THE CLASSICAL REVIEW

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

VOLUME V.

DAVID NUTT, 270 AND 271 STRAND, 1891,

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 th

RICHARD CLAY AND SONS, LIMITED, LONDON AND BUNGAY.

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 TABLE OF CONTENTS.

Nos. 1 and. 2.

PAGE J. G. FRAZER. Swallows in the house . 1 W. F. Allen's Annals of Tacitus. S. F. CARTER and M. W. HUMPHREYS. On HART 58 some uses of the Aorist Participle - 3 W. F. Allen's Roman History. S. HART 59 A. PALMER. Catulliana 7 Hime's Introduction to the Latin W. M. LINDSAY. Notes on Festus and Language. J. E. NIXON 59 Nonius 9 Peck's Latin Pronunciation. F. D. T. K. ABBOTT. On the quotations from ALLEN 60 the Old Testament in the Fourth R. Fisch on Latin Personals in -O. H. Gospel 11 N. . . 61 P. SCHWENKE. Apparatus Griticus to Commentationes Fleckeisenianae. J. B. Cicero De Natura Deorum 12 BURY 62 F. F. ABBOTT. Notes upon Latin Hybrids 18 Meister's Greek Dialects. H. W. SMYTH 62 Westcott's Epistle to the Hebrews. J. Seger's Nikephoros Bryennios. J. B. H. THAYER 18 BURY 63 Hude's Thucydides VI.—VIII. B. C. C. E. Bishop on verbals in -ros in Aes- MARCHANT 22 chylus. A. FAIRBANKS 63 Westermann's Demosthenes, Vol. III. Correspondence. W. WAYTE 24 A. Sidgwick on Mr. Page's Review of Headlam's Meleager. H. BABINGTON Papillon and Haigh's Aeneid . . 64 SMITH 26 Verse Translations by E. D. S., F. HAVER- Melber's Dio Cassius, Vol. I. G. Me. N. FIELD and C. E. S. HEADLAM . . 65 & 66 RuSHFORTH 27 Notes. Kaibel's Athenaeus. J. B. BURY ... 29 KavOtjXrj. W. LORING 66 Schmid on the Later Atticism. J. E. Soph. Aj. 651. R. WHITELAW ... 66 SANDYS 31 Thuc. II. 11. F. HAVERFIELD. . . 67 Fierville's Quintilian. W. PETERSON . 32 Tragic Tribrachs. F. HAVERFIELD . 67 Bauer's Silius Italicus. W. E. HEITLAND 36 The Latin Aorist Subjunctive. F. A. De Vries' Studies in Palaeography. KIRKPATRICK, W. H. BOCOCK . . 67 ROBINSON ELLIS 38 Spartian. Vit. Hadr. XI. E. N. Peck's Suetonius. A. T. MURRAY . . 38 BENNETT 68 Otto's Roman Proverbs. W. RHYS Res = ifnaTiM. J. B. M 69 ROBERTS 41 The Upright Stone at Kilmalkedar . 69 Schwabe's edition of Teuffel's Roman The Newly-discovered Treatise of Aris- Literature. G. C. WAKR 42 totle 69 Two Books on the Rigveda. E.V.ARNOLD 43 Monthly Record 72 Frazer's Golden Bough. W. W. FOWLER 48 Archaeology. Schmidt's Corcyrean Studies. H. F. Ephemeris Epigraphica. H. F. PEL- TOZER 53 HAM 74 Rhode on the Tunny Fish. H. F. TOZER 54 Miillenhoff's Deutsche Altertums- Mahaffy's Greek Pictures. H. F. TOZER 55 kunde. C. W. BOASE 75 Mahaffy's Greek World under Roman An early Graeco-Egyptian bilingual Sway. C. TORR 56 dedication. C. SMITH -77 New Editions of Kraner's Caesar. F. Aus der Anomia. C. SMITH .... 79 HAVERFIELD 58 Summaries 80 Oehler's Illustrations to Caesar Bell. Bibliography 85 Gall. F. H. • 58

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 IV THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

No. 3.

