CHECK OUT THE WEB | MORE ON GONZALES ONLINE | WWW.STUDLIFE.COM TUDENT IFE THE SINDEPENDENT NEWSPAPER OF WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY L IN ST. LOUIS SINCE 1878 VOLUME 129, NO. 57 WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 20, 2008 WWW.STUDLIFE.COM Gonzales appearance sparks political discourse WU to Gonzales demonstrators don jump- raise low- suits, show up en masse income aid v Protest subdued compared to other Gonzales appearances BY DAVID BRODY AND BEN SALES STUDENT LIFE STAFF BY SAM GUZIK Carnaghi, assistant vice chan- SENIOR NEWS EDITOR cellor for students. “They’re do- Washington University ing it in a respectful way. They students from families earn- Dressed in orange jump- organized [the protest] and I ing less than $60,000 will no suits, bearing signs and chant- give them a lot of credit.” longer be expected to take out ing anti-Gonzales slogans, more Even though the protestors’ student loans, the University than 100 Washington University actions did not prevent Gonza- announced yesterday. students and members of the les from speaking, some stu- Both newly admitted stu- St. Louis community protested dents expressed frustration dents and returning students former U.S. Attorney General about their choice to take action will be eligible for this new Alberto Gonzales’ speech on within the speech. aid. Tuesday night. “I think that while I would The University will instead “In a few minutes, former At- support anyone’s right to pro- provide those students with torney General Alberto Gonza- test, there was a more appropri- grants that will not need to be les will speak about civic duty,” ate time to voice disapproval repaid. These grants will be sa id De n ise L iebe r ma n , a profes- at the forum beforehand. It is funded by increased spending sor of political science, during a rude to interrupt him and it from funds garnered by the rally that preceded the speech. violates my right to hear him,” endowment, as well as unre- “He has a right to speak, but we said Jason Friedman, a junior. stricted University resources. have a right to speak back.” “More people should have taken “This is a part of our on- During his remarks, Gonza- advantage of the forum. I com- going commitment to ensure les addressed the protestors, mend him for doing it; not very that Washington University re- asking them to consider how mains an institution that can they would act if they were the See PROTEST, page 3 provide an educational experi- President facing an imminent SCOTT BRESSLER | STUDENT LIFE ence for students with moder- threat. Gonzales’ speech also ate fi nancial backgrounds,” detailed the imperative for civic said Chancellor Mark Wrigh- action, even for those who don’t ton. “We decided to reaffi rm vote. our commitment to providing “[The protestors] are saying fi nancial aid.” they disagree with something According to Vice Chancel- and they want to change some- lor for Finance Barbara Feiner, thing. But it is not enough to the new initiative will cost an protest,” said Gonzales. “Many additional $2.5 million, in ad- who complain the most do not dition to the approximately even vote.” $60 million that is currently While the formal protest spent on fi nancial aid. remained in an area outside While Wrighton regards the the main entrance of the 560 new policy, which will take ef- Building, there were several oc- fect this fall, as experimental, currences during the speech it- he expects the University to be self meant to draw attention to able to sustain it during the the discontent over Gonzales’ coming years. speaking appearance; these ac- “The commitment that we tions did not disrupt the fl ow of are announcing today is one the speech. that we anticipate will contin- On three occasions during ue on into the future,” he said. the speech, individual mem- “We have to look at this over bers of the audience yelled out a longer time frame. With the the phrases “liar,” “traitor” and realization of gains over sev- “perjurer” before walking out eral years, we fi gured that we of the building while Gonzales could sustain this.” was talking. The permission to enact this “Perjurer, you broke the law, further endowment spending you should be in jail,” shouted DAVID BRODY | STUDENT LIFE came from the University’s one student who left during the Demonstrators congregate outside the 560 Building on Delmar Blvd. to protest a speech by the former U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales (pictured Board of Trustees. speech, whose name was not The University’s announce- available. above) on Tuesday, Feb. 19, 