Lee Kuan Yew's Thinking on 38, Oxley Road
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
2011 PM Lee and his wife Ho Ching proposed to renovate the house without demolishing it. They suggested: Lee Kuan Yew’s thinking demolishing private living spaces to preserve the family’s privacy; keeping the historically signicant basement dining room; strengthening the decaying on 38, Oxley Road structure; creating a new living area. December 2011 Mr Lee accepted PM Lee’s proposal. He told the PM Lee: family it was best to redevelop the house straight away after he died, and do what PM Lee proposed. In December 2011, he In his ministerial statement, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong highlighted (Mr Lee Kuan Yew) key discussions on the family home when his father was alive, and what Dec 27, 2011 Mr Lee wrote to the Cabinet that if 38, Oxley Road told the family that it happened after Mr Lee died. was to be preserved, it needed to have its was “best to redevelop foundations reinforced and the whole building 38, Oxley Road refurbished. straight away”, after he PM Lee and Ms Ho proceeded along those lines, and kept the family fully informed. died, and do what we No one raised any objections to the plan. proposed. By redevelopment, he March 28, 2012 Oct 27, 2010 May 2011 means remove the Mr Lee signed the authorisation to submit Mr Lee wrote to the Cabinet to set on record his Mr Lee stepped down from the Cabinet a week the development application to the Urban private spaces, wish for his house to be demolished after his death. after the General Election on May 7. Redevelopment Authority (URA). renovate the house This was after his wife, Madam Kwa Geok Choo, died. without knocking it July 20, 2011 April 17, 2012 The URA approved the renovation plans. down. At around the Mr Lee wrote to the Cabinet again to reiterate that same time, on Dec 27, he wanted the house knocked down. March 23, 2015 2011, he wrote to Mr Lee died. Cabinet a third time. July 21, 2011 PM Lee: PM Lee invited Mr Lee to make his case to the “Cabinet members Cabinet in person. Ministers unanimously said they PM Lee on the issue: Why is there still were unanimous that opposed demolition. an argument? One “As far as I knew, that was how the family had settled the matter – rationally, amicably 38, Oxley Road PM Lee did not express a view, as he was both a possible factor may son and prime minister, and hence conicted. while Mr Lee was still alive, which was what he had hoped to achieve and strived very should not be be a dierence in Before and after this, Mr Lee continued to discuss hard to achieve. I heard nothing to the contrary until after my father died.” demolished as I the matter with his family. views between me and my siblings and wanted. I have During discussions, Mr Lee Hsien Yang at one point reflected on this and suggested that his father gift the property to the dierence is over decided that if 38, Singapore, on the condition that the house be this question: What demolished and a small public park be built in its did my father think Oxley Road is to be place. January 2011 about the house, preserved, it needs to PM Lee said he thought this was worth considering have its foundations Mr Lee’s book, Hard Truths To Keep Singapore apart from Going was published. In it, he said he told Cabinet: but also gave another option: demolishing the demolition? Was his reinforced and the house, redeveloping the site, and selling off the “When I’m dead, demolish it.” This drew a strong view black and whole building property and donating the proceeds to charity. public pushback and calls from Singaporeans for white, all or nothing refurbished. It must the house to be preserved. Mr Lee said he preferred PM Lee’s option. – demolish the house then be let out for March 2011 August 2011 no matter what? Or people to live in. An was he prepared to empty building will Mr Lee asked some newspaper editors for their Mr Lee decided to will 38, Oxley Road to PM Lee as views on the house. All wanted it to be kept. part of his share of the estate, and told the family so. consider alternatives soon decline and should demolition decay.” not be possible? My siblings’ view is that Ho Ching and I my father absolutely therefore proceeded wanted to demolish along these lines. We DEVELOPMENTS AFTER MR LEE KUAN YEW DIED knocked down. the house, with no kept the family fully He said that as a son, he wanted to see his father’s compromise... My informed of our April 12, 2015 wishes carried out. view is that while my considerations and our Mr Lee’s will was formally read to PM Lee and his father wanted the siblings, Dr Lee Wei Ling and Mr Lee Hsien Yang, April 15, 2015 intentions. We who objected to the renovation plans for the rst house to be e-mailed everyone, At the Cabinet meeting, PM Lee recused himself demolished, he was time. He wanted the house demolished from all discussions and decisions on the house, including my father, immediately. and placed Deputy Prime Minister Teo Chee Hean prepared to consider my sister, my brother PM Lee wanted to read their father’s Dec 27, 2011 in charge. alternatives should and his wife. No one letter to the Cabinet, as well as the full demolition Some time after the Parliament sitting, PM Lee the Government clause in his will, in Parliament the next day. raised any objections divested himself of the house. At rst, he offered to decide otherwise. Mr Lee Hsien Yang and his wife Suet Fern transfer it to his sister for $1 on the condition that to the plan. disagreed, but PM Lee said he would do so anyway. all proceeds or compensation would go to charity if His younger siblings issued a statement with the the house was sold or acquired. This fell through. full demolition clause that night. December 2015 April 13, 2015 PM Lee agreed to sell the house to his brother at PM Lee spoke in Parliament on how to honour Mr Lee. fair market value. They also agreed to each donate half the value of the house to charity. TEXT: CHARISSA YONG He told Parliament that it should not rush into PHOTOS: MALCOLM MCLEOD, making decisions on the matter, and also that his On top of that, PM Lee gave another donation equal STEPHANIE YEOW, GOV.SG SCREENGRAB, father had been unwavering in wanting the house to half the value of the house to charity. STRAITS TIMES FILE PHOTOS.