PAGE PAGE The New Aristotle Papyrus in its ITn-Aristotelian Words and Phrases in, bearing on Textual Criticism. W. G. J. B. MAYOR 122 RUTHERFORD 89 The New Antiope Fragments . . . .123 Ovidiana. A. PALMER 92 Emendations by W. G. RUTHERFORD Etymology of Osteria. F. F. ABBOTT . 95 and L. CAMPBELL , 124 Dr. Dbrpfeld on the Greek Stage. H. Notes. RICHARDS • . . • . 97 Leucon's Liberality to Athens. W. Verrall's Ion. A. GOODWIN 97 HOBHOUSE and C. TOKR 127 Shuckburgh's Herodotus V. Ev. ABBOTT 99 Eur. Bacch. 506. J. B. BURY . . -127 Tyrrell and Purser's Letters of Cicero. Eur. El. 797. C. H. KEENE .... 127 G. E. JEANS . 100 Thuc. II. 4, 4. E. C. MARCHANT . . 128 Palaiphatos, a Rationalist of the Fourth Cic. ad Att. I. 16 128 Century B.C. J. B. BURY 102 Verg. Aen. X. 1. W. J. EVANS . .128 Schubert's Ajax. E. B. ENGLAND . .103 Caper p. 103. W. M. LINDSAY . . .128 TJsener's Theodosius. A. PLUMMER . . 103 M£Te/ti/'i)^o)crts. J. H. SWAINSON . .129 Diibner's Sulpicius Severus. J. H. Stanko. J. H. ABRAHALL 129 LUPTON 103 Monthly Record. Collectio Juris Antejustiniani. E. C. Archaeology. CLARK 104 The House at Delos. F. B. TARBELL 130 Bousfield's Latin Verse. H. KYNASTON 104 Reinach's Bibliothequedes Monuments Aristotle on the Constitution of Figures, Vol. II 131 Athens:— A Stele in the British Museum. A. Emendations, pp. 105-119 : S. M 132 Notes by C. TORR, L. CAMPBELL, J. E. Excavations at Chester 132 SANDYS, J. E. B. MAYOR, H. JACK- Summaries 133 SON, H. RICHARDS, W. WYSE . 119-122 Bibliography 135

No. 4.

G. S. SALE : Notes on Horace . . . .137 Wickham's Horace, Vol. II. R. Y. A. PALMER : Horatiana 139 TYBRELL 169 J. A. CROSS : Quotations in the Fourth Eton Latin Grammar, Ed. 2. E. A. Gospel .142 ; SONNENSCHEIN 172 P. SCHWENKE : Apparatus Criticus to I Notes on the Constitution of Athens. Cicero. N.D 143 Emendations, pp. 175-182 : Jebb's Philoctetes. A. S. . . . • . .147 Alphabet, p. 183 : Gwatkin and Shuckburgh's Edition of Un-Aristotelian Words and Phrases. ' Aeschines in Ctesiphonta.' J. H. H. RICHARDS, J. B. MAYOR, A. WRIGHT 149 PLATT 184 Bywater's Ethics. H. RICHARDS . . . 152 New Fragments of the Antiope. W. Aristotle's Constitution of Athens. W. HEADLAM, J. E. SANDYS, R. GARNETT . 185 'L. NEWMAN 155 Notes. C. 53. The huurrfrai. W. R. HARDIE 164 Aen. VI. 743. R. WHITELAW . . .186 C. 44. The Deposition of Pericles. E. Soph. Aj. 651. G. E. MAKINDIN . . 186 C. MARCHANT 165 Correspondence. C. 4. Constitution of Draco. J. W. J. P. MAHAFFY 186 HEADLAM 166 Monthly Record 187 C. 22, 23, 28. L. WHIBLEY .... 168 ! Summaries 189 C. 25. Themistocles. G. F. HILL . . 169 | Bibliography 191 C. 52. The Eleven 169

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 TABLE OF CONTENTS. No. 5.

