DOCSLIB.ORG

Thompson 2019-Dissertation Final

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Thompson 2019-Dissertation Final The Orphaned Past: Ache Autonomy and Relationality in Times of Change by Warren Thompson A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Anthropology) in the University of Michigan 2019 Doctoral Committee Professor Webb Keane, Chair Professor Bruce Mannheim Professor Erik Mueggler Associate Professor Suzanne Oakdale, University of New Mexico Professor Emeritus Thomas Trautmann Warren Thompson [email protected] ORCID iD: 0000-0002-6963-2175 © Warren Thompson 2019 Acknowledgments The writing of this dissertation was made possible through a Block Grant Write- Up Fellowship and a Rackham Fellowship from the University of Michigan’s Anthropology Department. Research was funded through a doctoral research grant from the Fulbright Institute of International Education, a Rackham International Research Award from the University of Michigan, and two Dokumentation bedrohter Sprachen (DoBeS) grants administered through the Max Plank Institute for Psycholinguistics (MPI) in Nijmegen. I am grateful to these institutions for their support over the years. In particular, I wish to express my gratitude to Jost Gippert and Sebastian Drude for their advice and direction during the DoBeS grants and to Alexander Konig and Nick Wood at the MPI for technical support and the digitalization of a number of near-ruined recordings. The University of Michigan provided a stimulating intellectual environment to work through the ideas of this dissertation. The work of my committee members, Webb Keane, Bruce Mannheim, Erik Mueggler, Suzanne Oakdale, and Tom Trautmann has been an inspiration for my own, and their influence on the pages that follow will be clear to those familiar with their work. They have pushed me to develop and refine my ideas from the earliest stages of the dissertation to its final form, and their suggestions have benefitted the work immeasurably. During various stages of this project I benefited from the careful reading, critique, and ii recommendations of friends and colleagues. Adrian Deoanca, Georgia Ennis, Gillian Feeley-Harnik, Jan David Hauck, Randeep Hothi, Matt Hull, Matan Kaminer, Eric Kelley, Ozge Korkmaz, Carlos Londoño-Sulkin, James Meador, Prash Naidu, Nishita Trisal, and Richard Reed read parts of the dissertation and offered valuable feedback. Hélène Clastres generously granted access to the field recordings of Pierre Clastres and León Cadogan. Richard Reed’s captivating lectures at Trinity University first cultivated my interest in Paraguay as an undergraduate. He suggested that I work with the Ache, and his generous introductions made my first years in Paraguay possible. While in Paraguay, I benefitted from the experience of Marilin Rehnfelt, Adelina Pussineri, Lucio Godoy S.V.D, and Mario Bogado. I am especially grateful to Marilin for her invitation to teach a class at the Universidad Católica “Nuestra Señora de la Asunción,” which allowed me to extend my fieldstay by several months. I thank Ivan Vera for his friendship and generosity during much needed respites from the field in Asunción. Bjarne and Rosalba Fostervold deserve special thanks for my introduction to the Ache in 2006 and for the unflagging generosity I have received from them ever since. Without their encouragement and support, this dissertation would have been impossible. They walk the walk. Over the years, Kim Hill has been unsparing with his knowledge and advice, and his long experience with the Ache has greatly enriched my own. Jan David Hauck and Eva Maria Roessler have been collaborators in the field, sparring partners while writing, and devoted friends throughout the time we have known each other. I cannot thank them enough. iii I wish to thank my wife, Lauren; my parents, Bob and Sarah; and my brother, Robert for their love, patience, and support. The Ache I have known over the years have endured unimaginable hardship with dignity and a joy that refuses to be extinguished. I have tried in this dissertation to communicate some sense of the enormity of the changes they have undergone since their settlement and what they considered essential to those changes. In particular, I wish to thank Geronimo Tatugi and Francisco Bepegi. I cherish my conversations with Chimbegi, Pikygi, Kuategi, Krachogi, Kwewegi, Kybwyaragi