DOCSLIB.ORG

Competitive Gaming

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Competitive Gaming WORCESTER POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE Competitive Gaming Design and Community Building Interactive Qualifying Project Stefan Alexander and Maxwell Perlman Advisor: Brian Moriarty, IMGD 3/6/2014 Abstract This project attempts to characterize the qualities that make a competitive game successful. By researching the relevant literature and conducting original interviews with designers, players, and other people associated with the gaming scene, we identified three important development principles: 1. Competitive games should be designed for casual play and balanced for competitive play. Nearly every successful competitive game has far more casual players than it does competitive players. Players should want to play your game regardless of any fame or prize support they could gain from playing it competitively. 2. Understanding who your players are and what they want, both in terms of game content and what they want to gain mentally or emotionally from playing the game, can greatly assist in the design of competitive games. When a player gets to use a strategy they enjoy at a high level of play, the game becomes far more enjoyable. 3. A competitive game is defined by its community. When the community is open, accepting, friendly, and helpful, it reflects well on the game and leads to thriving casual and competitive communities. Communities are also vital to the evolution of their players’ skills. Without a supportive and helpful community, players in that community will have a much harder time being successful than if they were a member of a more supportive and caring community. Table of Contents Introduction and Background .............................................................................................. 1 Examples ............................................................................................................................ 1 Statistics ............................................................................................................................ 1 Introducing the Interviewed People .................................................................................... 3 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 3 Qualities of Competitive Games .......................................................................................... 6 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 6 Game Depth ....................................................................................................................... 6 Skill .................................................................................................................................... 7 Evolving ............................................................................................................................. 7 Lenticular Design .............................................................................................................. 9 Fun ..................................................................................................................................... 9 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 10 Defining Metagame and Balancing a Game ...................................................................... 11 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 11 Metagame .......................................................................................................................... 11 Metagaming ...................................................................................................................... 11 When a metagame breaks down… ................................................................................. 13 Balancing Your Game ...................................................................................................... 17 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 17 Randomness in Competitive Games .................................................................................. 18 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 18 Types of Luck ................................................................................................................... 19 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 20 Understanding Your Audience ........................................................................................... 21 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 21 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 24 Building Your Community .................................................................................................. 25 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 25 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 30 The Player’s Perspective..................................................................................................... 31 Q. How would you describe your job/hobby to a non-gamer? ....................................... 31 Q. Why are competitive games this popular worldwide? ............................................. 32 Q. What are the main qualities that make a competitive game? ................................ 33 Q. What about the prize money when playing competitive games? ............................ 34 Q. How would you describe the term “metagame”? ...................................................... 35 Competitive Game Spectators ............................................................................................ 37 Social Media in Competitive Games .............................................................................. 37 The Importance of Spectators ......................................................................................... 38 Demonstration of How a Game is Played Competitively ................................................. 41 The Different Types of Players ....................................................................................... 41 To Become the Master of Rhythm Games...................................................................... 43 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................... 47 Interview Transcripts ......................................................................................................... 48 T1. Interview with Daniel Maniago ............................................................................... 48 T2. Interview with David Sirlin ..................................................................................... 52 T3. Interview with Holon ................................................................................................ 72 T4. Interview with Kevin Landon .................................................................................. 76 T5. Interview with kurOa ............................................................................................... 79 T6. Interview with nazomen ........................................................................................... 83 T7. Interview with Nick Ranish ..................................................................................... 87 T8. Interview with Reid Duke ........................................................................................ 91 T9. Interview with Rich Hagon ...................................................................................... 95 T10. Interview with Zac Hill ......................................................................................... 113 T11. Interview with Zvi Mowshowitz ........................................................................... 121 Japanese Interview Transcripts without Translation .................................................... 144 T12. Interview with Holon ............................................................................................ 144 T13. Interview with kurOa ........................................................................................... 147 T14. Interview with nazomen ....................................................................................... 151 Works Cited ....................................................................................................................... 154 Resources ........................................................................................................................... 159 Introduction and Background Examples When writing about competitive games, we refer to a broad range of titles including RTS (Real-Time Strategy) games such as StarCraft/StarCraft II; other MMO games such as League of Legends (LoL) and Defense of the Ancients (Dota/Dota II); card games such as Magic: The Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh!; fighting games such as Super Smash Brothers (Melee, Brawl,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Will to Keep Winning Download Free (EPUB, PDF)
    The Will To Keep Winning Download Free (EPUB, PDF) "No matter what your life plan is, no matter what your project, a close reading of the life and thoughts of Daigo will give you deep insight into how to be successful and help you reach your goals."—Frank Lantz, Director, NYU Game Center"When Daigo wins, he does not simply elevate his own status, he elevates the entire genre alongside him. Through his play, and through his approach to life, Daigo changes the way people think about the game, and inspires even his enemies to new heights. This is what separates a mere winner from an all-time great."—Seth Killian, Lead Game Designer at Riot Games"Daigo and I started an international journey to showcase Street Fighter competition in 1998. Today, he is the Grand Master of fighting games and true inspiration to players worldwide.â€â€”Alex Valle, CaliPower, Mr. Street Fighter“It’s almost impossible to overstate the significance of The Beast for the practice and culture of gaming; as Bruce Lee was for the Martial Arts, so Daigo Umehara is for Fighting Games.â€â€”Prof. Chris Goto-Jones, Professor of Comparative Philosophy & Political Thought, Leiden University"I’m a professional fighting gamer. I was first crowned World Champion at seventeen in 1998, and I was recognized as “the most successful player in major tournaments of Street Fighter†by Guinness World Records in August 2010.This is my chance to tell you how I became World Champion and share insights as only a multiple time World Champion can.
