Scottish Silver Volume 2

Compendium of Scottish Silver volume 2

by Rodney R. Dietert, Ph. D. Janice M. Dietert, M.A.S.S. Main CoverMain CoverPhoto: Photo: (left) AA view1695ca of Edinburghminiature CastleThistle taken Mug fromby John the Seatoun (Edinburgh,Princes maker’s St. Gardens mark only) below. is illustratedPhotograph next by Janiceto a fully M. markedDietert. full size Thistle Mug from 1701/02 Edinburgh. The latter is by Edward Penman with James Penman, his father, as the assay master (right). Photograph by Janice Dietert.

by Rodney R. Dietert, Ph. D. Janice M. Dietert, M.A.S.S. The Internet-First University Press Ithaca NY 14853

Printed in the United States of America ii Compendium of Scottish Silver

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Disclaimer: Any errors within the book are solely the responsibility of the authors and in no way reflect on the individuals or institutions who were supportive of this endeavor.

The authors are deeply indebted to Henry Steuart Fothringham, Historian of the Incorporation of

Goldsmiths for Edinburgh, and George Dalgleish, Curator, National Museums of Scotland for their encouragement, sharing of notes, devotion of time, and direct assistance in the collection of data for this book. This book would not have been possible without their generous help. Mary

Grotrian of The Incorporation of Goldsmiths, City of Edinburgh, Irene Mackay of the National

Museums of Scotland and Robert Barker, researcher, also provided much appreciated support.

We express appreciation to Stephen Clarke and Jeanne Sloane of Christie’s and Peter Waldron and John Culme of Sotheby’s for allowing us access to a century of auction house records, lot descriptions and archival photographs. At Colonial Williamsburg, USA, John Hyman (Associate

Curator) and John Davis, Head Curator, came to our assistance at key times. Anonymous collectors in Canada, Scotland and the U.S. were instrumental in this project by providing both details of their collections as well as photographs for use. Numerous silver dealers provided exceptional aid including John H. Bourdon-Smith and his family, James McConnaughy and Bard

Langstaff of S.J. Shrubsole, Inc, Ben Goodwin (Goodwin’s Antiques, Edinburgh), Edward

Munves (James Robinson, Inc., NY), Nicholas Shaw, Alastair Dickenson, Brand Inglis and

George Schrager, (Shredds Antiques, London). We particularly thank Professor Emeritus J.

Robert Cooke, former Dean of Faculty of Cornell University and a steward of our university silver (Cornell University Mace Bearer) for his vision of free-access publishing and for the opportunity to contribute to this endeavor.

i Compendium of Scottish Silver

ii Compendium of Scottish Silver

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Volume 2

Miscellaneous ...... 291 Mugs ...... 307 General Mugs ...... 309 Thistle Mugs/Cups...... 323 Mustard Pots ...... 337 Porringers and Bleeding Bowls ...... 341 Quaichs ...... 345 Salts...... 361 Salvers...... 373 Sauceboats...... 411 Strainers ...... 419 Tankards...... 425 Tazzas...... 435 Tea ...... 441 Caddies ...... 443 Kettles, Stands and Trays...... 449 Teapots...... 455 Tea Services...... 509 Toast and Bannock Racks ...... 517 Urns...... 521 Wine...... 527 Coasters ...... 528 Funnels...... 530 Funnels Stands...... 532 Cups and Goblets...... 535 Labels...... 539 Brief Glossary and Explanations ...... xxiii Works Cited...... xxxv

iii Compendium of Scottish Silver

iv Compendium of Scottish Silver

Guide to the Compendium

This collection of more than 5,000 listings of extant Scottish silver was compiled over a period of two decades via the resources of the Cornell University library system and through the generous assistance of numerous silver dealers, historians, collectors, museum curators and other experts. While the focus was placed initially on Edinburgh silver, there are many important provincial silver examples included among the listings. Despite obvious limitations, we believe this compendium is one of the most comprehensive inventories of extant Scottish silver compiled

LQRQHUHVRXUFH:LWKWKHHDV\DFFHVVRIWKLVERRNYLDWKH,QWHUQHWDQG&RUQHOO¶V'VSDFHZH hope it will prove to be a useful guide for researchers, dealers and collectors as well as an inspiration for those who appreciate the Scottish goldsmiths and marvel at their wares.

Silver items are listed by category (e.g. bowls) and subcategory (e.g. sugar bowls) in chronological order. For categories with only a few listings, they are likely to be found within

WKH³0LVFHOODQHRXV´VHFWLRQ,QPRVWFDVHVWKHOLVWLQJLVDYHUEDWLPH[WUDFWIURPWKHPXVHXP catalog, auction record or magazine advertisement, etc. However, in several cases, the maker designation has been altered from an auction listing to reflect more recent advances in

DWWULEXWLRQV HJ-DPHV0LWFKHOOVXEVWLWXWHGIRUWKH(GLQEXUJKPDUN,0ILJXUHEHWZHHQDQG

-DPHV0LWFKHOVRQVXEVWLWXWHGIRUDWWULEXWLRQVWR-RKQ0DLQ RUPRUHUHFHQWFRQFHUQRYHU

SUHYLRXVPDUNDWWULEXWLRQV HJGLVWLQJXLVKLQJEHWZHHQ:LOOLDP'HPSVWHU¶VDQG:LOOLDP

'DYLH¶VYDULRXVSXQFKHV ,QPDQ\FDVHVWKHUHZDVQRGHVFULSWLRQRIDQLWHPEH\RQGDPDNHU year, and category. However, for some items (e.g. those currently in museums), the source listing itself may be used to obtain greater detail about a specific piece of interest.

v Compendium of Scottish Silver

When the same silver item was found in multiple sources, the sources were combined under one

listing (e.g. multiple shops in sequence, or auctions and then museums, etc.). In cases where two

or more items listed in different sources cannot be distinguished with certainty between them and

may be the same piece, the first listing appears in normal text while the subsequent similar

listings appear in italics. These may or may not be separate pieces and the user should be

cautious. This is particularly a problem for Scottish provincial pieces that have incomplete

descriptions and lack an annual date letter. Reference texts used in the compendium are

abbreviated in the listing. Full bibliographic information follows at the end of the book for these

sources. Journals and auctions are listed with as much information as was available. Even

though the citations are as complete as possible, some may inevitably prove problematic (via

errors in original transcription) or be difficult to pursue. We apologize in advance where this

may be the case.

vi Compendium of Scottish Silver

Abbreviations Used:

# in an auction catalog = lot

# in a book = the plate designation

³ LQFKHV appx = appendix ca = approximate di = diameter d = pennyweights (20 per troy ounce) g or gm = grams ht = height

PP PDNHU¶VPDUN oz = troy ounces p = page vol = volume (of a journal or multi-volume text)

vii Compendium of Scottish Silver

TIME-LINE OF SCOTTISH SILVER FORMS: EARLIEST APPEARANCES

This time-line is offered solely as a guide based on current surviving pieces found in the database. These pieces are not necessarily the earliest actually produced. In a few cases entries are included and specified for pieces known to have existed in the past based on detailed records (e.g. patron accounts, etc.) even when the continued existence of the piece is uncertain. Certainly, earlier pieces may come to light in coming years. We hope this timeline will encourage a continued examination of Scottish silver style development and innovation. We have attempted to provide both Edinburgh and provincial examples whenever possible.

Pre-1500

0D]HU²VFD---The Bute Mazer

Probable Scottish Mace--- Faculty of Arts, University of St Andrews

16th Century

&XSZLWK0DNHU¶V0DUNVFD7KH0HWKXQH&XSSRVVLEOHE\-RKQ9DLWFK

0DUNHG 0D]HU 7KH :DWVRQ 0D]HU SRVVLEO\ $GDP /HLV VV7KH6W 0DU\¶V0D]HU$OH[DQGHU$XFKLQOHFNIROORZHGE\WKH7XOORFKDQG*DOORZD\0D]HUV -DPHV*UD\&DQRQJDWH

6FRWWLVK&URZQUHZRUNLQJE\-RKQ0RVPDQDQG$GDP/HLVRIDQHDUOLHUFURZQ

6FRWWLVK6FHSWUHUHFDVWDQGDXJPHQWHGE\$GDP/HLV(GLQEXUJK

0DUNHG&RPPXQLRQ&XS+HQU\7KRPVRQH(GLQEXUJK RULJLQDOO\DVHFXODUYHVVHO

(ZHU-DPHV&RN,(GLQEXUJK

6HDOWRS6SRRQ ³7KH&XQQLQJKDP´ FD:LOOLDP&RN(GLQEXUJK

'LVFHQG6SRRQV*HRUJH+HULRW,,(GLQEXUJK

%DSWLVPDO%DVLQ-DPHV&UDZIRUG(GLQEXUJK RULJLQDOO\DVHFXODUYHVVHO

viii Compendium of Scottish Silver

1600s and 1610s

Slip-top Spoon --- 1609-10ca, Gilbert Kirkwood, Edinburgh.

The Heriot Cup (Nautilus cup) --- 1611-13 Robert Dennistoun, Edinburgh.

Horse Racing Prize---1617ca The Lanark Bell maker Hugh Lindsay, deacon Robert Dennistoun

All-Silver Mazer (bowl-type)---1619ca Thomas Cleghorne I, Deacon James Dennistoun, Edinburgh. (Documentary evidence shows that all-silver mazers existed at least as HDUO\ DV 7KH RWKHU H[WDQW H[DPSOH LV WKH 6W /HRQDUG¶V 0D]HU th-century, standing-type), University of St. Andrews.

City Mace (Edinburgh)---1617ca George Robertson I

1620s and 1630s

Wine Cup---1630ca Thomas Cleghorne, Edinburgh

Coronation Items---1633ca Gold Ampulla, used at the Scottish Coronation of Charles I, unmarked.

Bread Plates (Trinity Church) --- 1633ca Thomas Kirkwood, Edinburgh.

Coconut Cup --- 1637-39 Andrew Dennistoun, Edinburgh.

1640s and 1650s

:LQH)XQQHO²FD$GDP/DPEPDNHU¶VPDUNRQO\

6ZHHWPHDW'LVKRU:LQH7DVWHU7KRPDV&OHJKRUQH(GLQEXUJK

3XULWDQ6SRRQFD$OH[DQGHU6FRWW ZLWKVSRRQRIRIXQGHVLJQDWHGIRUP

Puritan Spoon --- 1651-53 or 1657-59 George Cleghorne, Edinburgh.

&RXUWRI6HVVLRQ0DFH GDWHG ²(GZDUG&OHJKRUQH $QGUHZ%XUUHOO'HDFRQ

1660s-1670s

7DQNDUG SHJ E\(GZDUG&OHJKRUQH,

4XDLFK IXOO\PDUNHG ²(GZDUG&OHJKRUQH,

ix Compendium of Scottish Silver

Set of Trefid spoons---1665-80 marks of Edward Cleghorne I and Alexander Reid (one maker, one deacon).

7UXPSHWV²FDE\7KRPDV0RQFXU*ODVJRZ$QGFD5REHUW%URFN

TazzasV:LOOLDP/DZPDNHU$OH[DQGHU5HLGGHDFRQ V$OH[DQGHU5HLGPDNHUDQGDOVRDVGHDFRQV$OH[DQGHU6FRWW

&DSVWDQ6DOWFD3DWULFN*DLUG\QH6W$QGUHZV

'LQQHU3ODWHVFD(GLQEXUJKE\$OH[DQGHU6FRWWGHDFRQ(GZDUG&OHJKRUQH WKLV EDVHGRQGRFXPHQWDU\HYLGHQFHRQO\WKHSUHVHQWZKHUHDERXWVRIWKHVHSODWHVKDYHQRW EHHQWUDFHG

,QNKRUQRU:ULWLQJHTXLSDJHFD7KRPDV&OHJKRUQH(GLQEXUJK

7ZR+DQGOHG3RUULQJHU:LOOLDP/DZ PDNHUDQGGeacon)

1680s

*RXUG&XSFD7KRPDV&OHJKRUQH,,(GLQEXUJK

7ZRKDQGOHG&XSDQG&RYHU$OH[DQGHU5HLG(GLQEXUJK

&DVWHU7KRPDV

)ODJRQ-RKQ/DZ(GLQEXUJK

7HD&DGGLHFD-DPHV&RFNEXUQ(GLQEXUJK

3DWFK%R[5REHUW%URFN*ODVJRZ

7REDFFR%R[E\5REHUW%URFN*ODVJRZ

3DLURI7DQNDUGV³7KH/\RQ7DQNDUGV´-DPHV&RFNEXUQ(GLQEXUJK

6DQFWXV%HOO²=DFFKDULXV0HOOLQXV(GLQEXUJK

7XPEOHU&XS²V7KRPDV0RQFXU *ODVJRZ 5REHUW*DLUG\QH 3HUWK 7XPEOHU&XS-DPHV3HQPDQ(GLQEXUJK 7XPEOHU&XS-DPHV/XNH*ODVJRZ

%HDNHU GDWHG E\ -DPHV 3HQPDQ 3DLU 7KLVWOH VKDSHGWZRRWKHUSURYLQFLDO EHDNHUVOLNHO\HDUOLHU0DGHDV&RPPXQLRQ&XSVRI/HVOLH

&KDOLFH³7KH)RUV\WK´FD=DFFKDULDV0HOOLQXV(GLQEXUJK x Compendium of Scottish Silver

Saucepan --- 1688/89 George Scott, Edinburgh.

Bleeding Bowl ---1689/90 by James Penman, Edinburgh. Circular bowl, trefoil handle pierced with clovers.

1690s

Table Knives --- 1690ca, JS, Edinburgh.

&RQGLPHQWRU&KLOG¶V6SRRQFD*HRUJH

3XQFK%RZO³7KH%UXFH%RZO´5REHUW%UXFH(GLQEXUJK

&KDPEHUVWLFNV-DPHV3HQPDQ(GLQEXUJK

&DVWHUV VHWRIWKUHH $QGUHZ/DZ(GLQEXUJK

7KLVWOH0XJV SDLU E\-DPHV&RFNEXUQ 7KLVWOH0XJ$QGUHZ/DZ

'LVK5LQJ-DPHV&RFNEXUQ

,QGLYLGXDO6DOW FLUFXODU 5REHUW%URFN*ODVJRZ $OVR,QGLYLGXDO6DOW:LOOLDP*HG(GLQEXUJK

7ZRKDQGOHG7KLVWOH&XS(GZDUG3HQPDQ(GLQEXUJK

7DEOHVWLFNV SDLU -DPHV3HQPDQ(GLQEXUJK

7DEOHIRUNV² $OH[DQGHU .LQFDLG VDPH \HDU 5REHUW %UXFH(GLQEXUJK 7UHILGV ERWK originally large sets, and one by Thomas Cleghorne in the National Museums of Scotland.

:DOO6FRQFHV-DPHV3HQPDQ 3DLU

Monteith --- 1698/99 Colin McKenzie, Edinburgh.

'RJQRVH VSRRQ (GLQEXUJK QR PDNHU¶V PDUN SUREDEO\ *HRUJH

1700s

7RW&XSFD$OH[DQGHU)RUEHV(GLQEXUJK

0DUURZ6SRRQ$OH[DQGHU.LQFDLG

6LOYHUPRXQWHG0LUURUSUREDEO\-DPHV3HQPDQ(GLQEXUJK

+DQRYHULDQ6SRRQV&ROLQ0F.HQ]LH(GLQEXUJK

xi Compendium of Scottish Silver

Hanoverian Forks----1702/03 Colin McKenzie, Edinburgh

Jug --- 1701/02 Thomas Ker, Edinburgh.

%DUEHU¶V%RZODQG(ZHU7KRPDV.HU(GLQEXUJK

&KLOG¶V5DWWOHFD5REHUW,QJOLV(GLQEXUJK

7RLOHW6HUYLFH³7KH.HLU´&ROLQ0F.HQ]LH(GLQEXUJK

&DVNHWFD7KRPDV.HU(GLQEXUJK

+DVK6SRRQ-RKQ/XNH-U*ODVJRZ

2IILFHU¶V%DGJH ,QFRUSRUDWLRQRI6XUJHRQV FD$OH[DQGHU.LQFDLG(GLQEXUJK

6SRXW&XS:DOWHU6FRWW(GLQEXUJK

6HDO%R[E\-RKQ/XNH,,*ODVJRZ

6DOYHUVPDNHUQRWVWDWHG(GLQEXUJK RULJLQDOO\+RSHWRXQFROOHFWLRQ

1710s

3LQFXVKLRQVLOYHUPRXQWHGFD5REHUW%UXFH(GLQEXUJK

&RIIHHSRW&ROLQ0F.HQ]LH SDUWRIVHW

+RWPLON-XJ&ROLQ0F.HQ]LH(GLQEXUJK $OVR0XQJR

7HDSRW &ROLQ 0F.HQ]LH DQG &ROLQ &DPSEHOO ERWK DSSUHQWLFHV RI -DPHV 3HQPDQ

7HD&DGG\FD-RKDQ*RWKHOI%LOVLQJV*ODVJRZ

7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHG&ROLQ0F.HQ]LH

6LOYHU6ZRUG+LOWFD+HQU\%HWKXQH(GLQEXUJK

)ODVNFD$OH[DQGHU.LQFDLG(GLQEXUJK

7HDSRWVWDQG-DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ(GLQEXUJK

6XJDU%R[:LOOLDP$\WRXQ$QRWKHUE\+HQU\%HWKXQH

&RYHUHG6XJDU%RZO-RKQ6HDWRXQ

6WUDZEHUU\'LVK+HQU\%HWKXQH(GLQEXUJK$QGVHHFD xii Compendium of Scottish Silver

Snuffer Stand---1719/20 Henry Bethune

Egg or Barrel-Shaped Teapot---1719/20 Henry Bethune (egg) and Colin McKenzie (barrel) (both James Penman apprentices).

1720s

Chocolate Pot --- 1720/21 Patrick Murray, Edinburgh.

Octagonal Teapot --- 1723/24 William Aytoun, Edinburgh.

Desert Spoons --- 1722/23 Kenneth McKenzie, Edinburgh.

Use of Wavy Border, Molded Edge, Bowls and Stands---1721/22 James Mitchelson-Private Collection UK, then 1723/24 James Ker; then 1725/26 James Ker (James Penman lineage).

Spirit Burner --- 1724/25 James Mitchelson, Edinburgh.

Strawberry Dish ---1725ca, by Robert Luke, Glasgow. (Edinburgh 1718-19)

Snuff Box --- Glasgow, 1725ca, Johan Got-helf-Bilsings, Glasgow.

Tea Kettle, Lamp and Stand---1725/26 James Mitchelson.

Snake-Handled Tea Urn---1723/24 William Aytoun, Edinburgh

Use of Curved Spout---1725/26 James Mitchelson (kettle) and Edward Penman (teapot) (apprentice of James Penman); 1726/27 James Tait

Three-Footed Sugar Bowl---1726/27 James Ker, Edinburgh

Pair of Branches for Candlesticks --- 1728/29 James Ker, Edinburgh.

Dry Mustard Pot --- 1729/30 William Aytoun, Edinburgh.

6TXDUH6DOYHUPDNHU¶VPDUNXQFOHDU(GLQEXUJK

1730s

Dessert Knives --- 1730ca, unmarked, Edinburgh.

Bun Pepper --- 1730/31 William Aytoun, Edinburgh.

Double-Lipped Sauce Boats --- 1730/31 James Mitchelson, Edinburgh.

xiii Compendium of Scottish Silver

Punch Ladle --- 1733/34 William Aytoun, Edinburgh.

Cream boats---1733/34 James Ker and Ebenezer Oliphant, 1735/36 William Aytoun

(YHUWHG5LP&KDVHG6XJDU%RZOV²-DPHV.HU IRXUIRRWHGSDUWRIVHW QRWHDOVR D-DPHV7DLWERZOWKUHHIRRWHGULPIODWHYHUWHGVKDSHGEXWXQGHFRUDWHG

Urn Stand --- 1735/36 James Ker, Edinburgh.

7HDVSRRQV6FRWVILGGOHSDWWHUQFD -RKQ5ROOR(GLQEXUJK

.HWWOH6HW(TXLSSHGIRU6LOYHU7DEOH-DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ

Taperstick --- 1736/37 James Ker, Edinburgh.

Gold Teapot --- 1736 James Ker, Edinburgh.

&UXHW)UDPH:LOOLDP0DUVKDOO,(GLQEXUJK1RWHWKLVPDNHUKDGDQXQWLPHO\ death shorten his career.

6QXIIHU7UD\/DXUHQFH2OLSKDQW(GLQEXUJK

Burgess-Ticket Box --- 1736/37 John Rollo, Edinburgh.

*UDY\%RDWFDPDNHU¶VPDUN5& possibly Edinburgh.

Cake Basket---1739/40 James Ker; also 1740/41 by James Ker and 1740ca by James Ker

Punch Strainer --- probably late 1730s William Aytoun, Edinburgh.

1740s

/LEUDU\ /DPS :LOOLDP $\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK DVVD\PDVWHU 'DYLG 0LWFKHOO )HE 6HSW

Traveling Canteen --- 1740/41 Ebenezer Oliphant. Edinburgh.

,QNVWDQG5REHUW*RUGRQ

8VHRI'ROSKLQ +DQGOH:' :LOOLDP 'HPSVWHURU:LOOLDP'DYLH RQDFUHDP boat.

8VHRI$UWLFKRNH)LQDO:LOOLDP$\WRXQFD-DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ

8VHRI%LUG6SRXWFD-DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ WHDSRW

&KLOG V5DWWOHFE\-DPHV*OHQ*ODVJRZ HDUOLHVWSURYLQFLDO

0DULQH7KHPHG+ROORZZDUH²:' SUREDEO\:LOOLDP'HPSVWHU Cakebasket. xiv Compendium of Scottish Silver

1750s

Tea Vases (pair) --- 1750ca James Glen Glasgow.

Use of Bird Finial---1753/54 Lothian & Robertson (kettle) and Robert Gordon (teapot).

Square Teapot---1753/54 Lothian & Robertson (Robertson trained by Edward Lothian).

1760s Pointed Old English Spoons --- 1763/64 Lothian & Robertson

Soup Tureen---1763/64 Alexander Gairdner (apprenticed to William Aytoun).

Sugar Tongs---1760/61 by Alexander Aitchison I

1770s

Bannock or Toast Rack---1773/74 Patrick Robertson.

Servers/Fish Slices---1778/79 Peter Mathie server, 1780/81 WD probably William Davie Fish Slice

2QVORZ 3DWWHUQ² .HU 'HPSVWHU DOVR :' VFULSW SUREDEO\ IRU William Davie or William Dempster, also one 1783-84 Alexander Gardner.

1780s

Wine Coaster---1781/82 WD for William Davie or William Dempster.

Wine Funnel Stand---1782/83 WD for either William Davie or William Dempster ditto --- 1783-4 by W. & P. Cunningham.

Vase Shaped Sugar---1783/84 WD for William Davie or William Dempster.

xv Compendium of Scottish Silver

xvi Compendium of Scottish Silver

LIST OF PLATES

Front Cover Two thistle mugs. The left is a miniature 1695ca Edinburgh by John Seatoun, PDNHU¶VPDUNRQO\7KHULJKWLVDIXOOVL]HGPXJE\(GZDUG3HQPDQ(GLQEXUJK assayed by his father, James Penman. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

PLATES

%DVNHWV$FDNHEDVNHWE\: VWDU 'SUREDEO\:LOOLDP'HPSVWHU(GLQEXUJK Courtesy of a private collector, photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

%HDNHUV3DLURIEHDNHUVE\3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ(GLQEXUJK3KRWRJUDSKFRXUWHV\RI The Maple Swan Collection.

%RZOV7ZRGLVWLQFWO\GLIIHUHQWERZOVWKUHHIRRWHGOLRQ¶VPDVNVXJDUERZOE\ -DPHV.HU(GLQEXUJK OHIW DQGFDFRYHUHGVXJDUERZOE\0LOQH &DPSEHOO*ODVJRZ ULJKW &RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ3KRWRJUDSKE\-DQLFH0'LHWHUW

3XQFK%RZOV$3UHVHQWDWLRQ3XQFK%RZOE\-DPHV0F.D\(GLQEXUJK Photograph courtesy of J. H. Bourdon-Smith, London.

6ORS%RZOV$WKUHHIRRWHGVKDOORZ6ORS RU6XJDU %RZOE\-DPHV7DLW Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

6WUDZEHUU\%RZOV$6WUDZEHUU\%RZO'LVKFDE\*HRUJH&RRSHU$EHUGHHQ Photograph courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

6XJDU%RZOV$6XJDU%RZOE\-DPHV0LWFKHOO(GLQEXUJK&RXUWHV\RI7KH Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

%R[HV$3UHVHQWDWLRQ6QXII%R[E\$OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU(GLQEXUJK WRSDQGERWWRP Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

%URDFKHV%DGJHVDQG0HGDOV$6FKRRO0HGDOE\3HWHU$LNHQ*ODVJRZ IURQWDQG EDFN &RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ3KRWRJUDSKE\-DQLFH0'LHWHUW

&DQGOHVWLFNV$SDLURI7DEOHVWLFNVE\-DPHV.HU(GLQEXUJK&RXUWHV\RI7KH Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

&DVWHUV$Q2FWDJRQDO&DVWHUPDGH)DOORIE\-DPHV.HU (GZDUG3HQPDQDVVD\HU Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

&KXUFK6LOYHU$&RPPXQLRQ&XS VFD E\:LOOLDP/LQGVD\IRUWKH&KXUFKRI Montrose. Photograph courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

&RPPXQLRQ&XSV$&RPPXQLRQ&XSFDE\(GZDUG&OHJKRUQH,(GLQEXUJKIRU6W /HRQDUG¶V&KXUFK6W$QGUHZV3KRWRJUDSKFRXUWHV\RI7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ

xvii Compendium of Scottish Silver

14. Patens. A Communion Paten 1650ca by Edward Cleghorne I, Edinburgh. Photograph courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

15. Plates. The Cruden Communion Bread Plate. Inscribed/dated 1691 for the church at Cruden Bay by GW, Aberdeen. Photograph courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

16. Coffeepots. An Edinburgh example 1759/60 by William Taylor. Courtesy of J.H. Bourdon- Smith, London.

17. Cream and Milk Containers. Group of three Edinburgh Cream Boats of different styles, 1744/45 Edward Lothian (left), 1752/53 Robert Gordon (center), 1741/42 James Weems (right). Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

18. Cruets. A Cruet 1760ca by Milne and Campbell, Glasgow. Photograph courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

19. Cups. A Tumbler Cup 1717-19ca Edinburgh by Henry Bethune. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

20. Dinnerware. One of two Covered Entrée Dishes 1829/30 Marshall and Son, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

21. Dish Crosses and Dish Rings. A Dish Cross 1767/68 by WD probably William Dempster, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

22. Plates. One of a pair of Ashets (meat dishes) 1821/22 by George McHattie, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

23. Flatware. A Scots Fiddle Pattern Tea Straining Spoon 1730ca by William Aytoun, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

24. Fish Slices. A Fish Slice 1807/08 by James Douglas, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

25. Forks. A pair of Trefid Tableforks 1698/99 by Alexander Kincaid, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

26. Knives. Two from a set of twelve 1786-90 Dessert Knives by Patrick Robertson, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

27. Ladles. A pair of Dundee Sauce Ladles 1790ca by James Douglas. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

28. Marrow Spoons and Scoops. Four Marrow Scoops. 1747/48 by Dougal Ged, Edinburgh (top), 1840/41 Bone Marrow Club by WC, Edinburgh, made for Andrew Rutherford (2nd from the top), a twisted stem example 1815/16 by George McHattie, Edinburgh retailed by Heron (next to bottom), and a 1811/12 bulbous connection example by John Ziegler, Edinburgh (bottom). Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert. xviii Compendium of Scottish Silver

29. Skewers. Top - A long skewer from a set of four 1820/21 by George Fenwick Center - a tiny skewer 1800 ca Inverness by Robert Naughton. Bottom - a leaf-decorated Skewer 1828/29 by Heron, Greenock, Glasgow assay. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

30. Spoons. A pair of Decorated Trefid Spoons 1682ca probably by Marion Cleghorne (Edward &OHJKRUQH,¶VZLGRZ (GLQEXUJK&RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ3KRWRJUDSKE\ Janice M. Dietert.

7RQJV7KUHH6XJDU7RQJV/HIW±FDE\3HWHU0DWKLH(GLQEXUJK&HQWHUFD -DPHV(UVNLQH$EHUGHHQ5LJKWFDE\3+3DLVOH\&RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[ Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

0LVFHOODQHRXV7RSOHIWDSDLURI%XFNOHV'XQGHHFDE\:LOOLDP6FRWW&HQWHUOHIW±D &KLOG¶V5DWWOHFDE\-DPHV*OHQRI*ODVJRZ%RWWRPOHIWDSDLURI6SXUV (GLQEXUJKE\-DPHV0F.D\5LJKWFDVWWRS XQPDUNHGEXW/RQGRQPDGH RIWKH*UHHQ Rod of Scotland. This top was made specifically for the Scottish coronation of George IV in 1821. All courtesy of a private collector. Photographs by Janice M. Dietert.

0XJV$(GLQEXUJKH[DPSOHE\3DWULFN0XUUD\,,&RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[ Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

0XJV*HQHUDO$Q(GLQEXUJKH[DPSOHE\'RXJDO*HG&RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[ Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

0XJV7KLVWOH$Q$EHUGHHQH[DPSOHFDE\*HRUJH5REHUWVRQ3KRWRJUDSKFRXUWHV\RI The Maple Swan Collection.

0XVWDUG3RWV7KH(GLQEXUJKH[DPSOHLVE\)UDQFLV+RZGHQ3KRWRJUDSKFRXUWHV\ of The Maple Swan Collection.

4XDLFKV$Q(GLQEXUJKH[DPSOHE\0DWWKHZ&UDZ&RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[ Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

3RUULQJHUVDQG%OHHGLQJ%RZOV$%OHHGLQJ%RZOE\'RXJDO*HG(GLQEXUJK &RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ3KRWRJUDSKE\-DQLFH0'LHWHUW

6DOWV7ZRIURPDVHWRIIRXU(GLQEXUJKKXPDQPDVN SRVVLEO\-DFRELWH VDOWVE\(EHQH]HU 2OLSKDQW &RXUWHV\RIDSULYDWHFROOHFWRU3KRWRJUDSKE\-DQLFH0'LHWHUW

6DOYHUV7KH*ODVJRZH[DPSOHRIFDLVE\5REHUW/XNH&RXUWHV\RI7KH3KRHQL[ Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

6DXFHERDWV7KH(GLQEXUJKH[DPSOHLVE\$OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU&RXUWHV\RI7KH 3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ3KRWRJUDSKE\-DQLFH0'LHWHUW

6WUDLQHUVDQG6TXHH]HUV$QRYDO2UDQJH6WUDLQHUFDE\$GDP*UDKDPRI*ODVJRZ Photograph courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

xix Compendium of Scottish Silver

43. Tankards. An Edinburgh example of 1695/96 by Alexander Forbes. Photograph courtesy of S.J. Shrubsole, NY.

44. Tazzas. An Edinburgh example of 1698/99 by John Yorstoun. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

45. Tea. Some components used in serving tea. A Sugar Bowl 1731/32 by Archibald Ure, a 1740/41 Cream Boat by James Mitchell, a 1739/40 Salver by James Mitchelson and examples of Scots Fiddle teaspoons by Ebenezer Oliphant, James Hewitt and WM. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert

46. Tea Caddies. The Edinburgh example is 1792/93 by William Robertson. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

47. Tea Kettles, Stands and Trays. The Kettle and Stand is 1758/59 by WD probably William Dempster, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

48. Teapots. An Edinburgh example of 1735/36 by James Ker. Photograph courtesy of Asprey, Ltd. London.

49. Tea Service. An assembled Edinburgh Tea Service. Sugar 1730/31, Cream Boat 1735/36, and Salver 1740/41 all by William Aytoun, the teapot is 1734/35 by Hugh Penman. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

7RDVWDQG%DQQRFN5DFNV$Q(GLQEXUJKH[DPSOHPDNHU¶VPDUNREVFXUHG Courtesy of the Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

51. Urns. An Ovoid Shaped Urn with Snake Handles 1738/39 by James Weems, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M. Dietert.

:LQH$:LQH/DEHOE\-+(GLQEXUJK:LQH)XQQHOQRPDNHU¶VPDUN:LQH Funnel Stand, 1810ca James McKay, Edinburgh. All courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photographs by Janice M. Dietert.

53. Wine Cups and Goblets. A Goblet 1807/08 by Robert Gray and Son, Glasgow (Edinburgh assay). Courtesy of J.H. Bourdon-Smith, London.

Back Cover Photograph of the authors by Janice M. Dietert.

xx Miscellaneous

Miscellaneous MISCELLANEOUS

Plate 32. Top Left - A pair of Buckles 1780 by William Scott, Dundee; Center - Child’s Rattle 1745ca by James Glen, Glasgow. Bottom Left - is above a pair of Spurs 1807/08 by James McKay, Edinburgh; Right - the cast top (London made) of the Green Rod of Scotland. This top was made specifically for the Scottish coronation of George IV in 1821. All courtesy of a private collector. Photographs by Janice M Dietert

291 Compendium of Scottish Silver t’s Hospital Trust Lanark Town Council Edinburgh #29 Finlay 1991 Glasgow Exhibition1911 vol I, p123 #21 of On loan to National Museums Scotland #32 Finlay 1991 Perth City Art Gallery and Museums Museum How of How of Edinburgh Private Collection of On loan to National Museums Scotland #22 Finlay 1991 Finlay 1991 #34 Finlay 1991 NA 338 Clayton Dictionary p251 #49 Hearst Collection of County Museum Angeles Los USA Art CA ht#17 Finlay 1991 monogram of Scotland National Museums tilus Cup Herio silver gilt rock crystal, 7” silver Ewer Erskine, Lord Swaythling rgh City Mace City of of the Corporation Lanark Racing Bell MISCELLANEOUS h VA in mm Girdle, Maggie’s Midside Edinburgh The Edinbu EdinburghNau Cup, a Heriot The Edinburgh The Erskine Edinburgh The Methune Cup, ssibly for John ssibly George Robertson I Robertson George Deacon George Crawford Deacon David Palmer Deacon George II Heriot Vaitch 1612 ca Ramsay Thomas 1612 ca Perth Ramsay Thomas 1617 (one year) Perth all in the arrow, a fitted caseaccompany Arrow, 4 medals The Rattray #37 Finlay 1991 appended to the ball medals unmarked of number with a The Rattray Ball, Perth City Art Gallery and 1608-10 Hugh Lindsay Edinburgh The 1608-10 Wilson Adam Edinburg 1611-13 Dennistoun Robert 1565-75 Cok I James YEAR1530-50 ca MAKER Vh po LOCATION DESCRIPTION SOURCE

292 Miscellaneous 1988 1988 ecember 14, ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Christies D Christies #238 Sothebys London October 16, 1961 #156 *DUUDUG¶V/WG Christies January 26, 1972 #126 #126 26, 1972 January Christies 145 #54 1991 Finlay Sommerveil Nicol Messrs. Cunningham Goldsmiths, of Incorporation The Edinburgh Scotland of Museums National 1238 MEQ on Hierarchy Catholic Scottish to loan Scotland of Museums National KJ1970.14 LK89 1961.2232 1961.2232 LK89 UWHULQJ0HOURVHHZHU GHHQ .LQJ¶V&ROOHJH$EHUGHHQ lver mounted mounted lver N and chased cherubs, fruit and scrolling foliage, a vacant cartouche and a and cartouche vacant a foliage, scrolling and fruit cherubs, chased and EDURQ¶VFRURQHW´KWR] ´KWR]EDVLQ´;´R] crest, 5 oz 5d 5 oz crest, Incorporation of Goldsmiths in 1674 in Goldsmiths of Incorporation (GLQEXUJK %DUEHU¶VVKDYLQJEDVLQDQGHZHUDUPVRI+DPLOWRQTXD Edinburgh Edinburgh 1648 Portsburgh of Barony the of Seal Scotland of Museums National Edinburgh Edinburgh the of Clerk Sommerveil Nicol to presented set, writing Traveling OYLOOH $EHUGHHQ 0DFHRI.LQJ¶V&ROOHJH$EHU Deacon George Cleghorne Thomas Cleghorne 1702-04 Thomas Ker Ker 1702-04 Thomas 1701 ca 1701 ca Penman James Edinburgh pierced cresting of cantle the borders, molded plain mirror, Silver-mounted YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1648 dated Dennistoun Andrew LOCATION SOURCE FD 1669 ca :DOWHU0H 1674 Moncur Thomas year) (one Glasgow Trumpet 1675 ca 1686/87 Brock Robert Mellinus Zacharias Edinburgh Glasgow 1695 ca Bell Sanctus Holyrood Trumpet Scott George Edinburgh si horn, Powder UK Collection Private #33 1991 Finlay UK Collection Private 1698/99 1700 ca Clerk William Gairdyne Patrick Glasgow Andrews St hilt with sword engraved handle, Silver baluster tall bow, to edge molded plain, bell, Table #35 1991 Finlay

293 Compendium of Scottish Silver Lord Blantyre Blantyre Lord th 6RWKHE\V$SULO Phillips J S UK Collection Private National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National LA124 6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 1983 #102 Scotland of Museums National 1565 MEQ Stirling Keir of *ODVJRZ([KLELWLRQYRO, p124 #29 &KULVWLHV0DUFK &OD\WRQ&KULVWLHVS #62 1991 Finlay Scotland of Museums National K.2004314 Scotland of Museums National 1556 MEQ 1512-13 Finlay 1991 #64 1991 Finlay Alcorn Fine Museum of Arts #251 p328-329 USA MA Boston &KULVWLHV2FWREHU of the 5 the of RQHW GLQJDFRUDO FUHVFHQWVKDSHG [ VHW )LQOD\ WZLWKDSSOLHGUHHGHGEDQGVFKDVHGZULJJOH HLQVFULSWLRQRQWKHEODGH )LQOD\ GZLWKDFUHVWEDOXVWHUKDQGOHFDSSHGZLWKD UDQ &OD\WRQ¶V'LFWLRQDU\S EHDGWRQJXHPLVVLQJó´KWR] ZRUNUHYHUVHHQJUDYHGZLWKODWHULQLWLDOV³($´DQGDGXFDOFRU ò´ZLGH EUDQFKHVRQHEHLQJWKHPRXWKSLHFHIRUDZKLVWOHWKHRWKHUKRO WHHWKHU EURNHQ LQVFULEHG³5%´ (GLQEXUJK 7KH.HLU7RLOHW6HUYLFH +RQ0DULRQ6WHZDUGGDXJKWHU (GLQEXUJK &KLOG¶VUDWWOHWKHFHQWHUIRUPHGDVDULEEHGVSKHUH (continued) (continued) (Probably Robert Inglis) 1715 ca 1715 ca Scott William FD +HQU\%HWKXQH Elgin (GLQEXUJK Spor Huntley The 6ZRUGZLWKVLOYHUKLOW-DFRELW &ROLQ&DPSEHOO (GLQEXUJK %HOORISODLQGHVLJQHQJUDYH 7KRPDV.HUFD (GLQEXUJK 5REHUW%UXFH 7KH+RSHWRXQ(ZHUDQG%DVLQDQG%R (GLQEXUJK 3LQFXVKLRQREORQJRQSDGIHH YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1703 ca 1703 ca McKenzie RI 1703/04 Colin

294 Miscellaneous DAG001360 DAG001360 Sothebys February 20, 1975 #93 1975 20, February Sothebys #101 1977 19, April Sothebys Jackson Marks p591 1983.29c MEQ Sothebys July 24, 1980 #29 1980 24, July Sothebys Scottish Art Academy Exhibit Exhibit Academy Art Scottish #427 Collection Stirling-Maxwell #141 4, 1958 February Christies AB Galleries MEQ 1038 1970.589 1970.589 1038 MEQ MEQ 562 1990 #319 24, October Glasgow Christies 1995 #478 Scotland of Museums National H.1996.263 Toronto Museum Ontario Royal 988.33.147 Canada HGULQJV FURVVKDQGOHV HWZHHQPROGHGERUGHUV³-RKQ&UDZIRUGRI a kettle a kettle Scotland of Museums National th crest and motto motto and crest th Scotland of Museums National no details details no Scotland of Museums National with detachable base, engraved at borders with bands of stiff leafage leafage stiff of bands with borders at engraved base, detachable with Kincaid Alexander to similar on stopper, screw chained, girdle, a simulating IODVNFDó´KWR] ò´GLR]G 0LOWRXQ(VT2ZQHU´VOLGLQJUHWDLQHUVORWVDQGDSSOL 9oz 15d 9oz KHDUWVKDSHGEUDFNHWPRXQWV´ RXWVLGHZLWKGRWVDQGGDVKHVDFHQWUDOEHDGHGIORZHU´D Glasgow Bible hasp clips, faceted edges in Scandinavian style, plain ball fasteners, 4 Edinburgh punched bottom, flat a to tapering round bowl, low taster, wine Miniature Bilsings Bilsings Aytoun William 1735 ca 1735 ca Gordon Patrick 1735/36 Ged Dougal Banff Edinburgh no details Ewer, for lamp, Hanging Brothers Crichton 1735 ca 1735 ca I D Edinburgh fitted body, shaped pear compressed Edinburgh, probably only, mm Flask, 1725 ca 1725 ca Walker George FD Aberdeen 5REHUW/XNH no details taster, wine Small *ODVJRZ 'RJFROODUSODLQEDQGLQVFULEHGE and Museums Aberdeen 1718/19 Bethune Henry Edinburgh tray, Snuffer 1719/20 Bethune Henry 1720 ca Edinburgh Johan Got-helf- motto and crest tray, Snuffer 1720 ca Probably WA 1721/22 Aytoun William Edinburgh long, ½" 7 handle, scroll border, shaped 4 feet, tray, snuffer Oblong 20, October USA NY Christies YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1716/17 LOCATION Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh wi flask, Whiskey SOURCE

295 Compendium of Scottish Silver Catalog 2004 p98 Noble Collection Nicholas Shaw 13, 1975 November Sothebys #125 Sothebys May 27, 1976 Sothebys May 27, Shrubsole NY USA 1981 E2081 USA NY Shrubsole Antiques1974 Magazine vol 106, p943 Clayton Christies p194, #41 Claytonp323, Dictionary #684 #72 Finlay 1991 of Scotland National Museums MEQ 1584 (or 1384) Sothebys August 28-29, 1978 How of Edinburgh Private Collection Christies November 27, 1963 Christies November #120 Christies October 14, 1970 #114 Christies October of Scotland National Museums MEQ 1063 ndant ring and 8 bells, 8 and ndant ring ndle at right angles to lip ndle at adjustable reflector ular molded base, on 4 base, ular molded uffers with mm only, 20 ½” ht, with mm uffers er arrow, shaft inscribed “Thos er arrow, shaft inscribed a crest, 9” long, 10 oz all 10 oz 9” long, a crest, s, plain oblong s, plain oblong mm only, 6” overall, 3oz 2d only, 6” overall, 3oz mm nal body, hung with a pe hung with nal body, border,feet, shapedhoof4 on handle with fleur- baluster body, turned wood ha body, turned wood baluster with reflector and snuffers, circ snuffers, reflector and with w on the Hill Trophy, silv oadsword, oadsword, no details Private Ownership rising from a shell motif, engraved with engraved a shell motif, rising from marked, Hill 3 Augst 1749”, not Harrow ye won ye Arrow at Saunders 10oz 19d 24” long, mm only, 5 ½” long only, 5 ½” mm initials “JB”, hung with 8 bells, de-lis, baron’s crest and motto crest baron’s de-lis, in 2 lobes and a fish head, 4 ¼” ht, 4oz 14d 4oz 4 ¼” ht, fish head, a in 2 lobes and scroll feet, plain stem with open work bracket, for 2 missing candle branches, candle for 2 missing work bracket, scroll feet, plain with stem open plain snuffer of pair for a pan shaped 53oz curved in at both ends, ring handle at top, sn at handle ring in at both ends, curved rghoctago rattle, knopped Child’s Edinburgh Trophy, Harro Edinburgh plain warmer, Brandy Aberdeen (?)Aberdeen AD marks handle, baluster rib above and plain bow, bell, plain, molded Table Edinburgh lamp lamp, Library Assayer Hugh Gordon said to be Assayer David Mitchell 1749 ca Not available 1746/47 Weems James 1740/41Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh1745 caStuartEdward Charles of Prince Canteen The Traveling Glen James 1745 ca Ker William Glasgow1962 March Christies London with mouthpiece whistle, octagonal rattle with II, Child’s rattle, George Edinbu 1740 ca1740/41 Colin Mitchell Dougal Ged Canongatebr Lochiel’s Edinburgh Snuffer stand, plain molded 1740 caAllan Coline YEAR1739/40 MAKER Aytoun William LOCATION DESCRIPTION SOURCE

296 Miscellaneous 6FRWODQG H1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI 1986-123 1986-123 Christies Scotland April 4, 1987 1987 4, April Scotland Christies #142 p16 #33 p16 #33 Scotland Sothebys May 8, 1969 8, May Sothebys #149 9, 1972 February Christies 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 1956.1498 Sothebys February 13, 1975 #132 1975 13, February Sothebys Galleries 1957.118 1957.118 Museum of FineMuseum of Boston MA Art, 33.131 USA Collection Rudkin WKHEDVH 5RE'XQEODLQ´´ORQJ DQGDZKLVWOHRQWKHRWKHU -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ WUHIRLOWHUPLQDWLRQLQVFULEHG³-RQ VFUHZRQFDSZLWKGHWDFKDEOHFRUNVKDSHGWRS´KWR] WKHQDPH³&DSHVWKRUQH´RQHWKHGHWDFKDEOHRYDOEHDNHUIRUPLQJ LQLWLDOVPPRQO\$3;¶V´ZLGHR]G FRUUXJDWHGLQVLGH´ORQJ (GLQEXUJK *ROGFKLOG¶VUDWWOHQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI William Dempster Dempster William -RKQ&ODUN1758/59 1760/61 Clark John (GLQEXUJK1763/64 Dempster William 1767/68 Edinburgh 0LFURVFRSHQRGHWDLOV Hill James Edinburgh details no Clark John tray, Snuffer Scotland of Rod White The Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Tray, Snuffer form, tapering curved of handle silver stick, walking Malacca Presentation )LOHVRIWK #92 1991 Finlay Collection Private 549 p Marks Jackson 1753/54 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh FD no details scoop, or cream hook Crumb &ROLQH$OODQ $EHUGHHQ &KLOG¶VUDWWOHFRUDORQRQHHQG 1991 Finlay 1750 ca 1750 ca Steven John 1750 ca probably WD Dundee details no bell, Table Art and Museums Dundee 1751/52 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh above 2 crests and monogram later with side one body, oval tapering Flask, 1750 ca 1750 ca Gordon Hugh 1750 ca AP Edinburgh pictured not tray, Snuffer Provincial contemporary with underside on engraved form, typical plain, boat, Pap p7 46 Park-Berne YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1750 ca LOCATION Telford Samuel Glasgow and arms strap long grips, finger oval and one round one tongs, Beefsteak SOURCE

297 Compendium of Scottish Silver DQG HXPVRI6FRWODQG '$* '$* 0XVHXPVDQG Q0XVHXPVDQG WLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 6RWKHE\V6FRQH3DODFH$SULO 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 1325 MEQ 0(4 *DOOHULHV$% 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1976 #102 6RWKHE\V6FRQH3DODFH$SULO MEQ 70 1990.99 1990.99 1976.22 1175 MEQ 6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK *DOOHULHV$% in 1981 acquired +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP HH2820/65 Edinburgh GDWHGWKH RRGò´KWò´GL 'DOODV0XVHXPRI$UW7;86$ XUYHGEODGHZLWKWXUQHGZRRGHQKDQGOHó´ KORRSKDQGOHVWUDLJKWVSRXWZULJJOHGHFRUDWLRQWR DWWOHQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XV WRSDQGGHWDFKDEOHFRYHUò´KWR] long long silver lining, scroll handle, plain mount to the lower junction of the handle handle the of junction lower the to mount plain handle, scroll lining, silver LQLWLDOHG³&+:´ò´KW RI(GLQEXUJK´KW 1RWHWKLVPD\EHWKHVDPHDVWKHRQH year) following (GLQEXUJK $VSDUDJXVWRQJVQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWO DP6FRWW 'XQGHH %XFNOHVSDLU 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU 1780 ca 1780 ca FD Willi $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK 6SXUVSDLUQRGHWDLOV 1D 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK $UJ\OOSODLQRYDOERG\ZLW FD 3HWHU0DWKLH (GLQEXUJK (ZHUSRVVLEO\IRUFUHDP $EHUGHH :LOOLDP'DYLHRU FD ³.HU´ 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK &UXPEKRRNVFRRSW\SLFDOF &KLOG¶VU FD -DPHV*RUGRQ $EHUGHHQ (ZHUVPDOOQRGHWDLOV $EHUGHHQ FD 0LOQH &DPSEHOO *ODVJRZ 7HDLQIXVHUVLOYHUDQGIUXLWZ 1768/69 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh body, cylindrical the to mounts lip and foot engrailed plain with Blackjack, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1767/68 LOCATION Robertson Patrick Edinburgh Wilson by work leather cylindrical, lining, silver tankard, leather Blackjack, SOURCE

298 Miscellaneous st 30, 30, st X Sothebys Gleneagles August 25, 25, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1997 #141 MEQ 859 859 MEQ The Maple Swan Collection MEQ 1315 1315 MEQ 1977 #163 1977 #163 Private Collection Collection Private April Castle, Fingask Christies 1993 27, August 21, 2003 #33 #33 2003 21, August 2002/03 p86 p86 2002/03 MEQ 1035 1035 MEQ Sandra Lipton, London #2943 #2943 London Lipton, Sandra LQHò´ORQJR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU HQJUDYHGZLWKIR[KXQWLQJVFHQHV´GL 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJ VKDSHGEDVHFKDLQVHFXUHGH[WLQJXLVKHUò´KWR] sleeve, bowl like cups on either side of the end, by this date William Davie Davie William date this by end, the of side either on cups like bowl sleeve, Dempster likely most is maker deceased, was at the corners, between intertwined ribbons, each engraved with "JH 1787", 1787", "JH with engraved each ribbons, intertwined between corners, the at 7/16" 2 X 2 7/8" head, thistle, King's "FH" marked head, initials "WK", 6 ¼" ht, 8.8oz ht, 8.8oz ¼" 6 "WK", initials head, Edinburgh Edinburgh no details scoop, Crumb Scotland of Museums National Edinburgh Edinburgh no details skimmer, or cream scoop Crumb Edinburgh silver long a to connected handle wooden turned a on cups/scoops Double Collection Swan Maple The Glasgow Glasgow cup stirrup head Fox Scotland of Museums National (GLQEXUJK %RRWSRZGHUHUFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI&DPSEHOORI%DOFDOG Edinburgh Edinburgh details no flask, Whiskey Scotland of Museums National illiam Davie or or Davie illiam ER mark mark ER ER mark mark ER William Dempster Dempster William Robert Gray Gray Robert Assayed Edinburgh William Dempster Dempster William William Davie or or Davie William Dempster William 1791/92 or Robertson Patrick 1791/92 or Robertson Patrick 1791/92 WD script script 1791/92 WD 1792/96 and 1792/96 94/95 FD :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK %XWWRQVVHWRIFLUFXODU 1790 ca 1790 ca I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh a saucer, from springing sconce and spindle the supporting straps jack, Wax 1785 ca 1785 ca W 1785/86 WD Script Script 1785/86 1785/86 WD Ziegler Alexander Edinburgh no details Buckle, Collection Swan Maple The 1787 ca 1787 ca Howden Francis Edinburgh flowers with decorated fastenings, steel original buckles, shoe silver Oblong 1784/85 available Not Edinburgh .7oz mm, no grater, Nutmeg Sale The Scottish Bonhams YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1782/83 LOCATION Robertson Patrick Edinburgh a unicorn's of crest a chain, on cap silver off pull flask, a Pilgrim's of Shape SOURCE

299 Compendium of Scottish Silver RI6FRWODQG RI6FRWODQG ,QWHUQHW&DWDORJ XPVDQG$UW O0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS &KULVWLHV1<86$2FWREHU % 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1977 #186 1- 0(4 0(4 *DOOHULHV SKW OOV 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ 1RYEHDWLQJVHYHQ th HDUOLHU 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ HDQGVQXIIHURQFLUFXODUEDVHZLWKWKXPE GFDSUHPRYDEOHRYDOFXSIURPORZHUERG\ GHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG EXWSRVVLEO\ ò´ORQJR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS QVFULEHGDURXQGWKHFROODU³:RQE\&DSW$ ZLWKEDQGVRISULFNGRWHQJUDYLQJR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ RQJVIHZGHWDLOV SLHFHKDQGOH´KWR] FUHVWDQGPRWWRRI0D[ZHOORI6SULQJNHOOPDUNHGRQQHFNDQGFX R] RWKHUV´R] *RUGRQ¶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¶VKHDGVWLUUXSFXSL SOURCE

300 Miscellaneous 1970-314 1970-314 1978-637 1978-637 Huntley House Museum Huntley House Edinburgh museum number not available Galleries 7%;DE MEQ 786 MEQ 711 Private Collection Collection Private Galleries Catalog 1990 p20 #82 p20 1990 Catalog MEQ 1974 1974 MEQ MEQ 860 RYRVW$GDP:KLWH´RQUHYHUVHVLGH LUH+XQW´ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG LWKJROGEDGJHDQGFKDLQXSULJKWRYDOFDVW EHUHGLQWKHKDQGOHZHOOKDQGOHODFNLQJ V 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG QVFUROOIHHW &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ ns and buckles, cased cased buckles, and ns Collectables Small Asprey no details details no Scotland of Museums National er, no details details no er, Art and Museums Dundee ILJXUHRIMXVWLFHHQJUDYHG³)LUVW3U 2 masted shipin front of a pier,rowing boat inthe foreground ´;´ DGGLWLRQDO*)72%$*2PDUN;R] Edinburgh Edinburgh details no stand, Snuffer Collection Swan Maple The WWLH )HQZLFN (GLQEXUJK %XWWRQVHQJUDYHG³/DQDUN5HQIUHZVK Howden 1818/19 FD I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh 1820 ca :LOOLDP-DPLHVRQ Wine cooler mm $EHUGHHQ AD FD 6SLULWODPSFLUFXODUVWDQGR )UDQFLV+RZGHQ 1820 ca Aberdeen (GLQEXUJK Booth &KDLQRI2IILFH3URYRVWRI/H George details no bell, Table Aberdeen Sugar sift #2 p264 Christies Clayton Art and Museums Dundee FD (GZDUG/LYLQJVWRQH 1820 ca 'XQGHH I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh 6KRHEXFNOHVSDLUQRGHWDLO details no Extinguisher, Scotland of Museums National 1817/18 William & James *HRUJH)HQZLFN (GLQEXUJK /LGRIHQWUpHGLVKSODLQQXP 1817/18 McHattie George Edinburgh details no cup, or Vase Scotland of Museums National 1813/14 McKay James Edinburgh chai with pair, Spurs, 1810 c a 1810 c McHa YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1809/10 LOCATION McPherson & Dick Edinburgh stand, Taper SOURCE

301 Compendium of Scottish Silver VRI6FRWODQG WLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational p100 1217 MEQ Private Collection Collection Private S National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National 1128 MEQ Private Collection Collection Private p100 p100 K.2002.368 1237 MEQ H.1996.30 H.1996.30 UGHHQ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ DQGPRWWRHQJUDYHGWR5REHUW'LFN PHG(OGHU &RUHWDLOHUV 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ KHDG 6KUXEVROH1<86$ VSRXWIODSòGLR]G 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ R] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ QJ´DFURVVR] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ LWDWRUPRQRJUDP HUQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXP ece, no details N RRVHHJJGHFDS PDUNHGGL Esq Esq original irongrater, ring at the other end,mm only (GLQEXUJK &UXPEVFRRSFRURQHWDQGFUHVWRI*RUGRQ(DUORI$EH II $QGUHZ:LONLH (GLQEXUJK 7-5 0HDWERQHKROGHUQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK 1XWPHJJUDW 1D -DPHV+RZGHQ (GLQEXUJK * 1830/31 Marshall William Edinburgh fully mount, and rim gilt silver in set whole relief, full in Academy Edinburgh -DPHV+RZGHQ &R (GLQEXUJK )R[KHDGVWLUUXSFXS´OR *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK 6QXIIHUVFLVVRUô´ORQJ 1823/24 Cunningham P & W 1823/24 Son & Gray Robert FD Glasgow 1RWDYDLODEOH details no trophy, Coursing 1828/29 *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK Sons & Marshall (GLQEXUJK 'RJZKLVWOHVKDSHGOLNHDGRJ¶V Edinburgh %UDQG\SDQDQGFRYHUKLQJHG '&5DLW Centerpi *ODVJRZ :KLVNH\IODVNUHFWDQJXODUZLWKFUHVW Scotland of Museums National YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1820/21 LOCATION Fenwick George Edinburgh details no pair, snuffers, Candle SOURCE Scotland of Museums National 1820/21 Haxton Richard Edinburgh with fitted interior agate, carnelian red with set lid grater, nutmeg Oval

302 Miscellaneous MEQ 1606 1606 MEQ MEQ 1286 1286 MEQ H.1995.638 A.1878.50 A.1878.50 MEQ 1127 1127 MEQ MEQ 1319 1319 MEQ MEQ VJ15 MEQ 919 Sothebys Gleneagles August 1987 #308 ation 1861 1861 ation Scotland of Museums National ife, no details details no ife, Scotland of Museums National details details Scotland of Museums National or scalpel box box scalpel or Scotland of Museums National esented to Patrick Weill by Practical Gardeners Gardeners Practical by Weill Patrick to esented Scotland of Museums National , no details details no , Scotland of Museums National ils ils Scotland of Museums National ece, statuette Sir of Walter Scott, Present Scotland grip made the year earlier earlier year the made grip Scotland 1859/60 1869/70 Marshall W & J Son & Robb Charles Edinburgh Edinburgh skimmer or cream scoop Crumb piggin handled 2 Collection Swan Maple The Collection Private 1855/56 Mc J 1856/57 Crichton Centerpi Edinburgh 1856/57 Crichton Michael 1858/59 Walker Marshall W & J Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Baton, Edinburgh deta no Ewer, piggin handled 2 2005 Collection Private Collection Private 1849/50 EM Edinburgh Presentation Trowel, no 1849/50 EM Trowel, Presentation Edinburgh 1843/44 McKay James Edinburgh pr Cup, Weill The 1836/37 Marshall William 1838/39 Edinburgh Naysmith James 1838/39 details no cup, Presentation Edinburgh 1839/40 Russell & Mitchell Glasgow lancet Presentation Whittet & Robb 1840/41 bowl of base in marked unengraved, edge, reeded boat, pap Victorian Early Edinburgh Marshall William Collection Private grater Nutmeg Edinburgh details no dish, Butter Scotland of Museums National Scotland of Museums National 1836/37 McKay James Edinburgh kn and fork Combination YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1835/36 LOCATION Wilkie Andrew Edinburgh of Museums National the from different this is presumably holder, bone Meat SOURCE

303 Compendium of Scottish Silver 99 99 ion ion DAG008693 DAG008693 ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational p47 #34 p47 #34 p60 #41 p57 #41 p57 #41 1969 LC90 J Bourdon-Smith Catalog 1991 1991 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J p47 #34 AB Galleries H.1995.107 H.1995.107 1978.102 1978.102 H.1991.1 H.1991.1 HU)HE´ò´KWR] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ ´KW´DFURVVR] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ RQJWKHRWKHUSDLU´ORQJR]DOO -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ HQJUDYHG³WR-DPHV0DUVKDOO)LQGOD\´ no details details no Scotland of Museums National Skene Dhu,no details The Maple Swan Collection ò´KWR] Christening set, no details details no set, Christening Scotland of Museums National Edinburgh Centerpiece, no details N Edinburgh Edinburgh details no timer, Egg Scotland of Museums National Tatton Tatton Edinburgh details no ring, Napkin Collection Swan Maple The Assayed Edinburgh & Co Co & Co Co 1920/21 Henry Roy Roy 1920/21 Henry 1972/73 RA 0DUVKDOO 6RQ1889/90 (GLQEXUJK Millard M George Edinburgh %URRNV 6RQ 6SDGHVSDLUVRQHSDLU´O horn hunting Victorian Rare (GLQEXUJK 3LJJLQZLWKEROGEDQGLQJ Collection Private 1907/08 Tatton & Young 1909/10 Edinburgh Inches & Hamilton Edinburgh Dhu, Skene and Dirk handle wood dark turned blade, curved tailed rat form, standard hook, Crumb Collect Private 1880 ca 1880 ca Cunningham Robb William 1880/81 McKay, Ballater pair buckles, Shoe and Museums Aberdeen - :0DUVKDOO (GLQEXUJK 3LJJLQHQJUDYHG³-RKQ$OH[DQG 1878/79 & Naysmith James 0F.D\ &KLVKROP (GLQEXUJK 3LJJLQZLWKOXJW\SHKDQGOHV 1874/75 Hamilton & Inches Edinburgh Edinburgh Inches YEAR MAKER & DESCRIPTION 1871/72 LOCATION 1874/75 Hamilton MC & G Edinburgh piggin handled 2 SOURCE Collection Private

304 Miscellaneous MEQ 1981.48 1981.48 MEQ MEQ 1616 1616 MEQ 1-3 K2004.22 Anniversary of the Anniversary of Edinburgh Office Assay National Scotland Museums of th se, no details details no se, Scotland of Museums National 1982/83 1989 E T Edgar Maureen Edinburgh Edinburgh va mounted Silver no details dirk, Highland Collection Swan Maple The 1990/91 2003 E T Kirk William Edinburgh Edinburgh base slate a on containers Two no details sporran, Dress Scotland of Museums National Collection Swan Maple The YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1978 LOCATION McDonald Grant Edinburgh 500 the for Rosebowl, SOURCE

305 Compendium of Scottish Silver

306 Mugs

MugsMUGS

Plate 33. A Mug 1739/40 by Patrick Murray II, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

307 Compendium of Scottish Silver

308 General Mugs

GeneralGENERAL MUGSMugs

Plate 34. A Mug 1734/35 by Dougal Ged, Edinburgh . Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

309 Compendium of Scottish Silver Exhibition, pl Maple Swan Collection othebys June 2, 1949 #101 1949 othebys June 2, Sothebys December 1, 1976 #107 December Sothebys J Phillips May 15, #91 J Phillips May 15, Sothebys March 20, 1975 #183 Sothebys1981 June#172 30, #63.53.7 Christies March 29, 1983 #52 Shaw Collection of Scotland National Museums 1983 1556 MEQ Christies November 24, 1974 Christies November #154 Park Lane Loan #29 XVII, Sothebys March 16, 1961 #72 16, 1963 #171 Christies October S J Phillips osite handles above ed “Ex dono XXX”, ed “Ex dono lded lip, scroll handle lded lip, flutes, stamped with foliage flutes, stamped base, scroll handle with later County Chester, 3 ¾" ht, 13.4oz ht, 3 ¾" County Chester, contemporary initials contemporary irdle and lobe straps above slight ring ll handles applied beaded rat tails, on applied handles ll scroll handle, engrav reeded rim foot, mo rim reeded aped body, engraved opp t, no details Jackson Marks p 546 a thistle mug AC Museum Metropolitan applied with g rical, molded lip and rical, molded ndle, engrave with ndle, engrave e pair above, 4"ht, 7oz above, 4"ht, e pair S tline, lower part tline, lower chased with (unfortunately NOT Scottish) (unfortunately tails The Maple Swan Collection n tapering cylindrical, on n tapering cylindrical, pair, no details The small, circular, plain, with scroll handle, central band on slightly band central plain, with scroll handle, circular, small, ug, small bell shaped, ug, small initials, with crest and motto, 3 ½", 7.4oz 3 ½", initials, with crest and motto, spreading rim base, 3 ½" ht, 5oz rim spreading foot, reeded strap ha “M/S MK/ K MK”, 1 ¾” ht, 1oz 9d 1oz ht, “M/S MK/ K MK”, 1 ¾” with rat tail extension, mm 2X’s, 3 3/8” ht, 6oz 5d 6oz ht, 3 3/8” 2X’s, mm rat tail extension, with 3 1/8” ht, 4oz , motifs, molded band above, reeded band above, molded motifs, MUGS the molded girdle with armorials, scro girdle with armorials, the molded of Davenham, Wyohe, of feet, Arms rim Mug, for a child, may be Mug, for a child, may rgh pair, Mugs, (apparently), bell sh inburgh tapering, cylind Mug, atesheadou shaped Mug, dinburgh to th similar Mug, Edinburghdate letter varian with Mug, n Edinburghde no Mug, GENERAL 1711/121712/13 Colin Campbell John Seatoun Ed 1710 ca McKenzie Simon Inverness 1710 ca1710/11 Not available1711/12 Henry Bethune1711/12 Mitchelso James Edinburgh Edinburgh Mitchell David Mug,ht, 4 ¾" 16.5oz Mugs, Edinburgh Mug, SothebysApril 29, 1986 1710 ca Robert Innes Inverness M 1709 ca Clerk William Glasgow plai Mug, YEAR MAKER1684/85 IS (pillar between)in Edinbu LOCATION DESCRIPTION SOURCE 1684/85 IS (pillar between)in E 1700 caFloat Augustin G

310 General Mugs 116 1974 #15 1974 ecember 20, Christies July 12-13, 1983 #78 1983 12-13, July Christies Clayton Christies Book p #440 1978 29, August Sothebys Christies March 19, 1934 #142 #142 1934 19, March Christies Collection Gardner J Bourdon-Smith Catalog Catalog Bourdon-Smith J #41 p20, 1999, Autumn Sothebys may 17-19, 1988 #993 #993 1988 17-19, may Sothebys (unsold) #197 1989 8, March Christies #191 Colonial Collection, Hyman Williamsburg #136 1990 Gleneagles Sothebys Christies May 18, 1938 #70 18, 1938 May Christies Sothebys December 4, 1958 4, December Sothebys Christies February 17, 1960 #131 17, 1960 February Christies #60 Maxwell and gift inscription, inscription, gift and Maxwell rms of 8.6oz both both 8.6oz 4oz 18d 4oz both 3 ¼" 3 ¼" 8.2oz ht, 9oz both (4oz 10d ea) ea) 10d (4oz both 9oz 5oz 8d 5oz scroll handle, molded lip and base, 3" ht, 4.8oz 4.8oz ht, 3" base, and lip molded handle, scroll 3 1/6" ht, 10oz 12d both (5oz 6d ea) ea) 6d (5oz both 12d 10oz ht, 3 1/6" 1717/18 Yorstoun Mungo Edinburgh 14d 11oz ht, 7/8" 2 Crichton, of motto and crest 2x's, "C" initial pair, Mugs, D Christies 1716/17 Bethune Henry Edinburgh ht, 3" handle, scroll with bodies shaped foot, molded a on each pair, Mugs, 1715/16 Campbell Colin Edinburgh ht, ¼" 3 handle, scroll sides, convex slightly foot, reeded plain, Mug, 1715/16 Seaton John Edinburgh 11.8oz ¼", 3 "M/JB", initials motto, and crest cylindrical plain, pair, Mugs, 1715 ca 1715 ca Ged William ca 1715 Edinburgh Ged William ht ½" 3 Maxwell, of Arms body, tapering slight with Mug Edinburgh A full body, tapering slightly Mug with 1992 4, March London Christies 1714/15 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh ht, 3 1/8" handles, scroll borders, molded with sided, straight pair, Mugs, 1713/14 Seatoun John Edinburgh ht, ¾" 3 handle, scroll base, reeded sides, bulbous Mug, cylindrical, 1713/14 Mitchelson James Edinburgh girdle, reeded a above inscribed body, cylindrical tapering gilt, later Mug, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1712/13 LOCATION McKenzie Colin Edinburgh ht ¼" 3 handle, simple Mug, cylindrical, SOURCE Book Library Huntington Wark, 1712/13 1713/14 Ker Thomas Penman Edward Edinburgh Edinburgh 5oz ht, ½" rim, 3 and feet reeded cylindrical, plain Mug, motto, and crest Napier thumbstops, molded cylindrical, pair, Mugs, #89 5, 1947 February Christies

311 Compendium of Scottish Silver Christies April 26, 1966 #115 #115 1966 26, April Christies Collection Vander C. AprilSothebys NY USA 1990 #445 #2618 Inventory Exchange #233 Edinburgh of How #3 XII vol Review, Arts Scottish back cover 121, vol Magazine Antiques p 1311 Advertisement Wyler S. #192 103 p35 vol 1939, advertisement How MEQ 1292-1293 1978.79-80 1978.79-80 1292-1293 MEQ Christies June 22, 1960 #100 1960 22, June Christies Shrubsole Jackson Marks p 545 p Marks Jackson Christies July 31, 1950 #128 31, 1950 July Christies foot and rim, 3" ht, 6oz 5d , no details details no , Scotland of Museums National flaring lip, 2 7/8" ht, 4oz 3d 3d 4oz ht, 7/8" 2 lip, flaring (6oz 6d ea) 6d ea) (6oz Edinburgh Edinburgh 13d 9oz ht, 3" MB", "PC initials sides, straight pair, Mugs, 1968 26, November Sothebys Edinburgh Edinburgh 7oz ht, ½" 4 handle, scroll form, baluster plain, Mug, 1992 March London Christies Charles Duncan Duncan Charles 1718/19 Kincaid Penman Edward 1718/19 Alexander Edinburgh 9oz ht, 7/8" 4 handle, loop high with body Mug, baluster Art California-European 1718/19 or I Dickson Charles 1718/19 available Not no details plain, Mug, May Magazine Connoisseur 1718/19 1718/19 Turnbull Patrick 1718/19 Simpson Alexander Edinburgh Edinburgh Turnbull Patrick details no Mug, details no Mug, Edinburgh "C", initial the with base, reeded rim, everted slightly Mug, cylindrical, Collection Swan Maple The Collection Swan Maple The 1717/18 Yorstoun Mungo Edinburgh small pair, Mugs, 1717/18 Ure Archibald Edinburgh both, 12d 12oz ht, 3 1/6" initials, engraved, cylindrical pair, Mugs, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1717/18 LOCATION Blair Charles Edinburgh 1d ht, 6oz 3 1/5" inscription, handles, scroll Mug, cylindrical, #47 1953 28, October Christies SOURCE 1717/18 Ged William Edinburgh molded cylindrical, Mug,

312 General Mugs 2004 2004 oun House, June June House, oun Christies November 10, 1971 1971 10, November Christies #135 Collection Shaw #34 1983 29, March Christies 1983, 12, July Glasgow Christies #195 p101 p84 J Bourdon-Smith advertisement Christies Edinburgh April 29, 29, April Edinburgh Christies 1992 #50 20, 1988 #151 1988 20, 20, February Turnbull & Lyon 2004 #253 Christies November 2, 1960 #166 1960 2, November Christies p35 103 vol advertisement How Nicholas Shaw Antiques Antiques Shaw Nicholas 2004 Magazine Antiques later later ´KW ³,&:´ò´ foot, engraved "R.A.I." on base,½" 3 5.9oz Nicholas Shaw Catalog pint, initials "A/RI" under base, 3 ½" ht, 5.8oz 5.8oz ht, ½" 3 base, under "A/RI" initials pint, 2004 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J ERG\FKDVLQJ VDLGWREH:LOOLDP-DPLHVRQEDVHGRQ-DFNVRQ ht, 11oz 11oz ht, IDFHWHGVFUROOKDQGOHHQJUDYHGRQORZHUWHUPLQDOZLWKLQLWLDOV other has the initials "AM HM", 3 3/8" ht, 11oz 12d 11oz ht, 3 3/8" HM", "AM initials has the other initials, 3" ht, 5oz 5oz ht, 3" initials, lip, plain capped scroll handle, crest and motto of Lockhart Lockhart of motto and crest handle, scroll capped plain lip, (5oz 16d ea) ea) 16d (5oz Edinburgh Mug on spreadingrim foot, molded girdle, leaf capped loop handle, Edinburgh Mug,half pint, slightly shaped body, tucked into amolded rim foot, everted probably Charles Duncan Duncan Charles 1720 ca 1720 ca Mitchelson James 1719/20 Inglis Robert Edinburgh spreading on Mug 1720 ca 1720 ca R N 1720 ca Tait James 1720 ca Robertson George Edinburgh Aberdeen foot flaring on sided, Mug, straight lip, everted foot, rim molded on each cylindrical, tapering plain of pair Mugs, 1oz ½"ht, 1 cup, Dram p114 June 1987 Life Country 2002/03 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1719/20 Ure Archibald Edinburgh the JL", "AM initials the has one handles, scroll feet, molded on pair, Mugs, 1719/20 or I Dickson Charles 1719/20 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh marriage with handle scroll single shape, cylindrical tapering plain, Mug, 1719/20 available Not 1719/20 McKenzie Kenneth Edinburgh 4.3oz ht, ½" 3 handle, a strap with foot, rim on body, tapering Mug, slightly Hopet Sothebys no details plain, Mug, 1939 May Magazine Connoisseur 1719/20 Ure Archibald Edinburgh both 12d 11oz ht, ¼" 3 tapering, slightly initials, cylindrical pair, Mugs, 1719/20 Robert Inglis Edinburgh Mug, half Inglis Mug, YEAR Edinburgh MAKER DESCRIPTION 1719/20 Robert LOCATION SOURCE

313 Compendium of Scottish Silver #64 1971 1971 Book ecember 15, Christies D Christies Christies April 13, 1977 #98 1977 13, April Christies Christies July 17, 1963 #122 17, 1963 July Christies Scottish Art Review vol XII, #2 #2 XII, vol Review Art Scottish 1969 cover back advertisement How 2004, Catalog Bourdon-Smith J #45 p24, Christies May 18, 1966 #77 18, 1966 May Christies 1943.248 1943.248 Sothebys February 14, 1980 #55 1980 14, February Sothebys (Christies source) 1939 #458 White Cathcart J. #293 2002/03 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p84 foot, with a crestand motto, 5.4oz foot, engraved initials "AG",ht3" 5.3oz foot, lip and rim, 3 ¾" ht, 5oz 17d details details Scotland of Museums National and slightly everted lip, engraved opposite handles, variation of Arms of of Arms of variation handles, opposite engraved lip, everted slightly and 15.3oz ht, ½" 4 Pencartland, of Hamilton 3" ht, 5oz 16d 5oz ht, 3" 3 ¼" ht, 6.4oz 1726/27 1727/28 Blair Charles Ker James Edinburgh 5d 5oz ht, ¾" 2 foot, molded outline, shaped fluted, partly Mug, Edinburgh base spreading plain in or tuck with cylindrical tapering slightly pair, Mugs, #64 1968 13, March Christies 1725/26 1725/26 Penman Edward Ker James Edinburgh details no Mug, Edinburgh molded on Mug, cylindrical, Collection Swan Maple The 1725/26 James Mitchelson Edinburgh ht Mug, 3.1" Wark, Huntington 1725 ca 1725 ca 1726/27 Luke Robert Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh Glasgow JT", "JS initials handle, capped leaf base, molded body, shaped Mug, circular 4d 6oz plain, Mug, #122 1946 5, March Christies 1723/24 1723/24 Mitchelson James no McKenzie Kenneth Edinburgh 1724/25 Edinburgh Mug, Edinburgh Kincaid molded on outline, Mug, shaped Kincaid Alexander cup or Mug 1724/25 Alexander Edinburgh ht ¼" 3 Mug, notes p546 Marks Jackson Exhibition Academy Art Scottish YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1720/21 LOCATION Mitchelson James Edinburgh flat shape, barrel Mug, slight SOURCE 1721/22 Tait James Edinburgh rim, stepped spreading handle on scroll initials, above lip added Mug, with

