Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (Final) Part 4 of 4
October 2018
THA: Chonburi Power Plant Project
Prepared by Gulf SRC Company Limited for the Asian Development Bank.
The environmental and social impact assessment report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the Term of Use section of this website. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. CHAPTER 6
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 6 Sriracha Power Plant Project Analysis of Alternatives
CHAPTER 6 ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
The analysis of alternative has been conducted for the proposed project as follows:
6.1 POWER PLANT (1) Criteria for Location Selection: The reasons for alternative consideration of the project implementation within Chon Buri and Rayong Provinces are mainly due to high electricity demand of the provinces and the target area located is in vicinity of Bangkok, the national economic centre. The advantages of such location for the provinces and for the entire nation are as follows: Majority of the Small Power Producers (SPP) are mostly located in the area of Industrial Estate or Industrial Park, where high electricity demand from industries in the area exists. Insufficient electricity in the Industrial area may cause black-out or electricity shortage which directly affects the industries, and local people. All of the Independent Power Producers (IPP) supply their electricity to EGAT to help maintaining national power stability. In order to conduct the project implementation with least impacts on the environment and make feasible the design and investment, the consideration of project site location alternatives is an extremely important procedure. Meanwhile, the Office of the Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning has specified the concept for studying alternative location of project site which is a process for initial screening for marking decision to choose the most suitable location of the project area. However, the project implementation may cause direct impacts to environmental quality and any vulnerable environmental parameters such as air quality, water quality, and community etc., during construction and operation periods. Those impacts may result in concerns about wastewater quality and air quality. Thus, the project site location selection must be thoughtfully conducted to prevent and mitigate any impacts to community and its environment. In addition, the selected location must possess feasible engineering, construction and maintenance as well as appropriate investment. Accordingly, the criteria of the project location consideration are specified as follows: Mainly utilize the areas of the industrial parks to mitigate impacts on people’s land use Avoid historic areas or archaeological sites Located in the areas with energy network or natural gas pipeline Have feasible engineering for both construction and maintenance
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61022-Chap6 Page 6-1 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 6 Sriracha Power Plant Project Analysis of Alternatives
Have enough basic infrastructure to support the need of the project Cause the least impact on sensitive environmental areas such as communities, religious places, schools, governmental offices and hospitals Avoid the areas specified in the attachment of the Notification of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment as specific conservative areas which have been protected by laws. The project location selection has been conducted based on the above mentioned criteria. The selected project site is in the area of the Hemaraj ESIE which has been developed to support and facilitate industrial plants with provided basic infrastructure facilities. Furthermore, the environmental impact assessment report of the Hemaraj ESIE was amended the project description and was approved by the Office of the Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning as indicated in the official letter No. TorSor 1009.3/10241 dated August 26, 2015. Moreover, further consideration on other related issues can be summarized as follows: According to a consideration on laws of city planning and prescription on future land use of Chon Buri and Rayong Provinces, the project location is not included in the boundary of the Comprehensive Master Plan. In addition, the location of the project is within the area which has been specifically developed for industry. Hence, this mitigates any impacts on community and other areas. According to a consideration of areas with energy network or natural gas pipeline, the location of the project is near the natural gas pipeline of the Petroleum Authority of Thailand (PPT) Co., Ltd. (Public). Additionally, the project location is near the electricity transmission line of the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand. (2) Criteria for Fuel Selection: Natural gas is an extremely important source of energy in terms of reducing environmental pollution. Thus, the use of gas turbines and steam turbines are accepted as major source of electricity generation. Particularly high efficiencies can be achieved through combining gas turbines with a steam turbine in combined cycle mode. Natural gas burns cleaner than other fossil fuels, such as oil and coal, and produces less carbon dioxide per unit energy released. For an equivalent amount of heat, burning natural gas produces about 30% less carbon dioxide than burning petroleum and about 45% less than burning coal. Combined cycle power generation using natural gas is thus the cleanest source of power available using fossil fuels, and this technology is widely used wherever gas can be obtained at a reasonable cost.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61022-Chap6 Page 6-2 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 6 Sriracha Power Plant Project Analysis of Alternatives
(3) Criteria for Technology Selection: According to the project location consideration coupling with the project development friendly to environment and community for sustainability, the project has adopted the criteria for alternative consideration defined by the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (ONEP) to appraise alternative methods of the project implementation. So, factors adopted by the project for consideration on methods of project implementation are as follows: (a) Electricity Generation Technologies Currently, electricity generation technologies are divided into 3 main types and the details of each alternative power plant are as follows: Fossil Fuel Power Plant Recently, fossil fuel power plant is mostly utilized. This power plant is a system of devices for the conversion of fossil fuel energy to mechanical energy that drives electric generator. Fossil fuel power plant can be divided by types of machinery as the following:
Steam Turbine Power Plant A principle of steam turbine power plant is to boil water to become superheated steam at extremely high temperature and high pressure in order that the steam drives the steam turbine connecting to an electric generator for generating electricity. After the steam expands through the turbine, it exits the turbine, then, it is cooled and condensed back to water in the cooling system. This condensate is then pumped to the boiler for boiling in order that steam repeatedly drives the steam turbine.
Combined Cycle Power Plant Combined cycle power plant is more efficient than steam turbine power plant because the combined cycle power plant has 2 steps for transmitting heat energy to mechanical energy. An additional part of the combined cycle power plant, which is more than steam turbine power plant, is a gas turbine. Commonly used fuel is natural gas or diesel oil. At first step, natural gas or diesel oil will be injected into combustion chamber, generating hot gas with high pressure exhausts. The hot gas will drive gas turbine; consequently, it produces two-third of energy. Hot gas which passes through gas turbine is still high in temperature. Consequently, it can be used for boiling water (Heat Recovery Steam Generator). Then, vapor is used for driving gas turbine and generating one-third of energy. This type of power plant is commonly found in Thailand such as Rayong, Wang Noi and Kheang Koi 2 power plants.
Gas Turbine Power Plant Gas turbine power plant is composed of gas turbine which is similar to a combined cycle power plant, but without boiler. However, hot gas exhausted by the gas turbine is discharged without reuse. Accordingly, producing cost of this power
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61022-Chap6 Page 6-3 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 6 Sriracha Power Plant Project Analysis of Alternatives plant is high if it uses diesel oil as fuel. However, producing cost of the power plant will be a little cheaper if it uses natural gas as fuel. This type of power plant will be operated only during high demand of electricity because it can be rapidly started as well as stopped. However, the efficiency of this power plant is lower than that of a steam turbine power plant and that of a combined cycle power plant. This power plant is low in efficiency, nevertheless, electric generating system still needs this power plant to generate electricity during short period of peak electricity demand. The gas turbine will stop generating electricity when electricity demand becomes low. Currently, gas turbine power plants in operation are such as Lan Krabue Power Plant, Surat Thani Power Plant, Wellgrow SPP2 Rayong Province power plants, etc.
Diesel Engine Power Plant Diesel engine power plant uses diesel engine as a source of energy. This type of power plant is small in size, and electricity producing cost is high. Currently, in Thailand, this type of power plant is no longer used excepted for the power plant of the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand in Mae Hong Son Province. Besides, industries or big building often has emergency generator when the main generator is out of order. This emergency generator uses diesel engine to generate electricity. Hydro Power Plant Principle of hydro power plant is to store water at high level by constructing dam connected to water pipe lining down to the hydro power plant at lower level. The water flowing through the pipe at high pressure directs through a turbine to generate electricity. The hydro power plant generates electricity without gas emissions such as nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, etc. In addition, the hydro power plant has no cost of fuel for generating electricity. Besides, water discharged from the process of electric generating can be used for consumption and irrigation. Hydro power plants in Thailand are such as Bhumibol Hydro Power Plant, Sirikit Hydro Power Plant, Srinakarin Hydro Power Plant and Lamtakong Jolabha Vadhana Hydro Power Plant, etc. Alternative Power Plant
Wind Power Plant Wind power plant or wind turbine is classified as alternative energy by using only wind as a source of energy to generate electricity. Thus, a location of the plant is mainly located in an area where strong wind could be expected for the whole year. Recently, this type of the power plant is not popular and needs further development. A wind power plant is currently operating at Laem Phromthep, Phuket Province with capacity of 192 kilowatt (kW), West Huay bong 2 and 3 wind power plant, Dan Khun Thot District Nakhon Ratchasima Province with capacity of 103.5 MW.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61022-Chap6 Page 6-4 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 6 Sriracha Power Plant Project Analysis of Alternatives
Solar Cell Power Plant Solar cell power plant is classified as alternative energy similar to wind power plant. Electricity generation will be by placing sets of solar cells on the roof or open areas for receiving sunlight as much as possible. As a result, the electricity is direct current, so it cannot be used with electric equipment in household. Direct current electricity must be converted to alternating current prior to the uses. The generated power can be transmitted via transmission lines of the Metropolitan Electricity Authority and Provincial Electricity Authority. In conclusion, to provide the power generation of 2,5เเ MW net capacity to the reliability level required by the power purchase agreement throughout the power purchase agreement term of 25 years, the fossil fueled power plant is therefore considered for this project. Of all the fossil fuel alternatives, the natural gas is selected as primary fuel for this project since natural gas, when compared with other fossil fuel, results in the least GHG per kWh generated. For technology used for power generation using natural gas, the large gas turbine combined cycle is selected as it provides the best efficiency compared with smaller gas turbine combined cycle, or reciprocating engine, or thermal power plant with steam turbine only. The best efficiency selected (b) Controlling Technology Air pollution which arises during the operation period of a combined cycle power plant is a result of fuel combustion activity during the operation of gas turbine (Combustion Turbine). The main contaminant of air pollution is nitrogen oxides (NOx). Volume of nitrogen oxides will be more or less depending mainly on nitrogen oxides control technology of gas turbine. Nitrogen oxides is produced from the combustion where nitrogen reacts with oxygen during combustion process. Nitrogen is derived from two sources: atmospheric nitrogen and fuel-bound nitrogen. Most nitrogen oxides are derived from combustion of atmospheric nitrogen (called Thermal NOx); meanwhile, nitrogen oxides which comes from fuel-bound nitrogen is little especially when there is small amount of nitrogen in natural gas or diesel oil. Thus, a developed technology of nitrogen oxides control is mainly for controlling nitrogen oxides from combustion of thermal NOx. This project selected Dry Low NOx (DLN) technology to control nitrogen oxides derived from using natural gas as fuel of electricity generation. In addition, water injection technology will be used to control nitrogen oxides arising from using diesel oil as fuel. Dry Low NOx combustor technology can better control occurrence of nitrogen oxides in accordance with principle that the lower temperature of combustion, the less occurrence of thermal NOx. This Dry Low NOx combustor technology is designed to mix fuel with air before combustion (Lean Premix) resulting in lower temperature than
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61022-Chap6 Page 6-5 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 6 Sriracha Power Plant Project Analysis of Alternatives using diffusion combustor technology. In diffusion combustor, fuel is directly injected into the air combustion causing higher temperature of combustion. Thus, combustion at lower temperature results in decreasing of nitrogen oxides. The water injection technology which the project selected to use to control nitrogen oxides arising from using diesel oil as fuel can better control occurrence of nitrogen oxides in accordance with principle that the lower temperature of combustion, the less occurrence of thermal NOx as mentioned above. Injection of water manages to decrease temperature from diesel oil combustion and reduces the occurrence of NOx. Moreover, the project will install Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) to further reduce nitrogen oxides from the combustion. The exhaust gas from the combustion chamber of gas turbine using Dry Low NOx Combustor (in case of natural gas) or Water Injection (in case of diesel) technology shall contain low levels of nitrogen oxides. The hot gas will also be treated with the SCR to further reduce nitrogen oxides. The principle of the SCR is to inject ammonia into the exhaust, the resultant catalytic reaction will convert nitrogen oxides into nitrogen gas and water without emitting any pollution from said reaction.
6.2 NATURAL GAS PIPELINE Criteria for Natural Gas Pipeline Route Selection: The study on alternative alignment of the natural gas pipeline to Sriracha Power Plant to link with the PPT pipeline was carried out by mean of preliminary survey in combination with investigation from aerial photograph of the area. The alignment must fulfill the objective of the Project development. Apart from this, the construction activities must have minimum effect to the environment and the local communities. The selection criteria are as follows: Avoid the local communities, or being as far as possible. Easy access and easy construction techniques. Utilize mainly on government land in order to minimize impact to private land. Not in Historical area / archaeological site or antiquities. Not in conservation area according to the law and the Cabinet Resolutions; e.g. conservation forest and protected watershed, etc. The alignment should avoid passing through surface water source and road, to minimize impacts on utilization of those resources. The alignment should primary base on the existing transportation route, to benefit from the ROW of the road. The alignment should be as short as possible, and feasible in terms of both engineering and construction. Avoid the risk area, and enforce strict safety standard.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61022-Chap6 Page 6-6 CHAPTER 7 INFORMATION DISCLOSURE, PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS AND PARTICIPATIONS
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
CHAPTER 7 INFORMATION DISCLOSURE, PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS AND PARTICIPATIONS
7.1 INTRODUCTION Public participation is the process in which the public or stakeholders have opportunities to exchange views and opinions to find appropriate and mutually acceptable options and decisions about the project. All concerned parties should have opportunities to participate in this process from the beginning as to reach understanding, learning, and modifying the project together to benefit all parties. The consultant has carried out the participatory activities during the EIA study on the basis of transparency and consistency in provision of project information. The communities were provided with opportunities to express their opinions, needs, and their worries about potential problems and obstacles from the project development. The collected information from concerned stakeholders will be used to develop the project to meet the locals’ requirement. The process of public participation was based on the concepts of two-way communication aiming at achieving a good understanding which will be helpful for the project development in the future.
7.2 OBJECTIVES
To clearly disseminate accurate project information to local people, relevant agencies and stakeholders. To obtain the opinions and understanding of local people, relevant agencies and stakeholders. To involve local people, relevant agencies and stakeholders in the beginning stage of the project development for making clear understanding about the project. To involve local people, relevant agencies and stakeholders in reviewing the adequacy of prevention and mitigation measures, and monitoring programs proposed by the project. To evaluate opinions and acceptances of the local people, relevant agencies and stakeholders toward the project and take them into consideration for further operation planning.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-1 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
7.3 APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY (1) Target Area The study on the environmental impact of Sriracha Power Plant in the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate (Hemaraj ESIE) covers the 5 km radius from the project area. However, the public relations and public participation activities will give opportunity to all sectors beyond the 5 km radius of the Project to participate. (2) Target Group Target groups or the stakeholder of the Project consist of 7 groups in accordance with the guideline on public participation and the social impact assessment in the environmental impact analysis of the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (2014). In this Project, the target groups within the 5 km radius of the project area as shown in Figure 7.3-1 are as follows: Affected persons including people who will gain benefits and people who will be affected by the operation of the Project; Organizations responsible for preparation of the report on the environmental impact assessment; Organizations responsible for consideration of the report on the environmental impact assessment; Related government agencies at the provincial, district, and sub-district levels in the study area; Private environmental organizations, private development bodies, local educational institutions, higher educational institutions, and independent scholars; Mass media; Interested general public.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-2 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
FIGURE 7.3-1: NEARBY COMMUNITIES SITUATED WITHIN THE 5 KM RADIUS FROM THE PROJECT AREA
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-3 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
7.4 OPERATIONAL COURSES
7.4.1 Public Relations Activities Public relations activities of Sriracha Power Plant Project of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. focuses on creating a better relationship between community and the company in regard to the Project. The publicity of information focuses on transparency, creating an understanding of the development process by using appropriate types of media and publicizing methods to create a public goodwill towards the Project. Sufficient volume of public relations materials will be distributed to reach all levels of the target groups with news and to update the material as the study progresses. The public relations materials will be revised to reflect the progress of the study and will be distributed to the target groups that participate in the public hearings at all stages and to households that have given the socio-economics information. The public relations materials will also be used to build wider awareness, covering all target groups.
7.4.2 Public Participation Activities The course of the public participation activities of the Project must conform to the framework of the constitution, rule and regulations. Consideration must also be given to the tactics of communication between the people who are responsible in the Project and the public, the participation, and the administration of the Project in an integrative manner as follows: (1) Constitution of the Kingdom of Thailand B.E. 2550 in regard to the right to information and complaints under Sections 56, 57, and the right of community under Section 67 which specifies the right of the people in the area to receive the information about the Project from government sector, includes the public hearing and stakeholder prior to the operation. Section 56 A person shall have the right to get access to public information in procession of a State agency, State enterprise or local government organization, unless the disclosure of such information shall affect the security of the State, public safety, interests of other persons which shall be protected or private information by law. Section 57 A person shall have the right to receive information, explanation, and reason from State agent, State enterprise or local government organization before permission is given for operation of any project or activity which may affect the quality of environment, health, and sanitary conditions, the quality of life or any other material interest concerning him or her or a local community and shall have the
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-4 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations right to express his or her opinion on such matters to agencies concerned for consideration in that matters. Section 67 The right of a person to participate, in conjunction with the State and communities, in the conservation, preservation, and exploitation of natural resources and biological diversity and in protection, promotion and preservation of quality of environment for normal and sustained survival in the environment which causes no harm to his or her health, well-being or quality of life, shall be protected as the case may be. (2) Regulation of the Office of the Prime Minister on Public Hearing B.E.2548 indicates that government sector which is responsible for a project must publicize the information about the Project to the public prior to operation of the Project and conduct a public hearing using appropriate means. Regarding the public hearing, the announcement of the government agency must be affixed no less than 15 days in advance to notify public of the hearing venue. After the public hearing, the conclusion of the public hearing must be prepared and publicized within 15 days. Should it show that the development of the Project will cause serious impact but the operation must continue, additional preventive measures must be introduced and publicized for the public awareness. (3) The guideline on public participation and the social impact assessment in the environmental impact analysis of the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (2014) indicates that the Project owner must conduct public hearing at least twice. The 1st public hearing will be staged at the beginning of the Project. The 2nd public hearing will be staged during the preparation of the draft report and the environmental impact prevention and mitigation measures using appropriate technical methods. Result of the public hearings must be considered during assessment of impacts and considered whether there are solutions to the problems and how. Then, environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures as well as appropriate monitoring measures will be proposed. All of these must be proposed as a part of the environmental impact assessment in the operational framework.
7.5 STEPS AND ACTION PLAN
7.5.1 Steps (1) Collection of Related Information The process of collection of related information for the study of the background and environmental conditions of the Project for the assessment of the situation together with the socio-economics study consist of the following:
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-5 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Study the information of the Project such as the rationale and characteristics of the Project, the development steps of the Project, and the environmental impact assessment plan. Review of the related documents such as the brief report of Chon Buri and Rayong Provinces and the brief report of the sub-district administration organizations (SAO) and the sub-district municipalities (SM) in the study area. Survey and study of the communities as a step of the preliminary examination on the list of communities, population, lifestyles, occupations and the characteristics of communities. Make observations and forecasts on both the positive and negative impacts which may occur by considering the relationship and compatibility between the information of the Project and the overall socio-economics conditions of the communities. Approach for consultation with representatives of governmental organization/leaders of community to create an initial understanding and search for the ideas of community which can be used for an appropriate public relations activities and the public hearing procedure of the communities. (2) Analysis of the target groups (stakeholders) The specification of the target groups includes people who receive positive and negative impacts during the construction period and operation period based on the stakeholder classification methods of the Environmental Impact Evaluation Bureau and the principle of inclusiveness. There are 7 main groups as shown in Table 7.5-1. (3) Production of media release for public relations and the publicity Media for the public relations is an important instrument in the publicity of the information of the Project, the promotion of knowledge and understanding to the target groups about the rationale of the Project, and helps the public relations to reach the objective of the Project. Media used in the Project include as follows: Instructional Media. This media emphasizes on the creation of target groups’ −nowledge and understanding which will lead to the acceptance of the development of the Project. This media includes the personal media, power point presentation, and supporting document for the meeting. Motivation Media. This media is produced for the target groups to receive knowledge about the activities in the operation of the Project, stimulates cooperation in the participation in activities. This media includes a notice board of the program/location of the public hearing, and invitation to participate in the public hearing.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-6 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.5-1 CLASSIFICATION OF STAKEHOLDERS RELATED TO THE PROJECT Classification of Stakeholders Stakeholders related to Stakeholder Groups Composition of the Group the Project แ. Affected Persons The affected persons Community leaders and local The beneficiaries people within the study area of the project including 6 SAOs and 1 SM as follows: Khao Khansong Sub-district Si Racha District, Chon Buri Province - Moo 4 Ban Khao Khansong - Moo 5 Ban Surasak - Moo 7 Ban Rawoeng - Moo 8 Ban Map San Suk - Moo 9 Ban Huai Ta Klao - Moo แเ Ban Chao Phraya Bowin Sub-district, Si Racha District, Chon Buri Province - Moo 7 Ban Nong Kang Pla Khlong Kio Sub-district, Ban Bueng District, Chon Buri Province - Moo 5 Ban Muen Chit - Moo 6 Ban Som - Moo 7 Ban Map Lambid Nong Suea Chang Sub-district, Nong Yai District, Chon Buri Province - Moo 5 Chaloem Lap Ta Sit Sub-district, Pluak Daeng District, Rayong Province - Moo แ Ban Khlong Kram - Moo 2 Ban Khao Rakhang - Moo 3 Ban Nong Kangkao Pluak Daeng Sub-district, Pluak Daeng District, Rayong Province - Moo 4 Ban Wang Ta Phin - Moo 5 Ban Wang Khayaeng Chomphon Chao Phraya SM, Pluak Daeng District, Rayong Province - Chomphon Community - Chao Phraya Community Related enterprises Nong Pla Lai Fisherman group
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-7 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.5-1 (Cont’d) CLASSIFICATION OF STAKEHOLDERS RELATED TO THE PROJECT Classification of Stakeholders Stakeholders related to Stakeholder Groups Composition of the Group the Project 2. Organizations responsible Project proponent Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. for preparation of the Corporation having rights to TEAM Consulting Engineering and report on the environmental prepare environmental Management Co., Ltd. impact assessment impact assessment report 3. Organizations responsible Organization considering Office of Natural Resources and for consideration of the environmental impact Environment Policy and Planning report on the assessment report (ONEP) environmental impact Organization granting Office of Energy Regulatory assessment permission Commission region 8 4. Related government Government agencies in Provincial government agencies of agencies at the provincial, the central, regional and Chon Buri and Rayong Province district, and sub-district local levels such as Governor and representatives levels in the study area of Provincial Office of Natural Resources and Environment, Provincial Industry Office, Office of Provincial Energy, Provincial Fisheries Office, and Provincial Public Health Office, etc. District government agencies of Si Racha District, Ban Bueng District, Nong Yai District, and Pluak Daeng District such as representatives of District Public Health Office, District Agricultural Extension Office, and District Community Development Office, etc. Sub-district government agencies within 5 km radius from the project area (comprises 6 Sub-district and แ SM including Khao Khansong, Bowin Sub-district, Nong Suea Chang Sub-district, Khlong Kio Sub-district, Ta Sit Sub-district, Pluak Daeng Sub-district, and Champhon Chao Phraya SM) such as Mayor/Chief Executive of SAO and representatives of Tambon Health Promoting Hospital in the study area
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-8 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.5-1 (Cont’d) CLASSIFICATION OF STAKEHOLDERS RELATED TO THE PROJECT Classification of Stakeholders Stakeholders related to Stakeholder Groups Composition of the Group the Project 5. Private environmental Educational institutions Representatives of educational organizations, private Religious place institutions within the study area development bodies, such as Khlong Kram School, Child local educational Development Center of Chomphon institutions, higher Chao Phraya SM and Ban Rawoeng educational institutions, School, etc. and independent scholars Representatives of temples in the study area such as Wat Chomphon Chao Phraya, Wat Khlong Kram and Wat Rawoeng Rangsan, etc 6. Mass media Mass media in the central Local newspapers such as Khao and local levels Chon, Siam news, CH Post, etc. Local mass media such as reporters of CTV, Thairath TV and TMN Cable, etc. 7. Interested general public Public interested in the Interested public not having to be project who will play a within the study area. role as observers. Source : TEAM Consulting Engineering and Management Co., Ltd, 2015
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-9 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Follow-up Media. This is the media which helps in a broad publicity of the progress of pro∑ect’s activity to the section of the public that did not participate in the activity. This media consists the conclusion of the public hearing which will be posted on the public relations board of the related governmental agency. Event Media. This form of public relation is conveyed through specified activities and participations in the current community’s activities include visits to a natural gas power plant, distribution of public relation leaflets to households, and participations in the activity of communities, organizations, and youth. (4) Arrangement of public relations activities and public participation (a) Public relations activities The public relations activities of Gulf Group of Companies for Sriracha Power Plant Project emphasizes the corporate social and environmental responsibility as an ongoing effort. The public relations activities consist of 2 main activities as follows: Power Plant Visit with the objective of creating an understanding of the power generating procedure and the management in connection with the environment. Social and Public Relations Activities with the objective of creating a benefit for the communities in the study area of the Project and to attract the public to participate in the operation of the Project will be done in various formats which conform to the needs of the communities such as sports sponsorship, personnel development seminar, festival, activities for children/disable children and underprivileged persons. (b) Public participation activities The public participation activities must follow the guideline on public participation activities in accordance within the framework of the constitution, rules and regulations as previously mentioned with details of activities as follows. st The 1 public hearing at The beginning of the Project” aims to give information to the public and related organizations on the development of the Project and on potential positive and negative impacts including the scope of study on the environmental impact by arranging the meeting for public hearing. The information presented in the meeting includes: - Rationale and objective of the Project. - Preliminary information of the Project such as the Project proponent, location of the Project, production procedure, initial management with regard to the environment, and project development plan. - Scope of the environmental impact study and public participation activities.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-10 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
nd Hearing of Fisherman Group prior to the 2 public hearing aims to give information to the fisherman group on the development of the Project and potential positive and negative impacts including the scope of study on the environmental impact by arranging the meeting. The information presented in the meeting includes: - Rationale and objective of the Project. - Preliminary information of the Project such as the Project proponent, location of the Project, production procedure, initial management with regard to the environment, and project development plan. - Result of the study on the water quality. nd The 2 public hearing during Preparation of the draft report” aims to build public confidence on the result of the study and the draft the environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures. The presented information includes: - Summary of the project description. - Results of environmental impact study including results of existing environmental survey and results of environmental impact assessment. - Draft the environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures. - Results of public participation activities including opinion of agencies and local people toward the project development, and involving the opinion of local people in environmental impact study. rd The 3 public hearing To present the changed project details” aims to build public confidence on the result of the study and the draft the environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures. The presented information includes: - Summary of the changed project details description. - Results of environmental impact study including results of existing environmental survey and results of environmental impact assessment. - Draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures. (5) Activities Evaluation and Analysis The Project will monitor all activities by taking note, taking still and motion pictures, and interviewing participants in activity. The conclusion will be taken into consideration for the improvement of the public relations method and the public participation operations as well as to specify environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures that are appropriate, practical and accepted by all concerns.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-11 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
7.5.2 Operational Plan (1) Survey the communities and the study area The survey of the communities and the study area will be done prior to the public hearing in order to study the conditions of the vicinity of the Project site, study and observe the social conditions, the main occupations of the people in the communities, compatibility of lifestyles and the occupations of the people in the communities to the public relations format and the public hearing activities, and factors obstructing and promoting the development of the Project. The results will be used to specify the format of public relations media, public relations plan, and public participation activities. (2) Public Relations Media Production Plan The consultant produced various types of public relations media as a tool to assist in building appropriate understanding of the situations. The material will be continuously updated as the study progresses. The quantity will be sufficient for distribution to all related parties. Media will be as follows: (a) Instructional Media comprises as follows: Personal Media consist of the study team from the consultant’s company and personnel of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Their mission includes explaining, clarifying, communicating with the target groups to help them understand the Project, publicizing information, meeting to discuss and explain information about the Project, arranging public hearing activities, coordinating with the related government agencies, community leaders, and the local informants during the study period in order that the operation would reach objective of the Project. Power Point Presentation and audio-visual media will be used to present the details of the Project through computer equipment and projectors so that participants understand the Project. The material will be revised to reflect the changing objective and the work progress. Meeting Documents Printed material will be distributed to participants of the meetings. The content includes details of the Project, rationale and objective, scope of study, approach of the assessment of the environmental impacts, the results of the study, and the draft the environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures. Printed material will be tailored to meet the objective of each meeting for distribution to the participants of the public hearings. (b) Motivation Media consists of the following: Notice of meetings will give details on the date and the venue of the public and stakeholder hearings. The notice will be posted on at the public relations board of related government agencies where the public can conveniently access.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-12 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Meeting invitation letters will be dispatched to the target groups to invite them to participate in the public hearings. (c) Follow-up Media consists of the following: Notice of conclusion of the public hearings give details on the date and the venue of the public and stakeholder hearings and the conclusion of the hearings. The notice will be posted on at the public relations board of related government agencies where the public can conveniently access. Evaluation Form will be distributed to collection information regarding the participants’ −nowledge and understanding and to obtain opinions of the participants. This will also be a channel to learn useful suggestions, concerns and impacts on the stakeholders. (d) Event Media consists of the following: Field Trip for the community to visit the natural gas power plant. This will directly promote the awareness and experience of the communities in the power plant vicinity. It will also create understanding in the process of power generating, fuel usage, and safety measures which should help reducing possible concerns about the Project. Participation in Activities of Communities such as the traditional religious ceremony of communities in the study area in order to create acquaintance, ask about the concerns, and explain and clarify various doubts during these activities. (e) Public Relations Plan of the Project The public relations to create an understanding of the communities within the radius of the study area of the Project will use various forms of activity. The objective is to create the right understanding about the development of the natural gas power plant. This activity should result in better understanding for the community regarding rationale and necessity to develop the Project. In order to make sure that the public relations activity was complete and comprehensive, the Project thereby conducted public participation activities and provided support to community activities within the radius of the study area of the Project and in the vicinity including field trip to the natural gas power plant. The time of field trip depended on the request from the communities. (3) Public Hearing Plan In order to listen to the opinions of the public and the stakeholder and to make sure that the process was complete and covered all target groups within the study area and in the vicinity with sufficient information, the public has sufficient knowledge and understanding of the study procedure, and accept the rationale and the necessity for the development of the Project, the consultant has made the following action plan (Table 7.5.2-1) :
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-13 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.5.2-1 SUMMARY OF PUBLIC PARTICIPATION ACTIVITY PLAN Number of Activity Activity Description Schedule Participants (Person) st st th The 1 Meetings with 1. The 1 Meetings with Related Between 24 691 th Related Government Government Agencies: To introduce June – 8 July Agencies the project and discuss about the 2014 project details with provincial/ district/local government agencies st st th th The 1 Public 2. The 1 Public Hearing with 21 July – 7 1,435* Consultation with people and related parties at sub- August 2014 People and Related district level to define the EIA Parties scope Survey of Socio- Survey of Socio-Economic Between 675 Economic Conditions Conditions and Opinions about 8 th -11 th and Opinions about the Project Development: September 2014 the Project individual interview/survey to and 3rd-23 th Development inquire about people’s anxieties, February, 2015 comments, and opinions about the project development nd th The 2 Meetings 3. The hearing of the related 12 February 29* nd with Consultation fisherman group prior to the 2 2015 with fisherman group Public Hearing with fisherman group which utilizes the Nong Pla Lai Reservoir nd nd th th The 2 Meetings 4. The 2 Meeting with Related 25 -29 May 1,691* with Consultation Government Agencies and 2015 with People and people and related parties at Related Parties sub-district level : To present details of the project environmental study results and draft environmental impact prevention and mitigation measures, and to solicit recommendations about the public consultation with people and related parties
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-14 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.5.2-1 (Cont’d) SUMMARY OF PUBLIC PARTICIPATION ACTIVITY PLAN Number of Activity Activity Description Schedule Participants (Person) The 3rd Meetings with 5. The 3rd Public Hearing to present 4th April 2018 598* Consultation with the change project detail: To People and Related present details of the changes in Parties project details and environmental study results and draft environmental impact prevention and mitigation measures, and to solicit recommendations about the public consultation with people and related parties Remark : * The number of participants does not include staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and of consultant company
(a) Consultation and meeting with heads of government agencies was an important activity in the early period of study. The objective was to search for information and explore the opinions of people who were important to the development of the Project as well as to get acquainted and to do the initial public relations work, and to consult on the important issues regarding problems, obstacles, and suggestions on the conduct of activity. Interviewees and focus group included members Governor of Chon Buri Province, Governor of Rayong Province, District Chief of Si Racha District, District Chief of Ban Bueng District, District Chief of Nong Yai District, Deputy District Chief of Pluak Daeng District, Director of Provincial Office for Natural Resources and Environment of Rayong, Director of Provincial Energy office of Rayong, Chief of Khao Khansong SAO, Chief of Bowin SAO, Chief of Pluak Daeng SAO. This activity was conducted during 24 June – 8 July 2014. (b) The 1st Public Hearing on the scope of study of the environmental impact with objective of giving information such as the rational and necessity of the Project, details and characteristic of the Project, the benefits and the impacts and welcoming stakeholders to participate in specifying the scope and course of study of the environmental impact of the Project in 8 stages in different areas during 21 July – 7 August 2014. (c) Survey of Socio- Economic Conditions and Opinions about the Project Development This activity is another channel for gathering opinions of people living within the radius of 5 km from the project area. The survey was conducted with 675 people during 8 th -11 th September 2014 and 3rd-23 th February, 2015. Survey details and methods are presented in Item 4.4.1 Socio-Economics in Chapter 4.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-15 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(d) The hearing of opinions of the fisherman group prior to the 2nd public hearing with objective of giving information to the related fisherman group and presenting the result of the study of the quality of water for the fisherman group’s awareness and to enable them understand the procedure of the Project thus reducing concerns about the impact to the livelihood of the fisherman group on Friday 12 February 2015. (e) The 2nd Public Hearing to present the result of the study and the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures aimed to present the result of the study and listen to the opinion on the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures of the Project. This activity also gave the opportunity to the stakeholders to participate in the review of the draft report and suggested additional measures to increase the sta−eholders’ confidence in the measures. The suggestions were included as a part of the report. This activity was conducted in 9 stages in different areas during 25 -29 May 2015. (f) The 3rd Public Hearing to present the changed project details: Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. has taken into consideration all stakeholders involved in the The Sriracha Power Plant project especially the communities surrounding the power plant area. To provide information concerning the changes in project details to the surrounding communities, Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. scheduled to a meeting and public hearing session to receive feedback from the communities concerning the changes in details of the environmental impact assessment report of Sriracha Power Plant Project. This activity was conducted in 2 stages in different areas during 4 April 2018.