W. R. HABDIE: Allusive Language in Notes. Greek Lyric Poetry ...... 193 Soph. Aj. 651, again. R. WHITELAW 230 F. CARTER : Notes on Thucydides IV. . 195 Swallows in the House. J. G. FRAZER, E. H. MILES : Latin Infinitive Passive. 198 D'ARCY W. THOMPSON, C. HAEPER 230 P. SCHWENKE : Apparatus Criticus on Arist. Post. Anal. I. 5, 2. C. S. Cicero. N. D 200 ADAMSON and H. RICHARDS . . .231 Sonnenschein's Rudens. ROBINSON ELLIS 205 Verg. Georg. I. 316. H. Richards . 232 Goetz' Miles Gloriosus. R. Y. TYRRELL 206 Verg. Aen. VI. 567. G. Me N. R. . 232 Benoist's Virgil. T. E. Page .... 208 Antiope. M. R. JAMES 232 Jacobs' Fables of Aesop. F. B. JEVONS 212 Hiberno-Saxon Symbol for Autem. Hilgard's Greek Grammarians. E. G. J. E. SANDYS 232 SIHLER • 215 v€P6. J. B. BURY 232 Blass, Pronunciation of Ancient Greek, Correspondence. English Translation. B. I. WHEELER 217 CECIL TORR 232 Wharton's Etyma Latina. H. D. DAB- Monthly Record 233 BISHIRE 217 Tozer's Islands of the Aegean. W. R. Merriam's Telegraphing among the PATON 237 Ancients. J. G. . . 220 Theatre of Megalopolis. L. DYER, E. Three Elementary Books on Greek . . 220 SELLERS 238 The Constitution of Athens :— Re-excavated Relics. F. HAVEEPIELD . 240 Attic Phratries. W. R. PATON . . 221 Acquisitions of the British Museum. The Authorship. L. WHIBLEY . . . 223 A. S. M 241 Miscellaneous. E. S. THOMPSON, W. A Vase-painting. W. WATKISS LLOYD 241 WYSE, H. RICHARDS 224 A Carthaginian Ambassador in a Greek Un-Aristotelian Words. E. J. CHIN- Inscription. J. HOSKYNS ABRAHALL . 242 NOCK 229 Summaries of Periodicals 242 Bibliography 243 No. 6. J. A. CROSS : Hours of the Day in the On the Use of the Hiatus. J. W. Fourth Gospel 245 HEADLAM 270 R. WHITELAW and F. CARTER : On Some Un-Aristotelian Words and Phrases. Uses of the Aorist Participle . . . 248 H. RICHARDS 272 F. G. PLAISTOWE : On Sonant Z . . . 253 Emendations by J. R. WARDALE . . 273 Campbell's Aeschylus. A. W. POLLARD 255 Emendations by Foreign Scholars . . 274 Dakyns' Translation of Xenophon. E. Further Notes by W. WYSE, E. S. S. SHUCKBUEGH ... • 257 THOMPSON, C. TOEE, C. SMITH . . 274 Aristophanes' Use of Prepositions. E. Notes. C. MAECHANT 258 A Carthaginian Ambassador. C. T.. 278 Some French Books on Palaeography. Plato Rep. 532 B. E. J. PALMES . . 278 E. MAUNDE THOMPSON 261 Arist. Ran. 1433. H. RICHARDS . . 278 Stowasser's Dunkle Wbrter. H. NETTLE- Hor. Ep. I. ii. 31. A. S. 0 278 SHIP 263 Ov. R.A. 207. E. D. S 278 Studies by Studemund's Pupils. E. A. Ov. Trist. III. xi. 33. P. SANDFORD 279 SoNNENSCHEIN 264 The Exile of Juvenal. H. A. STRONG 279 Montague's Selected Letters of Cicero. Wilkins' Roman Literature. W. K. F. F. ABBOTT 266 CLEMENT 279 Stephenson's Livy, Book XXVII. M. T. Danger of Quoting from Memory. G. TATHAM • . . 266 E. JEANS 279 Dr. Weymouth on the Greek Aorist and Archaeology. Perfect 267 The Harbours of Carthage. C. TOEK 280 Correspondence. Theatre of Megalopolis 284 Dr. Verrall on the Fire-Signals in the Summaries 285 Agamemnon 269 Monthly Record 287 The Constitution of Athens. | Summaries of Periodicals 289 New Readings of the MSS. F. G. Bibliography 290 KJSNYON 269

