DOCSLIB.ORG

Developing a Sentinel Monitoring Network for Scotland's Rivers And

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Developing a Sentinel Monitoring Network for Scotland's Rivers And CR/2016/07 Developing a sentinel monitoring network for Scotland’s rivers and lochs Daniel Chapman, Laurence Carvalho, Iain Gunn, Linda May, Mike Bowes, Matthew O’Hare NERC Centre for Ecology & Hydrology 27 th February 2018 Contents Executive summary ................................................................................................................................. 5 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 10 1. Representativeness of the existing river surveillance network ............................................................. 12 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 12 Introduction and aims ........................................................................................................................ 12 Methods ............................................................................................................................................ 13 Data ............................................................................................................................................... 13 Representativeness with respect to individual gradients .................................................................. 18 Representativeness with respect to all gradients ............................................................................. 18 Results .............................................................................................................................................. 19 Discussion and conclusions ............................................................................................................... 22 2. Designing a more representative and efficient river sentinel network .................................................. 23 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 23 Introduction and aims ........................................................................................................................ 23 Methods ............................................................................................................................................ 24 Results .............................................................................................................................................. 25 Discussion and conclusions ............................................................................................................... 30 3. Power of the river and loch sentinel networks to detect change .......................................................... 32 1 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 32 Introduction and aims ........................................................................................................................ 33 Methods ............................................................................................................................................ 34 Overview ....................................................................................................................................... 34 Trend models ................................................................................................................................. 34 Minimum detectable trends in the current monitoring data ............................................................. 38 Power of modified sampling regimes to detect trends in the river surveillance network .................. 39 Results .............................................................................................................................................. 41 Trend models ................................................................................................................................. 41 Minimum detectable trends in the current monitoring data ............................................................. 42 Power of modified sampling regimes to detect trends in the river surveillance network .................. 49 Discussion and conclusions ............................................................................................................... 53 4. Long-term changes detectable in the existing river and loch sentinel networks ................................... 56 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 56 Introduction and aims ........................................................................................................................ 56 Methods ............................................................................................................................................ 57 Overview ....................................................................................................................................... 57 Linear trend models ....................................................................................................................... 57 Nonlinear trend models .................................................................................................................. 58 Results .............................................................................................................................................. 59 Linear trend models ....................................................................................................................... 59 Nonlinear trend models .................................................................................................................. 62 Discussion and conclusions ............................................................................................................... 66 5. Review of innovative monitoring methods ......................................................................................... 69 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 69 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 69 Purpose .......................................................................................................................................... 69 2 Background ................................................................................................................................... 69 Approach ....................................................................................................................................... 70 Report Structure ............................................................................................................................. 70 Findings ............................................................................................................................................ 72 eDNA application to monitoring in Scotland .................................................................................. 72 Rivers – general monitoring review ................................................................................................ 