7.6 RESULT OF THE OPERATION
7.6.1 Public Relations of the Project (1) Corporate Social Responsibility of Gulf group of companies in the past The corporate social responsibility activities of the Gulf Group of Companies on Sriracha Power Plant Project was conducted under the policy to show the continuous responsibility to the community, the society, and the environment for the benefits of the communities in the study area and to enable them to participate in the operation of the Project. This was conducted in various formats of activity which conformed to the needs of the communities such as support for sports, personnel development training, traditional festival, activity for children/disable children and underprivileged persons.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-16 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Regarding activity in order to return benefit to society in the past, Gulf Group of Companies assigned personnel to survey the conditions of the area, meet community leaders to listen to their opinions, and ask about the needs and necessities of communities. Alternatively, the communities initiated projects and suggested them through the community leaders to Gulf Group of Companies for consideration whether it would be appropriate to sponsor or participate with the communities. The summary of ongoing activities since 2011 is shown in Table 7.6-1. The atmosphere of activities is shown in Photo 7.6-1.
TABLE 7.6-1 CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ACTIVITIES CONDUCTED IN THE STUDY AND VICINITY AREA DURING 2011-2018 Type of Supported Activities Activities Operation Period Traditional and cultural festival Buffalo racing festival August Loy krathong festival November-December Sweet pineapple festival April Songkran festival April Education and sport Sub-district sport day August Personnel development training August Motocross grand prix May Sub-district sport day May Training for the village health volunteer September and the civil defense volunteer of all sub-district in the study area National children’s day January Environment Planting to increase green area for all December sub-districts in the study area Nong Pla Lai reservoir closing ceremony May for spawning season Religious The conquest of drug addiction by December dharma camp Sub-district Kathin and offering ceremony October-November The ceremony of mounting the gable- January finial Candle procession festival August Source : Gulf SRC Co., Ltd., 2018
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-17 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
SAO relations activity at the sport field of Motocross grand prix of Pluak Daeng SAO Ban Pluak Daeng SM
Support for Kathin ceremony Activity on national father’s day of Map Yang Phon Sub-district at Ta Sit SAO
Activity on national children’s day 2012 Training for village health volunteers at Chomphon Chao Phraya SM at Khao Khansong SAO
PHOTO 7.6-1: CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ACTIVITIES CONDUCTED BY GULF VTP CO., LTD. DURING 2011-2018
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-18 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Support for activity on national mother’day Activity on national children’s day at Bowin SAO at Nong Suea Chang SAO
Support for Kathin Ceremony at Wat Rat Rueng Support for founding of Maha Janaka Center Suk (Map Lambid) Khling Kio Sub-district Pluak Daeng District
Support for sweet pineapple festival Participated in opening of self-learning Pluak Daeng District center of sufficiency economy at Pluak Daeng District
PHOTO 7.6-1: CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ACTIVITIES CONDUCTED BY GULF VTP CO., LTD. DURING 2011-2018 (Cont’d)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-19 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Nong Pla Lai reservoir closing ceremony for Activity on Songkran day spawning season
Pluak Daeng Sub-district sport day Activity on national children’s day
Activity on national father’s day Support for Kathin ceremony
PHOTO 7.6-1: CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ACTIVITIES CONDUCTED BY GULF VTP CO., LTD. DURING 2011-2018 (Cont’d)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-20 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(2) Field Trip to a natural gas power plant This activity aimed to create the learning process from a direct personal experience of the public target group and to create the understanding with one another which would be beneficial to the coexistence between the community and the Project. For this reason, a field trip to a power plant was arranged for the public in the vicinity of the Project and within the study area includes Si Racha District, Ban Bueng District, Nong Yai District of Chon Buri Province and Pluak Daeng district of Rayong Province with the objective of creating knowledge and understanding about the operation of power plant. A group of 648 participants were taken to visit Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2, Kaeng Khoi District, Saraburi Province during 8 November – 2 December 2015. Details are shown in Table 7.6-2.
TABLE 7.6-2 SCHEDULE AND NUMBER OF PARTICIPANT IN VISITING KAENG KHOI POWER PLANT 2 Number of Date Target Groups Participants (person) 8-9 November 2014 Khao Khansong Sub-district, Si Racha District, แ37 Chon Buri Province 13-แ4 November 2014 Khling Kio Sub-district, Ban Bueng District, Chon 87 Buri Province แ5-แ6 November 2014 Nong Suea Chang Sub-district, Nong Yai District, 9แ Chon Buri Province แ8-แ9 November 2014 Ta Sit Sub-district, Pluak Daeng District, Rayong 86 Province Chomphon Chao Pharaya Sub-district 74 Municipality, Pluak Daeng District, Rayong Province 28-29 November 2014 Bowin Sub-district, Si Racha District, Chon Buri 8เ Province แ-2 December 2014 Pluak Daeng Sub-district, Pluak Daeng District, 93 Rayong Province Total of Participants 648
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-21 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
To ensure the representatives of communities receive sufficient knowledge from the field trip, Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. arranged activities during the visit to the power plant and the natural gas pipeline system within the power plant. The participants viewed a video presentation and listened to briefing from the personnel of the Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2. The briefing included the information on background of Kaeng Koi Power Plant 2, the power generating process, the pollutant and water controls followed the generating process, the policy on the supervision of the environment and the conduct of the community relations activity. Additionally, stage was opened for participants to ask questions and the representatives of the Project including environment unit, community relations unit, personnel of Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2 jointly answered all questions. During the conduct of various activities, participants had questions on various issues both during the briefing in the meeting room and during the visit to the power plant and the natural gas pipeline. The representatives of Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2 explained, clarified all questions until participants understood the power generating process. More field trips would be arranged in the future in order that people in communities would have the knowledge about the power generating process throughout. This would greatly reduce the concerns about the development of the Project. The atmosphere of the power plant visit is shown in Photo 7.6-2.
7.6.2 Public Participation Activities The main public participation activities are as follows: (1) Consult representatives of related government agencies; (2) The 1st Public Hearing (meeting to listen to the public opinions regarded the scope of study and the course in environmental impact assessment); (3) Hearing of the opinions of the fisherman group (who utilized Nong Pla Lai Reservoir) prior to the 2nd Public Hearing; (4) The 2nd Public Hearing (meeting to listen to the public opinions regarded the study result and the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures). (5) The 3rd Public Hearing (meeting to listen to the public opinions regarding the changes in project details).
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-22 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
PHOTO 7.6-2: THE EXAMPLE PHOTO FOR VISITING KAENG KHOI POWER PLANT 2 (VISITED DURING 8 NOVEMBER - 2 DECEMBER 2015)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-23 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
The conclusions of the public participation in each activity were as follows: (1) Meet and consult with the related government agencies The project met with representatives of government agencies both on the provincial and district levels as well as participated in meeting with the chiefs of government agencies both in the district and sub-district levels with the objective of providing information about the Project and cooperating the public hearing and receiving suggestions the Project. These activities can be concluded as follows: (a) Meeting with representatives of government agencies on the provincial and district levels The consultant met with representatives of government agencies on the provincial and district levels including provincial governors, district chiefs, and related chiefs of government sectors on the provincial level during 19 June – 7 July 2014. Details are as shown in Table 7.6-3. (b) Meeting with chiefs of government agencies on the district and sub-district levels Meeting with chiefs of government agencies on the district and sub- district levels was arranged during 24 June – 8 July 2014. Details are as shown in Table 7.6-3. The types of media used were power point presentation and description as well as public relations document of the Project (the public relations document of the Project as presented in Appendix 7A-1). The opinion and suggestions received during the meetings are shown in Table 7.6-4. The photo of the atmosphere of the meeting and the participation are shown in Photo 7.6-3 and Photo 7.6-4.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-24 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-3 MEETING WITH REPRESENTATIVES OF GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE PROVINCIAL AND DISTRICT LEVELS AND CHIEFS OF GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE DISTRICT AND SUB-DISTRICT LEVELS Number of Date Types of Activity Location Representative (person) แ9 June 2014 Meeting with Si Racha District Chief Si Racha District Office แ 2เ June 2014 Meeting with Governor of Rayong Rayong Government แ Province Administrative Center 23 June 2014 Meeting with Director of Chon Buri Chon Buri Energy Office แ Energy Office 23 June 2014 Meeting with Senior Deputy District Pluak Daeng District แ Chief of Pluak Daeng District Office 24 June 2014 Meeting with Chiefs of government Si Racha District Office 25เ agencies of Si Racha District 25 June 2014 Meeting with Nong Yai District Chief Nong Yai District Office 4 แ July 2014 Meeting with Ban Bueng District Chief Ban Bueng District Office 2 2 July 2014 Meeting with Chiefs of government Pluak Daeng District แ34 agencies, Sub-district headmen and Office village headmen of Pluak Daeng District 2 July 2014 Meeting with Chiefs of government Ban Bueng District Office 25เ agencies of Ban Bueng District 7 July 2014 Meeting with Director of Rayong Provincial Office of 2 Environmental Section of Rayong Natural Resources and Provincial Office of Natural Resources Environment and Environment 7 July 2014 Meeting with Director of Rayong Wang Noi District Office แ Energy Office 7 July 2014 Meeting with Rayong Provincial Office of RIL Industrial แ Industry Office Estate 8 July 2014 Meeting with Chiefs of government Nong Suea Chang SAO 43 agencies, Sub-district headmen and village headmen of Nong Suea Chang District
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-25 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-4 OPINIONS AND SUGGESTIONS RECEIVED IN MEETING WITH THE CHIEFS OF GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE PROVINCIAL AND DISTRICT LEVELS Opinions and Suggestions Environmental Measures of the Project (Draft) Governor of Rayong Province Public Participation Aspect The public hearing arrangement should be done - at an appropriate time such as after a new government was formed or the Project should inform the area representative of The National Council for Peace and Order (NCPO) (in this case, it was the Military Circle 14). District Chief of Si Racha District Public Participation Aspect There should be a support for the development - of the Project because of the increase of demand for power in the area. It is expected that the construction will have no impact because the location is far away from the community. Director of Chon Buri Provincial Energy Office Public Participation Aspect - Disseminate information and news and Because Sriracha Power Plant will use natural gas publicize details of the project to the local as fuel, it should reduce the community protest. communities in various channels and forms, In any case, relationship with the community such as, brochure, media or other activities should be developed in order to create alliance consistent with the objectives of such to support the Project. measures. Be open for the community to participate in the monitoring of the project throughout the project duration. - Be open to feedback from the community regularly and continuously. - Develop good relationship with local government agencies and people in the communities through regular meetings and visits. Be ready to solve any problems or disturbance that may be caused by the project. Impact from the Project - Propose the environmental impact mitigation During the construction period, the Project owner and preventive measures and environmental and the contractor must be cautious about impact monitoring measures for air quality, potential impact on air, noise, transportation, noise, transportation, and health/occupational and accidents. During the operation period, the health and safety. The details of mentioned Project must monitor the operation to ensure it measures are presented in Chapter 9 is in accordance with the measures presented to Environmental Action Plan. Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (ONEP).
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-26 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-4 (Cont’d) OPINIONS AND SUGGESTIONS RECEIVED IN MEETING WITH THE CHIEFS OF GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE PROVINCIAL AND DISTRICT LEVELS Opinions and Suggestions Environmental Measures of the Project (Draft) Senior Deputy District Chief of Pluak Daeng District Public Participation Aspect Public Hearings should focus on sub-district and - Disseminate information and news and village levels and ensure that the hearing covers publicize details of the project to the local all stakeholders. Comparative study of the communities in various channels and forms, impact should be done in the format that is easy such as, brochure, media or other activities to understand. consistent with the objectives of such measures. Be open for the community to participate in the monitoring of the project throughout the project duration. - Be open to feedback from the community regularly and continuously District Chief of Nong Yai District Public Participation Aspect The study of the impact from the Project and the - Be open to feedback from the community communication with the community should be regularly and continuously. done in a straight forward manner in order to - Develop good relationship with local government create a good relationship with the community. agencies and people in the communities through regular meetings and visits. Be ready to solve any problems or disturbance that may be caused by the project. District Chief of Ban Bueng District Public Participation Aspect The project should cooperate with government - Develop good relationship with local government agencies and communities throughout the life of agencies and people in the communities the Project, and to return benefits to through regular meetings and visits. Be ready communities and create Power Development to solve any problems or disturbance that may fund. be caused by the project. Note: It is required that Power Development Fund committees in designated areas be established to manage the Fund in each - Help and support activities in the communities area. The Committee, comprising: representatives of the as appropriate to build good relationship, general public sector, representatives of the government sector; and Experts/Advisors. and as a mean to return benefits to the Authority and Duties of Fund Committee in Brief; 1. Determine areas of eligible Fund beneficiaries. community and the society. 2. Formulate and propose a strategic plan, an annual work plan and a money allocation plan. 3. Encourage and support a survey on power plant operation impact to help formulate proposals to improve a designated area. 4. Encourage a survey on the needs of local residents and power plant operation impact to serve as input for the formulation of community projects. Director of Environment Section, Rayong Provincial Office of Natural Resources and Environment Impact from the Project The presentation of the conclusion of the study - should be made to the government agencies and
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-27 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-4 (Cont’d) OPINIONS AND SUGGESTIONS RECEIVED IN MEETING WITH THE CHIEFS OF GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE PROVINCIAL AND DISTRICT LEVELS Opinions and Suggestions Environmental Measures of the Project (Draft) communities so they know that there will not be many changes to the current condition after the development of the Project. The presentation should not show only the comparison to the standard. Rayong Provincial Energy Office Public Participation Aspect The project must strictly keep its promises to the - communities. Rayong Provincial Industry Office Impact from the Project The project should mainly emphasize on the - study of the environmental impact and create the communities’ awareness of the study. Public Participation Aspect The public hearing should have a precise format. - Participants must register to attend.
(2) The 1st Public Hearing (meeting to listen to the opinion of the public on the scope of study and the approach to environmental impact assessment). The objective of the 1st Public Hearing at The start of the Pro∑ect was to provide information about the development of the Project and potential positive and negative impacts, the scope of study of the environmental impact to the public and related organizations. This was arranged on 8 stages in different areas during 21 July – 7 August 2014. The total number of 1,435 people (excluding the personnel of the Project owner and the consultant) participated as shown in Table 7.6-5. Participants consisted of community leaders, local residents who may be affected, establishments in the area, related government agencies on the sub-district level, educational institutions, the local mass media, and people who were interested in the Project. As for the related government agencies on both provincial and district levels, the consultant sent a request for a meeting to explain details of the Project and to listen to their opinions. This activity was conducted in conjunction with the socio-economics survey. The details and results are shown in Chapter 4 under Section 4.4.1 Socio-Economics. The list of the target groups which participated in the 1st meeting is shown in Table 7.6-6. The name list of participants in the 1st meeting is shown in Appendix 7A-2. Meeting documents of the 1st meeting are as shown in Appendix 7A-3. The questionnaire is as shown in Appendix 7A-4.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-28 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Governor of Rayong Province District Chief of Si Racha District
District Chief of Ban Bueng District District Chief of Nong Yai District
Senior Deputy Distirct Chief Director of Environment Section, Rayong of Pluak Daeng District Provincial Office of Natural Resources and Environment
Director of Chon Buri Provinceial Energy Office Director of Factory Section, Rayong Provincial Industry Office PHOTO 7.6-3 : THE EXAMPLE PHOTO OF MEETING WITH REPRESENTATIVES OF GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE PROVINCIAL AND DISTRICT LEVELS (CONDUCTED DURING 19 JUNE – 7 JULY 2014)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-29 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Si Racha District Pluak Daeng District
Nong Suea Chang SAO
PHOTO 7.6-4: THE EXAMPLE PHOTO OF MEETING WITH THE CHIEF OF GOVERNMENT AGENCIES ON THE DISTRICT AND SUB-DISTRICT LEVELS (CONDUCTED DURING 24 JUNE – 8 JULY 2014)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-30 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-5 SCHEDULE FOR THE 1st PUBLIC HEARING Date Location and Time Number of Participants (Person) Monday 2แ July 2014 Meeting room of Khling Kio Sub-district แ8แ Kindergarten School during เ9.3เ a.m. to แ2.เเ Tuesday 22 July 2014 Meeting room of Ta Sit SAO แเเ during 1.เเ p.m. to 3.เเ p.m. Wednesday 23 July Multi-purposes Building of Khao Khansong 385 2014 SAO during เ9.3เ a.m. to แ2.เเ Multi-purposes Building of Chomphon Chao 322 Phraya SM during 1.3เ p.m. to 3.3เ p.m. Thursday 24 July 2014 Multi-purposes Building of Bowin SAO แ64 during เ9.3เ a.m. to แ2.เเ Friday 25 July 2014 Meeting room of Pluak Daeng SAO แ98 during เ9.3เ a.m. to แ2.เเ Thursday 7 August 2014 Meeting room of Office of Eastern Seaboard แ9 Industrial Estate (Rayong) during แ.เเ p.m. to 3.เเ p.m. Pavilion for older person at Ban Chaloem Lap 66 during 5.3เ p.m. to 7.3เ p.m. Total of 8 stages 1,435 Remark : The number of participants does not include staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and of consultant company.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-31 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-6 TARGET GROUPS PARTICIPATING IN THE 1st PUBLIC HEARING Classification of Stakeholders Number of Participants (Person) 1. Affected persons within 5 km radius from the project location - Community headman 69 - Local people แ,เ95 - Related enterprises แ9 2. Organizations responsible for preparation of the report on the environmental impact assessment - Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. แแ - TEAM Consulting Engineering and Management Co., Ltd. 6 3. Organizations responsible for consideration of the report on the environmental impact assessment - Office of Natural Resources and Environment Policy and Planning - (ONEP) - Office of Energy Regulatory Commission region 8 - 4. Related government agencies - Agencies at provincial level - - Agencies at district level - - Agencies at sub-district level 2เ8 5. Private environmental organizations, private development bodies, local educational institutions, higher educational institutions, and independent scholars - Educational Institutions แ8 - Independent Commission on Environment แ3 6. Mass media แเ 7. Interested general public 3 Total of Participants 1,452 Remark : The number of staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and of TEAM Consulting Engineering and Management Co., Ltd. was counted only 1 time (1 stage).
Prior to the 1st public hearing, the Project sent invitations to the target groups (sample of the invitation to the 1st meeting is as shown in Appendix 7A-5) and posted a notice of the hearing on the public relations boards in public places at no less than 15 days before the meeting date. This was done during 2-3 July 2014 as shown in Photo 7.6-5 (sample of the 1st public relations announcement is in Appendix 7A-6). The atmosphere of the 1st meeting is as shown in Photo 7.6-6.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-32 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Rayong Provincial Hall Si Racha District Office
Pluak Daeng Hospital Ban Nong KangKao Tambon Health Promoting Hospital
Nong Yai District Agricultural Extension Community Headman Office Office at Chomphon Chao Phraya SM
PHOTO 7.6-5: THE EXAMPLE OF PHOTO ON POSTING NOTICES OF THE HEARING st BEFORE THE 1 PUBLIC HEARING (CONDUCTED DURING 2-3 JULY 2014)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-33 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Khling Kio Sub-district Ta Sit Sub-district
Khao Khansong Sub-district Chomphon Chao Phraya SM
Bowin Sub-district Pluak Daeng Sub-district
The enterprises within Hemarag ESIE and Nong Suea Chang Sub-district Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate (Rayong)
ST PHOTO 7.6-6: THE EXAMPLE PHOTO ON THE ATMOSPHERE OF THE 1 PUBLIC HEARING (CONDUCTED DURING 21 JULY - 7 AUGUST 2014)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-34 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(a) Opinions and Suggestions from the participants of the 1st meeting The meeting to listen to the opinions and suggestions of the participants gave the opportunity for the participants to express their opinions through 2 channels: 1) expression of opinions on the stage of meeting; and 2) filling in the questionnaire. The questions, concerns, suggestions and explanations classified by target groups, the opinions and suggestions to be used in preparation of the measures for the operation of the Project are summarized in Table 7.6-7. (b) Conclusion on the opinions of the participants of the meeting based on the questionnaire of the 1st meeting. After the hearing through questioning on the stage, the consultant asked for cooperation from the participants to fill in the questionnaires. The number of participants who expressed their opinions through questionnaires was 1,352 or equaled to 94.2 % of 1,435 participants (excluding the personnel of the Project owner and the consultant). The questionnaires are summarized as follows: (Appendix 7A-7). Awareness of Information relating to the Project: The majority or 77.1 % of all participants were aware that Sriracha Power Plant Project of Gulf SRC Company Limited was situated in the area of Hemaraj ESIE, Khao Khansong Sub-district, Si Racha District, Chon Buri Province. Around 19.5 % just learned about this with 3.4 % gave no comment. Details are as shown in Figure 7.6-1. The questionnaire respondents felt that public relations on the Project should be announced through community leaders, government agencies, and group sessions to listen to opinions.
No comment Hear about it 3.4% first time 19.5%
Heard about it 77.1%
FIGURE 7.6-1 : AWARENESS OF INFORMATION RELATING TO THE PROJECT
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-35 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups st th th th th Issue Question/Recommendation 1 4 Group 5 Group 6 Group 7 Group Participants Giving Opinion Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Plan Group Details of the Project แ. What will be the production capacity of Khlong Kio Sub-district Medical Installation capacity of the Project is 2,65เ Megawatt, with 2,500 the power plant of the Project? Practitioner megawatt in the sale agreement with Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT). 2. Where will be the source of the 63,000 Khlong Kio Sub-district Medical The Project will be located in Hemaraj ESIE. All public utilities m3/day of water use? Practitioner such as the water supply, wastewater, and electricity will be People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- supplied by the estate as agreed prior the land sale agreement. district Representative of enterprises 3. Does the 450 rai of land for the Sriracha People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- The 450 rai of land for Sriracha Power Plant Project does not Power Plant Project include the land which district include the land area of the 2 nearby small power plants, which was owned by the 2 small power plants. are also located in Hemaraj ESIE. 4. Whether or not the previous explanation Village health volunteer of The small power plants Project which was previously explained on the 2 small power plants and the Moo 4 Ta Sit Sub-district and Sriracha Power Plant Project are different projects. The 2 current explanation on Sriracha Power small power plants Project with the initial production capacity of Plant are for the same project? 125 megawatt and to be increased to 137 megawatt in the future had the objective to sell to EGAT and partly to other entrepreneurs in the estate. Sriracha Power Plant will be a big power plant with the production capacity of 2,650 megawatt to sell solely to EGAT in order to promote the stability of the nation’s energy. 5. Whether or not the 2 small power plants Village health volunteer of The 2 small power plants Project have plans to be constructed and Sriracha Power Plant will be Moo 4 Ta Sit Sub-district in 2015 while Sriracha Power Plant has a plan to be constructed constructed at the same time? in year 2018. 6. What will Sriracha Power Plant use as fuel Ta Sit Sub-district headman Sriracha Power Plant will use natural gas as the main fuel for the in the production of power? production of power and will use diesel as the backup fuel in case of natural gas shortage. The reserve of diesel will be enough to run the plant for 2-3 days. 7. According to the plan, Sriracha Power Ta Sit Sub-district headman Sriracha Power Plant Project has been developed under the plan Plant will be constructed in year 2561 to develop the power production capacity of Thailand for 2010- (A.D.2018). Why arrange the meeting to 2030 (PDP2010) which specifies that there must be new power listen to opinions now? Can the plants in accordance with the plan to create stability of the construction start sooner? nation’s energy. Presently, the Project is under the phase of making report on the analysis of the environmental impact which will take 1 year for the study and get approval. After that, there will be steps in preparing the construction such as seeking all approvals needed from related government sections and hiring a contractor before the actual construction can begin.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-36 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Details of the Project 8. Will it be possible that coal be used as Village health volunteer of Machine of the power plant is designed to use natural gas as (Cont’d) fuel in the future although natural gas was Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub-district the main fuel and diesel as the backup fuel. It cannot operate specified as fuel in the agreement? with coal as fuel. Besides, the sale agreement with EGAT indicated that natural gas will be used as the main fuel. Therefore, coal cannot be used. 9. Will the waste water from the Project be Deputy Chief of Khao The Project will be located in Hemaraj ESIE. Therefore, the released into the treatment system of the Khansong SAO waste water of the Project will be released to the estate to estate or a public canal? manage. The Project is required to treat waste water in accordance with the standard before releasing it to the estate. The Project incorporates information from the study in the surface water action plan. แเ. How will the Project handle with the People in Moo 4 Khao The Project will be located in Hemaraj ESIE. Therefore, the waste water and solid waste? Khansong Sub-district waste water of the Project will be released to the estate to manage. But the Project will initially treat it in accordance with the standard before releasing it to the estate. As for the solid waste and the general garbage, they will be sent to the local units to handle. As for the industrial waste, it will be sent to the organization licenced by the Department of Industrial Works for disposal. แแ. Where will be the location of Sriracha People in Chomphon Chao Sriracha Power Plant will be located in a 450 rai open area of Power Plant? Phraya SM Hemara∑ ESIE between East Sugar Co., Ltd.’s Community School Interested general public and Chomphon Chao Phraya Temple. แ2. Why increase the number of power plants People in Chomphon Chao Sriracha Power Plant Project is under the plan to develop the in this area? Phraya SM power production capacity of Thailand for 2010-2030 ( PDP 2010) which indicated that there must be new power plants in accordance with the plan to give the stability to the energy of the nation because currently, many power plants have operated to the expiry dates of their agreements and must be shut down. At the same time, the energy demand of the nation is on the rise. New power plants must replace the old power plants, especially in Chon Buri Province and Rayong Province because of the industrial growth in these provinces. Therefore, the demand for energy is also on the increase in these provinces. That is the reason for locating Sriracha Power Plant in this area.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-37 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Details of the Project แ3. Buffer Zone between the Project and Director of public health Because the power plant Project is in the estate, the estate (Cont’d) communities should not be limited to the division of Chomphon Chao itself has to have barrier as being reported in EIA. On the part wall of the Project. Phraya SM of the Project, green area has been specified. But at present, the design for the area is in the planning stage and details are not yet clear. However, green area in a form of a rubber plantation or a public park may be considered in order to reduce the impact on the scenery. The Project will specify measures in respect to green area and scenery. แ4. Will Sriracha Power Plant sell electricity to Community development Sriracha Power Plant will be a large power plant or a base power other establishments? volunteer of Bowin Sub-district plant. It will be a power generating base of the nation. It will generate and sell power solely to EGAT. It is different from the small power plants with the capacity of 100 megawatt which will add the stability to the system as well as selling electricity, steam or cold water to other private organizations. แ5. Does the Project have an emergency People in Moo 7 Bowin Sub- The Project will study emergency which may occur in all plan? district scenarios and consider the area of impact. It will also specify People in Moo 5 Nong Suea the emergency plan and emergency drills with outside agencies Chang Sub-district every year. The Project incorporates information from the study in the occupational health, safety and environment plan. แ6. When will Sriracha Power Plant be Chief of Pluak Daeng SAO Sriracha Power Plant will be constructed in year 2018. The constructed? construction period will be 40 months. It is expected to be completed and able to generate power into the system in year 2021. แ7. What is the layout of the Project and the Advisor to the Chief of Pluak Details are still in the designing stage. It will be presented in the components therein? Daeng SAO 3nd meeting. แ8. What is the size of the green area of the Advisor to the Chief of Pluak The Project specified the size of green area to be 5 % of the Project? Daeng SAO project area. Perennial trees will be planted along the fence of the project area. It is currently in the planning stage and details will be presented in the next meeting. The Project incorporates information from the study to the green area and scenery action plan.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-38 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Details of the Project แ9. Does the Project have an air filter system People in Moo 4 Pluak Daeng The Project is designed to use natural gas as the primary fuel (Cont’d) for emission from the stack? Sub-district and diesel as the backup fuel. The power generating system is separated from the air pollutant eliminating system. The Project is in the process of selecting an appropriate technology to reduce the impact on the air. Details will be presented in the 2nd meeting. The Project incorporates information from the study to the air quality action plan. 2เ. If the natural gas become unavailable in Vice Chairman of Pluak Daeng The plant is designed to use natural gas as fuel. It cannot use the future, will other fuels be used in the SAO Council other fuels. Besides, under the sale agreement with PTT, it generating of electricity? specified that PTT will supply the natural gas to the power plant throughout the Project agreement. 2แ. How much natural gas will be used? Is it Representative of enterprises in The daily volume of natural gas to be used is not yet known safe and what impact will it have? the estate because the technology is still under study and design. The gas pipeline meets the international safety standard. Besides, the Project has an emergency plan, a fire prevention plan, and an emergency drill every year. For the impact from the use of natural gas as fuel, there will be assessment on the impact on air by using a mathematical model to predict the impact. This will be presented in the next meeting. The Project incorporates information from the study to the occupational health, safety and environment action plan 22. How high is the emission stack of the Representative of enterprises in The height of the stack will be determined after completion of Project? the estate the study of the air quality in the studied area at present and when the plant becomes operational. The air quality value must not exceed the specified level. If the current value is already high, the Project will design a technology which will reduce the rate of pollutant emission or find an appropriate alternative. This will be presented in the next meeting. The Project incorporates information from the study to the air quality action plan. 23. What is the quantity of diesel to be People in Moo 4 Pluak Daeng Both the volume of the diesel and the size of the storage tank reserved for the Project and where will it Sub-district are still not known because the study and design are still in be kept? People in Moo 5 Nong Suea progress. In any case, the volume of diesel stored will be Chang Sub-district sufficient for 2-3 day usage.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-39 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Details of the Project 24. For what situations will diesel which is the Chairman of Nong Suea Chang Diesel will be used in 2 cases namely (แ) In case where natural (Cont’d) backup fuel be used? SAO Council gas cannot be used. The quantity of diesel in storage is sufficient for 2-3-day usage and (2) Testing & Commissioning of the system by using diesel to measure the efficiency for a few hours. In all cases, things will be done under the instruction of EGAT. Impact from the operation แ. Request for the Project to supervise the People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- The Project will take this into consideration. of the Project impact on water because there is water district The Project incorporates information from the study to water shortage although there are many usage action plan. reservoirs in Pluak Daeng District. 2. Whether or not the heat from the plant Village health volunteer of The heat from the Project will be released from a stack with will have impact on the rubber, pineapple Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub-district the height of no less than 40 m. The heat will flow and mix with of farmers in the area? Will the Project be Deputy Chief of Khao the atmosphere and will not be felt at the ground level. Power able to specify the direction of heat? Is Khansong SAO plant projects of Gulf Group of Companies which have already there a way of observation? People in Moo 4 Bowin Sub- been in operation such as Yala Green Power Plant and Nong La district Lok Power Plant have never received any complaint about the impact on rubber plantations. Anyway, the Project will consider additional measures such as using satellite pictures to check the heat from the Project both in dry and rainy seasons. The Project incorporates information from the study to the heat monitoring action plan. 3. Will the cooling water from the Project Chief of Nong Suea Chang SAO The impact from the release of cooling water of the Project is when released into the water source have Deputy Chief of Khao under study by both the estate and the Project. However, an impact on the tap water system? Khansong SAO according to the operation of the power plants in the past such as Kaeng Koi Power Plant 2 which has Nile Tilapia fish in floating baskets and a tap water system beyond the release point of cooling water received no impact from such release. The Project incorporates information from the study to surface water quality action plan. th 4. Whether or not the impact on the Chaloem Phra Kiat of 60 The Project will do the traffic counts at present and use them communication and transportation system Anniversary Celebrations of His as the benchmark for the assessment of impact during the from the Project during the construction Ma∑est’s Accession to the construction period and operation period of the Project. This period has been assessed in advance for throne Health Center will cover the 40 months of the construction period. year 2018 and during the 40 months of construction?
