Coastal Hazards in the Northland Region–Part II: Coastal

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Coastal Hazards in the Northland Region–Part II: Coastal Overview of Weather and Coastal Hazards in the Northland Region–Part II: Coastal NIWA Client Report: HAM2003-114 October 2003 NIWA Project: NRC04301 Overview of Weather and Coastal Hazards in the Northland Region–Part II: Coastal Hazards Robert G. Bell Richard M. Gorman Prepared for Northland Regional Council NIWA Client Report: HAM2003-114 October 2003 NIWA Project: NRC04301 National Institute of Water & Atmospheric Research Ltd Gate 10, Silverdale Road, Hamilton P O Box 11115, Hamilton, New Zealand Phone +64-7-856 7026, Fax +64-7-856 0151 www.niwa.co.nz All rights reserved. This publication may not be reproduced or copied in any form without the permission of the client. Such permission is to be given only in accordance with the terms of the client's contract with NIWA. This copyright extends to all forms of copying and any storage of material in any kind of information retrieval system. Contents Executive Summary iv 1. Introduction 1 2. Coastal setting for the Northland region 2 3. What are the coastal issues in the Northland Region? 3 4. Responses by NRC 6 5. Coastal hazard “drivers” 8 5.1 Tides 9 5.2 Sea-level fluctuations 12 5.3 Storms 15 5.3.1 Waves 16 5.3.2 Storm tides 21 6. Climate-change effects on coastal “drivers” 26 6.1 Sea-level rise 26 6.2 Climate change effects on ocean currents, winds, waves, and tides 27 7. Coastal sediment systems and coastal inundation in Northland 29 7.1 Overview of past studies and information 29 7.1.1 West coast Northland 29 7.1.2 Harbours and estuaries of Northland 30 7.1.3 Tidal inlets of Northland 32 7.1.4 Embayments, pocket beaches and continental shelf (east coast) 32 7.2 Climate-change impacts on sediment supply and coastal erosion 35 8. Conclusions—Coastal hazards 36 9. Acknowledgements 36 10. Bibliography and references 37 Reviewed by: Approved for release by: T.M. Hume T.M. Hume Formatting checked ………………… …… Executive Summary As a long peninsular, the Northland region is exposed to significant risks from both weather and coastal hazards. The long coastlines and the exposure to intense weather systems, be they ex-tropical cyclones or north Tasman-Sea lows, results in a region often confronted by natural hazard events. These events can lead to damage to properties and infrastructure, disrupting transport and lifelines, impacting upon the regional economy and in extreme cases they can put peoples lives at risk. This report (Part II) documents the current level of knowledge of coastal hazards for the Northland region, while Part I (Gray, 2003) covers the weather hazards. These two reports form part of an overview of the knowledge base on natural hazards for Northland, carried out under the umbrella of the NIWA/GNS Natural Hazards Centre, and commissioned by Northland Regional Council. The following sections provide a brief overview of the issues associated with coastal management in Northland, known information (publications and data) that exist on physical coastal environments and coastal hazards, and a broad outline of the effects of climate variability and climate-change. Generally, there is a reasonable pool of knowledge on coastal sediment systems, particularly on the east coast, and latterly within the Kaipara Harbour (west coast), especially by university and NIWA researchers. There are some gaps in developing fundamental databases on coastal “drivers”, such as wave climate, tides, winds and storms, to which these reports (Part I and II), partially address. Some projections are given for possible future impacts of climate change on the Northland region, with sea-level rise, effects on sediment supply to the coast and more intense storms likely to be the main impacts on coastal systems. Future work firstly needs to fill some gaps in the databases on coastal “drivers” and secondly usher in a more integrated “all-hazards” approach to coastal hazards, which examines the hazards from several different sources, including flooding. The latter will hopefully will be spurred on by the new Guidance Note for territorial authorities (MfE, 2003), which is based on a risk-management framework. Overview of Weather and Coastal Hazards in the Northland Region–Part II: Coastal Hazards iv 1. Introduction As a long peninsular, the Northland region is exposed to significant risks from both weather and coastal hazards. The long coastlines and the exposure to intense weather systems, be they ex-tropical cyclones or north Tasman-Sea lows, results in a region often confronted by natural hazard events. These events can lead to damage to properties and infrastructure, disrupting transport and lifelines, impacting upon the regional economy and in extreme cases they can put peoples lives at risk. This report (Part II) documents the current level of knowledge of coastal hazards for the Northland region, while Part I (Gray, 2003) covers the weather hazards. These two reports form part of an overview of the knowledge base on natural hazards for Northland, carried out under the umbrella of the NIWA/GNS Natural Hazards Centre 1, and commissioned by Northland Regional Council. The following sections provide a brief overview of the issues associated with coastal management in Northland, known information (publications and data) that exist on physical coastal environments and coastal hazards, and a broad outline of the effects of climate variability and climate-change. 