–1RYHPEHU 201, Brno, Czech Republic

Evaluating the descendants of from the Cor de la Bryère line in Czech breeding

Zuzana Kubikova, Iva Jiskrova, Barbora Kubistova Department of Animal Breeding Mendel University in Brno Zemedelska 1, 613 00 Brno CZECH REPUBLIC [email protected]

Abstract: The main aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of the Cor de la Bryère’s line in Czech Warmblood breeding. The significance of this breeding line was evaluated by performing a comparison of the body measurements of descendants by the most important stallions permitted to act as stud within Czech Warmblood breeding. The specific observed attributes for evaluating the quality of the stallions were the values of descendants’ basic body measurements, i.e. stick height at withers, tape height at withers, chest circumference and cannon bone circumference. A total of seven breeding stallions were compared, three of which were Holsteiners, three Hanoverians and one a Czech Warmblood. The comparison group consisted of 347 descendants of the Czech Warmblood breed by the sires Calanthano, Carlos, Carol, Cartouche, Catango Z, Comero and Chazar. A high statistically conclusive influence of the sire was only established for cannon bone circumference. With the other body measurements, the influence of the sire was not proven. When evaluating individual years according to cannon bone circumference, the best group was judged to be descendants born in the year 1994. Furthermore, it was determined that on average both sexes of the descendants of this line meet the breed standard for the Czech Warmblood in terms of cannon bone circumference. Another factor evaluated was stick height at withers, which, like cannon bone circumference, is subject to the breed standard for the Czech Warmblood. In this case it was not possible to statistically demonstrate the effect of the observed factors. In view of the importance of this body measurement, the maximum, minimum and average values were evaluated, and on this basis it can be said that for stallions from the Cor de la Bryère line, breeders should select mares with a smaller body frame but a thick cannon bone. Key Words: stallion, offspring, Czech Warmblood, Holsteiner, Hanoverian

INTRODUCTION History of the stallion Cor de la Bryère Cor de la Bryère was the son of the stallion Rantzau, who played an active role in French sport breeding. Rantzau was the leading stud horse for , showjumping and event horses in France between 1971 and 1973. His bloodline produced countless outstanding sport and stud horses (Muller 2018). Štěrba (2018) writes that in 1971 it was necessary to find a stud horse for Holsteiner breeding that would positively influence the jumping technique and rideability of his offspring, as these had been adversely affected by the massive use of the Thoroughbred. At that time the French stud was enjoying great successes, and so the board of the Holsteiner stud decided to lease a stallion of French breeding and thereby discovered the three-year-old stallion - rather immature but exuding quality - by the Thoroughbred Rantzau out of Quenotte by Lurioso. The French were not keen on him, did not include him in the breeding programme and advised his breeder to have him gelded. The main asset Cor de la Bryère brought to breeding was an unprecedented jumping style and action of the front legs. Each year he produced first-class horses for all equestrian disciplines. Some of the greatest include Contrast, followed by Corlandus (silver medal in dressage at the 1988 Olympic Games) and numerous showjumping champions such as Caletto I, Colando I, Corrado I, Cheyenne, Cera, Cordalmé Z, Cor d´Almé Z, Corland, Cash and many more.

108 –1RYHPEHU 201, Brno, Czech Republic

His grandchildren have also been very successful, such as the Olympic champion Classic Touch, the world champion Fein Cera, Coriano, Calvaro Z, Careful, Operette la Silla, Cayon, Cabrio and Clinton (Muller 2018). Verband der Züchter des Holsteiner Pferdes (2016) writes that Cor de la Bryère became another pillar of Holsteiner breeding after the stud horse Langraf. Along with the line of Ladykiller XX, the “Corde” line has therefore been one of the strongest lines in establishing modern sport . According to Kirsan (2017), at the time of Cor de la Bryère’s transfer to Holstein, including the Selle Français breed in Thoroughbred breeding was quite unprecedented. The Selle Français breed as a whole was not viewed positively at that time – not even in its homeland, much less abroad. However, this opinion was transformed by the legendary stallion Cor de la Bryère. The “Corde” line has also had an influence on Czech Warmblood breeding, where according to Dušek et al. (2011) the relatively short period of improvement and the number of breeds used has affected the variability of the conformation. Consequently, breeders’ efforts are now directed towards the greatest possible homogenization of conformation and consolidation of the breed.