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-40 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group th Impact from the operation 5. How will the Project supervise the people Chaloem Phra Kiat of 60 The Project will specify the measures for the supervision of of the Project (cont’d) who will come into the area during the Anniversary Celebrations of His construction workers both in the construction area and worker construction so there will be no impact on Ma∑est’s Accession to the camp in order to minimize the socio-economics impact on the the socio-economics of the communities? throne Health Center communities. The Project will study the impacts and present the measures in the second meeting. The Project incorporates information from the study to the socio-economics action plan. 6. Is the chemical of the power plant People in Moo 4 Ta Sit Sub- Chemical which will be used in the power plant Project is the dangerous should it leak out like it did at district same as the chemical used in water treatment plant. The Laem Chabang Deep Sea Port? Community development chemical will be stored in the project area. The Project will volunteer leader of Bowin Sub- assess the danger from such leakage and present in the 2nd district hearing. People in Chomphon Chao The Project incorporates information from the study to hazard Phraya SM action plan. 7. It’s recommended that a supervisory Community development The Project will specify the measures for the supervision of committee on foreign workers be formed. volunteer leader of Bowin Sub- construction workers both in the construction area and the There are concerns about the problem district work camp in order to minimize the socio-economics impact on that they may bring to the communities. the communities. The Project will study the impacts and present the measures in the 2nd meeting. Besides, the Project will form a committee to monitor the impact from operating the power plant. Such committee will have the representatives of the public in majority. This should create the public confidence in monitoring of the impact. The Project incorporates information from the study to public relations and public participation action plans. 8. There are concerns about the particulate Community development Because Sriracha Power Plant will use natural gas as the primary matter arisen from the operation of volunteer leader of Bowin Sub- fuel in heating water to generate electricity, the impact from project. district the particulate matter will be small when compared to using other types of fuel such as coal or biomass. 9.How will the Project manage the impacts Chief of Nong Suea Chang SAO The Project is in the process of studying these impacts and will nd from operating the power plant such as the Advisor to Chief of Pluak Daeng present them in the 2 hearing. The courses of managing the air quality, waste water, solid waste, noise, SAO environment are as follows. accident and safety, communication and People in Chomphon Chao Air quality: Project will specify that an emission monitoring transportation, and foreign workers? Phraya SM system be installed at the top of the emission stack. The People in Moo 7 Bowin Sub- reading will be shown on the monitor screen at the front of the district power plant for the communities to audit.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-41 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Impact from the operation Waste water: Most of the waste water of the Project is the of the Project (cont’d) cooling water. Project has a clarifier to reduce the temperature of the water and monitor the water quality prior to release it to the estate. Solid waste: General garbage will be sent to the local organization for disposal. The industrial solid waste will be sent to the organization licenced by the Department of Industrial Works for disposal. Noise: The noise at the fence of the Project must not be higher than 70 dB(A) by standard and this will be monitored both in the construction area and communities during both the construction period and the operation period. Accident and safety: The Project evaluated the hazard by collection of statistics from all over the world and will use the information to create a model to assess the impact. Besides, emergency plans for serious incidents were drawn up with an emergency drill in coordination with external parties annually. Communication and transportation: There will be traffic counts at present time and will be used as the benchmark for the assessment of impact during the construction period and operation period. Immigrated Foreign workers: Measures were specified for the supervision of construction workers of the Project both at the construction site and the worker accommodation in order to minimize the impact on the socio-economics of the communities. The Project incorporates information from the study to the action plans for air quality, noise, surface water quality, groundwater, management of solid waste, communication, hazard, and occupational health and safety. แเ. Request for the Project to consider the Director of Public Health Presently, the Project is conducting a study on the potential impacts as follows. Division of Chomphon Chao environmental impact. Collection of samples of the Transportation Aspect. Because the Phraya SM environment such the air quality, surface water quality, roads in the area have only 2 lanes, groundwater, sound level, aquatic ecology, and traffic counts there are concerns about the traffic are being made. The information will be used in the congestion. environmental impact assessment if the Project is developed. The Project will present the conclusion of the study and related measures in the 2nd hearing.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-42 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Impact from the operation Concerns that particulate during the The Project incorporates information from the study to the of the Project (cont’d) construction period will affect the action plan for transportation, air quality, surface water quality, nearby temples and schools. groundwater quality, noise, and public health and occupational Whether or not the waste water from health and safety. the Project will have any impact on the living organism and the public in the vicinity? What measures will the Project have on the noise impact on the nearby temples and schools? There should be an appropriate layout of the Project such as the storage area for diesel. The emergency plan of the Project must include the measure to inform temples and schools of an emergency. แแ. Were the wind directions considered in People in Moo 6 Bowin Sub- The consultant has specified the location for measuring the the environmental impact assessment on district environmental quality which considers the main wind air quality? directions. The information will be used as the database of the assessment of the impact on the air quality. The conclusion will be presented in the 2nd meeting. แ2. The volume of water used by the Project Assistant Pluak Daeng Sub- The Project will be located inside Hemaraj ESIE, public utilities is 63,000 m3/day. There are concerns that district Headman such as water supply, waste water, electricity will be provided in the case of water shortage, there will be and managed by the estate as agreed before the land sale problem between the Project and agreement was reached. The estate will supply efficient communities in scrambling for water. amount of water for the Project throughout the agreement term. แ3. How will the Project control noises? Vice Chairman of Ban Pluak The Project will have measures to control noise from machines Daeng SM Council not to exceed the standard level of noise from machines (not to be higher than 85 dB(A) at the distance of 1 m from the source). Additionally, the level of noise at the fence of the Project must not exceed 70 dB(A). These will be monitored both at the construction area and communities in both the construction period and operation period. The Project incorporates information from the study to noise action plan.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-43 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Impact from the operation แ4. The environmental impact assessment of Pluak Daeng Sub-district The environmental impact assessment of the Project such as of the Project (cont’d) the of other projects state that their Headman the air quality assessment employs a mathematical model in values of indices are within specified Nong Suea Chang Sub-district conjunction with the data from on sources of impacts within a standards. However, it is believed that the Headman distance of 5 to 10 km from the project area of the plants which combined values of indices from all are already in operation includes the information on the release projects will exceed the standard. of air pollutant of these projects to find out whether the air quality around the project area is within the specified standard. If the value is higher than standard, the Project will adjust the technology to reduce the impact further. Presently, the study is progressing and the conclusion will be presented in the 2nd meeting. Besides, the Project will have Continuous emission monitoring systems (CEMS) at the top of the emission stack and a screen monitor will display the reading in front of the plant for the communities to audit. The monitoring will be done twice yearly through the life of the Project. แ5. If a power plant were to operate in this Interested general public in Most plants in Map Ta Phut are heavy industrial plants. Plants area, would it be an air pollution like what Pluak Daeng Sub-district in Hemaraj ESIE do not engage in activity which produces as happened to Map Ta Phut? much air pollution as in Map Ta Phut. Therefore, the impacts are different. The conclusion of the study will be presented in the 2nd meeting. แ6. How will the Project use diesel as the Representative of enterprises in Regarding the use of diesel as the backup fuel in generating backup fuel and what method will be the estate electricity, in case where natural gas is unavailable, the diesel used to assess the difference of the will be sufficient for 2-3 days. impact from using natural gas? The assessment method of the impact on the air quality from the use of diesel will be the same as the method that used of the natural gas. The pollutant emitted will be different because diesel will create more sulfur dioxide and particulate. Therefore, the design of the emission control system will be different. แ7. How will the air pollution treatment Representative of enterprises in The Project will select an appropriate technology to reduce the system of the power plant Project work on the estate air pollutant such as the Dry Low NOx Burner to reduce the the pollutant emitted from the stack? temperature in the combustion chamber and minimize the nitrogen dioxide. During the entire operation, the pollutant emission will be controlled at a lower level than specified standard level. The Project incorporates information from the study to the air quality action plan.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-44 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Impact from the operation แ8. It was recommended that the Project Teacher of Wat Chaloem Lap Because the Project will use natural gas as the fuel in producing of the Project (cont’d) should study the impact of pollutants School power, the main pollutant from it will be nitrogen dioxide. As from the power plant such as particulate for sulfur dioxide and particulate, the amount will be very small matter, nitrogen dioxide, and sulfur dioxide when compareก to other types of fuel. The assessment of the which will affect the public health as an impact of all pollutants is already in the scope of study of the international study showed its relationship impact on the quality of the Project. to the higher mortality rate. แ9. There are concerns about the quality of Chief of Nong Suea Chang SAO The impact of the Project is under study and will be presented the water sources because the waste in the 2nd meeting. water of the Project will go into Nong Pla The Project incorporates information from the study to the Lai Reservior and may create impact on a surface water and groundwater action plan. large area. 2เ. There are concerns that if more Chairman of Nong Suea Chang There is only one standard for the course of environmental developments of industry and power SAO Council impact assessment on the air quality. Besides that, there are plant occur, the accumulated impact will laws and various standards which will be in place to control the make it impossible for the communities to pollution. The public today is also strong and therefore new survive. projects must select appropriate and modern technologies to reduce the potential impacts in order to be able to coexist with the communities. Public relations and public แ. When the power plant becomes Member of Khlong Kio SAO The Project will have Continuous emission monitoring systems participation operational, how will we know that it will Council Moo 1 (CEMS) at the top of the stack to monitor the air pollutant not create impacts to the communities? emission and reports will be issued to Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand and the Department of Industrial Works which are the agencies that granted permission to the Project. Also, a monitor screen will be placed in front of the power plant for the communities to observe. The Project has specified that there will be monitoring of the ambient air quality of the communities around the project area every 6 months throughout the operation period. This is to monitor the impact on the air quality from the operation of the power plant. The Project incorporates information from the study to the air quality action plan.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-45 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Public relations and Public 2. It was recommended that the Project Mayor of Chomphon Chao The Project will take this into consideration and incorporate it Participation (Cont’d) provide a field trip to an operational Phraya SM in the measures. power plant by publicize about the field People in Moo 2 Ta Sit The Project incorporates information from the study to socio- trip through sub-district administrative Sub-district economics action plan. organization and Sub-district Health People in Moo 3 Ta Sit Promotion Hospital in the project area. Sub-district Interested general public Pluak Daeng Sub-district 3. What will the people who live within 5 km Teacher of Ban Surasak School The Energy Regulatory Commission requires that a Power radius of the power plant get from the People in Moo 4 Bowin Sub- Development fund for the area around the power plant be power plant? district established for the representatives of communities to manage. Assistant Pluak Daeng Sub- The power plant must make contributions to the fund from the district headman start of the construction period until the end of the Project. Representative of enterprises in Besides, the Project will directly support the activities of the the estate communities in culture, festival, and education through the life of the Project. The Project incorporates information from the study to the public relations and public participation action plan. 4.How can the communities know that the People in Moo 4 Khao The Project will have Continuous emission monitoring systems operation of the power plant will not have Khansong Sub-district (CEMS) at the top of the stack to monitor the air pollutant impact and if it did, how would the being emitted which will show the result on the monitor screen at Project take responsibility or assist? the front of the power plan for the communities to audit. If the operation of the power plant does cause impacts to the communities, the power plant will have to take the responsibility. Initially, the Power Development fund for the areas around the power plant will be able to resolve the trouble. The Project incorporates information from the study to the public relations and public participation action plan. 5. If the power plant created impact on the People in Chomphon Chao The power plant will have a designated unit in charge of communities, what will be the channels of Phraya SM approval of activities of the Project. This unit also has the power complaint or what organization is in charge to revoke the permission to operate should the power plant of the supervision? commits a wrongdoing. Besides, there are other channels for communities to complaint about the impact from the operation of the Project such as local government agencies, community leaders, and the committee to monitor the impact of the operation of power plant. The Project incorporates information from the study to the public relations and public participation action plan.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-46 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Public Relations and Public 6. It was recommended that the Project Mayor of Chomphon Chao The Project will take this into consideration. Participation (Cont’d) should consider the maximum return of Phraya SM benefit from the development fund to communities. 7. Because the site of the power plant Mayor of Chomphon Chao The Project will take this into consideration. Project is near Chomphon Chao Phraya Phraya SM The Project incorporates information from the study to the Temple and Chomchon Borisatnamtal public relations and public participation action plan. Tawan Aok School, assistance and support in the activities of the temples and schools should be considered. 8. Will the Project take care of this area just Director of Public Health Project will take care of the communities through the life of like before after the construction of the Division of Chomphon Chao the Project agreement. power plant is completed? Phraya SM The Project incorporates information from the study to the public relations and public participation action plan. 9. It was recommended that the Community development The Project will take this into consideration appointment of the committee of the volunteer leader of Bowin Sub- development fund for the area around the district power plant truly represents the public sector. แเ. It was recommended that prior to the Community development Project will set up a committee to monitor the impact from the construction period, a committee volunteer leader of Bowin Sub- operation of the power plant prior to the construction period comprising representatives of government district of the Project by mainly includes the public sector in order to agencies, the company and the Vice Chairman of Ban Pluak create a true community confidence in the monitoring of the communities be formed in order to Daeng SM Council impact. monitor the impact from the power plant Teacher of Wat Chaloem Lap The Project incorporates information from the study to the and the progress of the Project and inform School public relations and public participation action plan. the public accordingly. Chairman of Nong Suea Chang SAO Council แแ. It was recommended that after the Mayor of Ban Pluak Daeng SM The Project will make conclusion of the questions and meeting is completed, the Project should explanations and post it at related government sections in the inform the related agencies of the result studied area such as town hall, district office, sub-district of the meeting. administrative office, municipality office and the Sub-district Health Promotion Hospital for the public to know and check on the issue which was raised.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-47 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Public Relations and Public แ2. It was recommended that the Project be Editor of Khao Thai newspaper After the power plant becomes operational, there will still be Participation (Cont’d) conducted in sincerity to the communities public relations personnel to take care of the communities in the area. If the Project cannot keep its through the life of the Project. promises such as the establishment of the If there is any complaint on the operation of the power plant Power Development fund, what measure because the power plant did not follow the specified will be taken? measures, the penalty will include suspension of the permit or close down of the operation. As for the development fund for the area around the power plant, the regulatory agency is the Energy Regulatory Commission. The power plant only has the duty to pay into the fund. The fund will definitely have the supporting budget. แ3. It was recommended that pro and con of Interested general public in Impact of the Project is in the process of being study and will the Project be presented to the public. Pluak Daeng Sub-district be presented in the 2nd meeting. แ4. Will the Project inform the communities of Nong Suea Chang Sub-district Presently, the Project is under study. It is necessary to have the the rate in which pollutant will be headman result of the study of the current condition of air before the remitted from the power plant? prediction of the impact when the Project become operational can be done. Then the information will be used in the design of the rate of emission of the power plant. When combining the rate of emission of the Project with the current condition of the air which has already received impacts from other sources, the total impact on the communities must not exceed the specified standard. The information on the rate of emission will be presented in the 2nd meeting. The Project incorporates information from the study to the air quality action plan. Other issues แ. What is the meaning of the 7 consecutive Member of Khlong Kio SAO In the course of study of the impact of the air quality of the days of monitoring the air quality? Council Moo 1 power plant project, there must be the measure of impact on the air quality at 4 stations around the project area in 2 seasons depends on the wind directions in the area. Each measurement must be done for 7 consecutive days. 2. How will the measure of the air quality be Member of Khlong Kio SAO The measure of the air quality in the studied area around the done at station A4 (Rawerng Rungsan Council Moo 1 Project will give the information of the air quality at present Temple)? which will be used as the database for the environmental impact assessment. In case that the Project be implemented, it would be used to predict the impact by using a mathematical model.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-48 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Other issues (Cont’d) 3. If the present air quality from the measure Member of Khlong Kio SAO The Project will bring the information to consult with other is at a dangerous level to the Council Moo 1 organizations such as the public health, sub-district communities, what will the Project do? administrative organization to analyze and find the cause in order to plan and specify the technology of the Project to reduce the impact. There will be monitor screen at the front of the power plant to show the measurement. The Project incorporates information from the study to the air quality. 4. Will the Project plant trees (to People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- The Project will specify that the size of the green area be no compensate) or create a public area? district less than 5 % of the project area. Perennial trees will be planted along the fence of the project area. The Project incorporates information from the study to the green area and scenery. 5. It is evident that Gulf will have many more Village headman Moo 3 Ta Sit The Project will take this into consideration. projects of both small and large power Sub-district plants in the area of Pluak Daeng District. But presently, the area already experiences brownouts. Please look into it. 6. For what reason the measures of quality of Secretary to Chief Khao The selection of the points to measure the air quality must the Project are done at temple or school Khansong SAO consider the main wind directions in the area. The reason for but not at the communities? Also when Teacher of Wat Chaloem Lap selecting temple or school because communities are always the measures are done, the result should School near temple or school and can represent the communities. be explained to the public. The measures of the air quality are done in 2 seasons. The result will be presented in the 2nd meeting. 7. It was recommended that environment be People in Moo 4 Bowin Sub- The Project will take this into consideration. taken care after the power plant is district The Project incorporates information from the study to the operated. public relations and public participation. 8. Whether or not the Project will have the People in Moo 4 Bowin Sub- The Project will study impact on health and specified the study on the impact on health and specify district related measures. The result of the study will be presented in the preventive course? the 2nd meeting. The Project incorporates information from the study to the public health/occupational health and safety. 9. It was recommended the people who live People in Moo 7 Bowin Sub- The Project has the policy of giving priority to local hiring, within 5 km radius of the Project be hired district depending on the qualification of the applicants. by the power plant. The Project incorporates information from the study to the socio-economics.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-49 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Other issues (Cont’d) แเ. It was recommended that a public park or People in Moo 2 Bowin Sub- The Project will take this into consideration. health park be created near the power district plant in order to compensate the communities. แแ. It was recommended that a budget be Assistant village headman Moo The Project does not have the direct authority but will take given for the installation of public lighting 4 Khao Khansong Sub-district this into consideration and will support the related at various risk areas within 5 km radius of Community leader of Ban Eua organizations. the Project in order to prevent crimes. Arthon Pluak Daeng (Moo 4 Pluak Daeng Sub-district) แ2. It was recommended that monitor points Mayor of Ban Pluak Daeng SM The Project will take this into consideration. be set up in the area that receives the air The Project incorporates information from the study to the air pollutant in order to create confidence of quality action plan. the public in other areas. แ3. It was recommended that garbage be used Pluak Daeng Sub-district Presently, Gulf Group of Companies has already conducted a study as renewable source in the production of headman of various renewable energy sources. The result are as follows. electricity and to help the communities. Garbage: Need a daily volume of a few hundred tons of garbage and there is always resistance of communities on the location of such power plant. Wind: Need a large area for operation and the operation cost is high. Solar: Must find an appropriate area where the concentration of sun light is appropriate. Renewable energy gives low level of power production and is not sufficient for the support of the demand of power of the nation. แ4. It was recommended that the Project has Interested general public in The Project does not have the direct authority but will take this a plan to suppress narcotics. Pluak Daeng Sub-district into consideration and support the related authority. แ5. What is the route of the natural gas Representative of enterprises The Project is currently coordinating with PTT on the question pipeline to the power plant and how will in the estate of which pipeline of the system will be used to supply the the particulate from the construction be natural gas to the power plant. When the pipeline issue is controlled? clear, report of the analysis of the environmental impact of the gas pipeline Project must be done. The communities will be informed in the future.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-50 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-7 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 1ST PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to the Environmental Action Issue Question/Recommendation 1st Group 4th 5th 6th 7th Participants Giving Opinion Plan Group Group Group Group Other issues (Cont’d) แ6. Whether or not the criteria in selecting the Representative of enterprises Criteria in selecting the quality monitor points of the Project air quality monitor stations sufficient and in the estate come from the consideration of the prediction by using appropriate? mathematical model to indicate where in the communities/areas will have the maximum level of pollutant. Normally, the consideration will be given to the communities within the wind directions. แ7. What are the components of the natural People in Moo 5 Nong Suea The natural gas has the components of hydrocarbon. Carbon gas which will be used at the power Chang Sub-district has methane as the main component. plant? แ8. It was recommended that there should be Nong Suea Chang Sub-district The Project will take this into consideration. a mobile/ station to monitor the air headman quality as Map Ta Phut has for Nong Suea Chang Sub-district.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-51 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Regarding the opinions on the scope of study and the course of the assessment of the impact which were presented, about 62.1 % of the participants wanted further study of impacts on the issues such as the air quality, public health, water source, and living organism in the water while 37.9 % thought that the current scope of study was sufficient and no need for further study as shown in Figure 7.6-2.
No need for further study 37.9% Want further study of other impacts 62.1%
FIGURE 7.6-2 : OPINION ON THE SCOPE OF STUDY AND THE COURSE OF THE PRESENTED IMPACT ASSESSMENT
After the hearing, the Project prepared document on the conclusion of the 1st Public Hearing as shown in Appendix 7A-8 and post it on the public relations board of related government sectors between 20-21 August 2014 (within 15 days from the end of the 1st Public Hearing) as shown in the Photo 7.6-7 for public relations/opportunity for interest parties to know the details of the operation including concerns and explanations of the Project (letter requesting assistance to post the announcement of the 1st Public Hearing as Appendix 7A-9). (3) The hearing of the related fisherman group (fisherman group which utilizes the Nong Pla Lai Reservior) prior to the 2nd Public Hearing. The hearing of the fisherman group who utilizes Nong Pla Lai Reservior has the objective of presenting detailed information of the Project and the result of the study of the water quality from the development of the Project to the related fisherman group in order to reduce the concerns of the target group. The hearing was arranged for Friday 12 February 2015 between 10:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. at the multi-purpose building Moo 1 Pluak Daeng Sub-district, Pluak Daeng District, Rayong Province. The total number of participants was 29 as shown in Table 7.6-8 (Name list of participants shown in Appendix 7B-1) and the photographs of the atmosphere of the meeting is shown in Photo 7.6-8.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-52 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Office of Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate Pluak Daeng District Office
Chon Buri Provincial Office of Natural Khao Khansong SAO Resources and Environment
Ban Tha Cham Tambon Health Promoting Chomphon Chao Phraya SM Hospital
st PHOTO 7.6-7: THE EXAMPLE OF PHOTO ON POSTING CONCLUSION OF THE 1 PUBLIC HEARING (CONDUCTED DURING 20-21 AUGUST 2014)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-53 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-8 FISHERMAN GROUP PARTICIPATING IN THE MEETING Group Number of Participants (Person) แ. Conservation tourism group 7 2. Conservation group 6 3. Ban Prap fisherman group 6 4. Condominium fishery group แเ Total of Participants 29
PHOTO 7.6-8: THE EXAMPLE OF PHOTO FOR THE HEARING OF THE FISHERMAN GROUP (CONDUCTED ON 12 FEBRUARY 2015)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-54 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(a) Opinions and suggestions of the participants Listening to the opinions and suggestions of the participants came in 2 channels namely แ) the expression of opinions on the stage of the meeting and 2) the information written on the questionnaire. The conclusion of the question, concern, recommendation, and explanation are shown in Table 7.6-9.
TABLE 7.6-9 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, AND EXPLANATION FROM THE MEETING WITH THE FISHERMAN GROUP Question/Recommendation Issue of Explanation Participant Question/Recommendation President of the - At what depth did the water - The study of the surface water Conservation Tourism Group sample for analysis being quality and aquatic ecology of collected? the Project will be done in accordance with the specified depth and the method of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment. - Water sample should be - The Project will take this into collected at the bottom of consideration. the reservoir for analysis. - It was recommended that - The Project will take this into the Project plant trees in a consideration. plot of land to test the air quality. - The operation monitoring - Most members of the committee committee of the Project will be selected from the public should be formed with people where communities will who sacrifice themselves nominate their representatives. and be straightforward. Conservation Group - Will the cooling water - The Project will control the discharged from the Project quality of the cooling water in into Nong Pla Lai Reservoir accordance with the measure of create any impact in the the estate and the Ministry of long run? Industry’s Notification Volume 2 (B.E.2539) on the specification of the quality of wastewater released from factory. As for the TDS value, the standard on the waste water discharged into the water way of the Royal Irrigation Department will be used.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-55 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-9 (Cont’d) ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, AND EXPLANATION FROM THE MEETING WITH THE FISHERMAN GROUP Question/Recommendation Issue of Explanation Participant Question/Recommendation Conservation Group (Cont’d) - Besides, the Project has studied the impact on the quality of the water way which receives the wastewater. It was discovered that the impact on Kram Canal, Khlong Rawoeng Canal, and Nong Pla Lai Reservior was very low to moderate - There is no concerns about - The estate must also follow the the operation of the power standard on which the plant, but have concerns permission was granted to about the management prevent impact on the system of the estate. community. - During the visit to Kaeng - The production using diesel is Khoi Power Plant 2, only the done only in emergency for no power production by using more than 2-3 days at a time gas was demonstrated, but under instruction from EGAT. not diesel. Committee of Conservation - The water quality of Nong - The Project will take this into Group Pla Lai Reservior affects the consideration. quantity of living organism in the water and has impact on the livelihood of the fisherman. The Project should take care of the overall environment. Source: TEAM Construction Engineering and Management Co., Ltd., 2015.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-56 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(b) Conclusion from the questionnaires after the meeting After listening to opinions through the stage of the meeting, the consultant requested for cooperation from the 29 participants to fill in the questionnaires as another channel. The conclusions from questionnaires are (see Appendix 7B-2) as follows:
Information on the condition of the fisherman groups All participants were registered as member of the fisherman groups. The majority of 34.5 % were members of the Condo Group. Another 20.7 % were members of the Village No. 3 Fisherman Club and about 10.3 % were members of Soi 3 and 4 Group.
