Students As Change Agents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
uarterly COUNCIL ON UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH FALL 2012 | Volume 33, Number 1 StudentS aS Change agentS Also in this issUE Undergraduate Researchers Change learning and teaching: A Case study in Australia and the UK A Circular Model for Framing the Undergraduate Research Experience www.cur.org The Council on Undergraduate Research Quarterly is published in the Fall, Winter, Spring, and Summer by the Council on uarterly Undergraduate Research. COUNCIL ON UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH The mission of the Council on Volume 33, Number 1 Undergraduate Research is to support and promote high-quality undergraduate student-faculty collaborative research and Editor-in-Chief Chemistry scholarship. Kelly McConnaughay, College of Liberal Arts Alex Norquist, Department of Chemistry and Sciences Haverford College The Council on Undergraduate Research Bradley University [email protected] Quarterly and CURQ on the Web serve as [email protected] the official public “voice” of CUR to both its Geosciences members and to a broader community. Their Issue Editors Christopher Kim, School of Earth purpose is to provide useful and inspiring infor- James T. LaPlant, College of Arts and Sciences and Environmental Sciences mation about student-faculty collaborative Valdosta State University Chapman University research and scholarship from all disciplines at [email protected] [email protected] all types of institutions. The goal and function is to advance the mission of CUR. To this end, Janet Stocks, Office of Academic Affairs Health Science the operation and editorial policies are flex- Baldwin Wallace University Alan Utter, Department of Health, Leisure, ible so that its content and deadlines meet the [email protected] and Exercise Science immediate needs of the communities that it Appalachian State University serves. The CURQ on the Web can be found at Copy Editor [email protected] Cheryl Fields www.cur.org/publications/curquarterly/. [email protected] Mathematics and Technical Editor Computer Sciences Terri Lenox, Department of Mathematics Lindsay Currie CUR Advertising Policy and Computer Science [email protected] Westminster College The Council on Undergraduate Research [email protected] accepts advertising from organizations and Feature Editors individuals if such ads are in line with our Book Review Physics and Astronomy tax-exempt educational purpose, which is Ami Ahern-Rindell, Department of Biology Hank Yochum, Department of Physics to promote undergraduate research and University of Portland and Engineering education. We retain the right to refuse any [email protected] Sweet Briar College advertising that we feel does not fall within [email protected] our guidelines. International Desk Psychology For more information, contact the National Mick Healey Office at [email protected] or 202-783-4810. Professor Emeritus Amy Buddie, Department of Psychology University of Gloucestershire Kennesaw State University Healey HE Consultants [email protected] Subscriptions [email protected] Social Sciences For CUR members, the CUR Quarterly is Alan Jenkins Elizabeth Perry-Sizemore, Economics and delivered as a benefit of membership. For Professor Emeritus Business Department other individuals, the annual subscription rate Oxford Brookes University Randolph College is $42. For libraries, the subscription rate is [email protected] [email protected] $87 annually. Undergraduate Research Highlights Undergraduate Research Program To order a subscription, visit: www.cur.org/ Nicole Bennett, Department of Chemistry Directors publications.html. Appalachian State University Sumana Datta, Department of Biology [email protected] Texas A & M University ISSN 1072-5830 [email protected] Council on Undergraduate Research 2012-2013 Divisional Editors Publisher 734 15th Street NW, Suite 550 Arts and Humanities CUR National Office Washington, DC, 20005-1013 Steve Heinemann, Department of Music Council on Undergraduate Research Bradley University 734 15th Street NW, Suite 550 Washington, DC 20005-1013 Cover Photo: [email protected] Phone: 202-783-4810 Roxane Krutsinger, undergraduate at Southern Illinois At-Large Fax: 202-783-4811 University Edwardsville and industry collaborator Vic Jost of Jost Greenhouses place cuttings in a research Carl Wozniak, Department of Psychology www.cur.org project on the Student Success Center Green Roof. Kennesaw State University [email protected] Production and Mailing Design and Prepress Production Biology Automated Graphic Systems Lonnie Guralnick, Department of Math White Plains, MD 20695 & Natural Sciences www.ags.com Roger Williams University [email protected] uarterly COUNCIL ON UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH CONTENTS Fall Focus: Students