RCUK REVIEW of E-SCIENCE in the UNITED KINGDOM
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RCUK Review of e-Science 2009 Section 1 Information for the Panel Overview: Funding of Science and Innovation in the UK RCUK REVIEW OF e-SCIENCE IN THE UNITED KINGDOM EVIDENCE TO THE PANEL NOVEMBER 2009 Research Councils UK (RCUK) Polaris House, North Star Avenue Swindon, SN2 1ET Wiltshire, UK http://www.rcuk.ac.uk RCUK Review of e-Science 2009 Section 1 Information for the Panel Overview: Funding of Science and Innovation in the UK Contents 1. Preface and Summary 1.1 Table of acronyms 1.2 Review of e-Science evidence framework 2. Current UK Science and Innovation Policy and Research Funding Overview 2.1 Setting the scene 2.2 How funding for science is secured 2.3 Funding for research 3. An Introduction to e-Science Research in the UK 3.1 Overview 3.2 Background and introduction 3.3 Funding for e-Science research in the UK 3.4 Bibliometric evidence 3.5 International engagement 3.6 Support for people 3.7 Knowledge Transfer 3.8 Further related funding 4. The Institution Perspective 4.1 Invited institutions evidence 4.2 Other institutes evidence RCUK Review of e-Science 2009 Section 1 Information for the Panel Overview: Funding of Science and Innovation in the UK 1. Preface and Summary This document has been produced in preparation for the 2009 RCUK Review of e-Science. The review is being organised by EPSRC, on behalf of RCUK and aims to inform stakeholders about the quality and impact of the UK science base. The purpose of this document is to provide an overview of research in e-Science in the UK in terms of its people, funding, organisation and policy. This should inform the Review Panel’s deliberations as it addresses the issues raised in the evidence framework. A variety of background data has been used and sources are acknowledged. The data has been provided for use by the Review Panel and will be published on the RCUK web site on completion of the Review (documentation provided in confidence will not be published). No data from this document may be quoted or used publicly without written permission from EPSRC. Evidence in this document has been compiled from the Research Councils’ management records and the UK e-Science research community. Note that due to the variety of sources some data is more up to date than others. However, wherever possible dates of the financial years 2001 to 2008 has been taken (UK financial years run from 1 April to 31 March). Additionally panel members should note that the Research Council data in this document refers to the ‘e-Science Programme’, and the ‘e-Science Core Programme’ which now no longer exist. It must be remembered when reading this document that no inferences or conclusions have been made from the data by the writers. It is not the purpose of this document to steer the opinion of the Panel in any way but merely to present the Panel with information it may interpret as it sees fit. Authors: Jo Garrad and Sarah Fulford Contributors: David Robey, AHRC Michael Ball and David McAllister, BBSRC Susie Douglas, EPSRC Suzanne Mills, ESRC Ghada Zoubiane, MRC Michelle Truman, NERC Trish Mullins and Malcolm Booy, STFC The e-Science research community 1 RCUK Review of e-Science 2009 Section 1 Information for the Panel Overview: Funding of Science and Innovation in the UK 1.1. Table of acronyms AHM All Hands Meeting AHRC Arts and Humanities Research Council BBSRC Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council BEP Bioinformatics E-Science Programme Referred to as BEP1 and BEP2 BERR Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory In 2009, BERR merged with Reform another Government department (DIUS) to form BIS (dept. for Business Innovation and Skills) BIS Business, Innovation and Skills Department (established Formerly DIUS and BERR 2009) CCLRC Council for the Central Laboratory of the Research Merged with PPARC to Councils become STFC (Science and Technology Facilities Council) CERN European Organisation for Nuclear Research Co-I Co-investigator CSA Chief Scientific Advisor CSR Comprehensive Spending Review DELNI Department of Education and Learning in Northern Ireland DGSI Director General of Science and Innovation DIUS Department of Innovation Universities and Skills Formerly OSI. In 2009, DIUS merged with another Government dept. (BERR) to form BIS (dept. for Business Innovation and Skills) DTA Doctoral Training Account DTC Doctoral Training Centre DTI Department of Trade and Industry (Abolished 2007) When the DTI closed many of its functions were transferred to BERR EPSRC Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council ESRC Economic and Social Research Council EU European Union fEC Full Economic Costing FTE Full-Time Equivalent HE / HEI Higher Education / Higher Education Institution HECToR High End