Chua 2014 Dissertation (Filing)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Chua 2014 Dissertation (Filing) The Sacredness of Being There: Race, Religion, and Place-Making at San Francisco’s Presbyterian Church in Chinatown by Christopher Viboon Chua A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Ethnic Studies in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Elaine H. Kim, Chair Professor Catherine C. Choy Professor David K. Yoo Professor Minoo Moallem Fall 2014 Abstract The Sacredness of Being There: Race, Religion, and Place-Making at San Francisco’s Presbyterian Church in Chinatown by Christopher Viboon Chua Doctor of Philosophy in Comparative Ethnic Studies University of California, Berkeley Professor Elaine H. Kim, Chair Established in 1853, the Presbyterian Church in Chinatown (PCC) in San Francisco, CA is the oldest Asian church of any Christian denomination in North America and the first Chinese Protestant church outside China. Its history in the United States reaches back to the earliest days of Chinese migration to this country, giving the church a rootedness in Asian America that few other institutions can match. This dissertation examines how the contemporary community at PCC negotiates its institutional memory in creating a sense of place and a sense of collective self that is simultaneously both Protestant Christian and distinctively Chinese American. Employing the use of archival materials and oral histories conducted specifically for this project, the study explores how the three language ministries which currently comprise the church—English, Mandarin, and Cantonese—navigate historical resources and contemporary memories in different ways to support varying ideological positions in the present. The project focuses specifically on place-making and the process of investing the physical space of the church and its location in a historically evolving Chinatown with meanings that distinguish the community from the white American Protestant establishment on the one hand and from non-Christian Chinese society on the other. This process of place-making is mapped over three defining moments in the life of PCC: the church’s founding, its institutionalization, and its struggle to redefine itself in the wake of trauma from clergy sexual abuse. The study argues that these three chapters, reaching from 1853 to the recent past, are especially formative for PCC’s identity, because they span the period of white missionary leadership at the church from beginning to end and, as a result, become the terrain over which the racial/ethnic meanings of being Chinese American Christian are negotiated, contested, and defined. In its founding moment, the intersection of racialized thought and theological justification for the establishment of a physical home for anticipated Chinese Christians resulted in the first enduring expression of religion that was conceptually Asian American, rather than simply Asian religion transplanted to the United States or Western religion imposed upon Asian immigrants. The institutionalization of the church was the enfleshment of this concept 1 with Chinese believers, whose practices of place subverted missionary understandings of Christianity and church by reinterpreting the Gospel message within the social, economic, and political contexts of being a racial/ethnic minority in the oftentimes hostile environment of the United States. Even as this hostility eventually seemed to give way before new visions of plurality in the 1960s, it lingered at PCC in the form of clergy sexual abuse, which came to define the final chapter of missionary leadership at the Chinatown church. Inscribing its insistence on truth and healing into the physical space of the church, PCC has embraced its response to the trauma as a defining element of its identity as a Chinese American congregation at the beginning of a new era beyond missionary control. 2 Table of Contents Acknowledgments ii Preface iv 1. Introduction 1 2. Religion and Race as Praxis 28 Vignette A: The Earliest Locations 51 3. Anchoring Memory 52 Vignette B: The Neo-Gothic Building 81 4. Institutionalizing a Community 84 Vignette C: The Post-Earthquake Building 123 5. Reimagining a Chinese American Church 126 6. Conclusion 161 Endnotes 164 Bibliography 192 i Acknowledgments In writing this dissertation, I benefited greatly from the kindness of others. The members of the community at the Presbyterian Church in Chinatown cradled this project with their generosity, sharing with me their stories and their memories, their encouragement and their blessing. Far more persons in the church family than I can possibly name here individually have contributed to my understanding of this venerable institution, and just as many have helped me find my own place within it over the years. For this project specifically, fifteen persons—some of them currently associated with the church and others associated with it in the past—sat for oral history interviews: