DOCSLIB.ORG

Parliamentary Debates (Hansard)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) Friday Volume 522 4 February 2011 No. 112 HOUSE OF COMMONS OFFICIAL REPORT PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) Friday 4 February 2011 £5·00 © Parliamentary Copyright House of Commons 2011 This publication may be reproduced under the terms of the Parliamentary Click-Use Licence, available online through the Office of Public Sector Information website at www.opsi.gov.uk/click-use/ Enquiries to the Office of Public Sector Information, Kew, Richmond, Surrey TW9 4DU; e-mail: [email protected] 1159 4 FEBRUARY 2011 1160 House of Commons Anonymity (Arrested Persons) Bill Second Reading Friday 4 February 2011 9.34 am The House met at half-past Nine o’clock Anna Soubry (Broxtowe) (Con): I beg to move, That the Bill be now read a Second time. I am grateful, Mr Speaker, for the opportunity, which PRAYERS arose as a result of my being drawn in the ballot for private Members’ Bills, to introduce the Bill in the [MR SPEAKER in the Chair] House. It is important that I begin by explaining where the Bill comes from and what I seek to achieve, because Anna Soubry (Broxtowe) (Con): I beg to move, That I hope to cure a real mischief. Hon. Members will recall the House sit in private. what happened last summer, and I am not keen to rekindle that debate. The coalition Government proposed Question put forthwith (Standing Order No. 163), and that anonymity be given to people when they were negatived. arrested and subsequently charged with the offence of rape. There was much debate; many of us did not think that it was a good idea and, in various ways, we made it clear that such a change in law was not required. We made representations both in private and in public, and it is very much to the credit of the Government and of the Under-Secretary of State for Justice, my hon. Friend the Member for Reigate (Mr Blunt), that there was a change of heart. I say that, because I know that he had a long-held belief born quite properly out of a constituent’s case with which he had dealt many years ago, and which had stayed with him. I hope all hon. Members would wish to act when they come across something that they think is wrong, and we have the great benefit of having a place in the Chamber and a process that we can use to succeed in righting a wrong. I should like to play a part in righting what I believe is a serious wrong. The Bill comes from that debate. Many of us, even though we did not necessarily support the coalition’s proposals, felt that we could all come together and agree that there was a serious problem that had evolved over the years and that needed to be solved. In the past, the press did not publish the name and address of someone when they were arrested, but waited until they were charged to do so. Over the past few years, that has all changed. The press not only publish the name and address of someone when they have been arrested but they give more details. As we have recently seen with events in Bristol, it has reached the stage where many of us believe it has got to stop. A great wrong is being done, and it is time that it was righted. That is what I seek to do—to stop this sort of reporting. Sir Peter Bottomley (Worthing West) (Con): The problem with publicity arrangements when someone has been arrested is that the media can refer to all kinds of detail that they are not allowed to refer to once a charge is brought. Is my hon. Friend trying to fill that gap? Anna Soubry: My hon. Friend is quite right—that is exactly what I am trying to do. I do not want to turn this into a debate about press freedom, because it is not as simple as that. I should like to explain where I am coming from—a dreadful modern expression, but it is an accurate description. About 30 years ago, I first became involved in student politics—you may remember those times, Mr Speaker. I was a student reading law—you were 1161 Anonymity (Arrested Persons) Bill4 FEBRUARY 2011 Anonymity (Arrested Persons) Bill 1162 [Anna Soubry] and the nature of the allegation, and on top of that, the person’s name and address appear in the local paper. If probably at kindergarten—and I became involved in it is a high-profile case, they appear in the national student politics. I then trained to become a barrister. papers. Student politics, rather bizarrely, took me to Scotland, because I won an election. I blame not just the good Mike Freer (Finchley and Golders Green) (Con): It is students of Stirling university for that but my hon. not just the naming of someone as a person of interest. Friend the Member for Finchley and Golders Green If we recall the landlord in Bristol, it was the castigation, (Mike Freer)—we, too, go back many years. I ended up the crawling over of that gentleman’s background, the as the honorary president of Stirling university, and I questioning of his looks, his eccentricity and his sexuality was in need of a job. that were abhorrent and that will follow him around for It had always been my intention and ambition to ever. Does my hon. Friend agree that the problem is not work in the broadcast media, for reasons that I do not just the naming, but the castigation that follows such need to divulge to the House. The only good advice that people around afterwards? I ever got about how to achieve my ambition was to start on a local newspaper