Legislating the Criminal Code: Offences Against the Person and General Principles (1992)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Legislating the Criminal Code OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON AND GENERAL PRINCIPLES LAW COMMISSION LAW COM No 218 The Law Commission (LAW COM. No. 218) CRIMINAL LAW LEGISLATING THE CRIMINAL CODE OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON AND GENERALPRINCIPLES Presented to Parliament by the Lord High Chancellor by Command of Her Majesty November 1993 LONDON : HMSO E1 5.30 net Cm 2370 The Law Commission was set up by section 1 of the Law Commissions Act 1965 for the purpose of promoting the reform of the law. The Commissioners are: The Honourable Mr Justice Brooke, Chairman Mr Trevor M. Aldridge, Q.C. Professor Jack Beatson Mr Richard Buxton, Q.C. Professor Brenda Hoggett, Q.C. The Secretary of the Law Commission is Mr Michael Collon and its offices are at Conquest House, 37-38 John Street, Theobalds Road, London WClN 2BQ. THE LAW COMMISSION LEGISLATING THE CRIMINAL CODE OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON AND GENERAL PRINCIPLES CONTENTS Paragraphs Page PART I: INTRODUCTION 1 The history and purpose of this project 1.1-1.6 1 PART II. THE NEED FOR ACTION 3 Introduction 2.1-2.4 3 The response on consultation on LCCP 122 3.1-3.7 4 Justice and practicality 4.1-4.8 5 PART Ilk NON-FATAL OFFENCES AGATNST THE PERSON 8 Introduction 5.1-5.2 8 Fault terms 6.1-6.2 8 “Intention” 7.1-7.14 8 Introduction 7.1-7.3 8 The basic definition: intention as ‘purpose” 7.47.5 9 A special and limited case 7.6-7.14 9 “Recklessness” 8.1-10.4 11 Introduction 8.1-8.3 11 A brief history 9.1-9.6 11 The need for definition 10.1-10.4 13 OFFENCES COMMITTED BY OMISSION 11.1 14 Offences subject to liability by omission 1 1.2-1 1.3 14 Duties to act 11.411.6 14 OFFENCES OF VIOLENCE 12.1-12.4 15 The need for reform 12.5-12.13 16 The present law 12.14-12.20 18 A restatement of sections 18, 20 and 47 of the 1861 Act 12.15 18 Section 47: the meaning of “assault 12.16-12.19 18 Section 47: causation 12.20 19 The difficulties of the present law 12.21-12.35 20 Introduction 12.21 20 The mental element 12.22-1 2.24 20 Degrees of injury 12.25 20 Erratic application of the accused‘s fault 12.26-12.29 21 The practical effect of the law 12.30-12.31 22 Conclusion 12.32-12.35 22 INTENTIONAL SERIOUS INJURY, RECKLESS SERIOUS INJURY AND INTENTIONAL OR RECKLESS INJURY 13.1-13.2 23 The general structure and its rationale 13.3-13.5 23 The terms of the new offences 13.6 24 Intention and recklessness 14.1-14.26 24 Introduction 14.1-14.4 24 LCCP 122 and the response on consultation 14.5-14.9 25 Recklessness in clauses 24of the Criminal Law Bill 14.10-14.13 26 Principle 14.14-14.16 27 Complexity 14.17-14.19 28 Justice 14.20-1 4.22 28 Usability and effectiveness 14.23-14.26 29 Injury 15.1-15.31 30 Introduction 15.1-15.3 30 “‘Injury” or “personal harm” 15.4-1 5.5 31 Inclusion of minor injuries 15.6-15.7 31 “Serious” injury 15.8 32 ... 111 Unusual forms of physical injury 15.9-1 5.19 32 (a) “or any other impairment of a person’s physical condition” 15.9-1 5.1 1 32 (b) Pain and unconsciousness 15.12-1 5.14 32 (c) Illness or disease 15.15-1 5.19 33 1 Injury to the mind 15.20-1 5.31 34 Power of arrest 16.1 36 1 Jurisdiction 17.1 36 1 ASSAULT 36 1 Statutory definition 18.1-18.7 36 ~ The problem of consent 19.1-19.4 38 “Trivial Touchings” 20.1-20.7 39 Assault and alternative verdicts 2 1.1-2 1.3 40 1 Special cases of assault 22.1-22.12 41 1 Assault on a constable 22.4-22.6 41 Assault to resist arrest 22.7-22.11 42 Assault with intent to rob 22.12 42 THREATS TO KILL OR TO CAUSE SERIOUS INJURY 23.1 43 ~ OTHER NON-FATAL OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON 43 Introduction 24.1-24.3 43 Administering a substance without consent 24.4-24.10 43 Torture 24.1 1 44 ~ Offences of detention and abduction 24.12-24.14 44 OTHER AMENDMENTS OF THE 1861 ACT 25.1 45 ~ PART IV-GENERAL DEFENCES AND OTHER PROVISIONS INCLUDED IN THE BILL 46 1 INTRODUCTION 26.1-26.5 46 1 1 PRESERVATION OF COMMON LAW DEFENCES 27.1-27.9 46 j DURESS BY THREATS 48 Introduction 28.1-28.6 48 Law reform background 28.1 48 Clause 26 of LCCP 122 28.2 48 Further questions 28.3-28.6 49 The proposed defence 29.1-29.16 49 The threat 29.1 49 The person threatened 29.2 49 The possibility of official protection 29.3-29.7 49 The actor’s view of the facts 29.8-29.10 51 Is the threat one which the actor should resist? 