$)#*+, * Martin Seeger**

6"!"&7-'#5M'C/*&7-6!$) C/0(!(7 C/0(&7-.)*7-" ,5x$ 7-)M#7-6!" '.7. LS–S ,5x#&! )!7-6!" '.7. LŒ‘’ ,5!M-)!6! 4!!($ 0 5"$)'6)// '.7. LŒS‘ $‰) 6!7-%)&7- $7-6!%6 P‘ ‚!(Q!" &5 (!" 0 5!($M-,5Q7-Q)7- )))4 '0( )! )),! 5 7 7 M' # M'% 7-,56!$

"88" : 6!$, *% 7 - 6!$, '7M%''#7$,& )!7-, '&#757-, M &!

 ( ) !"#$ %&' (*++,), ./' 0 () !"#$%&' 1"2/" 3 04 55. 162/ ".04 ' Martin Seeger Research Committee of the Association of Southeast Asian Studies in the United Kingdom (ASEASUK) funded by The British Academy !2/" " Justin McDaniel 2/1 #5#" &.06 (. ' ..87 6)7 9& ' ., %%. (; 66) !"& ' ., & ' . 9.; 6 ;.1 9 52/#5#" * #' = ./ ./ >9 ** Senior Lecturer #0;; & 4? ./ ' ;&9@4 ! "## $%&-& ''( Mae Chis’ Access to Higher Monastic Education in

Abstract

This research investigates the relationship between Thai mae chis’ access to higher monastic education, provided by the , and their opportunities to find appropriate accommodation and financial support. While the Mahanikaya Sangha has supported mae chis in their Abhidhamma Studies since 1951, the Dhammayuttika-Nikaya Sangha has provided mae chis with the opportunity to pursue Pali Studies in a similar way to since 1963 (even though there still exist some significant differences). As a consequence of the enactment of their University Acts in 1997, both Mahachulalongkornrajavidyalaya University and Mahamakut Buddhist University have been able to admit mae chis to their programmes. Our research will show that monastic educational career opportunities for mae chis have improved significantly over the last 10 years or so. A major objective of our research is to provide an analytical investigation of the interviews we conducted with students, administrators and teachers in higher monastic education. Here, we will discuss the views and experiences of our interviewees in order to study the potential and effectiveness of the monastic education that has been made available to Thai mae chis in recent years.

Keywords : Thai mae chis, access to higher monastic education, gender in Thai Buddhism, Pali Studies, Buddhist Studies, bhikkhuni - . / Martin Seeger

. 9 )!7-6!"‚ '.7. LŒLP %6, P‘ ‚!(Q * C&) ,! " M'-, 5 6!4 7- ) 7& - )6 %! $ !" '$'7 * % Q& % %D !"4$ %‚ '.7. LŒSL “ 6)! !8 ( * ) ! " #$%%!$&'()& N6& ( *‰ *+ &),$"+ % 6!7-) // ! '' #7& ,-.#$*%""*+ & '0(7-.)6!!7 ),$!"/) $ " 6!7!5 ! & Q" -! #$)01()*2&*+ # $7- ) //* * " ,#3,%! ) œ,6& %6 60( (&'%!") !$,-., ( 7 -% ‚ '.7. LŒŒP (7 %,66!7 " ,+ 2!$ œ,6& , LŒŒP) 8%2 ("%',) 2 !(6!$!7-)&7-" $! && &9, #*!/ "#$ 7-)7-#7- %‚ '.7. *+/),$,'(3&%&* LŒRR 0 7-# ,! 8( :,& " + ; % #$ ) 6!$ .M!( 6) &! -22!"*+” *,6!) 6!$ 6 / ('$'7 *, LŒŒ’: P–P) )7- #7-#7- %))7-))*! (7.) ($ N," 5 8( ( Q ( !( 6'# #7-)!7- '6)// 7- 6 '.7. LŒSL $ %4/!()6$$)67!8( '( (U)) !( L) '.7. LŒSŒ 0 6!!# 7 - 7 -))% ." 6!7 %7-$%)//!//* & .M67 ! Z$ ‰ ! //%Z)$ .)) // !" ‰ ! 0 ) Entrance 8(! %  5./694F ;;65.%$5. 2.$.0 '... 9; .$0 G ;H ‰ 7 -$ *$ !";.#;1 9" .;6I 9 .;I 9N ./9N 9;H9'$.0'G ./;$ 29././.O  5. ;95/., #5.& #;0  5.# 0&P, - & 9/F., ;6%. V, 66; , #;0, 9/ , 1 *Q @40. ././>9, 1 W+ .$ *+++, .04 '. *+++, .04 '. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

Entrance )6$ /%& )6! Q6 ‚ '.7. LŒŒ‘ -& ) 5 ~5 7 5 .6/, 5 )/& %& Q& “6 (Lindberg-Falk) $ ! !( )7 - 6!$ )6!$))6” " % 0 !( ) )6/ (Lindberg Falk Monica, Z)$ ‰ M'! 7- 2007) $ 7 - 6!$ “6!$$ ) (!U'55!M(.) 6! /& 7!( - ) // !!(  5 7 -$ œ,6-& 7$$!( !"4!*. ) 6!!( ‰ ! ) //* // 7 - ) 7& -$ ” % '# 5 .)@ 5 6! " '.7. LŒSL ! !" ) 5 ~5 (Lindberg-Falk) $4 " ! P ‚ œ,6& $ ‰ 5!(7-U'C)& // !'&#7),J6M# " *#) “œ,6& !( ‰ ,'#7& 5 % ‚ '.7. LŒSR .) 6!@ 5 *%6!7-%)//$,!'7- 6/ N6& 8 ( U')”& (Lindberg Falk Monica, 2007: 201) 5!$‰*%6!7-$% %!!"$#)'( !)6"! ) // ! ( '.7. LŒSL //* ‚ '.7. LŒSŒ (courses) !(6!!$ )5 ~5 // ‚ '.7. LŒS– %!" 4 ! (Lindberg-Falk) ' *%7 - ) // !(%0())7-!(6! !6)!( ! ! " $ $ !( !" %,!(6 $" &œ,6&N- 6 $ 7-7-* 7-D 6!!( !") $ !7-)!()!(%)) 7-).)6!!(*5 $" " !( *‰ !" !( !(!./$ %6 * 6 $ $ % %%7-50(!"!(

“Mae Chiis have not been entitled to study for Bachelor degrees at the two Buddhist universities in Thailand and  !"&.' .69 ' 6/ , // 0" there are few opportunities for them to attain higher 6 ./ & , 9;./, 1 *+ . education” (Lindberg Falk, Making Fields of Merit, /" *+++, .04 '. *WQ).  /%&=, 0%. “…, Thai mae chiis have been excluded from the %&,' ./ ./ >9 . Buddhist universities with the exception of some courses  = ././.X #;0 that are open to them” (Lindberg Falk, Making Fields of %.= 9/ F.. Merit, /" WVQ). - . / Martin Seeger

6 $!( *%‰ 6! (!($) 7- 5" " !(  5" $%&)"//!// $)&6)!! % 0 “)” 8( !''5 " %‚ '.7. 8( *! 6! " % '# 5 LŒŒR M- &,!# $! “  5 L //8 ( 0( !( Minnesota % ‚ '.7. %&'› "&N6&œ- LŒŒR Kaoru Adachi ! “*% ,6 " % 7 - ', 7-0())U))!0((!(6!! %#& " C !( ) & ,!(Z))&'M-&%7- ),Z)!($M-!-A ) 7& -Q  5 Z)$ "/6 7-'&#7!(%% *7-% 6! Q)0 0(  5" !" .U''M - & 5 *%7-!"0(./ 4 0( !(%6)# ) $ (serious)” (Adachi, Kaoru, n.d.: 40) !" ",!,"<,&, ,$92&2, 0 *& !( $ ' ')! & ,$%, =, ? ” %)!" M- &,!#$ $ ' %)$!" Q) *Q/ % 7 -% 5'"'B0(7M' #M'*&7-!(*,5 $ " ! C &)' %"  Faith Adiele ;" ; 1 & 495.? “I know that maechi are often relegated to the ghetto, cooking œ,6& N-& and cleaning and serving monks to earn their keep. 6 *7-),57- Religious study is generally not open to them, certainly 6!!(7-%) D !( œ,& - not at the two Dhamma universities in Bangkok,…” (Adiele, Faith, Meeting Faith: An Inward Odyssey, New York: 6&N6 W. W. Norton, 2004, /" q+) /9 9z Faith Adiele ;. 3 M#*6 )!7- " .2' { .&. *+,| Iz /9 ;1 2/} 5." &?4" 5 /C * 7 -% 2 953 66 $ 9? 66;; ;H + .5{ " ,5!(7-6!Q!()7- % 5I;H" Faith Adiele ."$?9 I; /9 ;z . ;3 ? ;1 ; 595.1 6! ,$ %" 0( .6 ! "9".2/".. %*$ $ N # '7 !#'  04%.., , (9;./: 4 9&. *%))7! - !(*,$5 #, *++~) /" +|. 1"9..“.3 592 ;99"91#”9%.. 5 %6 !( $4 6 40 '7 ; " “. 3 [Iz “.592; 99 9" #1 %))7-'#Q7-M- ”] 5;.;1 .H ;1 ; 04H 9@429 )!'5))!7-6! %$) .9 & 4? 1 ?3 /1 F;. M (!(Z.0) (6!,Z 29;z;.4 *+,Q 5;H'9 !"   95.;? 04H / 9”?1 (04 U B ,5 LŒŒL: LL“-LL”) Z) )* %.., , /" +*) – U''M- & // ! $$ ))! 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