Information on the livelihood of fisherman and the aquaculture Most of the participants utilized Nong Pla Lai Reservoir to do Tub fishery (86.2 %). Most did their own fishing (79.3 %). Another groups were hired hands and aquaculture fisherman (both at 3.5 %). Majority of fisherman at 17.2 % used motor boats. The types of fishing equipment were fishing net, net, and fishhook. The types of fish caught by using fishing net were Nile Tilapia (30.8 %), Common Silver Barb Carp (23.1 %), and Giant Snake-Head fry (15.4 %). The types of fish caught by using net were Nile Tilapia (33.3 %), Common Silver Barb Carp (30.1 %), and Siamese Mud Carp (18.0 %). The types of fish caught by using fishhook were Clown Knifefish (46.7 %), Small Scale Mud Carp (20.0 %), and Common Silver Barb Carp (13.3 %). The fishing time were 11:00 a.m. to 3:59 p.m. and 4:00 to 8:59 pm. (both at 20.7 %). The catch was for wholesale (24.1 %), fisherman own consumption (20.7 %) and retail sale to neighbor (17.2 %). Acknowledgement of information and opinion on the Project About 65.5 % of the participants had been aware that Sriracha Power Plant of Gulf SRC Company Limited would be developed. The majority of this group at 57.1 % knew about the power plant from participating in the 1st Public Hearing in July 2014. The next group at 33.3 % knew about it from neighbor/people in the village and the last group at 9.6 % knew from the government sector. As for the concerns about the development of the Project, the majority at 51.7 % did not have any concerns because they had visited a power plant of the Project (Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2, Saraburi Province) and gained confidence in the Project. Nevertheless, some still had concerns about the air, waste water, and that the quantity of aquatic animals may decrease. Public Relations of the Project Majority of the participants at 44.8 % suggested that group sessions should be conducted for the public relations of the Project. Next group at 24.1 % suggested that the Project should inform through community leaders/government sector,
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-57 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations and the last group at 3.5 % suggested that the Project should inform through community radio station. nd (4) The 2 Public Hearing (Meeting to listen to the public opinions on the study result and the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures) The 2nd public hearing of the public opinion draft report preparation period through the 2nd Public Hearing (meeting to listen to the public opinion on the study results and the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures) aimed to present the study results of the environmental impact and listening to the opinions on the draft measures of the Project. This was arranged in 9 stages in different areas between 25-29 May 2015 with 1,691 participants (excluding the personnel of the Project owner and the consultant) as shown in Table 7.6-10. The participants consisted of community leaders, the local residents who may be affected, establishments in the area, related government sectors, educational institution, local mass media, and interested public. The summary of the target groups which participated in the 2nd public hearing is shown in Table 7.6-11. The document of the 2nd Public Hearing is shown in Appendix 7C-1. List name of participants of the 2nd meeting is shown in Appendix 7C-2. Communication media of the 2nd meeting is shown in Appendix 7C-3 and questionnaire of the opinion is shown in Appendix 7C-4. Before the 2nd Public Hearing, the Project sent letter of invitation to the target groups (a sample of the letter of invitation to the 2nd meeting is shown in Appendix 7C-5) and the invitation was posted on the public relations board to invite the public in no less than 15 days in advance between 7-8 May 2015 as shown in Photo 7.6-9 (a sample of the 2nd public relations announcement is shown in Appendix 7C-6). The photographs of the atmosphere of the 2nd meeting are shown in Photo 7.6-10.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-58 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-10 SCHEDULE FOR THE 2nd PUBLIC HEARING Date Location and Time Number of Participants (Person) Monday 25 May 2015 Meeting room of Khling Kio Sub-district แ82 Kindergarten School during เ9.3เ a.m. to แ2.เเ p.m. Tuesday 26 May 2015 Multi-purposes Building of Khao Khansong 403 SAO during เ9.3เ a.m. to แ2.เเ p.m. Pi Phit Pho Kai meeting room of Chon Buri 17 Provincial Hall during 14.00 p.m. to 16.30 p.m. Wednesday 27 May 2015 Multi-purposes Building of Bowin SAO 182 during เ9.3เ a.m. to แ2.เเ p.m. Meeting room of Office of Eastern Seaboard 44 Industrial Estate (Rayong) during แ4.เเ to แ6.30 p.m. Pavilion for older person at Ban Chaloem Lap 100 during 18.00 to 20.3เ p.m. Thursday 28 May 2015 Meeting room of Ta Sit SAO 219 during 09.30 a.m. to 12.00 p.m. Multi-purposes Building of Chomphon Chao 364 Phraya SM during แ3.3เ to แ6.3เ p.m. Friday 29 May 2015 Meeting room of Pluak Daeng SAO 180 during 09.30 a.m. to 12.00 p.m. Total of 9 stages 1,691 Note : The number of participants does not include staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and of consultant company.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-59 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-11 TARGET GROUPS PARTICIPATING IN THE 2nd PUBLIC HEARING Classification of Stakeholders Number of Participants (Person) 1. Affected persons within 5 km radius from the project location - Community headman 6 - Local people 824 - Related enterprises 32 2. Organizations responsible for preparation of the report on the environmental impact assessment - Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. แ3 - TEAM Consulting Engineering and Management Co., Ltd. 6 3. Organizations responsible for consideration of the report on the environmental impact assessment - Office of Natural Resources and Environment Policy and Planning - (ONEP) - Office of Energy Regulatory Commission region 8 1 4. Related government agencies - Agencies at provincial level 16 - Agencies at district level 20 - Agencies at sub-district level 243 5. Private environmental organizations, private development bodies, local educational institutions, higher educational institutions, and independent scholars - Educational Institutions 27 - Independent Commission on Environment 20 6. Mass media แ6 7. Interested general public 426 Total of Participants 1,710 Note : The number of staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and of TEAM Consulting Engineering and Management Co., Ltd. was counted only 1 time (1 stage).
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-60 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Rayong Provincial Hall Si Racha District Office
Pluak Daeng Hospital Ban Nong KangKao Tambon Health Promoting Hospital
Nong Yai District Agricultural Extension Multi-purposes pavilion Office of Chomphon Chao Phraya SM
PHOTO 7.6-9: THE EXAMPLE OF PHOTO ON POSTING NOTICES OF THE HEARING ND BEFORE THE 2 PUBLIC HEARING (CONDUCTED DURING 7-8 MAY 2015)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-61 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Khlong Kio Sub-district Ta Sit Sub-district
Khao Khansong Sub-district Chomphon Chao Phraya SM
Bowin Sub-district Pluak Daeng Sub-district
Hour’Rayong Provincial Government Agencies Nong Suea Chang Sub-district and the Enterprises within the Industrial Estate
ND PHOTO 7.6-10: THE EXAMPLE PHOTO FOR THE ATMOSPHERE OF THE 2 PUBLIC HEARING (CONDUCTED DURING 25 - 29 MAY 2015)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-62 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(a) Opinions and Suggestions from the participants of the 2nd Meeting The hearing of the opinion and recommendation from the participants of the meeting provided 2 channels for the participants to express their opinions namely แ) express the opinion on the stage of the meeting and 2) write the information on the questionnaire. The conclusion on the questions, concerns, suggestions and explanations will be used to specify the measures in operating the Project as shown in Table 7.6-12. (b) Conclusion of the 2nd public hearing from the questionnaires After hearing the opinions from the stage of meeting, the consultant requested cooperation from the participants to express their opinions in the questionnaire forms. About 1,616 participants out of the total of 1,691 participants or equivalent to 95.6 % of all participants (excluded personnel of the Project owner and the consultant) sent in the questionnaires. The conclusions from questionnaires (Appendix 7C-7) are as follows: Acknowledgement of the information about the Project. Majority of the participants at 81.4 % had received some information about Sriracha Power Plant. Only 18.6 % knew about the Project for the 1st time. (Figure 7.6-3). Around 81.4 % of the participants had already known about the Project learned from the 1st Public Hearing in July-August 2014. Next group at 25.9 % received information from local government organizations such as the municipality or the sub-district administrative organization and community leaders such as sub-district headman, village headman, and chairman of community public health volunteer. Additionally, the participants asked whether additional public relations should be done and by which channels. The majority at 30.9 % said that the public relations should be done through community leader/government sector. Next group at 20.9 % recommended the use of community stage. Last group at 16.0 % preferred public relations through wire broadcasting. Opinions about the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures: The majority of the participants at 85.4 % understood the draft measures presented in the meeting. Only 14.6 % did not fully understand and wanted further information. Majority of the participants thought that the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures of the project were appropriate/sufficient (82.4 % and 82.6 % respectively). Details are shown in Figure 7.6-4 and Figure 7.6-5.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-63 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2nd PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT PROJECT Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project แ. What firefighting equipment will the Deputy Chief of Khlong Kio Project was designed to install the firefighting equipment in power plant install? The quantity should SAO accordance with the international standard ( NFPA: America be sufficient because the project area is District Chief of Si Racha Nation Fire Protection Association) and the related laws (for high- far from the central unit of the province District rises or large buildings (height of over 23 m). Project will design and the travel time is long. Representative of Chon Buri the fire preventive system of building in accordance with the Provincial Office of Disaster Ministerial Regulation Volume 33 (B.E.2535) issued by virtue of the Prevention and Mitigation Building Control Act B.E. 2522 such as installation of fire extinguisher, foam, sprinkler system, heat detection system, and smoke detector. As for the gas pipeline system, leak and fire control valve will be installed. The Project has designed a 2-hour water reserve system with capacity of 189,000 m3 for firefighting. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Ensure that the fire prevention system and fire suppression system of the Power Plant meet the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) standard and related standards. Arrange annual drills of the emergency plan both on the part of the power plant itself and to drill the emergency plan jointly with Hemaraj ESIE and external organizations. Give training to employees at least once a year so that they are equipped with skills and expertise in relieving emergency. 2. Whether or not the Project will inform the People in Moo 9 Khlong Kio The Project has 2 levels of emergency response plan as follows: community in emergency case? Sub-district When fire is seen in the power plant, the basic firefighting People in Moo 4 Bowin Sub- procedure would be performed. If unsuccessful, the director district of the power plant would be informed (Emergency plan level Representative of enterprises 1 of the Project). in the estate If the fire could not be controlled within the power plant, the estate must be requested for assistance (Emergency plan level 2 of the Project) and entered into the emergency plan of the estate. Under the emergency plan level 2 of the estate, the estate would inform the public/outside organization under the procedure of the estate. Additionally, public relations of information to the public would be done through various channels.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-64 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: (Cont’d) Be open to feedback from the community regularly and continuously. Develop good relationship with local government agencies and people in the communities through regular meetings and visits. Be ready to solve any problems or disturbance that may be caused by the project. 3. Regarding the Pro∑ect’s use of water Representative of Chon Buri According to the operational plan of East Water, there is a plan supplied through pipes by East Water Provincial Irrigation Project to develop the Nong Pla Lai-Nong Kor pipeline system (Line 2) Company, would there be problem to the which is expected to be completed in 2018 to increase the pipes if the water volume exceeds the capacity in supplying water to overall area and the Project. capacity of the water pipes? Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Consider ways to increase the efficiency of water usage, such as, reduction of water draining from the cooling system or recycling water within the project for maximum benefits. 4. What types of chemical will be used in the People in Bowin Sub-district Majority of chemicals which will be used in the power plant will Project. be for treatment of the water quality. These chemicals will be stored according to their properties in the chemical warehouse. There will be a surrounding dyke to prevent chemical leak to the outside in case of accident. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Consider ways to increase the efficiency of water usage, such as, reduction of water draining from the cooling system or recycling water within the project for maximum benefits. 5. How many workers will the Project have People in Bowin Sub-district The Project will have a maximum of 3,200 workers for short during the construction period and what durations of the construction period. There will be measures to measure will be used to manage them? control and supervise the workers such as specified rules and regulation and strict supervision. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Ensure the contractors comply with labor laws regarding physical health check and risk-based heath check. “se strict security system in the construction wor−ers’ living quarters. Supervisor and ensure that the contractors comply with the contract such as monitoring wor−ers’ living quarters, random drug test, garbage sorting in the wor−ers’ living quarters in accordance with the principle and methods of for garbage management.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-65 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project 6. What steps the power plant will take in Representative of enterprises All electricity generated by the Project will be sold to Electricity (Cont’d) case it cannot distribute electricity? in the estate Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT). The plant will operate under the instruction of EGAT. Therefore, in case the electricity distribution failure, EGAT will evaluate the situation and instruct other power plants to increase their productions in order that the electricity in the system is stable and does not affect the users. 7. Will there be any possibility that the power People in Chomphon Chao The Project will use natural gas as the primary fuel in the process plant will explode and how to prevent it Phraya SM of generating electricity and will have a boiler to heat water into from happening? steam. There will be risks of danger from natural gas leakage and explosion of the boiler. Therefore, the Project has specified measures in the control and supervision in order to reduce the risks as follows. Natural Gas: There will be an automatic monitoring gas and the valves to control the distribution of gas. The power plant will have personnel to control and supervise the situation 24 hours a day. Boiler: There will be safety valve to control the pressure in the steam pipe in order to prevent the boiler from splitting. The steam pipeline will be inspected annually by engineers. Therefore, the boiler will always be safe. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Maintain natural gas and diesel oil pipeline systems together with equipment to be ready for working and keep watching for safety. Arrange annual drills of the emergency plan both on the part of the power plant itself and to drill the emergency plan jointly with Hemaraj ESIE and external organizations. Give training to employees at least once a year so that they are equipped with skills and expertise in relieving emergency. 8. Will the Project change fuel to coal? Chairman of Pluak Daeng SAO In the preparation of the EIA report of the Project, the assessment Council of the impact of the Project was based on the use of natural gas as the primary fuel and diesel as the backup fuel. If there is any change in regard to fuel, preparation of a new EIA report and request for permission must be done. Besides, the machine in the power plant was designed to use natural gas and diesel only. It cannot use coal.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-66 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project 9. During the construction period of the People in Moo 3 Ta Sit Sub- During the construction period of the Project, there will be a (Cont’d) Project, will a water treatment plant be district pond to collect the waste water before sending to the estate to constructed? manage. So there won’t be any impact on the water sources on the outside. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Provide drainage gutter in the construction area with wastewater holding pond to hold uncontaminated discharged water from the construction activities for inspection of the quality in accordance with the requirements of Hemaraj ESIE, before draining to the estate’s central wastewater treatment system. Provide sufficient toilets under proper hygienic principle for the construction workers as required by law and provide septic ponds or ready-made wastewater treatment tanks to treat wastewater from daily consumption of the construction workers. แเ. Is it correct that the pond can hold the Assistant to Ta Sit Sub-district The Project will not directly release waste water into the public cooling water for 1 day before releasing it headman Moo 2 water sources because the Project is in the estate. The waste to the outside? Will the waste water from Secretary of Chief of Pluak water of the Project is composed of the follows. 3 the Project be smuggled to be released Daeng SAO (Chairman of General waste water will be 50 m /day. This will compose of into public canals? network of environmental the waste water from the production process such as waste surveillance of Pluak Daeng water from treating the water quality and waste water from District) consumption. The Project will conduct initial treatment in accordance with the standard. There will also be a waste water pond of the Project which will be used to collect the waste water before being released to the estate to manage. 3 Waste water from cooling water will be about 12,000 m /day. It will stay in the waste water pond for 1 day before being released to the estate where it will be in a waste water pond of the estate which has 1-day capacity before the estate will release it to Kram Canal. Besides, the estate will have to prepare another pond for emergency in case the water quality did not reach the specified standard. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Provide two cooling water holding ponds of the project each with capacity of 19,000 m³ with minimum holding capacity of one day per pond to collect the water drained from the cooling tower and line each pond with High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) to prevent leakage or build concrete pond.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-67 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project Ensure that the quality of the cooling blowdown meets the (Cont’d) requirement of Hemaraj ESIE which specifies that the cooling blowdown must meet the requirement prescribed in Ministry of Industrial’s Notification No. 2 (B.E.2539) re: Prescribing Standards of Quality of Discharged Water from Factories and the level of all Dissolved Solid must be within the standards of the quality of water discharged into the Irrigation waterway of the Royal Irrigation Department (TDS not exceeding 1,300 mg/l and the temperature not exceeding 34 C). Provide a wastewater holding pond capable of holding wastewater for at least 24-hour̊ in order to inspect the quality prior to draining into the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj ESIE. Ensure that the properties of the wastewater to be delivered to the central wastewater treatment system of the estate meets the requirements of Hemaraj ESIE. แแ.Detailed design of the pollutant emission Representative of enterprises For the pollutant emission stack of the Project, the height was stack. in the estate designed to be 60 m which is sufficient for dispersing the heat People in Chomphon Chao into the upper atmosphere and for the concentration of the Phraya SM pollutant to disperse away from the nearby area. Besides, a Continuous Emission Monitoring System (CEMs) will be installed at the top of the stack for online monitoring. It will monitor the level of the total suspended particulate, nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, oxygen, and the flow rate. All information will be displayed on the monitor screen in front of the power plant. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Install Continuous Emission Monitoring System; (CEMs) at the emission stack of the power plant in order to continuously monitor parameters including nitrogen oxides (NOx) sulfur dioxide (SO2) total suspended particulate (TSP) oxygen (O2) and the flow rate, display the measurement result (NOx, SO2 and TSP) of the area on the screen in the front of the project site, send the report to Hemaraj ESIE throughout the pro∑ect’s duration. แ2.The location of the worker camp of the Representative of enterprises Project has not definitely specified the location of the worker Project. in the estate camp. But prior to the construction, discussion will be conducted with the local administrative organization, government sector, and the estate one more time.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-68 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project แ3. Will the workers during the construction Representative of National The workers during the construction period will comprise of both (Cont’d) period be Thais or foreigners? Peace and Order Maintaining Thai workers and foreign workers. But the Project has specified Council the standard for controlling the foreign workers in accordance with the laws and measures to control the worker camp. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Supervisor and ensure that the contractors comply with the contract such as monitoring wor−ers’ living quarters, random drug test, garbage sorting in the wor−ers’ living quarters in accordance with the principle and methods of for garbage management. Monitor contagious disease jointly with the local public health agencies. แ4. It was recommended that the Project Manager of Hemarag ESIE The Project has specified the measure on communication and prepare a traffic plan for discussion with must have a traffic plan prior to the construction period and will the estate and create a clear coordinate with the estate before operating the Project. understanding with communities prior to Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: the construction period. Plan for the routes to be used for transportation of construction materials and equipment of the project to avoid traffic problems. Avoid transporting construction materials during the rush hours, such as between 07.30 to 08.30 a.m. and between 4.00 to 5.00 p.m. to alleviate problems of traffic congestion. If transporting during those hours is necessary, seek approval from the relevant agencies and notify the community at least two weeks in advance. แ5.What is the term of the power purchase Representative of Eastwater The term of the power purchase agreement entered into with agreement entered into with EGAT and Teacher of Chumchon Borisat EGAT is 25 years. According to the agreement, the production will when will the electricity production for Namtan Tawan-aok be commercially delivered to EGAT in 2021. EGAT start? แ6. Many entrepreneurs in the estate also use Representative of enterprises The Project has already entered into a natural gas sale agreement natural gas in their production processes in the estate with PTT. Initially, it is expected that PTT will construct an just like the Project. Will the use of natural onshore gas pipeline no. 5 for transmission of gas to the Project. gas by the Project affect them? The study of the environmental impact is expected to start in 2016. แ7. What are the compositions of the solid Representative of enterprises The solid waste from the production process of the Project will waste from the production process of the in the estate compose of the following. Project? District Chief of Si Racha Solid waste from the water quality treatment. It will be District disposed of by method specified by laws.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-69 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project
Details of the Project General garbage will be collected before sending to the (Cont’d) estate or local organization for disposal. Resin will be returned to supplier to dispose of or send to an organization licenced by the Department of Industrial Works for disposal. Lubricant will be collected into oil tanks before an organization licenced by the Department of Industrial Works for disposal. Air filters will be collected and sent to an organization licensed by the Department of Industrial Works for disposal when they become expired. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Provide collection bins for refuse with secure lids in sufficient number for collection of solid waste from the project for delivery to the company licensed by the government for disposal by mean specified by law. Collect and use recyclable refuses from the project as much as possible or sell them to the buying companies. Deliver the remainder to the company licensed by the government for disposal in accordance with Ministry of Industry’s Notification re: Disposal of Refuse or Discarded Materials B.E. 2548. Separate hazardous solid waste of characteristics prescribed with Ministry of Industry’s Notification re: Disposal of Refuse and Discarded Materials B.E.2548 such as lubricant and solvent from cleaning tools from general refuses for disposal by the company licensed by the government. แ8. Will the power plant have preventive Teacher of Ban Chaloem Lap The Project is located in the area of low risk of earthquake measures in respect to earthquakes/flood School according to the seismic map of Thailand of the Department of or natural disaster? What is the reason for Chief of Khlong Kio SAO Mineral Resources. The area has never been an epicenter or not constructing a nuclear power plant? Village headman Moo 3 Nong received any damage from earthquake. Nevertheless, the Project Suea Chang Sub-district has taken the risk of earthquakes into consideration in the design of the power plant. The design of fuel to be used in the power plant of the Project was done according to the type of the power plant of the bid document specified by the Energy Regulatory Commission - natural gas must be used as the primary fuel and diesel as the backup fuel.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-70 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project Besides, the Project has studied the impacts from flood to the (Cont’d) waste water pond of the Project and discovered that the release of waste water of the Project will not have an impact or create flooding to Kham Canal both in rainy and dry seasons. แ9. Will the ammonia to be used by the Teacher of Ban Chaloem Lap Ammonia which will be used in the Project is the liquid ammonia Project has any impact on the School with 25 % concentration which is different from the ammonia gas community? with 99 % concentration. The liquid ammonia of the Project will be kept in tanks surrounded by dyke to prevent leakage to outside. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish preventive measures for protection against hazardous chemicals at the hazardous chemical storage areas. Preliminary mitigation measures include proper ventilation system, fire prevention system, spill retention dike to prevent chemical leaking out of the hazardous substance storage area and dedicated spill drainages unconnected to water drainage system. 2เ. What will happen at the end of the 25-year Deputy Chief of Nong Suea Normally, Project will be monitored and equipment of the power agreement term with EGAT? Will the power Chang SAO plant will be checked periodically against specified standards. If plant be improved or replaced by a new the power plant did not maintain its equipment of the power plant? production process or had an inefficient control system, the plant could not produce electricity as specified in the agreement. In such case, there is a penalty clause to follow or the plant operation may be suspended by the regulatory authority. In general, when a power plant operated to the expiry of the contract, a discussion with EGAT on the extension of the contract will be done. 2แ. Will the Project employ workers from the People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- The Project has a policy to consider local hiring first. During the local area? What positions are available? district operation period, the Project will need specialists in controlling Representative of National the machine and equipment. If the local workers have the skill, Peace and Order Maintaining the Project will be happy to consider them first. Council Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish measures for hiring qualified local people first to reduce impacts on the relationship with the people in the communities. Publicizing vacancies in the communities when job opportunities are available.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-71 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Details of the Project 22. The Project has measured the water People in Moo 7 Bowin Sub- The Project has measured the surface water quality in the area (Cont’d) quality and air quality. How were the district of Kham Canal because it flowed near the project area. As for results? The people of Bowin Sub-district the measurement of the ambient air quality, the Project specified would like to know the impact. 5 points around the project area which were covered by the main wind directions. The measuring station A5 was at Ban Nong Kang Pla, Sub-district of Bowin. The ambient air quality was within the standard for all measuring indexes. 23.Will East Water’s community school People in Chomphon Chao The operation of the Project will be in the project area only and remain where it is or move out when the Phraya SM will not disturb the school area. power plant operates here? Impact from the conduct of แ. How will the Project control the noise level Chairman of Nong Pla Lai The noise level at 1 m away from these machines are 85 dB and the Project of machines such as gas turbine, steam Reservoir Consevation will decrease as the distance to the source increases. turbine, gas compressor, and cooling tower Tourism Group Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: at the fence not to be over 70 dB(A)? Environmental committee of Establish specifications of machines and equipment which makes Planting trees alone will not be sufficient Moo 8 Khlong Kio Sub-district loud noise, such as Gas Turbine, Steam Turbine, Fuel Gas to reduce all the disturbance noise. Compressor and Cooling Tower to have the average Maximum Sound Pressure Level (Lmax) from the machines or noise absorbent material at the distance of 1 m of no more than 85 dB(A). Control the noise level at the area ad∑acent to the pro∑ect’s fence to be no more than 70 dB(A). In addition, trees will be planted around the project area and the trees will be grouped by shrub pattern and planted with zigzag pattern to efficiently help decrease noise level. 2. Whether or not the noise level of 90 dB(A) Deputy Governor of Rayong The assessment of the noise impact is done in 2 scenarios as considered to be over the standard? Province follows: General noise level: The Project will consider the result of the measure for the assessment of the impact from the Project where the 24-hour average noise must not exceed 70 dB(A) at the fence of the Project. Disturbance noise level: the Project will consider the noise level in percentile at 90 (L90) from the present measure for the assessment of the impact from activities of the Project. The disturbance value during the activities of the Project must not exceed 10 dB(A). The average level of noise not over 90 dB(A) is the 8-hour average noise which will be used to assess the noise during work hours or in establishment.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-72 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: the Project (Cont’d) Control the noise level at the area ad∑acent to the pro∑ect’s fence to be no more than 70 dB(A). Design machine to produce noise level to be in specified standard 3. What were the maximum and minimum Representative of enterprises The Project measured the noise level for 5 consecutive days. The levels of disturbance noise measured and in the estate highest 24-average noise level in community was 52.0 - 65.6 dB(A) was there hourly measurement? which did not exceed the standard (the average 24-hour noise level must not exceed 70 dB(A)). 4. How many times will the measurement of Assistant to Sub-district The Project will monitor the ambient air quality every 6 months the ambient air quality be performed headman of Moo 2 Ta Sit during the 3-year construction period. Measurement will also be each year? Sub-district performed during the 25-year operation period as follows. Measure the air quality at the top of the emission stack: The Project will install a continuous emission monitoring system (CEMs) at the top of the emission stack for online monitoring of the total suspended particulate, nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, oxygen, and the flow rate. The reading will be displayed on the screen monitor in front of the power plant. Measure the ambient air quality: It was specified that the monitoring of the ambient air quality of the vicinity of the Project will be performed every 6 months. 5. What air pollutants from the Project will Nong Suea Chang Sub-district The global warming is caused by human’s activities. The Pro∑ect be emitted? Every Project stated that its headman selected natural gas as the primary fuel in the production of emission of pollutants is within the Village headman of Moo 2 electricity because it is relatively clean and generates less standard. Will the combined pollutants of Nong Suea Chang Sub-district pollutant (causes of the global warming) than other types of a number of projects exceed the Environmental committee of fossil fuel. standard? What will be the level of Moo 8 Khlong Kio Sub-district The air pollutants from the Project will be nitrogen dioxide, total impact? Will it contribute to the global suspended particulate, sulfur dioxide. The Project will install warming? combustion system which will create oxide of dry low nitrogen (Dry Low NOx) in conjunction with the use of natural gas as fuel or install a water injection system in conjunction with the use of diesel as fuel. Additionally, Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) will be installed to control the amount of nitrogen oxides (NOx) by mean of creating a reaction between NOx and liquid ammonia to change the condition of nitrogen gas (N2) and water (H2O) which exists in nature.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-73 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of Standards which will be used to control air pollutants under the Project (Cont’d) consideration of the Project were as follows. Air pollutants in the general atmosphere: General air quality standard as specified in the National Environmental Board’s Notification will be used. Air pollutants from the emission stack: The standard as specified in the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment’s Notification will be used in the control of air pollutant from establishment to be within the level allowed by laws or regulation The assessment of the impact on the air quality will be monitored by using a mathematic model which will base the calculation on the value of air pollutant from the emission stack of the plant, which has been approved in the environmental impact assessment report. But this model has not been used on the 30 km x 30 km area in the conjunction with the value of the air pollutant emitted by the Project. From the result of the prediction through the use of model together with the maximum value of the pollutant in the atmosphere of the Project at present, the result of the impact on the air quality in the case where the Project got implemented will be known. From the assessment, it was discovered that the impact on the air quality would be very low. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Control the rate of emission of toxic pollutants from the emission stack to no more than the limit pre-set in the Environmental Impacts Assessment. If natural gas is used, control the formation of the nitrogen oxides by using the Dry Low NOx type of NOx (DLN) control system and the system of Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR). If diesel is used, control the formation of the nitrogen oxides by using Water Injection type of NOx control system and the system of Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR). Install Continuous Emission Monitoring System; (CEMs) at the emission stack of the power plant in order to continuously monitor parameters including nitrogen oxides (NOx) sulfur dioxide (SO2) total suspended particulate (TSP) oxygen (O2) and the flow rate, display the measurement result (NOx, SO2 and TSP) of the area on the screen in the front of the project site, send the report to Hemara∑ ESIE throughout the pro∑ect’s duration.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-74 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of 6. The specified location for the Representative of Chon Buri The field survey revealed that there was no utilization of the the Project (Cont’d) measurement of the groundwater is a high Provincial Irrigation Project groundwater near the project area. Therefore, the Project had to ground and far away from the Project. This consider collecting sample of the groundwater from the nearest may not appropriately represent the project well of the community, taking into consideration the flow area in the measurement of the impact direction of the groundwater. from the Project. 7. The accumulated impact of the emission Chairman of Nong Pla Lai The impact from operating the Project regarding emission of air of air pollutant and discharged water. Reservoir Consevation pollutant to the outside is as follows. Tourism Group Air quality: After the Project releases pollutants from the emission stack, these pollutants will change their forms in conformity with the natural cycle. The assessment of impact from the Project will consider the average hourly value and the yearly average value in order to predict the accumulated impact. The result of the assessment indicated that it was still within the standard. Surface water quality: The discharged water from the Project will consist of the general discharged water and the cooling water which will be the main discharged water. The Project will have a control on the quality of discharged water to conform with the specified standard of the estate before sending it to the estate to manage in accordance with their measures. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Control the rate of emission of toxic pollutants from the emission stack to no more than the limit pre-set in the Environmental Impacts Assessment. Install Continuous Emission Monitoring System; (CEMs) at the emission stack of the power plant in order to continuously monitor parameters including nitrogen oxides (NOx) sulfur dioxide (SO2) total suspended particulate (TSP) oxygen (O2) and the flow rate, display the measurement result (NOx, SO2 and TSP) of the area on the screen in the front of the project site, send the report to Hemara∑ ESIE throughout the pro∑ect’s duration. Install the Online Monitoring system for the inspection of the pH value, the conductivity and the Dissolved Oxygen in the area of retention water pond from the power plant’s cooling tower and report the values on the screen in front of the project site and to Hemara∑ ESIE’s Wastewater Control Centre.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-75 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of Ensure that the properties of the wastewater to be delivered to the Project (Cont’d) the central wastewater treatment system of the estate meets the requirements of Hemaraj ESIE 8. There were concerns about workers of the Chon Buri Provincial Office of Approaches to management of the impact caused by workers Project during the construction period in Disaster Prevention and of the Project during the construction period are as follows. respect of the management of the solid Mitigation Worker camp: The Project will discuss the issue with the estate waste, public utility, and their and the local organization in order to locate it far from the transportation. community. Transport of workers: The route for transport of workers will be the one which will cause least affect the community. Solid waste: The Project will coordinate with local organization to collect and dispose of the waste. Furthermore, the Project has specified measures to control and supervise workers during the construction period. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Supervise and ensure that the contractors comply with the contract such as monitoring wor−ers’ living quarters, random drug test, garbage sorting in the wor−ers’ living quarters in accordance with the principle and methods of for garbage management. Provide hygienic sanitary environment in the construction wor−ers’ living quarters and the construction site. 9. Can Canal accommodate the discharged Representative of Energy The Project had a study on the impact from flooding to the pond water of the Project? Regulatory Committee Office for the discharged water from cooling water system of the region 8 Project, as specified by regulation of the estate, before sending it Deputy Chief of Khao into the cooling water pond of the estate and released to Kram Khansong SAO Canal which revealed that the release of the discharged water did not create flooding to Kram Canal both in the rainy and dry seasons. แเ. Will the discharged water from the Project Teacher of Chaloem Lap Discharged water from the cooling tower will exchange heat with diluted by mixing with other water to School the air in similar fashion to a waterfall. Therefore, the oxygen will increase oxygen in the water? be increased into the water from the cooling tower. The amount of oxygen in the water will be sufficient for microorganism to use in decomposition process and prevent the water from becoming polluted.