314 General Mugs ber 19, Sothebys Gleneagles, August 25, 25, August Gleneagles, Sothebys 1997 #161 November Edinburgh Christies #38 1990 21, Collection Phoenix The Christies July 12, 1983, #199 #199 12, 1983, July Christies (unsold) J Bourdon-Smith Spring 1983 1983 Spring Bourdon-Smith J viewing Sothebys London June 18, 1987 1987 18, June London Sothebys #234 Christies Glasgow November 16, 16, November Glasgow Christies 1994 #680 1993 #193 1993 #193 #50 1976 13, April Sothebys #194 1970 22, April Christies Lyon & Turnbull February 20, February Turnbull & Lyon 2004 #245 Sothebys Gleneagles August 25, 25, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1977 #159 foot, scrollhandle, ht, 3" 5.2oz Sothebys November 26, 1969 spreading foot, 3¼"ht, 4.8oz misdated) misdated) a suite with bowl and stand and stand bowl with a suite PRWWRRQVSUHDGLQJIHHWVFUROOKDQGOHò´KWR]GERWK UHWDLQLQJWUDFHVRIHQJUDYHGLQLWLDOVó´KWR] KDQGOHò´KW FDSSHGVLQJOHVFUROOKDQGOH´KW handle,tucked in base on spreading foot,¼" 3 ht, 6.8oz 1734/35 Campbell Colin 1734/35 Edinburgh 1734/35 Campbell Colin 10d 10oz ht, ¾" 3 ID", "EQ initials patched, one pair, Mugs, Ged Dougal Edinburgh details no pair, Mugs, Edinburgh 1983 March Glasgow Christies ht 3" comes", Fortuna "Vertutis motto and crest with Mug, baluster, 1992 Edinburgh Goodwin's Collection Swan Maple The 1733/34 Penman Hugh Edinburgh a on tucked body handle, scroll capped plain with body, baluster plain Mug, 1732/36 Penman Hugh Edinburgh Bethune or Henry (possibly 4.5oz handle, scroll with foot, spreading Mug, on 1731/32 Ker James Edinburgh of part for Fairlie, probably motto crest, and head animal with Mug, engraved 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen and crest with each engraved bodies, cylindrical tapering slightly pair, Mugs, 1730 ca 1730 ca Luke Robert Glasgow handle, scroll plain foot, spreading on form, cylindrical tapering plain, Mug, 1730 ca 1730 ca Luke Robert Glasgow scroll foot, spreading and base in tucked body, cylindrical almost Mug, 1728/29 Ker James Edinburgh 5.7oz ht, 3" handle, foot, scroll spreading on form cylindrical tapering Mug, Decem London Sothebys 1728/29 Ker James Edinburgh spreading on form cylindrical tapering Mug, 1727/28 Ker James Edinburgh plain base, stepped a spreading on tucked straight sided, nearly plain, Mug, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1727/28 LOCATION available Not Edinburgh scroll capped rim, plain at flaring slightly cylindrical, tapering Mug, slightly SOURCE

315 Compendium of Scottish Silver Christies May 8, 1939 #44 #44 8, 1939 May Christies #121 11, 1960 May Christies 1996 1989 4, July Glasgow Christies #103 Christies May 15, 1963 #69 15, 1963 May Christies Nicholas Shaw Internet Catalog Catalog Internet Shaw Nicholas 1999 October #127 1985 30, April Sothebys Christies May 11, 1960 #122 11, 1960 May Christies #3 XV, vol Review Arts Scottish back cover advertisement Edinburgh of How Christies July 6, 1977 #162 #162 6, 1977 July Christies Christies Scotland November 25- November Scotland Christies #107 1997 28, WR] RRWUHHGHGULPGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOH´KW QGOHKWR]GERWK foot, crestand motto "THURE ETTURE", OVDQGFUHVWKWR]GERWK IRRWZLWKVOLJKWO\HYHUWHGOLSVFUROOKDQGOH´KW ZLWKFRDWRIDUPVRI0DF)DUODQHFDSSHGVFUROOKDQGOH´K R]GHD R] R] òKWR] R]GHD VFUROOKDQGOHKWR]ERWK R]GHD KDQGOHó´KWR] Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Mug, small, 547 p Marks Jackson Farquharson Farquharson 1737/38 Ker James 1737/38 Alexander 1738/39 Edinburgh Lothian Edward ht 3" sides, curved plain, pair, Mugs, Edinburgh handle opposite engraved foot, circular spreading on baluster, plain Mug, Canada Toronto Ltd, Wine, Louis -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 0XJVSDLUFXUYHGVLGHVVFUROOKD -DPHV&DPSEHOO (GLQEXUJK 0XJSODLQRQULP +XJK3HQPDQ (GLQEXUJK 0XJEDOXVWHUERG\RQVSUHDGLQJI 1735 ca 1735 ca ca 1735 Cooper George 1735 ca Cooper George Aberdeen Luke Robert Aberdeen no details pair, Mugs, details no pair, Mugs, Glasgow on flat base cut in tucked Mug, 108 pl 1991 Finlay #234 1987 June London Sothebys :LOOLDP$\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK 0XJVSDLUSHDUVKDSHGLQLWLD 1735/36 Ged Dougal Edinburgh double capped plain foot, spreading on each outline, shaped plain, pair, Mugs, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1735ca LOCATION 1735/36 II Luke Robert Ged Dougal Glasgow Folis of motto and crest foot, spreading on Edinburgh form, Mug, baluster scroll and lip everted foot, circular spreading on form, baluster Mug, small p91 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas SOURCE

316 General Mugs &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ1RYHPEHU 3KLOOLSV*ODVJRZ'HFHPEHU &KULVWLHV6FRWODQG1RYHPEHU #122 1997 27, 3KLOOLSV(GLQEXUJK'HFHPEHU 1999 #412 &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ-XO\ #42 &KULVWLHV-XO\ How Collection Collection How &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ AntiquesSimon Kaye Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1983 #489 6RWKHE\V$SULO AntiquesSimon Kaye 7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ ô´KWR] DYHGLQLWLDO³:´KW UROOKDQGOH &KULVWLHV-XO\ LRQ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG UROOKDQGOHVR]ERWK R]GHD &KULVWLHV0DUFK R]G 6RWKHE\V-XQH O\ZDLVWHGF\OLQGULFDOIRUPPROGHGFLUFXODUEDVH plain scroll handle with old repair, base engraved with contemporary initials initials contemporary with engraved base repair, old with handle scroll plain ³( 0.´PDUNV$, VWUXFNWZLFH SRWRIOLOLHVVFULSW/ 5.21oz 5.21oz foot, 3 1/8" ht, 5.9oz 5.9oz ht, 1/8" 3 foot, amatted ground,leaf capped double scrollhandle, on moldedrim foot, ó´KWR] *ODVJRZ 0XJFLUFXODUZLWKOLSDSSOLHGVWUDSZRUNGHVLJQHQJU (GLQEXUJK 0XJSODLQVKDSHGRXWOLQHRQVSUHDGLQJIRRWZLWKVF Edinburgh Mug, engraved and later chased withmonogram, scrolls andfloral sprays on Edinburgh ht 5/8" 3 "EC", over "DL" initials script form, Mug, baluster 1993 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J Assayer Archibald Ure (either wrong maker maker wrong (either or wrong year) Assayer Archibald Ure FD $OH[DQGHU-RKQVWRQ 'XQGHH 0XJKDOISLQWSODLQVOLJKW FDFD 5REHUW/XNH -RKQ/XNH-U *ODVJRZ 0XJGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHKW 1RWDYDLODEOH FD -RKQ%DLOOH %DQII 0XJVSDLUVKDSHGSODLQIOXWHGVF 1738/39 William Dempster Dempster 1738/39 William -DPHV.HU 3DWULFN0XUUD\,, (GLQEXUJK 0XJQRGHWDLOV -DFNVRQ0DUNVS -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 0XJZLWKH[WHQVLYHUHSRXVVHGHFRUDW YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1738/39 LOCATION Ker James Edinburgh spreading on handle, scroll double initials, with engraved body, Mug, baluster SOURCE

317 Compendium of Scottish Silver , 1974 1974 ober 24, 2000 2000 24, ober W HFHPEHU V/RQGRQ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS &KULVWLHV-XO\ #76 1971 10, November Christies $XWXPQS 'XPSKULHV0DUFK #39 p17 1997, Autumn 7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ Shaw Collection Collection Shaw &KULVWLHV0DUFK 6RWKHE\V-XQH &KULVWLHV' R]ERWK FUHVWDQGPRWWRRI%DOIRXU9,5786$' KDQGOHVKDSHGSOLQWK´KW 7KRPDV5RGGLFNDQG0HWFDOI foot, body of shaped outline,scroll handle, R] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ QGOHUDLVHGFLUFXODUIRRWLQLWLDOV´KWR] %RQKDPV2F (36ôKWR] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ $&7+(5$7(1',7òKWR] GRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHVHQJUDYHGZLWKFUHVWDQGPRWWR´KW ´KWR] KDQGOHSDWFKHGPDUNV,%,0ò´KWR] VFUROOKDQGOH´KWR]G HQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDOV´R]G (GLQEXUJK 0XJKWôGL(GLQEXUJK 0XJEDOXVWHUSODLQòKW -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ :7:LONHQVRQ/RQGRQ Assayer Edward Lothian Assayer Edward Lothian Edward Lothian Lothian Edward Edinburgh outline, shaped of bodies foot, molded circular on each plain, pair, Mugs, 1740/41 Aytoun William Edinburgh scroll double body, baluster Mug, (GZDUG/RWKLDQ 'RXJDO*HG (GLQEXUJK (GZDUG/RWKLDQ 0XJEDOXVWHUIRUP (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK 0XJEDOXVWHUIRUPHQJUDYHGZLWK 0XJEDOXVWHUIRUPóKW 6-3KLOOLS 7KRPDV0LWFKHOO (GLQEXUJK 0XJEDOXVWHUZLWKLQLWLDOV 7KRPDV0LWFKHOO (GZDUG/RWKLDQ (GLQEXUJK 0XJEDOXVWHUIRUPVFUROOKD (GZDUG/RWKLDQ 1740/41 1740 ca 1740 Baillie John Inverness handle, scroll lip, everted slightly foot, rim on each plain, pair, Mugs, 1740 ca 1740 ca Baillie John Inverness scroll double faceted foot, rim on outline, shaped of each plain, pair, Mugs, 1740ca Luke Robert Glasgow doubled lip, everted base, in tucked on body, cylindrical tapered plain, Mug, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1740 ca LOCATION Luke Robert Glasgow molded circular on plain, Mug, SOURCE

318 General Mugs Christies Glasgow March 29, 29, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #382 Christies May 18, 1988 #364 18, 1988 May Christies p71 74, vol Christies July 26, 1960 #139 #139 1960 26, July Christies 1990 12, October NY Sothebys #161 Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004, 2004, Catalog Shaw Nicholas p99 Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1983 #504 Scotland of Museums National 1177 MEQ 1974 June 13, Sothebys Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1998 #559 ó´KW plain capped double scroll handle, 3 ½" ht, 7oz 10d 7oz ht, ½" 3 handle, scroll double plain capped 6oz 6oz VFUROOKDQGOHDQGPROGHGULPHQJUDYHGZLWKVFULSWLQLWLDO³'´ both 19d 11oz DQLQLWLDOò´KWR]G 12.1oz 12.1oz bases, 3 ½" ht, 11oz both both 11oz ht, 3 ½" bases, VFUROOVKHOODQGIORUDOPRWLIVRQVSUHDGLQJEDVH´KWR] and rococo, leaf capped handle, ¾" ht, handle, 6 22.7oz leaf capped and rococo, Edinburgh Mug,plain, shaped outline, onrim foot, double scrollhandle, engraved with Edinburgh Pintmugs, pair, George II, baluster shape, chased with contemporary band of illiam Davie or or Davie illiam Assayer Hugh Gordon William Dempster Dempster William Assayer Hugh Gordon 1760 ca 1760 ca Law James Aberdeen ht ¼ " 5 sides, Mug, split 1996 London Bourdon-Smith J 1752/53 Gilliland James Edinburgh lip, molded foot, spreading stepped shaped slightly on outline, Mug, baluster 1747/48 Dempster Ker & 1747/48 Edinburgh Dempster Ker & no details pair, Mugs, 1939, Magazine Burlington 1749/50 Lothian Edward Edinburgh ht, ¾" 2 collection", goods S & M of "Property inscription, later with Mug, 1747/48 Lothian Edward Edinburgh with foot, circular spreading a on each shape, plain baluster of pair Mugs, 1744/45 1744/45 Aytoun William Oliphant Lawrence Edinburgh Edinburgh 1745 ca details no Mug, handle scroll capped acanthus chased, heavily gilt, Mug, silver W 1747/78 Lothian Edward p80 1991 Finlay Edinburgh ht, ¼" 3 "D", initial a script with engraved both form, baluster pair, Mugs, p547 Marks Jackson 1743/44 Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh spreading on handles, scroll double initials, later form, baluster pair, Mugs, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1743/44 LOCATION Aytoun William Edinburgh scrolls with armorials, around chased foot, spreading on body, baluster Mug, SOURCE

319 Compendium of Scottish Silver 47 76 #186 #186 76 Winter og Winter DAG011099 DAG011099 Sothebys February 3, 1972 #157 1972 3, February Sothebys 1987 #293 2001 p73 AB Galleries Christies March 24, 1965 #143 #143 1965 24, March Christies 2002/03 p84 p84 2002/03 Scottish Art Review vol VI, VI, vol Review Art Scottish #1 41 1956 p Bell Aberdeen of advertisement Sothebys Scone Palace April 10, 1978 #66 October 1999 1999 October foot, aved "1766/Ex "1766/Ex aved foliage, engr foliage, des, for beer, engraved with swags swags with engraved beer, for des, Scotland of Museums National ed swags of flowers and flowers of swags ed (3oz 5d ea) 5d ea) (3oz ò´KWR] Dono/Margt. Carruther", en suite witha salver crest and motto of Ross of Priesthill, 3 1/3" ht, 6.2oz 6.2oz ht, 1/3" 3 Priesthill, of Ross of motto and crest Edinburgh Edinburgh both, 6oz ht, ½" 2 one, on monogram handle, loop plain, shaped, pear Mug, Edinburgh Edinburgh 6.3oz ht, 3" motto, and crest foot, low on baluster, Mug, Catalog, Internet Shaw Nicholas William Dempster Dempster William William Dempster Dempster William 1770 ca 1770 ca Gordon James Aberdeen details no Mug, and Museums Aberdeen 1775 ca 1775 ca 1776/77 Campbell & Milne 1777/78 Glasgow Robertson Patrick 1781/82 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh 11d 11oz ht, ¼" 3 vi", via "Fit motto crest, head boar's pair, Mugs, or Davie William Edinburgh si straight with large Mug, 1782/83 14oz ht, 4" Cantroy, of Davidson of crest band, engraved pair, Mugs, Gairdner Alexander # 1981 24, June Christies Edinburgh 19 4, October Sothebys 1d 27oz monogram, initials Mug, cylindrical, 1977 June 2, Sothebys 1765 ca 1765 ca Graham Adam 1765/66 1769 ca Clark Robert Glasgow Campbell & Milne 1770 ca rim molded handle, scroll double capped leaf form, Mug, baluster Edinburgh Glasgow Campbell & Milne no details Mug, small, details no Mug, Glasgow 5.6oz ht, 3/8" 3 "G.C.W.", initials with engraved pint, half Mug, baluster Catal Shaw Nicholas p549 Marks Jackson August Gleneagles Sothebys 1765 ca 1765 ca Graham Adam Glasgow 7.6oz ht, ½" 3 "HD", initials script with engraved pint, half Mug, baluster, Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1764/65 Dempster & Ker Edinburgh restrain with Mug YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1761/62 LOCATION or Davie William SOURCE 1761/62 Gordon Robert Edinburgh foot, spreading on handle, scroll double capped plain form, Mug, baluster

320 General Mugs DAG008796 DAG008796 DAG008654 DAG008654 1964-141-1 1964-141-1 Nicholas Shaw Catalog Autumn Autumn Catalog Shaw Nicholas #38 1996 p25, #39 p17, 1997 Autumn Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2001 p77 + Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2000 p80 Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p105 AB Galleries in 1992 acquired Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2001 p84 Galleries AB Galleries 1988 acquired Nicholas Shaw Internet Catalog Catalog Internet Shaw Nicholas 2004 Galleries MEQ 820 VRQDOWHUQDWHSDQHOFUHVWDQGPRWWR,+23( JPRQRJUDPPHG³+/´ $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG ic style style ic Scotland of Museums National Sons, 3 7/8" ht, 6.6oz 6.6oz ht, 7/8" 3 Sons, 3 ¾" ht, 7.5oz 3.9oz 3.9oz Robertson Robertson 4.1oz 4.1oz 3/8", 9.6oz 9.6oz 3/8", Edinburgh Edinburgh details no engraved, Mug, Scotland of Museums National William Dempster Dempster William 1861/62 M J 1881/82 Reid J Glasgow Glasgow 4.9oz ht, ½" 3 case, its original in panels, engraved with Mug & C Rait D by retailed animals, 6 different with decorated mug, Christening Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 0DUVKDOO 6RQV (GLQEXUJK 0XJRFWDJRQDOFDVWILJXUH 1842/43 Sons & Marshall Edinburgh Mug, Goth 1815 ca 1815 ca Booth George 1816/17 Aberdeen 1830 ca McKay James Jamieson mugs tot William of pair Mugs, Edinburgh Aberdeen child, a Mug, for ht, 3/8" 3 Crawford", E. B. to ITM "From engraved baluster, plain Mug, and Museums Aberdeen 1991 USA NY Shrubsole 1810 ca 1810 ca Jamieson William Aberdeen mu Christening 1813/14 I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh of motto and crest throughout, chased foot, spreading on form, Mug, baluster 1800 ca 1800 ca Keith John 1810 ca I Keay Robert Banff Perth no details beer, Mug, for ht, 2 7/8" crest, head stag's a with engraved cylindrical, mug, Christening Art and Museums Dundee YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1782/83 LOCATION or Davie William SOURCE 1791/92 Robertson William Edinburgh 4 of height rib mid Ayrshire, of M'Adam of motto and crest cylindrical, Mug,

321 Compendium of Scottish Silver MEQ 1620 1620 MEQ YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1898/99 LOCATION KG or KC Edinburgh Dewar" Kern "Robert engraved mug, Christening SOURCE Scotland of Museums National

322 Thistle

ThistleTHISTLE MUGSMugs

Plate 35. A Thistle Mug 1710ca by George Robertson, Aberdeen. Courtesy of The MapleCourtesy Swan of The Collectio Maplen Swan. Photograph Collection by .Janice M Dietert.

323 Compendium of Scottish Silver QQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQHS 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV2FWREHU &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU &KULVWLHV0DUFK Collection Gardner 0XQUR&ROOHFWLRQ :DUN+XQWLQJWRQ/LEUDU\ +XJKHVS vol 90 vol 6RWKHE\V$SULO Christies Glasgow November 16, 16, November Glasgow Christies &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ0DUFK 6RWKHE\V0DUFK Dreweatt Neate , Donnington Donnington , Neate Dreweatt $SULO $%' ò´KWR] OLHGZLWKVWUDSV ´KWR] G LQDWLQJLQ 05KW $&0&´DERYHDFDO\[RI WHPSRUDU\VHWVRILQLWLDOVDERYHUHHGHG ZHUERG\RQULPIRRWDSSOLHGPROGHG LWKDUURZWRSSHGOREHVDSSOLHGYHUWLFDOOHDYHV PIRRWDSSOLHGORELQJWRORZHUERG\PROGHG DSSOLHGOHDYHVPLGULELQLWLDOVEHORZPLG SOLHGJLUGOH´KWR] &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK$XJXVW JLUGOHVFUROOKDQGOHHQJUDYHGZLWKFRQWHPSRUDU\LQLWLDOVó UHHGHGPLGULEIODWVFUROOKDQGOHLQLWLDOVEHORZWKHOLS$' R] JLUGOHóKWR] girdle with band pricked of dots, scrollhandle work withwriggle curved oval and thumbpiece, dot pricked with decoration corded of band with applied EDQGVLQVFULEHGZLWKLQLWLDOV³,600´PDUNVXQGHUEDVH±*: JRWKLF'±´KWR] 7KLVWOHPXJLQYHUWHGEHOOIRUPRQFLUFXODUULPIRRWERG\DSSEHORZDPROGHGULEEHDGHGVFUROOKDQGOHGPDUNHGXQGHUEDVH JLUGOHHYHUWHGOLSORZHUSDUWRIERG\ZLWKDSSOLHGOREHVWHUP LQYHUWHGKRRSVDWULPIRRWGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHó´KWR] applied beaded lobes, double scroll handle, handle, scroll double lobes, beaded applied DP6FRWW %DQII 7KLVWOHPXJPLQLDWXUHHQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDOV³ THISTLE -DPHV&RFNEXUQ (GLQEXUJK :LOOLDP&OHUN 7KLVWOHPXJLQLWLDOVDERYHDS *ODVJRZ 7KLVWOHPXJVSDLUQRGHWDLOV &R FD 5REHUW%URFN *ODVJRZ 7KLVWOHPXJDSSOLHGORELQJWROR -RKQ6HDWRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7KLVWOHPXJKDOISLQWJLUGOHZ -DPHV&RFNEXUQ (GLQEXUJK 7KLVWOHPXJVSDLUHQJUDYLQJ FD *HRUJH:DONHU $EHUGHHQ 7KLVWOHPXJVSDLUHDFKRQDUL 1690 ca 1690 ca Clerk William Glasgow FD 05FRQMRLQHG ,QYHUQHVV 7KLVWOHPXJHQJUDYHGZLWKFRQ 1688 ca 1688 ca 1690 ca Elphinstone Robert Inverness Willi miniature mug, Thistle UK Collection Private YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

324 Thistle 20 J Bourdon-Smith Catalog 2005 2005 Catalog J Bourdon-Smith p8 #46 Collection Jackson National Wales Museum of p65 2000 Catalog Shaw Nicholas Christies May 30, 1904 #97 1904 30, May Christies XI 1968 vol Review Art Scottish cover #4 back advertisement Edinburgh of How p215 Holland Sothebys November 30, 1973 1973 30, November Sothebys #137 73 1ol April Magazine Antiques advertisement Bell #170 1963, 16, October Christies 1979 #248 of courtesy p49 Luddington Sothebys #75 9, 1926 February Christies Tessiers London Private Collection Collection Private Private Collection UK UK Collection Private p1 1991 text Finlay t full size, no details no size, full t may be the miniature listed next and no and next listed the miniature be may handled, engraved "Fordoun", 3 3/8"ht, 7.3oz 3 14/" ht 3 14/" 6oz 18d 18d 6oz initials "B/B", 3 1/6" ht, 6.2oz 6.2oz ht, 1/6" 3 "B/B", initials miniature both exist, no details details no exist, both miniature and size full if unclear above, as same be may miniature, mug, Thistle 1694/95 Yorstoun George 1694/95 Edinburgh Law Andrew handle scroll triple lobes, applied thing long girdle, double mug, Thistle p544 Marks Jackson Edinburgh reeded band, rib mid reeded leaves, curved applied with mug, Thistle 1694/95 Seatoun James Edinburgh "WF/BF", initials block reeding, of bands 2 leaves, applied with mug, Thistle 1694/95 Cockburn James Edinburgh 1694/95 12d 5oz ht, 3" leaves, above dot mug, Thistle Seatoun John 1694/95 Edinburgh Seatoun John 18d 6oz handle, beaded leaves, vertical with mug Thistle Edinburgh 27, ht, ¼" August 3 Gleneagles handle, Sothebys tail rat leaves, vertical mid-ribs, 2 reeded mug, Thistle #22 1921 8, June Christies 1694/95 II Law Andrew Edinburgh handle, strap beaded appliqué, leaf vertical girdle, double with mug Thistle 1694 ca 1694 ca Graham Walter Canongate YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1694 ca LOCATION Graham Walter Canongate mug, Thistle SOURCE

325 Compendium of Scottish Silver er 1934 #147 #147 1934 DAG001386 DAG001386 Sothebys NY October 28, 1992 1992 28, October NY Sothebys #348 1973 Edinburgh of How H.1996.275 Connoisseur Magazine 1934 1934 Magazine Connoisseur 93 p348 vol #52 1936 Edinburgh of How UK Collection Private 23, 1930 July Christies Exhibit Academy Art Scottish Galleries AB Galleries Goodwin's Edinburgh 1995 Edinburgh Goodwin's Collection Phoenix The Williamsburg p58 1943, Review Art Scottish #13 advertisement How 169 pl 1992 Exhibition How 1970 vol 112 p82 112 1970 vol Christies June 23, 1920 #47 1920 23, June Christies Country Life August 1964 1964 August Life Country p331 136 vol p215 Holland UGOHDQGOREHòKWR] +\PDQ&ROOHFWLRQ±&RORQLDO lobed leaf, engraved initials, girdle, 3 ½" ht, 5oz 15d 15d ht, 5oz ½" 3 girdle, initials, engraved leaf, lobed Novemb Magazine Burlington applied lobes, girdle, 1 ¾" ht, 1oz 1oz ht, ¾" 1 girdle, lobes, applied thumb ridges, 3 ¼ 3 ¼ ridges, thumb " ht, 13d 5oz 1 5/8" ht 1 5/8" top top (5oz 3d ea) 3d ea) (5oz grip), applied lobes, lobes, applied grip), Aberdeen Aberdeen size dram given, details few probably, mug, Thistle and Museums Aberdeen younger 1695 ca 1695 Scott William 1695 ca Scott William Banff mug thistle Miniature Scotland of Museums National 1696/97 Forbes Alexander Edinburgh with handle pattern, chain with lip and foot leaves, vertical mug, Thistle 1695 ca Scott William Banff above, the one from different handle handle, mug, strap thistle Miniature 1696/97 II Law Andrew Edinburgh 17d 5oz ht, 3" handle, scroll beaded rib, mid leaves vertical mug, Thistle 19, March Christies FD &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH 1695 ca (GLQEXUJK Scott William 0LQLDWXUHWKLVWOHPXJZLWKJL Banff IE", "RR initials entwined, center handle loop mug, thistle Miniature 1695 ca 1695 ca Seatoun John Edinburgh across ¾" 1 ht, ½" 1 lobes, leaf applied handle, strap mug, thistle Miniature 1695 ca 1695 ca Seatoun John Edinburgh mug, Thistle 1695/96 Law Andrew Edinburgh both 7d 10oz leaves, vertical band, mid reeded pair, mugs, Thistle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1695/96 LOCATION Elder Scott William Banff (thumb notches horizontal with handle strap Trophy, Huntley mug, Thistle SOURCE

326 Thistle Picture Files Files Picture Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 p95 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas Christies May 16, 1916 #17 16, 1916 May Christies #502 Collection How Collection Gardner 1934 Magazine Connoisseur 93 p348 vol How Exhibition 1992 #27 pl 16 16 pl #27 1992 Exhibition How Glasgow Exhibition 1911, vol I, I, vol 1911, Exhibition Glasgow #20 p123, +HUULRW¶V+RVSLWDO7UXVWHHVRQ of Museums National to loan Scotland Jackson Marks p544 MEQ 1556 1983 1983 1556 MEQ Scottish Christies 1939 #914 1939 #914 Collection Cathcart-White J # 48 1991 Finlay 1949 October Magazine Antiques 56 vol Scotland of Museums National 1943.249 HKWR]G &KULVWLHV0DUFK "MR" under coronet on bottom bottom on coronet under "MR" Scotland of Museums National OOHDYHVUHHGHGPLGULEEHDGHGVWUDSKDQGOH UHHGHGPLGULEEHDGHGVFUROOKDQGOH HVEHDGHGVFUROOKDQGOH $UW7UHDVXUH([KLELWLRQ of Newton, 3 ¼" ht, 5.2oz 5.2oz ht, ¼" 3 of Newton, ht, 3 ¼" 5oz 6d script initials "IB MC", 3" ht, 4oz 15d 15d 4oz ht, 3" MC", "IB initials script confused with the Andrew Law pair of 1695/96 1695/96 pair of Law Andrew the with confused (GLQEXUJK 7KLVWOHPXJZLWKYHUWLFDOOHDYHVEHDGHGVFUROOKDQGO (continued) (continued) Bruce :LOOLDP&OHUN1698/99 Robert *ODVJRZ 7KLVWOHPXJVSDLUYHUWLFDOOHDY 1698/99 Bruce Robert Edinburgh of Montgomery crest with rib, mid a reeded leaves, applied with mug Thistle 5REHUW%UXFH (GLQEXUJK 7KLVWOHPXJZLWKYHUWLFDOOHDYHV -RKQ6HDWRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7KLVWOHPXJZLWKSRLQWHGYHUWLFD 1696/97 II Law Andrew Edinburgh are they chance slight 1682/83, as misdated originally mugs, thistle Pair of 1696/97 Cockburn James Edinburgh ht ¼" 3 handled, 2 mugs, thistle Pair of #122 1959 18, March Christies YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1696/97 Robert Bruce Edinburgh mug, engraved thistle Miniature

327 Compendium of Scottish Silver Sothebys July 20, 1982 #151 1982 20, July Sothebys XIV vol Review Art Scottish cover 1973 back advertisement Edinburgh of How OctoberSothebys NY USA 28, 1992 #348 #56 1936 Edinburgh of How 16, November Glasgow Christies 1994 #685 1939 Magazine Connoisseur p35 103 vol advertisement How Sothebys June 15, 1978 #25 1978 June 15, Sothebys Private Collection Collection Private Apollo 1933 vol 25 p18 25 1933 vol Apollo advertisement How 1939 Magazine Connoisseur p35 103 vol advertisement How London Christies #54 1936 Edinburgh of How WC, Tree etc., S, 5.3oz 5.3oz S, etc., Tree WC, #55 1936 Edinburgh of How PROGHGVWUDSKDQGOHULPIRRWPPRQO\ô´KWR] beading below the girdle, engraved with initials above, scroll handle, on rim rim on handle, scroll above, initials with engraved girdle, the below beading IRRWô´KW 1 ½" ht almost vertically, straight body, 8.7oz both both 8.7oz body, straight vertically, almost Edinburgh Edinburgh 7.4oz handle, scroll corded leaves, vertical with mug Thistle #94 1935 19, June Christies 1700/01 Alexander Forbes Forbes 1700/01 1700/01 Alexander Seaton John Edinburgh details no mug, Thistle Collection Swan Maple The 1700 ca 1700 ca II Scott William 1700 ca Banff Scott William handle strap reeded miniature, mug, Thistle Banff girdle, molded below applied work strap vertical Mug, Thistle Miniature Antiques Castle Grantully 1700 ca 1700 ca Walker George Aberdeen and work strap vertical applied shape, thistle typical Mug, Thistle Miniature 1699/1700 1699/1700 Bruce Robert 1700 ca Forbes Alexander Edinburgh Edinburgh 14d 4 oz ribs, mid reeded leaves, vertical with mug Thistle initials, later and contemporary girdle, reeded mug, thistle Miniature #130 31, 1918 July Christies :LOOLDP&OHUN *ODVJRZ 7KLVWOHPXJPDUNHG± YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1698/99 LOCATION Clerk William Glasgow lobes applied girdle, broad beading, with handles strap pair, mugs, Thistle SOURCE

328 Thistle 28, 1968 1968 28, , 1972 , 1972 #240 agles August 28, 28, August agles Christies Edinburgh November November Edinburgh Christies #35 1990 21, Shrubsole London 1991 Collection Phoenix The 1975 #134 90 p206 vol #57 1937 Edinburgh of How 1929 Exhibition House Seaford #535 trust Hamilton of Duke #40 Edinburgh of How Christies April 15, 1964 #103 #103 1964 15, April Christies Alcorn, Fine Art Museum of #249 p327 #32.407 1932 Edith Playfair Lady of Gift 1992 Exhibition How EHDGHGWKXPESLHFHLQLWLDOV.-´ top the across ¼" 3 or Alexander Kincaid of Edinburgh, 1 ¾" ht ¾" 1 Edinburgh, of Kincaid or Alexander underneath "IR;S", 3 3/16" ht, 5oz 3/16" 3 "IR;S", underneath Edinburgh Thistle mug, spiraled leaves at the base, midrib band, beadedhandle, 3 ½"ht, $VVD\HU±-DPHV Penman 1701/02 Edward Penman Penman 1701/02 Edward 1701/02 McKenzie Colin Edinburgh 4d 11oz ht, ¼" 3 underneath, "IL" initials leaf, no girdle, pair, mugs, Thistle Glene Sothebys 1701/02 McKenzie Colin 1701/02 Edinburgh Seatoun John 6oz ht, 1701/02 3 ¼" above, the of one probably no leaf, mug, Thistle Edinburgh Inglis Robert 5.9oz mug, Thistle Edinburgh 1989 18, October NY Christies leaves vertical pair, mugs, Thistle #84 1, 1931 July Christies 1932, Magazine Connoisseur 1700 ca 1700 ca 1700 ca McKenzie Colin Penman James Edinburgh ht 2 ½" only, mm "G", initial the with engraved base girdle, mug, Thistle Edinburgh 11 October Christies handle, scroll girdle, molded lobing, leaf only, mm mug, thistle Miniature 1700 ca 1700 ca McKenzie Colin Edinburgh ht 1 3/8" no leaf, girdle front, initial on engraved mug, thistle Miniature November Sothebys 1700 ca 1700 ca Kincaid Alexander 1700 ca Edinburgh only mm cipher mug, thistle Miniature Edinburgh of Forbes Alexander to attributable possibly mug, thistle Miniature #25 1978 June 15, Sothebys YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1700/01 LOCATION Penman James Edinburgh initials lobes, applied handles, strap beaded girdle, applied with mug Thistle SOURCE

329 Compendium of Scottish Silver 934 #146 #146 934 Jackson Marks p568 p568 Marks Jackson Sothebys April 26, 1979 #138 #138 1979 26, April Sothebys 1979 11, October Sothebys House Hopetoun Sothebys #96 1978 13, November Exhibition Academy Art Scottish 1931 #109 Collection Ashburton 1939 Exhibition Empire Glasgow #190 Exhibit Academy Art Scottish 1939 #942 Collection Noble Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1981 #458 Christies March 1993 #112 1993 March Christies +\PDQ&ROOHFWLRQ±&RORQLDO Williamsburg Sothebys Hopetoun House House Hopetoun Sothebys #63 1978 13, November advertisement Bell Collection Gardner Christies Glasgow September 8, 8, September Glasgow Christies 1987 #101 1995", 1995", December th mug, no details no details mug, handle, engraved later "Presented to Duncan by his mother Ellen Carline Carline Ellen mother his by Duncan to "Presented later engraved handle, McPherson Glencoe, McDonald of 25 initials underneath "IH IL", 3 14/" ht, 10oz 10oz ht, 14/" 3 IL", "IH initials underneath beaded 3" ht, strap handle, 10.6oz beaded scroll strap scrollhandle, later crest (shortedand lighter thanaverage), ht, ¾" 2 4.1oz 5oz 5oz ´KW Edinburgh Edinburgh the opposite initials girdle, a mid below leaves lobed pair, mug, Thistle III 1703 ca 1703 ca Walker George Aberdeen Cleghorne 5d 5oz band, mid reeded leaves, vertical mug, Thistle 1703/04 Thomas 1703/04 Bruce Robert #86 1940 24, March Christies Edinburgh scroll capped leaf with girdle, a reeded below leaves lobed large, mug, Thistle 1703/04 Jr Scott George Edinburgh decoration, leaf girdle, decoration, beaded handle, strap pair, mugs, Thistle 1704/05 1704/05 I Murray Patrick 1704/05 Jr Luke John Edinburgh Jr Penman John no details be, to presumed mug, Thistle Glasgow Edinburgh Thistle 7d 5oz ht, ½" 3 handle, scroll reeded rib, reeded no leaf, mug, Thistle 1 19, March Christies 544 p Marks Jackson 1703/04 Rae Richard Edinburgh the to tail rat beaded girdle, reeded a below leaves applied with mug, Thistle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1702/03 LOCATION Bruce Robert Edinburgh ht, ¼" 3 handle, plain scroll leaves, applied no girdle, double mug, Thistle SOURCE

330 Thistle 106 #739756 #739756 gative gative Christies November 14, 1945 1945 14, November Christies #116 Brothers Crichton #14 p62 Institute Art Clark Gees, Mr. Goldie-Tanbaman Goldie-Tanbaman Mr. #170 28, 1973 February Christies Ne Christies Garrards London London Garrards #149 1965 28, June Christies Clayton Christies Book p #180 1937 8, April Christies Collection Ivory 1939 Magazine Connoisseur p29 103 vol advertisement Guille #574 1989 April NY Christies 2001 5, June London Sothebys #391 Shaw Collection Collection Shaw 29, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #36 Sothebys March 27, 1984 #93 1984 27, March Sothebys How Collection Collection How Sothebys February 28, 1974 #118 1974 28, February Sothebys no lobes, 5oz 11d 5oz no lobes, ht, 10oz 10d 10oz ht, 5oz 13d 5oz between them, girdle, straploop handle reeded with bands, with base a PRQRJUDPò´KWR] KDQGOHULGJHGIRRW´KWR]G 10oz 4d 10oz Edinburgh Edinburgh 2.6oz ht, 3" girdle, handle, scroll rib mid leaf, no pair, mugs, Thistle #701 1929 Exhibition Lane Park Edinburgh Edinburgh straps leaf rib, mid "h" initial script case small mug, thistle Miniature #69 1941 13, August Christies Robert Inglis Inglis Robert 1705/06 George Scott Scott 1705/06 George 1705/06 McKenzie Colin Edinburgh 3.1" repairs, old "IB/HG", initials leaves, applied no plain, pair, mug, Thistle 1705 ca 1705 ca 1705/06 available Not Inglis Robert Edinburgh handles, scroll initials "M/AM/CR", lip, band, spreading reeded mug, Thistle plain mug, Thistle #591 Book Waldron 1705/06 Jr Luke John Glasgow ht, 3" EG", "IL initials girdle, leaf vertical handle, beaded mug, Thistle 1705 ca 1705 ca RI 1705 ca 1705 ca 1705 ca Robertson George Walker Aberdeen George ht 3" "M/WL/MG", initials leaf, no girdle, pair, mug, Thistle Aberdeen tongues card cut with small lobes, applied foot, molded on mug, Thistle 28, 1973 February Christies 1705 ca 1705 ca Munro John Inverness scroll rim, double flared below girdle reeded applied mug, thistle Miniature YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1704/05 LOCATION Jr Luke John Edinburgh ht, 3" lip, under motto and crest later leaf, pointed girdle, pair, mugs, Thistle SOURCE

331 Compendium of Scottish Silver d 1, 1973 #149 1973 1, Sothebys December 16, 1971 1971 16, December Sothebys #164 p187 103 1939 vol Christies January 31, 1979 #195 #195 31, 1979 January Christies p11 5, 1979 July Life, Country #166 Provenance of How of Edinburgh 5R\DO2QWDULR0XVHXP7RURQWR 980.99.1e Canada Sothebys Gleneagles September 2, 1981 #452 #151 21, 1952 May Christies PhillipsEdinburgh December 4, 1997 #333 20, February Turnbull & Lyon 2004 #264 MEQ 791 1965.1882 1965.1882 791 MEQ 1936.279 1936.279 foot, lower part of body applied with flutes, DQGIRRWHQJUDYHGDWWKHOLSZLWKLQLWLDOV aves, script initials "JM" or "IM" "IM" or "JM" initials script aves, Scotlan of Museums National details details Scotland of Museums National shallow fluting below a decorative tooled band, 3 ½" ht, 5.1oz 5.1oz ht, ½" 3 band, tooled a decorative below fluting shallow KDQGOHLQLWLDOV³)5*´ reeded bandabove, everted lip,reeded scrollhandle, engraved with crestand PRWWR´KWR]G above, initials "W*N" below a later crest, scroll handle, unusually tucked in in tucked unusually handle, scroll crest, later a below "W*N" initials above, 4.5oz ht, 3/8" 3 foot, on spreading scroll beaded handles, each engraved with later date crest and initials initials and crest date later with engraved each handles, beaded scroll ³56$6´GDWHGR]ERWK 5REHUW,QJOLV (GLQEXUJK 7KLVWOHPXJZLWKODWHUKDQGOH 1709/10 Forbes Alexander Edinburgh inscription engraved leaves, no plain pair, mugs, Thistle April Magazine Connoisseur 1708/09 1708/09 Turnbull Patrick Luke John Edinburgh 8d 3oz handle, scroll plain, rib mid no leaf, mug, Thistle Glasgow opposite engraved girdle, applied lobes, applied 12 shaped, bell mug, Thistle #28 1908 26, March Christies 1707/08 Ker Thomas 1708/09 Jr Luke John Edinburgh 6d 4oz rib, mid beaded leaves, vertical mug, Thistle Glasgow rim on fluted, partly mug, Thistle #37 12, 1918 February Christies 1707/08 Seaton John Edinburgh girdle applied rim, flared body, shaped bell leaves, no applied mug, Thistle 1707 ca 1707 ca Luke John Glasgow double lobes, appliqué of calyx lip, everted with each pair, mugs, Thistle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1705/06 LOCATION Luke John Glasgow no mug, Thistle SOURCE 1705/06 1706/07 Jr Luke John 1706/07 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh Glasgow Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh 5d 4oz ht, 3" handle, strap foot, low no leaf, girdle, applied mug, Thistle details no mug, Thistle le engraved with mug, Thistle June 2 Sothebys p568 Marks Jackson

332 Thistle n 1933 #68 1933 1980 1980 939 #125 #125 939 ecember 13, ecember 10, Jackson Marks p771 #1000 #1000 p771 Marks Jackson Collection Girdwood Collection How Christies D Christies Christies July 3, 1984 #126 #126 3, 1984 July Christies PhillipsEdinburgh October 24, 1986 #181 Collection Shaw 29, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #35 D Christies #128 Sothebys March 6, 1990 1990 6, March Sothebys Christies February 5, 1947 #90 #90 5, 1947 February Christies +\PDQ&ROOHFWLRQ±&RORQLDO Williamsburg Christies March 19, 1934 #145 #145 1934 19, March Christies Provenance of How Exhibit Academy Art Scottish 1939 #944 Scotland of Museums National Collection Gardner 1934 Magazine Connoisseur 93 p348 vol Sothebys December 17, 1964 1964 17, December Sothebys #285 foot, molded girdle, scroll foot, lower part of body with "Suddie", 1oz 1oz "Suddie", 12d handle, initials and later date of 1724, 1 5/8"ht, 1oz 1oz 5/8"ht, 1724, 1 of date later and initials handle, applied fluting,reeded rib above, scrollhandle, engraved with initials ³0,*/'´PPRQO\ò´KWR]G applied molded girdles, simple loop handles handles loop simple girdles, molded applied the one above, 3 ¼" ht, 5oz 5d 5oz ht, 3 ¼" above, one the 6oz 3d 6oz Inverness Inverness engraved handle, rib scroll mid leaves, vertical mug, thistle Miniature 1710 ca 1710 Ker Thomas 1710 ca McKenzie Simon Edinburgh ht½" 1 mug, thistle Miniature 1992 Exhibition How 1710 ca 1710 1710 ca Robertson George Aberdeen Ker Thomas handle scroll leaves, applied lobed, band, mid rib with mug, Thistle Edinburgh rim on a body shaped bell mug, thistle Miniature Collectio Swan Maple The 1710 ca 1710 ca Robertson George Aberdeen rim molded on Anne, Queen mug, Thistle 1710 ca 1710 ca Bethune Henry Edinburgh "IT/RB", handle opposite initials leaves, applied no pair, mugs, Thistle 1709/10 Jr Luke John Glasgow from different weight apparent rib, mid molded leaves, vertical mug, Thistle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1709/10 LOCATION Blair Charles Edinburgh 5d 4oz ht, handle 3" tail rat lip, everted shaped, bell plain, mug, Thistle 5, 1 July Christies SOURCE 1709/10 Jr Luke John Glasgow ht, ¼" 3 handle, scroll beaded leaves, vertical rib, mid beaded mug, Thistle

333 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1930 #49 1930 981 #48 ecember 17, Christies June 24, 1981 #41 1981 24, June Christies D Christies Christies November 8, 1972 #80 1972 8, November Christies #54 1987 5-10, October Sothebys #260 Lyon & Turnbull, February 20, 2004 #318 Christies Scotland November 14, 14, November Scotland Christies 1985 #292 J. R. Medrum p120 text 1991 Finlay Museum Metropolitan Possibly 1984 1679 MEQ How of Edinburgh Edinburgh of How Toronto Museum Ontario Royal OHPDUNV±:6 OREHVLQLWLDOV³:5,0´ 5oz 10d 5oz body below molded central band, strap handle, engraved with betrothal betrothal with engraved handle, strap band, central molded below body LQLWLDOV³$60)´´KW faceted molded scrollhandle, reeded on foot, undersides engraved "RE", 3 ¼" ht, 13.7oz FRQMRLQHG$%'ò´KWô´GL later monogram and date "1883", 3 ¼" ht, 5.6oz 5.6oz ht, ¼" 3 "1883", date and monogram later ´KW´GLDWWKHPRXWKGLIIHUHQWIURPFDPXJ Edinburgh Edinburgh part girdle, molded applied lips, everted shaped, bell pair, mugs, Thistle $EHUGHHQ 7KLVWOHPXJPLQLDWXUHRQPROGHGULPIRRWVWUDSKDQG Inver Inver miniature mug, Thistle Scotland of Museums National ,QYHUQHVV 7KLVWOHPXJPLQLDWXUHVWUDSKDQGOHJLUGOHDSSOLHG illiam Scott the the Scott illiam Younger McKenzie (continued) (continued) Innes 1711/12 John Seaton Seaton 1710/11 1711/12 John McKenzie Colin Edinburgh 1711/12 15d 5oz handle, scroll rib, mid reeded leaves, Vertical Campbell Colin 1711/12 1711/12 Edinburgh Mitchelson James 1715 ca lip, to widening underneath, "RDS" initials Mitchelson James no leaf, girdle, mid Edinburgh mug, Thistle 1716/17 Edinburgh McKenzie Simon 5d 7oz handle, rib scroll mid mug, Thistle #46 1943 9, June Christies Bethune Henry 15d 7oz ht, ½" 3 girdle, no leaf, foot, tall circular a Inverness on mug, Thistle 1720 ca miniature mug, Thistle Edinburgh Ross Hugh 1 24, June Christies 1720 ca motto and crest later girdle, applied mug, Thistle W Tain #141 1945 23, March Christies lobed shape, thistle traditional gauge heavy only, mm miniature, mug, Thistle 1968 28, November Sothebys UK Collection Private 1720 ca 1720 ca Simon Possibly M YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1710 ca 1710 ca 1710/11 available Not Seaton John Edinburgh with handle, scroll girdle, applied molded leaves, no applied mug, Thistle Hamilton of Duke of Trustees ribs, applies pair, mugs, Thistle #699 1929 Exhibition Lane Park 1720 ca Robert Probably RI

334 Thistle Art G , 1981 #47 , 1981 er 14, 1976 #186 #186 1976 er 14, E 1986-126 1986-126 1939 #916 1939 #916 Stirling-Maxwell Bt #143 1965 24, March Christies USA 64:25 USA 1987 #293 Galleries Christies April 15, 1969 #103 #103 1969 15, April Christies PhillipsEdinburgh November 21, 2000 #276 Shrubsole NY USA Toronto Museum Ontario Royal 988.33.139 Canada Canada 988.33.138 988.33.138 Canada Pô´KW PRQRQHòKWR] ´GL 6DQ'LHJR0XVHXPRI$UW&$ LQLIVLPLODUWRHDUOLHUWKLVWOHPXJVLQIRUP 'XQGHH0XVHXPVDQ GEDQGFUHVWRI'DYLGVRQRI&DQWUR\KWR] 6RWKHE\V2FWR both (3oz 5d ea) ea) 5d (3oz both calyx of petals, molded rib above, reeded scroll handle, engraved with a a with engraved handle, scroll reeded above, rib molded petals, of calyx FLSKHUSRVVLEO\WKHVDPHDVWKHRQHLQWKH5R\DO2QWDULR0XVHX ZLWKLQLWLDOV³'0+´PPRQEDVH+5FRQMRLQHGò´KW´GL UHHGHGJLUGOH6KDQGOH´KWô´GLDWWKHULP (GLQEXUJK 7KLVWOHPXJSHDUVKDSHGSODLQORRSKDQGOHPRQRJUD :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU (continued) (continued) FD +XJK5RVV 7DLQ 7KLVWOHPXJSHDUVKDSHG´KW :LOOLDP'DYLHRU 1816/17 FD McKay James 'DYLG0DVRQ Edinburgh no details mug, thistle Miniature 'XQGHH 7KLVWOHFXSPXJQRGHWDLOVXQFHUWD 1991 NY Shrubsole 1747ca 1747ca Telford Samuel Glasgow ht 3" rib, mid leaves, vertical mug, Thistle Exhibit Academy Art Scottish 1769 ca 1769 ca Campbell & Milne 1775 ca Glasgow Campbell & Milne details no mug, Thistle Glasgow 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK11d 11oz ht, ¼" 3 vi", via "Fit motto crest, head boar's pair, mugs, Thistle 7KLVWOHPXJVSDLUHQJUDYH 24 June Christies August Gleneagles Sothebys 1730 ca 1730 ca Forbes Alexander Aberdeen applied with body of part lower foot, molded slightly mug, thistle Miniature 1730 ca 1730 ca Ross Hugh Tain engraved foot, on spreading body squat girdle, applied mug, thistle Miniature YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1730 ca 1730 ca Forbes Alexander Aberdeen lobes, applied rim, foot round on shape bell inverted miniature, mug, Thistle

335 Compendium of Scottish Silver

336 Mustard Pots

MustardMUSTARD POTS Pots

Plate 36. A Mustard Pot 1811/12 by Francis Howden, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

337 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1971-981 1971-981 MEQ 815 1987 #299 Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p102 Noble Collection Collection Noble #79 1983 29, March Christies p89 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1982 1, December Sothebys Galleries Collection Private ece, oval domed R] ece, scriptinitials Mustard pot, no details details no pot, Mustard Scotland of Museums National spreading base, detachable cover with swirl lobes and fluted, engraved with with engraved fluted, and lobes swirl with cover detachable base, spreading IORZHUVGLDSHUDQGRWKHUPRWLIVEDOXVWHUILQLDO´KW ht,"G.E.C.", 3 3/8" 9.2oz a reededa bandapplied to the and body, the unpierced crest with dome pull cover off body lower piercing, foliate and scroll simulated with engraved 3.6oz ht, ¼" 4 Cunningham, of motto lid, original blue glass liner, marked on base and lid, engraved initials initials engraved lid, and base on marked liner, glass blue original lid, 10d 2oz ht, ¼" "WES", 2 MUSTARD POTS Assayed in Edinburgh 1810/11 available Not 1811/12 1823/24 Howden Francis 1825/26 McHattie George Edinburgh McHattie George Edinburgh no details pot, Mustard Edinburgh pot drum-shaped circular, no details pot, mark, Mustard "RK" with struck over mm pot, Mustard 8d 4oz di, ½" 2 liner, glass blue original shaped, drum pot, Mustard Collection Private August Gleneagles Sothebys 1993 London Bourdon-Smith J Collection Swan Maple The 1809/10 J. F. 1809/10 J. 1745 ca 1745 ca Glen James 1780 ca Robertson Patrick Glasgow 1786/87 Edinburgh 1788/89 Downie David shoulder, molded below initials shape, pear inverted II, George vase, Mustard no details given, no date pot, Mustard 1790 ca Duffus Thomas Edinburgh Douglas James Edinburgh 4.4oz ht, 1/8" 5 lid, domed with shaped, urn pot, Mustard 1795/96 no details Pot, Mustard Edinburgh 1795/96 Henderson Alexander Edinburgh pi thumb shaped urn handle, reeded oval, plain, pot, Mustard Fenwick George no details pot, Mustard Edinburgh p95 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas pi thumb shell leaves, cut bright with oval pot, Mustard Art and Museums Dundee p550 Marks Jackson p550 Marks Jackson 1729/30 Aytoun William Edinburgh with foot, spreading molded on finial, no type, bun baluster pot, mustard Dry YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

338 Mustard Pots Edinburgh HH3225/68 HH3225/68 Edinburgh 1999 p62 1966.1000 853 MEQ Edinburgh HH3568/71 HH3568/71 Edinburgh LWKVLOYHUPRXQWVDQGKLQJHGOLGVô´GL +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP PRXQWVVLGHGó´KW´GL +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP JDGURRQHGERUGHU 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ no details details no Scotland of Museums National 1827/28 Paton George 1842/43 Urquhart Leonard Edinburgh 1849/50 Edinburgh 4.7oz ht, ½" 2 crest, shaped, circular pot, Mustard available Not pot, Mustard - :0DUVKDOO Edinburgh -RKQ&ULFKWRQ (GLQEXUJK pot mustard drum-shaped plain pot, Mustard 0XVWDUGSRWWDOOF\OLQGULFDO (GLQEXUJK 0XVWDUGSRWVSDLUFXWJODVVZ Autumn Catalog Shaw Nicholas #19581 2006 London Phillips SJ YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1825/26 LOCATION McHattie George Edinburgh silver with glass pot, Mustard SOURCE

339 Compendium of Scottish Silver

340 Porringers and Bleeding Bowls

PorringersPORRINGERS & AND Bleeding BLEEDING BOWLS Bowls

Plate 37. A Bleeding Bowl 1749/50 by Dougal Ged, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

341 Compendium of Scottish Silver The Phoenix Collection Collection Phoenix The Sothebys December 3, 1959 #132 #132 1959 3, December Sothebys Shaw Collection Shaw March 29, Glasgow Christies 1983 #100 Sothebys December 9, 1976 9, December Sothebys Sothebys August 28, 1969 #163 1969 28, August Sothebys Shaw Collection Collection Shaw #101 1983 29, March Christies 71 pl 1991 Finlay Noble Collection Collection Noble Brothers Crichton 1997 6, November Sothebys #190 Silver Scottish Old in Exhibited Empire Collection Loan 1938 #60 Glasgow Exhibition, 1925-21-3 Bulletin February February Bulletin 1925-21-3 #118 p22 1928 XXII Vol Finlay 1991 # 55 1991 Finlay Scotland of Museums National 1460 MEQ QGOHR] 3KLODGHOSKLD0XVHXPRI$UW monogram "AP" or "AS" on front, 4 ¼" di, 5 ¾ over handle handle over ¾ 5 di, ¼" 4 front, on "AS" or "AP" monogram IRUPHGDVDOHDIHQJUDYHGZLWKDODWHUFUHVWô´GLR]G handled shaped as a stylized acanthus leaf, with a crest, motto and coronet, coronet, and motto crest, a with leaf, acanthus a stylized as shaped handled 8.7oz scrolls around vacant cartouches, scrolling monster handles, on rim bases, bases, rim on handles, monster scrolling cartouches, vacant around scrolls DOVRVWDPSHG³0´´KWR]GERWK motto above chased decoration of flowers, scrolls and foliage, sides applied applied sides foliage, and scrolls flowers, of decoration chased above motto ZLWKVQDNHHQWZLQLQJVFUROOKDQGOHVó´R]G engraved initials on handle "EW to EP", the underside of handle bears a case a case bears handle of underside the EP", to "EW handle on initials engraved 5.5oz above, crown a with ID possibly mark, another of impression handle pierced with clovers, 5 ½" di, 7.5oz body, possibly originally with a lid lid a with originally possibly body, PORRINGERS AND BLEEDING BOWLS AND BLEEDING PORRINGERS Edinburgh Porringer/bleeding bowl, compressed circular bowl, evertedlip, casthandle Edinburgh Edinburgh lip, everted with circular plain, handled, single bowl, Porringer/bleeding Edinburgh Porringer, Circular body, engraved on one side with contemporary crest and Assayer Hugh Gordon Over striking another another striking Over possibly Edward Assayer Hugh Gordon 1749/50 Patrick Robertson Robertson 1749/50 Patrick 1749/50 Patrick Robertson Robertson 1749/50 Patrick 1748/49 Dempster Ker & 1749/50 Ged Dougal Edinburgh script handle, pierced rococo with handled, single bowl, Porringer/bleeding 1745 ca 1745 ca Glen James Glasgow and floral sprays with chased bodies of part lower II, George pair, Porringers, FD $' $EHUGHHQ %OHHGLQJERZOLQLWLDOVLQEORFN³:6´RQKD 1722/23 Bethune Henry Edinburgh handle, triangular pierced with handled, single bowl, Porringer/bleeding 1689/90 Penman James Edinburgh trefoil "BM", initials bowl, circular handled, single bowl, Porringer/bleeding 1675-77 Law William Edinburgh bulbous "TS/SM", lip the under initials handles, scroll handled, 2 Porringer, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

342 Porringers and Bleeding Bowls V0DJD]LQHYRO Sothebys Hopetoun House, House, Hopetoun Sothebys 1RYHPEHU 0(4 6FRWWLVK$UWV5HYLHZYRO back cover Edinburgh of How 0(4 advertisement Shrubsole S advertisement Gebelein &KULVWLHV-XO\ QGOHGFLUFXODUZLWKWULDQJXODUVW\OL]HG F\OLQGULFDOIRUPZLWKVFUROOKDQGOHVLQLWLDOV century style, lower chased, body handles with th no details details no Scotland of Museums National RQWKHXQGHUVLGHRQDULPIRRWòKWR] acanthus leafhandle, inscribed "Betty Dunbar gifted her by Grandmama, /DG\+HPSULJJVR] GROSKLQPDVNVDQGIROLDJH´KWR] Glasgow Glasgow front the on initials script handle, on leaves bowl, Bleeding Scotland of Museums National Assayed in Edinburgh Lothian Lothian 5REHUW*UD\ 6RQ 1755/56 Dempster & Ker 1755/56 Edinburgh Dempster Ker & Porringer, Edinburgh -DPHV*LOOLODQG details no cover, with Porringer, (GLQEXUJK %HQMDPLQ7DLW 3RUULQJHUQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK 3RUULQJHUKDQGOHGRIIODUHG p305 63, vol Magazine Antiques $QWLTXH 'RXJDO*HG (GLQEXUJK 3RUULQJHUEOHHGLQJERZOVLQJOHKD 1755/56 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh 17 in handled, 2 Porringer, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

343 Compendium of Scottish Silver

344 Quaichs

QuaichsQUAICHS

Plate 38. A Quaich 1808/09 by Matthew Craw, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

345 Compendium of Scottish Silver 2004-112 2004-112 Sothebys Hopetoun House May May House Hopetoun Sothebys 1990 #108 Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas p81 2002/03 Jackson vol 2, part III, p743, p743, III, part 2, vol Jackson 972 & 971 Fig p147 Kirk Alvah Session of Private Collection UK UK Collection Private Firestone & Parsons 1962 Parsons & Firestone Boston Fine Museum Art of 1962.168 Huntley House Museum Huntley House HH3527/70 Edinburgh Galleries foot, lug with ends downturned, decoratedwith panels of but struck 3X, 8" long, 6.5oz long, 6.5oz 8" 3X, struck but the other lug, unmarked, 10" over lugs leaves, engraved near foot,narrow 3 bands engraved around stave with the inside body, initials "M/RS/CL" panels block lip, the near tulips and roses of lines indicated under Communion cups) cups) Communion under indicated groups of hatched lines of intervals, center of the bowl engraved with a mirror mirror a with engraved bowl the of center intervals, of lines hatched of groups well, as initials and Arms other coronet, Baron's a beneath "R" of monogram 14.2oz di, 1/16" 7 ht, 3" lugs, over 10 5/8" Roughead to John Pringle Lister Burgess of Edinburgh Anno 1632, not not 1632, Anno Edinburgh of Burgess Lister Pringle John to Roughead PDUNHG´GL QUAICHS Edinburgh Quaich, large, withlugs 2 Jackson Marks p542 Edinburgh Edinburgh with decorated band a triple by interrupted staves, line with exterior Quaich, Dundee Quaich,no details Dundee Museums and Art Deacon James James Deacon Symontoun Deacon Alexander Reid II) 1680 ca 1680 ca available Not details no marked, not Quaich, 1983 p598 Annual Review Lyle 1675-80 ca ca 1675-80 Moncur Thomas 1680 ca Glasgow available Not no details Quaich, indistinct mark initials, leaves, and rose thistle, of panels alternating Quaich, UK Collection Private 1670 ca 1670 ca available Not 1675 ca available Not no details Quaich, on Sinclair of Arms lug, on one Bruce of Arms wood, mounted silver Quaich, 53 vol 1948 Magazine Antiques 1665-67 II Reid Alexander 1669-71 William Law Law 1669-71 William 1670 ca 1670 ca Moncur Thomas Glasgow rim a on Quaich 1640 ca 1640 ca (or I Gairdine Robert 1663-81 I Cleghorne Edward Edinburgh (also Alvah, of Kirk the by cups as communion 4, used of set Quaichs, 1632 ca 1632 ca available Not James by gifted lugs, rim, 4 the around band gold with wooden Quaich, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

346 Quaichs LQHYRO RQ8. OHFWLRQ8. YDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. LYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. Connoisseur Magazine 1938 1938 Magazine Connoisseur YROS #68 1938 10, March Sothebys )LQOD\ Scotland of Museums National p20 +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP (GLQEXUJK++ 0XVHXP6LOYHU6KRS1<86$ DGYHUWLVHPHQW ,QIRUPDWLRQIURPD3ULYDWH &ROOHFWRU Shaw Collection Collection Shaw Sothebys Picture File #56 29,1983 March Christies $UW,QVWLWXWHRI&KLFDJR 1( DV LQLWLDOV³,&´ L RPSDQHOVRIOHDYHV V %XUOLQJWRQ0DJD]LQH HOORI$UNLQJODVVLQLWLDOV³,&´RQRQH QLWLDOVRQOXJV³0*DQG³039´´GL QRLQLWLDOVRQOXJVRYHUOXJVGL bowl, 8oz 8oz bowl, ´RYHUOXJV narrow hatched bands and upper panels of alternating flower heads, Arms of of Arms heads, flower alternating of panels upper and bands hatched narrow (DUORI$EHUFRUQ +DPLOWRQ ORQJKWERZOG RQRQHOXJDQG³,6´RQWKHRWKHUDUPVRI&DPSEHOORI$UGNLQJO DOWHUQDWLQJSDQHOVRIIORZHUVOXJVHQJUDYHGZLWKURSHERUGHUV KDQGOH´RYHUKDQGOHV (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKVLPLODUWRWKHRQHDERYHZLWKVFULSWLQLWLDO (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKRQULPIRRWOXJVZLWKGRZQWXUQHGHQGVERWW Assayer John Borthwick 1685/86 James Penman Penman 1685/86 James 5REHUW%URFN -DPHV3HQPDQ *ODVJRZ (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKPDUNV5%WRZQPDUN5% 4XDLFKHQJUDYHGIORZHUVWDYHV :LOOLDP/DZFD -RKQ/XNH, (GLQEXUJK 5REHUW(OSKLQVWRQH 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV ,QYHUQHVV *ODVJRZ 4XDLFKVPDOOOXJJHG 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV $QWLTXHV0DJD] 3UL 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWL :LOOLDP/DZ (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKZLWKVWDYHVPDUNHGL FD Law 7KRPDV/LQGVD\,, 1681/82 William 'XQGHH -DPHV3HQPDQ 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKZLWKOXJVPPRQO\ 3U 3ULYDWH&RO 1680 ca 1680 Brock Robert Glasgow with outside staves, simulated with body foot, rim circular on lugs, 2 Quaich, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION FD LOCATION 5REHUW%URFN *ODVJRZ 4XDLFKRQULPIRRWDUPVRI&DPSE SOURCE

347 Compendium of Scottish Silver S Country Life April 28, 1960 1960 April 28, Life Country p914 127 vol Christies Glasgow July 3, 1984 1984 3, July Glasgow Christies #66 How of Edinburgh 1936 #60 1936 Edinburgh of How p97 Clayton Dictionary #423 Dictionary Clayton #112 1959 15, April Christies 19, 1898 May Christies +\PDQ&ROOHFWLRQ±&RORQLDO Williamsburg p147 p147 1937 #87 of How Edinburgh Williamsburg 1998 August Magazine Antiques p194 Metropolitan Museum Museum Metropolitan AC#63.53.9 OXJV &OD\WRQ&KULVWLHV%RRN alternating near lip, 7 ½" long, 14oz 5d 5d 14oz long, ½" 7 lip, near alternating listed 1700ca) listed 1700ca) one and "IG" on the other, 7 ¼" di, 14oz 10d 10d 14oz di, ¼" 7 other, the on "IG" and one 1704 ca ca 1704 1704/05 McLean William Jr Luke John Inverness indistinct mm mounted, silver Quaich, Glasgow flowers of panels above, 3 bands in panels, leaves faint body lower Quaich, UK Collection Private 1700/01 Ker Thomas 5REHUW.HU Edinburgh "IS" initials outside, and inside lines stave simulated Quaich, (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKQRWSLFWXUHG´RYHU 79 vol 1961 Magazine Antiques 1700 ca 1700 ca available Not 1700 ca McKenzie Colin ca 1700 Edinburgh McKenzie Colin 1700 ca no details Quaich, Edinburgh Law William no details Quaich, 14d 3oz lugs, over 6" only, mm engraved, staff Quaich, 1700/01 Edinburgh McKenzie Colin lugs, across 7/8" 4 out, and inside lines stave Quaich, Edinburgh others some from is different this that clear entirely not (Note: 3.6oz Quaich, #233 1990 1, November Sothebys Colonial - Collection Hyman 53 vol 1948 Magazine Antiques 53 vol 1948 Magazine Antiques YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1694/95 LOCATION 1695 ca Brock Robert Seaton John Glasgow Edinburgh no details Quaich, 1oz miniature, Quaich, SOURCE p568 Marks Jackson #59 1936 Edinburgh of How 1698/99 Clerk William Glasgow on "SG" initials with lugs heads, flower and staves with ,decorated Quaich

348 Quaichs 7, 1965 1965 7, (GLQEXUJK Metropolitan Museum Museum Metropolitan $& #101 25, 1970 February Christies 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ %ODLU6HSWHPEHU 1935 #205 1935 #205 1939, Magazine Connoisseur YROS 278-283 pp 71, vol How Exhibition 1992 #32, pl 18 18 pl #32, 1992 Exhibition How MEQ 800 YROS 6RWKHE\V0DUFK Auction sale sale Auction #158 1960 23, March Christies 1968ca ôERZOGL $'(5PPRQO\ò RYHUDOO &KULVWLHV-XQH :&DOWHUQDWLQJSDQHOVRIIORZHUKHDGV SOH %UHDGDOEDQH&ROOHFWLRQ6DOH QDOWHUQDWLQJSDQHOVQHDUOLSRYHUOXJV &RXQWU\/LIH-XQH &´WKHRWKHU³,,´ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG &0 $. 4XDLFK´ZLGHR] RYHUOXJVòGLERZOR]G QHDUULPRXWVLGHVLPXODWHGVWDYHOLQHVDFURVVOXJV 16oz (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKHQJUDYHGKRRSVDQGVWDYHVLQLWLDOVRQOXJV Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Quaich, p296 Hayden (continued) (continued) Assayer James Penman FDFD &KDUOHV%ODLU 5REHUW.HU (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKPLQLDWXUHR] +RZRI 1709/10 Clerk Glasgow Clerk William 1709/10 William Glasgow details no Quaich, 1937 Magazine Burlington 1709/10 -RKQ6HDWRXQ Clerk William (GLQEXUJK Glasgow 4XDLFKVWDIIHQJUDYHGLQLWLDOV exam 1707 the to similar Quaich, -DPHV)DOFRQHU *ODVJRZ :LOOLDP&OHUN 4XDLFKGHFRUDWHGZLWKIORZHUVL *ODVJRZ 4XDLFKLQLWLDOVRQOXJV$&DQG YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1705 ca 1705 ca Inglis Cumming Thomas 1705/06 Robert Glasgow only mm Quaich, Castle Antiques Grantully FD -DPHV)DOFRQHU *ODVJRZ 4XDLFKLQLWLDOVRQOXJVRQH³0

349 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG001361 DAG001361 1966-26 1966-26 V0XVHXPRI6DQ YDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. 6RWKHE\V1<$SULO #289 )UDQFLVFR&$86$ ORDQLWHP Breadalbane Collection Sale Sale Collection Breadalbane 1935 #200 -DFNVRQ0DUNVS $SROOR-XO\S &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH YROS 1994 #139 1994 #139 Aberdeen Museumsand AB Galleries Galleries #63 1937 Edinburgh of How S Crichton Brothers advertisement Christies 1984 #66 The Morris Morris The #66 1984 Christies Sale 26, May Edinburgh Christies 1998 #57 Sale Scottish The Bonhams #14 2003 21, August WXOLSVLQDOWHUQDWLQJ GVRIOXJVGL &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH)HEUXDU\ OXJVòRYHUWKHOXJVR] 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW R] +D\GHQS OXJVR] SDQHOVKDQGOHVHQJUDYHG,0&DQG$&GLR] lugs "ED" and "TS" "TS" and lugs "ED" (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKODUJHOXJVH[WHULRUZLWK7XGRUURVHVDQG (continued) (continued) $OH[DQGHU.LQFDLG (GLQEXUJK &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKOXJVODUJHVL]H )LQH$UW 3UL FD :LOOLDP*HG (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKLQLWLDOV*6DQG0.RQ 1715 ca 1715 ca MP over 5" underneath, initials also "IP", and "EY" initials with lugs Quaich, 1711/12 Penman Edward Edinburgh :LOOLDP+RGJHUW no details Quaich, Inglis *ODVJRZ -DPHV7DLW1713/14 Robert 4XDLFK´DFURVVOXJV (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKYHU\SODLQGRZQWXUQHGHQ Art and Museums Dundee YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1710 ca 1710 ca Scott William Aberdeen on initials outside, the on worn but outside, and inside lines stave Quaich,

350 Quaichs Antique Silver vol I 1941 p20 1941 I vol Silver Antique p405 Apollo June 1974 vol 99 p486 99 vol June 1974 Apollo 2, 1974 February Christies #89 1956 27, March Christies 5, 2005 July London Christies Autumn 2005, p20 #40 p20 2005, Autumn 2001 p68 2001 p68 J Bourdon-Smith Catalog 2004 2004 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J p11 #45 back cover advertisement Edinburgh of How p68 112, 1994 #138 vol 98 p241 98 p241 vol R] +RZRI(GLQEXUJK1RWHVRQ long, 20oz 20oz long, edged with a band of simple diagonal hatched decoration, engraved "ER" and and "ER" engraved decoration, hatched diagonal simple of band a with edged lugs over ½" 7 "WW", Edinburgh 12" mark, town 2X overall, no mm "1714", date and "WJ" initials Quaich, Banff Banff lug either on "CP" and "L.F.C.' initials staves, with engraved Quaich, Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Quaich, 87 1982 p Review Silver Lyle illiam Scott, Scott, illiam $VVD\HU±(GZDUG Penman younger $VVD\HU±(GZDUG Penman 1721/22 available Luke Robert 1721/22 Not Glasgow no details Quaich, 96 vol 1969 Magazine Antiques 1720 ca 1720 ca W FD 6LPRQ0F.HQ]LH ,QYHUQHVV 4XDLFKô´DFURVVWKHOXJV 1719/20 Inglis Robert 1719/20 Edinburgh Tait James 1719/20 5oz lugs, over ½" 7 lip, below marked Quaich, James Tait 1720 ca Edinburgh 1720 ca Blair Charles 6.3oz Quaich, Edinburgh available Not 6oz lugs, the over ½" 7 lip, the at "M/GS/MK" initials Quaich, Edinburgh di ¾" 2 Quaich, #1 X, vol Review Art Scottish 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys vol 1943 Magazine Connoisseur #129 1978 21, April Phillips 1720 ca 1720 ca Ged William Edinburgh 2oz lugs, ¼" over 5 lug, each on "AML" initials Quaich, Catalog Bourdon-Smith J YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1716/17 LOCATION Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh 5.4oz Quaich, SOURCE 1936 Magazine Connoisseur 1719/20 Inglis Robert Edinburgh lugs 2 outside, and inside lines stave with engraved bowl, plain Quaich,

351 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG001241 DAG001241 Apollo May 1973, vol 97 p3 97 p3 vol 1973, May Apollo 1996 London Bourdon-Smith J 1977 23, November Christies #168 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1977 Brand Inglis 1980 p137 #153 #153 p137 1980 Inglis Brand Shaw Collection Collection Shaw 20, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #37 Aberdeen Museumsand AB Galleries #124 1993 #169 L.1972.5 p872 Spink Ltd London #46 How of Edinburgh 1937 #89 1937 Edinburgh of How Collection Shaw 29, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #53 G³*60´ foot with flange,maybe with a latercrest, profile of 7 ½" over lugs, 5.5oz 5.5oz lugs, ½" over 7 lugs slight raised raised lugs slight UHVSHFWLYHO\´RYHUOXJVR] DQGRXWVKDSHGOXJVZLWKDEDQGRIKDWFKLQJLQLWLDOV³0)´DQ Glasgow Glasgow no details Quaich, 98 vol 1970 Magazine Antiques Edinburgh Edinburgh 4 of set Quaichs, Glasgow 2.5oz Quaich, p213 Holland #62 1936 Edinburgh of How Bilsings Bilsings (continued) (continued) Charles Duncan Duncan Charles Bilsings Bilsings 1730/31 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh initials, no lugs, on borders chevron lines, stave 16 with incised bowl Quaich, 1725 ca 1725 ca Blair Charles 1725 ca Ross Hugh 1725 ca Edinburgh Got-helf- 10d 1oz ½" wide, 4 Robertson only, mm George miniature, Quaich, 1725/26 Johan Tain Aberdeen lugged 3 Quaich, long 1/5" 4 engraved Quaich, 1975 13, November Sothebys August Gleneagles Sothebys Scotland of Museums National 1729/30 Anderson James Edinburgh collar on plain, Quaich, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1722/23 or I Dickson Charles 1725 ca 1725 ca Johan Got-helf- 1725 ca 1725 ca Cruickshank Robert Aberdeen inside staves simulated with engraved foot, rim on lugs, 2 miniature, Quaich,

352 Quaichs n House April April n House Q$QWLTXH6LOYHU Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 p94 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas vol I 1941 p20 p20 I 1941 vol The Maple Swan Collection Finlay 1991 # 65 1991 Finlay Scotland of Museums National L.1969.679 L.1938.536 L.1938.536 56, vol 1949 Magazine Antiques p272 p213 Holland MEQ 135 #46 2005 p20 1988 #48 1988 #48 s in alternating panels panels alternating in s Scotland of Museums National lugs, 1.5oz 1.5oz lugs, lugs Edinburgh Edinburgh lugs 2 with Quaich Scotland of Museums National Glasgow Glasgow 17d 1oz lugs, over ¼" 4 "CLL", initials Quaich, Glasgow 6.2oz di, bowl ¾" 4 listing, previous the than example larger Quaich, 1968 29, March Christies #96 1986 29, April Sothebys Assayer Archibald Ure Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings FD -RKQ%DOOLH ,QYHUQHVV 4XDLFKRQULPIRRW +RZ¶V1RWHVR 1735 ca 1735 ca 1736/37 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh Blair Charles no details Quaich, Edinburgh flower size, large Quaich, 1982 p87 Review Silver Lyle 1737/38 David Mitchell Mitchell 1736/37 1737/38 David Blair Charles Edinburgh K" "IH initials Quaich, #114 1938 7, April Sothebys 1740 ca 1740 ca available Not 1740 ca Innes Robert Inverness over 4 7/8" lug, on either "AM" and initials "SM" 3.4oz staves, lugs, engraved Quaich, 5" over "IP", and "EY" lugs on engraved Quaich, Autumn Catalog Nicholas Shaw YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1730 ca LOCATION Johan Got-helf- SOURCE 1730 ca 1730 ca Johan Got-helf- 1730 ca 1730 ca Baillie James Innes Robert Banff Inverness initials no clear lugs, on border Quaich, lugs 4" over no initials, lugs, on border inside, lines stave simulated Quaich, Hopetou Sothebys advertisement Bell 1735 ca 1735 ca Lothian Edward Edinburgh on leaves TO ONE", HUNDRED "A motto and crest lugs, 3 with Quaich,

353 Compendium of Scottish Silver S +RXVH$SULO %RRN PVRI6FRWODQG 1994-310 1994-310 on-Smith Catalog Catalog on-Smith G HHGH%HDX[$UWV0RQWUHDO %RQKDPV$XJXVW 0DUFK$SULO Christies February 27, 1974 #149 27, 1974 February Christies -%RXUGRQ6PLWK/RQGRQ $XWXPQS 6-$ 1988 #41 1988 #41 Breadalbane Collection +RZ V1RWHVRQ$QWLTXH6LOYHU S H.1994.1098 H.1994.1098 Canada 1981.Ds.21 1981.Ds.21 Canada Galleries ´WKHXSSHUVXUIDFHRI GH$UPVRQOXJV /RV$QJHOHV0XVHXP([KLELWLRQ OXJRYHUOXJVR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS ´DQG³00.´´GL $QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU$SULOS HGKROORZOXJKDQGOHV 'XQGHH0XVHXPVDQG$UW ZOVFULSW*RWKLFLQLWLDOVRQHDFKOXJòGLR] -%RXU RYHUOXJVR]G &OD\WRQ&KULVWLHV DLFKQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHX RQHOHJHQJUDYHG³´ listed) listed) Quaich, on details details on Quaich, Scotland of Museums National (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKVLPXODWHGVWDYHOLQHVRQWKHXSSHUKDOIRXWVL Inverness or or Inverness Glasgow :LOOLDP'DYLH or Baillie) Baillie) or :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU FD ,+ 4XDLFKOXJVVLGHVHQJUDYHG³'0F.´DQG³(0F' /RWKLDQ 5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKLQLWLDOVRQOXJV FDFD -RKQ%DLOOLH -RKQ6WHYHQ ,QYHUQHVV 'XQGHH 4XDLFKOXJVZLWKLQLWLDOV³$0. 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV 6RWKHE\V+RSHWRXQ 5REHUW/RZ /RWKLDQ 5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKVWDIIOLQHVLQER 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV -DFNVRQ0DUNVS FD -DPHV*OHQ &ROLQH$OODQ *ODVJRZ $EHUGHHQ 4XDLFKHQJUDYHGWKLVWOHVRQHLWKHU 4X YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1740 ca LOCATION Bilsings (probably IB SOURCE FD -RKQ%DLOOLH ,QYHUQHVV 4XDLFKò´;´;ó´ 0XV FD $OH[DQGHU-RKQVWRQ 1743 ca 'XQGHH Glen James 4XDLFKSODLQFLUFXODUVKDS Glasgow quaichs Glen other as same is the this if tell cannot (Note: no details Quaich,