    [Show full text]
  • Optic Gaming Wins Call of Duty® MLG Orlando Open
    August 8, 2016 Optic Gaming Wins Call of Duty® MLG Orlando Open NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- The road to the 2016 Call of Duty® World League Championship, Presented by PlayStation® 4 finished its last live qualifying competition yesterday with an epic showdown in Orlando as Optic Gaming won the Call of Duty® MLG Orlando Open. Yesterday's finals completed a thrilling weekend of competition, as eager fans in attendance, online at MLG.tv and other livestreams, and those tuning-in directly through an in-game (BOIII PS4) Live Event Viewer, watched 72 hours of compelling action. Optic Gaming took home the top prize after besting Team Envyus to be the top of more than 100 teams from around the world. Yesterday's exciting tournament also served as the final CWL Pro Points event of the season, as competition now moves to the North American online qualifier as the final stop before the highly anticipated CWL Championship at Call of Duty® XP. At the CWL Championship, 32 teams will play for their share of the biggest single event prize pool in Call of Duty® history, $2 million. With the growth of the Call of Duty World League, Call of Duty esports viewership has increased by more than five times year-over-year to 33 million views of the Stage 1 events this year. The Call of Duty World League Championships at Call of Duty XP is expected to be our most viewed Call of Duty esports event in history by a wide margin. After the dust settled, over 1.4 million cumulative viewers across distribution platforms, including MLG.tv, generated over 8 million video views during the event, consuming over 2 million hours of content throughout the weekend, and peaking at 164,000 concurrent viewers during the thrilling finals match.1 Here are the top eight teams from the Call of Duty MLG Orlando Open: Optic Gaming Team Envyus Team Elevate Faze Clan Rise Nation Luminosity Gaming Cloud9 Complexity Gaming On August 15, 2016, a live broadcast on youtube.com/callofduty will determine the grouping for all the qualified teams.
    [Show full text]
  • Game Design 2 Game Balance
    CE810 - Game Design 2 Game Balance Joseph Walton-Rivers & Piers Williams Friday, 18 May 2018 University of Essex 1 What is Balance? Game Balance Question What is balance? 2 Game Balance “All players have an equal chance of winning” – Richard Bartle Richard covered a combat example in the first part of the module. 3 On Strategies Game Balance • What about higher level strategies? • Zerg rush? • Dominant strategies • Metagaming 4 Metagaming - Rock Paper Scissors • A beats B, B beats C, C beats A • If there are lots of A players, people will play C • Then there are a lot of C players, so people play B • and so on... 5 Metagaming - Dominant Strategies • What if A is significantly stronger? • No one will use the other two strategies • We want to encourage variety in play 6 Can we detect this? • Can we detect strategies which are overpowered? • Try to punish strategies we don’t want to see • We did this earlier in the week with rotate and shoot! • Can we measure this? 7 Automated Game Tuning • Academics seem to think so... • Ryan Leigh et al (2008) - Co-evolution for game balancing • Alexander Jaffe et al (2012) - Restricted-Play balance framework • Mihail Morosan - GAs for tuning parameters 8 Game Curves First Move Advantage First Move Advantage • Typically affects turn based games • Going first in tac tac toe means either a win or adraw • White has > 50% win rate over all games • Worse effects if you have resources • We need a way of dealing with this 9 First Move Advantage Magic Second player gets an extra card Go Second player gets 7.5 bonus
    [Show full text]
  • Esports High Impact and Investable
