Agenda Park Board City Of Edina, Minnesota City Hall Council Chambers 4801 W. 50th St. Tuesday, September 13, 2016 7:00 PM I. Call To Order II. Roll Call III. Approval Of Meeting Agenda IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes A. Minutes: Park Board, August 8, 2016 V. Community Comment During "Community Comment," the Board/Commission will invite residents to share relevant issues or concerns. Individuals must limit their comments to three minutes. The Chair may limit the number of speakers on the same issue in the interest of time and topic. Generally speaking, items that are elsewhere on tonight's agenda may not be addressed during Community Comment. Individuals should not expect the Chair or Board/Commission Members to respond to their comments tonight. Instead, the Board/Commission might refer the matter to sta for consideration at a future meeting. VI. Reports/Recommendations A. 2016 Work Plan Update B. Edina Baseball Association Brick Campaign C. 2017 Park Board Work Plan VII. Correspondence And Petitions A. Correspondence and City Council Updates VIII. Chair And Member Comments IX. Sta Comments X. Adjournment The City of Edina wants all residents to be comfortable being part of the public process. If you need assistance in the way of hearing amplication, an interpreter, large-print documents or something else, please call 952-927-8861 72 hours in advance of the meeting. CITY OF EDINA 4801 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424 www.edinamn.gov

Date: September 13, 2016 Agenda Item #: IV.A.

To: Park Board Item Type: Minutes From: Ann Kattreh, Parks & Recreation Director Item Activity: Subject: Minutes: Park Board, August 8, 2016 Action

ACTION REQUESTED:

INTRODUCTION:

ATTACHMENTS:

Descr ipt ion

Park Board, Aug. 8 Tour and Retreat Minutes Park Board, Aug. 8 Meeting Minutes Draft Minutes ☒ Approved Minutes ☐ Approved Date: Click here to enter a date.

Minutes City Of Edina, Minnesota Park Board Tour and Retreat Braemar Golf Course August 8, 2016

I. Call To Order Chair McCormick called the meeting to order at 5:08 p.m.

II. Roll Call Answering roll call were Chair McCormick, Members Dahlien, McAwley, Meyer, Miller, Strother and Student Members Crist and Lohani. Staff present: Park Board Staff Liaison Ann Kattreh, Assistant Parks & Recreation Director Susan Faus, Administrative Support Specialist Janet Canton and Recreation Supervisor Eric Boettcher.

Member Gieseke arrived at 5:10 p.m.

III. Approval Of Meeting Agenda None

IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes None

V. Community Comment None

VI. Reports/Recommendations A. Tour – Proposed Winter Recreation Site at Braemar Park The Park Board took golf carts and toured the area at Braemar Golf Course where the proposed winter recreation site would be located.

B. Dinner and Activity The Park Board had dinner and then played bean bag game

VII. Correspondence And Petitions None

VIII. Chair And Member Comments None

Draft Minutes ☒ Approved Minutes ☐ Approved Date: Click here to enter a date.

IX. Staff Comments None

X. Adjournment Motion made by Dahlien to adjourn the Aug. 8, 2016 tour and retreat at 6:36 p.m. Motion seconded by McAwley. Motion carried.

Draft Minutes ☒ Approved Minutes ☐ Approved Date: Click here to enter a date.

Minutes City Of Edina, Minnesota Park Board Braemar Golf Course August 8, 2016

I. Call To Order Chair McCormick called the meeting to order at 6:41 p.m.

II. Roll Call Answering roll call were Chair McCormick, Members Dahlien, Gieseke, McAwley, Meyer, Miller, Strother and Student Members Lohani and Crist. Absent Members: Good and Nelson Staff present: Park Board Staff Liaison Ann Kattreh, Assistant Parks & Recreation Director Susan Faus, Administrative Support Specialist Janet Canton and Recreation Supervisor Eric Boettcher,

III. Approval Of Meeting Agenda Motion made by Strother to approve the meeting agenda. Motion seconded by Dahlien. Motion carried.

IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes Motion made by Miller to approve the July 12, 2016 minutes. Motion seconded by McAwley. Motion carried.

V. Community Comment Cathy Johnston, Hyde Park Circle, indicated she would like to see the flowers put back in along Braemar Golf Course on Gleason Road by the sign. She does not like the native restoration that is currently there.

VI. Reports/Recommendations A. Weber Park Playground Replacement Recreation Supervisor Eric Boettcher presented the proposed Weber Park playground replacement. Park Board members asked questions.

Motion made by Miller to approve the design of the Weber Park playground and to recommend to the City Council its purchase and installation and related ADA improvements by Northland Recreation. Motion seconded by Strother.

Draft Minutes ☒ Approved Minutes ☐ Approved Date: Click here to enter a date.

Motion carried.

B. Braemar Winter Recreation Proposal and Feasibility Study Presentation Staff Liaison Kattreh presented the Park Board with a draft of the feasibility study. Staff Liaison Kattreh went through the production schedule, key milestones and explained how they got to where they currently are with the feasibility study. She also went through the preliminary market analysis financial model budgeting and the tax impact noting they are preliminary estimates only.

Paul Pasco and Mike Horn, both from SEH, went through a power point presentation of what is being proposed for the Braemar Park winter recreation area. They went through the details of the following: • Nordic ski trail alignment design • Machine-made snow and natural snow • Proposed tubing area • Fat tire mountain biking (which included non-winter and single track) area • LED lighting • Traffic impact • Opinion of cost • Reasons why they would like to open during 2017 (simultaneously with the golf course construction)

Park Board members asked questions throughout the presentation.

Staff Liaison Kattreh asked each Park Board member for their comments and if they would like to recommend as proposed, do not recommend or recommend with modifications or changes. She explained the Park Board comments will be forwarded to the City Council for the Sept. 7 public hearing.

C. 2016 Park Board Work Plan Addition – Arden Park Natural Resources Master Plan Staff Liaison Kattreh explained to the Park Board how the Arden Park Natural Resources Master Plan came to be a project.

Members McAwley and Strother indicated they would like to participate in the natural resource planning process of Arden Park.

D. 2017 Park Board Work Plan Discussion

Draft Minutes ☒ Approved Minutes ☐ Approved Date: Click here to enter a date.

Chair McCormick informed the Park Board they need to finalize the 2017 Park Board Work Plan at the September Park Board meeting. Chair McCormick went through the 2016 Work Plan items. The Park Board decided the following items will be carried over to the 2017 Work Plan: • Fred Richards Master Plan • Park Signage Replacement and Implementation • Pollinator Garden Expansion • Edina To Go App Roll Out (if needed)

Chair McCormick led a discussion of suggestions for the work plan items for 2017. Included in the discussion were items from the Strategic Plan for consideration. The following items are to be considered to add to the 2017 Park Board Work Plan:

• Marketing Initiative with City Communications Department • Arden Park Natural Resource Plan • Braemar Park Master Plan

Chair McCormick asked the Park Board to look over the items so that they can decide as a board what their top items are for the 2017 Park Board Work Plan at their Sept. 13 Park Board meeting.

VII. Correspondence And Petitions Chair McCormick acknowledged the Park Board’s receipt of various correspondences.

VIII. Chair And Member Comments • Chair McCormick thanked the Park Board for their comments; it was a difficult meeting • Chair McCormick thanked the Student Park Board members for their time on the board • Student Member Crist thanked the Park Board for the experience, it’s been great and she would recommend it to upcoming high schoolers • Student Member Lohani thanked the Park Board and noted he had a great time listening and participating

IX. Staff Comments • Staff Liaison Kattreh thanked the Park Board for their comments and Chair McCormick for managing a difficult meeting very well

Draft Minutes ☒ Approved Minutes ☐ Approved Date: Click here to enter a date.

• Staff Liaison Kattreh informed the Park Board that last week was the grand opening of the Academy 9 and driving range and the feedback so far has been good • Staff Liaison Kattreh informed the Park Board that Annika Sorenstam was at Braemar Golf Course last week; she had a great message to share as well as signed autographed photos • Staff Liaison Kattreh handed out a brochure they are giving out to educate people on the native restoration they are doing in different naturalized areas; she added there is also some signage around the golf course as well • Staff Liaison Kattreh informed the Park Board that on Aug. 11 there will be a ribbon cutting at Creek Valley School Park for the new sun shelter and bench that were recently donated.

X. Adjournment Motion made by Dahlien to adjourn the Aug. 8, 2016 meeting at 9:45 p.m. Motion seconded by Miller. Motion carried.

CITY OF EDINA 4801 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424 www.edinamn.gov

Date: September 13, 2016 Agenda Item #: VI.A.

To: Park Board Item Type: Report and Recommendation From: Ann Kattreh, Parks & Recreation Director Item Activity: Subject: 2016 Work Plan Update Discussion, Information

ACTION REQUESTED: Review and discuss the 2016 Park Board Work Plan.

INTRODUCTION: Chair McCormick will lead a discussion regarding the status of items on the Park Board's 2016 Work Plan. ATTACHMENTS:

Descr ipt ion

2016 Park Board Work Plan Updates Board/Commission: Park Board 2016 Annual Work Plan

Initiative 1 ☐☐☐ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☒☒☒ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Inclusive Playground – Rosland Park December 2016 $250 ,000 Assistant Director – 80 Funds are part (Board will propose to develop an inclusive hours, Park Superintendent of the CIP. playground.) – 4 hours, Recreation Supervisor – 30 hours. Progress Report: Koren Nelson , Eileen McAwley Staff Lead - Susan Faus . Completed. Construction will begin on 9/19/16

Initiative 2 ☐☐☐ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☒☒☒ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Fred Richards Park Master Plan October 2016 $75,000 Director – 160 hours , If p roject is Assistant Director – 160 pushed to hours, Administrative 2017 then this Support Specialists – 16 initiative can hours, Public Works Director be removed – 20 hours and added next year. Progress Report: Gerry Green, Greg Good , Eileen McAwley , Matt Dahlien , Michael Miller Staff Lead - Ann Kattreh . Consultant selection is underway. Master planning will begin in November/December.

Initiative 3 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Park Signage Replacement Plan & Begin December 2016 $500,000 Director – 120 hours and Funds are Implementation Assistant Director – 120 from the Park (Board will propose plan to council for approval. If hours, Park Maintenance – Dedication approved, the board will implement plan. 40 hours fees. Progress Report: Koren Nelson , Julie Strother, Brenda McCormick, Dan Gieseke , Michael Miller Staff Lead – Susan Faus . Perspective design teams are being vetted by staff. Park Board members will be consulted shortly when information is gathered.

Approved by City Council on December 15, 2015

Initi ative 4 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Grandview Facility Planning July 2016 $60,000 Director – 160 hours , (Grandview Task Force will provide Assistant Director – 120 recommendation to the Park Board, Park Board will hours, Art Center General provide recommendation to City Council.) Manager – 160 hours, Recreation Supervisors – 100 hours Progress Report: Completed. Koren Nelson – Staff Lead – Ann Kattreh

Initiative 5 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Analysis of current programs and Cost Recovery December 2016 0 Assistant Director – 80 Expectations (CRE) for City recreational programs. hours, Recreation Supervisors – 120 hours Progress Report: Greg Good, Aanik Lohani , Michael Miller . Staff Lead – Susan Faus . Completed. Reviewed program classifications and made updates. Established program metrics to measure success. Provided CRE for core program areas.

Initiative 6 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Recreation Programming and Facilities December 2016 0 Assistant Director – 80 Marketing and Communication Delivery hours, Recreation Review. Study utilization opportunities and Supervisors – 80 hours, implement Edina To Go App for Parks & Facility General Managers – Recreation. 20 hours, Communications Department Staff - ?? Progress Report: Julie Strother, Brenda McCormick , Matt Dahlien, Lauren Crist Staff Lead – Susan Faus. Staff have met and are working on implementing Edina To Go App for Parks & Recreation. Staff will set up meeting to present information to Park Board representatives in June/July.

Initia tive 7 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments

Approved by City Council on December 15, 2015

☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Engage External Resources to Provide December 2016 0 Recreation Supervisors – 40 Environmental Programming hours Progress Report : Julie Stother, Dan Gieseke Staff Lead – Amanda Clarke. Staff worked with Tim Zimmerman and Luther Overholt to plant a variety of plants to attract pollinators at Pamela Park this summer. Currently, engaging Three Rivers Park District and Nine Mile Creek Watershed District to participate in upcoming special event and partnering with Three Rivers Park District on environmental programs. Amanda will be looking into grant opportunities through the Minnehaha Watershed District, as well as compiling a list of potential partners for future environmental programming opportunities.

Initiative 8 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Pollinator Garden – Park Property or Partnership August 2016 $500 Recreation Supervisors – 40 with Edina Public Schools hours (Board will propose plan to establish a pollinator garden on City or School District Property. If approved by Council, they will implement.) Progress Report: Brenda McCormick Staff Lead – Amanda Clarke . Phase 1 completed March 2016. Programming will be added at Pamela Park to educate youth on pollinators and the importance. Staff is working on a partnership with Three Rivers Park District to offer another educational workshop for families. Phase 11 – Qualitative assessment of the program at the end of the summer. Phase 111 – Based on input determine if program should be expanded, continued or changed.

Initiative 9 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Multi -year Playground Renovation Plan December 2016 0 Assistant Director – 40 hours, Public Works Director, Park Maintenance – 40 hours Progress Report: Julie Strother , Eileen McAwley , Matt Dahlien , Michael Miller Staff Lead – Susan Faus . This is a Q3 init iative. Will start in October.

Initiative 10 ☒☒☒ New Initiative Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required Liaison ☐☐☐ Continued Initiative Date Comments ☐☐☐ On-Going Initiative Collaborate with Energy and Environment December 2016 0 Recreation Supervisors – 20

Approved by City Council on December 15, 2015

Commission on providing a recommendation hours , Facility General regarding bottled water sales at City facilities. Managers – 20 hours REMOVED Progress Report: Park Board Members – REMOVED FROM WORK PLAN

Ongoing Responsibilities

Capital Improvement Plan Review; Fees and Charges Review; Election of Officers; Work Plans

Other Work Plan Ideas Considered for Current Year or Future Years Cooperative Agreement with School District for use, upgrade and maintenance of Creek Valley Park athletic fields and Cornelia School Park athletic fields.

Proposed Month for Joint Work Session : June

Council Comments: Work plans proposed by the Boards and Commissions were reviewed at the December 1 work session. The following changes/comments were made and are reflected on this work plan: • Keep Fred Richards initiative. • Remove initiative 8 - Fundraising – Friends of the Parks • Initiative 5 – changes as recommended by City Manager.

Approved by City Council on December 15, 2015

CITY OF EDINA 4801 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424 www.edinamn.gov

Date: September 13, 2016 Agenda Item #: VI.B.

To: Park Board Item Type: Report and Recommendation From: Eric Boettcher, Recreation Supervisor Item Activity: Subject: Edina Baseball Association Brick Campaign Action

ACTION REQUESTED: Approve brick paver fundraising project for the Edina Baseball Association at Courtney Field.

INTRODUCTION: Please see attached staff report. ATTACHMENTS:

Descr ipt ion

Staff Report: Edina Baseball Association Brick Campaign at Courtney Fields Concession Building Brick Campaign Promotion Engraved Brick Example Wall Facing Field #1

September 13, 2016

Park Board

Eric Boettcher, Recreation Supervisor Jeff May, Edina Baseball Association

Edina Baseball Association Brick Campaign at Courtney Fields Concession Building

Information / Background: Edina Baseball Association (EBA) has a great history of contributing to help improve baseball facilities throughout the City of Edina. This campaign would involve selling brick pavers that would be placed along the back wall of the Courtney Fields concession building to allow community members to be a part of the history of the complex. The donations raised would be used for Courtney Field upgrades that would include new lights, netting and overall facility and safety improvements.

Proposed Brick Project

Courtney Fields concession building, northeast exterior wall, area left of door facing field #1.

Total Area: (8ft 9in x 9ft 6 in) 11,970 Square inches

Projected Revenue

Three brick sizes are being considered; one will be selected.

Size Price Total Raised

Option 1 4”x8” brick $125.00 $67,500

Option 2 8”x8” brick $250.00 $67,500

Option 3 12”x12” brick $500.00 $60,000 REPORT / RECOMMENDATION Page 2

The project will be completed in two phases. The first order will take place in the spring of 2017. The fundraising drive will then continue to collect the rest of the bricks to complete the wall with the goal of phase two completion in the spring of 2018.

Timeline

Kick-off Fundraiser Fall of 2016

Complete Phase 1 Spring of 2017

Continue Fundraising Summer 2017-Spring 2018

Complete Project Spring of 2018

Action Requested:

Approve Brick Paver Fundraising project for the Edina Baseball Association at Courtney Fields.

THANK YOU . EDI A BASEBALL THE KENNEDY FAMILY POLARENGRAVING.COM 11 11 EIN=•11 Mill MEM OM OM ■ 1111111•11111111M I Mill MEM U MOM 1111•1111111111111111 Mil ENE INS

EMI MIR MN MEE MIN I U MEM

41111111110m6misi---:--_ _ CITY OF EDINA 4801 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424 www.edinamn.gov

Date: September 13, 2016 Agenda Item #: VI.C.

To: Park Board Item Type: Report and Recommendation From: Ann Kattreh, Parks & Recreation Director Item Activity: Subject: 2017 Park Board Work Plan Action

ACTION REQUESTED: Approve a proposed Park Board Work Plan for City Council review and final approval.

INTRODUCTION: See attached work plan proposal. ATTACHMENTS:

Descr ipt ion

2017 DRAFT Park Board Work Plan

Board/Commission: Choose an item. 2017 Annual Work Plan Proposal *Complete each section with a white background Definitions: *Liaisons need to fill out budget and staff support required New Initiative – not on previous work plan *Return to MJ Lamon by September 23, 2016 Continued Initiative – carried over from a previous work plan with a revised target completion date Ongoing Responsibility – annually on the work plan and may or may not have a target completion date

Initiative Council Charge Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required ☐☐☐ 1 ☐☐☐ 2 ☒☒☒ 3 ☐☐☐ 4 Date (Staff Liaison) (Staff Liaison) ☒ New Initiative ☐ Continued Initiative ☐ Ongoing Responsibility Dec. 2017 $0 Ann Kattreh – 40 hours Arden Park Natural Resource Plan Liaison Comments : Eileen McAwley and Julie Strother have volunteered to participate in this planning process. The process is being led by the City of Edina Engineering Department along with a partnership with the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District. City Manager Comments : Click here to enter text. Progress Report: Click here to enter text.

Initiative Council Charge Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required ☒☒☒ 1 ☐☐☐ 2 ☐☐☐ 3 ☐☐☐ 4 Date (Staff Liaison) (Staff Liaison) ☒ New Initiative ☐ Continued Initiative ☐ Ongoing Responsibility July 2017 Click here to enter Click here to enter text. Marketing Initiative with City Communications Department text. Liaison Comments: Click here to enter text. City Manager Comments: Click here to enter text. Progress Report: Click here to enter text.

Initiative Council Charge Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required ☐☐☐ 1 ☐☐☐ 2 ☒☒☒ 3 ☐☐☐ 4 Date (Staff Liaison) (Staff Liaison) ☒ New Initiative ☐ Continued Initiative ☐ Ongoing Responsibility Dec. 2017 $60,000 Ann Kattreh – 160 hours , Susan Braemar Park Master Plan Faus, 100 hours & Janet Canton - 40

hours , Park Maintenance – 20 hours Liaison Comments: A master plan of Braemar Park will be completed in 2017. This master plan will encompass Nordic ski, mountain bike, snow shoe, and and walking trails and extensive buckthorn removal and tree replacement in addition to other recreational opportunities. City Manager Comments: Click he re to enter text. Progress Report: Click here to enter text.

Initiative Council Charge Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required ☐☐☐ 1 ☐☐☐ 2 ☒☒☒ 3 ☐☐☐ 4 Date (Staff Liaison) (Staff Liaison) ☐ New Initiative ☒ Continued Initiative ☐ Ongoing Responsibility Oct. 2017 $70,000 Ann Kattreh – 160 hours, Susan Fred Richards Master Plan Faus, 100 hours & Janet Canton - 40 hours, Park Maintenance – 20 hours Liaison Comments: Complete a master plan of Fred Richards Park. Project will begin in November or December of 2016 and will be completed in Q2 2017. City Manager Comments: Click here to enter text. Progress Report: Click here to enter text.

Initiative Council Charge Target Completion Budget Required Staff Support Required ☐☐☐ 1 ☐☐☐ 2 ☒☒☒ 3 ☐☐☐ 4 Date (Staff Liaison) (Staff Liaison) ☐ New Initiative ☒ Continued Initiative ☐ Ongoing Responsibility July 2017 $500,000 Susan Faus – 120 hours , Janet Park Signage Replacement Project Canton – 40 hours, Ann Kattreh – 40 hours Liaison Comments: Park Board will assist with sign design and final selection. Board will be asked to provide review and comment to the City Co uncil. City Manager Comments: Click here to enter text. Progress Report: Click here to enter text.

Parking Lot: (These items have been considered by the BC, but not proposed as part of this year’s work plan. If the BC decides they would like to work on them in the current year, it would need to be approved by Council.)

Proposed Month for Joint Work Session (one time per year, up to 60 minutes) :

Council Comments:

CITY OF EDINA 4801 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424 www.edinamn.gov

Date: September 13, 2016 Agenda Item #: VII.A.

To: Park Board Item Type: Correspondence From: Ann Kattreh, Parks & Recreation Director Item Activity: Subject: Correspondence and City Council Updates Information

ACTION REQUESTED:

INTRODUCTION:

ATTACHMENTS:

Descr ipt ion

City Council Updates Aug. 16 and Sept. 7 Correspondence received through Aug. 29 Correspondence received through Sept. 8 City Council Updates By Scott Neal

August 16, 2016

• Nothing to Report

September 7, 2016 • Approved an amendment to the contract with golf course architect Richard Mandell to provide $230,000 for on-site construction management services during the Braemar Golf Course renovation project.

• Awarded a $100,000 contract to Play Power LT Farmington/Little Tykes to replace the existing playground structure at Weber Park with new playground equipment. The removal of the existing playground equipment will start in mid-September. Construction is scheduled to begin in late September. The project is slated to be completed by the end of October.

• Conducted a public hearing for the proposed Braemar Winter Recreation program. After two hours of public hearing, and two more hours of additional discussion, the Council directed staff and the Park Board to begin the process of master planning Braemar Park and to include Nordic ski trails, mountain bike trails, snow shoe trails, walking trails, extensive buckthorn removal and tree replacement. The 2017 budget includes funding to create a Braemar Park master plan. The Council's direction does not include construction of ski trails up the ridge line of Braemar's east hillside or the equipment/infrastructure associated with making artificial snow.

Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2016 7:35 AM Subject: FW: Support Braemar Development

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Dave Hruby [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, August 08, 2016 6:22 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Support Braemar Development

Please do not allow a few people to spoil an amazing community enhancement prove t that would benefit citizens of Edina greatly.

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2016 7:45 AM Subject: FW: Please vote NO to the current Nordic Ski Park plan (in Braemar Golf Course) (for now)

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Wufei Zhang [mailto:wzhang5(agnnail.corn] Sent: Monday, August 08, 2016 6:14 PM To: James Hovland Subject: Please vote NO to the current Nordic Ski Park plan (in Braemar Golf Course) (for now)

Dear Mayor Hovland, Thank you for reading my letter! I just heard that there is a proposal for a "Winter Park" in Braemar Golf Course. After reviewing the details of the proposal from SEH, I strongly oppose this plan because of the decimation of natural forestry and wildlife at Braemar Golf Course to simply construct a very advanced Nordic X-country ski trail for a very limited group of people. There is a snow-tubing area for more general public, but the majority is for a 3-mile long 50' wide advanced X-country ski trail on the hill, and I believe majority of the expense is related to that. I do not support this endeavor as it injures precious green space, will create a public hazard due to snow- making machines, and is stated to be an expensive yet losing proposition financially. I WOULD LIKE TO URGE YOU TO VOTE NO ON THIS, PROJECT. I ask that please consider more environmentally friendly (and less costly) ways to enhance Braemar for public use: mountain biking trails, hiking, etc. Please redirect this funding to other, higher-priority level projects that improve (not diminish) public safety, or which impose no such damaging impacts on the environment or residents. People are talking about "Braemar Native Restoration". Why should we destroy the last natural reserve in Edina?

Ihave talked to quite some people, most of them not living in Braemar area, and only one person is very for it, and he has a kid in Nordic club. Most of the rest are strongly against, and a few ski-. lovers thought the park would be nice, but they also agree that there are better options for the use of the funds that could benefit much larger group, given the Hyland park is just minutes away.

1 The snow-spill will definitely also create a very dangerous situation, especially for our kids. The Gleason road will be extremely slippery, and imagine our kids walking on that road to wait for the school bus in the winter. There are several school buses driving on Gleason.

Thank you! Wufei Zhang

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2016 5:59 PM Subject: FW: Vote NO on Braemar Nordic Ski proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Wendy McNulty [mailto:w mcnulty("ayahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2016 4:23 PM To: Mary Brindle; James Hovland; Kevin Staunton; Robert Stewart; swensonannlOgmail.com; Ann Kattreh Subject: Vote NO on Braemar Nordic Ski proposal

Dear City Council Members- 1 attended the Park Board Meeting last night at Braemar to hear the presentation given by SEH regarding the Braemar Nordic Ski Project.

It became clear from the board member comments and questions (the audience was not allowed to question or comment) that this project is not a good idea.

Almost every board member questioned the unprecedented fast track of this project. It was pointed out the Braemar golf project has been in the works for at least 2 years, this would have given plenty of time for additional project proposals and studies.

The cost is way too high. Some of the questions to SEH revealed that all costs are NOT included and could be significantly higher that the $3 million soft estimate. There was also an unanswered question regarding insurance increases to the city. It seems highly unlikely that this project would not increase city insurance costs (and in turn Edina resident taxes). The insurance would surely increase if only in anticipation of lawsuits arising from slippery road and driveway accidents due to overspray of snowmaking. It is rather alarming this was not considered.

The sound was another issue. SEH stated 50 dbs was the nighttime limit in Edina. The snow making machines came in right at 50 dbs. He did not say when this study was done - and no questions were asked regarding this. Because of the fast track of this project, I assume the testing was done sometime after May 17th. This test would be faulty, obviously, because the leaves on the trees would soften the sound. The ice and the snow in winter would carry sound further. The 50 dbs estimate would not be accurate, and in reality would be significantly higher.

There were many other concerns, but the general consensus of the board members seemed to echo the concerns of the neighborhood: Moving WAY to fast Too expensive Too expansive Not enough testing done

1 Hazardous conditions for surrounding neighborhood Decimation of trees and wildlife

Almost everyone on the board agreed that a much smaller scale natural project would be more appropriate for the area without snow making machines, lights, noise, etc.

I hope you will all vote NO on this project.

Thank you. Sincerely, Wendy McNulty 6001 Bonnie Brae Dr.

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 10, 2016 9:13 AM Subject: FW: Keep Edina's Braemar Green & Safe

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Randy Harris [mailto:Randy.HarrisCatoro.corn] Sent: Wednesday, August 10, 2016 7:57 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Keep Edina's Braemar Green & Safe

I am writing to request that you not approve the proposed Braemar Snow Tubing and Nordic Ski Trail development project.

My family and neighbors oppose this project for the following four reasons: 1. Edina residents should not be stuck funding such an expensive project with a dubious ROI. 2. The noise and light pollution resulting from snow making/grooming and operating the facility, as well as the excess traffic that will result, will severely alter the surrounding neighborhood. 3. Hyland Lake Park Reserve, a mere 5 miles away, offers 9.5 miles of fantastic Nordic ski trails. The surrounding community does not need more supply. 4. This project has clearly not been vetted with the residents of Edina, especially those who will be most impacted, those of us living in Braemar Hills.

Please reject this proposed project.

Regard,

Randy Harris 7017 Mark Terrace Drive Edina, MN 55439

This electronic message including any attachments ("Message") may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under trade secret and other applicable law. If you are not the intended recipient, notify the sender immediately, permanently delete all copies of this Message, and be aware that examination, use, dissemination, duplication or disclosure of this Message is strictly prohibited.

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 10, 2016 9:15 AM Subject: FW: Keep Braemar Green!

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I vvww.EdinaMN.qov

From: Maggie Harris [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 10, 2016 8:26 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Keep Braemar Green!

Dear Edina City Council;

I am a writing as a lifelong Edina resident and as a concerned community member. I follow most city improvements and feel that most are discussed and reviewed and many times residents have the opportunity to vote. My husband and I have been very supportive of all referendums to improve the schools and fix streets and finally add a critical bike path link. So I do not usually find myself in the position of protesting a project in Edina. However the project to add skiiing trails and a tubing hill snuck up on a lot of us and I am scratching my head to understand who wants this? Who is driving this project? And why hasn't it been discussed or residents allowed to vote? There are a few key reasons this makes no sense to me. 1. The green spaces in our city are critical to keeping it looking established and wooded more like Deephaven or North Oaks than a new suburb. One reason why many young families pay a lot for older houses and spend a lot fixing them up to live in a beautiful established community. Clearing away woods and the animals that live within hurts the richness of our city. 2. I can not imagine this is going to be a profit generator and therefore will add costs that most city members do not want. 3. Hyland Park reserve is UNDER 5 miles from this proposed spot. Have you studied to understand how many people actually use that facility and would switch to using the one in Edina? It seems the need is already being met in a facility close by.

I am asking that you table this project and the expense until you know it is a worthy initiative. Push the pause button. I would be surprised if there was an overwhelming call by the citizens of Edina for this project. This is an example of our City Council not doing their due diligence on a project that creates additional on-going city expenses which will need to be covered by more taxes for the greater good of a few.

Sincerely, Maggie Harris

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Thursday, August 11, 2016 9:14 AM Subject: FW: Please Support the Braemar Winter Recreation Area

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Mitchell Granberg [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 10, 2016 6:08 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Please Support the Braemar Winter Recreation Area

Dear Edina City Council:

I recently received a letter from the City detailing a nordic ski trail and other improvements to Braemar. I was excited, as I live very close by and know that many golf courses benefit from winter sports. I for one would very much appreciate a nearby facility for winter sports. Please support this -- I believe it will improve Edina and make it a better place to live. Finally, I am surprised at those who are against it, but I hope you continue to push to make our community better.

Thank you,

Mitchell W. Granberg 6721 Galway Drive Edina, MN

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, August 12, 2016 8:16 AM Subject: FW: Nordic ski trail/snow tubing

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Charles Carroll [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, August 11, 2016 9:09 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic ski trail/snow tubing

Please vote NO to this. We are against this project.

Thank you, Charles & Carrie Carroll

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 9:38 AM Subject: FW: A note to Mayor Hovland and Edina City Council members

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.gov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Kay Bach [mailto:rkbachOnnindspring.com] Sent: Friday, August 12, 2016 5:22 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: A note to Mayor Hovland and Edina City Council members

Hello -- first of all, I want to thank you all for the time and energy that is used to benefit your constituents like me! I have lived in Edina for more years than I should admit to, and have been very involved in many ways with the City, with pleasure. From the 1988 Centennial celebration all the way to the present, where I've just retired after 3 terms with the Edina Historical Society.. Years with the League of Women Voters of Edina and much more... I mention those to let you know that I (and husband Ron) really love living here... My reason to write you all now is in regard to the possible development of a new large (50 ft wide!!) trail for a Nordic Ski Track in Braemar Park -- with the addition of making snow for it! And the price tag of $3 million (plus additional annual maintenance) -- and using up 300 million gallons of water per year! What would that do to our water sources?? We homeowners are urged in our utility bills, to save water, and limited to certain days and times for lawn watering etc... which I agree with for the health of our community.. In addition, the cost of this project is huge -- and when the nearby Hyland Park has all of these features, a mere 3 miles away!! It is not at all necessary or desirable for this project to go forward. I believe that Braemar should stay with what we have there -- and let the trees continue to grow, the walking/hiking/biking trail continue in its nature setting, and not the noise and machinery creating more disruption, noise and light pollution to our area... much less the water that would be used annually. We would all miss the old trees and the deer around the Park... (not so much the increased number of turkeys though!)...and the feeling of being in the quiet of nature.. hearing and seeing the ducks, geese and herons daily here on Indianhead Lake. Thank you all for your attention, Kay and Ron Bach 6625 Dakota Trail -- 55439 952-941-9589 [email protected]

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 9:43 AM Subject: FW: Proposed Amusement Park at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: [email protected] [mailto:JerDodBock(aaol.corn] Sent: Saturday, August 13, 2016 7:49 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Proposed Amusement Park at Braemar

I am totally opposed to the planned destruction of Braemar to install skiing and tubing concessions and the snow-making and grooming equipment to support them. How did this plan get started? Who authorized the spending and hiring of the consultant? Who made this "boondoggle a priority? I went to the public meeting a few weeks ago and we heard no one from the audience support the plan. But we heard all of the unanswered questions.

I urge the mayor and council to kill this bad idea and only work on the agreed upon city priorities.

Jerome Bock 6727 Apache Road Edina, 55439

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 9:45 AM Subject: FW: Opposing Braemar tubing and Xcountry trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Paul Grangaard [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 13, 2016 3:42 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Opposing Braemar tubing and Xcountry trails

Dear Mayor and City Council --

I'm opposed to the further redevelopment of Braemar as planned. It'll significantly disturb the peaceful winter nights in West Edina and create excessive traffic on slippery roads through neighborhoods like mine. It also doesn't seem to be financially wise, especially after the referendum to upgrade school facilities. With the lighted and snowmaking-capable Hennepin County ski trails just on the other side of 494, why double up on this activity? I enjoy skiing around Braemar golf course in the winter already. The woods along the side of groomed trails make it quite nice. Why do we need more than that experience?

Please don't turn Braemar into Hyland Hills 2 with bright lights, extra noise, squirting water machines, ice blown onto roads, and increased traffic. We're a bedroom community wth plenty of amenities already. Quietude and dark winter nights with stars out are among my favorites.

Thanks for reading.

Paul Grangaard (former School Board Member and mostly lifelong Edina resident) 6927 Mark Terrace Circle Edina

Typed on my iPhone.

Paul Grangaard President & CEO [email protected] t +1262 235-6667

Allen Edmonds Corporation 201 East Seven Hills Road Port Washington, WI 53074 USA Allen Edmonds.com

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 9:48 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Golf Course

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: John Debby [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 13, 2016 6:12 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Golf Course

Please cancel the plan to eliminate 9 holes on the golf course. It makes no sense, will cost millions plus the loss revenues while the balance of the course undergoes unneeded improvements.

Sent from my Sprint Samsung Galaxy S7. Janet Canton From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 11:09 AM Subject: FW: Braemar winter proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Bob MacPhail [mailto:bobmacphail100(@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 10:45 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar winter proposal

Hi, and thanks for your work for our city.

Please do NOT approve the plan to spend $3 million of our tax money on the Braemar winter proposal. There is no reason to spend this huge amount of our hard earned tax money to do this, especially when something very similar already exists a few miles away at Hyland Park.

Looking into trails or other uses for this area is fine, but please consider only proposals that are minimal / low cost. Perhaps it makes sense to cut some trails through the woods for minimal cost and let people ski or bike for free. But please dispense with high cost ideas of installing and running the man made snow equipment and lighting, hiring people to charge admission, etc.

This is a horrible use of tax money. The supposed 'break even' scenarios presented conveniently ignore the $3 million capital cost!

It seems like simple ski and / or bike trails might be a good idea for this area. If so, fine, but please do not spend significant tax money on this.

Thanks!

Bob MacPhail Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 4:17 PM Subject: FW: Nordic Ski Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Ann Platt [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 3:52 PM To: Kevin Staunton; James Hovland; Robert Stewart; Mary Brindle Cc: Buc SC Subject: Nordic Ski Proposal

Jim, Kevin & Bob:

The following are comments by one of the neighbors that truly outlines the issues that I concur are problematic with this proposal. I'm not sure if $3MM is the best use of funds with no ROI and end up costing Braemar for operating expenses: 1) The way the public was "info -tiled" of the proposal. Special interest groups were notified more than 2 months before the general residents (they found out in very early May). We waited until early July to hear about what was already being scoped for OUR resource. The parks dept cited that a Sun article and STrib article were published as well. That is not a way of notifying the public and being inclusive in the process. 2) The timeline of this proposal is ABSURD. We spend years filibustering over the most necessary things in Edina (sidewalks as an example), and yet we're pushing for this to happen in 4 months. 4 MONTHS when people are out of town enjoying their summer. If this is something we need -- or even want -- we can take the time to slow down and get everyone's opinion. 3) We don't have $3MM. The city council has stated that we maintain a AAA credit rating, which only relates to borrowing. Have we thought about whether we should borrow? Why increase taxes over something that is largely unwanted/unneeded? We kick the can down the road every year by deferring CIP like roads (+$10MM worth), bridges, sidewalks and other infrastructure...all of these investments are what make a community livable. A "Premier Nordic Facility" is not a need...it's a want. 4) We cite Buckthorn and other irrelevant issues as a reason why we need to. Buckthorn is a problem. This does NOT solve it. Creating a strategy around eradication and preservation moves us toward solving it. 5) This proposal benefits very few, and the cost per capita is ENORMOUS. We have a special interest group of —200 children who have a passion for Nordic skiing. That's great. But this is a $3MM proposal tailor fitted for them. Let's even say there are 500 people who would really use this facility for which it's intended (I think that's generous). That's costing us as a tax base $6K per individual. That's the cost of a good used car. 6) We have previous obligations to maintain the wetlands of Braemar, which have been left unfulfilled. As a part of our 1992 agreement with the US Army Corps of Engineers we were obligated to eradicate invasive species in the park. This was a trade off for getting permission to build the "Clunie Nine", which included modifying wetlands. We've also talked about maintaining our natural resources, and not obliterating them for capricious over-development sake. 7) Why do we NEED to do anything? Show me a resident survey that corroborates the need to develop a ski and tubing facility? One does not exist. In 2014 Edina residents were asked for what they feel is important. XC ski and tubing did not appear on that list of things that matter to residents. In fact, we drafted a strategic plan that

1 calls for preserving our resources. Let's follow that plan. 8) This plan undermines the safety of an already hazardous stretch of roadway, and potentially damages the rights and property of local homeowners. The developer has openly admitted to it creating extra snow on local roadways and homes that the homeowner can just "brush off' at their expense. That will trickle down to the taxpayer base once there are accidents and issues that arise from the amusement park we're proposing to build. 35W has large digital signs warning drivers of snow on the road when snow is being made at Buck Hill. That ski area is further away from the freeway than the snow-making would be from Gleason Road. 9) There was an issue removing trees from the golf course during renovation...apparently the tree preservationists have not heard about this! 10) it has also been noted that they track would be rented out to organizations for competitive events which would bring more traffic to the area and limit the amount of time it is available for " locals" to use the trail that it is proposed to benefit. Not sure if that is a benefit to Edina residents.

Feel free to read the petition for other reasons at BraemarGreen.ORG There are so many reasons why this is a bad idea, and I'm hoping the council is not ignoring them. Ann Platt Office M-F 9:00-5:30 7625 Metro Boulevard Minneapolis, MN 55439 Office: 952/837-1877

Pet Care in Private Homes since 1982

Facebook

liTiwitter

Website

Ann has owned Pets Are Inn for 25+ years, A Member of the Rotary Club of Edina and on the Executive Board; Rotary Club of Edina President 2016-17 Member of the Southdale YMCA Board

Original Message Subject: Re: Comments & Agenda for Tonight's Meeting with Parks to Discuss Nordic Ski Proposal From: "Nextdoor Dewey Hill" Date: Mon, August 15, 2016 3:03 pm To: aplattpetsareinn.com

Joshua Ahlberg, Indian Hills

Another few things I see as problematic (sorry in advance for the novel): 1) The way the public was "informed" of the proposal. Special interest groups were notified more than 2 months before the general residents (they found out in very early May). We waited until early July to hear about what was already being scoped for OUR resource. The parks dept cited that a Sun article and STrib article were 2 published as well. That is not a way of notifying the public and being inclusive in the process. 2) The timeline of this proposal is ABSURD. We spend years filibustering over the most necessary things in Edina (sidewalks as an example), and yet we're pushing for this to happen in 4 months. 4 MONTHS when people are out of town enjoying their summer. If this is something we need -- or even want -- we can take the time to slow down and get everyone's opinion. 3) We don't have $3MM. The city council has stated that we maintain a MA credit rating, which only relates to borrowing. Have we thought about whether we should borrow? Why increase taxes over something that is largely unwanted/unneeded? We kick the can down the road every year by deferring CIP like roads (+$10MM worth), bridges, sidewalks and other infrastructure...all of these investments are what make a community livable. A "Premier Nordic Facility" is not a need...its a want. 4) We cite Buckthorn and other irrelevant issues as a reason why we need to. Buckthorn is a problem. This does NOT solve it. Creating a strategy around eradication and preservation moves us toward solving it. 5) This proposal benefits very few, and the cost per capita is ENORMOUS. We have a special interest group of —200 children who have a passion for Nordic skiing. That's great. But this is a $3MM proposal tailor fitted for them. Let's even say there are 500 people who would really use this facility for which it's intended (I think that's generous). That's costing us as a tax base $6K per individual. That's the cost of a good used car. 6) We have previous obligations to maintain the wetlands of Braemar, which have been left unfulfilled. As a part of our 1992 agreement with the US Army Corps of Engineers we were obligated to eradicate invasive species in the park. This was a trade off for getting permission to build the "Clunie Nine", which included modifying wetlands. We've also talked about maintaining our natural resources, and not obliterating them for capricious over-development sake. 7) Why do we NEED to do anything? Show me a resident survey that corroborates the need to develop a ski and tubing facility? One does not exist. In 2014 Edina residents were asked for what they feel is important. XC ski and tubing did not appear on that list of things that matter to residents. In fact, we drafted a strategic plan that calls for preserving our resources. Let's follow that plan. 8) This plan undermines the safety of an already hazardous stretch of roadway, and potentially damages the rights and property of local homeowners. The developer has openly admitted to it creating extra snow on local roadways and homes that the homeowner can just "brush off" at their expense. That will trickle down to the taxpayer base once there are accidents and issues that arise from the amusement park we're proposing to build. Feel free to read the petition for other reasons at BraemarGreen.ORG There are so many reasons why this is a bad idea, and I'm having a really hard time understanding why the council is ignoring them. I WILL NOT vote for anyone who supports this destructive proposal.

Original post by Joshua Ahlberg from Indian Hills (17 replies): Hi Neighbors, Attached you will find a link to tonight's agenda for the parks meeting where they will discuss the Nordic Ski proposal. As a reminder, this is not a meeting where public input Aug 8 in General to 17 neighborhoods

Thank Private message Not interested in following this discussion? You received this update because you thanked or replied to this post. Stop receiving immediate updates on this post

You can also reply to this email or use Nextdoor for iPhone or Android

3 This message is intended for aplatt©petsareinn.com. Unsubscribe or adjust your email settings

Nextdoor, 760 Market Street. Suite 300, San Francisco; CA 94102

4 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 16, 2016 9:18 AM Subject: FW: Please keep snowmaking on the table!