354 Quaichs 1976 #163 1976 ROS $UW5KRGH,VODQG H&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV%RRNS 0DUNVS WLHV7KH0RUULV6DOH 1935 #197 1935 #197 -DFNVRQ0DUNVS #151 6DOH 6FKRRORI'HVLJQ3URYLGHQFH5, 86$ %XOOHWLQ)HEUXDU\ YRO;;,,S GGLWLRQDOVFULSWLQLWLDOòLGR]G 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ UDYHGó´GLR] %UHDGDOEDQH&ROOHFWLRQ6DOH DQG³,)´´GL $QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU$SULOS LDOVPPLQGLVWLQFWóR] 6RWKHE\V+RSHWRXQ+RXVH$SULO VKDSHGGLR] %UHDGDOEDQH&ROOHFWLRQ6DOH QG³'0.´R] 3KLODGHOSKLD0XVHXPRI$UW QGSRVVLEO\³,0.´´GL $QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU$SULOS QG³$0F.´´GL $QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU$SULOS ôGLERZOR] &KULVWLHV-XO\7KH0RUULV KLQLWLDOV.0'$0'DOVRD FDFD $OH[DQGHU6WHZDUW ,QYHUQHVV $OH[DQGHU6WHZDUW ,QYHUQHVV -DPHV*LOOLODQG 4XDLFKOXJVHQJUDYHG³00/´ FD 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK -DPHV7D\ORU 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV *ODVJRZ 4XDLF &OD\WRQ %UHDGDOEDQ -DFNVRQ FD -0PDUN 1RWDYDLODEOHFD *ODVJRZ 7KRPDV%RUWKZLFN ,QYHUQHVV ,QYHUQHVV 4XDLFKQRGHWDLOV 4XDLFKERUGHURQOXJVQRLQLW 4XDLFKôGLR] &KULV $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHY FD 7KRPDV%RUWKZLFNFD ,QYHUQHVV 0LOQH &DPSEHOO 4XDLFKHQJUDYHGLQLWLDOV FD *ODVJRZFD 7KRPDV%RUWKZLFN 4XDLFK´ORQJ ,QYHUQHVV 7KRPDV%RUWKZLFN ,QYHUQHVV 4XDLFKOXJVLQLWLDOV³5&´D 4XDLFKOXJVLQLWLDOV³05´D 0XVHXPRI FD 7KRPDV%RUWKZLFN ,QYHUQHVV 4XDLFKOXJVLQLWLDOV³(0´D YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION FD LOCATION $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 4XDLFKVKDSHGKDQGOHVVOLJKWO\HQJ SOURCE .HU 'HPSVWHU (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKVLOYHUGRXEOHOXJJHG

355 Compendium of Scottish Silver pril 1973 p75 1973 pril $ Private Collection Collection Private 1225 MEQ 1961.99 1961.99 Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto Toronto Museum, Ontario Royal 928.13.2 Canada MEQ 1 Collection Phoenix The #44 p23 2002 Autumn p347 93, vol Sothebys August 23, 1976 #12, #12, 1976 23, August Sothebys withdrawn Museum Huntley House HH3338/68 Edinburgh Sale #151 #151 Sale 90 p205 ERZOOREHGIOXWHGWKLQKDQGOHVSODLQVOLJKW DQG³)0´ $QWLTXH&ROOHFWRUS HH0XVHXPDQG$UW*DOOHULHV´DQG³+0´´GL $QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU ured ured Scotland of Museums National details details Scotland of Museums National no details details no Scotland of Museums National flared rim, foot, no mm, 4" di, 6 ½" over lugs, 4oz 7d 4oz lugs, over ½" 6 di, 4" no mm, foot, rim, flared ó´ZLGH possible notall correct 5*PP´GL Glasgow Glasgow hallmarked other the and thistle with one bands, half 2 with wooden Quaich, Assayed Edinburgh 1814/15 G & N Edinburgh pict not Quaich, FD &KDUOHV-DPLHVRQ 1RWDYDLODEOH ,QYHUQHVV 4XDLFKOXJVLQLWLDOHG³'0.´ (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKVKDSHGERZOTXDWUHIRLO 1800 ca 1800 ca Jamieson Charles FD Inverness 1808/09 &KDUOHV-DPLHVRQ Quaich, Craw Matthew ,QYHUQHVV1809/10 Ziegler A & W 4XDLFKOXJVLQLWLDOHG³'XQG Edinburgh 1810 ca lugs over 4 5/9" "JMcL", initials script with lug one Quaich, Edinburgh Jamieson Charles 1810 ca di 3" Man", "The Auld by won lugs, thistle Quaich, Inverness Fraser Donald no details Quaich, 1991 Edinburgh Goodwin's Inverness no Quaich, Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1934 Magazine Connoisseur 1793/94 R G G 1793/94 R 1800 ca Jamieson Charles Inverness gamecock, a crowing of lug one on crest foot, ring bowl, circular Quaich, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1783 ca LOCATION Borthwick Thomas Inverness 3.2oz bowl, ¾"di 2 "1783", Dated SOURCE Morris The 3, 1984 July Christies 1790 ca 1790 ca Jamieson Charles 1793/94 Inverness Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh no details Quaich, piece mm only, possibly "1793", date engraved with lug, one Quaich, vol 1932 Magazine Connoisseur

356 Quaichs 182 p182 Book, Book p DAG001363 DAG001363 1986-141 1986-141 L.1980.2 L.1980.2 Museum Huntley House HH2229/68 Edinburgh 1987 #307 Galleries Christies February 27, 1974 #145 27, 1974 February Christies 1298 1978-85 The #50 3,1984 July Christies #50 Sale Morris Aberdeen Museumsand AB Galleries Williamsburg Huntley House Museum Huntley House HH2047-60 Edinburgh Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2001 p75 d out, engraving inside the rim rim the inside engraving out, d Scotland of Museums National no details details no Scotland of Museums National RQHKDOOPDUNHG´GL 0DUVKDOO´;´GL;´KW 1.5oz 1.5oz Edinburgh Quaich, wooden, bound with cane,half 2 bands of silver, one withathistle, Edinburgh Edinburgh W & J retailer lined, gilt handles, head fox embossed small, Quaich, Glasgow Quaich, engraved crest andmotto, "Clarior Hinc Honos", Buchanan, of 4"di, Andrew Wilkie Wilkie Andrew Edmonstoun Edmonstoun Peter Aiken 1831/32 Possibly AW 1831/32 P G 1832/33 C Rait D Edinburgh Glasgow no details Quaich, no details Quaich, August Gleneagles Sothebys Art and Museums Dundee 1830/31 Son & Gray Robert Glasgow Quaich, 1818/19 1820 ca Howden Francis Naughton Robert Edinburgh Inverness no details Quaich, 1821/22 2.7oz , bowl di ¾" 2 inscription, with Quaich 1828/29 script JH Aiken Peter 1829/30 Alexander Edinburgh Glasgow 4d 2oz 3" di, Black", Peter to "Presented inscribed Quaich, no details Quaich, Collection Breadalbane #161 1976 26, February Sothebys Christies Clayton Colonial - Collection Hyman 1830 ca 1830 ca or Arthur Peter 1830/31 1830/31 C Rait D Co & F W Glasgow Edinburgh no details Quaich, 15d 1oz lugs, over 4" Quaich, Christies Clayton advertisement Hobart YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1816 dated Livingstone Edward LOCATION Dundee an inside rays with Quaich, SOURCE

357 Compendium of Scottish Silver r r H 182 2005 2005 Winter og Winter Book p 1978-659 1978-659 MEQ 1337 1337 MEQ Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2000 p91 200 p91 200 p91 Galleries 2000 p91 2000 p91 #44 p23 2002 Autumn 2001 p77 2001 p77 p104 MEQ 1301 1301 MEQ 2001 p77 2001 p77 FKDVHGZLWKIORZHUVòGLR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQW ece, chased throughout,½" 3 lugs, over 1.7oz Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2 lugs lugs 2 Scotland of Museums National rampant, 8" di, 7.1oz 7.1oz di, 8" rampant,

Quaich, leaf handled handled leaf Quaich, Scotland of Museums National 1839/40 1840/41 C Rait D Aiken Peter 1841/42 1842/43 Marshall W & J Glasgow Glasgow Marshall W & J Edinburgh no details size, small Quaich, no details Quaich, Edinburgh no details Quaich, 2.1oz ht, 1" Arrierre", "Jamais motto with a dog, of crest Quaich, Winte Catalog Nicholas Shaw Foundation Fowler E Francis Art and Museums Dundee Christies Clayton 1849/50 Marshall W & J Edinburgh -RKQ+D\ di ½" 2 Club", Curling "Achleeks engraved Quaich, (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKIR[¶VKHDGRQHDFKOXJERG\ Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1875/76 Mathie P Edinburgh thumbpi head fox Quaich, 1878/79 Hamilton & Inches Edinburgh Edinburgh Inches & 1878/79 Hamilton 1879/80 1891/92 Inches & Hamilton Edinburgh Crichton John 90" Borders "Highland engraved Quaich, Edinburgh with Quaich, 1993 USA MA Antiques Asley 1896/97 Chisholm & MacKay Edinburgh a lion of with crest engraved foot rim, stepped on shape circular Quaich, 1835/36 1835/36 Co Elder & 1837/38 McKay James available Not Edinburgh Edinburgh no details size, small Quaich, no details size, small Edinburgh Quaich, di 1/6" 3 Esq., Martin, George to presented treen, mounted silver Quaich, Catalog Shaw Nicholas Foundation Fowler E Francis Foundation Fowler E Francis YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1833/34 LOCATION Son & Keay Robert Perth 2.4oz di, 1/8" 4 1879", Proctor W. by "Won engraved heavily, chased Quaich, Catal Nicholas Shaw SOURCE

358 Quaichs and O ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Canada 974.150.19 974.150.19 Canada L.1938.12 L.1938.12 p104 +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP HH3340/68 Edinburgh National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National 1109 MEQ MEQ 1300 1300 MEQ MEQ1511 MEQ 846 Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2001 p84 HQWHGWRWKH(GLQEXUJK6RFLHW\RI WRWKH(GLQEXUJK6RFLHW\RI0XVLFLDQV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRW ´DFURVVOXJV 5R\DO2QWDULR0XVHXP7RURQWR Quaich" Quaich" Scotland of Museums National ed bowl bowl ed Scotland of Museums National 'DOURVVZLWKWKHGDWH´GL 0XVLFLDQV« 2.2oz 2.2oz %DOODWHU 3ODLQORQJ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ $VVD\HGLQ Edinburgh 1918/19 William Robb Robb 1918/19 William 0DFND\ &KLVROP (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKFLUFXODUERZO 1915/16 Son & Brook Edinburgh Ranger "The 1907/08 B N M Edinburgh Quaich N %URRN 6RQ1907/08 Inches & Hamilton (GLQEXUJK Edinburgh 3DLURIOXJJHGTXDLFKVSUHVHQWHG of Stuart McDonald Mrs. from as bowl below inscribed plain, Quaich, %URRN 6RQ (GLQEXUJK 4XDLFKVSDLUZLWKOXJV«3UHV 1900/01 Kirkwood HB & R Edinburgh shap Quaich YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1897/98 LOCATION Sons & Edwards Glasgow ht, 5/8" 1 Jubilee, Victoria's Queen of date with pierced lug each Quaich, SOURCE

359 Compendium of Scottish Silver

360 Salts

SaltsSALTS

Plate 39. Two from a set of 4 human mask (possibly Jacobite) Salts 1743/44 by Ebenezer Oliphant, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

361 Compendium of Scottish Silver Breadalbane Collection Sale Sale Collection Breadalbane &KULVWLHV-XQH withdrawn Catalog Bourdon-Smith J $XWXPQ 1939 #419 1REOH&ROOHFWLRQ 6RWKHE\V$SULO 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU #90 +RZRI(GLQEXUJK Breadalbane Collection Sale Sale Collection Breadalbane 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ$XJXVW 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S MEQ 1464.1-4 Finlay 1991 #40 1991 Finlay UEDVH WGLR] 1REOH&ROOHFWLRQ SHGZLWKFRQFDYHVLGHVHDFKZLWKLQLWLDOV HGHGERUGHUVHQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDOV³,/00´ FRUQHUVDFFRPSDQ\LQJ3DWULFN REORQJZLWKFXWFRUQHUVVRPHWLPHVFDOOHG FUHVWR]GERWK R]GHD &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ KHUWZRDUHZLWKREORQJFXWFRUQHUV GZLGH 6FRWWLVK$UW$FDGHP\([KLELWLRQ LV DVGHVFULEHGIRUWKHSDLUEDVHVWDPSHG rd LQFXUYHGVLGHVDQGRYDOERZORQVWHSSHGEDVHDQGUHHGHGERUGH VWDPSHG%UHDGDOEDQHôORQJR]WRWDO RFWDJRQDOZLWKLGHQWLFDOFUHVWVDQGPRWWRVôR]ERWK Graham salts %UHDGDOEDQH ´GLR]G +$EHORZD9LVFRXQW VFRURQHW SALTS 3DWULFN7XUQEXOO (GLQEXUJK +HQU\%HWKXQH 6DOWVSDLURFWDJRQDOVKDSH (GLQEXUJK 7ZRVDOWVRIDVHWRI +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 6DOWRQHRIDVHWRIWKHRW +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7UHQFKHUVDOWVSDLUSUREDEO\ 5REHUW%URFN :LOOLDP*HG1710/11 *ODVJRZ Ged William 6DOWWUHQFKHUFLUFXODUZLWKFUHV (GLQEXUJK +HQU\%HWKXQH 7UHQFKHUVDOWVVHWRIRYDOVKD Edinburgh 4 of (GLQEXUJK set salts, Trencher 6DOWVSDLURFWDJRQDO1DSLHU Scotland of Museums National 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 7UHQFKHUVDOWREORQJZLWKFXW 1670 ca 1670 ca Gairdyne Patrick Andrews St form standing single, Mary, St salt, Master Andrews St College, Mary's St FD 5REHUW%URFN *ODVJRZ 7UHQFKHUVDOWFHOODUFLUFXODUUH YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

362 Salts 2006 #25565 #25565 2006 ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Sothebys Gleneagles August 19, 19, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1996 #138 26, May Edinburgh Christies 1998 #67 MEQ 945 Sothebys November 14, 1963 1963 14, November Sothebys #90 Edinburgh of How Sothebys Gleneagles August 1987 #287 p54 Book Delieb 1952.45 1952.45 Christies July 10-11, 1987 #346 #346 1987 10-11, July Christies Sothebys November 14, 1963 1963 14, November Sothebys #90 Edinburgh of How Christies June 13, 2000 #247 #247 2000 13, June Christies withdrawn Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 2000 Autumn 1935 Magazine Connoisseur 96 p55 vol h (1oz 12d ea) ea) 12d h (1oz #91 1, 1940 May Christies details details Scotland of Museums National footed N alts, pair octagonal , with engraved initials "AT" over "SH" "SH" over "AT" initials engraved with , octagonal pair alts, London Phillips J S "ICM", late inscribed underneath "Eigg" and "George IInd 1732", 3" long, long, 3" 1732", IInd "George and "Eigg" underneath inscribed late "ICM", 3.5oz engraved with initials, 3" wide, 10.1oz for 4 salts salts 4 for 10.1oz wide, 3" initials, with engraved 5.6oz long, ½" 2 molded border, 6.6oz 6.6oz border, molded pair Salts, pair, small, octagonal, 2oz 5d bot 5d 2oz octagonal, small, pair, Salts, erdeen erdeen 3 pair, Salts, Edinburgh Edinburgh borders, molded sides, incurved corner, cut with oblong, pair, Salts, Assayer Archibald Ure (continued) (continued) 1734/35 Ure Archibald Edinburgh corners cut with oblong 4, of set Salts, 104 vol Magazine Antiques 1732/33 Mitchelson James Edinburgh initials sides, incurved and corners cut with oblong pair, salts, Trencher 1729/30 James Mitchelson Mitchelson 1729/30 James 1730 ca Cooper George Ab 1729/30 Graham Patrick Edinburgh corners, cut with oblong , Edinburgh 2 others with sold pair, salts, Trencher 1728/29 Ker James Edinburgh no salt, Trencher 1723/24 Patrick Graham Graham Edinburgh 1723/24 Patrick 1728/29 Ker James Edinburgh a above sides incurved with corners, cut with oblong pair, salts, Trencher YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1719/20 1722/23 Simpson Alexander Edinburgh available Not s Trencher Edinburgh Graham Patrick 1729/30 with sold corners, cut with oblong salt, Trencher

363 Compendium of Scottish Silver 2001 2001 p182 #1 Book y 24, 1973 #186 #186 1973 y 24, ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Christies January 29, 1969 29, 1969 January Christies AntiquesSimon Kaye #392 2001 p69 Sothebys Gleneagles August 27- #233 1975 28, Sothebys December 1, 1982 # 1982 1, December Sothebys 1517-1518 1517-1518 1982 Christies Glasgow April 12, 1983 1983 12, April Glasgow Christies #66 a+ 1858.119 b 1939 #431 1939 #431 Gilmour, G R Sir UK Collection Private Christies London June 24, 1981 1981 24, June London Christies oof feet, with later blue oof feet, 9oz Phillips Bayswater June 18, footed N 3 high scroll feet, band of applied molded drops drops molded applied of band feet, scroll high 3 Salts, pair, circular shaped, shaped, circular pair, Salts, Salts, set of 4, compressed circular, corded rims, h rims, corded circular, compressed 4, of set Salts, to shallow bowls, 9.7oz 9.7oz bowls, shallow to UHHGHGULPVò´GLR]G JODVVOLQHUVò´GLR] the shoulder, sold with one salt by William Dempster, 10.5oz for 4, 4, for 10.5oz Dempster, William by salt one with sold shoulder, the details no pair, Salts, Scotland of Museums National Glasgow Glasgow below motto and crest with engraved circular, compressed pair, cellars, Salt Edinburgh Edinburgh corners cut with oblong 4, Salts, p92 1984 USA NY Christies lson lson Edinburgh about foliage chased with feet, hoof 3 on each shape, 3 circular of set Salts, Bilsings Bilsings Assayed Archibald Archibald Assayed Ure 1737/38 Lothian Edward Edinburgh h rims, work rope circular, 4, of set Salts, 1736/37 Ker James 1740 ca Edinburgh Forbes Alexander 1740 ca on each pair, circular Salts, Aberdeen Got-helf- Johann 3.7oz 2" di, feet, hoof 3 on circular, pair Salts, Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1740 ca 1740 ca Baillie John Inverness 1735 ca 1735 ca Tait Mitchell Colin Edinburgh 1735/36 James Canongate 1735 ca 1735 ca Mitche James 1734/35 Ker James Edinburgh ht 1/3" 1 corners, cut with oblong pair, Salts, Exhibition Academy Art Scottish 1734/35 Archibald Ure Ure YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1734/35 Archibald LOCATION SOURCE 1734/35 Ure Archibald Edinburgh 6.5oz motto, and crest with engraved sides, concave 4, of set salts, Trencher Januar Christies 1734/35 Aytoun William Edinburgh motto with animal, an of crest corners, cut with oblong, of pair Salts, Christies Clayton

364 Salts tember tember 2004 2004 S log 2004 2004 log D p101 Sothebys Chester December 13- #1162 1983 16, 15- February Chester Sothebys #1210 1984 17, p101 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1983 #503 Sothebys March 25, 1965 #85 1965 25, March Sothebys 1, 1981 1, 1981 #444 Sothebys Gleneagles August 1988 #458 Christies Edinburgh April 29, 29, April Edinburgh Christies 1992 Collection Private Christies June 22, 1966 #135 1966 22, June Christies Sothebys June 18, 1964 #132 1964 June 18, Sothebys Christies July 5, 1972 #22 #22 5, 1972 July Christies oof feet, with crest, UHHGHGULPVSODLQRQKRRIIHHWò´GLR] DUVKDSHRQKRRIIHHWPPUXEEHGô´GL IIHHWURSHHGJHERUGHUòKWR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ RIIHHWZLWKURSHHGJHERUGHUóGLR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DW ZLWKDFUHVWDQGPRWWRòGLR] 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV6H HDFKRQXQXVXDOKXPDQSHULRGPDOHIDFHIHHW R] motto, below a moldedrim, on 3hoof feet, with 2 later blueglass liners, òGLR] 16d attachments, beaded rim, engraved with the crest of a stag's head, crest is is crest head, a stag's of crest the with engraved rim, beaded attachments, faces the feet, unusual very Dick, is possibly but Hunter, of that be to stated PD\EHD-DFRELWHWULEXWHWR3ULQFH&KDUOHVôGLR] R]DOO ò´GLR] make a set of 4, London Salts by David Willaume 1722/23 1722/23 Willaume David by Salts 4, London of a set make 6DOWVVHWRIFLUFXODUHDFK JK 6DOWVVHWRIFLUFXODU Edinburgh Salt cellars, pair, compressed circular shape, each engraved with crestand Edinburgh Edinburgh to salts London 3 match to single corners, cut with oblong salt, Trencher Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Dougal Ged 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVLQJOHFRPSUHVVHGFLUFXO 1744/45 James Mitchelson Mitchelson 1744/45 James 1744/45 Mitchelson James :LOOLDP$\WRXQ Edinburgh no details pair, cellars, Salt (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVSDLUFLUFXODURQKR Collection Swan Maple The :LOOLDP$\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVSDLUFLUFXODURQKRR FD -DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ 6DOWFHOODUVSDLUJLOWLQWHULRUV (GZDUG/RWKLDQ (GLQEXUJK (EHQH]HU2OLSKDQW (GLQEXU 1742/43 Lothian Edward Edinburgh h 3 on rim, molded shape, circular plain 4, of set Salts, 1741/42 James Ker YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1741/42 James LOCATION SOURCE 1741/42 Ker James Edinburgh initials, feet, hoof 3 on borders, corded shape, circular compressed pair, Salts,

365 Compendium of Scottish Silver toun House toun House Sothebys Scone Palace April 13, 1976 #107 1939 #423 1939 #423 QueenHM Mary Collection Sothebys May 24, 1970 #65 1970 24, May Sothebys #193 1984 28, March Christies November 12, 1979 #59 1979 12, November #31 1965 June 2, Sothebys 1994 Canada, Toronto #43 37, p 2001 Autumn Christies January 7, 1939 #244 #244 7, 1939 January Christies Collection Hearst eet, mark rubbed, rubbed, mark eet, oof f RRIIHHWô´GLR] shape, gilt interior possibly later, 2 ¾" di ¾" 2 later, possibly interior gilt shape, Hope Sothebys circular shape, repoussed and chased with flowers flowers with chased and repoussed shape, circular KRRIIHHWôGLR] DQGIROLDJHJDGURRQHGULPVRQK HQJUDYHGò´GL mm IM figure between, glass liners, 10oz 4d 4d 10oz liners, glass between, figure IM mm (2oz 5d ea) 5d ea) (2oz edges gadrooned with feet, paw and mask 4 on each oval, 3, Salts, UK Collection Private both 11oz about wide, ¼" 3 feet, pad 3 on shaped, shell 4, of set Salts, Edinburgh Edinburgh di ¾" 2 flowers, chased feet, mask circular, 4, of set Salts, Exhibit Academy Art Scottish Edinburgh Edinburgh chased circular, pair, Salts, Center, Antique View Harbor Edinburgh Edinburgh foliage with chased lined, gilt feet, pad on shaped, cauldron pair, cellars, Salt #262 1977 21, March Christies Edinburgh Salt cellars, 4, set of eachhoof on 3 feet, engraved witha crest andmotto, William Dempster Dempster William Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon 1755/56 James Gilliland Gilliland 1753/54 1755/56 James Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh 1751/52 or Davie William 1752/53 Dempster Ker & 1753/54 Edinburgh Gordon Robert di ½" 2 border, 4, crimped of set salts, Cauldron Edinburgh 3 on interiors, gilt rims, molded with shape, circular compressed of pair Salts, Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1747/48 Oliphant Ebenezer 1747/48 Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh circular compressed cellar, Salt 1747/48 James Mitchell Mitchell 1747/48 James 1750/51 1751/52 Taylor William Dempster & Ker Edinburgh Edinburgh feet on circular, pair, Salts, compressed 6, of set Salts, 1993 London Bourdon-Smith J 1746-58 JL Glasgow h 3 on each festoons, floral with chased 2, cellars, Salt 1746/47 Robert Gordon Gordon YEAR MAKER Edinburgh DESCRIPTION 1746/47 Robert LOCATION SOURCE

366 Salts 1967 1967 ecember 20, Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1978 #356 Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1978 #356 Christies July 20, 1966 20, 1966 July Christies #22 1967 26, April Christies AntiquesSimon Kaye #60 1959 29, October Sothebys &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ$XJXVW Sothebys June 25, 1968 June 25, Sothebys Scottish Art Review vol IV #3 #3 IV vol Review Art Scottish advertisement Bell Sale Scottish the Bonhams $XJXVW Collection Phoenix The 6RWKHE\V0D\ Christies D Christies #168 #6 1968 2, May Sothebys V R] ell feet, sold with 3 QWHULRUVHDFKRQKRRIIHHW oof feet, withgadrooned rims and later blue glass HGERUGHUVRQKRRIIHHWR] 3KLOLSV(GLQEXUJK$XJXVW alts, pair of compressed circular shape, with everted crimped rims, on hoof hoof on rims, crimped everted with shape, circular compressed of pair alts, FDEULROHOHJVZLWKUHHGHGWRHFDSSHGIHHWòKWGL VXSSRUWVZLWKODWHUEOXHJODVVOLQHUVòGLR] 13.1oz all all 13.1oz others, 2 from 1760/70 MK conjoined and one 1785-86 James Hewitt, Hewitt, James 1785-86 one and conjoined MK 1760/70 2 from others, ò´GLR]DOO VDOWVSRRQVZLWKWKHVDPHFUHVWò´GLR]ZLWKVSRRQ crest OLQHUV´R] feet, en suite with a pair of 1772 salts by Patrick Robertson Robertson Patrick by 1772 salts of pair a with suite en feet, lion paw feet, sold with 3 matching salts dated 1836/37 by T A Finlayson, 2 2 Finlayson, A T by 1836/37 dated salts matching 3 with sold feet, paw lion ô´GLR]IRU similar Edinburgh 1817/18 salts, mm rubbed 6.9oz for 3 for 6.9oz rubbed mm salts, 1817/18 Edinburgh similar with sold crest, feet, 3 shell on interiors, gilt and rims gadrooned pair, Salts, (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVVHWRIFLUFXODUZLWKVFDOORSHGULPVJLOWL Weems Edinburgh S Weems Edinburgh WD or Dempster William Davie William 1759/60 and 1759/60 60/61 1759/60 Ged Dougal Edinburgh 3 on edges, scalloped everted with shape, circular compressed of pair Salts, 1759/60 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh 3 sh on rim, projecting scalloped shape, circular plain Salt, 1759/60 James 1759/60 James 1758/59 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh 1758/89 Coutts Benjamin Edinburgh -RKQ(GPRQVWRXQ1758/59 di 3/8" 2 feet, hoof 3 on rim, beaded with circular, pair, Salts, (GLQEXUJK Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh 6DOWVSDLUFLUFXODUJDGURRQ with feet, 3 shell on rim, everted crimped form, circular squat Salt, single, 1993 Bourdon-Smith J 1757/58 Gordon Robert Edinburgh h 3 on salts, cauldron Pair of 1757/58 Ged Dougal Edinburgh 3 on each rims, everted crimped with shape, circular compressed of pair Salts, 1755/56 Low Robert Edinburgh 3 on interior, gilt motif, hair ragged with rim the corded below Salt, chased YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1755/56 LOCATION available Not Edinburgh 2 with sold feet, hoof 3 rim, on molded shape, circular plain Salt, single, SOURCE

367 Compendium of Scottish Silver 6FRWODQG &KULV*ODVJRZ1RYHPEHU 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU London Koopman 6RWKHE\V-XQH National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National 0(4 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ p101 Christies South Kensington Kensington South Christies 2FWREHU %OXP$QWLTXHV6W3HWHUVEXUJ)/ 1993 Collection Phoenix The 0(4 Christies Edinburgh November November Edinburgh Christies 10, February Glasgow Christies &KULVWLHV0DUFK Sothebys Gleneagles August 30, 30, August Gleneagles Sothebys DOORSLQJ oof feet, KD/RQGRQVDOW &KULVWLHV-XO\ SDLUHGZLWKD/RQGRQVDOW &KULVWLHV-DQXDU\ KDSHZLWKIODPHERUGHURQVKHOOHQGHG KRRIIHHWHQJUDYHGLQLWLDO%GL XODUVKDSHVFDOORSHGULPVVKHOODQGSDGIHHW UVKDSHRQKRRIIHHWPPUXEEHGò´GL ODUVKDSHSODLQZLWKUHHGHGDQGJDGURRQHGULPV IRUPRQVKHOODQGKRRIIHHW RRIIHHWZLWKWKXPESULQWSLHFUXVWVF HDGHGULPSLHUFHGRYDOVROGZLWKHOHFWURSODWHG QRGHWDLO 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI RQKRRIIHHWò´GLR] R] legs and feet R] around the edge, molded rim, 2 ½" di di ½" 2 rim, molded edge, the around ZLWKFUHVWVR]DOO salts salts ò´GLR] ODVJRZ 6DOWVSDLURIFLUFXODUVKDSHRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVFLUFXODURQKRRIIHHWLQLWLDOVSDLUHGZLW 7D\ORU (GLQEXUJK 6DOWFLUFXODUVKDSHRQKRRIIHHWLQLWLDOV DLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVSDLUFRPSUHVVHGFLUFXOD DLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVVHWRIVTXDWFLUFXODU William Dempster Dempster William *LOOLODQG .HU (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVSDLUFRPSUHVVHGFLUFX 1RWDY FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 6DOWVLQJOHFRPSUHVVHGFLUFXODUV FD $GDP*UDKDPFD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ * 6DOW FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 6DOWVSDLUFLUFXODURQK -DPHV+HZLWW (GLQEXUJK 6DOWVVHWRIFRPSUHVVHGFLUF 1RWDY 1761/62 and Dempster Ker & 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOWFODZDQGEDOOIHHWE 1761/62 William 1761/62 William YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1760 ca LOCATION Craw William Canongate h 3 on rims, fluted with shape, circular compressed pair, Salts, SOURCE

368 Salts TX USA USA TX ed 1993 1993 ed th 1969-168 1969-168 1963-739-2-3 1963-739-2-3 Christies Glasgow March 29, 29, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #30 Galleries Scottish Art Review 1953 vol IV, IV, 1953 vol Review Art Scottish #3 advertisement Bell 1995 Victoria & Albert Museum 1981 1981 Museum Albert & Victoria Seabright Museum Albert & Victoria Sothebys October 29, 1959 #60 #60 1959 29, October Sothebys p584 1988 Collection Phoenix The 1995 Galleries oof feet Mary Cooke Antiques London oof feet, petal shaped borders, gilded interior, 4.1oz Shaw Collection alts, pair, circular with blue glass liners liners glass blue with circular pair, alts, Collection Private feet, en suite 1757 Dougal Ged pair pair Ged Dougal 1757 suite en feet, birds, 3 ¼" long with 2 other 1759/60 and 1785/86 Edinburgh, possibly by James McKenzie, McKenzie, James by possibly Edinburgh, 1785/86 and 1759/60 2 other with ò´GL Edinburgh Edinburgh h on liners, blue circular, pair, Salts, Edinburgh Edinburgh pair 1769 following the like liners, blue with circular pair, Salts, London Antiques Cooke Mary William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William 1780 ca 1780 ca Scott William Dundee details no pair, Salts, Art and Museums Dundee 1780 ca 1780 ca Lumsden Benjamin Aberdeen h 3 on circular, pair, Salts, 1770 ca 1770 ca Clark Robert Edinburgh 3oz pair, Salts, G, 27 Price Warman 1771/72 Robertson Patrick 1772/73 Edinburgh Robertson Patrick salt Oval Edinburgh 3 on each rims, everted crimped with shape, circular compressed of pair Salts, 93 p Hughes 1769/70 or Dempster William 1771/72 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh and foliage pierced bequest, rim, gadrooned waved, oval, 4, of set Salts, 1770 ca 1770 ca Campbell & Milne Glasgow S YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1767/68 LOCATION Robertson Patrick Edinburgh feet pad 3 on rims, gadroon flame with salts, circular pair, Salts, Antiques, Antonio San SOURCE 1767/68 or Dempster William 1769/70 conjoined MK Edinburgh sold feet, shell 3 on rim, scalloped everted shape, circular plain pair, Salts, 1768/69 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh details no pair, Salts, Art and Museums Dundee

369 Compendium of Scottish Silver ondon ondon DAG011131 DAG011131 Minneapolis Institute of Art of Institute Minneapolis 1,2 77.22.48 1995 1995 USA 1993 London Huntley House Museum Huntley House HH2533-64 Edinburgh Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p107 Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2001 p75 MEQ 1079-80 1972 1972 1079-80 MEQ 63 vol 1953 Magazine Antiques p160 advertisement Shreve Sothebys October 29, 1950 #60 #60 1950 29, October Sothebys Galleries AB Galleries ´KWR] oof feet, withrope edge border, engraved llars, reeded rim and base, on bracket feet, crest of of crest feet, bracket on base, and rim reeded llars, ed ed 1993 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J each GH[WHUDUPFODVSLQJDVSXUDQGDVFULSW³&´ô´;´; ´;´ cartouche, 3 3/8" long, 2.6oz 2.6oz long, 3/8" 3 cartouche, "R", "R", 2 ½" di, 5.3oz this time, no details no details time, this RWKHUVHDUOLHU(GLQEXUJKò´GL Salts, pair, oval shape shape oval pair, Salts, Scotland of Museums National Edinburgh Edinburgh , Edinburgh in assayed just possibly letter, date no shaped, boat pair, Salts, Edinburgh Edinburgh by dead was Dempster James since maker as Douglas James likely most Salt, Aberdeen Aberdeen liners glass blue with pair, Salts, and Museums Aberdeen ailable ailable shap boat pair, Salts, George Bain or James Douglas Douglas James James Douglas Douglas James 1795/96 Robertson William Edinburgh crests rubber 2 liners, blue with cut bright oval, 4, of set Salts, L Antiques, Simmons M J 1795/96 Cunningham P & W 1800 ca Edinburgh Fenwick & McHattie shaped boat pair, Salts, 1800 ca Edinburgh shaped GB boat 4, of set Salts, NY, Plattsburgh Gordon's, The Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1795 ca 1795 ca Christie George Edinburgh ce paneled pair, Salts, 1795 ca 1795 ca Erskine James Aberdeen leaf laurel engraving, cut bright of bands 2 shape, oval of pair cellars, Salt 1790/91 or Dempster James 1790/91 Mathie Peter Edinburgh h 3 on shape, circular of pair Salts, 1786/87 1790 ca Dempster James 1790 ca av Not Edinburgh I Keay Robert details no cellar, Salt Perth 550 p Marks Jackson YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1780 ca LOCATION or Gordon James SOURCE 1785/86 Hewitt James Edinburgh 3 with sold feet, shell 3 on rim, scalloped everted shape, circular plain Salt,

370 Salts talog Autumn Autumn talog 1971-978-1 - 4 1971-978-1 MEQ 1612 1612 MEQ MEQ 1180-81 1976.27-28 1976.27-28 1180-81 MEQ MEQ 113-14 113-14 MEQ MEQ 880 1999 p62 1999 p62 Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto Toronto Museum, Ontario Royal c-f 961.123.8 Canada #46 p26 2005 Autumn H.1994.1128 H.1994.1128 Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p103 Galleries 1991 #124 1991 #124 aped, Traprain design design Traprain aped, Scotland of Museums National foot decorated with ornamental band,crest of Gibson- no details details no Scotland of Museums National no details details no Scotland of Museums National Carmichael, with 2 others by Paul Storr Storr Paul by others 2 with Carmichael, details no pair, Salts, August Gleneagles Sothebys Edinburgh Edinburgh details no 4, Salts, Scotland of Museums National Inverness Inverness shaped boat of pair Salts, Collection Noble Edinburgh details no pair, Salts, Scotland of Museums National amieson & & amieson Crichton Naughton Naughton George Booth 1926/27 Son & Brooks Edinburgh sh triangular pair, Salts, 1862/63 1872/73 McKay James Michael & George Edinburgh no details pair, cellars, Salt Collection Swan Maple The 1888/89 Hamilton & Inches & 1888/89 Hamilton 1839/40 Marshall W & J Edinburgh pair, Salts, 1828/29 McKay James 1832/33 Paton George Edinburgh 12oz crest, mermaid with legs, 4 on pair, salts, Cauldron Edinburgh 7.2oz di, 3" rim, on leaves scrolled feet, mask lion 3 on pair, salts, Cauldron Ca Shaw Nicholas Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1815 ca 1815 ca J 1821/22 1823/24 Neville J CB Glasgow details no pair, Salts, Edinburgh and top 4, of set Salts, 1993 Edinburgh Goodwin's, 1820 ca 1820 ca Jamieson William Aberdeen details no 4, of set Salts, Art and Museums Dundee 1810/11 Fenwick George Edinburgh dish, Salt 1805 ca 1805 ca Son & Gray R Edinburgh YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

371 Compendium of Scottish Silver 2002/03 p89 p89 2002/03 YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1929/30 LOCATION Sons & Brooks Edinburgh , 10oz di ½" 4 pair, salts, Traprain SOURCE Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas

372 Salvers

SalversSALVERS

Plate 40. A Salver 1740ca by Robert Luke, Glasgow. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

373 Compendium of Scottish Silver 999 p62 999 Sothebys January 14, 1960 #56 1960 14, January Sothebys 1980.4 MEQ MEQ 1235-1236 1977.34-35 1977.34-35 1235-1236 MEQ Christies July 25, 1973 #189 25, 1973 July Christies MEQ 934 Sothebys Gleneagles, August 27- August Gleneagles, Sothebys #137 1971 28, MEQ L.1983.21 L.1983.21 MEQ Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1998 #551 Sothebys Gleneagles, August 27- August Gleneagles, Sothebys #114 1970 28, Bonham Sale 10914, #9 #9 10914, Sale Bonham Alcorn, Fine Art, Museum of p331 #253 MEQ 1347 1347 MEQ foot, liage, liage, GLR] ular, molded beaded edge edge beaded molded ular, Scotland of Museums National foot, sides later chased with flowers, scrolls, fo ay, no details details no ay, Scotland of Museums National no details details no Scotland of Museums National TXDUWHULQJ+RPHFKDVHGZLWKVFUROOVIORZHUVDQGIROLDJHó´ with crest and motto, 6 ½" di, 6.6oz 6.6oz di, ½" 6 motto, and crest with Union," onnarrow rim foot, 6½" di 7.2oz armorials of McLean of Barclay, 7" di, 8.6oz with its teapot, 6 ¾" di di ¾" 6 teapot, its with FHQWHUHQJUDYHGZLWKWKHFUHVWRI%XUQVLGH´GLR] shallow circulardish onplain flaringrim, attributed to Charles Dickson I but 11.9oz di, 5/16" 7 ht, 3/16" 1 Duncan, Charles by likely most SALVERS, STANDS AND WAITERS AND WAITERS STANDS SALVERS, helson helson Edinburgh shape hexagonal small Salver, Scotland of Museums National 1725/26 Bethune Henry 1725/26 Ker James Edinburgh stand, Teapot Edinburgh circ borders, wavy pair, Salvers, 1724 ca 1724 ca 1725 ca Forbes Alexander Mitc James Aberdeen 15oz ½"di, 8 initials "M/JA/JS", engraved border, Chippendale Salver, 1 Catalog Nicholas Shaw 1725 ca 1725 ca Luke Robert Glasgow Drummond of armorials with engraved later a tazza, possibly foot, on Salver, 1721/22 Bethune Henry Edinburgh rim on stand Teapot 1720/21 Hay Thomas Edinburgh "The Happy inscribed ship a and crest a with engraved circular stand, Teapot 1720 ca 1720 ca Ged William Edinburgh details no Salver, Scotland of Museums National 1719/20 Mitchelson James Edinburgh with center feet, 3 panel on rim, raised molded simple circular, plain Salver, 1719/20 Bethune Henry Edinburgh rim narrow on edge upturned with circular plain, perfectly stand, Teapot 1719/20 Mitchelson James Edinburgh rim, scalloped circular, "AH", initials with engraved underside stand, Teapot 1717/18 Bethune Henry Edinburgh tr or dish Shallow 1718/19 Duncan Charles Edinburgh coronet, Earl's an under "EL" cypher a with in center engraved stand, Teapot YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

374 Salvers p182 Christies November 8, 1950 #159 1950 8, November Christies Sothebys August 29, 1978 #423 1978 29, August Sothebys Scotland of Museums National 1977.10 1211 MEQ p546 Marks Jackson p819 Book Sothebys 1970 18, November Sothebys #225 N Bloom & Sons Clayton Christies Book #25 5, 1972 July Christies Edinburgh of How 366 1963 12, December Sothebys 1983 March Glasgow Christies #74 How's Notes How's Notes on Antique Silver I, 1941 p23, Shaw Collection Collection Shaw 29, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #84 p107 illustration p107 illustration Private Collection UK UK Collection Private foot How of Edinburghadvertisement ay (also called Ford Set Tray), engraved with with engraved Tray), Set Ford called (also ay oof feet, scalloped moldedrim, ½" 7 di 7oz 16d stand, 8" di, 10.9oz turned upside down) down) upside turned 8 ½" di, 12oz 19d 12oz ½" di, 8 19d 10oz armorials for Johnson 8oz 5d 8oz Edinburgh Circular salver with shaped wavy border, onrim foot, wavy border teapot Edinburgh Edinburgh Mitchelson James of that likely more is mark this (Note: details, no Salver, Edinburgh Edinburgh 12 points, foot, rim on crests, 2 edge, molded border, wavy with Stand Edinburgh wide, 7/8" 6 feet, bracket on cartouche, worn in motto crest, waiter, Square Jamieson Jamieson Or James Mitchelson Assayer Archibald Archibald Assayer Ure Assayer Archibald Ure Assayer Archibald Ure 1729/30 William Jamieson Jamieson 1729/30 William 1729/30 William 1729/30 William Ker 1729/30 James Ker 1729/30 James 1729/30 Mitchelson James Edinburgh 15d 6oz ¾", 4 Haig, of motto and crest waiter, Square #65 1959 29, October Christies 1728/29 1728/29 Ker James Ker James Edinburgh a coronet Edinburgh under motto crest, square, pair, Waiters, h (stand), waiter Circular #114 1953 25, June Sothebys 1727/28 Ker James Edinburgh Tr Service Tea Johnson The 1726/27 Bethune Henry Edinburgh di, 7" "IAS", initials border, plain form, dish foot, rim on stand, Teapot YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1725/26 LOCATION Aytoun William Edinburgh Annandale of Marquess Johnston, of crest Stand, Annandale The #92 1937 Edinburgh of How SOURCE 1725 ca 1725 ca Luke Robert Glasgow rim low dish on as shallow stand Teapot

375 Compendium of Scottish Silver p91 XPVRI6FRWODQG Sothebys April 30, 1985 #78 #78 1985 30, April Sothebys MEQ 46 Christies July 26, 1972 #359 26, 1972 July Christies 1957 27, November Christies 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW± #281 1987 1, Sept Provenance: J Stuart Stevenson 21, November Christies Esq. 1957 #126 Brooklyn Museum 63.95.1 Sothebys June 26, 1968 1968 June 26, Sothebys Spink Apollo 1934, vol XXV p20 vol 1934, Apollo advertisement Sharp & Wilson Sothebys April NY USA 12, 1994 #290 Christies NY USA April 12, 12, April USA NY Christies 1994 #290 MEQ 1983.24 1983.24 MEQ 1727 1727 VWE\.HU HHW´GLR] foot, molded edge,12 points, with ROGHGHGJHSRLQWVR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ DYHGLQFHQWHUZLWKYDFDQWRYDOLQVFUROOLQJ JUDYHGZLWKEULFNZRUNURXQGHOHQFORVLQJ GIRRWVOLJKWUDLVHGPROGHGERUGHUSRVVLEO\D FKDVHGRXWERUGHUDFURVV 4XHHQ V6LOYHUSSO ZLWKDUPRULDOVIROLDWHPDQWOLQJDQGPRWWRV RRIIHHWô´GLR]G ray, on cylindrical foot, scalloped wavy rim, molded edge, crest and and crest edge, molded rim, wavy scalloped foot, cylindrical on ray, DOYHUQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVH IODWFKDVHGZLWKGLDSHUDQGIUXLWV&KLSSHQGDOHULPVFUROOI WD]]D´GLR]G and crest helm, mantling, foliate below Scotland, Barrowfield, of Orr of arms PRWWR³%21,6201,$%21$´PROGHGULPRQWUXPSHWVKDSHGIRRW ó´GLR]G IROLDJHFDUWRXFKHRQK PRWWR³:LOO*RG,6KDOO´SDUWRIWKHHDUO\7HD6HUYLFHWKHUH Ker tea service tea service Ker between indentations, center with a crest andmotto, onshaped 4 panel 22oz ½", 10 unclear, mm each, on mark one supports, and motto, 10 ½" wide, 10 ½" and22oz wide, motto, lson lson Edinburgh details no stand, Teapot Scotland of Museums National FDFD *HRUJH&RRSHU *HRUJH&RRSHUFD $EHUGHHQ 5REHUW/XNH,, $EHUGHHQ 6DOYHUVTXDUHVKDSHGFRUQHUV 6 *ODVJRZ 6DOYHUZLWKZDY\ERUGHUZLWKP FD 5REHUW/XNH *ODVJRZFD 6DOYHURQIRRWFLUFXODUODWHUHQ *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 6DOYHUODWHUHQJUDYHGLQFHQWHU FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 6DOYHURQFHQWUDOWUXPSHWVKDSH FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 6DOYHU&KLSSHQGDOHERUGHUHQJU 1729/30 Henry Bethune Bethune Salver/t Edinburgh 1729/30 Henry 1729/30 Bethune Henry Edinburgh rim on border, wavy stand, Teapot, 1729/30 available Not Edinburgh sides, convex and straight alternate with square/octagonal, shaped, Salver, 1729/30 James Mitche YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1729/30 James LOCATION SOURCE 1729/30 available Not Edinburgh crest feet, panel clear, not mm foot, each on marked square, shaped, Salver,

376 Salvers DAG001002 DAG001002 DAG001359 DAG001359 LRQDU\S Galleries AB Galleries in 1975 acquired Scottish Art Review vol VI 1956 1956 VI vol Review Art Scottish S advertisement Bell John Aberdeen Museumsand Galleries Galleries AB Galleries &KULVWLHV-XO\ &KULVWLHV-XO\ &KULVWLHV-XQH G1996-221 Williamsburg Sothebys August 29-30, 1977 1977 29-30, August Sothebys Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 p91 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 6RWKHE\V-XQH Spink Ltd London R]G lat chased border of shells and scrolls, scrolls, and shells of border lat chased PROGHGERUGHUò´GLR]G 6RWKHE\V6HSWHPEHU oof feet, f RRIIHHWô´GLR]G OLDJHò´GLR] stand, no details details no stand, Colonial - Collection Hyman VFUROOVIORZHUVDQGIR UHYHUVHHQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDOVô´VTXDUHR]G DQJOHVHQJUDYHGRQUHYHUVHVLGHZLWKLQLWLDOV³3$6´ô´GL ZLWKODWHUFUHVWDQGLQLWLDO´GLR]G R] IROLDJHFDUWRXFKHRQK center flowers, and fruit of band with chased flat border, Chippendale Waiter, een een details no square, Waiter, and Museums Aberdeen 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen motto and crest arms, of coat with Salver, Family Duff the Salver, and Museums Aberdeen FD *HRUJH&RRSHU 1730 ca Cooper George $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVWDQG´GL Aberdeen of band a with chased border, scalloped feet, 4 on circular, large tray, Tea &OD\WRQ'LFW 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George 1730 ca Aberdeen Luke Robert 1730 ca teapot or Salver Cooper George Glasgow Aberd details no stand, Teapot Scotland of Museums National 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen angels, shaped with border molded flat feet, scroll on square, plain Waiter, 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen incurved border, raised slightly feet, 4 bun on square, shaped plain Waiter, FD 1730 ca 5REHUW/XNH Cooper George *ODVJRZ Aberdeen 6DOYHUHQJUDYHGZLWKPRWWRVKDSHG 1730 ca 1730 ca II Luke Robert Glasgow h 4 on salver, square Shaped YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1730 ca LOCATION Cooper George Aberdeen scrolling in oval vacant with in center engraved border, Chippendale Salver, SOURCE

377 Compendium of Scottish Silver #185 How advertisement advertisement How p33 #43 Dictionary Clayton How of Edinburgh 1937 #107 1937 Edinburgh of How Christies July 6, 1972 6, 1972 July Christies Edinburgh of How J Bourdon-Smith Catalog 1983 1983 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J p14 The Maple Swan Collection 1985 1585-86 MEQ Sothebys February 10, 1966 10, February Sothebys Collection Vander Sothebys Gleneagles, August 28, 28, August Gleneagles, Sothebys 1975 #46 25- November Scotland Christies #113 1997 27, Apollo October 1988 vol 88 p95 vol 1988 October Apollo Antiques Haviland De advertisement #160 4, 1968 July Sothebys MEQ 1983.24 1983.24 MEQ oof feet, 7½" di, Campbell, 12 points points 12 Campbell, above, 20.5oz 20.5oz above, and motto, 6 1/7", 15.1oz 6 and motto, 15.1oz 1/7", sugar bowl, 9 points, 7 ¾" di ¾" 7 9 points, sugar bowl, 9.6oz 9.6oz center on 4 hoof supports, 6 ¼", 10.6oz 10.6oz ¼", 6 supports, hoof 4 on center 13 ¾" , 48oz lson lson Edinburgh details no stand, Teapot Scotland of Museums National 1733/34 Aytoun William Edinburgh stand rim, molded border, wavy with Salver, 1982 p91 Review Silver Lyle 1733/34 1733/34 Aytoun William Aytoun William Edinburgh 14d 11oz di, 8" edge, molded border, wavy rim, Edinburgh on Stand 11oz di, 8" foot, on rim rim, molded circular, shaped Salver, #137 27, 1980 February Christies 1988 14, December Christies 1733/34 Aytoun William Edinburgh impaling Menzies of Arms bowl, with edge molded border, wavy Stand, 1733/34 Aytoun William Edinburgh and rib a in motto and crest with center corners, cut square, pair, Salvers, 1732/33 1732/33 Mitchelson James Aytoun William Edinburgh 15d 9oz square, ½" 5 border, molded square, plain Salver, Edinburgh crest corners, incurved with border molded feet, bracket 4 on square, Waiter, #7 1923 10, April Christies 1731/32 Aytoun William Edinburgh 50oz 11", feet, bracket on engraved, octagonal, Tray, Scotland of Museums National 1731/32 Ker James Edinburgh with edge, beaded molded and border wavy stand, teapot circular Salver, 1731/32 Tait James Edinburgh h 3 on underside, on initials border, bath a with Circular 1731/32 Bethune Henry Edinburgh in motto and crest angles, at incurved border molded square, shaped Waiter, 1731/32 James Mitche YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1731/32 James LOCATION SOURCE 1731/32 Aytoun William Edinburgh Stewart, or Hathorn of motto and crest feet, bracket 4 on octagonal, Salver,

378 Salvers 105 1933 #36 1933 #96 y Exhibit Exhibit y ecember 13, Clayton Dictionary #651 Dictionary Clayton #121 1977 15, June Christies Scotland of Museums National 1211 1977.10 Christies Glasgow April 12, 1983 1983 12, April Glasgow Christies #171 Christies June 13, 2000 #231 2000 13, June Christies Christies London July 10-11, 10-11, July London Christies Negative file Picture 1984 #375 #25239 #899 Collection Stirling-Maxwell Scotland of Museums National 1985 1585-56 MEQ December 13, 1967 #22 #22 1967 13, December Treasures From Scotland #149- 1967 Edinburgh Houses 152 Collections of Girdwood and Noble foot, 12 points, re, rounded corners, molded border, 6 ¼" square, 10oz 10d 10oz ¼" square, 6 border, molded corners, rounded re, 1946 25, June Christies Hopetoun Service, 9 3/8" wide wide 9 3/8" Service, Hopetoun originally sold/appeared with a teapot in 1965, ¼" in di, a 1965, teapot 8 with 9oz sold/appeared originally borders, center with full armorials for Wauchope quartering, Wauchope of of Wauchope quartering, Wauchope for armorials full with center borders, 49oz ¾" wide, 10 "26:4", "25:8", weights scratch with each Edmondstone, 12 points, 7" di, 8.5oz 8.5oz di, 7" 12 points, James Mitchelson Mitchelson James Edinburgh both 21.4oz points, 6 with borders both fledged, full pair, matched Salvers, # 1937 Edinburgh of How 1734/35 Lothian Edward Edinburgh squa Waiter, 1734/35 Lothian Edward Edinburgh details no Salver, p547 Marks Jackson 1734/35 & & 1734/35 1738/39 1734/35 1734/35 Aytoun William Ker James Edinburgh di ¾" 7 chasing, flat feet, pad 3 on Salver, Edinburgh the of part Hope, of coronet motto, and crest chased, shaped, Salver, 2005 London Antiques Schredd's 1733/34 Tait James Edinburgh rim on border, molded circular shaped stand, Teapot 1733/34 Aytoun William Edinburgh molded with feet bracket 4 on each corners, incurved square, pair, Salvers, 1733/34 Ure Archibald Edinburgh probably "AH", initials edge, molded with border, wavy with stand, Teapot YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1733/34 LOCATION Aytoun William Edinburgh Service Tea Girdwood of part rim, on border wavy stand, pot Tea D Christies SOURCE 1733/34 Ker James Edinburgh di 14" foot), (central base tazza detachable with one feet, 4 on pair, Salvers, Academ Art Scottish

379 Compendium of Scottish Silver 128 DAG008579 DAG008579 DAG001003 DAG001003 Pictured in Furniture & Silver Silver & Furniture in Pictured article 1959.17.8 2004/05 Christies April 26, 1966 # 1966 26, April Christies #103 1990 21, Galleries AB Galleries Galleries AB Galleries Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 p93 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1983 March Glasgow Christies J Bourdon-Smith London Christies November 24, 1976 #50 1976 24, November Christies Christies Scotland May 23, 1996 23, 1996 May Scotland Christies #446 oof feet Sothebys April24, 1978 # liage and shells shells and liage oof feet, with molded waved border, urgh City Museum, no details details no Museum, City urgh Scotland of Museums National ³-*´ $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG oof feet, flat chased flowers,fruits and shell, oof feet, chased with scrolling fo , circular, raised scalloped rim, 12.5oz 12.5oz rim, scalloped raised circular, , Gallery Art University Yale Waiter, marks include a gothic A or E or A gothic a include marks Waiter, and Museums Aberdeen borders in between, 14 ½" X 11 ½", 37oz 37oz ½", 11 X ½" 14 between, in borders ´GLR] 8", 11.8oz on a matted ground, engraved with later crest, motto and coronet, 5 ¾" wide, wide, ¾" 5 coronet, and motto crest, later with engraved ground, matted a on 16.2oz foliate scrolls, 5 ¾" wide, 8oz 8oz wide, ¾" 5 scrolls, foliate Edinburgh Edinburgh and shells with chased feet, hoof 4 on corners, turned in with square Waiter, Farquharson Farquharson 1735/36 Edward Lothian Lothian Salver Edinburgh 1735/36 Edward 1735/36 Ker James Edinburgh scrolled ordinants, ____ on sections rounded with oblong, modified a Tray, 1735/36 Ged Dougal 1735/36 Ker James Edinburgh no details circular, Salver, Edinburgh Edinb by 2004-05 acquired Salver, November Edinburgh Christies 1735/36 Mitchelson James Edinburgh h 4 on circular, shaped, plain Salver, FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVWDQGFLUFXODUPRQRJUDP 1735 ca 1735 ca 1735 ca Cooper George Luke Robert Aberdeen 1735 ca foot central on plain, Salver, Cooper Glasgow George 10oz di, ¾" 7 feet, rim plain on border, wavy stand, Teapot Aberdeen Collection Shaw Collection Private 1735 ca 1735 ca Alexander 1735 ca 1735 ca II Luke Robert Glasgow h 3 border, Chippendale Salver, 1734/35 Ker James Edinburgh h 4 on square pair Salvers, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1734/35 LOCATION Ker James Edinburgh h 4 arms, of coat with center border, molded shaped square, Salver, SOURCE

380 Salvers t 970 #57 ecember 9, 1 Christies April 26, 1966 #144 #144 1966 26, April Christies Christies D Christies 1994 London Bourdon-Smith J 2001 p71 2001 p71 27, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1990 Phillips, Edinburgh July 22, 1983 22, 1983 July Edinburgh Phillips, #245 Edinburgh of How XVI vol Review Art Scottish 1984 #1 Scotland of Museums National 1984 1574 MEQ Dewar Collection Collection Dewar 1987 London Sothebys Christies April 24, 1950 #130 #130 1950 24, April Christies #962 #158 1954 12, April Christies #212 oof feet, molded wavy border,10 ½" di, 20oz and motto, 7oz 7oz motto, and 11oz di, 7 3/8" "SW", or initials "LW" andhatched border, on 4 stump supports, 14½" long, 36.5oz arms inside, onshell 4 feet 49oz 13d 49oz Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Salver, 1989 August London Sothebys Assayer Archibald Ure 1736/37 Ker James Edinburgh Grant Castle set, Salvers, p150 Cripps 1735/36 Mitchelson James 1736/37 Edinburgh Lothian Edward 1736/37 rim, crest molded shaped center with foot, molded on circular shaped Salver, Edinburgh Mitchelson James 1736/37 13.9oz di, ¾" 8 feet, 4 scroll on circular, shaped plain, Salver, Edinburgh Aytoun William 10d 11oz di, ½" 7 border, bath circular, small Salver, Edinburgh Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas script central 2 points, 6 scrolls, with border type bath reeded circular, Salver, Collection Private 1735/36 Ker James Edinburgh shell, scroll an engraved by bounded center, plain shape, quatrefoil stand, Urn 1735/36 Aytoun William Edinburgh of coat with shield central border, shaped reeded square, modified Salver, 1735/36 Mitchelson James Edinburgh 14d 17oz di, 9" Arms, engraved feet, 3 on border, shaped Salver, Exhibi Academy Art Scottish 1735/36 Rollo John Edinburgh di, 14" border, molded feet, shell and 4 scroll on circular, plain, Salver, 1735/36 William Aytoun Aytoun YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1735/36 William LOCATION SOURCE 1735/36 Mitchelson James Edinburgh h 4 on circular, shaped Salver,

381 Compendium of Scottish Silver 27, 27, Sothebys Olympia April 12, 2005 2005 12, April Olympia Sothebys #265 Christies February 19, 1964 #161 19, 1964 February Christies #111 1987 June 4, ? Sothebys Sothebys January 13, 1966 #? 1966 13, January Sothebys London Koopman Christies May 4, 1977 #164 #164 4, 1977 May Christies Sothebys January 14, 1970 #162 1970 14, January Sothebys #46 p120 I, vol 1911 Exhibition 1984 #262 1984 #262 Christies October 8, 1980 #182 1980 8, October Christies The Phoenix Collection Collection Phoenix The Christies June 25, 1946 1946 25, June Christies Christies March 24, 1982 #70 #70 1982 24, March Christies liage liage KWO\UDLVHGVKDSHGERUGHU´GLR] &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK oof feet, chased witha band of shells, fo 8" di, 23.5oz 23.5oz 8" di, RIVKHOOVIORZHUVDQGIROLDJHó´GLR] EDVHDQGULP´GLR] band of scrolling foliage and cartouches, with flowers, dipper work between between work dipper flowers, with cartouches, and foliage scrolling of band 50oz 1/8", 15 arms, of coat a with DQGIROLDJHRQKRRIIHHW´GLR] coronet, and arms of coat later with center ground, matter a on scrolls and ´GLR] crest of a dragon impaled with anarrow, on 3 pad feet, 8 ¼"di 15 ½" di, 65oz 65oz ½" di, 15 handle, with crest and motto, 5.4oz 5.4oz motto, and crest with handle, Edinburgh Salver, large, on 4 shelland scroll feet, withmolded border,center flat chased Edinburgh Edinburgh borders shaped with pair, Waiters, 1993 USA NY Robinson James Assayer Archibald Ure 1738/39 William Aytoun Aytoun 1738/39 William -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK :DLWHURQKRRIIHHWSODLQVOLJ 1738/39 Lothian Edward Edinburgh decoration, work wiggle later with border molded circular, shaped Salver, 1738/39 Ker James Edinburgh border with chased center rim, molded shaped feet, hoof 3 on circular Salver, 1738/39 Ker James Edinburgh on marked feet, hoof on border, Chippendale plain, quite circular, Waiter, 1737/38 Aytoun William 1737/38 Edinburgh Ged Dougal details no di, 9" "WA", to ascribed Salver, Edinburgh h 3 on circular shaped Salver, Glasgow Sharp & Wilson 1737/38 Dougal Ged Ged 1737/38 Dougal 1737/38 Lothian Edward Edinburgh flowers, work, diaper shells, with chased later border, Chippendale Waiter, 1738 ca 1738 ca Luke Robert Glasgow with center circular, shaped shells, and scrolls flowers, with chased Salver, 1736/37 Ged Dougal Edinburgh baskets, engraved fruits, and flowers border, molded octagonal, Salver, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1736/37 LOCATION Oliphant Lawrence Edinburgh rising scroll border, molded feet, 4 on form, hour glass shaped tray, Snuffer SOURCE

382 Salvers MEQ 511 Phillips November 6, 1991 #199 1991 6, November Phillips 28, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1995 #168 Sothebys April 19, 19, April 1973 #102 Sothebys # 1973 31, October Christies #173 2, 1964 January Christies Sothebys Scone Palace, April 23, 1979 #94 #48 p121, 16- October USA NY Christies #445 1995 17, #44 1971 10, November Christies #116 1972 14, June Christies ó´ZLGH ´GLR] UDWFKZHLJKW details details Scotland of Museums National 42:19, 42.1oz 42.1oz 42:19, VKDSHGPROGHGHGJHUDLVHGRQKRRIIHHW´GLR] fruit, of baskets and foliage flowers, of band chased flat Prestonfield, &KLSSHQGDOHERUGHURIYROXWHDQGVKHOOVXSSRUWVô´GLVF chased with band of baskets of fruit, flowers and trellis work, engraved with with engraved work, and trellis flowers fruit, of baskets of band with chased FUHVWDQGPRWWRô´GLR] VFUROOVSRVVLEO\WKHVDPHDVWKHRQHLQWKH*ODVJRZ([KLELWLRQ with broad band flowers of and shells andrococo panels, engraved with crest, ô´GLR] 7½" di, 8.6oz 16oz supports, oblong cartouche with crest, flat chased with shaped panels of birds of panels shaped with chased flat crest, with cartouche oblong supports, RQPDWWHGJURXQGURFRFRGHFRUDWLRQPROGHGERUGHUDSSOLHGULP chased with band baskets of of fruit, flowers and trellis work, engraved with FUHVWDQGPRWWR´GLR] Edinburgh Edinburgh of Dick of probably motto, and crest with engraved center Salver, Edinburgh Edinburgh and foliage shells, of band with chased feet, hoof 3 on circular shaped Salver, Edinburgh Salver, circular, on 3hoof feet, with scalloped moldedrim, center chased Edinburgh Salver, shaped square withnotched canted corners, on 4 knurled and shell Edinburgh Salver, shaped circular, on 3hoof feet, with molded scalloped border, center Assayer David Mitchell Assayer Archibald Ure Assayer David Mitchell Assayer Archibald Ure Assayer Archibald Ure 1739/40 James Ker 1739/40 James 1740 ca Cooper George Aberdeen no Salver, 1739/40 James Ker 1739/40 James Mitchell 1739/40 James 1739/40 Mitchell James Edinburgh below panels diaper and fruit, flowers, with chased flat circular, Salver, 1738/39 1739/40 Ker James Ker Ker James 1739/40 James Edinburgh Oliphant Edinburgh details no waiter, or Salver 1739/40 Lawrence details further no di, 8" Salver, 1739/40 Oliphant Lawrence Edinburgh center border, scalloped molded with feet, hoof 3 on circular, shaped Salver, 547 p Marks Jackson I, vol 1911, Exhibition Glasgow YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1738/39 LOCATION Tait James Edinburgh feet, hoof 3 on border, Chippendale a with crested circular, shaped Salver, SOURCE

383 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG001355 DAG001355 Christies January 29, 1964 # 29, 1964 January Christies p32 #2 advertisement Moffat Muirhead Christies March 26, 1969 #84 #84 1969 26, March Christies Spink London probably Shrubsole NY USA Sothebys November 22, 1973 1973 22, November Sothebys #171 #136 1978 27, April Sothebys Christies Glasgow August 16, 16, August Glasgow Christies 1983 # J Bourdon-Smith London 1995 London Bourdon-Smith J Collection Phoenix The 25 November Scotland Christies ± Phillips May 20, 1988 # 111 111 # 20, 1988 May Phillips AB Galleries #11 p171 Dictionary Clayton 1984 3, July Glasgow Christies Sothebys December 5, 1968 # 1968 5, December Sothebys lat oof feet, f R] WDERYHWKH ] upports, 18oz 17d 17d 18oz upports, oof like s alloped molded rim, center chased with with chased center rim, molded alloped HHW´GLR]G &KULVWLHV-XO\ oof feet, sc ed, scalloped border with 18 indents and 9 points points 9 and indents 18 with border scalloped ed, DLWHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQI ERUGHURIIORZHUVDQGVKHOOVLQURFRFRSDQHOV´GLR SHDUVKDSHGKDQGOHGHFRUDWHGZLWKIOHXUGHOLVEDURQ¶VFRURQH FUHVWRIDVWDJ¶VKHDGPRWWREHORZ´ORQJR] chased with band fruit of clustersand flowerheads in scroll cartouches, on 3 KRRIIHHW´GLR] PDWWHGJURXQGUDLVHGVKDSHGPROGHGERUGHU´GLR] HQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDOV³-:2´VFUDWFKZHLJKWô´ZLGH through a pelican, city mark partitioned into segments, 8" di 8" segments, into partitioned mark city pelican, a through alternating with 9 crescents, on 3 feet feet 3 on crescents, 9 with alternating GRWWHGò´ZLGHR] later chased scrolls and flowers, on 4 h 4 on flowers, and scrolls chased later 1740/41 Lothian Edward Edinburgh feet scroll 3 on circular stand, Teapot XI, 1967 vol Review Art Scottish 1740/41 Gilchrist William Edinburgh h 3 on circular, Salver, 1740/41 Ged Dougal Edinburgh h 4 on ends, shaped border, molded form, hourglass tray, Snuffer 1740/41 Ker James Edinburgh motto, and crest with engraved border, Chippendale with circular, Salver, 1740/41 Aytoun William Edinburgh on scrolls and foliage heads, flower with chased feet, paw on circular Waiter, 1740/41 Aytoun William Edinburgh center border, molded fluted feet, paw 3 on hexagonal, shaped Waiter, 1740 ca 1740 ca Luke Robert Glasgow arrow an of crest border, chased feet, pad 3 on border, chipped Salver, FD *HRUJH&RRSHU 1740 ca $EHUGHHQ 1740 ca Johnston Alexander : Dundee Cooper George details no Waiter, Aberdeen engrav no Waiter, UK Descent Family Private 1740 ca 1740 ca Cooper George Aberdeen details no Waiter, and Museums Aberdeen 1740 ca 1740 ca Baillie John Inverness X INS, IB, marks 3 feet, bracket on corners, incurved shaped, square Salvers, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1740 ca LOCATION Coline Allan Aberdeen band of narrow for except plain center border, Chippendale circular, Salver, SOURCE

384 Salvers 1969 1969 #967766 #967766 gative gative ecember 17, Sothebys July 4, 1968 #52 4, 1968 July Sothebys 1990 #296 1990 #296 #152 1974 14, March Sothebys Sothebys July 14, 1968 #52 1968 14, July Sothebys Spink Ltd London Finlay 1991 pl 78 pl 1991 Finlay Collection Nobel 1981 24, June Christies Ne Christies #194 Christies May 7, 1969 7, 1969 May Christies D Christies 1950 20, November Christies #143 1995 London I Franklin, & N Christies January 30, 1963 30, 1963 January Christies Christies Edinburgh April 29, 29, April Edinburgh Christies 1992 #49 J Bourdon-Smith London 1992 London Bourdon-Smith J #618 1984 12, March Sothebys Collection Phoenix The oof feet,chased \'RXJDO*HG R] ò´GLR] form, on 3 volute feet, flat chased band of foliage, foliage, of band chased flat feet, volute 3 on form, oof feet, molded border, chased with shell work and scrolls, RIDOLRQKROGLQJDEUDQFKLQLWVGH[WHUIURQWFDPEô´GL branch with leaves RUQDPHQWò´GLR] instead the of maker as it carried William Dempster's mark as well border applied of underside on mm and letter date mark, HQJUDYHGZLWKDFUHVWò´GLR] fruit and flowers, 13" di, 35oz 35oz di, 13" flowers, and fruit EDQGRIIORZHUVVKHOOVDQGVFUROOVFHQWHUZLWKDQLQLWLDO VKDSHGPROGHGERUGHUFUHVWRIDVWDJ¶VKHDGOLVWHGDVEHLQJE the at master assay was Ged state records but master, assay as Lothian with WLPHò´GLR] of shells, scrolls, leaves and flowers, possibly the same as the Christies 1983 1983 Christies as the the same possibly and flowers, leaves scrolls, shells, of 10oz di, 8 7/8" auction, Edinburgh Edinburgh 11oz di, ¾" 8 Salver, 14, April USA NY Christies Edinburgh Salver, chased, circular, on4hoof feet, Finlay may have cited theassayer Edinburgh Edinburgh of a band with chased rim, scalloped molded feet, shell 4 on circular, Salver, Edinburgh Salver, circular with Chippendale border, on 4 paw feet, chased with border Assayer Dougal Ged Assayer Dougal Ged Assayer Dougal Ged Assayer Dougal Ged 1741/42 Edward Lothian Lothian 1741/42 Edward 1742/43 Ker James Edinburgh crest feet, hoof 3 on border, Chippendale form, circular shaped pair, Waiters, 1741/42 Ker James Edinburgh a holding passant a lion of crest feet, pad 3 on border, chipped pair, Waiters, 1741/42 William Dempster Dempster 1741/42 William 1742/43 Aytoun William Edinburgh of band with chased flat supports, paw 3 on border, Chippendale Salver, 1741/42 Ebenezer Oliphant Oliphant 1741/42 Ebenezer 1741/42 Mitchell James Edinburgh h 3 on Salver, 1742/43 Lothian Edward Edinburgh no assayer a castle, with marked border, chased 3 feet, on circular, Salver, 1741/42 Mitchell James Edinburgh h 3 on border, scalloped molded form, circular shaped Salver, 1740/41 William Aytoun Aytoun YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1740/41 William LOCATION SOURCE 1741/42 Lothian Edward Edinburgh circular shaped Salver,

385 Compendium of Scottish Silver #189 #189 U PLWK/RQGRQ Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas S 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU Sothebys December 1, 1982 #132 #132 1982 1, December Sothebys /\RQ 7XUQEXOO)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV$XVWUDOLD-XO\ #714 &KULVWLHV-XQH 17 vol 1933 Magazine Apollo advertisement Edinburgh of How Sothebys Gleneagles August 25, 25, August Gleneagles Sothebys Breadalbane Collection Sale Sale Collection Breadalbane 1935 #355 Christies January 24, 1973 #185 #185 24, 1973 January Christies U´GL ´DFURVVR] LWKLQVKDSHG lat chased with a band of flower flower of a band with lat chased oof feet, chased witha band of fruit, RRIIHHWFHQWHUZLWKLQLWLDOVô´GLR] 6RWKHE\V6HSWHPEH óDFURVVR]G &KULVWLHV-XQH GERUGHUSDGIHHWVTXDUHR]G 6RWKHE\V$SULO oof feet, f TXDUHZDLWHUUDLVHGERUGHU ERUGHUò´R] KHDGVIROLDJHDQGVFUROOVHQJUDYHGZLWKVFULSWLQLWLDO³5´Z IORZHUVDQGVKHOOPRWLIVRQKRRIIHHWFUHVWDQGPRWWRô PRWWRRI%UXFHRI0RZDQFH6KHWODQG´GL IORZHUVDQGIROLDJHô´GLR] crest andmotto of Stewart of Appin or of Ardsheal, or one of the Appin IDPLOLHVDFFRPSDQ\LQJDOHJJHGFRIIHHSRWE\-DPHV.H R] UDLVHGERUGHURQSDZIHHWô´GLR] RUQDPHQWDWLRQô´GLR] IORZHUVDQGVFUROOVZLWKDFUHVWDQGPRWWR´GLR] gh gh and crest feet, 3 scroll on border, scalloped and shell form, circular Waiter, (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVSDLUFUHVWDQGPRWWRóGL -%RXUGRQ6 Edinburgh Edinburgh feet, paw 3 on foliage, and scrolls with chased form, circular shaped Salver, Ebenezer Oliphant William Davie Davie William 1743/44 Jr Luke Robert Glasgow 5REHUW*RUGRQh 3 on circular, shaped Salver, (GLQEXUJK 6 1743/44 Dougal Ged and and Ged 1743/44 Dougal -DPHV0LWFKHOO (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVTXDUHFKDVHGFKLSSH 1743/44 Ged Dougal Edinburgh foliage, scrolling chased flat of band border, molded square, shaped Salver, 1743/44 or Dempster William 1743/44 II Dickson Charles Edinbur 1743/44 Aytoun William Edinburgh with chased feet, paw 4 on border, molded form, circular shaped Salver, 5REHUW/RZ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHU&KLSSHQGDOHERUGHURQK 1743 ca 1743 ca Glen James Glasgow molded ornamentation, rococo of band broad chased flat circular, Salver, 1743 ca 1743 ca Luke Robert Glasgow rococo and fruit, flowers of band chased flat border, shaped Salver, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1742/43 LOCATION Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh h 3 on border, molded circular, Salver, SOURCE