marĩ, and Achĩpurãngi marĩ, and I thank them for the care and patience they have shown so that I might “know well” the many things they have tried to teach me. iv Table of Contents Acknowledgements ii List of Tables vi List of Figures vii List of Appendices viii Abstract ix Introduction 1 Chapter 1 The Give and Take of Ownership 27 Chapter 2 Other Times, Other Places 55 Chapter 3 Scolding, the Agonism of Ache Ethics 70 Chapter 4 The Dangerous Remainder 87 Chapter 5 Ownership and Bodily Integrity in the Settlement Process 115 Chapter 6 God the Owner, God the Healer 131 Chapter 7 Seeing is Believing 169 Conclusion 189 Appendices 193 References 205 v List of Tables Table 1.1 Age Grades 45 Table 8.1 Consonants 195 Table 8.2 Vowels 196 vi List of Figures Figure 1.1. Map of Paraguay 26 Figure 1.2 Minõngi carrying a tapir head, 1982 33 Figure 5.1 Jesus Manuel de Pereira, 1960 129 Figure 5.2 Pereira cutting an Ache man’s hair, 1960 130 Figure 5.3 The sinful body 162 vii List of Appendices Appendix 1 A Note on Orthography and Transcription 193 Appendix 2 Glossary of Ache Terms 198 Appendix 3 Account of September 1973 contact by NTM 200 viii Abstract The concept of “ownership” has assumed some prominence in the recent anthropology of lowland South America (Fausto 2002; 2012; Bonilla 2005; Costa 2017). “Ownership,” as it is typically defined, is a hierarchical relation that gradually develops between an “owner” and a person owned (whether human or non-human) through continued acts of care and feeding. In this dissertation, I explore the notion of ownership through the history of settlement of one group of South American hunter-gatherers, the Ache of eastern Paraguay. Attending to ownership relations between kin, between the living and dead, between Ache and Paraguayans, and between humanity and the Christian God, I argue that hierarchical relations of ownership contain important moral presuppositions. I describe how relations are evaluated in these domains to show that an essential aspect of ownership is the evaluation of it, and the risks inherent in the relation are integral to the continuous feeding and care that sustains it. ix Introduction One humid summer night in 2009, the grandmother Djakugi packed her carrying basket with a few possessions— an axe, a handleless knife with a worn blade, a woven-palm mat, and a plastic jug. She had heard the calls of her long-dead parents and brothers, and, moved by their siren-like pull, went to meet them. As her husband slept, Flora slipped the finely woven strap of her carrying basket over her forehead and shuffled across the clearing, and disappeared through the dark wall of vegetation. In the dawn hours of the next morning, Djakugi’s absence caused some alarm in the community, and a group of hunters assembled to search for her as a group of women speculated about the reasons for her absence. There was only a small patch of forest outside of the community left for her to retreat to, and the hunters had no difficulty in finding her. After following her trail for a short time, they found her sitting alone in a small forest clearing less than a kilometer outside the village. She wanted to die, she told them. She would join her dead kin in the western skies. “Come back,” the hunters pleaded. “You still have your half-sister,” they reminded her, hoping that the care she felt for her living relative would be enough to coax her back to the community. The excitement subsided upon her return, and satisfied at the resolution, people returned to their houses. Little more was said about her brief disappearance. As people returned to their routines, I wrestled with how to understand what had just 1 happened and what caused this episode. When I asked one young man why Djakugi had left the village, he lowered his eyes and laughed nervously. “She has lost her head,” he said. “She is crazy.” His words were revealing. Although he spoke in Spanish (I was not yet proficient in Ache), he retained the Ache word tollã, which means, literally, “headless.” According to the young man, there could be no reason, no understanding, guiding her actions. It was little wonder that the young, who knew their grandparent’s life in the forest only from stories, couldn’t relate to the old woman’s anguish. But years later I would come to learn that what the young man had attributed to