The Flamenco Dance in the Cafés Cantantes Epoch: a Historiographical Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Revista del Centro de Investigación Flamenco Telethusa • ISSN 1989 - 1628 • Cádiz 2012 • 5(5) • pp.5-12 Review article / 050501-2012 The flamenco dance in the cafés cantantes epoch: a historiographical review El baile flamenco en la época de los cafés cantantes: un recorrido historiográfico PhD. Juan Zagalaz (1) Email: [email protected] PhD. Javier Cachón-Zagalaz (2) (1) Department of Didactics of Musical Expression. University of Castilla–La Mancha. Albacete, Spain. (2) Department of Didactics of Corporal Expression. University of Jaén. Jaén, Spain. Received: November 29, 2011 Editorial review: December 2, 2011 Peer-review: December 23, 2011 Accepted: December 27, 2011 Published online: January 3, 2012 Abstract Resumen The main objective of this article is to examine Este artículo tiene como principal objetivo revi- the perception of flamencology and flamenco sar la percepción de la flamencología y la histo- historiography regarding the phenomenon that riografía flamenca, del fenómeno que consolidó strengthened flamenco dancing in the era of al baile flamenco en la época de los cafés can- the ‘cafés cantantes’, from the second half of tantes, comprendida entre la segunda mitad del the 19th century to the early years of the 20th siglo XIX y los primeros años del XX. Para ello, century. For this purpose, we have performed a se ha realizado un profundo trabajo bibliográ- thorough bibliographic review in which we have fico, en el que se han analizado las diferentes analysed various interpretations from the most interpretaciones de los más destacados espe- prominent specialists in the field in order to cialistas, con el fin de ofrecer, en la medida de offer, as closely as possible, a transversal and lo posible, una visión transversal y sintética que synthetic vision that helps to decipher the state ayude a desentrañar el estado de la cuestión. of the art. Thus, we have taken a close look at Así, se ha observado el surgimiento de elemen- the emergence of key elements in the establis- tos determinantes para la consolidación de este hment of this art, such as the appearance of a arte, como la aparición de un nuevo espacio new theatre space, the progressive professiona- escénico, la paulatina profesionalización de los lization of the dancers, or the various technical intérpretes o los diversos avances técnicos y es- and stylistic advances. Furthermore, we have tilísticos. Además, se han analizado los distintos analysed the different types of dances perfor- tipos de bailes que se llevaron a cabo en el pe- med during this period, reaching the main con- riodo, obteniendo como principal conclusión la clusion of the existence of a multitude of histo- existencia de multitud de perspectivas historio- riographical perspectives and the absence of a gráficas y la ausencia de un estudio específico specific study of the period which corresponds del periodo que corresponda a la importancia de to the importance of this art in the development éste en el desarrollo del baile flamenco. of flamenco dance. Palabras Clave Keywords Bailaor, bailaora, tablao, flamencología, soleá, Bailaor, bailaora, tablao, flamencology, soleá, alegrías. alegrías. 5 Zagalaz J, Cach J The flamenco dance in the cafés cantantes epoch: a historiographical review González A, Gómez R, Fernández J, Costa JL González A, Gómez R, Fernández bailaoras de flamenco de las amplitudes articulares y acortamientos musculares en Valoración Rev Cent Investig Flamenco Telethusa 2012 • 5(5)• pp.5-12 Introduction Flamenco dance in the ‘cafés cantantes’ era: a historiographical review In recent years, flamencology has made marked advancements with the proliferation of regulated Martínez’s1 work is one of the most complete studies and the consequent emergence of new and most focused on dance, and it retains much means of transmission and research. Even so, of its relevance despite originally having been the historical category of flamenco as one of published in 1969. The author rigorously goes the most developed and characteristic national deep into the universe of flamenco dancing in artistic representations of the entire European a well-organized fashion, in a practical dealing spectrum requires a more in-depth study which has an interesting and complete opening that highlights its outstanding attributes. The section dedicated to its origin and historical constant difficulty stemming from the study of evolution. It divides the history of flamenco both corporal and musical artistic expressions dance into three phases, the second stage is perfectly well-known, particularly those from being the one which corresponds to the ‘cafés specific historical periods that solely provide us cantantes’. This section outlines a brief historical with graphic representations, direct and indirect context that makes the importance of this time mentions, or less-specific iconographic and period evident, in which the styles are set, the literary material. While in other artistic domains, rhythm is disciplined and the rules that will have such