386 Salvers 1970 #918599 #918599 1962 DAG001310 DAG001310 gative gative ecember 18, 1993 Sothebys April 29, 1986 1986 29, April Sothebys 520 p Marks Jackson Christies D Christies 1963 19, December Sothebys Christies July 25, 1973 25, 1973 July Christies 20, 1987 May Christies Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2000 p67 AB Galleries Sothebys July 20, 1967 #60 1967 20, July Sothebys 31, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1981 #455 #11 1979 7, March Christies Ne Christies Sothebys May 3, 1984 #81 1984 3, May Sothebys Sothebys April 23, 1993 #293 #293 1993 23, April Sothebys 2005 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J Christies February 3, 1943 #131 #131 3, 1943 February Christies Collection How VHGZLWKDEDQGRI HUFKDVHGLQVLGHEDQG LSSHQGDOHULPRQSDZIHHWô´GLR]G 6RWKHE\V-XO\ d, for a chocolate pot, no details details no pot, a chocolate for d, and Museums Aberdeen PROGHGULPRQKRRIIHHWô´GLR]G FHQWHUHQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDOVô´GLR]G DQGVFDOHZRUN´GLR]G scrolls, foliage and rococo ornament, molded shaped border, engraved with with engraved border, shaped molded ornament, rococo and foliage scrolls, LQLWLDO³5´ò´GLR]G with a monogrammed roundel, flat chased with blooms and foliate scrolls on on scrolls foliate and blooms with chased flat roundel, monogrammed a with DPDWWHGJURXQGò´ZLGHR] 30oz di, 1/3" 6 and di 8 1/3" PRWLIVDQGVFUROOVó´GLR] GHFRUDWLRQô´GLDQGô´GLR]DOO (7oz 13d ea) ea) 13d (7oz (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHU SDLURIZDLWHUV±VHWVKHOODQGVFUROOERUG *ODVJRZ :DLWHU*HRUJH,,KH[DIRLO2QFXUYHGKRRIIHHWFKD Weems Edinburgh Salver, shaped square,raised and applied border,hoof on 4 feet, laterapplied Weems Edinburgh Salvers, pair,rococo, crest andmotto the of Earl Weems, of 10" Shrubsole Assayer Hugh Gordon 1745 ca 1745 ca Luke Robert Glasgow and foliage, diaper scrolls, of border chased, flat circular shaped Waiter, 1744/45 James Ker 1744/45 James 1745 ca Glen James Glasgow Stan 1745 ca 1745 ca Luke Robert 1745 ca Glen James FD Glasgow :LOOLDP$\WRXQ border, molded feet, 3 scroll on circular, shaped plain II, George Waiter, (GLQEXUJK :DLWHU*HRUJH,,FUHVWHG&K 1745 ca 1745 ca Ker James Edinburgh foliage flowers, with chased border shaped oval, plain II, George tray, Spoon 1743/44 James 1743/44 James 1743/44 Penman Hugh Edinburgh shell flowers, chased with rim waved the near bordered center plain Salver, 1743/44 Ker James Edinburgh chased flat border, shell feet, and shell volute sizes, different 2 of Salvers, 1743/44 James 1743/44 James YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1743/44 LOCATION Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh both 5d 14oz di, ½" 6 borders, molded octagonal, plain, pair, Waiters, SOURCE

387 Compendium of Scottish Silver # 744575 gative gative V &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ #176 Ne Christies &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV0D\ &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0D\ &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0D\ &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ 1994 ZLWKLQLWLDOV QKRRIIHHW´GLR] 6RWKHE\V-XQH FKDVHGZLWKEDQGRIIUXLW WFKDVHGZLWKDUPVRI OFLUFXODU 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ ULP &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ-XO\ PROGHGHVFDOORSHGERUGHUGLR]G &KULVWLHV-XQH GZLWKLQLWLDOV³+$´EDVHGKDVEHHQ PDWFKLQJDVPDOOHUYHUVLRQRIWKH ORSHGERUGHUEDVHHQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDO HDQGVFUROOERUGHUFUHVWDQGPRWWRR]G &KULVWLHV-XO\ RRIIHHWVKDSHGPROGHGVKHOOULPô´GL SUHFHGLQJVDOYHUôGLR] 1LVEHWGLRUR] ³,0)´RQKRRIIHHW´GLR] PRXQWHGPDUNV±,*WUHH,*6R] IORZHUVVFUROOVZLWKPROGHGVKHOODQGVFUROOERUGHUHQJUDYHG ó´GLR]G Z 6DOYHUHQJUDYHGVKHOODQGIROLDJH (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHURQVFUROODQGVKHOOIHHWVKHOOERUGHUIOD (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHU*HRUJH,,VKDSHGFLUFXODURQKRRIIHHW (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUFUHVWHG&KLSSHQGDOHULPLQLWLDOVRQEDVHR OH :DLWHUFLUFXODURQK *ODVJRZ 6DOYHURQSDZIHHWVKHOOIROLDW illiam Davie or or Davie illiam $VVD\HU+XJK *RUGRQ William Dempster Dempster William -DPHV*OHQ -DPHV.HU *ODVJRZ (GLQEXUJK :DLWHURUWHDSRWVWDQGVKDSHGVPDO 6SRRQWUD\REORQJHYHUWHGFKDVHG FD 1RW$YDLODE -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVDPHGHVFULSWLRQDVDERYH -DPHV.HU FD -DPHV*OHQ FD -DPHV*OHQ *ODVJR FD -DPHV.HU FD1745ca -DPHV*OHQ James Glen FD *ODVJRZ -DPHV*OHQ Glasgow 6DOYHUSODLQZLWKPDUN0 details no Salver, *ODVJRZ 6DOYHUVPDOOFLUFXODUSODLQHVFDO 7HVVLHU August Gleneagles Sothebys YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1745 ca LOCATION W SOURCE FD -DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ 6DOYHUODUJHFLUFXODUEDVHHQJUDYH

388 Salvers and and O 1975 #87 1975 ecember 10, Bonhams the Scottish Sale, Sale, Scottish the Bonhams $XJXVW &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU &KULVWLHV$SULO 6RWKHE\V0D\ 2586$ 6RWKHE\V0D\ J Bourdon-Smith Catalog 1993 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ 6RWKHE\V-DQXDU\ Christies July 30, 1975 #195 30, 1975 July Christies D Christies 6RWKHE\V-XO\ 3KLOOLSV*ODVJRZ$SULO #101 KDVHG R] LR] R] ´GLR] WRQFDEULROHOHJVSDG DFHIODWFKDVHGZLWKEDQGRI ODQGVFUROOERUGHULQLWLDOVEHORZ(DUO V ³)LGHV6XIILFXW´RI6LU3HWHU+DONHW 3RUWODQG$UW0XVHXP3RUW oof feet, chased witha border of scrolls, shells and IORZHUKHDGVZLWKUDLVHGVKDSHGVFUROODQGVKHOOULP´G FKDVHGLQWHULRUFDWDORJOLVWHGPDNHUDV+XJK*RUGRQôGL IUXLWDQGIROLDJHUDLVHGERUGHUZLWKPROGHGULPò´GL coronet, 7" di, 18oz 15d 18oz di, 7" coronet, flat chased shells, fruit and flowers, rim applied with scroll and rococo rococo and scroll with applied rim flowers, and fruit shells, chased flat PRWLIVRQURFRFRYROXWHIHHW´GLR] IROLDJHDQGIORZHUVLQLWLDOVRQXQGHUVLGHRQKRRIIHHWó feet, 6 ½" di di ½" 6 feet, VFUROOVHQJUDYHGZLWKODWHUFUHVW´GLR]G LQVFULEHG³$8'$&(6-892´ ,ZLOOKHOSWKHEUDYHRQHV ERUGHUF shell cast with rim raised motifs, scallop and scrolls, heads, flower with PRWLIVRQVFUROODQGOHDIFDSSHGIHHWô´GLR] (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQVKRUWVFUROOIHHWVXUI Edinburgh Salver, circular, engraved in center with crestand motto withina border of Edinburgh Salver, shaped circular, flat chased withina shell and scroll border,typical Edinburgh Salver, shaped circular, on 3 feet, border pierced and cast with vines and Edinburgh Salver, shoulder engraved with cartouche and crest Buchanan of Touch, of (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUFKDVHGZLWKVKHOOVVFUROOVIORZHUVDQGIUXL :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU $VVD\HU+XJK Gordon $VVD\HU+XJK Gordon $VVD\HU+XJK Gordon $VVD\HU+XJK Gordon $VVD\HU+XJK Gordon 3UREDEO\:LOOLDP Dempster 1747/48 Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh h 3 on circular, Salver, :LOOLDP'DYLHRU 1747/48 Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh border, scroll and shell motto, and crest feet, volute rococo 3 on Salver, 1747/48 Ebenezer Oliphant Oliphant 1747/48 Ebenezer 1747/48 James Gilliland Gilliland 1747/48 James -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVSDLURQKRRIIHHWVKHO YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1746/47 LOCATION available Not 'RXJDO*HG (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHURQIHHWFUHVWDQGPRWWR 10oz di, 10" border, scroll Salver, SOURCE #130 3, 1894 July Christies 1747/48 Oliphant Ebenezer 1747/48 Dempster Ker & %ORFN:'

389 Compendium of Scottish Silver &KULVWLHV0D\ Christies Edinburgh November November Edinburgh Christies #722 1993 18, Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1987 #284 Christies May 26, 1998 #83 26, 1998 May Christies Christies November 21, 1990 #41 1990 21, November Christies Sothebys Gleneagles August 26- #178 1991 27, Sothebys Sussex February 20, February Sussex Sothebys 1996 #738 6RWKHE\V6XVVH[-XO\ Christies Edinburgh November November Edinburgh Christies #738 1993 17-18, Sothebys December 22-27, 1987 1987 22-27, December Sothebys #261 XSSRUWV RZURQJ\HDU VWVGDWHOHWWHU RQKRRI PRQRJUDP HOODQGVFUROO OVKRRIV KHPROGHGULP KFRDWRIDUPVRI RRIIHHW´GLR]G 6RWKHE\V0DUFK DEDQGRIIUXLWIORZHUV QGVKHOOERUGHURQKRRI G GZLWKEDQGRIIROLDJHDQG WFKDVHGZLWKEDQGRIIUXLW DEURDGEDQGRIPDWWHGIUXLW ODWFKDVHGZLWKEDQGRIGLDSHUVKHOOV ODWFKDVHGZLWKEDQGRIIUXLWDQG ´GLR] RRIIHHWI QWHUHQJUDYHGZLWKFUHVWIODWFKDVHGEDQGRIGLDSHU DQGVFUROOVPROGHGIROLDJHDQGVFUROOERUGHUHQJUDYHGZLWKD ó´GLR]G IROLDJHUHWDLQLQJWUDFHVRIDQHQJUDYHGFRDWRIDUPVZLWKLQVK ERUGHUó´GLR] IHHWó´GLR]G VFUROOVIOXWHGVKHOOIROLDJHDQGVFUROOERUGHUHQJUDYHGZLW 0DF'RZDOODQG*DUWKODQG*DOORZD\´GLR] DQGIROLDJHUDLVHGERUGHUZLWKPROGHGULPHQJUDYHGZLWKFUH VOLJKWO\UXEEHGSUREDEO\UHDOO\ ZRUNDQGIORZHUVVKHOOPRWLIVDQGFDUWRXFKHVPROGHGERUGHUIHHWó´GLR] DQGVFUROOVDSSOLHGVFUROOERUGHUZLWKVKHOOPRWLIVDWLQWHUYD PPZURQJO\DVFULEHGWR-RKQ0DLQ´GLR] DQGIROLDJHZURQJO\DVFULEHGWR-RKQ0DLQSUREDEO\DVVLJQHGW VKRXOGEHò´GLR] HDUO¶VFRURQHWZLWKLQDWUHOOLVZRUNDQGIROLDWHVFUROOFDUWRXF ZLWKVKHOOVDWLQWHUYDOVRQKRRIIHHW´GLR] (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQKRRIIHHWFKDVHGZLWK (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQYROXWHIHHWIODWFKDVH (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQKRRIIHHWVXUIDFHIOD (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQKRRIIHHWI (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODUSODLQZLWKDSSOLHGVFUROOD (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUHQJUDYHGZLWKFUHVW&KLSSHQGDOHERUGHURQK (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQK Edinburgh Edinburgh an below initials with engraved lightly each circular, shaped pair, Waiters, (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODUODWHULQLWLDOVFKDVHGZLWK Weems Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon James Ker Assayer Dougal Ged Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon James Mitchelson Mitchelson James Assayer Dougal Ged Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon 1748/49 Robert Lowe Lowe 1748/49 Robert 1748/49 Dempster Ker & 1748/49 *1740ca 1748/49 Dempster Ker & 1748/49 William Aytoun Aytoun 1748/49 William 1748/49 James 1748/49 James 1748/49 *1740 /DZUHQFH2OLSKDQW (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODUFH 1747/48 James Ker YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1747/48 James LOCATION SOURCE 1748 ca 1748 ca Mitchelson James

390 Salvers V0D\ WLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 1968 #139 1968 #139 #41 1990 21, 1987 #283 1991 #178 1991 #178 0(4 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU 6RWKHE\V-XQH 6RWKHE\V0D\ J Bourdon-Smith #70b 1973 20, August Sothebys #84 1960 14, January Sothebys $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQH)HEUXDU\ 1987 advertisement Shrubsole #304 1984 USA NY Christies 6RWKHE\V-XQH 1977 22, September Sothebys #121 #213 1978 19, January Sothebys ´ó´GL R]G G VFUROOVDQGIUXLWVKHOODQGVFUROOULPRQKRRIIHHW´GL 60oz 13d 60oz VFUROOERUGHURQKRRIIHHWò´GLR] UHVWLQJRQYROXWHIHHWFDSSHGZLWKIROLDJHPPVDLGWREH³,6 feet, ball and claw 4 on border, decorated similarly below motifs rococo and ò´GLR]G (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUFKDVHGRQFDVWIHHWò´GLR] 3KLOOLS Edinburgh Edinburgh chased of band narrow a within crest later with center in engraved Waiter, Edinburgh Edinburgh and shell monogram, foliate later with center in engrave circular, Salver, Edinburgh border, Chippendale designs, foliate scrolling with engraved later Salver, Edinburgh foliage with chased flat crest, engraved with center circular, shaped Salver, Assayer Dougal Ged Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1748/49 LOCATION II Dickson Charles Edinburgh 18.1oz 11" di, feet, 3 paw on border Chippendale Salver, 28, August Gleneagles Sothebys SOURCE 1748/49 Ker James 1748/49 Aytoun Aytoun William 1748/49 William Edinburgh Edinburgh circular shaped Salver, details no Salver, November Edinburgh Christies August Gleneagles Sothebys 1748/49 Oliphant Lawrence Edinburgh (EHQH]HU2OLSKDQW 16oz ¼" di, 10 border, chased crest, circular, Salver, (GLQEXUJK (EHQH]HU2OLSKDQW 6DOYHUVQRGHWDLOV August Gleneagles Sothebys 1D -DPHV*LOOLODQG -DPHV6WLUOLQJ (GZDUG/RWKLDQ

391 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG001039 DAG001039 Scottish Art Review vol VI 1958 1958 VI vol Review Art Scottish p41 Bell Aberdeen of advertisement MEQ 1110 1110 MEQ AB Galleries Christies July 21, 1954 #36 21, 1954 July Christies Antiques London Cooke Mary 1996 #18 Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 p99 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2000 p68 Christies August 16, 1982 #206 1982 16, August Christies #172 29, 1985 May Christies #120 1977 8, December Sothebys Christies May 29, 1985 #172 29, 1985 May Christies GOD IS òGLR] &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK oof feet, crest andmotto "IN feet, monogram in circular medallion, 5 ¾" square, square, ¾" 5 medallion, circular in monogram feet, details details Scotland of Museums National 5LFKDUG2VZDOGDSSOLHGDQGFKDVHGERUGHU´GLR] CA", border with indentations, semicircular, with initials "WHC", on pad 3 IHHWóGLR] R]G DQGDVLQJOHEHHòGLR] $//IRU)UDVHUR] later chased with flowers and scrolling foliage, with presentation inscription, inscription, presentation with foliage, scrolling and flowers with chased later ò´GLR] IHHWò´GL scrolls, molded shell and scroll border, engraved with later coat of arms and and arms of coat later with engraved border, scroll and shell molded scrolls, PRWWR´GLR]G 6DOYHUZLWKFUHVWDQGPRWWRRQKRRIIHHWPPVWUXFNWZLFH Edinburgh Salver, circular, molded below the leaf decorated scroll border, on 3hoof Edinburgh Salver, shaped circular, on 3 claw feet, chased with band flowers of and Weems Edinburgh Salver, shaped circular, onhoof 3 feet, applied shelland scrollrim, ground Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon 1750 ca 1750 ca Coline Allan Aberdeen Salver Family Gordon The Salver, and Museums Aberdeen 1750 ca 1750 ca Glen James Glasgow to given Glasgow, of City the of Arms and inscription with presentation Tray, 1750 ca 1750 ca WS 1750 ca Allan Coline Aberdeen no Salver, 1750 ca 1750 ca 1750 ca Coline Allan Coline Allan Aberdeen Aberdeen and shells scrolls feet, 3 scroll on Salver, and "ABD marks elements, floral and scrolls with decorated circular, Salver, 1983 March Glasgow Christies 1750 ca 1750 ca Allan Coline Aberdeen scroll 4 on square, Waiter, 1750 ca 1750 ca Coline Allan Aberdeen scales fish with engraved circlets, inset with border C-scroll molded Salver, 1749/50 Dempster Ker & 1750 ca Coline Allan Aberdeen h 3 on border, Salver, Chippendale YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1749/50 LOCATION Dempster Ker & SOURCE 1749/50 James 1749/50 James

392 Salvers 1961-242 1961-242 Christies July 31, 1963 #153 31, 1963 July Christies Christies October 14, 1987 #195 1987 14, October Christies PhillipsEdinburgh December 16, 1983 #197 20, January Edinburgh Phillips 1984 #50 Huntley House Museum Huntley House HH3188/68 Edinburgh Sothebys October 21, 1965 21, October Sothebys Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2000 p72 Christies Australia July 20, 1993 20, 1993 July Australia Christies #725 Sothebys June 11-14, 1985 #964 #964 1985 June 11-14, Sothebys Sothebys March 12, 1959 #51 1959 12, March Sothebys National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National 1108 MEQ Galleries oof feet, ´GL oof feet,the GLR] oof feet, chased with scrolls, flowers, RUGHURQOHJVLQLWLDOV³5´³5)´DQG RUP´GL 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. roll and foliate rims, claw and ball feet, border chased chased border feet, ball and claw rims, foliate and roll ar, shaped molded shell and foliage rims, on 3 h 3 on rims, foliage and shell molded shaped ar, FKDVHGERUGHURIIORZHUVDQGVFUROOV´GLR] JURXQGFKDVHGZLWKDEDQGRIGHFRUDWLRQô´GLR] chased flowers, fruit and scrolls, later engraved inscription and names, names, and inscription engraved later scrolls, and fruit flowers, chased ´GLR] ³´´RYHUSRLQWV RI%UHDGDOEDQHGLR] with flower sprays, scrolls and shell motif, identical crests and mottos in the the in mottos and crests identical motif, shell and scrolls sprays, flower with FHQWHUV´GLR]DOO HQJUDYHGDQGFKDVHGZLWKIORZHUVIUXLWDQGVKHOOGHFRUDWLRQ R] ZLWKODWHUFUHVWDQGPRWWRVFULSWLQLWLDOVXQGHUQHDWK´ OHDIDJHDQGVKHOORUQDPHQWDWLRQò´GLR] fruit fruit 1751/52 Mitchell James Edinburgh circul pair, Waiters, 1751/52 /RWKLDQ 5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK Low Robert 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODUI Edinburgh h 3 on border, foliage and scroll form, circular shaped Salver, 1751/52 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh feet, ball and 3 claw on border, scroll and shell chased circular, Salver, 5REHUW/RZ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUKH[DJRQDOFKDVHGIORUDOE 1750/51 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh Earls Campbell, of motto and crest rim, around shells circular, shaped Salver, 1750/51 Dempster & Ker Edinburgh sc shell, pair, Salvers, 1750/51 Gordon Robert Edinburgh feet, pad and scrolled 3 on border, scroll floral and leaf circular, Salver, 1750/51 Gilchrist William Edinburgh engraved feet, pad border, Chippendale applied form, circular shaped Waiter, 1750 ca 1750 ca Coline Allan 1750/51 available Not Aberdeen no details Salver, Edinburgh h 3 rim, on scroll and shell Salver, Art and Museums Dundee YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1750 ca LOCATION Taylor James Glasgow and flowers work, diaper alternating of band inside border, shaped Salver, SOURCE

393 Compendium of Scottish Silver ber 27, 1987 #426 1987 ber 27, Sothebys Gleneagles August 19, 19, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1996 #133 advertisement Bell Sothebys Gleneagles August Sothebys March 17, 1966 1966 17, March Sothebys Christies March 5, 1991 #251 #251 1991 5, March Christies Christies November 10, 1960 #40 1960 10, November Christies London Asprey Christies January 28, 1970 #181 #181 28, 1970 January Christies 1979 #70 1979 #70 Private Collection Collection Private A.1943.270 A.1943.270 #41 p30 1993 Autumn MEQ 795 R] GLR] oof feet, center oof feet, the ground oof feet, 7¼", 8.8oz Sothebys Scone Palace April 23, oof feet, edge finely chased with fruit, flowers details details Scotland of Museums National ³&RQVLOLR1RQ,PSHWX´RI$JQHZ´GLR] ó´GLR] ZLWKFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI6SRWWLVZRRGHRI'XQLSDFH´GL FKDVHGZLWKDQDUURZIULH]HRIDUDEHVTXHVFUHVWDQGPRWWR´ ZLWKDEDQGRIIUXLWIROLDJHDQGVFUROOVô´GLR] and scale work, underside inscribed "Isobel Tweedie's Gift to Isobel 8 ¾" di, 7d 1753", Crawfurd, 15oz burgh burgh 16:9 weight scratch "N/CE", initials Salver, Scotland of Museums National 1753/54 1753/54 Dempster Ker & Gordon Robert Edinburgh 18oz di, ½" 10 Sefton, of Arms later border, scroll and shell circular, Salver, Edinburgh Octo Christies 16oz di, ½" 6 motto, and crest pair, Waiters, Magazine Antiques 1753/54 Gordon Robert Edinburgh motto and an eagle, crest, a with centers form, circular shaped pair, Salvers, 1753/54 Gilliland James Edinburgh initials, with underside chased, 3 feet, on border, scroll and shell Salver, 1752/53 Gordon Robert Edinburgh h 3 on border, scroll and shell molded plain, pair, Waiters, 1752/53 Gilliland James Edinburgh h 3 on border, applied form, circular shaped Salver, 1752/53 Gilliland James Edinburgh chased feet, hoof 3 on border, scroll and shell form, circular shaped Salver, 1751/52 Low Robert 1751/52 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh Edinburgh h 3 on border, scroll and shell circular, Salver, details no Salver, p 548 Marks Jackson 1751/52 Clark John 1751/52 Low Robert Edinburgh 9.5oz di, 7" chased, flat border, scroll and shell with Waiter, Edinburgh h 3 on circular, shaped Salver, Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1751/52 Edward Lothian Edinburgh Salver, no Lothian Salver, Edinburgh YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1751/52 Edward LOCATION SOURCE 1751/52 Robertson & Lothian Edin

394 Salvers sties Edinburgh November November Edinburgh sties ques Magazine 1970 vol 94 94 vol 1970 Magazine ques Sothebys September 14, 1978 1978 14, September Sothebys #118 Sothebys Gleneagles August 27- #191 1979 28, #2 III, vol Review Art Scottish advertisement Bell Christies May 21, 1986 #196 21, 1986 May Christies Sothebys Gleneagles August 27, 27, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1979 #193 Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1977 #180 Sothebys January 16, 1975 #123 1975 16, January Sothebys 1996 #133 1996 #133 p948 #47 1990 21, #123 1975 16, January Sothebys liate liate oof feet, gadroonedrim, border of bright cut oof feet, molded gadrooned border, shell and fo trailing vines and wiggle work, center with armorials, since William Ker was was Ker William since armorials, with center work, wiggle and vines trailing KRRIIHHWGLR] FHQWHU´GLR] ERUGHUFUHVWDQGPRWWRó´GLR] R] RQKRRIIHHWGLR] matching border, on 3 hoof feet, center with later armorials and supporters supporters and armorials later with center feet, hoof 3 on border, matching EHORZDFUHVWDQGPRWWRó´GLR] decoration, center with a crest andmotto McDonald of andMcDowell, ´GLR] rgh rgh details no Waiter, Anti burgh Waiter, no details details no Waiter, burgh Chri Edinburgh Edinburgh foliate of band border, shell and scroll form, circular shaped Waiter, (continued) (continued) James McKenzie or James Mitchelson 1757/58 1758/59 Taylor William Ker William Edinburgh details no salver, Small Edinburgh h 3 on circular, shaped Salver, 548 p Marks Jackson 1757/58 Low Robert Edinburgh on foliage, and flowers of band narrow a with chased circular, shaped Salver, 1756/57 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh the in crest feet, hoof 3 rim, on shell and scroll form, circular shaped Salver, 1756/57 1756/57 available Not Gordon Robert Edinburgh h 3 on circular, Salver, ea) 6d (9oz both 12d 18oz di, 7" shell, and gadrooned pair, Waiters, #129 3, 1984 July Christies 1756/57 Gordon Hugh Edinburgh di, 8" feet, hoof 3 on rim, and shell scroll crest, center circular, shaped Salver, 1755/56 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh chasing, rococo within motto and crest center border, shell and scroll Salver, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1753/54 Robert Gordon Gordon Edinbu 1753/54 Robert 1753/54 1753/54 Edmonston John Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh 1754/55 Edin no details tray, Small rectangle a in IM 1755/56 Gordon Robert Edinburgh a within shells and flowers foliage, with chased flat circular, shaped Salver, 548 p Marks Jackson

395 Compendium of Scottish Silver t L HXPVDQG$UW KDZ&DWDORJ$XWXPQ 0DJD]LQHYRO 6RWKHE\V1<86$2FWREHU 6RWKHE\V$SULO 6RWKHE\VPDUFK 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU 6RWKHE\V$SULO *DOOHULHV %RQKDPVWKH6FRWWLVK6DOH $XJXVW S 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ S *HEHOLQDGYHUWLVHPHQW %RVWRQ 86$ 6KUXEVROH1<86$ HHWERUGHURI RQKRRIIHHWFKDVHG WDLOV -DFNVRQ0DUNVS ORZHUVVKHOODUPRULDOVLQFHQWHU´GL ZLWKFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI'XQGDVZLWKJDGURRQHG OOERUGHUIODWFKDVHGHQJUDYHG:óGLR] 1LFKRODV6 HUURFRFRVWUDSZRUNò;ô 6FRWWLVK$UW$FDGHP\([KLE GHFRUDWLRQPROGHGULPRQKRRII DQGVKHOOERUGHURQSDGIHHWOHDSLQJKRXQGDQG DLWHUZLWKFKDVHGERUGHURII EDQGRIIORZHUVDQGIROLDJHODWHULQLWLDOHGó´GLR] ZKHDWVKHDIFUHVWò´GLR] IORZHUVDQGH[RWLFELUGVFHQWHUZLWKDFUHVWò´GLR] R] ODWHUó´GLR] ERUGHUVRQKRRIIHHWòR] (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODUIRUPVKHOODQGVFUROOERUGHU :LOOLDP'DYLH (continued) (continued) be should date the or wrong is maker the either time, this at a freeman yet not :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU /RWKLDQ 5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVFUROODQGVKHOO /RWKLDQ 5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUFLUFXODUVFUROO FD -DPHV*LOOLODQG (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUQRGHWDLOV 'XQGHH0XV FD 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK : /RWKLDQ 5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUôGL /RWKLDQ 5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUREORQJRSHQERUG $QWLTXHV 0: (EHQH]HU2OLSKDQW (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUZLWKVKDOODQGVFUR (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVPDOOPDNHUQRWLGHQWLILHGQRGH -RKQ&ODUN (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVSDLUóGLR]ERWK YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 5REHUW*RUGRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVSDLUSODLQFLUFXODU

396 Salvers Phillips Edinburgh March 22, 22, March Edinburgh Phillips 1985 #93 Sothebys July 24-27, 1984 #1566 #1566 1984 24-27, July Sothebys #556 5, 2001 July Bonhams 1995 8, June London Sothebys #136 88 vol 1965 Magazine Antiques p730 advertisement Shreve Sothebys October 19, 1970 #200 #200 1970 19, October Sothebys 1981 16-17, November Sothebys #423 Sothebys January 16, 1970 #163 1970 16, January Sothebys Private Collection Collection Private USA oof feet, made out of an earlier footed tazza, VFUROOERUGHURQKRRIIHHWFUHVWDQGPRWWRò´GLR] DSSOLHGVFUROODQGVKHOOERUGHUSDGIHHWó´GLR]ERWK decoration, center with crest and motto of Robertson of Lanarkshire Lanarkshire of Robertson of motto and crest with center decoration, service tea matching di ½" 12 feet, scroll marriage John of Wilson, Provost Dumferline f o and Katherine Stevenson in ´GLó´KW FUHVWDQGPRWWRò´GLR] ornament, scroll and shell patternrim, on3hoof feet, underside with laterLQLWLDOVó´GLR] 8 ½" di, 10oz 10d 10oz ½" di, 8 fruit of band borders, foliate and scroll form, circular shaped Waiter, Edinburgh Edinburgh and raised leaves, and flowers chased flat of band circular, pair, Salvers, Edinburgh Teapot stand, oval, applied shell and Edinburgh scroll border, onhoof 4 feet, sold as a 3 on leaves, and scroll border, out chased shells, with border circular, Salver, Edinburgh Salver, on 3hoof feet, shell decoratedrim, chased scroll andfloral border, Edinburgh Edinburgh repairs has chased, Waiter, VA Antiques, House Moreland Edinburgh Salver, shaped circular, on 3hoof feet, 7" di Private Collection William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William Davie William Possibly James Oliphant William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William 1761/62 or Dempster William 1762/63 or Dempster William 1762/63 or Dempster William 1761/62 IO 1761/62 James Oliphant Edinburgh and shell chased decoration, fruit and floral chased lightly circular, Salver, 1762/63 Robert Gordon Gordon Edinburgh 1762/63 Robert 1761/62 Clark John Edinburgh for possibly Clark, initials by salver larger match to made miniature, Salver, 1761/62 1761/62 Robertson John or Dempster William Edinburgh no details Salver, 548 p Marks Jackson 1761/62 or Dempster William 1761/62 Clark John Edinburgh and scale shells foliate flowers, of border chased with circular, Salver, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1761/62 LOCATION Robertson John Edinburgh h 3 on circular, shaped, Salver, SOURCE

397 Compendium of Scottish Silver g Winter g Winter 1977 1977 #171 R HFHPEHU &KULVWLHV2FWREHU 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZYRO9,S #4 advertisement Bell &KULVWLHV$SULO 2000 p92 2000 p92 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ Christies November 27, 1963 #61 1963 27, November Christies Sothebys Scone Palace April 14- Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p102 S &KULVWLHV' G 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ OLDWHDQGVFUROOERUGHUFKDVHGZLWK -XQHGLR] HQJUDYHG00ôR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ$XWXPQ th UROOERUGHUIODWFKDVHGZLWKWUDLOLQJIROLDJH DQGIROLDJHHQJUDYHGLQFHQWHU([ DVHGZLWKIORZHUVDQGVFUROOVRQKRRIIHHW OERUGHULQVFULEHG$SUHVHQWIURP$* 6* FUHVWDQGPRWWRRI6WLUOLQJGLR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDO RZHUVDQGIROLDJHVKDSHGVKHOODQGVFUROOULPRQ HQJUDYHGZLWKDVSUD\RIOHDYHVFUHVWDQGPRWWR RRIIHHWJDGURRQHGERUGHUFUHVWó´GLR] oof feet, molded shell and scroll border, with band of RRIIHHWPROGHGIR to theirniece MG in James Court 12 'RQR0DUJW&DUUXWKHUVZLWKDPXJ DQGODWHULQVFULSWLRQV´GLR] KRRIIHHWóGLR] VKHOODQGVFUROOERUGHULQVFULSWLRQVRQEDVHR]ERWK RQKRRIIHHW´GLR] a band of flowers, scrolls and foliage on a matted ground, with later names, names, later with ground, matted a on foliage and scrolls flowers, of a band ´GLR] IORZHUVDQGIROLDJHó´GLR] (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHURUNHWWOHVWDQGVOLJKWGLVKHGôGLR] Possibly James 0F.HQ]LH, *LOOLODQG .HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVWDQGVKHOODQGVFURO 1763/64 conjoined MK .HU 'HPSVWHU (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUFKDVHGEDQGRIIORZHUV 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVWDQGRQULPIRRW -DPHV*LOOLODQG (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVPDOOZLWKEDQGRIIO -DPHV*LOOLODQG (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKDSHGFLUFXODUZLWK *LOOLODQG .HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVWDQGZLWKWHDSRWFK FD $GDP*UDKDPFD $OH[DQGHU-RKQVWRQ *ODVJRZ 'XQGHH 6DOYHUKH[DJRQDOJDGURRQHGERUGHU 6ODYHUFLUFXODURQK YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1763/64 LOCATION available Not Edinburgh h 3 on circular, Salver, SOURCE FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 6DOYHUFLUFXODUZLWKVKHOODQGVF FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 6DOYHUFLUFXODURQK

398 Salvers YRO, Sothebys NY USA OctoberSothebys NY USA 2-5, Shaw Collection Collection Shaw &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 6RWKHE\V1<86$$SULO Phillips London September 23, 23, September London Phillips S 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU 6RWKHE\V-DQXDU\ 6RWKHE\V-DQXDU\ #1768 6RWKHE\V0D\ &KULVWLHV0DUFK &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU Bonhams March 6, 2001 #163 2001 6, March Bonhams Sothebys Gleneagles, #211 ó´GLR] ´GLR] oof feet,center OVFKDVHGRXWERUGHUóGL 6W\OHV$QWLTXHV EUDFNHWIHHWVFUROODQGVKHOOERUGHUIODW HGJDGURRQHGULPOLQHQIROGERUGHUHQJUDYHGZLWK Waiter, circular, shell and scroll border, center engraved with coat of arms of of arms of coat with engraved center border, scroll and shell circular, Waiter, SDLUVRIIORZHUVDOWHUQDWLQJZLWKVFUROOZRUNóGLR] FKDVLQJGLR] WULPFKDVHGERUGHUôGLR] FKDVHGZLWKIROLDWHVFUROOVó´GLR] supporters and headed by a crest, scroll and shell border, arms of Seton of Seton of of arms border, shell and scroll a crest, by headed and supporters &ROEHJ&RXQW\6WHUOLQJRQKRRIIHHW´GLR]G VKHOOERUGHURQSDGVXSSRUWVò´GLR]G border, band incorporating flowers,leaves and similarmotifs, hoof on 3 feet, ò´GLR]G DSURQVEHWZHHQFDVWZLWKRSHQZRUNVKHOOIROLDJHDQGVFUROOV 5DPVD\.LQRIWKHHDUOVRI'DOKRXVLHZKROHRQKRRIIHHW DSSOLHGVFUROODQGVKHOOERUGHURQKRRIIHHW´GLR]G Edinburgh Salvers, circular, Arms Keith-Falconer, of Earl Kintore, of circular, shells on Edinburgh Salver, shaped circular, engraved in center with coat arms of with greyhound (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUGLQRIXUWKHUGHWDLOV *ODVJRZ([KLELWLRQ William Davie Davie William William Dempster Dempster William :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUFLUFXODUZLWKVKDS 1766/67 Alexander Gairdner Gairdner 1766/67 Alexander 1766/67 Gilliland James Edinburgh h on border, and scroll shell with circular, shaped Salver, 1767/68 'DQLHO.HU * D W (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUFLUFXODUERUGHUZLWKVKHO $OH[DQGHU=LHJOHU (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVKDSHGFLUFXODURQ 1766/67 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh and scroll applied within motto and crest engraved circular, shaped Salver, 1766/67 Ker William Edinburgh shell and scroll below chased flat initials, later with center in engraved Salver, 1766/67 Dempster & Ker Edinburgh pierced feet, shell with supports scroll capped leaf 3 on circular, stand, Plate 1766/67 James Gilliland Gilliland Edinburgh 1766/67 James YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1766/67 LOCATION available Not Edinburgh and raised a within floral scrolls of band with chased flat circular, Salver, SOURCE

399 Compendium of Scottish Silver OH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ H0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ Sothebys Gleneagles August 27, 27, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1979 #212 Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1981, #441 1992 USA Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 p95 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas London 1992 Asprey Collection Phoenix The 9LUJLQLD0XVHXPRI)LQH$UWV 5LFKPRQG9$86$ )RJJ$UW0XVHXP+DUYDUG 8QLYHUVLW\%RVWRQ0$86$ 1948.50 #301 eBay #7392845190 NY USA USA #7392845190 NY eBay )HEUXDU\±0DUFK 2000 p72 2000 p72 ROLDWHVSULJVEHQHDWKDQDSSOLHGJDGURRQHG DVHGEDQGVJDGURRQHGHGJH 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU QHGERUGHUFUHVWDQGPRWWR 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ-XQH , initials within scrolling foliage, raised and applied applied and raised foliage, scrolling within initials , ERUGHURQKRRIIHHWóORQJR] gadrooned border, onhoof 3 feet, 7 1/8", 9.4oz 7" di, 7.7oz 7.7oz 7" di, RYDOFDUWRXFKHORQJóZLGH ô´ORQJ;ó´ZLGH LQLWLDOV´GL LQLWLDO³5´ò´GL JK :DLWHUVSDLURYDOJDGURR Edinburgh Stand, oval, chased with shellsand scrolls, on 3 pad feet, engraved vacant Edinburgh Teapot stand, oval, gadroonedrim, onEdinburgh 4pad feet, eagle crestand motto, Salver, on 3pad feet, gadrooned edge, engraving in center, crest or script Probably William William Probably Dempster Dempster William Dempster William 1774/75 Gairdner Alexander FD Edinburgh 0LOQH &DPSEHOO no details Stand, (GLQEXUJK -DPHV*LOOLODQG 6WDQGRYDOZLWKWHDSRWFK (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHURYDOHQJUDYHGZLWKI Boston Parsons, & Firestone 1770/71 * D W 1772/73 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ or Davie William (GLQEXUJK1773/74 7HDSRWVWDQGQRGHWDLOV or Davie William 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXU 3ODWWHUQRGHWDLOV 7K 7KH0DS 1773/74 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh circular shaped Salver, 1770/71 Hewitt James Edinburgh band, outer chased narrow edged, gadrooned circular, shaped Salver, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1770 ca LOCATION 1770 ca Taylor James Thompson Alexander Aberdeen Glasgow 7.7oz di, 1/8" 8 border, shell circular, shaped Salver, 9.3oz di, 1/8" 8 crest, with border, bath with Waiter, Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas p91 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas SOURCE 1770 ca 1770 ca Graham Adam Glasgow the and crest a with engraved border, beaded feet, pad on circular, Salver,

400 Salvers RO, ril 16-17, ril 16-17, S '$* '$* 0XVHXPVDQG ([KLELWLRQYRO, HV *DOOHULHV$% *DOOHUL *DOOHULHV$% 0(4 p122 #66 p122 #66 S H%D\6FRWODQG )HEUXDU\±0DUFK 1947 Firestone and Parsons, Boston USA 17 p1226 vol Magazine Antiques G 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ LQ*RG¶ $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG UKHDY\FKDVLQJ 6RWKHE\V$SULO UHVWPRWWRDQG%DURQFRURQHWRQKRRIIHHW 6RWKHE\V1<86$$ QRGHWDLOV 'XQGHH0XVHXPVDQG$UW ´;´R] ERUGHUDUPVDQGPRWWR³9LUHVFLW9XOQHUH9LUWXV´ô´GL Edinburgh Edinburgh motto and crest rooster oval, stand, Teapot (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVWDQGQRGHWDLOV 1992 Bourdon-Smith J 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUGLQRGHWDLOV *ODVJRZ([KLELWLRQY Edinburgh Salver, on 4 ball and claw feet, shaped beaded edge, embossed swag nearthe am Dempster or or Dempster am William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William William Dempster Dempster William William Dempster Dempster William FDFD 5REHUW*UD\ -DPHV*RUGRQFD *ODVJRZ -DPHV/DZ $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVWDQGXQHQJUDYHGRYDOVKDSH 7HDSRWVWDQGQRGHWDLOV $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVWDQGRYDOPRWWR³0\WUXVW $EHUGHHQ FDFD 0LOQH &DPSEHOO *ODVJRZ 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUVKHOODQGVFUROOERUGH 7HDSRWVWDQGZLWKWHDSRW 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUQRGHWDLOV *ODVJRZ :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU FD :LOOL 1778/79 or Davie William 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUJDGURRQHGERUGHUF YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1776/77 LOCATION Gilliland James Edinburgh star and a stag with 2 crests service, a tea of part Stand, March Magazine Connoisseur SOURCE 1776/77 or Davie William 1777/78 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh engraving, center feet, scroll border, beaded oval, stand, teapot Waiter,

401 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1968, 1968, QH D\RU-XQH eBay #7389358628 February #7389358628 February eBay 2006 UK Sothebys Scone Palace, April 23, 1979 #44 1118 MEQ vol 143 vol vol 143 vol 143 vol Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1978 #378 Christies April 26, 1966 #98 1966 26, April Christies Private Collection Collection Private 14d oof feet, 6 1/8" di, 6oz ular, beaded rim, on 3 shaped feet, crest and motto of of motto and crest feet, 3 shaped on rim, beaded ular, , circular, flat chased scrolls, scale work and foliage, on 3 feet, feet, 3 on foliage, and work scale scrolls, chased flat circular, , ò´;ò´R] 8 ½", 12.7oz 8 ½", 12.7oz hoof feet, 9" di,13oz Hay, 7" di, 15oz 1d both (7oz 10d ea) h 3 on edge, gadrooned foliage, Edinburgh Edinburgh details no stand, Teapot Scotland of Museums National (GLQEXUJK :DLWHUVSDLUFLUFXODUGL &RXQWU\/LIH0D\RU-X (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUFLUFXODUGL Edinburgh teapot with feet, claw with legs, cabriole capped leaf 4 on stand, Teapot Edinburgh #645 p307 Dictionary Clayton Salver, with center crestand motto, flat chased band fruit, of flower, etc, on 3 &RXQWU\/LIH0D\RU-XQH Edinburgh Edinburgh 10d 30oz di, 1/8" 13 Salver, Collection Private Edinburgh Edinburgh rounded of band with ,decorated circular small stand, teapot or Waiter Edinburgh Edinburgh details no teapot, with stand, Teapot (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVWDQG±SDUWRISLHFHVHUYLFH Collection Swan Maple The &RXQWU\/LIH0 -DPHV'RXJODV William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William Davie William William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William -DPHV'HPSVWHURU 1788/89 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh center, in armorials and band cut bright feet, bracket 6 on oval, Tray, 1784/85 1784/85 Robertson Patrick or Dempster William Edinburgh 25oz di, mark, 8" duty pre borders, beaded pair, Salvers, Collection Private 1784-86 or Dempster William 1784/85 or Dempster William 1785/86 or Dempster William 1786/87 or Dempster William 1788/89 Patrick Robertson Edinburgh Salver Edinburgh Robertson 1788/89 Patrick 1780/81 or Dempster William 1783/84 or Dempster William 1783/84 or Dempster William YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1780/81 LOCATION Robertson Patrick Edinburgh circ plain, pair, Waiters, SOURCE

402 Salvers UNVS HV LVWLHV0D\ Rockville, MD US Collection Collection US MD Rockville, Sothebys Gleneagles August 31, 31, August Gleneagles Sothebys #147 1992, Collection Private *DOOHUL p99, #1 p99, YROS %UDFKHU 6\GHQKDP advertisement 98 pl 1991 Finlay 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1979 #222 Canada 1947.Ds.2 1947.Ds.2 Canada ´;´ 0XVHH'H%HDX[$UWV0RQWUHDO URQSDQHOIHHW$UPVRI'UXPPRQG HQJUDYHGORQJR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS GHFRUDWLRQORQJR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ HFHVHUYLFH &RXQWU\/LIH)HEUXDU\ QRGHWDLOV 'XQGHH0XVHXPVDQG$UW IROLDWHGPRXQWLQJVó´;ô´H[FOXGLQJKDQGOHVR] X 8 3/8" 6 1/8" UDLVHGDSSOLHGERUGHURQSDQHOIHHWôZLGHR] TXDUWHULQJ)RUEHVDQG:LOOLDPVóR] 1791/92 William Robertson Edinburgh Salver Edinburgh Robertson 1791/92 William *HRUJH&KULVWLH1791/92 (GLQEXUJK Dempster William :DLWHUQRGHWDLOV Edinburgh with handles end threaded edge, threaded rim with molded oval, Tray, -DFNVRQ0D 1791/92 )UDQFLV+RZGHQ Robertson William (GLQEXUJK Edinburgh 7HDSRWVWDQGRYDOEULJKWFXW 1791/92 pi 4 stand, Teapot Robertson William Edinburgh service, piece a 4 of part supports, panel plain 4 on stand, Teapot )UDQFLV+RZGHQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVWDQGRYDOEULJKWFXW 1790/91 Cunningham P & W Edinburgh the below formal quatrefoils of band a with cut bright oval, stand, Teapot 1789/90 1789/90 Howden Francis Robertson Patrick Edinburgh : 3&XQQLQJKDP Edinburgh no details circular, Salver, (GLQEXUJK )UDQFLV+RZGHQ feet straight fluted 4 on octagonal, stand, Teapot 6WDQGSDUWRIDVHUYLFH (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUFLUFXODUUHHGHGERUGH # 98 1991 Finlay Collection Swan Maple The &KU YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION 'DYLG0DUVKDOO (GLQEXUJK 6DOYHUWHDSRWVWDQG´; SOURCE

403 Compendium of Scottish Silver #99 Christies March 2, 1966 #179 #179 1966 2, March Christies Private Collection Collection Private Sothebys London 1987 #436 #436 1987 London Sothebys Collection Monroe advertisement Shreve #230 p162 #370 1, 1998 1, 1998 #542 advertisement Shreve Christies January 22, 1947 #59 #59 22, 1947 January Christies 1970 20, March Sothebys Sothebys Scone Palace April 19, 1977 #100 Sothebys Blair Castle, Sept' 12, 12, Sept' Castle, Blair Sothebys 1980 #107 ece service, pot by same makers N & I Franklin ´ZLGHR] :DUN+XQWLQJWRQ/LEUDU\ERRN ece service Sothebys Gleneagles, September ece set,¾" 6 di 7 ½" di, 20oz 8d 20oz ½" di, 7 #75 1975 24, April Sothebys 24 ¼" long 24 ¼" long and 17" Edinburgh and of Stirling Bt, 30" long, 189oz 189oz long, 30" Bt, Stirling of and Edinburgh with a later fitted case,12", 30oz borders, gadrooned sizes, different of dishes presentation 2, dishes, Meat 1796 ca 1796 ca Erskine James Aberdeen oblong stand, Teapot #109 1991 Finlay 1795 ca 1795 ca Cunningham P & W 1795 ca Edinburgh Cunningham P & W no details pair, Salvers, 1795 ca Edinburgh Livingston Edward 7d 104oz di, 20" circular, Salver, Dundee )UDQFLV+RZGHQ1795/96 (GLQEXUJK McLean octagonal Graham & stand, Teapot Edinburgh 7UD\PLQLDWXUH¶ORQJ;ò pi a 4 of part "JB", engraved stand, Teapot 1974 28, November Sothebys 72 p590 vol Magazine Antiques # 111 1991 Finlay 1794/95 1794/95 McPherson & Dick Edinburgh Howden Francis 1794/95 pair, Waiters, Mathie Edinburgh 1794/95 Spence Alexander Edinburgh 1794/95 Peter ½" di 7 oval, Salver, Cunningham P & Edinburgh W Edinburgh Arms border, leaf cut rim, bright gadrooned oval, pair, Salvers, pi 4 stand, Teapot 1959 14, October Christies p343 51, vol Magazine Antiques 1794/95 Spence Alexander Edinburgh pi a 4 of part stand, Teapot 1793/94 I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh of the City of those are Arms armorials, 2 with center oval, large Tray, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1792/93 LOCATION Robertson William Edinburgh border, cut bright inscription, later a enclosing center, the in roundel Salver, SOURCE

404 Salvers Christies November 19, 1919 #42 1919 19, November Christies Sothebys April NY USA 13, 1988 #173 1988 #79 Bonhams Sale 10914, #24 #24 10914, Sale Bonhams #94 1977 15, November 2000 #314 1993 #325 advertisement Bell #170 20, 1987 May Christies 1991 Canada #250 rms National Museums Scotland of ece set Salver, crest andmotto, oval, swags of flowers,drapes and scrolls, 10 ¾" di, 20oz Fettes, 13 7/8" di, 17.3oz 17.3oz di, 7/8" 13 Fettes, Edinburgh Edinburgh 1d 27oz " di, 12 feet, ball and 3 claw on circular, Salver, 1968 28, November Sothebys Assayed Edinburgh Simpson Simpson 1802/03 Cunningham P & W 1802/03 Edinburgh I N no details pair, Trays, Edinburgh 4 pi Company, Royal the to gift engraved, oval, stand, Teapot April House Hopetoun Sothebys 1798/99 C & M 1799/1800 I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh 1800/01 teapot with feet, panel 4 on Stand, Teapot Edinburgh McDonald James 1800/01 20.2oz di, 10" feet, panel 3 on border, reeded with circular, Salver, Edinburgh Fenwick & McHattie 1800/01 Edinburgh 34oz di, 7/8" 13 motto, and crest with Salver, Fenwick & McHattie details no Salver, House, Hopetoun Sothebys Edinburgh 1800/01 61oz long, ¼" 17 1800, July 21 date Tray, 1801/02 Fenwick & McHattie Edinburgh 24, April Howden Francis Wallis, & Woolley a 1801/02 and crests 2 with Archers, of Company Royal the to Tray, Prize King's Edinburgh 1801/02 Fenwick & McHattie Edinburgh 22, October USA NY Sothebys 12oz Salvers, S & M 19d 38oz di, 10" "R", initial Salver, 1966, 1, December Sothebys 91 #810 vol Magazine Antiques #83 1977 28, April Sothebys Toronto Antiques Lorentz YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1797 ca LOCATION & Cunningham SOURCE 1797/98 1797/98 Cunningham A Cunningham P & W Edinburgh Edinburgh of crest with engraved center stand border, Teapot raised feet, hoof 3 on circular Salver, #147 1, 1959 July Sothebys

405 Compendium of Scottish Silver 2004 f Scotland House April DAG001376 DAG001376 Milwaukee Art Museum loan loan Museum Art Milwaukee item #59 in catalog AB Galleries 1988 #71 1988 #71 #120 1988 #477 1988 #76 1988 #76 #96 1955 12, October Christies H.1992.1830 H.1992.1830 1977 #171 gadroonedhandles with applied shelland acanthus leafage,hairy 4 paw and EDOOIHHWFRDWRIDUPVFUHVWDQGPRWWR´ORQJR] Lochtim, 16" wide, 55oz 16d 55oz wide, 16" Lochtim, Salver, 9" di 9" Salver, 1991 USA, NY Robinson's J Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Salver, April House Hopetoun Sothebys Edinburgh Edinburgh long ½" 21 gadrooned, handles, 2 with Tray, Edinburgh Salver, oblong, gadroonedrim, border of flowers, Arms of Anderson of #105 1972 11, October Christies McHattie McHattie Also "Milby"Also Simpson Simpson Simpson Simpson Assayed Edinburgh 1810 ca 1810 ca Jamieson William 1810/11 George Edinburgh details no Salver, and Museums Aberdeen 1810/11 McHattie George 1810/11 Edinburgh Fenwick George 1811/12 100oz long, 21" handles, 2 with Tray, Edinburgh 1811/12 McKay James tray Tea Finlayson James Edinburgh Glasgow 33oz di, 13" grapes, and vines with rim, engraved edged gadrooned Salver, Antiques Shaw Nicholas border engraved vine and leaf border, rope circular, Salver, 1967 29, November Christies 1992 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J August Gleneagles Sothebys 1808/09 Cunningham & & 1808/09 Cunningham 1809/10 Fenwick George Edinburgh rim, gadrooned applied lip, molded raised corners, rounded rectangular, Tray, 1808/09 Cunningham & & 1808/09 Cunningham YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1804/05 LOCATION Fenwick & McHattie Edinburgh '52" 5 May Edinburgh Jeffrey, "Robert engraved later rectangular, Tray, o Museums National SOURCE 1804/05 S & M 1805/06 McDonald John 1806/07 Edinburgh Cunningham P & W Edinburgh 94oz di, ¼" 20 circular, Salver, 26.7oz Kincraigie, of armorials central borders, gadrooned pair, Salvers, Hopetoun Sothebys 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys

406 Salvers DAG008824 DAG008824 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU Cincinnati Art Museum, Museum, Art Cincinnati &LQFLQQDWL2+86$ Sothebys London 1987 #136 #136 1987 London Sothebys #249 Collection Private p39 112, 1970 vol AB Galleries 1988 #480 2001 p77 2001 p77 Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas p87 2002/03, long, no details details no long, p603 88 vol Magazine Antiques PRQRJUDPPHGLQVFULSW³&0´LQFHQWHU ball feet and ball feet, center engraved with impaled arms said to be of Collyer and and Collyer of be to said arms impaled with engraved center feet, ball and 12d 8oz ht, 6 1/8" Chancellor, engraved, 13"di, 33oz Edinburgh Edinburgh claw work scale and scroll 2 border, gadrooned circular, heavy plain, Salver, *ODVJRZ 6DOYHUFLUFXODUFDVWDSSOLHGERUGHU´GLR] nwick Edinburgh Salver, ob Salver, Edinburgh nwick II Assayed in Edinburgh 1812/13 1812/13 McKay James McKay James 1813/14 Edinburgh Cunningham P & W Edinburgh border shell and rope reticulated, Salver, 1814/15 23oz di, ¾" 7 motto, and crest pair, Salvers, 1814/15 Cunningham P & W Edinburgh P W 1815 ca center in armorials border, rococo cast with circular, Salver, Jamieson William 1815/16 Aberdeen Cunningham P & W 1815/16 Edinburgh Edinburgh cartouche vacant oblong, Salver, # 102 1991 #327 1991 Finlay USA NY Sothebys 1816/17 maker? Aiken Peter possible Parkins William 1968 pair, 28, Salvers, November Sothebys no details Stand, Russell & Mitchell Glasgow no details Salver, October Magazine Burlington and Museums Aberdeen August Gleneagles Sothebys 1993 London Bourdon-Smith J 1816/17 Henderson Alexander Edinburgh feet, shell 3 on motif, shell and gadrooned rim with applied Salver, 1812/13 George Fe 1812/13 1812/13 George Fenwick George 1812/13 Edinburgh Fenwick George details no oblong, Tray, Edinburgh 4 corner, each elements engraved center, in Arms reticulated, oblong, Salver, Collection Swan Maple The YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1811/12 LOCATION McKay James Edinburgh grapes, and vines of band outer with edge gadrooned circular, Salver, SOURCE

407 Compendium of Scottish Silver al Museums of Scotland al Museums Bourdon-Smith Catalog Bourdon-Smith SothebysNY USA April 27, UK Antique Shop Autumn 1991 p47 #34 1991 p47 Autumn #34 1991 p47 Autumn #28 Galleries ABDAG001377 J Bourdon-Smith Catalog J Bourdon-Smith #46 2005 p26 Autumn MEQ 622 Galleries ABDAG011112 MEQ 795 1965.1866 MEQ 1096 1990 USA 32.5.3 USA Bell advertisement z Catalog J Bourdon-Smith 36ozvol Magazine Antiques nister of the Borough of Glasgow, Borough nister of the , 11 ½" di, 30oz J chased, 8 ¾" di, 14.5o di, chased, 8 ¾" est of Moncrieff, 10"di, 10"di, of Moncrieff, est deDayton OH Dayton Art Institute, Son, 18 ½" di, 88oz 1820 ca, no details Nation details of Scotland National Museums drooned border, chased alver, gadrooned border, Salver, with inscribed dedication to a mi dedication with inscribed Salver, engraved by Gray & 7 ¼" di, 12.2oz hwi 26” long X 17” Tray, Edinburghno details Salver, of Scotland National Museums Glasgow21oz 20 ½" di, Salver, Also AC Assayed Edinburgh 1826/27 P. G. Glasgow Salver, ga 1827/28Sons Robert Gray & Glasgow S 1825 ca Pirie James 1825/28 Mitchell & Son Aberdeen Glasgow no details Waiter, circular, and Museums Aberdeen 1825 ca Pirie James Aberdeen Salver, on 3 bracketed feet, rope border, 6 ¾" di, 8oz 1983 Christies Glasgow March 1820 ca Peter Ross1820/21 McKay James Aberdeen Edinburgh rimbeaded with Waiter, circular, of Bannerman, and crest on scrollfeet, arms Salver, chased, lion paw and and Museums Aberdeen 1819/20 McKay James Edinburghno Salver, 1750 caShirras Alexander Banff Salver, listed as 1819/20 Howden James YEAR1817/18 MAKER Elder & Co Edinburg LOCATION DESCRIPTION SOURCE 1817/18 McKay James 1818/19 Peter Aiken Edinburgh cr circular, pair, Salvers,

408 Salvers Smith London 1993 Smith London 1993 Smith p107 of Scotland National Museums L.198.47 MEQ MEQ 1109 p107 MEQ 145 MEQ 934 Edinburgh HH2188/62 ¼" long, 4.6oz¼" long, 2005 Catalog Nicholas Shaw ss handles, 85ozss handles, Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 X 14”X Huntley House Museum ecorations Bourdon- J last piece struck with the thistle mark last lar, chased J Bourdon- d, octagonal, bright cut decoration, 6 bright cut decoration, octagonal, d, details of Scotland National Museums , presentation, oval, 20” , rectangular, with 2 handles, 23 ½" acro 23 ½" with 2 handles, rectangular, , Salver, with shell d rghno details Salver, of Scotland National Museums inburgh Salver, circu es Edinburgh Tray, circular, 1973/74 & Inch Hamilton 1930/31 W. R. Sorley Glasgow Tray 1905/06 Brook & Son Edinburgh no Salver, YEAR1830 ca MAKER McKay James Edinburgh LOCATION DESCRIPTIONno details Tray, SOURCE of Scotland National Museums 1836/37 Leonard Urquhart Ed 1836/371844/45 A G Wighton Marshall William Edinburgh Edinbu 1860/61 & Son Robb Charles 1904/05 Edinburgh Inches & Hamilton Salver Edinburgh Teapot stan

409 Compendium of Scottish Silver

410 Sauceboats

SauceboatsSAUCEBOATS

Plate 41. A Sauceboat 1763/64 by Alexander Gairdner, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

411 Compendium of Scottish Silver 966 #118 HFHPEHU Christies July 5, 1967 #111 #111 5, 1967 July Christies 'H+DYLOODQG Christies March 21, 1988 1988 21, March Christies &KULVWLHV' Christies October 14, 1987 14, October Christies Christies March 13, 1968 1968 13, March Christies Sothebys March 12, 1984 1984 12, March Sothebys 1984 29, November Sothebys Sothebys June 29-30, 1981 #193 #193 1981 June 29-30, Sothebys Finlay 1991 p69 1991 Finlay #111 3, 1968 July Christies Scotland of Museums National MEQ 944 Sothebys Sussex January 17, January Sussex Sothebys 1990 #1980 Christies London November 27, 27, November London Christies 1976 #170 G LQLWLDOVRQSDZIHHWR] 3KLOOLSV-DQXDU\ George II, on 3 trefoil and paw feet, scrolling everted rim chased chased rim everted scrolling feet, paw and trefoil 3 on II, George GRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHHQJUDYHGZLWKDFUHVWó´R] DQGVKDSHGERUGHUFKDVHGZLWKVKHOOVIORZHUVDQGVFUROOVR] with foliage and scrolls and double scroll handle, 6oz 5d 6oz handle, scroll double and scrolls and foliage with Sauceboat, George II, on 3 shell and mask feet, body later repoussed and and repoussed later body feet, mask and shell 3 on II, George Sauceboat, handle scroll rising rim, scalloped trelliswork, and foliage fruit, with chased IRUPHGDVDVHDVHUSHQWR]G foliage and a shell, leaf capped double scroll handle, on 3 paw supports, supports, paw 3 on handle, scroll double capped leaf a shell, and foliage XQGHUVLGHKDVLQLWLDOV´R]G WRQJXHPRWLIVHDFKRQSDGVXSSRUWVô´R]G spouts, double scroll handles, scalloped rim, engraved twice with crest and and crest with twice engraved rim, scalloped handles, scroll double spouts, PRWWRKDQGKROGLQJGDJJHUXSULJKW³'XPVSLURVSHUR´R] VFUROOVDERYHVWHSSHGSDGVXSSRUWVVFUROOKDQGOHó´GLR] SAUCEBOATS SAUCEBOATS Edinburgh Sauceboat, small, George II, on 3 scrolland hoof feet, double scrollhandle Limerick Limerick Glasgow Available Available Assayer Hugh Gordon or Johann Got-helf Got-helf or Johann Bilsings James Ker Ker James Edinburgh lipped double years, consecutive in marked pair, Sauceboats, #5 176 p Christies Clayton 1746/47 Not 1746/47 Not 1745 ca 1745 ca Buck Johnathan FD 1745 ca -DPHV*OHQ Gordon Hugh *ODVJRZ Edinburgh 6DXFHERDWSODLQEDVHHQJUDYHGZLWK arabesques, with rim chased shaped feet, hoof knurled on shallow, Sauceboat, 1745 ca James Glen Glasgow Sauceboat, 1745 ca 1745 ca Glen James Glasgow flowers, with engraved rim everted shaped and lip II, George Sauceboat, 1740 ca 1740 ca IG overlapping with decorated handles, scroll flying crested, oval, 2 Sauceboats, 1738/39 Mitchelson James Edinburgh the beneath drop molded foot, molded oval on lipped, double Sauceboat, 1730/31 & 1733/34 Mitchelson James 1734/35 Edinburgh lipped double pair, Sauceboats, UK Collection Private 1735 ca 1735 ca Luke Robert Glasgow and shells with chased rim, shaped everted oval, boat, cream or Sauceboat, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

412 Sauceboats er 30, 1974 #192 1974 er 30, Christies Edinburgh November November Edinburgh Christies Bell of Aberdeen 1969 Aberdeen of Bell Lyon & Turnbull sale Collection Murray The 21, 1990 #40 1990 21, Christies June 3, 1959 1959 3, June Christies How of Edinburgh 1937 #109 1937 Edinburgh of How 1985 Sothebys Hopetoun House, April House, Hopetoun Sothebys #59 1988 26, 4, 1968 July Sothebys #172 5, 1973 July Sothebys Sothebys Gleneagles August 27- #235 1979 28, House Hopetoun Sothebys #47 1980 10-11, November 50 58 p vol Sothebys October 2, 1980 #50 1980 2, October Sothebys OXWHIHHW´ foot 10d no details details no 544 P Marks Jackson at, no details details no at, February USA NY Sothebys high C-scrollhandle, on stepped oval pedestal foot, 7¼" long, 9oz crest, 9oz 30.7oz 30.7oz with flower, scroll and shell motifs, leaf capped double scroll handle, on 3 3 on handle, scroll double capped leaf motifs, shell and scroll flower, with SDZIHHW´R]G hoof feet,6oz by headed feet claw 3 on side, one on motto and crest with spout, pointed OREHGPRWLIVò´R]G IORZHUVDQGIROLDJHOHDIFDSSHGVFUROOKDQGOHVKHOOKHDGHGYR 12d 8oz Edinburgh Edinburgh chased flat rim, everted the below monogram a with engraved Sauceboat, Edinburgh Edinburgh somewhat lip, waved projecting design, shallow typical oval, Sauceboat, Edinburgh Edinburgh with chased flat rim, shaped the below initials II, George oval, Sauceboat, Weems Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon 1755/56 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh capped leaf decoration, floral chased body, shaped pear inverted Sauceboats, 1753/54 1754/55 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh 5.4oz feet, shell 3 on handle, scroll flying border, scalloped Sauceboat, spreading a on and chased Sauceboat, Octob Christies 1753/54 available Not Edinburgh a with feet, shell 3 on handle, scroll rim, fling scalloped plain Sauceboat, 1751/52 Ged Dougal Edinburgh rim, gadrooned handle, scroll feet, scroll and shell 3 on pair, Sauceboats, 1747/48 CL mark mark Gordon 1747/48 CL Sauceboat, Edinburgh 1747/48 Robert 1748/49 James 1751/52 Gordon Hugh 1751/52 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh Edinburgh no details pair, Sauceboats, Saucebo 1992 August Magazine Antiques 1746/47 Dougal Ged Ged YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1746/47 Dougal LOCATION SOURCE 1746/47 Clark John Edinburgh 3 on handle, scroll double capped leaf rim, waved everted oval, Sauceboat,

413 Compendium of Scottish Silver Sothebys Scone Palace, April 19, Collection Private 6RWKHE\V0D\ #661 &KULVWLHV-DQXDU\ Sale Scottish the Bonham's #2 2005 24, August Bonham the Scottish Sale August August Sale Scottish the Bonham #19 2003 21, Catalog Bourdon-Smith J #45 p15 2004 Summer #112 1970 14, October Christies AntiquesSimon Kaye &KULVWLHV$SULO 6RWKHE\V0DUFK 6RWKHE\V0DUFK Phillips Edinburgh June 9, 1995 1995 9, June Edinburgh Phillips #291 August 20, 2003, #190 2003, 20, August KHUVPP aved with Royal Royal with aved d ground, later engr later ground, d oat, oval, chased and embossed floral foliate and scroll decoration, decoration, scroll and foliate floral embossed and chased oval, oat, scroll handle, on oval gadrooned spreading base, crest and motto in a riband, riband, a in motto and crest base, spreading gadrooned oval on handle, scroll ôORQJR] $UPVLQVFULEHGIURP4XHHQ9LFWRULDWRWKHUR\DOFRPSDQ\RI$UF UXEEHGòÓRQJR] chased with flowering foliage on a matte a on foliage flowering with chased foliage capped scroll handle, 21oz both both 21oz handle, scroll capped foliage foot, with everted scalloped rim, acanthus capped flying scroll handle, handle, scroll flying capped acanthus rim, scalloped everted with foot, PRQRJUDPDQGLQLWLDOVR] DQGPRWWR$'$5'8$9,5786ORQJR] on mask 3 and shell feet, 7.4oz ÓRQJR] KHDGHGE\VKHOOPRWLIVÓRQJR] wavy border, on 3 shell feet,the base with a crest andmotto, 9.4oz Edinburgh Edinburgh edge cyma with Sauceboat, 1975 26, September Bonhams Edinburgh Sauceboats, pair, oval with gadrooned foot, leaf capped scrollhandles, crest Edinburgh Edinburgh 3 supporters handle, scroll flying capped leaf rim, wavy oval, Sauceboat, William Davie Davie William or William Davie Robert Gordon Edinburgh Sauceboats, 2, oval, each on spreading circular foot, gadrooned border, William Davie Davie William (continued) (continued) 1761/62 or Dempster William 1760/61 Gordon Robert Edinburgh double capped rim, leaf gadrooned body, shaped pear inverted Sauceboat, 1760 ca 1760 ca Robertson Patrick Edinburgh lip shells, wavy by terminated and headed supports body, oval Sauceboat, :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU DQG 61/62 1756/57 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh domed spreading on form, shape pear inverted of or creamboat, Sauceboat 1756/57 or Dempster William 1756/57 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh handles, scroll capped leaf scrolls, and fruit flowers, with chased Sauceboat, 1755/56 Taylor William Edinburgh motto, and crest feet, hoof 3 handle, scroll flying rim, shaped oval, Sauceboat, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1755/56 Dempster & Ker Edinburgh Sauceb

414 Sauceboats Sothebys Gleneagles August 31, 31, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1999 #497 Sothebys December 9, 1976 #34 1976 9, December Sothebys Sothebys December 9, 1976 #34 1976 9, December Sothebys 1988 June 6, Glasgow Phillips #340 Sothebys Gleneagles August 28, 28, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1969 #86 %RQKDP¶VWKH6FRWWLVK6DOH $XJXVW #366 Linden & Co Antiques, London 2006 #1642 Sothebys March 31, 1966 1966 31, March Sothebys Sothebys July 6, 1967 #188 6, 1967 July Sothebys Christies July 9, 1986 #248 #248 9, 1986 July Christies Shrubsole London 1991 Collection Phoenix The J Bourdon-Smith Catalog 2000 2000 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J #42 foot, W YHVFUHVWDQG DWHGQRGHWDLOV 6RWKHE\V1<86$2FWREHU GHOHDIFDSSHGGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOH VFUROOKDQGOHSDGVXSSRUWVôÓRQJ PFKDVHGOHDIFDSSHGIO\LQJVFUROOKDQGOH UGHUVFUROOKDQGOHVHJPHQWHGOHJVRQVKHOO IRUPFKDVHGOHDIFDSSHGIO\LQJVFUROOKDQGOH IRUPJDGURRQHGOLSVOHDIFDSSHGGRXEOH IODUHGULPOHDIFDSSHGGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHRQ HUWHGSHDUVKDSHGERG\FKDVHGZLWKIORUDOVZDJVRQ R]G IHHWKHDGHGDQGWHUPLQDWHGE\VKHOOPRWLIVóÓRQJR] IHHWKHDGHGDQGWHUPLQDWHGE\VKHOOPRWLIVóÓRQJR] IHHWR]ERWK upper part, bordered with semi lobing, shell lined bowl backs applied with with applied backs bowl lined shell lobing, semi with bordered part, upper handle scroll double capped leaf LQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHGERG\ZLGH PRWWR7RXMRXU3UHWXQGHUVSRXWôORQJRYHUKDQGOHòK JDGURRQHGIRRWHDFKVLGHFKDVHGZLWKDEDQGRIIORZHUVDQGOHD VFUROOKDQGOHVGHFRUDWHGEDVHVòÓRQJR]ERWK VFUROOKDQGOHVLGHQWLFDOFUHVWVòÓRQJR]ERWK ´RYHUKDQGOH Edinburgh Edinburgh double capped leaf bases, pedestal rims, gadrooned matching, 2, Sauceboats, Edinburgh Edinburgh details no pair, Sauceboats, p66 86 vol 1967 July Apollo William Dempster or or Dempster William :LOOLDP'DYLH William Davie Davie William 'DQLHO.HU (GLQEXUJK 6DXFHERDWRYDOZDY\ULPIO\LQJ .HU 'HPSVWHU (GLQEXUJK .HU 'HPSVWHU 6DXFHERDWVSDLUJDGURRQHGER (GLQEXUJK 6DXFHERDWRUFUHDPERDWRYDO FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 6DXFHERDWRUFUHDPERDWRYDOIRU FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 6DXFHERDWQRWPDUNHGPDNHUVSHFXO $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK 6DXFHERDWVSDLURYDOLQY FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 6DXFHERDWVOLJKWO\HYHUWHGULPZL 1762/63 and 1762/63 67/68 1762/63 or Dempster William $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK 6DXFHERDWRYDOJDGURRQHG 5REHUW*RUGRQ (GLQEXUJK 6DXFHERDWVSDLURYDOEDOXVWHU YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1761/62 LOCATION Gordon Robert Edinburgh gadrooned raised on handle, capped leaf edge, gadrooned Sauceboat, SOURCE

415 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG000099 DAG000099 JD]LQH2FWREHU XU0DJD]LQH Sothebys Hopetoun House House Hopetoun Sothebys #39 1977 15, November AB Galleries J Bourdon-Smith Catalog Catalog Bourdon-Smith J #41 p38 1999 Autumn Sothebys Blair Castle September #41 1980 12, vol 93 p 347 347 93 p vol Sothebys Scone Palace April 13, 1976 #122 1978 #418 Bell advertisement advertisement Bell J Bourdon-Smith London Christies July 3, 1984 #102 #102 3, 1984 July Christies Sothebys May 3, 1962 #154 1962 3, May Sothebys 1961.544-555 G òR] y, flat chased with fruit, swags, 2 swags, fruit, with chased flat y, HFHGLQJR] 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW ir, no details details no ir, Scotland of Museums National at, oval inverted pear shaped body, chased with flowers and foliage foliage and flowers with chased body, shaped pear inverted at, oval Sauceboat, oval inverted pear shaped bod shaped pear inverted oval Sauceboat, YDFDQWFDUWRXFKHVOHDIFDSSHGVFUROOKDQGOHVSUHDGLQJEDVH FDSSHGKDQGOHRYDOPROGHGIRRWòR] DQGPRWWRRI%UXFHORQJR] below a waved rim, leaf capped scroll handle, on spreading foot, mate to next next to mate foot, spreading on handle, scroll capped leaf rim, a waved below RQHR] SODLQEDVH´KW HQJUDYHGZLWKFUHVWPPRQO\R]GERWK ULPDQGIRRWGRXEOHVFUROOOHDIFDSSHGKDQGOHò´ZLGHR] *ODVJRZ 6DXFHERDWQRGHWDLOV &RQQRLVVH 1775 ca 1775 ca Lumsden Benjamin FD Aberdeen 0LOQH &DPSEHOO details no Sauceboat, and Museums Aberdeen 1781/82 James Gilliland Gilliland Edinburgh 1781/82 James 1773/74 Gilliland James Edinburgh leaf rim, waved cartouche, vacant style, rococo in chased oval, Sauceboat, 1776/77 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh crest handles, scroll double feet, bracket borders, gadrooned pair, Sauceboats, 1771/72 Gilliland James Edinburgh pr one the to mate Sauceboat, 1771/72 James Gilliland Gilliland Saucebo Edinburgh 1771/72 James :LOOLDP.HU (GLQEXUJK 6DXFHERDWQRGHWDLOV $QWLTXHV0D 1770 ca 1770 ca Graham Adam Glasgow tall oval handle, scroll double rim, inner to chasing floral and shell Sauceboat, 1768/69 Ziegler Alexander 1768/69 Edinburgh 1770 ca Gairdner Alexander pa Sauceboats, Edinburgh Gordon James details no Sauceboat, Aberdeen handle, scroll capped leaf rising with feet, 3 on oval, plain pair, Sauceboats, Collection Swan Maple The YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1766/67 LOCATION Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh fluted and lobed sprays, flower with chased and repousse oval, Sauceboat, SOURCE

416 Sauceboats Sothebys Hopetoun House House Hopetoun Sothebys #124 1977 15, November K.2004.206 K.2004.206 Autumn Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1999 p54 1999 Collection Private #39 p31 1997 Autumn #23 10914 Sale Bonham's Shreve advertisement advertisement Shreve aved either side with crest and helm within foliate foliate within helm and crest with side either aved hope, 4 ¾" ht, 6.7oz 6.7oz ht, ¾" 4 hope, Scotland of Museums National no details details no Collection Swan Maple The mantling, beaded borders, capped loop handles, on oval pedestal both base, 20.8oz 8 ½"long, conforming foot, beaded borders, urn finials,½" 5 ht athandles, 25.9oz Edinburgh Sauce tureens, pair, George III, with covers, classical vase shape, on Glasgow Glasgow no details pair, Sauceboats, 63 vol Magazine Antiques William Dempster Dempster William Assayed Edinburgh 1793/94 Mathie Peter Edinburgh details no Sauceboat, 550 p Marks Jackson 1784/85 Mathie Gilliland James Sauceboat, Edinburgh 1784/85 Peter Edinburgh 1786/87 12.4oz handles, hoop high body, shaped helmet tall Sauceboat, Robertson Patrick 1786/87 Edinburgh or Davie William 1788/89 10oz 8" long, MacKay, of motto and crest gadrooned, Sauceboat, 31, August Gleneagles Sothebys Howden Francis Edinburgh Catalog Bourdon-Smith J engr oval, pair, Sauceboats, 1783/84 James McEwan McEwan YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1783/84 James LOCATION SOURCE 1783/84 Downie Davie Edinburgh Stan of crest Sauceboat,

417 Compendium of Scottish Silver

418 Strainers and Squeezers

StrianersSTRAINERS AND& SqueezersSQUEEZERS

Plate 42. An oval Orange Strainer 1765ca by Adam Graham, Glasgow. Courtesy of The Maple Swan Collection.