MATERIAL AND METHODS The underlying database was created on the basis of data obtained from the website of the Association of Czech Warmblood Breeders. Seven stud horses from the Cor de la Bryère line were selected and the relevant data on the stud horses and their offspring were collected. The database contains a total of 347 descendants, and the following data were recorded for each of them: name, year of birth, body measurements stick height at withers (SWH), tape height at withers (TWH), chest circumference (ChC) and cannon bone circumference (CBC) and information about the sire. Table 1 Distribution of descendants into groups according to the year of birth Number Year of birth 1 1994 2 1995 3 1996 4 1997 5 1999 6 2000 7 2001 8 2002 9 2003 10 2004 11 2005 12 2006 13 2007 14 2008 15 2009 16 2010 17 2011 18 2012 19 Other

109 –1RYHPEHU 201, Brno, Czech Republic

Table 2 Distribution of stud horses into groups Number Stallion 1 2772 Calanthano 2 2800 Carlos 3 410 Carol 4 2726 Cartouche 5 814 Catango Z 6 411 Comero Table 3 Distribution of horses into groups by sex Number Sex 1 Mare 2 Stallion 3 Gelding Model equation: yijk = μ + pi + qj + rk +eijk where: yijk is the observed effect (KVP, KVH, OH, Ohol) μ is the total average of the set pi is the fixed effect of the i-th group of sires (i = 1,…, 7) qj is the fixed effect of the j-th year of birth (j = 1,…, 22) rk is the fixed effect of the k-th sex (k = 1,2,3) eijk is the random effect Based on the results from the general linear model, the differences between values were established by subsequent testing according to Tukey-B. The test was conducted at a significance level of P ≤ 0.05. The database of descendants was created in the programme Microsoft Office Excel 2010. The data acquired were then statistically processed using a GLM linear model in the statistical programme UNISTAT 6.5. The underlying database for evaluating the general linear model contains seven stud horses and their 347 descendants. Each stud horse was assigned an internal identification number from 1 to 7 solely for our purposes. The influence of the sire, year of birth and sex on the values of the basic body measurements was observed. The descendants’ years of birth were also given a number, with item number 19 (other) encapsulating descendants born in the years 1993, 1998, 2013 and 2016, which had to be amalgamated because of their low numbers. Likewise, it was necessary to number sex distribution, this time from 1 to 3.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Evaluation by the GLM model revealed statistical conclusiveness of the observed influences for only one basic body measurement – cannon bone circumference. This confirmed that the transfer of sires’ phenotypic traits to offspring exhibits a degree of heritability, but according to these results it is primarily bone mass. The influence of the year of birth emerged as statistically inconclusive for the attributes SWH, TWH and ChC. In the case of CBC, however, this influence exhibited high statistical conclusiveness. This result can be explained by the fact that in one of the years more descendants with an above-average cannon bone circumference were born. Cannon bone circumference is an important breed attribute subject to the standards for the Czech Warmblood. That is why the values of this measurement are extremely important, since