29.11-29.14 51 Voluntary exposure to duress 29.15-29.16 52 Application of the defence to murder 30.1-30.22 52 Preliminary 30.1 52 Statutory reform of the common law 30.2-30.3 53 The decision in Gotts 30.4-30.7 53 The consultation 30.8 54 The arguments of principle and the practical considerations 30.9-30.16 54 Whether duress should reduce murder to manslaughter 30.17-30.22 55 Duress as a complete defence 3 1.1-3 1.8 56 Application of the defence to other offences if our recommendation as to murder is rejected 32.1-32.6 58 Attempted murder 32.1 58 Other offences of violence 32.2-32.4 58 Treason 32.5 59 Marital coercion 32.6 59 Burden of proving duress 33.1-33.16 59 The practical effect of reversing the burden 33.9-33.12 61 The European Convention on Human Rights 33.13-33.15 62 Our recommendation 33.16 62 Notice of defence 34.1 62 . iv i DURESS OF CIRCUMSTANCES 35.1 62 The nature of the defence 35.2-3 5.7 63 Authority 35.2 63 Relation to duress by threats and to necessity 35.3-35.7 63 Some details of the defence 3 5.8-3 5.9 64 The danger 35.8 64 Other matters 35.9 64 Application of the defence 35.10-35.12 64 THE JUSTJJX4BLE USE OF FORCE 65 Introduction 36.1-36.9 65 The approach of the Criminal Law Bill 37.1-37.10 67 Purposes for which the use of force can be justified 38.1-38.34 68 The concept of use of force 38.1-38.2 68 Types of conduct that may justifv the use of force 38.3-38.18 ‘ 69 Defence against non-culpable acts: particular cases 38.19-38.23 72 Defence against non-culpable acts: mistaken belief or suspicion 38.24-3 8.29 73 Use of force in effecting or assisting in a lawful arrest 38.30-38.34 75 Other features of this defence 39.1-39.1 1 76 Force against a constable in the execution of his duty 39.1-39.5 76 Must the use of force be, or be thought to be, immediately necessary? 39.6-39.7 76 Preparatory acts 39.8 77 “Self-induced’ occasions for the use of force 39.9 77 Opportunity to retreat 39.10 77 Circumstances unknown to and unsuspected by the actor 39.11 77 Relation to other defences 40.1-40.4 77 Necessity and duress of circumstances 40.1L40.3 77 Excessive self-defence 40.4 78 SUPERVENING FAULT 41.1-41.2 78 The general principle 41.3 79 Clause 31 of the Criminal Law Bill 41.4 79 Some details 41.541.9 79 TRANSFERRED FAULT 42.1-42.2 80 Transfer of fault required for “the offence” 42.3 80 Recklessness 42.4-42.5 80 Transferred defences 42.6 81 THE EFFECT OF INTOXICATION 81 Introduction 43.1-43.5 81 Intoxication at common law: the Majewski rules 44.1-44.9 82 Introduction 44.1 82 Majewski: basic and specific intent 44.2-44.4 82 Majewski: limited to allegations of recklessness? 44.5-44.6 83 The policy of the Criminal Law Bill: recklessness 44.74.9 83 Defences based on mistaken belief 45.145.4 84 Definition of terms 46.146.6 84 Introduction 46.1 84 “(Intoxicant ’’ 46.2 84 “Voluntary intoxication” 46.3-46.6 85 PART V: RECOMMENDATION 87 APPENDIX A Draft Criminal Law Bill with Explanatory Notes 88 APPENDIX B: Recommendations in Respect of Certain Specific Sections of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 131 APPENDIX C Offences Against the Person Act 1861: Current Status 139 APPENDIX D: List of Respondents to Consultation Paper No. 122 145 V ABBREVIATIONS In this Report the following abbreviations are used: " 1861 Act ',: The Offences against the Person Act 1861 (c 100) " CLRC ',: the Criminal Law Revision Committee " CLRC Fourteenth Report ',: Criminal Law Revision Committee, Fourteenth Report: Offences against the Person (Cmnd 7844, 1980) " Code Team Report ": Report to the Law Commission on the Codijkation of the Criminal Law (Law Com No 143, 1985) " Draft Code ',: the draft Bill contained in Volume 1 of A Criminal Code for England and Wales (Law Com No 177, 1989) " Code Report ',: the remainder of Volume 1, and Volume 2, of Law Com No 177 " LCCP 122 ',: Law Commission Consultation Paper No 122, Legislating the Criminal Code: Offences against the Person and General Principles (1992) " LCCP 127 ',: Law Commission Consultation Paper No 127, Intoxication and Criminal Liability (1993) " Criminal Law Bill " the draft Bill implementing the recommendations of this Report, contained in Appendix A to this Report.