Maryland Historical Magazine, 1979, Volume 74, Issue No. 4
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Maryland Historical Magazine Annual Report 1978-1979 Volume 74 Index Published Quarterly by The Museum and Library of Maryland History The Maryland Historical Society Winter 1979 MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY BOARD OF TRUSTEES J. Fife Symington, Jr., Chairman* Leonard C. Crewe, Jr., President* Robert G. Merrick, Sr., Honorary Chairman* H. Furlong Baldwin Richard R. Kline Frederick Co. Mrs. Emory J. Barber St. Mary's Co. Mrs. Frederick W. Lafferty* James R. Herbert Boone Charles D. Lyon Washington Co. Thomas W. Burdette Calvert C. McCabe, Jr.* Philip Carroll Howard Co. Robert G. Merrick, Jr. Mrs. James F. Colwill Michael Middleton Charles Co. Owen Daly, II Richard P. Moran Montgomery Co. Emory Dobson Caroline Co. John E. Motz Mrs. Deborah B. English Thomas S. Nichols John G. Evans* J. Hurst Purnell, Jr. Kent Co. Charles O. Fisher Carroll Co. George M. Radcliffe Mrs. Jacob France (Honorary) Adrian P. Reed Queen Anne's Co. Louis L. Goldstein Calvert Co. Richard C. Riggs, Jr.* Kingdon Gould, Jr. Howard Co. David Rogers Wicomicp Co. William Grant Garrett Co. John D. Schapiro Benjamin H. Griswold, III Jacques T. Schlenger* E. Phillips Hathaway* Truman T. Semans R. Patrick Hayman Somerset Co. T. Rowland Slingluff, Jr. Louis G. Hecht Jess Joseph Smith, Jr. Prince George's Co. T. Hughlett Henry, Jr. Talbot Co. John T. Stinson Samuel Hopkins* Mrs. W. Wallace Symington, Jr. E. Ralph Hostetter Cecil Co. Thomas D. Washburne Elmer M. Jackson, Jr. Anne Arundel Co. William C. Whitridge* Mrs. Thomas F. Johnson Worcester Co. Jeffrey P. Williamson Dorchester Co. H. Irvine Keyser, II William L. Wilson Allegany Co. 'Executive Committee James T. Wollon, Jr. Harford Co. MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY COUNCIL Thomas H. G. Bailliere. Jr. Mrs. Frederick W. Lafferty* Mrs. Calhoun Bond Calvert C. McCabe, Jr.* Thomas W. Burdette Robert G. Merrick, Sr.* Mary E. Busch Morgan H. Pritchett Leonard C. Crewe, Jr.* George M. Radcliffe John G. Evans* Richard C. Riggs, Jr.* Arthur L. Flinner Jacques T. Schlenger* E. Phillips Hathaway* John T. Stinson Louis G. Hecht J. Fife Symington, Jr.* Edgar G. Heyl Charles L. Wagandt, II Allen C. Hopkins John Walton Samuel Hopkins* G. Luther Washington Bryden B. Hyde William C. Whitridge* 'Executive Committee Romaine Stec Somerville, Director Larry E. Sullivan, Head Librarian P. William Filby, Consultant The Maryland Historical Magazine is published quarterly by the Maryland Historical Society. 201 W. Monument Street, Baltimore Maryland 21201. Contributions and correspondence relating to articles, book reviews, and any other editorial matters should be ad- dressed to the Editor in care of the Society. All contributions should be submitted in duplicate, double-spaced, and consistent with the form outlined in A Manual of Style (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1969). The Maryland Historical Society disclaims responsi- bility for statements made by contributors. Vol. 74, No. 4 December, 1979 (ISSN 0025-4258) CONTENTS Annual Report 1978-1979 313 Alexandra Lee Levin James Buchanan's Letters from Baltimore, 1798 344 Richard J. Cox A Bibliography of Articles, Books, and Dissertations on Maryland History, 1978 358 Book Reviews Brooks and Rockel, A History of Baltimore County, by Dean Esslinger • Lewis, Coal, Iron, and Slaves: Industrial Slavery in Maryland and Virginia, 1715-1865, by David Curtis Skaggs • Oblinger, Interviewing the People of Pennsylvania, by Betty McKeever Key • Jeffries, Maryland Naval Barges in the Revolutionary War, by Dr. F. E. Chatard • Ackerson, Holy Trinity, Collington: Her People and their Church, by Garner Ranney • Thornton, Politics and Power in a Slave Society: Alabama, 1800-1860, by Whitman H. Ridgway • Holifield, The Gentlemen Theologians: American Theology in Southern Culture, 1795-1860, by John B. Boles 367 BOOKNOTE 378 NEWS AND NOTICES 379 COUNTY HISTORICAL SOCIETY HAPPENINGS 380 VOLUME 74 INDEX 385 [BALTIMORE STREET LOOKING WEST FROM CALVERT STREET] Trimmed impression laid down on grey mount and surrounded by two black borderlines with words LITHO- GRAPHED AND IN COLOURS PRINTED BY E. SACHSE & COMP. 3 N. LIBERTY STR. BALTIMORE printed below. Stokes and Haskell mention a later state with words PRINTED IN COLOURS being the only change. ** Lithograph, printed in colors. 34.5 x 48.9 cm. MdBE, MdBPM (unmounted, lithographer's proof printed in black with hand coloring), MdHi, VBHo (framed, no letters visible), Washington County Museum (framed, no letters visible). Baltimore Street (sometimes called Market) was the city's principal thoroughfare which, a visitor said, "forms a great promenade in fine weather, and contains many handsome shops." This enormously popular view, lithographed and printed in brilliant colors, shows the street in the early fifties. The tall building at the left is Carroll Hall, where Abraham Phillips, tailor and clothier, occupied the ground floor. On the opposite corner is the building shared by Robert Brown, Sr., jeweler and watchmaker and William Wooddy & Son, printers. The building at right, used principally at the time of this print as a theater, takes its name from Rembrandt Peale's Museum which origi- nally occupied the top floors. Colvin & Company's lottery office is shown on the ground floor next to Armstrong & Berry's bookstore. Several nearby buildings are occupied by Alex. Brown & Sons, bankers; Fielding Lucas, Jr., book publisher; and Samuel Kirk & Son, silversmiths. One visitor, having the typical sidewalk awnings in mind, wrote that Baltimore is "principally distinguished from an English town by the tall, green posts, planted in the earth at the edge of the pavement, in front of the shops, to hand awnings upon." [Lewis], Across the Atlantic, p. 153; Pairpoint, Uncle Sam, p. 222; Stokes and Haskell, Historical Prints, p. 115. Annual Report 1978-1979 Museum and Library of Maryland History Maryland Historical Society 314 MARYLAND HISTORICAL MAGAZINE TRUSTEES J. Fife Symington, Jr., Chairman Leonard C. Crewe, Jr., President Robert G. Merrick, Sr., Honorary President Vice Presidents Secretary Owen Daly, II Mrs. Frederick W. Lafferty Calvert C. McCabe, Jr. Treasurer George M. Radcliffe John G. Evans Richard C. Riggs, Jr. Counsel Jacques T. Schlenger Past President Samuel Hopkins The officers listed above constitute the Executive Committee H. Furlong Baldwin Mrs. Thomas F. Johnson Worcester Co. Mrs. Emory J. Barber St. Mary's Co. H. Irvine Keyser, II James R. Herbert Boone Richard R. Kline Frederick Co. Philip Carroll Howard Co. Charles D. Lyon Washington Co. Mrs. James F. Colwill Joseph H. McLain Kent Co. James W. Constable Robert G. Merrick, Jr. Emory Dobson Caroline Co. John E. Motz Mrs. Gerson