May 21, 2010

Adrienne Taub MTA City Transit 2 New York, NY 10004 via e-mail to [email protected]

Re: Proposed Emergency Ventilation Structure at Mulry Square

Dear Ms. Taub:

I write to you regarding the latest proposal for the MTA/NYC Transit’s Emergency Ventilation Structure at Mulry Square, about which the Society for Historic Preservation (GVSHP) has great concerns.

In a letter of July 2009, we had made the following comments in response to three earlier designs:

1) The primary façade should be constructed of be real, red brick; 2) The design should avoid utilizing a screen of red bricks over a grey masonry façade; 3) The fenestration should relate to its surroundings, but needn’t directly imitate them; 4) The public space at the corner should be designed as a welcoming gathering space; 5) The MTA should engage an outside design consultant in the project

Upon seeing the latest proposal, we are disturbed that none of these comments have been considered. There remains a secondary brick façade suspended over a grey masonry building, and there has been no attempt made to create a friendly public space at the corner. The windows are direct imitations of those around them, yet appear ghost-like without glass panels. Additionally, no outside consultant has been engaged, as we had suggested would help resolve some of these design issues.

GVSHP has consistently maintained that the structure should be located underground and/or at an alternative location. We have so far been given no explanation as to why these options have not been considered, and continue to urge the MTA to consider them. However, if the MTA does move forward with above-ground construction on Mulry Square, as it seems committed to doing, we would like to ensure that whatever is built is appropriate for this very prominent location at the convergence of two highly-trafficked avenues and several smaller streets in the heart of the Greenwich Village Historic District.

I have attached our letter of July 2009, which you may review to understand our concerns in greater depth. GVSHP has been responsive to the MTA’s request for community comment, but I am disappointed that our concerns have been ignored. I strongly urge the MTA to revisit the proposal to incorporate these critical elements into the design.

I appreciate your attention to this matter.

Sincerely,

Andrew Berman Executive Director

Cc: New York State Historic Preservation Office NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission NYC Design Review Commission Borough President Scott Stringer Congressman Jerrold Nadler City Council Speaker Christine Quinn State Senator Tom Duane Assemblymember Deborah Glick Community Board #2 Greenwich Village Block Associations Mulry Angle/West 11th Street Block Association

July 10,2009

{ i l'r"r'rrlr ich Adrienne Taub \ illirsr' MTA Transit 5olir'lr {irl 2 Broadway llistolir' New York, NY 10004 l)r'r'sr.rr:rl iori via e-mail to adrienne.taub@ny ct.com

21tr 1,,[slr rt]r Street Structure at Ncu' \irrli, Nerv \brk roool Re: Commentson ProposedEmergency Ventilation Mulry Square (rrr) t-; ();Ei (rrr) lil\: f-i ()i8, r s r.gr slrl,.,rrg Dear Ms. Taub:

'i),

\trrlr cw licrrrarr The GreenwichVillage Societyfor Historic Preservation(GVSHP) has reviewedthe MTA,A{YC Transit'smaterials illustrating the threeoptions it is i'.,:,'tttt,i,,

\larr \rrr \risrrr;rr proposingfor an EmergencyVentilation Structureat Mulry Square. GVSHP has expressedserious concerns to the MTAAIYC Transit in the past about these plans, and we continue to have deep reservationsabout what has been presented.

\rlrir"l ltrlrrlker I rrrl;r \rrur'll I must reiteratethat no clear rationale has yet been presentedas to why this structuremust be built at this particularlocation, which is not only surrounded l\r1 lrr rr( S{ lr(r)ilo\r'r by sensitivehistoric resources,but is adjacentto the massiveplanned St. Vincent's/Rudindevelopment, construction and demolition for which is likely to l,ilrrr ll,rr.,rr take years and will overlap with the constructionof the planned Emergency I'r.rr.lo1x.li.rr c,rrr llliz,,h rlr Ll\ Ventilation Plant. In terms of a location and its potential negative impact, it would seemthat few poorerchoices could havebeen made. .Jol lrrrrrilt,,rr 'I lrour.rsI lrrrrrr.r' L,.slrc S. \lasorr The MTA's last presentationof possibilitiesfor constructionof an Emergency Itrrlr \l((i^ lJIrrlrrt llortllet Ventilation Plant included severaloptions which would place the structure I',.r{ r \l,rllan entirelyunderground. However, the MTA's newestpresentation only includes ,\rrrln r S. I);rul (lrrtlria ll rrrro threeabove-ground possibilities. Little rationalehas been provided as to why It,rlx.rt llrxtrs the below-groundpossibilities have been eliminated, other than perhaps the J()rirtllrrr IlLlsso convenienceof the MTA. .lrrrlitlr Storrr'lrill