senility was not an uncommon affliction for old women and men. Djakugi had been overcome by some sort of fugue state, where she, instead of forgetting the past, had completely succumbed to it. The images of dead kin that had pulled Djakugi away were more than upsetting recollections. As I was later told, sad and despondent people were said to forget their living kin and feel a pull toward their dead kin. Djakugi, aged and childless, her husband Chinigi long dead from snakebite, could no longer see herself in the world that surrounded her. Her memories had roused her dead kin and brought lured her to them. Her attempted “escape” was one of the early glimpses into the struggle with the past that that I encountered during the course of my fieldwork. Such struggles, as I would gradually learn, were intensely ethically laden, providing both the ground and the substance for everyday evaluations. Djakugi’s fugue state had put her at odds with the moral expectations of both the past and the present.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Original Institutional Economics and Political Anthropology
    Original Institutional Economics and Political Anthropology: Reflections on the nature of coercive power and vested interests in the works of Thorstein Veblen and Pierre Clastres Coauthored by: Manuel Ramon de Souza Luz; Faculty of Economics; Federal University ABC; São Paulo, Brazil [email protected] John Hall, Department of Economics, Portland State University; Oregon, USA [email protected] Abstract: Our inquiry advances a comparison of the anthropological content of Thorstein Veblen’s evolutionary perspective with the foundations of the political anthropology drawn from selected works of Pierre Clastres. We seek to establish that what can be referred to as a clastrean reference can simultaneously offer new perspectives on institutionalism, while maintaining a radical and emancipatory understanding of Veblen’s writings. In this sense, we seek to reconsider and reevaluate the role of economic surplus drawn from Veblen’s anthropology, while also offering a general and critical perspective for understanding the emergence of coercive power within societies. (94 words) JEL Classification Codes B15, B25, B41 Key Words: Coercive Power, Original Institutional Economics, Pierre Clastres, Political Anthropology, Thorstein Veblen (Front matter: 169 words) This inquiry considers contributions of Thorstein Veblen by juxtaposing them to selected contributions of Pierre Clastres, a scholar heralded as a founder of French political anthropology. Differing from Veblen, with his backgrounds in Economics and Philosophy, Clastres’ generated an anthropology founded on fieldwork investigations. These investigations abetted his constructing a theoretical synthesis that considers the nature of power and, relatedly, countervailing institutions within selected indigenous societies found across the South American continent. His body of research stresses that the classless and egalitarian character of indigenous societies was not an outcome of the comparatively modest levels of technology and the lack of accumulated surpluses.
    [Show full text]
  • Pierre Clastres As Comparative Political Theorist : the Democratic Potential of the New Political Anthropology
    This document is downloaded from DR‑NTU (https://dr.ntu.edu.sg) Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. Pierre Clastres as comparative political theorist : the democratic potential of the new political anthropology Holman, Christopher 2017 Holman, C. (2017). Pierre Clastres as comparative political theorist : the democratic potential of the new political anthropology. European Journal of Political Theory. doi:10.1177/1474885117729772 https://hdl.handle.net/10356/145146 https://doi.org/10.1177/1474885117729772 © 2017 SAGE Publications. All rights reserved. This paper was published in European Journal of Political Theory and is made available with permission of SAGE Publications. Downloaded on 26 Sep 2021 06:51:29 SGT PIERRE CLASTRES AS COMPARATIVE POLITICAL THEORIST: THE DEMOCRATIC POTENTIAL OF THE NEW POLITICAL ANTHROPOLOGY Christopher Holman Advanced publication in European Journal of Political Theory in 2017. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1474885117729772 Introduction: Clastres and the Project of Comparative Political Theory Within the history of 20th century French ideas the philosopher-turned-anthropologist Pierre Clastres holds a significant place.1 In particular, Clastres’ ethnological work detailing the social structure of indigenous Amazonian societies and the political mechanisms through which this structure is instituted – in particular their rejection of coercive power in the name of a principle of equality – influenced a generation of some of the most talented democratic political theorists in France, such