1 For more details and quarterly Update, see web site: http://www.naturalhazards.net.nz/ Overview of weather and coastal hazards in the Northland region—Part II: Coastal hazards 1 2. Coastal setting for the Northland region Northland consists of a long, narrow peninsula, only 80 km across at its widest point, and 6 km at its narrowest point. It is bounded by the Tasman Sea on the west and Pacific Ocean on the east. Northland is dominated by rolling hill country, with modest areas of flat low-lying land are restricted to areas adjacent to the Awanui and Northern Wairoa rivers. Northland’s population of 140,130 (2001 Census) live mainly on the east coast, concentrated in Whangarei District and the Bay of Islands area. Northland’s coastline is around 1,700 km long, with no part of the region more than 40 km from the ocean. Consequently, the economic, environmental, social and cultural “goods and services” derived from coastal environments is an important component of life in Northland. Northland’s coast exhibits very contrasting types between the west and eastern coasts. The west coast of the region is a continuous sandy dissipative beach backed by active (transgressive) sand dune systems, broken only by the mouths of four harbours (Kaipara, Hokianga, Whangape and Herekino) and the rocky headland forming Tauroa Point (Ahipara). In contrast, Northland's eastern coast forms a very irregular shoreline with rocky headlands, sheltered deep-water harbours, sandy bays and mangrove forests. Also, there are numerous islands along the region's east coast that provide partial sheltering from easterly waves. The major island groups are those in the Bay of Islands, Poor Knights, Hen and Chickens and Cavalli Islands. The east coast is sheltered from the prevailing west to southwest winds, resulting in a mild wave climate, but is exposed to high wave activity from occasional northeasterly gales and extra-tropical cyclones. In contrast, the west coast is continually subject to active seas and swell originating from the Southern Ocean. Overview of weather and coastal hazards in the Northland region—Part II: Coastal hazards 2 3. What are the coastal issues in the Northland Region? Some of the pressures and issues faced by NRC with regard to natural character and coastal hazards are, as outlined in (NRC, 2002): 2 • Escalating demand for coastal subdivision and use of the coastal area has resulted in increased pressures on coastal margins, particularly foredune environments (especially where there is unformed access). • Extraction of sand in the NRC region has concentrated around the entrances to the Kaipara, Paregarenga and Mangawhai harbours. There is potential for erosion on adjacent shorelines. • Historically, development in coastal catchments, including land clearance and associated catchment development, has resulted in impacts on estuaries and harbours from sediment-laden waters (e.g., Fig. C.1) Figure C.1: Land clearance and partial reclamation of an estuary tidal creek in Bay of Islands area in the early 1980s [ Photo: RG Bell ]. • The threat to existing and future communities from natural hazards, the potential and nature of which may be unknown. 2 http://www.nrc.govt.nz/special/soe.2002/coastal/natural.character.of.the.coast/index.shtml http://www.nrc.govt.nz/special/soe.2002/coastal/coastal.hazards/index.shtml Overview of weather and coastal hazards in the Northland region—Part II: Coastal hazards 3 • Recognition and understanding of the range of existing natural hazard threats and the likely frequency and magnitude of particular events. • Identification of areas of high hazard risk, especially those prone to erosion, flooding (river or sea) and land instability, and provision of related information on avoidance measures to people. • Incorporation of comprehensive systems of hazard identification and analysis into the resource consent and building consent processes. • Damage to natural systems through inappropriate hazard protection measures. • The contribution that certain land-use activities have in increasing the hazard threat especially in high-risk areas. Such activities include: o clearance of vegetation by mechanical or other means in areas exposed to the elements and/or with poor soil structures; o changes to sediment load of rivers and streams (+ or –) due to changing land-use patterns; o earthworks, including mineral extraction, in sensitive foreshore and riparian areas; o erection of structures, especially buildings, in flood plains. • Maintenance of existing protection works, including flood control schemes and coastal protection works, and their future effectiveness.