7-6! $$))&), 7 ),& %)5 7- 6 ,)& )Q& !( .7-.))6/ 7- 6!0( P‘ ‚!( “ 6! P.L Q)7- ) 6!!( ' $0 !# M'! )Q 0(Z# / 7-")!7- M#7- &7-% % 7-) $ )6! ) D !(Q0 #!M-,)5 & '4 ! ',6!%M')6 4)66!)&!(!() ! )6/ ” (6 ,)& )Q,& ),75 -* )& !( )* LŒSŒ: P‘–) ! )0 $ 7 - # &C/!(Q6/%!)!7- '5!(6!$ ! $ M#7-&7-%,!"4‰ % “%7-, 50(D ($%6 7 - *% 6!!% 7 !(.!( .) $ *%‰ Q/ !( M-, 5 $% Q/ 0 6!'! # !((%, (6!@-, )'M - ,& 0 *%‰ Q/ -*U) 6!!(Q7-!(*,5 #” ( ! )0 , LŒŒP: LPL) )//*//& (%‚ 6 ,)& )Q& ! )0 $ '.7. LŒSL '.7. LŒSŒ .)) C &) )&'!' .. .5 !( œ,-& " !"%/ Q 6 ,M'& 6 S ‚ ! (qualitative) !#! $ !" ),5"%ZQ)7-Q P. M-, ))5 (in-depth interviews 7- .%,$!*!( (%6. ‰ 6!(M-, 5 ) L & %6 0 $ %%Q !(%' B 0 .‰!#M'6! P.P Q7- 8( !)) !( (%,! ," 4 . ! Q*)7-.))6@5!( )  $5 " )# ) ! L. M-, 5 & (focus group) &œ,6 #)! M-,5&6! P‘ !(!)!7- &N6 #)!x M#7-&7- '0(%$!() 6 'Q%/ )) D0( '70( - 7),5)& !(.% ,4 7),57-$6"

 .5.%66.& ;," .%. V, 0%. = , 66 ;, #./' ./. X , 1 W  .5.19.. 1 Wq O. *++~, 9/. *++,, .04 '. .04'. - . / Martin Seeger

8(.%$ ' ! 4 /6C * 6 7-6 ( " 'U" ))) !" " # M'% 7 -$ !" $$ %6 % 65 ,% " !" 4 4(!(6!4!"%M' 6&,M'!(!*65.)"!" 7 - ' )," )5 &5(!" 0 )!( 6!)%6!. (6 5 $!( M-, 5Q7- )* $)'66 Q)7- )))4 N'#50(D )66) !(Q0%6 '0( )! )),! 5 7 7 M' M-,56!!(!)!7- M#7- #M'%7-,5 !)&7-& '#!4) 6!$ !(!# M' %60( N '# 5 '&6!!(M-,5 . &"!" "%!(!(!)!) 7), '5 , D '0( %, 5C&)$!" . (" !""" 6!& !"4$ !( 6!( 7-))757-!(,5 7$) ! ,$ 7-Q'' R. )4 6 , %6D &,M, 5 (..&—*) '$ 7- ,'B)))$) 0( !" 0( $) 5 )))0, R‘‘ 6&*!"%4) ,5 7 -, 5 % ' 0( 65 , $ 4 0( !6(!(!.Q))!( )))!()&7- )6!$ &œ,6 " 8( )))$!" )4 7-% $% ! 6 !( Œ 6!U'& !$&))) " ,5Q! !( . R‘‘ 6&!"%$ '%0( 7- !(-*D %!( # Q)))$6!$ 6&6&'7& 6 '.7. LSRL ( (7$ $4 Q$.4 œ,6& , LŒS‘: R) $! %))) !( 6!" R‘‘ #& 8( 6!( 0( œ,& - 4 )5 $!( M-, 5 6 '.7. LSR’ $" N6& '%0( 4 /6C * # M'% (#, LŒR’: ŒL’) " !"

 !"39215$.z3F'  ;1z1./%;H ./>9- 9393;z155$.29"93392 2 1 W~ .&. *,~V. (./ ;z11";9$". ./>9 , *+,: ~) 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

*6 !( Œ ,$5 7- M-)" ! $! ) 7& - 'M - & % "'5$A ,%N6& ( N-& !()7-$ %‚ '.7. LSSP *% 6, LŒR’) ‚ '.7. LS–‘ ,5x '5 Q 7-% 66 8( 0 U) ) $(!%)&7- $!(7%6%" %*7-" 'M-&,!(&œ,6 $7-5))5% (&N6, LŒS‘: LL) '- 7 -) $0 6 $ ! 6&! (..&—*) “ ~0" 7 - $& 6 % N6& )"'0(0),#6!( Œ 8(.% ! 7 5 #& A! 6$6!($7-) ('6&! ( #— —*), LŒSL: L-R) Z$!*&7-0('0 "6!( Œ 7-$$!(*!( 7-)Z"% ))%Z 7 75 - 66!(!Z7-Z ! * ))'5%Q%*! 6$6%6)” ('6&! (..&—*), $ ...: S‘-SP) '6&! (..&—*) $0(!" '6&! (..&—*) $ U' ‚ “')0( '4 & 4 '.7. LŒP“ “7-%" % '.7. LSŒR " & 6 !( Œ % Z 6$ 6$ ’ " 6!( 7- 6 4Q$' %/7$ %6)6$ !!(4!" 6, “’-”‘ & Z 7- ) Z Z ) 7-&'0(!(!*0 7-. )-A 5 70 -6 $ )! ” ('6&! (..*),& LŒL–: 7-)"$.x! R–) Z)7-)&7- 7- 6 % . )'M - ,& 8$( 4$(%6) '6&! (..&—*) ( 7-( 4 & & $” $%5 “&œ- ('6&! (..&—*), LŒL–: R’) 0 Z% ,6 '.7. LŒPP-LŒP’ ' ! ./% 70( - 5 $!. 66), –– ) '&#7%Q7-6 '6&! –P %,!(%Z (..&—*) #)% ‚ '.7. LŒL– “%* 7-%/6'%0% Q7-6&U))&Q " '.7. !66)$'! ’ 0 LSŒ’ $!. ' 5 # $ ”” ('6&! (..&*), '0 #& ”! ('6&! (..&—*), LŒL–: LŒL–: SS) R’) ( ‚ '.7. LS”– ,5x#& - . / Martin Seeger

