DOCSLIB.ORG

Choosing an Identity a General Model of Preference and Belief Formation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Choosing an Identity a General Model of Preference and Belief Formation Choosing an Identity A General Model of Preference and Belief Formation Sun-Ki Chai Ann Arbor Copyright c by the University of Michigan 1999 All rights reserved Published in the United States of America by The University of Michigan Press Manufactured in the United States of America ∞ Printed on acid-free paper 2002 2001 2000 1999 4 3 2 1 A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Chai, Sun-Ki Choosing an identity: a general theory of preference and belief formation /Sun-Ki Chai p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-471-?????-? (alk. paper) —ISBN 0-471-?????-? (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Social theory. Rational Choice. 2. Political development. Comparative. 3. Culture. Values and beliefs. I. Chai, Sun-Ki. II. Title. LOC Call No. 1999 Dewey Call No. 99-????? CIP For my family Contents Preface vi 1. The Success and Failure of Rational Choice 1 The Assumptions of the Rational Choice Approach 5 The Strengths of Conventional Rational Choice 8 The Weaknesses of Conventional Rational Choice 12 The Chapter Structure of This Book 19 2. Alternatives to Conventional Rational Choice: A Survey 24 Structural Assumptions and Models 25 Assumptions about Decision Making 31 Preference and Belief Assumptions 59 Conclusion 77 3. A General Model of Preference and Belief Formation 81 An Identity Coherence Model of Preference and Belief Formation 82 Assumptions of the Model 83 Basic Implications of the Model 97 Preference and Belief Change 100 Rewards and Preference and Belief Change 105 Implications for Dynamic Choice 111 Implications for Collective Choice 116 Plan for the Following Chapters 124 Proofs of Theorems 124 4. Ideology Formation and Policy Choice in Ex-Colonies 129 Theories of Policy Formation 130 The Conventional Model of the State 133 Variations on the Conventional Model of the State 138 vii An Identity Formation Theory of Oppositional Ideology Formation and Policy 148 A Statistical Analysis of Economic Intervention 163 Conclusion 172 5. The Origins of Ethnic Identity and Collective Action 174 Rationalist Theories of Ethnic Collective Action 175 A Coherence-Rational Choice Theory of Ethnic Group Formation 190 Case Studies 203 Conclusion 211 6. Structural Change, Cultural Change, and Civic Violence 213 Theories of Tradition and Modernity 215 An Coherence Rational Choice Theory of Structural Change, Altruism, and Collective Action 228 Conclusion 241 7. Conclusion 242 Modifying the Assumptions of the Model 242 Justifications for the Coherence Model 246 Summing Up 254 References 256 viii Preface This book provides a general model of preference and belief formation, integrating it with a model of rationality to generate a unified model of preferences, beliefs, and actions. The basic concept behind the model is one that appears under a variety of guises, depending on the social science literature from which it is taken: regret, dissonance, and coherence to name but a few. I argue that there is an essential theoretical unity to these concepts and that, properly defined and constrained, they can form the basis of a general positive model with implications not only for rational choice theories, but also for issues of personal identity and culture. I also argue that identity and culture are not antithetical to rationality but instead are essential to its having any meaning. The central premise of the model is that individuals act to optimize their preferences and beliefs within a set of phenomenological constraints, analogously to the way that they act to optimize actions within a perceived set of structural constraints. Indeed, optimization is seen to occur jointly across preferences, beliefs, and actions, as individuals seek to construct an optimal life plan that constitutes their identities. By providing this model, I hope to address some the major problems that have plagued attempts to extend the boundaries of the rational choice approach: (1) the ability to make determinate predictions and (2) the ability to make the transition from micro to macrolevel explanation. The model is examined in an extended fashion through three empirical studies that address major unresolved issues in the comparative study of long-term development. While writing this book, I have incurred debts to a wide range of teachers and colleagues. This book was originally my dissertation at the Stanford poltical science department, and I would like to thank the members of my dissertation committee: my adviser Robert Packenham, Gabriel A. Almond, and John Ferejohn. I would also like to thank the people from whom I received regular comments and advice during various stages of writing: David Abernethy, Michael Hechter, James G. March, and the late Aaron Wildavsky. I would also like to thank those who provided helpful comments on drafts of chapters, including George A. Akerlof, Jonathan Bendor, Richard Brody, Dennis Chong, William Dixon, Geoffrey Garrett, Kurt Gaubatz, David Grusky, Ted R. Gurr, Dwight Hahn, Satoshi Kanazawa, Sunhyuk Kim, Masaru