The Hybrid Library Revisited

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Hybrid Library Revisited The Hybrid Library Revisited Judith Pearce Director, Web services National Library of Australia [email protected] Monica Berko, Director, Applications National Library of Australia [email protected] Abstract: Four years out, this paper revisits the theme of VALA2000 and looks at the extent to which integrated library management systems have been developed to operate as hybrid library systems by focussing on the National Library of Australia’s requirements in this area. A range of commercial portal products now extend (and may eventually replace) the OPAC. However, there is still a gap in the market place for workflow systems supporting the routine digitisation of collection material. In addition, library system vendors are only just beginning to provide the level of support needed by libraries that wish to build innovative web-based services based on the catalogue. Introduction At VALA2000 staff from the National Library of Australia (Pearce et al) delivered a paper on “The Challenge of Integrated Access: The Hybrid Library System of the Future”. The term ‘hybrid library’ had been coined by the elib Electronic Libraries Program (JISC, 2002) to describe systems and services providing integrated access to both print and electronic resources. The elib hybrid library projects used broker architectures to unite heterogeneous ‘provider systems’ under a single user interface. For example, the Agora Project (2001) which had as its aim to build a Hybrid Library Management System (HLMS) was an implementation of the Models Information Architecture (MIA) in spite of the play on the LMS acronym. Such architectures take the content of provider systems as givens and focus on the use cases, schemas and protocols needed to use such systems via a single user interface. By contrast, an Integrated Library Management System (ILMS) deals with the acquisition, description and maintenance of collections as well as resource discovery and delivery. Its role is not just to provide access to a library’s collections but also to support internal operations. The authors of the VALA paper looked at the issues arising from the development of separate systems and processes by libraries for managing physical format and electronic collections and highlighted the need for ongoing development of the Integrated Library Management System (ILMS) to deal with both kinds of collection material. They identified the need for additional technical modules to support the management of electronic resources. This would not only achieve operational efficiencies but also ensure that such resources were described using the same cataloguing rules as other collection items and could be discovered through the catalogue. At the resource discovery end, they argued that the catalogue had a central role to play as a provider system in the delivery of hybrid library services at the local level; and that union catalogues such as the Australian National Bibliographic Database had a similar role to play at a regional or national level. To operate effectively in this role there needed to be a shift in development priorities from the OPAC to the Z39.50 server. Background to the Requirement Twelve months previously as part of its Digital Services Project the National Library of Australia had issued an information paper, outlining its requirements for products that would assist it to develop an integrated approach to digital service delivery (National Library of Australia, 2003). The Library had an immediate need for a system to support the delivery of a service providing access to images held in Australian collections. The first product purchased was thus a Metadata Repository and Search System that could be used to aggregate resource descriptions from a range of sources and to search across other systems using Z39.50 protocols. This was put to use at once to deliver the new PictureAustralia service (http://www.pictureaustralia.org). In the meantime a separate request for tender was released for a Digital Collection Management System. When the VALA paper was presented, the Library had just completed evaluation of responses to the request for tender and had failed to identify a suitable integrated solution to its digital collection management needs. A range of mature products were available in the market place to support the storage of digital objects but digital library applications were still at an early stage of development and did not have the required functionality or modularity. From this exercise, the Library learnt that there was no technical reason to store its digital objects inside a database management system. In fact that there were benefits in keeping the storage and management requirements separate in the logical systems architecture. The Reference Model for an Open Archival Information System (OAIS) provided a conceptual framework that supported this approach through its focus on ‘ingest’, storage and access (RLG, 2002). The ‘Submission Information Package’ received from producers and the ‘Dissemination Information Package’ presented to consumers is opaque to the OAIS compliant archive. Processes to create, collect and describe electronic resources and to ensure their discovery and delivery fall outside the scope of the framework. A range of different functions might be needed to support these processes depending on the community to be served by the archive and the type of material to be archived. The Library had therefore just begun work on the specifications for two separate procurement processes at the time of the VALA paper: one for a Digital Object Storage System and one for a Digital Object Management System. ‘Buy not Build’ In spite of not having identified a suitable product through the previous procurement process, the Library was still determined to take a ‘buy not build’ approach to the digital object management requirement, preferring not to develop software in-house unless off-the-shelf products did not yet exist that met its requirements. In one specific area, however, the Library did decide to develop a software solution