Sabrina Cheng, Calvin Chinn, Noël Chun, Douglas Clark, Harriet Hall, Sharlene Hall, Sabrina Gee-Shin, David Lee, Linda Lee, Jeremy Lue, Li Oi Lung, David Mote, David Pan, David Kao, and Bradford Woo. In addition, Nicholas Li spent many hours helping me with Chinese-language materials and talking with me about immigrant perspectives on church life. Their responses to my questions and their insights were invaluable contributions. A large portion of the research was conducted at libraries and archives, and at each, there were staff-people who kindly helped me find my way through the collections, most especially: Wei Chi Poon at the Ethnic Studies Library at UC Berkeley; Michael Peterson and Mary Moore at the San Francisco Theological Seminary Library; Lisa Jacobson, Charlene Peacock, and the entire warm and welcoming staff at the Presbyterian Historical Society; and Kelly Wong and Beth Skrondal at the San Francisco Planning Department. Without their guidance, I would surely have been lost. Philip Choy welcomed me into his home with tea and shared with me his vast knowledge of Chinatown architecture. Judy Yung met with me to share her vast knowledge of archives. At the same time I was researching and writing this dissertation, I taught as a lecturer in the Asian American and Asian Diaspora Studies Program at UC Berkeley. Balancing the two roles would likely have been far more challenging had it not been for all the support I received from the faculty, the staff, and my students. Michael Omi has been an inspiring mentor, from whom I learned a great deal about teaching at Cal, and the fifth-floor staff in Barrows Hall do a thousand things behind the scenes every day to make the classroom experience feel seamlessly smooth. My Graduate Student Instructors and my students have been unfailingly wonderful in every single semester I have taught at the university. The curiosity, energy, and good humor they bring into the classroom remind me why scholarship, teaching, and the effort that went into this dissertation are important and worthwhile. ii My Dissertation Committee was always responsive and warmly supportive. Catherine Choy, from whom I learned an appreciation for archival research, also chaired my Qualifying Exam, and her comment at the examination that I ought to pursue my thoughts on how painful experiences can be a community’s most distinguishing ones, despite its best attempts to distance itself, was a great encouragement for the final body chapter of this dissertation. David Yoo has been a friend and a counselor throughout my graduate-school experience, teaching me how to frame questions of religious experience in ways that are simultaneously respectful and academically meaningful, and teaching me by example how a scholar answers with accountability the messy needs of communities beyond the printed page. Minoo Moallem, who insists on academic engagement that involves the senses and not simply the mind, was as generous with her supportive feedback to me as she is big-hearted in her intellectual pursuits. Like all my other Dissertation Committee members, Minoo, too, sat on my QE Committee, and I will not forget the day I showed up in her office to discuss the paper she supervised, suffering tremendously from antibiotics-induced misery in the wake of a freak MRSA infection. That day was the low point of my graduate-school experience, and Minoo’s kindness and encouragement were what saw me through. Elaine Kim chaired my Dissertation Committee but, for far longer than that, has been an amazing teacher, mentor, inspiration, and friend to me. Every piece of advice or encouragement she gives manages to communicate her regard for me as a whole person. This dissertation has benefited much from her careful feedback; my intellectual journey has benefited no less from her modeling of imaginative and engaged scholarship; and my growth as a person has benefited even more from her constant example of compassionate leadership. In all aspects of my life, including this dissertation but extending far beyond it, my family is my greatest source of support. My Dad is undoubtedly happy that I have seen this project to completion. My sisters, Amelia and Belinda, whom I admire more than words can express, have cheered me on from the day I was born. They remember when I used to ask them how to spell every other word I had in mind to write and may perhaps, in part, cheer the completion of this dissertation as a tangible sign that those days are finally past. My Mom may never fully understand my explanations of what I have written here, but she will listen to me with her heart. And she will be the proudest of them all. To all of these people, and many more left unnamed, I owe my gratitude. Thank you. iii Preface I first came to the Presbyterian Church in Chinatown in the spring of 1991. Recently returned to the San Francisco Bay Area, I was looking for a church to join, preferably a Presbyterian one, since I had grown up in that tradition.