1, .\rrtlrorrr ZLurilo lll The proposeddesigns for the new above-groundEmergency Ventilation Plant structureare extremely disappointing at best, especially as they relate to Kt'rrt llaru ick integrationof the 9-11 Memorial Tiles. Without gettinginto the detailsof the .ti,arrK. I)av(tsor Ohrrstopher I'brbes relativedrawbacks of eachparticular design proposal, I insteadsuggest that the \iargarct Halscy {iardirrr MTA considerdoing herewhat it hasdone with otherprojects across the city, \largot Oaylc I,llizahetlr( lilnrore which is engagean outsidedesign consultant. Hopefully suchadditional (iarrl (lrcitzr:r expertisewould help the MTA to better engageand addressthe design issues lbrrl I liss \larLirr llurler with the structure,the 9-11 Tiles, the site,and its context. Jarrrs Sn rvart PolshcL I,llirrrr llatrrt'r I lcrrn' I lope Reed Finally, it must also be noted that the tiny amount of open spacewhich any of Atttte Marie Sumner theseplans leave for the public is extremelydisappointing. The public was lead Ualvin liilirn to believe that as mitigation for this project, the MTA would createa meaningful Jeau Claude r-m Itallie (ieorge Vellonakis Yicki l\einer {nthonv Cl. Wood andusable public open space on thesite. However,the dimensions of the site proposedto be dedicatedto publicuse are minimal, and seem hardly usable.

I stronglyurge the MTA to considerand respond to theseissues before making any decisionsregarding the locationof anddesign for the Emergency VentilationPlant structure.

Sincerely, ,4 / I rt /,/ UobpltY Andrew Berman ExecutiveDirector

Cc: New York StateHistoric PreservationOffice NYC Landmarks PreservationCommission NYC DesignReview Commission BoroughPresident Scott Stringer CongressmanJerrold Nadler City Council SpeakerChristine Quinn StateSenator Tom Duane AssemblymemberDeborah Glick Community Board#2 GreenwichVillage Block Associations Mulry Angle/West 1lth StreetBlock Association July 16,2009

Adrienne Taub { !i'{,t.lir-\ !{ ii MTA New York City Transit '. !! lii!1 2 Broadway 5i,i ir.t,. ii'; New York, NY 10004 i lr"iuri, via e-mail to adrienne.taub@ny ct.com |'t r",r't",ltI;irtt

trlr llnsl nth 5lr(.1 Re: Additional Commentson ProposedEmergency Ventilation \r'w firrli. \eu \nrk roo,ri Structure at Mulry Square

(r,:) 1-; q;8:, lir\: (r -:I l-; (,-)3tr s r l.qr slr1,org DearMs. Taub: ,|) The GreenwichVillage Societyfor Historic Preservation(GVSHP) would like \rrrlrls Il r rrrrrrr to offer someadditional comments regarding the MTAA{YC Transit'splans and designsfor an EmergencyVentilation Structureat Mulry Square. \l,rrr \rrr \risrrlrl

While we stronglybelieve that other sitesand other approaches,such as locating

\r l,ir"l l,rrlar Lr r the plant entirely underground,must be considered,we feel stronglythat the l.,i,,l;, \,,*i.it MTA must also considercertain factors if it doesmove aheadwith an above- groundstructure at this location.

h,rtlrcr ul Sr lroorroLlr First, we cannotstress strongly enough how critical this site and this corneris. ,,,,,,, Mulry Squareis wherethe rectilinearstreet grid of Manhattangives way to the ll lclolr.l!,u,.rLr pattern LIrrirl,, rlr l.l\ irregularstreet of GreenwichVillage. Additionally, this corneris at or nearthe intersectionof two wide avenuesand severalsmaller streets, and thus whateveris built therewill be quite prominentand highly visible within this I lrorrr.rsI l;rrrrcr t.,.\ti,.s \t.rs(,rl mosthistoric of New York City's neighborhoods.The MTA mustconsider this Itrrtlr i\lr'(iov contextwhen consideringany designfor this site. In this vein, we also strongly lfl,)ft,rr llofIll( l l1 i( r \lullarl urgethat the MTA not usea standarddesign for this location,but one crafted \rrrlr',s : I'rul specificallyto respondto the site's particularconditions and context. (ivntlrrrr ll rrrcv It,,ltr,rr l(,'r', s If the MTA is to usea brick motif for the exterior of the structure,we think it is irrrlrtlr St,rnelrrll critical that it be real brick, and we think that a reddishbrick would be vastly 1,1\rrtlrorrr Zrrrrirro III preferable.We were concernedthat the two optionspresented were for a grey masonrybuilding and for the samebuilding with a screenof red bricks surroundingit to make it "contextual." If sucha building is to be built, we feel it would be vastly preferableto actuallyconstruct its fagadeof red brick. In this samevein, we feel it is important that the fenestrationof any new structure relateto its surroundings,but needn't directly imitate them.

Finally, we feel that the relationshipbetween the building andthe 'public' space at the corner,as modestas it is, is extremelyimportant. This will in many ways be the face of the building as seenby the public, and as it presentsitself to the surroundingstreetscape. None of the proposeddesigns currently emphasizethis view or this relationship,and we feel it needsto be morestrongly stressed and betterarticulated.

I appreciateyour attentionto this matter,and hopethe MTA will seriously considerthese comments as it contemplatesmoving ahead with this project.

Sinc-,erely, f) // n V i&a")o- AndrewBerman ExecutiveDirector

Cc: New York StateHistoric Preservation Office NYC LandmarksPreservation Commission NYC DesignReview Commission BoroughPresident Scott Stringer CongressmanJerrold Nadler City CouncilSpeaker Christine Quinn StateSenator Tom Duane AssemblymemberDeborah Glick CommunityBoud#2 GreenwichVillage Block Associations Mulry Angle/West1lft StreetBlock Association