as Change Agents Undergraduate Research on UR Leads to College-Wide Change ..................................................................8 —Margaret A. Anderson, Kimberly Filer, Julie S. Lyon Undergraduate Research as a Catalyst for Institutional Change ...............................................................13 — Andrea M. Karkowski, Jody S. Fournier, Broader Impacts of Undergraduate Research at a Community College: Opening Doors to New Ideas ..............................................................................................................17 —LaRoy S.E. Brandt, Jack Lee Hayes The Impact of Student-Directed Research at an Undergraduate Liberal Arts Institution ...............................22 —Michaela A. Gazdik, Jason D. Powell Undergraduate Researchers Become Change Agents for Sustainability ......................................................28 —Laura Pawlow, William Retzlaff Other Articles From the International Desk: Undergraduate Researchers Change Learning and Teaching— A Case Study in Australia and the United Kingdom ................................................................................33 —Sally Sandover, Lee Partridge, Elisabeth Dunne, Sue Burkill A Circular Model for Framing the Undergraduate Research Experience .....................................................40 — Sebastian van Delden Departments From the President—Mary Crowe .............................................................................................................2 CURQ on the Web .................................................................................................................................2 From the Executive Officer—Elizabeth Ambos ..............................................................................................4 Calendar ..............................................................................................................................................5 From the Issue Editor—Janet E. Stocks ........................................................................................................6 Meet the CUR Quarterly and CURQ on the Web .......................................................................................7 Book Review: Engaging Student Voices in the Study of Teaching and Learning ................................................48 —Amelia J. Ahern-Rindell www.cur.org 1 FALL 2012 • Volume 33, Number 1 From CUR’s President As I began to pack up my office tion displayed for creating the best possible research experi- contents to move them to my ences/learning environment for undergraduate students. new job as associate provost for More recent issues are helping to document how transfor- experiential education at Florida mative the experience can be for students with respect to Southern College, I’ve taken some learning outcomes, persistence, and a gateway to graduate time to thumb through older study (CURQ Spring 2009 and Spring 2012) issues of the CUR Quarterly—spe- What has been largely missing from the CUR Newsletter and cifically those published in the CUR Quarterly, however, is the impact that our undergradu- late 1980’s and early 1990’s when ate researchers have had on us, our research programs, and the publication was known as the on our institutions. I think we have trouble identifying how CUR Newsletter. There were many individual students have impacted our lives, but I know articles focused on the impor- that, collectively, my undergraduate researchers have taught tance of supporting students so me patience, the importance of paying attention to detail, that they “move from being pas- and that students’ avoidance of a task or procedure usually sive test takers to active participants” (Morig 1989); benefit means a lack of confidence in their own abilities. from “intellectual cross-fertilization” that results from pre- senting their work at a meeting (Mills 1988); and receive I believe many of us would agree that a simple question “financial support” (Shinn and Maxwell 1988 and Harward posed by a novice researcher not bound by disciplinary 1990). As one skims CURQ issues as they progress through assumptions can change the direction of our research pro- the years, articles shift from one theme to another, but what grams. An undergraduate researcher’s project that “tinkers remains markedly consistent is the care, interest, and devo- around the edge” can spur us to step over disciplinary IN THIS ISSUE OF CURQ on the Web CURQ on the Web, Fall 2012 edition www.cur.org/quarterly/webedition.html Informal Local Research Aids Student and Faculty Learning—Laurie McMillan Transforming Practice Through Undergraduate Researchers—Padmanabhan Seshaiyer CURQ Vignettes: Additional Examples of “Students as Change Agents” Deconstructing “Race” in (Re)constructing Change—Ayanna Brown and Holly Copot Students’ Commitment