    [Show full text]
  • Apellidos Guaraníes En Paraguay. Una Actualización De Su Vigencia a Partir De Mil Apellidos Guaraníes, De León Cadogan
    ISSN 1851-3751 (en línea) / ISSN 0327-5752 (impresa) MT [99-117] Memoria Americana. Cuadernos de Etnohistoria 99 CONVOCATORIA ABIERTA 29.1 (Junio 2021) Apellidos guaraníes en Paraguay. Una actualización de su vigencia a partir de Mil apellidos guaraníes, de León Cadogan Domingo A. Aguilera Jiménez* " Fecha de recepción: 5 de agosto de 2020. Fecha de aceptación: 29 de marzo de 2021 Resumen Este artículo presenta los apellidos guaraníes vigentes en la población para- Palabras clave guaya actual, conforme con la base de datos del Sistema de Identificación onomástica paraguaya Policial de la Policía Nacional paraguaya ,a partir de una comprobación de reducciones jesuíticas la lista publicada por León Cadogan en Mil apellidos guaraníes ([1960] 2005). cultura guaraní Esta recopilación, contiene en total 1.189 apellidos guaraníes, relevados por etnografía el autor en parroquias de las antiguas misiones y pueblos de indios. De esta cantidad, solo 79 (6,6 %) están vigentes hoy, con nacimientos que abarcan no solo Paraguay, sino también Argentina, Brasil, Bolivia, Uruguay, Chile y España. En total, estos apellidos llevan unas 11.602 personas, nacidas en los últimos 150 años (1869-2019) en el área de extensión. Asunción es la localidad con mayor variedad de apellidos registrados (40 en total), y el departamento de menor cantidad es Boquerón (6 en total). El departamento de Caazapá con- centra la mayor cantidad de nacimiento de personas con apellidos guaraníes en toda el área. Guaraní surnames in Paraguay. An update of their current use from Mil Apellidos Guaraníes, by León Cadogan Abstract This article presents the Guaraní surnames currently used in Paraguayan Key words population, according to the database of the Police Identification System of Paraguayan onomastics the Paraguayan National Police, based on a check of the list published by León Jesuit reductions Cadogan in Mil Apellidos Guaraníes ([1960] 2005).
    [Show full text]
  • POLITICAL ANTHROPOLOGY: an Introduction, Third Edition
    POLITICAL ANTHROPOLOGY: An Introduction, Third Edition Ted C. Lewellen PRAEGER Political Anthropology POLITICAL ANTHROPOLOGY An Introduction Third Edition Ted C. Lewellen Foreword by Victor Turner, Written for the First Edition Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Lewellen, Ted C., 1940– Political anthropology : an introduction / Ted C. Lewellen ; foreword to the first edition by Victor Turner.—3rd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–89789–890–7 (alk. paper)—ISBN 0–89789–891–5 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Political anthropology. I. Title. GN492.L48 2003 306.2—dc21 2003052889 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data is available. Copyright ᭧ 2003 by Ted C. Lewellen All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, by any process or technique, without the express written consent of the publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2003052889 ISBN: 0–89789–890–7 0–89789–891–5 (pbk.) First published in 2003 Praeger Publishers, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881 An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. www.praeger.com Printed in the United States of America The paper used in this book complies with the Permanent Paper Standard issued by the National Information Standards Organization (Z39.48–1984). 10987654321 CONTENTS Foreword, Written for the First Edition vii Victor Turner Preface ix 1. The Development of Political Anthropology 1 2. Types of Preindustrial Political Systems 15 3. The Evolution of the State 43 4. Religion in Politics: Sacred Legitimacy, Divine Resistance 65 5. Structure and Process 81 6. The Individual in the Political Arena: Action Theory and Game Theory 95 7.