419 Compendium of Scottish Silver Dictionary p156 #2 and Sothebys Hopetoun House March House Hopetoun Sothebys 27, 1984 #134 Hyman Collection - Colonial Hyman Williamsburg L1988-470 Bell of Aberdeen 1951 Bell of Winter Catalog Nicholas Shaw 2000 p85 Christies July 3, 1984 #127 Provenance John Noble Esq., 24, June Sale, Christies London 1981 #70 2a 1984 Christies Glasgow July 3, Galleries ABDAG001358 MEQ 1559 1983 Shaw Collection 29, March Christies Glasgow 1983 #75 #303 Galleries 1978-658 Hyman Collection - Colonial Hyman Williamsburg L1986-130 all flat shaped handle, lug handles, lug handles, asymmetrical one shaped handle pierced with a handle pierced trefoil, one shaped mm only 3X's, 6 ¾" wide6 ¾" 3X's, mm only 1981 16, February Christies handle and a clasphandle Clayton er coronet on handleser coronet of Scotland National Museums circular with 2 shaped circular concentric circles, small bowl, sm concentric circles, small detailsArt and Dundee Museums ug handle, no details ug handle, and Museums Aberdeen motto, open scroll handled, marked on handle, 4 ½" di, 2.1oz di, 4 ½" on handle, marked handled, scroll open motto, Strainer, small, Old English, pierced bowl, molded rim, slim shaped flat shaped slim rim, bowl, molded pierced Old English, Strainer, small, 4 ¾" long handles, under cleats positioning Drummond, handles, crest of piercing, 6 5/8" long, 3oz long, piercing, 6 5/8" engraved with initials “AFS”, mm 3X’s, 4 ¼” di, 3oz 7d 3oz 4 ¼” di, 3X’s, engraved with initials “AFS”, mm STRAINERS AND SQUEEZERS pierced with stylized Celtic cross pierced dinburghno strainer, Lemon Aberdeen bowl form, Strainer, shallow Scotland 1760 caGairdner Alexander Edinburgh crest and rim, below a molded bowl pierced simple circular Tea strainer, 1750-80 Not available Possibly 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen one with circular Strainer, 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen l Tea strainer, 1740 ca Ker James 1740 ca Edinburgh Ker James 1740 ca und crest strainer, Orange Dougal Ged1740/41 Edinburgh Dougal Ged handles, 2 pierced Strainer, E Edinburgh plain, strainer, Lemon 1730 ca George Cooper YEARPre-1689 MAKER Scott I William Aberdeen LOCATION DESCRIPTIONpierced in Strainer, SOURCE

420 Strainers and Squeezers DAG001312 DAG001312 g L1988-46 g L1988-46 Hyman Collection - Colonial Colonial - Collection Hyman L1989-362 Williamsburg 551 p Marks Jackson Lyon & Turnbull Sale collection Murray The #176 2003 20, August HH3144/67 Edinburgh Colonial - Collection Hyman L1989-138 Williamsburg Jackson Marks p463 MEQ 1205 1205 MEQ AB Galleries Christies June 24, 1986 #163 1986 24, June Christies Christies also Probably #106 1989 26, April Edinburgh 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1978 #420 Colonial - Collection Hyman Williamsbur Christies Glasgow July 2, 1983 1983 2, July Glasgow Christies #153 The Maple Swan Collection OHV +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP m, foliate Old English piercing, one short rococo rococo short one piercing, English Old foliate m, ar, with open work foliate handles, molded rim, rim, molded handles, foliate work open with ar, er, no details details no er, Scotland of Museums National handle over dip 4" di bowl of side on crest shell, inset handles, overlapping circles aspunched pattern, (Note: different from oval shaped VWUDLQHUE\*UDKDP ´RU´ Strainer, deep bowl, foliate small scale Old English piercing, everted everted piercing, English Old scale small foliate bowl, deep Strainer, studs positioning handles, pierced neo-classical flat rim, gadrooned feather motif, 4" di, 2.4oz 2.4oz di, 4" motif, feather DPRQJSXQFKFLUFXOHVLQERZOPDUNV´ZLGH (GLQEXUJK /HPRQVWUDLQHUKDQGOHVò´GL´RYHUKDQG Edinburgh rococo short rim, molded everted piercing, English Old foliate, Strainer, Scotland Scotland Edinburgh Edinburgh a with cut bright handle, scroll and bowl circular pierced with strainer Lemon William Dempster Dempster William Dempster William Possibly William William Possibly Davie 1782/83 or Davie William 1782/83 or Davie William 1784/85 Gray Robert Glasgow ri flat wide bowl, Lozenge 1775 ca Thompson Alexander 1775 ca Aberdeen Robertson Patrick no details Tea strainer, Edinburgh handle, C-scroll a with edge, threaded with bowl pierced circular Strainer, and Museums Aberdeen 1770 ca 1770 ca WD 1770 ca available Not 1770 ca 1773/74 Dempster James Possibly Robertson Patrick Edinburgh Edinburgh no details strainer, Lemon strain Orange Collection Swan Maple The 1765 ca 1765 ca Graham Adam Glasgow circul strainer, Orange YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1765 ca LOCATION Graham Adam Glasgow outline star feathering, rococo handled, 2 bowl, shaped oval strainer, Orange SOURCE

421 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG000063 DAG000063 2004-134 2004-134 Hyman Collection - Colonial Colonial - Collection Hyman L1988-138 Williamsburg J Bourdon-Smith Catalog Catalog Bourdon-Smith J #43 p57 2001 Autumn #126 Galleries AB Galleries 1987 acquired Hyman Collection - Colonial Colonial - Collection Hyman 1988.146 L Williamsburg MEQ 1066 1066 MEQ The Maple Swan Collection Collection Private Galleries iner, no details details no iner, and Museums Aberdeen lyre form handles, shell terminals, positioning studs studs positioning terminals, shell handles, form lyre Brodie, 13" long long 13" Brodie, Lemon squeezer, no details details no squeezer, Lemon Collection Swan Maple The spoon type handles cast with a foliate surround, stamped crest of Langlands Langlands of crest stamped surround, foliate a with cast handles type spoon holes holes demi-leopard, motto "sans tache", Edinburgh marks for 1810/11 1810/11 for marks Edinburgh tache", "sans motto demi-leopard, Glasgow Glasgow details no strainer, Lemon Scotland of Museums National Glasgow Glasgow a of crest small with engraved handles, loop plain bowl, oval strainer, Lemon Assayed Edinburgh Assayed Edinburgh Philip Grierson Grierson Philip 1826/24 Son & Gray Robert Glasgow rim decorated a clip, and handle one strainer, Lemon Collection Private 1822/23 Sons & Mitchell 1823/24 Glasgow 1825/26 JM Son & Gray Robert no details strainer, Lemon Glasgow cast piercing, English Old heavy rim, gadrooned bowl, flattened oval Strainer, Glasgow shells wavy Strainer, 1990 October USA NY Sothebys 1993 Shrubsole 1822/23 Russell & Mitchell Glasgow of crest the with engraved handle, each on brackets small with Punch strainer, 1813/14 Son & Gray Robert 1816/17 M D 1820 ca Jamieson George Aberdeen stra Tea 1801/02 1804/05 Dempster James 1810/11 JO Script Edinburgh & Newlands James 1811/12 oval an in JD mm Strainer, Son & Gray Robert Glasgow piercing, English Old heavy rim, gadrooned bowl, flattened oval Strainer, decorations shell Strainer, 1991 London Shrubsole 1993 USA CT Toby's, 1790 ca 1790 ca Dickson Robert Perth punched pattern, fan handle, loop single with circular strainer, lemon Strainer, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1790 ca LOCATION JS Dundee no details strainer, Punch SOURCE Art and Museums Dundee

422 Strainers and Squeezers MEQ 744 1993 USA p89 2002/03 MEQ 56 ndles, flowered rim rim flowered ndles, Scotland of Museums National ng's pattern, no details details no pattern, ng's SC Charleston Austin, Elizabeth rainer rainer Scotland of Museums National 1832/33 1857/58 JW C Rait D Ki 1905/06 Strainer, Edinburgh Inches & Hamilton Glasgow Edinburgh no details , handled 2 Strainer, 7.2oz di, 1/8" 7 squeezer, Lemon Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1993 US NYC Heritage ADC YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1827/28 LOCATION C Rait D Glasgow ha harp shaped strainer, Lemon SOURCE 1830/31 Son & Gray Robert Glasgow st Lemon

423 Compendium of Scottish Silver

424 Tankards

TankardsTANKARDS

Plate 43. A Tankard 1695/96 by Alexander Forbes, Edinburgh. Courtesy of S. J. Shrubsole, NY USA.

425 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1960 1960 Christies June 23, 1976 #109 1976 23, June Christies 1955 Advertisement picture BFAC 1901 B.43 (from (from 1901 B.43 BFAC Grimdex) Collection Morgan P. J. Jones, 23 2005 #03_06 USA NY Shrubsole OctoberSothebys NY USA 28, 1992 #339 #166 19, 1907 July Christies The Maple Swan Collection Finlay 1991 # 49 1991 Finlay Exhibit Academy Art Scottish 1939 #965 Collection Stirling-Maxwell 77 vol #37 1960 24, March Sothebys #65 1943 9, June Christies Collection Lumley Onein House Museum Huntley (stolen) HH3529/70 Edinburgh Onein National Museums of 1597 MEQ Scotland ece, 8 ¼" ht, ece, Arms, crestand eces, 7"ht, 65oz 10d Antiques Magazine March eces, 31oz 3d Connoisseur Magazine April ece motto, fluted baluster finial, 8" ht, 35oz 35oz ht, 8" finial, baluster fluted motto, 42.5oz 42.5oz chased, foliate thumbpi foliate chased, TANKARDS TANKARDS 1697/98 Yorstoun Mungo Edinburgh thumbpi lid, cockscrew and base gadrooned Tankard, 1695/96 Cockburn James Edinburgh 10d 1695 ca 43oz ht, ¾" 8 handle, on 4X's mm marked, fully Tankard, Cockburn James Edinburgh p 768 II, vol Jackson thumbpi like eagle Tankard, 1685/86 Cockburn James Edinburgh pi thumb lion pair, Tankards, 1690 ca 1695/96 Cruikshank Robert Aberdeen Forbes Alexander Edinburgh engraved handle, scroll base, reeded on plain, Tankard, thumbpi horn spiral ram's cover, and base gadrooned Tankard, #40 1991 Finlay 1663-81 Cleghorne Edward Edinburgh heavily body lower feet, ball and 3 claw type, Scandinavian Tankard, Peg YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

426 Tankards 991 #113 #113 991 00 #606 #606 00 $QWLTXH6LOYHU Sothebys January 28, 1971 #100 1971 28, January Sothebys #49 1991 Finlay p8 II, 1942 vol Exhibition Loan Charlotte Queen 1929 UK Collection Private Christies May 20, 1904 #46 20, 1904 May Christies #35 1921 8, June Christies Wilson and Sharpe Sothebys NY USA NovemberSothebys NY USA 1997 21, Colonial - Collection Hyman Williamsburg 1998 August Magazine Antiques p195 Finlay 1991 #58 1991 Finlay Scotland of Museums National 1159 MEQ UK Collection Private YHU´KW t card work, foliate top, acorn finial, Arms, 7 ¼" ht, 30oz 30oz ht, ¼" 7 Arms, finial, acorn top, foliate work, card t 1 23, October Sothebys 30oz 16d 30oz border, scrollhandled with applied beaded spine and scrolled thumbpiece, tapering cylindrical sides,reeded applied girdle on gadrooned foot, alsoHQJUDYHGDUPRULDOVDQGODWHULQVFULSWLRQPDUNHGRQEDVHDQGFR thumbpiece 30oz 19d 30oz Edinburgh Tankard,gadrooned lid and base, cut card work on girdle, elaborate $VVD\HU±(GZDUG Penman 1700/01 Edward Penman Penman 1700/01 Edward -RKQ6HDWRXQ1701/02 (GLQEXUJK Ker Thomas 7DQNDUGR] Edinburgh no details Tankard, +RZ¶V1RWHVRQ p21 text 1991 Finlay 1699 ca 1699 ca Cumming Thomas Glasgow gadrooned finial, knopped double lid, domed molded III, William Tankard, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1697/98 LOCATION Bruce Robert Edinburgh ½" 8 handle, on tails rat 2 gadrooning, work, card cut decorated Tankard, p 4 Dictionary Clayton SOURCE 1699/1700 1699/1700 Ker Thomas Edinburgh ht, ¼" 7 finial, shaped vase handle, tail rat border, gadrooned Tankard, 1698/99 John Seatoun 1699/1700 Bruce Robert Edinburgh Edinburgh no large, Tankard, details cu Tankard, 1991 text p121 Finlay

427 Compendium of Scottish Silver KLELWLRQ 8. HZYRO,9 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZ9RO,,, %HOORI$EHUGHHQ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG Christies February 3, 1910 #138 #138 1910 3, February Christies 1926 Magazine Connoisseur advertisement #304 76 vol Scottish Art Revi Art Scottish %HOORI$EHUGHHQ +ROODQGS 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ &KULVWLHV0D\ &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK1RYHPEHU &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK$SULO UK Collection Private ò´KWR] HFHZLWKFXWFDUGZRUN VWDQGPRWWRRI*RUGRQRI HUò´KWR] 6RWKHE\V1<'HFHPEHU OLDWHWKXPESL DOERG\DSSOLHGUHHGHGJLUGOHIODWOLG HUEDOXVWHUILQLDOULEVFUROOKDQGOHó´KW 6HDIRUG+RXVH([ FDOERG\JLUGOHFXWFDUGZRUNRQWRS UQHDWK´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ IRRWKLJKIR R] decorated leaves, gadrooned border, 31oz 9d 9d 31oz border, gadrooned leaves, decorated EDOXVWHUILQLDOKDQGOHZLWKEHDGHGUDWWDLOSODLQUHHGHGIRRW gadrooned base, initials .QRFNVSRFNQRSLFWXUH (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGLQLWLDOVLQIROLDWHRQIURQWUHSDLUVWRFRY (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGSRVVLEOHHDUOLHUGDWHOHWWHU PLVUHDG" FUH (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGQRGHWDLOV -DFNVRQ0DUNVS $VVD\HU±3DWULFN 0XUUD\ $VVD\HU±-DPHV 3HQPDQ $VVD\HU±-DPHV 3HQPDQ (GZDUG3HQPDQ (GLQEXUJKFDFD 7DQNDUGJDGURRQHGIROLDJH -RKQ/XNH 5REHUW,QJOLV *ODVJRZ (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUG´KW 7DQNDUGODWHULQVFULSWLRQXQGH 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ -RKQ6HDWRXQ 1704/05 Seatoun John Edinburgh thumbpiece, and handle top, on work card cut cover, domed slightly Tankard, 1702/03 Robert Inglis Inglis 1702/03 Robert 5REHUW,QJOLV (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGJDGURRQHGIHHWDQGFRY 7KRPDV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGSODLQWDSHULQJF\OLQGULF 1701/02 George Scott Scott YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1701/02 George LOCATION SOURCE -RKQ6HDWRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGSODLQWDSHULQJF\OLQGUL

428 Tankards Exhibition Exhibition XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG ecember WWLVK$UW$FDGHP\ Christies November 28, 1979 #42 1979 28, November Christies &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ 6RWKHE\V$SULO #67 1991 Finlay Sothebys Edinburgh April 28, 1992 #104 Christies January 29, 1999 #20 #20 29, 1999 January Christies 1986 18, March London Christies #224 Christies D Christies Huntley House Museum Huntley House (GLQEXUJK++ Sothebys February 20, 1964 #85 1964 20, February Sothebys #67 1991 Finlay Scotland of Museums National 1568 MEQ ece, scrollhandle with beaded rat HFHó´KWR] H±:RROHQ0DQXIDFWRUVRI*ODVJRZWR ³(QVHHW«´EXOERXVERG\WXFNHGLQDWEDVH +ROODQGS ULQJF\OLQGULFDOIRUPDFRUQILQLDOGRPHGFRYHU´KW 6FR DQNDUGQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0 GRPHGFRYHUDFRUQILQLDOò´KWR] spreading stepped domedandreeded foot, cockscrew thumbpiece, no finial, ball and button finial, corkscrew thumbpi corkscrew finial, button and ball scratch initials, betrothal escutcheons, oval in arms of coat adorsed 2 tail, ZHLJKWXQGHUEDVH$UPVRI+RSH´KWR] girdle, stepped domed lid, acorn finial, scroll handle, applied rat tail, tail, rat applied handle, scroll finial, acorn lid, domed stepped girdle, DUPRULDOVSRXULQJOLSDGGHGDWDODWHUGDWH´KWR] 7KRPDV0DQDGHQ´ò´KWR] -XQH´KW´GLWRS FRPSUHVVHGEDOOILQLDOIROLDWHWKXPESL 1709/10 Tait James Edinburgh tape tankard, Peg 1708/09 1709/10 Bethune Henry Seatoun John Edinburgh no details Tankard, Edinburgh cylindrical Suttie, impaling Rutherford quartering Hepburn of Arms Tankard, &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGDUPVFUHVWDQGPRWWR p545 Marks Jackson 1710/11 Turnbull Patrick Edinburgh of girdle, reeded molded applied body, cylindrical tapering Tankard, &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH (GLQEXUJK 7 1707/08 I Murray Patrick Edinburgh finial, dome stepped girdle, applied body, cylindrical tapering plain Tankard, 1709/10 1710/11 Bruce Robert Bethune Henry Edinburgh Edinburgh no details large, Tankard, applied reeded foot, spreading on molded body, cylindrical tapering Tankard, UK Collection Private -RKQ/XNH-U *ODVJRZ 7DQNDUGHQJUDYHG³7KHJLIWRIWK 1706/07 Penman Edward Edinburgh Neilson, William to gift arms, of coat Edinburgh the with engraved Tankard, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1705/06 LOCATION Forbes Alexander Edinburgh lid, domed high girdle, applied cylindrical, tapering sided, straight Tankard, SOURCE

429 Compendium of Scottish Silver &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ2FWREHU %RQKDPV¶6DOH $SROOR$SULOYROS 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ +RZRI(GLQEXUJK -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ YROS 6RWKHE\V6FRQH3DODFH$SULO 3DUN/DQH([KLELWLRQ 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. &KULVWLHV-XQH &KULVWLHV0DUFK &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH0D\ 1REOH&ROOHFWLRQ 3URYHQDQFHRI3DPHOD&DPSEHOO 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW R] UHHGHGJLUGOH Oò´KW UO¶VFRURQHWWDSHULQJ KDQGOHVWHSSHGOLG LDOV³:&0&´ò´KW VEHORZWKH ] 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ HFHVFUROOKDQGOHZLWKUDWWDLO$UPV VVHGIROLDWHVSUD\ GRPHGFRYHU´KWR]G &KULV$SULO HUILQLDOVOLJKWO\VKDSHGERG\ò´KW QGULFDOVSUHDGLQJFLUFOHIRRWVFUROOKDQGOHPLG OERG\RQPROGHGIRRWUHHGHGJLUGOHVWHSSHG OERG\HQJUDYHZLWKVHWVRIDUPRULDOVRQHZLWK GRPHGOLGDFRUQILQLDOIROLDWHWKXPESL FUHVWDQGPRWWR³&852'8048,(6&2´RI0D[ZHOOò´KWR] ULEFRUNVFUHZWKXPESLHFHVWHSSHGFRYHUDFRUQILQLDOò´KW DFRUQILQLDOò´KWR] R] F\OLQGULFDOERG\JLUGOHVWHSSHGGRPHGOLGEDOXVWHUEXQILQLD R] R]G VXSSRUWHGWKHRWKHUEHWZHHQFUR GRXEOHGRPHFRYHUDFRUQILQLDOVFUROOKDQGOHò´KWR] (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGPROGHGSHGHVWDOIRRWWDSHULQJERG\VFUROO (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGWDSHULQJF\OLQGULFDOIRUPZLWKJLUGOHLQLW (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGFLUFXODUFDUWRXFKHHQFORVLQJPRQRJUDPDQG(D $VVD\HU±(GZDUG Penman $VVD\HU±(GZDUG Penman VWULNLQJDQRWKHU PDNHU $VVD\HU(GZDUG 3HQPDQRYHUVWUXFN E\+XJK*RUGRQ FRQWLQXHG VFUROOKDQGOHZLWKDSSOLHGUDWWDLOò´KWR &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGWDSHULQJF\OLQGULFD &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGSODLQWDSHULQJF\OL -RKQ6HDWRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGPLGULEDFRUQILQLDO :LOOLDP*HG FD -DPHV.HURYHU &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGVWHSSHGFRYHUEDOXVW -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGWDSHULQJF\OLQGULFD YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

430 Tankards 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZYRO9,, S advertisement Aberdeen of Bell 6RWKHE\V$SULO 6RWKHE\V-XQH Sothebys Hopetoun House April House Hopetoun Sothebys 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW± 6HSWHPEHU &KULVWLHV-XO\ 6RWKHE\V$SULO Jessop Antiques 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW &OD\WRQ&KULVWLHV%RRNS &KULVWLHV-XQH advertisement Shrubsole 6RWKHE\V0D\ $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHYROS advertisement Shrubsole Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas S ece, rat R]G SOLHGPROGHGJLUGOHRQVSUHDGLQJEDVH VOLJKWO\WDSHULQJF\OLQGULFDOJLUGOH KDQGOHKLQJHGGRPHGOLGDFRUQILQLDOPROGHGEDVHó´KW domed lid,acorn finial, leaf shaped thumbpiece, double scrollhandle, scratch ZHLJKW³2XGU´ò´KWR]G ZD\GRZQWKHERG\YROXWHWKXPESLHFHGRPHGOLG´KWR]G WDLORQKDQGOHR] engraved with Arms for the Earl of Hopetoun, stepped domed lid, acorn acorn lid, domed stepped Hopetoun, Earl of the for Arms with engraved finial,handle withrat tailleaf cappedthumbpiece, lid and engraved base with DIORZHUô´KWR] 'RXQILHOGò´KWR] VWHSSHGOLGDFRUQILQLDOò´KWR] Glasgow Glasgow miniature Tankard, UK Collection Private Bilsings Bilsings FD -RKDQ*RWKHOI 1720 ca 1720 Luke Robert Glasgow scroll double girdle, reeded body, cylindrical tapered size, smaller Tankard, FD 5REHUW/XNH *ODVJRZ 7DQNDUGSODLQF\OLQGULFDOERG\DS 5REHUW,QJOLV (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGPDUNHGRQERG\DQGOLG 1717/18 Turnbull Patrick 1717/18 Edinburgh Ged William picture no Tankard, Edinburgh thumbpi leaf finial, acorn cover, domed rib, mid cylindrical, Tankard, p84 116, vol Magazine Antiques 1717/18 Turnbull Patrick Edinburgh girdle, applied foot, reeded on spreading body, cylindrical tapering Tankard, 1717/18 Bethune Henry Edinburgh of Rigg of Arms finial, acorn girdle, applied cylindrical, tapering, Tankard, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1716/17 LOCATION McKenzie Colin Edinburgh foot, spreading flattened handle, scroll sided, straight form, plain Tankard, SOURCE

431 Compendium of Scottish Silver ew 1955 vol V, 1955 vol ew &ROOHFWLRQ 0DUFK &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH p60 125 vol advertisement Edinburgh of How &KULVWLHV-XO\ 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYL S advertisement Aberdeen of Bell 6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 1983 #90 November Edinburgh Christies 1991 6RWKHE\V0D\ Christies Edinburgh April 27, 27, April Edinburgh Christies 1988 #61 #128 1977 15, June Christies %RQKDP¶V7KH6FRWWLVK6DOH $XJXVW 1LFKRODV6KDZ$QWLTXHV DFRUQILQLDOVKLHOGZLWKODWHU NHGLQRQDEURDGORZEDVHGRPHG GHWDLOVQRPP 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. HFHVFUROOKDQGOHR] stepped lid with a bell finial on stem, scroll handle, full armorials, opposite opposite armorials, full handle, scroll stem, on finial bell a with lid stepped KDQGOHZLWKVXSSRUWHUVDUPVLQFOXGHWUHHFURZQVR] PRQRJUDPIROLDWHWKXPESL girdle, on spreading domed foot,reeded acorn finial, leaf thumbpiece, scroll tail rat applied with handle reeded girdle, domed cover,acorn finial, open work corkscrew thumbpiece, UHYHUVHVFUROOKDQGOHò´KWR] +RSHô´±´KWR] Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Tankard, London Ltd, Walter William Edinburgh Edinburgh of motto and crest coronet, finial, acorn lid, stepped sided, straight Tankard, Assayer Edward Penman Charles Duncan Duncan Charles -DPHV7DLW 1RWDYDLODEOH -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGQRGHWDLOV 7KH³6PDOO+RSHV´7DQNDUGQR 7DQNDUGZLWKDUPV 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ 6RWKHE\V 1725 ca 1725 ca Aytoun William 1725 ca FD available Not 5REHUW/XNH Edinburgh finial center plain, Tankard, *ODVJRZ 7DQNDUGVOLJKWO\EXOERXVERG\WXF p633 Waldron -DPHV7DLW (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGVKDSHGERG\GRPHGFRYHU 1722/23 or I Dickson Charles 1722/23 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh low reeded molded applied above initials body, cylindrical tapering Tankard, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1720/21 LOCATION Bethune Henry Edinburgh above Ogilvy of arms late circular, molded form on bulbous slightly Tankard, SOURCE

432 Tankards HXPVRI6FRWODQG RNS H&ROOHFWLRQ8. 0(4 &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\SDQG S +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP (GLQEXUJK 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU 0(4 &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ YROS 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU #169 NHGZLWK HUFUHVWEHORZ VSUHDGLQJEDVH ó´KWR]G %XUOLQJWRQ0DJD]LQH G\VSLUDOKDQGOHR] %UHDGDOEDQH&ROOHFWLRQ6DOH HGEDQGRIVFUROOVFRUNVFUHZDQGOHDIRQ SRVLWHWKHKDQGOHZLWKWKHDUPVRI7URWWHURI DYHGZLWKDPRQRJUDPLQDVFUROOLQJIROLDWH DLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG HGWDSHULQJF\OLQGULFDO .LQJ¶V&ROOHJH$EHUGHHQ WKHPRWWR 0RUWRQKDOOLPSDOLQJ7URWWHU&KDUWHUKDOOWKHOLGZLWKWKH7URWW FDUWRXFKHGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHGRPHGOLGEDOXVWHUILQLDORQ VLOYHUDGGHGZKHUHDODWHUSRXULQJVSRXWZDVUHPRYHGSDWFKPDU PRGHUQKDOOPDUNVó´KWR] WRS´KWR] (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGLQLWLDO³0-/.5´RQIURQWDFRUQILQLDO Edinburgh Edinburgh picture no Tankard, 1933 15, February Christies Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Tankard, Collection Swan Maple The OH $EHUGHHQ 7DQNDUGQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XV Charles Duncan Duncan Charles $VVD\HU±(GZDUG Penman Charles Duncan Duncan Charles Charles Duncan Duncan Charles 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGTXDUWVL]HQRGHW FD -DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ 7DQNDUGTXDUWFDSDFLW\EDOXVWHUER FDFD :LOOLDP&UDZ 1RWDYDLODE FD &DQRQJDWH :LOOLDP&UDZ 7DQNDUGQRSLFWXUH &DQRQJDWH 7KH7URWWHU7DQNDUGHQJUDYHGRS &KULVWLHV%R FDFD 5REHUW/XNH 5REHUW&UXLFNVKDQN $EHUGHHQ -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ *ODVJRZ (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGODUJHVWUDLJKWVLG 7DQNDUGH[FHSWLRQDOO\ODUJH 7DQNDUGEDOXVWHUERG\HQJU 3ULYDW YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1729/30 LOCATION or I Dickson Charles SOURCE 1729/30 or I Dickson Charles 1729/30 or I Dickson Charles FD 5REHUW/XNH (GLQEXUJK 7DQNDUGODUJHEXOERXVERG\FKDV

433 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1 XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU )LQOD\ MEQ 1336 . GRPHGFRYHUPRQRJUDPó´KWR] &KULVWLHV0DUFK EDQGVRQVLGHVô´KWR] 7DQNDUGIRUEHHUQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0 1785/86 Robertson Patrick FD Edinburgh $'&6% details no lidded, Tankard, $UEURDWK 7DQNDUGILVKKHDGVKDSHGPLGULE Scotland of Museums National FD -RKQ.HLWK %DQII YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1785/86 LOCATION Robertson Patrick Edinburgh reeded edge, gadrooned overhanging with lid hinged flat cylindrical, Tankard, SOURCE

434 Tazzas

TazzasTAZZAS

Plate 44. A Tazza 1698/99 by John Yorstoun, Edinburgh. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

435 Compendium of Scottish Silver tion tion SILJ WWLVK$UW$FDGHP\([KLEL 6RWKHE\V$SULO %DQNRI6FRWODQG&ROOHFWLRQ Edinburgh $SROOR1RYHPEHUYRO S Edinburgh of How 6RWKHE\VDXFWLRQ1RYHPEHU &KULVWLHV0DUFK Scotland of Museums National 0(4 Stuart- Mrs. of Collection 6WHYHQVRQ 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW )LQOD\ 6HDIRUG+RXVH([KLELWLRQ Scotland of Museums National 0(4 )LQOD\ 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ-XQH 6RWKHE\V-XO\ 6RWKHE\V$SULO Scotland of Museums National 0(4 ,'´$UPVRI+RJJRI ROGJDGURRQERUGHURQWUXPSHWIRRW HGó´GLR]ERWK %UHWWS IRRWFXWRXWIRRWJDGURRQHGULP´GL 6FR IRRWJDGURRQHGERUGHU´GL -DFNVRQYROV XQGHUVLGHZLWKLQLWLDOVò´GLR]ERWK &DPPR´GLR] /RUG6WUDWKPRUH¶VLQYHQWRU\RI LPSDOLQJ1DLUQHVLPSOHQRQJDGURRQHGIRRW´GLR] TAZZAS Edinburgh Tazza on foot, raisedreeded edge, semi-gadroonedrim, Arms of Dick (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRQIRRWFHQWHUODXUHOZUHDWKZLWKLQLWLDOV³:+ William Law Law William Deacon Alexander Reid Law William Deacon 5REHUW,QJOLV (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DSODLQ FD 5REHUW%URFN *ODVJRZ -DPHV&RFNEXUQ 7D]]DFLUFXODURQWUXPSHW (GLQEXUJK 5REHUW%UXFH 7D]]DVSDLURQIRRWJDGURRQ (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLUVPDOOHDFKZLWKE 1674/75 Or Penman 1675-77 James 1665-70 ca ca 1665-70 Scott Alexander Edinburgh in mentioned dish, fruit raised or a tazza Originally Tazza. Strathmore The YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

436 Tazzas #77 XPVRI6FRWODQG JDWLYH JDWLYH YDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. &KULVWLHV$SULO &KULVWLHV-XQH 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 0(4 &KULVWLHV0DUFK &KULVWLHV1H &KULVWLHV)HE &KULVWLHV1H *DUUDUGV/RQGRQ 6RWKHE\V-XO\ 6RWKHE\V%RRNS 6RWKHE\V0DUFK Edinburgh of How %ULDQ%HHW 1993 30-31, August Sothebys -%RXUGRQ6PLWK/RQGRQ Collection Phoenix The SODLQERUGHUFUHVWRI HLQWHUORFNLQJVFULSW ROGHGERUGHULQLWLDOVô´GLR] &KULVWLHV$SULO KDSHGIRRW´GLR] ODWHUDUPRULDOVDQGIODWFKDVLQJODWHUDGGHG FRDWRIDUPVEHWZHHQNQLJKWDQGKRUVH foot, plain but with gadroonedborder, underside VKHV )LQOD\ RRWPROGHGERUGHULQLWLDOV³0:/0*´HQ VXSSRUWHUVZLWKPROGHGERUGHUò´GLR] FUHVFHQWPRRQPRWWR³$FWRU'XP3URFUHGLRU´ò´GLR] VXLWHZLWKDSDLURIFXSVô´GL IHHWó´GLR]ERWK LQLWLDOVRYHUJDUODQG³.'´RU³'.´ò´GLR] HQJUDYHG³%´ô´GLR] (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRQWUXPSHWIRRWODWHUFUHVWDQGPRWWRPROGHG (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLUODWHUHQJUDYHGRYHUHUDVHGFRURQHWDERY III $VVD\HU-DPHV 3HQPDQ Assayer Edward 3HQPDQ -RKQ6HDWRXQ 5REHUW%UXFH (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLUGHHSRUIUXLWGL 7D]]DSODLQHYHUWHGWUXPSHWV &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH (GLQEXUJK 7KRPDV&OHJKRUQH 7D]]DRQIRRWHQJUDYHGZLWK :DOWHU6FRWW (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DSODLQRQWUXPSHWIRRWP 7KRPDV.HU $OH[DQGHU)RUEHV *HRUJH6FRWW-U (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLUQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRQFHQWUDOVSUHDGLQJI 3UL 5REHUW%URFN *ODVJRZ 7D]]DQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVH 3DWULFN0XUUD\ (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLUJDGURRQHGERUGHU YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1698/99 LOCATION Yorstoun John Edinburgh pedestal spreading on Tazza, SOURCE

437 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1930 #60 1930 ecember 17, &KULVWLHV-XQH Aberdeen Museumsand ABDAGGalleries, 001001 Christies London June 15, 1977 1977 15, June London Christies D Christies 11, February USA NY Christies Sothebys April 16, 1953 #160 #160 1953 16, April Sothebys National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National MEQ 1983.22 Breadalbane Collection Sale Sale Collection Breadalbane 1935 #366 National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National a + 251 1943, Scottish Art Academy Exhibition Exhibition Academy Art Scottish 1939 #894 J Cathcart White Collection foot, RI+RSHô´GLR] &KULVWLHV-XQH DUPVDQGPRWWRUHSDLUVEHQHDWK QVHHW$QLPR´ 6RWKHE\V$SULO PV$UPVRI-RKQVWRQRI6HWWDPô´GL ³$JQRVFDU(VHQWX´RYHUD0DOWHVHFURVVFUHVWLQFHQWHU HQJUDYLQJPPFRXOGEH-RKQ6HDWRXQ´GLR]G R]GERWK R]GHD +RSHô´GLR] GLIIHUHQWWD]]DVIURPWKHDERYHVLQJOHò´GLR] ò´GLR] Collection or the Breadalbane Collection pair) pair) Collection Breadalbane the or Collection 7D]]DDUPVFUHVWDQGPRWWR³( ó´GL (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLURQSDZIHHWFHQWUDOIRRWODFNLQJ$UPV Assayer Edward Penman ,$ (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLUFUHVFHQWVDERYHRQHEHORZ 1709/10 Not available available 1709/10 Not 1710 ca Robertson George Aberdeen engraved I:J:R:I:J:F, e, or a Gothic castles, 3 BF, BF, marked Tazza, 1710/11 McKenzie Colin &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH Edinburgh motto (GLQEXUJK and crest arms, with Tazza, #69 1991 Finlay -RKQ6HDWRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLUVOLJKWO\UDLVHGDU 1709/10 Ker Thomas Edinburgh arms of coat central pair, Tazzas, Collection Linlithgow 1709/10 available Not Edinburgh of Arms with center border, molded feet, paw applied later 3 on pair, Tazzas, 1710-16 McKenzie Colin Edinburgh but family same arms, no below, motto with crest small, pair, Tazzas, 1708/09 Turnbull Patrick Edinburgh expanding and stem expanding rim, on molded stemmed, Tazza, 1708/09 Turnbull Patrick Edinburgh White the either probably (Note: details, no plain, stands, or pair, Tazzas, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1708/09 LOCATION Turnbull Patrick Edinburgh foot, spreading on motto, and crest centers, depressed circular, pair, Tazzas, SOURCE

438 Tazzas 9, HZYRO9 LHV$SULO Sothebys Gleneagles August 3DUN/DQH([KLELWLRQ 6RWKHE\V1<86$$SULO 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ &KULVWLHV0D\ &KULVWLHV1<86$2FWREHU 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU -DFNVRQ0DUNVSQRWH 6RWKHE\V$SULO T Lumley +RZ&ROOHFWLRQ Revi Art Scottish S advertisement Aberdeen of Bell &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK1RYHPEHU &KULVWLHV6FRWODQG1RYHPEHU *DUGQHUDQG+RZ&ROOHFWLRQ +RZ&ROOHFWLRQ VHWVRILQLWLDOV ZLWKFLUFXODUPDWWHGJURXQGDUPVFUHVW GLR]GIRUDOO &KULVW RWSODLQPROGHGULPXQGHUVLGHZLWKLQLWLDOV QWVRIWKHDVVD\PDVWHU¶VPDUNFDVWOHDQGGDWH ZDLVWHGVWHPXQGHUVLGHZLWKLQLWLDOV³*':´ XQGHUVLGHVZLWKFRQWHPSRUDU\LQLWLDOVDQG ´GLR] &KULVWLHV-XQH WPROGHGULPô´GLR]G &KULVWLHV0DUFK IRRW$UPVRI/RFNKDUWô´GLR] &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK DQGPRWWR³%RQLV2PQLD%RQD´ó´R] ò´GLR] VFUDWFKZHLJKWVò´GLR]ERWK ³,:,7´´GLR] OHWWHUDVQRWHGLQ-DFNVRQDSSDUHQWO\QRPP ô´GLR] JK 7D]]DRQWUXPSHWIRRWSODLQPROGHGERUGHUXQGHUVLGHZLWK FD -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 5REHUW/XNH 7D]]DIRUPGLVKZLWKDFUHVW *ODVJRZ 7D]]DSODLQPROGHGHGJHFHQWHU +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DSODLQRQFHQWUDOIRRW &ROLQ0F.HQ]LH (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVSDLURQFDSVWDQIRRW &ROLQ&DPSEHOO (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRQFHQWUDOVSUHDGLQJIR -RKQ6HDWRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DVVHWRIô´DQGó´ $OH[DQGHU.LQFDLG (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRQFHQWUDOVSUHDGLQJ 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRUVDOYHUFDUULHVYDULD 1710 ca 1710 ca Ged William Edinbur YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION FD LOCATION -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DSODLQRQWUXPSHWIRR SOURCE

439 Compendium of Scottish Silver '$* LYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ + Aberdeen Museumsand *DOOHULHV$% -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ S Collection Shaw &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 1983 #98 &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK0D\ bove a LUFXODUZLWKVOLJKWO\UDLVHGHGJHLQLWLDO³.´ DLOVPRWWR³7UXVWLHWRWKH(QG´D PRWWRRI+DOGDQHó´LGR] 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU OHWWHU& 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. /HLWKIDPLO\WD]]DIHZGHW cross LQFHQWHUSRVVLEO\ODWHUó´GLR] milton & Inches Inches & milton Edinburgh details no Tazza, Scotland of Museums National FDFD *HRUJH&RRSHU $OH[DQGHU)RUEHV $EHUGHHQ +D $EHUGHHQ 7D]]DSODLQRQFHQWUDOIRRW 7D]]DPDUNV±$)FDVWOHV 3U -DPHV7DLW (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRQFHQWUDOIRRWFUHVWDQG -DPHV7DLW (GLQEXUJK 7D]]D YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7D]]DRQFHQWUDOVSUHDGLQJIRRWF SOURCE

440 Tea

TeaTEA

Plate 45. Some Components used in Serving Tea. Sugar Bowl 1731/32 by Archibald Ure, Edinburgh; Cream Boat 1740/41 by James Mitchell, Edinburgh Salver 1739/40 by James Mitchelson, Edinburgh; examples of Scots Fiddle Teaspoons by Ebenezer Oliphant, James Hewitt and WM, Edinburgh Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

441 Compendium of Scottish Silver

442 Tea Caddies

TeaTEA Caddies CADDIES

Plate 46. A Tea Caddy 1792/93 by William Robertson, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

443 Compendium of Scottish Silver '$*DQG J$UW0XVHXP+DUYDUG $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG *DOOHULHV$% DFTXLUHG p90 135 vol &KULVWLHV0DUFK Collection Shaw Provenance #122 3, 1984 July Christies /\RQ 7XUQEXOO$XJXVW 2003 %HOORI$EHUGHHQ 6RWKHE\V0DUFK &KULVWLHV0DUFK &KULVWLHV0DUFK 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 1255-57 &KULVWLHV0DUFK Collection Shaw University, University, Collection Hutchinson 1949.114.3 ;¶V LDO³%´HQJUDYHG GRPHGOLGV ´ZLGH \OLQGULFDOGRPHG IRRWVLPLODUO\PROGHGVKRXOGHUFLUFXODU UNKLOO7HD6HUYLFHILYHSLHFHV FUHVWDQG URZPROGHGEDVHVGRPHGFDSFRYHUV SULJKWERG\FDQWHGFRUQHUVODWHUHQJUDYHG RFWDJRQDOZLWKVWHSSHGFRYHUFUHVW´ORQJô´KW )RJ VWRSSHUZLWKEDOXVWHUILQLDOHQJUDYHGRQVLGHZLWKVFULSWLQLW XQGHUEDVHZLWKLQLWLDOV³*5&)´ò´KWR] PRWWRRI*RUGRQEDVHGPDUNHGWKUHHWRZHUV*&*RWKLF$RU( IORUDOVSUD\VDQGFDUWRXFKHVZLWKVFULSWLQLWLDO³0´SXOORIIWXUQHGILQLDOVVFUDWFKLQLWLDOVRQEDVHVFULSW³*-%´ô´KW ´GHHSR] baluster finials, each engraved with 2 13d baronial 15oz cartouches,tops, enclosing one and a angles the on flowers of sprays and initial later borders, slightly raised covers conforming in outline with later crest below a below crest later with outline in conforming covers raised slightly borders, 31oz motto, scrolling cover, engraved with coat of arms of Ferrier, probably impaling Galbraith Galbraith impaling probably Ferrier, of arms of coat with engraved cover, foliage, stylized of band with shoulders on chased cartouche, baroque with FRYHUHQJUDYHGZLWKDFUHVWIXOO\PDUNHGRQEDVHDQGFRYHUPP ò´KWR] TEA TEA molded with oblong box, shagreen mounted silver later in pair, caddies, Tea *ODVJRZ 7HDFDGG\REORQJ4XHHQ$QQHDSSOLHGUHHGHGERUGHUVF Bilsings Bilsings TEA CADDIES 1730 ca 1730 Cooper George FD Aberdeen *HRUJH&RRSHU service tea a of part pair, caddies, Tea $EHUGHHQ 7HDFDGG\RFWDJRQDOPROGHGULP 1955 Magazine Connoisseur FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDFDGGLHVSDLU SDUWRI7KH.L FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDFDGGLHVSDLUUHFWDQJXODUX FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDFDGGLHVRFWDJRQDOSDLUQDU :LOOLDP$\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK 1720 ca 1720 ca Johan Got-helf- YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION 1685 ca Cockburn James +HQU\%HWKXQH Edinburgh panels the around engraved scene, landscape with hexagonal, Tea caddy, (GLQEXUJK#23 1991 Finlay 7HDFDGG\ SOURCE

444 Tea Caddies ABDA G001004 G001004 ABDA How of Edinburgh, 1937, #102 1937, Edinburgh, of How advertisement Hammond Sothebys October 17 1963 #29 17 1963 October Sothebys Edinburgh of How Christies April 12, 1983 #185 #185 1983 12, April Christies Spring Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1983 4XHHQ¶V6LOYHUS p4 20, 1934 vol Apollo advertisement Bell MEQ 806 L. 1980.S 1980.S L. MEQ 1590 Finlay 1991 #107 1991 Finlay Sothebys October 25, 1984 #269 #269 1984 25, October Sothebys Aberdeen Museumsand Galleries onal, in a wooden box box wooden a in onal, Scotland of Museums National details details Scotland of Museums National decorated with deep chasing and repousse work, lids with similar band of of band similar with lids work, repousse and chasing deep with decorated FKDVLQJODUJHEXGILQLDOV$UPVRIWKH&LW\RI*ODVJRZR] chased flower heads and foliage to upper and lower body, stepped domed domed stepped body, lower and upper to foliage and heads flower chased and lock side center, to motif floral chased and border molded with lid hinged NH\ò´KWR]ERWK FRYHUPROGHGIRRWERG\ZLWKLQLWLDO³0´ò´KWR] feet, paw silver on case chased, heavily all lids, low bodies, (OL]DEHWKDV'XFKHVVó´KW body body detachable domed lid, marks are GC, 3 towers, gothic e, scratch weight 9:22, 9:22, weight scratch e, gothic towers, 3 GC, are marks lid, domed detachable ô´KWR]G (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGGLHVSDLUQRGHWDLOVEdinburgh Tea caddie, balusterribbed, chased fruitand flower festoons, loose domed $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHYRO Edinburgh Tea caddies,pair, inverted pear shape, engraved with the crest Queen of William Davie Davie William Davie William William Davie Davie William 1750ca 1750ca Glen James 1756/57 or Dempster William 1761/62 Glasgow or Dempster William should form, pear inverted elongated slightly shaped, vase pair, Tea caddies, 1765/66 available Not no details Tea caddy, p969 Marks Jackson 1762/63 or Dempster William 1745 ca 1745 ca Glen James Glasgow flat of band with foot, molded stepped on each rectangular, pair, caddies, Tea 1762/63 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh shaped bombe pear inverted case, mahogany original 3, in of set Tea caddies, 1740 ca 1740 Cooper George 1740 ca Aberdeen Luke Robert box a wooden in octagonal, pair, caddies, Tea Glasgow no caddie, Tea Scotland of Museums National 1735 ca 1735 ca Cooper George Aberdeen octag pair, caddies, Tea 1735 ca 1735 ca Luke Robert Glasgow of and bottom top bands, scroll and floral chased cover, oval, with Tea caddy, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1730 ca LOCATION Cooper George Aberdeen motto, and crest with side one on engraved form, plain octagonal Tea caddy, SOURCE

445 Compendium of Scottish Silver HXPVRI6FRWODQG March 19, 1975 #121 #121 1975 19, March 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ 0(4 Finlay 1991 #101 #101 1991 Finlay %RQKDP¶VWKH6FRWWLVK6DOH $XJXVW H%D\0DUFK London 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ$XWXPQ S 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU 2000 &OD\WRQ&KULVWLHVS &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU MEQ 1191 1191 MEQ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 1068 MEQ DO OLNHWDEVIRU R] QJVPRWWR top and bottom, sides sides bottom, and top VHVFHQH )LQOD\ YDFDQWFDUWRXFKH 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG ERG\EDQGVRIEULJKWFXWGHFRUDWLRQRQWRSDQG OLG$UPVRI:KDUWRQLPSDOLQJ0F'XII DLVHGIODWWRSSHGFRYHUULQJILQLDO´KWR] &KULVWLHV YDOIRUPERG\HQJUDYHGZLWKVW\OL]HGEDQGVDQGD GOLGVHWZLWKIORZHUDQGOHDIILQLDOOHGDQGERG\ JKWFXWZLWKFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI+DONHWWKLQJHG QJIRUPZLWKURXQGHGFRUQHUVSODLQVWUDLJKWVLGHV swelling body with reeding reeding with body swelling addy, oval outline, oval addy, EULJKWFXWIURQWHQJUDYHGZLWKFUHVWDQHDJOHIODSSLQJLWVZL ³$OWLRUD3HWR´RULJLQDONH\ò´DFURVV´KW chased in 3 bands of fluting and counter-fluting, vacant cartouche below the the below cartouche vacant counter-fluting, and fluting of bands 3 in chased ERWWRPYDFDQWFDUWRXFKHGRPHGKLQJHGOLGLYRU\PXVKURRPILQL´KW´DFURVVR] crest within a navette-shaped panel, flat lockable flush hinged lid, oval urn urn oval lid, hinged flush lockable flat panel, navette-shaped a within crest ILQLDOFUHVWLVDELUG¶VKHDGDQGQHFNPRWWR³68)),&,7´ô´ TXDUWHULQJ'XIIò´KWR] OLGV´KWR] UHHGHGPROGHGEDQGDWWKHIRRWDQGULPFRYHUVZLWKKLQJHGIDQ ILQLDOVSUREDEO\GHVLJQHGWRILWLQDFDVH (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGG\EULJKWFXWOHDYHVDQGIORZHUV 1DWLRQDO0XV :LOOLDP'DYLHRU :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU : 3&XQQLQJKDP (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGG\ZLWKZRRGILQLDO 1795/96 I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh c Tea :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGG\RYDOIODWKLQJH :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGG\RYDOGHFWDJRQDO $OH[DQGHU6SHQFH (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGGLHVSDLUHDFKRIR 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGG\VTXDUHVWHSSHG :'VFULSW $OH[DQGHU6SHQFH (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGGLHVSDLURYDOEUL FD 0LOQH &DPSEHOO *ODVJRZ 7HDFFDGGLHVZLWKFKDVHG&KLQH 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDFDGGLHVVHWRIREOR YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1765/66 LOCATION Robertson Patrick *LOOLODQGDQG.HU Edinburgh no details (GLQEXUJK case, with Tea caddies 7HDFDGGLHREORQJVKDSHU SOURCE p310 Marks Jackson

446 Tea Caddies Bell advertisement advertisement Bell 1053-54 MEQ p50 #41 Tea caddy, no details no details Tea caddy, #39 1989 April Sothebys (continued) (continued) finial wooden block counter-fluting, with lid dome keyhole, Assayed Edinburgh 1801/02 Cunningham P & W Edinburgh edge top beaded double, Tea caddy, p2 90 vol 1969 August Apollo YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1801/02 Cunningham P & W mark 1802/03 Edinburgh 1835/36 TAF McKay James lidded double, caddy, Tea 1844/45 Edinburgh Cunningham William 11oz crest handle, reeded plain, shaped, cube Tea caddy, Edinburgh 12oz crest, head griffin body, oblong plain caddy, Tea 1993 London Bourdon-Smith J 1999 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J Scotland of Museums National

447 Compendium of Scottish Silver

448 Tea Kettles, Stands and Trays

Tea Kettles,TEA KETTLES, Stands STANDS AND and TRAYS Trays

Plate 47. The Kettle and Stand are 1758/59 by WD, probably William Dempster, Edinburgh Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

449 Compendium of Scottish Silver &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S Scotland of Museums National 1208-1211 MEQ a-c 1207 MEQ DF &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ &OD\WRQ&KULVWLHVS Wilson & Sharp Ltd 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. $SROOR0DUFKYROS advertisement Bell Scotland of Museums National 0(4 &KULVWLHV0DUFK 6RWKHE\V+RSHWRXQ+RXVH$SULO H%D\0DUFK nd PSEHOO ´KWR] WRXQVHUYLFHVSKHULFDOERG\FKDVHGOLJKWO\ LWKVKDSHGULPPROGHGERUGHUSRLQWV )LQOD\ stand on 3 shell and scroll feet, burner with domed hinged lid, the kettle later later kettle the lid, hinged domed with burner feet, scroll and shell 3 on stand part a with foliage, and shells lattice-work, scrolls, with overall chased finial, ball wooden lid, flush hinged and handle swing leather-covered later patched, kettle unmarked, stand arms, of coat a with twice engraved $UPVRI&DPSEHOORI6XFFRWKLPSDOLQJ%DOELUQLFIRU$UFKLEDOG&D upper body and lid, wood ball finial, curved half fluted and half leaf capped capped leaf half and fluted half curved finial, ball wood lid, and body upper spout, silverhandle with fluting, insulatedin center, arms a below coronet on of mouth the to in center connecting skirt leaves, swag with stand lamp, body, feet hoof in end that legs cabriole capped leaf 3 on face, male human a handle, hanging lamp on chain, stand with rococo border on 3 cabriole legs legs 3 cabriole on border rococo with stand chain, on lamp hanging handle, WKDWHQGLQWDOOKRRIIHHWR] DSSOLHGKLQJHZRRGHQNQRSFXUYHGVOLJKWO\IODULQJVSRXWò DOONHWWOHR]VWDQGDQGEXUQHUR] spherical body, on ball 3 feet, standlike a strawberry dish, wood finial, crest DQGPRWWR³$XJHRU'XP3URJUHGLRU´ %Wô´KWR] and bottom, flush lid with ivory mushroom finial, stand oncabriole 3 leaf salver, and stand with kettle tea spherical compressed stand, and kettle Tea (GLQEXUJK 7HDNHWWOHDQGVWDQG 6RWKHE\V-XQH Edinburgh Edinburgh top fluting flame later with body compressed burner, and stand kettle, Tea $VVD\HU$UFKLEDOG 8UH oval oval TEA KETTLES, KETTLES, TEA KETTLE STANDS KETTLE AND TRAYS :LOOLDP$\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDNHWWOHZLWKVWDQGSDUWRI+RSH 1731/32 Mitchelson James Edinburgh silver finial, ball spout, simple curved body, spherical flattened Tea kettle, 1RWDYDLODEOH -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDNHWWOHVWDQGFLUFXODUZ 1727/28 Bethune Henry Edinburgh with lid flush body, spherical compressed burner, and stand Tea kettle, :,RU,0LQDSODLQ 1725/26 Mitchelson James Edinburgh flattened spout, curved handle, insulated lamp, and stand with Tea kettle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

450 Tea Kettles, Stands and Trays YRO 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZYRO9 S %HOORI$EHUGHHQDGYHUWLVHPHQW &KULVWLHV-XO\ 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 0(4 $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHYROS %HOODGYHUWLVHPHQW IVXSSRUWV VPDUNHGRQ XVHDVD RWWRVOLJKWO\ LQJKDQGOH IORZHUVDQG HOODQGVFUROO R] KELUGILQLDO YHGVSRXWDQG SRXWVLOYHU DWFKDVHGWR UROOVDQG HUSDZ WUD\ZLWK ZLWKDEXUQHU YHULQVXODWHG RQ³6´FXUYHG ULSW³$$´EHORZD SHUSDUWRINHWWOHFKDVHG EXUQHUYDFDQWDV\PPHWULFDO \IODWFKDVHGZLWKIORZHUVVKHOOVDQG PGHFRUDWHGURXQGWKHVKRXOGHUZLWK OERG\VFUROOHGVLOYHULQVXODWHGKDQGOHIOXWHG SKHULFDOERG\DUPVFUHVWDQGPRWWRFKDVHGOLJKWO\ WKHVWDQGZLWKWKUHHOHDIFDSSHGVFUROOVXSSRUWVDQGVKHOOIHHW URFRFRIORZHUVIROLDJHHWFYDFDQWFDUWRXFKHVGRPHGOLGZLW R] ZLWKIORZHUVIROLDJHDQGVFUROOVRQPDWWHGJURXQGIOXWHGFXU GRPHGFRYHUFRQHILQLDOVFUROOLQJVZLQJKDQGOHVWDQGRQVK IHHWSLHUFHGDSURQVEHWZHHQR] EXUQHUVXVSHQGHGIURPFKDLQVò´KWR]DOO ZLWKVKHOODQGURFRFRPRXQWVIOXVKKLQJHGOLGZRRGILQLDOIO PDWFKVWDQGZLWKSHQGDQWORRSHGULEERQVEHWZHHQYROXWHDQGKRR FDUWRXFKHVZLWKLQFKDVHGEORVVRPVDQGVFUROOVIOXWHGVSRXWVZ IROLDJHSHQGDQWEHWZHHQWKHGHWDFKDEOHEXUQHUSHQGDQWRQFKDLQ EDVHVWDQGDQGEXUQHUô´KWR] VXSSRUWVZLWKDSLHUFHGDQGFDVWDSURQIHDWXULQJURFRFRPDVNV VFUROOVZLWKWZRV\PPHWULFDOFDUWRXFKHVRQHZLWKDFUHVWDQGP VFUROOVZLQJKDQGOHZLWKLQVXODWRUVWKHVWDQGRQUDLVHGVOHQG GRPHGOLGDOVRFKDVHGDQJXODUEXGILQLDOIROLDWHGELUGQHFNV ZLWKVKHOOVOHDYHVDQGGLDSHULQJDOVRRQOLGZRRGILQLDOVLO KDQGOHFXUYHGVSRXWODPSVWDQGZLWKVNLUWRILQWHUORFNLQJVF FLUFXODUSODTXHRQ³6´FXUYHGOHJVZLWKVKHOOLQVXODWHGIHHW FKDVHGERUGHUDQGHTXLSSHGZLWKWKUHDGHGFHQWUDODWWDFKPHQWIRU VLOYHUWDEOH WRSSHGOHJVHQGLQJLQVKHOOIHHWIHVWRRQHGVNLUWVLQLWLDOVVF FRURQHWò´KW FXUYHGVSRXWWDOOIDOOILQLDOVWDQGZLWKVZDJVNLUWRIOHDYHV OHJVHQGLQJLQVKHOOIHHWERG\URFRFRFKDVHGZLWKGHFRUDWLRQ JK 7HDSRWVOLJKWO\IODWWHQHGV (GLQEXUJK 7HDNHWWOHLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHVWDQGDQGEXUQHUXS :HHPV (GLQEXUJK 7HDNHWWOHVSKHULFDOFRPSOHWHZLWKVWDQGDQG :HHPV (GLQEXUJK 7HDNHWWOHQRGHWDLOV $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQH $VVD\HU+XJK *RUGRQ William Jamieson or or Jamieson William John Main FD -DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ .HWWOHRQD6WDQGLQYHUWHGSHDUIRU :LOOLDP$\WRXQ -DPHV FD 5REHUW/XNH *ODVJRZ .HWWOHDQG6WDQGQHDUVSKHULFDOERG -DPHV -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXU :LOOLDP$\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDNHWWOHIODWWHQHGVSKHULFD YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

451 Compendium of Scottish Silver Apollo 1933 vol 17 pXIII pXIII 17 1933 vol Apollo advertisement How Source ? #84 1991 Finlay Christies March 31, 1971 #75 #75 1971 31, March Christies Sothebys June 29-30, 1981 #202 #202 1981 June 29-30, Sothebys Jackson Marks p549 I, vol 1911 Exhibition Glasgow p108 #21 Shrubsole, NY 1981 E2081 1981 NY Shrubsole, QHILQLDOWKH UG¶VKHDGVSRXWVFUROOVZLQJKDQGOHFR insulated handle, chasing on upper body and lid, lamp, rococo skirt on stand, stand, skirt on rococo lamp, and lid, body upper on chasing handle, insulated ³6´FXUYHGOHJVOHDIFDSSHGHQGLQJLQVKHOOIHHW heavily chased, artichoke finial, curved half fluted spout, silver handle with with handle silver spout, fluted half curved finial, artichoke chased, heavily leaf 3 skirt, flower and leaf rococo heavy with stand lamp, capping, leaf FDSSHG³6´FDEULROHOHJVHQGLQJLQVKHOOIHHW VWULNLQJWKH/RQGRQPDNHU¶VPDUN IROLDJHDQGVFUROOVEL stand on three scroll and shell supports with pierced foliage and scroll aprons aprons scroll and foliage pierced with supports shell and scroll three on stand between,and with circular lamp, engraved witharmorials, 58oz band of flowers and foliage on a matted ground, fluted leaf-capped curved curved leaf-capped fluted ground, matted a on foliage and flowers of band the scrolls, foliate the from emerging caryatid with handle swing spout, with topped tripod the finial, foliate with and top the at decorated lid domed stand, on and kettle of base on marked burner, with complete masks, hound ô´KWR] with a cartouche, scrolls and foliage, cartouche with an inscription, domed lid lid domed inscription, an with cartouche foliage, and scrolls cartouche, a with applied with stand spout, capped leaf half-fluted curved finial, baluster with legs scroll capped leaf 3 on heads, rococo with vines and scrolls of swags endingin shell feet two rococotwo cartouches, one witha crest, withinfant bacchanal finial, the stand on threehoof feet with floralapron Edinburgh Edinburgh lamp with stand and Tea kettle 1981 #30 USA NY Sothebys Assayer Hugh Gordon 1753/54 Gordon Robert Edinburgh multiscrolled finial, bird lid, dome with body pear inverted Tea kettle, 1753/54 Gilchrist William Edinburgh both lid, domed body, tapering shaped pear inverted stand, with kettle Tea 1753/54 Dempster Ker & 1753/54 Dempster and Ker Edinburgh over Dempster and Ker with made London apparently Stand, and Kettle 1752/53 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh fruit, with chased shoulder body, shaped pear inverted lamp, and stand Kettle, 1752/53 Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh broad a with chased body upper shape, pear inverted and burner, stand Kettle, 1751/52 Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh shoulders the around chased body, shaped pear inverted stand, and Tea kettle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1750ca LOCATION Glen James Glasgow and flowers with chased shoulder body, shaped pear inverted Stand, on Kettle SOURCE

452 Tea Kettles, Stands and Trays V2FWREHU MEQ 1163 1163 MEQ Private Collection Collection Private Edinburgh of How *DUWK¶V$XFWLRQV2KLR86$ #817 2004 June 19, MEQ 872 1967.630 1967.630 872 MEQ Private Collection Collection Private Huntley House Museum, Huntley House Edinburgh LR 60 MEQ 1922.29a-b 1922.29a-b MEQ Christies NY USA April 2004 2004 April USA NY Christies #107 #1361 sale QGLQVKHOOIHHW LWKQDPH³+HQULHWWD ò´ORQJ;´KWó´KWZLWKKDQGOHXSR]G &RQH0DUVK´ò´RYHUDOO body with vacant cartouche, wood finial, curved spout withleaf end, LQVXODWHGKDQGOH³6´FXUYHGOHDIFDSSHGFDEULROHOHJVWKDWH Tea kettle, no details details no kettle, Tea Scotland of Museums National Stewart, Lord Provost, with crest andmotto of Trotters of Dreghorn cartouche, swinghandle withreeded leaves insulationand on flowers stand,3 with feet, on leaf skirt feet, pad circular 3 top balls to knees capped *ODVJRZ 7HDNHWWOHODPSDQGVWDQGKHDYLO\UHSRVHGHQJUDYHGZ Edinburgh Tea kettle, on stand with lamp,rococo chased pot with curved spout, ailable ailable Edinburgh mm no decorations, swag with kettle Tea Scotland of Museums National Assayed Edinburgh Assayer Hugh Gordon 1839-41 McKay Edinburgh Son & Gray Robert 1847/48 James 1789/90 available Not Edinburgh no mm, handle, swag raffia-covered the for and back oval, Tea kettle, 1786/87 Not av 1786/87 Not 1756/57 Low Robert 1758/59 -DPHV:HOVK Dempster William Edinburgh Edinburgh (GLQEXUJK no details Tea kettle, chased, both lid, domed body, pear inverted lamp, and stand with kettle Tea 7HDNHWWOH´KWR] 75 vol 1959 Magazine Antiques &KULVWLH YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1755/56 LOCATION Dempster William Edinburgh details no stand, and kettle Tea SOURCE Scotland of Museums National 1755/56 James Welsh Welsh 1755/56 James 1755/56 Dempster and Ker Edinburgh Archibald from presented over, all chased burner, and tripod with Kettle

453 Compendium of Scottish Silver

454 Teapots

TeapotsTEAPOTS

Plate 48. A Teapot 1735/36 by James Ker, Edinburgh. Courtesy of Asprey,Courtesy Lond ofon. As prey,Photograph London. by Janice M Dietert.

455 Compendium of Scottish Silver Picture File File Picture Christies NY USA October 20, 20, October USA NY Christies YROS Sothebys March 9, 1967 1967 9, March Sothebys Sothebys Gleneagles August 30, 30, August Gleneagles Sothebys Christies Glasgow September 20, 20, September Glasgow Christies Christies Scottish Scottish Christies 1935 25, July London Sothebys #149 Collection Crichton Nicholas Shaw Antiques 2004 2004 Antiques Shaw Nicholas p95 Scotland of Museums National K2004.209 Alcorn, Fine Art Museum of #1921.1971 p330 #252 Christies June 25, 1969 #129 1969 25, June Christies 1972 29, November Sothebys #76 London Antiques Koopman UK Collection Private ] IZLWKFUHVW± WLQLWLDOV³:),'´IRU:LOOLDP)RUEHVDQG SHGGRXEOHVFUROOVLOYHUKDQGOHIODWWLVKOLG VHGDQGHQJUDYHGZLWKVKHOOVVWUDSZRUN WDSHULQJVSRXWDOPRVWIODWKLQJHGOLGVLOYHU HRISULRU%HWKXQHSRWV &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH mounted turned wood finial, plain capped silver scroll handle handle scroll silver capped plain finial, wood turned mounted foliage and diaper work at the shoulder and on the slightly domed lid, straight straight lid, domed slightly the on and shoulder the at work diaper and foliage WDSHULQJVSRXWGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHZRRGILQLDOó´KWR ZLWKDSSOLHGKLQJHILQLDOLQWKHIRUPRIDKHUDOGLFZKHDWVKHD DQDQFKRUDQGPRWWRô´KWR] handle, 16oz 16oz handle, KLVZLIH-DQHW'\HU%DQQIVKLUHVLOYHUKDQGOHR]G ò´KW´ORQJR] ³$%:´SRVVHVVLRQOLQHDJHHQJUDYHGRQVLGH´KW tapering spout, wooden capped loop handle, detachable cover with ball and and ball with cover detachable handle, loop capped wooden spout, tapering button finialreeded on a mount, 17.4oz TEA POTS TEA +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOVHDUOLHUVDO +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGVWUDLJKW +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGODWHUFKD +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGSODLQFDS 1716/17 available Not Edinburgh capped leaf spout, tapering straight lid, hinged flush shaped, apple Teapot, 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGRQORZIRR 1715/16 McKenzie Colin Edinburgh knop finial, lid, wood off pull handle, wood body, shaped apple Teapot, 1714/15 McKenzie Colin 1715 ca Edinburgh Cruickshank Robert Aberdeen no details Teapot, initials script spout, straight handle, wooden hinge, applied lid flat Teapot, #133 1991 Finlay 1714/15 Campbell Colin Edinburgh straight foot, skirt spreading molded on circular shaped, bullet plain Tea pot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

456 Teapots '$* DAG001000 DAG001000 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU 230 $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG AB Galleries 1969) (acquired *DOOHULHV$% DFTXLUHG 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU Finlay 1991 #75 1991 Finlay Sothebys Gleneagles August 1987 #280 Scotland of Museums National 1598 MEQ Sothebys Gleneagles August 27- #114 28 1970 12, April USA NY Christies 1994 #288 #529 Abercrombie Collection WRZHUV VDQGPRWWR G³(['RQR´ KW VSKHULFDOFUHVWDQGPRWWRV³3HU0DUH(W 7HUUDV´DQG³0HDQ6SHDNGRHZHOO´PDUNHGEDVH*5*5WKUHH JRWKLF$RU( DUPRULDOVIRU-RKQ8UTXKDUWRI0HOGUXP&R$EHUGHHQVXSSRUWHU shoulders below, mottos and crests later 2 side, other the on initials with matted on work strap scrolling and foliage clusters, flower with chased straight handle, silver and motif fluted applied on finial spherical ground, WDSHULQJVSRXWRQVSUHDGLQJULPIRRW´KWR]G applied hinge, acorn finial, capped wooden loop handle, 13.7oz 13.7oz handle, loop wooden capped finial, acorn hinge, applied UHHGHGDFRUQILQLDOHQJUDYHG³-/´ô´KWR] DQGGDWHGVFUDWFKZHLJKWô´KWR]DOO KDQGOHIODWOLGZLWKDSSOLHGKLQJHUHHGHGDFRUQILQLDOô´ stand including oz 25.3 tapering spout, capped and pointed loop woodenhandle, body engraved withFRQWHPSRUDU\FLSKHU³"%´XQGHUDQ(DUO¶VFRURQHWEDVHLQVFULEH Edinburgh Edinburgh straight finial, ball hinge, applied with lid flat nearly shape, apple Teapot, Charles Duncan Duncan Charles 1720ca 1720ca Robertson George Aberdeen CF GF, ABD, GR, - marked base engraved, silver, Teapot, and Museums Aberdeen FD *HRUJH5REHUWVRQ $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRW7KH8UTXKDUW7HDSRW 1720 ca 1720 ca Robertson George Aberdeen contemporary with side on one engraved finely shaped, bullet Teapot, 1719/20 Bethune Henry Edinburgh with lid flat almost spout, straight tapering base, flat on shaped, apple Teapot, 1718/19 or I Dickson Charles 1719/20 1719/20 McKenzie Colin Bethune Henry Edinburgh Cunningham of Arms finial, wood turned handle, wood shaped, apple Teapot, Edinburgh #75 1991 Finlay handle, wood crest, later spout, tapering straight shaped, or egg ovoid Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1718/19 LOCATION Yorstoun Mungo Edinburgh no details Teapot, SOURCE 1929 Exhibition House Seaford 1718/19 Bethune Henry Edinburgh loop capped wooden spout, tapering plain stand, with shaped, apple Teapot,

457 Compendium of Scottish Silver 76 Christies January 31, 1945 #59 #59 31, 1945 January Christies 1961 Collection Aberdeen of Bell #7 Scotland of Museums National 1386 MEQ Sothebys Gleneagles August 1990 #173 +\PDQ&ROOHFWLRQ±&RORQLDO Williamsburg 1996 June Magazine Antiques p845 Antiques Magazine 1959 vol 75 vol 1959 Magazine Antiques #238 James Robinson, NY advertisement October USA NY East Christies #353 1996 15, Chicago of Art Institute Antique Collector March 1949 March Collector Antique advertisement Phillips SJ File Picture Christies #141 1950 11, May Sothebys p88 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1950 Magazine Connoisseur p224 126 vol p32 51 1950 vol Apollo Museum Scottish Royal 1948 of Exhibition Galleries Galleries 1967-257 z Finlay 1991 # 1991 z Finlay mily, flat lid, 18o lid, flat mily, KDVHGGHFRUDWLRQ´KW crest and motto for Seatoun fa Seatoun for motto and crest 14oz 10d 14oz handle foot, straight spout, silver finial, cone with compressed ball in the middle middle the in ball compressed with cone finial, silver spout, straight foot, ³7+´PP´KWR]G (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWHJJVKDSHGFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI)ROLVODWHUF Edinburgh Edinburgh conjoined finial, acorn spout, straight handle, silver shaped, apple Teapot, Assayer Edward Penman 1722/23 Henry Bethune 1722/23 Henry 1722/23 Mitchelson James Edinburgh worn shaped, barrel Teapot, 1720/21 Thomas Hay Hay 1720/21 Thomas 1721/22 McKenzie Colin Edinburgh scroll double silver finial, ball lid, repair on area hinge shaped, apple Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1720ca LOCATION Robertson George Aberdeen details no shape, spherical Teapot, SOURCE Art and Museums Dundee 1720/21 1720/21 Bethune Henry Bethune Henry Edinburgh Edinburgh 5d 15oz handle, wood finial, tall octagonal, Teapot, octagonal raised on handle, wood evident, chasing no octagonal, Teapot, #42 1943 26, October Christies

458 Teapots &KULVWLHV0D\ Crichton Brothers Brothers Crichton Christies London October 25, 25, October London Christies 1989 &KULVWLHV0D\ AngelesLos County Museum #171 Exhibition Maybury Rodman Paul Collection #43 1918 14, March Christies $SROOR-XO\YROS Son and Mallet 1999 #314 1999 #314 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS 1LFKRODV6KDZ$QWLTXHV 1951 Lumley Thomas Sothebys April NY USA 23, 1993 #299 1958 Lumley Thomas Exhibition of the Royal Ontario Canada Museum Christies London July 1987 #219 1987 #219 July London Christies Collection Ivory ò´KW W´KWR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS R]G &KULVWLHV$SULO GKDQGOHEXGILQLDOò´KWR] &KULVWLHV1<86$2FWREHU KDQGOHDFRUQILQLDOVWUDLJKWVSRXWò´KW VSRXWR]G DFRUQILQLDOó´KW R]G RXWVLGHKLQJHRQOLG´KWR] R]G ó´KWR] 7HDSRWRFWDJRQDOLYRU\KDQGOHODWHUFKDVLQJVWUDLJKWVSRXW -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV -DFNVRQ0DUNVS -DPHV.HU1723/24 Tait James (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSRXW Edinburgh the around work card cut lid, around engraved lightly spherical, Teapot, 1723/24 William Aytoun Aytoun Edinburgh 1722/23 1723/24 William Aytoun William Edinburgh 1723/24 spou straight handle, wood octagonal, Teapot, Bethune Henry Edinburgh spout, lid, straight on hinge handle, exposed wood shaped, egg plain, Teapot, 1722/23 Tait James Edinburgh replaced, possibly handle wood spout, curved simple spherical, Teapot, &ROLQ&DPSEHOO (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGERG\ZRR -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGVLOYHU YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1722/23 LOCATION Blair Charles Edinburgh spout, straight finial, acorn handle, silver shaped, apple circular Teapot, SOURCE

459 Compendium of Scottish Silver 241 241 $2FWREHU &OD\WRQ&KULVWLHV6LOYHU%RRN p152 &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV6FRWWLVK3LFWXUH)LOH )LQOD\ &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S &KULVWLHV0DUFK &KULVWLHV2FWREHU &KULVWLHV2FWREHU -DFNVRQ &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ &RXQWHVVRI0RUD\&ROOHFWLRQ 6DVVRP 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. +HDUVW&ROOHFWLRQ I+DLJRI JHGIRRWZLWKVWUDLJKWVSRXWOLGZLWK VSRXWLYRU\KDQGOHó´KWR] 6RWKHE\V0D\ HDGLQJIRRWGRPHGOLGVLOYHUEXGILQLDOVLOYHU ZDUG3HQPDQ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG XWODWHUFKDVHGVLOYHUKDQGOH´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V1<86 XWEDOOILQLDOò´KWDERXWR] &KULVWLHV-DQXDU\ LJKWVSRXW 3DUN/DQH([KLELWLRQ HDSRWVSKHULFDO 0DOOHW 6RQ handle 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOò´KWR] &KULVWLHV2FWREHU" EDOXVWHUILQLDOZRRGKDQGOHDSSOLHGKLQJHFUHVWDQGPRWWRR %HPHUV\GH5RYEXUJKVKLUHò´KWR] (GZDUG3HQPDQ (GZDUG3HQPDQ (GLQEXUJK (GZDUG/RWKLDQ (GLQEXUJKFD 7HDSRWOLJKWO\FKDVHGFXUYHG (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV 1RWDYDLODEOH 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOSRVVLEO\(G 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV +ROODQGS -DFNVRQS +HQU\%HWKXQH +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK 7 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSR +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQSODLQVSU :LOOLDP$\WRXQ1725/26 (GLQEXUJK Aytoun William 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOSODLQVWUD Edinburgh -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWHORQJDWHGDSSOHVKDSHIODQ YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSR SOURCE

460 Teapots 959 p130-33a 959 p130-33a Bell of Aberdeen Collection, Collection, Aberdeen of Bell #13 1961, Sothebys London February 4, 1988 #23 4XHHQ¶V&ROOHFWLRQ 1987 #285 1987 #285 &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ-XQH #230 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ-XQH #309 Christies October 22, 1951 #157 1951 22, October Christies p130 Hayden Scotland of Museums National 1952.185 p223 130, vol 1939 p4 advertisement Bell p28 103 vol KWR]G OHò´KW foot, tapering straight spout,hinged dded dded 1939 May Magazine Connoisseur VLOYHUKDQGOHSDUWRIDVHW 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW G\RQUHHGHGULPIRRWGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOH ian decoration a decoration ian IRRWVLOYHUKDQGOHô´KW ZLWKZRRGLQVXODWRUVFXUYHGVSRXWLQLWLDOVRQXQGHUVLGHô´ coronet coronet domed lid, ball finial, leaf capped silver scroll handle, ivory insulators, insulators, ivory handle, scroll silver capped leaf finial, ball lid, domed PDUNHGRQXQGHUVLGHOLGLVXQPDUNHGó´KWR] LQLWLDOV³&--´ò´KWR] 19oz 6d 19oz 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSRXWEDOXVWHUILQLDOVLOYHUKDQG 1725ca 1725ca Luke Robert Glasgow pedestal spout, straight hinge, and lid domed slightly plain, spherical, Teapot, FD -RKQ:DONHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWSODLQFLUFXODUWDSHULQJER 1725 ca 1725 ca Walker George Aberdeen and crest decoration, light spout, straight handle, silver spherical, Teapot, FD -RKQ:DONHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGFXUYHGVSRXW 1725 ca 1725 ca Luke Robert Glasgow circular spreading on spherical, Teapot, 1725/26 1725/56 Aytoun William Aytoun William Edinburgh 1725 ca decoration no hinge, external spout, Edinburgh straight 1725 ca finial, ball handle, wood Teapot, Luke Robert 1 Life Country pictured not Teapot, Luke Robert 1725 ca Glasgow Glasgow Luke Robert finial ball handle, 1725 ca silver spout, curved Teapot, stand with Teapot, Luke Robert Glasgow Victor later Teapot, Glasgow contemporary arms, later handle, wood spout, straight shaped, apple Teapot, 1939 Collection Antique 1952 Magazine Connoisseur February Magazine Connoisseur 1725/26 William Aytoun Aytoun Edinburgh YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1725/26 William LOCATION SOURCE

461 Compendium of Scottish Silver Picture File File Picture DAG008631 DAG008631 &KULVWLHV0DUFK Apollo 1934 vol 20 p25 20 1934 vol Apollo advertisement Sharp and Wilson +RZ¶V1RWHVRQ$QWLTXHV6LOYHU p23 I, vol 1941, Gordon Small 1963 Small Gordon Sothebys April NY USA 23, &KULVWLHV0DUFK« Scottish Christies Edinburgh of How 90 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas #93 1937 Edinburgh of How 4XHHQ¶V&ROOHFWLRQ &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH'HFHPEHU 1939 p2989 MEQ 602 MEQ 1560 1983 1983 1560 MEQ AB Galleries OHSODLQGRPHOLG´ DLUVWDQVTXDUWVL]H*ODGVWDQVDOVRZLJJOHZRUN crest and motto motto and crest Scotland of Museums National IRRWFXUYHGVSRXW´KWR]G Johnson Tea Service Service Tea Johnson R] silver handle, script initial in circular cartouche, with matching bowl one year year one bowl matching with cartouche, circular in initial script handle, silver later ´KWR] decoration around lid, silver handle, straight spout, misattributed to John John to misattributed spout, straight handle, silver lid, around decoration Main apparently different from the one below (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWWDSHULQJVSRXWZRRGKDQG Glasgow Glasgow crest, and band engraved handle, silver spout, straight spherical, Teapot, Bilsings Bilsings 1727/28 Thomas Mitchell Mitchell 1727/28 1727/28 Thomas Ker James Edinburgh set a of part spherical, Teapot, #34 1991 Finlay 1727 ca 1727 ca Johan Got-helf- 1727/28 Kincaid Alexander 1727/28 Edinburgh Ker James handle silver stand, with Teapot Edinburgh The of part crest, finial, ball handle, silver spout, straight spherical, Teapot, p68 1947 March Apollo 1726/27 available Not Edinburgh lip, around decoration period band, small spout, straight spherical, Teapot, -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDO$UPVRI+ YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1725 ca LOCATION Robertson George Aberdeen handle wood Teapot, SOURCE Scotland of Museums National 1725/26 Ker James Edinburgh with shaped, apple Teapot, 1726ca 1726ca Walker John 1726/27 Tait James Aberdeen 1726/27 -DPHV7DLW IGF? engraved crosses, three IWR IWR, marked base no details, Teapot, Mitchelson James Edinburgh Edinburgh and Museums Aberdeen (GLQEXUJK band decorated small with spherical, Teapot, decoration, no spout, straight finial, ball handle, silver spherical, Teapot, 7HDSRWSODLQVSKHULFDO #80 1971 31, March Christies