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-76 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of แแ. Will a magnetic field be created when the People in Chomphon Chao The electricity generating process will not create a magnetic field the Project (Cont’d) Project starts to generate electricity and Phraya SM and through the conduct of projects in the past, there was no what will be the impact on the human impact on employees or community around the power plant. body? แ2. What will be the impact from the Project People in Moo 1 Khlong Kio Regarding the impact on the water quality during the operation, and its level on the waterway? The Sub-district there will be 2 types of discharged water from the activities as Project assessed the impact on the water People in Moo 9 Khlong Kio follows. quality of Kham Canal which will receive Sub-district The general discharged water with the volume of 50 m3/day. the discharged water of the Project to be Deputy Governor of Rayong This will consist of the discharged water from the production at the moderate level. Will it be possible Province process such as the waste water from treatment of the water to reduce the impact to the low level? Village headman of Moo 3 quality and discharged water form daily consumption. The What will be the impacts? Will there be Nong Suea Chang Sub-district Project will perform an initial treatment and collect it in the an impact on the tap water system of the Chairman of Nong Suea pond for discharged water of the Project before sending it to the community in the future? How will the Chang SAO Council estate to manage. public monitor? Discharged water from the cooling tower with the volume of 12,000 m3/day: it will be sent to the cooling water pond of the Project before sending it to the pond for cooling water of the estate and released to Khlong Kram. The Project will control the quality of cooling water from the cooling tower before release it to the pond for cooling water of the estate to let the solid substance be completely dissolved in the water ( TDS) to the level of no more than แ ,3 เ เ milligrams/liter, which is an accepted standard of the Royal Irrigation Department and for farmer use. From the assessment of the impact on the water quality, it was discovered that the level of impact on the water quality was between low to moderate levels. Nevertheless, the Project has specified the measure in monitoring the quality of discharged water in the pond for discharged water and the pond for cooling water of the Project using an online system under the requirement of the estate before sending it into the central wastewater treatment system and the pond for cooling water of the estate respectively. The value of the measurement will be displayed on the monitor screen in front of the power plant and the Project has specified the monitoring of the water quality in Kram Canal downstream continuously through the life of the operation of the Project.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-77 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of Besides, the Project has established an environmental impact the Project (cont’d) monitoring committee by selecting the majority of the members from the community. The committee will have the authority to give opinion, recommendation, and monitor the operation of the power plant. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Install the Online Monitoring system for the inspection of the pH value, the conductivity and the Dissolved Oxygen in the area of retention water pond from the power plant’s cooling tower and report the values on the screen in front of the project site and to Hemara∑ ESIE’s Wastewater Control Centre. Ensure that the quality of the cooling blowdown meets the requirement of Hemaraj ESIE which specifies that the cooling blowdown must meet the requirement prescribed in Ministry of Industrial’s Notification No. 2 (B.E.2539) re: Prescribing Standards of Quality of Discharged Water from Factories and the level of all Dissolved Solid must be within the standards of the quality of water discharged into the Irrigation waterway of the Department of Royal Irrigation (TDS not exceeding 1,300 mg/l and the temperature not exceeding 34 C). Ensure that the properties of the wastewater to be delivered to the central wastewater treatment system̊ of the estate meets the requirements of Hemaraj ESIE. Provide a Neutralization Pit to adjust the water condition to neutral condition before draining it to the pro∑ect’s wastewater holding pond and then to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj ESIE. Establish Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee before the construction period. แ3. There are concerns about the impact Representative of enterprises The exact transportation routes have not yet been specified. The from the transportation and would like in the estate Project will assess the impact on all routes around the project the Project to indicate the transportation People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- area especially the national highways and rural roads which will route of the Project for the public to district be used together with the community. As for heavy equipment avoid during the construction period. Also People in Chomphon Chao and large transporter, coordination will be made with the police, will the Project repair the roadways if they Phraya SM local administrative organization, as well as to consult with the are damaged? estate to make a traffic plan prior to the construction period in order to avoid transportation during rush hours and have personnel to facilitate during such transport. In case of damage to the communication routes, the contractor will repair and return the roads to the previous state or better.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-78 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: the Project (Cont’d) Plan for the routes to be used for transportation of construction materials and equipment of the project to avoid traffic problems. Avoid transporting construction materials during the rush hours, such as between 07.30 to 08.30 a.m. and between 4.00 to 5.00 p.m. to alleviate problems of traffic congestion. If transporting during those hours is necessary, seek approval from the relevant agencies and notify the community at least two weeks in advance. แ4. If the Project created any impact on the Village headman of Moo 2 If the operation of the Project affects the public, the Project will public such as their respiratory system in Nong Suea Chang Sub-district be willing to remedy and be responsible for such impact. But the future, how would the Project People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- during the past 10 years of operation of 10 power plants by Gulf proceed? district Group of Companies, there was no complaint on the impacts in respect to the public health around the project area. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee before the construction period. แ5. It was recommended that during the Mayor of Chomphon Chao The Project has specified mitigation and preventive measures construction period, there should be a Phraya SM on the impact on the air quality during the construction period preventive measure to reduce dust that such as spray water 2-3 times a day to reduce the impact from may affect Chumchon Borisat Namtan dust. Tawan-aok School. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Spray water in the construction area, the soil mounds or where project construction activities causes the dispersion of total suspended particulate, such as the road, the area undergoing filling and grading, etc. to reduce the dispersion of the total suspended particulate, at least two times/day (morning and afternoon) and more as necessary. Assign workers clean up traffic surface in the area in front of the project area after the entry or exit of the delivery trucks. Limit the use of the area in front of the site to the absolute necessities and to proceed with the construction promptly.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-79 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of แ6.During the construction period of the People in Chomphon Chao The Project requires that non-local workers provide information the Project (Cont’d) Project, there will be non-local workers Phraya SM on the number and ages of their children if they want to enroll coming into the area. How will the Project in the local school. All non-local workers must properly register supervise the impact on the public health in accordance with the laws as well as going through health check and the education from the non-local and provide information to the public health organization in the workers? area. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Prepare a list of construction workers, report the number and their chronic diseases to the public health station responsible for the area prior to coming to work. Ensure the contractors comply with labor laws regarding physical health check and risk-based health check. Ensure that the contractors coordinate with schools especially kindergarten to primary education level at least 6 months prior to the project construction in the case some workers need to enroll their children in the local schools. แ7. The arrival of the power plant into the area People in Moo 3 Pluak Daeng Besides the environmental impact assessment, the Project will may cause changes of the livelihood of the Sub-district also study the socio-economics impact, especially during the community. It was recommended that the construction period which non-local will come into the area and Project should conduct a study the impact worker camp will be set up far away from the community. on the social condition and livelihood of Additionally, the Project will support activity of the community the community. as follows. Budget of Gulf Group of Companies: The supports have been given since the beginning of the study mostly in form of support to the community in cultural activity, festival, education, and environment. Budget from the Power Development fund: The Project will contribute money into the fund at 50,000 baht/megawatt/year during the construction period and 1 satang/unit of production during the operation period. The Community Development Committee in the area around the power plant area will manage the fund. The majority of the committee members will come from the public. The community will present the Project to the committee to withdraw the fund for development of the quality of life and education.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-80 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Impact from the conduct of Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: the Project (Cont’d) Establish measures to return benefits to the communities, such as, supports for local education, local public health, religion promotion and supports for other public benefits. Public relations and public แ. Complaints could be done 24 hours a Member of Khlong Kio SAO In general, the length of time for solving problem of the Project participation day. The response time to complaints or Moo 1 depends on the characteristic of each problem. The Project will time to do the public relations to the take this into consideration and would discuss with the government section/ community should consultant in order to specify the response time on the progress be made known to public. or public relations to government section/community. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish a Complaint Receiving Center in order to publicize the project and to listen to opinions, suggestions and complaints. Those affected by the project can complain about the impacts or the problems through the channels in any manners or as deem appropriate, e.g. verbal complaints, telephone, memorandum, letter, Email, fax, etc. 2. What will the public benefit from the People in Moo 7 Khao The Power Development fund was established under the Energy power plant? Khansong Sub-district Industry Act B.E. 2550. It specified that the Project will contribute People in Bowin Sub-district money into the fund at 50,000 baht/megawatt/year during the construction period and 1 satang/unit of production during the operation period. Community Development Committee in the area around the power plant area will manage the fund. The majority of the committee members will come from the public. In addition, Gulf Group of Companies will continuously support the activity of the community. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish measures to return benefits to the communities, such as, supports for local education, local public health, religion promotion and supports for other public benefits. 3. Why is the 2nd Public Hearing necessary? People in Bowin Sub-district The preparation of the report on the analysis of the People in Moo 6 Bowin Sub- environmental impact of power plant Project was in accordance district with the procedure specified by the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning that requires at least 2 Public Hearings as follows: st 1 hearing: This will be done at the start of the Project to explain details, the rationale, and necessity of the Project, and the scope of study on the analysis of the environmental impact of the Project.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-81 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project nd Public relations and public 2 hearing: This will be the presentation of the result of the participation (Cont’d) study, the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures. 4. Whether or not there was any local public Representative of National The Project has considered the use of natural gas and located resistance to the conduct of the Project in Peace and Order Maintaining the Project in the estate to reduce the impact from the Project the past? Council and continued the public relations activities. Although there may be various opinions and suggestions, the Project has explained and taken these issues to improve the operation including a field trip to the power plant in operation in order to reduce the concerns which may exist. Therefore, there has been no protest. 5. Will there be another meeting with the Teacher of Ban Chaloem Lap The Project has public relations personnel who will stay in the people once the report on the School area through the life of the Project. The meeting may be in the environmental impact is approved? form of group sessions. Besides, after the environmental impact report is approved, a committee will be established to monitor the environmental impact of the Project before the construction period will begin. The committee will make up of the public representatives in majority, government sections, and representatives of the power plant. Meetings will be held on a regular basis. The conclusion of activity in the operation of the Project will be reported to the committee to acknowledge and complaints will be forwarded to the committee which acts as the representative of the community. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures s are as follows: Develop good relationship with local government agencies and people in the communities through regular meetings and visits. Be ready to solve any problems or disturbance that may be caused by the project. Be open to feedback from the community regularly and continuously. Disseminate information and news and publicize details of the project to the local communities in various channels and forms, such as, brochure, media or other activities consistent with the objectives of such measures. Be open for the community to participate in the monitoring of the project throughout the project duration. Establish Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee before the construction period.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-82 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Public relations and public 6. It was recommended that personnel should Community committee in The Project will take this into consideration. participation (Cont’d) conduct emergency drills with East Water’s Chomphon Chao Phraya SM Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: community school and the communities. Arrange annual drills of the emergency plan both on the part of the power plant itself and to drill the emergency plan jointly with Hemaraj ESIE and external organizations. Give training to employees at least once a year so that they are equipped with skills and expertise in relieving emergency. 7. It was recommended that the Project Principal of Chumchon The Project will take this into consideration. should support the education if schools Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: would have to accept children of non-local Establish measures to return benefits to the communities, such workers during the construction period. as, supports for local education, local public health, religion promotion and supports for other public benefits. 8. Will the community enjoy the electricity at People in Moo 3 Pluak Daeng The Project belongs to a private company which entered bid to low charge? Sub-district produce electricity and sell all of it to EGAT to manage the stability of the entire electricity system. The price of electricity is controlled and specified by the government sector. 9. How will the community know that the Nong Suea Chang Sub-district The Project has installed a continuous emission monitoring impact on the air quality will not exceed headman system (CEMs) at the top of the stack to continuously monitor the standard? the total suspended particulate, nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, oxygen, and the rate of flow online to the screen monitor at the front of the power plant. Additionally, the Project will measure the air quality in the vicinity of the Project every 6 months both during the construction period and the operation period. The result of the measures will be used in the monitoring report of the environmental impact and sent to the authorities such as the Office of Energy Regulatory Commission and the Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Install Continuous Emission Monitoring System; (CEMs) at the emission stack of the power plant in order to continuously monitor parameters including nitrogen oxides (NOx) sulfur dioxide (SO2) total suspended particulate (TSP) oxygen (O2) and the flow rate, display the measurement result (NOx, SO2 and TSP) of the area on the screen in the front of the project site, send the report to Hemara∑ ESIE throughout the pro∑ect’s duration. Control the rate of emission of toxic pollutants from the emission stack to no more than the limit pre-set in the Environmental Impacts Assessment.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-83 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Public relations and public แเ. It was recommended that the Project Assistant Sub-district The Project will coordinate through the community leaders or participation (Cont’d) should rotate the representatives on the headman of Moo 2 Ta Sit the local administrative organization to select representatives of field trips to visit power plant of Gulf Sub-district the community to go on field trips to visit a power plant. The Group of Companies throughout. Project will take this into consideration. แแ. How many village representatives will be People in Bowin Sub-District The establishment of the Impact Monitoring Committee will be on the Impact Monitoring Committee? Assistant Sub-district done after the environment impact assessment report has been headman of Moo 2 Ta Sit approved. Presently, it cannot be specified how many Sub-district representatives will come from each community. แ2.Can the public participate in the monitoring People in Moo 2 Ta Sit Sub- Prior to the construction, there will be an establishment of the of the pollution from the power plant? District Environmental Impact Monitoring Committee of the Project. People in Moo 8 Khao Almost the committee members will be selected from Khansong Sub-District representatives of communities. The authorities and duties of the People in Bowin Sub-District committee are to express opinion and recommendation as well People in Moo 7Khao as monitor the project operation. The Project will arrange a seminar Khansong Sub-District to educate the monitoring committee on the knowledge of monitoring the environmental quality. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee before the construction period. แ3. How will the representatives of the Teacher of Chumchon Borisat Prior to the construction, there will be an establishment of the communities be selected into the Impact Namtan Tawan-aok School Environmental Impact Monitoring Committee of the Project. Monitoring Committee? About a half of the committee members will be selected from representatives of communities. The rest will be the representatives of government section, and the representatives of the power plant. There will be coordination with the district office and local administrative organization to select or elect representative of each community to be representative on the monitoring committee. The Project will arrange a seminar to educate the monitoring committee on the knowledge of monitoring the environmental quality. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee before the construction period.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-84 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Public relations and public แ4. From today until the start of the Teacher of Chumchon Borisat Presently, the Project has the community relations personnel participation (Cont’d) construction, will the Project inform the Namtan Tawan-aok School who will be in the project area from the start of the construction community of the progress of the Project? to the end of the Project. The community will be able to ask about the progress of the Project from them. Additionally, the Project has specified measure in public relations which is to inform the public 1 month in advance of the construction. Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Participate in awareness of Sriracha Power Plant Project by means of dissemination of the pro∑ect’s information through the media or any of the following: local radio broadcasting, installation of notice boards displaying construction plan at key points in the area, such as, at the offices of the community leaders, at the Sub-district Administrative Office organization office and by other methods consistent with the objectives of such measures, etc. one month prior to the construction. Develop good relationship with local government agencies and people in the communities through regular meetings and visits. Be ready to solve any problems or disturbance that may be caused by the project. Be open to feedback from the community regularly and continuously. แ5. It was recommended that the Mayor of Chomphon Chao The Project will take this into consideration. representatives of the estate/IEAT be on Phraya SM the Environmental Impact Monitoring Committee of the power plant. แ6. It was recommended that the Project Principal of Chumchon The Project will take this into consideration and will arrange such support a seminar to give knowledge or Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok activity with East Water’s community school at least once a year. arrange exhibition about safety for East School Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Water’s community school. Appoint a safety officer to organize activities to promote knowledge and understanding about occupational health, safety in conjunction with schools in the vicinity, such as the Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok School, at least once a year. แ7. It was recommended the representatives Principal of Chumchon The establishment of the committee is in the hands of the of Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok community. When the operation begins, the school may school, Wat Chomphon Chao Phraya, and School coordinate with the leader of the community and recommend the community be included in the such course. committee to monitor the impact from the operation of the power plant.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-85 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Public relations and public แ8. It was recommended that representatives Village headman of Moo 3 The Project will take this into consideration. participation (Cont’d) of Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok Pluak Daeng Sub-district school and the estate come to confirm or talk with the local community. Other issues แ. It was recommended that the Project Deputy Chief of Khao The Project will take this into consideration. increases the measures in taking care of the Khansong SAO Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: quality of life of the people in the vicinity Mayor of Chomphon Chao Establish measures to return benefits to the communities, such of the power plant. Phraya SM as, supports for local education, local public health, religion promotion and supports for other public benefits. 2. It was recommended that the water contract Representative of Chon Buri The sale contract of water specifies that East Water guarantees with East Water should have a penalty Provincial Irrigation Projects to the estate that it is able to supply the water to the estate. clause to prevent negligence that will However, the Project will take this into consideration. create impact on overall usage of water. 3. The power plant in under the scope of People in Bowin Sub-district The Sriracha Power Plant Project is a large Project under the what type of Power Development fund? scope of the Power Development fund type A. The fund will cover a within 5 km radius. 4. Because the Project uses natural gas as the Representative of enterprises On the overall picture of the electricity production at present, primary fuel in producing electricity, will in the estate 60-70 % of the electricity is generated by using natural gas and this have an impact on the price of natural there are imports of liquid natural gas and natural gas from gas in the future? Myanmar. The price of gas is specified by the state. The Project is unable to tell whether or not the price will be higher in the future. 5. Will the Project talk to East Water to Chairman of Nong Suea The Project will take this into consideration. supply water to the communities at the Chang SAO Council same price as it charges the establishments? 6. It was recommended that the Project Chairman of Nong Suea The Project has considered the measure of the present ambient establish an air quality measuring station in Chang SAO Council air quality in accordance with the main wind directions as per the Ban Chaloem Lap to monitor the impact information of the air statistics of the Department of Meteorology from the conduct of the Project. near the Project. As for the consideration of the locations of the monitoring stations, the assessment using the mathematical model was considered. 7.It was recommended that the Project should Chairman of community The Project will take this into consideration. The Project supports give priority to Pluak Daeng District because council of Pluak Daeng Sub- the community in cultural activity, festival, education and it looks like area at risk of lack of water and district environment from the start of the study. After the construction accident from the Project. period, the Power Development fund will support these projects in the community.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-86 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-12 ISSUE OF QUESTION, SUGGESTIONS, EXPLANATION FROM THE STAGE OF THE 2ND PUBLIC HEARING AND ITS APPLICATION TO SPECIFY THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES OF SRIRACHA POWER PLANT (Cont’d) Target Groups Explanation and Application to Specify Measures/Operation Issue Question/Recommendation Participants Giving Opinion 1st Group 4th Group 5th Group 6th Group 7th Group Plan in respect to Environment of the Project Other issues (Cont’d) Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: Establish measures to return benefits to the communities, such as, supports for local education, local public health, religion promotion and supports for other public benefits. 8. It was recommended that Gulf should Village headman of Moo 3 The Project will take this into consideration. support the installation of light in the Pluak Daeng Sub-district Proposed mitigation and preventive measures are as follows: public area or risk area of Pluak Daeng Establish measures to return benefits to the communities, such District. as, supports for local education, local public health, religion promotion and supports for other public benefits.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-87 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Hear about it first time 18.6%
Heard about it 81.4%
FIGURE 7.6-3 : ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF THE INFORMATION ABOUT THE PROJECT
Not appropriate/ Not sufficient 17.6%
Appropriate/Sufficient 82.4%
FIGURE 7.6-4 : DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES
Not appropreate/ Not sufficient 17.4%
Appropriate/Sufficient 82.6%
FIGURE 7.6-5 : DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND PREVENTIVE MEASURES
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-88 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Following the public hearing, the Project prepared the document on the conclusion of the 2nd public hearing as Appendix 7C-8 and posted it on the public relations board of related government section during 11-12 June 2015 (within 15 days from the end of the 2nd Public Hearing) as in Photo 7.6-11 as a public relations/opportunity for interested individual to be informed about the details of the operation includes the concerns and explanations of the Project (letter to request for assistance to post the conclusion of the 2nd public hearing as Appendix 7C-9)
Chon Buri Provincial Office of Natural Si Racha District Office Resources and Environment
Si Racha District Public Health Office Khao Khansong SAO
Si Racha District Agricultural Extension Office Chomphon Chao Phraya SM
ND PHOTO 7.6-11 : THE EXAMPLE OF PHOTO FOR POSTING CONCLUSION OF THE 2 PUBLIC HEARING (CONDUCTED DURING 11-12 JUNE 2015)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-89 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
rd (5) The 3 Public Hearing (Meeting to listen to the public opinions on the changes in project details and the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures) At least 15 days prior to the meeting and public hearing session, the consultants sent out an invitation letter to the target group and posted the project meeting schedule on the public relations boards in public places to invite all stakeholders and those who are interested, including Sriracha District Office, Nong Yai District Office, Ban Bueng District Office, Pluak Daeng District Office, and Local Administrative Organizations located within the study area, etc. The announcement was posted on 15-16 March 2018 (a sample of the announcement notice of meeting invitation was shown in Photo 7.6-12). The public hearing meeting was organized to hear feedback from the public and those involved concerning the changes in details of the environmental impact assessment report of Sriracha Power Plant Project. The meeting aimed to present the changes made in the environmental impacts study results, the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures. The meeting was held on Wednesday, 4 April 2018 at 2 stages; stage 1: Public Consultation (Sub-district Level) with people and related parties at sub-district level and stage 2: Public Consultation (Provincial Level) with related provincial and district government agencies and Related enterprises (details in Table 7.6-13). The meeting covered 7 target groups of stakeholders, which were categorized according to the guideline on public participation and the social impact assessment in the environmental impact analysis of the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (ONEP). The meeting participants were representatives from relevant agencies including the Chonburi Energy Office, Irrigation Office 9, Provincial Waterworks Authority District 1, Pluak Daeng District Office, Nong Yai District Office. The meeting was also attended by Senior Deputy District Chief of Siracha, Community Development District Officer of Siracha, representatives from religious organizations, representatives from schools in the study area representatives from local administrative organizations, such as deputy district chief, board of directors, members of local municipality/Subdistrict Administrative Organization, municipal clerks, sub-district headmen, village headmen, chief inspectors, representatives of the communities in the study area, media, representatives from the local businesses, and the general public who are interested.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-90 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
PHOTO 7.6-12 : THE EXAMPLE OF PHOTO FOR POSTING NOTICES OF THE PROJECT MEETING SCHEDULE
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-91 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
TABLE 7.6-13 SCHEDULE FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING Day Location Number of Participants (Person) Wednesday 4 April 2เแ8 Multi-purpose Building of Khao Khansong 568 during เ9.เเ - แ2.เเ hrs. SAO Wednesday 4 April 2เแ8 Meeting Room, Eastern Seaboard Industrial 3เ during แ3.3เ - แ6.เเ hrs. Estate (Rayong), Pluak Daeng District, Rayong Total of 2 stages 598 Remark: The number of attendees is counted per head, not include staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and of consultant company.
Media for meeting used in the Project include as follows: Personal media: Representatives of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd (project owners) and representatives of the environmental consulting firm. Documentation: meeting documents, presentation slides, Evaluation form for use during the meeting. During the meeting and public hearing, the atmosphere was good (Photo 7.6-13) After the representatives of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and the representatives of the environmental consulting company completed presenting the information, the opportunities were given to the participants to comments on the results of the studies. The opinions and suggestions could be given via two channels as follows: The meeting to listen to the opinions and suggestions of the participants gave the opportunity for the participants to express their opinions through 2 channels: 1) expression of opinions on the stage of meeting; and 2) filling in the questionnaire. The questions, concerns, suggestions and explanations classified by target groups, the opinions and suggestions to be used in preparation of the measures for the operation of the Project. (1) By asking questions during the meeting The project provided opportunities for meeting participants to express their views and concerns by asking questions during the meeting. The key points from questions raised during the meeting are summarized in Table 7.6-14. (2) By completing the questionnaire during the meeting In addition to opportunities to ask questions during the meeting, the participants were able to express their views through the questionnaire. A total of 521 out of 598 respondents completed the questionnaire. Details are as follows:
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-92 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Morning meeting atmosphere
Afertnoon meeting atmosphere
PHOTO 7.6-13 : THE EXAMPLE PHOTO FOR THE ATMOSPHERE OF THE PUBLIC HEARING ON 4 APRIL 2018 (2 STAGES)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-93 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(2.1) The questionnaire results from the meeting participants (sub- district level) were given by 495 respondents. A summary is as follows: Being informed of the information concerning Sriracha Power Plant Project: 78.4% of respondents said that they had received the information about Sriracha Power Plant in the past, mostly from attending public hearing meetings of Sriracha Power Plant project, the community leaders, the local government agencies. They also heard about the project from the public relations staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and neighbors/colleagues. The other 21.6% stated that they had never received such information before. Views on Sriracha Power Plant project public relations: 89.3 % of the respondents said that Sriracha Power Plant Project should provide more information. The top 3 channels of public relations proposed by the respondents are community leaders, local announcement media, occasional meetings, leaflets/brochures, and local announcement media. The remaining 10.7 % indicated that no more publicity was needed. The understanding towards the changes in the details of Sriracha Power Plant Project: After hearing the details of the project detail changes, 87.7% of the respondents indicated that they understood the changes. 12.3% of the respondents said that they did not quite understand. The top three issues that they didn’t understand were: the details of the changes such as safety, the amount of diesel fuel used as reserve fuel, potential impacts, and potential/additional pollutions such as air pollution, etc.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-94
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations We want to know the reason why Presently, the area of both Chonburi and Rayong provinces - the power plant must be located have increasingly expanded towards industrialization, raising near Wat Chomphon Chao Phraya the demand for electricity in the area. Also, Gulf SRC Co., Ltd and Chomchon Borisat Namtal has the policy to build a power plant in the industrial estate
Tawan-aok School. We are as public utilities are already in place ready for use by industrial concerned about the impacts factories that aim to operate within the industrial estate. caused by the project operation. Building a power plant in the industrial estate will help reduce impacts occurred on the surrounding communities and allow the Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand the ability to follow- up and monitor the power plant. The Sriracha Power Plant is located on a large plot of land within the industrial estate and is near the path of the PTT natural gas pipeline and the EGAT transmission line, making it an ideal location for a power plant, which requires a large functional space. In the case that the power plant If it is discovered that an adverse impact found is due to the General Supporting Measures is built, what are the practical construction or operation of the power plant, the power plant In case a concern is raised by the community measures to alleviate any adverse will be responsible for such impact occurred. regarding the operation of the project, the impact on the community? company shall immediately correct the problem and record the matter in a report.
Page 7 Chapter
7-
95
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations Economic and Social Measures In case there is any misunderstanding between the power plant and the community, the project shall urgently inform the people of the situation details
through various communication channels and media so that people are informed with accurate information. The company shall be proactive in demonstrating its willingness to take responsibility and care for the feelings of the people. Safety Measures for Life and of Property If it is discovered that the impact occurred is caused by the power plant, the company must immediately remedy the situation, and record the issue in the database with categorization into Affected Individual or Group of Affected Individuals . The company shall propose a safety measure to prevent future occurrence. Keep a record of affected individuals. Collect key matters arising from complaints or situations and keep the information as organized entry record as
Page evidence. Entry records of details from the 7 Chapter
7- investigation, problem resolutions, and negotiation
96
matters as evidence of the power plant’s operation.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations It is recommended that a specific Presently, the four small power plants under Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. General Measures fund is established for Ta Sit Sub- in Ta Sit Sub-district are currently operating and have Establish a good rapport with local government district in addition to the Power contributed funds to the Power Development fund. Although officials and the community members. Development fund because the the Energy Regulatory Commission has not announced the Provide support and assistance to community
authorization procedures of the scope of the fund, the companies under Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. activities as deemed appropriate in order to build Power Development fund are have been supporting various community activities. good relationships and make positive contributions difficult. to the community and society. Economic and Social Measures Initiate measures on providing beneficial returns to the community, for example, supporting local educational or public health agencies, promoting and providing support to religious activities, and support various public welfare. Provide opportunities for the public to visit the power plants to alleviate their concerns. Initiate policies that improve the quality of life, promote and support local businesses for sustainable economic and social development of the community.
Page A question on which part of the Measures to reduce impacts on Chomchon Borisat Namtal Tawan- Safety Measures for Life and of Property power plant area will be the green aok School are as follows: If it is discovered that the impact occurred is 7 Chapter
7- area?, and a recommendation for caused by the power plant, the company must 97 The pro∑ect’s green areas will account for 5ั of the total area
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations the project to monitor any of the power plant. Most green areas will be located next to immediately remedy the situation, record the potential impact that may affect the fence around the project area. issue in the database with categorization into Chomchon Borisat Namtal Build a sound-proof fence on the side adjacent to Chomchon Affected Individual or Group of Affected Tawan-aok School Borisat Namtal Tawan-aok School to reduce any potential Individuals . The Company shall propose a safety
impact from noise. measure to prevent future occurrence. In addition, the pro∑ect’s environmental impact preventive Keep a record of affected individuals. Collate key measures mandate the establishment of the environmental impact matters arising from complaints or situations and monitoring committee, which comprises representatives from keep the information as organized entry record as government agencies, community, and power plant. The project evidence. Entry records of details from the must present the findings from the power plant impact monitoring investigation, problem resolutions, and negotiation activities to the committee. matters as evidence of the power plant’s operation. Measures on Green Area and Aesthetics To allocate a minimum of 5% of the project area as a green area; to plant 3 rows of perennial trees, shrubs, and grass with a zig-zag manner alternating between perennial trees and tall shrubs. The trees to be planted are, for example, Asoke tree, Moulmein Lancewood, Dolichandrone Serrulata, Cochlospermum Regium, or other suitable plants
Page that have a diameter of no less than 5 inches. The 7 Chapter
7- planting distance should take into consideration
98
the size of the tree or shrub when it is fully grown.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations How will the change in project Based on the assessment of raw water quality, the monthly Measures on Water Usage details particularly on sending data indicated that the raw water quality was mostly within the Look for ways to improve water consumption raw water directly to the cooling range suitable for use in the cooling tower. The maximum efficiency such as reducing the amount of water tower help reduce the water water turbidity was used in the study and was what the model discharged from the cooling system or considering
consumption? was based on. Raw water can be used without having to water recycling to ensure maximum utilization of undergo preliminary water quality treatment system, reducing water. the amount of water that could be wasted when passing Check the condition of water pipes and repair any through the treatment system (The exception will be during leakage immediately to prevent loss of water. the period when water turbidity is high. The project will control In the case that water is in shortage and that the the quality of water in the cooling tower before sending it to industrial estate is unable to supply water to the the cooling water holding pond of the industrial estate. The project, the project will reduce production aforementioned measure helps reduce the water consumption capacity or cease the operation. from 63,000 cubic meters per day to 59,991 cubic meters per day. How does the gas pipeline connect The gas pipeline connect to the Sriracha power plant has a to the project site? And will the diameter of 28 inches. It connects with Line 5 of the gas project construct a new high transmission system of PTT, which is located near the gas voltage transmission line as this is pipeline Line 4, which already exists. The starting point is concerning human rights located under the 500 kV transmission line. The pipeline is laid deprivation and impacts on the along the road and the central area of the industrial estate
Page community. except for the pipeline crossing Kram Canal and Sugar Mill- Pluak Daeng Road. The total length of the gas pipeline is 7 Chapter
7- approximately 2.67 kilometers.