    [Show full text]
  • Leadership in State Genesis: Creative Vicediction, Guardianship, and the Crystallization of Sovereign Authority
    Leadership in State Genesis: Creative Vicediction, Guardianship, and the Crystallization of Sovereign Authority DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Tahseen Kazi Graduate Program in Comparative Studies The Ohio State University 2014 Dissertation Committee: Eugene Holland, Advisor Sonja Amadae Philip Armstrong Mathew Coleman Luis Lobo-Guerrero Copyrighted by Tahseen Kazi 2014 Abstract The complicity of leadership in the genesis of sovereign authority is neglected in contemporary political thought to the detriment of our understanding of both of these concepts. Dissatisfied with contemporary reliance on notions such as sovereign decision which ultimately imply primal repression as the sole source of all authority, my research takes the genesis of sovereignty as a problem to be solved rather than as an unalterable, natural occurrence to be presumed. Drawing on such diverse resources as Foucault’s concept of parrhesia, Weber’s concept of charisma, anthropological and mythological accounts of authority, Simondon’s theory of the genesis of the individual as crystallization, and primarily on Deleuzian philosophy, I offer an account of the genesis of the sovereign state as the result of the conjugation of two modes of leadership: leadership by guardianship and leadership by creative vicediction. Whereas leadership by guardianship in the Platonic tradition makes claim to judgment on the authority of customary founding myths, thereby severely limiting leadership’s transformative potential, leadership by creative vicediction, a ii concept I develop, trespasses on such myths to critically engage with their representation of the present circumstance, and presubjectively and affectively guides others toward another way of being.
    [Show full text]
  • POWER and ITS DISGUISES Anthropological Perspectives on Politics
    POWER AND ITS DISGUISES Anthropological Perspectives on Politics Second Edition JOHN GLEDHILL Pluto P Press LONDON • STERLING, VIRGINIA First published 1994 Second Edition 2000 by PLUTO PRESS 345 Archway Road, London N6 5AA and 22883 Quicksilver Drive, Sterling, VA 20166–2012, USA www.plutobooks.com Copyright © John Gledhill 1994, 2000 The right of John Gledhill to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0 7453 1686 7 hbk ISBN 0 7453 1685 9 pbk Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Gledhill, John. Power and its disguises : anthropological perspectives on politics / John Gledhill.—2nd ed. p. cm.—(Anthropology, culture and society) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–7453–1686–7 1. Political anthropology. 2. Power (Social sciences) I. Title. II. Series. GN492.G55 2000 306.2—dc21 00–026069 09 08 07 06 05 04 03 02 01 00 10987654321 Designed and produced for Pluto Press by Chase Production Services Typeset from disk by Stanford DTP Services, Northampton Printed in the European Union by TJ International, Padstow CONTENTS Preface to the Second Edition vii 1. Locating the political: a political anthropology for today 1 How not to use the West as a point of departure 8 The distinctiveness of the modern state 15 Wider implications of historical discontinuity 18 Political anthropology reconstituted 20 2. The origins and limits of coercive power: the anthropology of stateless societies 23 The externalization of the political as the negation of power 27 Sexual politics in stateless societies 32 Civilization, mother of barbarism 38 ‘Stateless societies’ under the modern state 41 3.
    [Show full text]
  • 2 the Origins and Limits of Coercive Power
    22 Power and Its Disguises their objectives on a global scale. Though particular situations always reflect the interaction of the local and the global, local social and cultural histories I' now find expression in action in ways that are part of a common experience of modernity. as I stress in Chapter 7. Only concrete, contextualized analysis 2 THE ORIGINS AND LIMITS OF COERCIVE of particular situations will enable us to understand what is happening and POWER: THE ANTHROPOLOGY OF why it is happening (in Europe and the United States as well as other parts of the world). But little that is happening anywhere can be understood STATELESS SOCIETIES without reference to the historical discontinuities produced by the rise of the modern state and modern forms of power. Although Clastres' s polemic against traditional political anthropology would be an appropriate starting-point for a discussion of 'stateless' societies. the late Stanley Diamond advanced a critique of the state which is broader than Clastres's observations about indigenous South American societies. Diamond's 19 51 PhD dissertation was an ethnohistorical study of state formation in the West African kingdom ofDahomey, but his wider paradigm for a 'dialectical anthropology' reflected his New York Jewish background and experience as a volunteer with the British Army during the Second World War in North Africa. There he met Black African 'volunteers' from South Africa. Pressed into service by the South African government through the good offices of chiefly clients of the regime, these men were sent to die in an unknown land in an unknown cause in place of Whites (Gailey 1992: 4).