2008. ment comes in the wake of a In another instance, a group decision made by Harvard Uni- of students that had left the pro- versity last year to distribute test to listen to the event chose In speech, Gonzales exhorts students to take on civic duty grants to families making less to turn their backs on Gonzales, than $180,000 a year. While rather than applaud him. BY PERRY STEIN “We truly live in a coun- these protesters did not dis- about 600 tickets were given the University announced last The largely respectful treat- NEWS EDITOR try where dreams come true. turb the speech and only away before the event out of month that it did not expect to ment that Gonzales received This is why I believe Ameri- turned their backs to him in- an approximate 1,000 avail- see a signifi cant rise in schol- broke with his reception at some After a several months of ca is worth fighting for and stead of clapping, Gonzales able tickets. arship funds, now more of the other university appearances. hype for Alberto Gonzales’ dying for,” said Gonzales in did acknowledge them by al- While most students said endowment is available. For example, while speaking at speech on campus, the for- his speech. “She [my mother] luding to the challenges that they did not expect him to “We wish that we had more the University of Florida, stu- mer Attorney General calmly never dreamed I would take face the United States in the address any of his actions in the way of our endowment dents dressed in orange jump- walked onto the stage of the her from the cotton fields to war on terror. that he has become infa- dedicated to fi nancial aid, suits and black hoods walked 560 Building, wearing a tra- the Oval Office.” “It is not enough to pro- mous for, such as the alleged but this is a good start,” said onto the stage and stood next to ditional suit with an Ameri- Included in the audience test,” said Gonzales. “What illegal authorization of tor- Wrighton. the former attorney general as can Flag pin, to a mixture of were members of the College choices are you prepared to turing, College Republicans The grants may also be he spoke. cheers and jeers, and deliv- Democrats, Peace Coalition make to bring abut change?” Public Relations Officer available to families with in- “I think its great. We’ve got ered a 24-minute speech of and other campus detrac- Despite the anticipation, Brinton Callaghan said that comes slightly higher than students on both sides and his American dream to Uni- tors dressed in bright orange members of the College Re- $60,000 on a case-by-case ba- probably in the middle,” said Jill versity students. prison jump suits. While publicans said that only See SPEECH, page 3 sis. “We’re going to do what it takes to honor our commit- ment,” said Director of Student Financial Services Bill Wit- Medical student attends AIDS summit, focusing on women brodt, regarding the amount of money to be spent. “It is 5 and Feb. 18. to those who have none, edu- The students and profes- students, because we com- hard to predict because there BY MIN WANG She was joined by three cating about current issues sionals met with members of pose the future of medicine are so many variables.” CONTRIBUTING REPORTER other students from the Phy- from a medical perspective Congress and congressional and other fields. It is encour- But Wrighton encourages sicians for Human Rights to break misconceptions and staff to inform them of the aging to see that politicians families to apply for the grant Several students, includ- Chapters in Florida, New change policy,” said Jia. plight of women and educate do care about what we have regardless of their exact earn- ing a student at the Wash- Hampshire and Minnesota There were more than 30 them on the problem of AIDS to say,” said Jia. ings. ington University School of to discuss the topic of HIV/ experts on the subject of in Africa, particularly sub- Physicians for Human “It’s not a black-and-white Medicine, recently attended AIDS, women and human women and AIDS present Saharan Africa. Rights is using the Washing- cutoff,” he said. “Any student a summit in Washington, rights. at the event, many of whom Of the experience, Jia ton, D.C. summit to launch a that feels a fi nancial challenge D.C. discussing the impact The event, which was or- have worked both domesti- spoke of the difference she new platform on the femini- being a part of our community of HIV and AIDS in Africa. ganized by Physicians for cally and internationally to felt that she and the others zation of the HIV/AIDS pan- should feel comfortable com- Shijing Jia, a student at Human Rights, included