DOCSLIB.ORG

Post-Medieval Poverty: an Integrated Investigation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Post-Medieval Poverty: an Integrated Investigation Post-medieval Poverty: An Integrated Investigation Keri Elizabeth Rowsell PhD University of York Archaeology September 2018 Abstract This study stemmed from our contested state of knowledge regarding under- and malnutrition in long-18th century England. The project aims to connect environment, nutrition and health, through the combined approach of osteological, biomolecular and historical research methods, and was motivated by three main research questions: (1) Is the potential scurvy biomarker identified during earlier work a true marker for scurvy in Human Skeletal Remains (HSR)? (2) Can we track potato consumption (a good source of Vitamin C) during this period through evidence of potato starch granules in human dental calculus? (3) Can we use a combination of HSR and historical documentary evidence to trace dietary and social change? A variety of different methods for extracting collagen from HSR were systematically tested, and a new technique has subsequently been established. This was applied to HSR from five post- medieval sites. These extractions - along with those of control samples - were run using MALDI-TOF-MS, and the resulting data analysed to a level of detail that has not previously been carried out, in the search for a scurvy biomarker. These analyses ruled out the potential biomarker, but revealed information that may help with the biomolecular identification of scurvy in the future. Dental calculus samples from individuals buried at one of the sites included here were analysed using light microscopy, but this element of the project was terminated as the data that could be produced was of limited use to the central research questions. Historical documentary evidence related to the sites included here has revealed the complexity of the factors influencing burial ground demographics. All five sites were identified by archaeologists as being linked to ‘poverty’, but this is an oversimplification when historical debate is taken into account. Throughout, this project evidences the benefits of a wider adoption of interdisciplinary approaches to historical research questions. 2 List of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................. 2 List of Contents ................................................................................................. 3 List of Tables ..................................................................................................... 6 List of Figures ................................................................................................... 7 Acknowledgements ......................................................................................... 12 Declaration ...................................................................................................... 14 Chapter One: Introduction ........................................................................... 15 Background to the Project .................................................................................... 15 Outline of the Project ............................................................................................ 17 Aims and Objectives ........................................................................................... 17 The Relevance and Importance of the Project .................................................... 19 Thesis Structure ................................................................................................... 20 Chapter Two: Research Context - Methods of Extraction ......................... 23 The Structure of Collagen ..................................................................................... 23 The Role of Vitamin C in Collagen Synthesis and Proline Hydroxylation ...... 26 Bone Turnover Rates of Collagen ........................................................................ 27 A Brief History of Collagen Extraction from Archaeological Bone ................. 30 The Future of Collagen Extraction from Archaeological Bone ........................ 33 Collagen Extraction in Relation to the Study of Scurvy .................................... 35 Discussion & Conclusions ..................................................................................... 37 Chapter Three: Systematic Method Development ...................................... 39 Phase One ............................................................................................................... 41 Materials .............................................................................................................. 41 Methods ............................................................................................................... 42 Results & Discussion .......................................................................................... 47 Phase Two ............................................................................................................... 51 Materials .............................................................................................................. 51 Chemicals and Equipment ................................................................................... 53 Methods ............................................................................................................... 54 Results & Discussion .......................................................................................... 56 Chapter Conclusions ............................................................................................. 58 Chapter Four: Research Context - Diet and Scurvy in England ............... 61 Diet .......................................................................................................................... 62 Nutrition and its Effects on Health ...................................................................... 62 The McKeown Debate ........................................................................................ 63 Percentage of Household Budget Spent on Food ................................................ 67 Access to Food Outside of the Cash Economy ................................................... 68 Potato Consumption ............................................................................................ 71 Optimists vs. Pessimists in the History of Diet ................................................... 73 Scurvy ..................................................................................................................... 