and learn my trade as a Anna Soubry: I am grateful to my hon. Friend, who journalist. I did that. I worked for a year on a newspaper makes exactly the point that is most pertinent. It is the called the Alloa and Hillfoots Advertiser and Journal.It vilification. I have used the expression and I do not was a great publication. It employed at least two reporters, hesitate to use it again. What we saw in Bristol was, in and I was one of them. I covered everything, from the effect, a feeding frenzy and vilification. Much of the fortunes of Alloa Athletic right through to the editing coverage was not only completely irrelevant, but there of the pigeon club—one of my greatest moments in was a homophobic tone to it which I found deeply journalism. In all seriousness, I honed a trade there. offensive. The slurs on the man were out of order. All I learned a great deal. At that time we never published good and decent people in this country accept that. the name and address of anybody who was arrested, I include in that number fellow journalists. because a convention existed. I am grateful to all the people who have contacted me In due course I was lucky enough to go into television. by letter or e-mail. Among them have been journalists, I worked in television for many, many years, not just as some of whom wanted to speak privately. Among good, a presenter, but as a reporter. I have always been very sensible journalists there is a desire now for clarity. I will proud of my membership of the National Union of deal in due course with the Contempt of Court Act Journalists. I was shop steward. That does not make me 1981. It as if those journalists want us, as Parliament, to a good journalist, but I hope it explains where I am help them in a way that they cannot do themselves. coming from, and I do not want my remarks to be seen They cannot self-regulate because of the financial pressure as an attack on all the people with whom I had the great that is being placed especially on our newspapers and honour to work and whose skills I still admire. on our broadcast media. I shall deal with that point If we look at what is happening in Egypt, we know later. that it is because of the courage of the media there that Enough is enough. We must do something about the not just all of us know what is going on there, but most matter and stop it. It is not just ordinary members of importantly, the people of that country, notwithstanding the public and journalists who want clarity and who the oppression in place, know what is happening. We want the present practice to end; it is also the police. sometimes forget the invaluable work that the media do, I shall touch on that as I go through my speech. The and how brave and courageous many reporters are, man who was first arrested in Bristol was not the first, especially in such situations. I am keen to emphasise but I want him to be the last. There are other examples. that this is not an attack on the media, but it is a serious Again, I am grateful for the e-mails that I have received criticism of the antics that have prevailed for too long and the information that I have been given from various among certain sections of the media. That is what the sources to remind me of other people who have found Bill seeks to address. themselves in a similar position. I mentioned events in Bristol. Let me make it clear that I do not intend to name anybody, and I am sure Iain Stewart (Milton Keynes South) (Con): Another that hon.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Better Death in a Digital Age: Post
    Publishing Office Aims and scope Abramis Academic ASK House Communication ethics is a discipline that supports communication Northgate Avenue practitioners by offering tools and analyses for the understanding of Bury St. Edmunds ethical issues. Moreover, the speed of change in the dynamic information Suffolk environment presents new challenges, especially for communication IP32 6BB practitioners. UK Tel: +44 (0)1284 700321 Ethics used to be a specialist subject situated within schools of philosophy. Fax: +44 (0)1284 717889 Today it is viewed as a language and systematic thought process available Email: [email protected] to everyone. It encompasses issues of care and trust, social responsibility and Web: www.abramis.co.uk environmental concern and identifies the values necessary to balance the demands of performance today with responsibilities tomorrow. Copyright All rights reserved. No part For busy professionals, CE is a powerful learning and teaching approach that of this publication may be reproduced in any mate- encourages analysis and engagement with many constituencies, enhancing rial form (including pho- relationships through open-thinking. It can be used to improve organization tocopying or storing it in performance as well as to protect individual well-being. any medium by electronic means, and whether or not transiently or incidentally Submissions to some other use of this Papers should be submitted to the Editor via email. Full details on submission – publication) without the along with detailed notes for authors – are available online in PDF format: written permission of the www.communication-ethics.net copyright owner, except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Subscription Information Designs and Patents Act Each volume contains 4 issues, issued quarterly.