*666)$ 7 - #)),5 “), )&7-!(.*Z) ''! $7 ‚ ’‘,‘‘‘ ) )0 (..&—*) “66$!M $'%6 )!(&N 7- 66!(%($ .D $ $!. $ ))7- Z 4 7 6 $ )! $ $ )! ” (. 5 Z, LŒRL: 0” ('' ! (..&—*), ...: PS) " R-R–) “%6 ‰ %! ! 7 -% )&!( )6 '#A‰ 0 $ ! (.4 )$0 $ ! ' (..&—*) '( “$%6!( 0)$!5 !*&!!$! '5!(6 % 7 - $ !( $~~”• (. 5 Z, LŒRL: LP) /C Z)” $ 4 ,54$7-% ),)%& . 66!( )67 M' # M' 7& - ,5Q6/ & %$! )$! )7 - 0(! 0 !6(!(7-Z'B"$ Z '#A‰ (..&—*) ' ( “ $ %. / 7 -, 5 6'!( $ $%6 $ Q 4 !( 4 4.$$)7- 6)!(,56$ 4%6$)7-! 5 7-M-)!"!()$!A 4 $ 'x Z $4 $ ) )7-'M - ,& 4'! ! ' ! Q'$ 0( 7 .0 .'M- ,%&  $5 )) ”" ('#A‰ (..&—*), ...: ." )%, ! )), $ SR-SS) '%6 'Z) )%  .5 7-) 0(!))Z '' ,5"$ $ %Q 7 - Z '$! &,M, 5 (..&—*) %!( $ ))&7. M!" “% ‚ '.7. LŒP’ " !( #7 5 $' '%! 7 - . 5 Z !7- ”,Œ‘‘ $)),Q ,& 5 %( ! “0( ! 5 ),%) 7- '% $ '$5 $  &';&4 #9' 9;F, ;5 .&. *,V, ;6%. V , ". %;; !%% 0( !"!' ),! 5 .% &4? ./1 ; 2/F;. , ;#9#5/9 7 - $! $ ) 0(” ' ./ ./ >9 .&. *,V|, (. 5 Z, LŒRL: P“) $ ) ! #9&" ., & „ Q .&. *+**-*+*~. &%) .5 Z$ .0./ ./ >9 ! 9" *+,-*+++, 1 4%? ./ ./ >9 - , = & ' #= $, .#=. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

SL,””R,R‘‘.‘‘ ) %6U!( (..&—*) $%!(%!()&B7- Œ,‘SŒ.‘‘ ) % ‚ LŒP’ 6" !(œ,6-& '5 “'5)!/ – 0) 8(!',!" –“Œ ! 5!(Z$)4$%7 )," " ’‘‘,‘‘‘ ) (),Q ”! ('6&! (..&—*), LŒL–: ’”) S.J. % & & PŒ‘,‘‘‘ )) " $)& M 5 Tambiah $! !( ) )7 -) ! 7)#8! )) 'M- ,8& ( Q ! ,0( R’ ‚!( ($ %6 U!( ’PŒ )” ('' “'M- & ,0 )!( /#! R * &,M, 5 (..&—*), LŒŒL: R”-R–) (Chatsumarn !%#75$ Kabilsingh, 1986: 62-80) " '6&! *" !( L $ ) /#! (..&—*) & 0( $!" “7-M - & ’ *7-% ,%/ $ )66)& .& *!" #7$5 $0( 7!" -) $! * '%0% 7),Z $$4 7 -$ ” (Tambiah S.J., 1976: !(&))7-Z !(Z 294) ,J5M-!!(.” 5"!'!( ('6&! (..*),& LŒL–: P‘–) )0 0( %Z)) //M' !(Z)$)&B7-%  5 ," 5Q%/,Q )  5 " %& 'M - ,& !( )! $ $0('6) //  5 0( '.7. LŒ‘‘ 7-% ) //*%7$$ '6&! %‚ ! $!" N Z " $4 !!( 0 ) &  Gosling 2 { *+*~ “There is a certain irony !(!. 0!($!M' &C in the fact that the secular universities in Thailand do not !" .%& 6 $ recognize degrees from the Buddhist Universities. Graduates 0.%'6)// from both Mahamakut and Mahachulalongkorn have no $$ )', ," 54' difficulty in finding places in post-graduate courses at Indian Universities and to a lesser extent at universities $%( ‚ '.7. LŒL“ Z)7 ) in Europe and the U.S.A. One Mahachulalongkorn undergraduate who had passed prayog nine was fairly recently allowed to transfer directly to an undergraduate course at Cambridge. But even on completing his  '. ' 9/ ' ( 04 %..) ; Mahachulalongkorn B.A. he would not have been eligible 2{ *+*V “The central problem regarding these to start an undergraduate course at any secular Thai Buddhist universities (which the monks themselves university.” (Gosling, David, (1980), “New Directions in emphasize as the most urgent) is the need to be academically Thai Buddhism”, Modern Asian Studies, Vol. 14. No. 3, /" recognized by the government.” (Chatsumarn Kabilsingh, ,WQ). Chatsumarn Kabilsingh, “Buddhism and National “Buddhism and National Development: A Case Study of Development: A Case Study of Buddhist Universities”, /" q+. Buddhist Universities”, /" |Q. - . / Martin Seeger

'6)// .ZQ . 4 6 N%!( PR “&&($!( ''&#7%'6)//U))")U' Z)%‚” &B7-Q!()//!)!" " L ‚% '.7. LŒSL ( œ,6& , LŒS‘: ’L) $5 ‰ )@ 58(4 " 6!%. " %'6)//!!" “%Q.46 Q& $!( )$ %'6) // ''#7& ' # Q# “*")7-" Q)! /#! * !Z '.0( 7 - %) 6"// ! ! “/#! *” %6- 6''&#7'M-&, “.#. –” ('6)// .ZQ . 4 @ 5” 0(  5" '6)! // 6''#7,& LŒL“) 0 . 4 ),! 6 'M- & ",5 ($%6•!( ,!( ) ! ! % ,5 ')"!"Z))'! 6!) ! 'M - ,& .)@ 5 //) " $ $ ) Z. 6/4 %,57-%!()0//! $4  $5 )$ " $ 7 - ) //*$ M7- !( " .% !), % ‚ '.7. LŒL“-LŒR– '5!()! $' '$! Œ‘ ‚ !( 5$!7-) !$$ 0($) '&#7%7$%'7!('M-&5$ 668( $ $ " '6&! (..&—*) $6!"% $4 M !! ( !(./%)) !" 40$$ !$ 7-!(Z.7-,5'! M7- 0( M'7-Z " //! “,58()!( !$M7-!(0( ''&#7%7$,!" ('.7. LŒL–) ! '7M 40, '.7. LS“‘ 0( 7- & // ! Q .74 - & Q/$$$!*!(!%$ (6 ,57-%"$ "xQ/!&M#O&4 6 $ ! L 0 P) $7 $! 6 /6 !( $! ( , LŒS“: !(7 ! L) $ $ ! $ L”) (Terwiel, Barend Jan, 2012: 102-104) @ ”5 ," 5$ '6) // % ‚ '.7. LŒR“ !(& Z) ) % ‚ '.7. LŒS‘ 0(  5" '6! - )// $ ) & & Z) $  66 ./ . W . *+,.  66 ./ . W . *+,. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

. > 6 0 D >?? 0 $!( )$4 %),!" 7-M'7 - $).'4/%*65Q0(% ) 7& -) !7-' M" #7 - !" $!. 6!'%0( M'4 !(6 *7-7 - 7 % ' 6! 6!5"!'6)// " N0 )# .)0 /*6& ). & ''#7& )'5 ”" * 5 %75)0(6!$ 6,5 ...: ŒS) " $ ! !( )7 - 0 !%75$)6% 6!%75 ,!( & )6 0( & !( 8 5 !(!Z 7.5 ) )5 $!)&!() 7- 6!$N" % 6 !( – 6!% #%& '.7. LLRL %& “! 07-'M # “ ‚ ’ 0 !" 6)60( & 6 $ N – 6" $ ‰ ! %" '.7. LS–S !( !6D! $$ !&” (8! ) ,5 LŒS”: * #)&! '& (M#*6 Œ‘“) &U))*5 655 8( , LŒŒS: “Œ) 7 -, 5 6x(7!(%0$&# $ x.*'' # ( M) 6! “6! M'! $ !( *‰ ) 6! ! )' 5 " )%.06! !(! %‚ '.7. LŒ‘– ! 6!.4 . L 6!M%!("& $).'4/'! 6!!(!.4M#"! M40(!()0(%*! C &) (LŒŒS) . PŒL U!( 6!!(! " !( .. " ..4 !(&% ‚ '.7. LŒR” . P‘ (*!(')'55 $ !.A,J5 /%& )6! 6 $! 0( & Œ‘ ‚ " '0( • **"0'M-& & ! !"0 !!(&M' .)66%6 % *$& 5 !'#!!(./D '$ %. !( ) R-S %%!( D $ N /, .A0  %9N'./%9@4OP, 9N. M - & " '@N )5 99' (. . 9N ' .&. *+,Q), 0./ ./ >9 * . /9 & " 5& /M D .&. *,VW-*+, 5 .&. *+*~-*+~* .& P" 1 %*) 5 %/ 0 )' 5 ! .;I'. - . / Martin Seeger

