Bill Oppenheim, December 17, 2003–Class Of ‘99 at that price. FROM THE DESK OF... The Form Lines... Bill Oppenheim Rock of Gibraltar was only ever beaten three times in 13 career starts, and among his 10 wins he won seven CLASS OF '99 consecutive Group 1 races over two seasons, breaking The year they ran 1-2-3 in the French Derby, future the great Mill Reef’s record. In Racehorses of 2002, top sires Darshaan, Sadler’s Wells, and Rainbow Quest Timeform engaged in a discussion of the misapplication were rated 133, 132, and 131, respectively, in of the word ‘great,’ and they rated Rock of Gibraltar Timeform's Racehorses of 1984. Rainbow Quest was 133, whereas Mill Reef--a true great--was rated 141. the only one of the three to race on at four, and he Fair enough, and relevant, also, that Mill Reef was a improved his rating to 134. Though we didn’t know it truly influential sire, an accolade that is as difficult to at the time, the 1984 French Derby was a seminal race earn as ‘true great’ is for a racehorse. But, at 133, in determining future top pedigrees in Europe for what’s Rock of Gibraltar is plenty good enough (Darshaan 133, about to be the next 20 years. Sadler’s Wells 132, Rock of Gibraltar’s own sire, By the same token, four horses who achieved Danehill, 126) and so are his two contemporaries. comparable Beyer ratings in handicap company in North Though he raced for only two seasons instead of the America in 1997-98 all retired to stud in 1999, had others’ three, Rock of Gibraltar was arguably the their first foals in 2000, and their first three-year-olds soundest, and certainly the most consistent, of the this year. Formal Gold, Skip Away, Gentlemen, and three, and he’s the one, not surprisingly, that ties the Will’s Way all registered Beyer figures over 120--most form lines together. Having been bought privately from of them more than once--which conservatively (+12 breeders Aidan O’Brien and his father-in-law, Joe points) equates to a Timeform 132. So being able to Crowley, and racing in the colors of Sue Magnier, Rock run over 130 Timeform is no guarantee of sire success. of Gibraltar broke his maiden over five furlongs in April None of those four are among the top 10 North at the Curragh, and went straight to Royal Ascot for American second-crop sires (2002-03 earnings) this the Coventry, but encountered loads of trouble in the year. race and finished sixth, three lengths behind stablemate Usually when you see a cluster of horses at top-class Landseer. When he ran back less than 12 days later at level, it suggests the form is suspect. None of them are the Curragh, he went off at 1-2, with stable jockey good enough to break away from the pack. But Mick Kinane up, and won the G3 Railway S. by two occasionally, as with the 1984 French Derby (proven by lengths from stablemate Hawk Wing. That colt, who subsequent breeding influence) and the 1997 American won his debut over seven furlongs at Tipperary in May, two-turn handicappers (proven by speed figures), there was dropping back in distance and went off at 12-1. is a cluster of top-class horses who are, in fact, even Neither ran back for another seven weeks. Rock of better than the usual top-class horse. You get kind of Gibraltar next ran in the G2 Gimcrack S. at York, now caught up in superlatives: exceptional, star, superstar, with Sir Alex Ferguson as co-owner. He uncorked a pick your own. My view is that there were three devastating turn of foot and won easily by three European milers foaled in 1999 who fit the description: lengths. Hawk Wing, meanwhile, easily beat stablemate Rock of Gibraltar, Hawk Wing, and Dubai Destination. Sholokhov in the G2 Futurity S. at the Curragh three Rock of Gibraltar, of course, went to stud this year; days later. Hawk Wing and Dubai Destination kick off in 2004, Rock of Gibraltar headed for the seven-furlong G2 along with the fourth-best miler of his generation, Champagne S. at Doncaster, where he went off a Where or When. He goes to stud at Cheveley Park for short-priced favorite against Dubai Destination, trained only £6,000, and if I’m right that the three in front of as a two-year-old by David Loder. The Kingmambo colt him were superstars, he must be a worthwhile gamble had been upset at 1-2 in a six-furlong maiden at PINE BLUFF Danzig S Rowdy Angel