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 Vl THE CLASSICAL REVIEW. No 7. A. E. HOUSMAN : Adversaria Ortho- Etienne, La Langue Franchise. F. graphica 293 SPENCER 329 R. SEYMOUB CONWAY : Origin of the Goyau's Chronologie de l'Empire Romain. Latin Gerund and Gerundive . . . .296 E. G. HARDY . . 329 J. P. Postgate ; Latin Future Infinitive Perry's Greek Literature. B. PEEEIN . 330 in -turum • . . 301 Fagan's British Museum 331 F. T. TABBBLL : Greek Deliberative Sub- Greek Elegiacs. L. CAMPBELL .... 331 junctive in Relative Clauses .... 302 'A.6rjvaiu>v IIoA.iT€ia. P. SCHWBNKE : Apparatus Criticus on Recent Literature. F. G. K. . . . 332 Cicero. N. D 302 A Reply to Professor Gomperz. H. Bury's Nemean Odes. J. E. SANDYS . . 305 RICHAEDS 333 Merry's Edition of the Birds. R. Y. Further Notes by H. RICHARDS, W. TYEBELL 309 WYSE, E. S. THOMPSON, E. POSTE . . 334 Demosthenes De Corona, by F. Blass. Notes. S. H. BUTCHER 309 Pindar Nem. IX. 22. A. C. PEARSON 337 Plutarch's Lives of Galba and Otho, by Virg. Aen. VI. 567, III. 702. A. E. G. Hardy. H. HOLDEN .... 315 PLATT 337 Epigrams of Crinagoras. J. H. WEIGHT 317 Hor. C. II. xi. 21. P. SANDFOED . . 337 Krumbacher's History of Byzantine Hor. Ep. I. vii. 29. H. A. STRONG . 337 Literature. J. B. BURY 318 Ncpo. W. LEAF .338 Rossbach and Westphal's Greek Metres. Reply to Professor Clement. A. S. C. B. HEEBERDEN 320 WILKINS . 338 Schoell's Casina. E. A. SONNENSCHEIN . 321 Telegraphing among the Ancients. Peskett's Caesar B.C., Book I. B. A. C. MEREIAM, J. G., & W. R. PATON 338 PEEEIN 324 Split Totems. A. PLATT 339 Whibley's Livy, Book V. H. M. Archaeology. STEPHENSON 325 Monthly Record. H. B. WALTEES . 339 Lindsay's Juvenal. M. H. MORGAN . • 326 Acquisitions of the British Museum Scott's Translation of Calpurnius. E. (1-5), A. S. MURRAY, (6) C. SMITH . 341 D. A. MORSHEAD 327 The Greek Theatre. A. C. MERRIAM, Autenrieth's Homeric Dictionary. T. MISS SELLERS, EDITOE 343 D. SEYMOUR • 328 A Megaric Inscription. M. L. EAELE 344 Gelzer's Georgius Cyprius. F. HAVER- Summaries of Periodicals 345 FIELD ... • . . . • 328 Bibliography 347 No. 8. EDITORIAL 349 Allen's Notes on Greek MSS. E. M. T. 387 E. L. HICKS, H. JACKSON, R. ELLIS, on Bayfield's Alcestis. W. S. HADLEY . . 387 HERODAS • 350 Notes. L. CAMPBELL, on the Papyrus Fragment ; Aesch. Agam. 557, 1118. 1125, 1227. of the Phaedo 363 ' E. A. L. M. and H. L. B 388 A. C. CLARK : The Library of J. G. Aesch. Supp. 819, 970. C. J. BEENNAN 388 Graevius 365 Soph. Trach. 504. L. H. S 389 W. M. LINDSAY : Latin Accentuation . 373 Plut. Them. 21. H. RICHAEDS . . .389 J. STRACHAN : Ambulare 377 Inscribed Whorl from Troy. A. H. F. W. THOMAS : Non, Noenum, NwSwos 377 SAYCE 389 Ellis's Noctes Manilianae. E. A. SONNEN- ; Herodas IV. A. S. MURRAY . . .389 SC'HEIN 379 Thuc. IV. 64. G. E. MABINDIN . . 389 Hessels' Latin Anglo-Saxon Glossary. : Liddell and SCOTT S.V. orpai/u.a. C. H. NETTLESHIP • . . 382 TOER 390 Seyffert's Dictionary of Classical An- Archaeology. tiquities. A. S. WILKINS 384 j Monthly Record. H. B. WALTERS . 390 Weidner's Juvenal. E. G. HARDY . . 385 : Notes from Italy and Greece. H. A. V. Henry's Comparative Grammar. P. TUBBS • 393 GILES 387 Summaries • 394 Paul's History of Language. H. D. Periodicals 395 DAEBISHIRE 387 ; Bibliography (English) 396

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 TABLE OF CONTENTS. vu

No. 9.