G. Eisenberg Thomas S. Nichols Charles O. Fisher Carroll Co. Adrian P. Reed Queen Anne's Co. Mrs. Jacob France Honorary Richard C. Riggs, Sr. Louis L. Goldstein Calvert Co. David Rogers Wicomico Co. Louise Gore Montgomery Co. John D. Schapiro Kingdon Gould, Jr. Howard Co. Truman T. Semans William Grant Garrett Co. A. Russell Slagle Benjamin H. Griswold, III T. Rowland Slingluff, Jr. Louis G. Hecht John T. Stinson T. Hughlett Henry, Jr. Talbot Co. Mrs. W. Wallace Symington, Jr. C. A. Porter Hopkins Dorchester Co. T. Hammong Welsh, Jr. E. Ralph Hostetter Cecil Co. Prince George's Co. Elmer M. Jackson, Jr. Anne Arundel Co. William C. Whitridge Mrs. Harold Duane Jacobs William L. Wilson Allegany Co. Louis P. Jenkins Charles Co. James T. Wollon, Jr. Harford Co. The Executive Committee and the Committee Chairmen constitute the Council. COMMITTEES Committee on Addresses G. Luther Washington, Chairman J. Walter Fisher, Vice Chairman Mrs. Louis Azrael Lester S. Levy Edgar G. Heyl *John Poe Tyler 'Deceased Annual Report 315 Committee on Buildings and Grounds Allen C. Hopkins, Chairman Richard W. Ayers, Vice Chairman Arthur M. Gompf Walter J. Skayhan, III Francis H. Jencks Frank H. Weller, Jr. Committee on Education Morgan W. Pritchett, Chairman D. Randall Beirne, Vice Chairman Ludlow H. Baldwin Mrs. Francis S. Key Mrs. Philip Briscoe James A. Sensenbaugh Rebecca E. Carroll Nettie B. Taylor Gerson G. Eisenberg Mrs. Vernon H. Weisand Committee on Finance Truman T. Semans. Chairman John T. Stinson, Vice Chairman Benjamin H. Griswold, III Thomas S. Nichols Robert G. Merrick, Jr. William C. Whitridge John E. Motz Committee on the Gallery Bryden B. Hyde, Chairman Arnold Rothschild, Vice Chairman Mrs. Howard Baetjer, II Eugenia C. Holland Harry D. Berry, Jr. R. McGill Mackall Hammond J. Dugan, III, M.D. *Robert H. McCauley, Jr. Mrs. Gerson G. Eisenberg J. Jefferson Miller, II William V. Elder, III Elisabeth C. G. Packard Mrs. Mac K. Griswold Richard H. Randall, Jr. Committee on Genealogy and Heraldry John Walton, Chairman George B. Wilson, Vice Chairman Anna M. Cartlidge J. Seeger Kerns John G. Diuguid Jon Harlan Livezey 'Deceased 316 MARYLAND HISTORICAL MAGAZINE P. William Filby Freeman E. Morgan, Jr. Mrs. Norris Harris Morgan H. Pritchett Edgar G. Heyl Ella Rowe Phebe Jacobsen Milton Rubincam Henry R. Kelly A. Russell Slagle Mary Virginia Slaughter Committee on the Library Edgar G. Heyl, Chairman Antonio R. Raimo, Vice Chairman Robert W. Black, Sr. John A. Pentz Curtis Carroll Davis A. Russell Slagle Ralph L. DeGroff John Walton P. William Filby Lester S. Levy Honorary Bayly Ellen Marks Huntington Williams Honorary Braxton D. Mitchell Committee on the Maritime Collection Helen Delich Bentley, Chairman Norman A. Rukert, Vice Chairman Lewis A. Beck, Jr. Charles A. Masson Hugh Benet, Jr. William B. Matthews, Jr. Donald W. Carroll, Sr. Robert E. Michel, Sr. Randolph W. Chalfant Rolfe Pottberg S. Vannort Chapman George M. Radcliffe Ferdinand E. Chatard J. Dawson Reeder T. Marshall Duer, Jr. Philip B. Schnering John Goldsborough Earle Melbourne Smith Vera Ruth Filby Albert H. Trout William E. Hill L. Byrne Waterman Committee on Membership Louis G. Hecht, Chairman Mrs. Bryden B. Hyde, Vice Chairman Mrs. Wilbur Nelson Baumann Mrs. Edwin W. Obrecht, Jr. Mary Helen Cadwalader D. Worthington Pearre Mrs. M. Austin Fine Thomas G. Pullen, Jr. Edwin Warfield Gramkow W. Cameron Slack Michael Joyce Mrs.