as painting, sculpture or architecture, we to last more-or-less undistorted until our time possess artistic fact in itself, in music and dance, are forged1 (p. 28). The section dedicated to up until the appearance of video and techniques technical documentation in regards to dance is for recording and mechanical reproduction, we particularly useful. Therein, the author divides only retain visual and textual representations: the prominent stylistic parameters in flamenco individual perspectives to narrate a dynamic dancing that were produced during the ‘cafés and changing reality. Is it possible to reconstruct cantantes’ era into five points. The constant expressions of music or dance exclusively references to this work in the historiography of through writings, testimonies and graphic, the dance, as we will see below, position it as pictorial or photographic representations? Can one of the central works when being introduced one tell the history of dance and music? Can to the world of flamenco dancing, both on a flamenco fact be passed on solely with words? theoretical-historical plane as well as on a practical and performative plane. When recreating these types of representations, the accuracy will vary depending on the Martínez, more recently, wrote an interesting information available. This is what flamencology chapter2 in which she stresses the importance of has produced in order to narrate the state of the academies in consolidating flamenco dance, flamenco during its consolidation in the nineteenth placing great relevance on the appearance century. Therefore, different specialists have of a characteristic theatre space, the ‘cafés made a great effort in that reconstruction, basing cantantes’, where the professionalism of the it on the existing sources, which though not dance would be produced. Moreover, she exactly scarce, aren’t as numerous as one would highlights the analytical ability of the maestros like, either. This article attempts to examine the of the dance, who perceived the capacity of reflection of dance in flamenco historiography, flamenco to attract society and remove the dominated by the Andalusian folk song, during expressive tricks and variants that the gypsies the ‘cafés cantantes’ period, dated between attached to existing popular dances. the last third of the 19th century and the first years of the 20th century. In order to do that, Álvarez3 makes an in-depth analysis based we’ve analysed the most prominent historical on historical documents of varying types. The literature on flamenco, from books dedicated to author delves into the origins of the ‘cafés general history to those dedicated specifically cantantes’ in a descriptive tone, constantly to dance, as well as practical or theoretical inserting contemporary sources into the playful -practical manuals. The comparative study of and rowdy atmosphere of these establishments, flamenco has given a current perspective of the as observed in the words of the Nicaraguan poet most important time period in the consolidation Rubén Darío included in his work: of flamenco dance, from the ‘café’ flamenco bars to the professionalization, stylisation and After they’ve danced, the female bolero and artistic independence of its origins: the guitar flamenco dancers come down to visit the and the folk song. consumers at their tables, to make them spend as much as they can, at the orders 6 Rev Cent Investig Flamenco Telethusa 2012 • 5(5) • pp. 5-12 Zagalaz J, Cach J of the café’s owner […] From table to table to Estébanez Calderón. From this to the ‘cafés pouring manzanilla and more manzanilla, from cantantes’ and from these to the theatre, without table to table where there are foreigners and significant clarifications. (p. 217) 5 visitors, because the locals know the game and don’t allow themselves to be exploited. (p. 57)3 Manfredi6, another classic flamenco historian, Thus, the surface on which flamenco dance succinctly mentions dancing, although his work ended up strengthening itself is demystified, is much more focused on flamenco singing. The flamenco dance in the cafés cantantes epoch: a historiographical review although there are no specific mentions of the According to his vision, the gradual separation of dance made until the chapter titled The dance song and dance has been verified, between the evolves, which focuses on the role played by 19th and 20th centuries, based on the idea that these local patrons in the direct development initially the singer was the centrepiece and that of the dance. The final result is a genuine and nowadays it seems like the song is on a second historically verified vision in which many aspects plane, only there as an accompaniment. Thus, relating to the general history of flamenco dance he states that dancing has invaded the forbidden are clarified. territories of folk singing and acknowledges that some dancers have taken the ‘soleá’ to peaks as For his part, Navarro4 performs an excellent high as those reached by the masters of the folk analysis of the historical development of the song. (p. 152)6 dance in Andalusia since Roman times with the known exponent of Telethusa.