Improved Cell-Penetrating Zinc-Finger Nuclease Proteins for Precision Genome Engineering
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Citation: Molecular Therapy—Nucleic Acids (2015) 4, e232; doi:10.1038/mtna.2015.6 © 2015 The American Society of Gene & Cell Therapy All rights reserved 2162-2531/15 www.nature.com/mtna Improved Cell-Penetrating Zinc-Finger Nuclease Proteins for Precision Genome Engineering Jia Liu1,2,3,4, Thomas Gaj1,2,3, Mark C Wallen1,2,3 and Carlos F Barbas III1,2,3,5 Safe, efficient, and broadly applicable methods for delivering site-specific nucleases into cells are needed in order for targeted genome editing to reach its full potential for basic research and medicine. We previously reported that zinc-finger nuclease (ZFN) proteins have the innate capacity to cross cell membranes and induce genome modification via their direct application to human cells. Here, we show that incorporation of tandem nuclear localization signal (NLS) repeats into the ZFN protein backbone enhances cell permeability nearly 13-fold and that single administration of multi-NLS ZFN proteins leads to genome modification rates of up to 26% in CD4+ T cells and 17% in CD34+ hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells. In addition, we show that multi-NLS ZFN proteins attenuate off-target effects and that codelivery of ZFN protein pairs facilitates dual gene modification frequencies of 20–30% in CD4+ T cells. These results illustrate the applicability of ZFN protein delivery for precision genome engineering. Molecular Therapy—Nucleic Acids (2015) 4, e232; doi:10.1038/mtna.2015.6; advance online publication 10 March 2015 Subject Category: Gene insertion, deletion & modification Gene vectors The emergence of site-specific DNA endonucleases and expression from DNA could lead to increased off-target genome editing has empowered researchers with the activity,26 a detrimental side effect that might have serious unprecedented ability to manipulate virtually any gene consequences for therapeutic genome editing. Indeed, in across a broad spectrum of cell types and organisms.1–3 order for nuclease-mediated genome engineering to reach The technologies most commonly used to achieve this— its full potential, new methods that improve their specificity homing endonucleases,4,5 zinc-finger nucleases (ZFNs),6–8 and safety are needed. TAL effector nucleases (TALENs),9–11 and CRISPR/Cas912– The direct delivery of nuclease proteins into mammalian 14—have the potential to revolutionize basic biological cells has been shown to be a viable alternative to DNA or research and transform medicine, as evidenced by recent mRNA-based delivery systems. Unlike methods that rely on clinical trials for HIV/AIDS based on ZFN-mediated modifi- expression from nucleic acids, protein delivery poses no risk cation of the HIV-1 coreceptor chemokine (C-C motif) recep- for chromosomal insertions and only exposes the cell to the tor 5 (CCR5).15 These systems are generally configured nuclease for a short period of time, thereby reducing off-tar- to induce targeted DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) that get effects.27 To date, nuclease proteins have been admin- stimulate the cellular DNA repair machinery, typically lead- istered directly into cells via cell-penetrating peptides,28–30 ing to one of two outcomes: gene knockout16 via mutagenic ligand-mediated endocytosis,31 electroporation,32,33 or trans- nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) or, in the presence of an fection34 and retro-35 or lentivirus particles.36–38 In particular, accompanying donor template, targeted gene integration17 we previously showed that ZFN proteins are inherently cell- or correction8,18 by homology-directed repair (HDR). While permeable and capable of inducing genome modifications recent technological advances have helped make genome via their direct application to human cells.27 ZFNs are chi- editing a routine endeavor for nonspecialized laboratories, meric endonucleases consisting of the cleavage domain of establishing safe and efficient delivery methods for sensi- the FokI restriction endonuclease and a custom-designed 39,40 tive applications remains challenging. Current methods for Cys2-His2 zinc-finger DNA-binding protein, the latter of achieving this are based on transfection or electroporation19 which possesses the innate ability to cross cell membranes of nuclease-encoded DNA or mRNA or the use of viral vec- likely due to its high overall positive charge. Due to its sim- tor delivery systems.20 These strategies, however, are lim- plicity and ability to improve the specificity of genome editing, ited by a number of factors: viral vectors are time-consuming ZFN protein delivery represents a promising approach for to produce, capable of chromosomal integration, hampered modifying cells for ex vivo genome engineering applications. by repetitive elements (e.g., TAL effector repeats)21–23 and, in However, for most cell-types, consecutive protein treatments the case of adenoassociated virus (AAV), size-constrained. are necessary to achieve high levels of genomic modifica- Nonviral delivery systems, on the other hand, are restricted