Cultural Resource Investigations Near White Crack, Island-In-The-Sky
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 I 29.86/3: 1 Cultural Resource Investigations Near White Crack, Island-in-the-Sky District, Canyonlands National Park, Utah PUBUC DOCUMENTS DEPOSITORY ITEM by JAN 15 1999 CLEMSON Betsy L. Tipps, Andre D. La Fond, and Robert I. yirnie library CULTURAL RESOURCE SELECTIONS No. 11 INTERMOUNTAIN REGION 1996 NATIONAL PARK SERVICE 30273-101 - REPORT DOCUMENTATION 1. REPORT NO. 3. Recipient * Accession No PAGE 411-02-9617 4. "Title and Subtitle 5. Report Data Cultural Resource Investigations Near White Crack, September 1996 Island-in-the Sky District, Canyonlands National Park, Utah 7. Authors) 8. Performing Organization Rapt. No. Betsy L. Tipps, Andre' D. La Fond, and Robert I. Birnie CRR 411-02-9617 ». Performing Organization Nam* and Address 10. Proi*ct/Te»k/Work Unit No. P-III Associates, Inc. 11. Contract(C) or Grant(G) 2759 South 300 West No. Salt Lake City, UT 84115 (O CX 1200-4-A063 (G) 12. Sponsoring Organization Name and Address 13. Type of Report A Period Covered National Park Service 1991-1996 Intermountain Regional Office Final Report 12795 West Alameda Parkway 14. Lakewood, CO 80225 IS. Supplementary Notes 16. Abstract (Limit: 200 words) This document is the final report of cultural resource inventory, limited testing, and collections research in the Island-in-the- Sky District, Canyonlands National Park, Utah. The area has a high site density that appears to be related to the presence of a major access route and the abundance of natural chert sources. Most sites are short-term camps or limited-activity loci associated with the use of the local toolstone sources. Many were also used for domestic activities and restocking mobile toolkits. The lack of permanent water sources, arable land, and firewood, and the exposed project setting were major deterrents to long-term occupation. Use was probably during the warm seasons and timed to coincide with the availability of water in potholes. Research issues are addressed regarding Chronology and Cultural Affiliation, Settlement Patterns, and Environmental Adaptation. The results challenge many earlier interpretations about area prehistory, particularly regarding chronology, resources, and settlement patterns. A model of toolstone procurement and use is presented. The Canyonlands toolstone typology is revised and problem areas are identified. The results of radiocarbon and flotation studies on open lithic sites are given. Finally, the usefulness of the Gateway Tradition for interpreting prehistoric sites in the park is assessed. 17. Document Analysis a. Descriptors /cultural resources inventory /cultural resources testing/archaeology /archaeological studies/prehistoric remains/field investigations/historic preservation/lithic studies/ lithic analyses b. Identifiers/Open Ended Term* /Canyonlands Archeological Project/Southwestern Archaeology /Canyonlands National Park/ Island-in-the-Sky/Archaic/Formative/Chipped Stone Analyses c. COSATI Held/Group "• A*....*"* stataman; Available from National Technical 19. Security Class (This Report) 21. No. of Pages Information Service, Operations Division, 5285 Unclassified Port Royal Road, Springfield, Virginia 22161 20. Security Class (This Pago) 22. Price Unclassified (SMANSt-Z39.lt) See Instructions on Reverse OPTIONAL FORM 272 (4-; (Formerly NTIS-35) Department of Commerce Cultural Resource Investigations Near White Crack, Island-in-the-Sky District, Canyonlands National Park, Utah by Betsy L. Tipps, Andre D. La Fond, and Robert I. Birnie with contributions by Susan C. Kenzle, Nancy J. Coulam, Daniel K. Newsome, and Scott M. Whitesides Submitted in partial fulfillment of Contract CX 1 200-4-A063 to National Park Service Intermountain Regional Office P.O. Box 25287 Denver, Colorado 80225 Submitted by P-III Associates, Inc. 2759 South 300 West Salt Lake City, Utah 841 15-2932 Cultural Resources Report 41 1-02-9617 Permit U-90-PD-161N 1996 White Crack project area and surround- Cover Illustration: Artistic landform map showing the the right of the drawing. Adapted from An ing areas of Canyonlands National Park. North is to Floyd Sharrock, University of Utah Archeological Survey of Canyonlands National Park, by University of Utah Press. Anthropological Paper 83, 1966. Map appears courtesy of the FOREWORD The National Park Service, Intermoun- Almost all of the recorded sites are lithic tain Region, is pleased to present this scatters or lithic source sites. Lithic scatters volume as the latest in a series of reports are the most common type of archeological concerning prehistoric and historic cultural site in the park, and indeed in most parks in resources in regional parks. This volume is the Intermountain West; yet, they are often the third in the series to report on