99
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations The construction of the new high voltage transmission line to connect the project site and the Pluak Daeng Power Plant of EGAT will be carried out by EGAT. EGAT will designate a committee to make a decision on the location of the
transmission line. It is also necessary to receive an approval and permission for the power grid area from the Energy Regulatory Commission. The decision made on the transmission line will take into consideration the stability, safety, and impacts on the community. Will the machine operation using Sriracha Power Plant is a large power plant designed to operate Measures on Noise Impact diesel, which is reserve fuel, lead using diesel, which is reserve fuel. Diesel fuel will be used in In the installation of machines causing loud noise to noise or smoke pollution the case that natural gas cannot be used according to the for the Sriracha power plant project, a noise (smoke) or not? sales and purchase agreement between the power plant and reduction equipment must be installed. For EGAT, or in the case that EGAT orders for the operation to be example, Silencer will be placed at the end of the continued using reserve fuel, but only for a short period of tube that may potentially produce a loud noise. time. The project has evaluated the impacts on various A building will be built to enclose machinery relevant aspects. For example, the impact on the quality of located at a combustion chamber of the gas the air in case of using diesel as fuel was evaluated using a turbine, power generator area, gas turbine, water mathematical model, and it was found that the air quality was pump motor, and stream generator unit (HRSG).
Page still within the range of the specified standards. As for the The propeller used for the cooling unit will be the
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
impact from noise, the project used the maximum volume of type that creates low noise level.
7-
100 the machine operation to evaluate the impact, and it was
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations found that the noise level was within the specified standards. The noise level at the fence area of the project must not exceed 70 decibels (A). Construct noise mapping/noise contour to identify areas with the high noise level in the first year of
the operation and continue with the process every 3 years. Install a noise barrierat the fence area in the northeast direction of the project, which is adjacent to Chomchon Borisat Namtal Tawan-aok School. The height of the wall must be at least 10 meters. The material used for the wall initially will be glass fiber reinforce cement with a thickness of approximately 100 millimeters, or other materials that have transmission loss (TL) of 40 decibels (A). Please inform clearly on how The pro∑ect’s demand for diesel fuel, which is reserve fuel, Measures on Diesel Transportation much the project should hold a equals that specified in the approved report, which is at 8,500 Training on emergency plan execution reserve on diesel fuel, and what cubic meters per day. The section requested for a change is Measures to prevent fuel leakage the storage method will be. the volume of the two diesel storage tanks from 14,300 cubic Oil spill response must have equipment ready for Has the project been authorized meters for each tank to 23,615 cubic meters for each tank to an emergency at all times.
Page by the Department of Energy ensure sufficient supply of reserve fuel for a 5-day operation Oil spill containment – take action according to
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
Business? instead of a 3-day operation. The project has designed the the oil spill and leakage prevention and response
7-
101 storage tanks to be located in an area surrounded by a plan
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations concrete dike that can hold fuel at 100% of the capacity of the Preventive measures on natural gas pipeline system biggest tank in case the storage tank cracks or leaks. The and diesel pipeline system within the project area practice is in accordance with the Ministerial Notification titled Maintain the gas pipeline system, diesel pipeline Oil Depot B.E. 2556 (2เแ3) . Also, the fire extinguish system system, and operating equipment in a ready-to-
must cover the additional area. use condition. Have a monitoring measure to With regards to the authorization from the Department of ensure safety at all times. Energy Business, it will be processed after the authorized Have a shutdown control system and a relief valve agency grants an approval to the report requesting for changes system to accurately detect abnormalities of in the environmental impact assessment report of the Sriracha pressure in the pipes in a timely manner. Power Plant. Diesel storage tanks are located in an area surrounded by a concrete dike that can hold fuel at 100% of the capacity of the biggest tank in case the storage tank cracks or leaks. The practice is in accordance with the Ministerial Notification titled Oil Depot B.E. 2556 (2เแ3) . The community is concerned Wastewater generated in the project mainly comes from the Management Measures of Cooling Water from the about the wastewater from the cooling tower. The temperature of wastewater will be Project pro∑ect. What are the pro∑ect’s controlled to not exceed 34 degrees Celsius by holding the Provide two cooling water holding ponds with a wastewater treatment measures? wastewater in the pro∑ect’s cooling water holding pond for แ capacity of 19,000 cubic meters each. Each pond
Page It is recommended that the project day. While the wastewater is sitting in the holding pond, the has a 1-day holding capacity to receive water
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
present the wastewater water quality will be tested continuously (online) to ensure discharged from the cooling tower. To prevent
7-
102 monitoring findings to the that the water quality is within a specified standard before leakage, the floor of each pond will be paved with
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations community representatives. being discharged from the cooling tower to the cooling water High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE), or the pond holding pond of the industrial estate, which has been designed will be built as a concrete pond. to hold the cooling water from the power plant before Install an online monitoring system to monitor releasing it to Kram Canal. temperature, acidity, conductivity, and dissolved
Besides specifying the monitoring measures of water quality oxygen level in the cooling water holding pond of before discharge to the industrial estate, which is in line with the power plant. The monitoring results will be the measures of the industrial estate, the project has also displayed on the measurement monitoring screen initiated measures to monitor the quality of surface water placed in front of the project site and at the during the construction and operational period of the project. wastewater control center of the Hemaraj Eastern The monitoring results of the wastewater quality of the project Seaboard Industrial Estate. and the quality of surface water will be collated into a report The project must ensure that the quality of water of measure implementation results. The report will be drained from the cooling tower follows the submitted to the government agency and the pro∑ect’s measure of the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial environmental impact monitoring committee, which also Estate. The measure mandates that the quality of consists of the community representatives as members the effluent from the cooling tower must be in The project has evaluated the combined impacts of accordance with the Notifications of the Ministry wastewater from the project and wastewater from the of Industry No. 2 (B.E. 2539), which specifies the industrial estate on surface water quality and water ecology. quality of water discharged from the plant. The results showed a low level of impact on aquatic organisms, However, for the total dissolved solids, the effluent
Page and water was fit for watering plants. must meet the effluent standard for irrigation water set by the Irrigation Department (TDS must not 7 Chapter
7-
103 exceed 1,300 milligrams/liter). Also, the
temperature must not exceed 34 degrees Celsius.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations Drainage Measures Provide the rainwater drainage gutter of the project is connected to the drainage system of the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate.
Contaminated rainwater will be drained into the oil separator to filter out oil. Non-contaminated water will be discharged to the wastewater pond for a quality check to ensure that the standard set by the industrial estate is met before discharge to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. Regularly check the rainwater drainage gutter in the project area to avoid clogging problems. Clean the drainage gutter during the dry season of every year to improve drainage efficiency in the project area Public Relations Measures Establish an environmental impact monitoring committee that starts operating from the pre-
Page construction period to the operational period. The term of office is 4 consecutive years, not 7 Chapter
7-
104 exceeding 2 terms.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations A concern was raised regarding The floor of the wastewater holding pond and the cooling Drainage Measures the flow direction of wastewater water holding pond will be paved with HDPE to ensure that Provide the rainwater drainage gutter of the from the project and whether there is no wastewater seepage into the groundwater. In project is connected to the drainage system of the wastewater would be released to addition, the water quality will be tested continuously (online) Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate.
the wellspring area outside the to ensure that the water quality is within a specified standard Contaminated rainwater will be drained into the project site. before being discharged to the industrial estate. Also, the oil separator to filter out oil. Non-contaminated industrial estate will check the quality of wastewater again water will be discharged to the wastewater pond before discharge to Kram Canal. for a quality check to ensure that the standard set by the industrial estate is met before discharge to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. Regularly check the rainwater drainage gutter in the project area to avoid clogging problems. Clean the drainage gutter during the dry season of every year to improve drainage efficiency in the project area. Most of the wastewater discharged It is a recommendation. Drainage Measures from the project is wastewater Provide the rainwater drainage gutter of the from the cooling tower. The project is connected to the drainage system of the
Page project and the industrial estate Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. 7 Chapter
discharge this wastewater into Contaminated rainwater will be drained into the
7-
105 Nong Pla Lai Canal. Therefore, oil separator to filter out oil. Non-contaminated
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations the project should carefully water will be discharged to the wastewater pond monitor the quality of wastewater for a quality check to ensure that the standard set from the project because the by the industrial estate is met before discharge to Nong Pla Lai Reservoir supplies the central wastewater treatment system of
water for agricultural purpose as Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. well as for consumption in Regularly check the rainwater drainage gutter in nearby areas, such as Bang the project area to avoid clogging problems. Lamung District and Sriracha Clean the drainage gutter during the dry season of District. every year to improve drainage efficiency in the project area. Since the power plant area is According to the Factory Act and the Department of Labor Public Relations Measures located in proximity to the Protection and Welfare, the project must conduct a training In case there is any misunderstanding between the community, how does the project exercise on an emergency plan together with the industrial power plant and the community, the project shall take measures to prevent and estate and other relevant agencies at least once a year. The urgently inform the people of the facts of the correct emergencies? power plant must also carry out an inspection for fire situation through various communication channels protection system, including a sprinkler system and fire and media so that people are informed with accurate extinguishers, every 6 months according to the stipulation of information. The company shall be proactive in relevant laws. Additionally, since the Sriracha Power Plant is demonstrating its willingness to take responsibility located in the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate, in and care for the feelings of the people.
Page case of an emergency that is beyond the capabilities of the Provide opportunities for the public to visit the
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
power plant to handle, the project will coordinate with the power plants to alleviate their concerns.
7-
106 industrial estate to execute the industrial estate’ emergency
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations response plan, which will involve external emergency response Safety Measures for Life and of Property agencies. If it is discovered that the impact occurred is caused by the power plant, the company must immediately remedy the situation, record the
issue in the database with categorization into Affected Individual or Group of Affected Individuals . The Company shall propose a safety measure to prevent future occurrence. Keep a record of affected individuals. Collate key matters arising from complaints or situations and keep the information as organized entry record as evidence. Entry records of details from the investigation, problem resolutions, and negotiation matters as evidence of the power plant’s operation. Why is the project able to reduce The change in project details did not affect the utilization of - the size of the project area the area for electricity generation and transmission system layout? compared with before. It was simply an organization of various components within the project for more compact space and
Page reducing unnecessary space.
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
7-
107
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations A recommendation to set up a It is a recommendation. Public Relations Measures committee consisting of community Establish an environmental impact monitoring representatives, such as the committee that starts operating from the pre- village headman or community construction period to the operational period. The
leader, with each village being term of office is 4 consecutive years, not represented by one person. This exceeding 2 terms. committee is to be included in the environmental impact monitoring committee of the project A request to have the village members join the environmental impact monitoring committee of the project A recommendation for traffic The project has set up transport control measures to ensure Traffic Control Measures management during the construction that the project contractors strictly adhere to the project Plan out the pro∑ect’s materials and equipment period due to frequent traffic measures. transportation routes to avoid creating traffic obstruction problems. Review and revise the pro∑ect’s materials and
Page equipment transportation routes regularly, and make adjustments according to the current 7 Chapter
7-
108 situation.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations Avoid transporting construction materials during rush hours, between 07:30 AM to 08:30 AM and 4:00 PM to 5:00 PM, to reduce traffic congestion. If transportation during such period is required,
the project must request for a permission or approval from relevant agencies and inform the community 2 weeks in advance. Place security staff at the project entrance and exit to provide any necessary assistance. Limited the truck speed on the highway to not exceed 80 kilometers/hour, according to the Land Traffic Act B.E. 2522 (1979) and the Highway Act No. 2 and No. 3 B.E. 2542 (1999). Additionally, the speed limit shall not exceed 40 kilometers/hour in the community area. A suggestion of an additional It is a recommendation. - agenda in a meeting between the project and relevant agencies on the environment to raise
Page awareness on environmental issues
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
7-
109
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations Due to concerns regarding Heat is emitted from the pro∑ect’s pollutant stac−, which is 6เ- Monitoring Measures on Heat Emitted from Power agricultural impacts, it was meter high. Hot air released from the stack will expand and Plants recommended that a thermal become lighter causing it to rise and consequently transfer the Have in place a measure to monitor the emission impact assessment in a 5- temperature to the surrounding atmosphere. The cooler air radius of heat generated from the project
kilometer radius be conducted. then falls down to the ground. From the monitoring of the operation. The monitoring is to cover the project satellite images of the project in the past, it was found that construction area and the air quality monitoring heat was located only in the area of the pollutant stack. station areas; monitor the project’s temperature Power plants, such as Kaeng Khoi 2 Power Plant and Yala Green from the pre-construction period, construction Power Plant, has been operating for more than 10 years under period, and operational period using satellite Gulf Group. The surrounding areas of these power plants are images. agricultural areas. Up until now, no impact from heat on the agricultural output has been found. Having said, the project has put in place a measure to monitor heat emitted from the power plants. Will the operation of the power Heat is emitted from the pro∑ect’s pollutant stac−, which is 6เ- Monitoring Measures on Heat Emitted from Power plant in the future have any meter high. Hot air released from the stack will expand and Plants impact on Chomchon Borisat become lighter causing it to rise and consequently transfer the Have in place a measure to monitor the emission Namtal Tawan-aok School temperature to the surrounding atmosphere. The cooler air radius of heat generated from the project then falls down to the ground. From the monitoring of the operation. The monitoring is to cover the project
Page satellite images of the project in the past, it was found that construction area and the air quality monitoring heat was located only in the area of the pollutant stack. station areas; monitor the temperature 7 Chapter
7- pro∑ect’s
110 Therefore, heat emission at the stack will not increase the from the pre-construction period, construction
atmospheric temperature around the power plant. period, and operational period using satellite images.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations A suggestion to organize a power The project is already providing a site visit activity for the Public Relations Measures plant site visit for the community community. However, should there be more people who are In case there is any misunderstanding between the as a way to communicate project interested, they can form a group and contact the power plant power plant and the community, the project shall information to the people through the pro∑ect’s community relations officer to request a urgently inform the people of the facts of the
site visit. situation through various communication channels and media so that people are informed with accurate information. The company shall be proactive in demonstrating its willingness to take responsibility and care for the feelings of the people. Provide opportunities for the public to visit the power plants to alleviate their concerns. A participant saw a sign at Khao The project will not deliver the same impacts as those stated Public Relations Measures Noi junction protesting against in the protest sign, which mentions black smoke and flame In case there is any misunderstanding between the the power plant. The person coming out from stacks. This is because our power plant is run power plant and the community, the project shall asked for further clarification on by natural gas, which its combustion does not generate black urgently inform the people of the facts of the how the project would ensure smoke. The operation of the project is a closed system, and situation through various communication that such impact like what the hence no flame will come out. The smoke floating above the channels and media so that people are informed sign referred to would not take cooling tower during the evening is the steam that is vented with accurate information. The company shall be
Page place out and is exposed to cold air in the atmosphere, causing it to proactive in demonstrating its willingness to take
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
condense to fog. responsibility and care for the feelings of the
7-
111 people.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations Safety Measures for Life and of Property If it is discovered that the impact occurred is caused by the power plant, the company must immediately remedy the situation, record the
issue in the database with categorization into Affected Individual or Group of Affected Individuals . The Company shall propose a safety measure to prevent future occurrence. Will the request to change the The project is currently in the process of studying and preparing - details of the project lead to the a report requesting for changes in project details. Once change of the construction plan completed, the report will be presented to the authorizing from the original plan that aims agency for an approval. Then, the letter of approval will be to commence the construction in attached to the application for a construction permit that will March 2019? be submitted to the Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand and the Office of the Energy Regulatory Commission. The construction is expected to commence by the end of 2018, in order to keep pace with the power supply schedule of the first unit in March 2021 (construction period is approximately 3 years). Page The pro∑ect’s measure to reduce Construction Period: The project has planned to set up a 5- Noise Control Measures (Construction period) 7 Chapter
noise impacts states that a 5- meter high temporary noise barrieron the side adjacent to Ensure that all equipment and tools are
7-
112 meter tall noise barrierwill be Chomchon Borisat Namtal Tawan-aok School. In addition to inspected, maintained, and repaired in good
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations installed on the side adjacent to this, during the construction period, a wooden barrier will be condition by following the maintenance manual Chomchon Borisat Namtal used to reduce the impact of the pile driver and pile. of the tool and equipment. Tawan-aok School. If the school Additionally, space will be allocated for pile driving activities Safety Measures for Life and of Property still experiences noise disturbance to further reduce noise impact generate. If it is discovered that the impact occurred is
after the wall installation, what Operational Period: The project has planned to plant trees caused by the power plant, the company must would be the additional measure around the project area and to install a 10-meter noise immediately remedy the situation, record the the project take to resolve the barrieron the on the side adjacent to Chomchon Borisat Namtal issue in the database with categorization into issue? Tawan-aok School. If the school is still affected by the noise Affected Individual or Group of Affected during the operational period, the project will discuss with the Individuals . The Company shall propose a safety school again to implement a more effective measure to reduce measure to prevent future occurrence. noise impact generated. Measures on Noise Impact (Operational Period) In the installation of machines causing loud noise for the Sriracha Power Plant Project, a noise reduction equipment must be installed. For example, Silencer will be placed at the end of the tube that may potentially produce a loud noise. A building will be built to enclose machinery located at a combustion chamber of the gas turbine, power generator area, gas turbine, water
Page pump motor, and stream generator unit (HRSG). The propeller used for the cooling unit will the 7 Chapter
7-
113 type that creates low noise level.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations The noise level at the fence area of the project must not exceed 70 decibels (A). Construct noise mapping/noise contour to identify areas with the high noise level in the first year of
the operation and continue with the process every 3 years. Install a noise barrierat the fence area in the northeast direction of the project, which is adjacent to Community School of Namtan Ta Wan Oak Company. The height of the wall must be at least 10 meters. The material used for the wall initially will be glass fiber reinforce cement with a thickness of approximately 100 millimeters, or other materials that have transmission loss (TL) of 40 decibels (A). Does the project have a contour Since the raw water supply for the industrial estate comes from Management Measures of Cooling Water from the check of groundwater? Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate and is sourced by Project East Water, the project does not use groundwater. Having said, Provide two cooling water holding ponds with a the floor of the wastewater holding pond and the cooling capacity of 19,000 cubic meters each. Each pond
Page water holding pond will be paved with HDPE to ensure that has a 1-day holding capacity to receive water
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
there is no wastewater seepage into groundwater. In addition, discharged from the cooling tower. To prevent
7-
114 the project has put in place a measure to monitor a quality of leakage, the floor of each pond will be paved with
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations groundwater in the project area. High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE), or the pond will be built as a concrete pond. Install an online monitoring system to monitor temperature, acidity, conductivity, and dissolved
oxygen level in the cooling water holding pond of the power plant. The monitoring results will be displayed on the measurement monitoring screen placed in front of the project site and at the wastewater control center of the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. The project must ensure that the quality of water drained from the cooling tower follows the measure of the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. The measure mandates that the quality of the effluent from the cooling tower must be in accordance with the Notifications of the Ministry of Industry No. 2 (B.E. 2539), which specifies the quality of water discharged from the plant. However, the total dissolved solids of the
Page effluent must follow the standard for irrigation water set by the Irrigation Department (TDS must 7 Chapter
7-
115 not exceed 1,300 milligrams/liter). Also, the
temperature must not exceed 34 degrees Celsius.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations Drainage Measures Provide the rainwater drainage gutter of the project is connected to the drainage system of the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate.
Contaminated rainwater will be drained into the oil separator to filter out oil. Non-contaminated water will be discharged to the wastewater pond for a quality check to ensure that the standard set by the industrial estate is met before discharge to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. Regularly check the rainwater drainage gutter in the project area to avoid clogging problems. Clean the drainage gutter during the dry season of every year to improve drainage efficiency in the project area Since LLIT Co., Ltd., which is next The project is located within the industrial estate, which has Management Measures of Cooling Water from the to the power plant area, is situated rainwater collection system and a retention pond designed for Project in a higher ground compared with the industrial estate. The project has also designed rainwater Provide two cooling water holding ponds with a
Page our power plant, does the project drainage gutters to be used within and surrounding the project capacity of 19,000 cubic meters each. Each pond
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
have a measure to prevent water area during the construction and operational period. Rainwater has a 1-day holding capacity to receive water
7-
116 flowing from the surrounding areas? collected in the project area will be stored in the retention discharged from the cooling tower. To prevent
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations pond for reuse within the project area. This also helps reduce leakage, the floor of each pond will be paved with impact from water discharge from the project on the High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE), or the pond surrounding area. will be built as a concrete pond. Install an online monitoring system to monitor
temperature, acidity, conductivity, and dissolved oxygen level in the cooling water holding pond of the power plant. The monitoring results will be displayed on the measurement monitoring screen placed in front of the project site and at the wastewater control center of the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. The project must ensure that the quality of water drained from the cooling tower follows the measure of the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. The measure mandates that the quality of the effluent from the cooling tower must be in accordance with the Notifications of the Ministry of Industry No. 2 (B.E. 2539), which specifies the quality of water discharged from the
Page plant. However, the total dissolved solids of the effluent must follow the standard for irrigation 7 Chapter
7-
117 water set by the Irrigation Department (TDS must
not exceed 1,300 milligrams/liter). Also, the
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Consultationsand Public Information Disclosure, PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.6-14 SUMMARY OF KEY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS RAISED BY MEETING PARTICIPANTS, AND RESPONSES FOR FURTHER IMPLEMENTATION (CONT’D) Key Questions, Concerns, and Responses at Forum/Additional Clarifications Proposal of Measures to Support Implementation Recommendations temperature must not exceed 34 degrees Celsius. Drainage Measures Provide the rainwater drainage gutter of the project is connected to the drainage system of the
Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. Contaminated rainwater will be drained into the oil separator to filter out oil. Non-contaminated water will be discharged to the wastewater pond for a quality check to ensure that the standard set by the industrial estate is met before discharge to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. Regularly check the rainwater drainage gutter in the project area to avoid clogging problems. Clean the drainage gutter during the dry season of every year to improve drainage efficiency in the project area.
Page
Chapter 7 7 Chapter
7-
118
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
Suitability/Sufficiency of Measures to Prevent and Resolve Environmental Impacts Stemmed from the Changes in Details of Sriracha Power Plant Project: 79.0% of the respondents said that the measures taken were appropriate/ sufficient to prevent and resolve the environmental impacts caused by the changes in project details. Another 12.1% indicated that the measures taken were not suitable/not enough and that additional measures regarding air quality, preventive measures of sensitive areas, noise measures, and measures to prevent long-term impact etc., should be added. Another 7.1 % said that they were not sure because the project had not started. However, the impacts should be clearly stated/should be resolved clearly in case there are any impacts arisen from the operation, power generation, etc. The remaining 1.8 % did not give any comments because the project had not started yet, they did not have the knowledge about electricity, and they would like to study the details first. Suitability/Sufficiency of Monitoring Measures of Environmental Impacts of Sriracha Power Plant Project: 77.8% of the respondents said that the measures were appropriate/sufficient to monitor the environmental impacts, while 11.7% indicated that it was inappropriate/inadequate, saying that additional measures should be added, for example, details of data used in assessing the long-term impacts of the project, air quality measures, involvement of the community members in the monitoring process, and communication of the project information to the public, etc. Another 8.1% of the respondents were uncertain, and the remaining 2.4% did not comment. Concerns towards the changes in project details of the Sriracha Power Plant Project: 75.4% of the respondents did not have any concerns regarding the change of project details, while 24.6 % were worried about the change in the details of the project. Points of concern were such as air quality (dust, air, smoke), the frequency of environmental impact assessment, the long-term environmental impact, the impact on nearby residents, the impact on water consumption, safety, the impact on water quality such as wastewater, and measure compliance of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Suggestions/Comments: Respondents gave the following comments and useful suggestions as follows: Environment and Measures
Consider planting trees within the project because some community representatives visited other power plants in the past and found that there were no trees planted at all. Therefore, the project should plant some trees to create a green area within the power plant area.
The project should have explained/met with the community to clarify the cause of the white smoke, which is actually steam generated from the operation. Since the community
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-119 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
didn’t −now what that white smo−e was and what impacts could it bring, hence the people were are quite frightened and misunderstood that it was fire.
The meeting presentation should address whether or not the chemicals used are dangerous or could pose negative impacts on the health of the people.
Suggestion to use bored piles instead of driven piles. This will reduce the impact on noise level and the vibration during the construction period
Look for a source of reserve water to support the production of electricity.
The project should ensure the best quality control of water discharged from the project before releasing into the natural stream. Water quality control must encompass all aspects, especially water temperature and other contaminants.
Strictly comply with the relevant laws/regulations as agreed with the community. Public Participation
A suggestion to organize activities with the community regularly to build good relationships with the people
The people in the community should be involved in the environmental impact assessment and monitoring of the project measures.
A suggestion for a regular meeting to clarify or listen to the opinions of people in the community
If any operation or any activity that results from the production process that generates a significant impact, the project should notify the community and the companies/businesses nearby.
There are activities or activities that result from the production process that have quite an impact, it is requested to notify the community and the company/businesses nearby. Participants also gave their comments in the questionnaire. Key issues are summarized as follows: Environment and Measure Establishment
Why do you choose to operate in an area close to the temple community or school?
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-120 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
If the nearby community or nearby school is affected by the operation, how will the company remedy the situation? Increase the green area within the power plant by building a natural wall made of layers of large trees especially on the side that is adjacent to the school because trees help absorb the toxins.
Will the operation of the power plant have any future impact on the area/community? During the construction period of the power plant, what are the tangible solutions/remedies to the community regarding the impact on the traffic? Concerns regarding the environmental impact during the construction period. Strict control measures should be put in place to ensure that impacts on various areas – such as water, noise, air, dust – are under the specified standards. After the construction has been completed, what measures/guidelines are the company going to establish for areas such as occupational health, potential accidents? Where does the water source for the project come from? How much water is needed to produce electricity? The water quality of the power plant should be checked before discharging into public water.
Will there be a chance of leaking in the long run for natural gas that is passed through the pipeline? Operations should not create negative impacts such as air quality, noise from the operation, and wastewater treatment on the community/agricultural activities During the production of electricity, the evaporation of water will result in water vapor that will not fall into the atmosphere. How will the community know?
The project should strictly follow what was stated/what was told to the people. Public Participation
In case of setting up 3 committees, all villages/communities should be given opportunities to be part of the committees so that the people can inquire about project information from the community leaders. More community representatives should have opportunities
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-121 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
to visited/learn about the project because not many people in the community have a chance to visit the project site. Most of the visitors are the community leaders. Therefore, the opportunity should be distributed fairly.
The communities should be given opportunities to be involved in monitoring the environmental impact of Sriracha Power Plant.
Support community activities, for example, providing health checkups for children and elderly people in the area every year, supporting educational activities such as English language, music and sports. What benefits does the power plant operation give to the community surrounding the power plan?
A suggestion for the power plant to set up a fund for each sub-district and specify the amount of each fund. The money will be used to assist the respective sub-district residents in the case of natural disasters such as typhoon, flood, etc. After the meeting and the public hearing session, the consultants prepared a summary of outcomes of the meeting and the public hearing session including the details of the project, meeting agenda, list of attendees, questions, concerns, suggestions, explanations/additional clarifications. A request was made to post the summary of outcomes of the above activities from 17-19 April 2018 at the local government offices and the communities within the study area (an example of the post of the meeting summary is shown in Photo 7.6-14).
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-122 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
PHOTO 7.6-14 : THE POSTING CONCLUSION OF THE PUBLIC HEARING
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-123 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
7.7 CONCLUSION OF PUBLIC PARTICIPATION ACTIVITIES The public participation activities under the study and preparation of the report on the environmental impact assessment for Sriracha Power Plant Project” of Gulf SRC Company Limited emphasized on giving information about the Project from the start of the study phase, during the study of the environmental impact, and the preparation of the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures of the Project through the correct and precise explanation of the information to the target groups, using the appropriate format of activities suitable to the condition of the area and the target groups. The conclusion of the activities is as follows: (1) Activity taken in accordance with the 2014 guideline on public participation and the social impact assessment in the environmental impact analysis of the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (a) Media used in the three Public Hearings included personal media and printed media. It was found that the personal media was an efficient mean because it was a two-way communication with conversation, consultation, and exchange of opinion. The activities covered all levels of the target groups and made it possible to know the initial reaction of the target groups. As for the printed media used such as public relations brochure of the Project, meeting document, still picture for PowerPoint presentation, questionnaire for opinions in the meeting were able to promote the understanding of the target groups and express opinion about the Project in various channels. (b) Contents in the publicity of the three Public Hearings are as follows: st Documents of the 1 public relations of the Project set out details of the background of the Project, initial details of the Project, studied area, operation area, procedure of the operation, length of the operational period, and the scope of study of the environmental impact. nd Documents of the 2 Public Hearing of the Project set out details of the results of study of the environmental impact, draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures and the communication channels. rd Documents of the 3 Public Hearing of the Project set out details of the changes in project details. The public relations and publicity of the details of the Project help public become aware of the details about the Project throughout the study period and the period for the preparation of the environmental impact assessment report and build knowledge and understanding of the development of the Project.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-124 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(c) The participation in the knowledge of the information about the Project gave the opportunity to the public to express opinions, concerns, and suggestions which were beneficial to the Project through the study period from various channels such as through the public relations personnel of Gulf Group of Companies, through activity of the Public Hearings and questionnaire in the hearings. The target groups could be categorized into the groups which participated in the 1st and 3rd Public Hearings in accordance the 2014 guideline on public participation and the social impact assessment in the environmental impact analysis of the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning as shown in Table 7.7-1. Key issues from the public hearings are summarized as follows: st Incorporate the issues from the 1 hearing to improve the initial scope of study on the environmental impact; outline the draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures; outline draft environmental impact monitoring measures it in the documents of the 2nd hearing. nd rd Incorporate the issues and concerns from the 2 and 3 hearing to improve the measures to be more comprehensive and conformed to the demands and concerns of the community and appended them in the environmental impact assessment report which is in the Chapter 9 Environmental Mitigation Plan. Moreover, the Questionnaire survey will be used for interviewing according to sample size and statistic calculation once a year, for entire construction and operation periods as details in the Chapter 9 Environmental Mitigation Plan. (2) Implementation following Regulation of the Office of the Prime Minister on Public Hearing B.E.2548 The environmental impact study of Sriracha Power Plant Project” of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. emphasizes on creating knowledge and understandings which will lead to acceptance of the project and participation in monitoring by the target groups at all level. This is consistent with the Constitutional Law of the Kingdom of Thailand B.E.2550 on the Right regarding Information and Complaints (Section 55 and Section 57), and the Right of Communities (Section 67) together with an approach on public participation in relation to assessment and its procedure of social and environmental impact B.E.2557, Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning and the framework of the Prime Minister’s Office on Public Participation B.E.2548 (2เเ5). The pro∑ect implementation following the Regulations of the Office of the Prime Minister on relevant issues can be summarized as shown in Table 7.7-2.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-125
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-1 STAKEHOLDER GROUP PARTICIPATING IN 1ST, 2ND AND 3RD PUBLIC HEARING Classification of Stakeholders Number of Participants (Person) Stakeholder Group and Its Composition Stakeholders Group Related to the Project 1st Hearing 2nd Hearing 3rd Hearing แ. Affected Persons including affected persons and - Community headman within 5 km radius from 69 66 the beneficiaries the project boundary - Local people within 5 km radius from the project แ,เ95 824 490 boundary - Related enterprises แ9 32 2. Organizations responsible for preparation of the - Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. แแ แ3 report on the environmental impact assessment - TEAM Consulting Engineering and Management 6 6 including a project proponent and corporation Co., Ltd. 15 having rights to prepare environmental impact assessment report 3. Organizations responsible for consideration of the - Office of Natural Resources and Environment - - report on the environmental impact assessment Policy and Planning (ONEP) including organization considering environmental - Office of Energy Regulatory Commission region 8 - แ 3 impact assessment, report, organization authorized (ERC) to approve the project and organization granting permission 4. Government agencies - Provincial government agencies such as - แ6 Provincial Office of Natural Resources and 91 Environment, Office of Provincial Energy and
Page Provincial Public Health Office, etc.