    [Show full text]
  • Paul Gambaccini
    2017­6­12 An Evening With Paul Gambaccini An Evening With Paul Gambaccini By Alexander Baron ­ Oct 31, 2015 Paul Gambaccini 6 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 18 6 0 SHARES a d y n f h k m Paul Gambaccini may be a DJ, radio presenter and noted musicologist, but when he turned up at the Law Society Hall in London’s Chancery Lane on Thursday night, the last thing on his mind was entertainment. With him on the stage was Christopher Jefferies, and sitting between them was Owen Bowcott, Legal Affairs Correspondent of the Guardian newspaper. If the name Chris Jefferies is not familiar to you, he was in the news five years ago for all the wrong reasons. The retired teacher owns several properties in the Bristol area, and when one of his tenants was found murdered, he was an obvious suspect; families, friends and acquaintances along with any enemies of the victim always are. It was not unreasonable that he was arrested, but for reasons that need not concern us here he was subjected to considerable vilification by the tabloids which would clearly have prejudiced his trial had he been charged. https://www.infotextmanuscripts.org/tln/An%20Evening%20With%20Paul%20Gambaccini­.html 1/6 2017­6­12 An Evening With Paul Gambaccini After he was released on police bail, another suspect came to light. Vincent Tabak would eventually be convicted of the murder of Joanna Yeates, and there is no uncertainty about his guilt. While Mr Jefferies was accused of a real crime, Paul Gambaccini was accused of an entirely imaginary one, and although it was a far less serious allegation, it would still have destroyed his life had it stuck.
    [Show full text]
  • The Undergraduate Journal of Sociology 13
    IDEATE The Undergraduate Journal of Sociology 13 Contents First year essays Natasha Bristow: SC111 The Sociological Imagination • Introduce and discuss Du Bois’ notion of “double consciousness”. Is the notion still relevant today? Angella M Denman: SC101 Researching Social Life I • Research Proposal: Is there a linK between morbidity and ethnic inequality? Which “model of explanation” (biological, behavioural or socio-economic) is most significant in explaining this linK? Liberty Faygo: SC101 Researching Social Life I • Outline and discuss the key principles of research ethics. Why are research ethics important? Ingrid Haave: SC111 The Sociological Imagination • Why is it difficult to define the word ‘race’? Bethany McCarthy: SC111 The Sociological Imagination • ‘Organised’ crime in the UK is, in fact, largely ‘disorganised’. Discuss Amie Mills: SC104 Introduction to Crime, Law and Society • Explain and evaluate the difficulties in defining and punishing crimes of the powerful Georgiana Nica: SC111 The Sociological Imagination • Why is it difficult to define the word ‘race’? Christina Sewell: SC104 Introduction to Crime, Law and Society • Explain and evaluate the difficulties in defining and punishing crimes of the powerful Hayley Wood: SC104 Introduction to Crime, Law and Society • Explain and evaluate the difficulties in defining and punishing crimes of the powerful Second year essays Sabrina Bullert: SC203 Researching Social Life II • The Impact of Reading Fashion Blogs on Consumption Robin Brooker: SC203 Researching Social Life II • To what extent do Anglicans aged 18-25 perceive secularisation to have affected their beliefs, practices and identity as Christians? Christopher Cunningham: SC276 Social Anthropology: Birth and Sex and Death • ‘FGM is not cultural, it is criminal; it is not tribal, it is torture.’ Keith Vaz MP.
