FROGS in an EFFLUENT SOCIETY Risks, Remedies and Responsibilities by Dr Sara Broomhall First Published in June 2004 by WWF Australia © WWF Australia 2004
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FROGS IN AN EFFLUENT SOCIETY Risks, Remedies and Responsibilities by Dr Sara Broomhall First published in June 2004 by WWF Australia © WWF Australia 2004. All Rights Reserved. ISBN: 1 875941 67 3 Author: Dr Sara Broomhall WWF Australia GPO Box 528 Sydney NSW Australia Tel: +612 9281 5515 Fax: +612 9281 1060 www.wwf.org.au For copies of this booklet or a full list of WWF Australia publications on a wide range of conservation issues, please contact us on [email protected] or call 1800 032 551. The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of WWF. Special thanks to Craig Cleeland for supplying the photographs for this booklet. CONTENTS FROGS AS ENVIRONMENTAL BAROMETERS The aim of this booklet is to help What is a pollutant? 2 you understand: Australian frogs 2 How do frogs interact with their environment? 3 What pollutants are – Life stages 3 – Habitat requirements 3 How frogs interact with their environment – Ecological position 3 – Frogs and pollutants in the food chain 3 Why water pollution affects frogs Why is environmental pollution a frog issue? 3 – Are frogs more sensitive to environmental pollutants than other species? 3 Where pollutants come from and how they enter the environment WHAT WE DO AND DON’T KNOW Why don’t we have all the answers? 4 How you may be polluting water – How relevant are these toxicity tests to real world situations anyway? 4 Categories of pollutants (such as pesticides) Where do pollutants come from? 4 How many chemicals do we use here in Australia? 4 and their effects on frogs Who produces pollutants? 4 Where you can go for further information WHAT’S HAPPENING? So how am I polluting? 6 What alternatives there are and Let’s take a ride through the wastewater system 6 what products you can substitute – The ins and outs of waste water 7 What do we know about agricultural pesticides and where they go? 8 THE USUAL SUSPECTS What can we really say about the effects that all the chemicals we use have on Australian Frogs? 9 – Pesticides 9 Organochlorines 9 Organophosphates 9 Carbamates 9 – Herbicides and fungicides 9 – Surfactants 10 – Additives 10 – Endocrine disrupting chemicals 10 – Fertilisers 10 – Combinations 10 – Metabolites 11 TAKING ACTION Where can I find out about these chemicals? 11 So what can you do? 12 – What can you do with leftover hazardous household products or pesticides? 13 – Some alternative suggestions 13 1 FROGS AS ENVIRONMENTAL BAROMETERS What is a pollutant? Australian frogs Pollutants are potentially harmful, Australia really is a lucky country – we have and sometimes lethal. It’s easy to think of more than 210 species of frogs! What is more, chemicals such as pesticides, detergents, because Australia has been isolated from industrial chemicals and so forth as pollutants. other land-masses for so long, our frog species Less obvious examples might be extremely are quite different from the species found high nitrogen or phosphorus levels in water in other countries. In Australia, we have due to fertiliser runoff and sewerage discharges, three main native frog families. They are the or sediment from cleared lands. Salinity and Myobatrachidae (or ground frogs), the Hylidae litter also cause pollution problems. (tree frogs), and the tropical Microhylidae. For the purposes of this booklet, our main emphasis is water-borne pollutants - those readily identifiable culprits such as pesticides, household detergents, assorted chemicals, and fertilisers. Pesticides are substances (or mixtures of substances) that are intended to prevent, kill, or repel a particular pest. ‘Pests’ are species that we want to get rid of, for any number of reasons. Pests can include insects, mice and other animals, unwanted plants (weeds), fungi, or microorganisms like bacteria and viruses. The term ‘pesticide’ therefore also includes herbicides and fungicides. Unfortunately, most pesticides have some risk of harm to non-pest species precisely because they are designed to be harmful. Of course, many things can be toxic in high enough amounts, even caffeine and parsley, but such high amounts are very unlikely to occur. Problems arise when the amounts we use regularly are directly harmful, or accumulate to harmful concentrations in nature. 