Recommended publications
  • Auckland & Northland Region Calendar
    Auckland & Northland Region Calendar Please refer to calendars on the Gymnastics NZ website for education registrations and competition entry forms and competitions in other regions. Date GymSport Competition/ Course STEP/Level/Pre-requsite Venue March 3-4 March – New Date MAG + WAG Junior Coach Artistic coaches who have WAG + MAG Counties Manukau GC Registrations close 21 Feb Course completed Elementary TUM Elementary Coach Coaches have completed Needs to be re-scheduled TUM Auckland?/Whangarei? course Foundation Coach 9-11 March – New Date Rhythmic coaches who have RG RG Junior Coach Course Counties Manukau GC Registrations close 28 Feb completed Elementary coach 25 March Coaches who have completed Understanding Movement Registrations close 14 All Codes Online Understanding Howick GC Practical March Movement 25 REC competition North Harbour Gymfest MAG / WAG recreational North Harbour GC 30 March – 2 April Easter Holiday April Coaches have completed TBC TRA TRA Elementary Coach Course Auckland Foundation Coach 7-8 Coaches have completed Hamilton, TBC (not run in RG RG Elementary Coach course Registrations close 28 Mar Foundation Coach Auckland/Northland) Eastern Suburbs Tumbling ESGC routines Tumbling, not 8 TUM Eastern Suburbs GC festival GNZ routines 8 XTND Group Management 2018 Year 1 students Counties Manukau GC Registrations close 28 Mar 8 XTND Trampoline Year 2 students Counties Manukau GC Registrations close 28 Mar 14-15 – New Date TRA Junior & Senior Judge TRA Trampoline Judges Icon Registrations close 4 April Course 14-15 –
    [Show full text]
  • Natural Areas of Whangarei Ecological District
    Natural areas of Whangarei Ecological District Reconnaissance Survey Report for the Protected Natural Areas Programme NEW ZEALAND PROTECTED NATURAL AREAS PROGRAMME Diana Manning Published by Department of Conservation Northland Conservancy P.O. Box 842 Whangarei, New Zealand © Crown copyright 2001 This report may be freely copied provided that the Department of Conservation is acknowledged as the source of the information. Cover photograph: Maungatapere Mountain. Topographic base maps reproduced under the Land Information New Zealand Map Authority 1991/42: Crown Copyright Reserved. ISSN: 0112-9252 ISBN: 0-478-22076-6 Cataloguing-in-Publication data Manning, Diana Natural areas of Whangarei Ecological District : reconnaissance survey report for the Protected Natural Areas Programme / Diana Manning. Whangarei, N.Z. : Dept. of Conservation, Northland Conservancy, 2001. 1 v. ; 30 cm. (New Zealand Protected Natural Areas Programme, 0112- 9252) Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0478220766. 1. Ecological surveysNew ZealandNorthland Region. 2. Natural areasNew ZealandNorthland Region. 3. Whangarei Ecological District (N.Z.). I. Title. II. Series: New Zealand Protected Natural Areas Programme (Series) Foreword The Whangarei Ecological District comprises a range of landscapes with significant wildlife and vegetation values. Whangarei Harbour, a major shallow estuarine habitat with extensive mudflats, saltmarshes, shellbanks and mangroves, supports a rich diversity of international and resident coastal and wading birds which seasonally number in their thousands, despite the concentrations of housing, and the port, airport, cement and fertiliser works around it. Surrounding the outskirts of Whangarei City are numerous young scoria cones, clothed with nationally unique volcanic broadleaf forest, which are an important food source for the threatened kukupa (NZ pigeon). The once vast Hikurangi swamp on the Wairua River flood plain has been much diminished through drainage and development.