    Needham Insights: Thought Leader Series Laura A. Martin, CFA & CMT – [email protected] / (917) 373-3066 September 5, 2019 Dan Medina – [email protected] / (626) 893-2925 eSports High Impact and Investable For the past decade, eSports has been growing on the main stage in Asia and in stealth mode in the US. This report addresses questions we get most often from investors about eSports: ➢ What is eSports? Definitions differ. Our definition of eSports is “players competing at a video game in front of a live audience while being live-streamed.” By implication, viewing, attendance, and playing time are linked, and each creates revenue streams for eSports. ➢ How big is eSports? Globally, one out of every three (ie, 33%) 18-25 year olds spent more than an hour a day playing video games, 395mm people watched eSports, and 250mm people played Fortnite in 2018. eSports revenue will be $1.1B in 2019, up 26% y/y. ➢ Should investors care about eSports? We would argue “yes”, owing to: a) global scale; b) time spent playing and viewing; c) compelling demographics; d) eSports vs traditional sports trends; e) revenue growth; and, f) sports betting should supercharge US eSports. ➢ Is eSports a fad? We would argue “no”, owing to: a) many US Universities now offer Varsity eSports scholarships; b) new special purpose eSports stadiums are proliferating; c) billionaires are investing to make eSports successful; d) audience growth; and, e) Olympics potential. ➢ Why have you never heard of eSports? Because zero of the top 30 earning players in the world were from the US in 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • Application of Retrograde Analysis on Fighting Games
    Application of Retrograde Analysis on Fighting Games Kristen Yu Nathan R. Sturtevant Computer Science Department Computer Science Department University of Denver University of Alberta Denver, USA Edmonton, Canada [email protected] [email protected] Abstract—With the advent of the fighting game AI competition, optimal AI. This work opens the door for deeper study of there has been recent interest in two-player fighting games. both optimal and suboptimal play, as well as options related Monte-Carlo Tree-Search approaches currently dominate the to game design, where the impact of design choices in a game competition, but it is unclear if this is the best approach for all fighting games. In this paper we study the design of two- can be studied. player fighting games and the consequences of the game design on the types of AI that should be used for playing the game, as II.R ELATED WORK well as formally define the state space that fighting games are A variety of approaches have been used for fighting game AI based on. Additionally, we also characterize how AI can solve the in both industry and academia. One approach in industry has game given a simultaneous action game model, to understand the characteristics of the solved AI and the impact it has on game game AI being built using N-grams as a prediction algorithm design. to help the AI become better at playing the game [30]. Another common technique is using decision trees to model I.I NTRODUCTION AI behavior [30]. This creates a rule set with which an agent can react to decisions that a player makes.
    [Show full text]
  • E-SPORTS Case Study
    E-SPORTS Case Study How E-Sports is a booming global industry ? c x c r u x . c o m INTRODUCTION Esports is a booming global industry where skilled video gamers play competitively. Contrary to common perception, Esports is not simply a phenomenon occurring in the basements of unemployed twentysomethings the industry is real, growing globally, and investable. In fact, over 380 million people watch esports worldwide both online and in person. More people watched the 2016 world finals of popular esports game League of Legends (43 million viewers) than the NBA Finals Game 7 that year (31 million viewers). www.cxcrux.com Page 2 WHICH ESPORTS GAMES ARE MOST POPULAR? Though the actual rankings of the most popular esports games change slightly month-to-month, the ten most-watched games on dominant streaming site Twitch remain consistent. As of right now, League of Legends remains the most-watched eSport in the world. It’s also worth noting, for those less familiar with esports, that the most popular games are not traditional sports-related video games such as Madden or FIFA. www.cxcrux.com Page 3 INVOLVED PARTIES PLAYERS Becoming a top Esports player is no simple achievement. To rise through the ranks, players specialize in a specific game, developing their skills through extensive, competitive play. Streaming: Gamers who Livestream themselves as they play video games are referred to as "streamers." This is typically done in casual play. While streaming can be incredibly profitable, many streamers have to decide whether they want to stream for a living or try and play professionally and run the risk of making less money.
