~
ra ra
f
Cl) Cl)
t ~ ~
th
I
an
0
019 019
a
2
2
s s
and and
e e
Order Order
s
e e
r r d
Office, Office,
01.
e
08/
tor
.
5
the the
presently presently
additional additional
cas
asse
es
Others Others
07
r
Nanniyode Nanniyode A A
Ord
Panchayath
c:er c:er
.
. .
to to
d d
Vazhapara Vazhapara
(KSPCB) (KSPCB)
n
& &
authorized authorized
i
e e
full full
e
O
to to
said said
with with
~
Environmental Environmental
. .
n
th
District District
e e
s s
E
TRIBUNAL TRIBUNAL
dat
and and
prmc1ple. prmc1ple.
am am
p
th
the the
er er
r r
al al
e
t
I I
. .
t
p
e
s' s'
S
in in
rry rry
Board Board
of of
.
Engineer Engineer
c:n
Kerala Kerala
a
holding holding
8
m
0 0
as as
Paluvally, Paluvally,
e e s
ord
Pay
2
~ ~
of of
that that
qu
:
Assistant Assistant
A A
e e
r r
0
Nanniyode Nanniyode
m
iron
ee ee
tak
facts facts
, ,
Chantharan Chantharan
e
e e
2
GREEN GREEN
compliance compliance
Eneineer, Eneineer,
Bi
m m
vid
th
DELHI DELHI
~ ~
E
, ,
in in
to to
l l
f f
the the
State State
Control Control
Usha Usha
C/o C/o
Pacha, Pacha,
Pachayilkonam, Pachayilkonam,
a
nt nt
508/2019 508/2019
submit submit
d d
a
presently presently Pollut
t
07.01.
'
ommitt
n n o
is
c
o
filed filed
ppara
s
d d
with with
NEW NEW
no. no.
oar
a
e
ti
on on
B
A~
is is
Rajakumar
nt nt
Tribun
d d
508/2019. 508/2019.
Environmental Environmental
dat
era
oi
e
n n
hereby hereby
j
p
l l
R. R.
NATIONAL NATIONAL
Pollution Pollution
Vazh
rol rol
o
a
t
e e
ee
bas
r
l l
No. No.
Vs Vs
do do
B. B.
th
report report
Environmental Environmental
on
G
BENCH, BENCH,
at at
ibun
l l
C
conversant conversant
. .
ega
of of
by by
a
tion tion
State State
this this
Application Application
Tr
ill
sa
d d
W/o. W/o.
g g
am am
Assistant Assistant
n n
n
e
. .
tion
, ,
I I
e
by by
a
a
fil
that that
ee
Engineer Engineer
r
Thiruvananthapuram Thiruvananthapuram
N
nt nt
by by
ral
charee charee
G
Kerala Kerala
e
e
that that
e e
omp
Application Application
years
Pollution Pollution
l l
c
K
port port
bl
a
Original Original
quarryin
'
e
e e
, ,
HONOURABLE HONOURABLE
r
t PRINCIPAL PRINCIPAL
37 37
and and
a
filed filed
m
t
ntal ntal
e e
Office, Office,
tion
e
a
Hon
to to
ra
submitted submitted
th
nvironm
N
e e
f f
a a S
THE THE
aged aged
Orieinal Orieinal
pu
l
e e
o
t t
additional additional
Board Board
th
a
, ,
e e e Applicant Applicant
follows: follows:
Respondent(s) Respondent(s)
of of
bl
s s
. .
ec
i
th
'
era
Environmental Environmental
District District
nth
s
as as
Report Report
9, 9,
the the
B.S
o o
nvironm
, ,
a
full full
t
e
b
of of
01
resp
nt nt
Hon
d d K
ana
r r
spectfully spectfully
e
e e
e
e
e
s
t
state state
e e
r
8.2
age age
matter matter
BEFORE BEFORE
e
th
ov
th
ec
.0
Bincy Bincy
m
is is
n n
hiruv
5
a
, ,
ec
I
the the
Interim Interim
holdine holdine
It It
repr
r
Thiruvananthapuram Thiruvananthapuram
Engineer charge charge
may may
with with
of of
T
d
dir
0 O
, ,
It It
is is
at at
to to of of
in in
of of
for for
the the
the the
the the
the the
upto upto
were were
of of
of of
rivers
unit unit
place place
from from
Regional Regional
operation operation
quarry quarry
visited visited
The The
between between
CB CB
nvironmental nvironmental
validity validity
other other
operational. operational.
anddecided anddecided
Department Department
construction construction
E
were were
residence residence
, ,
illegal illegal
permit permit
importance importance
residence residence
buildings, buildings,
KSP
alleged alleged
trees trees
No No
area. area.
was was
the the
with with
PCB
the the
under under
the the
quarry quarry
(n. (n.
, , neer
KS KS
at at
rubber rubber
19/2/2020 19/2/2020
gi
quarry. quarry.
quarry quarry
structure structure
n
the the
quarrying quarrying
E of of
temple temple
permitted permitted
on on
including including
from from
the the
a a
The The
including including
archelological archelological
infra infra
from from
environmentby environmentby
activities activities
20/11/2019 20/11/2019
is is
the the
consent/permit/ consent/permit/
ting ting
array array
Annexure Annexure
of of
e
from from
the the
obtained obtained
quarry quarry
as as
an an
50m 50m
me
social social
of of
to to
officials officials
sill.! sill.!
from from
There There
dated dated
is is
a a
the the
2 2
00m 00m
had had
of of
1 1
No No
than than
nvironmental nvironmental
residences residences
quarrying quarrying
to to
27/02/2020. 27/02/2020.
