DOCSLIB.ORG

The Formation of Ethical and Political Positions on Stem Cell Research

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Formation of Ethical and Political Positions on Stem Cell Research Eastern Michigan University DigitalCommons@EMU Senior Honors Theses Honors College 2006 Best-Fit Bioethics: The orF mation of Ethical and Political Positions on Stem Cell Research Emily Zehnder Follow this and additional works at: http://commons.emich.edu/honors Part of the Ethics and Political Philosophy Commons Recommended Citation Zehnder, Emily, "Best-Fit Bioethics: The orF mation of Ethical and Political Positions on Stem Cell Research" (2006). Senior Honors Theses. 26. http://commons.emich.edu/honors/26 This Open Access Senior Honors Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Honors College at DigitalCommons@EMU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Senior Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@EMU. For more information, please contact lib- [email protected]. Best-Fit Bioethics: The orF mation of Ethical and Political Positions on Stem Cell Research Abstract Few issues in bioethics inspire controversy and garner headlines like human embryonic stem cell research. This cutting-edge research can be at once confusing, exciting, and disturbing. Scientists eagerly tout the potentially life-saving therapies this research could produce, giving hope to the millions who suffer from debilitating diseases and to their loved ones. However, to obtain these longed-for miracles of modern science, human embryos must be destroyed. And many people object to this aspect of the research. Despite being sympathetic to those who suffer, these people do not believe that any benefits merit the large-scale destruction of what they consider to be a unique individual human life. Others believe that the embryo, though deserving of respect, should never be equated with a developed human person in a way that precludes its use to potentially benefit umh anity. Most people seem to be caught somewhere in the middle. They ra e pulled in two directions— between helping people and protecting life—and it is this pull that characterizes the debate over stem cell research. Degree Type Open Access Senior Honors Thesis Department History and Philosophy First Advisor Richard Nation Second Advisor Ronald Delph Keywords Embryonic stem cells Research Moral and ethical aspects, Stem cells Research Moral and ethical aspects Subject Categories Ethics and Political Philosophy This open access senior honors thesis is available at DigitalCommons@EMU: http://commons.emich.edu/honors/26 BEST-FIT BIOETHICS: THE FORMATION OF ETHICAL AND POLITICAL POSITIONS ON STEM CELL RESEARCH By Emily Zehnder A Senior Thesis Submitted to the Eastern Michigan University Honors Program in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for Graduation with Honors in Religious Studies Approved at Ypsilanti, Michigan, on this date ___________________________________ ____________________________________ ____________________________________ Supervising Instructor Department Head Richard Nation Philip Schmitz ____________________________________ ____________________________________ Honors Advisor Honors Director Ronald Delph James Knapp To my parents ii CONTENTS INTRODUCTION . 1 CHAPTER ONE: ONTO NEW GROUND. 4 The Properties and Acquisition of Stem Cells . 4 Potential Benefits . 7 Obstacles . 9 Research Results and Unanswered Questions . 14 CHAPTER TWO: SEARCHING FOR BRIGHT LINES . 18 The Nature of Potential. 19 Boundaries for Moral Status . 22 Human Rights . 28 In-Vitro Fertilization . 30 Other Concerns . 35 CHAPTER THREE: GUIDANCE AND INTERPRETATION . 39 Christianity . 40 Judaism . 51 Islam . 55 Eastern Religions . 57 Common Social Concerns. 60 CHAPTER FOUR: SETTING LIMITS AND SENDING MESSAGES . 62 The Current Policy . 63 Practical Problems . 65 Impact of the Policy . 67 Principles in Policymaking . 72 Public Support . 77 iii CONCLUSION . 80 APPENDIX A . 84 APPENDIX B . 85 APPENDIX C . .86 GLOSSARY . 87 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY . 90 iv INTRODUCTION Few issues in bioethics inspire controversy and garner headlines like human embryonic stem cell research. This cutting-edge research can be at once confusing, exciting, and disturbing. Scientists eagerly tout the potentially life-saving therapies this research could produce, giving hope to the millions who suffer from debilitating diseases and to their loved ones. However, to obtain these longed-for miracles of modern science, human embryos must be destroyed. And many people object to this aspect of the research. Despite being sympathetic to those who suffer, these people do not believe that any benefits merit the large-scale destruction of what they consider to be a unique individual human life. Others believe that the embryo, though deserving of respect, should never be equated with a developed human person in a way that precludes its use to potentially benefit humanity. Most people seem to be caught somewhere in the middle. They are pulled in two directions— between helping people and protecting life—and it is this pull that characterizes the debate over stem cell research. Stem cell research is, in one sense, entirely modern and unprecedented. But the questions it raises about the origins of life and the alleviation of suffering have concerned people for hundreds of years. There are sources available for people to look to for guidance in untangling the ethical issues involved. Ethicists, and others, can use reason and logic to find and sort out the relevant issues and the best arguments. They try to discover or create clear distinctions and boundaries, puzzling