    [Show full text]
  • Columbus and Other Cannibals
    Table of Contents Title Page Dedication Foreword Acknowledgements Introduction ONE - The Genesis of the Universe and the Creation of Love TWO - Consuming Another’s Life The Wétiko Cannibal Psychosis THREE - Columbus Cannibal and Hero of Genocide FOUR - Deception, Brutality, and Greed The Spread of the Disease FIVE - The Structure of the Cannibal’s Insanity Arrogance, Lust, and Materialism SIX - Becoming a Predator The Process of Corruption SEVEN - The Mátchi Syndrome Fascination with Evil EIGHT - Colonialism, Europeanization, and the Destruction of Native (Authentic) Cultures NINE - Savages, Free People, and the Loss of Freedom TEN - Terrorism A Frequent Aspect of Wétiko Behavior ELEVEN - Male Violence, Female Subordination, and the Perpetuation of ... TWELVE - Organized Crime Planned Aggression, Planned Predation THIRTEEN - If Jesus Were to Return FOURTEEN - Seeking Sanity Reversing the Process of Brutalization FIFTEEN - Finding a Good Path, a Path with Heart The Universe is Our Holy Book Notes Bibliography Credits and Permissions About the Author About Seven Stories Press Copyright Page Dedicated to Antonio del Buono 1900-1975 Otomi . Mexicano . Italiano . Chicano . Cosmic Man . A Man to be Remembered A Man to be Imitated: He came to this Earth to be an Eagle and a Jaguar Foreword COLUMBUS AND OTHER CANNIBALS is, I think, the most important book ever written on one of the most important topics ever faced by human beings: why is the dominant culture so excruciatingly, relentlessly, insanely, genocidally, ecocidally, suicidally destructive? I’ve written many books about precisely this subject, and I have to admit that this question still baffles me. How could any group of people, no matter how insane, no matter how stupid, actually destroy the planet on which (or rather, whom) they live? I often shake my head sharply, or pinch myself, hoping I will wake up and find that this culture and its destructiveness have all been a very bad and incomprehensible dream.
    [Show full text]
  • Kings for UCP.Png
    In anthropology as much as in popular imagination, kings are fgures of fascination and intrigue, heroes or tyrants in ways presidents and prime ministers can never be. Tis collection of essays by two of the world’s most distinguished anthropologists—David Graeber and Marshall Sahlins—explores what kingship actually is, historically and anthropo- logically. As they show, kings are symbols for more than just sovereignty: indeed, the study of kingship ofers a unique window into fundamental dilemmas concerning the very nature of power, meaning, and the human condition. Refecting on issues such as temporality, alterity, and utopia—not to mention the divine, the strange, the numinous, and the bestial—Graeber and Sahlins explore the role of kings as they have existed around the world, from the BaKongo to the Aztec to the Shilluk and beyond. Richly delivered with the wit and sharp analysis characteristic of Graeber and Sahlins, this book opens up new avenues for the anthropological study of this fascinating and ubiquitous political fgure. * * * If you deem that anthropology is neither a form of pompous navel- gazing, nor an exercise in making preposterous generalizations out of sketchy personal experiences, this book is for you. With impecca- ble scholarship, conceptual imagination, and wit, David Graeber and Marshall Sahlins think anew, and within a broad comparative scope, an ancient and illustrious question: why and how can a single man come to rule over the many as the embodiment or the delegate of a god? Such a question, they show, can only be answered by shifting towards an analysis where human, non-human, and meta-human persons are treated on the same ontological level as parts of a hierarchical cosmic polity.
