Extraskeletal Myxoid Chondrosarcoma: a Clinicopathologic, Immunohistochemical, and Ploidy Analysis of 23 Cases Andre M
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Extraskeletal Myxoid Chondrosarcoma: A Clinicopathologic, Immunohistochemical, and Ploidy Analysis of 23 Cases Andre M. Oliveira, M.D., Thomas J. Sebo, M.D., James E. McGrory, M.D., Thomas A. Gaffey, M.D., Michael G. Rock, M.D., Antonio G. Nascimento, M.D. Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology (AMO, TJS, TAG, AGN) and the Department of Orthopedics (JEM, MGR), Mayo Clinic and Mayo Foundation, Rochester, Minnesota Extraskeletal myxoid chondrosarcoma (EMC) is a Twenty-three cases of extraskeletal myxoid chon- rare soft tissue sarcoma that was recognized as a drosarcoma, evaluated at the Mayo Clinic between distinct pathologic entity by Stout and Verner 1968 and 1996, were studied for clinicopathologic in 1953 (1). However, it was not until 1972 that features, immunohistochemical profile, Ki-67 activ- Enzinger and Shiraki (2) defined the clinicopatho- ity, and ploidy status to identify adverse prognostic logic features of EMC, showing a relatively pro- factors. Females and males were equally affected, tracted clinical course and a better prognosis than and the median age at diagnosis was 50 years. The that with conventional bone chondrosarcomas. tumors were located mainly in the lower extremities In 1992, Saleh et al. (3) reassessed the clinical (83%), and the median tumor size was 9.5 cm. Six- features of EMC in a series of 10 patients and teen tumors showed low cellularity (70%), and eight showed the “indolent but resilient” nature of this tumors had high mitotic activity (more than two per neoplasm; 7 of the patients died of tumor up to 17 10 high-power fields). The tumors were immunore- years after the initial diagnosis. Seven years later, active for vimentin (89%), synaptophysin (72%), ep- Meis-Kindblom et al. (4) studied a large series of ithelial membrane antigen (28%), and S-100 protein EMCs, most consultation cases, and showed that (17%). Nine tumors were diploid, three aneuploid, older age, larger tumor size, and proximal tumor and one tetraploid. Mean Ki-67 activity was 11% location were associated with decreased survival by (range, 1 to 45%). The 10-year overall survival rate multivariate analysis. was 78%. On univariate analysis, tumor size > 10 The histogenesis of EMC is still a subject of con- cm, high cellularity, presence of anaplasia or rhab- troversy. However, chondroblastic differentiation doid features, mitotic activity more than two per 10 has been supported by ultrastructural (5–15) and high-power fields, Ki-67 > 10%, and Ki-67 “hot histochemical (16–18) studies. In addition, cytoge- spot” > 25% were associated with decreased netic and molecular analyses have shown that EMC metastasis-free or overall survival. Ploidy status was is a distinct entity with the characteristic transloca- not associated with any adverse outcome. The pres- tion t(9;22) involving the EWS gene (22q12) and the ence of any of these adverse prognostic factors can TEC gene (9q22) in a majority of the cases (19–29). indicate the possibility of a more aggressive behav- We reviewed the clinicopathologic, immunohis- ior in extraskeletal myxoid chondrosarcoma, and a tochemical, and ploidy features in a series of 23 closer follow-up is suggested. cases of EMC evaluated at a single institution to identify potential prognostic factors associated with KEY WORDS: Extraskeletal myxoid chondrosar- a more aggressive behavior. coma, Immunohistochemistry, Ki-67, Ploidy, Prog- nostic factors. Mod Pathol 2000;13(8):900–908 MATERIALS AND METHODS Twenty-three patients in whom EMC was diag- nosed between 1968 and 1996 were included in this Copyright © 2000 by The United States and Canadian Academy of study. Eighteen patients with EMC were diagnosed Pathology, Inc. VOL. 13, NO. 8, P. 900, 2000 Printed in the U.S.A. and primarily treated at the Mayo Clinic, and five Date of acceptance: February 22, 2000. patients were referred by other institutions for ad- Address reprint requests to: A.G. Nascimento, M.D., Department of Lab- oratory Medicine and Pathology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905; ditional treatment or evaluation. Fifteen cases from e-mail: [email protected]. this series will be described in another article (30). 