Kohno, Stephen D. Krasner, David Laitin, Hye-ryeon Lee, Linda D. Molm, Susan Olzak, Kenneth Organski, Bertrand Roehner, Tibor Scitovsky, Paul M. Sniderman, the late Amos Tversky, and Barry R. Weingast. I apologize to anyone whose name I have left out inadvertedly. I also would like to thank the members of the Pizza and Politics and the Brown Bag Dissertation Writers groups at Stanford for risking indigestion on several presentations of my main ideas. I would also like to thank the University of Arizona sociology department for being ecumenical enough to hire a graduate from another discipline. Thanks also ix Preface x to research assistants Jason Miller and Kristi Clark for help with copyediting the document. I would like express appreciation to everyone at the University of Michigan Press, including the successive politics editors: Malcolm Litchfield, Charles T. Myers, Jeremy Shine as well as their staff, for their admirable patience, as well as to two anonymous reviewers and one anonymous member of the executive committee for their detailed comments. Along with the usual thanks, I would also like to offer some apologies. First of all, to the people at Michigan, who were promised a completed manuscript by August 1995. This clearly did not happen! Sorry for the long wait, and I hope that the resulting improvements in the text at least partly compensate for it. I should also acknowledge my ebtedness to the text-processing language Plain TEX, which was used to typeset this document, and the programming languages Snobol4 and Icon, which were used to write scripts for converting the citations, generating the index, and dealing with other last-minute changes of mind on formatting. Moreover, as an aside to those scholars whose theories are discussed and compared in this book: the nature of my topic has meant that I have had to skate over an extremely wide range of literature in a relatively short space. Hence, the dangers of superficiality or misrepresentation are omnipresent. Despite my best efforts, I am sure I have not always managed to avoid such dangers. I should also emphasize that each theory is evaluated in light of its applicability to the particular issue being discussed in the relevant chapter, not with regard to its overall usefulness, and I hope my comments will be taken in that light. Nonetheless, to those whose theories I have wronged in some fashion, I offer apologies in advance. Finally, I would like to apologize to my wife, Hye-ryeon Lee, and my son, Alex, for seeming to walk around in a fog at times while I was writing the book. Chapter 1 The Success and Failure of Rational Choice The rational choice approach, despite widespread criticism, has reached a point of unrivaled prominence among general theoretical approaches for explaining human action. This prominence extends across the entire range of social sciences. In economics, rational choice remains unchallenged as the dominant, if not defining, theoretical paradigm, and is sometimes referred to simply as the “economic approach .”1 In political science, largely under auspices of the public choice school, the rational choice approach has grown to the point where it has more adherents than any other, and its threatened dominance has set off an intense debate that has polarized the discipline.2 In psychology, rational choice can claim close ties to a wide variety of theories located under the broad rubric of expectancy-value analysis.3 Furthermore, the rapidly-growing subfield of decision theory, while often rejecting the economist’s optimizing version of rational choice, uses it as the standard against which to compare its own bounded rational choice models.4 In sociology, rational choice has risen from obscurity to become a major theoretical approach in both Europe and the United States, benefiting from the strong support of some the most prominent names in the discipline.5 While anthropology is less interested than other social science disciplines in grand theories, rational choice has nonetheless been at the center of perhaps the main ongoing theoretical debate in cultural and social anthropology, that over whether interpretation of unfamiliar cultural practices should always proceed on the assumption that participants in such practices are rational.6 Furthermore, it could 1 See, for instance, Becker 1976b; Monroe 1991; Radnitzky and Bernholz 1987; Radnitzky 1992. 2 Numerous books have been written on the topic of rational choice theory and political science, many of which are cited later in this chapter. For a journalist’s overview of this intradisciplinary strife, see Cushman 1994. 3 Although the exact boundaries of expectancy-value analysis are open to debate, it is usually defined as encompassing theories in which action is based on the value placed on different outcomes and the perceived effect of each alternative in achieving these outcomes. These include achievement motivation theory, some versions of social learning theory, some versions of decision theory, the theory of reasoned action, field theory, and purposive behavior theory.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Wanderlust // Malaysia