out their positions and attempting to justify their chosen courses of action. Some find these arguments convincing, and others take the parts of these views that fit best with their own beliefs and values. Other fundamental sources of guidance to the decisions that people make concerning stem cell research are religious texts and traditions. On issues of life and death, those who are religious desire to make decisions that are consistent with their faiths. Religious sources can give guidance on new and confusing issues based on the treatment of similar cases from the past. However, since these sources always address analogous problems, rather than the circumstances of stem cell research itself, they often lend themselves to competing interpretations. There is no one religious position on stem cell research in the U.S. nor in Christianity alone nor even within individual denominations. The faithful have access to texts and traditions, but they still interpret these traditions in light of their own consciences and values. This thesis articulates the ways that people and organizations have determined, justified, and put into practice their own “best-fit” positions on the morality of stem cell research. It is a primer on the scientific, ethical, religious, and political aspects of stem cell research. In the first chapter, I explain the relevant science, to provide a basic foundation and to dispel some of the confusion that pervades public understanding of this research. In chapter two, I delve into the secular arguments made by ethicists who look to reason to provide clarity and answers. The third chapter details the various religious positions taken by people of faith. I note the ways they avail themselves of the traditions and sacred texts of their faith, as well as their own interpretations. Finally, in the fourth chapter, I explain the current policy on stem cell research and look at the role of personal 2 beliefs in shaping policy decisions. I conclude that, because this issue has so many elements that tug in different directions, it lends itself well to individual interpretation. People take from all of the sources available to them, and based on their previous beliefs and values, they craft a solution with which they can be comfortable. 3 CHAPTER ONE ONTO NEW GROUND Despite widespread knowledge that stem cell research exists, there remains a great amount of confusion over its exact nature and purpose. Explanations of stem cell research often fall into one of two camps: those that are overly simplified and lack any real depth, and those in scientific journals that are too technical for the lay- person. It is difficult to engage in debates over the ethics or funding of this research with only a passing familiarity of the science involved, so this chapter provides a basic foundation for understanding this complicated subject. I will introduce the concept of stem cells and their properties and kinds, as well as discuss the potential for this research and the obstacles that must be overcome in order to realize this potential. I will briefly compare adult and embryonic stem cell research, give a sense of some current developments, and explain the disagreements among scientists and the questions with which they are struggling. The Properties and Acquisition of Stem Cells Definition and classification. Stem cells are a very diverse group, but generally they are characterized by their capacity for self-renewal—that is, to divide and produce more cells like themselves—and their potential for differentiation into 4 another kind of cell or, often, many other kinds of cells.1 While these cells are present from very early in development, they also permeate every part of the adult body and keep the cells of the body renewed. These cells can be classified by their origins or by their developmental capacities.2 The main categories by origins are embryonic stem cells, which are derived from the cells of a pre-implantation embryo, and adult stem cells, which can be derived from the cells of many tissues in the human body. These cells are classified according to their capacities
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Eros, Storge, Phileo, and Agape
    Eros, Storge, Phileo, and Agape INTRODUCTION II. Storge Love is ambiguous in the English language. A. This is natural affection—family, kin, the There is “Strawberry Shortcake Love.” We love humblest of loves. We love each other simply cats, dogs, and ice cream. This is trite and with- because we are of the family. B. It is negative in Romans 1:31 and 2 Timothy out depth or permanence. There is “Aunt Minnie 3:3, used regarding homosexuals. Love” which is reserved for “special” people C. It is used in withdrawal in 2 Timothy 3:14, 15. who are sweet and lovable. Sometimes it is con- Withdrawal is not excommunication, put- descending. There is “Bowling Team Love” for ting one out of the church. It is what it says, “buddies” in a reciprocal way. Moderns do not withdrawal of fellowship. zero in on “Tough Love.” So there is a Greek word study. However, the III. Phileo Bible is not learned in a seminary; it is learned A. This is tender affection and brotherly love. out on the street with people in local work. (Philadelphia is the city of “brotherly love.”) Footnotes will not preach. Also, the Bible must B. However, sometimes we make too clear a not be reduced to word studies. You can get so distinction between phileo and agape. Be care- ful. There are surprises. Read Titus 2:3, 4; far out on a limb looking at a leaf you forget the Romans 12:9, 10; 1 Corinthians 16:22; He- tree. Word studies can be helpful, but they can brews 13:1; John 16:27; and 1 Peter 1:22.