ex- bring relief to those affected were making. demic. ing to talk to us.” the School of Medicine and perts on women and AIDS by the illness. “The most important “We are working to edu- Wrighton added that he a member of the Physicians from the United States and The keynote speaker was thing is that our voices as cate professionals and stu- recognizes the high cost of at- for Human Rights Student Africa. Stephen Lewis, a former health care providers are dent about issues that make tending the University but ex- Chapter, attended the sum- “Physicians for Human United Nations special envoy valued on Capitol Hill and mit, which was held on Feb. Rights is about giving a voice on HIV and AIDS in Africa. especially our opinions as See SUMMIT, page 4 See AID, page 3
Gonzales protest, caught on tape The Academy meets Cadenza INSIDE: NEWSROOM PHONE 314-935-5995 Want to know what it was Think the Academy is the Sports ...... 5 ADVERTISING PHONE really like? Hear the chant- only judge for the Oscars? Forum...... 6 ing and voices of dissent Maybe not...Cadenza offers 314-935-6713 from the students them- us their ideas of who should Scene ...... 8 E-MAIL US selves from last night’s take home the trophy this [email protected] Gonzales protest. Sunday. Cadenza, Page 9 Cadenza ...... 9 www.studlife.com Sudoku ...... 11 2 STUDENT LIFE | NEWS Senior News Editor / Sam Guzik / [email protected] WEDNESDAY | FEBRUARY 20, 2008 STUDENT LIFE Green Action lobbies WU for increased sustainability One Brookings Drive #1039 #42 Women’s Building BY ELIZA ADELSON of the sheets used to collect peti- he has still not been convinced tips such as using natural light University still needs work. Saint Louis, MO 63130-4899 CONTRIBUTING REPORTER tion signatures. that signing something like this in class, as well as larger sugges- “The hardest piece to con- The petition demands not is appropriate.” tions, such as installing green vince people is that global warm- News: (314) 935-5995 Last Wednesday, Green Ac- only that the University have a “This thing has so many de- roofs and green screens on ex- ing affects communities around Advertising: (314) 935-6713 tion presented Chancellor Mark positive impact on the environ- tails that we don’t even know if terior walls to absorb more car- the world, not just polar bears Fax: (314) 935-5938 Wrighton with a petition bearing ment, but also that the students we can accurately track some of bon dioxide and better insulate and penguins,” said Cordova. e-mail: [email protected] 1,986 signatures in support of take on a personal responsibility the information they are asking buildings. “The environment is fairly low www.studlife.com making Washington University to improve their impact on the for. The answer here is not no, “The education sector has a on most people’s priority list, but carbon neutral and joining the world. it’s just that this is something responsibility to lead the way in we tried to explain how global Copyright 2008 President’s Climate Commit- “Washington University shall we are constantly looking at,” sustainability, to set an example warming is much more than an ment. commit to 100% carbon neutral- continued Wild. to others,” said Cordova. “We feel environmental issue.” Editor in Chief: Erin Fults This commitment has already ity through reliance on renew- “Understandably, the Chan- that our eventual goal should be Matthew Malten, assistant Executive Editor: David Brody been signed by 492 other univer- able, clean energy sources and cellor does not want to commit carbon neutrality, so that we will vice chancellor for campus sus- Managing Editors: Shweta Murthi, Mallory Wilder sities, and according to senior a substantial cutback on energy to carbon neutrality without un- not be responsible for any con- tainability, acknowledged that Senior News Editor: Sam Guzik Lee Cordova, president of Green consumption. In addition, as a derstanding how much carbon tributions to global warming.” global climate change is a sig- Senior Forum Editor: Nathan Everly Action, it represents a commit- Wash. U. community member, I dioxide we emit, and therefore As a part of the petition, sev- nifi cant issue for everyone. Senior Cadenza Editor: Brian Stitt ment to reach carbon neutrality will commit to re-evaluating my how hard we will have to work eral statistics were provided in “We are in the midst of con- Senior Scene Editor: Meghan Luecke based on a timeline to be deter- lifestyle and habits to signifi - to bring these gas levels to zero,” regards to the University’s im- ducting our campus green- Senior Sports Editor: Trisha Wolf