    WANDERLUST // MALAYSIA www.travel3sixty.com A FEAST JPeppered by infl uences from faraway and exotic lands, the culinary heritage of Malaysia’s Jawi Peranakan community is enriched by a tapestry of cultures. WI WORDS: CHITRA SANTHINATHAN PHOTOGRAPHY: CHEWWIN WIN 114 DEC 2016 t360 Dec2016_081116_A_tsy.indd 114 11/11/2016 5:34 PM WANDERLUST // MALAYSIA www.travel3sixty.com A FEAST JPeppered by infl uences from faraway and exotic lands, the culinary heritage of Malaysia’s Jawi Peranakan community is enriched by a tapestry of cultures. WI WORDS: CHITRA SANTHINATHAN PHOTOGRAPHY: CHEWWIN WIN Flavoured with the leaves of the lemuni plant (vitex trifolia), nasi lemuni is believed to restore vitality, and is mainly eaten by women in confi nement. The Jawi Peranakan use butterfl y pea fl owers to give the grains a blue tinge. 114 DEC 2016 t360 Dec2016_081116_A_tsy.indd 114 11/11/2016 5:34 PM t360 Dec2016_081116_A_tsy.indd 115 11/11/2016 5:34 PM s a Malaysian, I’m utterly spoilt for from Europe, the Middle East, China and the Jawi Peranakan communities are largely based choice when it comes to food. Malay- Indian subcontinent to this part of the world. in Penang, Melaka and Singapore, where their sia’s cuisine, a marriage of flavours Many adventurous souls, besotted by the forefathers once docked in search of the riches inspired by the communities that call charms of the land, settled on her shores and of the Far East. this land home, mirrors the cultural di- forged new lives for themselves. While the history of the Jawi Peranakan Aversity of a nation populated by a multi- Intermarriage between these foreigners and people offers an intriguing insight into the racial melange.
    [Show full text]
  • Malaysia's National Language Mass Media: History and Present Status
    South East Asian Studies, Vol. 15, No.4, March 1978 Malaysia's National Language Mass Media: History and Present Status John A. LENT* Compared to its English annd Chinese language newspapers and periodicals, Nlalaysia's national language press is relatively young. The first recognized newspaper in the Malay (also called Bahasa Malaysia) language appeared in 1876, seven decades after the Go'vern­ ment Gazette was published in English, and 61 years later than the Chinese J!lonthly 1\1agazine. However, once developed, the Malay press became extremely important in the peninsula, especially in its efforts to unify the Malays in a spirit of national consciousness. Between 1876 and 1941, at least 162 Malay language newspapers, magazines and journals were published, plus eight others in English designed by or for Malays and three in Malay and English.I) At least another 27 were published since 1941, bringing the total to 200. 2) Of the 173 pre-World War II periodicals, 104 were established in the Straits Settlements of Singapore and Penang (68 and 36, respectively): this is understandable in that these cities had large concentrations of Malay population. In fact, during the first four decades of Malay journalism, only four of the 26 newspapers or periodicals were published in the peninsular states, all four in Perak. The most prolific period in the century of Malay press is the 35 years between 1906-1941, when 147 periodicals were issued: however, in this instance, 68, or nearly one half, were published in the peninsular states. Very few of the publications lasted long, to the extent that today, in Malaysia, despite the emphasis on Malay as the national language, there are only three Malay dailies.
    [Show full text]
  • Bahasa Tanjong: the Evolution of the Identity and Ideology of a Northern
    Kajian Malaysia, Vol. 33, Supp. 2, 2015, 91–111 BAHASA TANJONG: THE HERITAGE LANGUAGE OF THE JAWI PERANAKANS OF PENANG1 Hajar Abdul Rahim School of Humanities, Universiti Sains Malaysia, MALAYSIA Email: [email protected] Bahasa Tanjong (Tanjong language) in the present discussion refers to a Malay dialect which has been labelled as "Penang Malay" and "George Town Malay" by past researchers. It is a variation of the Northern Malay dialect of Peninsular Malaysia which emerged over two centuries ago in the George Town area of Penang, also known locally as Tanjong. It is a hybridised form of Malay that grew out of the language contact situation between two cultures, Malay and South Indian Muslims. The intermarriage between the two groups produced an Indo-Malay community known as Jawi Peranakans who are the native speakers of the dialect. Bahasa Tanjong, as with other languages is a product of culture and is inextricably bound to its speech community. Thus, while considered a Northern Malay dialect, its emergence amidst a locale that was considered a colonial cosmopolitan caused it to possess features that are distinct from other Malay dialects. Early descriptions of bahasa Tanjong, such as Hamilton's discussion of "Penang Malay" published almost a century ago, considers the distinguishing characteristics of the dialect as a deviation of the Northern Malay Dialect. This is the point of departure for this article that argues that the features are in fact cultural markers that contribute to the construction of the bahasa Tanjong identity. Its Indian linguistic heritage, particularly Tamil, as well as its inclination to allow influences from other languages, sets it apart from other Northern Malay dialects.