73 Lochs – general monitoring review ................................................................................................ 75 General observations ......................................................................................................................... 76 Future challenges for surveillance networks ................................................................................... 76 References ............................................................................................................................................. 78 Appendices ........................................................................................................................................... 88 Appendix 2.1: Priority water bodies for removal from the river surveillance network ............................. 88 Appendix 2.2: Priority water bodies for addition to the river surveillance network ................................. 96 Appendix 2.3 R code to analyse and improve the representativeness of a monitoring network ................ 99 R Functions ....................................................................................................................................... 99 Example workflow .......................................................................................................................... 103 Appendix 3.1 R code to run power analysis ......................................................................................... 105 R function ....................................................................................................................................... 105 Example workflow .......................................................................................................................... 106 Appendix 5.1: Detailed review of innovative monitoring methods ....................................................... 110 Rivers .............................................................................................................................................. 110 Biological Quality Elements (BQEs)
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Drainage Plan.Pdf
    100 Í A9 TO INVERNESS SHEET AREA AT 1:1250 SCALE # DENOTES SHEET NUMBER NOTES 1. ONLY PLAN SHEET EXTENTS ARE SHOWN ON THE Millimetres KEY PLAN. #5.16J RET. POND ZA POND RET. Í B9154 TO DAVIOT 10 #5.16J #5.16I RET. POND XA POND RET. 0 RET. POND 9A POND RET. RET. POND YA POND RET. #5.16I #5.16H DO NOT SCALE #5.16H RET. POND 8A POND RET. #5.16J LOCH MOY INF. BASIN 7B BASIN INF. #5.16G 7A POND RET. LYNEBEG #5.16G JUNCTION MOY RAIL BRIDGE RET. POND 6A&B POND RET. FUNTACK BURN #5.16F MOY SOUTH RET. POND 5A&B POND RET. JUNCTION #5.16F DALMAGARRY #5.16E #5.16E #5.16K PROPOSED RUTHVEN LINK ROAD P01 RC GA RB 30/03/18 FIRST ISSUE Rev Drawn / Des Checked Approved Date #5.16D Description Drawing Status Suitability FINAL B Client Í A9 TO INVERNESS #5.16D #5.16B C1121 C1121 TOMATIN SOUTH Drawing Title FIGURE 5.16A JUNCTION #5.16C RIVER FINDHORN DRAINAGE PLAN SHEET 0 OF 10 TOMATIN NORTH A9 TO PERTH Scale Designed / Drawn Checked Approved Authorised A9 TO PERTH JUNCTION AS SHOWN RC GA RB SB #5.16B C1121 Î Original Size Date Date Date Date A1 30/03/18 30/03/18 30/03/18 30/03/18 Î Drawing Number Revision KEY PLAN KEY PLAN Project Originator Volume A9P12 - AMJ - HGN - P01 5HSURGXFHGE\SHUPLVVLRQRI2UGQDQFH6XUYH\RQEHKDOIRI (SCALE 1:12500) (SCALE 1:12500) +062&URZQFRS\ULJKWDQGGDWDEDVHULJKW2018. All rights X_ZZZZZ_ZZ - DR - DE - 0516 Plotted: Mar 30, 2018 - 4:43pm by: UKSMY600 UHVHUYHG2UGQDQFH6XUYH\/LFHQFHQXPEHU Location Type Role Number 100 NOTES: 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Hydrology Hydrogeology and Geology.Pdf
    HYDROLOGY, HYDROGEOLOGY AND GEOLOGY 11 CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................. 1 LEGISLATION, PLANNING POLICY AND GUIDANCE ............................................................................. 1 Legislation ...................................................................................................................................................... 1 Planning Policy ............................................................................................................................................... 2 Guidance ........................................................................................................................................................ 2 SCOPE AND CONSULTATION .............................................................................................................. 4 Consultation .................................................................................................................................................. 4 Effects Assessed in Full .................................................................................................................................. 5 Effects Scoped Out ........................................................................................................................................ 6 APPROACH AND METHODS ............................................................................................................... 6 Assessment
    [Show full text]
  • Place-Names in and Around the Fleet Valley ==== D ==== Daffin Daffin Is a Farm at the Head of the Cleugh of Doon Above Carsluith
    Place-names in and around the Fleet Valley ==== D ==== Daffin Daffin is a farm at the head of the Cleugh of Doon above Carsluith. There is a Daffin Tree marked on the 1st edition OS map at Killochy in Balmaclellan parish, and Daffin Hill in this location on current OS maps, across the Dee from Kenmure Castle; Castle Daffin is a hill in Parton parish and a house by Auchencairn. This is likely to be Gaelic *Dà pheiginn ‘two pennylands’. Peighinn is ‘a penny’, but in place-names it refers to a unit of land, based on yield rather than area. It probably originated in the Gaelic-Norse context of Argyll and the southern Hebrides, and was introduced into the south-west by the Gall- Ghàidheil (see Ardwell above). It occurs in place-names in Galloway and, especially, Carrick as ‘Pin- ‘ as first element, ‘-fin’ with ‘softened ‘ph’ after a numeral or other pre-positioned adjective. Originally a pennyland was a relatively small division of a davoch (dabhach, see Cullendoch above), but in the south-west places whose names contain this element appear in mediaeval records as holdings of relatively substantial landowners, comprising good extents of pasture, meadow and woodland as well as the arable core, and yielding much higher taxes than the pennylands further north. Indeed, peighinn may have come to be used more generally in the region for a fairly substantial estate without implying a specific valuation. *Dà pheiginn ‘two pennylands’ would, then, have been a large and productive landholding. However, a Scots origin is also possible, or if the origin was Gaelic, reinterpretation by Scots speakers is possible: daffin or daffen is a Scots word for ‘daffodil’, but as a verb, daffin(g) is ‘playing daft, larking about’.