Chapter 7Chapter
7-
126
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-1 ST ND RD STAKEHOLDER GROUP PARTICIPATING IN 1 , 2 AND 3 PUBLIC HEARING (CONT’D) Classification of Stakeholders Number of Participants (Person) Stakeholder Group and Its Composition Stakeholders Group Related to the Project 1st Hearing 2nd Hearing 3rd Hearing - District government agencies such as District - 2เ Public Health Office, District Agricultural Extension Office, and District Community Development Office, etc. - Sub-district government agencies such as SAO 2เ8 243
and Tambon Health Promoting Hospital, etc. 5. Private environmental organizations, private - Local educational institutions แ8 27 development bodies, local educational institutions, - Environmental network แ3 2เ 6 higher educational institutions, and independent scholars Mass media comprises mass media in the central - 6. Local mass media and newspaper แเ แ6 1 and local levels 7. Interested general public comprises Public - Interested public not within the study area. 3 426 interested in the project who will play a role as 7 observers. Total of Participants 1,452 1,710 613 Remark : The number of staff of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and of TEAM Consulting Engineering and Management Co., Ltd. was counted only แ time (แ stage).
Page
Chapter 7Chapter
7-
127
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-2 PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION FOLLOWING REGULATIONS OF THE PRIME MINISTER’S OFFICE ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION B.E.2548 (2005) Regulations Steps taken by the Project Clauses แ, 2, 3 and 4 - Definition Clause 5 – Prior to commencement of any state projects, Implementation on public participation for the study and preparation of report on environmental impact the responsible agencies must disseminate information, assessment of Sriracha Power Plant Project of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. was undertaken as follows: following clause 7 to inform the people and may 1. Dissemination of the Project Information organize a public consultation by one or more means, as Meeting with related government agencies and community headman within the study area to
specified in clause 9. promote and inform preliminary project information, and consult about conducting public participation. Media used for public relations activities at sub-district level in the study area of 5 km radius from the project location was personal amd printing media and documents such as the 1st public relation leaflets of the project were distributed to inform about preliminary implementation of the project for public awareness, etc. The invitation notice to participate the meeting was posted 15 days prior to the meeting date to invite interested people to participate in 3 times of public hearing. The first one was to introduce the project to the communities, the second one was to present findings from the study together with environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures and the third one was to present the changes in project details. Prior to the meeting, supplementary document and other public relation media were distributed to the participants so that they are aware of project information before the meeting starts.
Page
Chapter 7Chapter
7-
128
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-2 (Cont’d) PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION FOLLOWING REGULATIONS OF THE PRIME MINISTER’S OFFICE ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION B.E.2548 (2005) Regulations Steps taken by the Project 2. Public Consultation Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. and the consultant recognize the importance of a public participation and as such, organized public participation activities among the target groups in order to exchange information and reflect attitudes / idea through two-way communication. They are: st The 1 public hearing was held during 21 July - 7 August 2เแ4. Eight forums were organized, with 1,452 participants in total. The public hearing for Fisherman Group was held on 12 February 2015, with 29 participants in total. nd The 2 was held during 25-29 May 2เแ5. Nine forums were organized, with 1,710 participants in total. rd The 3 was held during 4 April 2เแ8. Two forums were organized, with 598 participants in total. Clause 6 – In case the government agencies do not organize The Sriracha Power Plant Project had organized public hearing activities since the beginning of the public participation activities prior to commencement of project together with during the preparation of report on environmental impact assessment. the projects under clause 5, paragraph 1, and stakeholders request through a minister, the officials at the central or local level would assign the line agencies to listen to people attitudes. In this case, the public participation activities could be organized immediately. Clause 7 – Information related to the state projects must The project aims to create knowledge and understandings among concerned agencies and people. be disseminated to the public. This includes: Media used for public relations comprised all information and contents as specified by the regulations of
Page (1) Rationale and objectives of the project the Office of the Prime Minister under clause 7. They are:
Chapter 7Chapter
7- (2) Main contents of the project (1) Personal Media
129 (3) Implemented agencies and venue Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. staff comprises community relation staff, and environmental engineer
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-2 (Cont’d) PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION FOLLOWING REGULATIONS OF THE PRIME MINISTER’S OFFICE ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION B.E.2548 (2005) Regulations Steps taken by the Project (4) Procedure and implemented period The consultant staff consists of staff who studied on environmental impact, socio-economics and (5) Outputs and outcomes of the project public participation. (6) Potential impact on local people and workers at (2) Printing Media implemented venue and surroundings, including Gulf SRC Co., Ltd and the consultant has produced various media to create knowledge / environmental impact mitigation and preventive understandings among the target groups as follows: st measures and environmental impact monitoring Leaflets for 1 public hearing show project details, rationale and objectives of the project, measures. important contents of the project, implemented area, project proponent, outputs and outcomes (7) Troubles or damage due to potential impact of the project, procedure of the study on environmental impact and public participation together with related expenses. In case of the state approach. nd project, source of implemented fund should be Leaflets for 2 public hearing show project details, rationale and objectives of the project, specified. important contents of the project, implemented area, project proponent, outputs and outcomes of the project, environmental impacts, and draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures for environmental impacts. rd Leaflets for 3 public hearing show the changes in project details, rationale and objectives of the project, important contents of the project, implemented area, project proponent, outputs and outcomes of the project, environmental impacts, and draft environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures for environmental impacts. Announcement of invitation to all interested parties, to attend the meeting for 3 times of public hearing. Presentation by mean of explanation and computer program, which explained the project Page background and details, procedure of construction and the study on environmental impact,
Chapter 7Chapter
7- including findings.
130
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-2 (Cont’d) PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION FOLLOWING REGULATIONS OF THE PRIME MINISTER’S OFFICE ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION B.E.2548 (2005) Regulations Steps taken by the Project Clause 8 – In relation to a public participation activities, The three public hearing activities performed by the study team aimed to create correct understanding the government agencies must put emphasis on clear among public as follows. understandings of the public regarding the state projects, (แ) Provision of information through various public relations media to create correct understanding of together with compilation peoples’ opinions towards the the people about the project. project, including troubles and damage which may occur (2) During the public consultation, peoples were invited to ask questions, discuss and suggest their to the public. The government agencies can listen to the attitudes towards the project. peoples’ opinions and disseminate the information in (3) The consultant had compiled people’s opinions toward the project such as suggestion, concerns, the same time. etc. through various media as follows: Direct expression by asking in the meeting (compiled by tape recording and taking short-note) and expression in the meeting through recommendation form The result was then compiled and used as inputs to formulate environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures to suit the needs and the concerns of the target groups. Clause 9 – Public participation activities under clause 8 Public hearing activities were performed in various forms in order to suit each target group as follows. may be conducted via one method or more, as follows: (1) Meeting with related government agencies and community headman within the study area to (แ) Survey on opinions, by promote and inform preliminary project information, and consult about conducting public (a) Individual interview participation. (b) Invitation to express opinions by post, (2) Three times of public hearing were held as follows: st telephone, fax or through any IT system or other means The 1 public consultation titled The Pro∑ect Opening to give information to the public about (c) Open opportunity for the people to receive the project development. Page nd information and express their opinions to government The 2 public consultation to present finding of the study together with environmental impact
Chapter 7Chapter
7- agencies which responsible to the projects. mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures for
131 (d) Focus group discussion environmental impact.
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-2 (Cont’d) PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION FOLLOWING REGULATIONS OF THE PRIME MINISTER’S OFFICE ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION B.E.2548 (2005) Regulations Steps taken by the Project rd (2) Consultation, by The 3 public consultation to present the changes in project details with environmental impact (a) Public hearing mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures for (d) Public discussion environmental impact. (c) Exchange information (d) Interactive work shop
(3) Other means as specified by the Office of the Permanent Secretary, the Prime Minister’s Office. Clause แเ – In case the government agencies want to Public consultation organized by the project achieved its purpose and therefore there was no need listen to the peoples’ opinions via other methods than to implement by other methods. those specified in clause 9, such public participation activities under clause 8 can be performed by that method. The results must be reported to the Office of the Permanent Secretary, the Prime Minister’s Office. Clause แแ – To organize a public consultation, the Prior to 3 times of the public hearing, the study team had posted notices to invite relevant government agencies must announce the methods used, agencies/organizations, stakeholders and interested people to attend the meetings, 15 days prior to time, venue and details sufficient for public the meeting date. They were posted at the notice board of relevant agencies (in Si Racha District Office, understanding and enable to express opinions under Ban Bueng District Office, and Nong yai Si Racha District Office at Chon Buri Province, as well as Pluak paragraph 1. The announcement must be posted at a Daeng Si Racha District Office at Rayong Province) such as Provincial Office of Natural Resources and conspicuous place at any local authorities’ offices and Environment, Provincial Energy Office, Provincial Public Health Office, District Office, hospitals and SAO the place where the state project will be developed at within the study area, etc. The letters for asking permission to post the notices were sent to those Page least 15 days prior to the public consultation date. It relevant agencies. The durations of notice posting are as follow:
Chapter 7Chapter
7- also has to be posted at the IT system provided by the First time during 2-3 July 2014
132 Second time during 7-8 May 2015
Environmental Report for submittalADB to Report Environmental Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations Public Information Disclosure, Consultationsand PlantPower Project Sriracha
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 TABLE 7.7-2 (Cont’d) PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION FOLLOWING REGULATIONS OF THE PRIME MINISTER’S OFFICE ON PUBLIC PARTICIPATION B.E.2548 (2005) Regulations Steps taken by the Project Office of the Permanent Secretary, the Prime Minister’s Third time during 15-16 March 2018 Office. Clause แ2 – After the public consultation, the government The study team had prepared summary of the public hearing and posted for the public information agencies must prepare its summary. This will be posted within 15 days after the meeting. The summary was posted at the relevant government agencies. The for public information within 15 days from the public durations of summary posting are as follow:
consultation date. Clause 11, paragraph 2 applies to the First time during 20-21 August 2014 notice under this clause. Second time during 11-12 June 2015 Third time during 17-19 April 2018 Clause แ3 - After the public consultation, in case any state Gulf SRC Co., Ltd appointed a community relation team to work in the project area since before the projects cause more impacts other than those informed study and during the study. This activity is ongoing until the construction period, and system testing in to public under clause 7 (7), if necessary for the project order to minimize impacts other than those found during the environmental impact study. The tasks to proceed, the responsible agencies must formulae are: additional preventive, mitigation and remedy measures แ. Dissemination information about the project and construction periodically. It is necessary that the for troubles or damage that may be occurred from those team informs project information to community within the study area before the project activities impacts before commencement of the project. This has starts. to be announced to the public. In this regard, clause แแ, 2. Listening to opinions/suggestions of the people and clarification responded to the public worries paragraph 2 applies to this clause. towards the activities implemented by the project. 3. Receiving complaints in relation to damage which may be caused by the construction activities and coordination with relevant parties in terms of improving / remedy the damage. 4. Monitoring the contractors to ensure they strictly follow the mitigation measures. Page
Chapter 7Chapter
7-
133
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 7 Sriracha Power Plant Project Information Disclosure, Public Consultations and Participations
(3) Implementation following ADB requirements Stakeholders for this project were identified in accordance with the guideline on public participation and the social impact assessment in the environmental impact analysis of the ONEP (2เแ4). Comparison of sta−eholder’s groups with ABD requirements (ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT GUIDELINES, 2003) and ONEP are as shown in Table 7.7-3.
TABLE 7.7-3 COMPARISON OF STAKEHOLDER’S GRO“PS WITH ABD REQ“IREMENTS (ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT GUIDELINES, 2003) and ONEP ADB Requirement ONEP(2014) There are 5 categories of stakeholders: There are 7 categories of stakeholders: 1.Local communities 1.Project Affected Persons including both gain and losses benefits: Community leader and local people within the study area of the project 2.Civil society Community leader in 1. 3.Government and local government 3.Organizations responsible for consideration of the bodies report on the environmental impact assessment; 4.Related government agencies at the provincial, district, and sub-district levels in the study area; 4.Private sector bodies 5.Private environmental organizations, private development bodies, local educational institutions, higher educational institutions, and independent scholars; 5.Other institutions 2. Organizations responsible for preparation of the report on the environmental impact assessment; 6. Mass media 7. Interested general public
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61023-chap 7_1 Page 7-134 CHAPTER 8 GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 8 Sriracha Power Plant Project Grievance Redress Mechanism
CHAPTER 8 GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM
8.1 COMMUNITY GRIEVANCES Complaints related to communities’ issues complaints or inconveniences caused by the project during construction and implementation shall be handled and prioritized for immediate resolution. Scheme of operation on GSRC Power Plant Pro∑ect’s complaint receiving as shown in Figure 8.1-1 and Figure 8.1-2. The power plant will be the complaint receiving center (CRC) and this information will be continuously disseminated by the public relations staff including project information using local radio, announcement post on strategic areas such as community leader offices and sub district organization offices, and other methods which are related to objectives for a month before starting construction activities. Local peoples could send complaints by verbal, telephone, memorandum, letters, e-mail, and fax. Timely and effective redress of stakeholder grievances contribute to bringing sustainability in the operations of a project. In particular, it will help advocate the process of forming and strengthening relationships between the project and the stakeholder community groups and bridge any gaps to create a common understanding, providing the project management a good environment to operate in the area. The grievance redress mechanism proposed for the Project will help achieve the objectives of sustainability and cooperation by dealing with the environmental and social issues of the Project. The proposed grievance redress mechanism will be designed to cater for the issues of the people that can be affected by the Project. The population that can be affected by the Project has been identified in previous sections (Description of Socioeconomic Environment), and comprises of the people residing within three kilometers from both banks of the river.
8.2 FRAMEWORK FOR GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM
8.2.1 External Communications GSRC will implement and maintain a procedure for external communications that includes methods to (i) receive and register external communications from the public; (ii) screen and assess the issues raised and determine how to address them; (iii) provide, track, and document responses, if any; and (iv) adjust the management program, as appropriate. In addition, GSRC is encouraged to make publicly available periodic reports on their environmental and social sustainability.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61024-Chap 8 Page 8-1 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 8 Sriracha Power Plant Project Grievance Redress Mechanism
FIGURE 8.1-1 : SCHEME OF OPERATION ON GSRC POWER PLANT PROJECT’S COMPLAINT RECEIVING
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61024-Chap 8 Page 8-2 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 8 Sriracha Power Plant Project Grievance Redress Mechanism
Complainant
Sriracha Power Plant Complaint Center
Forward to management to assign personnel to undertake corrective action
Corrective action in 24 hr.
Inform Complainant of
Progress
Monitor progress and report to local administrative organization
FIGURE 8.1-2 : EMERGENCY COMPLAINT PROCEDURE
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61024-Chap 8 Page 8-3 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 8 Sriracha Power Plant Project Grievance Redress Mechanism
8.2.2 Grievance Mechanism for Affected Communities Where there are affected communities, GSRC will establish a grievance mechanism to receive and facilitate resolution of Affected Communities’ concerns and grievances on the power plant’s construction and operation. The grievance mechanism should seek to resolve concerns promptly, using an understandable and transparent consultative process that is culturally appropriate and readily accessible, and at no cost and without retribution to the party where the issue or concern. The mechanism should not impede access to judicial or administrative remedies. The client will inform the Affected Communities about the mechanism in the course of the stakeholder engagement process.
Ongoing Reporting to Affected Communities GSRC will provide periodic reports to the affected communities that describe progress of implementation of the agreed action plan/remedial measures on issues raised. The frequency of these reports will be proportionate to the concerns of affected communities but not less than annually.
Proposed Mechanism for Grievance Redress Under the Project the following will be established or appointed to ensure timely and effective handling of grievances: Complaint Receiving Center (CRC), which will be responsible to receive, log, and resolve complaints. Local Committee or Environmental Impact Committee, may be leaders or representatives from each community or village that can be approached by the community members for their grievances against the Project. The Local Committee or Environmental Impact Committee also forms part of a group in charge of monitoring environmental impacts of the project. Facilitation of grievance resolution will be their additional function
Details of the proposed mechanism are given below. Function and Structure of CRC During the construction period when the issues are mainly expected to arise, public relations staff will be responsible for coordinating correspondence and preparing documentation work and will assist the unit. The local staff assigned at the site will be responsible to prepare the documentation which will be reviewed by the head of CRC. The CRC will be responsible to receive, log, and resolve grievances.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61024-Chap 8 Page 8-4 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 8 Sriracha Power Plant Project Grievance Redress Mechanism
Function and Structure of CRC The CRC will function as an independent body that will operationalize the grievance redress process. It will comprise of: Manager of environment, health and safety department, GSRC Site Manager / Plant Manager that is responsible to oversee the contractors, GSRC Operation Manager Maintenance Manager Administrative Manager A representative of Community Relation Department The CRC will meet with the Local Committee or the Environmental Impact Committee once every three months to review the grievance redress process; the frequency can be changed depending on the nature and frequency of grievances received. The performance will be gauged in terms of the effectiveness and the timeliness with which grievances were managed. In case there are any unresolved or pending issues, the CRC will deliberate on mechanisms to resolve those and come up with solutions acceptable to everyone.
Procedure of Filing and Resolving Grievances Grievances will be logged and resolved using the following steps: Step 1: Receive and Acknowledge Complaint Once the CRC receives a complaint, which could be the complainant giving it in person, via letter or email, through phone call, or through the Local Committee or the Environmental Impact Inspection Committee (LC/EIIC), an acknowledgement of receipt of the complaint will be sent within one working days to the complainant. Complaints could be able to be anonymous as well. Step 2: Investigation The CRC will work to understand the cause of the grievance for which the CRC may need to contact the complainant again and obtain details. The CRC will be required to complete preliminary investigations within five working days upon receipt of complaint and send a response to the complainant documenting the results of their investigations and what the CRC plans to do ahead. Step 3: Resolution through CRC Once the CRC have investigated a grievance, it will share with the complainant the proposed course of action to resolve the complaint, should CRC believe any to be necessary. If the complainant considers the grievance to be satisfactorily resolved, the CRC will log the complaint as resolved in their records.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61024-Chap 8 Page 8-5 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 8 Sriracha Power Plant Project Grievance Redress Mechanism
In case the grievance remains unresolved it will be reassessed and LC/EIIC will have further dialogue with the complainant to discuss if there are any further steps, which may be taken to reach a mutually agreed resolution to the problem. For minor or less complex grievances, Steps 1, 2 and 3 or Steps 2 and 3 can be merged. Step 4: Resolution through LC/EIIC In case the CRC is unable to resolve the issue, the matter will be referred to LC/EIIC. All complaints that could not be resolved within four weeks will by default be referred to LC/EIIC. However, the complainant or the CRC can convene the LC/EIIC at any point in time, depending on the nature and urgency of the issue. If the complainant is still not satisfied with the resolution of issues or complaints, he/she can go to local judicial proceedings.
Operating Principles for CRC The CRC will operate on the principles of transparency, approachability and accountability. To achieve these, the CRC will be required to: be equipped to handle grievances in the local languages; be equipped to work through all possible modes of communication, such as, emails, by-post and face-to-face meetings at plant site or requiring visits; maintain a log of all grievances, with record of the date and time of the complaint logged and stakeholder information, such as, name, designation and contact details; provide opportunity to the stakeholder to revert with their comments on the proposed plan of action; keep the stakeholder informed of the progress in grievance resolution; obtain stakeholder consent on the mechanism proposed to redress the grievance and document consent; and maintain confidentiality of the stakeholder, if requested so.
Stakeholder Awareness The stakeholders will be informed of the establishment of the CRC through a short and intensive awareness campaign. Under the awareness campaign, the proponent will share: objective, function and the responsibilities of the CRC; means of accessing the CRC and the mechanics of registering a grievance at the CRC; operating principles of the CRC; and contact details. Additional awareness campaigns may be organized, if necessary.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61024-Chap 8 Page 8-6 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 8 Sriracha Power Plant Project Grievance Redress Mechanism
8.3 WORKERS GRIEVANCE For wor−ers’ grievance, the HR department will be responsible for overall workers in our company, including those working at the site. Grievances/issues will be handled according the regulation of Ministry of Labour. The HR Manager will take the lead in Grievance redress mechanism for workers and grievances will be logged and reported by the HR Department as part of E&S Annual Report for the project. For grievance mechanism for contractors, subcontractors and their workers, workers can feedback to their supervisor, foreman, or administration officer for the issues they have. Also, EPC Construction Contract clause 4.แ.8 (b) states that Contractor shall not take any action to prevent its employees from lawfully exercising their right of free association and their right to organize and bargain collectively. Contractor further agrees to observe applicable Legal Requirements relating to a minimum age for employment of children, acceptable conditions of work with respect to minimum wages, hours of work, and occupational health and safety, and not to use forced labor. Contractor shall give its employees the right to remove themselves from work situations or areas that present serious danger to life or health without ∑eopardizing their future employment.
RNP/ENV-P/P02810/FR (ADB)/RE61024-Chap 8 Page 8-7 CHAPTER 9 ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
CHAPTER 9 ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
The Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. has planned to construct a combined cycle power plant, using natural gas as its primary fuel and diesel as secondary fuel, in the 450 rais area of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate (Hemaraj ESIE). The electricity generating capacity of the power plant is 2,650 MW. The generated power will be sold to EGAT. According to the conduct of EIA within the construction and operation periods, it was found that the project may cause impacts to environment, at low to medium levels. Thus, the project has formulated environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures including measures for monitoring environmental quality. The aims are to reduce environmental impacts to be lowest so that environment resources can be utilized sustainably. Not only the specific action plans for environmental and social aspects, but also general action plan such as guideline of preparation of monitoring report, requirements of modification of the project description, etc. was prepared. The details of a general action plan are as follows: (1) Implement following the environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures in form of environmental action plan, as proposed in the EIA of Sriracha Power Plant Project in Si Racha District, Chon Buri Province. This will be used to inspect, control and examine people, concerned agencies and organizations as well. (2) Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. use details of measures for environmental action plan to formulate the contract conditions, and designate as strictly implementation in order to be effective. (3) Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. submits report on compliance with environmental action plan to the Energy Regulatory Commission of Thailand, Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand, ONEP, Chonburi and Rayong Province to be considered, as 6 months timing. This will follow the approach of presenting examination results of the project environmental quality. (4) Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. maintains and inspects the cooling water system to be in good conditions, ready to be used, and being safe for the working staff and people nearby. (5) In case, the environmental quality examination shows the trend of creating problems together with the complaints from communities due to the project implementation, the company must fix those problems quickly and report to the Energy Regulatory Commission, Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand, ONEP, Chonburi and Rayong Province soon. These aims are established for problems’ solving.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-1 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
(6) In case, Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. is willing to change the project details together with the environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures and environmental impact monitoring measures for environmental impacts that had been already alleviated, the company has to inform the agencies that full has authority to approve as: - In case, the authorized agency considers that the change contributes to positive impacts more than or equivalent to the measures as formulated in the approval EIA, the agency has to inform criteria and conditions designated by relevant laws. The copy of this change has to be submitted ONEP. - In case, the authorized agency considers that the change contributes to the major contents of the approval EIA, the agency has to submit the report on this change to the ONEP for further submission to the concerned EIA Expertise Committee for approved in order to have comments before the change occur. When the project is approved, the authorized agency has to inform ONEP. (7) In case, there are still problems and worries of communities towards the project implementation, the project has to solve those problems immediately in order to alleviate the conflicts with local communities. (8) After the project has been implemented, within the steady state and it is found that the air pollutant emission is lower than the value set in the report, the company has to use the lower value as control value. This has to be informed to ONEP soon. The action plans propose the details for mitigation measures and responsible party for both construction and operation periods. There are 14 action plans as follows: (1) Air Quality Action Plan (2) Noise Action Plan (3) Surface Water Quality and Groundwater Quality Action Plan (4) Water Use Action Plan (5) Transportation Action Plan (6) Waste Management Action Plan (7) Drainage and Flood Control Action Plans (8) Socio-economic Action Plan (9) Public Participation and Relation Action Plan (10) Public Health/Occupational Health and Safety Action Plan (11) Major Hazard Action Plan (12) Green Area and Aesthetics Action Plan (13) Monitoring Action Plan on the Heat Generated from the Power Plant (14) pH of Rainwater and Sulfate Radicals in Soil Monitoring Action Plan Details of each action plan are as follows:
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-2 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Environmental Impact or Risk to Institutional related activities to Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Aspect be Mitigated Responsibilities Construction Period 1. Air Quality - Dust dispersion and − Trucks carrying construction materials must be covered and/or having items being carried tied up to - The result of ambient air quality monitoring Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total exhaust emission prevent the materials from falling and to reduce the amount of dispersion of suspended particulate. within National Ambient Air Quality Standard construction contract impact from − Spray water in the construction area, the soil mounds or where project construction activities causes and WHO Ambient Air Quality Guidelines. cost construction the dispersion of suspended particulate, such as the road, the area undergoing filling and grading, etc. activities to reduce the dispersion of the suspended particulate, at least two times/day (morning and afternoon). When the weather is hot, dry or windy, it is estimated that the sprayed area getting dried and there is a tendency to caused dust dispersion the project will consider to increase frequency on spraying water at the area. − Inspect and maintain condition of engines/machines used in the construction to reduce the emission of air pollutants regularly, each month. − Install shading nets or fences with the height of 3 meters from the ground around the project construction site to prevent suspended particulate from the construction.
− Assign workers cleaning up traffic surface in the area in front of the project area after the entry or exit of the delivery trucks
− Wash tires of the delivery trucks before leaving the construction area or area related to the construction activities to prevent the debris of earth and sand from falling on the road surfaces both inside and outside the project area.
− Prohibit the burning of scrap materials or garbage in the construction area.
− Limit the speed of vehicles in the construction area not to exceed 20 kilometers/hour, not exceeding 40 kilometers/hour in the urban area and not exceeding 80 kilometers/hour on highways.