    [Show full text]
  • 2021 Whangarei Visitor Guide
    2021 VISITOR GUIDE CENTRAL WHANGĀREI TOWN BASIN TUTUKĀKĀ COAST WHANGĀREI HEADS BREAM BAY WhangareiNZ.com Whangārei Visitor Guide Cape Reinga CONTENTS EXPLOREEXPLORE 3 District Highlights 4 Culture WHANGĀREI DISTRICT 6 Cultural Attractions NINETY MILE 7 Kids Stuff BEACH 1f Take the scenic route 8 Walks Follow the Twin Coast Discovery 13 Markets signs and discover the best of 14 Beaches both the East and West Coasts. 16 Art 18 Town Basin Sculpture Trail New Zealand 20 Waterfalls Kaitaia 22 Gardens Bay of 10 Islands 23 Cycling Kerikeri 24 Events 1 36 Street Prints Manaia Art Trail H OK H IA AR NG CENTRAL BO A Climate UR Kaikohe Poor Knights 12 Islands WHANGĀREI Whangārei district is part of 1 Northland, New Zealand’s warmest CENTRAL 26 Central Whangārei Map WHANGĀREI Waipoua WHANGĀREI and only subtropical region, with 12 30 Whangārei City Centre Map Kauri TUTUKĀKĀ an average of 2000 sunshine hours Forest COAST 31 See & Do every year. The hottest months are 28 Listings January and February and winters are mild WHANGĀREI WHANGĀREI 34 Eat & Drink – there’s no snow here! 14 HEADS Average temperatures Dargaville BREAM BAY BREAM Hen & Chicken Spring: (Sep-Nov) 17°C high, 10°C low BAY Islands 12 Waipū 40 Bream Bay Map Summer: (Dec-Feb) 24°C high, 14°C low 1 42 See & Do Autumn: (Mar-May) 21°C high, 11°C low 12 Winter: (Jun-Aug) 16°C high, 07°C low 42 Listings 1 Travel distances to Whangārei WHANGĀREI HEADS • 160km north of Auckland – 2 hours drive or 30 minute flight 46 Whangārei Heads Map • 68km south of the Bay of Islands – 1 hour drive 47 See & Do UR K RBO Auckland • 265km south of Cape Reinga – 4 hours drive AIPARA HA 49 Listings TUTUKĀKĀ COAST This official visitor guide to the Whangārei district is owned by Whangarei 50 Tutukākā Coast Map District Council and produced in partnership with Big Fish Creative.
    [Show full text]
  • Northland Feb 2020
    Newsletter of the Northland Region of the Ornithological Society of New Zealand - trading as Birds New Zealand February 2020 Amokura 127 (Published in February, July and October of each year) MEETINGS of the Northland Branch of Birds New Zealand are held each month on the second Thursday, for the period FEBRUARY to DECEMBER. TIME: 7-30p.m. VENUE: Founders Room, Alzheimer’s Society, 148 Corks Road, Tikipunga, Whangarei. COST: A donation of $3-00 per person per meeting is requested toward the cost of Hall hire, supper and the production and distribution of "Amokura". Or you can pay an Annual fee of $30.00 to the Northland Branch bank account 12-3099-0614160-00. Payment Due after the AGM Be sure to include your Surname and the word Sub in the details. ALL WELCOME PROGRAMME TO JULY 2020 FEBRUARY 13 MEETING – 7-30p.m. WEST COAST BEACH PATROL – Contact Prue Cozens Ph. 09 4377760 15 NGUNGURU SHOREBIRD COUNT – Meet at Te Maika Rd, Ngunguru 1:00pm 18 EAST COAST BEACH PATROL (Meet at the Kensington Carpark 12:30pm) MARCH 12 MEETING – 7-30p.m. WEST COAST BEACH PATROL – Contact Prue Cozens Ph. 09 4377760 17 EAST COAST BEACH PATROL (Meet at the Kensington Carpark 12:30pm) 14 APRIL 09 MEETING – 7-30p.m. WEST COAST BEACH PATROL – Contact Prue Cozens Ph. 09 4377760 14 EAST COAST BEACH PATROL (Meet at the Kensington Carpark 12:30pm) MAY 14 NO MEETING WEST COAST BEACH PATROL – Contact Prue Cozens Ph. 09 4377760 19 EAST COAST BEACH PATROL (Meet at the Kensington Carpark 12:30pm) JUNE 11 MEETING – 7-30p.m WEST COAST BEACH PATROL – Contact Prue Cozens Ph.