in-house. A Collecting System was needed to replace PAMS, a modest system that had already been developed in-house to gather web sites for the PANDORA archive (http://pandora.nla.gov.au). In this area, Australia was ahead of other countries taking on an archive role and suitable products had yet to be developed. The selective approach to web archiving adopted by the Library was resource-intensive. To make the service sustainable there was a need to minimise the cost of collecting each title. A small team of developers embarked on a project to build a workflow system to meet this requirement. By separating the storage requirement from the management requirement and taking workflow support for collecting web sites out of the equation, the Library hoped to find products that could be customised over time to meet its needs. Vendors of integrated library management systems were turning their attention to digital library requirements of their customers. In the broader market place digital asset management systems were being developed for allied communities such as museums and publishers. Digital asset management system vendors were more likely to offer products that could be customised quickly to meet the Library’s needs. They had expertise in different file formats, technical metadata and the processes required to interface with a digital object storage system. They were more likely to have used the latest Java-based technologies to develop their product and to have application-programming interfaces that could be used to develop support for library-specific workflows. Library system vendors had a better understanding of the requirement to treat the intellectual work as the primary object for management and discovery and the need to support collection hierarchies. They also had expertise in library standards such as MARC and Z39.50, thesauri, filing and sorting algorithms and non-Roman character sets. Their business was to improve the operational efficiency of library workflows and it seemed a natural extension for them to develop modules to support the management and delivery of digital collections. However, this was not core functionality needed by all libraries and there was not a high level of support for the requirement in existing products. Preference for an Integrated Solution The Library had a preference for a solution that could form part of an integrated library management system. Since 1996 it had been routinely digitising new picture acquisitions and making them accessible on the web through its Images1 service. Images1 was a stand-alone system using Oracle for its metadata repository and search system and a simple, pre-Dublin Core metadata schema for resource description. Behind the scenes, another stand-alone system based on an Access database - Pictorial Manager - had been developed to enable staff to create batches of pictures for dispatch to an external agent for digitisation and to acquit the batches on their return. This was an inefficient way to operate. Staff needed special skills to use Pictorial Manager and workflows were interrupted at each point where data needed to be transferred from one system to another. Digitisation is expensive and efficiencies in this area make the difference between one-off digitisation projects to showcase treasures and digitisation as a sustainable ongoing operation to open up access to the collections. Regardless of the solution, a key requirement of the product chosen was to enable use of the catalogue server as the master source for resource descriptions and the web interface to the catalogue as the first point of entry to the Library’s collections. The Images1 collection had grown to 20,000 images by 2000 but users were still only able to discover through this service less than 5% of the Library’s collection of over 600,000 paintings, photographs, prints and posters. In addition, much of the material that had been digitised was only described at collection-level in the Library’s catalogue. Users had to know to search both databases to be sure of discovering the full diversity of the collection.
Recommended publications
  • Educating the Academic Librarian As a Blended Professional: a Review and Case Study
    Educating the Academic Librarian as a Blended Professional: A Review and Case Study Professor Sheila Corrall Head of Department and Chair in Librarianship & Information Management University of Sheffield Introduction The challenges and opportunities facing academic librarians are continually changing as changes occur in the operating environment at both global and institutional levels. Key trends affecting their roles and skills include convergence of academic services, combining libraries with IT and/or other learning support services; awareness of information literacy and recognition of the teaching role of librarians; and a maturing role in institutional repository management and its suggested extension to research data management. The increasingly specialised nature of their work is reflected in the use of terms such as ‘para-academic’, hybrid librarian’ and ‘blended professional’ to highlight their boundary-spanning activities and identities. The challenges and opportunities facing professional educators are similarly fluid. Professional education for librarians has to anticipate changes and developments in professional tasks, roles and expectations, both at the macro level of the profession as a whole and the micro level of different library specialties. Education programmes must take account of standards set by national and international professional bodies, in addition to reflecting the realities of professional work in the sector. Programme content should also be informed by research in the discipline, enabling the academy to influence professional thinking and practice, contributing to the development and positioning of the profession. The challenges facing educators are significant, with some employers and graduates questioning the value of academic preparation for professional practice, while others see both initial and continuing education as a worthwhile investment, but want flexible tailored provision, not just a standard offer.