    [Show full text]
  • Agape and Eros: a Critique of Nygren
    AGAPE AND EROS A. S. DEWDNEY O one can read Bishop Nygren's great work Agape and Eros without Ngratitude and much delight. This is one of those monumental works of which only a very few are produced in any generation and which help to clarify and mould the thinking of men everywhere. Agape and Eros are words which are here to stay in our theological vocabulary because they express the two great motifs underlying the more inclusive word "love". They enable us to distinguish these elements and to handle them with more precision and understanding of what they mean. All preachers and theologians have suffered in the past in attempting to clarify what is involved in the Christian idea of love, whether it is the love of God to man, of man to God, of man to his neighbour, or the meaning and place to be given to self-love. We now have a clear word for two aspects of what are commonly called love, and for this we must be forever indebted to Bishop Nygren's clear and searching analysis. He has helped us to resolve much of this ambiguity. Nygren distinguishes two types of love. One is the love of desire. It is the love which values and seeks to possess some good in its object. It is motivated by that good. We love that which is good, that is, that which is good for us. Such a love is self-centred. However lofty the object on which it places its love, essentially it sees that object as a good to be possessed.
    [Show full text]
  • Parent Handbook
    AGAPE LEARNING CENTRE Early Childhood Services We would like to welcome you and your child to our kindergarten and ECS (preschool) programs at Agape Learning Centre. We are looking forward to an exciting year of new experiences and lots of fun! It is during the first years of life that children form attitudes about themselves, others, learning, and the environment, so we work very hard to find ways to help children develop positive attitudes. Educating a child is most successful when families and schools work together in the best interest of the child; after all, you are your child’s first teacher! Parents are the most important teachers and play a central role in the lives of their children. When children begin ECS, parents and teachers form a partnership to support learning at home and at school. In school the values and beliefs of the home are acknowledged, and the cultural diversities of families are recognized. We appreciate your input and assistance in our program so please feel comfortable to come and join us in the classroom. The goal of our program is to meet your child’s needs not only intellectually, but also physically, socially, spiritually and emotionally. Going to school is one of the most important experiences in a child’s life. School can be an exciting place where children meet new and different people and participate in many new and different experiences. We promise to work diligently to provide the children with wonderful experiences that help them to feel good about themselves and their school. The ECS program is funded by the Department of Alberta Education.
    [Show full text]
  • Agape Strong January/February 2016
    Agape for Youth, Inc. Newsletter Agape Strong January/February 2016 2015………REFLECTING UPON AGAPE’S YEAR OF CELEBRATION!!! As I’ve written throughout the Agape youth and families reunification families from the Agape’s Strengths year, this has been, and continues participated at events including the BJKids91 Foundation, along with to be an amazing journey for Vectren Dayton Airshow, receiving over $400,000 in The combined top Agape! Columbus Zoo, Idle Hour Ranch, donated household items and five Strengths of the Dayton Dragons game, Young’s merchandise through our During 2015, we served over 160 staff at Agape are: Dairy, Laser Tag, and bowling made partnership with Good 360 was youth through our Foster Care possible through Agape’s Youth provided those we serve, and Developer program, had 19 of our youth and Family Fund built through the made available to other non- Empathy adopted by one of our many “Agape Strong” fundraiser bringing profits in our community. dedicated foster families, and had in a record breaking over $50,000, Responsibility more than 100 families (which and additional community Grants from the Reynolds and Belief included over 240 youth) be served donations. Reynolds Foundation, Vectren Positivity through our Reunification Services Foundation, PNC Foundation, program. Our belief that “the The youth we serve were provided and Hossie Martin Foundation, more we serve, the more with education incentives for their along with a significant ‘employee’ opportunities we will be given to success, tutoring services again outreach donation from serve” played out ten-fold. made possible through our CareSource (where they provided community support.