mined by the school. cantly reduce my usage of en- said Cordova. “We are not re- proving environmental policy. house gas emissions inventory; Senior Photo Editor: David Hartstein Additionally, Green Action ergy, water and disposable prod- questing that the University be- Among them were the facts we are collecting the necessary Senior Graphics Editor: Rachel Harris set up an all-day display on the ucts,” reads the petition. come carbon neutral tomorrow, that the power plant on campus data to calculate/quantify our News Editors: Perry Stein, Ben Sales, Women’s Building lawn with pa- Rob Wild, assistant to the and we respect the sometimes switched from coal to more en- greenhouse gas emissions,” said Puneet Kollipara News Manager: Teddy White per windmills as a visual repre- Chancellor, said that although lengthy process of developing vironmentally friendly natural Malten. “With this information, Forum Editors: Altin Sila, Jill Strominger, sentation of the strong student the Chancellor has not signed a strategic action plan, but we, gas and the University’s total we will then be informed on the Christian Sherden, Dennis Sweeney will to combat global warming the petition, he is still looking along with nearly one third of air emissions decreased by 94 scale of our contribution to the Cadenza Editors: Elizabeth Ochoa, David and the great potential for clean into it. the student body that signed our percent from 1992 to 2003, the problem and, by default, how Kaminsky, Cecilia Razak, Michelle Stein energy and effi cient operations “Signing something without petition, feel that global warm- last year for which such data was much it would require us to re- Scene Editors: Lana Goldsmith, Kate on campus. knowing for sure whether we ing is so important that carbon available. duce to become carbon neutral. Gallagher The hundreds of windmills can realistically achieve without neutrality should be a goal of the The total mass of equipment This information is crucial for Sports Editors: Johann Qua Hiansen, Un- represented the 492 other schools knowing all the details sets the University.” and paper recycled at the Uni- us to understand not only how aiz Kabani, Josh Goldman that have signed the President’s University up for failure,” said The petition contains a list versity has also increased by 150 much we must reduce, but what Photo Editors: Lucy Moore, Lionel Sobe- hart, Jenny Shao Climate Commitment. Many of Wild. “I think [the Chancellor] of different ways to support the percent over the last fi ve years, reductions are technologically Online Editor: Scott Bressler these windmills were made out is constantly looking at it, but environment, including small but Green Action believes the and economically feasible.” Design Chief: Anna Dinndorf Design Editors: Dennis Sweeney, Zoë Scharf, Brittany Meyer Copy Chief: Brian Krigsher Students gain close access to Gonzales in Q&A session Copy Editors: Elyse Kallen, Puneet Kollip- ara, Hannah Schwartz, Stephanie Spera BY KAT ZHAO rogate Gonzales, many walked “I wanted to know exactly of the Washington University self.” Designers: Jamie Reed, Kate Ehrlich, Kim STAFF REPORTER away disappointed. what he thought of torture. I Political Review. “It’s a very odd response Yeh, Susan Hall, Liz Klein, Niki Dankner, Alyssa Anzalone-Newman, Sophia Agapo- “It was what I expected. I wanted a specifi c example of Adler said he was grateful that speaks to a sense of sub- va, Evan Freedman, Chris Maury, Courtney Less than an hour before just think the whole environ- when he thinks torture would for the unique opportunity to missiveness and the failure to LeGates, Mia Feitel, Joe Rigodanzo his formal speech was set to ment was designed to show be appropriate, but I don’t hear Gonzales speak, but still acknowledge responsibility,” begin last night, Alberto Gon- that he is a nice guy, that he is think he answered that ques- perceives Gonzales as an un- said Adler. General Manager: Andrew O’Dell zales met with a small group just like everybody else,” said tion,” he said. suitable fi gure for his former Gonzales gave the appear- Advertising Manager: Sara Judd of 25 students for a session of senior Steven Hoffmann. “To As part of one of his ques- role as Attorney General. ance through his responses as questions and answers. me, it was a phony event.” tions for Gonzales, Hoffmann “I think Mr. Gonzales is a a soldier claiming only to be Copyright 2008 Washington University Student The session was moder- Winograd of the College read a verse from poet and prime example of what we need following orders in war crime