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 Ibiunno(&,EdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Anne 3 Hinrichs [mailto:a.hinrichsOnnsn.com] Sent: Monday, August 15, 2016 9:02 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Please keep snowmaking on the table!

Hello City Council members— Clearly the Braemar neighborhood has voiced their concerns about snowmaking at Braemar. I think a lot of them are reacting to misinformation. Until there has been clarification and additional time for the Nordic community to garnish additional support from Edina at large, I'd like to ask you to please keep the possibility of snowmaking at Braemar alive. I'd like to have this decision addressed in September rather than at the meeting this week.

A few key points to keep in mind: The Edina Nordic Team can NOT ski regularly at Hyland. I know a lot of people think we could just go to Hyland but we truly only get on average one team permit per week, and that is for about 60 skiers max. As a result, we make snow and practice at EHS.

Snowmaking does not need to happen every day! HARDLY! Some of the information being spread by the Braemar neighborhood says that snow will be made daily. If Mother Nature is not cooperating and giving us the real stuff, we make snow a few times each season.

Yes, we've been able to ski at EHS for the past several years. That's because we have volunteers making snow and because we have established a trail system ourselves. The EHS construction changes that are currently underway AND the Nine Mile Creek plans impact our trail system dramatically. We need Braemar to keep 197 students active after school. They benefit substantially from exercise, fresh air and community. We are a no-cut sport and give our athletes a chance to balance their academic, sedentary lifestyle by doing some Nordic skiing. Please help us continue to offer this to the youth in our community AND to all people from Edina!

Thanks— Anne Hinrichs

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, August 16, 2016 10:44 AM Subject: FW: Nordic Ski Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Jim Platt [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 16, 2016 10:20 AM To: Kevin Staunton; James Hovland; Robert Stewart; Mary Brindle Subject: Fwd: Nordic Ski Proposal

Mary, Jim, Kevin & Bob:

After attending the Park Board Meeting last week at Braemar .. I was totally unaware that the Cost of the Project was $3M with NO pay back and looking to Braemar for $50,000 to subsidize operating expenses and STILL there would be a year-end-operating-loss.. All to feed more business to the Tin Fish ... This is NOT what we are known for in Edina for Fiscal Responsibility. In addition, I had no idea there was an overwhelming demand for Cross Country Skiing ( which there is NOT) .. not to mention the safety hazards along Gleason Road and West 78th Street!

The following are comments by one of the neighbors that truly outlines the issues that I concur are problematic with this proposal. I'm not sure if $3MM is the best use of funds with no ROI and end up costing Braemar for operating expenses:

1) The way the public was "informed" of the proposal. Special interest groups were notified more than 2 months before the general residents (they found out in very early May). We waited until early July to hear about what was already being scoped for OUR resource. The parks dept cited that a Sun article and STrib article were published as well. That is not a way of notifying the public and being inclusive in the process. 2) The timeline of this proposal is ABSURD. We spend years filibustering over the most necessary things in Edina (sidewalks as an example), and yet we're pushing for this to happen in 4 months. 4 MONTHS when people are out of town enjoying their summer. If this is something we need -- or even want -- we can take the time to slow down and get everyone's opinion. 3) We don't have $3MM. The city council has stated that we maintain a AAA credit rating, which only relates to borrowing. Have we thought about whether we should borrow? Why increase taxes over something that is largely unwanted/unneeded? We kick the can down the road every year by deferring CIP like roads (+$10MM worth), bridges, sidewalks and other infrastructure...all of these investments are what make a community livable. A "Premier Nordic Facility" is not a need...it's a want. 4) We cite Buckthorn and other irrelevant issues as a reason why we need to. Buckthorn is a problem. This does NOT solve it. Creating a strategy around eradication and preservation moves us toward solving it. 1 5) This proposal benefits very few, and the cost per capita is ENORMOUS. We have a special interest group of —200 children who have a passion for Nordic skiing. That's great. But this is a $3MM proposal tailor fitted for them. Let's even say there are 500 people who would really use this facility for which it's intended (I think that's generous). That's costing us as a tax base $6K per individual. That's the cost of a good used car. 6) We have previous obligations to maintain the wetlands of Braemar, which have been left unfulfilled. As a part of our 1992 agreement with the US Army Corps of Engineers we were obligated to eradicate invasive species in the park. This was a trade off for getting permission to build the "Clunie Nine", which included modifying wetlands. We've also talked about maintaining our natural resources, and not obliterating them for capricious over-development sake. 7) Why do we NEED to do anything? Show me a resident survey that corroborates the need to develop a ski and tubing facility? One does not exist. In 2014 Edina residents were asked for what they feel is important. XC ski and tubing did not appear on that list of things that matter to residents. In fact, we drafted a strategic plan that calls for preserving our resources. Let's follow that plan. 8) This plan undemiines the safety of an already hazardous stretch of roadway, and potentially damages the rights and property of local homeowners. The developer has openly admitted to it creating extra snow on local roadways and homes that the homeowner can just "brush off' at their expense. That will trickle down to the taxpayer base once there are accidents and issues that arise from the amusement park we're proposing to build. 35W has large digital signs warning drivers of snow on the road when snow is being made at Buck Hill. That ski area is further away from the freeway than the snow-making would be from Gleason Road. 9) There was an issue removing trees from the golf course during renovation...apparently the tree preservationists have not heard about this! 10) it has also been noted that they track would be rented out to organizations for competitive events which would bring more traffic to the area and limit the amount of time it is available for " locals" to use the trail that it is proposed to benefit. Not sure if that is a benefit to Edina residents.

Feel free to read the petition for other reasons at BraemarGreen.ORG There are so many reasons why this is a bad idea, and I'm hoping the council is not ignoring them.

I will be at the September 7th City Council Meeting when this issue is address.

Thanks in advance for your consideration!

Jim

Jim "Buc" Platt Edina Resident since 1979 BMC 26 Year Member BMC Board Member Edina Rotary Member Edina Chamber of Commerce Member Support of the Edina Y Member St. Patricks Church Realtor/Broker "The Realty House" E-mail: iplatt(&,JimBucPlatt.com Owner: Pets Are Inn, Inc. E-mail: jplatt(&,PetsAreInn.com 7723 Tanglewood Court Edina, MN 55439 Office: 952-746-7557 Cell: 651-402-8085

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 17, 2016 3:57 PM Subject: FW: KEEP GREEN AND SAFE!

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Kathleen Carter [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 17, 2016 3:55 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: KEEP GREEN AND SAFE!

Dear Edina City Council,

I strongly oppose the decimation of natural forestry and wildlife at Braemar Golf Course to construct a Nordic ski trail. I do not support this endeavor as it injures precious green space, will create a public hazard due to snow-making machines, and is stated to be an expensive yet losing proposition financially. I ASK YOU TO VOTE NO ON THIS PROJECT. Thank you!

Regards,

Kathleen M. Carter 4500 Vandervork Avenue Edina, MN 55436

0: 952-926-3370 C: 612-237-9011 [email protected]

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 8:13 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Park Project

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 20, 2016 1:50 PM To: James Hovland; Kevin Staunton; Mary Brindle; [email protected] Cc: Robert Stewart Subject: Braemar Park Project

Dear Mayor Hovland and City Council Members,

As Braemar Hills residents, we would like to express our concern over the proposed re-development project at the Braemar Park. We believe the project is not the highest and best use of Edina's natural or financial resources, and is a duplication of services provided by a county park that is only five minutes away from Braemar Park.

The City of Edina's own website enthusiastically describes Braemar Park as "500 acres of rolling hills and scenic lakes surrounded by beautiful, untouched oak ridges". As one of very few undeveloped areas in Edina, we support keeping it as untouched as possible - especially given that public winter recreation facilities are already available at nearby Hyland Park Reserve and Highland Hills ski area.

Please pause and reflect on the ramifications that come along with the proposed project, including the snow making machines, commercial lighting, upkeep of a 50' wide track for skiers and the 11-lane snow tubing area, removal of many trees and the one-year community disruption of commercial construction. Negative impacts to Edina residents include ongoing increased noise, light pollution, and decreased natural habitats. We also have safety concerns including wind blowing manufactured snow across Gleason Road (which is already a driving challenge in the winter) and increased traffic/parking on surrounding roads. Finally, the ongoing costs to run this operation will be a continued and unnecessary tax burden on all Edina residents.

We urge you to vote no on the project, and hope the council will promote more environmentally friendly and less costly ways to improve our parks when improvements are called for by the community and deemed financially prudent.

Thank you for your service to the City of Edina.

Regards,

Trudi and Tom Meloche 6916 Gleason Road

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 8:19 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Nordic ski proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Judy fundingsland [mailto:judy fcomcast.net] Sent: Sunday, August 21, 2016 11:03 AM To: James Hovland Cc: Mary Brindle; Kevin Staunton; Robert Stewart; [email protected] Subject: Braemar Nordic ski proposal

"Dear Edina City Council,

I strongly oppose the decimation of natural forestry and wildlife at Braemar Golf Course to construct a Nordic ski trail. I do not support this endeavor as it injures precious green space, will create a public hazard due to snow- making machines, and is stated to be an expensive yet losing proposition financially. I ASK YOU TO VOTE NO ON THIS PROJECT. I ask that you consider more environmentally friendly (and less costly) ways to enhance Braemar for public use: mountain biking trails, hiking, etc. Please redirect this funding to other, higher-priority level projects that improve (not diminish) public safety, or which impose no such damaging impacts on the environment or residents.

Thank you!

Judy Fundingsland A concerned citizen in Edina Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 8:41 AM Subject: FW: Braemar winter sports area

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.gov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: John King [mailto:johnking2©comcast.net] Sent: Sunday, August 21, 2016 6:32 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar winter sports area

Hello,

I am opposed to the proposed changes at Braemar for the winter sporting events including the cross country area and tubing hill. These sports can currently be enjoyed at Braemar without spending a cent. There is already a hill for tubing and cross country skiing can be done on the golf course. The expense and destruction of the forest do not justify the end result. PLEASE do not proceed with this plan!!!

John King 7300 Schey Drive Edina, MN 55439

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 10:31 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Ski Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Bobby Martin [mailto:martibobby©gmail.com] Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 9:29 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Ski Proposal

About the ski proposal.

We don't oppose skiing. We don't oppose skiing at Braemar.

We do oppose spending $3M in borrowed money that will never pay for itself when skiing was not on the list of resident preferred issues through surveys.

We do oppose the light and noise pollution. We do oppose the deforestation of Braemar.

We do oppose the unsafe icing conditions it would create.

And why should we pay and disrupt hundreds of taxpayers homes for something we can already do for free at Braemar? There are XC ski trails at Braemar now, as well as sledding.

Let's find a better solution for our city.

Bobby

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 3:00 PM Subject: FW: Braemar Snow making

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Edward Crandall [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 2:52 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Snow making

Hello, I'm not an Edina resident, but I use Braemar to play golf, enjoy a meal in the fabulous new set up! We have cross country skied on the property and would very much support the addition of snow making. It seems like a very large piece of property to not take advantage of all seasons fully. We live in the Lake Harriet area where lots of Edina residents enjoy the lakes, concerts and outdoor events. We welcome them to our area. Thanks, Ed

Edward Crandall 4237 Linden Hills Blvd Minneapolis, MN 55410 612,860,5417 [email protected]

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 3:28 PM Subject: FW: The most important fact to consider regarding the Braemar Ski Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.00v I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: [email protected] [mailto:rnnartin(@superiorford.conn] Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 3:09 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: The most important fact to consider regarding the Braemar Ski Proposal

To whom it may concern,

First, let me say they I am not opposed to any rational idea to making our city better for our residents, particularly for our children. There have been many negative facts presented regarding the Braemar Ski Proposal. I won't focus on the obvious....the extraordinary expense, the noise and light pollution and the deforestation of Braemar. I will however focus on what I feel is the fact that should be in the forefront of your consideration....the overblow and ice accumulation in the surrounding areas from the snow making machines. This issue was confirmed by the developer at the Park and Rec Meeting which was the first time residents were made aware of this proposal, even though the Nordic Ski Team had started petitioning long before, which is an issue in itself. He stated unequivocally that the surrounding areas around Braemar would have ice when others would not, at least from November to January and probably beyond. I live on Tanglewood Court off of Gleason Road...the side of our house is the Braemar woods. We moved to Minnesota from New York in September of 1992. As a requirement for my job in New York, I had been through two extensive defensive driving courses...one with the NY State Police and one with the New York Police Department. These courses covered all facets of defensive driving in all conditions. In November of 1992, I was driving my girls to school at Creek Valley. Conditions were not bad in general and I was well under the speed limit, but I hit a patch of ice and the vehicle went into an uncontrolled spin into oncoming traffic. Fortunately, due solely to my previous training, I was able to maneuver the skid into a snow bank rather than into an oncoming vehicle and damage only the front end of my car instead of the worst case scenario. Imagine the typical driver who doesn't drive Gleason daily coming off of a completely dry W. 78th St. and hitting the first of several "S" curves? This is just inviting catastrophe! Even those that live miles away that won't be affected by the other issues mentioned will still have to get there, and how many 1st year inexperienced drivers from the ski team will be risking their lives as well as others? It's a fact...due to the nature of the curves on Gleason, if you lose control of your vehicle you will be sliding into oncoming traffic. In my opinion, this fact alone should be enough to stop and re-think this entire proposal and scale it down to a version that will not effect the safety and properties of Edina residents. I hope you will feel the same way, and I thank you for your service and your consideration.

Regards,

Rob Martin 7714 Tanglewood Court Edina MN 55439 612-812-6727 (cell)

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 8:47 AM Subject: FW: I urge you to vote "NO" on the proposed Braemar Nordic Ski and Tubing proposal on September 7

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: t&r [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 8:46 PM To: Edina Mail Cc: James Hovland; Mary Brindle; Kevin Staunton; Robert Stewart; [email protected] Subject: I urge you to vote "NO" on the proposed Braemar Nordic Ski and Tubing proposal on September 7

Mayor James Hovland; Council Members: Mary Brindle Kevin Staunton Bob Stewart Ann Swenson

Dear Mayor Hovland and Edina City Council Members:

I am writing you today because, for the first time since moving to Edina more than 20 years ago, there is a proposal before the City Council that I believe is so fundamentally flawed and so heavily promoted by outside "consultants" with intrinsic conflicts of interest that I feel I must speak out.

I urge you to vote a resounding "NO" for the Nordic ski and commercial tubing hill development as proposed for Braemar Park.

A standard interstate highway lane in the U.S. is 12 feet wide. This project, as proposed, will result in the clear cutting of more than five acres of Oak Savannah in order to place the equivalent of a four lane interstate freeway (25' x 2 OR 50' contiguous width in some sections) across the wooded ridge at Braemar. Please consider the scale of this proposed "ski path" (1) the next time you are traveling on a four lane section of Hwy 494 or the divided four lane layout of Hwy 62. This wooded area, one of the precious few remaining undeveloped areas in Edina, is home to numerous wildlife species including a large population of raptors, owls, fox, deer, bats, a variety of small animals and birds as well as frequent appearances by a mature Bald Eagle. The commercial scale of the proposed Nordic Ski operation would decimate the native habitat, pump millions of gallons of water from our aquifers, and make a mockery of the strong

1 environmental statement made by the Edina leadership just last year with passage of the widely lauded Edina Tree Ordinance (2).

The Braemar Nordic Ski proposal fares no better from a financial perspective than from its embarrassing environmental impact. Three River Park District, funded with taxes from every Edina property owner, operates a much larger Nordic ski facility at Hyland featuring 9.5 miles of trails, snow making and lighted paths and which is less than 3 miles driving

distance from the Braemar club house (3). According to Google Maps, this distance can be traversed in less than 8 minutes in normal traffic. Even the most optimistic operating budget for the proposed Braemar project only hopes to break even, with the debt service for the $3 million proposed capital expenditure left for the Edina taxpayers. I can only imagine that our schools, fire, police or other community resources could find better uses for this $450k annual tax burden (before likely operating losses) than to create a facility that is duplicative of existing Nordic ski facilities in such close proximity and already paid for by Edina taxpayers.

Finally, the proposed project would have a hugely negative impact on the neighboring community with nightly noise and light pollution as well the public safety risks created by prevailing NW winds frequently icing Gleason road and neighboring walkways with snowmaking overspray. Two months of overnight snowmaking utilizing two 60 HP pumps, 7 snowmaking cannons and ongoing trail grooming with heavy equipment on trails that are less than 250 feet from many bedroom windows would devastate the livability of neighboring homes and associated property values. Additionally, Gleason road can be treacherous in the winter today with crashes occurring every year as drivers spin off the road onto sidewalks and yards while attempting to navigate Gleason's sharp bends and turns in this neighborhood. Covering this road (as well as adjacent sidewalks and driveways) with ice and snow from a city operated facility would be irresponsible and dangerous, potentially exposing the city to liability and possible litigation.

Please send this proposal back to the drawing board and ask the Edina Park Board to consider other options that are less expensive and far less intrusive on the environment and the community. At a minimum, the proposed commercial tubing facility should be excluded from further consideration and exploration of reasonable alternatives for expanding the existing Nordic ski and snowshoe trails within the existing developed areas of the Braemar golf course should be considered.

Since projects of this nature can never be undone, I suggest that the citizens and leaders of Edina may also be at a crossroad, facing an obligation to establish better defined priorities of preservation vs. city sponsored commercial development of the remaining natural land and wildlife habitat owned or controlled by the City of Edina. This discussion requires important decisions that affect future generations of Edina residents and deserves broader input, debate and possible referendum.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

Thomas C. Wagner 6004 Bonnie Brae Drive Edina, MN 55439

1) Within the presentation materials prepared by the consulting firm SEH, the artist rendering of the finished project dramatically understates the magnitude of this destruction by not drawing the proposed path to scale — clearly visible when compared to the known dimensions of Gleason Rd. which is also depicted in the illustrations

2 2) At a minimum, should we not apply the same Tree Ordinance preservation standards to the evaluation of this proposed project as are applicable to all Edina Residents?

3) The feasibility study materials presented by SEH reflects the distance to the Hyland facilities as being 6 miles away— still a short distance and possibly true if measured from City Hall — but as the bird flies these sites are less than two miles apart and we should be fairly certain that you would be able to see the Hyland facility and its extensive lighting from the Braemar ridge site once the proposed project's deforestation was complete.

3

Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 8:52 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Ski Trail

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Anderson, Tracy [mailto:AndersonTLOPellaMN.com] Sent: Monday, August 22, 2016 6:08 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Ski Trail

Hello — Mayor Hovland was nice enough to come to my neighborhood a couple weeks ago to address concerns over the proposed ski trail and tubing hill. Clearly I am in the minority as I think the project is a great idea. My husband and I use the existing trails frequently to walk our dog and have always enjoyed the woods and our close proximity to it. We certainly don't believe a lighted ski trail will detract from our pleasure, it will enhance it. I was recently surprised to learn that most of the people that are so against this project have never even been in the woods. Honestly, if they didn't see anyone cutting down a tree they would have no idea any trees had been removed. I feel their reasons are disingenuous as they don't care about keeping Edina green and I'm not sure what the safety issue is but it does sound good, who isn't for safer things. I can understand not wanting your "space" to be changed but this really seems like a great improvement to the area.

Thanks for listening to a positive view point, Tracy

Tracy Anderson Commercial Sales Consultant 612-840-8154 AndersonTLPellaMN.corn http://professional.pella.com/

COMMERCIAL SOLUTIONS 11011.111 1111

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 8:58 AM Subject: FW: Braemar ski proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: Karen Seay [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 7:35 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar ski proposal

I am just learning about the scope and the effects of the major changes at Braemar, and I am astonished that construction of this project will proceed in October if the city does not scrap the plan. I would like to voice my strong opposition to allowing these changes to go forward, with the resulting environmental effects, noise and light pollution, and deleterious consequences to nearby neighbors, not to mention the cost. Please reconsider this project, and institute a well-thought-out bid and budgeting process to make a sound determination of what should go forward.

Thank you for having the courage to take another look at this plan before damage is done and money is wasted on it.

Karen Seay 6808 Dovre Drive Edina, MN 55436 (952) 927-4820

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:21 PM Subject: FW: Advocate for Edina Mtn. Bike Trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Steven Manderscheid [mailto:manderscheid(acsp.edu] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:17 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Advocate for Edina Mtn. Bike Trails

I am advocate for mtn. bike trails at Braemar. I am 47 years old and I have mtn. biked for 30 years. I have watched the sport grow and I now have a son on Edina's mtn. bike team. Local mtn. bike trails are low impact on the environment and low cost to maintain. Moreover, they can serve not only the team but many citizens who find mtn. biking a great source of exercise. I suggest that you conduct some research on communities like Crosby, MN (Cuyuna Lakes), Eagan, MN (Lebanon Hills), etc. etc. My sense is that these cities have benefited tremendously from sponsoring local mtn. bike trails.

Regards,

Steve Manderscheid Edina Resident Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:49 PM Subject: FW: Braemar Development

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Leigh Mazion [mailto:mazionleighOgmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:25 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Development

My name is Leigh Mazion and I'm the director for the Edina High School and Middle School Cycling teams. Our team has grown from 12 student athletes in 2013, to over 60 this year. We participate in mountain bike racing as a Fall Sport. Mountain bike racing is a fast growing High School sport with over 55 teams and 1,000 athletes in Minnesota. Our sport improves fitness, develops self reliance, and promotes a team spirit. Our goal is to provide our athletes with personal growth opportunities and introduce them to a life long sport. Our most significant challenge is providing a safe training environment for a fast growing team. We currently meet for practice at Weber Park and commute by bike to the Wirth trail system. This involves moving up to 60 athletes 5 miles through town. Our hope is that the City will add mountain bike trails to the Braemar project. This would provide a safe local meeting spot for the team to train. Mountain bike trails are inexpensive to create and can be maintained by volunteers. Our team regularly volunteers to maintain the Wirth trails.

I hope you will consider supporting the Edina Cycling Team by supporting mountain bike trails at Braemar.

Thank You!

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 3:41 PM Subject: FW: In support of mountain bike trails at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 Ibiunno(@.EdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Kristi Trostel [mailto:ktrostelOgmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:28 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: In support of mountain bike trails at Braemar

Hello! As the head coach of the Edina Cycling team I would like to voice my support for the construction of mountain bike trails at Braemar.

High school mountain biking started in Minnesota 5 years ago, under the direction of the National Interscholastic Cycling Association (www.nationalmtb.org, www.minnesotamtb.org). The Edina team currently has 60 athletes, the second largest team in the state. Although the sport is not part of the Minnesota High School league, we are an Independent Sports Provider with the Edina HS.

Team practices pose unique challenges, namely safely getting dozens of teenagers riding bikes from a point in Edina to a place where we can practice. Most often, this is Theodore Wirth Park, less often the hilly residential streets around Edina HS.

Practice trails (gravel, double track, single track) at Braemar would let us get to our off road practices much more quickly and safely. Such trails would also give us a location without cars to do hill repeats.

The sport of high school mountain biking uniquely blends serious cardiovascular endurance with technical cycling skills. Our team is coed and has provided a team sports experience to many Edina students who previously had never participated in team sports. I could give many examples of how the sport has changed a team member's life for the better.

Mountain bikes are not motorized. Mountain biking is quiet, leaves next to no impact on established trails, and does not require any lighting. Mountain bike trails generally incorporate natural features such as trees and rocks, so trees don't need to be removed to build the trails. Once single track trails are established, they require minimal maintenance. This maintenance is generally done by hand or with simple hand tools and would be performed by the team.

Please consider including mountain bike trails at Braemar so that we can continue to offer this athletic opportunity to Edina's youth.

Thank you Kristi Trostel head coach Edina Cycling Team

1 Kristi Trostel

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 3:41 PM Subject: FW: Mountain Biking Trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: melissaP412511c.com [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:32 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Mountain Biking Trails

To whom it may concern,

I am emailing to ask you to consider having mountain biking trails added to Braemar. My son, who is a tenth grader at Edina High School, has just started participating on the Edina Mountain Biking Team. This is the first sport I have seen him really enjoy and it would be good for him to have trails that are close to our house. I believe it would be safer for him than having to bike long distances. Plus this is a sport he can participate in all his life. For him it is more than a sport, it is also a way to help him manage his ADHD. After he comes back from biking he is able to concentrate much better and has been able to manage his energy level much better.

Thanks for your consideration,

Melissa Mathwig (Edina Resident)

Sent from my iPhone

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 3:45 PM Subject: FW: Vote NO on Braemar Nordic Ski Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 Ibiunno(&.EdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Kelly McNulty [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 2:49 PM To: Mary Brindle; James Hovland; Kevin Staunton; Robert Stewart; [email protected]; Ann Kattreh Subject: Vote NO on Braemar Nordic Ski Proposal

Dear City Council Members:

As we draw near to the vote regarding the Proposal to turn Braemar's hills into a commercialized Nordic Ski location, I wanted to take a minute to focus everyone's attention on the beauty that is Braemar, including the description as listed on the City of Edina's very own website:

"Braemar Park is 500 acres of rolling hills and scenic lakes surrounded by beautiful, untouched oak ridges. There's a feeling of seclusion amidst its urban setting, only 20 minutes from downtown Minneapolis."

Further down the page it also notes:

"In the winter, many people enjoy cross-country skiing and snow-shoeing on the trails through the golf course. You can view a map here"

I love the second paragraph, as this sums up how we should be managing this discussion. Cross- country skiing (and snow-shoeing) in the untouched natural beauty. I just want to reiterate that we are not against cross-country skiing at Braemar. We are against doing it the wrong way, which is what this proposal will do. I implore you - each and every one of you as the decision makers deciding the fate of this beautiful location - to help make the best decision, the one that works best for Braemar, the neighbors, and the city.

Please Vote No on the Nordic Ski project and work with community members to develop a responsible, green plan to enhance Braemar for winter activities.

Thank you. Sincerely, Kelly McNulty 6001 Bonnie Brae Dr.

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 8:10 AM Subject: FW: Mountain biking trails at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Anna Lampron [mailto:annalampron(agmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 4:31 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Mountain biking trails at Braemar

Dear Edina City Council, I'm contacting you all to show my support for the proposed mountain biking trails near Braemar in Edina. I'm a student at Edina Highschool and a member of the EHS Cycling Team. It would really benefit our team to have a "home trail" that would be safe and easy to access for practices. I would also love to use it in my free time with my younger brother and sister who aren't on the team. As an environmentalist, I also strongly support the trails as they are low impact and need very little matinence to maintain. That matinence will be done by volunteers from our cycling community so it will be self sustaining. Thank you so much for considering these trails and I hope you will support them.

Thanks again, Anna Lampron

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 8:13 AM Subject: FW: comments to date in support of Braemar snowmaking project http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/braemar-skiing

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Jarvinen [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 5:13 PM To: Edina Mail Cc: 'julie turnbull'; [email protected]; Paul V. Gage'; 'Noah' Subject: comments to date in support of Braemar snowmaking project http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/braemar- skiing

Dear Edina City Council,

A petition in support of Braemar snowmaking was started a few days ago. So far over 355 people have signed in support. Signatures are also being collected on paper (no count of those currently available). Below are the written comments in support of the Braemar snowmaking project received at the following address as of this morning: http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/braemar-skiing

Craig Jarvinen

Name Date Comments I enthusiastically support the effort to make this wonderful recre; 1 Noah Swiler 8/18/2016 16:56 activity more accessible to Edina families! Nordic skiing is my familyâ€TMs favorite winter activity. A trail sys Braemar Park will put to good use the underutilized resources avi without impacting the golf operation. Snowmaking will guarante( 4 Paul Gage 8/18/2016 19:52 successful endeavor.

6 Max Thiele 8/18/2016 23:18 This petition makes some great points as a counter to the petitiot 7 Jeff Kirkwold 8/19/2016 0:48 Our son is a Nordic skier at EHS 9 Jeff Jackson 8/19/2016 1:35 I'll come visit your park if you build it! This project will help people from all over the state of Minnesota a life-long activity which will increase their physical, mental and e 11 Kevin Johnson 8/19/2016 1:42 well-being. Snowmaking is such an asset for any trail system. I will be so jeolc the amenaties that Edina has, but look forward to making the trig 16 Nathan Porath DDS 8/19/2016 2:09 visit them.

1 We need to build our winter recreation opportunities in all of our communities. This is for the health and well being of our childrer plenty of research to support how important being outside is for 17 Amy Cichanowski 8/19/2016 2:10 (and adults). We live in MN and need to embrace winter! 19 Tyler olson 8/19/2016 2:16 Would be great to have another place to ski! 20 Greg Klave 8/19/2016 2:20 I would buy a pass to ski there! 22 Martin Burg 8/19/2016 2:31 Edina needs ski trails!!! This would be a great addition for the Edina park system. You will 23 Jim Agre 8/19/2016 2:33 of folks, who will purchase trail passes.

I am a coach with the Edina High Cross Country Ski Team. This we huge asset to the team- especially since the school expansion anc appropriation of a considerable amount of the present trail for a trail will make it nearly impossible for the team to have meaningf 24 Thomas SHaw 8/19/2016 2:53 affordable practice. I love braemer, and know it would make a world class nordic ski c a resident of Minnetonka, there a few option for skiers in this par metro. Having a top knotch facility like braemar available would c 25 Bill van cleaf 8/19/2016 2:59 have me voting with my wallet. 27 Alice Flanders 8/19/2016 3:13 Yes please. 31 Matt liebsch 8/19/2016 4:30 We need more outside rec items like this 43 Vilanouth Inthasorot 8/19/2016 12:31 I would love to see this park being done.

As a resident a few miles north of this, I would love to see this ad Edina. It would be a closer place to ski than driving to Hyland or E Nordic skiing is a lifelong sport as well, so it has major lifelong bet those that get into it. Amenities like this help make a community as well raising the standard of living even further for Edina. With 45 Clayton Keim 8/19/2016 13:06 being a problem among our society, we need more places like thi This is great and so good for healthy youth (and adults). It is fun 55 Kathryn Jarvinen 8/19/2016 14:03 prevents obesity. This is something the city of Edina and the greater metro area cot greatly use. It promotes a lifelong sport that is so heathy and sup 58 Dan Rasmussen 8/19/2016 14:22 our great winters in MN! 61 Kevin Brochman 8/19/2016 14:31 This will keep people happy active and healthy. I am a Nordic High School Coach and this would really help all Hig 63 Larry Myers 8/19/2016 14:38 skiing! 65 Terese Holden 8/19/2016 14:46 Great addition to enhance community health and family fun 68 Amelia Svenningsen 8/19/2016 15:04 XC ski trails at braemar would be a great addition to our commun 70 Oscar Friedman 8/19/2016 15:08 Go Team CXC Consistently maintained trails at Braemar would help further bro. 74 Kyle lidstone 8/19/2016 15:16 strengthen the Nordic community in the metro area. I am a Three Rivers Park Commissioner and an out-door enthusia 81 Gene Kay 8/19/2016 15:34 strongly support this effort. As a competitive XC skier, I love being in nature and think other p 84 Genevieve Connell 8/19/2016 15:42 should share this love and appreciation as well. 85 Jack Christianson 8/19/2016 15:42 Help grow Midwest skiing development!

2 Please make this happen. As a taxpaying citizen living in Edina, th 87 Darren Ruschy 8/19/2016 15:50 BIG win for our community. I have coaching XC for 20 years snowmaking is vital for developin, 88 Eric Jacobson 8/19/2016 16:15 competitive youth XC skiers I'm 100% for snowmaking Nordic is an amazing sport, and the addition of ski trails at Braem 97 Peter Zahn 8/19/2016 16:52 be very beneficial to the team and the community as a whole. A former resident of Golden Valley, I continue to support the Twi 102 Bob Schoenecker 8/19/2016 17:03 efforts to provide superior outdoor activities.

I have sent emails and attended a community meeting on this tor know some of the nearby neighbors are concerned, but I think it well planned and would be an asset to many. Although I recently to Bloomington, my daughter has attended Edina schools all her I 104 Carri Mosborg 8/19/2016 17:04 senior at EHS this fall and went to State with her Nordic team Iasi Snowmaking at Braemar is very important to the Edina Nordic tei 106 Samantha Bevers 8/19/2016 17:07 our ability to practice. 109 Taylor Fletcher 8/19/2016 17:17 Do it

113 Charlie Zdechlik 8/19/2016 17:23 I love skiing and it would be sweet if there were more trails 114 Gretchen johns 8/19/2016 17:24 Parents of two Nordic skiers at EHS /Mpls residents 117 kari anderson 8/19/2016 17:29 more snow! I think Nordic ski trails are a good addition to the Braemar golf co Other golf courses have incorporated ski trails. Given how crowd( 118 Steven Kloiber 8/19/2016 17:33 trials are at Hyland Park, there is the demand for it. The snowmaking/trail proposal will benefit the entire community health lifestyles, encourage family outings, and allow youth to lez 120 William Hittler 8/19/2016 17:46 enjoy winter and cross-country skiing 122 Jim Gregg 8/19/2016 17:54 Would visit the area of there was snow.

We strongly support the making of snow for the nordic ski trails a Braemar golf course, and the grooming of the ski trails. It will enh quality of life for the people of our city. However, we only suppor cross country ski trails aspect of the winter additions proposed fo 124 Anne Lindquist 8/19/2016 18:03 Braemar Park. I am a parent of a current Edina High School Nordic ski team men of a former team member who has graduated. I was a long-term of Edina until last month. I strongly support the trails and, as a ski 125 Sara Jones 8/19/2016 18:07 myself, would happily pay a fee for trail use as a non-resident. 129 Zach Nelson 8/19/2016 18:26 We need more snow making trails for cross country skiing 130 Renate Stone 8/19/2016 18:27 In support of X Ctry ski at Braemar 133 Mark Scott 8/19/2016 18:40 Yes,yes, yes! Snow making during lean snow seasons keeps skiers active. This i 136 Jim Cloutier 8/19/2016 19:05 for the Twin Cities area. Please make it a priority. More snow making trails will take some of the pressure off the fe we have and help grow the sport. Based on usage of other snow i 139 Angela Robinson 8/19/2016 19:23 trails it will be well used. 100% support this proposal. Amenities like this are what make Ed 142 Shelly Howe 8/19/2016 20:05 quality of life what it is. 3 The addition of cross country skiing to the Braemar golf course is way to increase its usage while leveraging the existing infrastruct would be another example of how Edina promotes healthy lifesty residents, and it would benefit the more than 200 students (rang completely new skiers to competitive racers) who join the high sc team to have a place to call their training space. This is a no-cut s 144 Sheryl Gage 8/19/2016 20:15 provides a great experience for kids of all skill levels. 147 Andrea Brandt 8/19/2016 20:26 I fully support the trails and all the great reasons listed in the peti What a bonus this would be to the community, as well as a draw business from the surrounding area as well as schools. Silent spo as skiing and biking should embrace this collectively, as they both 148 Doug Boonstra 8/19/2016 20:33 benefit as will the greater community of Edina. 149 Tracy Shand 8/19/2016 20:42 We support this cross country ski trails and snow making at Braer 153 Matthew Waite 8/19/2016 20:52 Yes, I would definitely drive to this facility from St Paul. 155 Dan Sweeney 8/19/2016 20:59 Build trails with snowmaking 156 Theresa Yanchar 8/19/2016 20:59 Definitely

158 Susan Schultz 8/19/2016 21:05 I am an Edina resident and fully support xc ski trails at Braemar Pi 166 Carol Russell 8/19/2016 21:37 I vote yes primarily for the high school winter sports teams. 167 The Rubin Family 8/19/2016 21:55 Family of six active in nordic skiing

168 Curt Werdal 8/19/2016 22:14 I would love to be able to ski here in the winter! 171 Janelle Erickson 8/19/2016 22:45 I support this cross country proposal for the Braemar location! Please support this important and beneficial investment, and dor 174 John Ellenberger 8/19/2016 23:13 deceived by specious arguments against it. Thank you. 176 Kate chamberlain 8/19/2016 23:24 Make this happen! :) It's important to Edina Nordic, and all of Edina that this project is 183 Matthew Egger 8/20/2016 0:38 be finished!

I ski on the Edina Nordic team. The team means an incredible am me, and it would be a great privilege to be able to use braemar tc Nordic team is full of respectful student athletes who would quie carefully use the braemar parks to train and enjoy the winter. I st 184 Peter Rock 8/20/2016 0:56 support the use of braemar park for Nordic skiing. We spend so much money on hockey. How about the 200 memb 186 Anita Burg 8/20/2016 1:04 Edina High School nordic ski team!!! Let's support this great opportunity for our student athletes and i community. We live in a winter weather state- let's support wint( 195 Kathleen Mulrooney 8/20/2016 4:05 weather activities. 198 Craig Ringsven 8/20/2016 5:23 Would love to see this happen! 199 Kim Rudd 8/20/2016 5:37 Vote yes for ski trails ! Cross Country skiing is a life long sport that can be enjoyed by vir 207 Barry Rotman 8/20/2016 12:40 anyone. 213 Diane Schember 8/20/2016 13:36 As a St Paul small business and a skier I support this! 223 steve m icha Is 8/20/2016 15:25 Please approve this wonderful ski trail

4 This will be a great addition to the metro area outdoor winter ski trails. Please make this happen my family and I will definitely ma 225 Steve Eberly 8/20/2016 15:50 this facility and pay any fees required. I am a Minnesota Youth Ski League club leader for over 20 years. snow is the single largest factor in determining the number of chi 226 Tim Miner 8/20/2016 15:54 can introduce to skiing. I started cross country skiing in gym class as a high school student West in 1976. As a senior I was part of the ski team and have bee ever since. Hoping Edina will vote to continue to inspire Twin City 228 Mary Luoma 8/20/2016 15:59 residents to enjoy this wonderful sport. Edina has always been a leader in the community, being able to I( 231 Bob Britz 8/20/2016 16:37 the future is important and this project will be a great addition! This snowmaking loop would be awesome for nordic ski commun snowmaking loops @ elm creek, hyland park and Wirth have bee 232 Chris Torvi 8/20/2016 16:41 reason Nordic skiing is growing! 238 Jed Gorlin 8/20/2016 17:33 Hyland is overcrowded so this would be a great addition 241 Rodney Binfet 8/20/2016 18:03 I would use this trail extensively! The southwest could use another option for man-made cross cou 242 Rhett Carlson 8/20/2016 18:16 trails. 243 Tommy Carlson 8/20/2016 18:24 It would alleviate traffic at other parks. 247 Pam Stegora Axberg 8/20/2016 19:16 Super! And good for the broader community. 250 Dan Beno 8/20/2016 20:09 Would love to see this trail! More outdoor activity for kids and al Great use of existing underutilized real estate resource. Nordic sl 252 Liz Abt Ellenberger 8/20/2016 20:23 life long sport to enjoy what winter throws at us. I fully support this as a wonderful addition to the outdoor activitii 253 Greg Fields 8/20/2016 20:45 Minnesotans enjoy in the winter.

The ski trails and tubing hill are much-needed and will complete t winter activity options available in Edina which will appeal to a br base of residents. I am excited at the possibility of having a non h /ice skating winter activity available locally without having to tra\o 254 Andrea Brink 8/20/2016 20:55 Minneapolis or surrounding suburbs. I support adding XC Skiing to extend use of this wonderful venue 255 Greg Bernhardt 8/20/2016 21:01 winter. this would be a great asset both for the community and for the hi 256 Mark Larson 8/20/2016 22:07 school program. Let's do it! 260 Martin Richmond 8/20/2016 22:50 This would be so great for so many people. Don't miss this oppor As a ski coach and an advocate for outdoor activities for the corm this would be a great asset to the city of Edina and its youth (and 261 Jack Collis 8/20/2016 23:07 people too) 264 Elizabeth Burnett 8/21/2016 0:27 Please vote YES! The City of Edina needs to make the Breamar park land available 271 John Horns 8/21/2016 2:27 variety of uses. 281 Roy Vosberg 8/21/2016 13:46 We need more ski trails.

5 As a former member of the U.S. Nordic Ski Team and resident of I believe we have a unique opportunity to support this great life-lo outdoor activity in our community. Would we question this proje were in support of our hockey programs? I love hockey but love running and Nordic skiing too. Let's find a way to set aside our dii 282 Tom Wagner 8/21/2016 14:07 and make this work in our community. Congratulations for Edina to take the lead on a new nordic ski arc the East Metro had something like this! I already drive to Hyland 283 Christopher Gerlach 8/21/2016 14:24 much, and would definitly make use of this as well.

291 Artie Huber 8/21/2016 18:48 I would use the trail system and support local businesses while in A tremendous asset that will increase property values and attract 292 Dave Hruby 8/21/2016 20:03 active families to Edina.

Nordic skiing is a lifelong activity that can be embraced and enjoy Edina residents of all ages and abilities. The ski trails at Braemar provide convenient access to a resource that will help to promotE build healthy and active lifestyles among our residents. I strongl• the proposal for nordic ski trails at Braemar with snow making 293 Paul Arbisi 8/21/2016 20:58 capabilities. Living in Edina right now, I think this would be huge for both the community and for the Twin Cities area as a whole! I would use tl 295 Thomas Kendrick 8/21/2016 23:45 least a few times a week. Our family would use Nordic Ski Trails at least once a week . This 299 Lise Crosby 8/22/2016 13:16 a great benefit for the entire community.

We would love to see Edina continue to be a leader in providing r active healthy families to enjoy outdoor recreation together by p1 this year-round trail with winter snowmaking. We've gladly suppc facilities for every kind of recreation; this is a great chance to sup popular, growing, life-long winter sport, with trails residents can 303 Neal Blanchett 8/22/2016 14:00 round. Would be a valuable resource to the City of Edina and area high s have a ski venue. Would be supporting and active, outdoor lifesty 306 Chris Harvey 8/22/2016 14:22 youth.

As an assistant cross country ski coach, I am very excited that the be another place to practice for the large community of high schc This is so important as now we only have 2 reliable snowmaking t 308 Mark Kobilka 8/22/2016 14:43 they cannot handle the number of students that want to ski. 309 Ellen Jones 8/22/2016 15:00 This would be a huge benefit to the community! 311 Kate Turnbull 8/22/2016 16:10 Please pass this proposal for winter fun in Edina!