    [Show full text]
  • In This Issue…
    S P R I N G 2 0 0 9 V 1 7 I s s DIRECTIONS u e 8 FAMILIES OF SPINAL MUSCULAR ATROPHY In this Issue… (SMA news to shout about!) New SMA Care Booklets Breathing Basics – covering critical aspects of respiratory care for SMA. ............................................................3 Caring Choices - for parents of infants newly diagnosed with SMA Type I .....................................................13 25th Anniversary Conference See the full agenda for our annual family and professionals conference in Cincinnati, OH ...................................................4 25 Voices of SMA See the first profiles spotlighting families, clinicians and researchers from the SMA community ..................................6 Legislative News Updates on the SMA Treatment Acceleration Act and other topics from the new congress and administration ................8 “Ask the Expert” Service New system to submit important SMA care and health- related questions and search for answers online ................11 SMA Registry Online New website launched ...........................................................29 www.curesma.org DEAR families & friends www.curesma.org ur annual conference this year will be the perfect time for us to celebrate 25 years of FSMA and all that has been accomplished. O$50 Million raised and funded for SMA research over the last 25 years is an amazing achievement and has brought us incredibly far. However, this will not just be a year of looking back. We are a community that is in no way comfortably satisfied with where we currently stand. Families of We are a non-profit, 501(c)3 tax exempt SMA is aggressively increasing our funding commitments for research and organization. Funds will be specifically clinical programs to develop a treatment and cure.
    [Show full text]
  • The Four Kinds of Love Activity Instructions
    The Four Kinds of Love Activity Instructions Activity 1 Preparation: Cut up the texts on each of the four kinds of love Photocopy them onto different colour paper Set Up & Instructions Put the students in groups of 5 or 6 Tell the students their aim is to make notes on their table for each kind of love, using the information on the texts. Explain that the sub-box under each table category is for writing in examples of that kind of love. The students have 4 minutes per text, then shout “swap”: the students must put their text down and pick up another one. After 16 mins, give the students a few additional minutes to check their info with their partners, and complete anything missing. Feedback the answers. Activity 2 Summing Activity Explain how the love of a parent for their child can consist of all four kinds of love. Activity 3/ Plenary Nominate students from the class to choose a letter from the alphabet, name an adjective starting with that letter that would describe one kind of love. Encourage the students to explain their choice. Eg R - Romantic, C - caring Sacred Heart High School/mrumian 2009 The Four Kinds of Love Storge , or “affection” can be shown to people of objects. Towards people, storge is being fond of someone because we like and have got used to having them around. Eg a family member, or neighbour we have grown up with. Towards objects, storge is the loving satisfaction of having a good meal, or a fit and healthy body.
    [Show full text]
  • Levinas Between Agape and Eros
    Levinas Between Agape and Eros CLAIRE KATZ, Texas A&M University Anders Nygren's Agape and Eros, first published in the 1930s, was a landmark treatment of the radical distinction between eros and agape.! Realizing that the Christian Bible makes large use of agape and little use of eros, Nygren seeks to understand why this is the case. Eros, Nygren tells us, is largely associated with Plato while agape is largely associated with Paul. Where eros is the desire to behold and participate in divine attributes, to make them part of oneself, agape is God's love freely bestowed on us. Although the most colloquial usage of eros does not point to a religious connotation, eros, like agape, is deeply religious in its original meaning, even as the two terms differ in significant ways. We can see remnants of this same discussion in the ethical project of Emmanuel Levinas, which became the subject of terrific criticism, pre­ cisely because he separated the ethical relation from the erotic experi­ ence. As a result, Levinas's commentators frequently compare Levinas's ethics to Christian agape. 2 Using the same distinction between agape and eros, even if implicitly, these commentators conclude that if Levinas distances the ethical relation from eros, his ethics must be like agape. Conversely, other commentators, for example, Luce Irigaray, prefer to bring together Levinas's ethics and eros while still maintaining some of the structure of Levinasian ethics. 3 That is, they are not satisfied with this separation, yet they are persuaded by some of the structure that identifies Levinas's ethical relation.