    [Show full text]
  • Daripada Jawi Peranakan Kepada Melayu: Tinjauan Terhadap Komuniti Jawi Peranakan Di Pulau Pinang Pada Abad Ke-21
    Sari - International Journal of the Malay World Omarand Civilisation Yusoff & Noriah 28(2) (2010):Mohamed 63 - 8263 Daripada Jawi Peranakan kepada Melayu: Tinjauan terhadap Komuniti Jawi Peranakan di Pulau Pinang pada Abad ke-21 OMAR YUSOFF & NORIAH MOHAMED ABSTRAK Makalah ini meninjau tentang komuniti Jawi Peranakan yang menetap di Pulau Pinang. Tinjauan dilaksanakan menerusi kaedah kualitatif dan berfokus kepada tinjauan pustaka dan temu bual tidak berstruktur antara penyelidik dan informan Jawi Peranakan. Tinjauan mendapati bahawa kedatangan golongan pendatang dan pedagang dari India dan Arab ke Pulau Pinang telah mewujudkan kelompok Jawi Peranakan menerusi perkahwinan campur antara golongan ini dengan wanita Melayu tempatan. Golongan hibrid ini pada mulanya dikenali sebagai Jawi Pekan tetapi kemudian disebut sebagai Jawi Peranakan. Sekarang, golongan Jawi Peranakan ini lebih cenderung mengamalkan budaya Melayu dan dalam menuju ke arah menjadi Melayu, proses asimilasi dan amalgamasi yang dilalui oleh golongan ini sejak sekian lama, telah menyebabkan sebahagian besar mereka tidak lagi mempertahankan budaya mereka yang ada antaranya dikatakan bertentangan dengan akidah Islam. Pergeseran bukan sahaja berlaku terhadap budaya, malah aspek bahasa juga mempamerkan keadaan yang sama. Makalah ini cuba mendeskripsikan Jawi Peranakan dan meninjau perubahan budaya dan penggunaan bahasa Jawi Peranakan di Pulau Pinang pada masa ini. Kata kunci: Jawi Pekan, Jawi Peranakan, Melayu, Pulau Pinang, budaya ABSTRACT This paper will review the Jawi Peranakan community that settled in Penang. A survey was conducted through qualitative methods and focused on library research and non-structured interviews between the researcher and the Jawi Peranakan informants. This survey found that the arrival of the immigrants and traders from India and Arab to Penang gave rise to the Jawi Peranakan community through inter-marriage between these groups with local Malay women.
    [Show full text]
  • The Question of the Future of Indian Muslims in Malaysia: the Post-Mahathir Legacy Era
    AFRICAN AND ASIAN STUDIES African and Asian Studies 11 (2012) 219-246 brill.nl/aas The Question of the Future of Indian Muslims in Malaysia: The Post-Mahathir Legacy Era Ahmad Noor Sulastry Yurni* Department of Anthropology & Sociology, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, University of Malaya, 50603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] Abstract The Malays, Chinese and Indian community in Malaysia have been homogenized since British colonialism. The existence of Indian Muslims’ identity caused a new paradigm shift in Malaysia involving the racial discussion. This paper traces the diffference in Indian Muslims’ identities from Indian and the Hindus. I argued that Indian Muslims share Islam as their religion and faith, while maintaining a Malay way of life and custom in their daily practices. In Malaysia, the Indian Mus- lim community struggled to place their future in terms of social, economic allocation and politi- cal justifijication among the other communities. However, the strength of ethnic politics clearly charted out their involvement in the political base and moved them to fijight for their cause and rights. Hence, today’s Indian Muslim community has caused an Islamic resurgence, which has brought a new Indian dimension as a whole. Keywords homogenized; religion; race; identity and human rights Introduction As a multi-racial country, Malaysia has four major ethnic groups, each with its own traditions: Malay, Chinese, Indian and the indigenous people. Indians form 7.8 percent of the country’s total population of 27 million and are mostly Hindu with origin from Tamil Nadu. The Muslim Malays form 60 percent of the population while the Chinese, who account for 25 percent, are Buddhists or Christians.