    [Show full text]
  • Video Games and the Mobilization of Anxiety and Desire
    PLAYING THE CRISIS: VIDEO GAMES AND THE MOBILIZATION OF ANXIETY AND DESIRE BY ROBERT MEJIA DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Communications in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2012 Urbana, Illinois Doctoral Committee: Professor Kent A. Ono, Chair Professor John Nerone Professor Clifford Christians Professor Robert A. Brookey, Northern Illinois University ABSTRACT This is a critical cultural and political economic analysis of the video game as an engine of global anxiety and desire. Attempting to move beyond conventional studies of the video game as a thing-in-itself, relatively self-contained as a textual, ludic, or even technological (in the narrow sense of the word) phenomenon, I propose that gaming has come to operate as an epistemological imperative that extends beyond the site of gaming in itself. Play and pleasure have come to affect sites of culture and the structural formation of various populations beyond those conceived of as belonging to conventional gaming populations: the workplace, consumer experiences, education, warfare, and even the practice of politics itself, amongst other domains. Indeed, the central claim of this dissertation is that the video game operates with the same political and cultural gravity as that ascribed to the prison by Michel Foucault. That is, just as the prison operated as the discursive site wherein the disciplinary imaginary was honed, so too does digital play operate as that discursive site wherein the ludic imperative has emerged. To make this claim, I have had to move beyond the conventional theoretical frameworks utilized in the analysis of video games.
    [Show full text]
  • Consumer Motivation, Spectatorship Experience and the Degree of Overlap Between Traditional Sport and Esport.”
    COMPETITIVE SPORT IN WEB 2.0: CONSUMER MOTIVATION, SPECTATORSHIP EXPERIENCE, AND THE DEGREE OF OVERLAP BETWEEN TRADITIONAL SPORT AND ESPORT by JUE HOU ANDREW C. BILLINGS, COMMITTEE CHAIR CORY L. ARMSTRONG KENON A. BROWN JAMES D. LEEPER BRETT I. SHERRICK A DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Journalism and Creative Media in the Graduate School of The University of Alabama TUSCALOOSA, ALABAMA 2019 Copyright Jue Hou 2019 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ABSTRACT In the 21st Century, eSport has gradually come into public sight as a new form of competitive spectator event. This type of modern competitive video gaming resembles the field of traditional sport in multiple ways, including players, leagues, tournaments and corporate sponsorship, etc. Nevertheless, academic discussion regarding the current treatment, benefit, and risk of eSport are still ongoing. This research project examined the status quo of the rising eSport field. Based on a detailed introduction of competitive video gaming history as well as an in-depth analysis of factors that constitute a sport, this study redefined eSport as a unique form of video game competition. From the theoretical perspective of uses and gratifications, this project focused on how eSport is similar to, or different from, traditional sports in terms of spectator motivations. The current study incorporated a number of previously validated-scales in sport literature and generated two surveys, and got 536 and 530 respondents respectively. This study then utilized the data and constructed the motivation scale for eSport spectatorship consumption (MSESC) through structural equation modeling.
    [Show full text]
  • Fighting Games, Performativity, and Social Game Play a Dissertation
    The Art of War: Fighting Games, Performativity, and Social Game Play A dissertation presented to the faculty of the Scripps College of Communication of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy Todd L. Harper November 2010 © 2010 Todd L. Harper. All Rights Reserved. This dissertation titled The Art of War: Fighting Games, Performativity, and Social Game Play by TODD L. HARPER has been approved for the School of Media Arts and Studies and the Scripps College of Communication by Mia L. Consalvo Associate Professor of Media Arts and Studies Gregory J. Shepherd Dean, Scripps College of Communication ii ABSTRACT HARPER, TODD L., Ph.D., November 2010, Mass Communications The Art of War: Fighting Games, Performativity, and Social Game Play (244 pp.) Director of Dissertation: Mia L. Consalvo This dissertation draws on feminist theory – specifically, performance and performativity – to explore how digital game players construct the game experience and social play. Scholarship in game studies has established the formal aspects of a game as being a combination of its rules and the fiction or narrative that contextualizes those rules. The question remains, how do the ways people play games influence what makes up a game, and how those players understand themselves as players and as social actors through the gaming experience? Taking a qualitative approach, this study explored players of fighting games: competitive games of one-on-one combat. Specifically, it combined observations at the Evolution fighting game tournament in July, 2009 and in-depth interviews with fighting game enthusiasts. In addition, three groups of college students with varying histories and experiences with games were observed playing both competitive and cooperative games together.