    [Show full text]
  • Hybrid Librarians in the 21St Century Library: a Collaborative Service-Staffing Model Lisa Allen
    Hybrid Librarians in the 21st Century Library: A Collaborative Service-Staffing Model Lisa Allen Abstract one’s attention to the need for adaptation and innova- Due to library patrons’ ever-changing information tion by academic libraries. Disruptive technologies that needs and the widespread adoption of information have driven the transition from the automated to the technology in higher education, academic libraries need electronic library “require new service models…that to evolve by employing “hybrid librarians” on teams that challenge established organizations and the interests provide instructional and information services in the and expertise of the individuals within them.”4 These departments they serve, while staffing and maintaining changes are occurring in an environment of decreas- the physical library space as it also evolves. Evidence ing resources (human and financial)5 and increasing that these changes are occurring is reflected in recent demands of users.6 According to James Neal, change job advertisements in the field of academic librarian- is an organizational constant that encourages hybrid ship. The core elements of a hybrid service-staffing structures, programs and roles.7 With information model are: collaboration of librarians and technologists technology’s immersion in higher education, we need serving on cross-functional technology teams that to move from an instructional to a learning paradigm;8 provide more integrated, personalized services at the we need to rethink education.9 Libraries are also fac- point-of-need; an organizational culture that supports ing value conflicts that may result in fragmentation of and reflects new ways of providing service; and a learn- library cultures, according to Kaarst-Brown.10 Two ele- ing organization framework to address issues related to ments of a hybrid service model in the academic library the training and development of hybrid librarians.
    [Show full text]
  • Management of Hybrid Libraries for Effective Library Services in Nigeria: New Trends in Accessing Information
    Global Journal of Academic Librarianship. Volume 1, Number 1 (2014), pp. 1-7 © Research India Publications http://www.ripublication.com Management of Hybrid Libraries for Effective Library Services in Nigeria: New Trends in Accessing Information ANDREW UCHENNA OGBONNA, UZOAMAKA IGEWSI and UCHE V. ENWEANI E-Reference Librarian, Digital Library Section Prof. Festus Aghagbo Nwako Library Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka, Nigeria ([email protected]) Center for Energy Research & Dev. Library University of Nigeria, Nsukka Enugu State, Nigeria ([email protected]) Anambra State University Library, Igbariam Campus Igbariam, Anambra State, Nigeria. Abstract This paper highlights the many ways available to library managers and patrons on the management and use of hybrid libraries, especially in academic libraries in Nigeria. The paper focused on the best practices that exist for making an effective use of library services by both patrons and library administrators. Considering the growing trends in new ways for accessing information which resulted from the emergence and explosion of Information and Communication Technologies, the paper looked at the needs, problems and strategies for making library services available and more efficient for the clienteles. Among these needs are, fast, improved and convenience- based services which hybrid library system is expected to provide. This is hoped to be enhanced by the appropriate installation and use of the Internet by both library administrators and patrons. Being focused at the developing nation like Nigeria, the problems ranged from poor information environment, poverty, lack of facilities to help the establishment of the hybrid system, to patrons’ inability to adapt to the foreseeing trends and the administrators’ inability to organize training workshops for their workers.
    [Show full text]
  • The New Hybrid Art Library: Printed Materials and Virtual Information
    World Library and Information Congress: 71th IFLA General Conference and Council "Libraries - A voyage of discovery" August 14th - 18th 2005, Oslo, Norway Conference Programme: http://www.ifla.org/IV/ifla71/Programme.htm May 27, 2005 Code Number: 020-E Meeting: 76 Art Libraries The new hybrid art library: printed materials and virtual information Alicia García Medina Biblioteca Instituto del Patrimonio Histórico Espanol, Madrid Teresa Coso Biblioteca del Museu Nacional d’Art de Catalunya, Barcelona Abstract: The development of new technology has an important impact in libraries and especially in art libraries because these institutions manage a great volume of visual information. The new digital tools provide a lot of digital information that must be adquired and preserved in a library. One of the challenges facing librarians actually is how to manage and specially, how to preserve this kind of information. We think that traditional library tasks as cataloguing and indexing and are now more important than ever jointly with preservation. Most of our art libraries are now virtual libraries because we cannot ignore the digital resources that increase our collection and affect the printed collection, specially because this material have increase the concept of “ephemera” in our library. In fact, most of the digital information is ephemera, for example we dont know if we must print the information that is located in a web site or if this can be saved in a library server or merely linked to. We want to discuss with our collegues the ways we can catalogue, indexing, preserve and present this information to users. We think that this discussion is very exciting because there are differents points of view and we can to work according to the kind of infomation just to build a hybrid library.