    [Show full text]
  • Minutes – AGM 15Th Sep 2016
    MINUTES of THE COMBINED ANNUAL MEETING of QUALIFIED PROPRIETORS of THE RIVER DEVERON DISTRICT SALMON FISHERY and ANNUAL PUBLIC OPEN MEETING held at CASTLE HOTEL, HUNTLY on Thursday, 15th SEPTEMBER 2016 at 5pm Present: A Allwood (Muiresk), Mrs M Burnett-Stuart (Ardmeallie, Boat of Turtory), R Cooper (Mains of Auchingoul), J Cruickshank (Carnousie, Ardmiddle, Inverkeithny Glebe, Inverkeithny, Upper Netherdale, Lower Netherdale), M Hay (Edinglassie) also as mandatory for J G Brown’s Trust (Coniecleugh), Glennie 2011 Settlement (Tillydown), Ms I Hofmann (Lesmurdie), A G Morison (Mountblairy and Bognie), A Cheyne (Mains of Mayen and Mayen & Garronhaugh), A D Tennant (Forglen), Mrs D A Stancioff (Dunlugas), J Ingleby (Cairnborrow & Blairmore), Mrs P Ingleby (Mains of Aswanley), W Booth (Duff House), D Borthwick (co-optee represents salmon anglers) as mandatory for Huntly Fishings, F Henderson (co-optee represents salmon anglers), R Breakell (co-optee represents salmon anglers), D Galloway as mandatory for Banff & Macduff Angling Association (River Deveron), Mrs J Player as mandatory for J player (Upper Inverichnie), J Begg as mandatory for Mr & Mrs D A Sharp (Corniehaugh), M Crossley as mandatory for Turriff Angling Association. Also in attendance: Mrs S Paxton (Clerk to the Board); J Minty (River Bailiff); R Miller (River Director); six members of the public including members of the Deveron, Bogie and Isla Rivers Charitable Trust, Ghillies, Estate Managers and Anglers. Apologies for Absence: CR Marsden and MCR Marsden (Duff House); J G Brown’s Trust (Coniecleuch); Glennie 2011 Settlement (Tillydown) (per R Foster); I Hofmann (Lesmurdie); Mr & Mrs D A Sharp (Corniehaugh); A Higgins (Castle Fishings); J D Player (Lower Inverichnie); Messers F M Stewart & Sons (Gibston); R Shields (Avochie); Mrs D Goucher (Eden South, Lower Inverichnie); Belcherrie Farms Partnership (Lynebain); C Innes (Euchrie & Kinnairdy).
    [Show full text]
  • CYCLING Stewartry
    CYCLING in and around Stewartry The natural place to cycle See also:- - Cycling Signposted Routes in Dumfries and Galloway - Sustrans Maps www.sustrans.org.uk - The National Byway Map www.thenationalbyway.org.uk Particular thanks to John Taylor CTC for route and text contributions and for photographs. Photographs also by Alan Devlin and Dumfries and Galloway Tourist Board This publication has been, designed and funded by a partnership of: Supported by Solway Heritage through the Landfill Tax Credit Scheme A Message from the Health Improvement Group Cycling can seriously improve your health & happiness. Enjoy! CYCLING IN STEWARTRY This booklet is one of a series of four covering the whole of Dumfries & Galloway that suggest a variety of cycle tours for visitors and locals of all abilities. Local cycling enthusiasts, using their knowledge of the quieter roads, cycle routes and byways, have researched the routes to provide an interesting and rewarding taste of the region. A note of distance, time, terrain and facilities is given at the start of each route. All start points offer parking, toilets, snack places and accommodation. Some routes include stretches off-tarmac and this is indicated at the start of the route. Parking discs are required for some car parks and these are available at Tourist Information Centres and in local shops. Stewartry is part of the old province of Galloway. In those centuries when the easiest way to travel any distance was by sea, it held a strategic place on the west coast, Irish and Isle of Man routes. This explains the many archaeological remains near the coast.