110 –1RYHPEHU 201, Brno, Czech Republic they indicate the strength of the skeleton, which is highly desirable. Especially at present, it is essential that stud horses with the ability to pass on a strong skeleton to their descendants are included in breeding, because the influence of a large variety of different breeds in Czech Warmblood breeding has resulted in it becoming lighter, which is highly undesirable for breeding. The evaluation of sex within CBC again revealed a highly statistically conclusive influence. It can therefore be stated that the importance of monitoring this attribute was confirmed and statistically proven. The breed standard for Czech Warmblood breeding gives the threshold for cannon bone circumference as 19.5−22 for mares and 21−22.5 for stallions. Table 4 Comparison of results of the stud horses according to CBC of descendants by Tukey-B testing Stud horse No. of descendants Average CBC 2772 Calanthano 31 20.35 2667 Chazar 9 20.48 410 Carol 91 20.57 411 Comero 59 20.77 814 Catango Z 118 20.78 2726 Cartouche 36 20.96 2800 Carlos 3 21.17 This table shows that the highest average values for the cannon bone circumference measurement are achieved by descendants of the stud horse 2800 Carlos. Although this group of descendants contains only three mares, all of them achieve the upper threshold of the breed standard. According to Hanušová (2002), the stud horse 2800 Carlos is the great-grandson of the excellent stallion Calypso II, one of the most important sons of the founder of the line. As far as the other groups of descendants are concerned, it is positive that on average all of them achieve values of 20.3 and above. However, each stud horse has mares among its offspring which do not achieve even the lower threshold of the standard for cannon bone circumference. Mares with a lighter skeleton of this type are not beneficial for further breeding. Table 5 Results of multiple comparison according to Tukey-B for individual years Year No. of descendants Group average 1997 1997 9 19.96 cm 1995 7 20.03 cm Other 8 20.13 cm 1999 13 20.22 cm 2009 14 20.46 cm 1996 7 20.50 cm 2005 39 20.61 cm 2003 33 20.62 cm 2002 34 20.69 cm 2010 13 20.74 cm 2006 32 20.75 cm 2001 16 20.76 cm 2011 8 20.79 cm 2000 11 20.82 cm 2007 17 20.85 cm 2008 43 20.91 cm 2004 27 20.95 cm 2012 11 21.07 cm 1994 5 21.82 cm ** The results marked by **are statistically significant on P<0.05.

111 –1RYHPEHU 201, Brno, Czech Republic

Based on the results obtained by multiple comparison according to the Tukey-B method, it can be said that a statistically highly conclusively greater cannon bone circumference is achieved by descendants born in 1994 compared with the year 1997. Upon closer examination of the initial database, it can be said that descendants from the year 1997 were considerably influenced by dams. It was found that in five out of nine cases the dams were registered in the stud book for the English Thoroughbred. In contrast, in the year 1994 two descendants had pedigrees which were entirely free of the English Thoroughbred to the fifth generation; in another two cases the Thoroughbred did not appear in the pedigree until the fourth and fifth generation, and only one descendant had a Thoroughbred dam. This finding confirms the fact that the influence of the English Thoroughbred in lightening the skeleton of the Czech Warmblood is very marked. Štencl (1977) stated in his publication that the imprudent choice of an unsuitable stud horse results in undesirable traits being introduced into the breeding of half-breds, particularly lightening of the skeleton. It is therefore obvious that this has been an issue in breeding for more than 40 years. For this reason, breeders should be careful in the selection of mating pairs and should not include mares that do not even fulfil the minimum values of the breed standard in Czech Warmblood breeding. Table 6 Comparison of the results of sex according to CBC by Tukey-B method Sex Number Average CBC Mares Mares 322 20.64 cm Stallions 14 21.25 cm ** Geldings 11 21.64 cm ** The results marked by **are statistically significant on P<0.05. This table shows that stallions and geldings have a statistically highly conclusively greater cannon bone circumference than mares. This result can be considered very positive, since stallions and geldings should have a stronger skeleton than mares through the influence of sexual dimorphism. Bílek et al. (1957) claim that horses for breeding should have clearly expressed dimorphic traits, because horses with poorly expressed sexual dimorphism do not generally produce good results in breeding. The average values of all the groups thus meet the breed standard for the Czech Warmblood. What is clearly disadvantageous for breeding, however, is the fact that stallions have a smaller cannon bone circumference in the group average than geldings, which cannot be used for subsequent breeding. Table 7 Comparison of the results of maximum, minimum and average values of SWH between sexes Group Sex Maximum Minimum average Mares 186 cm 158 cm 173.47 cm Stallions 186 cm 153 cm 174.29 cm The statistical evaluation of stick height at withers failed to demonstrate statistical conclusiveness of the influence of the sire, year of birth or sex. However, it is possible to determine the minimum, maximum and average values and then compare these with the breed standard. For mares this is in the range 161−167 cm and for stallions 162−170 cm. According to the table, it can be stated that the maximum for both mares and stallions greatly exceeds the standard, while the mimimum falls significantly below it. Even the average values of both sex groups exceed the breed standard, by 6.47 cm for mares and 4.29 cm for stallions. This finding suggests that for stallions from the Cor de la Bryère line, breeders should select mares with a smaller body frame but a thick cannon bone. This is confirmed by the Association of Czech Warmblood Breeders (2016), which in its yearbook places emphasis on the conformation of the modern Czech Warmblood horse, which can only be achieved by the careful selection of horses for breeding.