Media, Inc. (WUSMI). Student Life is the fi nancially and editorially independent, student-run newspaper ated by Professor Ronald Levin Republicans praised the re- writer Wendell Berry’s “Blessed to avoid in selecting people for scenarios, says Adler. serving the Washington University community. First from the Washington Univer- sponses of Gonzales despite Are the Peacemakers: Christ’s positions with responsibility,” “[His] job as an Attorney copy of each publication is free; all additional cop- sity School of Law. the many diffi cult questions Teachings About Love, Com- said Adler. General for the United States ies are 50 cents. Subscriptions may be purchased Among the group of stu- thrown at him. passion & Forgiveness.” “He has been given an ex- is not to just be a consultant — for $80.00 by calling (314) 935-6713. dents were President Charis “He was doing a very good “I think the whole Bush traordinary amount of power, your job is to take leadership. Student Life is a publication of WUSMI and does Fischer and Vice President job of answering the questions. administration has run on which he misused,” said Hoff- This is a fundamental problem not necessarily represent, in whole or in part, the Ryan Winograd from the Col- I’m glad they gave him tough the idea that it’s a Christian mann. in his approach to politics. views of the Washington University administration, lege Republicans, President questions,” said Winograd. administration, and a lot of Adler says he was discon- It speaks to why we need an faculty or students. All Student Life articles, photos and graphics are the property of WUSMI and may Ben Guthorn and Vice Presi- “I thought he was extremely Americans have bought that,” certed by Gonzales’ response administration in place that not be reproduced or published without the express dent Dustin Palmer from the open. It was very informative, sad Hoffmann. “How can you to the question of whether he respects the rule of law and written consent of the General Manager. Pictures College Democrats, Student and I hope the other students reconcile your Christian be- wanted to be a judge in the Su- the idea of democracy,” said and graphics printed in Student Life are available Union President Neil Patel and there got something out of it.” liefs with torturing people?” preme Court. Adler. for purchase; e-mail [email protected] for more several students unaffi liated Gonzales had specifi cally Hoffmann was not the only “[Gonzales] said that Bush Adler also expressed con- information. Student Life reserves the right to edit all submissions for style, grammar, length and with any students group. asked for more liberal-minded student dissatisfi ed with Gon- asked him, ‘Do you want to go cern for Gonzales’ rhetoric. Ac- accuracy. The intent of submissions will not be al- According to Levin, the ses- students to attend the session, zales’ responses. the courts?’ and he answered cording to him, the former At- tered. Student Life reserves the right not to publish sion was organized primarily because he knows his actions “The best thing we can do is with, ‘Do you want me to go?’” torney General frequently used all submissions. for the benefi t of the students are justifi able, says Winograd. acknowledge he has little to of- said Adler. “This answer really the word “serve” and “client” If you’d like to place an ad, please contact the Ad- and critics of Gonzales. “I think he gave more than fer us in terms of interpreting struck me. For me, that says a to refer to President Bush. vertising Department at (314) 935-6713. Although students present suffi cient answers,” he said. the Constitution or viewing lot about him. It shows a lack “But his ‘client’ should re- at the question-and-answer Senior Matt Adler dis- current events,” said sopho- of independent resolve and a ally be the American people,” If you wish to report an error or request a clarifi ca- took the opportunity to inter- agreed. more Greg Allen, layout editor lack of standing up for him- said Adler. tion, e-mail [email protected]. WEDNESDAY | FEBRUARY 20, 2008 Senior News Editor / Sam Guzik / [email protected] STUDENT LIFE | NEWS 3 AID v FROM PAGE 1
pects the administration to help prospective students pay that cost. “A Washington University edu- cation is, without a doubt, one of the most expensive investments one will ever make,” wrote Chan- cellor Mark Wrighton in a letter to parents, and added in an in- terview, “Garnering admission to Washington University is an ad- mission to come. We want people to know that if they are admitted, we will work to make a University education possible for them.”