E
rock rock
marked marked
Quurry Quurry
to to
unit unit
There There
monuments monuments
damage damage
on on
quarry. quarry.
. .
more more
and and
Geology Geology
due due
the the
nearby nearby
nearest nearest
convened convened
the the
of of
compliance compliance
more more than
NanniyodeGramaPanchayat NanniyodeGramaPanchayat
to to
comprising comprising
exposed exposed
visited visited
and and
Application. Application.
and and
toassess toassess
of of
time, time,
order,Chief order,Chief
were were
historical historical
plantation
and and
the the
property property
was was
or or
submitted submitted
and and
distance distance
the the
this this
to to
is is
at at
nearby. nearby.
quarry quarry
which which
site site
Mining Mining
by by
proximity proximity
Original Original
inspection inspection
question. question.
distance distance
rubber rubber
quarrying quarrying
with with
in in
the the
of of
the the
seen seen
at at
verify verify
Geology Geology
the the
by by
which which
that, that,
close close
of of
joint joint
was was
of of
damages damages
situated situated
ecosystems ecosystems
a a
was was
and and
in in
to to
Thiruvananthopuram Thiruvananthopuram
residences residences
quarry quarry
unit unit
noted noted
r r
entrance entrance
e
the the
compliance compliance
19/11/2020 19/11/2020
In In
surrounded surrounded
applicant applicant noticed noticed Accordingly Accordingly
Department Department
was was
the the
boundary boundary The The
sensitive sensitive
of of
Clearanceconditions Clearanceconditions
worship worship
ord Mining Mining
conduct conduct
Office. Office.
applicant applicant
assessing assessing Three Three
C C
u u
~ ~
'
., .,
' '
_
, ,
,
-
I.\\
\ \
i:i,,
0 0
,Q~ ,Q~
\ \
r
I.'~,,~-
-
r,
~
11'\t 11'\t
-
I I
,<: ,<:
'
1111.'.l
!-!
111
ii ii
,
' '
lll
C
[l..
~r ~r
house house
lllllllll
s s
'
--
U111l'~ U111l'~
lll lll
·
i
1111 1111
.
,~1
y y
~~
petitioner
,
,
quarr
facing facing
1hc 1hc
area area
quarry quarry
inside inside
the the
of of
the the
J J
of of
Google Google
view view n
map map
-
• •
lc
si
y y
Google Google
boundary boundary
e e
th
<)unrr
at at
provided provided Fencing Fencing
\ \
,: ,:
---
:;t :;t
· ·
'"
,:, ,:,
~
1:. 1:.
, ,
0
_~ _~
. .
--
\\
~
Q
-
',t ',t
,
:.;.•·
.
::,-_ ::,-_
. .
,"•
:;. :;.
.,.
"
no no
no no
the the
the the
4~~ 4~~
~~~
and and
~st
r
-->-
was was
been been
~ ~
'
/
'
·,iEr
of of
owner owner
quarry quarry
nt:t:
was was
was was
that that
damage damage
~i
-
dust dust
n
Palliative Palliative
provided
quarrying quarrying
evergreen evergreen
has has
minimum minimum
Minister's Minister's
E
side side
the the
unit unit
. .
operational. operational.
of of
d d
a a
,
there there
. .
the the
\ \
and and
nl
No No
There There
the the
S
.
the the
depression depression
visible visible
day
be be
been been
B
mt'
Chief Chief
was was
on on
n
inside inside
~ ~
transportation. transportation.
visit visit
~\
condition condition
no no
.:
But But
Pain Pain
per per
n
from from
unit. unit.
in,
hall hall
i.e i.e
s
~tY ~tY
Bi
premises premises
the the
m m
have have
quarry quarry
the the
3 3
E
was was
the the
suppression suppression
in in
during during
Roads Roads
quarry quarry 00m 00m
the the
to to
quarrying. quarrying.
anl anl
towards towards
1 1
. .
Compensation Compensation
t
and and
in in
s
(B.P) (B.P)
for for
~1
2 2
during during
to to
60,000/-
~
the the
There There
activities. activities.
, ,
Nanniyod Nanniyod
\
,
violation violation
. .
out out
stored stored
than than
Rs Rs
tarred
a a
around around
magazine magazine
visit: visit:
covered covered
subject subject
due due
is is
for for
,
that that
of of
water water
CSR CSR
points points
remitted remitted
or or
Points Points
area. area.
for for
rocks rocks
season
was was
more more
site site
of of
seen seen
for for
area area
carried carried
fund fund
water water
of of
4 4
plantation
the the
formula
licensed licensed
within within
Border Border
premises. premises.