    [Show full text]
  • HUMAN CLONING Papers from a Church Consultation
    HUMAN CLONING Papers From a Church Consultation Evangelical Lutheran Church in America October 13-15, 2000 Chicago, Illinois Roger A. Willer, editor HUMAN CLONING Papers From a Church Consultation Roger A. Willer, editor Copyright © 2001 Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. Produced by the Department for Studies of the Division for Church in Society, 8765 W. Higgins Rd., Chicago, Illinois, 60631-4190. Permission is granted to reproduce this document as needed provided each copy carries the copyright notice printed above. Scripture quotations from the New Standard Revised Version of the Bible are copyright © 1989 by the Division of Christian Education of the National Council of Churches of Christ in the United States of America and are used by permission. Cover image © copyright 1999 PhotoDisc, Inc. The figure found on page nine is adapted from the National Institute of Health, Stem Cells: A Primer at <www.nih.gov/ news/stemcell/primer.htm>. ISBN 6-0001-3165-8. Distributed on behalf of the Division for Church in Society of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America by Augsburg Fortress, Publishers. Augsburg Fortress order code 69-1550. This publication may be found online in its entirety as a downloadable PDF (portable document file) at <www.elca.org/ dcs/humancloning.html>. Printed on recycled paper with soy-based inks. Contents Contributors 3 Preface 4 Introduction 5 Section One, The Science and the Public Debate Kevin Fitzgerald Cloning: Can it be Good for Us? 8 Margaret R. McLean Table Talk and Public Policy Formation in the Clone Age 14 Richard Perry Broadening the Churchs Conversation 23 Section Two, Theological Resources Philip Hefner Cloning: The Destiny and Dangers of Being Human 27 Richard C.
    [Show full text]
  • Playing with Fire: an Ethnographic Look at How Polyamory Functions in the Central Florida Burner Community
    University of Central Florida STARS HIM 1990-2015 2015 Playing with Fire: An Ethnographic Look at How Polyamory Functions in the Central Florida Burner Community Maleia Mikesell University of Central Florida Part of the Anthropology Commons Find similar works at: https://stars.library.ucf.edu/honorstheses1990-2015 University of Central Florida Libraries http://library.ucf.edu This Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by STARS. It has been accepted for inclusion in HIM 1990-2015 by an authorized administrator of STARS. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Recommended Citation Mikesell, Maleia, "Playing with Fire: An Ethnographic Look at How Polyamory Functions in the Central Florida Burner Community" (2015). HIM 1990-2015. 613. https://stars.library.ucf.edu/honorstheses1990-2015/613 PLAYING WITH FIRE: AN ETHNOGRAPHIC LOOK AT HOW POLYAMORY FUNCTIONS IN THE CENTRAL FLORIDA BURNER COMMUNITY by MALEIA MIKESELL A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements For the Honors in the Major Program in Anthropology In the College of Sciences and in the Burnett Honors College at the University of Central Florida Orlando, FL Spring Term 2015 Thesis Chair: Dr. Beatriz Reyes-Foster Abstract This thesis asks the question as to whether polyamory functions as a community glue or solvent for the Central Florida Burner Community. It explores the definition of polyamory and how it relates to the Burner counter-culture. This thesis explores what polyamory’s effects are on the individual and community levels for those who participate in it. The findings concluded that overall the participants reported a perceived positive impact on both the individual level and on community cohesion in this case.