    [Show full text]
  • CRBF and Carter Holt Harvey
    PUBLIC Version ISSN No. 0114-2720 10103 Decision No. 589 Determination pursuant to the Commerce Act 1986 in the matter of an application for Proposal CRBF LIMITED and CARTER HOLT HARVEY LIMITED The Commission: Paula Rebstock Denese Bates QC Peter J M Taylor Summary of Application: CRBF Limited seeks clearance to acquire shares and assets owned by Carter Holt Harvey Limited, relating to forestry estates located in Northland, Auckland, central North Island and Nelson. Determination: Pursuant to section 66(3)(a) of the Commerce Act 1986, the Commission determines to give clearance to the proposed acquisition. Date of Determination: 05 October 2006 CONFIDENTIAL MATERIAL IN THIS REPORT IS CONTAINED IN SQUARE BRACKETS CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................i GLOSSARY .................................................................................................................iv Terms ........................................................................................................................iv Parties.........................................................................................................................v THE PROPOSAL ..........................................................................................................1 PROCEDURE................................................................................................................1 STATUTORY FRAMEWORK.....................................................................................1
    [Show full text]
  • Reply Report Tracked Changes Version of the Plan
    Reply Report Tracked Changes Version of the Plan October 2018 Purpose of this document This document is the Proposed Regional Plan for Northland with council officer recommended changes as a result of the hearings. Guide to recommended changes In this document, recommended additions are shown as underlined and recommended deletions as strikethrough. The original document is the notified verion. The yellow changes are the s42A recommended changes. The green changes are the officer recommended changes as a result of the hearings. Each recommended change is referenced with an endnote (yellow changes) or footnote (green changes) of one of the following: • A submitter that gives jurisdiction for the change e.g. “Department of Conservation”. There may be other submissions that may also provide the jurisdiction but only one has been referenced. • Consequential changes - under Schedule 1 clause 10(2)(b) of the RMA. • Clarifications - alterations and corrections of minor effect made under Schedule 1 clause 16(2) of the RMA and the general decision making powers of clause 10, Schdule 1, RMA. This document retains the numbering of the Proposed Regional Plan for Northland as notified. New provisions are numbered sequentially – for example a new policy appearing after Policy D.2.2 would be number D.2.2A Karakia He karakia ki nga Atua A prayer to Māori gods Ko Rangi There's Rangi Ko Papa There's Papa Ka puta The birth's Ko Rongo Of Rongo Ko Tane Mahuta Of Tane Mahuta Ko Tangaroa Of Tangaroa Ko Tumatauenga Of Tumatauenga Ko Haumietikitiki Of Haumietikiki
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 3D: Archaeological & Historic Heritage Values
    Marsden Point Refinery: A Resource Consent Application to Renew 20 Resource Consents from the Northland Regional Council Prepared for: ChanceryGreen on behalf of The New Zealand Refining Company Limited, trading as ‘Refining NZ’ Prepared by: Gavin Kemble, Director Bridgette Munro, Chairperson Blair McLean, Senior Planner George Sariak, Planner Date Finalised: July 2020 Volume 3d: Archaeological & Historic Heritage Values MARSDEN REFINERY WHANGAREI HARBOUR DREDGING: ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT Report prepared for The New Zealand Refining Company Limited By Simon Bickler (PhD) Rod Clough (PhD) July 2017 Clough & Associates Ltd. [email protected] 321 Forest Hill Rd, Waiatarua AUCKLAND 0612 Telephone: (09) 8141946 Mobile 0274 850 059 www.clough.co.nz TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 1 Project Background ........................................................................................................... 1 Methodology ..................................................................................................................... 1 Results ................................................................................................................................... 4 Physical Environment ....................................................................................................... 4 History..............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Northland CMS Volume I