Environmental Environmental
noticed noticed
were were
Border Border
nsation nsation
30000/-
rain rain
on on
house house
summer summer
exposed exposed
e
the the
quarrying quarrying
maximum maximum
entrance entrance
and and
of of
in in
Charity Charity
rubber rubber
a a
Rs Rs
in in
was was
sprinkling sprinkling
that that
displayed. displayed.
distance distance
the the
maintained maintained
excavation excavation
quarry quarry
comp
by by
of of
based based
between between
out out
a a
unit unit
Being Being
surrounding surrounding
and and
and and
following following
anywhere anywhere
is is
d d
quarry quarry
seen seen
it it it
construction. construction.
at at
the the
e
stored stored
s
soil soil
the the
ntal ntal
guidelines, guidelines,
the the
e
the the
applicant's applicant's
day day
vi
Manual Manual
around around
the the
in in
Fund Fund
informed informed
are are
details details
in in
carri
were were
top top
e e
from from
the the
under under
it
tailings tailings
per per
provided provided
account account
out out
depression. depression.
seen seen
is is
no no
using using
Temple Temple
surrounded surrounded
sprinkling. sprinkling.
upto upto
of of
was was
e e s
CPCB CPCB
tarred. tarred.
a a
trees trees
owner owner
is is
Relief Relief
times times
the the
was was
observations observations
as as
th
environm
exhibitinglocation exhibitinglocation
for for
facing facing
r r
ing ing
is is
w
were were
in in
5000/-
e
not not
y
g g
Society. Society.
products products
carried carried
ess ess
p
roads roads
which which
unit unit
explosives explosives
submitted submitted
e e
unit unit
separate separate
rr
r
tr
these these
Rs Rs
a
e e
e
used used
position position
h
e
The The
is is
Care Care has has
quarry quarry water water
calculated calculated
The The
The The
No No
Blasting Blasting
Dis
Fencing Fencing
of of general general
As As
Pillars Pillars
seen seen
were were
The The
plants plants
area area
There There
to to
Durin
Th
d
T
Qu
Specific Specific
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• • • •
l l
g g
in in
of of
of of
for for
m/ m/
the the
ga
ued ued
y y
s s
of of
i
0 0
a
.
ss
5.4 5.4
taken taken
di11 r1 r1
ille
i
1
m
red red
Minin
c
11
, ,
a a
from from
m
ll
lly lly
of of
a
ime ime
t t
which which
t
u
ma
1II/ 1II/
s
perate perate
f
maximum maximum
H
s s
which which
mini,,11
being being
O
(u
m
( (
and and
11
thi
or or
condition condition
u u
permi
to to
and and
g g
e e
ro ro
on on
of of b
250 250
80) 80)
c
500, 500,
nt nt
Board. Board.
s s
60 60
c11 c11
d d
y y
the the
c;c c;c
= =
place place
c·
se
as as
mi
n
of of
Department Department
below) below)
11c
l
n
durin
of of
(Quarry (Quarry
took took
the the
nrn
11p
p
bn
EC
{
for for
f
Co
. .
80 80 Rupee
the the
by by
take take
)
and and
=
,1 ,1
be be
taken taken
.5 .5
0
20/11/2019. 20/11/2019.
l
violation violation
in in
the the
took took
0
d d
be be
s, s,
11 11 is is
25
whld, whld,
obtained obtained
ued ued
e e
in in
on on detailed detailed
ul
, ,
s
11 11
h
from from
to to
violation violation
s s
u
maximum maximum
11
day
is
i
is is
minimum minimum
c
sector sector
ntl,,n ntl,,n
H('
n n
Integrate Integrate
l
a a
h h
rnrntlo
e
later later
index index
tor tor
o
e e
c
muy muy
c
k
and and
112 112
deriving deriving
tion tion
vl
be be
th
the the
umed umed
h h
a
tu tu
which which
permit permit
1wc
s
c
Geology Geology
h h
which which inspection inspection
mp 00 00
g g
5 5
whi
of of
y y
l l
had had
for for
l l
of of c,;
n
Operate Operate
as
l
lcul
d d
C'o
h
may may
s s
whi Compensation Compensation
rlu
s s
industrial industrial o
of of
to to
is is
1
and and
l l
u11ll
, ,
w
rivi
5.4 5.4
s
Ca
11
o
pollution pollution
joint joint
unit unit
n
e
during during
of of
11
g g
rnlion rnlion
d
unil
o
Compensation Compensation
nt
peri
( (
i
n
c
s s
c
i
obtained obtained
Rupee
""' ""'
l11du
a a
provided provided
which which
LF LF
2**(
00
ge ge
op
for for
zat
r
The The
5
• •
day
X X
l I I l
Mining Mining
in in
mining mining du, du,
a
ri
of of
Index Index
not not
Consent Consent
. .
11 11
of of
for for
r r
during during
not not
=
s s
of of
of of
minimum minimum
iro11m
r r l
Average Average
of of
e e
e
ytl ytl
condition condition
l,., l,.,
cc
ex ex
l
v
X X
ego
ri
a a
fo
250)) 250))
t
and and
a
d
had had
I~ I~
of of
nd
facto R R
s s
was was
5 5
I
b1
sc
Environmental Environmental
ca
.
Board
ractor ractor
be be
plac
a
Rup
100. 100.
J J
mum mum
category, category,
X X 1
R R
of of
n n
r r
s s n n
i
y y
i
n n
o
xi
noticed noticed
i i
N N
fo
unit unit
tr
lo
N N
Pollution Pollution
er er
Geology Geology
Number Number
= =
s
nd nd
' '
the the
Integrated Integrated
s s
X X
Environmental Environmental
X X
a
nw
= =
or or
= =
ll>r ll>r
= =
1 1
t
llut
H
1
l
c
,
of of
umb
1
violation violation
by by
Department Department
The The
and and
Fencing Fencing quarrying quarrying
the the
Pl Pl
Pl
N N
Locat
R R
indu
nd nd
c
P(
r
N
Fa
. .
a
Fnc
c
== ==
I
• •
2. 2.
ge ge
• •
r
l l
00 00
a
I I
f:(' Wh
l
LF LF
R R
medium medium
P
N N
Violation
S S
Where,EC
EC= EC= Calculation Calculation
of of
as as
ce ce
on on
we we
5 5
that that
.