    [Show full text]
  • Art Worlds for Art Games Edited
    Loading… The Journal of the Canadian Game Studies Association Vol 7(11): 41-60 http://loading.gamestudies.ca An Art World for Artgames Felan Parker York University [email protected] Abstract Drawing together the insights of game studies, aesthetics, and the sociology of art, this article examines the legitimation of ‘artgames’ as a category of indie games with particularly high cultural and artistic status. Passage (PC, Mac, Linux, iOS, 2007) serves as a case study, demonstrating how a diverse range of factors and processes, including a conducive ‘opportunity space’, changes in independent game production, distribution, and reception, and the emergence of a critical discourse, collectively produce an assemblage or ‘art world’ (Baumann, 2007a; 2007b) that constitutes artgames as legitimate art. Author Keywords Artgames; legitimation; art world; indie games; critical discourse; authorship; Passage; Rohrer Introduction The seemingly meteoric rise to widespread recognition of ‘indie’ digital games in recent years is the product of a much longer process made up of many diverse elements. It is generally accepted as a given that indie games now play an important role in the industry and culture of digital games, but just over a decade ago there was no such category in popular discourse – independent game production went by other names (freeware, shareware, amateur, bedroom) and took place in insular, autonomous communities of practice focused on particular game-creation tools or genres, with their own distribution networks, audiences, and systems of evaluation, only occasionally connected with a larger marketplace. Even five years ago, the idea of indie games was still burgeoning and becoming stable, and it is the historical moment around 2007 that I will address in this article.
    [Show full text]
  • Super Smash Bros. Melee: an Interdisciplinary Esports Ethnography
    "Melee is Broken": Super Smash Bros. Melee: An Interdisciplinary Esports Ethnography Abbie ·spoopy' Rappaport A Thesis In the Department of Humanities Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements F or the Degree of Master of Arts (Individualized Program) at Concordia University Montreal, Quebec, Canada May 2020 © Abbie 'spoopy' Rappaport, 2020 CONCORDIA UNN ERSITY School of Graduate Studies This is to ce1tify that the thesis prepared By: Abbie ''spoooopy' Rappaport Entitled: Mellee iis Brrokkeenn”":: Supperr Smassh Bros.. Melleee:: An Interrdiisscciipplliinnary Esporrttss Etthnography and submitted in prutial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Indiivviiddualized Mastterss (IINDI MA)) complies with the regulations of the University and meets the accepted standru·ds with respect to originality and quality. Signed by the final examining committee: Rachel Berger Chair Darrrren Werrsshllerr Examiner Barrtt Siimon Examiner Pipppin Barr Thesis Supervisor(s) Darren Wershlerr,, Bart Simon,, Piippppin Baarrrr Approved by Rachel Berger Chair of Department or Graduate Program Director Effrosyni Diamantoudi, Dean, Date iii Abstract "Melee is Broken": Super Smash Bros. Melee: An Interdisciplinary Esports Ethnography Abbie 'spoopy' Rappaport This work presents a qualitative analysis of the esports community that plays and watches Super Smash Bros. Melee (SSBM) , a platform-based fighting game released for the Nintendo GameCube in 2001. SSBM is unusual as an esport for the way that it is built on a grass-roots foundation shaped by players (rather than the game's developers) and is contingent on the continued use of residual media objects, specifically the CRT television, Nintendo GameCube and Wii console coupled with the restraints of analog signal processing. SSBM players show particular dedication to dominant community practices like strict tournament rules and settings, shared use of dialect/nomenclatures, mode of play and so on, which are derived from, embedded in, and reinforced by specific hardware and software objects.
    [Show full text]
  • Time War: Paul Virilio and the Potential Educational Impacts of Real-Time Strategy Videogames
    Philosophical Inquiry in Education, Volume 27 (2020), No. 1, pp. 46-61 Time War: Paul Virilio and the Potential Educational Impacts of Real-Time Strategy Videogames DAVID I. WADDINGTON Concordia University This essay explores the possibility that a particular type of video game—real-time strategy games—could have worrisome educational impacts. In order to make this case, I will develop a theoretical framework originally advanced by French social critic Paul Virilio. In two key texts, Speed and Politics (1977) and “The Aesthetics of Disappearance” (1984), Virilio maintains that society is becoming “dromocratic” – determined by and obsessed with speed. Extending Virilio’s analysis, I will argue that the frenetic, ruthless environment of real-time strategy games may promote an accelerated, hypermodern way of thinking about the world that focuses unduly on efficiency. Introduction Video games have been a subject of significant interest lately in education. A new wave of momentum began when James Paul Gee’s book, What Video Games Have to Teach Us About Learning and Literacy (2003a), was critically acclaimed, and was followed by a wave of optimistic studies and analyses. In 2010, a MacArthur Foundation report, The Civic Potential of Video Games, built on this energy, drawing on large-scale survey data to highlight the possibility that games that certain popular types of video games might promote civic engagement in the form of increased political participation and volunteerism. The hypothesis that video games, a perpetual parental bête-noire and the site of many a sex/violence media panic, might actually be educationally beneficial, has been gathering steam and is the preferred position of most educational researchers working in the field.
    [Show full text]