",‚ “-– ‚ ‚ '.7. LŒPP ' 5 ! )' $5 &N- ,5#&&6@-A O ' 5 '-& 6'!!())Q x $'M! # 7-) ! 6! " $$ % .) 6!7 - )' 5 .6!!(.74 - )!07-,5 M#" '.7. LŒPP-LŒŒS !. LŒ‘ " 6!$$ ) )' 5 (Gosling David % ‚ '.7. LŒŒP ! 6!.74 -M #. L., 1988: 126) 6!!()! !&.! PL !(& P– " ‚ P‘ 0 PS ( % PL "$!6!!(!.4)! ))! 7 -M #, ...) '.7. LŒLS 7- 6" !( – '! ! 6!!()Q) !6" !( ’ " %‚ M#$(&œ,6-- '.7. LŒL– ! 6!.)4 !6" !( – '! P " !"%&' ) LR ‚! 6!.74 - " Œ“ (M#*6 , LŒŒS: “Œ-“’) !6!.)4 !7- – * !(& ‚ L %‚ '.7. LŒ‘’ &N6- " " '.7. LŒ‘’ LŒŒS S– ‚ ,5x#&$7- !6!.)4 !7- – *%7$ " M-)!6!!" – 6" %6!) L‘ &N6)7-)! 6!7!)'!7%  .&. *+V 5.;0 %.#; ./I # * , .&. *+W #;#I ~ , .&. *+W, #;I ~ , $)), 5 .7 .&. *+W+ #;I * , .&. *+Wq #;I , , .&. *+W| N6& “%%6 ,J 5 Q #;I V , .&. *+WQ #;I V , .&. *+WV #;I q , .&. *+* #;I W , .&. *+*W #;I ~ , .&. *+** #;I W , .&. *+*~ #;I , , .&. *+*, ..5.#;,I  5. 6 , %$5. .&. *+++. .&. *+*+ #;I W , .&. *+*q #;I * , .&. *+*| ;5, //"5.$5. 9/ #;I , , .&. *+*Q #;I + , .&. *+*V #;I W , . 1 *+ @40. *+++, .04 '. .&. *+~ #;I W , .&. *+~W ..5.#;,I .&. *+~*  5..& ; 9,I #;I &?4 V 59 #;I , , .&. *+~~ ..5.#;,I .&. *+~, #;I + ;&, 9., 1 W| %. *+++, .04 '. , .&. *+~+ #;I + , .&. *+~q #;I q , .&.  .&. *+*V .5. #;I V ;9 W , { .&. *+~| #;I + , .&. *+~Q #;I W , .&. *+~V *+~+ 5.#;I W , { .&. *+~Q 5.#;I W , { .&. #;I | , .&. *+, #;I V , .&. *+,W #;I ~ , *+~V 5.#;I * , { .&. *+, 5.#;I * , { .&. .&. *+,* #;I + , .&. *+,~ #;I , , .&. *+,, *+,W .5. #;I * , { .&. *+,* 5.#;I W , { #;I W , .&. *+,+ #;I , , .&. *+,q #;I + , .&. *+,~ ..5.#;,I { .&. *+,, .5. #;I W , { .&. *+,| #;I , , .&. *+,Q #;I ~ , .&. *+,V .&. *+,+ .5. #;I W , { .&. *+,q .5. #;I * , #;I | , .&. *++ ..!"#;,I .&. *++W ..!"#;,I { .&. *+,| .5. #;I W , { .&. *+,Q ..5.#;,I &. *++* #;I * , .&. *++~ #;I W , .&. *++, { .&. *+,V .5. #;I W , { .&. *++ .5. #;I #;I W , .5.1;#; I 953 .&. *+V-*++, # W , { .&. *++W .5. #;I W , { .&. *++*-*++~ W+* , 9; , N 9N ., 9;./, ..5.#;I { .&. *++, .5. #;I * , 9;, *++,. ./ ./. X , ;#;. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

'#Q)! 68(%'M-&,7- ,J5 Q) !7-**”& ( '#Q#Q)! N6& , LŒSR) %)70( )! ” ('6)//.ZQ.4 ' ! 7 6!! ! ! 6''#7,& LŒL“) %6 !(!'6)// !" )!7- R )!7- ’ )!7- – $) )7-,5" 6!$" '! 7' 7 )! % R M!"! #) 6!$ 6!$$ )) & 0 )!7- R ’ " )7 )! %!5 ' ! 7 '4 6 .)) !7- %#758( – $)'!7'75#'5 !(""0( !( L“ & '.7. *!'6& '54 LS““ (http://th.wikipedia.org/wiki/. %6 0( !( P“ '! 7 6!!(.)4 !7- – *" '@-M LŒŒŒ.) 7 5 .6 / %75 7 -M-) ! 6!$% $!(6!$$7-% '.7. LŒL– !(M7-&N6 #7 5 “$!))! A0 6! %! %)!7- P-L, S, Œ, ’, “, ” )U' #75 $!6!! 7!)4'60Q4 0( ',! $! !()6$ & !( '6 )!*0$6!$))".( 6!$)7-) ! 'M0 - & @5)6$!6!! % , 4!! ( $!( 0 0 M- ,& '.7. LŒL” '! 5 %! ) //* !(!)* – " $)M (0) !(&œ,5$ % Z)*Q7 C&)!"Q. #7 $5 N ! 6!! ''&#76 .)6!!())!7- – % '.7. LŒS‘ #7 5 %‰ * $$ )M 6 " !( 6 '!" 6'#77& - ! 6! ! P " ‚ 7-) !7-6!$$6 '.7. LŒS‘ ‚ '.7. LŒŒS ! 6!! PP "$$)*)%)! . ! 6!.! 4 ” ! ( . 7 -M-) %! 6! #7 5 ‰ 0 )! 7- N6& 7-

M-),! $5 ))* '6)! //  $5. 9;.3 z1 1 *Q 9/. .&. *+W*. '.7. LŒL“ % R “6'' #7&  & ' . 9.; 6, #0' 6 &&' ./%.&', &?4 ;6%. V , %& = , 6./ =  .5. 9 #/., V 1 * 9 ./ ; ; , 6 4O = >9 ./' . ;&, #' ;$ ( 5. ) 1 ** @40. *+++, $./1 >9 , #;0%9 9/ .. .04'. - . / Martin Seeger

7 - " ) & 7 - $'6!"%6..60() ,J 5 8( ‰ !( .66%7- $!)$!$ 6! )6 & #! ! C . " $ 4 ! 6!)& " !(&$! !(‰ 0. (http:// !(&œ,6 th.wikipedia.org/wiki/.. %6 &N6!'6)//% 0( !( P“ '@-M LŒŒŒ.) % ‚ '.7. LŒL‘ ! 6! '.7. LŒS‘ 7- 6!%6 P‘ ‚!(Q 7-%.& 06!&7! !"!")&0// !(6!" 6& " Œ ‚ 0 '.7. LŒLŒ 6!!) 0(7-,5!(( (0! & 6!&' 5 $ 7 -% '6)// $ $ & !" 6!!) & % “%" $!( !A) 8%6( " ) ! !( . " $ /& ' ! “0(” %'6)// )6 $ %! * 0(  5 '.7. LŒS‘ !& 5 % $!4$ (!) 6! 7 - !& %5 7 - ".6!&!($! %) 6'' #7& 'M - & .” *& ## 6 %" ,@ 5 " '.7. LŒSL ‚ '.7. LŒLP ‰ (Wikipedia.org/wiki/ œ,6& $ ‰ ) 6!@ 5 *& ## 6. %6 !( P“ '@-M ! ) //* 6!&!( ! LŒŒŒ.) !(!(6!07- &œ,6" S !.4 &!(6!07-!(‰"!" R %6! R " .74 - // !( '!$ )67-$ œ,6& P .4 ‰)7-$.. 7-$ % // !( 7! ! P " 6"$!.)6! 5 !( œ,6& ,$).6!!()! 6)! ! ‚ '.7. LŒSR ! " 6  66./ ./>9 566./.X.  ;#;, = ././>-  5. . , 3#04; 6, &?4 ,, ' 9 . .&. *+,*. ;&4./1 ;$ .$ 5. , 1 4?  &.06, 9&', ., 9% 9!"#‘’/./;$, 1 W, ‘’ ././>9, 1 , .$ *+++, .04 '. 9/. *++~, .04 '. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