Recommended publications
  • Outside Lands Outside Lands History from the Western Neighborhoods Project 2 Where in West S.F.? (Previously Issued As SF West History)
    OutsideSan Francisco HistoryLands from Western Neighborhoods Project Volume 14, No. 1 Jan–Mar 2018 100 Years of the Twin Peaks Tunnel I NS I DE 1 Inside the Outside Lands OUTSIDE LANDS History from the Western Neighborhoods Project 2 Where in West S.F.? (Previously issued as SF West History) January-March 2018: Volume 14, Number 1 3 OpenSFHistory Highlight John Martini remembers Fleishhacker Pool EDITOR: Woody LaBounty CONTRIBUTORS: Angus Macfarlane, John Martini, and Arnold Woods 6 Roosevelt History, Part One The Story of a Richmond District school Board of Directors 2018 by Angus Macfarlane Chelsea Sellin, President Jamie O’Keefe, Vice President Anisha Gupta, Secretary 10 Westward the Course of Empire Takes its David Gallagher, Treasurer Way–100 Years of the Twin Peaks Tunnel Richard Brandi, David Chang, Nicole Meldahl, Kyrie Whitsett, Arnold Woods by Arnold Woods Staff: Woody LaBounty, Dave Lucas 15 Thank You to Our Donors Advisory Board Those who supported us in 2017 Cammy Blackstone, Al Harris, Gretchen Hilyard, Brady Lea, Felicity O’Meara, Paul Rosenberg, Nate Tico, and Lorri Ungaretti 20 Historical Happenings The WNP Event Calendar Western Neighborhoods Project 4016 Geary Boulevard, Suite A 22 A Home for History San Francisco, CA 94118 New WNP digs at 1617 Balboa Street Tel: 415/661-1000 Email: [email protected] Website: www.outsidelands.org facebook.com/outsidelands twitter.com/outsidelandz instagram.com/westernneighborhoods/ Cover: Mayor Rolph driving the first streetcar out of the west portal of the Twin Peaks tunnel, February 3, 1918. (wnp15.174) © 2018 Western Neighborhoods Project. All rights reserved. Inside the Outside Lands Woody LaBounty estern Neighborhoods Project from the neighborhoods recon- (that’s us), the nonprofit with a nected, but just as many strangers mission to preserve and share became new friends in sharing their Wlocal history, now has a public space love of history and of the west side for exhibits, presentations, and com- of San Francisco.
    [Show full text]
  • Bay to Bay: China's Greater Bay Area Plan and Its Synergies for US And
    June 2021 Bay to Bay China’s Greater Bay Area Plan and Its Synergies for US and San Francisco Bay Area Business Acknowledgments Contents This report was prepared by the Bay Area Council Economic Institute for the Hong Kong Trade Executive Summary ...................................................1 Development Council (HKTDC). Sean Randolph, Senior Director at the Institute, led the analysis with support from Overview ...................................................................5 Niels Erich, a consultant to the Institute who co-authored Historic Significance ................................................... 6 the paper. The Economic Institute is grateful for the valuable information and insights provided by a number Cooperative Goals ..................................................... 7 of subject matter experts who shared their views: Louis CHAPTER 1 Chan (Assistant Principal Economist, Global Research, China’s Trade Portal and Laboratory for Innovation ...9 Hong Kong Trade Development Council); Gary Reischel GBA Core Cities ....................................................... 10 (Founding Managing Partner, Qiming Venture Partners); Peter Fuhrman (CEO, China First Capital); Robbie Tian GBA Key Node Cities............................................... 12 (Director, International Cooperation Group, Shanghai Regional Development Strategy .............................. 13 Institute of Science and Technology Policy); Peijun Duan (Visiting Scholar, Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies Connecting the Dots ..............................................