/ /
with with
issue issue
0
ll
(Ill). (Ill).
on) on)
cause cause
tioned tioned
noti
owner owner
n
c
lli
case case
to to
i
Number Number
be be
Copy Copy
m
e e
y y
Copitnl Copitnl
't'f 't'f
s
019). 019).
g
,
submined submined
y y
m
. .
Inspection Inspection
fun
e. e.
Spread Spread
:ll
i
n
/2
assessed assessed
show show
e e
this this
lar
declared declared
on on
is is
m
n
of of
mmittee mmittee
quarr
09
with with
fn_t:
is is
infom1ed infom1ed
o
environmental environmental
only) only)
In In
h h
y y
the the
2020
ed ed
the the
for for
unit unit
. co
tl tl
2/
c
n n
s
decided decided
y y
Anoexure Anoexure
0
n
da
try try
5 5
was was
the the
showcause showcause
:-
ied ied
.
s
to to
bu
the the
08 .
th
1
v
ace. ace.
lk'l11.
to to
whi
11 11
issued issued
and and
the the
l
ns ns
Geology Geology
of of
le
the the
was was
25
pl
he he
the the
,~ ,~
expert expert
indu
ess ess
humbl
ln'll
it it
l
m
due due
ond ond
to to
019 019
be be
and and
e e
B to to
tion. tion.
Thousand Thousand
l
uld uld
Crorc) Crorc)
is is
an an
/2
assess assess
is is
[m [m
o
notice notice
up up
y y
zn
e e
which which
takes takes
to to
t
t t
ty ty
co
and and
dat~ dat~
out out
n
05
s
ay. ay.
lockdown lockdown
it it
marked marked
hearing hearing
/
of of
plare-(N) plare-(N)
h h
un
ori
O
Pandemic Pandemic
,
c
and and
a a
l
g
for for
13
Repl
s s
e
medium medium
Mining Mining
11,20000/-
hi
t
(EC) (EC)
Twen
mnll mnll
'"
and and
But But
o
order order
s
w
= =
pennit pennit
ys ys
took took
dwunge, dwunge,
c
pee of of
Copy Copy
ned ned
for for
underw
o o
1 1
carried carried
(ll). (ll).
from from
y y
pollution pollution populntion populntion
da
. .
ve
s s
0 0
the the
Ru
is is ionwide ionwide
i
( (
the the .
tr
X X
L.akh L.akh
n
e e
tinn tinn
1
s
ce ce
of of
Covid-19 Covid-19
be be
i~ i~
b b
proceedings proceedings
th
ys ys
of of
co
Nat
in
ll. ll.
erewith erewith
0.5 0.5
th
tion tion
t t
thnn thnn
ndu
with with
of of
n
h iolation iolation
da
, ,
i
y y
o
1 (S
l' l'
6/2020
s s
opcm
,
ac
l
ride ride
X X
g_
ir n
m
2 2
quarrying. quarrying.
t'
,
s
Eleven Eleven
Compensation Compensation
n
c:
lc~
of of Department Department
of of
which which
11
22/
Aooexure Aooexure
Compensation Compensation
ed ed
e.'\.'-p
or or
S S
number number
250 250
t
lorgl' lorgl'
e e
'
(Si
nt nt
environmental environmental
/ /
i.
on on
S
oic oic
Spread Spread
c
for for
as as
.
e e
of of
X X
meetin
Chaim1an Chaim1an
could could
foctor
from from
0
illegnl illegnl
d&)
st
e e
s s
mpliance mpliance
icro icro
th
tm
the the
produced produced
-
y
n n
s
th
li11m
m
co
e e
of of
andfunher andfunher
112 112
-(Rupees -(Rupees
t11e t11e
t
fur fur
its
date date
'<-
da
/
is is
by by
ns ns
constitu
a
to to
r r
served served
in in
e e
X X
u
,
lnw
for for
un m1.
Board Board
it it
of of
mmittee mmittee
marked marked
pennit pennit
h_
th
ocatio
al
0 0
be be
c
80 80
v
was was
2
l
co
due due
after after
Environmental Environmental
id id
er er
~
0
umber umber
20.()00
F11
Environmental Environmental
"" ""
and and
r r
o o
w w
caused caused
uld uld received received
l. /2
:
t
val
from from
I I
o
fo
nsid
co
Joint Joint
LF
**N
S S
investigations investigations
EC= EC=
number number
the the
n
co
J
proceedings proceedings
ll ll
been been
18/03
~
days days
order order
JO
members members
e.Id e.Id
i
can can of of without without
Tot otthe otthe
Rupees Rupees
Subsequently. Subsequently. Thus Thus
on on notice notice
immediate immediate
herewith herewith
2J damage damage
notice notice
ln ln
hns hns
F
5 5 the the
' '
~~ ~~
-
e e e e
o o
i
s
th
e
f. f.
ol\ut th
,,,..--=---~ ,,,..--=---~
Board Board
---.:..=
for for
~ ~
'--
In In
belie
e e
// //
. .