    [Show full text]
  • Extend Time Duration of Tom Nan Clach Wind Farm from 3 to 5 Years
    Agenda THE HIGHLAND COUNCIL 5.7 Item SOUTH PLANNING APPLICATIONS COMMITTEE Report PLS/030/15 19 May 2015 No 15/01404/PAN: Nanclach Ltd Tom Nan Clach Wind Farm, Glenferness, Nairn Report by Head of Planning and Building Standards Proposal of Application Notice Description : Extend time duration of Tom Nan Clach Wind Farm from 3 to 5 years. Ward : 19 - Nairn 1.0 BACKGROUND 1.1 To inform the Planning Applications Committee of the submission of the attached Proposal of Application Notice (PAN). 1.2 The submission of the PAN accords with the provisions of the Planning etc. (Scotland) Act 2006 and was lodged on 13 April 2015. Members are asked to note this may form the basis of a subsequent planning application. 1.3 The following information was submitted in support of the Proposal of Application Notice: Site Location Plan Layout Plan; and Application Notice which includes: Description of Development; and Details of Proposed Consultation 2.0 DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT 2.1 The development comprises of: 17 wind turbines with tip-height of 110m; Access tracks; Turbine foundations and transformer plinths and enclosures; Electrical substation; Borrow pits; Permanent anemometer mast; and Temporary site construction compound. 2.2 The proposal is an application to preserve the current planning permission on the site for a 17 wind turbine development that was granted on Appeal on 14 June 2013 (09/00439/FULIN). No development has commenced. 2.3 It is unusual to receive a PAN for an application such as this, which is limited to consideration of time limits only, since most applications will have by now gone through the formal pre-application process introduced by the 2006 Act.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report and Accounts 2018/19
    The River Deveron District www.deveron.org Salmon Fishery Board The Deveron, Bogie and Isla Rivers Charitable Trust Annual Report and Accounts 2018/19 The Offices, Avochie Stables, Avochie, Huntly, Aberdeenshire AB54 7YY Tel: 01466 711 388 email: [email protected] www.deveron.org Report by RC Miller, MC Hay, M Walters and S Roebuck The Offices, Avochie Stables, Avochie, Huntly, Aberdeenshire AB54 7YY Tel: 01466 711 388 email: [email protected] www.deveron.org 3 Contents DeveronBogieIsla @DBIRCT FRONT COVER: The Deveron at Rothiemay river_deveron 05 Supporters and Funding Officials and Staff 06 Chairman’s Report View it at Henderson’s Country Sports 08 Deveron Salmon 26 Education and Community Outreach 09 Deveron Sea Trout Deveron Opening Ceremony and Morison Trophy Conservation Code and Statutory Regulations 28 Good Governance 10 2018 Catches 30 The Deveron, Bogie and Isla Rivers Charitable Trust accounts 11 Management Report 34 The River Deveron District 14 Angler’s Map of the River Deveron Salmon Fishery Board accounts 2019/20 Priorities 36 Deveron Angling Code for 16 Research and Monitoring Salmon and Trout 2019 Deveron Annual Report 2018/19 5 Supporters and Funding Officials and Staff The River Deveron District Salmon Fishery Board (RDevDSFB) The River Deveron District Salmon Fishery Board Members and The Deveron, Bogie and Isla Rivers Charitable Trust (DBIT) Representatives of upper proprietors would like to take this opportunity to thank all its supporters and M.C. Hay (Chairman), R.J.G. Shields, A.G. Morison, Mrs J.A. Player, funding partners who have helped implement our district fisheries R. Cooper, J.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Wildlife Review Cover Image: Hedgehog by Keith Kirk
    Dumfries & Galloway Wildlife Review Cover Image: Hedgehog by Keith Kirk. Keith is a former Dumfries & Galloway Council ranger and now helps to run Nocturnal Wildlife Tours based in Castle Douglas. The tours use a specially prepared night tours vehicle, complete with external mounted thermal camera and internal viewing screens. Each participant also has their own state- of-the-art thermal imaging device to use for the duration of the tour. This allows participants to detect animals as small as rabbits at up to 300 metres away or get close enough to see Badgers and Roe Deer going about their nightly routine without them knowing you’re there. For further information visit www.wildlifetours.co.uk email [email protected] or telephone 07483 131791 Contributing