    [Show full text]
  • Official Program
    MOSAIC ’16 TOP SPONSORS OFFICIAL PROGRAM THE PREMIER EVENT IN HEALTH SCIENCES INFORMATION Provide the most essential journals in the field. Radiology The authoritative reference for the most current, clinically relevant, and highest quality research in the field of medical imaging. W W IMPACT 300+ pages of original peer-reviewed Authoritative reviews, well-balanced research commentary & expert opinion 6.867 FACTOR RadioGraphics This unique journal publishes the best peer-reviewed educational material in radiology. W Each issue features 15-20 practice- W Top source for self-assessment continuing focused articles spanning across all medical education (SA-CME) credits towards OVER radiologic subspecialties maintaining professional certification 1,000,000 SA-CME AWARDED Radiology Legacy Collection A searchable electronic archive of Radiology issues from 1923 to 1998, revealing the evolution of medical imaging. W Thousands of articles chronicling the W An invaluable research tool with keyed evolution, breakthroughs, and triumphs metadata to facilitate searches INDUSTRY’S of radiologic science PREEMINENT REFERENCE TOOL STOP BY BOOTH 513 TO LEARN ABOUT THE EXPANDED RADIOLOGY LEGACY COLLECTION VISIT US AT BOOTH 513 Order Today! Pubs.RSNA.org PUB421 PUB421 MLA Program Ad FIN.indd 1 3/31/16 1:22 PM Bleed: 8.125” Trim: 7.875” Live: 7.375” Bleed: 10.75” Trim: 10.5” Trim: Live: 10” Live: The inside story Get in-depth drug evaluations in The Medical Letter® The Medical Letter is an indispensable tool that provides concise, critical, and authoritative drug information, giving you the expertise to make challenging treatment decisions. With a rigorous and thorough editorial process, The Medical Letter offers a detailed yet succinct analysis of drugs and therapeutics.
    [Show full text]
  • Electronic Resource Management and Design
    City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works Publications and Research New York City College of Technology 2015 Electronic Resource Management and Design Kimberly R. Abrams CUNY New York City College of Technology How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/ny_pubs/105 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] Electronic Resource Management and Design 1 Abstract: We have now reached a tipping point at which electronic resources comprise more than half of academic library budgets. Because of the increasing work associated with the ever-increasing number of e-resources, there is a trend to distribute work throughout the library even in the presence of an electronic resources department. In 2013, the author conducted a survey of electronic resources managers and the way in which electronic resource management is structured at their institutions. Most models focus on interdepartmental collaboration in order to accomplish the work of managing electronic resources. Key Words: Electronic Resources, Electronic Resource Management Systems, Library Management Author Note: Kimberly R. Abrams is an Acquisitions Librarian at Adelphi University. Received: September 28, 2014 Accepted: November 3, 2014 Electronic Resource Management and Design 2 Electronic Resource Management and Design Electronic resources workflows are notoriously difficult for librarians to navigate. In order to successfully organize, manage, and provide access to electronic resources, new workflows must be instated. This occurs on an ad hoc basis, but new workflows work best when there is a long-term strategy.