&œ,6$‰%)// !6!.47-)//! . SR %//!"‰)@56! %‚ '.7. ) //* . L– // . LŒS” &!(‰ // !6,0( P .6!!(.74 -  5 ) $ $ ) ) $ .%!( " -Z$ #) ‰)@56!!$%)//* 6!$!.!( N6& 4//! )"&œ,- 6!!&)!"(" 6 $ ‰ ) 6! %! ) 7& - ( '.7. LŒPL .)7 -M-) !") " '.7. % '.7. LŒSL LŒŒS $!6!.74 - LŒ‘’ $ $ !)7 - " % '.7. LŒSR ) //. P ) //*. &N6 7) PR ) // .! ” )!7-6!*)7 -M-) ! " œ,6-& 6! 7 )! % $ )7-'M # !(!! Q! !&B )7 -M-) ,! 5 $$ !)7 - Q.47-)! Œ *!%) M&œ,6* // ! Q. 74 -) ! – * ! ,M $7!) %) //*  5" 7-M #% ‚ '.7. LŒS’ %7 .7)! %! ) //* “7!)6M#!) % Z)$ !%7 #7- 7!)M#),J $!" “M!&%!! )! // ”! ( œ,6-& M-)!") *! P-L ) ! – *% , LŒS’) N6& * % A6& $ %6- “).7.” %%6 ,J 5 Q ‰)6!7-)//!"%‚ '.7. '#Q)! LŒSL //* '.7. LŒSŒ // '.7. LŒS– ,J5Q)!7-*&* %!)6") *)*!/#  &.06, 9&', ., 9% ‘’ ././>9, 1 , 9/. *++~, .04 '.  ; = , ./ ./. X ,  ;=, ././>9- *++,. .  $5. 93 ./1 ./.X ,  ; %& ,' ./ ./ >9- ;& /, 9;./, .&. *+,Q ." 93 9" . ./ ./. X #& #;0%.=  .', = 9/F.. ././.X, 1 W* 9/. *++,,  %., // 9" & 4,? ./ .04'. ./.X , .04 '. - . / Martin Seeger

'#Q)!” ( ),% ! $$ &N6, LŒSR) 7 !(%. ) Z) '! ! 7& !(! )&!M-)!%6!*%6 .. ))66 0$ Z0'5& %%6 ))!( 8()7-$ - ).7. 8( .4 “)!7-” 6 “)! $! ' '! #) ! 7- R” œ,6& '#*7 5 ( 4$5" #— *) $% Q& 6 ) “  5 &06%7-)&7-%6! $!'6)// $!),” œ,6& $" )Q!( '" &#!#& ()! /*,) % Q& .4M#*7-)//*$ '( “  5 ))! -,66 &A6)&B7-M-)! ) '5!) $ $ ' ” 6!*))! – *%//! ! ) //* " . >? ,!( M-, 5Q) ) œ-& ,6&N6 '.7. LŒPL ,5!(7- !( ) 5"&!(7-" &7-$'6 )//5 6!!@5 '0(%!$! !,5!('Q %/ "#& # %& . $ %( $) )&$46)%7-)&7- *65"*# ., "$)&'6)//5 * !(  $5 ! 7 -) !!(7 - " , 5 Œ‘ ‚ 0 0( $!Q!M-)! '5!- 5" ) 6! ! M-, ,5 58("*# 0(! Q)  5" ! 4 .4 @ 5 0 ( !())6!!&Q D 0$!'6)// $!  %.&,' &,' ., % ./ - ./>9, =, ;"  91!"/ 99./ ./ >9 9& 9;./, ~ 9/. *++~, .04', /?19 “;I.9;9;.2/"5..$2 &.06, 9&,' . 9%‘ ’ &4? ./.O & 4? 2/ 5." 29 ././>9, !";" ./>9&?40%.2/"5. “?19 3#04; 6 9;./, 1 , 9/. *++~, .04 '. O/.;} 92/ ;22/" 5." ;.&" 4”? (&.06,  %%., !"&'. , 9&',. ., 9%‘’./ %&', !";" ;..9. ./>9 , 1 , 9/. *++,, .04 .)' 9;./, 1 ~ 9/. *++~, .04 '. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

0(%00()&#O'5!(7-% C&) !" %))!( 5 ""'Q%/& 7- 7-% ) // ! //* " 0)%&Q00'5 '@5 5 ! % // U'M-)! '#! " $ !!"'5@5 !(% '6)// 0( 70 - //!"0(!&B $)&@5 '#*75 ( " Q)  5 0( ! #— —*) $6!"Q%& ‰ ) !( @ 5 !50( '&% ,#% ZM “% ' ! ! 7$!4.)&/)'#! '..$ " ‰) 7 % 5!(" !" @5” '&B6&, ($ *6*) '5 @5)&&-! !%&Q !( ! “,# 6)4 %!".%'5"%!. % %N )"%! "0 '7x x™ /C #'7 !( ) % N6& " '5” (Chatsumarn Kabilsingh, n.d.: 70) )6!!%5 $ “,'7'M - & 5 0( !( .)6!*%60(6)!! $ Q)5" )!!()# ’ 7-%)//! % 0( !"7*) ”! ,76/ ,7-75 '7!M/,! ( 5 — */)— #) “ 6''#7& 6M- "$%!!%!(!) @- % &œ,6- ' 0 ! 4 ! 4! ! Q! !( 6! M%, Q%/4%0(!($' (!4($ œ,6& .M!( ''(! )54 4 '7! #& %,! $4 ) %& ! C/ ” #8( . 6!%'& ‰ ! ) //**% 60( ! " 6!@ 5 !)&&- 66% ) &  %6 (9 ' 70), 9% ; &%! ., 1 *Q *++,, .04 '.  %.&,' &.., % ./ >9- , 1 ~ 9/. *++~, .04 '.  ( ), 9% ‘’ 9;&, WQ 9/. *++,, .04 '.  %%., =, ./  &.06, &, . 9%‘ ’ ./ ./>9 , , 9/. *++~, .04 '. ./>9 , !";" 3#04; 6  %.&,' % ./ ./ >9- 9;./, , 9/. *++~, .04 '. , 1 ~ 9/. *++~, .04 '. - . / Martin Seeger

. !" 4 6!! 7! - %4 !*$ % P‘ ‚!(QM'-, 5 % ) ',”"  6!!".) &./(406!! ) ,' 54)%7 M' ) 7- " . %QQ '7 " ‰*%6!5)!..! %N)" 0(!))!!( *Q !0M-&, 6 .!#& 6!!*$!0 &6@-AO &' .) 6!0N)#.%" %!$! 6!!().! ! # &&6@-A O *$)6/$)7!#!(D 0 “)!!(.! !"" '.7. LŒR’-LŒŒS M- & U')! 6 . 6!7 & .M ,% ) 0 ”" %M#*6 67 ! Z8 $( " '.7. LŒSL !6! M5 #. ” . C &) 6!!7-% ) 5"'@5 5" RP / 7 - !(6!( “%!"6! M#!")6@5 Q !%)0 $%$! %%%N)# 6!(%M-,5 “%%0( !"!‰%6!!"!($$ '7Q” 6!!(% $! $4 ! 4 !( 6!'B70( - œ,6& ! P " ‚ '.7. ”" 0( 6!!7-'@ N ) LŒŒP C &) (LŒŒŒ) %M-,5 “!( ! %).''#& ))6! )) ,J 7 - ) //* // !( $))%Z Q # ))%! 'M- & %5 ) & !( Q " #6 " $0( )7- $ ') ”& 6!!(6)!( ! ! !(" 6!( “6!!(# ( 6!) 8( %. ) 7!#*!%6&606&66) N6& . L 6!( !( 66 0 M - ,”& 8( !(6)! ! R ‚ $ ), 5 ).% M-,5 6!! ( “6 “ !" 4 6!! 7! -$ !(!)M@)70 #! %4 ! !*$%)7-)&7- 6/ 6!$6 ) ” 6!( ,5'M-&,%)% “0( $ !*$)7#! ! !"!* 7M' ))'M - ,& %& % "',4%))!4‰* %%&B7-Q %  5 %$6)!%',8(%!"$!