77 Writing the History of a Disease ......................................................................... 77 What do we mean by ‘scurvy’? ........................................................................... 79 Scurvy in the Bills of Mortality ........................................................................... 79 Antiscorbutic Remedies in Long Eighteenth Century England .......................... 81 3 General Historical Focus of Scurvy Studies in England ..................................... 83 Land Scurvy in England During the Long-Eighteenth Century .......................... 85 Palaeopathology of Scurvy .................................................................................. 86 A Lack of (Land) Scurvy in the Archaeological and Historical Records ........... 89 Scurvy from a Biomolecular Perspective ............................................................ 92 Discussion and Conclusions .................................................................................. 93 Chapter Five: Research Context - the Site Backgrounds ........................... 95 Introduction ........................................................................................................... 95 Comparing Demographics at the Different Sites ................................................ 98 Age ...................................................................................................................... 98 Sex ..................................................................................................................... 101 Palaeopathology – Scurvy ................................................................................. 109 Research Contexts of the Five Sites ................................................................... 113 St Thomas’ Hospital .......................................................................................... 115 Farringdon St Bride’s Lower ............................................................................. 121 Cross Bones ....................................................................................................... 126 Bow Baptists ..................................................................................................... 133 Priory Yard, Norwich ........................................................................................ 138 Conclusions ........................................................................................................... 146 Chapter Six: The Search for a Scurvy Biomarker .................................... 148 Establishing the Peptide Possibilities ................................................................. 149 Filtering the Peptide List .................................................................................... 152 Applying the Peptide List to Archaeological Data ........................................... 153 LC-MS/MS Analysis - Round One ..................................................................... 161 Eppendorfs vs Falcon Tubes ..............................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Halloween of Cross Bones Festival of 2007, the Role of the Graveyard Gates and the Monthly Vigils That Take Place There
    Honouring The Outcast Dead: The Cross Bones Graveyard Presented at the 'Interfaith & Social Change: Engagements from the Margins' conference, Winchester University (September 2010) by Dr Adrian Harris. Abstract This paper explores the emergence of a unique 'sacred site' in south London; the Cross Bones graveyard. Cross Bones is an unconsecrated graveyard dating from medieval times which was primarily used to bury the prostitutes who were excluded from Christian burial. Archaeological excavations in the 1990's removed 148 skeletons and estimated that some 15,000 bodies remain buried there. Soon after the excavations began, John Constable, a London Pagan, began to hear "an unquiet spirit whispering in [his] ear" who inspired him to write a series of poems and plays which were later published as 'The Southwark Mysteries ' (Constable, 1999). 'The Southwark Mysteries' in turn inspired the first Cross Bones Halloween festival in 1998, and the date has been celebrated every year since, to honour "the outcast dead" with candles and songs. Although the biggest celebration is at Halloween, people gather at the gates on the 23rd of every month for a simple ritual to honour the ancestors and the spirit of place. Offerings left at the site are often very personal and include ribbons, flowers, dolls, candles in jars, small toys, pieces of wood, beads and myriad objects made sacred by intent. Although many of those involved identify as Pagans, the site itself is acknowledged as Christian. Most - if not all - of those buried there would have identified as Christians and the only iconography in the graveyard itself is a statue of the Madonna.
    [Show full text]
  • Death, Time and Commerce: Innovation and Conservatism in Styles of Funerary Material Culture in 18Th-19Th Century London
    Death, Time and Commerce: innovation and conservatism in styles of funerary material culture in 18th-19th century London Sarah Ann Essex Hoile UCL Thesis submitted for the degree of PhD Declaration I, Sarah Ann Essex Hoile confirm that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Where information has been derived from other sources, I confirm that this has been indicated in the thesis. Signature: Date: 2 Abstract This thesis explores the development of coffin furniture, the inscribed plates and other metal objects used to decorate coffins, in eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century London. It analyses this material within funerary and non-funerary contexts, and contrasts and compares its styles, production, use and contemporary significance with those of monuments and mourning jewellery. Over 1200 coffin plates were recorded for this study, dated 1740 to 1853, consisting of assemblages from the vaults of St Marylebone Church and St Bride’s Church and the lead coffin plates from Islington Green burial ground, all sites in central London. The production, trade and consumption of coffin furniture are discussed in Chapter 3. Chapter 4 investigates coffin furniture as a central component of the furnished coffin and examines its role within the performance of the funeral. Multiple aspects of the inscriptions and designs of coffin plates are analysed in Chapter 5 to establish aspects of change and continuity with this material. In Chapter 6 contemporary trends in monuments are assessed, drawing on a sample recorded in churches and a burial ground, and the production and use of this above-ground funerary material culture are considered.