    [Show full text]
  • Making a Difference... Together
    ANNUAL CONFERENCE November 7-10, 2018 — Rochester, New York MAKING A DIFFERENCE... 3 Welcome 4 Conference Schedule 6 Special Events 8 CE Workshops 10 Thursday Programs 12 Friday Programs 16 Saturday Programs 27 Trade Show Guide 32 Maps TOGETHER 2018 NYLA Conference Catalog Introduction New York Library Association NYLA Council 2018 6021 State Farm Road / Guilderland, NY 12084 President ALA Chapter Councilor RASS Councilors-at-Large 518-432-6952 / 800-252-NYLA Tim Burke Jennifer Ferriss Julia E. Schult Elaine Lasda Bergman nyla.org / [email protected] Upper Hudson Library System Saratoga Springs Public Baldwinsville Public Library (2018) Executive Director Library University at Albany Jeremy Johannesen / [email protected] President-Elect SCLA Chapter Councilor Libraries Michelle L Young ASLS Todd Schlitt Director of Membership Services Clarkson University Libraries Jessica Clemons Half Hollow Hills Public Library Grace Riario (2018) Lois Powell / [email protected] University at Buffalo Ramapo Catskill Library Immediate Past President SMART System Director of Finance Barbara K. Stripling FLS Laura Osterhout Galina Tsvaygenbaum / [email protected] Syracuse University School Rebecca Fuss Rochester Regional Library Sandra Echols (2019) of Information Studies Friends & Foundation of the Council College of New Rochelle Communications & Marketing Manager Rochester Public Library Kelsey Dorado / [email protected] Treasurer SSL Jill Leinung (2019) Cassie Guthrie LAMS Penny Sweeney Questar III Director of Government Relations & Advocacy Greece Public
    [Show full text]
  • Design and Implement of Digital Library: an Overview
    Design and Implement of Digital Library: An Overview Kiran P Savanur Nagaraj M N kiransavanur@;rediffmaif.com [email protected] Raman Research Institute Raman Research Institute Bangalore-560080 Bangalore-560080 1. INTRODUCTION Several terms have been coined at different times to represent the concept of library without books, Libraries having influence on computer readable format or having access to influence on digitized or digital format. The terms which have been in vague at different times include: Paperless library, electronic library, virtual library, libraries without boundaries and now it has been moved to digital libraries. The tenn digital library on one hand, is used to refer to a system or application whose functions are chiefly to extend electronic access to material available in a conventional library to a remote user. On the other hand, it is used to describe both commercial and academic systems designed to enable electronic access to a large collection of electronic documents to authorized users. The term's digital library and electronic library are used interchangeably and synonymously. The term "virtual library" or "library without walls" usually refers to the meta resources, subject portals that extend virtual accessibility of digital collections from several diverse sources without the users even knowing where the resource actually resides. A virtual library wuld potentially be enormous, linking huge collections from all around the globe, or it could be very small, consisting of few hundred links to digital resources maintained by an individual. The hvbrid librarv is in the continuum between the conventional and dieital- libraries where electronic and paper-based information sources are used alongside each other.
    [Show full text]
  • 12 Page Booklet
    ISSN: 0047-0414 District of Columbia Library Association Volume 35 Issue 8 February 2006 DCLA, the American Library Association chapter of our nation‘s Creating “A City of Life-Long Learning”: capital ♦ http://www.dcla.org Mayor’s Blue Ribbon Task Force Issues Findings ♦ 202-872-1112 (messages only) by Kathryn Ray Established in September 2004, were proposed: Upcoming DCLA Programs and Meetings the Mayor’s Task Force on the 1. Basic Literacy – The library Future of the D.C. Public Library should continue to encourage ♦ Feb. 10 (Fri.) 9:00-5:00 was charged with assessing the the use of library facilities for Myers-Briggs (p. 4) current state of the public library literacy classes, tutoring, and system, making recommenda- literacy tutor training. There ♦ Feb. 12 (Sun.) 1:30-4:30 tions, and implementing a should be an abundance of CSK Award (p. 7) District-wide plan. DCLA was computer workstations with ♦ Feb. 14 (Tues.) 6:00-8:00 p.m. represented by Past President educational software that DCLA Board Meeting (p. 6) Susan Fifer-Canby and DCLA learners can use to improve Director Fran Buckley. their reading skill. ♦ Feb. 15 (Wed.) 2:00-3:30 2. Best Sellers and Hot Topics – History of Medicine (p. 5) “Listening Sessions” are now The library should respond to ♦ March 3 (Fri.) LC Learning underway. On February 7, patron’s interests in popular Center Workshop (p. 7) 6:30 p.m., at the Martin Luther cultural and social trends by King, Jr. Memorial Library, you providing a current collection ♦ March 7 (Tues.) 9:30 a.m.