~ ~
~ ~
r r
im
Engjneer Engjneer
(I/C) (I/C)
t
o:o:
and and
wn
Control Control
in
o
s' s'
g
n
E
k k d
l l
c
a
. .
o
D.S. D.S.
Engineer Engineer
l
month
S
.
B
r r
Pollution Pollution
o o
e
information information
:y :y
tw
irt1111110:11l
Environmental Environmental
~ ~
Hiney Hiney
und
Bim
m m
State State
~ ~
E
R R
llow llow a
a
w
lanl lanl
s
i
. .
s
to to
Environmental Environmental Kerala Kerala
Assistant Assistant
knowledge, knowledge,
gc
/\s
d d
trict trict
e
s
7 7
rny rny
2020 2020
di
Domu
pray
of of
e e
t t
s
th
be
ond ond
the the
humbly humbly
September September
c c
to to
s s
i
mi
of of
nvirunincnlOI nvirunincnlOI
e
it it
E
true true
nd
f f
a
dlly dlly
o
P
ccR ccR
arc arc
th
nt nt
8
9 9
e
ton
1
s
-
m
the the
id
ubovc ubovc
um
c
ir
ssess
this this
Cov
a c
t.otcd t.otcd
s
All All Outed Outed full
day
best
th
Board
8
Control
the
to
the
Engineer
(UC)
holding
Control
this
Others
Pollution
correct
on
Nanniyode
&
Vazhapara
TRIBUNAL,
Engineer B.S
and
presently
State
Pollution
verify
true
Environmental
~ Kerala
DELID
Bincy
State
GREEN
Paluvally,
of
are A
508/2019
Kerala
hereby
Chantharan
NEW
No. Engineer,
do
State
Usha
Environmental Assistant Kerala
above
C/o Pachayilkonam, Pacha,
·
Engineer
NATIONAL stated
BENCH,
belief.
is
Application
VERIFICATION
and Vs
Environmental
what
all
HON'BLE
Thiruvananthapuram,
Environmental
Original
PRINCIPAL
that
of
information
THE
Assistant
office,
B.S, charge
Applicant
District
BEFORE
knowledge
Respondent(s)
Bincy
September 2020,
our
I, additional Board, of of f
.,
e
o t
the
a
rv ty
i
P.O
u
.
St
o
s
riat
THE
t
e e e
11/1
a
Granite
.
t
o
uthor
ea ea ~ e OF
Treo
ll ll ll
a
No f
BUILDING
20-11-2019
o
ecre
10
: pve
Kerola
Co Co Co
S
subject
d ,
t.
uing
Paluvolly
MT
e di.
rem
V ct ~
L
, iss PURPOSES)/
i
e
ov
I
AND
Survey
Nome
e
Medi. Medi. M
No
N ;t
str
Land
9
Dat
i
2015
h
, . G . ,
n
t
i
T,
T
,
D
and
S S ST ST
17737
of
19-11-2020
Pacho
2015
Own
3(1),
,
Rules · ract
t /
-
STONE/LATERITE
- x
/
"'·-~
-
/
PRESCRIBED
69
Hectares
/
Address
RULES
RULES
5
s
o e
000
t
----- 2 . 251/
&
.
...:.:::...__,'
FOR
. 4. 4.25,688
rmit
9/
Amount ,
Rs.
.
......
Rs.1
e
Rs
GEOLOGY
e
p
Rs
0.5023 BUILDING
(I)
Vazhappara,
UNDER
ul
&
r
KERALA
USED
of 1/ f
ignature
al Concession
o
r
hayath
S
}
permitted
OF
c Thiruvananthapuram
arrying
/2
019
ne
i 019
u
CONCESSION
2
area
2019
2
SAND Veedu,
e
of
-
l q
GRANITE
M
MINING
u
f
thopurom
1)
r GRANTED
08
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
an - o
FORMM
- (
ode
:
,
l
Annexure . OF
under
OF
e hereby
05-08-
ub 05
09-08-
:
THAN
s
ramopan
Taluk
Pa
applicable)
is
Minor
,
typ
G
from
(if e
MINERAL
land ll Did
Dtd.
issued
&Date
Dtd.
System
See
a
•
,
/
OFFICE
08-2019
hiruvonon
- .
GOVERNMENT
T
rmitted
the
or
be
System)
Polic
yode
.
No.
land
e F 05 l
Kovllvllakath
(OTHER
10
i:r r
f
/
Kurupuzha
Kerala CRP
consent/NOC
:
p of
to
,
o
MINOR
r im
H,
of
mineral)
the
CRP
EXTRACTION .
H Did
g
DEPARTMENT
Vazhappara
.
f the
Nedumangad cer
SHELL/SEASHELL
Nann
n
Rule
,
halan
O. ,
of
of
cto
, DISTRICT o
ffi E
. SAND
ollecto
opted
/1433/DO1/ML/2019 n
NIL
C
e
P
of owner i
ry l
Nedumangad
.
O
posses
FOR
C
mineral
a
o
culars
t 9
1 i
.
28926201920M
t i
Thlruvananthapuram
11
7 ct s
,
of
e
/LIME case Insp
KERALA of
i
the
.: .