 5. 1 , 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 W 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 + 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 * 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 q 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 ~ 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 | 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

4!5 . " !( ! M 6! )7 6!%5$%60(!( ' ! )$ )& M 5 0( ! %” @ 5.%M-,5 6!( “//* % M-)! ! 6!!(! ) //$)&M5@5” 'M- ,& )7! !( !( ! ).0%$)0 )! '%!( M-, 5 6!( # ."%6%! !( “ ‰ )! ! $ 7- !.%'/ '!(6! 6)&!4 ',4%)&! 5 !M%$!%%)6 !(4! ',!(!4% *& !($)6 ! ! "* )70'0(%&%!! # 0 “6Q” 8( . )&6"” %&'.!)!!(6! $!(!)68(. “6 ! 0.!#&&6@-AO Q0'M-&” 6!$'@N))) .! ' . ! 6 . 'M- %& ) ( “0( !* ),56! ' .%) 6!40(0 ) 0 ( “)! *! ” – .!( ! 'M- &) %' 0( ) 4 ' $ ! ! & 'M- & ” , )7 - 'M- &!( /%& 6!M-)! ! ) !&%!(! '0( 6 '5 (!(&!(6! 0 08(” .!)!,5!( !('7 ) ! %!( % 6!'7 /%& 6!M-)! %! '.7. LŒ‘’-LŒL” )$!!('7!!(! %&' !U'%'& !( 6!7 ! '& 4 !(!".!!('76! $ .4)! – *6!7$ #&&6@-A 6O 6 .% 6!%7$( 0( % M-)! ! 6 ".M-! /  * ".!,5%!(‰ 'C % .!)!&$&/%6!!)! 0( '#7 , ' 6!%%%!" !%6% )6 * 6 MM 6 #6 #& ! !('7 $ !!(!  5. 1 Q 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '. %&'$$)6!%7& "  5. 1 V 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 W 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 WW 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 W~ 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 W* 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 W, 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '. - . / Martin Seeger

!(76!.) &N0!('7" . % $!( . ) ! 6 %". %,!(!%!( !" N#$ %0 Q7'& $0 4 !(Q''& % $ 6!Q6 / $& %6 % ! ) !!(7 . ) 6!) !($M-,5 &!(4D 0 *! ! % ) ! !( 7 ! 0(&7-!()! 6!$!M' $!! ) *! ! M-)! ! )6!(!()( 6!""% $!!('7 .M-, 5 6!( “" 7$7 " %$4! (!.) )"!!( $!!(!$ "6!%$!% %! ‚ LŒR’ .% 6! $ &4'( ”" $ N #$ $ !%/ !( )!!('7%6!)$! 6!)'.!" 6!)!($)&M5% . M-, 5 6!( “ 0( !('7 ' 0 ! 6!) !( % $! %6 4 '( 0( 6& ! !(!) $& $ ! )%! 0( ( 0 !()Q 6)” ) ) 6!$ 7- !(‰M#%%# 'M!" - ,& 6!)! ! 6!!(M! #% )$#%.) /7'& 0)&7-N# 0)7 0 7& M%0( " ) 6! " .)! 0( .M-, 5 $%6!!.4M#),J& 6!!(!)&7-( “$ %!)"$ 6!)$) 6. $4 $ ! '.%6 ‘Œ.‘‘ )%0( ! " 0( *M& œ 6 )M64 %4 PR.‘‘ )*M $')&C/%0(!(7*!( œ %! ) 7& - %6! 6 0( )$'76'7/ $$$.%*80") “%) " 6! $)%$” % 6!!( 'M - ,& !" )!( ! 6!%$ !& 6!!(!)M#),J6!!(!))! 4!&)&7- 7-” 7 -M # M-! 8( .& 6!660 0 !( 6! ).! ) 6!$%6 !& " )*) 07-"D )%8(")7-Z " /%& 6!$ 7 % 4 0 !("!( 6!( “7-* !"6!4!)& *%D”

 5. 1 W+ 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 Wq 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 WV 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 W| 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 * 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 WQ 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 *W 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

)!*))&7-6! 0( 7-% Œ‘,‘‘‘ ) 7- '5 ". 6!)60( M-)" ! 6 Q" $ )& % 7& - Œ,‘‘‘ )” “ % 6!!()Q* P,‘‘‘ ) . ) 7& - 6! )& % 6!!() ' ,5 .)*) !7- 0(6")!7-#7-&‚ *%& – *" !( ) P‘,‘‘‘ ) 0 )M - ,”& 4!) !($' % 0( ) !(!7-Z $! )% R‘,‘‘‘ ) " “$ $ *)$ % %0( & !/#7$'$ 6!” )& R,‘‘‘ ) '#) & %M #*6 $ ) & 6!!( “,‘‘‘ ) !(" L !" !Q! ! *) .0 ) %6! " ! U!%"'5, 6! $$)& .)"!& .) & /#! 7$ ' ) 7& - ) //* 6! L & & & '# ',5 6!$)& L“,Œ‘‘ ) ) & .( 74 - . )" !( 6! 7 //!!.& L & PL,R‘‘ ) U% ! ' 5!('Q %/ % ) .& 74 - " ).!( & $4 ) & ) & % !, ##'! ,% & 6!)%)4$$&!()0(6"Q 6!!(!!#//* 0!)!.47- .6! ‚ LŒŒP " " R $& #-! ( “$ ) & 7& - %0 & # P %& " ” M-,5Q)!(!6! ',%D $%6%" % “7- 6!" !" &N6 &%'M-& ( $7 - 6!M0 - ,& ,6!!(! N6& // ! "'" 6!)6 7 - ! %7 - " # #7- )!7-  .5.9 #/., '#./;$ ) %& 6!! ” ).% , &?4 V 1 * 9;&, 1 M-,5 6!!(.74 -) ! – * WQ %., .04 '. ". “0( .! )4 !7- – *  %.% (' ), % 9N './%9@4O P .// 9;./, 1 W| %. *+++, '4 6 5 (6 */)— )& .04'.  &. ( F;.%), !";" 9. .//, '!"5&?404, 1 WQ  5. 1 ** 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '. %. *+++, .04 '.  5. 1 *~ 1 W, @& *+++, .04 '.  5.6 ;.%, ;$%.$, 66  .;./I . 9 ' (9 86),7 ;" ; ./ ./ >9 , 1 W 9/. 3#04; 6, 1 *q *++~, .04 '. *++,, .04 '. - . / Martin Seeger

//* .) // !& P,‘‘‘ ) // ),!(5.6" %‚ LŒŒS ! *. R,‘‘‘ ) % 6)! ! . P & . P‘,‘‘‘ ) )% 6! L !(7-) // ! 6! 8( % Œ,‘‘‘ ) " 6!!&D 6 6M5 !&#6)!! 8(&'!(%& .) &4''6&)6&! & #75"'"6!!%64 $! 66!()Q# *&#$" " 667! # 6!$) & ! $0 $%0( ) & 0 6!@0 5 !!(.A0 &'Q%/ 6 6!,Z U B 5 8( 5$ !//* 6!7- $)&4 7-)!7- '6 5 (6 */)— ". N6& “% ‚ LŒŒP-LŒŒR $), M-!/ &' %#& Q . L‘‘,‘‘‘ ) % ‚ LŒŒS $), &6@-A O ##& #7'6/! 5 . P‘‘,‘‘‘ ), $!" %* $)&6!!())!7-$ ("‚ ).7& B# ()!7-) %Q), LŒRL 0((‚C&) "$ &N6 )!")7- )&6!!()#7-Q&6"‚ ,6!” #75!(! %/6 .'7!&# $)&& '&#7)//*60(D 8(! 7-% 6!)! ! )70( -) !6" !( – 'M- & 6!7 - ! %& ' ! //* $ ) %& ! //* // ! & ' ’‘ #7‚ 5 !" " 6!!(.! 7 & 8( . !( 0 '' #& U ’‘ #7‚ 5 6!!(‰ M-)! %! 6! ! )!"%U''M-&,!(! M-)$! ) & & & !(!( #7 5 % 6! $% & !(.6!&!"%# M- &,! ) 5 6& ) " &N6%&M50(6! 6 6@,& * Q!#O)& 0 ' .!"$)&M5C 6! @5 %)!(%6!$!% 66),)D . Q !&.) ! '# 5 .) 7- & )Q!( * '# 5& ”,‘‘‘  !&... z 9" %966 %&&4? 0 6 ./ %.& .' 1 ) ), %!( $* D W~ 9/. *++~, .04 '. 6 ) P‘‘,‘‘‘ ) %‚ LŒŒR !" .$ 7 -  ; ? .," % ., .! ";" 6 5 % D 6 #& 5 ./%9@4OP.// 1 | 9/. %*656'#5* *++,, .04 '. 5.. 9, 2/6 .9, &?4 V. 1 Q ;.4 *+++, .04 '.  %.. 1 W, .$ *++,, .04 '.  5. 1 *, 1 + 9/. *++~, .04 '. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

