Central and Eastern European Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPEAN REVIEW Volume 9, 2015 REVIEWS AND REPORTS ALBANIA AND KOSOVO by Antonia Young University of Bradford ISSN 1752–7503 10.1515/caeer-2016-0002 © 2015 CEER First publication Central and Eastern European Review REVIEWS AND REPORTS ALBANIA AND KOSOVO By Antonia Young University of Bradford ‘The Prison at Spaç—Why a Museum?’, Tirana, 23rd May, 2015. Conference report. Robert Elsie, The Albanian Treason Trial (1945). Albanian Studies, Vol. 3, 2015 344pp. ISBN 978–15077095ll. Review. Vincent W. J. van Gerven Oei, ed., Lapidari, Punctum Books: Brooklyn and Tirana, 2015, 280pp. ISBN: 9780692350461. Review. Elizabeth Gowing, The Rubbish Picker’s Wife; an Unlikely Friendship in Kosovo. Elbow Publishing, Cornwall, 363pp. ISBN: 978–0–957409–03–3. Review Gerda Mulder, Robert Elsie and Herman Zonderland, A Passion for Theth: Albania’s Rugged Shangri-La. Skanderbeg Books: Utrecht and Tirana, 2014. 278pp. ISBN 978–90–7905 35 8. Review. 3 Central and Eastern European Review CONFERENCE REPORT ‘The Prison at Spaç—Why a Museum?’ Tirana, 23rd May, 2015. The conference was organized jointly by the Justice and Peace Commission of Shkodër, Cultural Heritage without Borders (CHwB) and the German Maximilian Kolbe Foundation. A short film made up of clips shot during the time that Spaç prison was operational, with music but no words, was shown. Archbishop Angelo Massatra, Head of the Albanian Bishop’s Conference and Aleksandër Lala, Mayor of Orosh Commune (in which the prison is located), opened the meetings. Three members of the Ex-Politically Persecuted organization spoke about the history of Spaç prison (it had been built in 1967 by prisoners, alongside a copper mine where they became forced labourers), its conditions and the extent of the violation of human rights. One of them, Merkur Babameto, described the 3-day 1972 revolt. Two German speakers of the Maximilian Kolbe Foundation were to have spoken about the German experience of confronting the past and describing the model of Auschwitz as a place of commemoration, dialogue and hope. Unfortunately their flight failed to bring them. Fatos Lubonja, the well-known political writer and analyst was also unable to participate. He spent 17 years as a political prisoner and wrote up a part of his experience in his Second Sentence. Beni spoke on behalf of CHwB or plans they had started to formulate concerning the preservation of Spaç prison. Following a break, there was an impressive ‘Artistic Event’: 21 students from the Prenk Jakova Art School in Tirana, dressed in striped prison garb, stood with their backs to the returning audience. To the accompaniment of sombre music, they turned round, each holding an artwork which had been inspired by a recent visit to Spaç prison. About half the conference participants were former political prisoners. Notably absent from the conference, although all specifically invited, were any members from the Albanian Ministries and any media. After dinner on the Tirana International Hotel terrace, participants returned to take part in four workshops concerned with planning the realization of the future museum. 4 Central and Eastern European Review This year there have been many other moves towards recognizing the past and thereby acknowledgment, giving dignity to those who were killed and others who survived the suffering. There was an open day at The House of Leaves in central Tirana, hidden behind trees, right opposite the huge new Orthodox Cathedral (built in 2011). In this House, interrogations and torture had been performed under the Communist regime, and it is believed that some such continued under the Democratic Party regime of recent years. There has long been an interest, especially on the part of foreigners, in the 700,000 bunkers placed all over the country. Many people have written about them, photographed them, created exhibitions about them. Most are only large enough for two persons to squeeze inside and have widely been used as toilets, many are destroyed. Some of the larger ones were adapted for use as cafes or shops. But this is the first time I have seen any preserved simply as a part of Albanian history: opposite the international Rogner Hotel, one has been showcased, cleaned and protected by glass, it can be viewed by passers-by. Others, much larger, are being made comfortable for public view: known as ‘atomic’ bunkers, one of them on Dajti mountain, where Hoxha and his entourage would have taken shelter, contains the furniture taken by the regime from former wealthy families. Antonia Young 5 Central and Eastern European Review REVIEWS Robert Elsie, The Albanian Treason Trial (1945). Albanian Studies, Vol. 3, 2015 344pp. ISBN 978–15077095ll. Readers are spared the full length and poorly translated record of the trial in March, 1945, of 60 Albanians. The