—With additional reporting by Sam Guzik and John Scott ANNA DINNDORF | STUDENT LIFE
SPEECH v FROM PAGE 1 PROTEST v
Gonzales did address these between who should be tor- FROM PAGE 1 hard issues. tured and who should not?” “He addressed the issues “We don’t torture,” Gonza- many politicians would have.” that I think people wanted to les succinctly responded. The protest began with hear,” said Callaghan. Winograd decided to re- marches from the Big Bend Gonzales did concede that phrase the question to, MetroLink station and Ursa’s to he made some mistakes dur- “When is it appropriate to use the 560 Building, where Gon- ing his tenure but that he enhanced interrogation tech- zales’ speech took place. served his country to the niques?” At the rallying points, or- best of his ability, although While he did not give spe- ganizers distributed premade he did not get into any spe- cifics about the use of those signs, buttons bearing the slo- cifics during his speech. tactics, Gonzales responded gan “No Torture” and over 75 “In the pursuit of great by saying that since members orange jumpsuits. causes, mistakes will be of Al Qaeda do not follow the The primary organizers of made,” said Gonzales. “Dur- rules of war set by the Ge- the protest were the College ing my arena serving the neva Convention like the U.S Democrats and the Washington President my face was marred soldiers do, they are not en- University Peace Coalition, but by sweat, dust and blood.” titled to the same rights as several other groups took part During his speech, Gon- normal prisoners of war are. including the St. Louis chapter zales repeatedly made ref- “Terrorists do not fight ac- of Amnesty International. erences comparing himself cording to the laws of war, The protestors’ slogans and the Bush administration and so are not entitled to the and signs drew attention to to the presidency of Abra- protections of the Geneva Gonzales’ role in several con- ham Lincoln, suggesting that Convention,” said Gonzales. troversial policies that had Lincoln was highly criticized Gonzales also refuted alle- been implemented under the during his presidency and is gations that he dismissed the Bush administration, includ- now highly revered. leg iti macy of the Geneva Con- ing extraordinary rendition, According to Gonzales, the vention when he was quoted waterboarding and the denial truths about his actions will in the past as describing the of Geneva Convention rights to be revealed in years to come. provisions from the Conven- enemy combatants. “There is a difference be- tion as quaint. “There are a lot of issues we tween what you do and what “I said this statement to have with the policies Gonzales people say you do. It’s going have people look into wheth- instituted when he was White to take years for the entire er certain provisions of the House Counsel and Attorney story to be told,” said Gonza- Geneva Convention make General, [like] justifying tor- les. “If you worry about criti- sense,” said Gonzales. ture, opening the Guantanamo cism you end up paralyzed While members of the Bay prison camp, systemati- and do nothing.” College Republicans said cally eroding civil liberties,” After his relatively uncon- they think that Gonzales said Eric Reif, treasurer of Col- troversial speech about his adequately addressed these lege Democrats. “All of these personal story of triumph, controversial issues, College policies really take a toll on the there was a 14 minute ques- Democrats President Ben founding ideals of this coun- tion-and-answer session in Guthorn said he disagrees. try, take a toll on our justice which Gonzales was forced “I don’t think his speech system.” to tackle and address some of was worth $30,000, I don’t the more pressing issues. think any part of this experi- —With additional reporting College Republican Vice- ence was worth $30,000,” said by Perry Stein and Mindy Wang President Ryan Winograd, a Guthorn. “Frankly, if you’re sophomore, moderated the going to speak, then speak session and sorted through a to us honestly; don’t shuffle large pile of questions in or- around the question, which der to find appropriate ques- is, I think, what he did on nu- tions to ask the former at- merous occasions tonight.” torney general of the United Ultimately, Gonzales re- States. spectfully addressed the stu- Gonzales recognized this dent body and said that they deliberate omission of ques- have a responsibility to serve tion with a sense of humor. their country in any capacity, “They’re pretty bad?” said just like he did. Gonzales. “America’s greatness lays The audience laughed as in its people,” said Gonzales. Winograd casually responded “The choices you make in the to Gonzales, saying “Some of next five, 10, 20 years will these just aren’t questions.” have a profound impact on Gonzales gave a candid re- me and my children.” sponse regarding his views of torture after Winograd asked —With additional report- a question that read, “How ing by Puneet Kollipara and do you make the distinction Mindy Wang
Be a STUD Work for Student Life. E-mail [email protected]
Match your wits at Fitz
Trivia night happens every Thursday night starting at 9:30 in the upstairs loft at Fitz's. Pull together your own brain trust and compete for the coveted title of "Loop Brainiacs"