313 Stephanie Jones 8/22/2016 16:32 I would love to ski here!

314 Duncan Tomassen 8/22/2016 16:36 Great idea! 315 Alex Marble 8/22/2016 16:53 Don't be a dick about guys. C'mon I fully support this. I live in St. Paul and I'd drive there to ski. Big fi 316 Scott 8/22/2016 16:57 would be an asset to Edina and cause people to drive to your city

6 Kathleen and Doug We support creating cross-country ski trails at Braemar. Not only 318 Hokemeir-Seim 8/22/2016 17:27 they be great for the EHS ski team, but adults could use them as Snow is in short supply these days. Cross Country skiing is a great 320 Marie Jordan 8/22/2016 17:33 sport that everyone can enjoy. The time is right to acknowledge the growth of Nordic, trail runni Mtn biking and enhance the proud offerings of Edina parks. I will 321 Bill Kerker 8/22/2016 17:51 "pay to play"! 324 Dan DeRoma 8/22/2016 18:33 the earth is not getting any colder! I owned a house near Hyland Ski Area- the most expensive and fa 326 Alice Hulbert 8/22/2016 19:57 selling houses face the ski area. The addition of these ski trails and snowmaking will bring active I- benefits to the community and enable the Edina Ski team to con- 328 Katherine Ellis 8/22/2016 21:33 have a long lasting positive affect on young peoples lives.

Adding trails to Braemar will make the park far more accessible t( residents. There are some trails in that woods now, but they are occasionally overgrown and mostly used by neighbors to walk the grew up within a block of the proposed loop and wish it had beer when I was in high school! It will be a great addition for the high 329 Jennifer Rolfes 8/22/2016 21:39 team, xc skiers in the metro, and recreational skiers from Edina.

Global warming has made Minnesota winters far less predictable they have been in the past. Without man-made snow, many of enjoy non-ice dependent outdoor recreation during significant sty of the winter months. I would go so far as to say that Edina truly I 330 Kassandra Kuehl 8/22/2016 21:41 this project to move forward. I am a parent of an Edina Nordic skier that would benefit so muck this project. The proposal would certainly contribute to a world-c 331 Brett Bevers 8/22/2016 21:53 community like Edina. This addition would present Edina as a leader in promoting outdc education, physical fitness, and community empowerment throu 340 Jake Brown 8/23/2016 2:15 adventure, and nature preservation. I am a resident of Edina and would be pleased to have another o 343 Beth lhry 8/23/2016 12:11 skiing on man made snow.

7 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 8:15 AM Subject: FW: Mountain Bike Trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Jeff Merriam [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 6:44 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Mountain Bike Trails

Dear Madames and Sirs,

We area writing in support of the creation of mountain bike trails at Braemar Park. Both of our children are on the Edina Cycling Team and currently they need to bike city streets through Minneapolis to get to Theodore Wirth park to train for the racing season. Most cities in the metro area have a mountain bike trail system. My understanding of where the trails would be built is currently not used for anything. It contains overgrown weeds and buckthorn. The kids currently maintain the trails in Minneapolis and Crosby, MN. Wouldn't it be great if they could maintain bike trails in their own city? We urge you to support Mountain Bike Trails in Edina!

Best regards,

Jeff and Randalyn (Jack and Brennen) Merriam 5816 Zenith Ave S., Edina.

Sent from my iPhone

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 8:18 AM Subject: FW: Please support mountain biking trails at Braemar for safe mountain biking for out school team

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.ciov

From: Ann-Marie Forshay [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2016 9:32 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Please support mountain biking trails at Braemar for safe mountain biking for out school team

Mountain biking is here to stay and has come into its own. Please support our Mountain Biking team at Edina High School by allowing for safe trails for our children.

Thank you,

Ann Marie Forshay 5108 Oxford Ave Edina MN 55436 612 710 7964

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 8:22 AM Subject: FW: [Braemar Park Winter Recreational Area Open House]

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Joshua M. Ahlberg [mailto:notification+yy2694o9(afacebooknnail.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 7:47 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Re: [Braemar Park Winter Recreational Area Open House]

Joshua M. Ahlberg commented on City of Edina, MN (Local Government)'s post in Braemar Park Winter Recreational Area Open House.

Joshua M. Ahlberg 7:47am Aug24 I can't support this plan. It's incredibly costly ($3MM that the city would need to borrow and pay back in taxpayer bonds), it introduces safety risks to the community from snow-making overspray, it adds noise pollution, it adds light pollution, and it is incredibly destructive...

Original Post City of Edina, MN (Local Government) 8:55am Jul 8

View Post on Facebook - Edit Email Settings Reply to this email to add a comment. Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 8:23 AM Subject: FW: Braemar winter improvements

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: Andy [[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 7:57 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar winter improvements

Dear City Council members and Mayor: I wrote a letter to the editor of the Sun Current with two other families in support of improvements at Braemar that would allow snowmaking and additional trails.

This letter will appear in the 8/25 issue.

I talked to my neighbors last Sunday afternoon and received 15 signatures, within one hour, on a petition supporting the project. I look forward to the public hearing September 7th Sincerely, Andy Otness 5433 Kellogg Avenue 612:978-1681

Sent from my iPhone

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 11:29 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Mountain biking trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Rob Webb [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 11:23 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Mountain biking trails

Dear City Council and City Staff:

Thank you for all you do for Edina. As you consider all the factors that affect the plans for the Braemar recreational area. I do want to plug for mountain biking. It is a popular activity to help people live healthier lives. To be active and outdoors is a hallmark of Minnesota, and Edina in particular. Over 40 million people in the U.S. mountain bike, and it is a growing sport across many demographics. Many Edina residents are traveling to Eagan, Minneapolis and other suburbs for this activity, and those trails are increasingly experiencing over-crowding. It would be fantastic if Edina residents could mountain bike in their own community. There are excellent non-profit groups that develop and maintain the trails with deep respect for the environment. The mountain biking community is very respectful of the rules, trails, facilities, and surrounding areas, and would bring a positive contribution to the broader Edina community.

Including mountain biking at Braemar is a decision that will be admired as a good decision for generations to come. Thank you!

Rob Webb Edina Resident

Sent from my iPad Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 1:50 PM Subject: FW: WINTER SPORTS PARK PROJECT AT BRAEMAR

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: frank lorenz [mailto:franklorenz©msn.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 1:43 PM To: Ann Kattreh Cc: James Hovland Subject: WINTER SPORTS PARK PROJECT AT BRAEMAR

If the proposed Braemar ski trails stay open until 11 PM, will the snow making machines run till 5 AM? How much noise (db level)will they make? Will the floodlights have to stay on till 5 AM? How much water, electricity, and employee labor cost at O.T. rates will this consume during a winter season? Shouldn't Edina also have a full Pentathlon course with an outdoor winter firing range open until 5AM? Edina draws its potable water from a system of wells. Will the operation of snow making deplete our aquifer or the particular well(s) in the southwest corner of Edina? Frank Lorenz

PS: Edina's city PR machine makes much of our relatively low property tax (levy rate), compared to surrounding cities. But this is happening primarily because what other cities classify as normal/general street repairs/repaving, Edina charges as special assessments to each homeowner. Those assessments frequently exceed a homeowner's property tax assessment. One of the way corrupt politicians (including school district administrators) seek to fool the public is to fragment the total tax load into multiple taxes. EPS now has four lines in its annual assessment. YOU SHOULD KNOW THAT EDINA RESIDENTS ARE NOT BEING FOOLED BY THIS DEVICE.

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 1:54 PM Subject: FW: Braemar construction

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Kim Mcilwain [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 1:03 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar construction

Council members, As an Edina resident, I am asking you to vote NO on the proposed building of a ski area at Braemar.

Thank you, Kim Mcilwain 5408 Chantrey Road

Sent from my iPad Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 2:10 PM Subject: FW: Building a Healthy Community through Mountain Biking

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Jack Ellingson [mailto:ellingsonjack(&gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 2:00 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Building a Healthy Community through Mountain Biking

Hello Edina Government,

My name is Jack Ellingson. As a senior at Edina High School, I'm one of the captains of the Edina Cycling Team.

I personally know the many benefits mountain biking can bring to a community. Mountain biking can unite and strengthen the mental, physical, and social health of a community. Kids who would be bullied and harassed in school find a community where they are not only accepted, but well respected. Mountain biking can also inspire kids to peruse careers in STEM by actively engaging them with the complex mechanics found on a bicycle. These are just a few of the many benefits mountain biking will bring to Edina.

By building mountain biking trails in Edina, our community could better utilize the benefits that come with cycling. If you have any questions or concerns about building trails in Edina, please email me back.

Thanks, Jack Ellingson

Captain of the Edina Cycling Team Leader of FIRST Robotics Team 1816 - The Green Machine Captain of the EHS Business Club ,

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 2:11 PM Subject: FW: Revised Feedback on Braemar Park Winter Rec Area Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Doug Bennett [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 2:10 PM To: Robert Stewart; Ann Kattreh; Edina Mail Subject: Revised Feedback on Braemar Park Winter Rec Area Proposal

Ann, Bob, and all Edina City Council Members-

We are writing as a follow up to our July 9 letter (included below for reference); after learning more about this proposal, we are emphatically opposed to all elements of the plan. We are asking you to vote NO on this proposal/plan.

While we originally signaled strong opposition to the tubing hill and openness to the nordic ski trails, we are now against both of these concepts. The overall plan does not make sense financially, will be a nuisance for the neighborhood residents and permanently damages the the environment within Braemar Park.

I want to reiterate that we like the idea of multi-use trails that are cost effective for the community, but there is absolutely no reason to clear an additional 30-40 feet of woodland over 2+ km to achieve the desired nordic trail system. Why not use the soon to be available land from the 9 golf holes that will be no longer used (Clunie) for ski trails? This land is already cleared - this has much less environmental impact and if there is enough benefit to installing snowmachines to maintain those trails for a longer season then that MUST be more cost effective for Edina and its taxpayers. Those snowmaking machines would also be away from the roads and avoid expected safety hazards in the proposed plan.

Our hypothesis is that the contractor who drafted this plan wants to use the bluffs because it would become a signature trail system in their portfolio - but it is way too invasive.

Please vote no to this proposal and seek more reasonable options.

We will plan to be at the council meeting for this public discussion and vote. If you would like to discuss this with us in advance, please call us @ 612.963.3594

Sincerely, Doug and Heather Bennett 5708 Kemrich Drive

On Tuesday, July 12, 2016 10:32 PM, Heather Yahoo wrote:

Begin forwarded message:

From: Robert Stewart Date: July 12, 2016 at 3:27:46 PM CDT To: "dubesbennettyahoo.com" Subject: FW: Questions and Feedback on Braemar Park Winter Rec Area

Heather and Doug,

1 Thank you for your note. It is very helpful for the City Council members to hear all perspectives on these issues.

- Bob Stewart

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, July 11, 2016 8:49 AM Subject: FW: Questions and Feedback on Braemar Park Winter Rec Area

[cid:image001.gif©01D1DB51.1B31FDBO]

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 Ibiunno(EdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Ann Kattreh Sent: Monday, July 11, 2016 8:46 AM To: Edina Mail Cc: Janet Canton Subject: FW: Questions and Feedback on Braemar Park Winter Rec Area

Please include in City Council Correspondence

[cid:image003.png (01D1DB50.AED3FC901

Ann Kattreh, Parks & Recreation Director 952-826-0430 I Fax 952-826-0390 AKattrehEdinaMN.gov I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Heather Bennett [mailto:dubesbennettyahoo.corn] Sent: Saturday, July 09, 2016 1:55 PM To: Ann Kattreh Cc: Doug Bennett Subject: Questions and Feedback on Braemar Park Winter Rec Area

Ann- We may not be able to attend the open house and wanted to provide feedback on this proposed plan.

As we are within walking distance, our family of 6 regularly use Braemar park year round in its current state:

* golf in the summer * sledding on the hole 21 hill in the winter year-round walking/hiking on the bluff trails on the east side of the park - we walk on those trails 200-250 days each year

2 Overall, we have mixed feelings about this plan. On one hand, we are very supportive of utilizing this parkland year round. In fact, we have commented several times that the best improvement is the groomed snow trails that were introduced a few years ago. We walk/run/hike/snowshoe with and without our dog on those trails all the time. Further improvements of these trails is a positive for us if it can be cost effective for non-skivers and non-bikers.

On the other hand, we have real concerns about the proposed plan. First and foremost, we are very concerned that existing parkland trails that we regularly use will now have a usage fee associated with it. What will it cost to now utilize the trails because of the man-made snow and lights? What is the reality of time restrictions for using the trail because of the high school skiing team and other groups that will have regular practices and competitions? We also don't need lights to enjoy those existing trails - in fact is quite peaceful to walk through Braemar at night in the winter.

Why can't the high school ski team use the existing man-made snow trails at hyland park reserve that is less than 3 miles from Braemar?

We are strongly opposed to the groomed tubing hill for several reasons: First, the groomed tubing hill moves a great free resource that can be used at leisure into yet another expensive outing type experience. Why should we have to pay on a per use basis for a resource that we currently use for no incremental fees beyond our taxes? Kids have been tubing/sledding on that hill for many,many years and it already is a great resource. It is also an activity that is great because it is spontaneous. It snows and our kids want to go to the hill. If it is too crowded we come back another time. We don't need a reservation for a defined time and we aren't limited by a 2 hour window to utilize the resource.... and we certainly don't have to decide is this worth $50- 75-100 for our family to go enjoy the snow. We go to Buck Hill or Elm Creek 1 time a year, because it is $90 for our family.

Second, the tubing lift also discourages the exercise provided by walking up the hill. This an excellent unstructured physical activity for our kids where they get great exercise - why ruin it by grooming lanes and hoisting them up the hill mechanically? Third, the lights will be a nuisance for the neighborhood on the tubing hill - We live 1/2 west of Lewis Park and deal with lights for football games all fall season and even the hockey lights that are 1/4 mile from our house. I would not want to live on Gleason road with those lights on constantly for 3 months a year. Finally, traffic and parking will likely be an issue if you create a groomed tubing hill - there is already plenty of traffic around that area because of the hockey rinks, edina dome, and golf dome.

In summary, we can be supportive of the groomed multi-use trails if it can continue to be cost effective for hiking/walking. We are completely against the groomed tubing hill and encourage the Parks Department and City Council to separate these two decisions.

We would be happy to discuss this live and can be reached @ 952.693.3594.

Sincerely, Heather and Doug Bennett 5708 Kemrich Drive

3 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 8:47 AM Subject: FW: Mountain bike trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Chris O'Brien [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 5:55 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Mountain bike trails

I support mountain bike trails in Edina. I now have more adult friends who bike than any other sport. It has passed golf in activity of business leaders. MORC can help build sustainable trails. Thank you for considering this

Chris O'Brien 4713 Townes Road Edina

************************************************************************************************** *********************** This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. If you are not the named addressee you should not disseminate, distribute or copy this e- mail. Please notify the sender immediately by e-mail if you have received this e-mail by mistake and delete this e-mail from your system. Please note that any views or opinions presented in this email are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of C.H. Robinson. C.H. Robinson accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. (IP)

C.H. Robinson Worldwide, 14701 Charlson Road, Eden Prairie, MN, USA ************************************************************************************************** ***********************

1 Janet Canton From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 8:53 AM Subject: FW: Kristin Kiser Reichling commented on a link City of Edina, MN (Local Government) shared.

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Facebook [nnailto:update+yy2694o9Pfacebookmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 8:45 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Kristin Kiser Reichling commented on a link City of Edina, MN (Local Government) shared.

Facebook

Kristin Kiser Reichling commented on a link City of Edina, MN (Local Government) shared.

Kristin Kiser Reichling August 24 at 8:44pm

I am concerned that people don't realize that these drawings are not to scale. The ski trails are planned to be 50' wide. If you compare those lines to Gleason Road, they are-50-60% of the size they should be. It's interesting that the developer is sharing maps that aren't to scale and there are no callouts to that effect. Are people really ok with changing the landscape of Braemar that drastically? That hill will never look the same. Hiking and biking will be like going down a neighborhood street instead of a path through the woods. People can ski at Braemar now; there are other ways to build upon what is done today, rather than cut 50' paths.

This message was sent to [email protected]. If you don't want to receive these emails from Facebook in the future, please unsubscribe. Face-book, Inc., Attention: Community Support, Menlo Park, CA 94025

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 8:54 AM Subject: FW: Comments on Braemar Winter Facility

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: ChenXijian [mailto:home [email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2016 10:08 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Comments on Braemar Winter Facility

Dear City Officials, As an Edina resident and also a skier, I paid attention to the recent proposal of Braemar Winter Facility. And here I have some questions and comments:

(1)Lack of broad public benefit. It seems to be an open secret that the proposal is driven by and mainly serving Nordic Ski team. For example, the cross-country trails are on the hills to meet the team's expertise level. I don't think it is designed for casual skiers or kids. Rather than a pubic park, the Winter Facility seems more like a semi-private training camp for a small group. I doubt how much benefit the new park will bring to common people. Especially the well- established highland park is just 6 minutes's drive away. (2)Lack of transparency on decision making. The best part of democracy is to listen to all sides and get compromise. So far, I haven't seen that on this proposal. The project was suddenly brought to public attention in July and there is only two months time before making a decision for such a 3 millions dollar project. I cannot help asking what is reason of rushing in a hurry? A U.S house speaker once said that there is a reason that house makes decision slowly, as " we don't want to pass a bill in just a week which will mess up the country for next 20 years". Would that also apply to our city?

(3)Moral consideration For the proponents of the Winter facility, I wonder how many of them are in the nearly neighborhood or seriously stand in the shoes of the impacted people. Nobody's fun should be based on others' daily sacrifice. Why can't we build a park with least impact to the neighborhood, for example, walking or biking trail?

That is just my two cents. Thanks for your attention. Xijian Chen

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 3:31 PM Subject: FW: Proposed Cross Country Ski Trails at Baemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Greta Gage [mailto:glgage(acomcast.net] Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 3:29 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Proposed Cross Country Ski Trails at Baemar

Hello,

I'm an Edina High School Graduate (class of 2013) and former member of the high school nordic ski team. The nordic ski team was the highlight of my time in high school and the construction at Edina High School is limiting the available practice areas on campus. My May Term project was to make a ski trail on the Edina High School grounds with two of my friends for the ski team and community to use, but because of the construction at the high school, the trail has been rendered unusable.

In the early years of my membership (7th and 8th grade) on the ski team we had a small enough team to take busses to nearby ski trails, primarily those in the Hyland Lake Park Reserve in Bloomington. However, within the next four years our team grew from about 40-50 members to over 200 (becoming the 3rd largest sports team at Edina High School) and became far too costly to transport everyone to Hyland Lake Park Reserve for daily practices on top of the fact that the team cannot get a permit to practice there because of the drastic increase of skiers visiting the park after their recent addition of snowmaking.

Ski trails at Braemar will benefit not only the 200+ students who are on the ski team annually but the Edina community as a whole. Cross country skiing is one of the top-ten healthiest sports and can be done regardless of age or athletic ability. I've been a cross country skier ever since I was 3-years-old and plan to continue skiing for the rest of my life. My entire family cross country skis and is our favorite activity to do as a family, and I've met many families who share the exact same passion. Even though seasons change, children still have a lot of energy and instead of being cooped up in the house all winter they (and their families) could share in a new bonding experience and get exercise. This will also allow for children to become more in-touch with nature and their surrounding environment instead of being glued to the computer screen all day.

We should not let a community resource as valuable as Braemar go unused for half the year, I strongly support the proposed snowmaking cross country ski trails at Braemar and hope you do too.

Sincerely, Greta Gage

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 8:19 AM Subject: FW: Braemar snow making

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Therese [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 5:15 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar snow making

I am a lifelong cross country skier, as are my husband and grown daughters and sons-in-law. We support more opportunities for Nordic skiing in the Twin Cities. I identify Nordic skiing as a lifestyle all year long. Skiers are healthy, active, positive people who would bring their enthusiasm and spending to your community. Please support the snow making at Braemar. Sincerely, Therese White Shoreview

Sent from my iPhone

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 8:21 AM Subject: FW: I urge you to reject the proposal to build a Nordic Ski Trail at Braemar -- here's why

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.gov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Harlan Limpert [mailto:HLimpert(auuarorct] Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 7:39 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: I urge you to reject the proposal to build a Nordic Ski Trail at Braemar -- here's why

To City of Edina Elected Leaders:

I urge you to reject the proposal to build a Nordic Ski Trail and Tubing Hill at Braemar.

When I first read about the proposal, I thought, "Great, our elected leaders are taking another step towards enhancing the quality of life in Edina". But as I studied the proposal and learned the facts, I was rather astounded that the proposal would even be considered.

There are numerous reasons to reject the proposal. I wish to focus on two.

First, safety. Beyond the safety of me and my wife as we drive on Gleason Road and Tanglewood Court, I think of our two children and four granddaughters who come to visit twice a week. They would have to deal with the overspray of ice crystals that fall onto the roads and create a terrible driving hazard. Furthermore, having fallen in our driveway at 7737 Tanglewood Court once already and injured myself seriously enough to require surgery, I shutter to think of the possibility again caused not by a typical Minnesota winter, but by a project reviewed and approved by our civic leaders.

Second, the destruction of natural habitat. One of the best things about living in the Twin Cities -- and Edina in particular -- is the attentiveness our forbearers paid to setting aside land that would remain beautiful and accessible for all residents. Every day we pass by parks and open spaces that add to our collective quality of life. To consider a project that would include tearing down trees to cut a fifty-foot-wide path that would be artificially covered with snow created by loud and messy snow-making machines is abhorrent to me — and I know many, many others.

Please...reject the proposal being considered.

Sincerely, Home address: 7737 Tanglewood Ct. Edina, MN 55439

Rev. Harlan Limpert I Chief Operating Officer Phone (612) 669-0574 I [email protected] uua.org I Twitter l Facebook

UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST ASSOCJAt1ON

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 8:22 AM Subject: FW: Proposed Ski Trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 j Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Susan Brown [mailto:sbrownOvisi.conn] Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 8:12 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Proposed Ski Trails

Hello -

I am delighted with the proposed changes as Braemar. The ski trails are a wonderful way to extend the usage of the land in the winter months. What a great way to get more exercise in the cold. The snow making effort feels reasonable, and snowy trails will help to the High School X-Country team practice within our community. Your design seems well thought out.

As a gardener I am especially impressed with your planned Buckthorn removal.

I wish you the best —

Sue

Susan Brown 5528 Halifax Lane 612 .670.5644

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 8:25 AM Subject: FW: Support for Winter Park and Nordic Ski Trail at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: George Yi [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2016 11:40 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Support for Winter Park and Nordic Ski Trail at Braemar

I would like to write to you to show my family's support to create a winter park and nordic skill trail at Braemar.

All my family members love to do winter sports, we usually do that at Hyland. But in recently years, Hyland fees have increased 30% and become very crowded. And it still does not have a snow tubing area for younger kids. So when we heard about the new winter park, we are very excited and fully support the idea. We live at Breamar Hills Neighborhood, this park will be very convenient for us and we are willing to pay the extra tax levy and endure the construction noise and traffic congestion.

I know someone in our neighborhood have concerns about snow making noise, but I think this can be workout as put a curfew on snow making time and should not be a reason to stop the project.

Thanks for your considerations.

Yi Family 6232 Braeburn Circle, Edina, 55439

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 2:25 PM Subject: FW: Support for Nordic Trail System at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Talia Willmert [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 12:48 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Support for Nordic Trail System at Braemar

Dear Edina City Council,

My name is Talia Willmert, and I am writing to express my support for a nordic trail system with snowmaking capabilities at Braemar. I just graduated from EHS, and I was lucky enough to be a part of the nordic team for 5 years and serve as a captain as a senior. I met so many close friends through the program, was able to improve as an athlete throughout high school, and even qualified for the state meet with my team last year, which was an amazing experience. I can honestly say that the team is full of some of the most intelligent, involved, and talented students I've ever met, and I am so excited to see the team continue to grow and succeed in the years to come.

However, with the construction at the high school, the ski trails in the fields below are being compromised, and I feel that new ski trails at Braemar would be a great solution to the problem. Opponents argue that the ski facility at Hylands is close enough; why do we need trails at Braemar? However, I can say from personal experience that Hylands is often too crowded to practice, and it is not very accessible because it requires a bus to get all the way down there and a permit for the entire team to practice at once. Although it is a great facility, transporting 200 kids there for practice is not a feasible option.

Braemar is close by and is a wonderful choice for this project. And it could be used not only by the nordic team, but people of all ages; I know kids who have skied since they could walk and adults who picked it up at 50 years old. Skiing is a truly lifelong sport, and although I understand that residents have concerns about the project, I think long term it will be an asset to the community.

Ultimately, I think this plan is an amazing opportunity for Edina, and I truly hope it is approved! Thank you!

Sincerely,

Talia Willmert

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 8:17 AM Subject: FW: Nordic ski project

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 27, 2016 12:48 PM To: James Hovland Subject: Nordic ski project

I am just appalled at the way the proposed Nordic ski project has been handled. Can you explain to me how the Edina City Council is able to spend an exorbitant amount of money to have this proposal developed by just one company that has a vested interest in pushing it forward before any of the community knew about it. Also, can you tell me where we can find the results of the environmental study that was done on this property?

Thank you, Sheran McNulty

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 8:18 AM Subject: FW: Nordic Development Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Kristin Lindberg [mailto:kristin a [email protected]] Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 10:49 AM To: James Hovland Subject: Nordic Development Proposal

Dear Mr. Hovland,

I write to encourage you to vote NO to the current Nordic Development Proposal at Braemar. As a lifelong resident of Edina I am extremely concerned and opposed to:

• the continued development and loss of wildlife habitat in this green area and in our community in general • the additional traffic coming into our community, both directly in this area and in surrounding areas of Edina • the continued removal of green space in our community • the additional noise and dangerous conditions that will come with the construction and operation of this facility.

I am completely confused as to why our lawmakers would even consider spending this kind of capital on a project that will bring additional traffic and reduce the quality of life in our community. I have enjoyed cross country skiing in Edina for the past 40 years. This has been done peacefully at Braemar. Although my kids enjoy tubing, I am more than happy to drive them to facilities in surrounding communities for this. Why do we need this here???

Please vote NO on this proposal.

Sincerely,

Kristin Lindberg 5713 Grace Terrace, Edina

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 8:18 AM Subject: FW: Proposed Braemar Winter Center Questions

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoREdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Bernie/Dick Letsche [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 8:35 PM To: swensonannl; Robert Stewart; Kevin Staunton; Mary Brindle; James Hovland Subject: Proposed Braemar Winter Center Questions

To the Edina City Council:

Has anyone on the City Council considered these questions:

• Where will skiers/tubers go when they or their children need to use the restroom, need to get warm or want buy a warm drink or snack when the temperature or windchill factor plummet to below zero (or even when the temperature isn't below zero)? • Where will skiers leave their ski equipment when needing to use the, restroom or needing to warm up? • Where will skiers/tubers go to purchase tickets, etc.? • Would a separate ticket/warming house with bathrooms and concession stand be proposed? • Where would a warming house/ticket booth be placed and would the cost be factored into the already expensive, unbudgeted $3 million proposed cost for the project?

These questions, and others, are on my mind. I am a mother/grandmother who has taken children skiing, sledding and skating when these issues arose. I wouldn't want to face the prospect of finding a place to safely leave skis then trudging across the parking lot and up the hill to the clubhouse so I or my children could use the restroom, get warm, or buy a snack/warm drink.

Has anyone on the City Council considered how many days the Nordic ski trail and the tubing site will stand empty because the wind-chill factor, or actual temperature, will be near or below zero degrees? We may not have snow during any particular winter, but we have cold and wind-chill factor every winter.

These questions are aside from the destruction of the wildlife habitat and trees issue, the ice overspray issue, the environmental issue, the lighting issue, the noise issue, and financial burden issue (with no return foreseen for many years, if ever) that should be wisely and thoughtfully considered by the City Council.

Please vote NO to the Braemar Winter Center proposal as written. Let's slow down and find a better way to incorporate Nordic skiing into the landscape of Braemar Park.

1 Thank you, Bernadine Letsche 7435 Hyde Park Lane 952-944-2464

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 8:19 AM Subject: FW: Proposed Braemar Winter Center Questions

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Bernie/Dick Letsche [mailto:rblet2526(&yahoo.com] Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 8:39 PM To: swensonann1; Robert Stewart; Kevin Staunton; Mary Brindle; James Hovland Cc: Joshua M. Ahlberg; Karen Hazel Subject: Proposed Braemar Winter Center Questions

To the Edina City Council:

Aside from the destruction of the wildlife habitat and trees issue, the ice overspray issue, the environmental issue, the lighting issue, the noise issue, and financial burden issue (with no return foreseen for many years, if ever) that should be wisely and thoughtfully considered by the City Council, here are a few other thoughts to consider:

• Is the City prepared to salt, sand or plow Gleason Road and affected driveways EVERY DAY after snow making is done to rid curvy Gleason Road of subsequent ice overspray? • Is the City prepared for legal action which could result when the overspray on curvy Gleason Road results in accidents?

• Where will skiers/tubers go when they or their children need to use the restroom, need to get warm or want buy a warm drink or snack when the temperature or windchill factor plummet to below zero (or even when the temperature isn't below zero)?

• Where will skiers leave their ski equipment when needing to use the restroom or needing to warm up? • Would a separate ticket/warming house with bathrooms and concession stand be proposed? • Where would a warming house/ticket booth be placed and would the cost be factored into the already expensive, unbudgeted $3 million proposed cost for the project? • Has anyone on the City Council considered how many days the Nordic ski trail and the tubing site will stand empty because the wind-chill factor, or actual temperature, will be near or below zero degrees? We may not have snow during any particular winter, but we have cold and wind-chill factor every winter.

Please vote NO to the Braemar Winter Center proposal as written. Let's slow down and find a better way to incorporate Nordic skiing into the landscape of Braemar Park.

1 Thank you, Bernadine Letsche 7435 Hyde Park Lane 952-944-2464

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 10:06 AM Subject: FW: [Braemar Park Winter Recreational Area Open House]

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Joshua M. Ahlberg [nriailto:[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 27, 2016 1:13 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Re: [Braemar Park Winter Recreational Area Open House]

Joshua M. Ahlberg commented on City of Edina, MN (Local Government)'s post in Braemar Park Winter Recreational Area Open House.

Joshua M. Ahlberg 7:48am Aug 24 Take a look at the image attached. It's a side-by-side comparison of what SEH presented this in perspective versus what the 50 foot wide cut looks at the ground level. I used Gleason's 32 foot width as my basis of measurement.

This is not 100% scientific, but it should be pretty darn close. Everything they're showing us is shown from above the canopy of the trees. Last time I checked, I didn't live above the trees.

Comment History Bernadine Goodman Letsche 8:11am Aug 24 This layout looks like a cute trail through leafy trees. In reality, it will be a 50 foot ih swath cut through bare Savanah Oaks. Noise, snow overspray and lights will be a problem. Let's take time to figure out a sensible Nordic skiing program for Braemar. Harlan Limpert 10:12pm Aug 25 If it's true that this image is not to scale, and all evidence suggests it is not, then the proponents are being deceptive at best, unethical at worst. Is there someone seeing this post who can assure me and others what the proposed aerial view would actually look like? Bernadine Goodman Letsche 10:58am Aug 27 No, the developers skirted the issue of the drawing not being to scale or the fact —41 that there were lots of leaves on the trees when the noise levels were measured and how much overspray there would actually be. At first they said it would be ice that would need to be cleared every day on streets and driveways. Then they said it would be light crystals "that could be blown off with your breath". Not likely. This idea is shaky from the start, rammed through by a few and opposed by many . Joshua M. Ahlberg 1:13pm Aug 27 Take a look at the image attached. It's a side-by-side comparison of what SEH presented this in perspective versus what the 50 foot wide cut looks at the ground level. I used Gleason's 32 foot width as my basis of measurement.

This is not 100% scientific, but it should be pretty darn close. Everything they're showing us is shown from above the canopy of the trees. Last time I checked, I didn't live above the trees.

Original Post City of Edina, MN (Local Government) 8:55am Jul 8

View Post on Facebook • Edit Email Settings • Reply to this email to add a comment. Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 10:07 AM Subject: FW: Nordic ski trail project in Braemar golf course

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Millikan [rnailto:milikan [email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 27, 2016 1:44 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic ski trail project in Braemar golf course

Please vote against the Nordic ski trail project in Braemar golf course. This project would undoubtedly reduce the real estate value of neighborhoods around Braemar. No one desires to reside in a neighborhood polluted by noise and artificial light. If this project is approved the socioeconomic level of the residents around Braemar will decrease over time due to the affluent people moving out of the area and being replaced by less educated and affluent people who have limited options of where to live. The city of Edina will undoubtedly lose real estate value and real estate income tax.

Sent from my iPad

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 10:22 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Mountain Bike Trails - YES!!

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Tara Frimat [mailto:tefrimatOgmail.com] Sent: Saturday, August 27, 2016 7:25 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Mountain Bike Trails - YES!!

Hello, I am writing to express my support for the development of mountain bike trails at the Braemar golf course area. As a parent of a rider on the Edina High School Mountain bike team and a team volunteer, I can assure you that adding trails in Edina would result in safer practice options for our team. Trees would not need to be destroyed to build single track trails, and the team would maintain the trails, as we incorporate public service and trail maintenance into our team practice. But the benefits of the trails would not stop at our team. The entire community and riders of all ages would benefit from access to this fun, healthy activity that is becoming increasingly popular. On behalf of our family and the Edina Cycling Team, we encourage you to support what is sure to be a tremendous asset to the Edina parks and recreation facilities. Cordially, Tara & Patrick Frimat and family [email protected] 651-955-7803

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 10:24 AM Subject: FW: Ski Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Mary Ann Bull [nnailto:[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 27, 2016 11:05 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Ski Proposal

To all City Council Members,

Vote NO for Ski Path at Braemar. It is not need, will never pay for itself, will add noise, lighting and is not funded in any way! This would be irresponsible to proceed forward What a waste of $100K in tax payer money for the study!

Mary Ann Bull Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 10:28 AM Subject: FW: Nordic trac

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Betty Weingartner [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 10:15 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic trac

Stop this plan immediately. Our children were on the winter cross country team and were provided wonderful opportunities in Edina without this. Wasteful!! Sent from my iPhone

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 10:36 AM Subject: FW: Nordic Development Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoP,EdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Kristin Lindberg [mailto:kristin a lindberg(ayahoo.corn] Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 10:45 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic Development Proposal

Dear Edina Council Members,

I write to encourage you to vote NO to the current Nordic Development Proposal at Braemar. As a lifelong resident of Edina I am extremely concerned and opposed to:

• the continued development and loss of wildlife habitat in this green area and in our community in general • the additional traffic coming into our community, both directly in this area and in surrounding areas of Edina • the continued removal of green space in our community • the additional noise and dangerous conditions that will come with the construction and operation of this facility.

I am completely confused as to why our lawmakers would even consider spending this kind of capital on a project that will bring additional traffic and reduce the quality of life in our community. I have enjoyed cross country skiing in Edina for the past 40 years. This has been done peacefully at Braemar. Although my kids enjoy tubing, I am more than happy to drive them to facilities in surrounding communities for this. Why do we need this here???

Please vote NO on this proposal.

Sincerely,

Kristin Lindberg 5713 Grace Terrace, Edina

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 10:45 AM Subject: FW: Braemar To Scale Attachments: SideBySide(REV082716)jpeg

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 Ibiunno(&,EdinaMN.gov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Martin, Dawn [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 6:56 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar To Scale

Hello Council Members ...

As you are considering the Braemar Winter Project, I'd like you to consider the attached.

It's a "to scale" drawing of the project compared to what was presented by SEH, which was not to scale. Gleason Road is 32' across, so you can see from the attached the new rendering is to scale. And just for comparison's sake, 494's four lane highway is 48' wide. A 50' wide swath at the top of the range will be quite invasive.

I know you want what's best for Edina, and this proposal in it's current form is not in any way, shape or form good for our city for a number of reasons.

I urge you to slow down, form a task force made of XC fans, mountain bike fans, and the neighbors to come up with what's best for everyone, not just a few.

Thanks for your consideration.

Dawn Martin President Edina Soccer Club

DAWN MARTIN Vice President I Meetings & Shows d 952.844.4819 I m 612.964.8989 BI WORLDWIDE Australia I Canada I China I India I LATAM I UK I US www.biworldwide.com

Check out our multiple award winning video on social issues at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-xfNnkURIBM

Please consider the environment before printing.

This e-mail message is being sent solely for use by the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by phone or reply by e-mail, delete the original message and destroy all copies. Thank you.

2

Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 11:34 AM Subject: FW: Additional comments supporting Braemar cross country skiing with snowmaking since the 23rd of August.

fig Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 3 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Jarvinen [mailto:jarvinen©aol.com] Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 9:44 PM To: Edina Mail Cc: 'Julie turnbull'; [email protected]; 'Paul Gage'; 'Noah' Subject: Additional comments supporting Braemar cross country skiing with snowmaking since the 23rd of August.

Dear Edina City Council,

A petition in support of Braemar snowmaking was started on August 18th. Comments received from the start until August 23rd were previously forwarded. Here are additional comments received since the 23rd at http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/braemar-skiing.

Craig Jarvinen

Name Date Comments Street Address City of F I strongly support the proposed project for Edina High School skiers and all Edina residents. Hylands does not support skiing 346 Robert Syring 8/23/2016 14:59 for the entire HS team. 4117 Kipling Edina I've sent a detailed letter to the Park Board and City Council, 349 Bob McKlveen 8/23/2016 16:29 and encourage you to do the same if you have time. 5261. Lochloy Drive Edina

1 I support snowmaking at Braemar! It would ultimately benefit 350 Christie Franken 8/23/2016 17:16 Edina and the surrounding area. 4544 Parkside LN Edina This would be a wonderful addition to the parks, biking, and 352 Carol Holguin 8/23/2016 17:27 walking trails already in our lovely city. 5508 Glengarry PKWY Edina Is there any way to add a dog park to the area? Braemar could 354 Jackie Lund 8/23/2016 19:21 charge for a pass to pay any expenses. 5805 Hidden Lane Edina 356 Jeanne Riha 8/23/2016 21:00 Great Idea! 5213 Meadow Ridge Edina 357 Scott Putman 8/23/2016 21:44 This is a really good idea! 2539 Oakwood Ave. Green B This will not only be an asset to the city, but also the high school 359 Jeff Ingram 8/24/2016 1:10 and elementary schools. 14400 Lennell Drive Minnetc

Great thing to do. I hope more areas will do the same. I skied a park outside Brighton, MI that has a few klms of manmade snow. It was wonderful to be on snow when it was cold, but no 361 Alan Hough 8/24/2016 2:36 natural snow. Good luck!!! 417 Spring St Grove C 363 Keith Gilbert 8/24/2016 2:38 This is sorely needed in the West Metro. 1466 Skiles lane Arden H This is a very good thing to do with winters becoming less reliable. Plus, the timing is great, as the cost will be less due to 366 Jeanne Krantz-Swenson 8/24/2016 3:42 the other construction 8100 Russell Ave S #128 Bloomir 367 Kathryn Newsome-Herr 8/24/2016 11:05 I think this is a super idea. 6708 Galway Deive Edina My daughter open enrolled in the Edina School system and we 372 Stephen Bullard 8/24/2016 15:40 would use this facility as a family also 3327 Saint Paul Avenue Minneal 373 Floyd Grabiel 8/24/2016 15:42 Don't let the NIMBYs wear you down 4817 Wilford Way Edina 376 Kelly Grosd 8/24/2016 22:07 This would be amazing as we need more areas to ski.. 8934 Gould Road Eden Pr.

