Ambient Surface Water Quality of Rivers and Streams in the Upper Gila Basin Water Year 2000
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ambient Surface Water Quality of Rivers and Streams in the Upper Gila Basin Water Year 2000 By Doug McCarty, Steve Pawlowski, and Patti Spindler Maps by Lisa Rowe and Doug McCarty Arizona Department of Environmental Quality Open File Report 02-04 Water Quality Division Hydrologic Support and Assessment Section Surface Water Monitoring and Standards Unit 1110 W. Washington St. Phoenix, Arizona 85007 Credits Watershed Sample Planning: Steve Pawlowski, Lee Johnson, Kyle Palmer, and Roland Williams Field Sampling: Lee Johnson, Doug McCarty, Kyle Palmer, and Roland Williams Technical Advisory: Susan Fitch, Patti Spindler, and Douglas Towne Report Review: Lin Lawson, Kyle Palmer, Steve Pawlowski, Patti Spindler, Linda Taunt, and Douglas Towne Photo Compilation: Rebecca Followill Editorial Assistance: Steve Franchuk TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT: Ambient Surface Water Quality of Rivers and Streams in the Upper Gila Basin, Water Year 2000 ..........................................7 1.0 ADEQ SURFACE WATER MONITORING PROGRAM .......................................9 1.1 Purpose and Scope .........................................................9 1.2 SWMSU Monitoring Programs...............................................10 1.3 Sampling Sites ............................................................10 1.4 Monitoring Duration and Frequency .......................................... 11 1.5 Sample Collection......................................................... 12 1.6 Sample Analysis and Target Analytes ......................................... 13 1.7 Quality Assurance ......................................................... 14 2.0 THE REGION: UPPER GILA RIVER BASIN ............................................... 16 2.1 Physiographic Provinces and Ecoregions ....................................... 16 2.2 Hydrography............................................................. 17 2.3 Climate ................................................................. 18 2.4 Geologic Characterization................................................... 18 2.5 Land Ownership .......................................................... 19 2.6 Land Uses............................................................... 19 2.7 Cities and Towns.......................................................... 20 3.0 PREVIOUS WATER QUALITY STUDIES ................................................ 24 4.0 WATER DISCHARGE AND QUALITY CHARACTERIZATION .................................. 26 4.1 Flow Conditions in the Upper Gila Basin, Water Year 2000 ........................ 26 4.2 General Water Chemistry................................................... 31 4.3 General Water Quality of the Main Stem Gila River .............................. 36 4.3.1 Chemical Differences Between Solomon and Calva ...................... 36 4.4 Selected Physical Parameter Ranges by Stream.................................. 38 4.5 Nutrients................................................................ 38 4.6 Water Quality Standards Violations ........................................... 40 5.0 ANALYSES ..................................................................... 42 5.1 Parameter Level Covariation ................................................ 42 5.2 Statistical Analysis of Turbidity and Total Suspended Solids Data................... 44 5.2.1 Soil Hydrologic Groups ............................................ 44 5.2.2 Average Soil Erodibility Factor ...................................... 47 5.2.3 Upper Layer Soil Erodibility Factor ................................... 49 5.2.4 Conclusions...................................................... 49 5.3 Statistical Analysis of Geologic Setting and General Water Chemistry................ 52 5.4 Statistical Analysis of Land Use and Water Quality Data .......................... 54 6.0 BIOASSESSMENTS IN THE UPPER GILA RIVER BASIN ..................................... 58 6.1 Introduction .............................................................. 58 6.2 Results.................................................................. 59 6.2.1 Spring Bioassessments ............................................. 59 6.2.1.1 Geographic analysis of spring samples, 1992-2000 ............... 60 6.2.2 Fall Bioassessments ............................................... 63 6.3 Causes and Sources ........................................................ 64 6.4 Sediment impacts to cold water macroinvertebrate community structure .............. 65 6.5 Discussion............................................................... 66 7.0 SUMMARY ...................................................................... 68 8.0 REFERENCES .................................................................. 