    [Show full text]
  • ORIGINAL ARTICLE the Importance of the Indian Muslim Community To
    1354 Advances in Natural and Applied Sciences, 6(8): 1354-1360, 2012 ISSN 1995-0772 This is a refereed journal and all articles are professionally screened and reviewed ORIGINAL ARTICLE The Importance of the Indian Muslim Community to the Economic Development of the Malay Society in Malaysia 1,2Wan Kamal Mujani, 1Mohd Irman Mohd Abd Nasir, 3Azmi Aziz, 4Ahmad Munawar Ismail, 2Abdul Qayyum Abdul Razak, 2Allawati Kasri, 1,5Noor Inayah Yaakub and 1,2Ermy Azziaty Rozali. 1Institute of West Asian Studies (IKRAB), Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 43600 Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia. 2Department of Arabic Studies and Islamic Civilization, Faculty of Islamic Studies, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 43600 Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia. 3Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 43600 Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia. 4Department of Theology and Philosophy, Faculty of Islamic Studies, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 43600 Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia. 5Faculty of Economy and Management, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 43600 Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia. Wan Kamal Mujani, Mohd Irman Mohd Abd Nasir, Azmi Aziz, Ahmad Munawar Ismail, Abdul Qayyum Abdul Razak, Allawati Kasri, Noor Inayah Yaakub and Ermy Azziaty Rozali: The Importance of the Indian Muslim Community to the Economic Development of the Malay Society in Malaysia ABSTRACT Malaysia is a Muslim country, thus studies on the unity of the ‘ummah’ in Malaysia involving multiethnicity needs to be emphasized. The bigger Muslim ethnic groups such as the Indian Muslim, Chinese Muslim and Malays have the potential to form a Muslim middle class and contribute to national development. However, sociological studies regarding them are lacking in Malaysia, particularly in the economic context. For example, studies on the Indian Muslim community are mainly focused on the political scope and not enough on their economic achievement.
    [Show full text]
  • Analisis Jenis Bahasa Masyarakat India Muslim Di Malaysia
    Jurnal Peradaban, Jil. 9, 32-50 (2016) ANALISIS JENIS BAHASA MASYARAKAT INDIA MUSLIM DI MALAYSIA aMohd Irman Mohd Abd Nasir bAbdul Qayuum Abdul Razak aInstitut Islam Hadhari, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia bAkademi Pengajian Islam Kontemporari, Universiti Teknologi MARA Melaka, Malaysia Abstrak Makalah ini membincangkan identiti masyarakat India Muslim di Malaysia yang memfokuskan kepada bahasa pertuturan yang digunakan oleh mereka. Matlamat (Objektif) pertama adalah untuk mengenal pasti jenis-jenis bahasa masyarakat India Muslim sama ada di India dan di Malaysia. Matlamat kedua ialah menghubungkaitkan jenis-jenis bahasa tersebut dengan sejarah kedatangan mereka ke Tanah Melayu, tumpuan petempatan semasa berdasarkan kelompok bahasa dan masalah-masalah berkaitan bahasa di antara mereka. Kajian ini menggunakan tatakaedah kualitatif dengan menggunakan kaedah (metode) seperti pemerhatian, analisis dokumen dan temu bual. Kajian mendapati, terdapat dua kelompok utama dalam masyarakat India Muslim di Malaysia, iaitu mereka yang berbahasa Tamil dan berbahasa Malayalam. Mereka yang berbahasa Tamil datang dari wilayah Tamil Nadu, manakala Malayalam datang dari wilayah Kerala. Dari segi tumpuan petempatan, masyarakat Tamil Muslim kebanyakannya berpusat di Kuala Lumpur, manakala masyarakat Malayali atau Malabari Muslim berpusat di Johor. Abstract This paper discusses the identity of the Indian Muslim community in Malaysia based on their spoken languages. The first objective is to identify the languages used by the Indian Muslim community in India and in Malaysia. The second objective is to correlate the types of the language with the history of their coming to Malaya, the focus of the current settlement based on language and language-related problems among them. This research uses qualitative methodology with certain methods such as observation, document analysis and interview.