Well designed and well maintained trails throughout the woods make for a safer environment for all. I have seen the positive improvements at Theodore Wirth park after Mpls Parks put in more trails. These professionally designed ski trails at Braemar will definitely improve this section of Edina AND give countless 377 Wallace Alexander 8/24/2016 22:31 hours of outside exercise to student athletes and residents. 3912 Garfield Ave S Minnear

This is critical for the EHS Nordic Team and our community. The team has over 200 kids and is a no-cut sport--one of the few. it builds community and is inclusive and welcoming. Braemar Park 380 melissa raphan 8/25/2016 2:18 Recreation proposal must be passed. 4515 casco avenue edina 384 Jeff Patterson 8/25/2016 13:46 Cross country skiing is a silent sport and a healthy pursuit. 4537 Dupont Ave. S. Minneat

2 I'm an Edina High School Graduate (class of 2013) and former member of the high school nordic ski team. The nordic ski team was the highlight of my time in high school and the construction at Edina High School is limiting the available practice areas on campus. Ski trails at Braemar will benefit not only the 200+ students who are on the ski team annually but the Edina community as a whole. These ski trails will create new opportunities for Edina residents to take part in a lifelong sport (and one that can become a family-wide activity) with one of the kindest communities I've had the pleasure of being a 396 Greta Gage 8/25/2016 19:43 member of. 5813 Amy Drive Edina 399 Angie Askegaard 8/25/2016 20:25 We need snow to ski in west metro!! 9188 La Rivier Court Eden Pr. I strongly support snow-making for ski trails in Edina. As an avid skier, it would be wonderful to have one more option with 402 Patricia Carlen 8/25/2016 21:17 reliable snow. I know I would use the trails. 601 Montcalm Place Saint Pa This is another great opportunity8 to provide recreation, training, and enjoyment in Edina. Cross Country/Nordic skiing 406 Bob O'Hara 8/25/2016 21:57 has been growing as more trails are available. 6001 Goodrich Ave St. Louis There is a great need in the West Metro for consistent snow on 408 LuAnn Berg 8/25/2016 22:42 our trails. 4800 Orchid Ln N, Plymoui Mahton 411 Bob Brandt 8/25/2016 23:18 skiing is good. 9800 Janero Ct N 1338 Snowmaking is needed everywhere, especially after what we've seen the last two years. As an skier I would love to see as much 412 Matthew Dosland 8/25/2016 23:20 snowmaking in the cities as possible. 1196 Portland Ave Saint Pa This is a resource that will be used beyond what the numbers 413 Todd Johnson 8/26/2016 0:25 people will initially think possible. 1899 Fairmount Ave. St. Paul Promoting and supporting healthy activities for the community should be a priority for the leaders of all cities. If not you, who? 414 Betsy Longley 8/26/2016 0:50 If not now, when? 9514 Colorado Circle Bloomir 415 Marty Johnston 8/26/2016 0:58 It will get used :) 1841 Montreal Ave Saint Pa 418 mark Leach 8/26/2016 1:57 build it and they will come 244 10th Avenue North Hopkins Snow making here would get a lot of use and would be a great bonus to the community and a big support to a healthy life- 421 steve sonnesyn 8/26/2016 2:41 style; I would definitely ski there. 3110 jewel lane plymou1

3 This would be a great way to support the EHS Nordic ski teams who are losing their trails due to the new construction at EHS. It also would support our citizen skiers and utilize our parks on a 424 Mary Berntson 8/26/2016 4:02 year round basis. 6728 Point Drive Edina Please approve the cross country ski trails with snow making 426 Nancy Mendel 8/26/2016 4:11 capabilities!!! 7113 West Shore Drive Edina

Hundreds of kids in Edina enjoy cross country skiing during the winter months, and many train during the summer just to prepare for the winter season. This is a life-long sport that parents can enjoy with their children and continue to enjoy into their older years. Help us promote a healthy life style for our community by supporting a cross country ski trail at Braemar 427 Christian Lawler 8/26/2016 4:14 Park. 4601 Sunnyside Road Edina I would love to see cross country ski trails at Braemar. Our 429 Nancy Sinykin 8/26/2016 6:14 family would enjoy using the trails throughout the year. 4413 Fondell Drive Edina 433 Rong Zheng 8/26/2016 8:23 I am for it 7005 valley view rd Edina

Please pass this as a skier myself it would be great to ski locally... What a fabulous opportunity for our local high school kids who didn't get to ski much last year due to no snow and limited space at other parks. If this were your passion you 434 Erica klausen 8/26/2016 10:20 wouldn't hesitate. 5216 Grandview Lane Edina 442 Rick Passolt 8/26/2016 12:53 This is a wonderful idea and use of that land. I support it. 6536 Ridgeview Drive Edina This is a great use of public land that will benefit a large segment of the Edina population. We have a history in Edina of making far-sighted decisions that have made this a great place 447 Jeffrey Kuhs 8/26/2016 14:13 to live - let's continue making our city great. 5837 Chowen Av S Edina, N Let's promote these types of facilities for our kids to keep them active and healthy. This is a sport they can do for their entire 448 Clayt Tabor 8/26/2016 14:23 life. 6024 Grove Circle Edina I think this addition would be a great venue for not only team sports, but also families to also utilize the trails during the cold months. Please consider adding it as you have added other 449 Julie Tonsager Tabor 8/26/2016 14:29 facilities for team sports (such as turf fields) 6024 Grove Circle Edina, N Support this ONLY if EHS cc ski team has access to train and 453 Cathy Kidd 8/26/2016 15:44 compete 5528 Glengarry rd Edina 4 My daughter was on Edina's Nordic Ski team... And so was I back in the 1980's! It is one of the few winter sporting 455 Suzanne Weingartner 8/26/2016 17:07 opportunities where all are welcome to participate. 6904 Dakota Trail Edina 457 Carter Olson 8/26/2016 18:56 Most happen. 4001 wood end dr Edina 458 Jared Sundstrom 8/26/2016 19:29 This sounds like a wonderful idea! 2896 James Ave S Apt 208 Minnear 470 Annelies lijesen 8/27/2016 4:40 I am all for more ski Milages 4804 W Sunnyslope road Edina As a dedicated Nordic skier, both recreational and serious, I 471 Noah calvo 8/27/2016 15:54 insist that the addition of these trails is NECESSARY 5509 Dever Dr Edina 473 Dave Rohlf 8/27/2016 16:10 Great program that really needs our support. 4237 Scott Terrace Edina 475 Jeff Dykstra 8/27/2016 16:22 This would be a great benefit for the city -pls approve 4303 Branson st Edina

478 Seth hannula 8/27/2016 16:39 Better investment than 5 artificial turf fields with crumb rubber 4307 Oakdale av edina 479 Josh riff 8/27/2016 17:00 This would be terrific for our community 7116 Lanham lane Edina 482 Paul Hovelsrud 8/27/2016 17:32 The team and the community need this trail system. 4425 North ave Edina I believe that this project will only add to the overall life 483 steven e klos 8/27/2016 17:40 experience that the Edina community has to offer. 5019 Wooddale Lane Edina I have many friends who participate in xc skiing and having 485 Matthew Holderness 8/27/2016 17:47 more ski trails in Edina is always a good thing. 4604 w 58th street Edina 488 Mike Burg 8/27/2016 18:43 Skiing is a life long activity 5813 Oaklawn Ave. Edina We support the proposal for the cross country ski and mountain 489 Marian Delaney 8/27/2016 18:44 bike trails. 5717 grove st Edina 491 Kaia Burg 8/27/2016 18:46 I love snow and skiing 5813 Oaklawn Ave Edina 507 Timothy Grafe 8/27/2016 20:16 I support adding these trails! 4242 Grimes Av. S. Edina Yes I support this petition. The ski trail will be an asset to the 513 Priya 8/27/2016 21:45 community. 5817 Johnson Drive Edina Help support one of the healthiest winter sports for my 516 Steven Mosborg 8/28/2016 0:28 daughter's generation and beyond. 4430 West Lake Harriet Parkway Minnear

Nordic skiing is a fantastic sport for so many reasons: Minnesota heritage, athleticism, fitness, and enjoying the natural outdoors. It's also great for the whole family and it's a life-long activity. We need to support Nordic skiing in as many ways as we can 521 Elizabeth Cecchi 8/28/2016 3:56 and these trails would be a great asset for our community. 4209 Morningside Rd Edina

5 I would love to be able to ski on trails all season, with snowmaking, at Braemar. Trails at Hyland are very crowded, as are trails at Theodore Wirth. Wirth is expanding because those trails are so popular/busy. Like all trails, they are busiest evening and weekends, when I have time to go. My friends and I would use a Braemar trail 50+times per season. Thanks for your 527 August Blanchett 8/28/2016 18:15 support. 4737 Hibiscus Avenue Edina 531 James 8/28/2016 19:27 Ood 6224 loch moor dr Edina The trails sound like a win win for the city, community and avid 532 Cindy Scott 8/28/2016 19:52 skiers like my nephews who live there. Luling Ln Austin 535 Piotr Bednarski 8/28/2016 22:58 There is a huge demand for this ! lots of people will use it! 3100 Dean Ct Minnear

6 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 3:52 PM Subject: FW: Nordic Trail

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Miriam Martin [mailto:mmartin9520comcast.net] Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 3:37 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic Trail

There are many reasons to oppose this action including noise pollution from ice-mailing machines, disruption to the neighbors, expense, and removal of mature trees.

I urge the council members to accept that a large part of the community is not in favor of it.

Miriam Martin 6519 Biscayne Blvd. Edina 55436

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 8:26 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Winter Sports Facility

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: gary bartolett [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 6:33 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Winter Sports Facility

Vote No on Braemar Winter Sports Proposal

This proposal has too many unanswered questions to move at its present pace. If adopted there is no turning back. The damage is done and cannot be undone. The City will have a facility it is committed to support indefinitely no matter what the results or the costs are. Far too much money is being spent without taking the time to carefully evaluate the need for and consequences of the project.

I attended both the July 13, 2016 Open House and the August 8, 2016 Park Board meeting. Both featured a sales presentation by SEH. The presentation included maps, drawings and pictures of equipment and other projects and were basically identical. There was nothing in the visual materials to indicate scale or scope of the materials to give an impression of what might result in this case. The Open House included time for questions from attendees and a comment card.

Questions at the Open House were generally blown off by the salesman with a statement that "you won't notice anything" without explaining why nothing would be noticed. Noise, lighting and overspray were all questioned without getting much in the way of a response. On noise we learned that the grooming machines are super quiet because they have mufflers, on lighting we were told that the lights point down and will be seen as pinpricks on the horizon, on overspray the water that is ice hard enough to break your knuckles on the hill becomes "angel dust" by the time it reaches the street. I had a very specific question on snowmaking which was met by surprise that I had on the spot temperature records and a statement that their expert did a great job making snow for Vladimir Putin. This did not answer my question on how they planned on making snow at 35 degrees F (or 2 degrees C for Putin).

The Park Board meeting did not allow public questions or comments so all questioning was done by Board members. It would be charitable to call the questioning of SEH shallow. They received the same type of blow off responses as were given at the Open House and seemed to be willing to accept them. Questioning on the financials was somewhat different. One of the members asked some sharp questions which brought out the fact that about one third of the annual operating costs are hidden in the golf course. This means that unless some of the golf course employees do nothing useful in the winter or will work for free during the winter the financials are much worse than those shown. At the conclusion the Board was asked to make a recommendation to the City Council which they appeared unable to do.

1 Contrary to SEH's assertion I do believe we will notice something. We will notice more noise in the middle of the night as the high pressure hoses spit out water. We will notice as the grooming machines break up ice hard enough to break your knuckles on. We will notice the backup alarms every time the machines go in reverse. I had one of the noise meters in my backyard and it was the quietest of the three. In the winter with no foliage the folks at the other locations will have it even worse.

We will not see the lights as pinpricks on the horizon. If you see them from a location near the Southdale water tower where the horizon is miles away this may be true but my horizon is 200 feet away and the lights are above me. I can clearly see objects at that distance the size of the proposed lights. I will see a bar of light across the horizon with brighter full moon sized blobs at each light fixture. There will be diffused light from snow reflection on the entire hillside. Anything that lives on the hill will have perpetual daylight all winter and I will clearly see all activity on the hill; skiers, grooming machines, snow guns and all.

We will notice something from overspray but what is an open question. The SEH statement about ice becoming "angel dust" sounds like alchemy. While we all have seen hot water turn to ice at 20 below that is not quite what we have here. We will be trying to make ice in the twenties when it does not exactly flash freeze. How long it will take the water to freeze and how far it will travel is an open question. SEH has a diagram depicting the overspray zone and it includes all of Gleason Road from Dewey Hill almost to 78th Street. Per SEH the average property on Gleason Road is closer to the snowmaking operation than any at Hyland and Gleason Road is closer than the properties. At its closest approach Gleason Road may be within range of the snow guns. If ice is produced rather than "angel dust" the roadway will become extremely dangerous. This stretch of Gleason annually seems to lose several mailboxes and the occasional light standard to cars losing control on ice. I have seen cars go off the road on both sides in slippery conditions. If someone is in the wrong place at the wrong time they could be killed. This fear is not alleviated by the SEH statement that the skiing enterprise is so important that ice making may be done under less than optimal conditions and the surrounding area must accept the consequences of doing so.

The amount of destruction involved in this project is amazing. SEH was not able to discuss the number of trees to be destroyed or the amount of grading required but both are obviously large. A 50 foot clear cut that doubles back on itself in places and has switchbacks may require removing 25 percent or more of the trees. The northeast side of the hill will require substantial grading to carry the highway up the hill and through the switchbacks to the top. The remainder of the highway will require some grading to provide a plane for skiing. In the end we will have a bald hilltop with a thin fringe of greenery around it. The current path will be obliterated.

The financials on this project are a horror. From the information provided and assuming that the cost and revenue estimates are accurate all of the initial cost and about one-third of the annual operating costs are born by the taxpayers. If any of the estimates are optimistic it gets worse. Using standard accounting principles and 30 year amortization of debt service Edina taxpayers are paying two thirds of the cost and skiers one third. Stated another way, for every 75 dollar season pass sold non skiing taxpayers pay 150 dollars. More parochially, it is a great deal for Minnetonka skiers not for Edina taxpayers.

For these and many other reasons you should vote no on this proposal.

Gary L. Bartolett

7421 Gleason Road

Edina, Minnesota

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 8:29 AM Subject: FW: Nordic Ski Track

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: DEAN&MARY [mailto:dmswan2124(aconncast.net] Sent: Monday, August 29, 2016 9:26 PM To: Edina Mail Cc: mary and dean swanson Subject: Nordic Ski Track

We vote NO on this project. Where did it come from?? Why didn't anyone hear about it until it is just about a done deal?

It benefits very few, taking out beautiful trees, increasing pollution, running at a loss, increasing taxes. Nobody asked for it, just a company wanting to make money.

Do not let one person's greed contribute to ruining Edina's environment.

It reminds us of the subdivision on Blackfoot Pass that happened three years ago. It is a mess, all the trees on lower lot removed, not a pretty sight on our street. We still wonder how planning and zoning can vote against it and it sails through the council? Three people made money, the owners sons and Scott Busyn. The sales photos in magazines show the address will be Cheyenne Trail. That means that Scott will somehow get a variance to tear down the 60 year old historical brick wall and take out more oak trees. Mayor Hovelands last words were "Scott, I think this will be a beautiful addition to the neighborhood".

I invite all of you to go and see it now sad.

Respectfully, Mary and Dean Swanson 6617 Cheyenne Tr

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 10:01 AM Subject: FW: Braemar project

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Mabotb(thaol.conn [mailto:Mabotb(aaol.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 9:55 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar project

Please vote NO -- we do not need more unfunded city debt, we do not need this ill-conceived plan to destroy trees (& not address buckthorn problem) -- this project disregards the continuing effects of climate change (i.e., needing repeated artificial snow-production) -- etc, etc, etc!

Mary A. Bang 5200 Duggan Plaza Edina, 55439

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 9:22 AM Subject: FW: 9/7 letter of consideration-please read

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Marlese Alden [mailto:marlesekvyahoo.corn] Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 8:27 AM To: James Hovland Subject: 9/7 letter of consideration-please read

Dear Mayor Holland,

As a resident of the Braemar/Dewey Hill neighborhood for 30 years, I would like to ask you to vote NO on the Nordic Ski track plan. I believe it is a plan full of flaws and problems for my neighborhood. I ask that you consider these issues:

The noise and disruption of the construction

The noise and disruption of the traffic to and from the finished facility

The grinding noise from the snow-making machines nightly

The icy condition of Gleason Road-have you considered the lawsuits?

The annoyance of the outdoor night-time lighting

The huge cost of the project

And most disturbing to me the deforestation of the beautiful wildlife area near me

Instead of being an asset to this neighborhood, it will become a liability with the increased traffic and removal of the beautiful park-like setting we enjoy. My property value will decrease because of this plan. The traffic and foot traffic congestion will be distressing. Please vote NO for this plan as it stands. I ask that you consider a less costly, less destructive revision of this 3 million dollar plan.

I thank you for listening by reading this letter.

Sincerely,

Marlese Alden

7424 Hyde Park Drive

(1 block from Gleason Rd.)

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 10:21 AM Subject: FW: Mountain biking trails in Edina

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: P Seng [mailto:pseng2012(agnnail.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 9:59 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Mountain biking trails in Edina

To the Edina City Council,

As a lifelong enthusiast of various outdoor sports, and a 20+ year Edina resident, I have heard much discussion over the years about Edina developing some single-track mountain biking trails. This would be a great asset to the residents of our community. Edina has thousands of residents who bicycle, and many of these cyclists also enjoy mountain biking on good mountain biking trails. Currently, the closest mountain biking trail to the center of Edina (Hwy 62 & Hwy 100) is Theodore Wirth Park in Minneapolis which is 10 miles away via some busy roads. The next closest options are Lebanon Hills in Apple Valley (20 miles away), or Elm Creek Park Reserve (25 miles away).

Each Mountain Bike park location in the Twin Cities area is a beautiful wooded area where the trails are very narrow, and there is virtually no disruption to the local flora / fauna. Many of these locations also intersperse walking / hiking trails for residents as well. In my experience, Mountain Bike park locations tend to be very quiet / peaceful locations, as bikers tend to be quiet because they are busy exercising just like joggers / walkers / etc.

In addition to the many local adults who enjoy mountain biking, Edina also has a large contingent of youth riders including the Edina Cycling Team. This team consists of Edina students in high school and middle school who compete with other teams from Minnesota at larger and more remote cycling venues. For these student athletes to practice, they must bicycle across the metro during rush hour to access other Mountain Biking trail systems.

The Braemar location has been often discussed as a good location for Mountain Bike trails, and based on my experience, I believe this to be true. The terrain, with some hills and beautiful woods, would be ideal. The footprint / impact of the trail systems tend to be minimal, and the overall impact to a wooded area is minimal, because the trails are intended to fit into an existing landscape.

Mountain Biking trails also tend to be low cost because there is so little disruption to the natural environment. Additionally, the trails are a year-round amenity with many people now fat-biking in the winter on snow covered trails. (no snow-making required).

Offering an amenity such as Mountain Biking trails would be an asset to our community. Our residents have repeatedly supported bicycling and walking trails in various surveys. It's an important thing to have locally, giving our Edina resident riders a great location to which they can more safely navigate, instead of trying to bicycle across the metro in search of other Mountain Bike trails.

A walking trail in the woods around the Braemar Park area would also be very nice amenity for the residents living in the immediate area surrounding Braemar, and would co-exist nicely with Mountain Biking trails.

Thank you for your consideration of this topic.

Peter Seng 4522 Drexel Ave Edina, MN 55424

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 10:22 AM Subject: FW: The photo of the proposed Braemar project appears deceptive

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoaEdinaMN.qov l www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Harlan Limpert [mailto:HLimpert(auua.orq] Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 10:03 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: The photo of the proposed Braemar project appears deceptive

I'm concerned. The attached photo shows the proposed Braemar project. The assumption a person would make when looking at the photo is that the trail is to scale. But it simply cannot be.

Information shared by the City of Edina is that the trail is 50 feet wide. In the photo, the trail looks pencil-thin. My home is visible in the photo, at the end of Tanglewood Court. (7737 Tanglewood Court.) The length of my home and my neighbors (it's a twin-home) is 84-feet. The trail, if it were drawn to scale, would be over half the length of our home. In fact, the trail, when compared to our home, appears to be about 15-feet wide in most places and 25-feet wide at the widest parts.

If the photo is not to scale, it is at best misleading, and at worst, unethical to use it to promote the project.

Please respond. This seems like an extremely important detail that will affect Edina citizen's perception of the wisdom of the project.

Thank you.

Sincerely,

Li

Rev. Harlan Limpert I Chief Operating Officer Phone (612) 669-0574 I [email protected] uua.org I Twitter I Facebook N Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 10:26 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Winter Proposal Images Attachments: Trail Alignments Machine Madejpg; Primary Alignment City Websitejpg; To ski or not to ski (1).pdf; Braemar Images to Scale.PNG; Totally Tubular July 2016jpg

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Kristin Kiser Reichling [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 12:29 AM To: Edina Mail Cc: Ann Kattreh; Scott H. Neal Subject: Braemar Winter Proposal Images

Dear City Council Members, I would like to call your attention to issues with the most common images used in official city communications regarding the Braemar Winter Recreation proposal. MJ Lamon was kind enough to ask SEH about the images at my request, since they do not appear to be to scale, using Gleason Road as the example. The width of Gleason is 32'. The ski trails are estimated to be 50' wide.

SEH confirmed to MJ that the images were to scale, so I asked for a more detailed explanation. Mike Horn, from SEH, then stated that several images are not to scale, and were not intended to be to scale. He mentions "artistic liberty" and "an alignment exercise." That would be fine, if the lack of scale were clearly labeled and if there were accompanying explanations similar to what he stated in his response to MJ.

The challenge at hand is that the average person is not familiar with SEH design documents. The average person does not know the width of Gleason Road. It is highly likely that people are inaccurately assuming that the footprint of the proposed ski trails is far smaller than it really is. It's fair to say that a reader of the "Totally Tubular" article would assume that the accompanying picture is to scale.

By using images that contain artistic liberties and are not labeled as such, the city is essentially misleading residents. This proposal is very expensive, unbudgeted and would irrevocably change the landscape at Braemar. People are writing letters and trying to influence how the council votes. People who are supporting this proposal may be inclined to ask the council to slow down, rather than approve the SEH design, if they would have been exposed to more realistic images all along.

The city should replace images that are not to scale on Facebook and other social media, and on the city website. While it is far too late to try to reeducate the public on the actual effects on the Braemar landscape, I hope you will keep these points in mind as you consider your vote on September 7th. I ask you all to not approve the SEH proposal as written. It is highly likely that some of the proponents of the design, or people who are currently neutral on the proposal, were not aware of the real ski trail size, given the images to which they have had the most access. Thank you, Kristin Reichling

References: Mike Horn Email Response to City Staff (below) Image: "Braemar Images to Scale" (Email initially confirming that the images were to scale) Image: "Trail Alignments Machine Made" (The image that Mike attached to his email. This is to scale.) Image: "Totally Tubular" (The image featured in the Star Tribune and contains "artistic liberty." This is by far the most widely seen picture since it was in the Star Tribune. It is also the picture that was used in both petitions and in other social media outlets. It's the most popular image being sent around, probably because it was in the Star Tribune and therefore assumed to be realistic.) Image: "Primary Alignment City Website" (Located on the city website. This is an "alignment exercise" and is not to scale.) Sun Current Article: "To Ski or Not to Ski" (These images are also not to scale. While there is no date on this article, the Sun Current staff confirmed that it was published.)

Of Note: MJ Lamon has been extremely accommodating and responsive in tracking down answers to my questions.

From: Mike Horn [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 9:37 AM To: MJ Lamon Cc: Ann Kattreh ; Paul Pasko Subject: Re: Fwd: Communications Regarding Braemar Winter Proposal

MJ, the plan view image represents the trail alignment only, and does not represent the trail width, this was a preliminary graphic for an alignment exercise.

The graphic attached, in the report and the power point that was shown at the Public Meeting and Park Board Meeting, is a scaled representation of the potential trail clearing limits.

The Snowmaking Spill graphic is an aerial image with no control, i.e., no set elevation from which the photo was taken, no X on the ground to scale an image with, etc., thus is NOT a scaled image. The trail alignment shown is there for reference only and much artistic liberty was taken to make it appear like it was down on the ground not up in the tree tops as the image that someone else provided. As intended, this was to represent the potential snow spill from the snowmaking process and the impact to the neighborhood.

I hope this helps, let me know if you need anything else.

Michael Horn, PLA SEH 10901 Red Circle Drive, Minnetonka, MN 55343 320.248.7244 cell 612.255.4030 office sehinc.com Building a Better World for All of Us®

2 i t

t.

*

r

PRIMARY ALIGNMENT

ALTERNATE 1

ALTERNATE 2

NATURAL SNOW CONNECTION

TURNAROUND

BEGINNER ALIGNMENT 40•410ft INTERMEDIATE ALIGNMENT 11•WPW EXPERT ALIGNMENT TUBE LIFT

TUBING AREA

CLEARING AND GRUBBING LIMITS

PROPOSED GOLF COURSE TEE BOX

PROPOSED GOLF COURSE GREEN

PROPOSED GOLF COURSE 7-FAIRWAY ICCI"

1E0 A Winter Recreation at Braemar Park SEH

Cross-Country Ski Trail Alignment July 13, 2016 Legend --- Hiner). Cross Country Ski fillipment

▪ Anomaly* t Cross Gauntry Sb Angnment • M. Artsrnnt•.rr 2 Crass CrAinlry Sin Nignitirot Tate L41 Cross Country Ski Alignniont Turnorounn Tubing ken Privalaty aimed Property

Prepini '.1:014137403 rrnaand Mato 11.1.17Mt2.11S \A/IMTFP prr-.PpATIrThl AT RPAPAAAP DARK I _. Is tubing, cross country skiing in Braemar's future?

BY ETHAN 6ROOTHUIS nine lanes that aren't getting a revenue stream through sure GUMUT REW,MPEFIR used in the new Braemar Golf concessions at Tin Fish and Course design as it drops an elevated green that could Plans for a winter recre- from 27 to 18 holes, they are be converted into snowtubing ation facility at Braemar took making the land mutually ex- and snowboarding lanes. an uncertain but progressive clusive to golfing and winter A north-facing tubing hill step forward as the Edina activities. could fit six lanes for tubing City Council directed staff to The biggest components of with the right amount of slow look at a feasibility study for the winter activities in both down run out. A northwest- cross country skiing trails and cost and potential revenue facing tubing hill in the ex- snowtubing, among other ac- would be snowtubing and isting 21st hole could fit five tivities. cross country skiing. lanes and is naturally is slow- Paul Pasko, an engineer Some of the elements at er and would be more suited at SEH, presented plans for Braemar that the winter rec- for younger riders. activities that would use the reation site could use to the Both hills would have han- land freed up from the re- advantage of the taxpayers dle tow lanes to automatically duction in lanes at the golf is an existing well, which was bring tubers back up to the course. taken out of circulation for top of the hill, which Pasko "You have a unique op- drinking, running electrical said is also beneficial so that portunity that a lot of people power for snow making, an "grandma and grandpa aren't don't have," Pasko said, say- already constructed paved ing that using the area of the parking lot, the ability to add BRAEMAR -TO PAGE 10 option, which would be the main way to do this without impact to Brae a revenue source for the course. new hole number 10. I think it Dave Belin of RRC Associ- would be a lot more expensive PROM PAGE ates explained some of the mon- that way." ey breakdowns, including what Mayor James Hovland was forced to walk up the hill." the city would stand to gain on a cautious about moving forward Windrows of snow would pre- financial level. without a public meeting, espe- vent people from the different "If you don't invest in the cially since bidding, a feasibil- lanes from running into each front end, it would be substan- ity study and a design study as other, but would have enough tially smaller," Belin said, "It it is was proposed to be voted on room in each lane for multiple smaller, it won't be as attractive before the meeting would cost tubes to be attached to each to high school racing leagues or $330,000. The snowmaking pro- other. intermediate and expert skiers." cess may also have overspray "What is the fun if you can't They estimated ticketing at $9 on the closest neighborhood, leash each other together and for a day of Nordic skiing and which-would require the city to scream all the way down?" Pas- $75 for a season pass. For tub- do extra snow cleanup on days ko said. ing, it would be $12 for a two- where there is no natural snow- The plan also called for 3 ki- hour session. fall, such as what is done around lometers of Nordic skiing, in- If it did a short season of Highlands in Bloomington. eluding nearly a kilometer of 70 days, Belin estimated that it "I think all of us have seen beginner track, 1.45 kilometers would break even in year one or feel the wisdom of making of intermediate track and .75 hi- with a $120,000 revenue and Braemar a year-round recre- lometers of expert track. make about a 10 percent mar- ational facility," Hovland said. Snowboarding, snowshoeing, gin in the fifth year at about "Although we know that bond fat tire biking in the winter and $144,000. where the golf course itself pays mountain biking in the summer A longer season of 84 days it off, it is still a debt load that • could all be incorporated into would see about $138,000 in we are taking on, 6,7, 8 million the same areas, bringing a large year one, a 3 percent margin and in debt that we think the golf range of outdoor activity to the 12 percent in year five. course can handle. This is just Braemar course. If it skipped out on tubing such foreign territory. There is On top of lighting for the and only did Nordic skiing, the .an element of discomfort." trails for skiers to come before city would be losing money ev- But Hovland didn't like not or after work, equipment re- ery year until possibly the fifth asking neighborhoods what quired for the endeavor includes year when it would be barely they felt about the project until electricity and water for smow- breaking even. after bids were already ordered. making. . Another way it could make "It's a fait accompli that you Snowmaking machines, in- money is from the high school are going to have this ... this is eluding a hose and cable, blows team, who will be losing Hornet not the kind of process we have snow at such a high pressure that Hill after the subsequent Nine around here," Hovland said. it essentially atomizes water. Mile Creek trail and high school The council was able to nego- "This is not the snow like addition construction takes tiate a new schedule during the you think ... it is more ice than away from its practice hills. meeting that would still have snow," Pasko said. "You need "We have had significant dis- a feasibility study, as well as machines like Caterpillers to cussions with these trails. The adding a public meeting in Sep- break it down." high school is very interested in tember before calling for bids. Grooming machines would moving their Nordic operation Neighborhood meetings will be- need to run over the trails, which to Braemar," said Parks and gin in the middle of July. are at least 10 feet wide, requir- Recreation Director Ann Kat- Despite the change in sched- ing the paths to be 25 feet for treh. "Conversations so far have ule, Councilmember Bob Stew- machine turnaround. been about purchasing season art still was not on board. Other than grooming, the passes. That is standard in the "I like the idea of Nordic snowmaking would be run by industry. High schools purchase, skiing but also snowshoeing," computers, which would find the season passes." Stewart said. "I think all of us optimum snowmaking weather Unlike other projects, the like the concept of expanding to crank out the required snow quick time line on buying for de- and offering those kids of ame- windrows, which would mostly sign studies and bidding before nities. Having said that, I am suf- happen at night. getting public impact gave some feting from some sticker shock. Other cost savings would conic council members pause. Snowtubing has not been a huge from having concurrent con- "I would say this is somewhat priority for me, when we are in struction with the golf course, a unique situation," Kattreh a competitive enviromnent, it is including pipe installation and said. "We talked about it early not good to have a new product a pump house that would inter- on in that because of the time be the second rate product. If we fere with hole number 10 during line we are working on where are going to have a snowtubing regular season play. we are trying to move this in line hill, make it competitive with However, the cost is roughly with the golf course, doing a others to make it equal to or bet- estimated at $2-3 million, mostly feasibility study at the same time ter than the others. due to the power need to pump that we are preparing bid docu- "At this point, we have spent the water. ments. We mentioned [the time between $50,000 and $60,000 Without the high level of line] as one of the drawbacks. learning what we have learned," pumping, tubing wouldn't be an But .. I think there would be no he continued. "I have no ••-• .••• • • ...rev% • -••

• -v....ft-. ••••••

rhe above graphic details the three cross country courses, beginner in green, intermediate in blue and expert in black. Below, the two yellow paths show the potential tubing lanes. (Submitted graphics)

appetite to spend $330,000 to follow that lead." study this and design things. I The motion for a feasibility think it is good money after bad. study at $130,000 and an up- I don't think it is wise when there dated project schedule was ap- are so many uncertainties we proved 4-1, Stewart being the haven't addressed ... I'm going dissenting vote. to oppose this motion tonight. And I would like to suggest Contact Ethan Groothuis at that my fellow council members et ham grooth uis@ecm-inc corn. MJ Lamon, Project Coordinator 052-828-0340 I Fsx 552.828-0390 [email protected] wv,v; Ed,naf,M (4ov

From: Kristin Kiser Reichling [mailto:kristinare chlingPemail.comj Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2016 7:37 PM To: MJ Lamon Cc: Ann Kattreh Subject: Re: FW: Communications Regarding Braemar Winter Proposal

Hello MJ and Ann, I apologize for the second message this evening. Attached are two renderings that show the proposed trail and tubing hill to scale. I think the issue of scale was more with the ski trail being too narrow than tubing, but both are attached. Since the project description on the city website and the Facebook and Nextdoor pages feature a drawing that is not to scale, could these renderings be used instead, or minimally_ could the pictures be footnoted that the drawings are not to scale? Most people would assume the drawings would be to scale, so they might be getting the wrong impression regarding the actual size of the ski trail and need for snow-making. We have confirmed with our consultant that the pictures we have our to scale.

I heard back from Ethan at the Sun Current. He said the "To Ski or not to Ski" article ran but he doesn't know why it's not coming up in the search. He was going, to fix that. I appreciate you finding the article. I definitely missed reading it. Glad he followed up. I could not find it either so it was kind of a mystery to me too.

Thank you, Kristin 11 •--45, agr — m —

'1131 11".

• re.*1 0,36473/P. -4;

.11.1ups -

14

— — - 10. lawmr_ — -- I ' Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 10:37 AM Subject: FW: iPettion for Braemar park skiing with snowmaking Attachments: 2016 08 31 Petition for braemar kiing snowmaking.pdf

(16-nv, Lynette Biunno, Receptionist ) 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Jarvinen [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 10:36 AM To: Edina Mail Cc: 'Noah'; lune turnbull'; [email protected]; 'Hinrichs, Anne'; 'Paul Gage'; fotnessOgmail.conn Subject: iPettion for Braemar park skiing with snowmaking

Dear Edina City Council,

Attached is the online petition in support of cross country skiing with snowmaking in Braemar Park as of August 31, 2016. This includes all 587 online signers with their comments. This does not include the 151 additional signers who completed the paper version of this petition. Total petition signers is 738 in support. The majority of the signers of from Edina, MN.

Please vote yes for snowmaking and cross country ski trails in Braemar Park!

Craig Jarvinen

612-747-1677 [email protected] This petition has collected 587 signatures using the online tools at iPetitions.com

Printed on 2016-08-31

Page 1 of 72 SUPPORT CROSS COUNTRY SKIING AT BRAEMAR PARK WITH SNOWMAKING

About this petition

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

• Edina parks are for all to enjoy. Braemar Park, with 450 acres, is Edina's largest park. The proposed trail will open the door for people to enjoy Braemar Park's natural beauty during the winter. The trails can also be used for walking, jogging and bird watching during the warmer seasons. • Edina residents have consistently asked the city for more trails of all kinds, so the City of Edina has responded with high quality designs for a national class cross country ski trail with 3km of snowmaking. • Cross country skiing is a silent sport that offers an active and healthy lifestyle for Edina residents. • Edina will be a leader, by being one of the first cities in the area to offer this amazingly popular amenity for residents. • Cross country ski trails with manmade snow are in very short supply. There are only three other such trails in the metropolitan area. These three trails are in high demand, often congested. The proposed trail will help in a big way to meet the growing needs of cross country skiers of all ages in Edina as well as providing an additional option for neighboring communities. • The Edina Nordic Ski Team, the third largest sport at Edina High School with 200 athletes, has been practicing at the high school for many years, but that practice area will soon shrink dramatically due to new construction projects. After next year, the team will no longer have a place for most of the team to practice. The proposed ski trail at Braemar Park will alleviate that problem. • Approval of the proposed ski trail will cost the average Edina homeowner approximately $20 per year over the next 10 years. Operating revenues are expected to cover operating expenses after the trails become established over the next 3-4 years. Most endeavors operated by the City of Edina for residents do not generate enough revenue to cover operating costs. The Edina pool and the Edina liquor store are two notable exceptions. Therefore, cross country ski trails with snowmaking will be a welcome addition to Edina's rich array of amenities. • For more information about the project, visit http://edinamn.gov/index.php?section=winterrecbraemar

Page 2 of 72 Signatures

1. Name: Noah Swiler on 2016-08-18 16:56:37 Comments: I enthusiastically support the effort to make this wonderful recreational activity more accessible to Edina families! Street Address: 6108 Arbour Lane City of Residence: Edina

2. Name: julie turnbull on 2016-08-18 17:00:31 Comments: Street Address: 5437 Halifax Lane City of Residence: Edina, Mn

3. Name: Lori McNelis on 2016-08-18 19:16:29 Comments: Street Address: 5525 Hansen Rd. #110 City of Residence: Edina

4. Name: Paul Gage on 2016-08-18 19:52:32 Comments: Nordic skiing is my family's favorite winter activity. A trail system at Braemar Park will put to good use the underutilized resources available without impacting the golf operation. Snowmaking will guarantee this a successful endeavor. Street Address: 5813 Amy Dr City of Residence: Edina

5. Name: Leonard Bernstein on 2016-08-18 21:05:29 Comments: Street Address: 5808 Brook Drive City of Residence: Edina, MN

6. Name: Max Thiele on 2016-08-18 23:18:00 Comments: This petition makes some great points as a counter to the petition against. Street Address: 5524 Code Ave City of Residence: Edina

Name: Jeff Kirkwold on 2016-08-19 00:48:31 Comments: Our son is a Nordic skier at EHS Street Address: 5720 32nd Ave N City of Residence: Crystal

8. Name: Craig Jarvinen on 2016-08-19 01:23:46 Comments: Street Address: 4113 Chowen Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

Page 3 of 72 9. Name: Jeff Jackson on 2016-08-19 01:35:38 Comments: I'll come visit your park if you build it! Street Address: 124 Paisley Lane City of Residence: Golden Valley

10. Name: Rhoda Bernstein on 2016-08-19 01:38:51 Comments: Street Address: 5808 Brook Drive City of Residence: Edina

11. Name: Kevin Johnson on 2016-08-19 01:42:15 Comments: This project will help people from all over the state of Minnesota to learn a life- long activity which will increase their physical, mental and emotional well-being. Street Address: 1466 Brompton St City of Residence: Saint Paul

12. Name: Andy Keller on 2016-08-19 01:45:39 Comments: Street Address: 8831 Lake Susan Ct. City of Residence: Chanhassen

13. Name: anne rykken on 2016-08-19 01:47:27 Comments: Street Address: 1311 Arlington Ave W City of Residence: St. Paul

14. Name: ingrid leask on 2016-08-19 01:53:59 Comments: Street Address: 3455 shoreline dr apt b wayzata mn 55391 City of Residence: wayzata

15. Name: Michael Bleakmore on 2016-08-19 02:09:47 Comments: Street Address: 4624 43rd Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

16. Name: Nathan Porath DDS on 2016-08-19 02:09:50 Comments: Snowmaking is such an asset for any trail system. I will be so jeolous of all the amenaties that Edina has, but look forward to making the trip up to visit them. Street Address: 906 Crocus Ct City of Residence: Northfield

17. Name: Amy Cichanowski on 2016-08-19 02:10:37 Comments: We need to build our winter recreation opportunities in all of our communities. This is for the health and well being of our children. There is plenty of research to

Page 4 of 72 support how important being outside is for children (and adults). We live in MN and need to embrace winter! Street Address: 3320 Lyndale Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

18. Name: Ari Mahonen on 2016-08-19 02:15:06 Comments: Street Address: 1031 Winnetka Ave N City of Residence: Golden Valley

19. Name: Tyler olson on 2016-08-19 02:16:21 Comments: Would be great to have another place to ski! Street Address: 7075 gardenia ct City of Residence: Apple Valley

20. Name: Greg Klave on 2016-08-19 02:20:53 Comments: I would buy a pass to ski there! Street Address: 2636 30th Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

21. Name: Sasha Goftarsh on 2016-08-19 02:29:59 Comments: Street Address: 2905 stratton cir City of Residence: Minnetonka

22. Name: Martin Burg on 2016-08-19 02:31:35 Comments: Edina needs ski trails!!! Street Address: 5813 Oaklawn Ave City of Residence: Edina

23. Name: Jim Agre on 2016-08-19 02:33:33 Comments: This would be a great addition for the Edina park system. You will get lots of folks, who will purchase trail passes. Street Address: 175 Maple St, Excelsior,MN City of Residence: Excelsior

24. Name: Thomas SHaw on 2016-08-19 02:53:31 Comments: I am a coach with the Edina High Cross Country Ski Team. This would be a huge asset to the team- especially since the school expansion and the appropriation of a considerable amount of the present trail for a paved trail will make it nearly impossible for the team to have meaningful, affordable practice. Street Address: 116 W 49th St City of Residence: Minneapolis

25. Name: Bill van deaf on 2016-08-19 02:59:30

Page 5 of 72 Comments: I love braemer, and know it would make a world class nordic ski course. As a resident of Minnetonka, there a few option for skiers in this part of the metro. Having a top knotch facility like braemar available would definitely have me voting with my wallet. Street Address: 16601 Blenheim way City of Residence: Minnetonka

26. Name: Elizabeth Mahan on 2016-08-19 03:11:07 Comments: Street Address: 116 West 49th Street City of Residence: Minneapolis

27. Name: Alice Flanders on 2016-08-19 03:13:16 Comments: Yes please. Street Address: 6209 France Ave City of Residence: Edina

28. Name: Jay Adams on 2016-08-19 03:26:54 Comments: Street Address: 5801 Bernard pl City of Residence: Edina

29. Name: Dan Berntson on 2016-08-19 04:01:24 Comments: Street Address: 6728 point dr City of Residence: Edina

30. Name: Anne Hinrichs on 2016-08-19 04:06:03 Comments: Street Address: 4112 W 44th St City of Residence: Edina

31. Name: Matt liebsch on 2016-08-19 04:30:46 Comments: We need more outside rec items like this Street Address: Dakota City of Residence: Orono

32. Name: Torsten Brinkema on 2016-08-19 04:34:33 Comments: Street Address: 3425 Holmes Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

33. Name: Erica Wagner on 2016-08-19 04:38:45 Comments: Street Address: 1318 north 19th Avenue east City of Residence: Duluth

Page 6 of 72 34. Name: Landon Hunter Brodersen on 2016-08-19 04:44:48 Comments: Street Address: 13570 Technology Drive #2220 City of Residence: Eden Prairie

35. Name: Spencer Davis on 2016-08-19 04:54:17 Comments: Street Address: 2730 Acorn Road City of Residence: Chaska

36. Name: Miles Prahl on 2016-08-19 05:18:07 Comments: Street Address: 9049 Hyland Creek Rd City of Residence: Bloomington

37. Name: Jess Fauchier on 2016-08-19 05:42:20 Comments: Street Address: 3208 Maryland Ave North City of Residence: Crystal, MN 55427

38. Name: VAL Host on 2016-08-19 08:14:37 Comments: Street Address: 1311 Kenilworth Dr City of Residence: Woodbury

39. Name: Mary K Bauer on 2016-08-19 10:50:09 Comments: Street Address: 5340 36th Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

40. Name: Beau Larson on 2016-08-19 11:07:29 Comments: Street Address: 1511 Russell ave n City of Residence: Minneapolis

41. Name: Tom Ferry on 2016-08-19 11:53:20 Comments: Street Address: 1366 Schletti St City of Residence: St Paul

42. Name: Josh Larson on 2016-08-19 12:29:21 Comments: Street Address: 5843 Scenic Drive City of Residence: Minnetonka

Page 7 of 72 43. Name: Vilanouth Inthasorot on 2016-08-19 12:31:51 Comments: I would love to see this park being done. Street Address: 6509 regency In City of Residence: Eden Prairie

44. Name: Kevin Murphy on 2016-08-19 12:54:52 Comments: Street Address: 583 Lois Lane City of Residence: Lino Lakes

45. Name: Clayton Keim on 2016-08-19 13:06:24 Comments: As a resident a few miles north of this, I would love to see this addition to Edina. It would be a closer place to ski than driving to Hyland or Elm Creek. Nordic skiing is a lifelong sport as well, so it has major lifelong benefits for those that get into it. Amenities like this help make a community stand out as well raising the standard of living even further for Edina. With obesity being a problem among our society, we need more places like this. Street Address: 2837 Quentin Ave City of Residence: St. Louis Park

46. Name: Doug Debold on 2016-08-19 13:09:17 Comments: Street Address: 707 W 31st Street Unit 2 City of Residence: Minneapolis

47. Name: Dan Zenner on 2016-08-19 13:09:23 Comments: Street Address: 5201 Tifton Drive City of Residence: Edina

48. Name: Stan C Hokanson on 2016-08-19 13:10:17 Comments: Street Address: 44 Robb Farm Road City of Residence: North Oaks

49. Name: Brendan on 2016-08-19 13:21:08 Comments: Street Address: 5809 Arbour City of Residence: Edina

50. Name: BRIGITTE KETTERSON on 2016-08-19 13:29:01 Comments: Street Address: 9725 XYLON CT S City of Residence: BLOOMINGTON

Page 8 of 72 51. Name: Ben Dubay on 2016-08-19 13:38:00 Comments: Street Address: 10707 107th Place N City of Residence: Maple Grove

52. Name: Tim kokes on 2016-08-19 13:39:56 Comments: Street Address: 14873 sumter ave City of Residence: Savage

53. Name: Erin Beyer on 2016-08-19 13:42:53 Comments: Street Address: 6425 Wilryan ave City of Residence: Edina

54. Name: Mauricio Raigosa on 2016-08-19 13:59:29 Comments: Street Address: 5605 warden ave City of Residence: Edina

55. Name: Kathryn Jarvinen on 2016-08-19 14:03:56 Comments: This is great and so good for healthy youth (and adults). It is fun and prevents obesity. Street Address: 1750 Gilmore Ave City of Residence: Winona, MN 55987

56. Name: Brian Gregg on 2016-08-19 14:16:28 Comments: Street Address: 627 Thomas Ave N City of Residence: Minneapolis

57. Name: Caitlin Gregg on 2016-08-19 14:22:45 Comments: Street Address: 627 Thomas Ave. N City of Residence: Minneapolis