462 Teapots 3LFWXUH)LOH 3LFWXUH)LOHV 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV6FRWWLVK &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH YROS &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ0D\ /\RQ 7XUQEXOO)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV0DUFK &KULVWLHV6FRWWLVK 6RWKHE\V1<86$$SULO 1993 #297 6RWKHE\V$XJXVW &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU 6LPRQ.D\H$QWLTXHV %DUXFK&ROOHFWLRQ McKissick Museum, University RI6RXWK&DUROLQD&ROXPELD6& 86$ 0XVHH'HV%HDX[$UWV0RQWUHDO &DQDGD'6 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU London Koopman, 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS 1993 #298 1993 #298 ³+´ ´KWR]G ´ORQJ HHQJUDYHGZLWK DOVLOYHUGRXEOH OVRQDPDWWHG HUEDQGHGEDOXVWHU foot, capped curved spout, UFXODUIRRWVWUDLJKWVSRXWVFUROOKDQGOHEDOO WVDQGPRWWRVVLOYHUGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOH ILQLDOVLOYHU&VFUROOKDQGOHFDSSHGE\GRXEOHOHDIRQHVLG GHFRUDWLRQLVXQGHUODWHUFDGHFRUDWLRQó´KWR]G FUHVWDQGPRWWRHQJUDYHGXQGHUQHDWKZLWKVFULSWLQLWLDO³&´ VFUROOLQJIOXWHVSODLQGRPHGOLGZLWKDSSOLHGKLQJHEDOOILQL VFUROOKDQGOHó´KWR] EDOODQGEXWWRQILQLDOVFUDWFKZHLJKWXQGHUQHDWKó´KW ILQLDOFKDVHGDWDODWHUGDWHZLWKIORZHUVIROLDJHDQGVFURO JURXQGFRDWVRIDUPVR] FLUFXODUEDVHVW\OL]HGOHDIEDQGHQJUDYHGQHDUPRXWKHQJUDYHG XQGHUQHDWK´;´;´ ó´KWR]GWRWDO RI&DUQHJLHDQGDTXDUWHUIRUPDXOHPRWWR³7$&+(6$167$&+(´ ô´KWR] *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWDSSOHVKDSHGVWUDLJKWWDSHUHGVSRXWIOXVKFRY %LOVLQJV (continued) (continued) 1728 ca 1728 ca Johan Got-helf- 1727/28 Mitchelson James Edinburgh band original spout, straight handle, silver decoration, later spherical, Teapot, 1727/28 Mitchelson James Edinburgh spreading stepped on plain, spherical, Teapot, 1727/38 Aytoun William Edinburgh insulators, ivory spout, straight handle, silver scroll double spherical, Teapot, 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQPROGHGFL 1727/38 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh ogee-molded handle, scroll double spout, tapered straight spherical, Teapot, (GZDUG3HQPDQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWZLWKVXJDUERZOFUHV YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1727/28 Murray Patrick Edinburgh Arms chased, later finial, ball handle, silver spout, straight spherical, Teapot,

463 Compendium of Scottish Silver 996 996 103 J* +\PDQ&ROOHFWLRQ&RORQLDO Williamsbur +RZ&ROOHFWLRQ Connoisseur Magazine January January Magazine Connoisseur YROS 3HWHU*XLOOH1

464 Teapots 1986 1986 Picture File File Picture ecember 17, &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK-XQH Scottish Christies Christies NY USA April 12, 12, April USA NY Christies Christies Edinburgh November November Edinburgh Christies Sothebys Gleneagles August Sothebys Gleneagles August 27- 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ Sothebys February 1, 1973 1, February Sothebys N. Antiques Bloom Christies D Christies Brooklyn Museum NY USA 63.95.1 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU 6RWKHE\V$SULO 17, August Monaco Christies Nicholas Shaw Catalog 1999 p53 1999 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 6HUYLFH GPRWWR³1XQ ´KW DQGOHò´KW EOHVFUROOVLOYHU R] ZLJJOHZRUNDURXQGOLGSDWFKHGIURP IRRWZLWKHQJUDYHGVKHOOVIROLDJHDQGVFUROOV VWUDLJKWVSRXWEDOODQGEXWWRQILQLDODSSOLHG RIDPL[HGWHDVHUYLFHILQLDOKDVOHDIXQGHU aight spout, double scroll handle, ball finial on on finial ball handle, scroll double spout, aight NQREVLOYHUKDQGOHFKDVLQJSUREDEO\VOLJKWO\ODWHU´KW hinge, silver double scroll handle, on molded domed foot, no leaf under finial finial under leaf no foot, domed molded on handle, scroll double silver hinge, NQREÓRQJR] around the rim, straight tapering spout, silver plain capped double scroll scroll double capped plain silver spout, tapering rim, straight the around of Moubray of Arms of coat finial, hinge, orb flush lid, domed handle, &RFNDLUQLH)LIH´R] LQVLGHSRVVLEOHIXQILQLDOLQLWLDOV³6&ÉHORZWKHVSRXWGRXKDQG´KWR]G tapering spout, double scroll silver handle, engraved narrow band round the the round band narrow engraved handle, silver scroll double spout, tapering edge, near engraved similarly lid ornament, of lines zig-zag with mouth 19.7oz URXQGOLGZLWKOHDIDQGOLQHERUGHUURXQGPRXWKDUPVFUHVWDQ 4XDP1RQ3DUDWXVÍRU-RKQVRQSDUWRIWKHSLHFH-RKQVRQ7HD VFUROOKDQGOH 1RWHRULJLQDOO\DWWULEXWHGWR:LOOLDP-DPLHVRQ R]G similarly decorated domed lid, urn finial, straight spout, leaf capped double double capped leaf spout, straight finial, urn lid, domed decorated similarly VFUROOKDQGOHRQVSUHDGLQJEDVH´KWR] 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOHQJUDYHGIULH]HDURXQGOLGDQGULPVLOYHUK 17.8oz straight foot, spreading stepped molded on form, spherical almost Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh double silver chasing, later spout, curved body, spherical almost Teapot, Assayer Archibald Ure +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVROGDVSDUW +HQU\%HWKXQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOODWHUFKDVHG 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQVSUHDGLQJ -DPHV7DLW (GLQEXUJK -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSRXW :LOOLDP$\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK 1728/29 Ker James Edinburgh str shape, spherical Teapot, 1728/29 Aytoun William Edinburgh cartouche, crested scrolls, floral hanging with chased later spherical, Teapot, 1728/29 William Aytoun Aytoun Edinburgh YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1728/29 William LOCATION SOURCE

465 Compendium of Scottish Silver Picture File File Picture DAG001357 DAG001357 Aberdeen Museumsand AB Galleries Christies March 18, 1986 #99 #99 1986 18, March Christies #169 #160 14, 1978 July Phillips Scottish Christies Christies June 30, 1992 #206A #206A 1992 30, June Christies #124 3, 1984 July Christies Bonhams August 21-23, 2003 2003 21-23, Bonhams August #119 Christies NY USA April 12, 12, April USA NY Christies 1988 Steppes Hill Farm, London 1995 1995 London Farm, Hill Steppes Williamsburg Williamsburg VFUROOKDQGOHG lid, silver handle, wood wood handle, silver lid, ation on handle, plain body, 3 3 body, plain handle, on ation foot, chased around the rim with foot, straight tapering spout, silver OHHQJUDYHGPRQRJUDPR] &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU foot, wood insul ht chased decoration around around decoration ht chased ell decoration decoration ell Colonial - Collection Hyman ot, no details details no ot, p50 1930 Son & Mallet Gothic A A Gothic PDUNV±*&FDVWOHVJRWKLFô´R] VFUROOKDQGOHKLQJHGFRYHUEDOXVWHUILQLDOPP;¶VR]G EDQGVRIVW\OL]HGIROLDJHVWUDLJKWWDSHULQJVSRXWOHDIFDSSHG LYRU\EDOXVWHUILQLDO´KWR] scrolls, flower heads, and foliage, hinged domed lid, wooden finial, partly partly finial, wooden lid, domed hinged foliage, and heads, flower scrolls, IOXWHGVFUROOVSRXWVFUROOKDQGOH´KWR] scroll handle, ivory insulators, hinged lid with acanthus hinge, bud finial, finial, bud hinge, acanthus with lid hinged insulators, ivory handle, scroll UHSDLUWRVSRXWDQGEDVHPDUNV±WRZHUV*RWKLFH$*&± ´ORQJR] partitioned finial finial partitioned FD 5REHUW/XNH *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWVWUDLJKWVSRXWVLOYHUKDQG 1730ca 1730ca Cooper George Aberdeen towers, three GC,GC - marked based no details, wood, and silver Teapot, 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen rim on circular, shaped Teapot, 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George 1730ca Aberdeen Cooper George circular molded on shaped, spherical Teapot, Aberdeen double spout, straight foot, rim molded on shape, pear inverted plain, Teapot, 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen with chased shoulders foot, spreading stepped on shape, spherical Teapot, 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen on spreading body, shaped apple Teapot, 1730 ca 1730 ca Cooper George Aberdeen lig shaped, ball Teapot, 1730 ca 1730 1730 ca Cooper George Cooper George Aberdeen Aberdeen stand with Teapot, sh Teapot, p130-33 1959 April Life Country YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1730/31 LOCATION 1730 ca Bethune Henry Cooper George Edinburgh Aberdeen 4d lid, 20oz engraved lightly spout, straight spherical, Teapot, Teap #70 1925 3, December Christies SOURCE

466 Teapots '$* $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG *DOOHULHV$% 1986) (acquired +\PDQ&ROOHFWLRQ&RORQLDO :LOOLDPVEXUJ* 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ-XQH #309 1977 23, November Christies #169 Sothebys Blair Castle September #162 1980 12, Christies September 19, 1979 1979 19, September Christies #119 Christies May 15, 1963 #52 15, 1963 May Christies 6RWKHE\V-DQXDU\ Noble Collection Collection Noble QLWLDOV³&--´ ouble scrollhandle, HUDFRUQILQLDOOHDI foot, straight spout,double scroll G ò´KW -DFNVRQ0DUNVS 6HUYLFHRIILYHSLHFHVQRGHWDLOVEDVHG PDUNHGWKUHHWRZHUV*&*RWKLF$RU( capped handle capped handle, raised lid, ball finial, engraved with a monogram, 21oz 21oz monogram, a with engraved finial, ball lid, raised handle, lid, domed slightly base, spreading on handle, scroll double cartouches, EDOXVWHUILQLDOô´KWR]G RI/RFNDUWRI%LUNKLOO6FRWODQGXQGHUVLGHZLWKFRQWHPSRUDU\L ò´KWR] finial, hinged lid, 17oz 5d 17oz lid, hinged finial, OLGEDOXVWHUILQLDOò´KWR]G PROGHGVSUHDGLQJIRRW³KWR] *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWô´KWR]Glasgow Teapot, spherical shaped, engraved with scrolls, floral clusters, and2 vacant *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWEDUUHOVKDSHGVWUDLJKWVSRXWIODWFRYHUVLOY /\OH$QQXDO5HYLHZS Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWSDUWRI7KH.LUNKLOO7HD 1730 ca 1730 ca available Not FD -RKDQ*RWKHOI Edinburgh pot Penman Edward an be could spout, straight 2 crests, Teapot, FD -RKDQ*RWKHOI p860 Waldron, FD -RKDQ*RWKHOI 1730ca 1730ca Luke Robert Glasgow molded circular plain, spherical, Teapot, 1730 ca 1730 ca Luke Robert Glasgow armorials with engraved later lid, flat spout, straight shape, spherical Teapot, 1730ca Luke Robert Glasgow baluster spout, straight foot, molded circular on spherical, plain, Teapot, 1730ca 1730ca Luke Robert Glasgow flush hinged spout, tapering straight base, on flat body, oviform plain Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1730 ca LOCATION Luke Robert Glasgow 5d 17oz finial ball spout, straight Teapot, SOURCE #52 15, 1963 May Christies FD 1730 ca 5REHUW/XNH Luke Robert *ODVJRZ Glasgow 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOIOXWHGVSRXW d spout, tapered finial, ball plain, shape, spherical Teapot,

467 Compendium of Scottish Silver ial 1978-2060 1978-2060 Lyle Silver Review 1981 p116 1981 p116 Review Silver Lyle #90 1976 16, December Sothebys Christies November 22, 1995 1995 22, November Christies #126 Collection Private Sothebys April 25, 1975 #149 #149 1975 25, April Sothebys Sothebys Hopetoun House April House Hopetoun Sothebys #58 1988 26, Huntley House Museum, Huntley House Edinburgh 2128/61 HH 1981 7, April Sothebys Sothebys Scone Palace April 14, 1990 #119 p627 1981 Annual Review Lyle McKissick Museum, University SC Columbia, Carolina, South of 1.148 USA Collection Baruch Galleries Williamsburg G1992- G1992- Williamsburg Bell Collection, 1961, #9 1961, Collection, Bell ] DUPVRI0F/HRG´KWR] &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ0D\ QDQGFDUWRXFKHZLWKVFULSWLQLWLDOV³0*´DQG spout, silver double scroll handle, ball and button button and ball handle, scroll double silver spout, rical body, flat chased with flowers and scrolls near mouth, bun bun mouth, near and scrolls flowers with chased flat body, rical ODWHULQLWLDOVLQFDUWRXFKHVWUDLJKWVSRXWò´KWR] handle, tapering straight spout, lid with applied hinge, silver bun and button button and bun hinge, silver applied with lid spout, straight tapering handle, ILQLDO´R] KDQGOHKLQJHGOLGVSKHULFDOILQLDO´KWR] FDUWRXFKHHQFORVLQJDFUHVWDQGPRWWRRQRQHVLGHó´KWR DQGEXWWRQILQLDOFXUYHGVSRXWZRRGKDQGOHò´KWR]G ³'*´´KW´ORQJ ILQLDOZRRGHQLQVXODWRUV´KW´ORQJ VSRXWPROGHGIRRW´KW 1731/32 Ker James Edinburgh flowers, fruits, with chased handle, silver lid, hinged flush spherical, Teapot, 1731/32 Rollo John Edinburgh scroll double silver capped plain foot, on stepped body, near spherical Teapot, 1731/32 Tait James Edinburgh scroll spout, tapering straight a coronet, below initials engraved later Teapot, 1731/32 Ker James Edinburgh flowers, and foliage scrolling of bands with chased spherical, Teapot, 1731/32 -DPHV.HU Ker James (GLQEXUJK Edinburgh 7HDSRWFXUYHGVSRXWVLOYHUKDQGOH sphe Teapot, 1730/31 Ker James Edinburgh details no shape, spherical Teapot, Art and Museum Dundee $UFKLEDOG8UH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOIORUDOGHVLJ 1730/31 Bethune Henry Edinburgh straight spherical, Teapot, 1730ca 1730ca Cooper George Aberdeen mouth near engraved handle, silver straight spout, body, spherical Teapot, Collection-Colon Hyman YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1730ca LOCATION Cooper George Aberdeen tubular lid, dome handle, scroll silver (apple?), spherical tapering Teapot, SOURCE

468 Teapots Sothebys December 15, 1966 1966 15, December Sothebys #113 Christies July 30, 1945 #205 #205 1945 July 30, Christies 80, vol 1961, Magazine Antiques p498 advertisement Aberdeen of Bell 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZYRO9,,,S advertisement Bell #3 &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 1983 #82 6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ /\OH$QQXDO5HYLHZS ,YRU\&ROOHFWLRQ Exhibition #948 Exhibition Collection Gilmour Christies November 12, 1952 1952 12, November Christies #109 Bell of Aberdeen Collection Collection Aberdeen of Bell #14 1961, Sothebys Sale L05766 November November L05766 Sale Sothebys #157 2005 29, September 7, 2005 #315 #315 2005 7, September 1983.27 1983.27 ò´KW finial finial 1545, Sale NY Christies XSSRUWHUVVKHOODQG foot, engraved foliage, ball finial, finial, finial, coat of arms, 12.3oz spout, silver handle, ball handle, silver spout, H*LUGZRRG7HD6HUYLFH )LQOD\ rical body body rical Scotland of Museums National scrolling foliage on the shoulders and hinged lid, straight tapering spout, spout, tapering straight lid, hinged and shoulders the on foliage scrolling and hatching, straight spout, baluster spout, straight and hatching, FKDVLQJFUHVWDQGPRWWR³6$163(85´RI6XWKHUODQGR] HQJUDYHGSDWWHUQVXUURXQGLQJOLGFUHVWRI&KDUWLHUVIDPLO\ 23oz 5d 23oz cover cover lid around engraving spout, curved spherical, Teapot, Academy Art Scotland (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOZLWKFRQWHPSRUDU\DUPRULDOVZLWKV 1733/34 Aytoun Aytoun William 1733/34 William Edinburgh Th of part spherical, Teapot, 1732/33 Ure Archibald 1733/34 Ker James Edinburgh foliage of band with shoulders at chased foot, on spreading spherical, Teapot, Edinburgh flat delicate finial, ball handle, silver straight spout, body, spherical Teapot, 1732/33 Archibald Ure Ure 1732/33 Edinburgh 1732/33 Archibald Mitchelson James Edinburgh 11d 13oz spout, straight spherical, Teapot, #86 13, 1932 July Christies 1732/33 Aytoun William Edinburgh small spout, straight handle, scroll silver foot, and stem on spherical, Teapot, 1732/33 Aytoun William Edinburgh circular spout, straight spherical, Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1731/32 LOCATION Ker James Edinburgh straight plain, spherical, Teapot, SOURCE 1731/32 Ker James Edinburgh sphe plain Teapot, 1731/32 Mitchell David Edinburgh on decoration band handle, silver scroll double finial, ball spherical, Teapot,

469 Compendium of Scottish Silver 5 OOHFWLRQ REHU V-XO\ $SROOR-XO\YROS Shop Bros Crichton Christies June 24, 1965 #19 1965 24, June Christies &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU &KULVWLHV1<86$$SULO 0HWURSROLWDQ0XVHXPRI$UW 1<86$ &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK0D\ 3KLOOLSV(GLQEXUJK-XQH ] &KULVWLH GVROG QGEDOO LQDOO\ KVFULSWLQLWLDO VDQGIROLDJH LWKEHDGILQLDO DOOILQLDOR GLQJVWHSSHGIRRW IRRWô´KWR] 6LPRQ.D\H$QWLTXHV UFXODUPROGHGIRRWVWUDLJKWWDSHULQJVSRXW LUFXODUPROGHGIRRWZLWKVWUDLJKWWDSHULQJ HQJUDYHGVKHOODQGVWUDSVR]G &KULVWLHV0DUFK VKHOODQGVFUROOZRUNDURXQGPRXWKHQJUDYHG IRRWVWUDLJKWWDSHULQJVSRXWUHYHUVHVFUROO RXWHQJUDYHGEDQGRIIROLDJHE VSRXWEDOOILQLDOFKDVHGZLWKVFUROOVR]G &KULVWLHV2FW HUKDQGOHOLJKWFKDVLQJQHDUPRXWKò´R]G 8QWHPH\HU&R chasing GRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHSHGHVWDOIRRWò´KWR]G VLOYHUGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHZLWKLYRU\LQVXODWRUVKLQJHGOLGZ DQGHQJUDYHGIROLDJHDQGVKHOOVRQXSSHUERG\DQGOLGVLGHZLW ³:´ô´ORQJR] VSRXWDQGVKRXOGHUDQGOLGHQJUDYHGZLWKEDQGRIVKHOOVVFUROO RUEILQLDOR] finial, chasedto shoulders and lid with band of shellsand scrolls, FRQWHPSRUDU\EHWURWKDOLQLWLDOV³-/.0´XQGHUQHDWK 1RWHRULJ DWWULEXWHGWR:LOOLDP-DPLHVRQ ´KWR] KDQGOHZLWKKDUGZRRGLQVXODWRUVGRPHGOLGZLWKDSSOLHGKLQJHD LQLWLDOVVWUDLJKWVSRXWVLOYHUGRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHRQVSUHD ZLWK)UHQFKGXW\PDUNVRIIHUHGZLWKVZDJERUGHUVWDQGZKLFKKD VHSDUDWHO\LQ FRQWLQXHG GRXEOHVFUROOKDQGOHVSKHULFDOILQLDORQFLUFXODU (GZDUG/RWKLDQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVS 1733/34 -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ Mitchelson James (GLQEXUJK Edinburgh 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKW period light hinge, outside handle, silver spout, straight spherical, Teapot, -DPHV7DLW (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSRXW 1733/34 James Tait Edinburgh finial, baluster foliage, and shells chased spout, straight spherical, Teapot, .HQQHWK0F.HQ]LH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVWUDLJKWVSRXWVLOY -RKQ5ROOR (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQVSUHDGLQJFL +XJK3HQPDQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQVSUHDGLQJF -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQGRPHG YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE :LOOLDP$\WRXQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOIODWFKDVHG

470 Teapots 1994 1994 HFHPEHU 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW /\OH$QQXDO5HYLHZS &KULVWLHV' 6RWKHE\V-DQXDU\ AntiquesSimon Kaye &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ0DUFK 1983 Collection Shaw &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU Collection How p13 17, 1933 vol Apollo advertisement How Bonhams Knightsbridge Knightsbridge Bonhams )HEUXDU\$ %RQKDPV/RQGRQ1RYHPEHU 6RWKHE\V0DUFK 1989 USA NY Shrubsole &KULVWLHV0D\ AntiquesSimon Kaye Collection Phoenix The Apollo 1933 vol 17, p13 17, 1933 vol Apollo advertisement How ] ´KWR] foot, shoulderand border of lid RWHQJUDYHGZLWKVFUROOVR]G &KULVWLHV-XQH HQJUDYHGZLWKEDQGVRIVKHOOVDQGIROLDJHEDOXVWHUILQLDOR KLQJHó´KWR]G ZRRGLQVXODWRUVLQLWLDOV³$+´R] and flower sprays, pear shaped finial, straight tapering spout, on spreading SHGHVWDOEDVHò´KWR] 14oz 8d 14oz EDOOILQLDOVFUROOKDQGOHIOXWHGVSRXWRQFLUFXODUEDVH PROGHGFLUFXODUIRRWLQLWLDOVRQXQGHUVLGHó´KWR]G 13d 17oz handle, silver mouth, the 19oz 10d 19oz Glasgow Glasgow finial, spherical compressed handle, wood spout, neck swan plain, Teapot, Edinburgh around decorated chased, lightly finial, ball spout, straight spherical, Teapot, Bilsings Bilsings Assayer Archibald Ure 1734/35 Lothian Edward Edinburgh molded circular on spherical, Teapot, 1734/35 Lothian Edward Edinburgh flush handle scroll double chased, lightly spout, straight spherical, Teapot, 1734/35 Tait James Edinburgh handle with silver finial, ball chased, flat spout, straight spherical, Teapot, 1734/35 Kincaid Alexander Edinburgh masks scrolls, with mouth the around shoulder at chased spherical, Teapot, 1734 ca 1734 ca Penman Johan Got-helf- 1734/35 Hugh 1734/35 :LOOLDP$\WRXQ Kincaid Alexander (GLQEXUJK Edinburgh 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFLUFXODUIR and flowers, scrolls with chased shoulder foot, high on spherical, Teapot, 1734 ca 1734 ca Luke Robert Glasgow lid, hinged work, scroll and motifs, shells, with chased shaped, bullet Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1733/34 LOCATION Lothian Edward Edinburgh finial, ball handle, silver chasing, light spout, straight spherical, Teapot, SOURCE

471 Compendium of Scottish Silver #142 #142 and DAG008911 DAG008911 Christies January 26, 1949 26, 1949 January Christies p66 2000 Catalog Shaw Nicholas #959 1939 Exhibition #970 1939 Exhibition Galleries AB Galleries 1996) (acquired Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2000 p66 #89 1939 Exhibition Collection Stuart-Stevenson 1937 11, June Christies Collection How Christies April 12, 1967 #142 #142 1967 12, April Christies Christies June 18, 1969 #199 1969 18, June Christies AntiquesSimon Kaye upper part chased chased part upper L 6FRWODQG$UW$FDGHP\ foot, straight tapering spout, flushlid no details, base marked - GC, 3 castles, E castles, 3 GC, - marked base details, no Museums Aberdeen HQJUDYHGDUDEHVTXH´GL 6FRWODQG$UW$FDGHP\ foot, almost spherical body, and finial, 17oz 4d 4d 17oz and finial, VWUDLJKWVSRXWVFUROOZRRGHQKDQGOHó´KWR] with flowers and scrolls, straight spout, baluster finial, hinged lid, 21oz 21oz lid, hinged finial, baluster spout, straight scrolls, and flowers with with baluster finial, shoulder with band of shells and scrolls, 19.4oz 19.4oz scrolls, and shells of band with shoulder finial, baluster with *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSRXWDFRUQILQLDOò´G Bilsings Bilsings 1735 ca 1735 ca Cooper George FD Aberdeen 3DWULFN*RUGRQ 1735ca service with Teapot, %DQII Cooper George Aberdeen 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSRXW ivory, and silver spherical, Teapot, Academy Art Scotland 1735 ca 1735 ca 1735 ca available Not Johan Got-helf- 1735 ca 1735 ca Robertson George 1735 ca Robertson Aberdeen George repair plain, Teapot, Cooper Aberdeen George 18d 21oz engraved, spout, tapering spherical, Teapot, 1735 ca 21oz chased, finial, ball spout, straight spherical, almost Teapot, Aberdeen Cooper George 4d 19oz spout, straight plain, Teapot, Aberdeen 1967 12, April Christies handle, wooden spout, straight foot, molded circular shape, apple #82 tall Teapot, 17, 1946 July Christies #86 13, 1921 July Christies #865 Waldron 1735 ca 1735 ca Cooper George Aberdeen main body, on rim around and lid hinged on chased flat shape, pear Teapot, 1735 ca 1735 ca Robertson George Aberdeen molded on circular Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1734/35 LOCATION 1734/35 Ker James Ure Archibald Edinburgh Edinburgh Service Hopetoun The from Hope, of motto and crest spherical, Teapot, molded circular on spherical, Teapot, #121 1977 15, June Christies SOURCE

472 Teapots 1973 1973 1986 1986 1967 )LOHV HFHPEHU HFHPEHU #224 &KULVWLHV' 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ 6LPRQ.D\H$QWLTXHV $SROOR'HFHPEHUYROS &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQH2FWREHU 56 vol 1949 #012 5, 1972 July Christies &KULVWLHV' 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU #237 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1973 #70d 6RWKHE\V-XQH Christies October 22, 1952 #85 1952 22, October Christies Asprey London 1993 London 1993 Asprey Collection Phoenix The +RZ¶V1RWHVRQ$QWLTXH6LOYHU p.22. I, 1941 vol ó´KW foot, single scrollhandle with ebony ZLWKFUHVWVEHORZOLJKWO\FKDVHGVKRXOGHUV XOGHUGHFRUDWLRQQHDUPRXWKVWUDLJKW , slightly flattened lid with applied hinge, baluster baluster hinge, applied with lid flattened slightly , insulator to the upper socket, lower end secured directly to the socket with a a with socket the to directly secured end lower socket, upper the to insulator foliage shells, with mouth around engraved spout, curved fluted partly screw, arms, of coat later with body finial, baluster silver with lid work, diaper and FUHVWDQGPRWWRIRU$-'HQQHLVWRQ%URZQRI%DOORFK&DVWOH 'XPEDUWRQVKLUHR] straight tapering spout, double scroll handle, hinged lid with turned finial, on on finial, turned with lid hinged handle, scroll double spout, tapering straight ULPIRRW´KWR] Jocky up and 1736 presentation date, 20oz 4d all in all 4d 20oz date, presentation 1736 up and Jocky tapering spout, wooden capped handle, lid with silver ball finial, on spreading spreading on finial, ball silver with lid handle, capped wooden spout, tapering all 16.3oz foot, VWUDLQHUSXQFKHGZLWKWKLVWOHGHVLJQVFUDWFKZHLJKWRQERWWRP ó´KWR]G IM with a rose above, most likely to be the IM figure between mark, mark, between figure IM the be to likely most above, rose a with IM 10d 15oz and finial, bun half fluted curved spout and capped silver scrollhandle 22oz approximately JK 7HDSRWFXUYHGVSRXWOLJKWFKDVLQJ´KW 6RWKHE\V3LFWXUH Edinburgh Edinburgh with Legacy of depiction engraved only, mm handle, wood gold, Teapot, 1736/37 James Ker 1736/37 James 'RXJDO*HG (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOHQJUDYHGODWHU 1736/67 Aytoun William Edinburgh molded circular on bullet Teapot, 1735/36 William Aytoun Aytoun Edinbur 1735/36 William 'RXJDO*HG (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOIODWFKDVHGVKR 1735/36 Ker James 1735/36 Edinburgh Penman Hugh interior shells, with chased lightly handle, wooden spout, curved Teapot, Edinburgh heraldry, no finial, ball handle, silver chased, lightly spout, straight Teapot, 1735ca 1735ca 1735/36 Luke Robert Mitchell James Glasgow Edinburgh as no details described mm cover, around stand, with Teapot, engraved spout, tapering spherical, Teapot, UK Collection Private YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1735ca LOCATION Forbes Alexander Aberdeen spherical almost Teapot, SOURCE

473 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1956 # 1956 1956 1956 ecember 19, ecember 19, Phillips Edinburgh May 17, 1991 1991 17, May Edinburgh Phillips #116 Finlay 1991 #76 1991 Finlay On loan to the National Museums Scotland of Christies D Christies #147 1961 12, January Sothebys AntiquesSimon Kaye #79 1996 30, April Christies 26, May Edinburgh Christies 1998 #84 6RWKHE\V$SULO Sothebys December 19, 1995 1995 19, December Sothebys #191 19, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1996 #137 Connoisseur Magazine 1953 1953 Magazine Connoisseur p23 132, vol advertisement Garrard Christies D Christies #132 Christies October 23, 1940 23, October Christies Collections Noble & Rothechild Firestone Parsons, Boston USA Collection Bennet Ashton and Gallery Art City Manchester Museum H[DPSOH HU%ODLU er and scroll decoration at the shoulder, part part shoulder, the at decoration scroll and er , bullet with flat chased decoration of flowers and foliate scrolls over over scrolls foliate and flowers of decoration chased flat with bullet , the upper half of the body, possibly later, coat of arms with supporters and and supporters with arms of coat later, possibly the body, of half upper the 19.8oz another, and Campbell of possibly motto, DQGSUHVHQWDWLRQGDWH³´PRUHKHDYLO\HQJUDYHGWKDQWKH baronets of Blairquhan, Ayreshire, 24 oz scale work, part fluted curved spout, simple scrolled capped handle, on on handle, capped scrolled simple spout, curved fluted part work, scale VSUHDGLQJIRRWFUHVWDVWDJ¶VKHDGJXDUGHQWDQGPRWWRIRU+XQW scrolls, ball finial on lid, chased around the shoulder and lid with bands of of bands with lid and shoulder the around chased lid, on finial ball scrolls, 22.7oz a crest, with foliage, scrolling shells, fluted curved spout, crestandmotto Nairn, of sold with later 2 pieces mark of a London maker, Pere Pilleau Pilleau Pere maker, a London of mark 22oz 18d 22oz James Ker Ker James Edinburgh arms Royal spout, straight curve, single handle, wood gold, carat 18 Teapot, (continued) (continued) 1737/38 Charles Dickson Dickson Teapot Edinburgh 1737/38 Charles 1737 dated 1736/37 Mitchell David Edinburgh and shells, scrolls, formal with shoulder the at chased flat spherical, Teapot, 1736/37 Ker James Edinburgh reverse 2 as formed spout fluted foot, molded circular on spherical Teapot, 1736/37 Ged Dougal Edinburgh diap body, spherical Teapot, 1736/37 Ker James Edinburgh the striking over Ker James chased, flat and fluted shaped, melon Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1736/37 Ker James Edinburgh and flowers, shells of band chased spout, reverse fluted spherical, Teapot,

474 Teapots Picture Files Files Picture e #33889 e Christies October 31, 1984 #152 1984 31, October Christies Scottish Christies Negativ Inches and Hamilton Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2002/03 2002/03 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p83 2005 20, April Wallis & Woolley #862c Sale Scottish The Bonhams #1 2005 24, August #73 26, 1939 July Christies Jackson Marks p547 Apollo 1933 vol 17, p13 17, 1933 vol Apollo advertisement How Christies November 23, 1983 1983 23, November Christies #146 #141 9, 1984 May Christies 11, November Scotland Christies 1987 #? 30, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1982 #503 Christies October 31, 1984 #152 1984 31, October Christies upper body and cover chased chased cover and body upper foot, foot, partly fluted spout, scrollhandle, foot, curved spout, chased, silverhandle, ball finial, chased with shells, 21oz finial, 25oz HQJUDYHVFULSWLQLWLDOV³-5´ò´KWR] 19oz 18d 19oz roundthe mouth with fruit, flowers and strap work, with C shapedhandle, partly fluted curved spout, ball finial, some engravingremoved, 20 oz upper body and lid engraved with shells, foliage and trellis work, lid with ball ball with lid work, trellis and foliage shells, with engraved lid and body upper finial, 21oz 1737/38 1737/38 Lothian Edward 1738/39 Lothian Edward Edinburgh Ged Dougal 1738/39 Edinburgh 10d 23oz fruit, of band chased spherical, Teapot, details no Teapot, Ure Archibald Edinburgh Edinburgh details No Teapot, 2d 19oz handle, silver chasing, light spout, curved spherical, Teapot, #60 4, 1964 February Christies Picture File Sothebys p540 67 vol Magazine Antiques p547 Marks Jackson 1737/38 Gordon Hugh Edinburgh lightly finial, ball handle, silver fluted partly spout, curved spherical, Teapot, 1737/38 Forbes George Edinburgh ball flowers, and scrolls of band chased spout, curved spherical, Teapot, 1737/38 Ker James Edinburgh chasing, flat handle, loop silver capped leaf spout, curved spherical, Teapot, 1737/38 Ker James Edinburgh no spherical, Teapot, 1737/38 Aytoun William Edinburgh molded spreading on spherical, Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1737/38` LOCATION Gordon Hugh Edinburgh molded circular on spherical, Teapot, SOURCE

475 Compendium of Scottish Silver Private Collection Collection Private Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1983 #507 Sothebys February 12, 1970 #195 1970 12, February Sothebys Shrubsole NY USA Christies Geneva? November 9, 9, November Geneva? Christies 1976 #53 16, November Geneva? Christies 1993 #13 27, March Glasgow Christies 1984 #270 J Bourdon-Smith Catalog Spring Spring Catalog Bourdon-Smith J 1983 Argentum Antiques 1996 1996 Antiques Argentum Apollo October 1948 vol 48 p18 48 vol 1948 Apollo October advertisement Snyder & Bracher #178 1951 Collection Aberdeen of Bell #15 with alternate alternate with upper body flat chased flat body upper RULJLQDOLQVXODWHGVLOYHUKDQGOHó´KW OLJKWO\FKDVHGVLOYHUKDQGOHò´KW foot, ILJXUHEHWZHHQó´KWR]G work at the shoulder, flat lid with bun finial, part fluted spout, leaf capped capped leaf spout, fluted part finial, bun with lid flat shoulder, the at work KDQGOHò´KWR] fruit clusters within rococo matting, lid similarly decorated, spherical finial, finial, spherical decorated, similarly lid matting, rococo within clusters fruit with band of flower heads, foliage and scrolls, orbed finial, straight tapering tapering straight finial, orbed scrolls, and foliage heads, flower of band with 19oz side, each on one crests, 2 handle, loop silver capped leaf spout, cartouches shells, of and handle, bunches flowers loop of within capped strapplain work,hinged lid silver spout, curved semi-fluted finial, baluster with ´KWR] hingeand button and ball finial, curved semi-fluted spout,leaf capped silver ORRSKDQGOHò´ORQJR] 23oz 15d 23oz 19oz 12d 19oz Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Teapot, Edinburgh Teapot, spherical, on spreading foot, flat chasedat shoulderwith floral and 1987 #168 July Christies Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David 1739/40 James Mitchell Mitchell 1739/40 James Lothian 1739/40 Edward 1739/40 Mitchell James Edinburgh IM mm handle, silver insulated original spout, curved spherical, Teapot, 1738/39 available Not Edinburgh diaper and fruit, scrolls of baskets with chased flat near spherical, Teapot, 1738/39 Ker James Edinburgh chased, flat and cover body of part upper foot, circular domed on Teapot, 1738/39 Blair Charles Edinburgh spreading on circular Teapot, 1738/39 Ker James Edinburgh flush with lid mouth, around decoration chased flat contemporary Teapot, 1738/39 Hally James -DPHV:HP\VV Edinburgh (GLQEXUJK 8d 17oz HY, I mm chased, spherical Teapot, 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVSRXW #101 1962 7, March Christies YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1738/39 LOCATION Ure Archibald Edinburgh 11d 19oz chased, lightly spout, curved Teapot, SOURCE 1961 13, December Christies $UFKLEDOG8UH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVSRXW

476 Teapots DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG MEQ 603 &KULVWLHV0DUFK YROS &KULVWLHV0DUFK &KULVWLHV1HJDWLYH +ROODQG6LOYHUSRU &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU &KULVWLHV0DUFK &KULVWLHV0DUFK -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ6SULQJ &KULVWLHV0DUFK #167 1987 July 8, Christies 20, March Edinburgh Phillips 1987 # %XFKDQ´KWR] 7LFKHU,ULVK6LOYHUS VKRXOGHUDQGOLG HDUVSKHULFDOZLWK WO\IOXWHGVLOYHUKDQGOH HGURXQGWKHVKRXOGHU IOXWHGVFUROOVSRXWIOXVK UYHGVSRXWVKRXOGHUDQG XWVLOYHUKDQGOHOLJKWFKDVLQJ 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU IRRW³,/'..*0&´ 1 and lid with flowers, fruit, shells, and strap work, curved spout chased with a a with spout chased curved work, strap and shells, fruit, flowers, with lid and VKHOOEDOOILQLDOR] broadly decorated, end of spout with a slight notch notch slight a with spout of end decorated, broadly curved spout, chased at shoulder and on lid with scrolls, flowers, and foliage, foliage, and flowers, scrolls, with lid on and shoulder at chased spout, curved finial, bun with handle, scroll capped plain silver spout, half-fluted curved side, off of mid-point and spout between placed a motto below crest chased with fruit, foliage and scrolls, partly fluted curved spout, baluster baluster spout, curved fluted partly scrolls, and foliage fruit, with chased ILQLDOR] lid chased with flowers, wave ornament,and trellis work, orb finial, leafFDSSHGVLOYHUORRSKDQGOHR] hingedlid, ball and button finial, engraved round mouth with band of shells,VFUROOVDQGIROLDJHR] part of body chased with flowers, fruit and foliage on matted ground, baluster baluster ground, matted on foliage and fruit flowers, with chased body part of finial, 23oz (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQPROGHGFLUFXODUIRRWERG\FKDV (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRGHWDLO &RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWFRPSUHVVHGVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVKRUWVSRXWSDU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSUHYLRXVO\PLVVDVFULEHGWR'DYLG0LWFKHOOQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQVSUHDGLQJFLUFXODUIRRWSDUWO\ Edinburgh Edinburgh upper spout, curved fluted partly foot, molded circular on spherical, Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWFRPSUHVVHGVSKHULFDORQFLUFXODUPROGHGIRRW (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQFLUFXODUIRRWSDUWO\IOXWHGFX s Hally Hally s Assayer Archibald Ure Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell 0LWFKHOO PROGHGFXUYHGVSRXWVFUROOKDQGOHFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI Assayer David Mitchell 1739/40 Jame 1739/40 -DPHV.HU Ker James (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVKRUWFXUYHGVSR 1739/40 James Ker 1739/40 James 'DYLG0LWFKHOO (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWHQJUDYHGXQGHU 1739/40 Dougal Ged Ged 1739/40 Dougal 1739/40 James Ker 1739/40 James 1739/40 James Mitchell Mitchell 1739/40 James Mitchell 1739/40 James YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE 1739/40 James Mitchell Mitchell 1739/40 James

477 Compendium of Scottish Silver 955 #35 YROS ecember 7, 1 1985-181 1985-181 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG Galleries 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV6HSWHPEHU 1, 1981 #459 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ Asprey advertisement advertisement Asprey &KULVWLHV1<86$2FWREHU 1999 #312 Christies March 26, 1980 1980 26, March Christies p18 Silver in Holland Pictured MEQ 1983.28 1983.28 MEQ LWLDOV³,[/ DWFKDVHGZLWK [/5´HDFK WDLOV 'XQGHH0XVHXPDQG$UW UKDQGOHFKDVHGERG\ -%RXUGRQ6PLWK/RQGRQ SRWIODWWHQHGVSKHULFDOERG\ mouth, silver single scroll handle, spreading foot, domed lid with flush hinge, hinge, flush with lid domed foot, spreading handle, scroll single silver mouth, foliage within outline of strap work, floral festoons and pendants below, below, pendants and festoons floral rococo work, strap of outline spreading within son foliage finial, and handle wood spout, neck swan fluted ERUGHUHGIRRWô´KWR]G 5´VKDSHGFLUFXODUVWDQGRQKRRIIHHWPROGHGULPERUGHUIOVLPLODUGHFRUDWLRQHQJUDYHGZLWKEORFNLQLWLDOVRQUHYHUVH³, PDUNHGXQGHUEDVH´KW´GLR]ERWK shell joint, leaf capped double scroll handle, wood insulators, shoulder and and shoulder insulators, wood handle, scroll double capped leaf joint, shell cover flat chased with border of scrolls and flowers, flathinged cover VXUPRXQWHGE\WXUQHGZRRGILQLDOKDQGOHHQJUDYHGZLWKEORFNLQ mixed set with a Lothian sugar bowl and a cream boat, 21oz 21oz boat, cream and a bowl sugar Lothian a with set mixed Dundee Dundee round scrolls and shells, flowers, with chased flat shape, spherical Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh 20oz spherical Teapot, D Christies Edinburgh Edinburgh 21oz spout, curved handle, silver chased, Teapot, Edinburgh a as originally sold fluted, partly spout curved handle, circular silver Teapot, 1981 25, March Christies (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRW³6´VKDSHGVLOYHUKDQGOH $SROOR-DQXDU\ Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell Assayer David Mitchell FD $OH[DQGHU-RKQVWRQ FD $OH[DQGHU-RKQVWRQ 'XQGHH 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVKDSHQRGH 1739/40 Not available available 1739/40 Not 1740 ca 1740 ca Cooper George Aberdeen and ornament scale diaper, with shoulders at chased shape, bullet Teapot, 1739/70 James Mitchelson Mitchelson YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1739/70 James LOCATION SOURCE 1739/40 James Mitchelson Mitchelson 1739/40 James 1739/40 James Mitchelson Mitchelson 1739/40 James (EHQH]HU2OLSKDQW (GLQEXUJK +XJK3HQPDQ 7HDSRWFXUYHGVSRXWVLOYH (GLQEXUJK 7HD 1740 ca 1740 ca Cooper George Aberdeen with spout scroll base, circular spreading on shaped, bullet stand, and Teapot

478 Teapots 6RWKHE\V$SULO p847 Sharp & Wilson Colonial - Collection Hyman G1999-201 Williamsburg 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS Bell Collection, 1961, #10 1961, Collection, Bell Phillips Edinburgh August 24, 24, August Edinburgh Phillips 2001 #629 Christies Glasgow November 16, 16, November Glasgow Christies 1994 #681 Sothebys Gleneagles August 30, 30, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1973 #70c September Castle Blair Sothebys #162 1980 12, ODLUFDWDORJ ³H´´KW R] foot, fluted curved spout, engraved with chased decoration of flowers, foliage, scrolls scrolls foliage, flowers, of decoration chased with anddiaper work, short swanneck, spoutreeded and flutedthe at base, S- VFUROOKDQGOHFDSSHGZLWKIROLDJHPROGHGULPIRRW´KW ZLWKVWDQG´KW KDQGOHIOXWHGGXFNQHFNVSRXWGHFRUDWHGLQURFRFRVW\OH´KW 17oz 17oz with border of scrolls, trellis work, flower heads, foliage, hinged domed lid, lid, domed hinged foliage, heads, flower work, trellis scrolls, of border with engraved base handle, scroll finial, baluster wooden spout, tapering straight ZLWKLQLWLDOV³5 )´PDUNHGRQEDVH*&WULSOHWRZHUJRWKLF floraland fruit clusters andalso shell ornament, lid ahinged vacant cartouche on applied either side,handle, silver scroll double spout, curved molded FKDVHGDVERG\EDOOILQLDOó¶KWR] RUô´KWR]% around rim with diaper work and foliated scrolls, fluted baluster fruitwood fruitwood baluster fluted scrolls, foliated and work diaper with rim around B, gothic small castles, 3 GC, - base under marked handle, wood later finial, ´KWR] Edinburgh Edinburgh handle silver finial, rectangular pierced sides, convex 4 oblong, Teapot, 1996 June Magazine Antiques Glasgow Glasgow foliage, scrolling with chased body, compressed-spherical slightly Teapot, (continued) (continued) 23.9oz motto, and crest Bilsings initials, later with finial, bun &KDUOHV'LFNVRQ,, 1740 ca 1740 ca Tait James Edinburgh lid and shoulder Teapot, 1740ca 1740ca Cooper George Aberdeen castles three d, - GC, marks no details, Teapot, UK collection, Private 1740 ca 1740 ca Cooper George Aberdeen finial, wooden chasing, light handle, silver spout, curved spherical, Teapot, 1740ca 1740ca 1740ca Johnston Alexander Dundee Cooper George no details stand, with Teapot, Aberdeen scroll silver stem, tall on spherical, spoon, mashing and stand with Teapot, UK Collection Private YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION 1740ca - Johan Got-helf SOURCE 1740 ca 1740 ca Cooper George Aberdeen chased flat shoulders foot, spreading stepped form, spherical tapering Teapot, 1740 ca 1740 ca Cooper George Aberdeen circular spreading on spherical, Teapot,

479 Compendium of Scottish Silver Sothebys Scone Palace April 13, 1976 #54 Antiques Rix p13 17 1933 vol Apollo advertisement Edinburgh of How p70 2000 Catalog Shaw Nicholas Sale Scottish the Bonhams National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National Christies June 20, 1973 # 1973 20, June Christies Sothebys April 24, 1958 #96 p35 #96 1958 24, April Sothebys Shrubsole advertisement advertisement Shrubsole #19 1931 16, June Christies Sothebys 1980 #162 1980 #162 6RWKHE\V R] HDWKô´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ Hô´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V%ODLU&DVWOH6HSWHPEHU shape, curved spout, silver handle, crest and motto motto and crest handle, silver spout, curved shape, d chased with decoration of flowers, foliage scrolls scrolls foliage flowers, of decoration with chased d Teapot, spherical, chased at shoulder with fruit, foliage, flowers and scrolls, scrolls, and flowers foliage, fruit, with shoulder at chased spherical, Teapot, OHDIFDSSHGVFUROOKDQGOHGRPHGOLGFXUYHGVSRXWó´KW ³)25*(7127´´KWR] post-1948 sales sales post-1948 motif, sold with a later sugar bowl and cream boat, boat, cream and bowl sugar later a with sold motif, anddiaper work, short swan-neck spout,reeded and fluted at the base,double VFUROOOHDIFDSSHGKDQGOHPROGHGULPIRRW´KWR] in those from different handle, silver decoration, chased spherical, Teapot, floral stylized and flowers with chased collar and shoulder spherical, Teapot, *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWFXUYHGVSRXWZRRGKDQGOHLQLWLDOV³,&´XQGHUQ *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWFXUYHGVSRXWKHDY\ODWHUFKDVLQJVLOYHUKDQGO *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWô´KWR]G /\OH$QQXDO5HYLHZS Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings Bilsings 1740/41 James Mitchell Mitchell Edinburgh 1740/41 James 1740/41 Aytoun William Edinburgh spherical flattened Teapot, 1740/41 James Mitchell Mitchell Edinburgh 1740/41 James 1740/41 James Mitchell Mitchell Edinburgh 1740/41 James YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1740/41 LOCATION Lothian Edward Edinburgh no details Teapot, SOURCE 88 410 vol Magazine Antiques 1740 ca 1740 ca Coline Allan 1740 ca mark IS 1740 ca Aberdeen ca 1740 available Not 19d 21oz scrolls, and shells flowers, with chased spherical, Teapot, Johan Got-helf- 1740 ca Banff #6 1931 15, April Christies Johan Got-helf- 14oz Teapot, spout curved decorated, Teapot, #866 Waldron 1983 p626 Review Silver Lyle 1740 ca Johan Got-helf- 1740 ca 1740 ca Tait James Edinburgh li and shoulder Teapot,

480 Teapots 955 #111 ecember 7, 1 Sothebys Gleneagles August 28, 28, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1975 #64 #297 1963 18, July Sothebys #172 1967 5, July Christies Antiques Havilland de How of Edinburgh 1937 1937 #100 of How Edinburgh Ian McCan Antiques 2004 Antiques Ian McCan #190; 1992 14, October Christies November Edinburgh Christies #725 1993 17-18, Christies Scotland November 25- November Scotland Christies #108 1997 27, Sothebys November 22, 1973 1973 22, November Sothebys #188 Christies April 24, 1968 #93 1968 24, April Christies antiques Havilland de August 23, 2003 #11 #11 2003 23, August WR]G UHVW´KW DGLQJIRRW´KW HUKDQGOHô´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU spout, shoulderand lid chasedround themouth with bunches flowers of and Clarke or Clark James by says catalog scrollwork, and shells in fruit as above teapot, 23.2oz 23.2oz teapot, above as OLGZLWKVFUROOVDQGIROLDJHZRRGKDQGOHFXUYHGVSRXWô´K acorn finial, somewhat later coat of arms in rococo cartouche of Spearman Spearman of cartouche rococo in arms of coat later somewhat finial, acorn LPSDOLQJ

481 Compendium of Scottish Silver Picture files files Picture Hyman Collection-Colonial Collection-Colonial Hyman G1997-11 Williamsburg Sothebys Scone April 14-15, 14-15, April Scone Sothebys 1983 #46 MEQ 180 Christies July 13, 1966 #142 13, 1966 July Christies #193 1968 30, May Sothebys Christies February 9, 1972 #133 #133 9, 1972 February Christies #94 1967 26, January Sothebys 1957.362 1957.362 Sothebys June 20-30 1981 #136 #136 1981 June 20-30 Sothebys #186 1981 22, October Sothebys 1983 p626 Annual Review Lyle Sothebys May 3, 1962 #12 1962 3, May Sothebys AntiquesSimon Kaye #251 1987 June 18, Sothebys Scottish Christies LWKPDVNDQG ò´KWR]DOO FUROOERUGHU XSSHUSDUWRIERG\ KDVHGELUG¶VEHDNVSRXWDUWLFKRNH RXWQRRWKHUGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG FLUFXODUPROGHGIRRW details details Scotland of Museums National finial, cartouches, domed cover, cone finial,loop handle, on spreading base, ó´KWR]G decoration within scrolling foliage, semi fluted curved spout, leaf capped capped leaf spout, curved fluted semi foliage, scrolling within decoration rubbed, mm lid, hinged flush finial, bun base, molded handle, scroll ò´KWR]G and cover chased with flowers and scrolls, with partly fluted curved spout, EDOOILQLDOEHDULQJWRZQPDUNRIWUHHEHOODQGILVKR] FKDVHGZLWKEURDGEDQGRIIUXLWIORZHUVVKHOOVDQGVFUROOV FKDVHGZLWKVKHOOVDQGVFUROOVWHUPLQDWLQJLQDELUG¶VKHDGZ vacant 2 and scrolls, flowers, shells, with chased shoulder handle, scroll shell rococo cartouches,hinged domed lid chased witha band shells of and scrolls, VW\OL]HGEXGILQLDOVWDQGRQVFUROOIHHWPROGHGVKHOODQGV floral ornament, with two vacant cartouches, leaf-capped silver loop handle, handle, loop silver leaf-capped cartouches, vacant two with ornament, floral partly lobed curved spout, on spreading base, flushhinged lid witha band of IODWFKDVHGGHFRUDWLRQEDOOILQLDOô´KWR] rim flat chased with foliage and flowers, ball finial, silver leaf capped single- capped leaf silver finial, ball flowers, and foliage with chased flat rim VFUROOKDQGOHLYRU\LQVXODWRUVZLWKDFUHVWDQGPRWWR´KW FD -DPHV*OHQFD -DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWDUWLFKRNHILQLDOOHDIHQGVS *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUERG\KHDYLO\F 1743 ca 1743 ca Glen James Glasgow 2 vacant blooms, and scrolls with chased flat shape, pear inverted Teapot, 1743 ca 1743 ca available Not Glasgow rococo and fruit flowers, of collar with chased flat shaped, bullet Teapot, FD 5REHUW/XNH-U *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWDOPRVWVSKHULFDOIRUPRQ 1743 ca 1743 ca Glen James Glasgow spout curved foot, molded circular on form, pear inverted stand, and Teapot 1742/43 John Welsh Edinburgh Teapot, no no Welsh Teapot, Edinburgh 1742/43 John 1742/43 Mitchelson James Edinburgh and scroll shells, with rim the below chased flat shape, spherical Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1742/43 LOCATION Lothian Edward Edinburgh and shoulders AG, by probably 1744/45 bowl a sugar with offered Teapot, SOURCE

482 Teapots 2004 2004 ew 1967 vol XI XI 1967 vol ew &KULVWLHV0D\ &KULVWLHV1HJDWLYH vol 133 p6 133 vol %HOODGYHUWLVHPHQW 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYL S advertisement Co & Moffat &KULVWLHV-XQH &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S ($-RQHV%RRN $VKEXUWRQ&ROOHFWLRQSO Collection Farrer p100 Sothebys London June 25, 2003 2003 25, June London Sothebys #316 &KULVWLHV-DQXDU\ MEQ 1186 1186 MEQ SRXWR]G &KULVWLHV0D\ HLQLWLDOV³$(´RQWKHERWWRPIRUWKH HQJUDYHGR]G &KULVWLHV0DUFK $UPVRI0D[ZHOO%DURQHWô´KW 6RWKHE\V0DUFK WVLOYHUKDQGOHFKDVHGò´KWR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ LQDFDUWRXFKHLQLWLDOV³:)6´R] Erskine family, near spherical, chased, silver leaf capped loop handles, semi semi handles, loop capped leaf silver chased, spherical, near family, Erskine fluted curved spout curved spout, silver handle, 20oz 18d 20oz handle, silver spout, curved foot, shell-fluted curved spout, leaf-capped scrollhandle, artichoke finial, ô´KWR] Teapot, no details details no Teapot, Scotland of Museums National Glasgow Glasgow not pictured Teapot, 1954 Magazine Connoisseur (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQDFLUFXODUIRRWSDUWO\IOXWHGV %LOVLQJV $VVD\HU(GZDUG Lothian 1743ca Johan Got-helf- Johan 1743ca -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK :LOOLDP$\WRXQ 1743/44 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVWUDLJKWVSRXW Aytoun William Edinburgh crest 1744/45 finial, cone spout, fluted partly curved handle, silver spherical, Teapot, II Dickson Charles Edinburgh +XJK3HQPDQ no details Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVSRXW p547 Marks Jackson -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWIURPWKH(UVNLQH7HD6HUYLF (GZDUG/RWKLDQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVSRX 1743/44 Lothian Edward Edinburgh fruit, and scrolls flowers, with shoulder the around chased spherical, Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1743 ca LOCATION Glen James Glasgow SOURCE 1743/44 Lothian Edward Edinburgh rising circular on arabesques, of frieze a with body shape, spherical Teapot,

483 Compendium of Scottish Silver '$* ecember 10, 6RWKHE\V6HSWHPEHU #921 1939 Exhibition Glentanar Lord of Provenance Aberdeen Museumsand *DOOHULHV$% *DOOHULHV 6RWKHE\V+RSHWRXQ+RXVH$SULO 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ-XQH Christies D Christies Sothebys Scone Palace April 13, 1976 #131 ò´KW OHDIFDSSHG EDOOILQLDO´KW L 6FRWODQG$UW$FDGHP\ foot, curved spout, cast RZHUVSDUWO\IOXWHGVSRXWR] &KULVWLHV-XO\ VSUHDGLQJIRRWHQJUDYHGZLWK³*%+/´ GHWDLOV0RQRJUDP³-*´EDVHGPDUNHG ed at shoulder with floral and foliate swags, leaf leaf swags, foliate and floral with shoulder at ed GC, three towers, Gothic A A Gothic towers, three GC, R]G ODWHUHQJUDYHGZLWKDFUHVWDQGPRWWRVLOYHUEXWWRQDQGKDQGOH R]G RQKDQGOHRQWKHXQGHUVLGHSDUWIOXWHGFXUYHGVSRXWOLGZLWK silver handle with wood fillets, and joined to body with a mouthless male male mouthless a with body to joined and fillets, wood with handle silver PDVNGRPHGFRYHUZLWKDFRUQFRQHILQLDOò´KWR]G flowerheads, foliage, rococo and 2 vacant cartouches, on spreading foot, foot, spreading on cartouches, vacant 2 and rococo foliage, flowerheads, IROLDWHDQGVKHOOHQFDVHGVSRXWWHUPLQDWLQJLQDVHUSHQW¶VKHDG and chased with shells, scrolls and foliage, shoulder similarly chased, baluster baluster chased, similarly shoulder foliage, and scrolls shells, with chased and ILQLDOWRWKHVOLJKWUDLVHGFRYHUPP5/R] capped silver loop handle, bud finial, part fluted curved spout, spreadingó´KWR] foot, *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWHORQJDWHGVSKHULFDOVKDSHFXUYHGVSRXWó´G *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWELUG¶VEHDNVSRXWò´KW 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ-XQH %LOVLQJV Bilsings 1745ca 1745ca Lothian Edward FD 1745 ca Edinburgh 5REHUW/XNH details no Luke Robert shape, spherical Teapot, *ODVJRZ Glasgow 7HDSRWSHDUVKDSHGFKDVHGZLWKIO decorated spout, curved Teapot, Art and Museum Dundee #132 9, 1972 February Christies 1745 ca 1745 ca Johan Got-helf- 1745 ca Johan Got-helf- FD *HRUJH&RRSHU $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVLOYHUDQGIUXLWZRRGQR 1745 ca 1745 ca Ker James Edinburgh and scrolls, flowers fruit, with chased flat lid hinged body, spherical Teapot, FD -DPHV*OHQ *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWJOREXODUERG\UHVWLQJRQD 1745 ca 1745 ca Glen James Glasgow of band with shoulder at chased body, shaped ogee II, George Teapot, 1745 ca 1745 ca Luke Robert Glasgow molded on form, spherical almost II, George Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1744/45 LOCATION Low Robert Edinburgh chas flat spherical, Teapot, SOURCE

484 Teapots LGHS Noble Collection Collection Noble 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS 6RWKHE\V1<86$-XQH Christies Scotland June 8-9, 1994 1994 8-9, June Scotland Christies 6RWKHE\V-XQH 6RWKHE\V$SULO #1517 Silver Vault IL USA 1994 USA IL Vault Silver 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU /\OH$QQXDO5HYLHZS p387 NY Inc. Sons, & James Graham advertisement USA 3KLOOLSV(GLQEXUJK'HFHPEHU 1997 HGVSRXW ] R]G WKHUVLGHVHPL OGHUDQGOLGVFUROOV DURIIROLDJHURFRFRZRUN ò´KWR]G XUYHGVSRXWFKDVHGUHSDLUHGKLQJH ODWFKDVHGFUHVWDQGPRWWR³:,7++($57 JIRRWFKDVHGDURXQGWKHULPDQGFRYHUZLWK W .RYHO¶V3ULFH*XLGHS HDSRWIROLDWHILQLDOò´K UHSODFHGILQLDOSDUWRIDSLHFHVHW HQFORVLQJFOXVWHUVRIIUXLWDQGVKHOOVYDFDQWFDUWRXFKHVRQHL OREHGVSRXWFRQHILQLDOORRSKDQGOHRQVSUHDGLQJIRRW´KW $1'+$1'´ô´KWR] HQFORVHGEORRPVDERYHDQGHQJUDYHGFUHVWDQGPRWWRIOXWHGFXUY OHDIFDSSHGORRSKDQGOHVSUHDGLQJEDVHEXGILQLDO´KWR shells, scrolls and foliage, partly fluted curved spout, leaf capped scroll scroll capped leaf spout, curved fluted partly foliage, and scrolls shells, KDQGOHRUEILQLDOROGUHSDLUWREDVH´KWR] and scrolls around the flush hinged lid, bud finial, part fluted leaf capped capped leaf fluted part finial, lid, bud hinged flush the around and scrolls VLOYHUORRSKDQGOHRQVSUHDGLQJGRPHIRRW C-scroll and foliate detail, circular lid, integral hinge, bud finial, leaf capped capped leaf finial, bud hinge, integral lid, circular detail, foliate and C-scroll KDQGOHDQGVSRXWFUHVWUHSDLUWRWKHIRRWR] HQGLQJVSRXWò´KWR] (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDO*HRUJH,,IODWFKDVHGDWWKHVKRX Edinburgh Teapot, spherical, flushhinged lid, surround flat chased witha band of scroll (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDO*HRUJH,,IODWFKDVHGZLWKDFROO Edinburgh Teapot, spherical, on circular pedestal foot, circular body with partly chased Assayer Hugh *RUGRQ Assayer Hugh *RUGRQ Assayer Hugh *RUGRQ Assayer Hugh *RUGRQ 1746/47 Edward Lothian Lothian 1746/47 Edward 1746/47 Robert Low Low 1746/47 Robert +XJK*RUGRQ -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWR] (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVLOYHUKDQGOHF .RYHO¶V3ULFH*X 1746/47 Edward Lothian Lothian 1746/47 Edward 1746/47 Lothian Edward Low 1746/47 Robert Edinburgh spout curved handle, loop silver spherical, Teapot, 5REHUW/RZ (GLQEXUJK 54 vol 1948 Magazine Antiques 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVSRXWI +XJK*RUGRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWEXOOHWVKDSHRQVSUHDGLQ (GZDUG/RWKLDQ (GLQEXUJK 7 YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1745/46 LOCATION Lothian Edward Edinburgh leaf curved crest, finial, button handle, wood chased, spherical, Teapot, SOURCE

485 Compendium of Scottish Silver 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV6HSWHPEHU &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ1RYHPEHU 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ)HEUXDU\ 1989 #348 #91 1989 July 11, Christies /\OH6LOYHU5HYLHZS 6RWKHE\V$XJXVW #189 &KULVWLHV$SULO p564 KDFDQWKXVOHDI VLOYHUEXWWRQ KLQJHGOLGIODWFKDVHG XWHGFXUYHGVSRXW XSSHUERG\DQGKLQJHGOLG UFXODUIRRW RWPDUNHGEDVHô´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V1<86$2FWREHU R]G 6RWKHE\V'HFHPEHU ZLWKVFUROOVDQGRWKHUPRWLIVVLOYHUKDQGOHZLWKLYRU\ILOOHUV ZURQJGDWHXQGHUVLGHHQJUDYHGZLWKLQLWLDOV³$6´ R]G chased with flower heads and foliate scrolls enclosing to each side a vacant a vacant side each to enclosing scrolls foliate and heads flower with chased URFRFRFDUWRXFKHSDUWO\IOXWHGFXUYHGVSRXWVFUROOKDQGOHZLW WKXPESLHFHEXGILQLDOò´KWR] scrolls below the rim, leap capped loop handle, part lobed curved spout, on on spout, curved lobed part handle, loop capped leap rim, the below scrolls VSUHDGLQJEDVHGRPHOLGZLWKEXGILQLDOò´KWR] finial, artichoke lid, hinged dome handle, scroll capped leaf spout, curved crest, with engraved arabesques, of frieze a with chased each cover and body ó´R] finial, artichoke lid, hinged domed handle, scroll capped leaf spout, curved crest, with engraved arabesques, of frieze a with chased each cover and body ô´KWR] spreading on spout, curved fluted finial, bud motifs, foliate and rococo with EDVHô´KWR]G shoulder and cover chased with flowers and scrolls, cone finial, 19oz 10d 19oz finial, cone and scrolls, flowers with chased cover and shoulder Edinburgh Teapot, inverted pear shape, flat chased with band of flowers, shells and Edinburgh rising fluted foot, shell circular a rising on shape, pear inverted Teapot, Edinburgh rising fluted shell foot, circular rising on shaped, pear inverted Teapot, Edinburgh cover the around chased flat crest, with engraved body, shaped pear Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRQVSUHDGLQJIRRWFRPSUHVVHGVSKHULFDOERG\ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDORQFLUFXODUPROGHGIRRWSDUWO\IO $VVD\HU+XJK Gordon Hugh Assayer Gordon Hugh Assayer Gordon Hugh Assayer Gordon Gilchrist William $VVD\HU'RXJDO*HG $VVD\HU+XJK Gordon Oliphant (EHQH]HU2OLSKDQW 1747/48 Ebenezer Oliphant 1747/48 Ebenezer Oliphant 1747/48 Ebenezer 1748/49 (EHQH]HU2OLSKDQW *1740 ca (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRFUHVWò´KW +XJK*RUGRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWEXOOHWVKDSHRQGRPHGFL 1746/47 Edward Lothian Lothian 1746/47 Edward YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1746/47 LOCATION II Dickson Charles Edinburgh no details Teapot, SOURCE 74 vol 1958 Magazine Antiques &KDUOHV'LFNVRQ,, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWFKDVHGUHSDLUHGIR

486 Teapots Antiques Magazine December p746 84 1963 vol advertisement Bell 118 vol Magazine Antiques p 197 Robinson NYadvertisement Christies March 25, 1936 #40 #40 1936 25, March Christies #107 28, 1936 July Christies Collection How Phillips Edinburgh March, 20, 20, March, Edinburgh Phillips 1987 #124 23, 1996 May Scotland Christies #529 1975 London Spink 20, October USA NY Christies 1998 1978 6RWKHE\V$SULO R] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ6SULQJ 20oz 20oz finial acorn handle, or 20oz 2d or 20oz figure between, 20oz 13d 13d 20oz between, figure foliage to upper body and hinged lid, silver knop finial, partly fluted spout spout fluted partly finial, knop silver lid, hinged and body upper to foliage figures, 2 male by arms supported of coat with engraved handle, loop and 1697, in born Braco, and Dipple of Duff for William Duff of those are arms probably 1759, Fife of Earl 1735 and Kilbryde of Braco Baron created DVVLJQHGWRWKHZURQJ\HDUVKRXOGEHó´KWR] with insulators, shoulder flat chased between with vacant figure cartouches IM on finial, each side, pinecone with cover rococo, and foliage scrolls, PP´KWR]G with foliate scrolls and rococo on a matted ground, 2 vacant cartouches, cartouches, vacant 2 ground, matted a on rococo and scrolls foliate with spreading base, leaf capped loop handle, fluted curved spout, cone finial, ò´KWR]G Edinburgh Teapot, inverted pear shape, curved fluted spout,leaf cap circular silver Edinburgh Teapot, spherical, on circular domed foot, plainlower body, chased with Edinburgh handle scroll capped leaf base, stepped spreading on shaped, bullet Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWFKDVHGGHFRUDWLRQò´IURPVSRXWWRKDQGOH Edinburgh Teapot, inverted pear shape, chased on the shoulder and domed edge of cover James McKenzie or I James Mitchelson Assayer Hugh Gordon Ebenezer Oliphant Assayer Dougal Ged Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon 1748/49 rectangle a in IM 1748/49 Aytoun William 1748/49 Edinburgh Lothian Edward 4d 19oz chased, foot, high Teapot, Edinburgh spout, fluted curved handle, chased, loop silver shape, pear inverted Teapot, #50 27, 1932 July Christies 1748/49 *1740 Mitchell 1748/49 James Oliphant 1748/49 Ebenezer 1748/49 Dempster Ker & 1748/49 Mitchell James Edinburgh 14d 22oz either between, figure IM mm shoulder, chased spherical, Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1748/49 LOCATION Mitchell James Edinburgh IM mm border, floral chased contemporary body, plain spherical, Teapot, SOURCE

487 Compendium of Scottish Silver Nicholas Shaw Catalog 1999 p63 1999 Catalog Shaw Nicholas Winter Catalog, Shaw Nicholas p70 2000, #111 1984 26, April Sothebys #144 1960 28, April Sothebys #209 1973 22, March Sothebys J Bourdon-Smith #110 1962 12, July Sothebys Collection Noble 1988 #68 Nicholas Shaw Catalog Winter Winter Catalog Shaw Nicholas 2001 p71 KLQJHGOLGSLQHDSSOHILQLDO´KWR]G spout, curved lobed part foliage, with lid domed cartouches, rococo vacant 2 VSUHDGLQJEDVHEXGILQLDOó´KWR]G rim molded on finial, cone with lid domed spout, curved fluted semi sprays, IRRW´KWô´GLR]G scroll, scale work and shell ornaments, with circular a vacant molded cartouche handle, on either side, capped leaf finial, bud lid, domed slightly hinged IRRWò´KWR]G decoration, swanneck spout,leaf cappedhandle, cone finial, onrim foot, (Note: should a different be maker since Rollo was no longer active atthis SRLQW ´KWR]G hinged lid, pineapple finial, engraved on body with contemporary coat of of coat contemporary with body on engraved finial, pineapple lid, hinged DUPVRI1LFKROVRQ´KW´ORQJR] Edinburgh Edinburgh and scrolls, flowers, with chased flat body upper shape, pear inverted Teapot, Edinburgh Teapot, inverted pear shaped body, chased with scrolls, shells, floraland fruit Edinburgh sprays, floral with chased body, shape pear inverted of part upper Teapot, Edinburgh rococo and flowers swags, fruit with chased crest, with shape, bullet Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh spout, curved partly base, circular domed squat, slightly spherical, Teapot, William Davie Davie William Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon James McKenzie or I James Mitchelson Assayer Hugh Gordon Assayer Hugh Gordon 1749/50 or Dempster William 1749/50 Dempster Ker & 1749/50 rectangle a in IM Rollo 1749/50 John 1749/50 1749/50 Aytoun William Lothian Edward Edinburgh 1749/50 19d 19oz shoulder, 1750 ca the over Edinburgh chased spout, fluted Teapot, Lothian Edward 15d 21oz shoulder, on chased shaped, vase Teapot, Glen James Edinburgh no details Teapot, Glasgow #80 1906 28, June Christies no details Teapot, #8 1943 24, November Christies p548 Marks Jackson April House Hopetoun Sothebys YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1748/49 LOCATION 1749/50 Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh Dempster Ker & 10d 23oz chased, spherical, Teapot, SOURCE #64 25, 1938 May Christies 1749/50 Welsh James Edinburgh body, the around chasing flat with decorated shape, pear inverted Teapot,

488 Teapots 1992 #100 1992 #100 I6FRWODQG D]LQHYRO '$* VHXPDQG$UW HV &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ-XO\ Christies October 25, 1989 #193 1989 25, October Christies Bell Collection, 1961, #16 1961, Collection, Bell #17 1961, Collection, Bell *DOOHUL 0(4 *DOOHULHV$% &KULVWLHV-XO\ 0(4 Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2001 p68 2001 Catalog Shaw Nicholas %HOODGYHUWLVHPHQW KWZR FKRNHILQLDO ´KWR] HFHVó´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ò´KW QHFNVSRXWGHFRUDWHGLQURFRFRVW\OH´KW R]G VFULSWLQLWLDO³/´ò´KWR] *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVR 1751/52 James Welsh Edinburgh heavy handle, on silver leaf floral chased Teapot, 1994 London I Franklin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ca LOCATION 1750 ca available Not Coline Allan Aberdeen 3 pi of set handle, wood shape, pear inverted Teapot, Scottish be to said finial, bird decorated, Teapot, SOURCE 867 p Waldron

489 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1959 #? #? 1959 ecember 9 Finlay 1991 #93 1991 Finlay 6RWKHE\V0DUFK #39 1974 31, October Sothebys Scotland of Museums National 0(4 /\OH6LOYHU5HYLHZS 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1994 #132 Christies D Christies 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ -DFNVRQ0DUNVS MEQ 29 Sothebys November 11 1993 1993 11 November Sothebys #443 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1994 #137 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ Robinson NYadvertisement ZLWKWKH foot, the upper part of the body ODWHUHQJUDYHGLQLWLDO³5´ò´KWR] sprays and scrolls, the also body with armorial engraved cartouches headed by lions masks, bud finial, on spreading foot, with curved partly-fluted handle, loop silver leaf-capped and spout the to finial bud fillets, later with handle loop silver leaf-capped scrolls, GRPHGIOXVKKLQJHGOLGRQVSUHDGLQJIRRWHQJUDYHG³.)´ERG\ FRPSDUDWLYHO\VPDOOIRRWô´KWR]G SRVVLEO\EHWKDWRI-DPHV*OHQ¶VZLGRZ chased with flowers, fruit and scrolls, with fluted curved spout, and cone ILQLDOó´KWR]G rococo scrolls enclosing plain cartouches on each side, leaf-capped silver KDQGOHFRQHILQLDODQGULEEHGVZDQQHFNVSRXWò´KWR] hinge,half-fluted curved spout, of wooden arms loop handle with cartouche, a thumb-piece, strap-work foliate and a brickwork within armorials *RUGRQLPSDOLQJ%URGLH´KWR] Teapot, no details details no Teapot, Scotland of Museums National Edinburgh Edinburgh and flowers foliage, with shoulders the at chased body, pear inverted Teapot, Edinburgh Teapot, inverted pear shape, the shouldersreposed with flowers sprays and Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Teapot, 91 p22 vol Magazine Antiques James McKenzie or James Mitchelson Robertson Robertson William Davie Davie William 1754/55 rectangle a in IM 1754/55 Dempster and Ker Edinburgh floral with chased lid, hinged flush domed body, shaped pear inverted Teapot, 1753 ca 1753 ca Glen James 1753/54 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh Glasgow handle, silver spout, curved bird finial, body, rectangular Teapot, 1752/53 Lothian and 1752/53 Lothian 1752/53 Ged Dougal Edinburgh molded on shape, pear inverted Teapot, 1752-55ca 1752-55ca Glen James Glasgow may punch, engrailed an in S GLS, mark, town GLN, - marks Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1752/53 LOCATION or Dempster William SOURCE 1752/53 Dempster and Ker Edinburgh flush and lid flat foot, circular molded on spherical compressed Teapot,