    [Show full text]
  • Winter 2014 Newsletter
    Chiltern District Welsh Society Winter Newsletter 2014 Written By Maldwyn Pugh Chairman’s Report London Walk - 26th July 2014 Well, we’ve had a very successful six months. We’ve welcomed yet more new members: we’ve held a diverse range of events, all of which have been well attended and enjoyed. If that sounds familiar it is because: (1) the Society continues to thrive; and (2) it becomes difficult to find new words to describe a thriving Society! A small group of members met our guide Caroline James, at the foot of The Shard on a A pleasant and informative walk around the sunny Saturday in June to explore sites South Bank; yet another enjoyable and sunny around Southwark. golf day; five days based in Swansea during which we saw barely a drop of rain (!); the The area is at the wonderful sound of the massed choirs at the southern end of Albert Hall: and that was just in a few London Bridge which months! in medieval times was closed at night. I don’t have the gift of words possessed by our most recent speaker, the poet Professor Many inns were built Tony Curtis, so I’m going to let the reports there and thrived as themselves do the talking. staging posts for travellers. Theatres We have a lot to look forward to, and I hope opened there as did our 2015 events prove as successful and hospitals for the popular as those of 2014 – not forgetting that poor, sick, incurables, and homeless. Bear we have one of our favourite events of the baiting, prostitution, and similar activities year – the Christmas Drinks party - still to which were come! illegal in the City flourished.
    [Show full text]
  • History of the Colony of New Haven
    KJ5W H AVEN and its VICINITY Con. HISTORY COLONYF O NEW HAVEN, BEFOREND A AFTF.R THE U NION WITH CONNECTICUT. CONTAINING A P ARTICULAR DESCRIPTION OFHE T TOWNS WHICH COMPOSED THAT GOVERNMENT, VIZ., WEW H AVEN, / B RADFORD, ts iTIILFOKD, , STA n roiti», A CUILFORD, SOUTHOLD, I ,. I. WITH A N OTICE OF TIIE TOWNS WHICH HAVE BEEN SET OFF FROM "HE T ORIGINAL SIX." fillustrateb 6 n .fffttn NEW H AVEN: PRINTED AND PUBLISHED BY HITCHCOCK & STAFFORD. 1838. ENTERED, A ccording to Act of Congress, in the year 1838, BY E DWARD R. LAMBERT, In the Clerk's Office of the District Court of Connecticut. PREFACE. AUTHENTIC h istory is of high importance. It exhibits the juris prudence, science, morals, and religion of nations, and while it •warns to shun their errors, holds forth their virtues for imitation in bold relief. But where is the history more interesting and important than that of our own, "our much loved native land," that abounds in incidents more romantic, or narrative more thrilling? Buta little more than two centuries have elapsed since the first band of the " Puritan Fathers" left their native home, crossed the wild Atlantic, landed on the snow-clad rock of Plymouth, and laid the first foundation stone of New England. Within this period a change has here taken place, and in our common counfry unparalleled in the history of mankind. A great and powerful nation has arisen. The desert has been made " to bud and blossom as the rose." And •what but the sword of civil discord can arrest the giant march of improvement, (yet advancing with accelerating rapidity,) till " the noblest empire iu the reign of time" shall extend from the Atlantic to the Pacific wave.
