Ecosystem-Based Management: Public Comments Received 1/24/2011-4/29/2011
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
National Ocean Council Ecosystem-Based Management: Public Comments Received 1/24/2011-4/29/2011 Table of Contents Comments ..................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Index: Attachments and Letters Received Pertaining to Ecosystem-Based Management ........................................... 28 National Council for Science and the Environment’s 11th National Conference on Science, Policy and the Environment: Our Changing Oceans ............................................................................................................. 29 West Coast Governors’ Agreement On Ocean Health .................................................................................. 31 Environmental Law Institute: Ocean Program .............................................................................................. 32 Sierra Club .................................................................................................................................................... 40 Coastal States Organization ........................................................................................................................... 43 COMPASS-Oregon State University et al. .................................................................................................. 49 Natural Resources Defense Council et al. .................................................................................................... 54 Steve Kolian, Rigs to Reef Act and Federal Public Hearing on Aquaculture ............................................... 59 Index: Attachments and Letters Received Pertaining to Ecosystem-Based Management and Other Strategic Action Plans ............................................................................................................................................................................ 76 Northeast Regional Ocean Council (NROC) et al. ....................................................................................... 77 Food and Water Watch .................................................................................................................................. 86 State of Maine, State Planning Office ........................................................................................................... 95 Letter from Congress ................................................................................................................................... 104 Clean Ocean Action .................................................................................................................................... 109 Coastal Treaty Tribes: Hoh, Makah, and Quileute Tribes and the Quinault Indian Nation ........................ 113 Northwest Atlantic Marine Alliance et al. .................................................................................................. 117 Brian Makokha, University of Vermont Law School .................................................................................. 128 Alliance to Protect Nantucket Sound .......................................................................................................... 130 City of Fort Bragg, California ..................................................................................................................... 133 National Ocean Council Page | 1 National Ocean Council Name Michael Helmholtz Organization Fla Marine Life Collectors Which Priority Objective would you like to provide comment on? Ecosystem-Based Management What near-term, mid-term, and long-term actions would most effectively help the Nation achieve this policy objective? Marine Life Collectors have been working with Fla Fish and Wildlife for 6 years to manage the Fishery's and now are working with the South Atlantic Fishery Management Councils Comprehensive Ecosystem-based Octocoral managment actions that addresses actions on fish habitat. What are some of the major obstacles to achieving this objective; are there opportunities this objective can further, including transformative changes in how we address the stewardship of the oceans, coasts, and Great Lakes? There are only a handfull of Octocoral Collectors like myself who harvest the species and there Billions of them in the waters of Florida and very little is known about the effects of are small impact on the Fish habitat yet the concil is lowering the limit and the quota has never been meet in 15 years I have been Harvesting in state and Federal waters.More reaserch from Harvesters who know the Habitat Not Regs That put people out of work for no good reason.The gulf of mexico is not effected by Rule set by concil members who should not have control over something they have no expertize in.FWCs Jessica Mcally has the knowledge not South Atlantic Fishery Management Council.Marinelife collectors sould be more involved.My MLD # is 1363 Michael Helmholtz [email protected] have first hand experance and will work to protect our Oceans coasts and Great Lakes.Hire me What milestones and performance measures would be most useful for measuring progress toward achieving this priority objective? Trip Ticket Data Attachment: National Ocean Council Page | 2 National Ocean Council Name Johnny Hines Organization Which Priority Objective would you like to provide comment on? Ecosystem-Based Management What near-term, mid-term, and long-term actions would most effectively help the Nation achieve this policy objective? 1st Is to stop pollution, and to start repairing what we've destroyed! Honestly not trying to be funny by mr. Jacque Fresco, yes founder of the Venus Project is the man who has a plan drawn up for all these questions and concerns for our environment. Mr Fresco is a leader for world peace! I put him up for nomination. What are some of the major obstacles to achieving this objective; are there opportunities this objective can further, including transformative changes in how we address the stewardship of the oceans, coasts, and Great Lakes? Yes, all this ties in with the enviornment. Start listening to mr. Fresco the man is trying to help all people. Jacque Fresco has had a Plan since 1974, shouldn't the US govt listen now. Time is most valuable! What milestones and performance measures would be most useful for measuring progress toward achieving this priority objective? A cybernated system is key all important information needs to be connected to one global system, a cybernated system. Mr. Jacque Fresco has more information on this. Please take all of his information serious! It's not a joke it's time for world peace! National Ocean Council Page | 3 National Ocean Council Name Roberts Leinau Organization lots of organizations Which Priority Objective would you like to provide comment on? Ecosystem-Based Management What near-term, mid-term, and long-term actions would most effectively help the Nation achieve this policy objective? It is important to set sustainable harvest limits and keep extractive money forces in check. It is also important to improve degraded resources. What are some of the major obstacles to achieving this objective; are there opportunities this objective can further, including transformative changes in how we address the stewardship of the oceans, coasts, and Great Lakes? Money lobby usually influences legislation more than good science. Go with academic honesty. LOOK A MINIMUM OF 100 YEARS OUT. Support local NGO's to work in their own communities. What milestones and performance measures would be most useful for measuring progress toward achieving this priority objective? comparative data collection National Ocean Council Page | 4 National Ocean Council Name William Frazier Organization BASS Which Priority Objective would you like to provide comment on? Ecosystem-Based Management What near-term, mid-term, and long-term actions would most effectively help the Nation achieve this policy objective? Overall, this entire concept has been lost. None of the primary concepts it began with have survived - or why do we have such imbalance in ecosystems. What are some of the major obstacles to achieving this objective; are there opportunities this objective can further, including transformative changes in how we address the stewardship of the oceans, coasts, and Great Lakes? Targets are chosen relative to "feel good" priorities. can we do something? Anything? Not what NEEDS to be done. It has become too fragmented and ego-based at the regulatory level. No one is on the same page anymore. We are creating more imbalance than solutoins. What milestones and performance measures would be most useful for measuring progress toward achieving this priority objective? What happened to private sector buy-in and cooperation? Transparency in goals and their management are nonexistant. Further, loss of some programs has made it impossible to define and develop realistic programs. It is a complete mess. National Ocean Council Page | 5 National Ocean Council Name Ed Kukla Organization Which Priority Objective would you like to provide comment on? Ecosystem-Based Management What near-term, mid-term, and long-term actions would most effectively help the Nation achieve this policy objective? You are couching this all wrong. Your question insists that something MUST be done. I am very concerned with the unintended consequences of over-reaching with onerous regulations. The boating industry, both commercial & recreational is a multi-billion dollar boost to our economy. Please