    [Show full text]
  • Download (119Kb)
    Towards Developing A Hybrid Library : An Organizational Frame Work Amit Kumar Das* Introduction A Library’s book stock still indicates the importance and the usefulness of the physical book and it contributes to documenting the history of the literature of a country and its bibliographic heritage. On top of the fact that the literature that is held in our libraries has as an inherent characteristic its validity that is that the content is still valid no matter how long ago it was published. Because of all that, these collections of printed materials are extremely valuable and we must preserve them and catalogue them accurately so we can offer our patrons the most precise information as possible. Automation and electronic information services are not newcomers to the library world. Back in the 1960s the early library automation systems were already beginning to prove their worth and the development of the MARC record format was well underway. The intervening thirty years have seen the power and features provided by library automation systems improve tremendously, the advent of online services, CD-ROM databases, the rise and growth of the Internet and its associated World Wide Web and beginnings of a truly digital virtual library appear. The development of new technology has an important impact in libraries because these institutions manage a great volume of visual information. The new digital tools provide a lot of digital information that must be acquired and preserved in a library. One of the challenges facing librarians actually is how to manage and specially, how to preserve this kind of information.
    [Show full text]
  • Facing the Challenges of Transition: the Next Generation Library”
    Purdue University Purdue e-Pubs Proceedings of the IATUL Conferences 2000 IATUL Proceedings “Facing the challenges of transition: the next generation library” Nancy V. Green The Linda Hall Library Nancy V. Green, "“Facing the challenges of transition: the next generation library”." Proceedings of the IATUL Conferences. Paper 12. https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/iatul/2000/papers/12 This document has been made available through Purdue e-Pubs, a service of the Purdue University Libraries. Please contact [email protected] for additional information. FACING THE CHALLENGES OF TRANSITION: THE NEXT GENERATION LIBRARY Green, Nancy V. The Linda Hall Library of Science, Engineering and Technology Kansas City, Missouri, USA On the verge of the 21st century, librarians recognize that fears of irrelevancy were greatly exaggerated. Today they carry on their work in a hybrid library environment. The revitalized role played by librarians in the Internet economy has forced an examination of processes and functions within libraries and librarianship. As the dust from the information revolution settles, the staff at the Linda Hall Library, like library workers elsewhere, provide a continuous tradition of service with an entirely new attitude. Librarians worldwide spent the last decade scrutinizing the past and speculating on the future. IATUL members from the University Library Twente, Maarten Van Bentum and Johanneke Braaksma explore the future of libraries through an analysis of changing user needs. Stuart Sutton of the San Jose State University reviews the past and conjectures about the future through a presentation of reference service as provided in model library types. In an effort to gain an understanding of our position and achieve the most we can under new circumstances, a holistic examination of library models is in order.
    [Show full text]
  • Development Team Paper Coordinator Principal Investigator Dr
    Paper No : 12 Special and Research Libraries Principal Investigator Module : 06 The Emergence& of Hybrid Special Library Subject Coordinator Development Team Paper Coordinator Principal Investigator Dr. Jagdish Arora, Director & Content Writer INFLIBNET Centre, Gandhinagar Subject Coordinator Content Reviewer Prof I V Malhan Paper Coordinator Professor and Head, Central University of Himachal Pradesh Dr Anjali Gulati Content Writer Senior Assistant Professor and Head, Department of Library and Information Science, Isabella Thoburn College Prof I V Malhan Content Reviewer Professor and Head, Central University of Himachal Pradesh 1 Library and Special and Research Libraries Information Science The Emergence of Hybrid Special Library Content Reviewer Description of Module Subject Name Library and Information Science Paper Name 12 Special and Research Libraries Module Name/Title The Emergence of Hybrid Special Library Module Id LIS/SRL-T /06 Pre-requisites Objectives Keywords 2 Library and Special and Research Libraries Information Science The Emergence of Hybrid Special Library 1. Introduction At the outset, this module has been designed to highlight several components such as, the concept of different types of libraries, what is hybrid library and special library, development of hybrid library and hybrid special library, prerequisites of hybrid special library design, elements of hybrid special library design and services of hybrid special library. The topics and sub topics of the module have specially focused on evolution and expansion of hybrid library. The development of hybrid library will depends on the type of institution and rate of development varies from library to library. It has been observed for a decade that there has been a shift to more and more electronic resources, but hybrid library scenario is likely to be around for several more years (Oppenheim & Smithson, 1999).
    [Show full text]