Electoral Violence and the Survival of Democracy in Nigeria’Sfourth Republic: a Historical Perspective
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by CSCanada.net: E-Journals (Canadian Academy of Oriental and Occidental Culture,... ISSN 1712-8056[Print] Canadian Social Science ISSN 1923-6697[Online] Vol. 10, No. 3, 2014, pp. 140-148 www.cscanada.net DOI:10.3968/4593 www.cscanada.org Electoral Violence and the Survival of Democracy in Nigeria’sFourth Republic: A Historical Perspective Adesola Samson Adesote[a],*; John O. Abimbola[b] [a]Lecturer, Department of History & Diplomatic Studies, McPherson University, Seriki-Sotayo, Nigeria INTRODUCTION [b]Principal Lecturer, Department of History, Adeyemi College of In every stable democratic society, election remains Education, Ondo, Nigeria. * the essential ingredient of transitory process from Corresponding author. one civilian administration to another. Elections have Received 11 January 2014; accepted 9 April 2014 become an integral part of representative democracy Pulished online 18 April 2014 that by and large prevails across the world. According to Lindberg (2003), every modern vision of representative Abstract democracy entails the notion of elections as the primary The historical trajectory of electoral process in the means of selection of political decision makers. Thus, it post colonial Nigeria is characterised by violence. In is incomprehensible in contemporary times to think of fact, recent manifestations of electoral violence, most democracy without linking it to the idea and practice of importantly since the birth of the Fourth Republic in 1999 elections. Ojo (2007), described election as the ‘hallmark have assumed an unprecedented magnitude and changing of democracy’ while Chiroro (2005) sees it as the ‘heart form, resulting in instability in democratic consolidation of the democratic order’. In all, elections constitute a core as well as the loss and displacement of many innocent component of democracy. The electoral process in Africa in general and Nigeria lives. The paper historicizes electoral violence and its st implications on the survival of democracy in the Nigeria in particular especially since the beginning of the 21 with major emphasis on the Fourth Republic. It argues century is characterised by violence. It is important to that the high incidence of electoral violence (pre and post) emphasize here that though violence has been a long- in the Fourth Republic in particular is closely associated standing feature of the democratisation process in the with neo-patrimonial character of the Nigerian state, post colonial Nigeria, its recent manifestations especially the nature and kind of party politics being played, the since the birth of the Fourth Republic has assumed an weak institutionalisation of democratic architectures and unprecedented magnitude thus constituting a major threat inefficient electoral management body among others. It to the survival democracy. Fundamentally, there is no posits that these were among the factors that led to the doubt the fact that electoral violence remains a major fall or collapse of the First and Second Republics. The source of political instability in a democratic society with paper therefore submits that the survival of democracy palpable threats of deconsolidation. Scholars among which in the Fourth Republic involves adherence to the ideals were Adigun Agbaje and Said Adejumobi have argued that and principles of electoral process as practised in ideal violence has become infused in political processes in most democratic societies. new democracies in Africa especially with respect to the 21st century. For instance, according to the 2008 Amnesty Electoral violence; Democracy; Nigeria Key words: International Report, ‘the violent struggle for power, even in states which do not descend into armed conflict, still Adesola Samson Adesote, John O. Abimbola (2014). Electoral Violence remains an important component of political life in Africa. and the Survival of Democracy in Nigeria’sFourth Republic: A Historical Perspective . Canadian Social Science, 10(3), 140-148. Available Nigeria, having survived decades of military from: http://www.cscanada.net/index.php/css/article/view/4593 dictatorship which was characterized by despotism, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3968/4593 violation of fundamental human rights, financial profligacy among others, eventually returned to democratic rule on Copyright © Canadian Academy of Oriental and Occidental Culture 140 Adesola Samson Adesote; John O. Abimbola (2014). Canadian Social Science, 10(3), 140-148 May 29, 1999 which culminated in the birth of the Fourth (s) election (permitting mass participation and method of Republic. The republic which started amidst great hope and choosing) a person or persons by vote for a public office expectations is yet to significantly convince the generality position in which state authority is exercised”. Roberts of the Nigerian populace its democratic success especially and Edwards (1991) cited in Omotola (2007) define with respect to the conduct of free, fair and credible election as: “A method for the selection of persons to fill elections devoid of election violence (pre and post). certain offices through choices made by an electorate; In fact, both at national and state levels, transition those (citizens who are qualified to vote under the rules from one civilian administration to another since 2003 and procedures of the electoral system” in particular has been very rough. This is noticeable in the various cases of electoral violence which has claimed 1.3 Electoral Violence several lives, displacement of innocent people and Fischer (2002) defines electoral violence (conflict) as any wanton destruction of property. The conduct of election random or organized act that seeks to determine, delay, or since the birth of the fourth republic up to 2011 has been otherwise influence an electoral process through threat, retrogressive rather than progressive. This work tends to verbal intimidation, hate speech, disinformation, physical interrogate electoral violence and the survival of democracy assault, forced “protection,” blackmail, destruction of in Nigeria through historical approach. For the purpose property, or assassination. Fischer’s definition has been of this discourse, the paper is divided into six parts. The modified by Megan Reif (2010) as cited in Majekodunmi, first part is the introduction; second focuses on conceptual R & Adejuwon, K.D (2012) where electoral violence is clarification; third deals with historical trajectory of defined thus: electoral violence in Nigeria; the fourth part discusses any spontaneous or organized act by candidates, party electoral violence in the fourth republic; the fifth part supporters, election authorities, voters, or any other actor examines electoral violence and the survival of democracy that occurs during an electoral process, from the date of voter in the fourth republic while the sixth part is the conclusion. registration to the date of inauguration of a new government, that uses physical harm, intimidation, blackmail, verbal abuse, violent demonstrations, psychological manipulation, or other 1. CONCEPTUAL CLARIFICATION OF coercive tactics aimed at exploiting, disrupting, determining, hastening, delaying, reversing, or otherwise influencing an SOME TERMINOLOGIES electoral process and its outcome. In a discourse of this nature, it is very imperative to Also, Igbuzor (2010) sees electoral violence as: conceptualize some major key concepts. Among these concepts include, violence, electoral violence, election any act of violence perpetuated in the course of political activities, including pre, during and post election periods, and and democracy. First, the word violence has been viewed may include any of the following acts: thuggery, use of force from different angles by different scholars from distinctive to disrupt political meetings or voting at polling stations, or standpoints. Thus, for the purpose of this discourse, we are the use of dangerous weapons to intimidate voters and other looking at violence in terms of both violation of human electoral process or to cause bodily harm or injury to any person rights and social injustice. This paper therefore examined connected with electoral processes. one major type of violence (electoral violence) that has International Foundation for Election Systems (2011) greatly led to loss of lives, wanton destruction of property, defines electoral violence as “any violence (harm) or massive displacement of innocent lives as well as threat to threat of violence (harm) that is aimed at any person or the survival of democracy in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic. property involved in the election process, or at disrupting 1.1 Violence any part of the electoral or political process during the According to Gilula & Daniels (1969) as cited in election period.” Wikipedia (2010), violence is ‘destructive aggression’. According to Albert (2007) electoral violence has to This conceptualization of violence implies the use of do with all forms of organized acts or threats – physical, physical force to injure persons or property; and this is the psychological, and structural – aimed at intimidating, core of most definitions of violence. The World Health harming, blackmailing a political stakeholder before, Organization defines violence as the intentional use of during and after an election with a view to determining, physical force or power, threatened or actual, against delaying, or otherwise influencing an electoral process. oneself, another person,