    [Show full text]
  • The Utopian Diaspora: Australians in Paraguay Andrew Harvey
    The Utopian Diaspora: Australians in Paraguay Andrew Harvey Abstract This chapter argues that the experiment of the Australians’ diaspora in Paraguay forms an important but neglected chapter in Australian history. Only two books, an occasional play, and no significant films have represented the ‘New Australia’ experiment, a paucity of coverage which is the result of both a deliberate forgetting and an underinvestment in national cultural institutions. The contrast with the Welsh government’s continuing support of Welsh settlements in Patagonia is striking, and the chapter examines the reasons behind these contrasting approaches and the cultural significance of Paraguayan collective amnesia. Key Words: Nationalism, identity, Australia, Paraguay, utopia, diaspora. ***** Class war was manifest in Australia in the 1890s. The shearers’ strikes had divided the nation: pastoralists wanted the ability to hire labour at will on free contracts, while the shearers and associated workers wanted guaranteed employment, wages and hours. Governments were close to the pastoralist interests, while the shearers ‘were armed and mobile’.1 One of the loudest advocates for the shearers’ interests was William Lane, a fiery wellread journalist with a knowledge of Das Kapital and a vision for the future. The shearers lost most of the battles, and Lane decided to exit the war stage left - far left. As the strikes were broken and workers suffered through drought and rising unemployment, the Australian Labour Party was born. Lane, though, wanted a more radical solution to the struggle than mere political franchise. Inspired by Edward Bellamy’s utopian vision outlined in his popular novel of the time, Looking Backwards, Lane led an expedition of two hundred ambitious souls to the shores of Paraguay in the Royal Tar in 1893.
    [Show full text]
  • Society Against the State – Pierre Clastres
    Society Against the State – Pierre Clastres “Pierre Clastres broke up with his mentor Claude Levi-Strauss to collaborate with Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari on their Anti-Oedipus. He is the rare breed of political anthropologist—a Nietzschean—and his work presents us with a genealogy of power in a native state. For him, tribal societies are not Rousseauist in essence; to the contrary, they practice systematic violence in order to prevent the rise in their midst of this “cold monster”: the state. Only by waging war with other tribes can they maintain the dispersion and autonomy of each group. In the same way, tribal chiefs are not all-powerful; to the contrary, they are rendered weak in order to remain dependent on the community.” -- Semiotext(e) http://www.semiotexte.com/authors/clastres.html Biography: Pierre Clastres, born in 1934, died in 1977 in a car accident. Was director of research at the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) in Paris, and member of the Laboratoire d'Anthropologie Sociale du Collège de France. Took part in the events of May ’68. Anti-Evolutionary Model Primitive Society characterized by ‘Savages’ lacking political power [Lapierre’s model] (8-10). *Political Power: “a relation that ultimately comes down to coercion” (11) *Weberian power: “state power as the monopoly on the legitimate use of violence” (11) Critiqued as ethnocentric: “the model…is…constituted in advance by the idea Western civilization has shaped and developed….[P]olitical power in terms of hierarchized and authoritarian relations
    [Show full text]
  • Paradise Regained? the Work of Mediation Technology in an Age of Open Communities by John Grech
    2/18/2016 TRANSFORMATIONS Journal of Media & Culture ISSN 1444­3775 2007 Issue No. 15 — Walter Benjamin and the Virtual Paradise Regained? The Work of Mediation Technology in an Age of Open Communities By John Grech This paper is about the propagation of an open global community in an age of technological mediation. Acts of mediation enable people to collectively create bonds and relations between themselves and others, whether this takes place through complex communication mechanisms such as the internet, or in direct acts of speech between individuals. The starting point of this essay is that communication technology may re-establish old forms of social bonds and cultural relations just as it may create new bonds and relations between individuals. Drawn from the work of Walter Benjamin and Pierre Clastres, it addresses issues in existing social bonds and cultural relations in the context of an emergent global communication network. Benjamin’s critical analyses of violence and the work of art in the modern era is essential in understanding how technology shapes bonds and relations between individuals in society. Clastres’s research into political relations in Indian societies suggests alternative political systems that govern relations between society and the State. My purpose is to extend Benjamin’s and Clastres’s analyses of relations between people and society and the State to the work produced when communication technologies are conceptualised as performances of mediation in a globally communicative digital era. The argument this paper develops is that an open democratic global community has the right, and it very much enforces that right, to insist that the system of governance used in regulating global social relations is not based on the capacity of the State to forcibly ensure that individuals act in accordance with the State’s decrees.
    [Show full text]