archeologi- overlooked in favor of more spectacular sites cal investigations in Canyonlands National with architecture and ceramics. This report Park. The two earlier volumes concerned the demonstrates that there is tremendous vari- archeology of the Needles District; this vol- ability within this site category. It also docu- ume presents new data on the lesser known ments that such sites have significant Island-in-the-Sky District. The results of the research potential and that their study is es- work significantly challenge earlier interpre- sential to understanding the full range of pre- tations regarding the chronology of occupa- historic lifeways in the region. I am pleased tion, the cultural groups that occupied the to make this information available to other area, and the types of activities that took researchers and the interested public. place. Despite the small size of the project and insubstantial nature of most sites, de- tailed site recording and thoughtful analyses that incorporated ethnographic models al- lowed the researchers to derive more substan- John E. Cook tive interpretations and conclusions than is Regional Director typical for such projects. Intermountain Region Mission: As the Nation's principal conservation agency, the Department of the Interior has responsibility for most of our nationally owned public lands and natural and cultural resources. This includes fostering wise use of our land and water resources, protecting our fish and wild- life, preserving the environmental and cultural values of our national parks and historical places, and providing for the enjoyment of life through outdoor recreation. The Department assesses our energy and mineral resources and works to assure that their development is in the best interests of all our people. The Department also promotes the goals of the Take Pride in America cam- paign by encouraging stewardship and citizen responsibility for the public lands and promoting citizen participation in their care. The Department also has a major responsibility for American Indian reservation communities and for people who live in Island Territories under U.S. Admini- stration. NPS-D-1 17. in IV ABSTRACT This document is the final technical tools, and restocking mobile toolkits. Forag- report of archeologicai investigations ing, with planned use of the lithic sources in the White Crack Area, Island-in-the-Sky embedded in the season round, is inferred as District, Canyonlands National Park, Utah. the primary mode of adaptation during most This work was undertaken as part of a multi- of prehistory. The area is not suitable for ag- year contract being conducted by P-III Asso- riculture. This, the lack of permanent water ciates, Inc., for the National Park Service. sources, the exposed environmental setting, The goals of the multiyear project are to col- and the lack of plants suitable for firewood lect information to improve the park's inter- were major deterrents to long-term or year- pretive program and guide management round occupation. Most prehistoric use was decisions, and addressing scientific research probably during the warm seasons and timed issues. to coincide with the reliable availability of The project involved inventory of 726 acres water in potholes along the White Rim. on and below the White Rim, limited testing Research issues are identified and ad- of eight features on five sites, and reanalysis dressed in three major problem domains: of an existing lithic collection recovered from Chronology and Cultural Affiliation, Settle- a large open site by the National Park Ser- ment Patterns, and Environmental Adapta- vice. Almost all of the recorded sites were tion. The results substantially challenge many lithic scatters or lithic source sites dating of Sharrock's (1966) interpretations about from the Archaic through the Late Prehistoric/ Island-in-the-Sky prehistory, particularly re- Protohistoric periods. The inventory revealed garding chronology, site function, settlement a relatively high site density that appears to patterns, and toolstone availability. Toolstone be related to the presence of an access route procurement and processing strategies are between the White Rim and the subrim can- analyzed and reconstructed to develop a yons and benchlands, as well as the abun- model of toolstone use in the project area. In dance of numerous Cedar Mesa Chert and addition, the Canyonlands chipped stone raw Chalcedony sources on the benches below material typology developed during earlier the White Rim. phases of the project is revised, and problem Despite the high site density, occupation areas requiring additional research are identi- was short term and intermittent during all pe- fied. The report also includes the results of riods. Most sites are camps or limited-activity additional radiocarbon and flotation