photographers p2 Small White butterfly © Ian Findlay, p4 Colvend coast ©Mark Pollitt, p5 Bittersweet © northeastwildlife.co.uk, Wildflower grassland ©Mark Pollitt, p6 Oblong Woodsia planting © National Trust for Scotland, Oblong Woodsia © Chris Miles, p8 Birdwatching © castigatio/Shutterstock, p9 Hedgehog in grass © northeastwildlife.co.uk, Hedgehog in leaves © Mark Bridger/Shutterstock, Hedgehog dropping © northeastwildlife.co.uk, p10 Cetacean watch at Mull of Galloway © DGERC, p11 Common Carder Bee © Bob Fitzsimmons, p12 Black Grouse confrontation © Sergey Uryadnikov/Shutterstock, p13 Black Grouse male ©Sergey Uryadnikov/Shutterstock, Female Black Grouse in flight © northeastwildlife.co.uk, Common Pipistrelle bat © Steven Farhall/ Shutterstock, p14 White Ermine © Mark Pollitt,
    [Show full text]
  • Tacsound On-Line
    TACSound is a non-profit division of the Teachers' Association (Canada) affiliated with the Royal Scottish Country Dance Society. Your volunteer manager, Lydia Hedge, is TACSound pleased to offer you a unique selection of available recorded music for Scottish Country Dancing and your listening pleasure. Recorded Music Division of TO ORDER: Teachers’ Association (Canada) ONLINE : Go to http://sound.tac-rscds.org Select the albums you want, add them to your CART then proceed to the CHECKOUT pages to select shipping method and payment option. Payment online can be by PayPal or Invoice/Cheque (which includes VISA). If you are a member of TAC, you are entitled to a 5% discount . You need a Discount Coupon to receive this online. Contact Lydia for your coupon number. (See next page for more details about discounts) BY MAIL : Complete an Order Form (back of this catalogue) including Item #, Title, Quantity. Mail it to: TACSound ℅ Lydia Hedge 624 Three Fathom Harbour Road RR#2, Head of Chezzetcook Nova Scotia Canada B0J 1N0 Do not send payment but please note on the order form whether you want to remit in Canadian dollars, U.S. dollars, or Pounds Sterling. We will send an invoice at the current exchange rate with the goods. September 2013 Catalogue : 902-827-2033 BY PHONE BY EMAIL : Just compose an email, indicating which albums you want. Send it to: All Prices Shown are in Canadian Dollars [email protected] All prices shown in the catalogue are in Canadian dollars and are subje ct to change without notice because of price changes from our suppliers or currency fluctuations.
    [Show full text]
  • The River Tay - Its Silvery Waters Forever Linked to the Picts and Scots of Clan Macnaughton
    THE RIVER TAY - ITS SILVERY WATERS FOREVER LINKED TO THE PICTS AND SCOTS OF CLAN MACNAUGHTON By James Macnaughton On a fine spring day back in the 1980’s three figures trudged steadily up the long climb from Glen Lochy towards their goal, the majestic peak of Ben Lui (3,708 ft.) The final arête, still deep in snow, became much more interesting as it narrowed with an overhanging cornice. Far below to the West could be seen the former Clan Macnaughton lands of Glen Fyne and Glen Shira and the two big Lochs - Fyne and Awe, the sites of Fraoch Eilean and Dunderave Castle. Pointing this out, James the father commented to his teenage sons Patrick and James, that maybe as they got older the history of the Clan would interest them as much as it did him. He told them that the land to the West was called Dalriada in ancient times, the Kingdom settled by the Scots from Ireland around 500AD, and that stretching to the East, beyond the impressively precipitous Eastern corrie of Ben Lui, was Breadalbane - or upland of Alba - part of the home of the Picts, four of whose Kings had been called Nechtan, and thus were our ancestors as Sons of Nechtan (Macnaughton). Although admiring the spectacular views, the lads were much more keen to reach the summit cairn and to stop for a sandwich and some hot coffee. Keeping his thoughts to himself to avoid boring the youngsters, and smiling as they yelled “Fraoch Eilean”! while hurtling down the scree slopes (at least they remembered something of the Clan history!), Macnaughton senior gazed down to the source of the mighty River Tay, Scotland’s biggest river, and, as he descended the mountain at a more measured pace than his sons, his thoughts turned to a consideration of the massive influence this ancient river must have had on all those who travelled along it or lived beside it over the millennia.