    [Show full text]
  • Print Culture Amongst Tamils and Tamil Muslims in Southeast Asia, C.1860-1960
    Working Paper No. 167 Print Culture amongst Tamils and Tamil Muslims in Southeast Asia, c.1860-1960 by Dr. S.M.A.K. Fakhri Madras Institute of Development Studies 79, Second Main Road, Gandhi Nagar Adyar, Chennai 600 020 February 2002 Print Culture amongst Tamils and Tamil Muslims in Southeast Asia, c. 1860-1960 Authors name and institutional affiliation: Dr SM AK Fakhri Affiliate, June-December 2001 Madras Institute of Development Studies. Abstract of paper: This paper is about the significance of print in the history of Tamil migration to Southeast Asia. During the age of Empire people migrated from India to colonial Malaya resulting in the creation of newer cultural and social groups in their destination (s). What this .meant in a post-colonial context is that while they are citizens of a country they share languages of culture, religion and politics with 'ethnic kin' in other countries. Tamils and Tamil-speaking Muslims from India were one such highly mobile group. They could truly be called 'Bay of Bengal transnational communities' dispersed in Myanmar, Malaysia, Singapore and Vietnam. The construction of post-colonial national boundaries constricted but did not affect the transnationalism of Tamils across geographies and nation-states. A thriving and successful print culture is a pointer to the manner in which Tamils and Tamil Muslim expressed their transnational (Tamil) identities. Such a print culture this paper suggests is a rich and valuable source of social history. Keywords Print, Print Culture, transnational communities, migration, mobility, social history, Tamils, Tamil Muslims, India, Indian migrants, Indian Ocean region. Acknowledgements This paper was presented at the Conference on 'Southeast Asian Historiography since 1945' July 30 to August I, 1999 by the History Section, School of Humanities, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Penang, Malaysia as 'Cues for Historiography?•: Print Culture, Print Leaders and Print Mobility among Tamil Muslims in Southeast Asia, c.
    [Show full text]
  • Pemikiran Dan Falsafah Adat Resam Perkahwinan Jawi Peranakan Pulau Pinang
    Journal of Human Development and Communication Volume 2, 2013 [141–159] Pemikiran dan Falsafah Adat Resam Perkahwinan Jawi Peranakan Pulau Pinang Omar Yusoff1, Noriah Mohamed1, Abdul Jalil Ramli2 dan Zainab Ahmad3 1Universiti Sains Malaysia 2Universiti Malaysia Perlis 3Institut Pendidikan Guru Malaysia, Kampus Perlis ABSTRAK Kertas kerja ini meninjau tentang komuniti Jawi Peranakan yang menetap di Pulau Pinang. Tinjauan dilaksanakan menerusi kaedah kualitatif dan berfokus kepada tinjauan pustaka dan temu bual tidak berstruktur antara penyelidik dan informan Jawi Peranakan. Tinjauan mendapati bahawa kedatangan golongan pendatang dan pedagang dari India dan Arab ke Pulau Pinang telah mewujudkan kelompok Jawi Peranakan menerusi perkahwinan campur antara golongan ini dengan wanita Melayu tempatan. Golongan hybrid ini pada mulanya dikenali sebagai Jawi Pekan tetapi kemudian disebut sebagai Jawi Peranakan. Sekarang, golongan Jawi Peranakan ini lebih cenderung mengamalkan budaya Melayu dan dalam menuju ke arah menjadi Melayu, proses asimilasi dan amalgamasi yang dilalui oleh golongan ini sejak sekian lama, telah menyebabkan sebahagian besar mereka tidak lagi mempertahankan budaya mereka yang ada antaranya dikatakan bertentangan dengan akidah Islam. Walaupun pada masa sekarang, komuniti ini menganggap diri mereka adalah Melayu, tetapi sebahagian besar daripada mereka masih lagi mengekalkan adat dan pantang larang yang diwarisi daripada nenek moyang mereka sejak turun temurun dalam menguruskan hal perkahwinan. Inilah di antara keunikan masyarakat ini berbanding masyarakat Melayu lain di Pulau Pinang. Kertas kerja ini cuba mendeskripsikan pantang larang dan adat resam perkahwinan Jawi Peranakan serta meninjau pemikiran dan falsafah di sebaliknya. 1.0 PENGENALAN Sebelum Pulau Pinang dibuka secara rasmi oleh Kapten Light pada tahun 1786, pulau ini dikenali sebagai Pulau Kesatu.