58. Name: Dan Rasmussen on 2016-08-19 14:22:58 Comments: This is something the city of Edina and the greater metro area could greatly use. It promotes a lifelong sport that is so heathy and supportive of our great winters in MN! Street Address: 6916 W 105th St City of Residence: Bloomington

59. Name: Triana on 2016-08-19 14:25:38

Page 9 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 4544 Rutledge avenue City of Residence: Edina

60. Name: Steven Yore on 2016-08-19 14:26:10 Comments: Street Address: 501 Theodore Wirth Parkway City of Residence: Golden Valley

61. Name: Kevin Brochman on 2016-08-19 14:31:03 Comments: This will keep people happy active and healthy. Street Address: 1776 dayton ave. City of Residence: St. Paul mn

62. Name: Alye DeRoma on 2016-08-19 14:35:56 Comments: Street Address: 2019 Oakview lane north City of Residence: Plymouth

63. Name: Larry Myers on 2016-08-19 14:38:38 Comments: I am a Nordic High School Coach and this would really help all High School skiing! Street Address: 3740 Evergreen In N City of Residence: Plymouth

64. Name: Emily Ruth Johnson on 2016-08-19 14:43:38 Comments: Street Address: 2042 Lincoln Ave. City of Residence: St. Paul, MN

65. Name: Terese Holden on 2016-08-19 14:46:13 Comments: Great addition to enhance community health and family fun Street Address: 5609 W 66th St. City of Residence: Edina

66. Name: Matthew Clarke on 2016-08-19 14:48:08 Comments: Street Address: 6100 W 94th Street City of Residence: Bloomington

67. Name: Henry on 2016-08-19 15:00:24 Comments: Street Address: 5112 Bedford Ave City of Residence: Edina

Page 10 of 72 68. Name: Amelia Svenningsen on 2016-08-19 15:04:38 Comments: XC ski trails at braemar would be a great addition to our community! Street Address: 6028 Berne circle City of Residence: Edina

69. Name: Brenner Sandberg on 2016-08-19 15:05:57 Comments: Street Address: 2917 Valle Vista St. City of Residence: New Hope

70. Name: Oscar Friedman on 2016-08-19 15:08:06 Comments: Go Team CXC Street Address: 310 W Kaye ave City of Residence: Marauegg

71. Name: Oscar Friedman on 2016-08-19 15:09:17 Comments: Street Address: 316 W kaye ave City of Residence: Marquette

72. Name: Sam Maret on 2016-08-19 15:14:08 Comments: Street Address: 515 20th Avenue South City of Residence: Minneapolis

73. Name: Andrew Elvester on 2016-08-19 15:16:13 Comments: Street Address: 2401 Forest Meadow Cir City of Residence: Minnetonka

74. Name: Kyle lidstone on 20'16-08-19 15:16:46 Comments: Consistently maintained trails at Braemar would help further broaden and strengthen the Nordic community in the metro area. Street Address: 12608 orchard Rd. City of Residence: Minnetonka

75. Name: Jack Swiler on 2016-08-19 15:18:05 Comments: Street Address: 6108 Arbour Lane City of Residence: Edina

76. Name: Dina Pesenson on 2016-08-19 15:22:49 Comments: Street Address: 1355 45th St City of Residence: Los Alamos

Page 11 of 72 77. Name: John Robert Shirriff on 2016-08-19 15:24:21 Comments: Street Address: 9608 Wyoming Terrace South City of Residence: Bloomington

78. Name: Melissa Shirriff on 2016-08-19 15:27:20 Comments: Street Address: 9608 Wyoming Terrace City of Residence: Bloomington

79. Name: Zak Ketterson on 2016-08-19 15:29:47 Comments: Street Address: 9725 Xylon Ct S City of Residence: Bloomington

80. Name: Carrie Ellingson on 2016-08-19 15:31:34 Comments: Street Address: 12806 lone oak dr. City of Residence: Minnetonka

81. Name: Gene Kay on 2016-08-19 15:34:39 Comments: I am a Three Rivers Park Commissioner and an out-door enthusiast. I strongly support this effort. Street Address: 415 Queensland Ln City of Residence: Plymouth

82. Name: Erik Gilder on 2016-08-19 15:38:29 Comments: Street Address: 5108 Abercrombie Dr City of Residence: Edina

83. Name: James Lind on 2016-08-19 15:39:15 Comments: Street Address: 5200 Mayview Rd City of Residence: Minnetonka

84. Name: Genevieve Connell on 2016-08-19 15:42:14 Comments: As a competitive XC skier, I love being in nature and think other people should share this love and appreciation as well. Street Address: s42w34770 Big Oak Drive City of Residence: Dousman

85. Name: Jack Christianson on 2016-08-19 15:42:23 Comments: Help grow Midwest skiing development!

Page 12 of 72 Street Address: 3213 Ridgewood Rd City of Residence: Arden Hills

86. Name: Becky DaWald on 2016-08-19 15:46:03 Comments: Street Address: 2610 w. 42 nd st. City of Residence: Mpls

87. Name: Darren Ruschy on 2016-08-19 15:50:42 Comments: Please make this happen. As a taxpaying citizen living in Edina, this is a BIG win for our community. Street Address: 5509 Doncaster Way City of Residence: Edina

88. Name: Eric Jacobson on 2016-08-19 16:15:18 Comments: I have coaching XC for 20 years snowmaking is vital for developing competitive youth XC skiers I'm 100% for snowmaking Street Address: 3255 coachman rd City of Residence: Eagan,man

89. Name: Megan Smaby on 2016-08-19 16:20:24 Comments: Street Address: 4528 Garfield Ave City of Residence: Minneapolis

90. Name: Suzanne Logan on 2016-08-19 16:21:53 Comments: Street Address: 5806 Olinger Road City of Residence: Edina

91. Name: Daniel Sullivan on 2016-08-19 16:39:56 Comments: Street Address: 5725 York Ave s City of Residence: Edina

92. Name: Satchell Mische-Richter on 2016-08-19 16:42:41 Comments: Street Address: 2324 Towerview Circle City of Residence: Bloomington

93. Name: Trevor Cotter on 2016-08-19 16:45:00 Comments: Street Address: 2417 Grand Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

Page 13 of 72 94. Name: Anders Sonnesyn on 2016-08-19 16:45:58 Comments: Street Address: 3110 Jewel Ln N City of Residence: Plymouth

95. Name: Lisa Hollensteiner on 2016-08-19 16:47:01 Comments: Street Address: 4006 Grimes AVe. S. City of Residence: Edina

96. Name: Mary Zdechlik on 2016-08-19 16:50:50 Comments: Street Address: 4425 Judson Lane City of Residence: Edina

97. Name: Peter Zahn on 2016-08-19 16:52:22 Comments: Nordic is an amazing sport, and the addition of ski trails at Braemar would be very beneficial to the team and the community as a whole. Street Address: 5216 Grandview Lane City of Residence: Edina

98. Name: Paul Zdechlik on 2016-08-19 16:56:49 Comments: Street Address: 4425 Judson Lane City of Residence: Edina

99. Name: Thomas J McGoldrick on 2016-08-19 17:00:23 Comments: Street Address: 4230 Water Street City of Residence: Deephaven

100. Name: Susan Rickert on 2016-08-19 17:01:35 Comments: Street Address: 4306 Brook zlane City of Residence: St. Louis Park

101. Name: Tara Wagner on 2016-08-19 17:03:02 Comments: Street Address: 6605 Limerick Lane City of Residence: Edina

102. Name: Bob Schoenecker on 2016-08-19 17:03:47 Comments: A former resident of Golden Valley, I continue to support the Twin Cities efforts to provide superior outdoor activities.

Page 14 of 72 Street Address: 2948 Strawberry Road City of Residence: Oak Harbor, WA 98277

103. Name: Chad Schwinghammer on 2016-08-19 17:04:34 Comments: Street Address: 5513 Valley Lane City of Residence: Edina

104. Name: Carri Mosborg on 2016-08-19 17:04:46 Comments: I have sent emails and attended a community meeting on this topic. I know some of the nearby neighbors are concerned, but I think it has been well planned and would be an asset to many. Although I recently moved to Bloomington, my daughter has attended Edina schools all her life, is a senior at EHS this fall and went to State with her Nordic team last year. Street Address: 4908 West 86th Street City of Residence: Bloomingon

105. Name: Erica klausen on 2016-08-19 17:07:24 Comments: Street Address: 5216 Grandview Lane City of Residence: Edina

106. Name: Samantha Bevers on 2016-08-19 17:07:46 Comments: Snowmaking at Braemar is very important to the Edina Nordic team and our ability to practice. Street Address: 7360 Gallagher Dr City of Residence: Edina

107. Name: Tori on 2016-08-19 17:15:18 Comments: Street Address: 4125 Kipling Ave City of Residence: Edina

108. Name: Constance Schey on 2016-08-19 17:16:06 Comments: Street Address: 2620 36th Avenue South City of Residence: Minneapolis

109. Name: Taylor Fletcher on 2016-08-19 17:17:38 Comments: Do it Street Address: 8839 gorgoza City of Residence: Park city

110. Name: Isabel Dunning on 2016-08-19 17:18:30 Comments:

Page 15 of 72 Street Address: 4519 Arden Ave. City of Residence: Edina

111. Name: Hailey Chrysler on 2016-08-19 17:19:07 Comments: Street Address: 5100 Meadow Ridge City of Residence: Edina

112. Name: Grace Zdechlik on 2016-08-19 17:23:01 Comments: Street Address: 4425 Judson lane City of Residence: Edina

113. Name: Charlie Zdechlik on 2016-08-19 17:23:27 Comments: I love skiing and it would be sweet if there were more trails Street Address: 4425 Judson lane Edina mm 55435 City of Residence: Edina mn

114. Name: Gretchen johns on 2016-08-19 17:24:13 Comments: Parents of two Nordic skiers at EHS /Mpls residents Street Address: 4134 beard Ave s City of Residence: Minneapolis

115. Name: Malla Corbett on 2016-08-19 17:26:37 Comments: Street Address: 3229 Jersey Ave S City of Residence: St Louis Park

116. Name: Sophia Behling on 2016-08-19 17:26:52 Comments: Street Address: 4368 Oakdale Avenue South City of Residence: Edina

117. Name: kari anderson on 2016-08-19 17:29:57 Comments: more snow! Street Address: 218 Logan City of Residence: Mols

118. Name: Steven Kloiber on 2016-08-19 17:33:22 Comments: I think Nordic ski trails are a good addition to the Braemar golf course. Other golf courses have incorporated ski trails. Given how crowded the ski trials are at Hyland Park, there is the demand for it. Street Address: 6528 Scandia Road City of Residence: Edina

Page 16 of 72 119. Name: Cally Chermak on 2016-08-19 17:37:22 Comments: Street Address: 4601 Sunnyside Rd City of Residence: Edina

120. Name: William Hittler on 2016-08-19 17:46:03 Comments: The snowmaking/trail proposal will benefit the entire community: support health lifestyles, encourage family outings, and allow youth to learn to enjoy winter and cross-country skiing Street Address: 2910 Garland Lane North City of Residence: Plymouth MN 55447

121. Name: Chris Sweeney on 2016-08-19 17:52:37 Comments: Street Address: 6118 Arctic Way City of Residence: Edina

122. Name: Jim Gregg on 2016-08-19 17:54:15 Comments: Would visit the area of there was snow. Street Address: 18599 sr 20 City of Residence: Winthrop

123. Name: Michael Bono on 2016-08-19 18:01:35 Comments: Street Address: 2411 west 21 street City of Residence: minneapolis

124. Name: Anne Lindquist on 2016-08-19 18:03:48 Comments: We strongly support the making of snow for the nordic ski trails at Braemar golf course, and the grooming of the ski trails. It will enhance the quality of life for the people of our city. However, we only support the cross country ski trails aspect of the winter additions proposed for Braemar Park. Street Address: 4904 Poppy Lane City of Residence: Edina

125. Name: Sara Jones on 2016-08-19 18:07:30 Comments: I am a parent of a current Edina High School Nordic ski team member and of a former team member who has graduated. I was a long-term resident of Edina until last month. I strongly support the trails and, as a skier myself, would happily pay a fee for trail use as a non-resident. Street Address: 5328 Humboldt Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

126. Name: Julie Cahoy on 2016-08-19 18:16:20 Comments: Street Address: 3917 E 26th Street

Page 17 of 72 City of Residence: Minneapolis

127. Name: Peter Kivimaki on 2016-08-19 18:18:34 Comments: Street Address: 5324 Hollywood Rd City of Residence: Edina, MN

128. Name: Craig Yellick on 2016-08-19 18:21:13 Comments: Street Address: 4425 Parklawn Court City of Residence: Edina

129. Name: Zach Nelson on 2016-08-19 18:26:12 Comments: We need more snow making trails for cross country skiing Street Address: 727 Laurie Court City of Residence: Maplewood, MN

130. Name: Renate Stone on 2016-08-19 18:27:32 Comments: In support of X Ctry ski at Braemar Street Address: 5721 HAWKES Dr City of Residence: Edina

131. Name: Virgil Stachura on 2016-08-19 18:36:56 Comments: Street Address: 8100 Lea Road City of Residence: Bloomington

132. Name: Matt Clasen on 2016-08-19 18:38:03 Comments: Street Address: 730 North 4th Street City of Residence: Minnrapolis

133. Name: Mark Scott on 2016-08-19 18:40:45 Comments: Yes,yes, yes! Street Address: 297 72nd st n City of Residence: Mahtomedi MN

134. Name: Wenjuan Wang on 2016-08-19 18:42:12 Comments: Street Address: 6429 Margaret's In City of Residence: Edina

135. Name: Catherine Jarocki on 2016-08-19 18:58:01 Comments: Street Address: 13570 Technology Dr

Page 18 of 72 City of Residence: Eden Prairie, MN

136. Name: Jim Cloutier on 2016-08-19 19:05:39 Comments: Snow making during lean snow seasons keeps skiers active. This is good for the Twin Cities area. Please make it a priority. Street Address: 13629 46th St. NE City of Residence: Saint Michael

137. Name: Kristin Engman on 2016-08-19 19:17:15 Comments: Street Address: 5236 west 56th street City of Residence: Edina

138. Name: Luke Brown on 2016-08-19 19:17:19 Comments: Street Address: 215 Woodlawn Ave. City of Residence: St. Paul

139. Name: Angela Robinson on 2016-08-19 19:23:15 Comments: More snow making trails will take some of the pressure off the few trails we have and help grow the sport. Based on usage of other snow making trails it will be well used. Street Address: 1955 Hythe St. City of Residence: Roseville

140. Name: Thomas Norman on 2016-08-19 19:38:15 Comments: Street Address: 5229 Meadow Ridge City of Residence: Edina

141. Name: Arleth Ulloa on 2016-08-19 20:00:01 Comments: Street Address: 6617 Southdale road City of Residence: Edina

142. Name: Shelly Howe on 2016-08-19 20:05:06 Comments: 100% support this proposal. Amenities like this are what make Edina's quality of life what it is. Street Address: 5169 Abercrombie Dr City of Residence: Edina

143. Name: Monica on 2016-08-19 20:07:20 Comments: Street Address: 1622 West brook street City of Residence: Santa Ana

Page 19 of 72 144. Name: Sheryl Gage on 2016-08-19 20:15:37 Comments: The addition of cross country skiing to the Braemar golf course is a great way to increase its usage while leveraging the existing infrastructure. It would be another example of how Edina promotes healthy lifestyles for its residents, and it would benefit the more than 200 students (ranging from completely new skiers to competitive racers) who join the high school team to have a place to call their training space. This is a no-cut sport and provides a great experience for kids of all skill levels. Street Address: 5813 Amy Drive City of Residence: Edina

145. Name: Michaela Keller-Miller on 2016-08-19 20:17:10 Comments: Street Address: 16935 40th pl no City of Residence: Plymouth

146. Name: dave horan on 2016-08-19 20:21:10 Comments: Street Address: 4215 lynn ave City of Residence: edina

147. Name: Andrea Brandt on 2016-08-19 20:26:03 Comments: I fully support the trails and all the great reasons listed in the petition. Street Address: 6624 Nordic Dr City of Residence: Edina

148. Name: Doug Boonstra on 2016-08-19 20:33:48 Comments: What a bonus this would be to the community, as well as a draw for more business from the surrounding area as well as schools. Silent sports such as skiing and biking should embrace this collectively, as they both will benefit as will the greater community of Edina. Street Address: 2602 Clover Field Circle City of Residence: Chaska

149. Name: Tracy Shand on 2016-08-19 20:42:12 Comments: We support this cross country ski trails and snow making at Braemar. Street Address: 4824 Townes Rd City of Residence: Edina

150. Name: Jennifer Kompelien on 2016-08-19 20:46:30 Comments: Street Address: 4208 West 44th Street City of Residence: Edina

151. Name: Shelly Howe on 2016-08-19 20:48:23

Page 20 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 5169 Abercrombie Dr City of Residence: Edina

152. Name: Erik Hendrickson on 2016-08-19 20:49:17 Comments: Street Address: 1630 Jersey Ave. City of Residence: St. Louis Park

153. Name: Matthew Waite on 2016-08-19 20:52:15 Comments: Yes, I would definitely drive to this facility from St Paul. Street Address: 1952 Portland Ave City of Residence: St Paul

154. Name: Thomas Woolhouse on 2016-08-19 20:53:32 Comments: Street Address: 2356 Olympic st. City of Residence: Brook Park Mn.

155. Name: Dan Sweeney on 2016-08-19 20:59:18 Comments: Build trails with snowmaking Street Address: 6118 Arctic Way City of Residence: Edina

156. Name: Theresa Yanchar on 2016-08-19 20:59:49 Comments: Definitely Street Address: 400 N 1st Streer City of Residence: Minneapolis

157. Name: Joan Hughes on 2016-08-19 21:04:07 Comments: Street Address: 4088 Utica Ave S City of Residence: St Louis Park

158. Name: Susan Schultz on 2016-08-19 21:05:47 Comments: I am an Edina resident and fully support xc ski trails at Braemar Park. Street Address: 5217 Abercrombie Drive City of Residence: Edina

159. Name: Gerald A Holguin on 2016-08-19 21:09:30 Comments: Street Address: 5508 Glengarry Parkway City of Residence: Edina

160. Name: Emily on 2016-08-19 21:12:15

Page 21 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 5036 William ave City of Residence: Edina

161. Name: Mari Steinbach on 2016-08-19 21:14:21 Comments: Street Address: 4526 Washburn Ave N City of Residence: Minneapolis

162. Name: Tiffany Wortman on 2016-08-19 21:16:07 Comments: Street Address: 1778 Wellesley Ave City of Residence: Saint Paul

163. Name: Erik Hinkie on 2016-08-19 21:17:01 Comments: Street Address: 5547 Malibu Drive City of Residence: Edina

164. Name: Olivia on 2016-08-19 21:24:36 Comments: Street Address: 2126 Commonwealth Ave. City of Residence: St. Paul

165. Name: Chris Behling on 2016-08-19 21:36:36 Comments: Street Address: 4368 Oakdale AVe. S City of Residence: Edina

166. Name: Carol Russell on 2016-08-19 21:37:24 Comments: I vote yes primarily for the high school winter sports teams. Street Address: 6623 Londonderry Dr City of Residence: Edina

167. Name: The Rubin Family on 2016-08-19 21:55:17 Comments: Family of six active in nordic skiing Street Address: 5 Woodland Road City of Residence: Edina

168. Name: Curt Werdal on 2016-08-19 22:14:05 Comments: I would love to be able to ski here in the winter! Street Address: Eden Prairie, MN City of Residence: United States of America

169. Name: Laura Williams on 2016-08-19 22:37:05

Page 22 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 5805 Kemrich Dr City of Residence: Edina

170. Name: Ellen Pflaster on 2016-08-19 22:39:39 Comments: Street Address: 5524 Kellogg Ave City of Residence: Edina

171. Name: Janelle Erickson on 2016-08-19 22:45:58 Comments: I support this cross country proposal for the Braemar location! Street Address: 7004 Lanham Lane City of Residence: Edina

172. Name: Courtney Elford on 2016-08-19 22:54:07 Comments: Street Address: 184 71st way ne City of Residence: Minneapolis

173. Name: Susan aylesworth on 2016-08-19 23:02:55 Comments: Street Address: 2395 Benson Avenue City of Residence: St. Paul, MN

174. Name: John Ellenberger on 2016-08-19 23:13:02 Comments: Please support this important and beneficial investment, and don't be deceived by specious arguments against it. Thank you. Street Address: 6920 Dakota Trail City of Residence: Edina

175. Name: Nathan Rivers on 2016-08-19 23:14:46 Comments: Street Address: 6013 Erin Terrace City of Residence: Edina

176. Name: Kate chamberlain on 2016-08-19 23:24:36 Comments: Make this happen! :) Street Address: 6516 stauder circle City of Residence: Edina

177. Name: Zoe Swiler on 2016-08-19 23:47:43 Comments: Street Address: 6108 Arbour Lane City of Residence: Edina

Page 23 of 72 178. Name: Tate on 2016-08-19 23:55:51 Comments: Street Address: 6118 Arctic Way City of Residence: Edina

179. Name: Calvin Bergen on 2016-08-20 00:13:33 Comments: Street Address: 1408 W 68th ST City of Residence: Richfield

180. Name: Patrick Sullivan on 2016-08-20 00:14:39 Comments: Street Address: 68xx St Patrick's Ln City of Residence: Edina

181. Name: Stephanie Michals on 2016-08-20 00:23:26 Comments: Street Address: 3300 47th ave s City of Residence: Minneapolis

182. Name: Madeline NcAlister on 2016-08-20 00:38:08 Comments: Street Address: 4128 Toledo Ave S City of Residence: St. Louis Park

183. Name: Matthew Egger on 2016-08-20 00:38:25 Comments: It's important to Edina Nordic, and all of Edina that this project is able to be finished! Street Address: 4006 grimes ave s City of Residence: Edina

184. Name: Peter Rock on 2016-08-20 00:56:02 Comments: I ski on the Edina Nordic team. The team means an incredible amount to me, and it would be a great privilege to be able to use braemar to ski. The Nordic team is full of respectful student athletes who would quietly and carefully use the braemar parks to train and enjoy the winter. I strongly support the use of braemar park for Nordic skiing. Street Address: 4515 Casco ave City of Residence: Edina

185. Name: Logan Sweeney on 2016-08-20 01:00:29 Comments: Street Address: 6118 Arctic Way City of Residence: Edina

186. Name: Anita Burg on 2016-08-20 01:04:58

Page 24 of 72 Comments: We spend so much money on hockey. How about the 200 members of the Edina High School nordic ski team!!! Street Address: 5812 Oaklawn Ave City of Residence: Edina

187. Name: Amy scott on 2016-08-20 01:23:25 Comments: Street Address: 5509 Dever Drive City of Residence: Edina

188. Name: Robert Economy on 2016-08-20 02:36:50 Comments: Street Address: 8330 RIVER BIRCH CT City of Residence: VICTORIA

189. Name: Kandace Ellis on 2016-08-20 02:59:58 Comments: Street Address: 5704 Camelback Drive City of Residence: Edina MN

190. Name: Anders Carlson on 2016-08-20 03:12:35 Comments: Street Address: 5916 Drew Ave S City of Residence: Edina

191. Name: Kevin Herrick on 2016-08-20 03:19:53 Comments: Street Address: 3636 35th Ave south City of Residence: Minneapolis

192. Name: Melissa Bernstein on 2016-08-20 03:32:32 Comments: Street Address: 5808 Brook drive City of Residence: Edina

193. Name: Will Schwinghammer on 2016-08-20 03:32:35 Comments: Street Address: 5513 Valley Lane City of Residence: Edina

194. Name: Melody Huttner on 2016-08-20 03:50:27 Comments: Street Address: 6628 Gleason Terrace City of Residence: Edina

Page 25 of 72 195. Name: Kathleen Mulrooney on 2016-08-20 04:05:03 Comments: Let's support this great opportunity for our student athletes and our entire community. We live in a winter weather state- let's support winter weather activities. Street Address: 4721 Upper terrace City of Residence: Edina

196. Name: Sue Schroeder on 2016-08-20 04:16:43 Comments: Street Address: 3900 4th Ave. S. City of Residence: Minneapolis

197. Name: Bryan Fletcher on 2016-08-20 04:34:18 Comments: Street Address: 751 E Valley Drive City of Residence: Heber City

198. Name: Craig Ringsven on 2016-08-20 05:23:23 Comments: Would love to see this happen! Street Address: 512 Ardmore drive City of Residence: Golden valley

199. Name: Kim Rudd on 2016-08-20 05:37:22 Comments: Vote yes for ski trails ! Street Address: 3810 Orleans lane n, City of Residence: Plymouth

200. Name: Cheryl Dulas on 2016-08-20 05:47:04 Comments: Street Address: 4609 Bruce Avenue City of Residence: Edina

201. Name: Jessica Heydt on 2016-08-20 09:44:57 Comments: Street Address: 622 Grand Ave., #308 City of Residence: St. Paul

202. Name: Zhong Yi on 2016-08-20 10:14:32 Comments: Street Address: 6232 Braeburn Circle City of Residence: Edina

203. Name: Dale Vaillancourt on 2016-08-20 10:16:38 Comments: Street Address: 13016 court place City of Residence: Burnsville

Page 26 of 72 204. Name: Diane Pattridge on 2016-08-20 11:06:17 Comments: Street Address: 3554 Lowell St City of Residence: Wayzata, MN

205. Name: Jerry on 2016-08-20 12:29:16 Comments: Street Address: 6220 balder In City of Residence: Edina

206. Name: Suzanne Rudi on 2016-08-20 12:36:20 Comments: Street Address: 4708 Valley View Road City of Residence: Edina

207. Name: Barry Rotman on 2016-08-20 12:40:16 Comments: Cross Country skiing is a life long sport that can be enjoyed by virtually anyone. Street Address: 42 South Lake St City of Residence: Grayslake, IL 60030

208. Name: Gustavo Johnson on 2016-08-20 12:43:24 Comments: Street Address: 10463 ponderosa drive City of Residence: Truckee

209. Name: Kaia Burg on 2016-08-20 13:04:20 Comments: Street Address: 5813 Oaklawn Av City of Residence: Edina

210. Name: Todd Cronin on 2016-08-20 13:24:57 Comments: Street Address: 1533 Lois Drive City of Residence: Shoreview MN

211. Name: Ashley on 2016-08-20 13:26:19 Comments: Street Address: 4444 Yates Ave n City of Residence: Crystal

212. Name: Elizabeth torkelson on 2016-08-20 13:27:28 Comments: Street Address: 4401 zenith avenue south

Page 27 of 72 City of Residence: Minneapolis

213. Name: Diane Schember on 2016-08-20 13:36:53 Comments: As a St Paul small business and a skier I support this! Street Address: 924 Goodrich Avenue City of Residence: Saint Paul

214. Name: Michelle Thoemke' on 2016-08-20 13:49:34 Comments: Street Address: 2121 Kings Valley Road West City of Residence: Golden Valley

215. Name: Jeffrey Steuernagel on 2016-08-20 13:58:11 Comments: Street Address: 12821 Eagle Ridge Drive City of Residence: Burnsville

216. Name: Gina Magnuson on 2016-08-20 14:02:01 Comments: Street Address: 10232 Hilltop Ct. City of Residence: Champlin

217. Name: Diane Rafats on 2016-08-20 14:40:46 Comments: Street Address: 2704 Colfax Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

218. Name: Ben Brandt on 2016-08-20 14:46:47 Comments: Street Address: 6524 Nordic Drive City of Residence: Edina

219. Name: Matt Jorgensen on 2016-08-20 14:46:50 Comments: Street Address: 3747 Crane Island Ct City of Residence: Minnetrista

220. Name: Steven Beck on 2016-08-20 15:01:06 Comments: Street Address: 1831 Bayard Avenue City of Residence: Saint Paul

221. Name: Zehyani Bankwala on 2016-08-20 15:02:14 Comments: Street Address: 6400 Willow Wood Rd

Page 28 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

222. Name: Maree Hampton on 2016-08-20 15:11:20 Comments: Street Address: 3425 Holmes Ave South City of Residence: Minneapolis

223. Name: steve michals on 2016-08-20 15:25:45 Comments: Please approve this wonderful ski trail Street Address: 4708 Isabel Ave City of Residence: Minneapolis

224. Name: Adam Johnson on 2016-08-20 15:46:32 Comments: Street Address: 1476 Independence Ave S City of Residence: St. Louis Park

225. Name: Steve Eberly on 2016-08-20 15:50:23 Comments: This will be a great addition to the metro area outdoor winter ski trails. Please make this happen my family and I will definitely make use of this facility and pay any fees required. Street Address: 4264 Linden Hills Blvd City of Residence: Minneapolis

226. Name: Tim Miner on 2016-08-20 15:54:52 Comments: I am a Minnesota Youth Ski League club leader for over 20 years. Reliable snow is the single largest factor in determining the number of children we can introduce to skiing. Street Address: 604 Old Mill Road City of Residence: Hudson

227. Name: Michael Miles on 2016-08-20 15:55:40 Comments: Street Address: 7340 Kochia Lane City of Residence: Victoria

228. Name: Mary Luoma on 2016-08-20 15:59:15 Comments: I started cross country skiing in gym class as a high school student at Edina West in 1976. As a senior I was part of the ski team and have been skiing ever since. Hoping Edina will vote to continue to inspire Twin City residents to enjoy this wonderful sport. Street Address: 8934 Chesshire Lane City of Residence: Maple Grove

229. Name: Pam Harens on 2016-08-20 16:13:38

Page 29 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 6832 Gleason Road City of Residence: Edina

230. Name: Peter Larson on 2016-08-20 16:20:21 Comments: Street Address: Arden Avenue City of Residence: Edina

231. Name: Bob Britz on 2016-08-20 16:37:59 Comments: Edina has always been a leader in the community, being able to look to the future is important and this project will be a great addition! Street Address: 3877 Marschall Rd City of Residence: Shakopee

232. Name: Chris Torvi on 2016-08-20 16:41:09 Comments: This snowmaking loop would be awesome for nordic ski community! The snowmaking loops @ elm creek, hyland park and Wirth have been a huge reason Nordic skiing is growing! Street Address: 1603 Wheelock ridge City of Residence: St. Paul

233. Name: Mike Calvo on 2016-08-20 16:56:59 Comments: Street Address: 5509 Dever City of Residence: Edina

234. Name: Alyssa on 2016-08-20 16:59:02 Comments: Street Address: 5809 tennison drive City of Residence: Fridley

235. Name: Tracy Ocel on 2016-08-20 17:00:33 Comments: Street Address: 222 40th Ave. NE City of Residence: Minneapolis

236. Name: Scott Ocel on 2016-08-20 17:14:18 Comments: Street Address: 222 40th ave me City of Residence: Columbia heights

237. Name: John Kendrick on 2016-08-20 17:15:25 Comments: Street Address: 1610 St. Clair Ave.

Page 30 of 72 City of Residence: St. Paul

238. Name: Jed Gorlin on 2016-08-20 17:33:37 Comments: Hyland is overcrowded so this would be a great addition Street Address: 805 park terrace City of Residence: Hopkins

239. Name: sara anderson on 2016-08-20 17:36:54 Comments: Street Address: 4807 maple road City of Residence: edina

240. Name: joe mayer on 2016-08-20 17:58:45 Comments: Street Address: 3232 Ensign Court City of Residence: New Hope

241. Name: Rodney Binfet on 2016-08-20 18:03:43 Comments: I would use this trail extensively! Street Address: 6728 mulberry circle City of Residence: Chanhassen

242. Name: Rhett Carlson on 2016-08-20 18:16:12 Comments: The southwest could use another option for man-made cross country ski trails. Street Address: 930 University Ave SE City of Residence: Minneapolis

243. Name: Tommy Carlson on 2016-08-20 18:24:49 Comments: It would alleviate traffic at other parks. Street Address: 1521 4th St NE City of Residence: Minneapolis

244. Name: Darrin Diedrich on 2016-08-20 18:42:24 Comments: Street Address: 10500 zinran Ave S City of Residence: Bloomington

245. Name: Heidi Engman on 2016-08-20 18:48:52 Comments: Street Address: West 56th street City of Residence: Edina

246. Name: Ellen Kluz on 2016-08-20 18:58:02 Comments:

Page 31 of 72 Street Address: 4521 Colfax Ave So City of Residence: Minneapolis

247. Name: Pam Stegora Axberg on 2016-08-20 19:16:21 Comments: Super! And good for the broader community. Street Address: 1427 Brookshire court City of Residence: New Brighton

248. Name: Dianne Ocel on 2016-08-20 19:22:28 Comments: Street Address: 13143 Aberdeen St. N.E. City of Residence: Blaine

249. Name: David Leske on 2016-08-20 20:09:25 Comments: Street Address: 6724 Plymouth ave City of Residence: Golden Valley

250. Name: Dan Beno on 2016-08-20 20:09:32 Comments: Would love to see this trail! More outdoor activity for kids and adults! Street Address: 7563 Ridgeview Point City of Residence: Chanhassen

251. Name: Robin Austin on 2016-08-20 20:18:40 Comments: Street Address: 5713 Melody Lane City of Residence: Edina

252. Name: Liz Abt Ellenberger on 2016-08-20 20:23:06 Comments: Great use of existing underutilized real estate resource. Nordic skiing is a life long sport to enjoy what winter throws at us. Street Address: 6920 Dakota Trail City of Residence: Edina

253. Name: Greg Fields on 2016-08-20 20:45:24 Comments: I fully support this as a wonderful addition to the outdoor activities many Minnesotans enjoy in the winter. Street Address: 4931 Triton DR City of Residence: Golden Valley, MN 55422

254. Name: Andrea Brink on 2016-08-20 20:55:27 Comments: The ski trails and tubing hill are much-needed and will complete the winter activity options available in Edina which will appeal to a broader base of residents. I am excited at the possibility of having a non hockey /ice skating winter activity available locally without having to travel to Minneapolis or surrounding suburbs.

Page 32 of 72 Street Address: 6324 Tingdale Avenue City of Residence: Edina

255. Name: Greg Bernhardt on 2016-08-20 21:01:30 Comments: I support adding XC Skiing to extend use of this wonderful venue to the winter. Street Address: 400 Harrison Av S City of Residence: Edina, MN

256. Name: Mark Larson on 2016-08-20 22:07:59 Comments: this would be a great asset both for the community and for the high school program. Let's do it! Street Address: 4628 Arden Ave City of Residence: Edina

257. Name: Kathy Brault on 2016-08-20 22:28:31 Comments: Street Address: 6829 James Av So City of Residence: Richfield

258. Name: Jacob Bauer on 2016-08-20 22:36:32 Comments: Street Address: 3729 Algoma Rd City of Residence: New Franken

259. Name: Kai Olstad on 2016-08-20 22:37:29 Comments: Street Address: 8000 257th st W City of Residence: Farmington

260. Name: Martin Richmond on 2016-08-20 22:50:54 Comments: This would be so great for so many people. Don't miss this opportunity. Street Address: 3539 Cedar Lake Ave City of Residence: Minneapolis

261. Name: Jack Collis on 2016-08-20 23:07:40 Comments: As a ski coach and an advocate for outdoor activities for the community this would be a great asset to the city of Edina and its youth (and us old people too) Street Address: 5320 Irving Ave S. City of Residence: Minneapolis

262. Name: Laura Templin on 2016-08-20 23:47:39 Comments: Street Address: 1655 Mahogany Ct SW City of Residence: Hutchinson

Page 33 of 72 263. Name: Ethan Brookner on 2016-08-21 00:15:33 Comments: Street Address: 5008 16th ave s City of Residence: Minneapolis

264. Name: Elizabeth Burnett on 2016-08-21 00:27:28 Comments: Please vote YES! Street Address: 4821 Vandervork Ave. City of Residence: Edina

265. Name: Craig Stolen on 2016-08-21 00:56:55 Comments: Street Address: 1608 23 red ave nw City of Residence: New Brighton, MN

266. Name: Odd Bersvendsen on 2016-08-21 01:05:43 Comments: Street Address: 119 City of Residence: Jackson

267. Name: Bradley Daniel Baas on 2016-08-21 01:23:36 Comments: Street Address: 1801 Townsend Dr City of Residence: Houghton

268. Name: Jan Ketterson on 2016-08-21 01:29:23 Comments: Street Address: 9725 Xylon Court South City of Residence: Bloomington

269. Name: Olof Hedberg on 2016-08-21 01:45:10 Comments: Street Address: 350 Revett Dr City of Residence: Breckenridge

270. Name: Halle Weisman on 2016-08-21 01:55:49 Comments: Street Address: 1771 Valley Ridge Place City of Residence: Chanhassen

271. Name: John Horns on 2016-08-21 02:27:48 Comments: The City of Edina needs to make the Breamar park land available to a variety of uses. Street Address: 6101 Jeffrey Lane

Page 34 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

272. Name: Tina Kivi on 2016-08-21 03:26:37 Comments: Street Address: 2809 County Road H City of Residence: Mounds View

273. Name: David Kranz on 2016-08-21 04:02:39 Comments: Street Address: 2401 34th Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

274. Name: Peter Schnorbach on 2016-08-21 04:11:41 Comments: Street Address: 6221 Balder Lane City of Residence: Edina

275. Name: Cece Boyle on 2016-08-21 12:09:11 Comments: Street Address: 3921 Goodwin Ave N City of Residence: Oakdale

276. Name: Scott Bloom on 2016-08-21 12:37:17 Comments: Street Address: 6610 Normandale Road City of Residence: Edina

277. Name: Phil Clark on 2016-08-21 12:41:23 Comments: Street Address: 8876 Braxton Drive City of Residence: Eden Prairie

278. Name: Bjorn Bakken on 2016-08-21 12:56:38 Comments: Street Address: 2737 Blaisdell Ave S Apt 9 City of Residence: Minneapolis

279. Name: Robert Bullis on 2016-08-21 13:01:22 Comments: Street Address: 19088 Dodge St NW City of Residence: Elk River

280. Name: Zoe Horns on 2016-08-21 13:24:30 Comments: Street Address: 6101 Jeffrey lane

Page 35 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

281. Name: Roy Vosberg on 2016-08-21 13:46:27 Comments: We need more ski trails. Street Address: N2989 830th Street City of Residence: Hager City, WI

282. Name: Tom Wagner on 2016-08-21 14:07:50 Comments: As a former member of the U.S. Nordic Ski Team and resident of Edina, I believe we have a unique opportunity to support this great life-long outdoor activity in our community. Would we question this project if it were in support of our hockey programs? I love hockey but love hiking, running and Nordic skiing too. Let's find a way to set aside our differences and make this work in our community. Street Address: 6605 Limerick Lane City of Residence: Edina

283. Name: Christopher Gerlach on 2016-08-21 14:24:23 Comments: Congratulations for Edina to take the lead on a new nordic ski area - I wish the East Metro had something like this! I already drive to Hyland too much, and would definitly make use of this as well. Street Address: 11191 Stonemill Mill Farms Curve City of Residence: Woodbury, MN

284. Name: sujata gholkar on 2016-08-21 15:32:03 Comments: Street Address: 5417 grove st City of Residence: edina

285. Name: Anna Coleman on 2016-08-21 15:50:32 Comments: Street Address: 1597 27th Ave NW City of Residence: Saint Paul

286. Name: Carrie Bloom on 2016-08-21 16:22:08 Comments: Street Address: 6610 Normandale Rd City of Residence: Edina

287. Name: Robert Iverson on 2016-08-21 17:52:55 Comments: Street Address: 13551 Eidelweiss St NW City of Residence: Andover

288. Name: Chris Johnson on 2016-08-21 18:30:24 Comments:

Page 36 of 72 Street Address: 3656 35th Ave. S. Minneapolis MN 55406 City of Residence: Minneapolis

289. Name: Stacy Beno on 2016-08-21 18:40:08 Comments: Street Address: 7563 Ridgeview Point City of Residence: Chanhassen

290. Name: Mckenzie on 2016-08-21 18:43:46 Comments: Street Address: 7563 ridgeview point City of Residence: Chanhassen

291. Name: Artie Huber on 2016-08-21 18:48:25 Comments: I would use the trail system and support local businesses while in the area Street Address: 8328 Padgett Cir NE City of Residence: Otsego

292. Name: Dave Hruby on 2016-08-21 20:03:58 Comments: A tremendous asset that will increase property values and attract young active families to Edina. Street Address: 5212 tifton drive City of Residence: Edina

293. Name: Paul Arbisi on 2016-08-21 20:58:41 Comments: Nordic skiing is a lifelong activity that can be embraced and enjoyed by Edina residents of all ages and abilities. The ski trails at Braemar will provide convenient access to a resource that will help to promote and build healthy and active lifestyles among our residents. I strongly support the proposal for nordic ski trails at Braemar with snow making capabilities. Street Address: 4632 Arden Ave City of Residence: Edina

294. Name: Eileen Lorentz on 2016-08-21 22:12:42 Comments: Street Address: 517 Blake Rd S City of Residence: Edina

295. Name: Thomas Kendrick on 2016-08-21 23:45:47 Comments: Living in Edina right now, I think this would be huge for both the community and for the Twin Cities area as a whole! I would use this at least a few times a week. Street Address: 5108 Lincoln Cir City of Residence: Edina, MN

296. Name: Bryce Gytri on 2016-08-22 02:58:39

Page 37 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 2117 Rockridge Circle City of Residence: Shakopee

297. Name: Josh Felton on 2016-08-22 03:35:24 Comments: Street Address: 5200 Tifton Dr City of Residence: Edina

298. Name: Mary Cavanagh on 2016-08-22 03:41:45 Comments: Street Address: 3953 Beard Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

299. Name: Lise Crosby on 2016-08-22 13:16:31 Comments: Our family would use Nordic Ski Trails at least once a week . This would be a great benefit for the entire community. Street Address: 6828 Valley View Rd City of Residence: Edina

300. Name: Lexi Granberg on 2016-08-22 13:33:32 Comments: Street Address: 6721 Galway Drive City of Residence: Edina

301. Name: scott ree on 2016-08-22 13:49:11 Comments: Street Address: 16920 11th Ave North City of Residence: plymouth

302. Name: Mark Burgoyne on 2016-08-22 13:54:08 Comments: Street Address: 603 Redwood Lane City of Residence: New Brighton, MN

303. Name: Neal Blanchett on 2016-08-22 14:00:20 Comments: We would love to see Edina continue to be a leader in providing places for active healthy families to enjoy outdoor recreation together by providing this year-round trail with winter snowmaking. We've gladly supported facilities for every kind of recreation; this is a great chance to support this popular, growing, life-long winter sport, with trails residents can use year-round. Street Address: 4737 Hibiscus Avenue City of Residence: edina

304. Name: Annika on 2016-08-22 14:09:54

Page 38 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 5574 Oak Glen Rd City of Residence: Edina

305. Name: Eleanor Bacso on 2016-08-22 14:10:36 Comments: Street Address: 803 North 27th Avenue West City of Residence: Duluth