    [Show full text]
  • R V Vincent Tabak [2011]-A Murder Case in Bristol, England
    R v Vincent Tabak [2011]-a murder case in Bristol, England 1 CHAPTER ONE Introduction Joanna Yeates was a 25 year old woman who was murdered on 15 December 2010. Her body was discovered on 26 December 2010 and on 23 January 2011 her next door neighbour Dr Vincent Tabak, a highly qualified Dutch architectural engineer (working in Bath, England, United Kingdom) was arrested and charged with her murder. The murder trial began on Monday 10 October 2011. Court One was court where the murder trial took place at Bristol Crown Court, Small Street, Bristol. The jury was sworn in a few days before the trial began. There were no black persons among the jury even though Bristol has a huge representation of black persons among its citizens.[1] The Court Bristol Crown Court is a modern, busy court. The Crown Court is the correct jurisdiction for a murder trial. The status, jurisdiction and administration of the Crown Court is governed by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, section 59 (5) and Schedule 11, paragraphs 1 and 26, and by certain sections of the Criminal Procedure Rules 2005. See the Statutory Instrument 2005 Number 384 (SI 2005/384). 2 Violence The concept of violence concerns most law-abiding citizens in all countries. Defining violence has long been debated among criminologists for most of this century and before this time. The term ‘violence’ some argue, lacks precision, which is why it is difficult to define, coupled with the fact that, embedded in events and actions which are perceived and understood as violent, are variable and conflicting conceptions of social and moral order.
    [Show full text]
  • (Arrested Persons) Bill Bill 9 of 2010-11 RESEARCH PAPER 11/13 2 February 2011
    Anonymity (Arrested Persons) Bill Bill 9 of 2010-11 RESEARCH PAPER 11/13 2 February 2011 The Anonymity (Arrested Persons) Bill is a Private Member’s Bill. It was presented to Parliament by Anna Soubry on 30 June 2010 as Bill 9 of 2010-11. It is due to have its second reading on 4 February 2011. The Bill would prohibit the publication or broadcast of the name, address or image (still or moving) of a person arrested for an offence if such information would be likely to lead members of the public to identify him or her as the person suspected of committing the offence in question. These reporting restrictions would remain in force unless and until the arrested person was charged with the offence for which he or she had been arrested. A Crown Court judge would, however, have the power to direct that the reporting restrictions should not apply in any particular case: for example, where identifying the suspect in the press might lead to additional complainants coming forward or to information that would assist either the police investigation or the suspect. The Bill follows recent controversy over press coverage of a man arrested (and subsequently released on bail without charge) on suspicion of the murder of Joanna Yeates. The Sunday Times has suggested that the Bill has the support of the Justice Secretary and the Attorney General, although it should be emphasised that there has been no official confirmation of the Government’s position. Sally Almandras Recent Research Papers 11/03 Localism Bill: Planning and housing [Bill 126 of 2010-11]
    [Show full text]
  • Contempt of Court
    Title: Impact Assessment (IA) Contempt by publication IA No: LAWCOM0024 Date: 17/10/2012 Lead department or agency: Stage: Consultation Law Commission Source of intervention: Domestic Other departments or agencies: Type of measure: Primary legislation Ministry of Justice Contact for enquiries: Criminal law team: 020 3334 0200 Summary: Intervention and Options RPC Opinion: RPC Opinion Status Cost of Preferred (or more likely) Option Total Net Present Business Net Net cost to business per In scope of One-In, Measure qualifies as Value Present Value year (EANCB on 2009 prices) One-Out? £m £m £m No NA What is the problem under consideration? Why is government intervention necessary? Under the Contempt of Court Act 1981, a publication which occurs when proceedings are active which carries the substantial risk of seriously prejudicing or impeding proceedings is an offence irrespective of whether the publisher was aware of the risk. Government intervention is necessary to rectify a number of problems. It can be difficult for the media to find out when proceedings are active or when reporting restrictions are in place. There is doubt over the meaning of terms like “prejudicing or impeding”. The procedure for contempt may be unfair and the range of possible sanctions is narrow. It can be unclear when the Attorney General will bring contempt proceedings. What are the policy objectives and the intended effects? The policy objectives are: 1. to clarify the law on contempt by publication; 2. to ensure that the law and procedures in this area are compliant with the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR); 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Face Value - the Long and Short
    Face value - The Long and Short https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face A magazine of innovation, new ideas and how the world is changing Face value Long Face value Researchers recently claimed to be able to use AI to infer the inherent 'criminality' of faces. It's an idea with a long, dubious and dangerous history 26th January 2017 By Rhodri Marsden Illustration by Luke Best When the BBC broadcast the recent documentary by Louis Theroux that looked back at the time he spent in the company of Jimmy Savile, there was disbelief across social media that no one had stepped in to stop Savile from committing his crimes. Some blamed the BBC, some blamed those in Savile's immediate circle, but others blamed a simple error of human judgment. "He literally couldn't look more like a paedophile," read one post – one of many to state a supposedly incontrovertible truth: that Savile's criminal tendencies could have been detected from the shape of his features, his eyes, his hair. Moreover, this has nothing to do with the benefit of hindsight and should have been picked up at the time. His looks, they suggested, were a moral indicator, with a wealth of compelling visual 1 of 13 9/29/19, 5:05 PM Face value - The Long and Short https://thelongandshort.org/society/is-there-such-thing-as-a-criminal-face evidence to support the claim. We know that paedophiles, murderers and other violent criminals come in many shapes and sizes. If we knew nothing about their criminal history, some of their photos might even appear attractive.