. )'60'M-&, ! 6!!*$)) %& 40)6” !" 7-.% &7- !(*,5 %" P‘ ‚!( ))6!%6) 0'" Q%)!( !" 6!!(M-,5%/ "!" "" %!"4 4! !),5!(!%$)7- ) 7& - !( ',!(!( !( *,*5 * )) & 'B** !4 ( .%!( 6! 7-!" “% !".) 6!*‰ " !*7 - " %60( &,5 *%‰ 6!&D $ ! ”" ! 6! 7-$ " " % P‘ (),5 “4 ‚!(Q!" 6!4$))&%))& 6!! /*4% 7-"!(%)!" 4 0 )6' #6& ! )' N#$ $ $ !M )6 , ',%4 )” 6!! ( '7 4 !( '0( $ )) & “7- 4!.%Q / $!( C D0( $ !('7 & $)/ '!(4 ) ! .) 7- ).47-)! !0' 4. U" 4! “%/ 6! ! )) 4%' 4!0' ! ".$~ 6!4 )6% ' 0 )! 0 )6 ( $) )$ $%6 )6% ” 4) % ) )$ .” “%66& - *')!( * (8( 4! ())!( M'-, 5 6!!"” ) ' )" )4 6! )" $4 ))4 .'7 !M/,! !( ) 6! “6!40 %,!" 5!" !)'6 '. 7M''%% ) & 0( ) !( ! ) & 0( %7& - !C/ ( .6!!( ! !8( &  191.2993 9 !9 9 ' Steve Collins 5 Justin McDaniel 993 ; ./ !( ) & 6!!(7 - 92;15.042;& ',!$Q6)6"&0)6 . Collins, Steven and Justin McDaniel (2010), , 0( )& L‘ )6‚ 'M - & 8( 0( “Buddhist ‘’ (mae chi) and the teaching of Pali in contemporary Thailand” Modern Asian Studies 44, 6, /" B#', M'7-Z! W~|~–W,Q 2 1 Steve Collins 5 Justin McDaniel ;&" 4.? ..95 95.' ' (2/&" 4)?  &.06, 9&', . 9% ;;"&?4'9&?45!"&?4. ‘’././>9, !"  5. 1 *q 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '. ;" 3#04; 6 9;./, Q 9/. *++,,  5. 1 *| 1 Wq O. *++~, .04 '. .04'.  5. 1 *Q 1 + 9/. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 *V 1 + 9/. *++~, .04 '. - . / Martin Seeger

8(.%6) *U') ) $!( L. * ' Z0" Q4 / !(!&5 !.' 50 )7 - !" ! $ !&' '5 '! )6! U" 64 4!* ))7 -, 5 $ !6'#5 4) "& %,! 6!!()) 7- 5 %!( & 7-,5&! '0(%6!('!(.)6! ' “6!!(&% !( ! // ! ! !"%!()*%7-4! * 4!$ !( '& ” # M' 0( %6 )) ! & ( .!( / 40 *% )) " “”• 6!!(!- 7- 6!( " )*) 7 - %" 7!( - ) U" ) ) 7& - 6!% ))!(.7-6! ,!()$ $ % ) & 6!0( !" " *)) !" '0(%6!$)7-) )7 - D !( 4 &7-!(,5C&)." 0( )Z 6!A ) L $ %!" " ) ) & !% Q& M'$A )Z 8( !" )66!6 ) & & P. ', !% $%6 /C !( 6!Q6/ . “ U'%& ! " % $( * !A M'6!!" 7- !"0 6'#5,!7-6!!(%4 ) ) ”" !" %! 6!)6!6!!($ )))66 Q%& 4 '!" ( )A ‰.) 6! (*)66!!(* 6% “6!...)0 $ ( " %( #! !(! $). 4 " !($” 'M' !")) %-,!)))!(! &0!()Z)66! .) 64 '%0( 6)67 -# ! " !" *‰ !( ) & 5 !"0 %M' -, 5!(!)) 6& 7!##%6!$*! M' -, 5!(!)) ( M' -, 5 Z)060.!0(6!.4 )6!!" Q'$ 7- !( 6!( “$ *%‰ 6!$$ -U'7! " - 6!%6 % *6 5 .0 %/ ! “Œ )

;., % ./ ./. X , &.06, 9&', . 9%‘’ 1 W~ 9/. *++~, .04 '. ./ ./ >9 , !";" ;., % ./ ./. X , 3#04; 6 9;./, Q 9/. *++,, .04 '. 1 W~ 9/. *++~, .04 '. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

'!( 6!4%6 0 ” %, *65.))!))& !('&#!/, (', 5 —*M*,) $ '%! )6M-&,!"6! “'B 6!*% 6!( %0( 56! * $$ ! M - &,!!*6%5 .M'6!%!6 ) 6!0($)7- !(6!( 6!%'! 5 *%‰ 6!$ “$$!( )7 - ”!" !%7 -'7QQ '7 6!! !( Q 6!$ “.) "6%)7-D ($” 6!' N)6!$$ ‰" (6/, 5 )/& ,& LŒŒP: ”‘) %,! " ! )Q& ''” 'U" 6! 6!.$$!( $ %% ))7 - $4.!%!M-&,!5" 0( & !( '0 )6" %!" 4 & 75 “)6''0( & 5 $)6'70( -” 0(M%&7-!( !('7!!(5 *,5$$0($M'7 "!(6$! '% 0( '!" /C " $0( M !(!Z #'7 " ),,5 ') !7-Z)*

 5. 1 ~* 1 Wq X. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 ~~ 1 + 9/. *++~, .04 '.  5. 1 ~ 5$..  ;; Gosling, David L., “The Changing Roles  5. 1 ~W 5$.. of Thailand’s Lay Nuns (Mae Chii)”, /" 136. - . / Martin Seeger

#. . P‘. / Krasuang Dhammakan. Rajkiccanubeksa. vol. 10. )! 7 -M #. LŒŒS. . '›:& œ,6& . / Department of Abhidhamma Student Registration. 2011. Abhidhamchotikavidyalai. Bangkok: Mahachulalongkonrajvidyalaya University. . LŒŒS. .. / Mahamakutrajwityalai University’s Department of Registration. 2002. Printed Material. . 5 Z. LŒRL. !. '›:& *'' 5 œ,6& . / Chamnong Thongprasert. 1989. Mahachula Nai Adit. Bangkok: Mahachulalongkonrajavidyalaya Press. 6/,5 )/& .& LŒŒP. "#$&'% . '›:& 7 5 -& #. / Channarong Boonnoon. 2008. Phrasongthai Nai Anakot. Bangkok: Princess Maha Chakri Sirindhorn Anthropology Centre. 8! ) 5. LŒS”. ! )( % *# . * 5 .*).& '›:& 7!C//. / de La Loubere,` Simon. 2005. Chot Mai Het La Loubere Rajanacaksyam (Du Royaume de Siam). tr. by San T. Komonbutra. Bangkok: Sri Panya. ,Z U B ,5 6!. LŒŒL. * -)% /: *23)/!456 7. '# 5 // 77),J 6 !7- #7 5. / Nat-hathai Chatthinwat, Mae Chi. 2009. Mae Chi’ Identity: A Case Study of Mae Chi Wat Pak Nam Phasicharoen. MA Thesis in Liberal Arts in Women Studies, Interdisciplinary School of Thammasatra University. 6 ,)& )Q.& LŒSŒ. )/2 42&3 . '›:& ., 7- 6 . Z .! / Parichart Suwanbubpha. 2002. Maechee Kap Pharakit Thang Kansueksa Nai Pratet Thai. Bangkok: Office of The National Education Commission, Office of the Prime Minister. ',M,& 5 (..&—*), '. LŒŒL. '&8/ / 9 vs. %. '›:& '" 5 .5 / Phromkhunaphon (P.A. Payutto), Phra. 2009. Khon Thai Chai Kob Thao vs. Latthi-Achan. Bangkok: Q. Print Management. "77 6!<= #6>( ? "" 2# ".2. @B@E. LŒL“. / The Royal Enactment on Graduate in Buddhism B.E. 2527. 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