    [Show full text]
  • Other Board Experiences Include Agape Shoppe, Brook- 376-',731',7 Haven Home, Corrections and Youth
    ffr BOARD OT DINEOORS President: Bernadine Schwartzentruber 376-2792 Vice Prcsident: Perry Steria and his wife Beth live near West Lowville. His Perry Steria other board experiences include Agape Shoppe, Brook- 376-',731',7 haven Home, Corrections and Youth Treasurer: Services Association (AYSA). He enjoys gardening, pho- Don Roggie togaphy, reading, oil painting, and leatherwork. In 1964- 376-30',76 1966 he served in Voluntary Service under the Mennonite pets Seqetary: Mission Board. Perry and Beth enjoy their and their Bernice Zehr nieces and nephews. His contributions that would benefit 376-2166 AMIIA include light carpentry, painting, clerical, accounting, teachilg and Caro\r Henry sauerkraut making. 853-6879 Joyce Birk is a homemaker. Her husband is a family Laveda Taube 493-3119 practice doctor at the Beaver River Health Clinic. Joyce was previously a Doctor of Podiatric Medicine Ralph Taube and a registered nurse. They have four children ages 493-31t9 6- 13. She served on the board ofa women's club in Phyllis Lyndaker Pusan, Korea. Her hobbies are fiber arts: spinning, 376-7643 weaving, knitting, tatting and history of fiber arts. a gift shop in Korea and organiz- Kendm Eberle Other volunteer activities included managing Cell3l5-489{052 ing a yearly bazaar for two years. She can contribute to AMHA by her intelest in the daily activities of early Americans. She loves "living history" and his- Joyce BiIk as fiber/clothes making, Cell315-408-9113 torical re-enactment of daiiy life such home skills, soap making, wood stove cooking, farm skills, and food preparation, generally Executive Director "how our ancestors survived".
    [Show full text]
  • The Language of Love
    Lindberg/Love: A Brief History Through Western Christianity 9780631235989_4_001 Page Proof page 1 24.11.2007 2:24pm Chapter 1 The Language of Love ‘‘The Greeks have a word for it’’ is an old cliche´ but nonetheless apt for our subject. Indeed, in relation to ‘‘love,’’ the Greeks not only had a word, they had many words! Like so many aspects of Western culture, our understandings and views of love have been influenced by contributions from Greek thought. The Greek vocabulary for ‘‘love’’ includes the nouns ‘‘storge,’’ ‘‘epithymia,’’ ‘‘philia,’’ ‘‘eros,’’ and ‘‘agape,’’ and their respective verb forms. On occasion some of these words for love are interchangeable but they are not strong synonyms. As we shall see, the history of the language of love is intimately related to the history of ideas. But as some wag once put it, the history of ideas is akin to nailing jello to the wall. Hence, caveat emptor, readers are warned that past historical contexts are often foreign countries and that words familiar to us may have been used quite differently in different times and places. For example, Cheyette notes in his study of medieval troubadour literature that when we moderns limit our concept of love to a sentiment, we miss its medieval political and social meanings. Bolkestein makes a similar Lindberg/Love: A Brief History Through Western Christianity 9780631235989_4_001 Page Proof page 2 24.11.2007 2:24pm 2 The Language of Love point in his study of pre-Christian social welfare when he notes that in classical culture ‘‘philanthropy’’ meant love among men or human love not charity or social welfare.
    [Show full text]
  • Release Agape Love in Your Marriage
    Release Agape Love In Your Marriage As I (Rick) was preparing for a men’s retreat to help men have an experiential knowledge of Father, I was looking at 1 John 4:16 where it says, “God is love.” It’s not that God has love, but that He is Love. Love is a person and Love is a substance that you can receive and give away! It’s one of the most important parts of a healthy and vibrant marriage and the reason that we would all say is why we married our spouse. For Sue and I with over 44 years of marriage, we have probably said, “I love you” many thousands of times, and we never get tired of hearing it said again (especially when it’s with real feelings and emotions)!!! What struck me was that, since God is Love, He is all the types of love too. He is agape love; He is eros love; He is phileo love; He is storge love; and I like to add, He is romantic love. You can Google on any of those you’re not familiar with, but I want to focus for a couple minutes on the first one, agape love. When I looked it up on line they said, “Agape is selfless, sacrificial, unconditional love, the highest of the four types of love in the Bible.” Jimmy Evans defines agape love as “a permanent, self-sacrificing commitment to act in the best interest of the other person regardless of negative emotions or difficult circumstances.” The best example of agape love is the way Jesus, as a son, interacted with the Father and what He did for us.
    [Show full text]