306. Name: Chris Harvey on 2016-08-22 14:22:15 Comments: Would be a valuable resource to the City of Edina and area high schools to have a ski venue. Would be supporting and active, outdoor lifestyle for our youth. Street Address: 8227 12th Ave S City of Residence: Bloomingtom

307. Name: Maggie Braun on 2016-08-22 14:38:49 Comments: Street Address: 5833 Jeff Place City of Residence: Edina

308. Name: Mark Kobilka on 2016-08-22 14:43:09 Comments: As an assistant cross country ski coach, I am very excited that there would be another place to practice for the large community of high school skiers. This is so important as now we only have 2 reliable snowmaking trails and they cannot handle the number of students that want to ski. Street Address: 5769 Three Oaks Ave City of Residence: Maple Plain

309. Name: Ellen Jones on 2016-08-22 15:00:17 Comments: This would be a huge benefit to the community! Street Address: 5261 Lochloy Dr. City of Residence: Edina

310. Name: Erik Erickson on 2016-08-22 15:22:44 Comments: Street Address: 2708 120th lane ne City of Residence: Blaine

311. Name: Kate Turnbull on 2016-08-22 16:10:21 Comments: Please pass this proposal for winter fun in Edina! Street Address: 5224 32nd Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

312. Name: Wayne Bishop on 2016-08-22 16:11:48 Comments:

Page 39 of 72 Street Address: 2709 Salem avenue south City of Residence: St. Louis Park

313. Name: Stephanie Jones on 2016-08-22 16:32:31 Comments: I would love to ski here! Street Address: 3811 W 31st St, Apt 101 City of Residence: Minneapolis

314. Name: Duncan Tomassen on 2016-08-22 16:36:30 Comments: Great idea! Street Address: 10065 Eden Prairie Road City of Residence: Eden Prairie

315. Name: Alex Marble on 2016-08-22 16:53:48 Comments: Don't be a dick about guys. C'mon Street Address: 6712 limerick lane City of Residence: Edina

316. Name: Scott on 2016-08-22 16:57:29 Comments: I fully support this. I live in St. Paul and I'd drive there to ski. Big fan. This would be an asset to Edina and cause people to drive to your city. Street Address: st paul City of Residence: st paul

317. Name: Mike Stucky on 2016-08-22 17:26:18 Comments: Street Address: 5954 Highview Place City of Residence: Shoreview

318. Name: Kathleen and Doug Hokemeir-Seim on 2016-08-22 17:27:35 Comments: We support creating cross-country ski trails at Braemar. Not only would they be great for the EHS ski team, but adults could use them as well. Street Address: 4514 Oak Drive City of Residence: Edina

319. Name: Craig Brandt on 2016-08-22 17:27:56 Comments: Street Address: 6524 Nordic Dr. City of Residence: Edina

320. Name: Marie Jordan on 2016-08-22 17:33:39 Comments: Snow is in short supply these days. Cross Country skiing is a great lifelong sport that everyone can enjoy. Street Address: 1948 Garfield St NE City of Residence: Minneapolis

Page 40 of 72 321. Name: Bill Kerker on 2016-08-22 17:51:07 Comments: The time is right to acknowledge the growth of Nordic, trail running and Mtn biking and enhance the proud offerings of Edina parks. I will gladly "pay to play"! Street Address: 4835 Thomas Ave. S. City of Residence: Minneapolis

322. Name: Arthur Marble on 2016-08-22 18:01:02 Comments: Street Address: 6712 Limerick Lane City of Residence: Edina

323. Name: John Munger on 2016-08-22 18:27:34 Comments: Street Address: 1211 Washburn Avenue North City of Residence: Minneapolis

324. Name: Dan DeRoma on 2016-08-22 18:33:01 Comments: the earth is not getting any colder! Street Address: 2019 Oakview Ln N City of Residence: Plymouth

325. Name: Stephen Ruble on 2016-08-22 19:02:27 Comments: Street Address: 543 Linden Lane City of Residence: Lino Lakes, MN 55014

326. Name: Alice Hulbert on 2016-08-22 19:57:12 Comments: I owned a house near Hyland Ski Area- the most expensive and fastest selling houses face the ski area. Street Address: 7221 Tara Road City of Residence: Edina, Mn

327. Name: Margaret Miller on 2016-08-22 21:01:41 Comments: Street Address: 5501 13th Ave South City of Residence: Minneapolis

328. Name: Katherine Ellis on 2016-08-22 21:33:38 Comments: The addition of these ski trails and snowmaking will bring active health benefits to the community and enable the Edina Ski team to continue to have a long lasting positive affect on young peoples lives. Street Address: 1896 Dellwood Ave. City of Residence: Roseville

Page 41 of 72 329. Name: Jennifer Rolfes on 2016-08-22 21:39:37 Comments: Adding trails to Braemar will make the park far more accessible to residents. There are some trails in that woods now, but they are occasionally overgrown and mostly used by neighbors to walk their dogs. I grew up within a block of the proposed loop and wish it had been there when I was in high school! It will be a great addition for the high school team, xc skiers in the metro, and recreational skiers from Edina. Street Address: 7675 Woodview Ct City of Residence: Edina

330. Name: Kassandra Kuehl on 2016-08-22 21:41:01 Comments: Global warming has made Minnesota winters far less predictable than they have been in the past. Without man-made snow, many of us cannot enjoy non-ice dependent outdoor recreation during significant stretches of the winter months. I would go so far as to say that Edina truly NEEDS this project to move forward. Street Address: 7360 Gallagher Dr. Apt. 121 City of Residence: Edina

331. Name: Brett Bevers on 2016-08-22 21:53:47 Comments: I am a parent of an Edina Nordic skier that would benefit so much from this project. The proposal would certainly contribute to a world-class community like Edina. Street Address: 2921 Greenfield Ave. City of Residence: Los Angeles

332. Name: Alan Grant on 2016-08-22 22:21:45 Comments: Street Address: 9032 Norway St NW City of Residence: Coon Rapids

333. Name: Kelly Streit on 2016-08-22 22:34:31 Comments: Street Address: 5421 Kellogg Ave., City of Residence: Edina

334. Name: Jan Monson on 2016-08-22 23:07:51 Comments: Street Address: 3945 west 49th street City of Residence: edina

335. Name: James Bischoff on 2016-08-23 00:06:54 Comments: Street Address: 4401 Park Glen Rd Apt 102 City of Residence: St Louis Park

336. Name: Jason Kalenborn on 2016-08-23 00:09:19

Page 42 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 5801 Tracy Avs. S. City of Residence: Edina

337. Name: Steve Benton on 2016-08-23 01:25:58 Comments: Street Address: 2830 Danbury Way City of Residence: Minnetonka

338. Name: Tom Marble on 2016-08-23 01:39:22 Comments: Street Address: 6712 Limerick Ln City of Residence: Edina

339. Name: Slater Crosby on 2016-08-23 01:49:22 Comments: Street Address: 6828 Valley View Road City of Residence: Edina

340. Name: Jake Brown on 2016-08-23 02:15:49 Comments: This addition would present Edina as a leader in promoting outdoor education, physical fitness, and community empowerment through sport, adventure, and nature preservation. Street Address: 215 Woodlawn Ave City of Residence: Saint Paul

341. Name: Loren Johnson on 2016-08-23 11:19:15 Comments: Street Address: 8011 cheyenne ave City of Residence: Chanhassen

342. Name: Elias Anoszko on 2016-08-23 12:03:22 Comments: Street Address: 948 Cromwell Ave City of Residence: Saint Paul

343. Name: Beth lhry on 2016-08-23 12:11:33 Comments: I am a resident of Edina and would be pleased to have another option for skiing on man made snow. Street Address: 4544 Parkside Ln City of Residence: Edina

344. Name: Bruce Carlson on 2016-08-23 13:27:37 Comments: Street Address: 5208 Glengarry Pkwy

Page 43 of 72 City of Residence: Edina, MN 55436

345. Name: Greg Rhodes on 2016-08-23 13:32:39 Comments: Street Address: 9301 Yukon Ave S. Bloomington, MN 55438 City of Residence: Bloomington

346. Name: Robert Syring on 2016-08-23 14:59:48 Comments: I strongly support the proposed project for Edina High School skiers and all Edina residents. Hylands does not support skiing for the entire HS team. Street Address: 4117 Kipling City of Residence: Edina

347. Name: Naomi Jarvis on 2016-08-23 15:13:33 Comments: Street Address: 1096 Covington PI City of Residence: Allison Park

348. Name: John Shirriff on 2016-08-23 15:45:19 Comments: Street Address: 9608 Wyoming Terrace South City of Residence: Bloomington

349. Name: Bob McKlveen on 2016-08-23 16:29:30 Comments: I've sent a detailed letter to the Park Board and City Council, and encourage you to do the same if you have time. Street Address: 5261 Lochloy Drive City of Residence: Edina

350. Name: Christie Franken on 2016-08-23 17:16:17 Comments: I support snowmaking at Braemar! It would ultimately benefit Edina and the surrounding area. Street Address: 4544 Parkside LN City of Residence: Edina

351. Name: Wendy Syring on 2016-08-23 17:25:37 Comments: Street Address: 4117 Kipling Ave City of Residence: Edina

352. Name: Carol Holguin on 2016-08-23 17:27:14 Comments: This would be a wonderful addition to the parks, biking, and walking trails already in our lovely city. Street Address: 5508 Glengarry PKWY City of Residence: Edina

Page 44 of 72 353. Name: Andrew Poffenberger on 2016-08-23 18:08:51 Comments: Street Address: 713 Minnehaha Ave E City of Residence: Saint Paul

354. Name: Jackie Lund on 2016-08-23 19:21:46 Comments: Is there any way to add a dog park to the area? Braemar could charge for a pass to pay any expenses. Street Address: 5805 Hidden Lane City of Residence: Edina

355. Name: Josh Jones on 2016-08-23 20:14:43 Comments: Street Address: 209 W 2nd Ave N, 03 City of Residence: AURORA

356. Name: Jeanne Riha on 2016-08-23 21:00:18 Comments: Great Idea! Street Address: 5213 Meadow Ridge City of Residence: Edina

357. Name: Scott Putman on 2016-08-23 21:44:11 Comments: This is a really good idea! Street Address: 2539 Oakwood Ave. City of Residence: Green Bay WI 54301

358. Name: Kim Swiler on 2016-08-23 23:35:11 Comments: Street Address: 6108 Arbour Lane City of Residence: Edina

359. Name: Jeff Ingram on 2016-08-24 01:10:03 Comments: This will not only be an asset to the city, but also the high school and elementary schools. Street Address: 14400 Lennell Drive City of Residence: Minnetonka

360. Name: Benjamin Creagh on 2016-08-24 01:33:06 Comments: Street Address: 16 White Pine Lane City of Residence: Birchwood Village

361. Name: Alan Hough on 2016-08-24 02:36:05 Comments: Great thing to do. I hope more areas will do the same. I skied a park outside

Page 45 of 72 Brighton, MI that has a few klms of manmade snow. It was wonderful to be on snow when it was cold, but no natural snow. Good luck!!! Street Address: 417 Spring St City of Residence: Grove City, PA

362. Name: Betsy Gilbert on 2016-08-24 02:37:52 Comments: Street Address: 1466 Skiles Lane City of Residence: Arden Hills

363. Name: Keith Gilbert on 2016-08-24 02:38:35 Comments: This is sorely needed in the West Metro. Street Address: 1466 Skiles lane City of Residence: Arden Hills, Mn

364. Name: Josie Nelson on 2016-08-24 03:09:42 Comments: Street Address: 239 Peninsula Road City of Residence: Medicine Lake

365. Name: David Nelson on 2016-08-24 03:12:01 Comments: Street Address: 239 Peninsula Road City of Residence: Medicine Lake

366. Name: Jeanne Krantz-Swenson on 2016-08-24 03:42:43 Comments: This is a very good thing to do with winters becoming less reliable. Plus, the timing is great, as the cost will be less due to the other construction Street Address: 8100 Russell Ave S #128 City of Residence: Bloomington MN

367. Name: Kathryn Newsome-Herr on 2016-08-24 11:05:28 Comments: I think this is a super idea. Street Address: 6708 Galway Deive City of Residence: Edina

368. Name: Cindy Huttner on 2016-08-24 13:46:57 Comments: Street Address: 6628 Gleason Terrace City of Residence: Edina, Mn

369. Name: Mike Huttner on 2016-08-24 14:29:51 Comments: Street Address: 6628 Gleason Terrace City of Residence: Edina

Page 46 of 72 370. Name: Therese White on 2016-08-24 15:01:22 Comments: Street Address: 3245 Richmond Ave. City of Residence: Shoreview

371. Name: Andrew Heyer on 2016-08-24 15:26:40 Comments: Street Address: 5717 Deville Dr City of Residence: Edina

372. Name: Stephen Bullard on 2016-08-24 15:40:46 Comments: My daughter open enrolled in the Edina School system and we would use this facility as a family also Street Address: 3327 Saint Paul Avenue City of Residence: Minneapolis Mn 55416

373. Name: Floyd Grabiel on 2016-08-24 15:42:43 Comments: Don't let the NIMBYs wear you down Street Address: 4817 Wilford Way City of Residence: Edina

374. Name: Ashley Larson on 2016-08-24 16:05:50 Comments: Street Address: 5843 Scenic Dr City of Residence: Minnetonka

375. Name: Cody on 2016-08-24 19:01:06 Comments: Street Address: 3053 Lake Shore Dr City of Residence: Minneapolis

376. Name: Kelly Grosd on 2016-08-24 22:07:07 Comments: This would be amazing as we need more areas to ski.. Street Address: 8934 Gould Road City of Residence: Eden Prairie

377. Name: Wallace Alexander on 2016-08-24 22:31:07 Comments: Well designed and well maintained trails throughout the woods make for a safer environment for all. I have seen the positive improvements at Theodore Wirth park after Mpls Parks put in more trails. These professionally designed ski trails at Braemar will definitely improve this section of Edina AND give countless hours of outside exercise to student athletes and residents. Street Address: 3912 Garfield Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

Page 47 of 72 378. Name: Richard Moore on 2016-08-24 22:38:53 Comments: Street Address: 4807 Maple Rd City of Residence: Edina

379. Name: Catherine Gump on 2016-08-25 01:34:57 Comments: Street Address: 4703 Sunnyside road City of Residence: Edina

380. Name: melissa raphan on 2016-08-25 02:18:43 Comments: This is critical for the EHS Nordic Team and our community. The team has over 200 kids and is a no-cut sport--one of the few. it builds community and is inclusive and welcoming. Braemar Park Recreation proposal must be passed. Street Address: 4515 casco avenue City of Residence: edina

381. Name: Tom Rock on 2016-08-25 02:56:29 Comments: Street Address: 4515 CASCO AVE City of Residence: EDINA

382. Name: Elizabeth Edblom on 2016-08-25 03:07:00 Comments: Street Address: 4606 Wooddale Ace. City of Residence: Edina

383. Name: Lijun Zou on 2016-08-25 12:55:55 Comments: Street Address: 6232 Braeburn Cir City of Residence: Edina

384. Name: Jeff Patterson on 2016-08-25 13:46:28 Comments: Cross country skiing is a silent sport and a healthy pursuit. Street Address: 4537 Dupont Ave. S. City of Residence: Minneapolis

385. Name: Sue Michals on 2016-08-25 15:06:34 Comments: Street Address: 4708 Isabel Ave. City of Residence: Minneapolis

386. Name: John Kleiber on 2016-08-25 16:21:24 Comments:

Page 48 of 72 Street Address: 6709 Limerick Lane City of Residence: Edina

387. Name: David Delforge on 2016-08-25 18:14:20 Comments: Street Address: 891 Lyman Blvd City of Residence: Chanhassen

388. Name: Amy Adams on 2016-08-25 19:21:35 Comments: Street Address: 4841 E. Lake Harriet Pkwy. City of Residence: Minneapolis

389. Name: Theresa Gifford on 2016-08-25 19:23:15 Comments: Street Address: 2170 lower st dennis City of Residence: St paul

390. Name: Jim Carlen on 2016-08-25 19:26:12 Comments: Street Address: 601 Montcalm place City of Residence: St. Paul mn

391. Name: Tyler Gilbert on 2016-08-25 19:30:17 Comments: Street Address: 600 10th Ave se #204 City of Residence: Minneapolis

392. Name: Chris Pope on 2016-08-25 19:31:08 Comments: Street Address: 4850 Colfax Avenue S City of Residence: Minneapolis

393. Name: Marshall Gifford on 2016-08-25 19:31:44 Comments: Street Address: 2170 Lower St. Dennis Rs City of Residence: St. Paul

394. Name: Jonah Gilbert on 2016-08-25 19:31:45 Comments: Street Address: 1057 26th ave se City of Residence: Minneapolis

395. Name: Emily Kennett on 2016-08-25 19:33:25 Comments:

Page 49 of 72 Street Address: 3100 West River Parkway City of Residence: Minneapolis, MN 55406

396. Name: Greta Gage on 2016-08-25 19:43:04 Comments: I'm an Edina High School Graduate (class of 2013) and former member of the high school nordic ski team. The nordic ski team was the highlight of my time in high school and the construction at Edina High School is limiting the available practice areas on campus. Ski trails at Braemar will benefit not only the 200+ students who are on the ski team annually but the Edina community as a whole. These ski trails will create new opportunities for Edina residents to take part in a lifelong sport (and one that can become a family-wide activity) with one of the kindest communities I've had the pleasure of being a member of. Street Address: 5813 Amy Drive City of Residence: Edina

397. Name: sandi on 2016-08-25 20:16:00 Comments: Street Address: 2711 vera cruz ave n City of Residence: crystal

398. Name: Elizabeth Cripe on 2016-08-25 20:23:31 Comments: Street Address: 4232 Standish Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

399. Name: Angie Askegaard on 2016-08-25 20:25:16 Comments: We need snow to ski in west metro!! Street Address: 9188 La Rivier Court City of Residence: Eden Prairie , MN 55347

400. Name: Elizabeth Shaffer on 2016-08-25 20:52:44 Comments: Street Address: 1776 Colfax Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

401. Name: Luke Wasson on 2016-08-25 21:16:09 Comments: Street Address: 1426 Idaho Ave W City of Residence: Falcon Heights

402. Name: Patricia Carlen on 2016-08-25 21:17:10 Comments: I strongly support snow-making for ski trails in Edina. As an avid skier, it would be wonderful to have one more option with reliable snow. I know I would use the trails. Street Address: 601 Montcalm Place City of Residence: Saint Paul

Page 50 of 72 403. Name: Mark Peugh on 2016-08-25 21:29:49 Comments: Street Address: 483 W Eagle Lake Dr City of Residence: Maple Grove, MN

404. Name: Michelle DeLaundreau on 2016-08-25 21:33:48 Comments: Street Address: 877 Carroll Ave City of Residence: Saint Paul

405. Name: Tom Egger on 2016-08-25 21:36:21 Comments: Street Address: 4308 Philbrook Lane City of Residence: Edina

406. Name: Bob O'Hara on 2016-08-25 21:57:30 Comments: This is another great opportunity8 to provide recreation, training, and enjoyment in Edina. Cross Country/Nordic skiing has been growing as more trails are available. Street Address: 6001 Goodrich Ave City of Residence: St. Louis Park

407. Name: Erin Savre on 2016-08-25 22:06:34 Comments: Street Address: 5525 Hansen rd #110 City of Residence: Edina

408. Name: LuAnn Berg on 2016-08-25 22:42:42 Comments: There is a great need in the West Metro for consistent snow on our trails. Street Address: 4800 Orchid Ln N, City of Residence: Plymouth

409. Name: Lars Parmekar on 2016-08-25 23:02:53 Comments: Street Address: 4311 Grimes Ave S City of Residence: Edina

410. Name: Craig Cardinal on 2016-08-25 23:13:21 Comments: Street Address: 1101 Elm St City of Residence: Northfield

411. Name: Bob Brandt on 2016-08-25 23:18:58 Comments: skiing is good.

Page 51 of 72 Street Address: 9800 Janero Ct N City of Residence: Mahtomedi, MN 55115-1338

412. Name: Matthew Dosland on 2016-08-25 23:20:11 Comments: Snowmaking is needed everywhere, especially after what we've seen the last two years. As an skier I would love to see as much snowmaking in the cities as possible. Street Address: 1196 Portland Ave City of Residence: Saint Paul

413. Name: Todd Johnson on 2016-08-26 00:25:28 Comments: This is a resource that will be used beyond what the numbers people will initially think possible. Street Address: 1899 Fairmount Ave. City of Residence: St. Paul

414. Name: Betsy Longley on 2016-08-26 00:50:36 Comments: Promoting and supporting healthy activities for the community should be a priority for the leaders of all cities. If not you, who? If not now, when? Street Address: 9514 Colorado Circle City of Residence: Bloomington

415. Name: Marty Johnston on 2016-08-26 00:58:20 Comments: It will get used :) Street Address: 1841 Montreal Ave City of Residence: Saint Paul

416. Name: Jackson Pope on 2016-08-26 01:33:02 Comments: Street Address: 4850 Colfax Ave s City of Residence: Minneapolis

417. Name: Kathy Pope on 2016-08-26 01:43:31 Comments: Street Address: 4850 Colfax Ave South City of Residence: Minneapolis

418. Name: mark Leach on 2016-08-26 01:57:51 Comments: build it and they will come Street Address: 244 10th Avenue North City of Residence: Hopkins

419. Name: John Rock on 2016-08-26 02:31:12 Comments: Street Address: 1955 Glenpaul Ave. City of Residence: Arden Hills

Page 52 of 72 420. Name: Flynn Codding on 2016-08-26 02:33:22 Comments: Street Address: 4629 W 56th st City of Residence: Edina

421. Name: steve sonnesyn on 2016-08-26 02:41:23 Comments: Snow making here would get a lot of use and would be a great bonus to the community and a big support to a healthy life-style; I would definitely ski there. Street Address: 3110 jewel lane City of Residence: plymouth mn 55447

422. Name: Andrew Brown on 2016-08-26 03:14:26 Comments: Street Address: 1346 E Como Blvd City of Residence: St. Paul

423. Name: Jay Rudi on 2016-08-26 03:52:34 Comments: Street Address: 4708 Valley View Road City of Residence: Edina

424. Name: Mary Berntson on 2016-08-26 04:02:08 Comments: This would be a great way to support the EHS Nordic ski teams who are losing their trails due to the new construction at EHS. It also would support our citizen skiers and utilize our parks on a year round basis. Street Address: 6728 Point Drive City of Residence: Edina

425. Name: Allison Mueller on 2016-08-26 04:06:27 Comments: Street Address: 5553 Colfax Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

426. Name: Nancy Mendel on 2016-08-26 04:11:08 Comments: Please approve the cross country ski trails with snow making capabilities!!! Street Address: 7113 West Shore Drive City of Residence: Edina

427. Name: Christian Lawler on 2016-08-26 04:14:44 Comments: Hundreds of kids in Edina enjoy cross country skiing during the winter months, and many train during the summer just to prepare for the winter season. This is a life-long sport that parents can enjoy with their children and continue to enjoy into their older years. Help us promote a healthy life style for our community by supporting a cross country ski trail at Braemar Park.

Page 53 of 72 Street Address: 4601 Sunnyside Road City of Residence: Edina

428. Name: Thomas Egger on 2016-08-26 06:12:55 Comments: Street Address: 4006 Grimes Ave City of Residence: Edina

429. Name: Nancy Sinykin on 2016-08-26 06:14:47 Comments: I would love to see cross country ski trails at Braemar. Our family would enjoy using the trails throughout the year. Street Address: 4413 Fondell Drive City of Residence: Edina

430. Name: Rich Sinykin on 2016-08-26 06:16:36 Comments: Street Address: 4413 Fondell Drive City of Residence: Edina

431. Name: Sofie shand on 2016-08-26 06:29:09 Comments: Street Address: Townes rd City of Residence: edina

432. Name: Andrew Egger on 2016-08-26 08:15:27 Comments: Street Address: 4006 grimes Ave south City of Residence: Edina

433. Name: Rong Zheng on 2016-08-26 08:23:02 Comments: I am for it Street Address: 7005 valley view rd City of Residence: Edina

434. Name: Erica klausen on 2016-08-26 10:20:37 Comments: Please pass this as a skier myself it would be great to ski locally... What a fabulous opportunity for our local high school kids who didn't get to ski much last year due to no snow and limited space at other parks. If this were your passion you wouldn't hesitate. Street Address: 5216 Grandview Lane City of Residence: Edina

435. Name: Debi Peterson on 2016-08-26 11:18:45 Comments: Street Address: 5543 Grand Ave S

Page 54 of 72 City of Residence: Minneapolis

436. Name: Cheryl Behling on 2016-08-26 11:33:13 Comments: Street Address: 4368 Oakdale AVe. S City of Residence: Edina

437. Name: Christy Thiele on 2016-08-26 12:02:35 Comments: Street Address: 5524 Code Ave City of Residence: Edina

438. Name: Eric Askegaard on 2016-08-26 12:04:15 Comments: Street Address: 11000 Optum Way City of Residence: Eden Prairie, MN 55347

439. Name: juliannelogan on 2016-08-26 12:24:33 Comments: Street Address: 5806 olinger road City of Residence: Edina

440. Name: scott thiele on 2016-08-26 12:33:41 Comments: Street Address: 5524 code ave City of Residence: edina

441. Name: Raegan Hinrichs on 2016-08-26 12:50:02 Comments: Street Address: 4112 W 44th St City of Residence: Edina

442. Name: Rick Passolt on 2016-08-26 12:53:38 Comments: This is a wonderful idea and use of that land. I support it. Street Address: 6536 Ridgeview Drive City of Residence: Edina

443. Name: peggy jessen on 2016-08-26 12:56:30 Comments: Street Address: 4627 arden avenue City of Residence: edina

444. Name: Brian Drought on 2016-08-26 13:30:46 Comments: Street Address: 3317 W 55th Street

Page 55 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

445. Name: pam krause on 2016-08-26 13:42:35 Comments: Street Address: 14255 fossil lane City of Residence: apple valley

446. Name: C Manning on 2016-08-26 14:09:38 Comments: Street Address: 3029 Galleria, Edina, MN, 55435 City of Residence: Edina

447. Name: Jeffrey Kuhs on 2016-08-26 14:13:47 Comments: This is a great use of public land that will benefit a large segment of the Edina population. We have a history in Edina of making far-sighted decisions that have made this a great place to live - let's continue making our city great. Street Address: 5837 Chowen Av S City of Residence: Edina, MN

448. Name: Clayt Tabor on 2016-08-26 14:23:08 Comments: Let's promote these types of facilities for our kids to keep them active and healthy. This is a sport they can do for their entire life. Street Address: 6024 Grove Circle City of Residence: Edina

449. Name: Julie Tonsager Tabor on 2016-08-26 14:29:44 Comments: I think this addition would be a great venue for not only team sports, but also families to also utilize the trails during the cold months. Please consider adding it as you have added other facilities for team sports (such as turf fields) Street Address: 6024 Grove Circle City of Residence: Edina, MN

450. Name: mfgrein on 2016-08-26 14:56:26 Comments: Street Address: 3608 w 55th st City of Residence: edina mn

451. Name: Mindyrose Sinykin on 2016-08-26 15:11:57 Comments: Street Address: 4413 Fondell Drive City of Residence: Edina

452. Name: David Bowlin on 2016-08-26 15:13:53 Comments: Street Address: 4618 Arden Ave

Page 56 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

453. Name: Cathy Kidd on 2016-08-26 15:44:28 Comments: Support this ONLY if EHS cc ski team has access to train and compete Street Address: 5528 Glengarry rd City of Residence: Edina

454. Name: Talia Willmert on 2016-08-26 16:01:13 Comments: Street Address: 4544 Rutledge Avenue City of Residence: Edina

455. Name: Suzanne Weingartner on 2016-08-26 17:07:13 Comments: My daughter was on Edina's Nordic Ski team... And so was I back in the 1980's! It is one of the few winter sporting opportunities where all are welcome to participate. Street Address: 6904 Dakota Trail City of Residence: Edina

456. Name: Max Owens on 2016-08-26 18:04:54 Comments: Street Address: 6816 Ridgeview Dr City of Residence: Edina

457. Name: Carter Olson on 2016-08-26 18:56:00 Comments: Most happen. Street Address: 4001 wood end dr City of Residence: Edina

458. Name: Jared Sundstrom on 2016-08-26 19:29:08 Comments: This sounds like a wonderful idea! Street Address: 2896 James Ave S Apt 208 City of Residence: Minneapolis

459. Name: Liz Marty on 2016-08-26 20:03:18 Comments: Street Address: 5221 W.61st Street City of Residence: Edina

460. Name: Timothy J Karlen on 2016-08-26 20:33:30 Comments: Street Address: 6704 Samuel Road City of Residence: Edina

461. Name: Jennifer Haefner Karlen on 2016-08-26 20:34:49

Page 57 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 6704 Samuel Road City of Residence: Edina

462. Name: Jack Sullivan on 2016-08-26 20:41:26 Comments: Street Address: 5808 Beard Avenue City of Residence: Edina

463. Name: Marta Martinez-Davison on 2016-08-26 21:27:52 Comments: Street Address: 4544 Rutledge Avenue City of Residence: Edina

464. Name: John Purdum on 2016-08-26 21:28:46 Comments: Street Address: 4544 Rutledge Avenue City of Residence: Edina

465. Name: emily kompelien on 2016-08-26 22:25:28 Comments: Street Address: 4208 w 44th street City of Residence: Edina

466. Name: Alexis on 2016-08-26 22:53:33 Comments: Street Address: 6232 Braeburn Circle City of Residence: Edina

467. Name: Kevin on 2016-08-26 22:54:40 Comments: Street Address: 6232 Braeburn Circle City of Residence: Edina

468. Name: Nick Idrofo on 2016-08-26 23:49:40 Comments: Street Address: 7004 Weston Circle City of Residence: Edina

469. Name: Megan Knudson on 2016-08-27 02:52:01 Comments: Street Address: 4211 W 44th St. City of Residence: Edina

470. Name: Annelies lijesen on 2016-08-27 04:40:32

Page 58 of 72 Comments: I am all for more ski Milages Street Address: 4804 W Sunnyslope road City of Residence: Edina

471. Name: Noah calvo on 2016-08-27 15:54:27 Comments: As a dedicated Nordic skier, both recreational and serious, I insist that the addition of these trails is NECESSARY Street Address: 5509 Dever Dr City of Residence: Edina

472. Name: AARON VOREIS on 2016-08-27 16:03:53 Comments: Street Address: 4004 w 42nd st City of Residence: EDINA

473. Name: Dave Rohlf on 2016-08-27 16:10:00 Comments: Great program that really needs our support. Street Address: 4237 Scott Terrace City of Residence: Edina

474. Name: Jared Anderson on 2016-08-27 16:11:44 Comments: Street Address: 4004 Monterey avenue City of Residence: Edina

475. Name: Jeff Dykstra on 2016-08-27 16:22:28 Comments: This would be a great benefit for the city -pls approve Street Address: 4303 Branson st City of Residence: Edina

476. Name: Ehren Seim on 2016-08-27 16:29:57 Comments: Street Address: 4115 Morningside Road City of Residence: Edina

477. Name: Angie Andresen on 2016-08-27 16:37:26 Comments: Street Address: 4201 W. 42nd St. City of Residence: Edina

478. Name: Seth hannula on 2016-08-27 16:39:00 Comments: Better investment than 5 artificial turf fields with crumb rubber Street Address: 4307 Oakdale av City of Residence: edina

Page 59 of 72 479. Name: Josh riff on 2016-08-27 17:00:27 Comments: This would be terrific for our community Street Address: 7116 Lanham lane City of Residence: Edina

480. Name: Chris McClain on 2016-08-27 17:10:21 Comments: Street Address: 4043 Sunnyside Rd City of Residence: Edina

481. Name: Shawn Murnan on 2016-08-27 17:26:37 Comments: Street Address: 4223 Oakdale Ave City of Residence: Edina

482. Name: Paul Hovelsrud on 2016-08-27 17:32:04 Comments: The team and the community need this trail system. Street Address: 4425 North ave City of Residence: Edina

483. Name: steven e klos on 2016-08-27 17:40:48 Comments: I believe that this project will only add to the overall life experience that the Edina community has to offer. Street Address: 5019 Wooddale Lane City of Residence: Edina

484. Name: Jonah Calvo on 2016-08-27 17:43:03 Comments: Street Address: 5509 Dever Drive City of Residence: Edina

485. Name: Matthew Holderness on 2016-08-27 17:47:16 Comments: I have many friends who participate in xc skiing and having more ski trails in Edina is always a good thing. Street Address: 4604 w 58th street City of Residence: Edina

486. Name: shawn gaither on 2016-08-27 18:19:24 Comments: Street Address: 5725 dale ave City of Residence: edina

487. Name: Kim Griswold on 2016-08-27 18:32:35 Comments: Street Address: 5312 Malibu Dr

Page 60 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

488. Name: Mike Burg on 2016-08-27 18:43:19 Comments: Skiing is a life long activity Street Address: 5813 Oaklawn Ave. City of Residence: Edina

489. Name: Marian Delaney on 2016-08-27 18:44:02 Comments: We support the proposal for the cross country ski and mountain bike trails. Street Address: 5717 grove st City of Residence: Edina

490. Name: Natalie Burg on 2016-08-27 18:44:23 Comments: Street Address: 5813 Oaklawn Ave. City of Residence: Edina

491. Name: Kaia Burg on 2016-08-27 18:46:06 Comments: I love snow and skiing Street Address: 5813 Oaklawn Ave City of Residence: Edina

492. Name: Dan lhnat on 2016-08-27 18:49:25 Comments: Street Address: 4220 Crocker Ave City of Residence: Edina

493. Name: Leonardo Rapallini on 2016-08-27 18:51:42 Comments: Street Address: 4513 Bruce Ave City of Residence: Edina

494. Name: Carl Sledgister on 2016-08-27 18:56:45 Comments: Street Address: 4320 France Ave S City of Residence: Edina

495. Name: Chelsea Grimes on 2016-08-27 18:59:07 Comments: Street Address: 5516 woodcrest dr City of Residence: mpls

496. Name: Sally Arndt on 2016-08-27 19:00:44 Comments: Street Address: 5505 Dundee Rd

Page 61 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

497. Name: Bob Cossack on 2016-08-27 19:04:03 Comments: Street Address: 3912 West 42nd Street City of Residence: Edina

498. Name: Sara Klos on 2016-08-27 19:15:50 Comments: Street Address: 5019 wooddale lane City of Residence: Minneapolis

499. Name: Mark Stevens on 2016-08-27 19:16:33 Comments: Street Address: 4224 Oakdale Ave S City of Residence: Edina

500. Name: Marcy Swenson on 2016-08-27 19:26:46 Comments: Street Address: 5501 Dever Drive City of Residence: Edina

501. Name: Michael Knudson on 2016-08-27 19:29:33 Comments: Street Address: 4211 w 44th st City of Residence: Edina

502. Name: Mark Swenson on 2016-08-27 19:29:57 Comments: Street Address: 5501 Dever Drive City of Residence: Edina

503. Name: Vittorio raimondi on 2016-08-27 19:30:40 Comments: Street Address: 5409 Doncaster way City of Residence: Edina

504. Name: Kim Strong on 2016-08-27 19:44:36 Comments: Street Address: 5412 Park Place City of Residence: Edina

505. Name: Kathy Simon on 2016-08-27 19:58:48 Comments: Street Address: West 42nd Street

Page 62 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

506. Name: Andrea Albertson on 2016-08-27 19:58:49 Comments: Street Address: 5409 Doncaster Way City of Residence: Edina

507. Name: Timothy Grafe on 2016-08-27 20:16:19 Comments: I support adding these trails! Street Address: 4242 Grimes Av. S. City of Residence: Edina

508. Name: Jeffrey Steele on 2016-08-27 20:34:54 Comments: Street Address: 4404 w 42nd street City of Residence: Edina

509. Name: Mitch Granberg on 2016-08-27 20:39:51 Comments: Street Address: 6721 Galway Drive City of Residence: Edina

510. Name: Cindy Miller on 2016-08-27 21:02:14 Comments: Street Address: 891 Lyman Blvd City of Residence: Chanhassen

511. Name: Jennifer Hovelsrud on 2016-08-27 21:06:02 Comments: Street Address: 4425 North Ave. City of Residence: Edina

512. Name: Russ freeman on 2016-08-27 21:16:21 Comments: Street Address: 5700 view lane City of Residence: Edina

513. Name: Priya on 2016-08-27 21:45:32 Comments: Yes I support this petition. The ski trail will be an asset to the community. Street Address: 5817 Johnson Drive City of Residence: Edina

514. Name: Arnout Lijesen on 2016-08-27 22:09:31 Comments: Street Address: 4804 west Sunnyslope road

Page 63 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

515. Name: Tara Frimat on 2016-08-28 00:27:39 Comments: Street Address: 5504 Dever Dr City of Residence: Edina

516. Name: Steven Mosborg on 2016-08-28 00:28:36 Comments: Help support one of the healthiest winter sports for my daughter's generation and beyond. Street Address: 4430 West Lake Harriet Parkway City of Residence: Minneapolis

517. Name: Tom Delaney on 2016-08-28 01:33:40 Comments: Street Address: 5717 Grove Street City of Residence: Edina

518. Name: Kari Clark on 2016-08-28 02:18:14 Comments: Street Address: 5501 Park Place City of Residence: Edina

519. Name: Gwen Smith on 2016-08-28 02:47:02 Comments: Street Address: 3913 Morningside Road City of Residence: Edina, MN 55416

520. Name: Peter Rebstock on 2016-08-28 03:26:26 Comments: Street Address: 4411 Branson St City of Residence: Edina

521. Name: Elizabeth Cecchi on 2016-08-28 03:56:02 Comments: Nordic skiing is a fantastic sport for so many reasons: Minnesota heritage, athleticism, fitness, and enjoying the natural outdoors. It's also great for the whole family and it's a life-long activity. We need to support Nordic skiing in as many ways as we can and these trails would be a great asset for our community. Street Address: 4209 Morningside Rd City of Residence: Edina

522. Name: Larry Lomax on 2016-08-28 11:48:47 Comments: Street Address: 5516 Park PI City of Residence: Edina

Page 64 of 72 523. Name: Carl Torgerson on 2016-08-28 13:26:18 Comments: Street Address: 2285 university ave w City of Residence: Saint paul

524. Name: Terri Menke on 2016-08-28 14:37:23 Comments: Street Address: 5201 Grove Street City of Residence: Edina

525. Name: Chris Gryskiewicz on 2016-08-28 14:47:23 Comments: Street Address: 8642 Wood Cliff Circle South City of Residence: Bloomington

526. Name: Charlotte McKlveen on 2016-08-28 17:32:15 Comments: Street Address: 5261 Lochloy Drive City of Residence: Edina

527. Name: August Blanchett on 2016-08-28 18:15:29 Comments: I would love to be able to ski on trails all season, with snowmaking, at Braemar. Trails at Hyland are very crowded, as are trails at Theodore Wirth. Wirth is expanding because those trails are so popular/busy. Like all trails, they are busiest evening and weekends, when I have time to go. My friends and I would use a Braemar trail 50+times per season. Thanks for your support. Street Address: 4737 Hibiscus Avenue City of Residence: Edina

528. Name: Ella lindberg on 2016-08-28 18:19:38 Comments: Street Address: 4629 Arden Ave City of Residence: Edina

529. Name: Morgan May on 2016-08-28 18:51:28 Comments: Street Address: 4906 Bruce Ave City of Residence: Edina

530. Name: Asa Bowen on 2016-08-28 19:25:32 Comments: Street Address: 6908 Mark Terrace Drive City of Residence: Edina

Page 65 of 72 531. Name: James on 2016-08-28 19:27:53 Comments: Ood Street Address: 6224 loch moor dr City of Residence: Edina

532. Name: Cindy Scott on 2016-08-28 19:52:19 Comments: The trails sound like a win win for the city, community and avid skiers like my nephews who live there. Street Address: Luling Ln City of Residence: Austin

533. Name: Pamela Gokemeijer on 2016-08-28 22:14:32 Comments: Street Address: 4334 Drew Avenue South City of Residence: Minneapolis

534. Name: Allison on 2016-08-28 22:17:47 Comments: Street Address: 6124 Scotia Dr. City of Residence: Edina

535. Name: Piotr Bednarski on 2016-08-28 22:58:25 Comments: There is a huge demand for this ! lots of people will use it! Street Address: 3100 Dean Ct City of Residence: Minneapolis

536. Name: Alex Ogren on 2016-08-28 23:02:59 Comments: Street Address: 5912 sun road City of Residence: Edina

537. Name: Shaoping Wu on 2016-08-29 00:35:26 Comments: Street Address: 5400 Creekview Ln City of Residence: Edina

538. Name: Brent Bjerkness on 2016-08-29 01:48:31 Comments: Street Address: 4940 17th Ave S City of Residence: Minneapolis

539. Name: Nate Richman on 2016-08-29 02:11:07 Comments: Street Address: 5828 Ewing Ave. S. City of Residence: Edina

Page 66 of 72 540. Name: Rachael Bentley on 2016-08-29 02:11:30 Comments: Street Address: 5120 Grove St. City of Residence: Edina

541. Name: Harry Rothberg on 2016-08-29 02:11:48 Comments: Street Address: 5824 Ewing ave s City of Residence: Edina

542. Name: Ted McKlveen on 2016-08-29 02:16:37 Comments: Street Address: 5261 Lochloy Drive City of Residence: Edina

543. Name: Scott on 2016-08-29 02:20:13 Comments: Street Address: Minneapolis City of Residence: Minneapolis

544. Name: Cecie Bourbour on 2016-08-29 02:36:49 Comments: Street Address: 6832 Gleason Road City of Residence: Edina

545. Name: Frannie Kuhs on 2016-08-29 02:59:56 Comments: This is a great addition for Edina and the community. Street Address: 5837 Chowen Ave City of Residence: Edina

546. Name: Kameron Poncius on 2016-08-29 03:28:21 Comments: Street Address: 4920 Trillium Lane City of Residence: Edina

547. Name: Paul schlaefer on 2016-08-29 03:46:49 Comments: Street Address: 5404 park place City of Residence: Edina, mn

548. Name: Chloe Michalak on 2016-08-29 03:50:39 Comments: Street Address: 4420 Grimes Avenue So City of Residence: Edina

Page 67 of 72 549. Name: Jenae Nelson on 2016-08-29 03:52:47 Comments: Street Address: 5912 Hansen road City of Residence: Edina

550. Name: Michael Toth on 2016-08-29 04:14:00 Comments: Street Address: 4309 Morningside Road City of Residence: Edina

551. Name: Monica Harrell on 2016-08-29 05:41:25 Comments: Please vote yes for the Braemer Park Winter recreation proposal. This will be utilized by so many for years to come and having a park in the metropolitan area is needed for exercise and being close to nature. For those who live out in rural MN, it will provide another place to visit to be outdoors. Street Address: 1352F McNally Drive City of Residence: Winona