900 TABLE 1. Antibodies Used in This Study totic activity, anaplasia, spontaneous necrosis, and Antibody Type Source Dilution vascular invasion. Cellularity was defined as high Vimentin 3B4 M DAKO 1:500 when the neoplastic cells represented 75% or more Desmin Der11 M DAKO 1:100 (and the myxoid matrix represented 25% or less) of Wide-spectrum keratin P DAKO 1:200 Epithelial membrane antigen (EMA) M DAKO 1:20 the tumor area within the nodules in at least 25% of Polyclonal carcinoembryonic P DAKO 1:800 all slides evaluated per tumor. Mitotic count was antigen (pCEA) performed in 10 different high-power fields (HPF, S-100 protein P HSC 1:2,000 ϫ Synaptophysin SY38 M ICN Biomedicals 1:40 400 ) and reported as the number of mitotic fig- Chromogranin M Boehringer 1:1,000 ures per 10 HPF. Anaplasia was defined as the pres- Mannheim ence of enlarged and vesicular nuclei with promi- Leu-7 (CD57) M Becton Dickinson 1:20 Actin HHF35 (actin muscle-specific) M DAKO 1:50 nent nucleoli in at least 25% of the tumor area. ␣-Smooth muscle actin 1A4 M DAKO 1:150 Immunohistochemical studies were performed MIC2 (CD99) M DAKO 1:50 on 4-m-thick sections of 10% formalin-fixed, Glial fibrillary acid protein (GFAP) P DAKO 1:300 Ki-67 (MIB-1) M Immunotech 1:50 paraffin-embedded tumor material in 18 tumors, HSC, Hospital for Sick Children; M, monoclonal; P, polyclonal. according to the avidin-biotin-peroxidase complex system (31). Appropriate positive and negative con- trols were used for each antibody listed in Table 1. Clinical data, including follow-up information, Immunohistochemical analysis addressed the pres- were obtained from medical record review, refer- ence or absence of stain in a focal or diffuse pattern. ring physicians, and telephone survey. Focal reactivity was defined when less than 25% of Hematoxylin-eosin–stained archival slides from cells were reactive for a specific antibody. Immu- the primary tumors (5 to 21 slides per case; average, noreactivity intensity was not categorized. 13) were available for review in all cases. The main Digital image analysis was performed in 13 histologic features investigated were cellularity, mi- neoplasms according to a previously described TABLE 2. Clinical Features of Extraskeletal Myxoid Chondrosarcoma in 23 Patients Age Size Case Sex Location Cellularity Ploidy Treatment Follow-up and Outcome (yr) (cm)* 1 47 M Thigh, left 16 Low D WLE ϩ postRx Lung, sternum, vertebral mets (10 mo); DOD (23 mo) 2 29 M Thigh, left 18 Low D WLE ϩ postRx Lung mets (9 yr), DOD (22 yr) 3 34 M Mets to chest wall, mediastinum, 4† Low D ME ϩ postRx Knee tumor discovered (4.3 yr), and lungs (primary tumor: knee, alive (13 yr) right) 4 57 F Ankle, right 1.5 Low D WLE Alive, NED (21 yr) 5 27 M Ankle, left 10 High ... ME Alive, NED (6 mo) 6 63 F Thigh, right with mets to regional 4.5 Low ... WLE ϩ postRx Alive with mets (1 yr) lymph nodes and buttock 7 63 F Thigh, left 6 Low ... WLE Local recurrence (8 yr), alive with NED (20.3 yr) 8 42 F Thigh, right 9 Low ... WLE ϩ postRx Alive, NED (23.5 yr) 9 55 M Thigh, left 10 High A WLE Lung mets (4 mo), DOD (8 mo) 10 54 M Thigh, right 10 High T PreRx ϩ WLE Rib and vertebral mets (3.3 yr), DOD (6 yr) 11 50 F Shoulder, right 13.5 High D WLE ϩ postRx Lung mets (5.5 yr), DOD (6.8 yr) 12 22 F Shoulder, right 5 High ... WLE Alive, NED (14.6 yr) 13 49 F Leg, left 10 Low ... WLE Lung mets (1.2 yr), alive with mets (6.5 yr) 14 47 F Ankle, right 9 High A Amputation Alive, NED (8.2 yr) 15 38 F Chest wall with lung mets 5 High D PreChx ϩ WLE Alive with mets (7 yr) 16 52 M Thigh, right 11 Low ... WLE ϩ postRx Lung mets (4 yr), alive with mets (6.8 yr) 17 78 F Foot, right 5 Low D Amputation Alive, NED (5.5 yr) 18 48 M Foot, left 9 Low D Amputation Alive, NED (6 yr) 19 70 M Paravertebral area, left 5.5 Low A WLE ϩ postRx Alive, NED (6.2 yr) 20 71 M Thigh, left 18.5 Low ... PreRx ϩ WLE ϩ Local recurrence (3 mo), lung postRx mets (6 mo), alive with mets (3.3 yr) 21 61 F Knee, right 11 Low D WLE Local recurrence (4.8 yr), alive with NED (17 yr) 22 44 F Ankle, right 4 Low ... WLE Alive, NED (13 yr) 23 51 M Foot, left 6.5 Low ... Amputation Alive, NED (2 yr) A, aneuploid; D, diploid; ME, marginal excision; mets, metastasis; postRx, postoperative radiotherapy; preChx, preoperative chemotherapy; preRx, preoperative radiotherapy; T, tetraploid; WLE, wide local excision. * Greatest tumor dimension. † Knee tumor. Extraskeletal Myxoid Chondrosarcoma (A.M. Oliveira, et al.) 901 FIGURE 1. Characteristic multilobular architecture of extraskeletal FIGURE 3. Areas composed of large cells with vesicular nuclei and myxoid chondrosarcoma. This was present in all cases. prominent nucleoli were found in three tumors. Interestingly, two of these patients died of disease. FIGURE 2. Cords and strands of small eosinophilic cells immersed in a myxoid matrix. This is the classic histologic finding in extraskeletal FIGURE 4. High cellularity was present in 30% of cases and was myxoid chondrosarcoma. associated with decreased overall survival by univariate analysis. method (32). An average of 158 cells were neous population of cells with distinct biological counted per tumor (range, 53 to 213 cells).