    [Show full text]
  • San Francisco Department of Public Works Bureau of Engineering Records, 1881-1947(Bulk 1908-1944),SFH 458
    http://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/c8z03f9r No online items Finding Aid to the San Francisco Department of Public Works Bureau of Engineering records, 1881-1947(bulk 1908-1944),SFH 458 Finding aid prepared by Tami J. Suzuki. San Francisco History Center, San Francisco Public Library 2018 100 Larkin Street San Francisco, CA 94102 [email protected] URL: http://www.sfpl.org/sfhistory Finding Aid to the San Francisco SFH 458 1 Department of Public Works Bureau of Engineering records, ... Title: San Francisco Department of Public Works Bureau of Engineering records, Date (inclusive): 1881-1947 Date (bulk): 1908-1944 Identifier/Call Number: SFH 458 Creator: San Francisco (Calif.). Public Works. Creator: San Francisco (Calif.). Dept. of Public Works. Creator: San Francisco (Calif.). Board of Public Works. Creator: San Francisco (Calif.). Bureau of Engineering. Physical Description: 39.2 Cubic Feet(41 boxes, 1 manuscripts box) Contributing Institution: San Francisco History Center, San Francisco Public Library 100 Larkin Street San Francisco, CA 94102 (415) 557-4567 [email protected] Abstract: Includes correspondence and project and subject files documenting public infrastructure construction in San Francisco, following the 1906 earthquake and fire. The collection is stored offsite. Language of Material: Collection materials are in English. Conditions Governing Access The collection is available for use during San Francisco History Center hours. Collections that are stored offsite should be requested 48 hours in advance. Photographs cannot be photocopied. Gloves are required when handling photographs. Conditions Governing Use All requests for permission to publish or quote from manuscripts must be submitted in writing to the City Archivist.
    [Show full text]
  • Fang Family San Francisco Examiner Photograph Archive Negative Files, Circa 1930-2000, Circa 1930-2000
    http://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/hb6t1nb85b No online items Finding Aid to the Fang family San Francisco examiner photograph archive negative files, circa 1930-2000, circa 1930-2000 Bancroft Library staff The Bancroft Library University of California, Berkeley Berkeley, CA 94720-6000 Phone: (510) 642-6481 Fax: (510) 642-7589 Email: [email protected] URL: http://bancroft.berkeley.edu/ © 2010 The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved. Finding Aid to the Fang family San BANC PIC 2006.029--NEG 1 Francisco examiner photograph archive negative files, circa 1930-... Finding Aid to the Fang family San Francisco examiner photograph archive negative files, circa 1930-2000, circa 1930-2000 Collection number: BANC PIC 2006.029--NEG The Bancroft Library University of California, Berkeley Berkeley, CA 94720-6000 Phone: (510) 642-6481 Fax: (510) 642-7589 Email: [email protected] URL: http://bancroft.berkeley.edu/ Finding Aid Author(s): Bancroft Library staff Finding Aid Encoded By: GenX © 2011 The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved. Collection Summary Collection Title: Fang family San Francisco examiner photograph archive negative files Date (inclusive): circa 1930-2000 Collection Number: BANC PIC 2006.029--NEG Creator: San Francisco Examiner (Firm) Extent: 3,200 boxes (ca. 3,600,000 photographic negatives); safety film, nitrate film, and glass : various film sizes, chiefly 4 x 5 in. and 35mm. Repository: The Bancroft Library. University of California, Berkeley Berkeley, CA 94720-6000 Phone: (510) 642-6481 Fax: (510) 642-7589 Email: [email protected] URL: http://bancroft.berkeley.edu/ Abstract: Local news photographs taken by staff of the Examiner, a major San Francisco daily newspaper.