552. Name: Alisa Lamont on 2016-08-29 11:05:48 Comments: Street Address: 5901 Ruth Drive City of Residence: Edina

553. Name: Josephine Kleiber on 2016-08-29 13:33:50 Comments: Street Address: 6709 Limerick Lane City of Residence: Edina

554. Name: Elise Wallen-Friedman on 2016-08-29 13:34:32 Comments: Street Address: Limerick Lane City of Residence: Edina

555. Name: Tracy Shand on 2016-08-29 13:41:58 Comments: We vote Yes for the Braemar Winter Park! Street Address: 4824 Townes Rd City of Residence: Edina

556. Name: Alex Melton on 2016-08-29 13:44:01 Comments: Skiing at Braemar is a natural extension of Braemar's important role as a community park. Street Address: 5617 Wycliffe Road City of Residence: Edina

Page 68 of 72 557. Name: Nils Gokemeijer on 2016-08-29 13:46:23 Comments: Street Address: 4206 W 44th St City of Residence: Edina

558. Name: Daniel Shand on 2016-08-29 13:59:17 Comments: Yes for Braemar winter recreation proposal. Street Address: 4824 Townes Road City of Residence: Edina

559. Name: Jim Vandervelde on 2016-08-29 14:04:31 Comments: Street Address: 6605 Biscayne Blvd City of Residence: Edina

560. Name: Michael Conover on 2016-08-29 14:32:22 Comments: I enjoy XC skiing, and would appreciate a closer venue than Highland. Street Address: 5417 Blake Rd S City of Residence: Edina

561. Name: Caitlin Houle on 2016-08-29 14:41:25 Comments: Street Address: 4532 Parkside Lane City of Residence: Edina

562. Name: Mike Kay on 2016-08-29 15:00:11 Comments: Add an ice rink and have concessions from Tin Fish. Awesome!! Street Address: 7225 Fleetwood Dr City of Residence: Edina

563. Name: John Lunieski on 2016-08-29 15:35:11 Comments: Edina Nordic Ski Team Member - Class of 2003 Street Address: 4121 Monterey Ave City of Residence: Edina

564. Name: Craig Gustafson on 2016-08-29 15:47:45 Comments: Street Address: 5025 Nevada Circle City of Residence: Bloomington

565. Name: Brian Kompelien on 2016-08-29 15:48:10 Comments: With 2 kids on the Edina Nordic Team, our family values this proposal very much. Nordic is a great sport and this would be a big step to improve the Edina Nordic Team! Street Address: 4208 W 44th St

Page 69 of 72 City of Residence: Edina

566. Name: Erica Rempert on 2016-08-29 15:53:45 Comments: Street Address: 5621 York Ave. City of Residence: Edina

567. Name: Amy Pisansky on 2016-08-29 15:55:24 Comments: Street Address: 1901 Skyhigh Driver City of Residence: New Brighton

568. Name: Erin Rapallini on 2016-08-29 16:09:45 Comments: Street Address: 4513 Bruce Ave City of Residence: Edina

569. Name: Susan Burnett on 2016-08-29 17:01:57 Comments: Edina cross country teams are losing their training space please put a cross country facility at Braemar Street Address: 4270 Lewis Ridge Parkway City of Residence: Edina 55439

570. Name: Mike on 2016-08-29 17:37:56 Comments: Street Address: 6004 wooddale ave City of Residence: Edina

571. Name: Nancy Killilea on 2016-08-29 18:52:37 Comments: Absolutely YES! Reaching a broader audience with healthy activities should be a priority. Street Address: 4236 Lynn Avenue City of Residence: Edina

572. Name: Leona Werner on 2016-08-29 19:42:54 Comments: Street Address: 6716 Point Drive City of Residence: Edina

573. Name: Cal Hardie on 2016-08-29 20:58:09 Comments: Street Address: 6833 Oaklawn Ave City of Residence: Edina

574. Name: Ellen Smalley on 2016-08-29 21:15:39

Page 70 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 5917 Halifax Ave City of Residence: Edina, MN

575. Name: Jerry Groven on 2016-08-29 21:36:23 Comments: Street Address: 5716 Benton Ave City of Residence: Edina, MN

576. Name: Peter Killilea on 2016-08-29 22:01:09 Comments: Street Address: 4236 Lynn Ave City of Residence: Edina

577. Name: Sue Arneson on 2016-08-30 02:05:08 Comments: Street Address: 6517 Scandia Road City of Residence: Edina

578. Name: Michael g burnett on 2016-08-30 03:18:34 Comments: Team needs place to practice --- that's 200 kids!!! Street Address: 7240 Lewis Ridge Parkway City of Residence: Edina

579. Name: Nancy Nash on 2016-08-30 11:05:36 Comments: Street Address: 7482 Cahill Road City of Residence: Edina

580. Name: Patricia Kendrick on 2016-08-30 21:19:20 Comments: Would be great for everyone to enjoy! Street Address: 4210 w 44th st City of Residence: Edina

581. Name: Stephan Dunning on 2016-08-30 22:46:56 Comments: Street Address: 4828 Townes Rd City of Residence: Edina

582. Name: Cathy Villas-Horns on 2016-08-31 01:03:22 Comments: Street Address: 6101 Jeffrey Lane City of Residence: Edina

583. Name: Jim Syverson on 2016-08-31 03:12:01

Page 71 of 72 Comments: Street Address: 3900 4th Ave. S. City of Residence: Minneapolis

584. Name: Piper Bain on 2016-08-31 03:47:58 Comments: Street Address: 5812 Amy Drive City of Residence: Edina

585. Name: Estelle Bain on 2016-08-31 03:49:05 Comments: Street Address: 5812 Amy Drive City of Residence: Edina

586. Name: Clark Bain on 2016-08-31 03:50:06 Comments: Street Address: 5812 amy drive City of Residence: Edina

587. Name: Tina Bain on 2016-08-31 03:50:48 Comments: Street Address: 5812 Amy Drive City of Residence: Edina

Page 72 of 72 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 2:12 PM Subject: FW: Vote NO--Braemar nordic ski/tubing

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: CBRUNKOWPcomcast.net [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 2:10 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Vote NO--Braemar nordic ski/tubing

Dear Council Members,

We are opposed to the proposed development of a nordic ski track and tubing hill. The Three Rivers Parks offers excellent nordic skiing throughout the metro area. Hylands is very close to Braemar--10 min drive or less. We should be supporting our parks! Regarding tubing--has a study been completed to determine usage? Where is the demand? Our children/grandchildren can sled "the old fashion way" There is value in that! Quietly enjoying the winter season and the surrounding nature without state of the art equipment noise and distraction.

Thank you for this consideration.

Cathy and Gary Brunkow 5101 Skyline Dr. Edina

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 4:01 PM Subject: FW: Proposed Braemar Ski Trail

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Janet Conn [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2016 3:59 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Proposed Braemar Ski Trail

Edina Council Members:

I strongly urge you to put an immediate halt to the project to build a Nordic Ski trail at Braemar Park. We don't need it, we don't want it, the city cannot afford it, and it would be an enviromnental barrel bomb.

Where did this project even come from? From what I've read on Nextdoor.com, it sounds like it was just slipped into the pipeline without the Board's vetting and approval.

We have too many expensive projects in Edina already, and there are plenty of other places for Edinans to go to ski and tube.

Janet Conn & Michael Debelak 5804 Oak Lane 952-929-1955

1 Braemar Park -Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy, We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

Signature Printed Name Address 01 - . m_ 7/1- '-._ tizoir6,,-L £/bs &0693) itisi, /10„5 02 , / i /4-1-CR 1 7-- '; ile;• /-6' D-) ) ,ilry q 1) ',' _s' >1 ", 3 /4/,; /- ,,i 4 r 03 ( ''',` 1e,,i('-(„ A, K ' ( Can eS EIA 6'62;3

0 I AM Al e I- 'Pit)11)/ Aks-7-6 ib L 2d 9- Hn LI-F-4x WE 05- r,77 'l 4 iipir /4/f4)( 06 vied

ji.6_,-, Me i *4 i .4 l'ilda- 4Cfa.° (CI `-5// 0 aa044 (Le -4-4C 07 i ta 62-ovtg-_ --17,„ 7.---1---\_.__ 5132. if--_-4 z) 7-0 Me-- - • ---'01,--1 et- 08 Ti

lids )114-6--c_ (1:10 --nevi r) i 1/11 e-1 o Li 6-1 / o A rde IA Ave - l5 din ,, og . toliv.A.0 ANF -.tai NA '1 E: 41?-cinlE \ X10.-2- .91)f--13?--D 10 \ t- 1

This petition was circulated by:

21(611.,-*a( 697(37.44,9,0mx AAA mirvil gy0.9b6-0775/ Name Address Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Support Cross Country Skiing at Braemar Park-with Snowmaking

Signature Printed Name Address 01 , -- --) i I -2----2 \ "lb SU-Q-- 0-46\1\Ce-.. ._,27/W WOC:C\Ce_L r .6.&4. 02' 6°' , i' - Npf, / Ok".e i ef 7r ' a • ,c.- PO 0 03 1 mh/uw .,/(7;/,,Le, bEtt)deili a:r- i., 04 , ' 0, 4r/ re 0 Niciipi C.. ircf e 05 va, ad, Tot/ 76 14(tic\ 6 6 woof ro NS c;vc,/c_ / 06 4 1/ 4 \ v- .7 5 /6C'k\ Ey-d-tru..5)A ----6---,2_ & 171 ti: 07 sr : wiijor--— 303 eve.60.AviNI 547-zi Atelt_ir,,m tAptrz_. 08 ,---- // 4 \ CUR(' a_ Iii: 5413 ifV\464( vuL_ -61 u A • e4 .5 0 5-‘.,:i ebede4 oe6---oa

10 11,-a617_,3_0, \57-/-e:Oelii i,___ e l'N Clke VI 62) ,-.) ii el,,,, -e .4 0-ef,,Ez i, . , jefW- :e, %Ill is 5- 1 [ t .40 rjr be 5. 13 _„ 1 , .,_ , Ag, 4 59-3(9 Oct.1

15 /- 555.6 .040„4 CO 0140r- z ;IA le/ Ave 16 1 , 14/41K4leg/a iwoufmli 5-67_ t0 it k+ve tei),-41 17 CIK6rat'li/thi-6tt,4 Cit, Ut> 0149(-760-00 Ct ir?.__ f__ El b7104 6'11Z.,1--/ '/IA .." A\ 6 c, 18 G2- Wo OD Liktab &-1 r---, &,AAI bill1VM ‘j AN E , WI. i_s j).*-1 -E,'N.NTA- L MI..1 „G-Git2-1-1-- 19 41 ''.4 "Ail/A,(Cif t 20 2---)-^\1\ 1-1-31 141%1A P1- 114b LN 53-q-0_,\I, ‘ Cr-ICJ P—Mtrj

This petition was circulated by: 9602 - 75'/ .0-\11//W4fiaaZ' 6L4` 7l/' /444 Zalefl Name ddress Phone The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal 661 2: t , 4

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Coucil to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round. 5 ?(Z._ 4*

Signature Printed Name Address oi ---.\ccAastc- Yoviti9 02 .,

eJ/ ,,, ,,,,,,,,,,d0 04 talk ....40,...ine""im gi 4 di ---7/0 '0-4-40D141- 05 /

/4 . ,, '6 t4 Ptf/' ;t1U, (6 4 rPek 9a'.* -,--f r - 06 _/ 6 100 () y 07 /1.2A 7-17C- TL) 1 ( KY)CirCr e- 56) °J. 6b71 -9-:_ 08 _ v05-k NC-1 09 (rilr ('W(1 k- , S Aw \kik ,31-.) YAR S1 0 S--- CC1 ;-S LcOe, 10 //: /, to , -k-1-4\--- c_ki-citva., e_-_)__ - s- - /G-- __(-_,,. k

This petition was circulated by: €,M$0- 15QOASk.tY) 3 6 Name Address Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. \\\

Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, een spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

Signature Printed Name Address 01

,1" (-•/ 4) 44 /6-/TC3 A e -5 -.. 721 ,e94-<- zi-----e 02 , PAL (.4 S; 0-4, / , 'F3- 1 LL fce__/-ek_-) -r '7f. /4,o 03 ) ' V ) P._,-- C, Vi/4/ / f

06 ) / /1 ct ' 1 Ihit 1` 17l\(. Of) f 07

08 / S (co 2_ \--.) (,(, 1' 1--4 SI --,--, -, 0 t4. \,,h._,L_ T)otz r t c 09 . ' \--.1)ut ;Q---- ' c- vis 5700 -c,,(3). 1,2„, 0

-2/06/ 47-1 ik ‘1741 4-117K;/7 -5-7° k 6 cre l'tz 7/ This petition was circulated by:

0 71k1 E.? 12, Nal-fie Address Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we Inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information.

Support Cross Country Skiing at Braemar Park with Snowmaking

Signature Printed Name Address 01 (---,---, -,4 i--)--,, ( v 5 -id (- ).__f '11) ('oM1 I c-R-ca- 0C 02 1 -( Ao) 0 i - \r)n• 0 v-) 03 / Adi, Zet,12-,J)_ t-4 e/4 spiv' (0 00/ ki,)e/ v14 04 — -

I ._ 45 ‘;°);Ja:A 1/1A). 05 V I) rk., ,S 6r- 5-7a ' (,(4 6g-CC, 57.-(7( 06 .- --t .<,F4A aaeA, .4- \,6,, 4frld-cr5o, 5-05 c_,,fLity&J' 07 ,5-el-fefrc 7"1-"re.,-e....---L.------i o ‘.ge_k 4'1_ tie , k 08 va IIe t ce-61 \,U1,e_. Ctikilki Viii-e, A\-\deA'iDn ;')Y.IA Cr e e_,IL 09

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

This petition was circulated by:

Name Address Phone The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

Signature Printed Name Address . 01 (-ni"--.2/1 ,, 'Ai 1 7 ,- h 4 ia- L1/1-5 0- /'X A 0 I ( Avve- '•. 4,i1 02 -'4,thJz.' In. Y:-60)-4' cvo t- m . ‘..t.w.‘ s ci 2 \ I vitc knu QY-) 03 A n 1. i CV/WI\ AACV\ 1-CT11)\ \ )1\ 57D --\, view izejone/ 04 , , , , _ _ 7 , , ‘2/2 Of )_. , 44' ,I, / 46,“ w-___ El/F-iq os c3, --,1 5 z_ 1,2c, i r -,1---ut L--- 06 (14(041 et-adey_, ka tr e IA Li-K:LI..di7\ 5116 ae t It'emAJ_Fdi‘Ko, An 07 /

08

09

10

This petition was circulated by:

//2//4/9 /6.&-(1 /6,262 //) Name Address Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will becdme public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information.

Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

Signature Printed Name Address 01

__ H, -moi. 11 CI ie dam, 02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

This petition was circulated by:

Name Address Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information.

Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES forthe Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

This petition %vas circulated by:

/ f -

-11,v ir,fonu ion tit. ,1110111 doh', ;at tom. 10:7:-. inFec pr.t 3W d;, r. t. vdral will

. Signature Printed Name Address i ,i17------,oldar qm 6Tr- i, Av,__s 0 ..4, _saw, ,,,-,______. Lor,,._. , f<-4-7 LA/ 1 6ri '(-, _s 0 i (

n A i V't .1 7 0 rirriaj- Alie S. 3 Altih( ',/-- - ) 6116t

9 561 - NMI It-i VA. 611,(Aki,/ t(-Ut 5 VAbgL / i , 7 ed/E (2") j--47,1,7p-1 Zei-A-7e, 5 (.eflit&--- .5-EZ iiicl,-.-/?,---) 0 !i/ \ I 6 , t :;) f_i . / 1 j. V44414 - - 1 V t ..,...., , , i ..„ , 0 ., 7 • / 63 62_ a ri 1_. (5Q, iNor)ri/si'f°°( 91-fre 8 -4W-4-- ,_0,, \,-, ol„ / - 5--r) u- Rya 4,/dic 0 1 - 9 I /, 41_,b N 8, _, be,e( 4(A7 2-

- , e &NV/0 z_ 57/3 gu/H ro)//ah)4DElm'

,, G /).-4),/, 6 ter` ' 1 2 1 G ,z-,- vD3/6.__,' /-r3 i 3 67, iA 2.11 f \. . ' Support Cross Co n ry Skiing at Braemar Park vs. ith pnowmaking 1 6( / -4

fi (41/1.44-'' C ./.5- 3 a ir pe , ,t.,,, 41--,- 17-) 1 4/po ,-if; -5--,._. , (,e_wi

Li, ( _ 5- , /An. a ,rt ...1.-0i 1 i u 6 I/ ' diktirda iik ke k/ Y .3 - . ,_ /11 0-V1111 le) A: 1 1 / , , L.- LI 6 ik.a.-,:‘,-AAA, - )- , 9 ' A )

• "' k 0 1? CI Q kr + )‹ . LY4- c c--€ V 39 ) CA--cilelt -i4_,,----. , t 2 ..., \ 1 C .3.- kV' 0 o \Nov L(3c) )c 1( 6(-b ikkt, IA: 2 / 2 i fi A V d-ic itilS47). 41 41370 aiit-dolei L./ 6—‹

3 .• ' 4,,(-- Af a I% i m if 6 A 1i 1/1) h ti 1,1 7 617421) '5 -c--Aitn.,1- • 2,-4,.... sophic Ket- iNuon LiLOG ic\rair\orrt 5+. 2 Sir\ AWC__. \CAP"4\NO'' 'S 6 i D(AA'tt \1&.',A _ ( 1% ',.,,, E WA i tit ei 11 ti , . l t ?Mil ) / If 2 C., 0 (4,,,,, e,-",, 0 ii) e',--7- €-;--,::(

2 9 3 0

This petition xvas circulated by: .,-.2)(Afir) oriri wizi,innte ndoiliet plreote 11, teumite,:lIne: We 111:1f,11iuYi!or reAtt, :thou! Pte or w...tIe data we ale :thi on bi kiln.!lodes itt(ot tt dot,. 1 ki.pelnion s heel ssksi ssyslN, it t:i:it nitii stistttsn,iive iii,el.,111cyttnoe fo, tetvitti.t! to 'A40)- Iii Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

Signature Printed Name Address 01 /grin 1/. 1y 1'3/ 7 --(-,_ f fib

JJ y (113 31 D a Iced a LZ-- i Edule, r 02 i 47 03 v-1 0 ckh- c\LJe Abe )11' 04 A ti c„i (itt4 i f ( 1-',:-/fr 1 ,,,jL Ave IkivI, P / -. 3,,l a 05 ci

06 y Ma I/Mir/2- L/VP-Y TM Vr Lf t5 ( h, c-S-C (.4 07 4- ; tY)C-(1'' AI 0 1 ' (3( 16 [6'6 08

09 q

10

This petition was circulated by:

M) P)EliLM Li 3 Q>cg 0c11(8oae \le , 95 2 2C biO Name Address Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices At requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Support Cross Country Skiing at Braemar Park with Snowmaking

Si nature Printed Name Address 0 1 /j1; , a..--._. _j,,,,?y e Z I o'xi7y7 e / . .., ."--, ec— 02 ,,-;-, r - --i (A Ave:-/ T) c /- k_ 5Th 1 L 01 _5 .z._ A w: 03 -- - 7 jL_. 5,,,,,- , .-'5-1--- --71/L C.2_------7- r --S-e c ci' 5c/7;st- 57o 04 7 /- 05

610/// c.rph4., j 4tWift ri-1 :c37'51 4M/J ---- 06 ,;-' ../ . I ide- ?), / 4/(abil-dat,--- 671 ky/ 07 , gil-cf_k___±1___I/N116'.3 b'cli krb6 7),A, 08 IS cd1 53 ve51, ff 6' 4 dred - I\ Mr'/ Rnre 09 -S-.?)( /%•J' 6-.-N S--)— 10 / r _____ y.„ W ert rc -.),,, GA/44v orziv. Jg)*Uzaleb .iorr 6;„770 D,k,--,',/Le

/ea i 46 i 7, 3 qi, ' - -}1 14 k , , j , m.„, , • , , ,. ( — \ , , \ ( ' 5 'LA 6 Kr7-)r) CAI- ;A- PALM-Oat° 4 -MANIAISS-01 li ., ,,,---) 5 • " 1(1- ki V cl V3

(two!) L ,i -L2 18

)4/A/9/ -04-- /ft74,(// 19 ,/e. c , 01 'iJ IAA9 )) 1 tiA i ki ) 'OA '1 ' t'l) IC 709 b.01,4' ,C(A 0 .._ , 001

This petition was circulated by:

//A Name Address Phone The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council. Public Hearing on Sept. 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

Signature Printed Name Address 01 , _5y,9.0 -gle/ i ,C,4 KL f\i I / / , /4 / A-L-Ly 1:.!ohk),SONi i„, ,(..), 4, Hici 02 1 / *,4-iGi --e--? 4 ''. i(7 4/_.- 41 Johpoc)f,) 03 /7-61,-Qa_)/ Kini-8.- -Pv ,02 yII' c--,36z71

040 - ,InSL- p5-- \\'\ -Aoc , 1 _, / 1 MAO (-- f\)u1(1\i'' cii) - 10 LOmA (cknA 6\rd s-c 06 dm *II 4 9 0 Ci C6. 2S ChoLor /9-0( & _ -Ltkbe .4()fi '.-tt,I;e., lens 5(06 6cuie-,t S ,

°81/4--P46e_____,G...,,...., 09 .

AIR/ t4-4. ki 6KOC) ,i(ri\) a4 14, 6P., ---* 71 --, - V't) VA ' ri (5X--- / S,0,1)7) 6-,J--w AZZA, L 7? efi

This petition was circulated by: v7g/[ tc Jt-/14-37 V,f zf,(/14/ 6)//7/142.- Qb—o? ,90' •-t;7 79) Name Address Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

We, the undersigned, hereby petition the Edina City Council to vote YES for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation proposal at the City Council Public Hearing on Sept 7, 2016.

We love living in Edina and appreciate all that it has to offer. We support all Edina facilities throughout our city that provide a full range of recreational opportunities for our fellow residents.

We believe that the addition of well-designed cross country ski trails and snowmaking at Braemar will enhance the impressive list of recreational amenities we already enjoy. We also believe that this facility will complement the expressed desire of the community for additional trails by providing safe, maintained, green spaces to be enjoyed by Edina families year-round.

Signature Printed Name Address

( . 17- 02 -7 6 c' .:7 e3-4 k;)( C)-/- LI 2- 3 ilk. L'efi.— (592,6- x2,02- (-:17- ,g 04 4 0 41' 0 0/ 1A,Dral-Ae_ 761- 82_ i- eCi yc ,S °5 CbtAAw ig -e_0_, Cal-iln eiri Vie Ue-e -q- 32- 'be atAroi AOrt c 06 P-"------. liwiD e-, go/te seirci kg1-6,46),fve 07 , ,- yo --v),,,,A0, ioq all 9--t))-3 E11- 7 1._741)-M9\vri,j ,D6-6 21ut 09 / 4de, 3.° \a/-:,--Ci‘& i2--14,(1 0--(- // Ai., iic 9,,,, -rev ia, ,i,

This petition was circulated by:

i3 Ate e1-/4/L-Pt-). Phone

The Minnesota Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of your rights about the private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted wilt become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Support Cross Country Skiing at Braemar Park with Snowmaking

Signature Printed Name Address oi ,r1r-d, ' ' - 61r)e)lei CaypeArv:1- 'Mil-. W .5-2Y2'( 'KY • 02 ,...4, c4.,_ * ' / eln, P/3'MCAfr 11, \M O& /0 53-4- oak/Ai d mst/ 03 Ve2-ee.11?,,E) E--- Ve;ct. pre (,:9.Ac6,1- 0.,ft-e-r-e2 , i._i- 04 . , ,// ' ' 70/w, ,- . -/ 7-A-,2w/,2 . ,c_?3(C,xk/_--ea/1/-/A/1--- 05 ' iv d-(j,-4- -it ,4 ---9•-/ '--a_.•-,:z--_ -e--45:3 ' il: L-4. 6e, LSC' ' 06 I i / i liP 4 07 ' 1 ii I ji l u ei[Zr '53-3 7 IV ©0 (09A-14,^i 08

gill ^•\ tat,/ t'' Wit(, P4 (I 6G01 1)000414C--- /40-E, 09

1)1(141) 4C,i/Li(-1 g H-121 5 54 - 011-1__ & 0b g' 161) r /le if AV, io /-1 1-ja, '1 11 ?l16 i / L A I GI /li &Cig - 7. 45tinroP 4 i 12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

petition was circulated by:

3'43.rj eij 7S' (6ffi/ Nam tess Phone The Mime a Data Practices Act requires that we inform you of y ur rights aboute private data we are requesting on this form. Under the law, your telephone number is private data. This petition when submitted will become public information. There is no consequence for refusing to supply this information. Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 3:17 PM Subject: FW: Proposed Cross-Country/Nordic Style Cross-Country Ski Trail and Tubing Hill Attachments: 2016 09-01 Ltr to City of Edina.pdf

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-88611 Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.ciov

From: Christina Stearns [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 2:51 PM To: James Hovland; Kevin Staunton; '[email protected]'; Mary Brindle; Robert Stewart Cc: John Cameron; Emeric Dwyer Subject: Proposed Cross-Country/Nordic Style Cross-Country Ski Trail and Tubing Hill

Dear Mr. Mayor and City Council Members:

Attached please find correspondence from John F. Cameron regarding the above referenced matter. Thank you for your time.

Christina Stearns CAMERON

4470 W 78th St. Circle Suite 210 Bloomington, MN 55435 612-341-0394 office 612-339-6787 fax www.cameronlawoffice.com

This e-mail message and its attachment(s), if any, are intended only for the use of the individuals to whom, or entity to which, it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by replying to this e-mail. CAMERON LAW OFFICE CHARTERED

JOHN P. CAMERON 612.355.7428 direct 612.341,0394 main 612.339,6787 fax 4470 W 78TH ST CIRCLE September 1, 2016 SUITE 210 BLOOMINGTON, MN 55435 VIA E-MAIL AND U.S. MAIL jolin@cameronlawoffice,com

Mayor Jim Hovland Kevin Staunton 4801 W. 50th St. 4801 W. 50th St. Edina, MN 55424 Edina, MN 55424 [email protected] [email protected]

Ann Swenson Mary Brindle 4801 W. 50th St. 4801 W. 50th St. Edina, MN 55424 Edina, MN 55424 [email protected] [email protected]

Bob Stewart 4801 W. 50th St. Edina, MN 55424 [email protected]

RE: Proposed Cross-Country/Nordic Style Cross-Country Ski Trail and Tubing Hill

Dear Mr. Mayor and City Council Members:

I write on behalf of myself and my wife, Holly Cameron, who reside at 7405 Gleason Road, Edina, MN 55435, and live next to the Braemar Golf Course and across from the proposed tubing hill. The City of Edina (the "City") proposes to construct a Nordic style cross-country ski course and tubing hill with mechanical towrope, snowmaking and lighting in the woods in Braemar (the "Project"). As set forth below, we have serious reservations about the Project and ask that the City Council not approve it.

On July 13, 2016 the city parks' department director and city consultant presented the proposed Project to us and other neighbors. The city's consultant confiuiied that the Project will (i) cost approximately Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000); (ii) be financed through a tax levy of approximately 1.5%; (iii) be illuminated by artificial lighting for night use; (iv) be serviced by snowmaking machines from December to March; and (v) cause overspray of snow onto the neighboring properties including those located along Gleason Road.

At the time of the meeting, neighbors and citizens overwhelmingly objected to the Project. Despite that, the Project has been pushed forward on an accelerated time-table. I want Edina City Council Page 3 of 4 September 1, 2016

but to seek damages for the same.

2. The Project will also contribute a serious increase in traffic accidents, which may also expose the City to liability. Spraying ice and snow onto Gleason Road daily will make it much more treacherous. I do not know how familiar you are with Gleason Road, but there is a problem existing already with people speeding along the winding road. With ice and snow on the road, this will lead to a large number of spin-outs and accidents. We already have problems with bad drivers taking out mailboxes and driving into yards. We are greatly concerned that this will result in someone walking along Gleason Road — or children waiting for the school bus — to be hit by a vehicle. Increased traffic at the site — especially in winter evenings — will exacerbate this problem. I cannot imagine that the City wants to increase the danger of car accidents, pedestrian accidents, injury, or death. I also cannot imagine the City wants to incur the increased liability it would suffer by contributing to such accidents.

3. The Project will also desecrate one of the few remaining natural areas in Edina which deer, owls, hawks, coyotes and eagles have and continue to call home. The Project contemplates a clear cut of an approximately fifty (50) foot for the "in and out" paths (twenty five (25) foot each). Once gone, we will never get it back.

4. The Project makes no financial sense. The Three Million Dollar ($3,000,000) Project cost will be funded by a 1.5% property tax levy to cover the construction costs. Going forward, it is proposed that the Project may break even and in year three (3) only reach a profit of Thirteen Thousand Dollars ($13,000). Meanwhile, the existing Highland cross- country ski facilities available to residents of Edina can serve their needs very well.

5. The proposed development is inconsistent with the overall and original design of the existing golf course. The current design of the golf course is ideal for a neighborhood setting because it centrally locates the majority of its activity near the clubhouse in the interior of the property. The current design allows use of the golf course without interference with the neighbors. As designed, neighbors have little interaction with the golf course, and it is non-intrusive. Under the proposed design of the Project, the uses would be moved to the exterior of the golf course. This will disrupt neighbors and traffic in a way the golf course never did.

I also want to express to the Council my serious reservations about the way this project was handled. The $3 Million project has been rushed through on a four-month basis with almost no public input. Further, the City staff and City Consultant have been deaf to the complaints of citizens. We ask City staff and their consultants to be neutral evaluators of projects; in this instance they have been cheerleaders for the Project regardless of the consequences. It seems that the Project is for the benefit of the very few, at great cost to City, neighbors, and the environment, and the City has not done the requisite planning, testing, and work necessary to truly understand it. Even if you are in favor of the concept of cross-country ski facilities generally, I ask you to reject the Project and push for a more thoughtful and through approach to the concept. Edina City Council Page 2 of 4 September 1, 2016 to make you aware of the following issues that make the project unsuitable:

1. The Project will subject the City to significant liability. The overflow, lighting, and sound of the Project will disrupt the surrounding residential properties on a daily basis while the tubing hill and ski-trails are in use.

Both the ski trails and the tubing hill will be fed by snow machines. The City's consultant confirmed at the July 13, 2016 meeting that the snow and spray from this snow machine will spread not only over the park, but onto Gleason Road and onto our properties. The consultant stated that we would have to shovel our properties each morning to remove the resulting snow and ice. In short, the City is proposing to — on a daily basis in winter — spray our properties with snow and ice and impose on us the obligation to clean it up.

There will also be noise from the snow machines, the groomers, tow-rope machines, increased traffic, and the people using the ski trails and tubing hills. The consultant stated that they had only tested the noise of the snow machines in June. Testing these machines in the summer — when trees have leaves — is insufficient. Further, the consultant did not test any of the other sound generating items — including the mechanized tow-rope machines and trail groomers. In winter, when there are no leaves on trees, sound carries much further. The neighbors will have to hear not only the snow machines, but also the groomers, tow rope machines, car doors slamming, people shouting, and other ambient noise. This is a stark contrast to the serene forest and open areas currently present.

Further, there will be light from the lights on the trails and tubing hills. This light will be generated in the winter when there are no leaves to block it. This light will also be reflected off the snow. The additional lights and reflections will illuminate our house — and our neighbor's house - in perpetual twilight. We do not believe there was any testing done about this issue.

All of this will constitute a taking by the City of our property. A "taking" is any interference "with the possession, enjoyment, or value of private property." Minn. Stat. § 117.025, subd. 2 (2015). The Minnesota Constitution requires a government to compensate property owners when it takes their properties. Minn. Const. art. 1, § 13. When a government has taken property without formally using its eminent domain powers, property owners have a cause of action for inverse condemnation. Alevizos v. Metro. Airports Comm'n of Minneapolis & St. Paul, 298 Minn. 471, 477, 216 N.W.2d 651, 657 (1974). The above described actions by the City would materially diminish our property values. We and our neighbors would have to take legal action accordingly. I do not believe the proposed budget for the Project includes the costs for purchasing the diminished value of property from each of the residents along Gleason road.

This interference with our properties will also constitute an illegal nuisance under Minn. Stat. § 561.01 ("Anything which . . . an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, is a nuisance"). Given the disruption the Project would cause to our lives and property, we would have no choice Edina City Council Page 4 of 4 September 1, 2016

For these reasons, and those voiced by my neighbors and fellow citizens, I ask you to reject the Project.

JFC/cs Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 4:20 PM Subject: FW: Proposed Cross-Country/Nordic Style Cross-Country Ski Trail and Tubing Hill Attachments: 2016 09-01 Ltr to City of Edina.pdf

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Christina Stearns [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 4:00 PM To: James Hovland; Kevin Staunton; [email protected]; Mary Brindle; Robert Stewart Cc: Emeric Dwyer; John Cameron Subject: Proposed Cross-Country/Nordic Style Cross-Country Ski Trail and Tubing Hill

Dear Mr. Mayor and City Council Members:

Upon review, the prior attachment was presented in a non-sequential order. Attached please find the corrected correspondence from John F. Cameron. Sorry for any inconvenience. Thank you for your time.

Christina Steams CAMERON

4470 W 78th St. Circle Suite 210 Bloomington, MN 55435 612-341-0394 office 612-339-6787fax www.cameronlawoffice.com

This e-mail message and its attachment(s), if any, are intended only for the use of the individuals to whom, or entity to which, it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by replying to this e-mail.

1 CAMERON LAW OFFICE CHARTERED

JOHN F CAMERON 612.355.7428 direct 612.341,0394 main 612.339.6787 fax 4470 W 78TH ST CIRCLE September 1, 2016 SUITE 210 BLOOMINGTON, MN 55435 VIA E-MAIL AND U.S. MAIL john@camerontawoffice,corn

Mayor Jim Hovland Kevin Staunton 4801 W. 50th St. 4801 W. 50th St. Edina, MN 55424 Edina, MN 55424 [email protected] [email protected]

Ann Swenson Mary Brindle 4801 W. 50th St. 4801 W. 50th St. Edina, MN 55424 Edina, MN 55424 swensonann 1 @grnail. corn [email protected]

Bob Stewart 4801 W. 50th St. Edina, MN 55424 [email protected]

RE: Proposed Cross-Country/Nordic Style Cross-Country Ski Trail and Tubing Hill

Dear Mr. Mayor and City Council Members:

I write on behalf of myself and my wife, Holly Cameron, who reside at 7405 Gleason Road, Edina, MN 55435, and live next to the Braemar Golf Course and across from the proposed tubing hill. The City of Edina (the "City") proposes to construct a Nordic style cross-country ski course and tubing hill with mechanical towrope, snowmaking and lighting in the woods in Braemar (the "Project"). As set forth below, we have serious reservations about the Project and ask that the City Council not approve it.

On July 13, 2016 the city parks' depatttnent director and city consultant presented the proposed Project to us and other neighbors. The city's consultant confirmed that the Project will (i) cost approximately Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000); (ii) be financed through a tax levy of approximately 1.5%; (iii) be illuminated by artificial lighting for night use; (iv) be serviced by snowmaking machines from December to March; and (v) cause overspray of snow onto the neighboring properties including those located along Gleason Road.

At the time of the meeting, neighbors and citizens overwhelmingly objected to the Project. Despite that, the Project has been pushed forward on an accelerated time-table. I want Edina City Council Page 2 of 4 September 1, 2016 to make you aware of the following issues that make the project unsuitable:

1. The Project will subject the City to significant liability. The overflow, lighting, and sound of the Project will disrupt the surrounding residential properties on a daily basis while the tubing hill and ski-trails are in use.

Both the ski trails and the tubing hill will be fed by snow machines. The City's consultant confirmed at the July 13, 2016 meeting that the snow and spray from this snow machine will spread not only over the park, but onto Gleason Road and onto our properties. The consultant stated that we would have to shovel our properties each morning to remove the resulting snow and ice. In short, the City is proposing to — on a daily basis in winter — spray our properties with snow and ice and impose on us the obligation to clean it up.

There will also be noise from the snow machines, the groomers, tow-rope machines, increased traffic, and the people using the ski trails and tubing hills. The consultant stated that they had only tested the noise of the snow machines in June. Testing these machines in the summer — when trees have leaves — is insufficient. Further, the consultant did not test any of the other sound generating items — including the mechanized tow-rope machines and trail groomers. In winter, when there are no leaves on trees, sound carries much further. The neighbors will have to hear not only the snow machines, but also the groomers, tow rope machines, car doors slamming, people shouting, and other ambient noise. This is a stark contrast to the serene forest and open areas currently present.

Further, there will be light from the lights on the trails and tubing hills. This light will be generated in the winter when there are no leaves to block it. This light will also be reflected off the snow. The additional lights and reflections will illuminate our house — and our neighbor's house - in perpetual twilight. We do not believe there was any testing done about this issue.

All of this will constitute a taking by the City of our property. A "taking" is any interference "with the possession, enjoyment, or value of private property." Minn. Stat. § 117.025, subd. 2 (2015). The Minnesota Constitution requires a government to compensate property owners when it takes their properties. Minn. Const. art. 1, § 13. When a government has taken property without formally using its eminent domain powers, property owners have a cause of action for inverse condemnation. Alevizos v. Metro. Airports Comm'n of Minneapolis & St. Paul, 298 Minn. 471, 477, 216 N.W.2d 651, 657 (1974). The above described actions by the City would materially diminish our property values. We and our neighbors would have to take legal action accordingly. I do not believe the proposed budget for the Project includes the costs for purchasing the diminished value of property from each of the residents along Gleason road.

This interference with our properties will also constitute an illegal nuisance under Minn. Stat. § 561.01 ("Anything which . . an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, is a nuisance"). Given the disruption the Project would cause to our lives and property, we would have no choice Edina City Council Page 3 of 4 September 1, 2016

but to seek damages for the same.

2. The Project will also contribute a serious increase in traffic accidents, which may also expose the City to liability. Spraying ice and snow onto Gleason Road daily will make it much more treacherous. I do not know how familiar you are with Gleason Road, but there is a problem existing already with people speeding along the winding road. With ice and snow on the road, this will lead to a large number of spin-outs and accidents. We already have problems with bad drivers taking out mailboxes and driving into yards. We are greatly concerned that this will result in someone walking along Gleason Road — or children waiting for the school bus — to be hit by a vehicle. Increased traffic at the site — especially in winter evenings — will exacerbate this problem. I cannot imagine that the City wants to increase the danger of car accidents, pedestrian accidents, injury, or death. I also cannot imagine the City wants to incur the increased liability it would suffer by contributing to such accidents.

3. The Project will also desecrate one of the few remaining natural areas in Edina which deer, owls, hawks, coyotes and eagles have and continue to call home. The Project contemplates a clear cut of an approximately fifty (50) foot for the "in and out" paths (twenty five (25) foot each). Once gone, we will never get it back.

4. The Project makes no financial sense. The Three Million Dollar ($3,000,000) Project cost will be funded by a 1.5% property tax levy to cover the construction costs. Going forward, it is proposed that the Project may break even and in year three (3) only reach a profit of Thirteen Thousand Dollars ($13,000). Meanwhile, the existing Highland cross- country ski facilities available to residents of Edina can serve their needs very well.

5. The proposed development is inconsistent with the overall and original design of the existing golf course. The current design of the golf course is ideal for a neighborhood setting because it centrally locates the majority of its activity near the clubhouse in the interior of the property. The current design allows use of the golf course without interference with the neiibors. As designed, neighbors have little interaction with the golf course, and it is non-intrusive. Under the proposed design of the Project, the uses would be moved to the exterior of the golf course. This will disrupt neighbors and traffic in a way the golf course never did.

I also want to express to the Council my serious reservations about the way this project was handled. The $3 Million project has been rushed through on a four-month basis with almost no public input. Further, the City staff and City Consultant have been deaf to the complaints of citizens. We ask City staff and their consultants to be neutral evaluators of projects; in this instance they have been cheerleaders for the Project regardless of the consequences. It seems that the Project is for the benefit of the very few, at great cost to City, neighbors, and the environment, and the City has not done the requisite planning, testing, and work necessary to truly understand it. Even if you are in favor of the concept of cross-country ski facilities generally, I ask you to reject the Project and push for a more thoughtful and through approach to the concept. Edina City Council Page 4 of 4 September 1, 2016

For these reasons, and those voiced by my neighbors and fellow citizens, I ask you to reject the Project.

JFC/cs Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, September 02, 2016 9:03 AM Subject: FW: Proposed Nordic Ski Trail

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Will McMillan [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 6:42 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Proposed Nordic Ski Trail

Dear Edina City Council,

I strongly oppose the decimation of natural forestry and wildlife at Braemar Golf Course to construct a Nordic ski trail. I do not support this endeavor as it injures precious green space, will create a public hazard due to snow-making machines, and is stated to be an expensive yet losing proposition financially. I ASK YOU TO VOTE NO ON THIS PROJECT. I ask that you consider more environmentally friendly (and less costly) ways to enhance Braemar for public use: mountain biking trails, hiking, etc. Please redirect this funding to other, higher-priority level projects that improve (not diminish) public safety, or which impose no such damaging impacts on the environment or residents.

Thank you! Will McMillan

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, September 02, 2016 9:16 AM Subject: FW: Keep Braemar Safe and Green

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Gmail [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, September 02, 2016 8:38 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Keep Braemar Safe and Green

Hi Edina City Council! My name is Rene Foss And I live at 7500 Cahill Road in Edina. Please consider voting against the development of a Nordic Ski and Tubing Park in our neighborhood.

I feel this would destroy the wildlife and natural beauty of Braemar . It will also create more traffic and lengthy construction.

It will involve snow making machines that are loud and bright lights. This would be an adverse impact for people who reside in what is a residential neighborhood . Aside from that it seems the funding is not secured and may involve tax increases.

People can enjoy winter sports at the nearby Highland snow park. It is less than 3 miles from Braemar.

Thank you for your kind consideration . I plan to attend the meeting on September 7,2016.

Rene Foss

Sent from my iPhone

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Friday, September 02, 2016 9:26 AM Subject: FW: Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: Charles Carroll [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 9:39 PM To: James Hovland Subject: Braemar

Dear Mayor Hovland,

My husband and I are vehemently against a proposal to turn Braemar golf course into a winter theme park including snow making, tubing and a Nordic ski trail.

Braemar is already perfect for skiing, walking and snow shoeing as it is. We don't want our hard earned tax dollars to be spent on a money losing project when there are more important things needed in the City of Edina. It is simply wasteful spending.

Also, we don't want the increase in people and traffic to our neighborhood. It means an increase in crime, road damage, accidents (as motorists already use it as a personal interstate) and noise. The beautiful setting that is already there would be ruined and our property values would drop, however our property taxes would not.