    [Show full text]
  • Media Law After Leveson: a View from the Coalface
    Regulation, Regulators, and the Crisis of Law and Government Media Law after Leveson: Brief Policy A view from the coalface Gillian Phillips The Foundation for Law, Justice and Society in association with the Centre for Socio-Legal Studies www.fljs.org and Wolfson College, University of Oxford The Foundation for Law, Justice and Society Regulation, Regulators, and the Crisis of Law and Government This programme examines the regulatory system in the wake of the global financial crisis, assessing its current weaknesses, the role of legislative and judicial bodies, and identifying measures for future reform of both markets and regulatory regimes. It aims to shed light on the recent failures of regulators, often captive of the very industries they are meant to regulate, and examine ways to improve the accountability and effectiveness of the regulatory system. This policy brief was written in April 2013, before the Defamation Bill was passed as an Act of Parliament. © The Foundation for Law, Justice and Society 2013 Executive Summary This policy brief aims to present a post-Leveson view on media law from the perspective of the in-house lawyer at the coalface. n The media are beset by more law and regulation than they have been at any other point in history. There is a strong consensus emerging from academics and others, prompted or encouraged by the Leveson Report, that now is payback time: the UK media have abused their privileged position, have got off too lightly, and (primarily the print press) need to be made subject to more rigorous controls. n The phone-hacking scandal was about unlawful conduct, much of it criminal; it is unlikely that any regulator would have been able to engage with or prevent it, yet the aftershocks from Leveson are continuing to be felt and are having an impact on the media law landscape.
    [Show full text]
  • Clifton College Enewsletter
    Having trouble reading this e-mail? View it in your browser. Print View eNews – January 2014 IN THIS ISSUE Welcome Back to top Welcome 2014 is not only the centenary of the start of the First World War, but also of the Clifton – Tonbridge cricket match at Lord’s. In acknowledgement of the former, we have an OC Old Cliftonian Tour of WWI Tour of the WW1 Battlefields led by Michael Ivey, himself an OC in Oakeley’s from ’78 – Battlefields August 29th – ’83. If you are interested please follow the links in the piece that follows. We are lucky to September 1st 2014 have secured this tour and I do urge you to consider joining it. Polack's For the second, we are delighted to announce that we have just secured a booking of the Nursery Ground at Lord’s for a School Match on Tuesday 24th June. We are hoping to OC News plan a big lunch, jointly with Tonbridge, for OCs and parents of current players. We have OCs in Print no details yet but please save the date and keep an eye out for further information which will be released as soon as we can. OC Business Community I would like to highlight two further pieces in this Newsletter. The first is the excellent OC Society Recent Events news that Simon Russell Beale is playing King Lear at the National Theatre until May. Follow the links for more information but note that the tickets are, not surprisingly, selling Provisional Events rapidly. Programme for 2013/2014 Secondly, we regret to announce the death of Professor Peter Geach, one of the most In Memoriam distinguished British philosophers of the 20th century.