    [Show full text]
  • Historical and Contemporary Perspectives of the Nyonya Food Culture in Malaysia
    J Ethn Foods 3 (2016) 93e106 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Journal of Ethnic Foods journal homepage: http://journalofethnicfoods.net Original article Historical and contemporary perspectives of the Nyonya food culture in Malaysia * Chien Y. Ng, Shahrim Ab. Karim Department of Food Service and Management, Faculty of Food Science and Technology, Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM), UPM Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia article info abstract Article history: Nyonya cuisine echoes the cultural identity of the Peranakans, who are both Chinese and localized. Received 18 February 2016 Despite the fact that the food is much localized, its symbolism remains traditionally Chinese. This paper Received in revised form explores the history, ingredients, and cooking methods crucial in the production of the cuisine, the types 23 April 2016 of food served for daily consumption, festivities and ancestral worships, as well as their Chinese sym- Accepted 2 May 2016 bolism. Furthermore, this paper also discusses factors that contributed to the obscurity of the culture and Available online 14 May 2016 the cuisine after the Second World War. Lastly, the revival of the culture through the immense interest in its cuisine, especially from the 1980s, and the extent of globalization of this cuisine are also examined. Keywords: fi Chinese symbolism Findings reported are expected to highlight the signi cance of Nyonya cuisine in Malaysia in the past and globalization the present. Nyonya cuisine © 2016, Korea Food Research Institute. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the Peranakans CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). revival 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Singapore and Sumatra's Westkust As a Malay Writing and Journalism
    International Journal of Social Science and Humanity, Vol. 6, No. 12, December 2016 Singapore and Sumatra’s Westkust as a Malay Writing and Journalism Hub before World War II Mohd Amirul Akhbar Mohd Zulkifli Singapore was at the centre of colonial communications. Abstract—This paper attempts to identify and assess The regions surrounding it as in Indochina and the Dutch Singapore and Sumatra’s Westkust (West Sumatra) as the East Indies created British insecurity to the colonial power in centre for Malay intellectual activities before World War II. Singapore. The colonials did not hold a monopoly. The present literature has not focused on this subject. Therefore, Indigenous systems and identities thrive with the fusion of what this paper does is examine the context of Malay publishing and journalism and the growth of newspapers. It tries to answer technologies arrived from Europe. why Malay journalism and writing thrive by identifying factors Meanwhile in West Sumatra the research toward the from geography, to colonialism to the cultural. In so doing, two development of printing development specifically the factors emerged as critical to the growth of Malay writing and newspapers industry was not extensive enough done. Perhaps journalism, that is, trade, and the consciousness for information the most comprehensive one was by Ahmat Adam under the and knowledge and rejection towards Pax Neerlandica. title The Vernacular Press and the Emergence of Modern Indonesian Consciousness 1855-1913 which was published Index Terms—Colonialism, journalism, Malay newspaper, publishing. in 1995. According to Ahmat Adam [3] the research on the development of newspapers industry in West Sumatra before World War 2 was too little.
    [Show full text]
  • Eaton Dissertation
    Governing Shōnan: The Japanese Administration of Wartime Singapore Clay Eaton Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 2018 © 2018 Clay Eaton All rights reserved ABSTRACT Governing Shōnan: The Japanese Administration of Wartime Singapore Clay Eaton The Japanese military administration of Southeast Asia during the Second World War was meant to rebuild the prewar colonial system in the region under strong, centralized control. Different Japanese administrators disagreed over tactics, but their shared goal was to transform the inhabitants of the region into productive members of a new imperial formation, the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere. Shōnan, the wartime name for Singapore, was meant to be the center of this Co-Prosperity Sphere in Southeast Asia. It was the strategic fulcrum of the region, one of its most important ports, and a center of culture and learning for the wartime Japanese. Home to thousands of Japanese administrators during the war and a linguistically, ethnically, and religiously diverse local population, Shōnan was a site of active debates over the future of the Sphere. Three assumptions undergirded these discussions: that of Japanese preeminence within the Sphere, the suitability of “rule by minzoku (race)” for Southeast Asians, and the importance of maintaining colonial social hierarchies even as Japanese administrators attempted to put the region on a total war footing. These goals were at odds with each other, and Japanese rule only upended social hierarchies and exacerbated racial tensions. The unintended legacy of the wartime empire lay, not only in the new opportunities that Japanese rule afforded to Southeast Asian revolutionaries, but in the end of the politics of accommodation with imperial power practiced by prewar Asian elites.
    [Show full text]