2 How do frogs interact with Ecological position Why is environmental their environment? Frogs are important components of many pollution a frog issue? ecological communities, consuming vast Life stages amounts of invertebrates and, in turn, providing The skin of a frog is very permeable. The Frogs generally start their life cycle as eggs an abundant food source for many other tadpole stage also relies on gills for breathing. encased in jelly capsules. Depending on the predators, such as birds and snakes. Both of these physiological characteristics make species, the eggs develop on land or in water. frogs and tadpoles very susceptible to a number Frogs and pollutants in the food chain They gradually turn into tadpoles, hatch, and of contaminants, which often easily penetrate If pollutants affect frogs, this can then have become free-swimming. Tadpoles breathe via exposed surfaces such as gills and skin. carry-on effects on the ecological community. gills, like fish. They continue to grow until they Pollutants that may not be easily excreted Consequently, because frogs inhabit water and reach a certain stage, when a complex hormonal or broken down by the body, can accumulate in land, they may have more opportunities to be process kicks in that changes them into frogs. body tissues. This is known as ‘bioaccumulation’. exposed to environmental contaminants than This is called ‘metamorphosis’, and it is really When these animals or insects are then many other animals. Frogs also have more ways quite remarkable. When they crawl out onto consumed by another animal, the toxins in the of being exposed than other animals, because land, the frogs are then mostly terrestrial and prey can then accumulate in the predator’s they have gills as tadpoles and a very permeable breathe via their skin and the back of their body. This process is called ‘biomagnification’. skin as an adult. throat. Frogs have an essentially "naked" egg After eating a few contaminated prey items, (it doesn’t have a shell) and, along with other Frog limb abnormalities have been proposed the concentrations of toxins in the body of amphibians such as salamanders and caecilians as a possible indicator of environmental top predators can become extremely high. (neither of which are native to Australia), are the abnormalities, particularly in agricultural areas. Frogs can bioaccumulate toxins by ingesting only vertebrate group that has both an aquatic However, deformed frogs are rare in Australia. contaminated insects and also through direct and terrestrial phase. exposure to pollutants, particularly in the water. Are frogs more sensitive to environmental Habitat requirements When frogs are killed by these pollutants, either pollutants than other species? Frogs need an environment that is moist, directly, or because the pollutants make them Yes and no. In some situations, and for some because they ‘drink’ and breathe through very sick and unable to escape a predator, then toxins, frogs may be particularly susceptible their skin. Most species lay their eggs in water, this causes problems all the way up the food to contamination. For example, the insecticide so the availability of water is essential. Some chain. Frogs, with their toxic payload, may make endosulfan is ten times more toxic to Rana frogs have evolved to take advantage of the animals that eat them very sick. With fewer tadpoles than to catfish or damselfly nymphs. temporary pools of water that are created frogs to eat insects, there are ecological We rarely test the effects various contaminants by heavy rain. Others lay their eggs in rivers, problems down the food chain as well. have on adult frogs so in many cases, we and yet others congregate around permanent simply don’t know how sensitive they are. ponds and streams. Unfortunately, there is not enough research to provide a definitive answer to this question for most frog species. 3 WHAT WE DO AND DON’T KNOW Why don’t we have all Where do pollutants Who produces pollutants? the answers? come from? The list of who produces pollutants is We are blessed with lots of frog species, Outside of natural disasters, almost all enormous because many things that we use in but environmental toxicology is a relatively new pollutants are the result of human activities, day to day life either cause pollution while being field here in Australia. The majority of aquatic whether created directly, or as by-products manufactured, or become a pollutant when toxicological testing usually focuses on species of production processes. we finish with them. such as fish, shrimp, and invertebrates. Take, for example, most peoples’ morning routine. How applicable are studies on fish and How many chemicals do we use here in Australia? You get out of bed. If it’s a wooden invertebrates to frogs? Good question!! bed, the wood has usually been treated with Generalisations are hard to make because a For a start, there are over 40,000 industrial preservatives and anti-fungal agents, perhaps frog’s sensitivity also varies according to the chemicals listed by regulatory authorities, and sealed with a varnish. Many of these treatment specific toxin tested. For example, we know that over 4,500 agricultural and 3,000 veterinary processes discharge waste water, not to frogs do not react to mercury the same way fish products registered for use in Australia. Do we mention the initial process to produce the do. Consequently, we cannot assume that frogs know the effects that each of these chemicals preservatives and varnishes, all of which are will react the same way as other animals – or have? Frogs are not a standard test species, so likely to be toxic to frogs in variable amounts.