    [Show full text]
  • America's Natural Nuclear Bunkers
    America’s Natural Nuclear Bunkers 1 America’s Natural Nuclear Bunkers Table of Contents Introduction ......................................................................................................... 10 Alabama .............................................................................................................. 12 Alabama Caves .................................................................................................. 13 Alabama Mines ................................................................................................. 16 Alabama Tunnels .............................................................................................. 16 Alaska ................................................................................................................. 18 Alaska Caves ..................................................................................................... 19 Alaska Mines ............................................................................................... 19 Arizona ............................................................................................................... 24 Arizona Caves ................................................................................................... 25 Arizona Mines ................................................................................................... 26 Arkansas ............................................................................................................ 28 Arkansas Caves ................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Regional Setting, Regulatory Considerations, Significance Standards and Analysis Methodology
    CHAPTER 4 Regional Setting, Regulatory Considerations, Significance Standards and Analysis Methodology 4.0 Introduction Chapter 4 includes discussion of baseline conditions and presents the thresholds of significance (“Significance Standards”) used in this EIR to assess the program-level impacts of the 2014 LRDP. Following this introductory material, the rest of this chapter is divided into 15 major sections, one for each environmental topic considered. Each major section contains: environmental and regulatory regional setting information regarding the environmental topic, relevant background and regulatory material, the Significance Standards and the analysis methodology for the topic. The Regional Setting section describes those regional baseline conditions pertinent to an environmental topic and thus, provides the context for an analysis of potential impacts resulting from implementation of the 2014 LRDP. Site-specific setting information applicable to a particular proposal at a campus site is presented in the relevant chapter in which campus site impacts are discussed (i.e., Chapters 6 through 9). The Regulatory Considerations section summarizes relevant federal, state and local laws that govern various aspects of an environmental topic. The preparation of this EIR was preceded by an Initial Study (included as Appendix A), which determined that the 2014 LRDP would not result in certain identified impacts. Each of the environmental resource sections clearly identifies those effects that were adequately addressed in the Initial Study and are therefore not evaluated further in this EIR. The topics of Agriculture and Forestry Resources and Mineral Resources were determined in the Initial Study to require no further analysis in the EIR. Accordingly, these topics are not discussed in this EIR.
    [Show full text]
  • Overview Agenda
    OVERVIEW AGENDA CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION http://www.catc.ca.gov April 13-14, 2005 Stockton, California Wednesday, April 13, 2005 1:00 p.m. Workshop – 2006 STIP Fund Estimate Assumptions San Joaquin Council of Governments Auditorium 555 East Weber Avenue Stockton, California 95202 3:15 p.m. or upon completion of the Workshop Commission Meeting San Joaquin Council of Governments Auditorium 555 East Weber Avenue Stockton, California 95202 5:30 p.m. Reception San Joaquin Council of Governments Patio Area 555 East Weber Avenue Stockton, California 95202 7:00 p.m. Commissioner’s Dinner Ernie’s on the Brick Walk 296 Lincoln Center Stockton, California Thursday, April 14, 2005 8:00 a.m. Commission Meeting San Joaquin Council of Governments Auditorium 555 East Weber Avenue Stockton, California 95202 CLOSED SESSION PERTAINING TO LITIGATION: The Commission will meet in closed session, pursuant to Government Code Section 11126(e)(2)(A) to confer with legal counsel with regard to the following litigation: Flying J, Inc. v. California Transportation Commission, et al., Kern County Superior Court, Case No. 253208 SPC. NOTE: The Closed Session will be scheduled in conjunction with the lunch break. Following the lunch break the Commission will reconvene in Open Session. A copy of this meeting notice and agenda will be posted 10 days prior to the meeting and related book items will be posted 5 days prior to the meeting on the California Transportation Commission Website: www.catc.ca.gov Questions or inquiries about this meeting may be directed to the Commission staff at (916) 654-4245, 1120 N Street (MS-52), Sacramento, CA 95814.