    CMS CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT STRATEGY N orthland 2014–2024, Volume I Operative 29 September 2014 CONSERVATION106B MANAGEMENT STRATEGY NORTHLAND107B 2014–2024, Volume I Operative108B 29 September 2014 Cover109B image: Waikahoa Bay campsite, Mimiwhangata Scenic Reserve. Photo: DOC September10B 2014, New Zealand Department of Conservation ISBN10B 978-0-478-15017-9 (print) ISBN102B 978-0-478-15019-3 (online) This103B document is protected by copyright owned by the Department of Conservation on behalf of the Crown. Unless indicated otherwise for specific items or collections of content, this copyright material is licensed for re- use under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 New Zealand licence. In essence, you are free to copy, distribute and adapt the material, as long as you attribute it to the Department of Conservation and abide by the other licence terms. To104B view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/nz/U U This105B publication is produced using paper sourced from well-managed, renewable and legally logged forests. Contents802B 152B Foreword803 7 Introduction804B 8 Purpose809B of conservation management strategies 8 CMS810B structure 9 CMS81B term 10 Relationship812B with other Department of Conservation strategic documents and tools 10 Relationship813B with other planning processes 11 Legislative814B tools 11 Exemption89B from land use consents 11 Closure890B of areas and access restrictions 11 Bylaws891B and regulations 12 Conservation892B management plans 12 International815B obligations 12 Part805B
    [Show full text]
  • Natural Character of the Coastal Environment, Including Protection from Inappropriate Subdivision, Use and Development
    6 COASTAL MANAGEMENT Summary RPS Objectives • The preservation of the natural character of the coastal environment, including protection from inappropriate subdivision, use and development. • Prevention of damage to and loss of traditional fisheries habitats and tangata whenua resources of significance to the tangata whenua. • Maintenance and enhancement of public use, enjoyment of and access to the coastal environment. • The minimisation of the conflicts between uses in the coastal environment and their effects on public health and safety. Pressures • Direct and indirect human-induced modification of natural coastal features, systems and processes. • Cumulative effects of increasing development pressure on coastal-land and coastal marine area. • Inappropriately sited coastal development affecting natural coastal processes. • Conflicting demand for coastal water space. State • Coastal systems have been extensively modified, with extensive loss of coastal forests, saltmarsh and modification of natural dune systems. • Development has occurred on many of the east coast lowlands, with many barrier- spit systems fully developed and the margins of the Whangarei and Bay of Islands harbours well developed. • The west coast is less developed, although there is increasing pressure for development as demand for coastal property increases. • There are currently more than 3800 active permits for coastal structures and moorings, with close to 90% of these situated on Northland’s east coast. • More than 700 subdivisions in Northland’s coastal area were approved by District Councils between 2002 and 2005. These subdivisions include more than 3800 lots. Northland Regional Council 2007 State of the Environment Report 75 6 - Coastal Management Doing well • Coastal monitoring is undertaken to better understand baseline dynamics of Northland’s beaches and estuaries.
    [Show full text]
  • Through Changing Scenes by K. Abercrombie Wesley Historical
    Through Changing Scenes by K. Abercrombie Rawene Church 1956 Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication #15 (1) 1956 Page 1 Through Changing Scenes by K. Abercrombie Introduction This compilation of the Rawene Methodist Church's first eighty years may differ from other such histories. Believing that history can be a pleasure I have minimised the use of "dates" which often tend to bore the reader. Rather I have stressed the triumphs and setbacks of the people-who after all, are the Church. It will be seen that the story often concerns the whole circuit. This has been done because while gathering information about Rawene, much concerned the circuit as a whole. Rather than let it pass into oblivion I have included it in this account. Much of the information in this booklet came not from manuscripts, but from people, and I wish to thank the following who provided much valuable information: The Revs. H. A. Cochrane, D. G. Sherson, B.A., R. Grice, C. B. Oldfield, A. W. McKay, J. W. Parker, and H. Bateup (former ministers of the Hokianga circuit), the Revs. G. I. Laurenson, E. W. Hames, M.A., and H. L. Fiebig, B.A. (Connexional Secretary), Miss N. E. Bawden, Messrs. Geo. Pearson, T. G. M. Spooner, M.A., K. Langton (photographs), G. F. G. Millar and T. P. Lane. This book has been made possible by the members of the Rawene Methodist Church Trust (Rev. H. D. Besant, B.A., Miss N. E. Bawden, Messrs. D. E. Fletcher, F. 0. J. Langton and Geo. Pearson). I extend my sincere thanks to Miss C.