490 Teapots 6KUXEVROH1<86$ (0 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU 6RWKHE\V1<86$$SULO 1994 #291 &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ2FWREHU #154 Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1974 #128 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ /DXGHU6DOH0D\ 6RWKHE\V+RSHWRXQ+RXVH0DUFK #125 1984 27, Sale Scottish The Bonhams #13 2003 21, August LRWD ´´KWR]DOO rd forearm fess-ways holding a cross, a cross, holding fess-ways forearm nd ULQJF\OLQGULFDOERG\RQWXFNHGLQEDVH ò´KWR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS RG\FKDVHGRQVKRXOGHUZLWKIORZHUVIROLDJH XGILQLDOXSSHUERG\FKDVHGZLWKIORZHUVDQG QGPRWWRSDUWRIDVHWGDWHDOVRJLYHQDVIRU LOOHJLEOHFUHVW±DPDLOHGIRUHDUPFODVSLQJDGDJJHU th cross, crosslets,4 rd URXQGPROGHGIRRWò´KWR] fruit, shell and scroll cartouches, curved fluted spout, hinged lid, foliate finial, finial, foliate lid, hinged spout, fluted curved cartouches, scroll and shell fruit, PROGHGULPIRRWR] scrolls, leaf capped silver loop handle, partly fluted curved spout, domed domed spout, curved fluted partly handle, loop silver capped leaf scrolls, FRYHU] simplerim foot, straight motto, tapering and crest spouthandle, with loop hinged capped flap, plain domed uninsulated lid, short urn finial, ò´KW cartouches, onelater engraved with initials, curved fluted spout, lid with appliedhinge, silver bun finial, probably wrong date,Thomas Leslie possiblyDVDUHWDLOHULIGDWHLVFRUUHFWô´KWR]DOO with asymmetrical scroll cartouches, one enclosing a crest, motto and initials, initials, and motto a crest, enclosing one cartouches, scroll asymmetrical with curved fluted part finial, bud with lid domed foliage, and flowers by flanked spout, capped woodenloop handle, spreading foot, laterinscribed on the XQGHUVLGH³7R6LU+DUU\DQG/DG\/DXGHUIURP/RUG /DG\)RUWHY remembrance of a happy evening, June 3 June evening, happy a of remembrance the set insulated silver handle, engraved with coat of arms, crest and motto, Arms Arms motto, and crest arms, of coat with engraved handle, silver insulated 2 rampant, lion first, quarterly - (worn) PRWWR³3HUPDUHSHUWHUUDP´ 3 Edinburgh Teapot, The Harry LauderTeapot, inverted pear shape, chasedthe at shoulder -DPHV0LWFKHOVRQRU -DPHV0F.HQ]LH, 1757/58 Gordon Robert Edinburgh lip, around decoration scroll and floral chased shape, pear inverted Teapot, .HU 'HPSVWHU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHGE ,0LQDUHFWDQJOH -RKQ&ODUN (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWXQXVXDOGHVLJQSODLQWDSH FD 'DYLG:DUQRFN .HU 'HPSVWHU *ODVJRZ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOVLOYHUKDQGOH 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHE 1754/55 Leslie Thomas Edinburgh and scrolls clusters, flower with relief low in chased near spherical, Teapot, $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWLQDFDVHFUHVWD YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1754/55 LOCATION Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh original scrolls, and flowers fruit, with chased shape, pear inverted Teapot, SOURCE

491 Compendium of Scottish Silver Christies June 24, 1986 #161 1986 24, June Christies Christies September 28, 1994, 1994, 28, September Christies #40 1961.1674 604 MEQ Bell of Aberdeen 1961 #18 1961 Aberdeen of Bell Colonial - Collection Hyman Williamsburg 1996 June Magazine Antiques p842 #6 Phillips Edinburgh May 18, 1990 1990 18, May Edinburgh Phillips #49 IV 1955 vol Review Art Scottish #4 advertisement Aberdeen of Bell Finlay 1991 #81 1991 Finlay Collection Private Finlay 1991 #93 1991 Finlay th floral, fruit and foliate foliate and fruit floral, th foot, partly fluted spout,hinged e, decorated with scroll, flowers and foliage in the the in foliage and flowers scroll, with decorated e, shape, upper part chased wi chased part upper shape, apot, part of a tea service, no details details no service, tea a of part apot, Scotland of Museums National spout, flame finial, flush hinged domed lid, leaf capped plain loop handle, handle, loop plain capped leaf lid, domed hinged flush finial, flame spout, ´KWR] domed lid, bud finial, leaf capped silver loop handle, engraved coat of arms in in arms of coat engraved handle, loop silver capped leaf finial, bud lid, domed DURFRFRFDUWRXFKHDUPRI+RSHRI+RSHWRXQó´KWR] RUQDWHFDVWVSRXWDQGKDQGOHó´KW rococo style, domed lid with flushhinge and silver finial, fluted spout, silver handle decoration, scrollhandle, molded circular foot, one vacant cartouche, other with 2 crests for Robertsonand McDonald, sold witha cream same jug by both probably 24.7oz maker 1763/64, chased shoulders, silverhandle flat lid, button finial, crest and motto motto and crest finial, button lid, flat capped loop handle, curved spout spout curved handle, loop capped Edinburgh Teapot, part a piece of 3 service of differentdates, inverted pear shape, William Davie Davie William 1759/60 1759/60 Robertson Lothian & Edinburgh available Not no details Teapot, Edinburgh circular spreading on spherical, Teapot, p548 Marks Jackson 1759/60 Robertson & Lothian 1759/60 Edinburgh Dempster Ker & Te Edinburgh curved fluted foot, circular spreading on shape, pear inverted plain Teapot, 1759/60 Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh finial, pelican Dunlop, of motto and crest chased, heavily square, Teapot, 1758/59 or Dempster William 1758/59 Ker Daniel Edinburgh shap pear inverted Teapot, 1758/59 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh pear inverted Teapot, 1758/59 1758/59 Robertson Lothian & Edinburgh Gordon Robert no details Teapot, Edinburgh handle, wooden spout, curved slightly shape, drum cylindrical , plain Teapot, p548 Marks Jackson YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1758/59 LOCATION Robertson & Lothian Edinburgh acanthus chasing, silver heavy with shoulder shape, pear inverted Teapot, SOURCE

492 Teapots st %RQKDP¶V7KH6FRWWLVK6DOH $XJXVW Scotland of Museums National . 6RWKHE\V-XQH AntiquesSimon Kaye &KULVWLHV0D\ 6RWKHE\V-XQH Antiques Havilland de 6RWKHE\V$SULO" J Bourdon-Smith, London Shreve advertisement advertisement Shreve 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW &KULVWLHV-DQXDU\ &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU LQDOIODWKLQJHG ´KWR] R] VHGFRQHILQLDOFUHVWR]G &KULVWLHV-XO\ VHGZLWKIROLDJHDQGVFUROOVYDFDQWFDUWRXFKH GRPHGFKDVHGFRYHUSLQHDSSOHILQLDOKDQGOH/RQGRQFD ´KWR] scrolls, partly fluted curved spout, slightly domed cover, bud finial, engraved engraved finial, bud cover, domed slightly spout, curved fluted partly scrolls, initial an with round the mouth, leaf-capped silver loop handle, half-scroll curved spout, spout, curved half-scroll handle, loop silver leaf-capped mouth, the round EOXVWHUVLOYHUNQRSò´KWR] IORZHUVFXUYHGIOXWHGVSRXWELUGILQLDOLQLWLDOHGò´KW OLGOHDGFDSSHG&VFUROOKDQGOHó´KWR] ZLWKIORUDOIHVWRRQVSDUWO\IOXWHGVSRXWZLWKGXFN¶VKHDGWHUP VFUROOKDQGOHIODWOLGLQLWLDO³%´EHORZD%DURQ¶VFRURQHW IOXVKOLGEDOOILQLDOFUHVWDQGPRWWRR] $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ-XQH Edinburgh Edinburgh and leafage scrolls, of band chased body, shaped pear inverted Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh and chased repoussed parts lower and upper body, cylindrical Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh capped leaf spout, curved swags, fruit with chased shaped, drum Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Teapot, 39 p54 vol Magazine Antiques Edinburgh Teapot, bombe form, sides chased with floral festoons, curved spout,hinged over striking another another striking over possibly Jamespossibly 2OLSKDQW Robertson Robertson William Davie Davie William William Dempster Dempster William Robertson Robertson 1760 ca 1760 ca Gordon J & Roger G FD %D\QH 1DSLHU 1RWDYDLODEOH *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHFKD 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHYRO ,2 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDOEDOXVWHUERG\FKD /RWKLDQDQG :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1760/61 LOCATION or Davie William SOURCE 1760ca 1760ca Warnock David Glasgow band narrow a with engraved lightly lid, domed body, near-spherical Teapot, /RWKLDQDQG 1763/64 Dempster & Ker Edinburgh and foliage flowers, with chased body upper foot, molded on circular, Teapot,

493 Compendium of Scottish Silver Apollo July 1940 vol 32 p29 #10 p29 32 1940 vol July Apollo Sothebys November 29, 1984 1984 29, November Sothebys #250 OctoberSothebys NY USA 28, 1980 #525 Sothebys June , 1959 #7 , 1959 June Sothebys Antiques Kaye Simon MEQ 53 Sothebys ?? #195 ?? Sothebys #155 24, 1972 May Christies Sothebys June 20, 1974 #189 #189 1974 June 20, Sothebys #143 1975 3, March Sothebys MEQ 53 Sale Sothebys #146 #116 22, 1957 February Christies chased with flowerheads below rim, rim, below flowerheads with chased WR]G 6RWKHE\V1RYHPEHU 25oz 25oz ´KWR] ORRSKDQGOHFXUYHGIOXWHGVSRXWô´KWR] ULPIRRWò´KWR] leaf-capped loop handle, lobed and fluted curved spout, domed decorated lid, lid, decorated domed spout, curved and fluted lobed handle, loop leaf-capped EXGILQLDODUPRULDOVò´KWR] ILQLDOVSUHDGLQJEDVHô´KWR] Teapot, no details details no Teapot, Scotland of Museums National Teapot, inverted pear shape, body flat flat body shape, pear inverted Teapot, gh gh details no acquisition, early Teapot, Scotland of Museums National Edinburgh Edinburgh shaped pear inverted Teapot, 1982 p116 Review Silver Lyle William Davie Davie William 1765 ca 1765 ca Wildgoose James Aberdeen finial, pineapple handle, curved handle, silver shape, pear inverted Teapot, FD $GDP*UDKDP1765/66 Gilliland James *ODVJRZ Edinburgh 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHô´K spout, curved cover, separate flat form, cylindrical tapered, straight, Teapot, 1765ca 1765ca Graham Adam Glasgow silver finial, bud wrapped leaf lid, domed plain, shape, pear inverted Teapot, 1765ca 1765ca Warnock David Glasgow finial, bird with lid handle, lead-capped spout, curved form, spherical Teapot, 1765ca Adam Graham Graham Glasgow Adam 1765ca 1765ca Adam Graham Graham Glasgow Adam 1765ca 1765 ca 1765 ca or Dempster William 1765ca Graham Adam Glasgow bud spout, fluted curved sprays, floral and scroll shape, pear inverted Teapot, 1765 ca 1765 ca Oliphant Ebenezer Edinburgh 20oz Teapot, p626 1983 Annual Review Lyle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1764/65 LOCATION Ker & Gilliland Edinburgh 14d 29oz chased, shape, pear inverted Teapot, SOURCE 1955 11, November Christies 1764/65 1764/65 Ker & Gilliland Ker & Gilliland Edinburgh Edinbur stand with Teapot, 92 p2 vol 1980 November Apollo

494 Teapots 1984 p753 atalog 2002 2002 atalog & '$* Christies Sale Sale Christies Christies Glasgow November 21, 21, November Glasgow Christies 1989 #52 Christies June 3, 1959 #142 #142 1959 3, June Christies #158 1975 10, April Sothebys Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1974 #89 Antiques Moffat Muirhead Aberdeen Museumsand *DOOHULHV$% p22 #44 p22 #44 Christies February 27, 1957 #? #? 27, 1957 February Christies Christies London February 22, February London Christies #333 #5839, 2005 Sale MEQ 1185 1185 MEQ ´KWR] ,*FURVVHV$%' VSRXWR] &KULVWLHV-XQH WKSXOORIIFRYHUEULJKWFXWGHFRUDWLRQR] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK KDQGOHVWUDLJKWVSRXWó´KWR]G 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ foot, partly fluted curved spout, upper part of body chased with wooden handle handle wooden with Scotland of Museums National cartouche, wriggle work borderto each side, partly fluted leaf capped spout, GRPHFRYHUEXGILQLDOVFUROOKDQGOHZLWKVSXUWKXPESLHFH with fruit, flowers and foliage, domed lid, bud finial, leaf capped silver scroll scroll silver capped leaf finial, bud lid, domed foliage, and flowers fruit, with KDQGOHò´KWR]G with flowers, shellsandrococo cartouches, one engraved with monogram, FRYHUZLWKFRQHILQLDOR]G clusters, scrolls and foliage, domed lid, bird finial, leaf capped fluted spout, spout, fluted capped leaf finial, bird lid, domed foliage, and scrolls clusters, SRVVLEO\LYRU\LQVXODWRUVò´KWR]G GR GR VSRXWFKDVHGGHFRUDWLRQR]IRUERWKLWHPV with bud finial, part chased with fruit, foliage, 2 vacant rococo cartouches, cartouches, rococo vacant 2 foliage, fruit, with chased part finial, bud with ó´GLR] $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVLOYHUDQGIUXLWZRRGQRGHWDLOVEDVHPDUNHG :HHPV (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWR] /\OH$QQXDO5HYLHZ George Roper Roper George -DPHV:HOVK (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDOIRRWVKDSHGFXUYHG 1767/68 James -DPHV*LOOLODQG (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWEDUUHOVKDSHGZRRGHQ 1766/67 Taylor William Edinburgh oval vacant with body base, circular molded on shaped, pear Teapot, 1766/67 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh chased shoulders motto, and crest with engraved body, shaped pear Teapot, 1766/67 Welsh John Edinburgh molded on Teapot, 1766/67 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh flower and fruit with shoulders at chased body, shaped pear inverted Teapot, 1766ca 1766ca and Gordon James -DPHV2OLSKDQW (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHGWHDSRWZL 1765/66 Ker and Gilliland Edinburgh curved fluted foot, molded circular shape, pear inverted stand, with Teapot, 1765/66 Dempster Ker & Edinburgh cover spout, and handle scroll foot, spreading shape, pear inverted Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1765 ca LOCATION Wildgoose James Aberdeen 3 feet, on Teapot, SOURCE

495 Compendium of Scottish Silver d Q '$* 0DJD]LQHYRO HV *DOOHULHV$% DFTXLUHG *DOOHUL )HEUXDU\ 6RWKHE\V1<86$2FWREHU 6RWKHE\V6FRQH3DODFH$SULO 6RWKHE\V%ODLU&DVWOH6HSWHPEHU 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZYRO9, p41 #4 %HOORI$EHUGHHQDGYHUWLVHPHQW Exhibition #896 Exhibition 6WLUOLQJ0D[ZHOO&ROOHFWLRQ vol 94 p138 94 vol LWKDIDLQW FRURQHW´KW ´KWR] RPHGFRYHUVZDQ HULPSDUWIOXWHG QHGILQLDOR]G &KULVWLHV)HEUXDU\ KDVHGZLWKLUUHJXODU GILQLDO :LOOLDP:DOWHU$QWLTXHV/RQGRQ GDUNZRRGQRGHWDLOVEDVHPDUNHG-:$%' $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVD L 6FRWODQG$UW$FDGHP\ DLOVQRGDWHSURYLGHG 'XQGHH0XVHXPDQG$UW HVKRXOGHUFKDVHGZLWKVFUROOVIORZHUVDQG FXUYHGVSRXWHQJUDYHGR] &KULVWLHV0DUFK QHFNHGVSRXWUHSDLUHGULPRYDOSHGHVWDOIRRWODWHUILQLDO EDQGRIEORVVRPVVFUROOVDQGURFRFRZRUNFDUWRXFKHVRQHZ FUHVWDQGPRWWRò´KWR] FXUYHGVSRXWORRSKDQGOHOLGZLWKLQLWLDO³%´EHORZD&DURQ¶V R]DOO IROLDJHGRPHGOLGZLWKEXGILQLDOVLOYHUORRSKDQGOHR] (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDOFKDVHGZLWKIORZHUVDQGVFUROOVJDGURR (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDOERPEHIRUPFKDVHGURFRFRGHFRUDWLRQG (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDOLQYHUWHGSHDUXSSHUERG\UHVWUDLQHGO\F (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHGFKDVHGZLWKIUXLWVZDJVEHORZWK :LOOLDP'DYLH :LOOLDP'DYLH :LOOLDP'DYLH :LOOLDP'DYLH :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU FD -DPHV:LOGJRRVH $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVPDOOVL]HVLOYHUDQG :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU FD 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWZLWKDVWDQGQRGHW :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU -DPHV+HZLWW (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHZRR 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK :LOOLDP'HPSVWHURU 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV 7HDSRWSODLQF\OLQGULFDO $QWLTXHV $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDS YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1767/68 LOCATION James Welsh Edinburgh oval Teapot, SOURCE 1934 Magazine Connoisseur 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHGò´G

496 Teapots , W NY USA 38.21.14 USA NY 1993 London Bourdon-Smith J 1981 #243 Scottish Art Review, 1956 vol vol 1956 Review, Art Scottish #1 VI, p41 advertisement Aberdeen of Bell Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 p91 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1990 #32 1990 #32 #55 Exhibition 1939 #978 #978 1939 Exhibition Collection Noble L1980.3 MEQ foot, curved spout,domed cover, WOLJKWFKDVLQJò´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V1<86$2FWREHU QIHHWIORUDOVSUD\Vò´KW 6FRWODQG$UW$FDGHP\ GRPHGKLQJHGOLGó´KWô´ORQJ 0HWURSROLWDQ0XVHXPRI$U Teapot, inverted pear shape shape pear inverted Teapot, Scotland of Museums National but probably made by either William Dempster or William Davie Davie William or Dempster William either by made probably but foliage with vacant cartouches, domed lid with bud finial, silver leaf capped capped leaf silver finial, bud with lid domed cartouches, vacant with foliage 22oz spout, fluted half curved handle, loop ô´KWR] Edinburgh Edinburgh Drummond William by made be to said form, 1730 circa spherical, Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Teapot, p549 Marks Jackson or William Dempster Taylor Taylor 1771/72 1771/72 Edmond David Davie William WD Edinburgh -DPHV'HPSVWHU no details Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVSRX p549 Marks Jackson *LOOLODQGDQG.HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRW,QYHUWHGSHDUVKDSH 1771/72 George & William 1771/72 Taylor William Edinburgh and flowers, scrolls, with chased shoulder shape, pear inverted Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1770 ca LOCATION Campbell & Milne Glasgow not pictured Teapot, SOURCE August Gleneagles Sothebys 1770 ca 1770 ca Campbell & Milne 1770 ca Glasgow FD Graham Adam 21oz handle, silver spout, curved spherical, Teapot, -DPHV:LOGJRRVH Glasgow $EHUGHHQ set mixed a with Teapot, 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHR 1977 19, April Scone Sothebys #18 23, 1962 May Christies 1770 ca 1770 1770 ca James Wildgoose Campbell & Milne Aberdeen 1770 ca Glasgow details no Teapot, Graham Adam Glasgow pedestal edge, beaded shape, urn Teapot, #208 Book Christies Clayton

497 Compendium of Scottish Silver 3LFWXUH)LOHV XQ+RXVH0D\ U\ YROS S 0(4DE 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ %RQKDP¶V6DOH 6RWKHE\V-XQH London Garrards, 6RWKHE\V1<86$-XQH &KULVWLHV6FRWWLVK %HOORI$EHUGHHQ #214 G 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW VKURRPILQLDORQ &KULVWLHV-XQH WKHUGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG GERG\ZRRGILQLDO -%RXUGRQ6PLWK HFHVHUYLFHRYDOLQYHUWHGSHDUIRUP 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ DFDQWKXVFDSSHGVFUROOKDQGOHELUGILQLDO´KWR] PROGHGVSUHDGLQJIRRWô´KWR]G VSRXWVFUROOHGZRRGKDQGOHô´KWR] (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRW'UXPVKDSHGVWUDLJKWVSRXWô´KWR] (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOFXUYHGVSRXWHDUO\VW\OHR]G (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVSKHULFDOLYRU\KDQGOHSRVVLEO\UHSODFHGPX Edinburgh tapered straight cover, flat crest, later swags, engraved form, oval Teapot, Edinburgh no details Teapot, Holland p21 (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHò´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V+RSHWR (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHò´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V)HEUXD (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHZRRGKDQGOHR] $SROOR-XO\ William Dempster Dempster William 6RQ 6RQ Davie William Davie William William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William William Davie Davie William FD -DPHV0F(ZDQ :LOOLDP'DYLHRU *ODVJRZ $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU 7HDSRWSDUWRIDSL (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDOEDVHVTXDUH 1774/75 Alexander Aitchison Aitchison 1774/75 Alexander $OH[DQGHU$LWFKLVRQ 1774/75 or Dempster William 1774/75 or Dempster William 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHGQRIXU -DPHV:HOVK (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV -DFNVRQ0DUNV YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1772/73 LOCATION or Dempster William SOURCE 1772/73 or Dempster William 1772/73 or Dempster William 1773/74 Ziegler Alexander Edinburgh flowers, and fruit with chased foot, domed shape, pear inverted Teapot,

498 Teapots al al ale, ale, V Museum, Hyman Collection-Coloni Hyman 6RWKHE\V1<86$)HEUXDU\ How of Edinburgh, 1937, #103 1937, Edinburgh, of How 26, January Wallis & Woolley Finlay 1991 #97 1991 Finlay MEQ 902 1968.3464 1935, #126 #126 1935, (GLQEXUJK++ 6KUHYHDGYHUWLVHPHQW Lt. Col. Hay Collection Collection Hay Col. Lt. Williamsburg G1994-133 G1994-133 Williamsburg th swags of foliage and and foliage of swags th R]G &KULVWLHV-XO\ lattened cover, large large cover, lattened VHQJUDYHGIHVWRRQVGRPHGFRYHUNQRS VDQGIROLDJH VWDQGFKDVHGEDQGV´KW 6RWKHE\V2FWREHU HGERG\XSSHUKDOIGHFRUDWHGZLWKFKDVHG HUFKDVHGZLWKIORUDOVFUROOLQJR] %UHDGDOEDQH&ROOHFWLRQ WVSRXWEODFNZRRGHQKDQGOHò´KW´ORQJ +XQWOH\+RXVH shape, upper body chased wi chased body upper shape, DUVKDSH´KW 6RWKHE\V3LFWXUH)LOHV neo-classical, oval engraved body, f body, engraved oval neo-classical, FRYHUOHDIFDSSHGVLOYHUORRSHGKDQGOHò´KWR]G finial, 24oz VZDJVIOXWHGVKDSHGVSRXWLYRU\ILQLDOR]ERWKSLHFHV flowers, curved spout, woodenhandle and finial gh Teapot, inverted pear shape, on a spreading foot, bright cut,partly domed Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Teapot, p210 36, vol Magazine Antiques :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU 1780/81 Hewitt James Edinburgh pe inverted Teapot, -DPHV+HZLWW (GLQEXU 1776/77 James Gilliland 1776/77 FD Edinburgh Gilliland James shape pear inverted Teapot, 0LOQHDQG&DPSEHOO Edinburgh *ODVJRZ stand with Teapot, 7HDSRWEDOXVWHUERG\VKRXOG Scotland of Museums National #15 p30 32 1940 vol July Apollo :LOOLDP'DYLHRU FD 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWYDVHIRUPEHDGHGERUGHU 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK -DPHV:HOVK 7HDSRWGUXPVKDSHVWUDLJK (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWF\OLQGULFDOZLWKIHVWRRQ FD 0LOQHDQG&DPSEHOO *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWZLWKVWDQGGUXPVKDS FD1776/77 0LOQH &DPSEHOO *ODVJRZ Gilliland James 7HDSRWUHFWDQJXODUERG\ZLWK Edinburgh pear inverted Teapot, 1775/76 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh 25oz flowers, and festoons with engraved crest, oval, Teapot, #101 1966 26, April Christies 1775/76 Alexander Gairdner Edinburgh Teapot, Teapot, Edinburgh Gairdner YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1775/76 Alexander LOCATION SOURCE

499 Compendium of Scottish Silver LRQ HE\V1<86$2FWREHU 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS )LQOD\SO 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 0(4 +RZRI(GLQEXUJK 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW &KULVWLHV-XO\ &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS %RQKDPVWKH6FRWWLVK6DOH $XJXVW &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK$SULO Collection Private ROLDWH R] QKDQGOHDQGILQLDOFXUYHGVSRXW ILQLDOOHDIFDSSHGVFUROOWRWKHSODLQORRS UG¶VKHDGWRVSRXWDQGKDQGOHERG\ZLWK JDQGERZFKDVLQJGROSKLQKHDGKDQGOHDQLPDO ERUGHUVHQJUDYHGZLWKIHVWRRQVRIIORZHUVDQG ô´KWR] handle,teapot marked for Edinburgh 1760ca andmarks over struck for UHWDLOLQJLQ*ODVJRZR] head spout spout head ILWWHGVWDQGIOXWHGVSRXWR]G DQLQLWLDOHGRYDOFXUYHGVSRXWRQRYDOSHGHVWDOEDVHò´KW neoclassical ribbon tied floral garlands, crest of Thompson, motto, initials initials motto, Thompson, of crest garlands, floral tied ribbon neoclassical ³0:7´IRU7KRPSVRQRGGVKDSHGZRRGILQLDOWRSSHGE\DVLOYHUI IHUXOH´KWR] ribbon tiedhusk festoons been neo-classical in have to style, domed appears lid good, with baluster too finial,not condition handle, scroll capped leaf silver GURSSHGò´KWR] (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRIDVHUYLFH /\OH$QQXDO5HYLHZ Edinburgh Edinburgh service a of part Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWZLWKVWDQGQRGHWDLOV 1968 June or May Life Country 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFW Edinburgh Teapot, oval, on paw and bracketed feet, woodenhandle, coat of arms, with amilton amilton Glasgow foliage, of band a with chased base, circular beaded shaped, vase Teapot, :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU William Dempster Dempster William :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU FD -DPHV0F(ZDQ :LOOLDP'DYLHRU *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUVKDSHZRRGH 1783/84 or Davie William :LOOLDP'DYLHRU :LOOLDP'DYLHRU FD -DPHV0F(ZDQ *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWLQYHUWHGSHDUIRUPVLOYHU 5REHUW%RZPDQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWVLOYHUJLOWWHDSRWVZD 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWYDVHVKDSHGEHDGHG FD $GDP*UDKDP *ODVJRZ 7HDSRWUHSDLUHGó´KWR] 6RWK -DPHV+HZLWW (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWFODVVLFDOYDVHVKDSHEL YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1780/81 LOCATION H & Taylor SOURCE

500 Teapots LQHYROS ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Christies Edinburgh May 1-2, May Edinburgh Christies J Bourdon-Smith Catalog 1997 1997 Catalog Bourdon-Smith J p34 #39 vol 135 # 31 # 31 135 vol Canada 1992 Canada MEQ 671 advertisement Firestone #144 1992 #236 Finlay 1991 #98 1991 Finlay William Walter Antiques, Antiques, Walter William London Collection Private MEQ 55 MEQ 1117 1117 MEQ Williamsburg G2003-87 G2003-87 Williamsburg ece service N ¶KWR] &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ0D\ bbons, tassels and festoons, straight spout, UDSHGVZDJVDQGIHVWRRQV /RUHQW]$QWLTXHV7RURQWR HFHDVHGE\WKLVGDWH ´DFURVVR] ece set, Arms Christie of Bedlay of Larkshire no details details no Scotland of Museums National ece service, straight spout, woodenhandle and finial Country Life February 13, 1964 William Davie was d was Davie William in a circle, straight spout, loop wooden handle handle wooden loop spout, straight a circle, in domed lid, original fruit wood handle, (Note: William Davie was deceased by by deceased was Davie William (Note: handle, wood fruit original lid, domed WKLVGDWH ó´KWR] Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Teapot, Scotland of Museums National Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Teapot, p550 Marks Jackson James Douglas Douglas James Edmonstoun Edmonstoun 1791/92 Robertson William Edinburgh pi 4 with Teapot, 1790/91 Dempster William Edinburgh (Note: Ballochyle, of Campbell Alexander to given cut, bright oval, Teapot, -DPHV0F.D\FD 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK1790/91 7HDSRWZLWKVWDQG I Cunningham P & W FD Edinburgh (GLQEXUJK pi a 4 of part Teapot, : 3&XQQLQJKDP, 3XQFKSRW$UPVRI6WXDUWQRPP (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWYDVHVKDSHGZLWKG $QWLTXHV0DJD] 1789/90 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh pi 3 a with handle, wooden Teapot, 1789/90 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh figure classical a with engraved panel each octagonal, sided straight Teapot, 1786/87 or Dempster James 1788/89 Dempster William Edinburgh ri swags, floral oval, Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1784/85 Alexander LOCATION SOURCE 1785ca 1785ca McEwan James Glasgow lid flattened spout, rococo body, chased oval neo-classical, Teapot, Collection-Colonial Hyman 1785ca 1785ca Gray Robert Glasgow stand, with Teapot,

501 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1978-2059-1 1978-2059-1 E\V/RQGRQ1RYHPEHU -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ p36 #46 Edinburgh 3187/68 HH 1 ,)UDQNOLQ Collection Private 1987 #114 Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1998 #542 MEQ 1945.37 Woolley & Wallis April 20, 20, April Wallis & Woolley #794 2005, 1994 London Shreve advertisement advertisement Shreve Galleries foot, V´KWR] DVHUYLFH QKDQGOH¶KW +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP ails ails Art and Museum Dundee IOXWLQJEULJKWFXWHQJUDYLQJLQLWLDOV³-%´LQ ece service, no det ó´KW cartouche, part a piece of 4 tea service ZLJJOHZRUNEDQGVLQLWLDO³1´XQGHUQHDWKSDUWRIDSLHFHWH ERG\ZLWKYDFDQWRYDOFDUWRXFKHVDIULH]HRIGUDSHU\IHVWRRQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWZLWKVWDQGRYDOVKDSHVWUDLJKWVSRXWZRRGH Edinburgh Edinburgh details no Teapot, Edinburgh no details Teapot, Collection Swan Maple The 7 p130 vol Magazine Antiques Fenwick I Co Co 1798/99 Leslie John Aberdeen stand, with finial, handle and wooden straight spout, body, oval Teapot, FD and : 3&XQQLQJKDP, 1798/99 McHattie (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRWSLFWXUHG 6RWKH 1795 ca 1795 ca 1796/97 Livingston Edward 1796/97 Dundee Robertson William Edinburgh Robertson William stand with Teapot, Edinburgh tray with Teapot, *UDKDP 0F/HDQ details no stand, with Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDORXWOLQHFRQFDYH Scotland of Museums National #111 1991 Finlay 92 p168 vol Magazine Antiques 1792/93 1793/94 Ziegler Alexander Cunningham Douglas James Edinburgh 1793/94 William no details Teapot, Edinburgh a set of part Teapot, 550 p Marks Jackson Antiques, Walter William 1794/95 & Graham Alexander 1794/95 Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh pi a 4 of part Teapot, 1794/95 Spence Alexander Edinburgh and leaves cut bright within cartouche drapery vacant with engraved Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1792/93 LOCATION I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh pedestal shaped navette spreading on body, shaped vase oval Teapot, SOURCE

502 Teapots S DAG000061 DAG000061 '$* %HOO&ROOHFWLRQ 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1999 Collection Private %HOO&ROOHFWLRQ 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1997 #122 Aberdeen Museumsand *DOOHULHV$% #28a 1961, Collection, Bell Woolley & Wallis April 24, 2002 2002 24, April Wallis & Woolley *DOOHULHV Aberdeen Museumsand AB Galleries 1978) (acquired Sothebys Gleneagles September foot, ´KWR] ò´KWR] ails ails Art and Museum Dundee FUHVWKXQWLQJKRUQDQGVWDJ¶VKHDGLQDVKLHOG UPLQJVWDQGR]GDOOLQ )LQOD\ KDQGOHLQLWLDOV³0-%´ó´KWR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ VHUYLFHò´KWR] &KULVWLHV1<86$$SULO ece service, no det WKHPRXWKDQGEDVHSODLQVKDSHGVSRXWZRRGHQKDQGOH¶KW VWUDLJKWVSRXWZRRGHQKDQGOHFUHVWRI-RKQVWRQHò´KW engraved bands acorns of and flowers below reeded bandsthe at shoulders, domed lid, silver finial, coat of arms, arms, of coat finial, silver lid, domed motif, NG, floral motif motif floral NG, motif, shaped cartouche, base marked Abd Ng, FXUYHGVSRXWZRRGHQORRSKDQGOHDQGILQLDOZLWKDVWDQG stand with crest and motto on the other, decorated matted band of foliage below the the below foliage of band matted decorated other, the on motto and crest HYHUWHGVKRXOGHUVWUDLJKWVSRXWGRPHGOLGZLWKEXWWRQILQLDO Glasgow Teapot, partthree a of pieces service, modified oval rectangular form, Newlands and and Newlands Grierson (GZDUG/LYLQJVWRQH 'XQGHH 1800ca date? 7HDSRWRFWDJRQDOZLWKFRQIR 1800ca 1800ca Gillet Nathaniel 1800ca Aberdeen Erskine James spreading borders, beaded engraving, delicate with shaped, urn Teapot, Aberdeen round engraving band of body, fluted concave oval large stand), Teapot,(with 0F+DWWLH )HQZLFN (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRIDSLHFH : 3&XQQLQJKDP, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWRYDOVKDSHZRRGHQ 1800ca 1800ca Gillet Nathaniel Aberdeen hinged bands, engraved with decorated shape, oval stand), (with Teapot, 1800ca 1800ca Gillet Nathaniel Aberdeen floral NG, motif, floral marked base no details, wood, fruit and silver Teapot, FD (GZDUG/LYLQJVWRQHFD 'XQGHH 1DWKDQLHO*LOOHW 7HDSRWSDUWRIDSL $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWVLOYHUZRRGDQGLYRU\ 1799/1800 1799/1800 I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh festoons, floral with engraved edges, beaded body, vase-shaped oval Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1799/1800 LOCATION I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh a and side one on initials enclosing wreaths 2 with cut bright oval, Teapot, SOURCE

503 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1951 vol 53 p5 53 p5 vol 1951 p88 MEQ 851 #305 Advertisement MEQ 1271 1271 MEQ N Horowitz Inc, NY USA 1996 USA NY Inc, Horowitz N Christies Sale Sale Christies #76 1988 26, Bracher & Sydenham Sydenham & Bracher advertisement Collection Rudkin Phillips Sothebys ece coffee set Sothebys April27, 1927 #174 ece set, Arms Kincragie of Sothebys Hopetoun April House ece service Apollo March details details Scotland of Museums National Teapot, bright cut, engraved, on 4 ball feet feet ball 4 on engraved, cut, bright Teapot, 2002/03 Catalog Shaw Nicholas Teapot, with stand stand with Teapot, p50 1927 Magazine Connoisseur Teapot, oval pot, straight spout, wood handle, full arms, crest and motto on on motto and crest arms, full handle, wood spout, straight pot, oval Teapot, 1806 date name, a with engraved also reverse, the on crest side, one 3HUWK 7HDSRWORZULVHò´KWR] .RYHO¶VS Assayed Edinburgh Assayed Edinburgh Assayed in Edinburgh Assayed in Edinburgh 1808/09 McPherson & Dick 1808/09 1808/09 McKay James McHattie George Edinburgh Edinburgh pi a 4 of part Teapot, details no Teapot, Scotland of Museums National 1808/09 Not available available 1808/09 Not 1806/07 R Keay Keay 1806/07 R 1806/07 I Cunningham P & W 1806/07 Edinburgh pi a I 3 of part Cunningham Teapot, P & W Edinburgh no Teapot, 1802/03 McDonald John 1802/03 Edinburgh I Cunningham P & W 1805/06 Edinburgh stand with Teapot, 14.5oz Teapot, Howden Francis 1806/07 Edinburgh McPherson & Dick a set of part Teapot, p61 46 Park-Bernet p625 1981 Annual Review Lyle p743 1984 Annual Review Lyle YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1802/03 LOCATION Spence Alexander Edinburgh pi a 3 of part Teapot, SOURCE

504 Teapots May 1-2, 1-2, May PVRI6FRWODQG 86$)HEUXDU\ HXPVRI6FRWODQG XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG XDO5HYLHZS YROS 6DNLHO,QF1<86$ )RJJ$UW0XVHXP+DUYDUG 8QLYHUVLW\ /HYHUHWW +RXVH 0(4 0(4 %HOODGYHUWLVHPHQW 0(4 1991 #246 1991 #246 6RWKHE\V/RQGRQ2FWREHU &KULVWLHV6DOH QJ UWRXFKHYDFDQW GFDUWRXFKHFXUYHGIOXWHG RWVLOYHUKDQGOHLYRU\LQVHUWVSLQHDSSOH ERPEHIRUP&UHVWRI+D\ZLWKLQLWLDO³+´ &KULVWLHV(GLQEXUJK HFHVHWZLWKLQLWLDO³+´ 6RWKHE\V)HEUXDU\ HFHVHW $SROOR SRWQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHX ILQLDOEULJKWFXWFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI5DQNLQLQUHFWDQJXODUFD FDUWRXFKHRQWKHUHYHUVHVLGH VSRXWOHDIFDSSHGVLOYHUKDQGOHPXVKURRPILQLDO´KW´OR R]G LQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRIDSLHFHVHW (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRISLHFHVHUYLFHIOXWHGERG\VFUROOH 7HDSRWQRWSLFWXUHG 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW Edinburgh Teapot, compressed circular,later chased with flowers, scrolls and fruit, &XQQLQJKDP,, Grierson $VVD\HG(GLQEXUJK 6RQ 1818/19 William and Patrick Patrick and 1818/19 William *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0 -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRIDSL -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRWSLFWXUHG 6RWKHE\V1< 5*UHHQRU5 -RKQ0F'RQDOG (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XV 7KRPDV'DYLH *UHHQRFN 7HDSRWPXOWLVLGHGGUXPVKDSHGS 1810/11 Patrick Cunningham Cunningham 1810/11 Patrick *HRUJH)HQZLFN (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRIDVHW /\OH$QQ -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJK 7HD *HRUJH)HQZLFN (G YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1809/10 LOCATION Fenwick George Edinburgh pi a 3 of part Teapot, SOURCE

505 Compendium of Scottish Silver OH³$(´ DAG000060 DAG000060 1940 p7 XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG MEQ 744 MEQ one of 949-51 1969 949-51 of one MEQ K2000.378 K2000.378 Bell advertisement advertisement Bell MEQ 1201 1201 MEQ MEQ 813 MEQ 1310 1310 MEQ Dundee Museums and Art Galleries 1994-307-1 Galleries AB Galleries 1977) (acquired ails ails Scotland of Museums National ece service Apollo May ece service, squatregency teapot, circular shaped body n Coursing Prize Prize n Coursing Scotland of Museums National details details Scotland of Museums National details details Scotland of Museums National and fluting around the outside of the lower half, handle decorated with with decorated handle half, lower the of outside the around fluting and feet bun 4 on insulators, as inserts bone two has and top the at leaf acanthus gh gh details no engraved, Teapot, Scotland of Museums National Perth Teapot, part a piece of 3 service, no det (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRIDSLHFHVHUYLFH 6RWKHE\V3LFWXUH)L Edinburgh Teapot, part a piece of 3 set Sothebys April26, 1988 #91 DP-DPLHVRQ $EHUGHHQ 7HDSRWEDFKHORU¶VQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0 Assayed Edinburgh Edmonstoun Edmonstoun Edmonstoun Edmonstoun 1828/29 II Keay Robert 1829/30 Leonard Urquhart Edinburgh Teapot, no Teapot, Edinburgh Urquhart 1829/30 Leonard 1820/21 Alexander 1820/21 Alexander 1823/24 1825 ca McKay James Willi Edinburgh not pictured Teapot, p619 1993 Annual Review Lyle 1826/27 Alexander 1826/27 Alexander 1827/28 James McKay McKay 1827/28 Edinbur 1827/28 James McKay James Edinburgh no details Teapot, p621 1993 Annual Review Lyle 1827/28 Son and Gray Robert Glasgow Ardrossa Teapot, 1820/21 Gray Robert Glasgow pi a 3 of part Teapot, 1820 ca 1820 ca McKay James Edinburgh no Teapot, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1820ca LOCATION Booth George Aberdeen unclear AB, AB, GB, - handle near on body ivory, and silver Teapot, and Museums Aberdeen SOURCE 1820ca 1820ca Cameron Alexander Dundee pi a 3 of part Teapot,

506 Teapots ecember 11, LRQ' QXDO5HYLHZS Christies April 23, 1983 #92 1983 23, April Christies 1977 Sothebys 2000 #14 2000 #14 1990 #101 1990 #101 Sale Sothebys 1972/3 MEQ 1074a,b 1074a,b MEQ 1972/3 Sale Sothebys Sothebys Sale Sale Sothebys MEQ 1216 1216 MEQ MEQ 736-38 964 736-38 MEQ ails ails Scotland of Museums National ece set Sothebys Gleneagles August 27, ece set Sothebys Gleneagles August 28, ece coffee set details details Scotland of Museums National Perth Perth details no stand, with Teapot, Scotland of Museums National Perth, Teapot, part a piece of 3 service, no det Assayed Edinburgh Assayed in Edinburgh YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1832/33 LOCATION Co Elder & Edinburgh pi a 3 of part Teapot, SOURCE 1833-36 McKay James Edinburgh 7$) a set of part Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSKHDVDQWILQLDO´KW 1984 Annual Review Lyle /XQGV$XFW 1834/35 Co Elder & Edinburgh pi a 3 of part Teapot, 1834-36 Co Elder & 1835/36 1839/40 Co Elder & Edinburgh II Keay Robert not pictured Teapot, Edinburgh pi a 4 of part Teapot, p618 1982 Annual Review Lyle 1839/40 1839/40 Co Elder & McKay James Edinburgh -DPHV0F.D\ Edinburgh a set of part Teapot, a set of part Teapot, (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWô´KWR]Gp593 1979 Annual Review Lyle p 593 1979 Annual Review Lyle /\OH$Q 1839/40 Whittet & Robb Edinburgh no Teapot, 1842/43 1842ca Chisolm & McKay Edinburgh II Keay Robert a set of part Teapot, p728 1983 Annual Review Lyle 1844/45 McKay James Edinburgh a set of part Teapot, p729 1983 Annual Review Lyle

507 Compendium of Scottish Silver VH0XVHXP 008855, 1995 008855, 1986-88 1986-88 Dundee Museum and Art Galleries Galleries Galleries 1986-88 ABDAG National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National MEQ 954 MEQ 942 36/60 LF of part Edinburgh Huntley House Museum, Huntley House 2809/65 HH Edinburgh 1986.150 1986.150 MEQ 811 eBay listing #6511177247, listing#6511177247, eBay 2005 10, February Sothebys Sale Sale Sothebys IO\GHFRUDWLRQ´KW ails ails Art and Museum Dundee finial finial Scotland of Museums National O\GHFRUDWHGFXUYHGVSRXWOLGZLWKILQLDOô´ ilver handle, ball handle, ilver ece service, no det HFHVHUYLFHFKDVHGFDUWRXFKHò´KWÓRQJHFHVHUYLFHFKDVHGZLWKDVFHQHIURP6LU:DOWHU6FRWW¶V +XQWOH\+RX ³/D\RIWKHODVWPLQVWUHO´ò´KWÓRQJ VFULSWLQLWLDO³%´LQFDUWRXFKH ÓRQJ KWóÓRQJIURPVSRXWWRKDQGOHR] gh gh pi a 3 of part Teapot, Edinburgh Edinburgh Hay Ramsay David by designed Teapot, Scotland of Museums National (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWSDUWRIDSLHFHVVHUYLFHRFWDJRQDOEXWWHU Marshall Marshall Sons 1899-1904 Ramsay James Dundee pi a 4 of part Teapot, 1874/75 Meldrum & Pollack 1896/97 Edinbur available Not Glasgow pi a 3 of part Teapot, 1994/95 Appleby Malcolm Edinburgh wood and silver Teapot, Cressbrooke The Teapot, Galleries and Museum Aberdeen 1854/66 Marshall William Edinburgh details no Teapot, Scotland of Museums National 1847/48 William & James 1857/58 Crichton Walker 1862/63 Edinburgh Crichton s body, round Teapot, Edinburgh engraved handle, on animal winged spout, curved decorated, heavily Teapot, 1846/47 William Marshall & & Marshall 1846/47 William YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1846/47 LOCATION Co & Howden James Edinburgh a set of part Teapot, SOURCE p619 1982 Annual Review Lyle 0DUVKDOO 6RQ (GLQEXUJK 7HDSRWIXOO\KDOOPDUNHGQLFH

508 Tea Service

TeaTEA ServiceSERVICE

Plate 49. An Assembled Edinburgh Tea Service Sugar Bowl 1730/31, Cream Boat 1735/36, Salver 1740/41 all by William Aytoun. Teapot 1734/35 by Hugh Penman. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

509 Compendium of Scottish Silver l I p108 #22 Lots 374-377 azine 1934 azine 1955 Connoisseur Mag vol 91, p342 #74 Finlay 1991 John Girdwood Collection 13, 1933 Christies #36 December 13, 1967 Christies #22 December Partridge Ltd London Christies May 22, 1991#85 Christies Picture File Neg Christies Picture File #25239 Christies Auction Connoisseur Mag p90 vol 135, 20, 1986 November Sothebys #108 advertisement of Edinburgh How and Museums Aberdeen Galleries ABDAG008510- 008505 Apollo 1934 vol 20 p21 Wilson & Sharp advertisement Silver How’s Notes on Antique 1941 vol I, p23 p126 Finlay 1991 vol I, p23 Antique Silver 1941, Sothebys July1968 4, #133 WilsonGlasgow & Sharp Exhibition 1911 vo spherical sugar bowl on e, all with the Arms of Arms with the e, all pot and 1728 sugar Henry Bethune, stand Bethune, Henry 1728 sugar and pot sugar bowl and matching stand bowl and matching sugar hoof feet 4 ½” ht, almost 4 ½” ht, almost hoof feet 1729/30 by Henry Bethun Henry by 1729/30 spout 6 ½” ht, baluster milk jug with leaf capped jug baluster milk spout 6 ½” ht, ea service, The Girdwood Tea Service, spherical teapot, covered hot milk covered The Girdwoodteapot, ea service, Tea Service, spherical jug, wavy border molded lip molded border wavy jug, 1733 by Archibald Ure, and cream boat 1737 by Edward Lothian Edward 1737 by boat cream Ure, and by Archibald 1733 sugar bowl, cream jug and pair of oblong tea caddies, crest, motto and the motto crest, tea caddies, of oblong pair jug and cream bowl, sugar all 50.8 oz initial “D”, spherical teapot, helmet cream jug with girdle, wavy border molded edge border molded wavy girdle, jug with cream helmet spherical teapot, sugar bowl, stand from Johnson and semi fluted curved and semi on 3 double scroll handles di, each piece foot 4 ¼” identically initialed, 35oz 11d all spreading rim sugar bowl, helmet cream jug cream bowl, helmet sugar rim Edinburgh1730 tea with set service, mixed Tea Aberdeen base with spreading teapot bullet shaped 3 piece set, Tea service, matching Archibald Ure Archibald Edward Lothian (teapot and jug) (teapot and TEA SERVICE 1730 ca George Cooper Aberdeen teapot, covered shaped 5 Kirkhill Tea Service, pieces, apple The Tea service, 1733/34 Aytoun William Edinburgh T 1728 -37 Henry Bethune 1727/28 Ker James Edinburghpieces, 4 Service, Ford Set, also called the Johnson Tea The Tea service, 1725ca George Robertson YEAR1723/24 MAKER Ker James LOCATION Edinburgh DESCRIPTION molded border, – wavy teapot later separated, probably Tea service,3 piece, SOURCE

510 Tea Service RU DWLYH &KULVWLHV-XQH $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHYRO 6KUXEVROH,QF &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S &RXQWU\/LIH'HFHPEHU +RZRI(GLQEXUJKDGYHUWLVHPHQW &KULVWLHV/RQGRQ$SULO &KULVWLHV1HJ p342 91 vol 6RWKHE\V-XO\ &KULVWLHV-XO\ $SROOR2FWREHUYROS 'H+DYLOODQG$QWLTXHV $SROOR-XO\YROS Spink Ltd, London $VSUH\/RQGRQ &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S &KULVWLHV-XQH 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG Q HOOVDQG ROOKDQGOHDQG HGZLWKWKH WKHVHOOHULQ IHHWLVVXLQJ LWKVFUROOVDQG KIORZHUVDQG YHUWHGULPV JHKDOIIOXWHG DPHV.HU IOXVKKLQJH SRRQWUD\RQ OOKDQGOHR] PRXWKFLUFXODU KLQJHGOLG XJDUERZODQGGROSKLQ eces, tea kettlewith stand, HFHVQHDUVSKHULFDOWHDSRW±FKDVHG HFHRULJLQDOO\DWWULEXWHGWR-DPHV&ODUNWHDSRWVSKHULFDOR HFHSRWZLWKSDUWIOXWHGFXUYHGVSRXWIOXVKKLQJHGOLGEDOO RQWKHVKRXOGHUZLWKDEURDGEDQGRIVFUROOVIORZHUVDQGIROLD VLOYHUEDOOILQLDOMXJDQGVXJDUERZOZLWKFKDVHGDQGVKDSHGH HDFKRQYROXWHFDEULROHOHJVZLWKSDZIHHWHDFKSLHFHHQJUDY LQLWLDOV³$(´IRUDPHPEHURIWKH(UVNLQHIDPLO\DQFHVWRUVRI VROGDOVRZLWK6FRWVILGGOHSDWWHUQWHDVSRRQVDOVRE\- VSRXWVLOYHUOHDIFDSSHGORRSKDQGOHVOLJKWO\GRPHGOLGZLWK R]ZLWKWKHVSRRQV PROGHGIRRWSDUWO\IOXWHGFXUYHGVSRXWDQGEDOOILQLDOIOXVK VFUROOZRUNFLUFXODUVXJDUERZO±IODWVFDOORSHGULPFKDVHGZLW FKDVHGDURXQGWKHPRXWKZLWKEXQFKHVRIIORZHUVDQGIUXLWLQVK VKHOOVFUHDPERDW±RQKRRIIHHWDFDQWKXVFDSSHGGRXEOHVFUHYHUWHGULPVLPLODUWRWKDWRIWKHERZOSURPLQHQWOLSFKDVHGZ GLDSHUZRUNR]DOO VWDQGVLPLODUO\FKDVHGVXJDUERZOODUJHUWKDQDYHUDJHVL]HRQ IURPWUHIRLOVFUROOVFUHDPERDWRQVLPLODUIHHWFDSSHGVFUR all DQGEXWWRQILQLDOVLOYHUFDSSHGORRSKDQGOHIODWFKDVHGQHDU KDQGOHGFUHDPERDWE\:' FRYHUHGPLONMXJ ´KW RYDOVXJDUERZORQIHHWRYDOV IHHWVKDSHGVTXDUHVWDQG ´ORQJ´ZLGH $UPVRI+RSH Edinburgh Edinburgh maker the not and assayer the was Mitchell David piece, 4 service, Tea 1934 Magazine Connoisseur (GLQEXUJK 7HDVHUYLFHSLHFHVHUYLFHWHDSRWE\0LWFKHOVRQV Mitchell, Archibald Archibald Mitchell, Ure James Mitchelson Mitchelson James William and 'HPSVWHURU:LOOLDP 'DYLH 1743/44 Ker James Edinburgh pi 3 Service, Tea Erskine The Tea service, 1739/40 James Ker, David David Ker, 1739/40 James -DPHV&DPSEHOO, (GLQEXUJK 7HDVHUYLFHSL -DPHV.HU (GLQEXUJK 7HDVHUYLFHSL 43/44 YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1734/35 LOCATION Ker James Edinburgh 6 pi Service, Tea Hopetoun The Tea service, SOURCE

511 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1956 vol 69 vol 1956 1951 vol 60 vol 1951 1978-1550-1-4 1978-1550-1-4 ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Christies London July 1992 July London Christies Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1998 #542 Sothebys Gleneagles August 25, 25, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1997 #149 671-674 MEQ 93 p347 Finlay 1991 #98 1991 Finlay 667-670 MEQ Galleries Sothebys Gleneagles August 1992 #147 Collection Private Bell of Aberdeen advertisement advertisement Aberdeen of Bell Scottish Art Review 1953 vol IV IV 1953 vol Review Art Scottish #4 advertisement Aberdeen of Bell #100 XQGHUVLGH R]DOO 1773, jug and sugar sugar and jug 1773, ece service,no details Antiques Magazine ece service,no details Antiques Magazine ece, no details ece,no details ece, teapot, stand, cream jugand sugar basket, bright cut N Dundee Museum and Art ece, no details N ece, all with classical6 sided diamond shape outline, coat of ece,no details Private Collection ece, no details a service, 3-4 pi 3-4 a service, OHDYHVDQGZULJJOHZRUNEDQGVYDFDQWFDUWRXFKHLQLWLDO³1´RQ arms bowl fully marked, bowl in inverted pear form, jug helmet shaped, teapot teapot shaped, helmet jug form, pear inverted in bowl marked, fully bowl finial flower silver and handle loop silver insulated spout, curved with RYDOVW\OHRWKHUVWRPDWFKSRWó´KWVWDQG´;´ scroll handle handle scroll Edinburgh Tea service 4 piece, teapot, stand, sugar basket, and cream jug,pot in plain Edinburgh Tea service, 3 piece, teapot withnoandmm perhaps ailable Edinburgh Te Edinburgh ailable WR probably Robertson William William Davie Davie William 1791/92 Robertson Patrick 1794/95 Edinburgh Gairdner Alexander 1794/95 4 pi Tea service, Edinburgh Spence Alexander 4 pi Tea service, Edinburgh 4 pi Tea service, 1789/90 Robertson Patrick 1790 ca Edinburgh Jr Stewart Alexander and 1790/91 Inverness 3 pi Tea service, 92/93 no details Tea service, vol 1934, Magazine Connoisseur 1791/92 Robertson William Edinburgh 3 pi service, Tea 1775 ca 1775 ca 1783/84 McEwan James or Dempster William Glasgow 3 pi Tea service, 1765/66 1767 ca Dempster Ker & Av Not Edinburgh a 3 pi probably Tea service, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1750 ca LOCATION Coline Allan Aberdeen 3 pi Tea service, SOURCE 1758/1770 1758/1770 Dempster William Edinburgh flying with jug cream bowl, sugar teapot, shaped pear inverted service, Tea

512 Tea Service p120 p295 #101 1974 vol 100 vol 1974 1986-136-1=3 1986-136-1=3 ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Sothebys Gleneagles August 25, 25, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1997 #122 MEQ 833 advertisement Aberdeen of Bell Galleries Galleries p17 advertisement Holmes 629-631 MEQ 1989 #42 1989 #42 GHWDLOV 6RWKHE\V+RSHWRXQ+RXVH$SULO upports, 39.6oz 39.6oz upports, alled rectangular form, with engraved bands of of bands engraved with form, rectangular alled ece,no details Antiques Magazine vol 38 p50 ece,no details ece,no details ece, no details ece,no details ece, teapot, stand, bowl, creamno details The LiptonCollection Apollo September Dundee Museum and Art N Antiques Magazine vol 41 ece,no details Antiques Magazine vol 46, ece, teapot, ov flowers below, reeded bandsthe at shoulders, the jug and basin with gilt interiors, each piece onapplied rim base with ball 4 s Tea service, 3 piece,no details N Edinburgh Tea service, 4 piece,no details Private Collection 3HUWK 7HDVHUYLFHSLHFH5.RYHUVWULNLQJDQRWKHU¶VPDUNQR Alexander Gairdner and Graham & McLean Assayed Edinburgh Assayed in Edinburgh 1795/96 and 1795/96 96/97 YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1795/96 LOCATION available Not Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, SOURCE 1797/98 Christie George Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1800/01 1800 ca I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh Livingstone Edward 1801/02 no details Tea service, Dundee I Cunningham P & W 1804/05 Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 4 pi Tea service, Spence Alexander 1807/08 Edinburgh McKay James 3 pi Tea service, Edinburgh 4 pi Tea service, 71 vol 1957 Magazine Antiques 1807/08 McPherson & Dick 1808/09 Howden Francis Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1808/09 I Keay Robert 1809/10 1810 ca McKay James Grierson & Newlands Glasgow Edinburgh no details service, 3 pi coffee and Tea service, Tea p87 85 1967 vol Apollo

513 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1990 p29 1990 1990 p29 1990 1983 p615 1991 #111 ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational Christies auction auction Christies 1990 #86 1990 #86 p1328 Shreve Inc Boston USA advertisement Shreve Inc Boston USA advertisement Fogg Art Museum, Harvard Harvard Art Museum, Fogg 1948.47-49 University National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National K.2004.117 vol 130 p24 130 vol MEQ 632-635 632-635 MEQ MEQ 1310-13112 1310-13112 MEQ FUROOKDQGOH JDGURRQHGULP ttish, no details details no ttish, 1952 Magazine Connoisseur ece,no details Lyle Annual Review ece,no details Sothebys Hopetoun March House ece, no details N ece plus a tray Sothebys Gleneagles ece, no details N ece, no details Finlay ece,no details Sothebys Gleneagles HFHWHDSRW±IOXWHGERG\FXUYHGIOXWHGVSRXWPXVKURRP scrolled cartouche cartouche scrolled ILQLDOVFUROOHGFDUWRXFKHVXJDUERZO±IOXWHGERG\KDQGOHG VFUROOHGFDUWRXFKHFUHDPMXJ±RYDOIOXWHGERG\OHDIFDSSHGV LQLWLDOV³$(´ Tea service, 3 piece, said to Sco be Assayed Edinburgh James McKay Edinburgh Tea service, 3 piece, bottom half gadrooned,heavily chasedwith script YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1811/12 LOCATION Fenwick George Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, SOURCE 1811/12 McKay James Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1812/13 McKay James 1816-19 Edinburgh McDonald James no details Tea service, 1817/18 Edinburgh McKay James no details Tea service, Edinburgh 4 pi Tea service, 115 vol Magazine Antiques 76 vol Magazine Antiques 1819/20 McKay James Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1820 ca 1820 ca McKay James Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1820/21 Not available available 1820/21 Not 1820/21 Livingstone Edward Dundee 3 pi Tea service, 1818/19 McKay James Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1819/20 I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1820/21 and 1820/21 22/23

514 Tea Service 1983 1983 ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational ational Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums ational p106 Sothebys 1987 #305 1987 #305 1988 #77 1988 #81 1988 #81 MEQ 949-951 1969.685-687 1969.685-687 949-951 MEQ 1988 #83 1988 #483 MEQ 641 Sothebys Sale Sale Sothebys MEQ 736-738 1965.1809-09 1965.1809-09 736-738 MEQ Sothebys Sale Sale Sothebys Bonhams Sale 10914 #1 10914 Sale Bonhams IRUPRQ UQILQLDOFUHDPMXJDQG ttish, no details details no ttish, #2 86 vol 1967 August Apollo ece,no details Apollo April-June 1968 vol 87 ece,no details Sothebys Gleneagles August ece,no details Sothebys Hopetoun April House ece,no details ece,no details ece, no details ece,no details Sothebys Hopetoun April House Sothebys Gleneagles August N Lyle Annual Review ece,no details Lyle Annual Review Teaand coffee service, 4 pieces, said to Sco be VXJDUERZO±ZLWKSLHUFHGVFUROOERUGHUDOODUHRIOREHGPHORQ Edinburgh Tea service, 3 pieces, no details Sothebys Hopetoun House April Perth Tea service, 3 piece,no details N Perth Tea service, 3 piece,no details N (GLQEXUJK 7HDVHUYLFHSLHFHWHDSRW±ZLWKGRPHGFRYHUDQGX Assayed Edinburgh Edmonstoun Assayed Edinburgh Assayed Edinburgh YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1823/24 LOCATION McKay James Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, SOURCE 1824/25 McKay James Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1825/26 available McKay James 1825/27 Not Edinburgh 1826/27 Alexander 3 pi Tea service, 1828/29 Son & Keay Robert 1829/30 McKay James 1832/34 Marshall William Edinburgh 1837/38 Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, McKay James 1842/43 3 pi service, Tea Chisolm & McKay Edinburgh Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 3 pi Tea service, 1842/43 II Keay Robert 1844/45 McKay James Edinburgh 3 pi Tea service, 1846/47 William Cunningham Cunningham 1846/47 William

515 Compendium of Scottish Silver A Pash & Sons London 2006 2006 London Sons & Pash A #e5406/8013 ece set,no details The Maple Swan Collection HFHZLWKFUHVWDQGPRWWR³75<´.HWWOH´KWDOOKLJKO\ decorated decorated

gh gh 4 pi service, Tea (continued) (continued) all 55oz foliage, scrolling panels, chased bases, octagonal 1900/01 Hamilton & Inches Edinbur Inches & 1900/01 Hamilton 1871/72 Son & C Rait D Glasgow 5 pi Tea service, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

516 Toast and Bannock Racks

ToastTOAST and AND Bannock BANNOCK RACKS Racks

Plate 50. A Toast Rack 1825/26, maker’s mark obscured. Courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

517 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG011098 DAG011098 The Phoenix Collection Collection Phoenix The Sothebys Scone Palace April 19, 1977 #28 AB Galleries MEQ 63 MEQ 1054 1054 MEQ Sothebys Gleneagles August 25, 25, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1997 #137 798 MEQ Sothebys Scone Palace April 10, 1978 #39 Shaw Collection Collection Shaw 29, March Glasgow Christies 1983 #66 1968.1820 682 MEQ 1955.62 1955.62 URQ ÓRQJ PHó´ZLGH ovoid with 6arched sections,ring handle, to Shaw collection example example collection Shaw to Scotland of Museums National no details details no Scotland of Museums National no details details no Scotland of Museums National ring handle, resting on bell shaped connection to central bar, support with the the with support bar, central to connection shaped bell on resting handle, ring FUHVWDQGPRWWR³3525(*(/(*(*5(*(ÍRU+HQU\%URXJKDP%D ó´ZLGH³WRWRSRIKDQGOH RI%URXJKDPDQG9DX[DQG/RUG+LJK&KDQFHOORUIRU*UHDW%ULWDLQ handle, on 4 bun feet EXQIHHWÓRQJR]DOO 12oz 12oz PRWLIVOHDI\VFUROOJULSVRQSDQHOIHHWVFUHZRQEDUIUD crumb tray with gadrooned edge, probably mate to National Museums of of Museums National to mate probably edge, gadrooned with tray crumb 6FRWODQGH[DPSOH´ TOAST AND BANNOCK RACKS TOAST Aberdeen Aberdeen details no rack, Toast Scotland of Museums National ailable ailable Edinburgh foliate pierced within center the in crested base oval mm, no rack, Toast Co Co 1810 ca 1810 ca Lambert Peter 1819/20 Son & Gray Robert Montrose Glasgow details no rack, Bannock rack, Toast and Museums Aberdeen 1820ca 1820ca & Jamieson William 1825/26 available Not Edinburgh bar, each for supports internal X and bars 7 with indistinct, mm rack, Toast 1800 ca 1800 ca Fenwick & McHattie 1800/01 Edinburgh available Not details no rack, Toast Edinburgh and central work arched wire double of bars 9 with rubbed, mm rack, Toast Scotland of Museums National 1793/94 available Not Edinburgh crested, lion one pair, rack, Toast 1785/86 Francis Howden Edinburgh Toast rack, rack, Howden Toast Edinburgh 1785/86 Francis av 1789/90 Not 1773/74 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh mate probably rack, Bannock 1773/74 Robertson Patrick Edinburgh the handle, loop central with from rack toast bar 10 rack, wide Bannock YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

518 Toast and Bannock Racks DAG001032 DAG001032 DAG0010351 DAG0010351 Galleries AB Galleries Galleries ABDAG001333 Galleries AB Galleries ERZZLWKDUURZ $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1826/27 LOCATION 1830 ca available Not Booth George Edinburgh Aberdeen no details rack, Toast no details GB, ABD, GB, - marked rack, Toast SOURCE and Museums Aberdeen Collection Swan Maple The 1830 ca 1830 ca Jamieson William FD Aberdeen *3 details no ABD, WGJ, - marked rack, Toast (GLQEXUJK 7RDVWUDFNHQJUDYHGERDU¶VKHDGDQGGUDZQ and Museums Aberdeen

519 Compendium of Scottish Silver

520 Urns

UrnsURNS

Plate 51. An ovoid shaped Urn with snake handles 1738/39 by James Weems, Edinburgh. Courtesy of a private collector. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

521 Compendium of Scottish Silver Phillips Edinburgh July 22, 1983 1983 22, July Edinburgh Phillips #245 Edinburgh of How Scotland of Museums National vol XVI #1 back cover cover back #1 XVI vol advertisement How Scotland of Museums National 1573 MEQ Holland p222 Holland Collection Noble #83 1991 Finlay 2004 USA NY Shrubsole p130-33 April 1959 Life Country Scotland of Museums National 1956.368 p74 103 vol Sothebys Gleneagles August 29, 29, August Gleneagles Sothebys 1978 #427 Sothebys Gleneagles September 1, 1998 #559 MEQ 1983.13 1983.13 MEQ p899 UK Collection Private center bounded by an engraved shell, scroll andhatched border, on 4 stump VXSSRUWVODWHUUHXQLWHGZLWKLWVXUQò´ORQJR] wooden mounts, coat of arms handle to the spigot, snake handles, on 3 double scroll legs terminating in in terminating legs scroll double 3 on handles, snake spigot, the to handle ZRRGHQSDZVKDSHGIHHWò´KWR] URNS AND URNSTANDS URNS 1735/36 Ker James Edinburgh plain shape, quatrefoil listing, previous is with belongs it urn stand, Urn 1732/33 Mitchelson James Edinburgh 1733/34 handles snake with Urn, oviform, Ure Archibald 1735 ca Ker James Edinburgh details no tea, Urn, Edinburgh tray with handles, snake with tea, Urn, p222 Holland 1984 Review Art Scottish 1939 Magazine Connoisseur 1729/30 Gordon Hugh Edinburgh on legs 3 between banner handles, snake spigot, silver shaped, Urn, egg 1723/24 Aytoun William Edinburgh handles snake with oviform, tea, for Urn, Scotland of Museums National 1724/25 Mitchelson James 1725 ca Edinburgh available Not handles snake with oviform tea, Urn, Edinburgh wooden with front at spout cover, domed detachable with Urn, oviform 1948 Magazine Connoisseur YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

522 Urns Baltimore Art Museum of %XUOLQJWRQ0DJD]LQH0D\ &OD\WRQ'LFWLRQDU\S 11, November Scotland Christies 1987 #58 &KULVWLHV*ODVJRZ$SULO Scottish Art Review 1967 vol XI XI 1967 vol Review Art Scottish cover #1 back advertisement How Bell of Aberdeen Antiques Castle Grantully Collection Private Sothebys Book p815 Book Sothebys Colonial - Collection Hyman G1995-187 Williamsburg 1996 June Magazine Antiques p848 OctoberSothebys NY USA 28, p197-99 +RZ¶V1RWHVRQ$QWLTXH6LOYHU I p12 1941 vol L.1983.14 L.1983.14 H³&QRFN(OD RGFUHVW± WHGLQWKHLU with snake handles handles snake with Scotland of Museums National eyes,leaf on 3 capped cabriole legs with paw feet, wooden chased aroundthe armorials, foliage, and scrolls with lid/cover the on and shoulder finial, wooden mounted silver spigot, handled masks, and foliage flowers, with chased richly body shaped pear shouldered snake finial, bun ebony decoration, similar with lid hinged domed flat catalog on p62, mm not clear clear not mm p62, on catalog &KDQ´DFRPSDUDEOHXUQLVLQWKH)ROJHU¶VFROOHFWLRQLOOXVWUD GHHU¶VKHDGPRWWR³6L-H3XLV´DUPVDQGPRWWRRQRSSRVLWHVLG WHUPLQDOVDQGSDZIHHWVSLJRWZLWKZRRGKDQGOHILQLDOSDUWZR with foliage tufts on a scale work background, flat chased around the mouth mouth the around chased flat background, work scale a on tufts foliage with with cover the foliage, scrolling and shells with cover domed the on and girdled orb and button finial,the spigot with woodenhandle, 45oz *RUGRQô´KWR]G Edinburgh Urn, oviform with snakehandles with shell cappedheads, no plumesthe at Edinburgh the of part upper the supports, cabriole paw and shell capped leaf Urn, on U+XJK Weems Edinburgh Urn, oviform, onplain 3 cabriole legs with shell feet, snakehandles, eyes William Dempster Dempster William Gordon 1746/47 or Davie William 1746/47 FD Ker James $VVD\H Edinburgh no details Urn, p547 Marks Jackson 1742/43 Ker James Edinburgh shell with legs cabriole capped leaf handles, snake body, shaped Urn, egg 1736/37 Ker James 1738/39 James Edinburgh 62.1oz feet, hoof legs, to knees capped acanthus tea, Urn 1939 Magazine Connoisseur 1736/37 Aytoun William Edinburgh impaling McKenzie of Arms handles, snake with tea, for shaped, egg Urn, YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1735/36 LOCATION Rollo John Edinburgh tea, for oviform Urn, SOURCE

523 Compendium of Scottish Silver &KULVWLHV$XFWLRQ $SROORS )LQOD\ $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHYROS 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG $SROORYROS )UHHPDQDGYHUWLVHPHQW &KULVWLHV1RYHPEHU *DOOHULHV $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQH2FWREHU YRO %HOODGYHUWLVHPHQW 0(4 ORZHUVVQDNH RDWRIDUPV ORRSKDQGOHV VFKDVHGZLWKIROLDJHSDZIHHWERG\FKDVHG QGZLWKWDOOOHJVFKDVHGKHDYLO\VQDNH ZLWKIOXWLQJDWWKHEDVHVWDQGLQJRQIODWEDVHRQ ODWEDVHZLWKJULOOZRUNVNLUWULVLQJLQEHOOVWHPWR IOXWHGERG\WDOOORRSKDQGOHVò´KWR] -DFNVRQ0DUNVS DVHVKDSHGERG\ 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ8. FKDVHGERG\KRRIIHHW 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG EDOOIHHWVQDNHFRLOHGKDQGOHVDOVRZUDSSHGDURXQGWKHERG\F IODWVWHSSHGOLGFRYHU ZLWKEHDGZRUN WKHERG\OLGFRYHUDOVRVKDSHGOLNHDEHOODOOKHDYLO\FKDVHG KDQGOHVVXUPRXQWHGE\ILJXUHRIDVZDQó´KWR]G ZLWKURFRFRFDUWRXFKHHQJUDYHGZLWKFRDWRIDUPVIHVWRRQVRII KDQGOHV$UPVRIWKH0F/DFKODQIDPLO\ò´KWR] (GLQEXUJK 8UQWHD´KW Edinburgh details no Urn, 6RWKHE\V3KRWRILOH 63 vol 1953 Magazine Antiques (GLQEXUJK 8UQQRGHWDLOV 'XQGHH0XVHXPDQG$UW :LOOLDP'HPSVWHU William Dempster Dempster William I FRQWLQXHG KDQGOHV´KWR] 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK 8UQODUJHWHDFODVVLFDOY 8UQODUJHFODVVLFDOIRUP :LOOLDP'DYLHRU 1781/82 or Davie William 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 8UQODUJHFXSVKDSHGERG\ $OH[DQGHU$LWFKLVRQ 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 8UQKHDUWVKDSHGERG\RQI %HQMDPLQ7DLW (GLQEXUJK 8UQRYLIRUPRQFDEULROHOHJ 1RWDYDLODEOH (GLQEXUJK 8UQHJJVKDSHGIRUWHDRQVWD $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK 8UQWHDVQDNHKDQGOHV YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

524 Urns LQHYROS H)LOH PEHU %HDX[$UWV0RQWUHDO DO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG LHOG&786$$XFWLRQ Private Collection Collection Private 0(4 )LUHVWRQHDQG3DUVRQV%RVWRQ 86$ %RQKDPV6DOH Private Collection Collection Private &DQDGD'VDE KW HUVHVLGH QNLQJVKLS LDP6LPSVRQ ´KWR] HU´KWR]G &KULVWLHV1<86$2FWREHU \EULJKWFXWHQJUDYLQJDSSOLHGRDNOHDYHVRQWKH DUHEDVHZLWKEDOOIHHWEULJKWFXWHQJUDYHGZLWK (VTLQ$XJWE\WKH3DSHU0DQXIDFWXUHUV1HDU(GLQU´´ R]G HQJUDYHGEHKLQGVSLJRWZLWKDUPVRI6LPSVRQLQVFULSWLRQRQUHY ³3DUWRI6LOYHU3ODWHYDOXH2QH+XQGUHG*XLQHDVYRWHGWR:LOO FRYHUDFRUQILQLDOô´KW JDUODQGDQGVFUROOERUGHUVDSSOLHGZLWKUHHGHGKDQGOHVó FKDPEHUHQJUDYHGEHKLQGVSLJRWZLWKLQLWLDOV³$0'´FUHVWRIVL PRWWR³'LVFHSDWL´ó´KWR] Edinburgh Urn,hemispherical, reeded on cushion shaped stand, with egg cuplamp, Edinburgh Urn, vase form,tall loop handle, square base on4 ball feet,internal heating (GLQEXUJK 8UQQRGHWDLOV(GLQEXUJK 8UQYDVHVKDSHGLQVFULSWLRQR]G 6RWKHE\V1RYH $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQHYRO (GLQEXUJK 8UQVLOYHUDQGLYRU\ò´;ô´;ò´ 0XVHHGHV William Robertson Robertson William William Davie or or Davie William Dempster William William Davie or or Davie William Dempster William :LOOLDP0F.HQ]LH :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 8UQ´KW :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ 8UQWHDQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQ 6RWKHE\V3LFWXU :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 8UQWHDQRGHWDLOV /LWFKI :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 8UQPDUNHGRQEDVHDQGFRY :LOOLDP5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 8UQIOXWHGDQGSDQHOHGERG YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1784/85 LOCATION or Rhind William SOURCE 1786/87 : 3&XQQLQJKDP, (GLQEXUJK 8UQSDLU $QWLTXHV0DJD] 1786/87 :0 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 8UQWHDYDVHVKDSHGVTX

525 Compendium of Scottish Silver p426 $SULO±-XQHYRO \OH6LOYHU5HYLHZS 86$ Clayton Christies Book #662 Wakefield advertisement advertisement Wakefield MEQ 663 1062 MEQ p106 Sale Sothebys HGó´KWR] 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW ] 6RWKHE\V-XQH ULQJKDQGOHVDWWDFKHGE\OLRQ¶VPDVNVXQLFRUQ ò´KW´GL 'D\WRQ$UW,QVWLWXWH'D\WRQ2+ WHDXUQR] / SUHVHQWDWLRQ finial, on flat base and 4 ball feet, 4 reeded looped supports connecting body body connecting supports looped reeded 4 feet, ball 4 and base flat on finial, WREDVHò´KW Edinburgh Edinburgh no details Urn, 128 #113 vol Magazine Antiques Edmonstoun Edmonstoun FD (OGHU &RPSDQ\ (GLQEXUJK 8UQ*HRUJLDQVW\OHWHDXUQ -DPHV0F.D\ -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJK (GLQEXUJK 8UQFRDWRIDUPVò´KWR 8UQ YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1800 ca LOCATION Alexander SOURCE 1801 ca 1801 ca Fenwick & McHattie 1802/03 Edinburgh Fenwick & McHattie details no tea, Urn, Edinburgh 1RWDYDLODEOH details no tea, Urn, (GLQEXUJK -DPHV0F.D\ 8UQFRIIHHQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK 8UQYDVHVKDSHGFRYHUHGLQVFULE Scotland of Museums National Scotland of Museums National $SROOR *HRUJH)HQZLFN (GLQEXUJK 8UQWHDEDOOVKDSHGERG\

526 Wine

WineWINE

Plate 52. Items Used With Wine Service Wine Label 1825/26 by JH, Edinburgh, Wine Funnel 1790, no maker’s mark, Wine Funnel Stand 1810ca by James McKay, Edinburgh All courtesy of The Phoenix Collection. Photograph by Janice M Dietert.