    [Show full text]
  • The Impact of Violent Crime on Physical Activity*
    Assaults, murders and walkers: * The impact of violent crime on physical activity Katharina Janke University of Lancaster Carol Propper Imperial College and University of Bristol Michael A. Shields Monash University 7th December 2015 Abstract We investigate an underexplored externality of crime: the impact of violent crime on individuals’ participation in walking. For many adults walking is the only regular physical activity. We use a sample of nearly 1 million people in 323 small areas in England between 2005 and 2011 matched to quarterly crime data at the small area level. Within area variation identifies the causal effect of local violent crime on walking and a difference-in-difference analysis of two high-profile crimes corroborates our results. We find a significant deterrent effect of violent crime on walking that translates into a drop in overall physical activity. JEL Classification: I12, I18, R23 Keywords: Violent Crime, Walking, Physical Activity, Externality Corresponding author: Carol Propper, Imperial College, London SW7 2AZ UK. E-mail: [email protected]. Tel +44(0) 207 594 9291 * We thank Jason Abaluck, Maarten Lindeboom, David Madden, Jane Ruseski, Helen Simpson and participants at the European Workshop on Econometrics and Health Economics (Rotterdam), Annual Health Economics Conference (PennLDI), Annual Conference of the Royal Economic Society (Manchester), Biennial Conference of the American Society of Health Economists (Los Angeles) and at seminars at Bristol, Melbourne and Monash for helpful comments. We are grateful to Sport England for giving us access to the Active People Survey. 1 Introduction It has been long recognised that crime has important externalities. One concern is the impact of crime on individuals’ ability to undertake their daily activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Department of Media and Communications Goldsmiths
    For Distribution to CPs Department of Media and Communications MC 7 1 0 5 8 A M edia Law & Ethics Term: Autumn 2011 for MA Practice students (MA Journalism, MA Television Journalism, MA Radio, and MSc Digital Journalism Course Leader: Tim Crook Course outlines are also available on http://learn.gold.ac.uk © September 2011 Department of Media and Communications Goldsmiths - University of London - New Cross - London -SE14 6NW Tel; 020 7919 7615 Goldsmiths Email: media-coninis@i;old.ac.uk UNIVERSITY OF LONDON hltn://ww'w. gold, ac.uk/media-commiinications/ MODI 00050305 For Distribution to CPs MC71058A for MA Practice students (MA Journalism, MA Television Journalism, MA Radio, and MSc Digital Journalism) Course Structure The Course will be taught by a series of 10 core lectures. Nine by the course tutor, one by Angela Phillips, followed by 5 seminar/lectures by the course tutor, directed to preparation for the 3 hour unseen examination held on the Thursday of the reading/monitoring week of the Spring term. Autumn term. Course convenor: Tim Crook. Core lectures on Tuesday evenings between 4 p.m. and 5.30 p.m. LG01 NAB. Course will also be supported by a course reader, interactive exercises, digital hand-outs and course materials provided on the resource at learn.gold.ac.uk. There is one set book that covers the media law and ethics curriculum Comparative Media Law & E th ic s by Tim Crook, published by Routledge 2009. It has an extensive companion website and key knowledge/skills resources are available in text and for MP3 audio downloads onto your Blackberries, iPhones or MP3 players.
    [Show full text]
  • Does Violent Crime Deter Physical Activity?
    Does Violent Crime Deter Physical Activity? Katharina Jankea, Carol Propperb, and Michael A. Shieldsc aUniversity of Bristol, United Kingdom bUniversity of Bristol and Imperial College, London, United Kingdom cMonash University, Melbourne, Australia October 31, 2014 Abstract We investigate an underexplored externality of crime: the impact of violent crime on physical activity through individuals’ participation in walking, for many adults the only regular physical activity. We use a sample of nearly 1 million people in 323 small areas in England between 2005 and 2011, matched to quarterly crime data at small area level. Within area variation identifies the causal effect of local violent crime on walking and a difference-in-difference analysis of two high- profile crimes corroborates our results. We find a substantive deterrent effect of violent crime on walking that translates into a drop in overall physical activity. JEL Classification: I12, I18, R23 Keywords: Violent Crime, Walking, Physical Activity, Externality 1 Introduction It has been long recognised that crime has important externalities. One key concern is the impact of crime on neighbourhood quality and community. Established negative externalities on neighbourhood include flight to the suburbs (Cullen and Levitt 1999, Ellen and O’Regan 2010), declining property values (Gibbons 2004), a reduction in the creation of new retail and personal service businesses (Greenbaum and Tita 2004) and geographical sorting of local businesses (Rosenthal and Ross 2010). In this paper we investigate an hitherto underexplored externality: the impact of violent crime on individuals’ participation in physical activity through their participation in the most common form of physical activity undertaken in their local area, walking.
    [Show full text]