Veedu
r
11
tted:
i e n
ohsildor str
holder
i
of rmit
(Name
T ub and trans
th t
occupier e
Thlruvananthapuram s D Village tion
i S Sec
:y
KL01582593201920M
KL005729027201920M
PERMIT
KL005
. . . . .
p .
c
CLAY
in
rem
iro1111
Patuvally 1
2 3 4
5
v
A~
the
e
of
e
IJim Village
3(1) tra
11
neral mentioned
e
:
i
perm
e
l
f Vljciyamohanan.T
ex Stone)
fe addres
m
Vljoyomohonan.T
o/
cabl
i
from
11ll : of of tv
the
Rule ,
of Kovllvllakath Nedumangad
Sri. Pecha,
l
expiry
concession/part
Se
R
d
al r
to r STONE/ORDINARY
s
Sri.
/
and
1
v
e 6/2019-20/GBS/QP e
e
S
y
of
Item
DMF
v
appl . o
e
ce
tails
ntity i ORDINARY
lication
R t
e
QUARRYING
e
e a ffi
nd onditions
A~~
o
u
No
Nedumongad Kurupuzha pp
(Bulldlng u c
D
O To
Cop
ec
A
(N Whether Q Nom Numb
mineral Dot
r ,
•
'
·
,;;
~
-
I
)'
in
·-
.,, or
not
the
--
and
593
~
the to
.-
A.
against
recover
the
another .
1
t:?020
0
1986
710/2017,
utilized of
to
should
t!)
815
---
1
LtJT
from
CETPs
22/06/2020
and
(Protection)
cw of
in R
.
D
in
.__
action
· No.
maintaining and
, damage
·
.
ACT,
·,
"
which
.'
,i_.
STPs,
the
for
Date:
Samiti
matter
·
.
chamber operate
penal O.A 4
.
to
authorized
-
Tribunal
00
and
the
the
scale
in
account
c
take
in
in
M
Board;
also
695
Environmental
50
own
1
Suraksha
.....;:.__..,;_-::;·
Green
-
8
www.
. 1
consent
may
:
the
maintaining
are
23
separate
:
pollution
n
their
CONTR
compensation
m1CDJl(lm web
a
t~ ~
Control
(PROTECTION)
12/03/2019
Tribunal,
and
(II)
2
nimin
l8.03.2020
in
h
5
National
without
srn
1
water C
"CPCB
environqient";
up
notified
down
8
Board's
on
Paryavaran
55
1
l
of
dated
3
Green
recover
8
'ble kept
c.fu
the the
1
2
the :
PolluLion
quany
of .2J
be
m~
~
Hon
laying
setting
and
5
by Annexure
l
fAX
S
Order
Control
I control
or
of
rock
Thiruvananthapuram
in mQfl
may
not
2J
conducted
.
POLLUTION National
,
directed
water;
Government
of
Central
ov
5J.
and
vidc
m l
O.
assess
of .
for
8
l
P
by
protection
fund
@g
l 9 l
i11ccr
l.2020
Board.
4
g
ENVIRONMENTAL
cb Ors.),
n
0.1J hearing
Pollution
p also .0 polluters
1
for
0 l 0 E
NGT
Hon'ble
s Central
the
l
k
STATE said
·
oCT\.l08
No.375/2012
07
fixed /2
a
s.
the
operation and
the
Pattom
1312'1 of
508/20
the
the the
m le
.S.
may
(T\)
-
plan
prevention
r;;;,~
the
l
State
of
B .
111c11l
GEN
§ UNDER
/
sca
dated
accountable
:y
0H
AS
ail:, the
India · No from
(Civil)
l
the
E
and
m
~
- wholesomeness
P
Bim
the
action
.
are
of
e
CPCB
for
Enviro11
ion
G~ of C'n:n.:rJ Kl!:RALA Minutes Order 0.A. Chairman that an 111 (W OffVM han a sat 1 1ii' t L Board \VHEREAS WHEREAS 2. and Unauthorized WHER ~ who of , . l 7 l 1986 NOTICE Union : ss pen f: A~, 20 le CB/H P Sub Re restonng Act, Vs. of those ETPs environment terms directed be com - 3 ,,. ~ ~ ~ nL·.:r nL·.:r at at of of of of gi the the the the n No. No. that that e e Act, Act, E New New their their from from Pays Pays b NGT NGT Water Water period period in in , , h say say down down of of c matter matter form form 0.A 0.A may may Assessing Assessing Assessing Assessing n the the the the direction's direction's to to apart apart e Control Control (Prevention (Prevention in in laid laid U 30 30 is is irun1nt'11lal irun1nt'11lal of of Hon'ble Hon'ble for for l l for for that that Pollution Pollution and and the the in & & be be ' 111 111 a Air Air and and · direction direction E d d (Protection) (Protection) ip exercise exercise e the the 50 50 c t t place place collected collected date date "Needles "Needles may may per per 1981 1981 ri1t in in . . 1986, 1986, is1a111 is1a111 a 80, 80, Fund"; Fund"; s CPCB CPCB Prin l be be as; as; c also, also, as as A, 20/11/2018 20/11/2018 of of took took Tribunal, Tribunal, damages damages the the to to Act, Act, Act, Act, rified 16 16 the the or or which which must, must, e (P[ (P[ vironmen v (Prevention) (Prevention) noted noted n "Methodology "Methodology by by dated dated Green Green Rs. Rs. environment". environment". scale scale Tribunal, Tribunal, Utilize Utilize 353/20 a a recover recover e e E in in 1974, 1974, violation violation sector sector observed/due observed/due NGT NGT . . liance liance application application to to th respectively) respectively) Water Water Pollution) Pollution) condition condition r r Order Order No Such Such and and (Protection) (Protection) (3) (3) e protect protect Circcn Circcn Act, Act, National National Plan Plan A A of of the the comp compensation compensation . other other l l which which to to the the und Green Green developed developed a O local local of of Hon'ble Hon'ble of of industrial industrial in in violation violation assess assess in in developed developed and and for for ay ay and and follows; follows; l the the of of the the Action Action l l s s to to e Compensation Compensation Hon'ble Hon'ble of of