71 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. San Francisco River near Martinez Ranch north of Clifton............................9 Figure 2. Site Establishment on the Blue River ........................................... 11 Figure 3. Bonita Creek riparian corridor. ................................................ 16 Figure 4. Water Quality Monitoring Sites, Upper Gila Basin WY 2000 ........................ 21 Figure 5. Geologic map of Upper Gila Watershed.......................................... 22 Figure 6. Land Ownership in the Upper Gila River Basin ................................... 23 Figure 7. Gila River near Duncan, March 2000. ........................................... 28 Figure 8. Gila River near Duncan, September 2000. ....................................... 28 Figure 9. Monthly flow averages vs. WY2000 flow for the Blue River near Clifton. .............. 29 Figure 10. Monthly flow averages vs. WY2000 flow for the San Francisco River near Clifton . ..... 29 Figure 11. Monthly flow averages vs. WY2000 flow for the Gila River near Clifton. ............. 30 Figure 12. Monthly flow averages vs. WY 2000 flow for the Gila River near Solomon. ........... 30 Figure 13. Piper trilinear diagram of water chemistry for the Upper Gila watershed, WY 2000. ..... 32 Figure 14. Water Chemistry Types, Upper Gila Basin sampling sites.......................... 34 Figure 15. Median Water Hardness by site, Upper Gila basin WY 2000. ....................... 35 Figure 16. Upper Gila Nutrient Dot Density Diagram. ..................................... 39 Figure 17. Exceedances as a percentage of total samples .................................... 40 Figure 18. Metal Detections as percentage of all metals sampled, Upper Gila WY 2000 ........... 40 Figure 19. Number of Metal Detections by Analyte........................................ 40 Figure 20. Metals Exceedances as Percentage of All Metals Sampled, Upper Gila WY 2000 ........ 41 Figure 21. Bonita Creek down-cutting near Gila confluence.................................. 44 Figure 22. State Soils Geographic Database Soils by Hydrologic Group ........................ 45 Figure 23. State Soil Geographic Database Soils by K (Soil Erodibility) Factor. ................. 46 Figure 24. Stream turbidity and the role of soils........................................... 47 Figure 25. State Soils Geographic Database by Upper Layer K (Soil Erodibility) Factor. .......... 48 Figure 26. Upper Gila turbidity exceedances, WY 2000 .................................... 51 Figure 27. Forest uses land-use classification. ............................................ 55 Figure 28. Number and percent of warm water IBI scores in each scoring category for Upper Gila River Basin sites, spring 1992-2000. ......................................................... 59 Figure 29. Number and percent of cold water IBI scores in each scoring category, spring 1992-2000. 5 9 Figure 30. IBI warm water scoring categories, spring 1992-2000 . ............................ 61 Figure 31. IBI cold water scoring categories, spring 1992-2000 .............................. 62 Figure 32. Number and percent of warm water IBI scores in each category, Fall 1996-98. .......... 63 Figure 33. Number and percent of cold water IBI scores in each category, Fall 1996-98. ........... 63 Figure 34. Causes of impairment of Upper Gila macroinvertebrate samples, spring 1992-2000. .... 64 Figure 35. Sources of impairment to Upper Gila macroinvertebrate samples, spring 1992-2000. .... 64 Figure 36. Comparison of macroinvertebrate community structure in cold water, unimpacted versus sediment impacted streams from the Upper Gila, spring 1992-2000. ..................... 66 LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Water chemistry types for Upper Gila sampling sites. .............................33 Table 2. Comparison of Median Values of Major Ionic Species and Selected Other Parameters for USGS Calva and Solomon Sites. ..................................................37 Table 3. Kruskal-Wallis Statistical Test Results for Geologic Significance ....................53 Table 4. Kruskal-Wallis Statistical Test Results for Land Use Classifications ...................57 Table 5. Scoring categories for warm water and cold water IBI scores in Arizona. ................ 58 Table 6. Ranges and means of index of biological integrity scores for warm and cold water macroinvertebrate samples collected from the Upper Gila River Basin across various seasons and years, 1992-2000. ............................................................ 60 Table 7. Mean metric scores for seven cold water metrics at sediment impaired and at unimpaired sites in the Upper Gila River Basin, 1992-2000. ........................................... 65 LIST OF APPENDICES Appendix A. Upper Gila Water Quality Sampling Sites ................................... 75 Appendix B. QC Data