trial was set up by the new government, for political activities during the period leading up to and during the Italian occupation of Albania from 7th April, 1939 and then the German occupation from September 1943 until November 1944, when the last German troops left Albania. Robert Elsie has selected records of fourteen of these hearings of whom six (out of a total of 17 executed) were shot immediately following the trials. Warnings of the accused’s misdeeds were first published daily, in Bashkimi (3rd February—l7th April l945), to inspire terror in the population. This important document is presented in readable form out of a full record which had been transcribed either by the British or the American Mission. Elsie explains that Vandeleur Robinson had been one of few foreign diplomatic observers permitted to attend the proceedings of the Treason Trial. His record contrasts to his observations in his book, Albania’s Road to Freedom, written following his visits in the years just before the Second World War, published in 1941. In the book, despite recognizing shortcomings of Zog, he nevertheless praises him for the range of reforms he has brought to the country. Robinson brought a copy of the transcribed trial record to the UK, as well as his own notes from the time. In Robinson’s own notes, included in this volume, he records that the general indictment ran to fourteen points: these are elaborated at the start of the official report of the Trial. As he explains, the indictments fell basically into two classes of offence: those in which the accused was found to be a traitor to his country who thus was considered to be a ‘war criminal’; and those who had been political opponents of the partisan movement and was thus an ‘enemy of the people’. In this new format the Treason Trial is prefaced with a brief contextual note by Elsie, pointing out, for example, that in the Second World War, more Albanians died fighting one another, than from the opposing Italians and Germans. Besides this and Robinson’s comments, there is a short excerpt from the memoirs of one of the 6 Central and Eastern European Review accused, Lazër Radi, recounting the growing tensions of the days before his arrest. Radi was sentenced to 30 years in prison, but was not in fact freed until the fall of Communism in 1991—shortly after this, Robert Elsie met him. Elsie first had sight of the Trial document that Robinson had brought to the UK, in 1996, thanks to Bejtullah Destani, Director of the Centre for Albanian Studies in London. The two most powerful men at the Trials were Koçi Xoxe, the President of the Tribunal described by Robinson as ‘a short, fat man’, and Bedri Spahiu, described by Robinson as a ‘small, monkey-like man’. Little would they have known at the time that their own fates would become similar to those of the men for whom they brought such terminal violence. Xoxe was executed in 1949 and Spahiu fell from favour after 1955 and spent most of the rest of his life in prison or in internment, freed in 1990, eight years before he died. There is an extremely useful section at the end of the book devoted to biographical details of individuals mentioned in various of the trials, including some of the accused. This greatly enhances, not only the interest of the book, but also its value as a very accessible reference resource for further research. Robert Elsie is not only a prolific writer, but also a prolific publisher, having edited and produced another six books in just a few months this year. These may all be viewed at tp://www.elsie.de/news.html and are also available on Amazon. (Prices vary between $l5–$30). Antonia Young 7 Central and Eastern European Review Vincent W. J. van Gerven Oei, ed., Lapidari, Punctum Books: Brooklyn and Tirana, 2015, 280pp. ISBN: 9780692350461. The publication of this book coincides with what appears to be a sudden awakening in Albania of the potential both to acknowledge the gruesomely oppressive period of its history, and thus to develop an advantageous exploitation of that history through tourism. This realisation of potential was also promoted through a conference in Tirana on 23rd May, 2015 concerning the possible transformation of Spaç prison into a museum. This notorious political prison and forced labour camp in the remote mountain region of Mirdite has been pillaged and vandalized for 25 years, but there are now moves to preserve it, both in order to educate Albania’s youth, and also to restore some dignity to those who died there as well as those who have survived tormented incarceration there. The current dual-language first volume (of three), Lapidari, brings together writing on the topic both from the oppressive communist period (1945–90), and recent analyses from different perspectives. This volume includes several illustrations of lapidars as they relate specifically to the ten written chapters.