$'7 *, '. LŒS’. "2#&'))> F. '›:& 0 . / Phaisan Wisalo, Phra. 2003. Buddhasasanathai Nai Anakhot Naewnom Lae Thang Ok Chak Wikrit. Bangkok: Rueankaewkanphim. M-&,!#. LŒŒR. !. '›:& 7. / . 2010. Bat Now. Bangkok: Songsyam. œ,6& . LŒS‘. BJ 4 Q !2 3 * . '›:& .... / Mahachulalonkonrajavidyalaya University. 1997. 50 Years of Mahachulalongkonrajavidyalaya’s Higher Education. Bangkok: n.p.. . LŒŒP. 42 * XZ # "( 2# *[ #- "2#%)24)/ "2 @BB\. / . 2008. Prakat Mahavidyalaya Mahachulalongkonrajavidyalaya Ruang Anumat Lak Sut Buddhasatra Mahabandit Sakhavija Buddhasat Lae Silpa Haeng Jivit Buddhasakaraj 2551. &N6. LŒR’. \JJ 4Q @]^_-@B^_. &'›: *''5 N6& . / Mahamakutrajavidyalaya University. 1993. 100 Years of Mahamakutrajwityalaya 1893-1993. Bangkok: Mahamakutrajavidyalaya Press. . LŒSR. 42 XZ 23. / . 2000. Prakat Mahawityalaya Mahamakutrajavidyalaya Ruang Palisueksa. ! )0 . LŒŒP. )"# !/ => 7>( "" 2#942& . '# 5 //' #7& -A& !),J 6'' #7)& ,J œ,6& . / Montri Suepduang. 2008. Feminist Perspective on Woman and Theravada . Ph.D. Dissertation in Buddhism Graduate School, Mahachulanlongkonrajavidyalaya University. &' 5. LŒSP. #""2#: 2347#9")2-)/ !4567 "' )#64)!'7. '#5 -7)5 ,J 7)! )! ),J . / Yuphin Duangjun. 1998. Buddhist Women and Ordination: A Comparative Study of The Status and The Attitude of The “Maechee” at Wat Paknam, Phasicharoen in Bangkok and at Deanmahamongkon Meditation Center in Kanchanaburi. MA Thesis in Comparative Religion, Graduate School, Mahidol University. 6&! (..&—*), '. LŒL–. 2-'*#$3 %: 47| .Z '›:& #*.! / Rajwaramuni (P.A. Payutto), Phra. 1986. Kan Sueksa Kanasong: Panha Thi Ro Thang Ok. Bangkok: Komonkhimthong Foundation. - . / Martin Seeger

. LŒSL. '*#$% "... 2)3 / . '›:& *'' 5 œ,6& . / . 1999. Kan Khanasong Kab Pho Ro Bo Kan Seuksa Haeng Chat. Bangkok: Mahachulalongkonrajwityalaya Press. M#*6 . LŒŒS. 42 *[ . '›:& #'. / Abhidhamchotikavidyalaya. 2011. The Diploma Ceremony for Abhidhampandit. Bangkok: Thana press. . LŒS“. 7# . '›:& . / Anek Nawikmun. 2004. Siamese Woman. Bangkok: Saeng Dao. Adachi, Kaoru. 2010. Leading with a Noble Misson: The Dynamic Leadership of Maechee Sansanee Shtirasuta. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Minnesota. Adiele, Faith. 2004. Meeting Faith An Inward Odyssey. New York: Norton. Collins, Steven and McDaniel, Justin. 2010. Buddhist ‘Nuns’ (Mae Chi) and the Teaching of Pali in Contemporary Thailand. Modern Asian Studies, Vol. 44, No. 6. Chatsumarn Kabilsingh. 1986. “Buddhism and National Development: A Case Study of Buddhist Univer sities.” in Religion. Bruce Matthews and Judith Nagata, eds. Religion, values and Development in Southeast Asia. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. Gosling, David. 1988. New Directions in Thai Buddhism. Modern Asian Studies. vol. 14. No. 3. . 1998. “The Changing Roles of Thailand’s Lay Nuns (Mae Chii).” Southeast Asian Journal of Social Science, vol. 26, no. 1. Lindberg Falk, Monica. 2007. Making Fields of Merit: Buddhist Female Ascetics and Gendered Orders in Thailand. Copenhagen/Washington: University of Washington Press. Tambiah, S. J.. 1976. World Conqueror and World Renouncer: A Study of Buddhism and Polity in Thailand Against a Historical Background. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Terwiel, Barend Jan. 2012. Siam Ten Ways to Look at Thailand’s Past. Gossenberg Oastasien Verlag.

. , . / Kancana Triamdhachook, maechee. (interview) , . !. " # %$ " &'$ " '%.$ / Channarong Boonnoon. (interview) !* +-, !. -%5+%! $&'" (&'$ " ) -+#-%; " " !" . / Duangphorn Khamhomku, Maechee. (interview) " -, !. -%5+%! $&'" &'$ " < &'$ ." / Dhanyamas Netrnoi, Maechee. (interview) 01 2 0 3 - 4 56 / 5 .-3 5889

%5&$ =-" -, !. %5" >& *.. ?@@@ " " >& %&- " !" . / Prathin Khwan-On, Maechee. (interview) *5 (%5 H$H), . !. -$!$&'"Q'$&'" X" .$ / Pradharmakoshacarya (Prayoon dhammacitto) (interview) *5 (* ), -!$ Y "!Z[\" $] &*5 &" &*^. / Pradharmasudhi (Peer Sujato) (interview) *5&$ $, - !" Z[\" $] &*^. / Prarajasiddhimuni. (interview) *5"# ($ %_H ),H -. !. --`$ q $ &'$ " Q'- &'$ ." / Prasrigambhirayan (Somcint Sammapanno)~~ (interview) *5" ("5 x$), -"!5 &*. / Prasrivajramuni (Vajra thitamedho). (interview) *5" (& $$), . !. !"X$ &'$ ." &'$ " Q'- &'$ ." / Prasudhidhamanuvatra (Thiap Sirinano)~ . (interview) *5&*%$"$$', -!$ &'$ " < &'$ ." / Pratheppariyattivimol. (interview) $ &" , . !. %5%&$ =*$ & z[ #%$ " &'$ " . / Montri Shirarocananand. (interview) "5 $ ,$ !. %5+#%$ " 5'%$ &'$ " . / Watchara Ngamchitcharoen. (interview) &-!, !{" "' *5- . / Somkhuan Thongdee, Maechee. (interview) * ,| !5" &*^. / Shomsri Carupheng, Maechee. (interview) !*5| " '" ( %_),H - !%" }+#[ $ &*^. / Somdec Pramaha Rajamangalacarya (Chuang Varapanno)~~ (interview) "*$*"~$$, *5%' !" !"X$ &'$ " &'$ " < &'$ ." / Sampiphadhanaviriyacarya, Pragru Palat. (interview) '" -% ," !%" }+#[ $ -*$['5&% [-z - +`q %!$ $&'." / Sisalap Upamai, Maechee. (interview) &,$ *5 " -* ~" " [z &'$ " < &'$ ." / Sutadharmakovid, Pragru. (interview) "& ', +" '" $= -+#-" "!%x." / Sunantha Rianglaem, Maechee. (interview) "~$ (> ),$ *5%' !" --!$ `q%5& &'$ " Q' &'$ ." / Suvadhanavajiragun, Pragru Palat (Sawai JotiKo) (interview) - . / Martin Seeger

--+>* #!" $]", -+ $$& -+#-%&- " !" . / Anamphai Bhasakchai, Maechee. (interview)

http://th.wikipedia.org/wiki/&'$ +." (={ -€ &"  ‚ *Z[# ?@@@.) http://th.wikipedia.org/wiki/&'$ " =& " .$ (={ -€ &"  ‚ *Z[# ?@@@.)