    [Show full text]
  • Does Collaborative Governance Increase Public Confidence in Water Management? Survey Evidence from Aotearoa New Zealand
    www.water-alternatives.org Volume 13 | Issue 2 Tadaki, M.; Sinner, J.; Stahlmann-Brown, P. and Greenhalgh, S. 2020. Does collaborative governance increase public confidence in water management? Survey evidence from Aotearoa New Zealand. Water Alternatives 13(2): 302-323 Does Collaborative Governance Increase Public Confidence in Water Management? Survey Evidence from Aotearoa New Zealand Marc Tadaki Cawthron Institute, Nelson, New Zealand; [email protected] Jim Sinner Cawthron Institute, Nelson, New Zealand; [email protected] Philip Stahlmann-Brown Manaaki Whenua – Landcare Research, Wellington, New Zealand; [email protected] Suzie Greenhalgh Manaaki Whenua – Landcare Research, Auckland, New Zealand; [email protected] ABSTRACT: Collaborative decision-making is widely understood as a democratic corrective to top-down forms of environmental management; it is a way in which citizens can contribute local knowledge to the policy process and have a more direct role in shaping policies and rules that affect them and their environments. However, while the democratic virtues of collaborative governance are often asserted, they are rarely evidenced; this leaves claims of democratic empowerment open to question. This study used a longitudinal survey of three New Zealand regions (n = 1350) to identify whether major multi-year investments in collaborative decision-making (2012-2018) are leading to increased public confidence in the effectiveness, responsiveness and fairness of water management institutions. Residents in collaborative catchments were found to have scores that were statistically indistinguishable from residents of non-collaborative catchments on management effectiveness, perceived agreement about water management, and fairness. Collaborative catchment residents did assign higher scores for water management responsiveness than did other residents, but the size of this difference was small compared to the effects of gender, ethnicity, region and level of individuals’ prior engagement in water management.
    [Show full text]
  • Vision for Growth Western Reclamation
    Northport VISION FOR GROWTH WESTERN RECLAMATION Assessment Of Landscape, Natural Character & Amenity Effects March 2021 CLIENT: Northport PROJECT: Vision for Growth Expansion of Northport: Western Reclamation DOCUMENT STATUS: Draft 4 DATE: April 2021 AUTHOR: Stephen Brown Brown NZ Limited 156 Parnell Rad Parnell Auckland 1052 Ph: 09 377 7771 Mob: 021 646 181 2 Brown NZ Ltd April 2021 ATTACHMENTS 1-27: ATTACHMENT 1: “Western Reclamation: General Cargo” – Concept Plan ATTACHMENT 2: “Western Reclamation: Shipyard” – Concept Plan ATTACHMENT 3: Northport “Vision for Growth” – Location Aerial ATTACHMENTS 4 & 5: Mitigation Concept – General Cargo & Shipyard Scenarios ATTACHMENT 6: Whangarei District Plan – Outstanding Landscape Areas & Notable Landscape Areas ATTACHMENT 7: Proposed Northland RPS – Outstanding Natural features / Landscapes & Areas of High / Outstanding Natural Character ATTACHMENT 8: Indicative Zone of Theoretical Visibility for land areas around Whangarei Harbour ATTACHMENT 9: Viewpoint Location Map ATTACHMENTS 10-24: Photos from locations near Northport & around Whangarei Harbour exposed to the Western Reclamation & “Vision for Growth” sites: ▪ The intersection of Port Marsden Highway & Ralph Trimmer Drive ▪ Port Marsden Highway ▪ Marsden Point Road crossing Blacksmiths Creek ▪ The Marsden Bay foreshore near Albany Road ▪ Beach access and lookout next to One Tree Point Road ▪ Coastal reserve next to Whangarei Heads Road south-east of Waikaraka Beach ▪ Above 178 Manganese Point Road ▪ Next to Whangarei Heads Road & The Pines
    [Show full text]