    [Show full text]
  • Scotland's Geodiversity, Provides a Source of Basic Raw Materials: Raw Basic of Source a Provides Geodiversity, Scotland's
    ROCKS,FOSSILS, LANDFORMS AND SOILS AND LANDFORMS ROCKS,FOSSILS, Cover photograph:Glaciatedmountains,CoireArdair,CreagMeagaidh. understanding. e it and promote its wider its promote and it e conserv to taken being steps the and it upon pressures the heritage, Earth Scotland's of diversity the illustrates leaflet This form the foundation upon which plants, animals and people live and interact. interact. and live people and animals plants, which upon foundation the form he Earth. They also They Earth. he t of understanding our in part important an played have soils and landforms fossils, rocks, Scotland's surface. land the alter the landscapes and scenery we value today, how different life-forms have evolved and how rivers, floods and sea-level changes a changes sea-level and floods rivers, how and evolved have life-forms different how today, value we scenery and landscapes the re continuing to continuing re CC5k0309 mates have shaped have mates cli changing and glaciers powerful volcanoes, ancient continents, colliding how of story wonderful a illustrates It importance. Printed on environmentally friendly paper friendly environmentally on Printed nternational i and national of asset heritage Earth an forms and istence, ex Earth's the of years billion 3 some spanning history, geological For a small country, Scotland has a remarkable diversity of rocks, fossils, landforms and soils. This 'geodiversity' is the res the is 'geodiversity' This soils. and landforms fossils, rocks, of diversity remarkable a has Scotland country, small a For ult of a rich and varied and rich a of ult Leachkin Road, Inverness, IV3 8NW. Tel: 01463 725000 01463 Tel: 8NW.
    [Show full text]
  • River Basin Management Planning River Deveron Catchment Summary
    River Basin Management Planning River Deveron catchment summary 1 Introduction The River Deveron catchment (shown on Map 1) includes the major tributaries of the River Bogie, River Isla and Turriff Water. The Deveron rises in west Aberdeenshire and then flows through Huntly and Turriff before joining the North Sea at Banff. Map 1: River Deveron catchment The catchment includes areas of moorland, farmland and forestry, and also has a number of distilleries including Chivas Regal, Glendronach and Knock. The Deveron and its tributaries are important salmon, sea trout and brown trout fisheries. Further information on the River Deveron catchment can be found on SEPA’s interactive map at www.sepa.org.uk/water/river_basin_planning.aspx 2 Classification summary of the catchment SEPA monitors the water environment on an ongoing basis and uses the resulting data to produce annual classifications. The summarised results for 2008 show that the catchment contains: 8 water bodies at good ecological status. 18 water bodies at moderate ecological status, 5 water bodies at poor ecological status and 5 water bodies at bad ecological status. Table 1 gives further details of these water bodies. There are no Heavily Modified Water Bodies in the catchment. The catchment is underlain by a number of groundwater bodies. The majority of these are classified as being at good status for both water quality and quantity, but the eastern catchment around Turriff has issues relating to over abstraction and diffuse pollution. These are discussed further in Table 1. The Deveron catchment joins the sea at the Banff and Macduff coastal water body which is classified as being at good ecological status.
    [Show full text]