    [Show full text]
  • Minutes of the Treasure Valuation Committee Meeting – 2Nd June 2011
    Minutes of the Treasure Valuation Committee Meeting – 2nd June 2011 The meeting was held in the Hartwell Room at the British Museum on Thursday, 2nd June 2011 at 11am. Present Committee: Other: Colin Renfrew (Chair) Caroline Barton (BM) Trevor Austin Roger Bland (BM) Ian Carradice Janina Parol (BM) John Cherry Ian Richardson (BM) Peter Clayton Kathryn Barrett (DCMS) David Dykes Helen Loughlin (DCMS) Tim Pestell Item 1: Lord Renfrew explained that he was honoured to be assuming the position of Chairman of the TVC, and led the Committee in noting its thanks to the former Chairman Norman Palmer for his many years of excellent service on the Committee. The Secretariat was asked to write a letter to Norman Palmer to that effect. Item 2: Minutes of the meeting of Friday 5th May 2011 The Minutes of the meeting were formally adopted as a true record. Item 3: Objects Roman artefacts 1. Roman silver finger-ring fragment from Crosby Ravensworth, Cumbria (2010 T765) The provisional valuer suggested £18-£20. The Committee inspected the item in light of this and felt that the fragment possessed less by way of attraction than had been accounted for in Ms ’s suggestion. The Committee recommended £10. Penrith and Eden Museum hopes to acquire. 2. Roman silver finger-ring from Crosby Ravensworth, Cumbria (2010 T766) The provisional valuer suggested £90-£110. The Committee examined the finger-ring in light of this and commented on the absence of the intaglio and evidence of heavy wear, which detracted from the ring’s appeal. On balance it was felt that the suggested range was slightly high, and the Committee recommended £70.
    [Show full text]
  • A Legal Examination of Prostitution in Late Medieval Greater London Lauren Marie Martiere Clemson University, [email protected]
    Clemson University TigerPrints All Theses Theses 5-2016 'Ill-Liver of Her Body:' A Legal Examination of Prostitution in Late Medieval Greater London Lauren Marie Martiere Clemson University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://tigerprints.clemson.edu/all_theses Recommended Citation Martiere, Lauren Marie, "'Ill-Liver of Her Body:' A Legal Examination of Prostitution in Late Medieval Greater London" (2016). All Theses. 2333. https://tigerprints.clemson.edu/all_theses/2333 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses at TigerPrints. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Theses by an authorized administrator of TigerPrints. For more information, please contact [email protected]. “ILL-LIVER OF HER BODY:” A LEGAL EXAMINATION OF PROSTITUTION IN LATE MEDIEVAL GREATER LONDON A Thesis Presented to the Graduate School of Clemson University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts History by Lauren Marie Martiere May 2016 Accepted by: Dr. Caroline Dunn, Committee Chair Dr. Lee Wilson Dr. Emily Wood ABSTRACT The following study endeavors to synthesize and enhance knowledge of what has previously been an under-represented field in the study of English medieval prostitution. It examines a variety of primary sources documenting the laws, punishments, and regulations concerning sexual commerce and reaches conclusions about the marginalization of prostitutes and the diverging systems of prostitution control implemented in the City of London and the Bishop of Winchester’s manor in Southwark. First, women, especially prostitutes, were marginalized in medieval English society. The prostitutes' inability to play an active role in either the secular or religious life of English communities cemented their position as outsiders.