PAGE E. B. CLAPP, on Mr. Bayfield's Doctrine Hild's Juvenal VII. H. N.. . • . . 429 of the Conditional Sentence . . . .397 Foerster on the Physiognomia of E. W. B. NICHOLSON : Notes on Some Apulehis. H. N 429 Fragments of Menander 399 Clarke's Evagoras of Isocrates. E. S. L. CAMPBELL : Notes on the Antiope . 401 THOMPSON 429 W. M. LINDSAY : Latin Accentuation Sabrinae Corolla, ed. 4. E. D. S. . . 430 (concluded) 402 Georges' Lexicon der Lateinischen Wort- P. SCHWENKE : Apparatus Criticus to formen. H. N 431 the Natura Deorum (continued) . . 408 Graves' Burial Customs of the Ancient Homeric Scholia (Schrader's Porphyrius Greeks 431 on the Odyssey and Nicole's Geneva Notes. Scholia on the Iliad). W. LEAF . .412 M. W. HUMPHREYS : iroAAoi KCU aAAoi 431 Plummer's Epistles of St. James and St. C. H. KEENE : Scholia on the Electra Jude. J. B. MAYOR 414 of Euripides • .... 432 Wilcken's Greek Palaeography. E. M. C. M. MULVANY : Notes on Proper- THOMPSON 417 tius 433 Graux, Facsimiles of Greek MSS. in G. Me. N. RUSHFORTH : Tisidium . . 433 Spain. E. M. THOMPSON 419 J. E. SANDYS : Pronunciation of Liebenam on the History and Organiza- Suidas 434 tion of the Roman Collegia. E. G. F. W. THOMAS : Suum Cuique . . . 434 HABDY • . . 420 H. RICHARDS : Herod. VIII. Ill . .434 Freeman's History of Sicily Vols. I. Archaeology. and II. A. HOLM 423 Monthly Record 434 Smith's Dictionary of Antiquities. New Theatre at Megapolis. C. T. . . .437 Edition. J. E. SANDYS 425 Summaries of Periodicals ...... 437 Kempf's Valerius Maximus. H. T. PECK 428 Bibliography (Foreign) . , . 440

No. 10.

J. ADAM : The Myth in Plato's Politicus 445 G. M. Edwards's Iliad XXIII. A. F. W. WALKER : Philological Notes . . 446 PLATT 476 C. A. M. FENNELL : Brugmann's Theory Stein's Herodotus VII. R. W. MACAN 477 of the Nasaiis Sonans 451 Xenophon's Memorabilia by Brietenbach L. CAMPBELL : On the Papyrus Fragment and Mttcke. P.G. ; by J. Marshall. of the Phaedo 454 E. S. SHUCKBURGH 477 R. ELLIS : On the Epoch of Herodas . . 457 Holden's Cyropaedia. E. G. COY . . . 478 P. SCHWENKE : Apparatus Criticus to the Stone's Anabasis IV. E. S. SHUCK- Natura Deorum (concluded) .... 458 BURGH 478 Wilamo witz-Moellendorf£' s Her akles. Dowdall's Hellenica I. A. H. COOKE . 478 N. WEDD 461 Pearson's Fragments of Zeno and Clean- Recent Literature on the 'A&jraiW thes. H. N. FOWLER 479 ITo\tma. H. RICHARDS 465 Notes. Cambridge Texts and Studies. Vol. I. Additional Fragments of Herodas. Part I. A. PLUMMER 468 F. G. KENYON 480 Dyer's Studies of the Gods in Greece. Corrected Readings of Papyrus. F. W. W. FOWLER 470 G. KENYON 482 Keil's Edition of Varro's Res Rusticae. The name Herodas in an Egyptian In- H. NETTLESHIP 474 scription. F. G. KENYON .... 483 Friedrich's edition of Cicero's Opera Notes on Herodas by \V. R. PATON Rhetorica. Vol. II. A. S. WILKINS 475 and A. C. PEARSON 483

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174 THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

PAGE PAGE Aristophanes Ach. 920—925. C. J. Plin. N. H. XXXV. 132. E. F. BBENNAN ; 484 BENSON 486 Ov. Trist. III. P. SAKDFORD .... 485 Macmillan Lekythos. WATKISS LLOYD 486 Juv. Sat. XI. 121. JOHN E. B. Ernst Curtius, Die Stadtgeschichte MAYOB ... -...,.... 485 der Athen. E. SELLERS 486 Scrupuli. H. D. DABBISHIRE . . . 485 Summaries of Periodicals 487 Archaeology. Bibliography 490 Monthly Record . . 485

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.76, on 26 Sep 2021 at 11:04:21, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00167174