tion, a drawback that limits the scope and scalability of this to certain cell types and have been reported to show toxicity methodology. from electroporation24 or transfection.25 In addition, regard- Here, we explore the use of nuclear localization signals less of the delivery strategy used, high levels of nuclease (NLS)—highly positively charged peptide domains that have 1The Skaggs Institute for Chemical Biology, The Scripps Research Institute, La Jolla, California, USA; 2Department of Chemistry, The Scripps Research Institute, La Jolla, California, USA; 3Department of Cell and Molecular Biology, The Scripps Research Institute, La Jolla, California, USA; 4Shanghai Institute for Advanced Immunochemi- cal Studies (SIAIS), ShanghaiTech University, Shanghai, China; 5Deceased. Correspondence: The first two authors contributed equally to this work. Jia Liu, Shanghai Institute for Advanced Immunochemical Studies (SIAIS), ShanghaiTech University, Shanghai, China. E-mail: [email protected] or Thomas Gaj, Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, California, USA. E-mail: [email protected] Keywords: genome editing; protein delivery; zinc-finger nuclease Received 26 January 2015; accepted 27 January 2015; advance online publication 10 March 2015. doi:10.1038/mtna.2015.6 Improved Cell-Penetrating ZFN Proteins for Genome Editing Liu et al 2 the innate ability to cross cell membranes—as a means to evident for either ZFN protein in cell culture (Supplemen- enhance ZFN protein cell permeability. We demonstrate that tary Figure S2). incorporation of tandem NLS repeats into the ZFN protein ZFNs typically contain a single N-terminal Simian vacuo- backbone enhances ZFN cell-penetrating activity and leads lating virus 40 (SV40) NLS sequence (PKKKRKV) that medi- to highly efficient genome modification in a diverse range of ates nuclear import but does not measurably contribute to cell types, including primary CD4+ T cells, CD34+ hematopoi- its intrinsic cell-penetrating activity.27 Because in some con- etic stem/progenitor cells (HSPCs) and induced pluripotent texts NLS sequences possess an innate ability to cross cell stem cells (iPSCs). In addition, we show that multi-NLS ZFN membranes45 and mediate protein transfection,46 we hypoth- proteins retain the ability to mitigate off-target effects and esized that tandem NLS repeats could enhance ZFN protein mediate high levels of dual gene modification in CD4+ T cells, cell-permeability. To test this, we fused one, two, three, or illustrating the potential of ZFN protein delivery for ex vivo four additional repeats of the SV40 NLS to the N-terminus genome engineering processes. of ZFN proteins that already contained one NLS and were designed to target the human CCR5 gene (Figure 1a).47 We generated ZFN proteins in high yield (>2 mg/l) and >80% Results purity from the soluble fraction of Escherichia coli lysates but observed varying levels of proteolysis of three-, four- and Improving ZFN protein delivery via tandem NLS repeats five-NLS ZFN proteins (Supplementary Figure S3). Com- As a means to enhance the innate cell-penetrating activity pared to native one-NLS ZFN protein, only four- and five- of ZFN proteins, we explored the possibility of genetically NLS proteins showed a decrease in cleavage activity in vitro fusing protein transduction domains (PTDs) to the N-ter- (Supplementary Figure S3). In particular, low-levels of non- minus of ZFNs. We27 and others29 previously reported that specific cleavage were evident for the five-NLS ZFN proteins incorporation of the cell-penetrating peptide sequence from (Supplementary Figure S3), likely due to nonspecific asso- the HIV-1 TAT protein41 or the poly-Arg peptide42 impairs ciation between the highly positively charged N-terminus of ZFN protein expression. We thus expanded the scope of the ZFN protein and the DNA backbone. this approach by separately incorporating two additional We evaluated the ability of these multi-NLS ZFN proteins PTDs, penetratin43 and transportan,44 into the ZFN protein to enter cells and stimulate mutagenesis using a previously backbone. While both fusion proteins could be expressed in described human embryonic kidney (HEK) 293 reporter yields sufficient for downstream analysis (Supplementary cell line (Figure 1b).27,48 This system features an integrated Figure S1), reduced activity was observed for both proteins EGFP gene whose expression has been disabled by the in vitro and no improvement in genomic modification was presence of a frame-shift mutation introduced by a ZFN acPKKKRKV 12 0.5 μmol/l One-NLS Zinc-finger Fokl 10 1.0 μmol/l 2.0 μmol/l Two-NLS Zinc-finger Fokl 8 4.0 μmol/l 6 Three-NLS Zinc-finger Fokl 4 Four-NLS Zinc-finger Fokl 2 Five-NLS Zinc-finger cells (%) EGFP-positive Fokl 0 One Two Three Four Five NLS repeats bde 10 1X 100 * * 8 * * * 2X 80 * CMV EGFP CCR5-R CCR5-R EGFP * * 3X 6 * * 60 Insertion (+2, 5, 8... bps) or NHEJ-mediated * deletion (-1, 4, 7...bps) mutagenesis 4 40 * CMV EGFP 2 20 EGFP-positive cells (%) EGFP-positive 0 cells (%) FITC-positive 0 o One Two Three Four Five One Tw Four Five Mock Three NLS repeats NLS repeats Figure 1 Tandem NLS repeats enhance ZFN protein activity.