    [Show full text]
  • Draft Agenda for the Archaeological Study of Historic Burials in Greater London
    A DRAFT AGENDA FOR THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL STUDY OF HISTORIC BURIALS IN GREATER LONDON Allen Archaeology Limited Report number: 2015083 Prepared for Historic England June 2015 Contents ­ 1.0 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 4 ­ 2.0 Proposed research themes ........................................................................................................... 4 ­ Environment and health (M3, L2, L4) ................................................................................................... 6 ­ The impact of urbanisation .............................................................................................................. 6 ­ Responding to catastrophe .............................................................................................................. 7 ­ The evolution disease (M3, M5) ........................................................................................................... 8 ­ Defining the Black Death .................................................................................................................. 8 ­ The origins and development of syphilis .......................................................................................... 9 ­ Revealing invisible diseases ............................................................................................................ 10 ­ Emerging and declining diseases ...................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter April 2020 Friends of Highgate Cemetery Trust Contents
    NEWSLETTER APRIL 2020 FRIENDS OF HIGHGATE CEMETERY TRUST CONTENTS President Editor Chair’s note ....................................3 The Lord Palumbo of Walbrook Ian Dungavell A mother’s sacrifice .......................4 Vice Presidents With thanks to A garden of remembrance for the Derek Barratt Martin Adeney, Frank Cano, John outcast dead ..................................6 Ian Kelly Constable, James Stevens Curl, John Murray Victor Herman, Russ Howells, Penny An unfortunate end for the largest Linnett, Katy Nicholls, Robin Oakley, airplane in the world ......................8 Chair Stuart Orr, Nick Powell, Max Reeves, The Loudon and cemeteries ....... 10 Martin Adeney John Shepperd. The lost Dickens .......................... 12 Trustees The August 2020 issue will The new Cedar of Lebanon .......... 13 Doreen Aislabie be posted on 17 July 2020. Katy Baldwin Contributions are due by 11 June News roundup .............................. 14 April Cameron 2020. Charles Essex Historic cemeteries news............ 16 Nicola Jones Registered Office Steve Kennard Highgate Cemetery Lucy Lelliott Swain’s Lane, London N6 6PJ Stuart Orr Telephone 020 8340 1834 Teresa Sladen Web www.highgatecemetery.org Nigel Thorne Eve Wilder Company Number 3157806 Charity Number 1058392 Protectors Dr Tye Blackshaw Richard Morris Philip Williams Staff Dr Ian Dungavell FSA Chief Executive Frank Cano Head Gardener Justin Bickersteth Registrar Claire Freston Deputy Head Judith Etherton Archivist Gardener Nikki Druce Volunteering Manager Gardeners Victor Herman Sexton Zurab Gogidze Sally Kay Bookkeeper & Membership Adam Howe Nick Powell Visitor Experience Przemyslaw Talaga Manager Lucy Thompson Operations Manager Cover photograph The grieving widow on a memorial near Comforts’ Corner in Highgate Cemetery West. 2 Highgate Cemetery Newsletter Chair’s note First of all a big thank you.
    [Show full text]
  • Teaching Emotive and Controversial History 3-19
    Teaching Emotive and Controversial History 3-19 A Report from The Historical Association on the Challenges and Opportunities for Teaching Emotive and Controversial History 3-19 A Report from The Historical Association on the Challenges and Opportunities for Teaching Emotive and Controversial History 3-19 Contents Page 1 An introduction providing 3 context and definition An executive summary of the 4 key findings and recommendations 3 The current context with the scope of 7 addressing the teaching of emotive and controversial issues generally across the 3–19 age range and specifically at each key stage 4 The current constraints that inhibit 14 the teaching and learning of emotive and controversial history 5 The key characteristics and examples 19 of effective practice with regard to teaching and learning with a case study for each key stage 6 Four case studies from experts on 37 the latest historical thinking and issues related to areas of controversy 7 Recommendations for developing 41 practice; some are short term and others longer term, some primarily aimed at teachers and schools, and others aimed at other stakeholders 8 Acknowledgements 46 Teaching emotive and controversial history 3-19 The Historical Association Introduction 1 This publication is the result of research carried out by There was also an acceptance that emotion, sensitivity The Historical Association and supported by a grant from and controversy can be affected by time, geography and the Department for Education and Skills. The project awareness. For example, an issue or person could have has been entitled T.E.A.C.H. (Teaching Emotive and been extremely emotive and controversial at the time, Controversial History) and covers the 3–19 age range.