“PINE BLUFF provides very solid value at this price.” S Bill Oppenheim, TDN PINE BLUFF is siring 16% stakes horses from starters. His most recent stakes winner is BOSSANOVA who led BOX 626, VERSAILLES, KY 40383 at every call to take the Grade 3 Fall Highweight H. (859) 873-7300 FAX (859) 873-3746 E-MAIL: [email protected] 2004 STUD FEE: $10,000 LIVE FOAL WEB SITE: www.lanesend.com Newbury in June, but had come back to win a seven- the knockers started calling Hawk Wing’s name. By the furlong maiden at Newmarket in July which has a time he finished down the track in the Breeders’ Cup history of being won by good horses. Dubai Destination Classic, they didn’t want to know. Winner of one race appeared to win the Champagne fair and square by a in six starts as a three-year-old, four times second; not length. He looked the better horse that day, but it a popular record for a pro-tem superstar. wasn’t until he won the G1 Queen Anne S. at Royal Rock of Gibraltar, meanwhile, won four more in a Ascot, 21 months later and in only his third start since, row, each one maybe easier than the one before: the that Dubai Destination won a Group 1 race. Rock of Irish 2000; the St. James’s Palace S. over stablemate Gibraltar had won seven consecutive Group 1s, broken Landseer, Kinane barely letting out a notch; the Sussex; Mill Reef’s record, and retired to stud in the meantime. and the Moulin. He went off at 4-5 for the Breeders’ In fact, two days after the Champagne, Hawk Wing Cup Mile, but broke slowly and suffered severe defeated Dubai Destination’s stablemate Naheef in the interference when his stablemate Landseer broke down G1 National S. at the Curragh, at odds of nearly 1-2, in front of him. Domedriver got there first under an and at that point Rock of Gibraltar looked like Aidan inspired Thierry Thulliez ride, but The Rock lost no caste O’Brien’s third-best two-year-old, behind Hawk Wing in defeat. Off to Coolmore for i90,000, he stayed in and a certain Johannesburg. Hawk Wing didn’t run the news, first because Danehill died and he ended up again that year; Rock of Gibraltar went to France and covering an even better first book than anyone could won the G1 Grand Criterium on Arc day (now run at have imagined, then because a spat between Sir Alex seven furlongs), and came back 13 days later to and John Magnier over ownership got very public. But, become the first horse to win the Grand Criterium- you know what, so what? How good was the horse, Dewhurst double, leading home an O'Brien 1-2-3 in the that’s all we care about. Dewhurst over Landseer and Tendulkar. The first Dubai Destination, for his part, was on the shelf for English-trained horse home was fourth-placed Where or most of his three-year-old year. He ran once, finishing When. Johannesburg, of course, won the G1 Middle second in the 11-furlong Predominate S. at Goodwood Park, then went to America and won the Breeders’ Cup in a last-gasp Derby prep. That was it; he didn’t run Juvenile for what was to be his last career win. But he again until this June. was rated 127 by Timeform in Racehorses of 2001, Hawk Wing came over for the G1 Lockinge S. at and was deservedly declared world champion two- Newbury in May in his first start this year, and buried year-old. Dubai Destination was rated 119p, Rock of Where or When by 11 lengths. Rock of Gibraltar had Gibraltar 118, and Hawk Wing 116p. never recorded a Postmark of higher than 128 (though he hardly came off the bridle at three), but Hawk Wing Three-Year-Olds: One Stayed at a Mile, One Went ran a Postmark 134 in the Lockinge, and Timeform Further, One Was Injured rates him 136 in the final ‘black book.’ Dubai Johannesburg and Rock of Gibraltar each ran seven Destination came back in a four-runner conditions race times at two, Hawk Wing four, Dubai Destination three. over one mile at Nottingham, which he duly won by six On that critical first weekend in May of their three- lengths at odds of 2-5. That set up a great match up in year-old campaigns, Hawk Wing and Rock of Gibraltar the G1 Queen Anne S. at Royal Ascot; Hawk Wing made their seasonal debuts in the 2000 Guineas at went off at 8-13, with Dubai Destination at 9-2. Dubai Newmarket, while Johannesburg, who had been beaten Destination ran a great race, winning decisively in a first time out in Ireland, went for the Kentucky Derby. Postmark 126; Hawk Wing trailed in sixth and was Stable jockey Kinane, who was suspended, was on subsequently retired. Dubai Destination ran twice more, none of them, but he would surely have been on Hawk both times badly, and was retired. Both left with Wing, who went off 6-4 favorite for the Guineas, with whimpers, not bangs. Rock of Gibraltar at 9-1. Hawk Wing finished five Having been rated 127 by Timeform as a three-year- lengths clear on the stands side, but four of the first old, Hawk Wing is liable to end up with something over five home were on the far side, including Rock of 130 with a question mark in Racehorses of 2003. Rock Gibraltar, who won by a neck over Hawk Wing. There of Gibraltar was rated 133 by Timeform as a three-year- were plenty of people who felt that Hawk Wing would old. Dubai Destination is likely to be rated around 127 surely have won had he also been on the far side, but (his final black book rating), but his one-length defeat of the debate was never settled on the racecourse. They Rock of Gibraltar (who gave him four pounds) at two never met again. Rock of Gibraltar ran five more times, reads rather better than that. Dubai Destination was all at one mile. Hawk Wing stepped up to 12 furlongs 119p as a two-year-old, and was rated above him for the Derby, for which Kinane chose him over inspite of getting weight. In my view, the form of his stablemate High Chaparral. Two furlongs out Hawk win over Rock of Gibraltar reads more like about 132. I Wing was the winner, but he didn’t get the trip, and don’t quite buy that, at his best, he was six pounds finished a valiant second. He then dropped back to 10 behind The Rock and Hawk Wing. furlongs, winning a substandard Eclipse easily over Rock of Gibraltar broke Mill Reef’s record for stablemate Sholokhov, then going down by a nose to consecutive Group 1 wins and will stand his second Grandera in the Irish Champion S. When he was beaten season at Coolmore for i65,000. Hawk Wing was by Where or When in the Queen Elizabeth S. at one surely in the same class, but he is by Woodman, who mile at Royal Ascot in September as the 1-2 favorite, has never sired a really successful sire, and has been knocked for inconsistency. He goes to Coolmore for i25,000, which I would say is a serious bargain for a horse as good as he was. Dubai Destination is by Kingmambo, about whose prospects as a sire of sires we’ll know a lot more shortly, as both Lemon Drop Kid and King’s Best will have their first two-year-olds next year. He’s going to Dalham Hall for £25,000, and I’d say that’s plenty reasonable for a horse as good as he was. When you throw in Johannesburg ($30,000 at Ashford, in Kentucky), and Where or When at £6,000, well, it’s a pretty interesting group of 1999 foals who are now all at stud. The Rock and Johannesburg have their first foals next year, the other three are now going to stud. I think they were a seriously good group.

BY THE NUMBERS Dubai Destination (Kingmambo--Mysterial, by Alleged) 2001: 3-2-1-0, $98,039. Timeform Rating: 119p. 2002: 1-0-1-0, $11,240. Timeform Rating: 119. 2003: 4-2-0-0, $271,080. Timeform Rating: *127. Hawk Wing (Woodman--La Lorgnette, by Val de l’Orne {Fr}) 2001: 4-3-1-0, $272,310. Timeform Rating: 116p. 2002: 6-1-4-0, $1,143,720. Timeform Rating: 127. 2003: 2-1-0-0, $194,574. Timeform Rating: *136. Rock of Gibraltar (Danehill--Offshore Boom, by Be My Guest) 2001: 7-5-1-0, $534,127. Timeform Rating: 118. 2002: 6-5-1-0, $1,353921. Timeform Rating: 133. *Final Black Book rating.