527 Compendium of Scottish Silver '$* Aberdeen Museumsand *DOOHULHV$% 2003 acquired Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p104 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p105 Breadalbane Collection Sale Sale Collection Breadalbane 1935 #92 Breadalbane Collection Sale Sale Collection Breadalbane 1935 #91 Antiques Magazine vol 90 p728 vol Magazine Antiques advertisement Bell 1965.1888 817 MEQ Sothebys Scone Palace April 10, 1978 #90 William Walter Antiques, Antiques, Walter William #SA174X4 2006 April London Nicholas Shaw Catalog Autumn Autumn Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1999 p50 GLò´KW PDUNHG³(´KDQGZLWKGDJJHU$EHUGHHQ ´DFURVVó´GHHS *RRGZLQV(GLQEXUJK town mark mark town SUHVHQWHGWR&DSWDLQ-RKQ'U\VGDOH´GL ô´GL en suite with next pair, maker not stated but possibly James Douglas Douglas James possibly but stated not maker pair, next with suite en en suite with the previous pair, maker not stated but possibly James Douglas Douglas James possibly but stated not maker pair, previous the with suite en pierced fansin between with turned wooden bases bases wooden turned with Wine coasters,pair, beaded edge, pierced 4 cartouches between swags of IHUQVDQGRQHFDUWRXFKHZLWKDFUHVWRIDELUGDQGDPRWWR´ WINE EDVHVDQGLYRU\LQLWLDOGLVNVò´GL Edinburgh Wine coasters,pair, circular shape,gadroon borders, lobed sides, wood bases, Edinburgh Wine coasters, 4 set of The Maple Swan Collection Edinburgh Edinburgh wood crest, pattern, navette with sides pierced circular, pair, coasters, Wine & Son James Douglas Douglas James William Davie or or Davie William Dempster William Assayed Edinburgh WINE COASTERS 1810/11 Patrick Cunningham Cunningham 1810/11 Patrick FD -DPHV(UVNLQH $EHUGHHQ :LQHFRDVWHUVLOYHUZRRGIHOW 1801/02 I D D 1801/02 I 1808/09 McKay James Edinburgh bases, wood border, gadroon double shape, 4, circular of set Wine coasters, -RKQ0F'RQDOG (GLQEXUJK :LQHFRDVWHUVSDLUSODLQò 1797/98 available Not Edinburgh probably threaded, rims waved the volutes, with pierced pair, Wine coasters, 1793/94 Spence Alexander 1797/98 Edinburgh available Not details no stand, decanter coaster, Wine Edinburgh probably threaded, rims waved the volutes, with pierced pair, Wine coasters, Scotland of Museums National 1790/91 I Cunningham P & W Edinburgh or cut bright bottom, and top near bands double pierced pair, Wine coasters, 1790 ca 1790 ca Spence Alexander Edinburgh rims, reeded below initials with engraved side straight pair, Wine coasters, 1781/82 1784/85 Not available available 1784/85 Not YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

528 Wine USA 2006 #03159 #03159 2006 USA OH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ Sothebys NY USA AprilSothebys NY USA 1993 #146 0(4 5DJDPRQW+RXVH$QWLTXHV CT Salisbury, Shrubsole, NY USA 1981 E4739 E4739 1981 USA NY Shrubsole, DOFUHVWHG HVPDGHIURPGRJFROODUV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG FRUDWHGZLWKJUDYHYLQHVDERYHDJDGURRQERWWRP RUPRIZLUHZRUNEDVNHWVULPGHFRUDWHGZLWK SHQGDQWJUDSHYLQHVIOXWHGLQWHULRUVFHQWHUHGE\HQJUDYHGDUPV EDQGJDGURRQWRSULPLQVLGHERUGHUOHDIWLSPDWFKHGRQFHQWUVLOYHUERVVHVò´GL Wine coasters,pair, baluster sides, band chased of leaf, scrolland flower GHFRUDWLRQFHQWHUEXWWRQZLWKLQLWLDO³5´ Assayed Edinburgh -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJK :LQHFRDVWHUVQRGHWDLOV 7KH0DS 5REHUW*UD\ 6RQ *ODVJRZ :LQHFRDVWHUVSDLULQWKHI *HRUJH3DWRQ (GLQEXUJK :LQHFRDVWHUVSDLURIZLQHVOLG 5REHUW*UD\ 6RQ *ODVJRZ :LQHFRDVWHUVSDLUVLGHVGH YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1824/25 CC LOCATION SOURCE

529 Compendium of Scottish Silver DAG001345 DAG001345 1987-153 1987-153 1965-190 Edinburgh HH3226/68 HH3226/68 Edinburgh Mary Cooke Antiques London Antiques London Cooke Mary 1996 MEQ 703 Galleries Autumn 2001 p46 #43 p46 2001 Autumn 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p103 MEQ 836 Galleries National Museums of Scotland Scotland of Museums National 1964.1824 686 MEQ AB Galleries ZLWKVWDQGóÓRQJ 1REOH&ROOHFWLRQ ´GL +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP J -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ VÓRQJR]G 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ no details details no Scotland of Museums National PDUNHG³(´FDVWOHVDQGPDLOHGILVW´KW´GLR] WINE FUNNEL 1800 ca $UFKLEDOG2FKLOWUHH (GLQEXUJK Cunningham P & W FD Edinburgh :LQHIXQQHOLQVHFWLRQ 5REHUW*UD\ funnel, Wine *ODVJRZ :LQHIXQQHOSODLQUHHGHGòÓRQ 1800 ca Livingstone Edward FD Dundee 5REHUW.HD\ details no funnel, Wine 3HUWK :LQHIXQQHOZLWKVWDQG´KW Art and Museums Dundee FD -RKQ.HLWK 1800 ca Jamieson Charles 1800 ca %DQII Inverness Livingstone Edward Dundee :LQHIXQQHOSODLQLQLWLDOV³-0&´ details no stand, with funnel, Wine details no funnel, Wine Scotland of Museums National Art and Museums Dundee 1640 ca 1640 ca Lamb Adam 1790 ca 1790 ca Edinburgh McHattie George 1790 ca available Not details no funnel, Edinburgh Wine Fowler Charles details no funnel, Wine 1795 ca Edinburgh Elgin Erskine James mm no base, on crest griffin sections, in 2 Wine funnel, Aberdeen details no funnel, Wine bowl, inner detachable ribs, pronounced initials, engraved Wine funnel, Collection Phoenix The #34 1991 Finlay 1993 London Bourdon-Smith J and Museums Aberdeen YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

530 Wine alog Winter W WLTXHV6DQ 0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ %RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ $XWXPQS 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ p108 )UDQFLVFR&$86$ $XWXPQS 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU S S 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU S $XWXPQS $XWXPQS 0(4 LVZURQJ PESLHFHÓRQJ 18d Collection Private -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ ZLWKYLQHVDQGJUDSHVFUHVWRID GHFRUDWHGSUHVHQWHGWR5HY¶G,QQHV7KRPVRQ W\OHHGJHZLWKUHHGHGERUGHUòÓRQJR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&D H´WDOOR] HJJDQGGDUWERUGHUVòÓRQJ -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ -XO\HLWKHUSUHVHQWDWLRQGDWHLVZURQJRUPDNHU¶VGDWH rd RQ R] FRFNHUHOÓRQJR] ÓRQJR] HUWK :LQHIXQQHOQRGHWDLOV $UJHQWXP$Q :LQHIXQQHORYDOZLWKFUHVWR] -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOQRGHWDLOV(GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOFLUFXODUEDVHJDGURRQERUGHUVKHOOWKX 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOJDGURRQERUGHUFUHVWRI1LVEHWR] - (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG Assayed Edinburgh Edmonstoun Edmonstoun Edmonstoun Edmonstoun II II $OH[DQGHU:LONLH (GLQEXUJK :5& :LQHIXQQHOZLWKVWDQG (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOYDVHVKDSHGFLUFXODUR] 7KH 1810 ca 1810 ca M & G : 3&XQQLQJKDP (GLQEXUJK *HRUJH0F+DWWLH :LQHIXQQHODOOLQRQHSLHF (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHODFDQWKXVOHDYHV $OH[DQGHU $OH[DQGHU FD 5REHUW.HD\, 3 : 3&XQQLQJKDP 5REHUW*UD\ 6RQ (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOFLUFXODUZLWK : 3&XQQLQJKDP 3*ULHUVRQ *ODVJRZ :LQHIXQQHOFDPSDQDVKDSHGFKDVHG YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION FD LOCATION &KDUOHV-DPLHVRQ ,QYHUQHVV :LQHIXQQHOSODLQFDPSDQDV SOURCE

531 Compendium of Scottish Silver RQ H$QWLTXHV9DQFRXYHU DWH&ROOHFWLRQ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ p103 1REOH&ROOHFWLRQ 0(4 (GLQEXUJK++ 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ *DOOHULHV &KULVWLHV0DUFK &DQDGD 0(4 2000 p74 2000 p74 *ORYH´ WKIXQQHOHQJUDYHGLQLWLDOV³-0&´ ´GL +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP ò´GLR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU GERUGHUGRPHGFHQWHUHQJUDYHGZLWKFUHVW QEHDGHGHGJH 7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ DUUHHGHGERUGHUò´GL 3KLOOLS(GLQEXUJK1RYHPEHU JQSDWWHUQHGHGJH 'XQGHH0XVHXPVDQG$UW HOQRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG DUUHHGHGULPHQJUDYHGZLWKDPRQRJUDPPP ó´GL ±DZLOGFDWFRXUUDQWEHORZWKHPRWWR³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ca 1760 Welsh James Edinburgh circul plain, stand, funnel Wine YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

532 Wine 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU S 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ:LQWHU S 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ$XWXPQ S GHULQLWLDOV³50F&´ZLWKIXQQHOò´GL HDIGHFRUDWLRQRQULPZLWKIXQQHOò´GL HO 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ FXODUZLWKDFDQWKXVERUGHUDURXQGULP R] ´GLR] R] FRQWLQXHG SUREDEO\IRU0DFNLQWRVK´GLR]G $OH[DQGHU:LONLH (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOVWDQGZLWKIXQQ *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOVWDQGDFDQWKXVO *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK :LQHIXQQHOVWDQGSODLQFLU FD 'DYLG*UD\ 'XPSKULHV :LQHIXQQHOVWDQGZLWKUHHGHGERU YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION SOURCE

533 Compendium of Scottish Silver

534 Wine Cups and Goblets

WineWINE Cups CUPS AND & GOBLETS Goblets

Plate 53. A Wine Goblet 1807/08 by Robert Gray & Son, Glasgow (Edinburgh assay). Courtesy of J H Bourdon-Smith, London.

535 Compendium of Scottish Silver 1973 Catalog 2001 #74 Christies July 3, 1984 #128 Sothebys November 6, 1969 #191 16, April Christies NY USA 1999 #335 Nicholas Shaw vol XIV #2 back cover #2 back vol XIV advertisement of Edinburgh How Sothebys Scone Palace April Sothebys 23- #89 1979 24, Finlay 1991 #35 Finlay 1991 Bonhams The Scottish Sale The Scottish Bonhams August 24, 2005 ## National Museums of Scotland National Museums MEQ 1567 Asprey Antiques Catalog June Asprey 1990 p26 lour impaling century communion century th s, on molded and domed s, on molded trumpet stem, applied stem, trumpet WG” on the other, 6 pedal WG” on the pindie Communion cups, Communion pindie a thin band of bright cut work, bright cut of band a thin Mercer of Aldie and Meik Mercer of ngraved with initials “AS”, 1oz with initials “AS”, ngraved igh domed foot, broad igh domed lly identical to the Kils “AC’ on one handle, “M handle, on one “AC’ t, daughter of Sir Thomas Stewart of Grantully, Kt, their of Grantully, Stewart Thomas of Sir t, daughter lip shaped bowls, baluster stem lip shaped bowls, on rim foot, shallow circular bow, engraved with engraved bow, shallow circular foot, rim on r, standing cups, decoration similar to 17 decoration similar cups, r, standing chalice, on stepped h chalice, on stepped cup, no detailscup, Finlay 1991 #32 simulated staves, flat handle, e staves, flat simulated baluster stems, 8 ¾” ht, 34.2oz ht, 8 ¾” baluster stems, engraved with festoons of flowers below flowers of with festoons engraved 6 ¼” ht, 7.1oz bases, 37.9oz both 37.9oz bases, those of Jean Stewar those of Jean in 1648 marriage occurred reeded girdle, plain bell shaped bowl, slightly everted rim, engraved “DEO engraved bowl, bell shaped rim, girdle, plain slightly everted reeded DE FERNY”, foot DOMINA SANDFORD DOROTHEA DICAVIT 7.3oz 6 1/3”, renewed, engraved with the arms of Sir James Sir James of with the arms engraved cups, 9” ht, 8 ¼” di of bowls, both 52oz flowers in the center in the flowers inburgh Wine cups, pair, tu Edinburgh bowl, border, bell shaped bead edged with base goblet, reel shaped Wine William Dempster William WINE GOBLETS, CUPS & TASTERS & CUPS 1724/25 Mitchelson James Edinburgh pai Wine cups, 1688 ca1710 ca Zaccharias Millinus EdinburghWalker George Chalice Forsythe The Wine chalice, Aberdeen small, taster, Wine #55 Finlay 1991 1685/86 Penman James Edinburghon with slightly flaring lips slightly bowls goblets, pair, Wine tapering 1767/68 Davie or William 1680 ca II Cleghorne Thomas Edinburgh only on lip mound and foot, mm stem trumpet reeded on spreading Wine cup, Art Review Scottish 1763/64 Alexander Gairdner Ed 1660 ca Gairdyne Robert Dundeevirtua pair, cups, Wine 1730/31 Aytoun William Edinburgh Wine YEAR MAKER1630 ca Cleghorne Thomas Edinburgh LOCATION DESCRIPTION Wine SOURCE 1647/48 Cleghorne Thomas Edinburgh engraved Wine taster,

536 Wine Cups and Goblets Q 0DJD]LQHYRO LVWLHV(GLQEXUJK1RYHPEHU 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS 1977 #178 1977 #178 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW 1975 #55 %RQKDPV7KH6FRWWLVK6DOH $XJXVW 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS -DPHV5RELQVRQ1< advertisement Lyon & Turnbull Turnbull & Lyon 7KH0XUUD\&ROOHFWLRQ$XJXVW Lyon & Turnbull 7KH0XUUD\&ROOHFWLRQ$XJXVW Mannheim advertisement advertisement Mannheim QJRQ LQLWLDOV³-'´ WKHU´KW RQ´´KWR]G 6RWKHE\V*OHQHDJOHV$XJXVW \WKH1&RIILFHUVDQGSULYDWHVRIWKH$EHUGRXU GHVWDOIRRWVOHQGHURYRLGERZOVJLOWLQWHULRUV HQJUDYHGFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI:DONHU³&XUDHW QVSUHDGLQJIRRWZLWKIOXWLQJFXSZLWKFUHVW±D VKDSHGERZOVHQJUDYHGZLWKFUHVW±JRDW¶VKHDG HPZLWKJDGURRQHGJHNQRSRQVSUHDGLQJIRRW JLOWURXQGIRRWó´KWR]HDFK 'DOODV0XVHXPRI$UW 9ROXQWHHUWR&DSW+XJK&RYHQWU\ô´KWR]ERWK DUPVRI.HOORFN´KWR] EHQHDWKWKHPRWWR³63$5(128*+7´IRU+D\JLOWLQWHULRUVUHVWL WUXPSHWEDVHVó´KWR] LQVGXVWULD´ô´KWR] R] OLRQ¶VKHDGLQLWLDOV³:)&´RWKHUVLGHFUHVWDQGPRWWRRI6WUR ZLWKIOXWLQJWKHFXSVHQJUDYHGZLWKDFUHVWDQGPRWWR³),50´ JLOWLQWHULRUVô´KWR] *ODVJRZ :LQHFXSVSDLULQVFULEHG³WR&DSWDLQ$OH[DQGHU+DPLOW *ODVJRZ :LQHJREOHWVSDLUQRGHWDLOV 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLR Assayed Edinburgh Assayed Edinburgh 5REHUW*UD\ 6RQ -RKQ0F'RQDOG (GLQEXUJK :LQHJREOHWVSDLUSUHVHQWHGE 5REHUW*UD\ 6RQ )UDQFLV+RZGHQ (GLQEXUJK :LQHJREOHWSDLUFLUFXODUSH *HRUJH)HQZLFN (GLQEXUJK 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ :LQHJREOHWò´KW (GLQEXUJK :LQHFXSVSDLUSODLQYDVH $QWLTXHV )UDQFLV+RZGHQ (GLQEXUJK :LQHJREOHWVSDLUEULJKWFXW 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ :LQHJREOHWQRGHWDLOV (GLQEXUJK :LQHJREOHWNQRSSHGVWHPR &KU 3DWULFN5REHUWVRQ (GLQEXUJK :LQHJREOHWVSDLUHDFKVW YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1773/74 LOCATION Gairdner Alexander Edinburgh no details pair, goblets, Wine SOURCE 91 #570 vol Magazine Antiques $OH[DQGHU*DLUGQHU (GLQEXUJK :LQHJREOHWVSDLUVLOYHU

537 Compendium of Scottish Silver YROS DAG008655, DAG008655, DAG008808 DAG008808 SHWRXQ+RXVH$SULO Argent Antiques advertisement advertisement Antiques Argent MEQ 1332 MEQ 1332 1980.61 Galleries, AB Galleries, DFTXLUHG Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2004 2004 Catalog Shaw Nicholas p105 2006 AB Galleries RI6WURWKHUô´KW DLGWREH6FRWWLVK 6RWKHE\V+RSHWRXQ+RXVH$SULO LRUFUHVW´KWR] 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJS on date 1821 1821 on date Scotland of Museums National 12.1oz 12.1oz Glasgow Glasgow details no pair, goblets, Wine Aberdeen Winegoblets, no details NY Shrubsole Sothebys Gleneagles August Glasgow Winegoblet, see photo J Bourdon-Smith London March :LQHJREOHWVDLGWREH6FRWWLVKQRGHWDLOV $QWLTXHV0DJD]LQH *ODVJRZ :LQHJREOHWVSDLUUHHOVKDSHGEDVHVFUHVWDQGPRWWR am Jamieson Jamieson am Aberdeen details no pair, goblets, Wine and Museums Aberdeen Assayed Edinburgh Over striking another another striking Over Assayed Edinburgh Assayed Edinburgh Assayed Edinburgh 1820/21 -RKQ+D\ Hay John /HLWK Leith :LQHJREOHWQRGHWDLOV presentati cup, Wine )LQOD\ FD 1RWDYDLODEOH :LQHFXSVWDQGLQJFXSPPLQGLVWLQFWV FD :LOOL 1806/07 *HRUJH)HQZLFN Son & Gray Robert (GLQEXUJK :LQHJREOHWVSDLUJLOWLQWHU 1807/08 James Gordon Gordon 1807/08 James 1807/08 Son & Gray Robert FD 1810 ca :LOOLDP-DPLHVRQ Jamieson $EHUGHHQ William 1810/11 Aberdeen available :LQHJREOHWVSDLU McDonald James WJ ABD, WJ, marked gilt, pair, goblets, 1814/15 Not Wine -DPHV0F.D\ Edinburgh no details goblets, Wine (GLQEXUJK :LQHFXSVQRGHWDLOV and Museums Aberdeen )LQOD\ 78 p525 vol Magazine Antiques 6RWKHE\V+R YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1805/06 LOCATION Son & Gray Robert SOURCE

538 Wine Cups and Goblets RUQLQJ VHXPVDQG Z&DWDORJ '$* '$* '$* '$* 1995-269 1995-269 &DWDORJ 0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG Nicholas Shaw Catalog 2005 p98 2005 Catalog Shaw Nicholas 1988 #80 1988 #80 p103 *DOOHULHV$% Galleries p103 0XVHXP$QWLTXHV6KRZ1< USA *DOOHULHV$% *DOOHULHV$% *DOOHULHV$% DQGZLWKGDJJHU³*,1´ $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG ZLWKYLQHVDQG%DFFKLFILJXUHV³3RUW´ 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ LWKIHDWKHUHGJH³3257´ 'XQGHH0XVHXPVDQG$UW FXW³3RUW´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ LQHODEHOPP;¶V³0$'(,5$´ ´KWR] Edinburgh Winegoblet, no details Sothebys Hopetoun House April *ODVJRZ :LQHODEHOEULJKWFXWFXUYHG³0DGHLUD´ 1LFKRODV6KD am Scott Scott am Dundee bright circular, label, Wine DP-DPLHVRQ $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHOPP;¶V³0$56$/$´ $EHUGHHQ0X WINE LABELS WINE Edmonstoun Edmonstoun Assayed Edinburgh FD :LOOL YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1830/31 Alexander LOCATION SOURCE 1832/33 C Rait D Glasgow interior, gilt foot, pedestal stepped circular on form, plain goblet, Wine FD 5REHUW*UD\ FDFD $OH[DQGHU=LHJOHUFD *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK -DPHV(UVNLQH (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOQRGHWDLOV :LQHODEHOHVFXWFKHRQVKDSHG $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHOPDUNHG³(´LQFXVHK 7KH FD (GZDUG/LYLQJVWRQH 'XQGHH :LQHODEHOFUHVFHQWIRUPZ FD -+FD -+ (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHO³:KLVNH\´ (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOIROLDJHERUGHU³*LQ &DOLIRUQLD'HDOHU& $VSUH\ FD -DPHV(UVNLQH $EHUGHHQ : FD -DPHV(UVNLQH $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHO12<$8PDUNHG,(,( 1800 ca 1800 ca Willi

539 Compendium of Scottish Silver 05 05 H6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ 1964-29-2 1964-29-2 1986-119 1986-119 1995-269 DV6KDZ&DWDORJ Galleries 0(4 S S UK 6FKUHGG¶V$QWLTXHV/RQGRQ S Galleries Galleries S YLQHOHDI³3257´ 3ULYDWH&ROOHFWLRQ IRU³:KLVNH\´DQG³5XP´PDUNHG±-( ODUODEHOV³*LQ´³3RUW´³:KLVNH\´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ FRUQHUV³:KLVNH\´ $VSUH\&DWDORJ OV 7KH0DSOH6ZDQ&ROOHFWLRQ LQ´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ UDQG\´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ ERUGHU³6KHUU\´ô´;´ H%D\0DUFK ³%UDQG\´XQPDUNHG rd with a 3 a with :LQHODEHO³0DGHLUD´QRGHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG *ODVJRZ :LQHODEHOFXUYHGHDFKHQGIRUPHGDQGHQJUDYHGDVD (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOVKDSHGVKLHOG³%UDQG\´³:KLVNH\´ 1LFKRO QVWDEOH 'XQGHH :LQHODEHO³&855$17´ 'XQGHH0XVHXPVDQG$UW $VVD\HG(GLQEXUJK $VVD\HG(GLQEXUJK II FD 5* FD $OH[DQGHU6WHZDUW ,QYHUQHVV :LQHODEHOUHFWDQJXODU³% FD 5REHUW*UD\ 6RQ FD *HRUJH)HQZLFN 1810 ca *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK Co William (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOVHWRIQRGHWDL :LQHODEHOVTXDUHZLWKURXQG FD $OH[DQGHU6WHZDUW ,QYHUQHVV :LQHODEHOUHFWDQJXODU³* FD -DPHV(UVNLQH $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHOVH\HVKDSHGODEHOV FDFD -RKQ0F'RQDOG -DPHV(UVNLQH (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOQRGHWDLOV $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHOFXWFRUQHUUHFWDQJX 7KH0DSO 1810 ca 1810 ca Cunningham P & W 1800 ca 1800 ca Douglas James FD : 3&XQQLQJKDP, Dundee (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOREORQJUHHGHG no details label, Wine Art and Museums Dundee YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION 1800 ca LOCATION Livingstone Edward Dundee details no 4, of set label, Wine SOURCE Art and Museums Dundee

540 Wine Cups and Goblets 6FRWODQG DQG$UW '$* XVHXPDQG$UW 0DJD]LQHYROS HV RODV6KDZ&DWDORJ *DOOHUL *DOOHULHV$% *DOOHULHV S *DOOHULHV 86$ 0(4 (GLQEXUJK++ $XWXPQS ´ORQJ´ZLGH +XQWOH\+RXVH0XVHXP $'(,5$´´;´ &LQFLQQDWL0XVHXPRI$UW '(,5$´ 'XQGHH0XVHXPDQG$UW GJH³0$'(,5$´ 0XVHXPRI)LQH$UW%RVWRQ0$ ODUWKUHDGHGJH³*LQ´ -%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ GHGFRUQHUV³/LVERQ´ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG GHWDLOV 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG $1'<´ $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOUHFWDQJXODU³6KHUU\´ 1DWLRQDO0XVHXPVRI DP5LWFKLH 3HUWK :LQHODEHOSODLQUHFWDQJXODU³:KLVNH\´ 1LFK -RKQ+D\/HLWK FD :LOOLDP-DPLHVRQ $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHO³%5 FD :LOOLDP0DUVKDOOFD (GLQEXUJK $OH[DQGHU&DPHURQFD 'XQGHH :LQHODEHOUHFWDQJXODUQR $OH[DQGHU&DPHURQ 'XQGHH :LQHODEHO³:+,6.(<´ :LQHODEHORUQDWHERUGHU³0$ 'XQGHH0 FD -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHO³3257 'XQGHH0XVHXPV -DPHV0F.D\ -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJKFD :LQHODEHOEURDGUHFWDQJXODU³0 $OH[DQGHU&DPHURQ (GLQEXUJK 'XQGHH -DPHV+RZGHQRU :LQHODEHOSODLQFHQWHUVKHOOH :LQHODEHO³6KHUU\´ $QWLTXHV -DPHV0F.D\ (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOREORQJ³3257´ FD *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOUHFWDQJXODUURXQ 1815 ca 1815 ca Willi YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION LOCATION 0LWFKHOO 5XVVHOO *ODVJRZ :LQHODEHOURXQGHGUHFWDQJX SOURCE

541 Compendium of Scottish Silver n R DWDORJ PVDQG PVDQG XPVRI6FRWODQG '$* '$* '$* 0XVHXPVRI6FRWODQG S S 6FKUHGG¶V$QWLTXHV/RQGRQ 0(4 *DOOHULHV$% *DOOHULHV 0(4 S S *DOOHULHV$% *DOOHULHV$% K $EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG KUHHGHGHGJH³3RUW´PDUNV±*( DLOV 0*HW]:DVKLQJWRQ'&86$ KHUU\´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ 3RUW´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ UW´³6KHUU\´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ XODUSODLQ³3RUW´³&ODUHW´³0DGHLUD´ 6FKUHGG¶V$QWLTXHV/RQG HODEHO³6KUXE´ 1DWLRQDO0XVH IRXOHGDQFKRU6W$QGUHZ¶V&URVV7/ DP/DZ 'XQGHH :LQHODEHOUHFWDQJXODU³*HQHYD´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ& FD -$XVWLQ 'XQGHH :LQHODEHOFXWFRUQHUVUHFWDQJXODU³ FD 1RWDYDLODEOHFD -$XVWLQ 'XQGHH :LQHODEHOUHWDLOHGE\)RUUHVWVQRGHW :LQHODEHOFXWFRUQHUUHFWDQJXODU³6 FD *( 6W$QGUHZV :LQHODEHOEURDGUHFWDQJXODUVKDSHZLW FD *HRUJH0F+DWWLHFD (GLQEXUJK -DPHV0F.D\ :LQHODEHO³%UDQG\´ (GLQEXUJK :LQ 1DWLRQDO FD $0F/HRG *ODVJRZ 1820 ca :LQHODEHO³6´ Willi FD 'DYLG*UD\ 'XPSKULHV :LQHODEHOSDLUUHFWDQJXODU³3R 'XQGHH0XVHXPDQG$UW FD *HRUJH0F+DWWLH (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOVHWRIUHFWDQJ YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION FD LOCATION *HRUJH%RRWK $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHO³:,1(´ SOURCE $EHUGHHQ0XVHX FD *HRUJH%RRWK $EHUGHHQ :LQHODEHO³:,1(´ $EHUGHHQ0XVHX FD 1RWDYDLODEOH :LQHODEHO³*,1*(5´SUHVXPDEO\6FRWWLV

542 Wine Cups and Goblets VHXPVRI6FRWODQG &HQWHU1<86$ %RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ S $XWXPQS $OH[DQGULD9$$QWLTXH&HQWHU 1995 7KH3KRHQL[&ROOHFWLRQ 1992 0(4 S S UDOERUGHU³3RUW´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ QJXODUIORUDOERUGHU³,VOD\´ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ HOOVDQGVFUROOVDQGOHDYHVDURXQGERUGHU QGDWHG 1DWLRQDO0X VKDWFKHGERUGHU³6KHUU\¶ 1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ ³3RUW´ - :0LWFKHOO *ODVJRZ :LQHODEHOEORFN³3´IRU3RUW - FD -DPHV+RZGHQFD 5REHUW.HD\ 6RQ (GLQEXUJK 3HUWK :LQHODEHOQRGHWDLOV :LQHODEHOREORQJSUHVHQWDWLR +\GH3DUN FD 5REHUW1DXJKWRQ ,QYHUQHVV :LQHODEHOUHFWDQJXODUFURV FD -/ &XSDU :LQHODEHOURXQGHGFRUQHUVUHFWDQJXODUIOR FD -DPHV+RZGHQ (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOVKDSHGRYDOZLWKVK YEAR MAKER DESCRIPTION FD LOCATION -0LOOLGJH (GLQEXUJK :LQHODEHOURXQGHGFRUQHUVUHFWD SOURCE

543 Compendium of Scottish Silver

544 Glossary

BRIEF GLOSSARY AND EXPLANATIONS

To aid the reader, a brief glossary of terms found in the compendium and related sources are provided along with explanations for some maker assignments within this book. For a far more FRPSUHKHQVLYHGHILQLWLRQRIWHUPVZHZRXOGUHIHUWKHUHDGHUWR0LFKDHO&OD\WRQ¶V'LFWLRQDU\RI the Silver and Gold of Great Britain and North America. (see Works Cited).

Acanthus = a leafy plant used as a model for some stylized decoration

Adam-style = following the architectural designs of Robert Adam, the important 18th century Scottish architect.

Argyll = a container with a heat preserving component (hot water jacket or a heated bar of iron) to enable gravy to stay warm.

Assay master = the goldsmith entrusted by the Incorporation with certifying the standard of wares wrought by the freemen. Prior to 1681, the elected deacon in Edinburgh also performed the function of assay master. The elected posts were separated in 1681 but the DVVD\PDVWHUFRQWLQXHGWRXVHKLVPDNHU¶VPDUNSXQFKIRUFHUWLILFDWLRQXQWLOWKHDGYHQWRIWKH thistle mark in 1759. The Scottish standard for silver was not the same as English sterling for much of the 18th century and earlier.

Ashet = an oval meat dish; the term is frequently used in Scotland and is derived from French.

Bale (or bail) = a swing handle as on a bucket

Baluster = a column or stem of small size with a shaped outline.

Bannock Rack = a variant on the toast rack but with fewer especially wide dividers to accommodate Scottish bannock bread.

Beaker = a tall cylindrical cup, usually of tapering-cylindrical form, without handles.

Blackjack = a leather tankard or bottle, sometimes with silver mounts

Bleeding Bowl = in this book a form of shallow dish or cup with a single handle (also called a porringer in some countries).

Bobeche = from the French, a collar on a candlestick nozzle used to catch wax drippings

Bombe = curving or bulging outward. Based on French and used extensively in furniture designs. This form would contrast with the inverted pear or baluster descriptions in that the bulge is usually dramatic but following a smooth line.

Cabriole = resembling the leg of a capering (e.g. goat) animal. It is a leg that curves outward at the knee and then narrows downward ending is an ornamental foot. The term and use was SURPLQHQWLQ7KRPDV&KLSSHQGDOH¶VIXUQLWXUHGHVLJQV

xxiii545xxi Compendium of Scottish Silver

Campana = the shape of a bell.

Canted corners = corners having slanted or oblique surfaces.

Canteen = a container usually with cutlery, spice containers and a cup or beaker for use when traveling.

Capped = sitting atop, as in a stylized leaf sitting atop a handle on a mug, (i.e. leaf-capped.)

Capstan = the shape of a vertical spool-shaped cylinder used on docks for securing boats

Caryatid = usually a supporting column that takes the form of a draped female figure.

Cartouche = an oval shaped decorated element usually engraved or as an applied plaque. Its function was usually to permit owner designations. It is either vacant or containing heraldic elements or initials.

Caster = a tall, narrow covered container for sugar and spices. They may have pierced covers or be blind (not pierced, but sometimes engraved to match the pierced design on others).

Casting = made involving a mold usually created in wood, metal or wax. Examples of casting would include spouts on teapots and some candlesticks. Exceptional Scottish casting required a different set of expertise from that of raising spoons, etc. Therefore, examples of cast Scottish candlesticks are found for only an expert subset of all Scottish goldsmiths.

&'OHWWHUVLQDKHDUWVKDSHGVKLHOG(GLQEXUJKPDNHU¶VPDUN 2ULJLQDOO\HDUO\th century FD &'PDUNVZHUHDWWULEXWHGVROHO\WR&KDUOHV'LFNVRQ,DJROGVPLWKLQERWK Edinburgh and Dundee. However, the recent appearance of items carrying the mark in question prior to Dickson becoming free suggests that Charles Duncan is the more likely attribution for the mark presented in Jackson. In this compendium, both names are listed in many cases where the source had attributed the piece to Dickson. This current confusion over this specific mark for Duncan vs. Dickson should be sorted out in favor of Duncan in the near future.

Chamfered corners = corners given a smooth rounded or beveled shape.

Chasing = the pushing of the silver surface with no removal of silver to create decorative patterns or designs. Flat chasing is performed from the front and is in low relief. In contrast, repousse chasing is done from the back where silver is pushed into raised patterns and then finished on the front

Chocolate Pot = of similar form to a coffee pot but with a finial either hinged or sliding to permit ready use of a stirrer for suspending the sediment before serving

Cinquefoil = an architectural design having five sides consisting of converging arcs. The origin is derived from five petaled flowers or the plant of the same name.

546xxiv Glossary

Cipher = a design of interweaving letters of a monogram in an intricate manner. With many cipher engravings the letters are virtually indecipherable or coded. Hence the derivation of the term

Citrine = a pale yellow type of crystallized quartz

Cover = a fully detachable lift-off top usually to a two-handled cup, sugar bowl or occasionally a few teapots.

Coconut Cup = a coconut shell usually mounted with silver.

Coronets = coronets on Scottish silver have different distinctions depending upon the exact form of the crown. This explains references made in the descriptions to the coronet of a duke, an earl, etc. Sometimes, a specific coronet and an initial (of the last name) are sufficient to suggest a likely family of prior ownership. Coronets are of five types distinguishing the ranks of duke, marquess, earl, viscount and lord in descending order. In the peerage of Scotland ³ORUG´LVWKHFRUUHFWWLWOHIRUWKHHTXLYDOHQW(QJOLVKUDQNRI³EDURQ´

Cowrie Box = a box, in this case-silver mounted, using the shell of a specific tropical marine gastropod

Cruet = a low stand with rings to hold casters, casters and bottles, bottles alone or egg cups

Cut-Card Work = a late 17th early 18th century decorative procedure involving pieces of silver, sometimes decorated itself, which were then applied to the body or cover of an item via solder. In Scottish silver, the most frequently seen examples are the lobes found on thistle mugs arranged in such a way as to suggest stylized leaves.

'HDFRQ WKH'HDFRQRIWKH,QFRUSRUDWLRQRI*ROGVPLWKVLQ(GLQEXUJKZDVWKHKLJKHVWHOHFWHG position and the post was most usually held for two years in duration. Until 1681, the deacon DOVRVHUYHGDVWKHDVVD\PDVWHUDQGKLVPDNHU¶VPDUNZDVXVHGIRUFHUWLI\LQJWKDWWKH appropriate silver standard had been used in making an item. Once a goldsmith had served as Deacon he continued to be referred to as Deacon in subsequent minutes, notes and correspondence of the Incorporation. This is a practice that can lead to some confusion in the present day.

Diaper-Work = a decorated usually engraved area consisting of a network of shaped geometric elements usually boxes or lozenges (sometimes with a dot in the center of each)

Dirk = a particular type of Highland dagger with a long straight blade. The dirk is at least twice the length of a skene dhu, slung from a belt at the waist when wearing the kilt.

Dish Cross = an X-shaped stand having a combination of four arms (usually adjustable in length) used to support a dish for serving and/or warming. Scottish examples may or may not be equipped with a central burner.

Dish Ring = In Scotland, a circular open ring or shallow cone on a stand used to accommodate a circular food container such as a serving dish. It serves the same function as a dish cross. It sometimes has a fitting for a spirit burner.

547xxv Compendium of Scottish Silver

Disk-end spoons = among the earliest form of Scottish spoon. The terminal is an almost complete circle joining the stem. The disk may carry decoration and/or engraving of initials or arms.

Dog-nose flatware/spoons = a modification of the trefid without any notches. The center of the terminal is rounded and projecting while the shoulders are also slightly rounded. The terminal is angled upward slightly from the plane of the stem (in contrast with wavy-end flatware). The pattern was found mainly between 1690-1715 in Scotland

Dolphin-handle = the famous dolphin handles applied to select Scottish cream boats, etc. of the 1740s and 50s was used by only a small cadre of Scottish goldsmiths. From close inspection of several cast forms, the figure does not resemble an actual dolphin but rather is a heraldic dolphin or stylized sea creature with mixed features derived from dolphins, eels and fish. The earliest use recorded to date is 1743/44 WD mm for either William Dempster or William Davie.

Double-scroll = two connected scrolls, as used in forming a handle, with the second curved at a different angle from the first.

Dredger = a container with a perforated cover for sifting through flour or other materials.

Edinburgh Silver post 1783 = Since Scottish silver was supposed to be assayed in Edinburgh and duty paid from 1784-, many provincial goldsmiths made work carrying Edinburgh marks, particularly between 1784 and the opening of the Glasgow assay office in 1819. Therefore, any pieces falling in this interval should be viewed as potentially crafted by goldsmiths based anywhere in Scotland and not necessarily the output of an Edinburgh goldsmith.

Engraving = design created by removing silver from the surface. Engraving was used in Scotland for including armorials, initials and also for other decorations. Bright cut-engraving is seen from about 1775 on and is created by using contrasting depths and angles of the cut.

Epergne = usually a centerpiece with a large central bowl and several smaller bowls distributed around the circumference: a French term

Everted = turned outward

Ewer = a pitcher of various shapes accompanying a basin, both were used for hand washing during meals (particularly necessary preceding the use of utensils).

Faceted = having multiple flat surfaces oriented at different angles as on a cut gemstone.

Fiddle pattern flatware/spoons (English) = this is the traditional flatware with the terminal half of the stem forming a slightly rounded rectangle. Slight projections can occur where this rectangle thins to the profile of the stem.

Flagon = frequently these were made for secular use but then later presented by donors to churches. These usually take the form of tall, slender tankards/pitchers, often they are cylindrical and on a spreading foot

548xxvi Glossary

Flange = a protruding rim or collar

Festoon = a draped arrangement of flowers and fruit tied at either end and sometimes secured in the middle as well

Filigree = openwork metal formed into geometric design or foliage-like ornament

Finial = an element, usually architecturally-derived, placed atop covers, lids and some spoons

Fluting = a series of long usually rounded grooves incised into otherwise flat surfaces, the effects resemble that of a pleated ruffle of cloth.

Foliate = resembling foliage

Freedom = as in Freedom Boxes. The granting of the right to become a burgess of a burgh or alternatively a freeman of an Incorporation or Guild. It could be given by town councils in gratitude or earned though apprenticeship and successful essays. Freedom Boxes were designed to hold the documents.

Gadroons = probably referring to gathered-rounds, in this case decorative raised arcs of silver used in the borders of tazzas, sauceboats, and on the bases of various pieces.

Girdle = in this case an applied band of silver, sometimes decorated, placed surrounding the body and used to strengthen the piece while providing decoration.

Hanoverian flatware/spoons = This is a pattern common across the UK and the earliest use in Scotland was 1702/03. The pattern has an upturned mostly rounded terminal on a stem sometimes with an upper midrib. Contemporary engraving was always placed on the terminal reverse.

+DVK6SRRQ KHUHDODUJHVHUYLQJVSRRQJUHDWHUWKDQ´LQOHQJWK

IB Glasgow 1707-50 mark = In this book, these marks are designated as by Johann Got-helf- Bilsings as according to Jackson. However, this maker assignment seems tenuous and is likely to be revised in the near future. The reader should approach this with caution. James Boyd became a freeman in 1707 and the earlier IB marks possibly pertain to him.

,0PDNHU¶VPDUNV(GLQEXUJK %DVHGRQWKHPRVWUHFHQWLQIRUPDWLRQDWSUHVVWLPH designation for the mark IM with a figure between has been given to James Mitchell. Pieces previously attributed to John Main have been assigned to James Mitchelson in this compendium. Pieces carrying the mark, IM in an engrailed rectangle, are listed as by either James McKenzie I or James Mitchelson. (see Silver Studies 2006 for more detail).

Knop = a decorative knob such as those found on the stems of some communion cups and candlesticks or on the tops of handles of some early Scottish two-handled cups.

Lattice (or Trellis) work = a framework of regularly overlaid lines.

Leith Race Prizes = The Leith Race was an annual horserace where prizes were awarded. The FRQWUDFWIRUSURGXFLQJWKHSUL]HXVXDOO\ZHQWWRWKH'HDFRQRIWKH(GLQEXUJK,QFRUSRUDWLRQRI

xxvii549 Compendium of Scottish Silver

Goldsmiths. The gold teapots by James Ker are examples of Leith prizes. Regrettably, only a small proportion of those that were made have survived.

Lid = a top to items such as a teapot, tankard or jug, that is not designed to detach completely and is hinged either via a flush hinge or through an applied hinge.

Lozenge = a heraldic device in a diamond-like shape.

/XJ OLWHUDOO\³HDU´WKH6FRWWLVKZRUGIRUDVPDOOKDQGOHDVRQDTXDLFKSLJJLQHWF

Maker vs. Deacon = For pre-1681 Edinburgh silver where the elected deacon served as the assay master, it is not always possible to determine with certainty which punch is that of the maker of a piece and which is by the deacon at the time of assay. Because of this, the same piece may appear to have different makers as described in different catalogs. A famous example is the set of trefid spoons carrying the marks of Edward Cleghorne I and Alexander Reid. We have attempted to use the most recent designations based on style and other considerations. %XWWKHVHVWLOOODFNFRPSOHWHFHUWDLQW\8VXDOO\WKHPDNHU¶VPDUNLVRQWKHOHIWRIWKHFDVWOH DQGWKHGHDFRQ¶VPDUNRQWKHULJKWEXWWKLVPHWKRGRILGHQWLILFDWLRQEUHDNVGRZQZKHQPDUNV are struck vertically on spoons, etc.

0DUURZ6SRRQ DVSRRQWKDWKDVWKHVWHPLQFRUSRUDWLQJDPDUURZVFRRS

Mazer = a shallow, broad bowl, often wooden, on a single foot that can range from a low rim to a WDOOHUSHGHVWDO IRU³VWDQGLQJPD]HUV´

0RQWHLWK DERZOXVXDOO\DSXQFKERZOZLWKDQRWFKHGULP VRPHWLPHVGHWDFKDEOH QDPHG DIWHUD6FRWVPDQZKRVHFORDNVZHUHQRWFKHGDWWKHERWWRP

Muffineer = a container with a perforated cover for applying sugar to breads, etc.

Nozzle = also called a socket. The top part of the candlestick into which the candle is inserted. 6RPHWLPHVWKHVHDUHPDGHWREHGHWDFKDEOH

Octagonal hollowware = silver items with eight-sided finished surfaces Employed in the early 18thFHQWXU\E\RQO\WKHPRUHH[SHUW6FRWWLVKJROGVPLWKV

Old English flatware/spoons = a modification of the Hanoverian pattern where the terminal FXUYHVGRZQZDUGVDQGXVXDOO\ZLWKDVPRRWKVWHPDQGQRPLGULE6HHSRLQWHG2OG(QJOLVK IRUDFRPPRQ6FRWWLVKYDULDQW

3DS%RDW DVKDOORZERZOXVHGIRUIHHGLQJ,WLVVKDSHGOLNHWKHWRSRID6FRWWLVKFUHDPERDWEXW without a foot or handle.

3DWHQ DFRYHUIRUDFRPPXQLRQFXS6RPHWLPHVLWLVQRWHDVLO\GLVWLQJXLVKDEOHIURPDVPDOO WD]]D&RPPXQLRQFXSVRIWKH&KXUFKRI6FRWODQGQHYHUKDYHSDWHQV3DWHQVJRZLWKFKDOLFHV and are used by the Catholic Church but they have no foot. Patens in the Episcopal Church of 6FRWODQGPLJKWRFFDVLRQDOO\KDYHDIRRWOLNHDWD]]DEXWDUHQRUPDOO\MXVWDVKDOORZGLVK ZLWKRXWDIRRW6FRWWLVKSDWHQVLIDQ\6FRWWLVKPDGHRQHVUHDOO\H[LVWEHIRUHWKHODWHUth century, are extraordinarily rare.

550xxviii Glossary

Piggin = A piggin is a miniature stave-built pail, with one of the staves rising above the rest to form a single vertical lug. This shape was occasionally copied in silver.

Pointed Old English = the variant derived from the Old English flatware (i.e. a down-turned rounded end on spoon terminals) pattern using a pointed rather than a rounded terminal. It was made mainly in Scotland, Ireland and by Scottish or Irish craftsman in the colonies. It has been called by a variety of names over the years. It has nothing whatsoever to do with being Celtic.

Points = repeating projections within the wavy borders of bowls, salvers and teapot stands. These may be enumerated as one means of distinguishing among otherwise identical pieces. 7KHQXPEHURI³SRLQWV´RQDVWDQGLVXVXDOO\PRUHWKDQWKHQXPEHURISRLQWVRQDVXJDU bowl within the same set.

Porringers = In this compendium, a form of two handled cups that are usually shallow, wide and bulbous near the base. Here it is distinguished from a bleeding bowl that has only one handle.

3XQFK%RZO LQWKLVERRNDERZORI´RUODUJHULQGLDPHWHU

Puritan spoons = modified from earlier slip-top spoons. The stem is not flat but rather largely square like a plank of wood. These spoons have essentially no special terminal beyond a cut made at right angles.

Quaich = a two-lugged shallow bowl. The earliest were originally made of wood. Many silver H[DPSOHV DWWHPSWWRVLPXODWHWKHZRRGHQVHFWLRQVE\HQJUDYLQJVWDYHOLQHV

Reeded = having a series of parallel incised lines.

Repousse = a technique of hammering designs in relief from the reverse side of metal.

Reticulated = a series of lines forming a net, mesh or network.

Riband = a ribbon used for decoration or to contain a motto.

Rocaille = decorative rococo work emphasizing shells and scrolls. Originally it meant artificial rock-work and this gradually slid into scrollwork. In contrast with rococo work, rocaille does not necessarily have to be asymmetrical.

Rococo = an ornate decorative style with intricate work of flowers, shells and scrolls. The defining element of rococo is that it is asymmetrical.

Roundels = a series of round panels.

6DOWLUH $6W$QGUHZ¶V&URVVLQWKHVKDSHRIDQ;

6DOYHU LQWKLVERRNDWUD\RQWKUHHRUPRUHIHHWRIJUHDWHUWKDQò´LQGLDPHWHU

Sander = a container, usually part of the 18th century writing implements set, with perforations in the cover to apply drying sand to documents just completed using ink. The sand aided in the drying process by stabilizing the ink on the document.

xxix551 Compendium of Scottish Silver

Sauceboats = this term for a handled sauce container of boat shape is somewhat confused with cream boats in 18thFHQWXU\6FRWODQG:HKDYHUHVHUYHGWKH³VDXFHERDW´WHUPJHQHUDOO\IRU HDUO\GRXEOHOLSSHGKDQGOHGERDWVDQGIRUODWHUERDWVRIODUJHUVL]HDQGGHHSHUVKDSHWKDQ WKRVHXVHGIRUFUHDP0DQ\ERDWVRIWKHVDQGHDUO\VWHUPHGVDXFHERDWVLQFDWDORJV were of a form described as cream boats in contemporary accounts.

6FDOORSHG KDYLQJFXUYHGSURMHFWLRQVIRUPLQJDQRUQDPHQWDOERUGHU'HULYHGIURPWKHPDULQH mollusk shell patterns. In this book, it is also used to describe the pie-crust-like borders on salts, etc.

6FRQFH SURWUXGLQJWRSSDUWRIDFDQGOHVWLFN VRPHWLPHVGHWDFKDEOH XVHGWRSUHYHQWZD[IURP GULSSLQJRQVXUIDFHVEHORZ

6FRWV)LGGOHSDWWHUQIODWZDUHVSRRQV GLIIHUHQWIURPWKHWUDGLWLRQ(QJOLVKILGGOHSDWWHUQ6FRWV fiddle is a pattern found mainly from 18th century Scotland. It is a modified Hanoverian ZKHUHWKHVWHPKDVWZRSURQRXQFHGEXOJHVZLWKWKHRXWOLQHUHVHPEOLQJWKHERG\RIDILGGOHRU YLROLQ7KHVHLWHPVZHUHXVXDOO\ZLWKPDNHU¶VPDUNRQO\7KHGHVLJQRYHUODSVZLWKVW\OHV VHHQLQ'HQPDUNDQGWKH1RUVHFRXQWULHV6FRWVILGGOHVXVXDOO\GDWHIURPFDFD

6FRWWLVKFUHVWVDQGPRWWRV XQOLNHIDPLOLHVLQ(QJODQGDQG,UHODQGZKHUHWKHPRWWRVZHUH placed beneath the crest, Scottish family mottos are usually seen on ribbons draped across the WRSRIFUHVWV$VDUHVXOWWKHYDVWPDMRULW\RIDUPRULDOVLOYHULQWKLVOLVWLQJZRXOGH[KLELW mottos placed above the crest. This helps readily identify pieces as previously Scottish owned. However, the maker of Scottish owned pieces may or may not be a Scottish JROGVPLWK/RQGRQPDGHVLOYHUZDVDOVRSXUFKDVHGE\6FRWWLVKSDWURQV6FRWWLVKPRWWRVDUH PRVWIUHTXHQWO\VHHQLQ/DWLQRU(QJOLVKEXWVRPHH[DPSOHVRI)UHQFKDQG6FRWVPRWWRVDOVR H[LVW7KHFRPELQDWLRQRIDVSHFLILFFUHVW XVXDOO\VKDUHGE\RQO\DIHZIDPLOLHV DQGPRWWR XVXDOO\VKDUHGE\DVPDOODQGRYHUODSSLQJVXEVHWRIIDPLOLHV LVDSRZHUIXOWRROLQLGHQWLI\LQJ WKHVLQJOH6FRWWLVKIDPLO\WKDWSUHYLRXVO\RZQHGDSLHFHRIVLOYHU3URYHQDQFHIRUPDQ\RIWKH VLOYHULWHPVLQWKLVOLVWLQJKDYHEHHQQDUURZHGWRDVLQJOHIDPLO\$QH[DPSOHRIDPRWWRLQ Scots is Quhidder will zieZLWKDXQLFRUQ¶VKHDGSHUWDLQLQJWRVHYHUDOIDPLOLHVRIWKH6WHZDUWV of Appin.

6FUDWFKZHLJKW WKHZHLJKWRIDQREMHFWDVGHVLJQDWHGWKURXJKXVXDOO\OLJKW³VFUDWFKHG´ HQJUDYLQJE\WKHJROGVPLWK6FUDWFKZHLJKWVDUHXVXDOO\SODFHGLQLQFRQVSLFXRXVSODFHVPRVW IUHTXHQWO\DSSOLHGWRWKHERWWRPRIPRUHVLJQLILFDQWLWHPVRIVLOYHU0RGHUQZHLJKWVRIROG SLHFHVVKRXOGEHVOLJKWO\ORZHUWKDQWKHVFUDWFKZHLJKWJLYHQWKHORVVRIVLOYHURYHUWLPH WKURXJKFOHDQLQJDQGZHDU6FUDWFKZHLJKWVFDQEHXVHIXOWRGHWHUPLQHLIDQLWHPKDVEHHQ DOWHUHGIURPLWVRULJLQDOIRUPDWVRPHWLPHLQWKHSDVW

Scrolls = decorative ornaments on silver and furniture that resemble, in form, partially unrolled rolls of paper

6HDO DGLHRUVLJQHWKDYLQJDUDLVHGRULPSUHVVHGV\PEROXVHGWRVWDPSWKHLPSUHVVLRQLQZD[ HWF,QWKLVFDVHXVHGWRVHDODQGHIIHFWLYHO\VLJQFRUUHVSRQGHQFH6HDOVZHUHIUHTXHQWO\ PDGHZLWKKDQGOHVRIVLOYHURUJROG6HDO%R[HVZHUHGHVLJQHGWRSURWHFWZD[VHDOV associated with important documents.

552xxx Glossary

Seal-top spoons = very rare in Scotland and from the late 16th century. Unlike English seals with balustoid elements as the terminal Scottish seals may consist of a terminal formed as a simple tapering rectangular section attached to the stem.

6HUYLQJ6SRRQ LQWKLVERRNDODUJHVSRRQXVXDOO\EHWZHHQ´LQOHQJWK

Silver Handles = It should be noted that silver handles on tea service items were not common in England or Ireland but were prominent in Scotland from 1720-50. Therefore, the descriptions indicate silver or wooden handles when the information was available.

6NHQH'KX PHDQLQJ³EODFNNQLIH´$ERXWKDOIWKHOHQJWKRIDGLUNDVNHQHGKXLVDVPDOO sheathed knife worn in the top of the right stocking when wearing the kilt.

Slip-top spoons = 17th century spoons similar to Puritan except that the end is cut at a severe angle (said to be slipped) rather than at a right angle.

Slop Bowl = a bowl used for disposal of used tea leaves or coffee sediment, usually broad and shallow compared with a sugar bowl. However, the distinction between slop and sugar bowls is not always clear.

Snuff Mull = a vertical snuff container usually of baluster form rather than a horizontal box. They may be all silver or simply silver-mounted.

Snuffer = usually a bell or cup shaped implement on a handle used to cover and extinguish the flame on a lighted candle or spirit lamp.

Socket = also called nozzle. The hollow upper part of a candlestick into which the candle is fitted. Sometimes sockets are made to be detachable.

Spherical = round, important in describing shapes of some teapots, milk jugs, covered sugars, etc. It is used here in place of the less-precise terms such as a globular and bullet.

Spool = of general cylindrical shape, slightly waisted.

Sporran = a Highland dress version of a leather or fur pouch worn at the front of the kilt and hung via a chain and leather strap. Frequently mounted with silver.

Spume = foam on a liquid as in breaking ocean waves at the shoreline.

Stands = early teapot and urn stands are usually supported on a simple rim foot contrasting with WD]]DVRQRQHSHGHVWDOIRRWRUVDOYHUVRQWKUHHRUPRUHIHHW$IWHUDERXWVSHFLDOL]HG stands became less frequent and salvers served the purpose.

Stippled = having a group of dots or flecks applied via short strokes.

Stirrup Cup = designed to be taken on foxhunts. It is a slender drinking cup shaped frequently OLNHDIR[¶VRUKRXQG¶VKHDG

Swags = ornamental draperies resembling draped curtains.

xxxi553 Compendium of Scottish Silver

Tazza = a salver or shallow dish on a raised pedestal foot

Thistle Mug = also called thistle cup. A relatively small mug of bell-shape with a flared rim similar to the shape of a thistle flower, usually with one or more applied girdles and frequently with several applied vertical lobes at the base simulating leaves. It may have a scrolled bead-decorated handle or a simple strap handle. It is uncommon outside of Scotland.

Toilet Service = equipment needed for the dressing table usually including a mirror, comb boxes, scent bottles, pin cushion, whisk, and sometimes candlesticks or ewers and basins.

Traprain silver (e.g. salts) = early 20th century reproductions of items from an ancient Roman silver hoard found on Traprain Law (hill), Scotland during quarrying activity in 1919. The firm of Brook and Son, Edinburgh, meticulously reproduced some items. The salts have a characteristic triangular shape.

Tray = In this book, it usually refers to a large salver with handles.

Trefid flatware/spoons = referring to a three lobed attachment or terminal as on a spoon. On a spoon this is created by flattening the upper part of the stem and using two notches two divide the terminal into three sections. When as attachments to bowls, etc the two side members are frequently described as commas. The trefid spoon terminal usually angles slightly upward form the plane of the stem. The trefid pattern was produced in Scotland mainly between 1670ca and 1710.

Trefoils = decorative elements of a leaf with three parts. Taken from the Trifolium genus.

Tumbler Cup = a cup without handles that tended to be broad but not deep. Sometimes these were nested when as sets. Scottish examples sometimes have slightly flared rims.

Two-Handled Cups = self explanatory except that they are distinguished from porringers by being more vertical compared with the diameter.

Unmarked Covers = Note that in 18th century Scotland and in contrast with London silver, the marking of covers was not common. Therefore, the descriptions lack a reference to this.

Vinaigrette = a small container (sometimes worn) designed to hold a sponge soaked in perfume or alternatively vinegar for use as smelling salts. It may be of small box form or take numerous other shapes.

Volute = a spiraled ornament resembling the designs found on gastropod mollusk (Volutidae family) shells (also used on Ionic capitals)

:DLWHU LQWKLVERRNXVHGIRUDWUD\UHVWLQJRQWKUHHRUPRUHIHHWDQG´RUOHVVLQGLDPHWHU

Warwick Cruet = a form of the cruet having the base designed with five rings. The earliest English example held five casters, however, many later examples hold two bottles and three casters.

Wavy-end flatware/spoons = similar to dog-nose in that it has a rounded center projection, like a GRJ¶VVQRXWDQGWZRVOLJKWO\URXQGHGVKRXOGHUVRQWKHWHUPLQDO+RZHYHULQWKLVFDVHWKH

554xxxii Glossary

end of the terminal of the spoon or fork is flat and in line with the stem. This is a largely early 18th century pattern in Scotland

Wax jack = an item used to distribute sealing wax from a reel to be melted and used in sealing FRUUHVSRQGHQFH7KHPROWHQZD[ZDVWKHQVWDPSHGZLWKWKHVHQGHU¶VVHDO

:'PDNHU¶VPDUNV(GLQEXUJK $WSUHVVWLPHWKHUHLVFRQVLGHUDEOHFRQIXVLRQ VXUURXQGLQJ(GLQEXUJK:'PDUNV:LOOLDP'UXPPRQGLVQRWLQFOXGHGLQWKHFRPSHQGLXP EHFDXVHKHPDGHOLWWOHLIDQ\VLOYHULQ(GLQEXUJK1XPHURXVYDULDQWVRI:'PDUNVZHUH employed between William Dempster and William Davie. The designations originally in -DFNVRQDUHQRZYLHZHGDVXQFHUWDLQDWEHVW,QPDQ\FDVHVDGHVFULSWLRQRIWKHOHWWHUV EORFN YVVFULSW LVSURYLGHGZKHUHSRVVLEOHDQGERWKPDNHUV¶QDPHVDUHOLVWHGLQPRVWFDVHV +RSHIXOO\WKLVZLOOEHUHVROYHGLQWKHQHDUIXWXUH

:LOOLDP-DPLHVRQ±WKHPDNHU¶VPDUNVKRZQLQ-DFNVRQPDUNVLVUHDOO\-DPHV0LWFKHOVRQ¶V PDUNWXUQHGXSVLGHGRZQ7KHUHIRUHLWLVSUREDEO\QRW-DPLHVRQ¶VPDUNDWDOOEXWUDWKHU 0LWFKHOVRQ¶VSXQFK,QVWHDGD:,RU,0LQDSODLQRYDOVHHPVOLNHO\WREHWKHPDUNIRUHLWKHU :LOOLDP-DPLHVRQRUSRVVLEO\-RKQ0DLQ7KLVTXDQGDU\VKRXOGEHUHVROYHGLQWKHQHDU future.

:LQH/DEHO DOVRFDOOHGZLQHWDJRUERWWOHWLFNHWXVXDOO\LQGLFDWLQJWKHW\SHRIZLQHRQD shaped shield or rectangle suspended around a bottle or decanted via a silver chain.

Wire and Wire work = Wire is created by drawing malleable silver through a series of smaller and smaller holes in a draw plate thereby reducing the gauge after each new pass and also VWUHQJWKHQLQJWKHVLOYHUZLWKHDFKKDUGHQLQJ7KHUHVXOWLQJVWULQJPD\EHURXQGVTXDUHRU PXOWLVLGHGDQGFDQEHXVHGDVDPRXWKZLUHWRIRUWLI\DERZOHWFULPRULWPD\EHWZLVWHGIRU use in decorative filigree work.

xxxiii555 Compendium of Scottish Silver

556xxxiv Works Cited

Works Cited

ARTICLES

Fell, H. G. “Scottish Silver at Stratton Street” [Messr. How of Edinburgh], in Connoisseur Vol CIII February 1939 pp107, 109. [How of Edinburgh 1939]

Jones, Alfred E. “Some Old Scottish and English Plate of the Marquess of Linlithgow, K T” in Apollo vol XVIII September 1933 pp153-161. [Linlithgow Collection]

………………… “Binning Collection of Old English and Scottish Plate,” in Burlington Magazine, vol LXVIII March 1936 pp199-225. [Binning Collection]

…………………”Collection of Plate of Sir John Stirling Maxwell, Bart. K T” in Apollo Vol XXIII April 1936 pp99-104, 207-214. [Stirling Maxwell Collection]

…………………”Silver at the Exhibition of Scottish Art” in Burlington Magazine Vol LXXIV 1939 pp71-72. [Scottish Art Exhibition 1939]

Oman, Charles C. “Scottish Silver at the Royal Academy” in Connoisseur vol CIII, February 1939 pp70-75. [Scottish Art Exhibition 1939]

BOOKS

Alcorn, Ellenor M. English Silver at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston Volume II. MFA Publications: Boston 2000 [Alcorn, Museum of Fine Arts]

Bannister, Judith. Collecting Antique Silver. Galahad Books: NY 1972. [Bannister]

Brett, Vanessa. The Sotheby’s Directory of Silver 1600-1940. Sotheby’s Publications: London 1986. [Brett]

Burns, Thomas. Old Scottish Communion Plate. R & R Clarke: Edinburgh 1892. [Burns]

Clayton, Michael. The Collector’s Dictionary of the Silver and Gold of Great Britain and North America 2nd edition. Antique Collector’s Club: Suffolk 1985. [Clayton Dictionary]

xxxv557 Compendium of Scottish Silver

…………………..Christie’s Pictorial History of English and American Silver. Phaidon- Christie’s Ltd: Oxford 1985. [Clayton Christie’s Book]

Connoisseur Art Sales Annual, Connoisseur London. [Connoisseur]

Cripps, Wilfred Joseph. Old English Plate: Ecclesiastical, Decorative and Domestic: Its Makers and Marks. J Murray: London 1906 [Cripps]

Curtis, Tony ed. The Lyle Official Antique Review 1979. Lyle Publication’s: London 1978 [Lyle Annual Review 1979]

………………….The Lyle Official Antique Review 1980. Lyle Publication’s: London 1979 [Lyle Annual Review 1980]

………………….The Lyle Official Antique Review 1981. Lyle Publication’s: London 1980 [Lyle Annual Review 1981]

………………….The Lyle Official Antique Review 1982. Lyle Publication’s: London 1981 [Lyle Annual Review 1982]

………………….The Lyle Official Antique Review 1983. Lyle Publication’s: London 1982 [Lyle Annual Review 1983]

………………….The Lyle Official Antique Review 1984. Lyle Publication’s: London 1983 [Lyle Annual Review 1984]

………………….The Lyle Official Antique Review 1994. Perigee 1993 [Lyle Annual Review 1994]

………………….The Lyle Antiques and Their Value: Silver. Voor Hoede Publications B. V.: NY 1982 [Lyle Silver Review]

Dalgleish, George and Stuart Maxwell. The Lovable Craft: 1687-1987. Pinpoint Direct Marketing: Edinburgh [Dalgleish and Maxwell]

Davis, John D. English Silver at Williamsburg. Colonial Williamsburg Foundation and University Press of Virginia: Charlottesville 1976. [English Silver at Williamsburg]

Delieb, Eric. Investing in Silver. Clarkson N Potter: NY 1967 [Delieb]

Finlay, Ian. Scottish Gold and Silver Work. Pelican Publishing Co: Gretna, LA 1991. [Finlay 1991]

558xxxvi Works Cited

*ULPZDGH$UWKXU7KH4XHHQ¶V6LOYHU$6XUYH\RI+HU0DMHVW\¶V3HUVRQDO&ROOHFWLRQ. The &RQQRLVVHXU/RQGRQ >4XHHQ¶V6LOYHU@

*XWKULH'U:LOOLDP'XQGHH6LOYHU:*XWKULH3XEOLVKHU

+DUNHQEURFK8QWHPH\HU&ROOHFWLRQ@

+D\GHQ$UWKXU&KDWVRQ2OG6LOYHU'RYHU3XEOLFDWLRQV,QF1< >+D\GHQ@

+ROODQG0DUJDUHW6LOYHU$Q,OOXVWUDWHG*XLGHWR&ROOHFWLQJ6LOYHU2FWRSXV%RRNV/WG +RQJ.RQJ >+ROODQG@

+RXDUW9LFWRU0LQLDWXUH6LOYHU7R\V$OSLQH)LQH$UWV1< >+RXDUW@

+RZ*(3DQG-DQH3+RZ(QJOLVKDQG6FRWWLVK6LOYHU6SRRQVYROXPHV

+XJKHV*HRUJH%HUQDUGDQG7KHUOH+XJKHV7KUHH&HQWXULHVRI(QJOLVK'RPHVWLF6LOYHU :)XQN1< >+XJKHV@

-DFNVRQ&KDUOHV-DPHV$Q,OOXVWUDWHG+LVWRU\RI(QJOLVK3ODWHYROXPHV&RXQWU\/LIH/WG $QG%7%DWVIRUG/RQGRQ >-DFNVRQ@ -DFNVRQ&KDUOHV-DFNVRQ¶V6LOYHUDQG*ROG0DUNVHG,DQ3LFNIRUG$QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU¶V&OXE 6XIIRON >-DFNVRQ0DUNV@

-RQHV($2OG(QJOLVK*ROG3ODWH%HPURVH 6RQV/WG/RQGRQ >-RQHV@

.RYHO5DOSKDQG7HUU\.RYHO.RYHO¶V$QWLTXHVDQG&ROOHFWLEOH¶V3ULFH/LVWIRUWKH 0DUNHWthHGLWLRQ&URZQ3XEOLVKHUV1< >.RYHOV@

««««««««««««.RYHO¶V$QWLTXHVDQG&ROOHFWLEOHV3ULFH/LVWIRUWKH 0DUNHW&URZQ3XEOLVKHUV1< >.RYHOV@

/HH*HRUJLDQDDQG5RQDOG$/HH%ULWLVK6LOYHU0RQWHLWK%RZOV,QFOXGLQJ$PHULFDQDQG (XURSHDQ([DPSOHV0DQRU+RXVH3UHVV6XUU\ >/HH0RQWHLWKV@

xxxvii559 Compendium of Scottish Silver

Luddington, John. Starting to Collect Silver$QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU¶V&OXE6XIIRON [Luddington]

3LFNIRUG,DQ6LOYHU)ODWZDUH(QJOLVK,ULVKDQG6FRWWLVK$QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU¶V &OXE6XIIRON >3LFNIRUG6SRRQV@

5DELQRYLWFK%HQWRQ6H\PRXU$QWLTXH6LOYHU6HUYHUVIRUWKH'LQLQJ7DEOH6W\OH)XQFWLRQ )RRGDQG6RFLDO+LVWRU\-RVOLQ+DOO3XEOLVKLQJ&RQFRUG0$ >5DELQRYLWFK@

5LQNHU+DUU\/HG:DUPDQ¶V$QWLTXHVDQG7KHLU3ULFHVth edition.UDXVH3XEOLFDWLRQV ,ROD:, >:DUPDQV@

7LFKHU.XUW,ULVK6LOYHULQWKH5RFRFR3HULRG,ULVK8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV6KDQQRQ >7LFKHU,ULVK6LOYHU@

:DOGHQ0DXUJKHULWD+RZDUGGH4XHHQ&KDUORWWH¶V/RDQ([KLELWLRQRI2OG6LOYHU0D\VW -XQHth6HDIRUG+RXVH%HOJUDYH6TXDUH/RQGRQ7KH6DLQW&DWKHULQH3UHVV5R\DO /RQGRQ >4XHHQ¶V([KLELWLRQ@

:DOGURQ3HWHU7KH3ULFH*XLGHWR$QWLTXH6LOYHUnd edition$QWLTXH&ROOHFWRU¶V&OXE 6XIIRON >:DOGURQ@

:DUN%HWK&DUYHU(QJOLVK,ULVKDQG6FRWWLVK6LOYHUDWWKH6WLUOLQJDQG)UDQFLQH&ODUN$UW ,QVWLWXWH+XGVRQ+LOOV3UHVV1< >:HHV&ODUN$UW,QVWLWXWH@

:LOOV*HRIIUH\&DQGOHVWLFNV&13RWWHU1< >:LOOV&DQGOHVWLFNV@

&$7$/2*6

%RQKDP¶V6DOHV&DWDORJV >%RQKDPV@

%UHDGDOEDQH&ROOHFWLRQRI6LOYHUVPLWK¶V:RUN7KH'RZHOO/WG6DOH&DWDORJ0D\ (GLQEXUJK >%UHDGDOEDQH&ROOHFWLRQ6DOH@

&DWDORJRI([KLELWLRQRI6FRWWLVK6LOYHU5R\DO6FRWWLVK0XVHXP$XJXVW±6HSWHPEHU >5R\DO6FRWWLVK0XVHXP([KLELWLRQ@

&DWDORJRI+LJKO\,PSRUWDQW(QJOLVK6FRWWLVKDQG&RQWLQHQWDO6LOYHUWKH3URSHUW\RI+LV*UDFH 7KH'XNHRI%XFFOHXFK«DQGWKH+RSHWRXQ(VWDWHV&RPSDQ\6RWKHE\¶V6DOHV&DWDORJ

560xxxviii Works Cited

25 July 1953 [Hopetoun Silver]

&KULVWLH¶V$UW7UHDVXUHV([KLELWLRQ&DWDORJ >$UW7UHDVXUHV([KLELWLRQ@

&KULVWLH¶V,QWHUQDWLRQDO6DOHV&DWDORJV [Christies]

([KLELWLRQRI6FRWWLVK6LOYHUIURPWKH&ROOHFWLRQRI-RKQ1REOH&KDLUPDQRIWKH6FRWWLVK&UDIW &HQWHU$XJXVW±6HSWHPEHU >1REOH&ROOHFWLRQ@

*ODVJRZ(PSLUH([KLELWLRQ0D\2FWREHU2OG6FRWWLVK6LOYHU&DWDORJXHRI/RDQ &ROOHFWLRQLQ6FRWWLVK+LVWRULFDO3DYLOLRQ7KH6FRWWLVK&RPPLWWHH >*ODVJRZ(PSLUH([KLELWLRQ@

+RZRI(GLQEXUJK/WG6LOYHU([KLELWLRQDW6WUDWWRQ6WUHHW/RQGRQ: 1936 >+RZRI(GLQEXUJK@

+RZRI(GLQEXUJK/WG6LOYHU([KLELWLRQDW6WUDWWRQ6WUHHW/RQGRQ: 1937 >+RZRI(GLQEXUJK@

-+%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJV/RQGRQ >-%RXUGRQ6PLWK&DWDORJ@

/RDQ([KLELWLRQRI2OG(QJOLVK3ODWH3DUN/DQH/RQGRQ >3DUN/RQGRQ([KLELWLRQ@

1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJV >1LFKRODV6KDZ&DWDORJ@

3DODFHRI+LVWRU\6FRWWLVK([KLELWLRQRI1DWXUDO+LVWRU\$UWV ,QGXVWU\*ODVJRZ YROXPHV >*ODVJRZ([KLELWLRQRI@

3KLOOLS¶V$XFWLRQ+RXVH&DWDORJV >3KLOOLSV@

6FRWWLVK3URYLQFLDO6LOYHUIURPWKH'DYLG0RUULV&ROOHFWLRQ-XO\DQG2FWREHU &KULVWLH¶V6FRWODQG6DOH&DWDORJV >7KH0RUULV&ROOHFWLRQ@

6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQRI,PSRUWDQW6FRWWLVK6LOYHUDQG3LVWROVWKHth0DUFK&KULVWLH¶V6DOH &DWDORJ >6KDZ&ROOHFWLRQ@

6LOYHU7HDSRWVIURPWKH-RKQ%HOORI$EHUGHHQ&ROOHFWLRQth1RYHPEHU±th'HFHPEHUDWWKH &H\ORQ7HD&HQWHU*ODVJRZ([KLELWLRQ&DWDORJ >%HOORI$EHUGHHQ@

xxxix561 Compendium of Scottish Silver

6RWKHE\¶V6DOHV&DWDORJV >6RWKHE\V@

JOURNALS

$QWLTXHV$WZRRG%RVWRQ >$QWLTXHV0DJD]LQH@

7KH0DJD]LQH$QWLTXHV6WUDLJKW(QWHUSULVHV1<SUHVHQW >$QWLTXHV0DJD]LQH@

$SROOR$SROOR/RQGRQSUHVHQW >$SROOR@

%XUOLQJWRQ0DJD]LQH%XUOLQJWRQ0DJD]LQH3XEOLFDWLRQV/WG/RQGRQSUHVHQW >%XUOLQJWRQ0DJD]LQH@

7KH&RQQRLVVHXU1DWLRQDO0DJD]LQH&RPSDQ\/RQGRQSUHVHQW >&RQQRLVVHXU0DJD]LQH@

&RXQWU\/LIH&RXQWU\/LIH/RQGRQSUHVHQW >&RXQWU\/LIH@

7KH6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZ*ODVJRZ$UW*DOOHU\DQG0XVHXPV$VVRFLDWLRQV*ODVJRZ SUHVHQW >6FRWWLVK$UW5HYLHZ@

6LOYHU6WXGLHV-RXUQDORIWKH6LOYHU6RFLHW\HG9DQHVVD%UHWW >6LOYHU6WXGLHV@

0(',$

&KULVWLH¶V1HJDWLYH)LOHLGHQWLILFDWLRQQXPEHUVIRULPDJHVKRXVHGDW&KULVWLH¶V/RQGRQ

&KULVWLH¶V3LFWXUH)LOHVSKRWRJUDSKVVWRUHGDW&KULVWLH¶V,QWHUQDWLRQDO/RQGRQ

6RWKHE\¶V3LFWXUH)LOHVSKRWRJUDSKVVWRUHGDW6RWKHE\¶V/RQGRQ

086(806

$EHUGHHQ0XVHXPVDQG*DOOHULHV

$UW,QVWLWXWHRI&KLFDJR,/86$

%DOWLPRUH0XVHXPRI$UW0'86$

562xxxx Works Cited

Berkshire Museum Pittsfield, MA USA

Birmingham Museum of Art, Birmingham AL USA

Boston Museum of Fine Art MA USA

Campbell Museum Camden NJ USA

Carnegie Institute Museum of Art, Pittsburgh PA USA

Cincinnati Art Museum OH USA

Clark Art Institute

Brooklyn Museum Brooklyn NY USA

Dallas Museum of Art TX USA

Dayton Art Institute OH USA

Detroit Institute of Art MI USA

Dewitt Gallery, Hyman Collection - Colonial Williamsburg [Hyman Collection - Colonial Williamsburg, VA USA

Dundee Museums and Art Galleries

Fogg Art Museum, Harvard University, Cambridge MA USA

Glasgow Museums Glasgow Scotland

High Museum of Art, Atlanta GA USA

Huntington Library San Mateo CA USA

Huntley House Edinburgh Scotland

Indianapolis Museum of Art IN USA

J B Speed Museum Louisville KT USA

Los Angeles County Museum CA USA

Lyman Allyn Art Museum New London CT USA

McKissick Museum University of SC Columbus SC USA

Metropolitan Museum of Art NY USA

Milwaukee Art Museum WI USA

xxxxi563 Compendium of Scottish Silver

Minneapolis Institute of Art MN USA

Musee de Beaux Arts Montreal Canada

National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh Scotland

National Museum of Wales Cardiff Wales

Nova Scotia Museum Hallifax Nova Scotia Canada

Perth City Art Gallery and Museum Perth Scotland

Philadelphia Museum of Art PA USA

Portland Art Museum OR USA

Rhode Island School of Museum Providence, RI USA

Royal Ontario Museum Toronto Canada

St Louis City Art Museum LA USA

San Diego Museum of Art CA USA

San Francisco, Fine Arts Museums of CA USA

Toledo Museum of Art OH USA

Victoria and Albert Museum London UK

Virginia Museum of Fine Arts Richmond VA USA

Yale University Art Gallery New Haven CT USA

564xxxxii Rodney R. Dietert, Ph.D, Professor of Immunotoxicology, College of Veterinary Medicine, at Cornell University has devoted over 25 years to researching and teaching about the health hazards of exposure to heavy metals and other environmental contaminants. Additionally, he directed both the Institute for Comparative and Environmental Toxicology and the Program on Breast Cancer and Environmental Risk Factors at Cornell. Dietert is listed in Who’s Who in Medicine and Healthcare, Who’s Who in America and Who’s Who in the World. Here, he directs his attention to the beneficial artistic and historical sides of metals - namely, the production of Scottish gold and silver work spanning four centuries.

Janice M Dietert, M.A., Learning Disabilities Specialist, has spent her life devoting herself to individuals with learning disabilities and Attention Deficit Disorder. While raising a daughter with both LDs and ADD, she also earned a degree in social science that gave her the background, pulled heavily from her coursework in English Literature and Linguistics and neuropsychology, primed for higher educational work with individuals challenged in these areas. However, she never left her first loves – computers and English Literature and Composition. Now that her life has begun another phase, she has shifted back to using her talents with camera, computer and words to aid in the compilation of this magnificent compendium.