Please vote no.

Thank you, Chuck & Carrie Carroll

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Friday, September 02, 2016 2:18 PM Subject: FW: Edina's Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Richard Peterson [mailto:petersonya(acox.net] Sent: Friday, September 02, 2016 2:05 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Edina's Braemar

Honorable Council members:

Please support the petition before you to "Keep Edina's Braemar Green and Safe." Sometimes less is more, and for this valuable nature preserve, the lighter the development footprint the better. Please reallocate the appropriated funds to other projects that better serve the community.

Thank you for your kind attention to this matter.

Respectfully,

Richard R. Peterson 5725 Blake Road, #109 Edina, MN 55436

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 10:02 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Winter Rec Attachments: Marker to House jpg; Slightly Closer jpg

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoREdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Martin, Dawn [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, September 04, 2016 3:15 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Winter Rec

Hello -

A friend and myself hiked the Braemar trails this morning. I was truly hoping that the proposed ski trails were not as invasive as they seem to be in the drawings, and wouldn't be as close to my home as I thought they might be.

Unfortunately, that was not the case. In fact, they are much, much worse than we all thought. Have any of you been up there? If not, I would highly recommend you see for yourself the number of beautiful old trees that would be lost, and the amount of grading that will be required. It will completely change the landscape of this part of town. The trail is extremely close to Gleason, so the overspray would indeed be a dangerous mess.

I live on Tanglewood Court. I have attached two photos from our hike this morning.

One is a shot from the pink marker (placed by SEH) toward my house. You can clearly see the roof, and in the winter when there is no foliage, you will see into the windows.

The second is about 15-20 feet from the marker toward the house.

I urge you to think about the 50+ residential homes that this will negatively affect. An entire neighborhood will never be the same.

We are not against using Braemar for winter sports — there already is a groomed XC ski path there (as advertised on the city website). Why this intrusive plan? Why destroy this much natural beauty and wildlife? The neighborhood?

There has to be a better way. Please vote no on Wednesday. Please.

Sincerely,

Dawn Martin President Edina Soccer Club

DAWN MARTIN Vice President I Meetings & Shows d 952.844.4819 I m 612.964.8989 BI WORLDVVIDE Australia I Canada I China I India I LATAM I UK I US www.biworldwide.com

Check out our multiple award winning video on social issues at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-xfNnkUFqBM

Please consider the environment before printing.

This e-mail message is being sent solely for use by the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by phone or reply by e-mail, delete the original message and destroy all copies. Thank you.

2 pink. Marker r;4:. ,4 •

.61

PhOto taken about 15-20 feet from marker

,toward-hous.), $

• \

411, Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 10:04 AM Subject: FW: Nordic Ski trail - vote NO

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Ellen CCS [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, September 04, 2016 5:38 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic Ski trail - vote NO

Dear Edina City Council,

I strongly oppose the decimation of natural forestry and wildlife at Braemar Golf Course to construct a Nordic ski trail. I do not support this endeavor as it injures precious green space, will create a public hazard due to snow-making machines, and is stated to be an expensive yet losing proposition financially. I ASK YOU TO VOTE NO ON THIS PROJECT. I ask that you consider more environmentally friendly (and less costly) ways to enhance Braemar for public use: mountain biking trails, hiking, etc. Please redirect this funding to other, higher-priority level projects that improve (not diminish) public safety, or which impose no such damaging impacts on the environment or residents.

Thank you! Ellen & Mark Smith 7719 Gleason Road Edina, MN 55439

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 10:05 AM Subject: FW: Nordic Trail

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: nealjblanchett(agnnail.com [mailto:nealjblanchett©gmail.corn] Sent: Sunday, September 04, 2016 11:28 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Nordic Trail

Dear Mayor, Councilmembers, and Staff:

Thank you again for considering what has become a contentious issue. I am writing to provide new information which I've obtained after signing the pro-trail petition.

The Trail Provides The Cheapest, Best Way to Address Buckthorn Infestation I've run the current Braemar trails numerous times but until now had not focused on the rampant buckthorn infestation. The natural oak savanna has been replaced with a buckthorn nursery. For every oak, there are 10- 20 buckthorn trees. Where there should be a canopy and open forest floor beneath, the entire area is choked with buckthorns. Clearly the existing management is not working; the oak forest cannot regenerate with the level of buckthorn, so it will continue its decline unless the buckthorn is removed. Buckthorn drives out native fauna and flora — its berries are non-nutritious and laxative; it robs competing tree saplings of sunlight and water. Buckthorn removal by the City is expensive. However, as we've seen in Minneapolis around the Cedar Lake and Wirth Park trails, a trail brings with it a corps of hard-working volunteers who care for the area and donate hundreds of hours of volunteer labor. Trail-user volunteers have removed thousands of buckthorn trees in Minneapolis. We've seen this kind of trail-volunteerism in Edina - the high school team has kept its 5k of trail clear for years, with volunteer labor. A vote to "keep Braemar green" is a vote for buckthorn infestation and eventually domination.

Nordic Skiing is a Great Family Sport for Edina Families All the industry statistics show that Nordic skiers are exactly the type of homeowners and families typical for Edina. According to Snowsports Industries America, 4.3 million Americans Nordic ski. The sport has good gender parity with 44% women and 56% men — better than golf or hockey (I fully support golf and hockey nearby at city-built Braemar facilities.) Nordic skiers are highly educated: 57% of Nordic skiers have a bachelor's degree or higher (30% of are under 24, which means that 80% of skiers over age 24 have a bachelor's degree or higher). Nordic skiers have good jobs and discretionary income: 53% overall, and 75% of those over age 24, have household incomes over $75,000. 49% of Nordic skiers are age 25-44, and 20% are age 45-64; exactly the ages people are raising families, looking for great communities. The ski trail will serve existing residents and attract new, financially-capable, well-educated homebuyers to Edina and particularly to the Braemar neighborhood.

1 The Proposal Offers a Great Trail at a Great Value This is a unique opportunity to get an outstanding amenity at a bargain price - half the cost of Hyland's system for a high-quality project - 5K lit snowmaking loop with 10-20k natural snow trail. It's true that we can ski there for free, now, just as we can play hockey for free on pond ice (when the snow is there and the ice is solid, respectively). Hyland's trail is packed after school and during the weekends; the demand is there. Edina has typically chosen to improve on natural conditions, adding soccer and baseball fields, ice rinks, lighting, a golf dome, and other improvements to lengthen our recreation seasons. A snowmaking trail is completely in keeping with Edina's philosophy.

Negatives Have Proven to Be Overestimated On Similar Projects The same negatives raised by these project opponents were raised by opponents of the other Nordic snow- making proposals - Hyland, Wirth, Elm Creek. None of them have come to pass. Instead those sites have become popular, treasured assets to their neighborhoods and cities. Trail construction will disturb 3 acres, equivalent to 3-6 typical house lots in the neighborhood. Noise levels are below that of a central air conditioner. Wildlife will move out during construction and move back in after, as at Hyland, and as will happen on the golf course. The oaks are spread out such that the vast majority of trees removed will be buckthorn; oak loss can be minimized, and buckthorn removal will allow replacement with higher-value trees. Higher-value trees will in turn provide an even better buffer to noise, light or overspray effects.

For these and the reasons others and I have indicated previously, please support this project. If you are not able to support it at this time, please make your concerns known and table the proposal so that staff and supporters can work to address your concerns. Again, thank you for your thoughtful consideration and leadership.

Sincerely, Neal Blanchett

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:11 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal Attachments: Braemar Proposal.doc

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Caitlin Gregg [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 11:43 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal

@CaitlinGregg Team Gregg on Facebook www. GoTeamGregg. corn 509-341-4380 Caitlin Compton Gregg 627 Thomas Ave. N Minneapolis, MN 55411 September 5, 2016

Dear Community of Edina,

My name is Caitlin Compton Gregg and I am a 2010 Cross Country Skiing Olympian living and training in the Twin Cities. I have been a part of the outdoor endurance community here for the past 13 years when I moved to Minnesota after graduating from college at Northern Michigan University.

My first winter here in the Twin Cities was plagued by low snow but it was the enthusiasm of the Cross Country Ski Community that convinced me this was the right place to train for the Olympics. At the time there were two snowmaking facilities (Elm Creek and Trollhaugen) and early morning skiing at the base of Hyland. I was beyond impressed by the number of skiers who would make the trek to the two snowmaking locations upwards of 45 minutes to an hours drive from the center of the City. Others would wake up in the early morning hours to get some time at the short base of an alpine hill. These snow making facilities were often full and a wonderful reminder of how great endurance snow sports are for the athletes and families who would visit them. I was beyond inspired every time I trained.

Fast forward 13 years later and participation in the sport has grown exponentially, especially here in the Twin Cities! The Winter can be cold in the Midwest and without snow the idea of going outside is a daunting one. The opportunity to have a facility that encourages outdoor play and exercise during the long winter is of the upmost importance for the health of the community.

I currently volunteer at the Jerry Gamble Boys and Girls Club in North Minneapolis and the single most important factor that helps keep the kids out of trouble and engaged in their studies is the opportunity to exercise and move. My passion beyond my own athletic career is to help connect residents of the Twin Cities no matter what their economic background to the enjoyment of exercise and the outdoors.

The more snow making and outdoor winter sports facilities we have the better! Creating a facility that offers these opportunities will give Braemar and the entire City of Edina a great name for promoting health, wellness and opportunities during the winter months. Let's embrace the beautiful rolling terrain and easy access to Braemar in the winter as an opportunity for great things to happen, whether it's an Olympic Medal, a healthier individual or a more focused student. Hope to see you out enjoying winter soon!

Sincerely, Caitlin Compton Gregg Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:12 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal Support Letter

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoPEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: brianjgredgOgmail.com [mailto:brianjgredgOgmail.corn] On Behalf Of Brian Gregg Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 11:43 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal Support Letter

Dear Community of Edina,

My name is Brian Gregg. I am a 2014 Olympian in the sport of Cross Country Skiing and I live in Minneapolis, MN. I actually credit a lot of my training in Edina, with countless hill repeats on roller skis up Shannon drive as one of the major factors towards achieving my dream of representing the United States in the Olympics. I am currently at a training camp at the Olympic Training Center in Marquette, MI and will be out of town for the September 7th meeting. I want to express my support for the Braemar Park Winter Recreation Proposal of cross country ski trails with snow making. Edina has an exciting opportunity to be a leader and forward thinker in regards to winter recreation. Cross country ski trails and snow making can make a major impact on the health and fitness of our community. The opportunity for Braemar Park to become a year round destination to renew ones body, mind and spirit is huge. It is just wonderful to visit an Edina high school ski practice and see a team of over 200 athletes. The students are learning a lifetime sport that can be enjoyed alone and in large groups. One of the best parts about cross country skiing is that it helps to grow a stronger community. I grew up skiing together with my family, and later on with my friends. Skiing is still my favorite way to catch up with old friends, meet new ones or to just take a moment to rejuvenate from the stresses of the day. The cross country trails with snow making at Braemar is a way for Edina to lead the way with a dependable winter outdoor health and fitness option for the community. The darkness and winter is dependable, but this Winter Recreation Proposal can help the community go from being disappointed and depressed about winter to perhaps having it become their favorite season. Please support the Braemar Winter Recreation Proposal.

Sincerely, Brian Gregg

Brian Gregg 2014 Olympian XC Skiing Team Gregg, LLC www.GoTeamGregg.com 509.341.4254 (cell)

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:13 AM Subject: FW: Veto Braemar Nordic Ski Track Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Laurel Ferris [[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 12:12 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Veto Braemar Nordic Ski Track Proposal

Dear City Council:

I am asking that the Council firmly veto the proposed redevelopment of Braemar Park.This for-profit venture to install a Nordic track is misguided and seems, frankly, suspect. Who financially gains by this project? Is it a priority for Edina residents?

Why develop this green space further? Is there a shortage of nearby recreational opportunities for people who like to ski? NO.Three Rivers Park offers beautiful scenic recreation: cross-country, downhill, telemark and nordic skiing.

VOTE NO.

- Laurel Ferris , 7028 Wexford Road, Edina 55439

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:14 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Nordic Ski Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: tom.mcnamee1(acomcast.net [mailto:tom.mcnamee1(acomcast.net] Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 1:31 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Nordic Ski Proposal

September 5, 2016

Dear City Council Members,

Hills of Braemar Association is a 23-unit common interest community located on Woodview Court at Gleason Road. Our location means that this community will be directly impacted by the proposed Nordic Ski proposal under review for Braemar. The Board of Directors of the Hills of Braemar Association is responsible and accountable for oversight of the efficient preservation of the value and amenities within our community. We are strongly opposed to the project's scope, cost and impact on residents near Braemar. The Hills of Braemar community will incur increased costs for snow removal, suffer noise and light pollution from planned nighttime snow-making and grooming activities, experience increased traffic and more treacherous driving on Gleason Road, and see our property values decrease. While our feelings are shared by people throughout Edina, Hills of Braemar will experience direct and significant damage if this proposal proceeds.

We, along with many members of our Association have actively participated in the July 13 Open House, an August 1 discussion with the Mayor on Tanglewood Ct, and respectfully listened at the Park Board meeting on August 8. As informed citizens, we have realistic concerns about the proposal, specifically:

• Safety hazards affecting Gleason Rd, other streets and neighborhoods • Disruption to quiet enjoyment in our homes with snow-making, trail equipment, light pollution and certain increased traffic flow and incidents on Gleason Rd • Anticipated negative impact on property values with no bail out in the proposal • A fast track approach from the feasibility study to Council vote • Limited public awareness and lack of public forums for productive community engagement • Expansive and expensive project terms • Financial unsustainability with years of deficit spending • A disconnect from residents' actual surveyed responses for desired park enhancements in strategic planning • Irretrievable deforestation from a 50' wide track and its troubling wildlife and environmental impact

1 • A resounding lack of support from Park Board members on August 8 • SEH's revelation that published ski trail images utilized "artistic liberty" without disclosure of same on both print and web sources • Advancement of an unbudgeted $3 million dollar line item that will displace other worthy capital projects already in the City queue.

We urge you to vote NO on September 7. We appreciate your time to read and understand our perspective — that of Edina citizens and members of a common interest community that will experience negative repercussions as a direct result of the Nordic Ski proposal before you.

Respectfully,

Hills of Braemar Association Board of Directors

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:16 AM Subject: FW: Winter Recreational Facility at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: Noah [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 6:12 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Winter Recreational Facility at Braemar

Dear City Council Member,

I am writing to express my strong support for the proposal to add cross country ski trails with snowmaking at Braemar Park. Cross country skiing is well known to be one of the most beneficial aerobic, low-impact recreational activities. It's a silent sport that can be enjoyed by enthusiasts of all ages and is especially appealing to active families. Unfortunately, low or no snow winters are now the norm so machine made snow trails are the only reliable means to ensure the survival of the sport. Like refrigerated ice for hockey players, snowmaking technology has made it possible for skiers to depend on a ski season regardless of undependable weather. Introducing a well designed trail to Braemar that offers the joys of skiing to beginners, weekend warriors and experts alike is a timely idea that will help fulfill residents' requests to see more natural trail space made available in Edina.

I know there are many Braemar neighbors and other Edina residents who have voiced valid concerns about this project. Some of what I have read in opposition offers valid questions and apprehension for various aspects of the proposal. At the same time, a great deal of what I have read constitutes hyperbole, rumor and fabrication. I've taken time to investigate several of the most frequently cited concerns and feel obliged to respond with actual facts:

Noise: The sound study done by SEH states that snowmaking impact on Gleason residences falls below 50 dBA out of doors. MPCA limits are 60 dBA during the day and 50 dBA at night. Let's put that in perspective: Normal conversation is 60 dBA. Lawn mowers (which currently run many months of the year at Braemar) are about 90 dBA. Snowmaking, as estimated by SEH, will require about 130 hours (less than 6 days) for an entire season. Most residents leave windows and doors shut during the winter months. Taking these facts into consideration, sound levels produced by snowmaking at Braemar should hardly be noticed by nearby residents if its audible at all.

Light: The lighting equipment proposed for this trail system is the same as currently utilized at Hyland Lake Park Reserve. These are LED directional lights that point down in a focused manner. They do not point out or up and do not flood the area with light. The SEH engineers described what residents might see as pinpricks of light on the trail if they see anything at all. There are currently one dozen street lights along the east side of Gleason Road across from the proposed trail area at Braemar. These street lights purposely create pools of light, they're located within 100 feet of many houses and they're operating from dusk to dawn. If Braemar follows the same type of schedule as Hyland or Elm Creek, trail lights will be turned off by 10 p.m. each day. Taking these facts into consideration, trail lights at Braemar will hardly be noticeable and will in fact be obscured by existing street lights during the hours they are in use.

Snowmaking Overspray: Several residents concerned about overspray of snow onto Gleason and nearby residences have cited existing snowmaking at Buck Hill and Hyland Ski and Snowboard Area as examples of what the Braemar neighborhood should expect. These are both alpine ski areas and it is critical to understand that the techniques used to make snow at these locations are much different than making snow for cross country ski trails. These alpine areas purposely run dozens of snow machines simultaneously in order to cover the vast acreage involved. They also purposely point the machines up and out in order to cover large areas more efficiently. Additionally, alpine areas are much more open and unobstructed by trees and brush which allows the snow to travel greater distances depending on conditions. As SEH engineers have pointed out, snow machines for cross country ski trails are pointed parallel to the ground and not up in the air. The goal is to create a whale or berm of snow which is subsequently pushed down the trail by a groomer. Many fewer machines are in use. The machines make snow in a specific location along the trail for a day or two, then moved down the trail to a new location. This isn't to say that there will be no overspray during snowmaking operations, but it will not create the conditions that snowmaking at alpine areas create. Finally, as noted above, snowmaking is estimated to run a total of 130 hours each winter, so any possibility of overspray will be kept to a minimum over the entirety of the season.

When the Bloomington City Council was considering the proposal to make snow at the Hyland Lake Park Reserve cross country ski trails, many residents raised the very same valid concerns about neighborhood impact that are now being raised here in Edina. The Bloomington City Council approved the snowmaking plan after adding stipulations as to how many hours snowmaking could occur, which hours of the day, which calendar days, etc. Snowmaking at Hyland Lake Park Reserve has now been in operation for the last 3 winter seasons. In the last few weeks I have made inquiries of the following persons with ongoing affiliation to the Hyland ski trail operations: Lynn Stoltzmann (Director of Facility Services at Three Rivers Park District), Dan Fjell (Hyland Lake Park Reserve Facility Supervisor) and Lynn Moore (City of Bloomington Environmental Health Manager). I specifically inquired as to whether any complaints have been received by their departments in regards to snowmaking for the Hyland XC Ski Trails. Neither Dan Fjell or Lynn Moore were able to identify any complaints. Lynn Stoltzmann was able to document a single (1) complaint in the last 3 years.

I am asking you to please vote yes on this proposal. Once approved, it will then be critical to have the City Council and Edina Parks and Rec Department support the process of designing and implementing a cross country ski trail with machine made snow that respects the natural setting it occupies and limits impact to the surrounding neighborhood.

Sincerely yours, Noah Swiler, Edina

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:16 AM Subject: FW: PLEASE VOTE NO

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: Marilyn Anderson [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 10:32 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: PLEASE VOTE NO

Dear Council Members, I write this to urge you to please vote no Wednesday night. Please vote no to making my neighborhood noisy, lit up, and polluted. I chose my neighborhood because it is quiet and natural. I'm listening to peace right now and I want to keep it that way. I am not against cross country skiing at all, I love that idea, we don't need to spend millions to do that. Please keep Braemar NATURAL and peaceful and safe. Please vote no. Please don't ruin my neighborhood. Kind regards, Marilyn Anderson Shannon Drive

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:17 AM Subject: FW: Nordic trail proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: Mary Roberts Scott [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 10:45 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic trail proposal

To the members of the council, Please vote no to the proposal up for vote to create a nordic recreation area at Braemar. Not only is the snow-making irresponsible for a city in this way, the trail is a poor excuse for taking care of the area. I hope the council will consider looking after the interests of Edina residents and area ski teams in new ways instead of this bad proposal. Regards, Evan Anderson. Edina resident.

Sent from my iPhone

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:41 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Ski

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Redangus [mailto:redangus220yahoo.com] Sent: Saturday, September 03, 2016 10:04 PM To: James Hovland Subject: Braemar Ski

Dear Mayor Hovland,

Thank you for being an excellent Mayor since 2005. A couple of weeks ago there was a pamphlet in the mailbox full of anxiety over the proposed Winter Recreational Facility at Braemar. I guess asteroids and zombie attacks were predicted in it, or something similar. Now I've read in the Sun Current that there is a big uproar between the zombie apocalypse is nigh crowd, and the "we want to wear our color-coordinated ski suits, and wiggle our tightly toned backsides through the cross-county ski trails in Braemar cause we're Edinians and that is what we do". I was bored so I googled the address of the color-coordinated individuals, they of course, live in Sunnyside, or over by Bredeson Park, so any noise or traffic issues will not be in their backyard.

My main concern is traffic, and noise for the people living near Braemar. The tightly toned group from my surmise, can go to Highland if they want a cross country ski slope, but you really can't escape traffic if it's in your backyard.

Thank you,

Chrissie

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:41 AM Subject: FW: Winter Facilities at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoAEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Lisa Nelson [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, September 04, 2016 5:39 PM To: Robert Stewart; swensonann10gmail.com; Kevin Staunton; James Hovland; Mary Brindle Subject: Winter Facilities at Braemar

I have looked at the information available on the city website, neighborhood sites, petitions (for and against), newspapers etc. I do not support the current proposal, but I would support the City investigating a scaled back proposal that facilitates recreational cross-country skiing, mountain biking and/or nature hiking.

I don't think there is adequate space for the cross-country trails proposed. They are too large, apparently primarily to accommodate x-country skiers who are racing (and therefore are skate-skiing - which takes more room than traditional x-country skiing - and then need room to pass each other). Increasing the trail size by 5 times to the width of four lanes of road is too much. Too much money, too many trees removed, and too far removed from a natural environment which is what citizens have requested more of.

I do not support lights or snow-making in any case. It will create light pollution, noise pollution, inconvenience for neighbors when snow lands on their property and potentially dangerous road conditions.

Nor do I think the City should be doing a project which seems primarily oriented toward helping the high school ski team, not the majority of citizens. EPS should figure out how to deal with the practice space for their teams in light of their remodel of EHS.

Last but not least, the expense is significant. It is acknowledged that it won't break even for several years, if then.

A much narrower trail without snow-making that could also be used in the summer by hikers or mountain bikers would serve the needs of Edina citizens at a much lower cost in all senses of the word.

This proposal should be tabled. Community input should be solicited, other professional proposals for how to use Braemar in the winter should be solicited and competitive bids should be obtained before any proposal is entertained. The benefit of doing it now when Braemar is under construction appears to be red herring. There is no infoiiiiation that would indicate that design, construction or other costs would be saved by doing them at the same time.

I am likewise opposed to the ten lane tubing hill. Kids have plenty of places to sled. I don't think most people are looking for Edina to become a destination activity spot, unless it is ancillary to getting something that our community itself needs and would use (like the golf course).This is too large, expensive and unneeded for our community.

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:42 AM Subject: FW: Edina Nordic Ski proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: Rand Evans [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, September 04, 2016 11:52 PM To: James Hovland; Mary Evans Subject: Edina Nordic Ski proposal

Dear Mr. Mayor:

My wife and I would like to attend the council meeting on Sept 7 to learn about the Nordic Ski proposal, however we will both be out of town. So we would like to voice our disapproval of the current proposal, as we understand it.

We live at 6701 Gleason Road, so we are far enough from Braemar that the light and noise pollution won't affect us; nor will the potential safety hazard of overspray on the roads.

What does concern us is the fiscal and environmental impact of this project.

I have enjoyed skiing and snowshoeing at Braemar many times in the 28 years we have lived here. The golf course is huge and covers much more skiing area than the proposed 2 miles of a lighted and groomed trail. Also, the free skiing that the golf course land provides today does not require anyone to clear-cut a 50 foot wide swath through a wooded area.

Since this project would be paid for with money the city currently does not have, it also seems fiscally irresponsible at this time. From what we know, it appears that this project was fast tracked ahead of other projects the Edina residents consider more worthy. Some comments make it sound like this is a now or never opportunity- we don't think so. We believe more study and a more prudent approach is advised.

Perhaps more discussion, or more consideration of other expenditures are in order before a decision is made on this proposal.

We are in favor of "progress" for Edina, and we don't believe that things should "stay the way they are". However, there is certainly no guarantee this Nordic ski facility will ever be a revenue generator, so let's take a more thoughtful approach before spending the taxpayers' money. Thanks for your consideration.

Respectfully,

Randy & Mary Evans

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:42 AM Subject: FW: Braemar ski proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 05, 2016 8:49 AM To: [email protected]; Robert Stewart; Kevin Staunton; Mary Brindle; James Hovland Subject: Braemar ski proposal

Could you please explain to me why, since you haven't voted on the Braemar ski proposal yet, there are pink stakes already all through the woods. Have any of you walked these woods? There is a very wide path that is easily navigated that has been there for quite awhile. Why can't this be slightly enhanced with no lights or snow making machines and no destruction of trees and wildlife? Can you please address these issues?

Sheran McNulty 6001 Bonnie Brae Drive Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 2:57 PM Subject: FW: Support for Mountain Biking at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Mrvos, Mertyce [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 2:56 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Support for Mountain Biking at Braemar

Mayor Hovland and Members of Edina City Council,

Our family is strongly in favor of mountain bike trails being added to Braemar. Our daughter is on the Edina Mountain Bike Team and currently travels (by bike) to Theodore Wirth Park for regular practices. Having a closer "home" location would be a much safer option for her and the entire team. Plus it would help the team be more competitive with other teams who have their own trails. In addition, my husband, son and I also enjoy mountain biking (noncompetitively) and would enjoy using trails in our neighborhood.

A nice thing about mountain biking is that the trails follow the natural landscape and topography, so "building" the trails would not involve cutting down trees or drastically impacting the natural setting. The trails would wind around and through trees and up and over hills. There's no paving of trails or lighting. There's also little maintenance of mountain bike trails. Things that fall on the trail (trees, branches, fall leaves) need to be removed and this is done by volunteers. The Edina Cycling Team organizes annual service days and requires volunteer hours to letter, so there's a built-in volunteer base right here with the team and their families.

Additionally, mountain biking trails at Braemar can be used year round. Fat tire biking through the snow has become very popular over the last few years. Mountain biking is a wonderful, lifelong activity that families can do together every season. Thank you for considering adding this terrific asset to our community!

Kind Regards, Mertyce Mrvos 5004 Bruce Avenue

Mertyce Mrvos Coordinator of Programs and Partnerships, Everlast Climbing 14 EVERLAST 4 CLIABING-

A PLA, CORE' 1335 Mendota Heights Rd Mendota Heights, MN 55120 Direct: 651.789.4224 Toll Free: 800.476.7366 x4224 Fax: 651.665.9130 1 [email protected] www.everlastclimbing.com

The contents of this message and any attachments are proprietary, confidential and/or legally privileged, and are intended solely for the use of the person(s) intended to receive this message. If you are not the intended recipient, then please be aware that any use of this message (including any copying, archiving, dissemination or distribution of this message) is strictly prohibited. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender, delete this message and any attachments and destroy all records and copies of it. Thank you.

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 4:17 PM Subject: FW: Braemar Golf Course development

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov

Original Message From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 3:43 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Golf Course development

Mayor Hovland, all council member:lt would behoove you to withdraw this new proposed development and be satisfied and take pride in our environmentally beautiful reserved natural asset called Braemar. Allow our suburban neighbors to continue with skiing options,hiking nature trails and Nordic skiing with out our competition! John & Patricia Dill

4610 Edina Boulevard Edina Mn.

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 4:25 PM Subject: FW: Braemar Recreational Facility- Alternative Options/Biking Trails

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.gov I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Nathan Peterson [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 4:16 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Recreational Facility- Alternative Options/Biking Trails

Dear Edina City Council-

I am writing in regard to the upcoming Council hearing on the Winter Recreational Facility at Braemar Park. I would like to compliment the council on exploring a project with some terrific goals: to promote health and wellbeing, to celebrate the natural assets in our community, and to provide a facility for recreation. However, based on the comment card report from the recent Park Board Open House meeting on this subject as well as community discussion forums, there are some consistent and strong objections to the project as it's currently planned: excessive costs—for construction, equipment, as well as ongoing operations; negative impact on the natural habitat and wildlife; and impact on the surrounding neighborhoods—light and noise pollution, increased traffic, snow over-spray.

That said, there is broad community support for a project that delivers on the original and basic premises of providing a facility to promote health and wellbeing in our community, utilizing the natural assets in the Braemar area, and increasing the recreational options for our residents. While the Winter Recreational Facility project as it's currently planned might have some community objections, I would encourage the council to explore alternative plans. I'm confident that an alternative proposal, which delivers on the original basic goals, while eliminating the objections that residents have with the current proposal, would be met with a broad level of approval and anticipation.

A central feature to consider for an alternative plan would be mountain biking trails. In community surveys, an increase in bike trails remains a top priority for our residents. Mountain biking is a great lifelong sport, and is seeing rapid growth at the youth levels. Last year, the National Interscholastic Cycling Association—the governing body for middle to high school student athletes—had a 51% increase in participation. And the Minnesota and Edina mountain bike programs are strong, and growing rapidly as well. With no current options for mountain biking in our community, a trail system at Braemar would fill a much needed void.

Most promising, a mountain bike trail system could be built and maintained in a manner that virtually eliminates all of the objections that the community has voiced to the current Winter Recreational Facility plans. Mountain bike singletrack trails and environmental conservation go hand in hand, and the trail system could be built with minimal impact to the natural surroundings. In fact, many trail systems realize an improvement to the broader natural surroundings, with stewardship and sustainability programs put into place by the biking community. And from a cost standpoint, the trail system could be constructed and maintained with minimal expenses—initial assessments project a $150,000 construction cost, and trail maintenance would be supported by volunteers for no additional ongoing costs to the city. A mountain bike trail system at Braemar would fill a need in our community, expand recreational options, as well as promote wellness; and it can be accomplished in a manner to ensure fiscal and environmental responsibilities to our community.

Best Regards, Nathan Peterson Edina resident

2 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 8:25 AM Subject: FW: Mountain Biking at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoREdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Sudeith, Tim [mailto:TSudeithplaycore.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 8:50 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Mountain Biking at Braemar

Dear Mayor Hovland and Members of the City Council,

I'm writing to ask you to support the addition of mountain biking trails to Braemar for five reasons:

1. Safety - This would provide a safe place for the Edina mountain bike team (62 children) to practice. The team currently rides 14 miles round trip (on the roads during rush hour) to practice at Theodore Wirth Park in Golden Valley. 2. Low cost - $20k per mile of single track trail. Braemar would be able to accommodate 4-6 miles of track. Total project cost = $120k. 3. Minimal impact —A single track trail is 18 inches wide and follows the contours and obstacles of the landscape. It would not require the removal of trees; only buckthorn and brush. 4. Low maintenance —There is very little maintenance required. All other trails in the metro area are maintained by volunteers. Volunteering is a requirement of the Edina mountain bike team, so they would maintain the trails. 5. Great asset for the community —The League of American Bicyclists awarded Edina a Bronze Award level of Bicycle Friendly Communities. This is an impressive accomplishment, one of only two suburbs in the state to receive this award. Having off-road cycling in our community, could help improve our status and move us up to Silver.

Thank you for considering adding mountain biking at Braemar.

Regards, Tim Sudeith (5004 Bruce Avenue)

Tim Sudeith Senior Vice President & Business Unit Manager, PlayCore LA\ (CORE 1335 Mendota Heights Road Mendota Heights, MN 55120 651.665.9131 [email protected] www.plavcore.com

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 8:30 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Hills Resident in Favor of Nordic Ski Area

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoREdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Kai Richter [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 9:45 PM To: Edina Mail; Mary Brindle; Kevin Staunton; Robert Stewart; swensonann1(agmail.com Subject: Braemar Hills Resident in Favor of Nordic Ski Area

Dear Council:

I am writing to voice my support, as a Braemar Hills resident, for the proposed nordic ski area. My family lives immediately adjacent to the Golf Course. The ski trails in the winter would be a very nice amenity, complementing the golf course in the summer. At least three people in our family would regularly use the ski trails, including my daughter, who attends Edina Public Schools and will be on the ski team this coming winter. Although I live on Gleason Road, I am not particularly concerned about traffic issues. It is hard to see how the traffic for skiing in winter would be any greater than the traffic for golf in the summer. As for worries about snow migrating onto the road, this concern also appears to be overblown. Prior to living in Edina, our family used to live in Maple Grove, and the snow making machines there (at Elm Creek Park) did not dump snow onto the park access roads. The purpose of the machines is to put the snow where it belongs -- on the trails -- and the volume of snowmaking is simply not on the scale of a downhill ski area like Buck Hill where those types of issues come into play because of the vast area being sprayed (and the heights at which it is sprayed). Finally, as for concerns about trees being cut down, it is evident from the design that the canopy will remain and the narrow band of trees that are cut will not be visible to anyone other than those actually using the trails. I don't see a lot of downside here. On the other hand, there is clearly a need in light of the loss of the trails by the high school and the lack of facilities with snowmaking generally. I urge the Council to approve the planned ski area. If there are improvements that can be made, so be it, but the benefits on the whole far outweigh the disadvantages. Thank you for your consideration.

Respectfully,

Kai Richter

7131 Gleason Road

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 8:31 AM Subject: FW: Edina City Council - In favor of mountain biking and x-country ski trails at Braemar

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Cynthia Hipwell [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 9:47 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Edina City Council - In favor of mountain biking and x-country ski trails at Braemar

Hello Mayor Hovland,

I am writing to express my support for the mountain biking and cross country ski trail development at Braemar. I was encouraged to see the plans for supporting lifetime healthy sports for our community. Our family does both mountain biking and cross country skiing together. It would be great to have this possibility nearby. In addition, this infrastructure is a key improvement for the mountain biking and cross country ski teams here in Edina. Both of these teams are "no- cut" sports that allow many kids participate. The teams in both sports have grown large and there is clearly interest growing each year. Since not all students make high-school level hockey, basketball, and soccer, these sports are critical to give other students a chance to participate in activities that keep them active and healthy. In addition, these are lifelong sports that they can take into adulthood and enjoy with their family. Currently the mountain biking team must ride through the city to Theodore Wirth park to practice. Not only is the additional city road travel not as safe as practicing locally, it reduces the amount of time the team can actually practice mountain biking and get in shape with hill drills, etc. Half of their practice time is actually the commute to Theodore Wirth and back. The effect was clear at the Mount Kato meet last year where hills were critical and we did not do well. The option to practice locally would be a great boost to the team. A few more things to add. I am neutral on the tubing hill. If the revenue is needed to support the other activities, I am fine with that. If it is cut, I am not devastated either. Also of note is that I live immediately adjacent to the Braemar parkland, so I am welcoming this activity to my own neighborhood. Thank you again for consideration of this community improvement and great way to use the city land and facilities.

Best regards,

Cynthia Hipwell Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 8:32 AM Subject: FW: Nordic Ski Track

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoREdinaMN.00v I www.EdinaMN.gov

From: Tom Bach [mailto:tom.j.bach(agmail.corn] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 11:04 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Nordic Ski Track

Dear Mayor and City Council, As a 50 year resident of Edina, I am writing to ask you to vote "NO!" to this half baked idea. Here are some key points for you to consider: 1. When I bought my home on Gleason Road across from a woods and golf course, that's what I was expecting to be there. The rec department can't rezone a woods into a commercial venture (pay to tube, pay to ski). This needs to have the planning department involved if this is re-zoned as proposed. 2. The economics of this proposal are weak, and destined to lose money forever. No one will pay for a 25 foot elevation tubing run, and it is crazy to run water/snowmaking and 50 foot wide trails through a beautiful woods. We live in Minnesota, and we get plenty of snow. We need to use what nature provides. The water piping will be a huge maintenance expense, fraught with upkeep issues. A basic 20 or 25 foot wide trail with natural snow is more than sufficient. 3. We cannot spend $3M (initial investment) to support a marginal high school sport. Then also have significant ongoing upkeep expenses. Trail maintenance, snow machines to make trails, maintenance workers to fix broken water lines and nozzles that don't work, etc. Did the economic analysis include the cost of plowing the entire Braemar parking lot? We don't do that now in the winter time. 4. Environmental impact study of making snow and blowing it all over a hillside. Where is this water coming from? 5. Safety issue on Gleason Road. I personally see 2-3 cars crashed into the retaining walls or across the side walk along Gleason every winter. My mailbox has been destroyed by a car sliding on a icy Gleason Road. The issue is the sun does not heat/dry Gleason due to being blocked by the hillside in Braemar. This plan will just make Gleason Road a complete road ice hazard. Where does the safety of my 3 children walking along Gleason to the school bus, etc., factor into this? There are more issues, but these are top of mind to me.

I hope you take the safety concerns, and the concerns of the tax paying citizens into account. Thank you. Thomas Bach

From Tom Bach

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 10:02 AM Subject: FW: Braemar Proposal

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: [email protected] [mailto:MaryPatLitwin(acomcast.net] Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 9:24 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Braemar Proposal

Dear City Council Member:

I urge you to vote AGAINST the proposal to develop Braemar with Nordic Ski Trails. Please leave Braemar just the way it is!

I am against this idea for several reasons: the extra congestion in the immediate area that will come with it; the lighting; the noise from the snow-making machines; the overspray; and the cost!!!!

Please vote against this.

Thank you.

Mary Pat Litwin 5808 Bernard Place Edina, MN 55436 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 10:08 AM Subject: FW: Edina City Council Braemar Meeting

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Craig Bourgeault [mailto:CBourgeauMspineolociy.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 9:48 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Edina City Council Braemar Meeting

Dear Mayor Hovland Do not vote to spend millions of taxpayer dollars on an expensive-to-maintain winter sports area that cannot possibly pay for itself, and that will see use only 1'0 weeks of the year. Please keep the character of the Braemar area intact. Keep the trees and the wild areas. An inexpensive to create, user maintained mountain biking area that will retain the trees and the character of the neighborhood, and that can be used year-round makes much more sense for a city like Edina.

I support a mountain biking trail at Braemar. I oppose spending taxpayer money, now and for years into the future, on a winter sports complex with limited utility.

Craig Bourgea u It 6212 Hailfax Ave S Edina MN 55424

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of James Hovland Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 11:50 AM Subject: FW: Edina City Council Braemar meeting

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 IbiunnoEdinaMN.qov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: Craig Bourgeault [mailto:CBourgeault(aspineology.corn] Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 11:21 AM To: James Hovland Subject: Edina City Council Braemar meeting

Dear Mayor Hovland Do not vote to spend millions of taxpayer dollars on an expensive-to-maintain winter sports area that cannot possibly pay for itself, and that will see use only 1'0 weeks of the year. Please keep the character of the Braemar area intact. Keep the trees and the wild areas. An inexpensive to create, user maintained mountain biking area that will retain the trees and the character of the neighborhood, and that can be used year-round makes much more sense for a city like Edina. I support a mountain biking trail at Braemar. I oppose spending taxpayer money, now and for years into the future, on a winter sports complex with limited utility.

Craig Bourgeault 6212 Hailfax Ave S Edina MN 55424

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 1:50 PM Subject: FW: Keep Breamer Green

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Shelley Psyhogios [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, September 07, 2016 12:00 PM To: Edina Mail Subject: Keep Breamer Green

Please vote NO on developing a ski/tubbing park. This is a residential neighborhood. DO NOT COMMERCIALIZE it. Highland Ski Hill is less then 3 miles away. Shelley Psyhogios 6228 Braeburn Circle 55439 Sent from my iPhone Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Thursday, September 08, 2016 9:45 AM Subject: FW: Thank you

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 [email protected] I www.EdinaMN.gov Original Message From: Bernadine Letsche [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 08, 2016 6:33 AM To: Edina Mail Cc: Joshua M. Ahlberg; Kristin Kiser Reichling; Karen Hazel Subject: Thank you

Thank you to the mayor and council members for your thoughtful and wise consideration of the Braemar Winter Center proposal. You listened to both sides, read all the emails and asked pointed questions and made comments for the designer and Park Board Chair. With more study and consideration I'm sure both proponents and opponents will come to an agreement on what should be done at Braemar.

If you want a subject researched and argued, just make it a little controversial; the public will run with it and give you more information that you ever thought possible. Maybe we don't need to pay for studies, we just need a little controve rsylIIIM

Good job.

Bernadine Letsche 7435 Hyde Park Lane 952-944-2464

1 Janet Canton

From: Lynette Biunno on behalf of Edina Mail Sent: Thursday, September 08, 2016 11:00 AM Subject: FW: Contact Us form submission

Lynette Biunno, Receptionist 952-927-8861 I Fax 952-826-0389 Ibiunno0EdinaMN.gov I www.EdinaMN.qov

From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 08, 2016 6:38 AM To: Edina Mail Subject: Contact Us form submission

Name: John Driscoll

Organization:

Website: [email protected]

Address 1: 6513 Limerick Drive

Address_2:

City: Edina

State: MN

Zip Code: 55439

Email: [email protected]

Phone: 612-418-9680

Referrer: other

Message: I could not make the City Council Meeting last night for the discussion of Braemar Hills Winter Recreation proposal. I will make my comments here. I am an avid, recreational cross country skier. I have skied races, the Norwegian Birkbeinner, the Swiss Endadin, etc., but I am not a racer. I am strictly a classic skier, not a skate skier. These artificial snow areas, Hyland/Wirth/Elm Creek, are designed for performance skiers, people that need to build endurance for racing and competition, which is the ski team and citizen racers, but does not necessarily appeal to recreational skiers. I ski at the Hyland snow making loop to get in shape, but it does not fulfill my reason for skiing. I ski many areas of the State and around the country for my 'One With Nature' need. I question the cost and the revenue projections, who is the market audience. I think I would be part of the target audience, I ski 2 to 3 times a week, but I don not think I will ever ski at Braemar. The distances are too short, and the trails way to wide for my liking. We will need to compete with Hyland, our source for water is well water, similar to Wirth, Hyland and Elm Creek use holding ponds, they can make snow at a higher ambient temperature than those using well water. They will usually open before Wirth for this reason, people who are interested in skiing as early as they can will buy passes for Hyland, and I doubt that they would buy another pass for a shorter length track and no other options. A pass at Hyland allows access to Elm Creek and all the non snow making 3 River Parks when there is natural snow, an option Braemer will never have. I do not see any storage facility or maintenance facility for the equipment necessary for grooming and pushing snow. I am a strong advocate for silent sports and cross country skiing, but I believe this venue will always need to be subsidized by the taxpayers of Edina. Please look at less intrusive and less costly ways to use the available resources at Braemar that will appeal to much more of the citizenry. Thank You.

2