    [Show full text]
  • The Outcast Dead, by Paul Slade
    The Outcast Dead, by Paul Slade. © Paul Slade 2013, all rights reserved. This book first appeared on http://www.PlanetSlade.com. The Outcast Dead by Paul Slade Contents Introduction 2 Chapter 1: The Romans 4 Chapter 2: Arriving at the vigil 7 Chapter 3: Laying siege 10 Chapter 4: Samhain at the gates 12 Chapter 5: Birth of the Liberty 15 Chapter 6: Emily’s plaque 23 Chapter 7: The Black Death 27 Chapter 8: The Invisible Gardener 34 Chapter 9: Farewell to the stews 38 Chapter 10: The Southwark Mysteries 43 Chapter 11: Bardic Bankside 45 Chapter 12: Going underground 51 Chapter 13: Puritans and plagues 56 Chapter 14: Crossbones Girl 61 Chapter 15: The stink industries 64 Chapter 16: Say my name 66 Chapter 17: Resurrection men 69 Chapter 18: John Crow’s megaphone 75 Chapter 19: Seeking closure 78 Chapter 20: What happens next? 89 Appendices 92 Sources & footnotes 117 © Paul Slade, 2013, all rights reserved. This book first appeared on www.PlanetSlade.com. 1 The Outcast Dead, by Paul Slade. © Paul Slade 2013, all rights reserved. This book first appeared on http://www.PlanetSlade.com. Introduction “I have heard ancient men of good credit report that these single women were forbidden the rites of the church so long as they continued their sinful life and were excluded from Christian burial. And therefore, there was a plot of ground, called the single woman’s churchyard, appointed for them far from the parish church.” - John Stow’s Survey of London, 1598. “Sleep well, you winged spirits of intimate joy.” - Note taped to Cross Bone’s fence, 2011.
    [Show full text]
  • Interpersonal Violence and Fracture Patterns in 18Th- and 19Th-Century London
    Interpersonal violence and fracture patterns in 18th- and 19th-century London Sarah Lockyer A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of Bournemouth University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2013 Bournemouth University Copyright Statement This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognise that its copyright rests with its author and due acknowledgement must always be made of the use of any material contained in, or derived from, this thesis. 2 Abstract Sarah Lockyer Interpersonal violence and fracture patterns in 18th- and 19th-century London Violent behaviour can be seen all over the world and across time; it is also intrinsically linked to culture. As such, the analysis of skeletal material presents excellent physical evidence of violent occurrences within communities. The current thesis looks to understand the possible presence of fracture patterns and interpersonal violence in London during the 18th and 19th centuries by analysing the fracture patterns observed on six skeletal collections from the geographical area and characterised by various social and economic contexts. The contextualisation of each burial ground proved to be imperative to the research. The statistical results revealed that grouping collections together based on their socioeconomic status does not describe nor explain the fracture patterns seen in the collections considering that some did not emulate the characterisation implemented upon them by the media or City officials at the time. It also was found that the patrilineal society and the subsequent sexual division of labour had a profound effect on the results especially when comparing the prevalence of fractures between men and women.
    [Show full text]
  • LHS 2 Book.Indb 1 21/02/2012 08:24:06 First Published 2012
    Books Survival Copyright LONDON’S HIDDEN SECRETS VOLUME 2 Discover More of the City’s Amazing Secret Places Books Graeme Chesters & David Hampshire Survival Copyright Survival Books • Bath • England LHS 2 Book.indb 1 21/02/2012 08:24:06 First published 2012 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or recorded by any means, without prior written permission from the publisher. Copyright © Survival Books 2012 Cover design: Di Bruce-Kidman Cover photo: The Gherkin (Wikipedia)Books Maps © Jim Watson Survival Books Limited Office 169, 3 Edgar Buildings George Street, Bath BA1 2FJ, United Kingdom +44 (0)1935-700060 [email protected] www.survivalbooks.net Copyright British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A CIP record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN: 978-1-907339-79-0 Printed in Singapore by International Press Softcom Limited LHS 2 Book.indb 2 21/02/2012 08:24:17 Acknowledgements e’ve been the fortunate recipients of much help, support and W enthusiasm in researching and writing this book. In addition to the many photographers (see page 318) who provided images, we would like to heartily thank the following, in no particular order: Stephen Freeth (Vintners’ Company), Lisa Miller (RGS), Robert Waite (Bruce Castle), Helen Walker (Pitzhanger Manor), Jacob Moss (Fan Museum), Karen Johnson (English Heritage), Vanda Foster (Gunnersbury Park Museum), Mark de Novellis (Orleans House Gallery), Vicky Carroll (William Morris Gallery), Julia Walton (Harrow
    [Show full text]