    [Show full text]
  • Caltrans Statewide Historic Bridge Inventory Update: Tunnels (PDF)
    Caltrans Statewide Historic Bridge Inventory Update Tunnels Prepared by Jessica B. Feldman, Architectural Historian Myra L. Frank & Associates, Inc. 811 West Seventh Street, Suite 800 Los Angeles, California 90017 August 2003 With revisions by David Lemon, Research Associate And Andrew Hope, Associate Environmental Planner California Department of Transportation January 2006 Summary of Findings This report presents the findings of an evaluation of 14 tunnels constructed in California prior to 1960, in accordance with the eligibility criteria for listing properties in the National Register of Historic Places. This tunnel survey updates a portion of the Statewide Historic Bridge Inventory, completed in 1986 by the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). There are 49 tunnels in California on state highways and local roads that were built before 1960. Five of these are currently listed in the National Register of Historic Places: three as contributors to the Forts Baker, Barry, and Cronhkite Historic District in Marin County; one as a contributor to the Presidio of San Francisco National Historic Landmark; and one as a component of the San Francisco – Oakland Bay Bridge. In addition, four tunnels on Highway 110 in Los Angeles are contributors to a pending National Register nomination of the Arroyo Seco Parkway. Seven other tunnels have previously been determined eligible for National Register listing: three which are contributors to the Feather River Highway (State Route 70) in Butte and Plumas Counties; the two Caldecott bores in Alameda and Contra Costa Counties; the Posey Tube between the cities of Oakland and Alameda; and the Stockton Street Tunnel in San Francisco. Of the remaining 33 tunnels, four were excluded from the present survey because they are owned and maintained by the National Park Service.
    [Show full text]
  • The Call of Gold (1936) by Newell D. Chamberlain
    Next: Title Page The Call of Gold (1936) by Newell D. Chamberlain • Title Page • Preface • Table of Contents • Illustrations • Prologue • 1. An Indian Wilderness • 2. Arrival of Gold Seekers and Establishment of County • 3. Arrival of John C. Fremont • 4. First Settlers’ Own Stories • 5. Beginnings of Hornitos and Coulterville • 6. War with Indians • 7. Discovery of Something Better Than Gold, Yosemite • 8. The First Authorized Mint and Early Mining Code • 9. Early Day Justice • 10. Lost Gold, Amusements, Hotel Rules • 11. Visit of Fremont and Savage • 12. Bunnell’s Mining Experiences • 13. Eventful Years of 1854 and 1855 • 14. First Newspaper Description of Yosemite • 15. Galen Clark, Outstanding Citizen • 16. Fremont’s Political and Mining Activities • 17. The Famous Trial of 1857 • 18. Judge Burke’s Decision and Sidelights Cover • 19. Battle of the Pine Tree • 20. Bear Valley and the Colonel • 21. Final Judgment for Fremont • 22. The First White Woman in Bear Valley • 23. Autobiography of John S. Diltz • 24. Mariposa around 1859 • 25. Gazette News, 1862 to 1870 • 26. Fremont’s Great Sale • 27. Mismanagement by Wall Street • 28. Fremont’s Later Career • 29. John Muir, World-Famous Naturalist • 30. Diltz, a Real Benefactor • 31. John Hite, Millionaire Miner • 32. Angevine Reynolds and His Writings • 33. Hi-Lights around Coulterville • 34. Color around Hornitos • 35. The Town with The Holy Name [Santa Cruz, later Indian Gulch] • 36. Indian Anecdotes • 37. Mariposa Al • 38. The Pioneer Spirit Exemplified • 39. Re-union of Old-Timers • Appendix: the Miners’ Ten Commandments About the Author Newell Day Chamberlain was born January 31, 1880 in San Pablo, California.