Control Control Nation d as as various various powers powers 018 018 Principle". Principle". scale scale to to has has Pollution) Pollution) 198 198 to to day c c is is and and Environment Environment /2 [n [n 1 nd nd the the index index bl a ' authorities authorities day day Orange Orange of of instance, instance, of of /1 LF LF the the n nd nd Pay's Pay's entitled entitled y y o 102/2014 102/2014 Act, Act, X X methodology methodology a l' 22 r regard regard I I CPCB CPCB for for o the the s s d d Red, Red, incidental incidental ce ce ntion ntion pursuant pursuant e are are e e ntrol ntrol and and tut under under prescribed prescribed the the n n of of a th in in for for t RX RX dat eve lian Number Number , , Environmental Environmental Co s Population Population ee authorities: authorities: Polluter Polluter - 2017 2017 N N Pr " having having order, order, 1974 1974 - - Compensation Compensation Compensation Compensation ( e e tw X X h e Pollution) Pollution) EAS EAS t the the Where, Where, PI PI and and EC EC N N b taken taken comp the the order order of of R P[ P[ , , powers Air Air exercise exercise 499/2014 499/2014 of of Act, Act, rE , , on on authorities authorities l l the the levels, levels, l l y y similar similar tion ta :V h rs rs 593 593 the the WHEREAS WHEREAS WHEREAS WHEREAS EC= EC= \ in in n e Control Control e 2014 / d llut rious rious Prevention Prevention 117 1986, 1986, Principle" Principle" Environmental Environmental passed passed hierarc va Environmental Environmental Pollution Pollution inci po O.A. O.A. and and statutory statutory prosecu ( ( Delhi Delhi r r t' ll' 1 i to to l l be be g Ob Ob of of for for m m for for 11 l l E and and u nta e m below; below; million million i l.5 l.5 . . -- million million shall shall 111:.1I 111:.1I s l l . ,: \ levied levied 30000 30000 l l are are 20000 20000 10000 10000 B 6250 6250 18750 18750 12500 12500 7500 7500 5000 5000 11250 11250 micro micro location location max 11111 i distance distance :y :y -- be be ru i for for nd nd population population units units 81m m m and and below below Environm a km km ~ than than million, million, Environmental Environmental E Compensation Compensation of of 0.5 0.5 of of for for l O O l nl nl e e 5 5 a 100 100 l th 2 2 less less to to f f < < type type o Compensation Compensation take take s s up up Assis a to to and and for for city/town city/town to to all all or or l l of of ( ( for for population population '.:?.50 '.:?.50 1250 1250 10000 10000 20000 20000 6250 6250 30000 30000 18750 18750 12500 12500 units) units) 7500 7500 million million l l 3750 3750 minimum minimum million million as as a a l l l O O l Calculated Calculated e e boundary boundary having having R R b Compensation Compensation large large Environmental Environmental Environmental Environmental population population city/town city/town calculated calculated than than ay ay for for on on m of of h h (Suggested (Suggested eration 1.5 1.5 violation. violation. less less c op population population city/town city/town Municipal Municipal consider consider to to on on based based minimum minimum whi and and of of in in , , for for for for s to to case case boundary boundary ee Compensation Compensation factor factor case, case, d d with with in in scale scale million million l.25 l.25 e t above.) above.) Rup 5 5 medium medium for for Kerala, Kerala, any any unit unit tion tion in in gges and and for for sa Type Type r r in in in in u l l n o t e e Location Location e Large Large Medium Medium Micro/Small Micro/Small municipal municipal c Factor Factor Large Large s s s - - - oo oo - i Medium Medium Fa s - omp Larg Medium Medium Micro/Small Micro/Small million million population population r - population, population, the the industrial industrial Environmental Environmental LF LF ~e ~e small, small, S - S C lt lt - - - o R the the Red Red Red , , Orange Orange Orange Orange Oran WHEREAS WHEREAS Green Green Green- Green-Micro/Small Green-Micro/Small WHEREAS WHEREAS ) 5000/day; 5000/day; 9 9 8 8 7 7 6 6 5 5 l l 4 4 ...... SI. SI. .) .) 