112 –1RYHPEHU 201, Brno, Czech Republic

CONCLUSIONS A highly statistically conclusive influence of the sire was established only with cannon bone circumference. With the other body measurements, the influence of the sire was not proven. When evaluating the individual years, it was found that the best group according to cannon bone circumference consisted of descendants born in 1994. Furthermore, it was established that on average both sexes of descendants from this line meet the breed standard for the Czech Warmblood in terms of cannon bone circumference, which is considered very positive. Another factor which it was necessary to evaluate was stick height at withers, which like cannon bone circumference is subject to the breed standard for the Czech Warmblood. In this case it was not possible to statistically prove the influence of sires, year of birth or sex. Due to the importance of this body measurement, evaluation of the maximum, minimum and average values was at least performed. According to the values obtained, it can be said that for stallions from the Cor de la Bryère line, breeders should select mares with a smaller body frame but a thick cannon bone, since the breed standard was greatly exceeded in the average values for both stallions and mares. It should be noted that all the stallions from the evaluated line are beneficial for Czech Warmblood breeding. Because of this, breeders should continue to include descendants of this line in breeding, thereby anchoring the traits passed on by the founder of the line.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was funded by the Internal Grant Agency at the Mendel University in Brno, Faculty of AgriSciences, under Grant TP 7/2017: Analysis of performance and behaviour of farm animals in relation to ambient temperature variability and possibilities of elimination of its impact.

REFERENCES Bílek, F. et al. 1957. Speciální zootechnika chov koní II. díl. 1.vyd., Praha: Státní zemědělské nakladatelství. Dušek, J. et al. 2011. Chov koní. 3. vyd., Praha: Nakladatelství Brázda. Hanušová, K. 2002. Vybrané linie chovu německého teplokrevníka – Cor de la Bryere. Jezdectví, 50(9): 31–32 Kirsan, K. 2017. Cor de la Bryere Corde - a classic Improvement Sire. Sport Horse Breeder. [Online]. Available at: https://www.sport-horse-breeder.com/cor-de-la-bryere.html. [2018-06-20]. Müller, J. 2018. Corrado II. Equinní reprodukční centrum Pardubice-Mnětice. [Online]. Available at: http://www.muller-equine.cz/reprodukce-koni-1/galerie-hrebcu/corrado-ii.htm. [2018-06-20]. SCHČT, 2016. Ročenka 2016 [online]. 1. vyd., Písek: AP tiskárna. Available at: http://www.schct.cz/cz/uvod/rocenky-schct/rocenka-2016.html. [vid. 2018-07-10]. Štencl, F. et al. 1977. Vývoj chovu koní u nás II. Díl. 1. vyd., Pardubice: Ústav veterinární osvěty. Štěrba, V. 2018. Nejznámější světové linie v původech sportovních koní – Cor de la Bryére. Česká společnost hipologická. [Online]. Available at: http://www.cshipo.estranky.cz/clanky/pro-zacinajici- chovatele/chov-a-slechteni-koni/nejznamejsi-svetove-linie-v-puvodech-sportovnich-koni---cor-de-la- bryere.html. [2018-06-20]. Verband der Züchter des Holsteiner Pferdes. ©2016. Ein zuchtkonzept setzt sich durch. Holsteiner Verband. [Online]. Available at: https://www.holsteiner-verband.de/der-verband/holsteiner- pferde/zuchtkonzept. [2018-06-20].

113