    [Show full text]
  • The Westfield Leader Arrive Safely the Leading and Most Widely Circulated Weekly Newspaper in Union County
    ......'!••- ''••' *" ' »;, DRIVE SAFELY- THE WESTFIELD LEADER ARRIVE SAFELY THE LEADING AND MOST WIDELY CIRCULATED WEEKLY NEWSPAPER IN UNION COUNTY SEVENTY-EIGHTH YEAR—No. 34 Second Claw* Postage Paid Published ; at We-tHald, N. J. WESTFIELD, NEW JERSEY, THURSDAY, APRIL 11, 1968 Every Thursday 33 Pages—10 Cents Good Friday Services Three-hour Good Friday serv- 2 Coimcilmeil Town in Tributeice*, "The Seven Words from the Cross" sponsored by the West- Propose 070.000 fitld Cornell of Chrches will be held from noon In 4 p.m. tomor- To Run Again To Rev. Dr. King row in the Presbyterian Church. J^ Westfield added its tribute to DrDr. Mrs. Charles Smith of LawrLawrence e Martin LuthLutheer King JJrr. with a meme- AvAve.e, who hhaa s been active ffoor mmany Walter G. Perry of 144 fit, Paul St, and' Robert G. Ferguson of 624 morial march and an evening serv- months in work in the ghettos there. Library Expansion Carieton Rd. today announced they would seek reelection to the Town ice Sunday at which about f 1,000 She had been responsible for bring- Borough Squad Expansion of reading room facilities in Westfleld's Memorial Library Council from the second and third wards. Both will seek the Republican was raised in an offering for theing the Queen of Angels Players was given initial approval by the Town Council Tuesday night, when an nomination in the June 4 Primary Election. Southern Christian Leadership Con- to Westfield earlier this year and ; ordinance providing for the expenditure of $70,000 for Ihe project wa* In announcing his candidacy, Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • The Twenty One Balloons William Pene Du Bois
    THE TWENTY ONE BALLOONS WILLIAM PENE DU BOIS WINNER OF THE NEWBERY MEDAL Author's Note Just before publication of The Twenty-One Balloons, my publishers noted a strong resemblance between my book and I story by F. Scott Fitzgerald entitled " The Diamond as Big as the Ritz." published by Charles Scribner's Sons. I read this story immediately and discovered to my horror that it was not only quite similar ·s to general plot. but was also altogether a collection of very similar ideas. This was the first I had heard of the F. Scott Fitzgerald story and I can only explain this embarrassing and. to me. maddening coincidence by a firm belief that the problem of making good use of the discovery of a fabulous amount of diamonds suggests but one obvious solution, which is secrecy. The fact that F. Scott Fitzgerald and I apparently would spend our billions in like ways right down to being dumped from bed into a bathtub is altogether. quite frankly, beyond my explanation. William Pene du Bois Januay 16, 1947 Introduction THERE ARE TWO KINDS OF TRAVEL. THE USUAL way is to take the fastest imaginable conveyance along the shortest road. The other way is not to I care particularly where you are going or how long it will take you, or whether you will get there or not. These two methods of travel are perhaps easiest to be seen by watching hunting hounds. One hound will follow his nose directly to his prey. Another will follow his nose in a roundabout way to molehills, empty rabbit holes, garbage cans, and trees; and perhaps not pay any attention to his prey even when he happens upon it.
    [Show full text]
  • Tin Pan Alley OTHER BOOKS by the AUTHOR
    Tin Pan Alley OTHER BOOKS BY THE AUTHOR By DAVID A.JASEN Recorded Ragtime 1897–1958 A Century of American Popular Music By DAVID A.JASEN and GENE JONES Spreadin’ Rhythm Around That American Rag! Black Bottom Stomp By DAVID A.JASEN and TREBOR J.TICHENOR Rags and Ragtime Tin Pan Alley AN ENCYCLOPEDIA OF THE GOLDEN AGE OF AMERICAN SONG David A.Jasen Routledge New York and London Published in 2003 by Routledge 29-West 35th Street New York, NY 10001 www.routledge-ny.com Published in Great Britain by Routledge 11 New Fetter Lane London EC4P 4EE www.routledge.uk.co Copyright © 2003 by David A.Jasen All illustrations are from the collection of David A.Jasen. Routledge is an imprint of Taylor and Francis Books, Inc. This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2005. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk”. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Cataloging-in-Publication Data Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Jasen, David A. Tin Pan Alley : an encyclopedia of the golden age of American song / David A.Jasen. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references.
    [Show full text]