2 2 No. No. (LF-1 (LF-1 Rs, Rs, , , l l e e to to of of a on on on on th n and and ad n~ini:i:r n~ini:i:r non g 5 5 d d io E e t of of lluti without without o lak.h lak.h of of . . r r man Na violation violation bas assessing assessing P S e . u directed directed c c t t Showcause Showcause !3 11.:nlal 11.:nlal 1 bl ; ; )' )' for for as day day ' be be and and Section Section i: Ncd p · · to ini11 quarry quarry - . . · State State Eleven Eleven · on on l l chamb Bin m m a . . not not H per per E the the e e 111 111 CPCB CPCB the the under under (Rs u th l for for 11/1 11/1 shall shall premises premises e e in in directed directed Kcrala Kcrala by by operated operated CHAIRMAN CHAIRMAN . . ;\~~1s for 02.09.2019 l0,000/- e e no unit unit . the the h vested vested to to have have quarry quarry Sy d d sc sc the the hereby hereby 1 l,20,000/- Rs. Rs. ; 03.2020 03.2020 l l c . in in you you the the is is . . developed developed ecte a a as as 20 g g why why (5) (5) powers powers compensation compensation Rs d d dir that that e cted cted unit unit to to r on on e e e of of 13.05.2019 13.05.2019 e t as as the the as as s h i the the ra ra insp g quarryin notic a of of from from re l l days; days; calculated calculated s s notice notice the the 986, 986, methodology methodology a NGT NGT l l 12 12 ega h is is 05.2019; 05.2019; extracted. extracted. l l conducted conducted . to to days days . . ill lc lc environmental environmental Nedumangad Nedumangad the the this this Officers Officers A 13 T.H., T.H., Vazhapp , , for for . exercise exercise a a Act, Act, 112 112 ur ur Compensation Compensation rock rock of of was was h on on O the the on'b f f . come come s [ yo in in P o I I from from U for for Board Board t t Veed, Veed, s t. t. e e has has pennit pennit n ni based based th receipt receipt it it the the o.i assess assess S hearing hearing only) only) g effect effect Compensation Compensation a of of a a to to quantity quantity Puluvalli Puluvalli (Protection) (Protection) l l e e vilak.ath vilak.ath a therefore, therefore, E/\S E/\S Vijayamohanan Vijayamohanan /mining /mining with with n th Environmental Environmental . . R ha, ha, days days l: nthapur:.im nthapur:.im ac ow ow an an a Board Board thousand thousand 15 15 P Kovil Kovil Shri n N \VHEREAS \VHEREAS Tribu WHEREAS WHEREAS WHEREAS WHEREAS WHEREAS WHEREAS WH ronmental ronmental ironment ironment consent consent inspection inspection n n ·i v y y nsidt!ring nsidt!ring ee To To ontrol ontrol twenty twenty deposit deposit En within within Em compliance compliance an undersigned; undersigned; the the co C Thiruva Gr ar ar m :; n E l l S S . B ~ ~ rnn~nw ~ ~ 1 mc B Em Em ~Lani ~Lani \.-., . ) ) 6 ( , , r e ne i , , Eng , , Engineer , , Office Office Environmental Environmental ional ional hiruvananthapuram hiruvananthapuram Reg District District Environmental Environmental Chief Chief T Thiruvananthapuram Thiruvananthapuram . . I to: to: ,.7- Copy Copy l . · r r • s e a i rd ed _ ng n l fo i th i and fi Non g e ee Boa ri embe appara ad itt O r tor Member M h h the assess - d es d az r age 9 e r r 1 caused V of m e m comm enclosed account- ENGINEER ____ to t . For a Member 20 Membe s 0 da Boa r / t . i r at ;· s of ORDER l i u - - · a , uvananthapuram uvananthapuram g reg 202 508 a ap . report ir r The 111be steps in . ' hir damage exper · head quarry 08 nth Th T ,:e . Membe r H No MENTAL a order has . the ssueo . . . 1 n - - an onment T 25 he take the A the Geology ) Geology t r . i quarry ruvananthapuram- ruvananthapuram f v O i l the to sd/- t. o ruva ders ity. i Office Vazhappa and Office and NGT en in Th Th from ( - f of . Or . g t Th CHAIRMAN al o -c-o_H....,T--R--0,-L-B~O~A--R--D ENVIR - assess . · Member Member in activ illegal budge FORWA}t N ice Board me . ng considered - ee - 2020 (Ill) i s . ' Department tt Mining Department Min i Office Off be Office Copy TIO . operation 01 the jayamohanan Dated Regional . Regional area of i U of CHIEF Tribunal . ) , year , illegal 07 7 quarry LL Village against ( Village comm shall Water ORDER ; strict Water egal the Head i Sri.V Tribunal ·,y. /J Assessment ected . PO District ill D \ PROCEEDINGS of the r y _:- weeks ir - Annexure . . 7ha member~ Green led b d - dated i - t: by current f "C TE - Illegal . , ,-::,;• to Engineer, Engineer l ~J"'h A regard Dire~torate Ground nspect Green Directorate two Ground "• "''J ~ ,Jf neer i ; upp Office i s ,II the onal i ~ 2014 ST '-'b 16, i .:r ~r / order • e;, due th 'I> own~d Kuruppuzha above -._ K 111.: >::. Engineer [! Eng IJJ from from . from \{ from . onal n LA g :,c following Nat , i i ~' ! quarry 11 from shall . : GEN l Constitution within a " NGT / t 508/2019 RA 508/2019- l - cer. . ronmental ,;er the Nat i read i ble . d ' environment ij . Accounts \ S KE ble . caused .:111a uvananthapuram Officer ' TVM Officer stone Off Officer apuram Officer No ('f no 13 11 Ho / ble Env 1 Environmental h ' with r the Y. A report action ronmental o q i Thir cause rnn Order Hon the HO ef age 1 i 111 / · ': to l 0 ~ - a committee Hon The 11 13 expenditure : - of : _ anant b Member Ch Senior Env Convener Senior Village Member Chief Se Senior Env1ronmen Convener tuted Vil Conti~gency to i ' vide damage . PCB . . . . . . . . nl . The 1 <1 2 5 3 The 4 1 The 3 5 2 4 l s Read 1 No Application Thiruv status the const and damage submit plan necessary To Copy . i\"