Computing Terascale Resources HEFCE Higher Education Funding Council for England HEFCW Higher Education Funding Council for Wales HESA Higher Education Statistics Agency HPC High Performance Computing ICT Information & Communications Technology ILL Institut Laue-Langevin (France) IP/IPR Intellectual Property / Intellectual Property Rights JISC Joint Information Systems Committee KT/KTN Knowledge Transfer / Knowledge Transfer Network KTP Knowledge Transfer Partnership LHC Large Hadron Collider MOD Ministry of Defence MRC Medical Research Council NCeSS National Centre for e-Social Science NERC Natural Environment Research Council NSF National Science Foundation (US counterpart to UK Research Councils) 2 RCUK Review of e-Science 2009 Section 1 Information for the Panel Overview: Funding of Science and Innovation in the UK OSI Office of Science and Innovation OSI was a Government department which was formerly known as OST (Office of Science and Technology), and became DIUS (Dept. for Innovation University and Skills) OST Office of Science and Technology OST was established in 2007 and then became the OSI PI Principal Investigator PPARC Particle Physics and Astronomy Research Council Merged with CCLRC to form STFC (Science and Technology Facility Council) R&D Research and Development RA Research Assistant RAE Research Assessment Exercise RAL Rutherford Appleton Laboratory RCUK Research Councils United Kingdom RDA Regional Development Agency SFC Scottish Funding Council SME Small / Medium sized Enterprise SR Spending Review SRIF Science Research Investment Fund STFC Science and Technology Facilities Council Formerly PPARC and CCLRC 1.1.1 Shown below is a diagram of the structural changes to the Government departments that support research. Figure 1 Structural changes to Government departments that support research Department for Pre 2007 Trade and Industry (DTI) Office for Science and Innovation Department for Research Department for 2007 Innovation and Councils Business Enterprise & Skills (DIUS) Regulatory Reform (BERR) Technology Strategy Board Technology Government Department for Strategy Board 2008 Business Innovation Agency of Government and Skills (BIS) Research Councils 3 RCUK Review of e-Science 2009 Section 1 Information for the Panel Overview: Funding of Science and Innovation in the UK 1.2 Review of e-Science evidence framework A framework is provided to assist the Panel during the Review week. The use of a standard framework is important in order to ensure coverage of all relevant strategic issues. The framework is not intended to restrict the panel; additional issues can be addressed as they arise. However, it is deemed helpful to have a framework for reference during the information-gathering and particularly in formulating conclusions and recommendations. The questions below were used for the public consultation exercise, which can be found in section 4. These questions have also been formulated in the ‘Panel Member diaries’, which are part of your panel pack. A. Did the UK e-Science Programme build a Platform which enables e-Science tools, infrastructure and practises to become incorporated into mainstream research in the UK? Did the Programme create a critical mass of capability in developing and exploiting e-Science tools and techniques? Is this capacity being sustained? To what extent have the e-Science technologies developed through the Programme changed the way researchers in other disciplines work? Are there new areas of research that have been enabled by the e-Science Programme? What can be done to increase this happening? Are the present infrastructure and communication channels sufficient? To what extent did the e-Science Programme contribute to and benefit from multi-disciplinary research? What barriers to such research did the Programme overcome and what opportunities did it enable? How effective is the education/training of e-Science practises and techniques at ensuring sufficient take up and adoption? What barriers to effective knowledge exchange and information flow remain and how can they be overcome? What are the barriers to the uptake of these tools and techniques? B. How does UK e-Science activity compare globally? How developed is the global e-Science Platform, and what has been UK e-Science Programme contribution? To what extent did the research undertaken through the Programme engage in “best with best” science-driven international interactions? In which areas of e-Science is the UK the international leader? What has contributed to UK strengths and what are the recommendations for continued strength? In which areas is the UK less strong and what are the recommendations for improvement? Are there sufficient numbers of research leaders of international stature evident in the UK, in comparison to other countries? If not, which areas have