− Limit the use of the construction area to the absolute necessities and to proceed with the construction promptly − The project will conduct quantification and monitoring of greenhouse gas emission annually in accordance with internationally recognition methodologies. − During construction activities, in case project find cultural heritage resources in the area the project have to stop activity and report to relevant agencies according to the law. 2. Noise - Noise impact from − Use construction equipment that produce loud noise only during the day time from 08.00-17.00. If it - The result of noise monitoring within National Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total construction is necessary to operate after working hours, the Project must obtain approvals from the related Noise Standard and WHO Community Noise construction contract activities agencies and must notify the communities and factories in the vicinity, at least two weeks prior to the Guidelines. cost operation. − Publicize the construction plan that will generate noise and the measures to control noise from the construction to the people of the communities in the vicinity at least two weeks prior to the construction. − Inspect, maintain and repair equipment and tools in good condition at all time and follow the maintenance manual for the equipment and tools continuously. − Install warning sign boards in the area of loud noise and provide protective equipment such as ear plugs and ear muffs for construction workers working in the area of noise exceeding 85 dB (A) and require workers to use the silencers when working in the area of loud noise. − Ensure that the construction contractors strictly comply with the prevention and mitigation measures for noise impacts and require that they use equipment and machines which produce low level of noise.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-3 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 2. Noise (Cont’d) − Install temporary noise barrier along the fence NE of the project which is adjacent to the Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok School and Early Childhood Development Center of Chomphon Chao Phraya Sub-district Municipality. The fence height is not less than 5 meters. The each end of noise barrier turn to noise sources. The west side has a length not less than 50 meters and the south- southeast side has a length not less than 100 meters. Install temporary noise barrier along the fence in the south side of the project which is adjacent to Wat Chompon Chaophraya and Proud Housing Eastate. The fence height is not less than 3 meters and the fence length is not less than 100 m. The chosen material is a steel with a thickness of 1.27 mm (Steel 18ga) or any materials with a transmission loss (TL) of 25 dB(A). (Figure 9-1) 3. Surface Water - Surface water Rain Water Management Measures − The result of wastewater sampling Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total Quality and contamination − Prepare gutters and temporary sedimentation pond within the project area to collect rainwater and within effluent quality standards of construction contract Groundwater allow it to precipitate. Solid sediments are separated from rainwater while the remaining clear water will Thailand and Effluent guidelines for cost Quality be reused for spraying of the project area to reduce the dispersion of the suspended particulate. The thermal power plant remaining water will be drained into the estate’s Rain Gutters. − If any scrap material is found falling into the gutters and blocking or obstructing the flow of the water, it must be removed to allow water to flow freely. − Forbid discarding of scrap material or dirt into the gutters. Measures for Management of Wastewater from the Office Building and the Construction Activities. − Provide sufficient toilets under proper hygienic principle for the construction workers as required by law and provide septic tank or ready-made wastewater treatment tanks to treat wastewater from daily consumption of the construction workers. Allocate wastewater holding pond with holding capacity for at least one day in order to inspect the quality of the discharged water to ensure that it meets the requirement for Building Type C according to the standards prescribed in Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment’s Notification re: Prescribing Standards for Discharged Water from Building of Certain Types and Sizes Prior to Draining Outside. − Provide drainage gutter in the construction area and wastewater holding pond to hold uncontaminated discharged water from the construction activities for inspection of the quality in accordance with the requirements of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate, before draining to the estate’s central wastewater treatment system. − Control the management the contaminated wastewater such as collective wastewater from the engine oil changes in tanks for delivery to a company licensed by the government to dispose. − Repair and maintain vehicles and machines regularly to prevent leakage of fuel provided that it is carried out in the designated area on solid surface with materials for prevention of leakage from flowing into Map Kradon Swamp. Measures for management of wastewater from workers’ camp − Provide for a ready-made wastewater treatment system in the area of the wor−ers’ living quarters including a discharged water retention pond with holding capacity for at least one day to inspect the quality of the discharged water to ensure that it meets the requirement for Building Type C according to the standards prescribed in Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment’s Notification Prescribing Standards for effluent from Building of Certain Types and Sizes Prior to Draining Outside. Measures for management of wastewater from Hydrostatic Test − Install grilles or fine mesh to trap debris or solid contaminants mixed in the water at the end of the drain of the wastewater from the hydrostatic test.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-4 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 3. Surface Water − Inspect the characteristics of the wastewater from the hydrostatic test, such as, pH value, Quality and temperature, suspended solid, oil and grease to ensure that the values are within the standard of Groundwater Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. − In case the wastewater quality is not within the standard of the estate, the project will deliver such Quality (Cont’d) wastewater to be disposed by the company licensed by the government for disposal. 4. Water Use - Water shortage − Require contractors to supply adequate water for use in the construction activities. - Water is sufficient for use during Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total − Require the contractors to provide adequate and hygienic drinking water for construction workers. construction period. construction contract − Require the contractors to coordinate with the estate to allocate water for the hydrostatic test. cost − Storm water from storm water holding pond will be used as the spray water for dust suppression purpose. 5. Transportation - Traffic congestion − Plan for the routes to be used for transportation of construction materials and equipment of the - Record of daily traffic accident occurred Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total and accident from project to avoid traffic problems. during the project construction phase construction contract project − Review and adjust the route plans for the transportation of construction materials and equipment of and produce a monthly report. cost transportation the project regularly to adapt to the current situation. − Avoid transporting construction materials during the rush hours, such as between 07.30 to 08.30 hrs. and between 16.00-17.00 hrs. to alleviate problems of traffic congestion. If transporting during those hours is necessary, seek approval from the relevant agencies and notify the community at least two weeks in advance. − Cover up all trucks completely with tarpaulin to prevent materials from falling on road surface. − Ensure that all contractors order their drivers to strictly comply with the traffic rules. − Control of the truc−s’ loading weight not to exceed the legal limits. − Provide training to and control drivers to comply with traffic rules strictly. − Inspect and maintain the vehicles used in the project, regularly. − Coordinate with traffic police in the area of the transportation of various materials and equipment. − Limit the truc−’s speed on the highway not to exceed 8เ −ilometers/hour in accordance with the Land Transportation Act B.E.2522 and the Highway Act No.2 and No.3 B.E.2542. Limit the speed at 40 kilometers/hour in the community zone. − Install speed limit sign displaying the limit within the construction area not to exceed 20 kilometers/hour. − Display the telephone number of the person in charge of the delivery vehicles as a channel to notify or complain to the project. − Provide security personnel to facilitate the entry into and exit from the project. 6. Waste - Hygiene problem − Assign workers to collect refuse in the designated area at least once a day. - Record of type and volume of general Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total Management − Sanitary toilets shall be adequately provided for construction workers as required by Thai Law. garbage and waste from construction construction contract Additionally, a septic tank or a prefabricated wastewater treatment plant shall be constructed to treat activities. cost wastewater from water used by construction workers so that treated effluents meet the effluent standard. The sewage in the prefabricated wastewater treatment plant shall be pump out for further disposal. The prefabricated wastewater treatment plant will be always maintained to ensure its efficiency throughout the construction phase. − Hazardous waste must be disposed of appropriately stipulated by the announcement of Ministry of Industry on Industrial Waste Management and Disposal B.E.2548 (2005). − Provide refuse bins for collection of refuse with well covered lids and coordinate with the company licensed by the government to collect refuse for disposal.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-5 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 6. Waste Management − Collect, store, and dispose of scrap materials, earth debris and refuse from construction by (Cont’d) appropriate means. − Control any oil waste management from the project i.e. from oil lubricant replacement of engine or construction equipment, kept in containers to be disposed of appropriately following the announcement of Ministry of Industry on Industrial Waste Management and Disposal B.E.2548 (2005). − Ensure that construction workers dispose solid waste in the bins and empty the bins regularly. − Allocate appropriate areas for stock yard. − Strictly prohibit the burning of refuses. − Sort refuses and reusable scrap materials such as, wooden scraps, scrap iron, bricks, paint tins, paint brushes, spray cans and recycle them or reuse or sell them to the buying companies. − The contractors must coordinate with the local municipality or government agency to collect the refuse in order to prevent the refuse from accumulating in the project area which will be a source of disease and foul smells. 7. Drainage and Flood - Flooding in the − Collect and sort scrap materials and refuse from construction activities and send them to the - No flood in construction area. Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total Control construction area company licensed by the government for disposal in order to prevent them from clogging the water construction contract draining route of the project. cost − Design an appropriate rainwater drainage system to prevent obstruction to existing waterways and flooding in the vicinity. − Prohibit discarding of refuse and scrap materials in the water drainage gutters. − Keep checking the water drainage gutters regularly to prevent clogging.
8. Socio-economic - During the Pre-Construction period − Results from socio-economic survey Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total construction period, General Measures and opinion interview with households, construction contract people in the − Support the activities within the community wherever appropriate in order to establish good people, community leader/local leader, cost communities might relationship as a mean of returning benefits to the community and the society. representatives of relevant agencies, still have some − Publicize and clarify facts to the public urgently, in case of misunderstanding between the power local organization and sensitive opinion conflicts plant, and the community through various channels or media so people receive factual information. receptors around the project site i.e. regarding concerns Be prepared to demonstrate that the pro∑ect will ta−e responsibility and care about people’s feeling. hospital, temple, school and about the project. measurement stations of environmental quality Construction period Environmental impact prevention and mitigation measures − Establish a Complaint Receiving Center in order to publicize the pro∑ect and to listen to opinions, suggestions and complaints. Those affected by the project can complain about the impacts or the problems through the channels in any manners or as deem appropriate, e.g. verbal complaints, telephone, memorandum, letter, Email, fax, etc. as shown in Figure 9-2 and in case of emergency as in Figure 9-3. − Comply with the environmental impact prevention and mitigation measures strictly. − Receive complaints regarding matters troubling people in the communities affected by the construction activities and take corrective action on such impacts urgently.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-6 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities
8. Socio-economic Measures Regarding Safety of Life and Property − Results from Socio-economic survey (Cont’d) − Give priority of hiring qualified local residents. and opinion interview with households, − Keep records of non-local and foreign workers. people, community leader/local leader, − Assign the head of the project to supervise workers. Assign employees to monitor entry into and exit representatives of relevant agencies, from the project strictly. local organization and sensitive − Control the construction activities and the wor−ers’ behaviors to prevent impacts to people in the receptors around the project site i.e. vicinity. hospital, temple, school and − Provide the rest area for the construction worker. The rest area should be sited in safe location and away measurement stations of environmental the work in progress area. quality − Issue work regulation and ensure that construction worker strictly comply with the regulations. − Monitor and control wor−ers’ behaviors closely if their living quarters are near local communities so as not to disturb the nearby communities. − Publicize and clarify facts to the public urgently, in case of misunderstanding between the power plant, and the community through various channels or media so people receive factual information. Be prepared to demonstrate that the pro∑ect will ta−e responsibility and care about people’s feeling. − Take corrective action urgently where it is proved that the power plant is the cause of such impacts. Set up a register of individuals or groups being affected and use the data to implement stricter measures to prevent the problems. − Prepare a register of people affected, recording issues from the complaints or from the event as evidence. Record information related to proof of facts, solutions, negotiations, and arrangements as evidence of the power plant operation. - Measures for Construction of NTF − Having representatives on site to coordinate, communicate any assist people in the area. − Coordinate with EGAT to inform the public of the schedule for construction, and address any concerns that the people in surrounding area may have. − For people within 5km radius from the project site, GSRC will form an environmental committee to consider and mitigate any possible impacts and also to ensure paying fair compensation for affected people. − For people outside the 5km radius, we will form environmental committee in case-by-case basis when there are impacts from NTF construction. − The committee set up will include representatives from EGAT, GSRC, community leaders, authorities in the area etc. 9. Public Participation - During the Pre-Construction Period − Record of activities that the project Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total and Relation construction period, − Establish Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee before the construction period. arranges for local communities. construction contract people in the Elements of the Committee cost communities might The Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee consists of community representatives, public sector still have some representatives, experts, the power plant’s representatives. Details are as follows: opinion conflicts − Community representatives from sub-districts, administrative districts within 5 km radius around the regarding concerns power plant as specified in the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) consists of 3 representatives about the project. from the sub-district where the power plant is situated, Khao Khansong Sub-district, and two representatives each from other sub-districts and administrative districts (the number shall be not less than half of the total number of the committee members)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-7 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 9. Public Participation − 4-5 representatives from government sector: 1 representative from and Relation Si Racha District Office, 1 representative from Khao Kansong Sub-district Administrative Office Organization, (Cont’d) and 1 representative from each relevant government agency. − 2 experts who are competent in the monitoring of the environmental impacts or the persons which the community jointly approved. − 1 representative from the power plant. The procedure of the Selection Process is as follows: - Community representative may come from the selection or election or the nomination according to the following procedure: (1) The power plant issues a letter of request to the relevant areas (Sub-district Administrative Office/Sub-district/Sub-district Municipality) within 5 km radius for nomination to the power plant the persons suitable to be the community representative in the committee. Then, let the areas select their representatives to be the member of the Community Representative Committee in accordance with the structure of the committee using a method preferred by the sub-districts. The selection process is to be completed within 30 days from the date of the request from the power plant and the list of member of the Community Representative Committee shall then be submitted to the power plant. (2) Applicants must be the person whose name has been in the household registration in the sub- district’s area not less than a year prior the selection date or the appointment date. (3) Applicants must be over 25 years of age on the date of selection, election or nomination. (4) Applicants must not possess the following characters: : Have improper conduct, corruption in official duty; : Be adjudged bankrupt or subject to the final court judgment for imprisonment except misdemeanor or guilty on ground of an act of negligence. : Be insane or have mental infirmity or being adjudged incompetent or quasi-incompetent; - 1 representative nominated by the Chief of Si Racha District and 1 representative nominated by the President of the Khao Kansong Sub-district Administrative Office Organization. - Other government sector representatives are to be decided which agencies to come from, through consultation between the power plant and the community representatives. For example, representatives may come from the Provincial Office of Natural Resources and Environment, the Provincial Office of Industry or other relevant government sector agencies. Request that such agencies nominate their respective representatives to the power plant. - Experts are to be selected jointly between the community representative and the power plant. Nominated experts must be knowledgeable in monitoring the environmental impacts or the persons which the community jointly approved. Then nominate the person to the power plant for consideration for selection only two experts. - Representative from the power plant shall be appointed by the power plant.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-8 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 9. Public Participation The Committee shall have the following authority: and Relation - Establish the guideline and practice on the environmental impact monitoring program of the power (Cont’d) plant during the construction and the operation period. - Receive complaints, consider and make decision on the complaints, receive suggestions from the people regarding environmental impacts from the construction and operation of the Power Plant. - Provide opinions to the power plant for improvement or correction of the construction or operation in line with the Environmental Impacts Assessment. - Make suggestions to the government agencies for the power plant to stop construction or stop operation temporarily in case of incompliance with the Environmental Impacts Assessment. - Appoint assistance for various tasks as appropriate. The Committee shall have the following duties: - Hold a meeting at least quarterly. - Publicize correct information regarding the power plant to the people. - Conduct field work to monitor the construction and the operation of the power plant - Post the complaints or requests from the people to the committee and announce the decision of the committee in a conspicuous place at the agencies’ office or in at least 3 public places. - Establish the rules on receiving complaints and the rules of appeals of the decision on the complaints and other rules as necessary. - Consider giving compensation for damage if it is proved that the impacts result from the operation of the project. - The compensation for damages, in case it is proved that the impacts are caused by the project implementation, the project will propose preliminary compensation cost to the committee for consideration. This committee would consist of representatives from 3 parties i.e., government agencies, communities within 5 km radius and the project proponent. Note: The composition, the selection process, the authority, the duty and other rules of the Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee during the pre-construction phase, the construction phase and the operation phase may be changed in accordance with the opinion or resolution of the Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee.
General Measures −
− Establish good relationship with officers of the local government and people in the communities. − − Participate in awareness of Sriracha Power Plant Pro∑ect by means of dissemination of the pro∑ect’s information through the media or any of the following: local radio broadcasting, installation of notice boards displaying construction plan at key points in the area, such as, at the offices of the community leaders, at the sub-district administrative office organization office and by other methods consistent with the objectives of such measures, etc. one month prior to the construction.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-9 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 9. Public Participation Measures in Public Relations and Relation 1. Objectives of the Public Relations (Cont’d) − The project aims to give news and information about the project continuously to people in the vicinity from the pre-construction period, the construction period and the operation period, act as a channel of communication between the local communities, listen to the opinions of the people in the vicinity who may be affected by the operation of the project, and give people the opportunities to express their opinions and suggestions to the project. 2. Channel of Public Relations: at least one of the following channels of information dissemination of the project, or activities relevant to such objectives, such as: - By means of Local Media such as through the cable broadcasting in the community or local cable media, as appropriate. - By means of Notice Boards or PR boards of relation local government agencies, in the communities or visible public places, for examples, PR boards of the district office involved in the project, PR boards of the municipality or the Sub-district Administrative Office organization office involved in the project, PR boards of the communities involved in the project, or PR boards of the public health agencies in the study area and at the project site. - By means of placement of project’s public relation documents and brochure to publicize details of the project and progress of the project (during each phase of the operation), safety information and prevention of emergencies, channel of communication in case of emergencies and channels of complaints on the operation of the project, channel of communication of the project, at the point of public relation of government agencies, the communities and at the points accessible by the people - By means of meeting to explain about the project as follow: Hold a meeting to report details/progress through local government agencies in the area (provincial level and district level) at least once prior to the construction or within the first month of the construction. Hold a meeting to report details/progress of the project to the villages/communities/ related sub-districts, at least once prior to the construction or within the first month of the construction. - By means of the Community Participation for Committee throughout the term of the Community Participation for Committee. . - By means of distribution of stickers with channel of contacts with the project to the communities in the vicinity as a channel of contact in case of emergency or desires to report information on the impacts from the operation of the project. - By other means as appropriate, such as, door-to-door campaign, mobile broadcasting, etc. The public relations activities must consist of details of the project, progress, construction duration, impacts from the project development, environmental impact prevention and mitigation measures, channel of contacts and communication with the project, channel for complaints on project operation and channel of contacts in case of emergency.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-10 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities
9. Public Participation Construction period − Record of activities that the project Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total SCR and Relation − Disseminate information and news of the pro∑ect and reporting the pro∑ect’s progress, displaying the arranges for local communities. Cost (Cont’d) information relating to the pro∑ect such as, the pro∑ect’s name, the pro∑ect’s construction plan, the − Record of activities of the contractors, the pro∑ect’s owner, the coordinator and the telephone number, etc. through local Environmental Impacts Monitoring media by one of the following: local radio broadcasting, installing sign board announcing the Committee are occurred every 6 construction plan at key points in the area, such as, at the office of the community leaders, in front months of the project site or other activities consistent with the objectives of such measures throughout the construction phase − Develop good relationship with local government agencies and people in the communities through regular meetings and visits. Be ready to solve any problems or disturbance that may be caused by the project. − Be open to feedback from the community regularly and continuously. − 2 education awareness raising events per year are held for local community members, including, if possible targeted measures for girls to enter STEM/ engineering training Measures in Public Relations − 1. Objectives of the Public Relations − The project aims to give news and information about the project continuously to people in the vicinity − from the pre-construction period, the construction period and the operation period, act as a channel of communication between the local communities, listen to the opinions of the people in the vicinity who may be affected by the operation of the project, and give people the opportunities to express their opinions and suggestions to the project. 2. Channel of Public Relations: at least one of the following channels of information dissemination of the − project, or activities relevant to such objectives, such as: - By means of Local Media such as through the cable broadcasting in the community or local − cable media, as appropriate. - By means of Notice Boards or PR boards of relation local government agencies, in the communities or visible public places, for examples, PR boards of the district office involved in the project, PR boards of the municipality or the Sub-district Administrative Office organization office involved in the project, PR boards of the communities involved in the project, or PR boards of the public health agencies in the study area and at the project site. - By means of placement of project’s public relation documents and brochure to publicize − details of the project and progress of the project (during each phase of the operation), safety information and prevention of emergencies, channel of communication in case of emergencies and channels of complaints on the operation of the project, channel of communication of the project, at the point of public relation of government agencies, the communities and at the points accessible by the people - By means of meeting to explain about the project as follow: − Hold a meeting to report details/progress through local government agencies in the area (provincial level and district level) at least once prior to the construction or within the first month of the construction.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-11 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities
9. Public Participation Hold a meeting to report details/progress of the project to the villages/communities/ related − and Relation sub-districts, at least once prior to the construction or within the first month of the (Cont’d) construction. - By means of the Community Participation for Committee throughout the term of the Community Participation for Committee. . - By means of distribution of stickers with channel of contacts with the project to the − communities in the vicinity as a channel of contact in case of emergency or desires to report information on the impacts from the operation of the project. - By means of the Community Participation for Committee throughout the term of the − Community Participation for Committee.
The public relations activities must consist of details of the project, progress, construction duration, − impacts from the project development, environmental impact prevention and mitigation measures, channel of contacts and communication with the project, channel for complaints on project operation and channel of contacts in case of emergency.
10. Public Health / Health/ Occupational Public Health − Statistical record of accidents Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in total Occupational Health Health and Safety − Provide a first-aid unit, basic medication, and transporting vehicle in case of emergency in the construction − Minute of meeting of Occupational construction contract and Safety impact on worker area in accordance with Ministry of Labour’s Notification re: Provision for Welfare in the Business Premises, Health, Safety and Environment cost B.E.2548. Committee − Provide clean drinking water for workers. − Provide toilets that meet the public hygiene principle with the ratio of 15 workers per toilet. − Before hiring workers, Contractor has the process to interview and carry out health & physical check- up and request for medical check certificate to confirm that the person has no incurable disease and congenital disease which obstruct to work. Contractor will provide first aid facility at Project site and worker’s accommodation. Local hospitals are used in case of emergency. All medical record will be maintained by Contractor at the project. − Train workers on health and hygiene, disease prevention, behavior to avoid causing disturbance, drugs. − 2 health awareness raising events per year are held for local community members, including, if possible targeted measures for girl's education in WASH practices, HIV/AIDS and safety. − Ensure the contractors comply with labor laws regarding physical health check and risk-based heath check. − Prepare a list of construction workers, report the number and their chronic diseases to the public health station responsible for the area prior to coming to work. − Provide training to workers and employees on the knowledge of health and action in case of serious accident or emergency prior to commencement of the construction. − Provide hygienic sanitary environment in the construction wor−ers’ living quarters and the construction site. - − “se strict security system in the construction wor−ers’ living quarters. − Monitor contagious disease jointly with the local public health agencies. − Prepare a list of construction workers, report the number and their chronic diseases to the public health station responsible for the area prior to coming to work. − Supervisor and ensure that the contractors comply with the contract such as monitoring wor−ers’ living quarters, random drug test, garbage sorting in the wor−ers’ living quarters in accordance with the principle and methods of for garbage management. − Provide channel of complaints through the Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-12 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 10. Public Health / − Ensure that the contractors coordinate with schools especially kindergarten to primary education level at - Occupational least 6 months prior to the project construction in the case some workers need to enroll their children in Health and Safety the local schools. (Cont’d) Occupational Health, Safety and Environment - Measures on General Safety − Specify occupational health and safety measures in the agreement, requiring the contractors to do as follows: • The project specifies in the contract that the contractors and the operation team working within the power plant under the contracts shall implement occupational health, safety and environment measures in their design, construction and operation to comply with the occupational health and safety standards, rules and regulation. • The project shall provide competent personnel to be in charge of occupational health, safety and the environment. • The project and the main contractors shall establish an Occupational Health, Safety and Environment Committee (OHS Committee) that also consists of heads of subcontractors. The Chairman of the OHS Committee will report directly to the project manager. The OHS Committee shall hold a meeting at least once a month to assess the results and make suggestions for corrective actions. • The project shall provide a first-aid unit, basic medication, and transporting vehicle in case of emergency in the construction area in accordance with Ministry of Labour’s Notification re: Provision for Welfare in the Business Premises, B.E.2548. • The project shall require inspection of personal protective equipment regularly or as specified in the Safety Procedure. • Ensure the contractors comply with labor laws regarding physical health check and risk-based heath check. This law is in accordance with Ministerial Regulation on the Prescribing of Criteria and Method of Conducting Health Check Up of Employees and Forwarding the Results of Health Check Up to Labour Inspector B.E. 2547 (A.D.2004). Risks Mitigation Measures − The steam production unit must have a steel structure with walking ramps and stairs for going up and down to enter the office safely. − Install insulation on the steam and hot water pipes for the safety in carrying out work. − Installation of equipment and construction will be carried out by reliable and experienced contractors with the safety officer supervising the safe conducts. Inspect and test the equipment and the construction by the engineer to ensure they meet the standard. − Inspect safety of the steam producing unit and to test the safety valves under the supervision of the engineer licensed for inspection of the boilers in accordance with the Engineering Profession Act, B.E.2505, before commissioning. Fire Prevention and Fire System − The main contractors must provide sufficient fire equipment for the persons working in the dangerous area or working with heat and exposed to fire. For example, in welding work, welding team must have a dry chemical fire extinguisher near the place of work. For welding at height, insulation lining must be placed underneath to prevent sparks from welding from catching fire underneath otherwise it is unsafe for persons working underneath the place of welding.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-13 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 10. Public Health / − The main contractors must establish plans to coordinate with the local fire department in case of emergency. Occupational − Control of the entrance and exit of the dangerous zone where the construction works are performed, Health and Safety control of the traffic, install warning clear signs by the supervisor in charge or by the safety officer. − Inspect function and condition of equipment to be used in the construction, especially at the places (Cont’d) exposing to danger or fire. − Inspect the working of the fire equipment regularly as specified in the Safety Procedure. 11. Major Hazard Explosion/fire during − Designate the areas for welding of natural gas and diesel oil pipelines as restricted areas , in which - No explosion/fire during construction construction working related to heat and sparking is prohibited. Signs of danger warning will be placed around the areas. In case it is necessary to work in the areas, permit must be obtained before accessing the areas. − Fence the welding areas and put danger warning signs, including establishment of work permit system. − Before construction, the contractor must prepare and submit occupational health and safety action plan to Gulf SRC Co., Ltd., to approve and control implementation as planned. − Provision of sufficient personal protection equipment, suitable for nature of work to staff. − Provision of security guards to watch and examine working, including to control the wearing of personal protection equipment suitable for nature of work, as necessary. − Provision of suitable numbers of portable chemical fire extinguishers and place them in the construction areas that may have firing. 11. Major Hazard − Provision of first aid equipment and Shuttle Emergency in construction areas as required by the Ministry of (Cont’d) Labor’s Regulations Welfare in Wor−place (B.E.2548). − Placing warning signs in the risk areas. No permission to work long in this area, if no personal protection equipment. − Coordinate with hospitals close to the project site for the case of emergency. 12. Heat Generated - from power plant 13. pH of Rainwater - and Sulfate Radicals in soil Operation Period 1. Air Quality - Air emission impact − Install Continuous Emission Monitoring System; (CEMs) at the stack of the power plant in order to - The result of air emission of stack within Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in from operation continuously monitor parameters including Oxides of Nitrogen (NOX) Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) Suspended limit pre-set in the EIA report operation cost activities Particulate (TSP) Oxygen (O2) and the flow rate, display the measurement results (NOX, SO2 and TSP) - The result of ambient air quality on the screen in the front of the project site, send the report to Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial monitoring within National Ambient Air Estate (Hemaraj ESIE) throughout the pro∑ect’s duration. Quality Standard and WHO Ambient Air − Inspect and calibrate instruments for the measurement of air quality at the stack (Audit CEMS) each Quality Guidelines. year throughout the pro∑ect’s duration − Control the rate of emission of are pollutants from the stack not to be higher than the limit pre-set in the Environmental Impacts Assessment as follows: Case of natural gas firing Capacity full load ▪ SO2 : concentration not to exceed 5.5 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 6.17 g/s/stack
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-14 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 1. Air Quality (Cont’d) ▪ NOx : concentration not to exceed 24.8 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 20 g/s/stack 3 ▪ Particulate : concentration not to exceed 20 mg/m at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 7.86 g/s/stack Capacity minimum load ▪ SO2 : concentration not to exceed5.5 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 3.96 g/s/stack ▪ NOx : concentration not to exceed 24.8 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 12.84 g/s/stack 3 ▪ Particulate : concentration not to exceed 20 mg/m at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 5.04 g/s/stack Case of diesel oil Capacity full load ▪ SO2 : concentration not to exceed 20 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 18.95 g/s/stack ▪ NOx : concentration not to exceed 29.4 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 20 g/s/stack 3 ▪ Particulate : concentration not to exceed 35 mg/m at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 11.60 g/s/stack Capacity minimum load ▪ SO2 : concentration not to exceed 20 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 16.02 g/s/stack ▪ NOx : concentration not to exceed 29.4 ppm at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 16.92 g/s/stack 3 Particulate : concentration not to exceed 35 mg/m at 7% O2 and emission rate not to exceed 9.81 g/s/stack − If natural gas is used, control the formation of the Oxides of Nitrogen by using the Dry Low NOx type of NOx (DLN) control system and the system of Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR). − If diesel is used, control the formation of the Oxides of Nitrogen by using Water Injection type of NOx control system and the system of Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR). − The concentration value of the Air pollutants as mentioned above is calculated under the normal condition at 25oC and the atmospheric pressure of 1 and volume of excessive Oxygen from combustion at 7%. − In case of breakdown of the air pollutant control system and the rate of emission exceeds the controlled level, the project will stop the gas turbine in order to inspect the NOx control system and to take corrective action promptly. − Provide competent personnel to control air pollutant emission rate of the Project. − The project will quantify direct emissions from the facilities within the physical project boundary − The project will conduct quantification and monitoring of greenhouse gas emission annually in accordance with internationally recognition methodologies. − A continuous ambient air quality monitoring program will be undertaken by collecting ambient air quality data from the existing AQMS in HESIE during the operational phase.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-15 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 2. Noise - Noise impact from − Install warning sign boards or symbols in the area of noise exceeding 85 dB (A) such as, the area at the - The result of noise monitoring within Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in operation activities Combustion Chamber of the Gas Turbine. Employees and persons entering such area have to put on National Noise Standard and WHO operation cost personal protective equipment such as ear plugs and ear muffs. Community Noise Guidelines. − Establish specifications of machines and equipment which makes loud noise, such as Gas Turbine, Steam Turbine, Fuel Gas Compressor and Cooling Tower to have the average Maximum Sound Pressure Level (Lmax) from the machines or noise absorbent material at the distance of 1 meter of not more than 85 dB(A). − Install noise reducing equipment such as silencer at the pipe’s ends that might generate noise, construct building covering the machines in the area of the Combustion Chamber of the Gas Turbine, at the area of Power Generator, Gas Turbine, Water Pump Motor and at the Steam Producing Unit (HRSG) and use the propellers of the cooling unit that are low-noise type. − Design steam turbine bypass system for 100% of the steam production to minimize the steam vent during the power plant startup and shutdown. − Construct building with double metal cladding and acoustic insulation, or concert precast panel wall for covering the machines in the area of the Combustion Turbine, Generator and Steam Turbine. − Control the noise level at the area ad∑acent to the pro∑ect’s fence to be no more than 7เ dB (A). Also, at sensitive receptor locations to ensure that noise incremental levels do not exceed 3dBA. − Inspect efficiency of the silencer regularly. − Prepare a Noise Mapping/Noise Contour to mark the areas of loud noise during the first year of operation and every three years thereafter. − Educate the employees so they have knowledge, understanding, positive attitude and desirable behaviors regarding occupational hygiene and safety at work at least once a year. − Organize a Hearing Conservation Program in the administrative management preventing the employees from prolong exposure to loud noise, such as, establishing duration of the working time to reduce the time which the employees are exposed to loud noise, rotate employees or alternate working days in the areas of loud noise and to update the information at least once a year. − Install noise barrier at northeast of the project that is adjacent to the Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan- aok School. The height fence is at a 10-meters minimum. The chosen material was a Glassfiber Reinfore Cement with a minimum thickness of 100 mm or other material with transmission loss (TL) at 40 dB(A). The each end of noise barrier turn to noise sources. The west side has a length not less than 50 meters and the south-southeast side has a length not less than 100 meters. (Figure 9-1) 3. Surface Water Surface water and Measures for Management of Cooling Water - The result of wastewater sampling within Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in Quality and groundwater − Provide two cooling water holding ponds of the project each with capacity of 19,000 m³ with minimum limit pre-set in the EIA report operation cost Groundwater contamination holding capacity of one day per pond to collect the water drained from the cooling tower and line each Quality pond with High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) to prevent leakage or build concrete pond. − Install the Online Monitoring system for the inspection of the pH value, the conductivity and the Dissolved Oxygen in the area of cooling water holding pond from the power plant’s cooling tower and report the values on the screen in front of the project site and to Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate’s Wastewater Control Centre.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-16 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 3. Surface Water − Ensure that the quality of the cooling blowdown meets the requirement of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Quality and Industrial Estate which specifies that the cooling blowdown must meet the requirement prescribed in Groundwater Ministry of Industrial’s Notification No.2 (B.E.2539) re: Prescribing Standards of Quality of Effluent from Factories and the level of Total Dissolved Solid must be within the standards of the quality of water Quality (Cont’d) discharged into the Irrigation waterway of the Department of Royal Irrigation (TDS not exceeding 1,300 mg/l and the temperature not exceeding 34 C). − Provide an emergency pond with the holding capacity of 19,000 m³ capable of holding water for at least one day to hold cooling blowdown. If the̊ cooling blowdown shows the values that do not meet the requirements of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate which specifies that the quality of the cooling blowdown must meet the standard prescribed by Ministry of Industry’s Notification No.2 (B.E.2539) re: Prescribing Standards of Quality of Effluent from Factories and the level of Total Dissolved Solid must be within the standards of the quality of water discharged into the Irrigation waterway of the Department of Royal Irrigation (TDS not exceeding 1,300 mg/l and the temperature not exceeding 34 C). (During the normal operation, the emergency pond will be kept dry.) − Use the aerators in the cooling water holding pond to increase the dissolved oxygen in the discharged water. − If the Dissolved̊ Oxygen level is under 4 milligrams/liter, the project will start the aerator to add air in the water until the Dissolved Oxygen level in the discharged water is no less than 4 milligrams/liter. − The project will design a water dispersion system at the point where water is released into the holding pond in order to add Oxygen to the discharged water. − Control the level of Chlorite in the wastewater from the cooling tower to not more than 1 milligram/liter otherwise the project will not drain cooling blowdown to outside the project area. − In case the project uses the wastewater from cooling tower to water the trees within the project, the SAR level must be within 0-10, conductivity must not exceed 2,000 µmhos/cm and TDS must not exceed 1,300 milligrams/liter or the quality of the discharged water must be improved to meet the standards before using it to water the trees. − In case the quality of the water drained from the cooling tower does not meet with the specified standard, the valves will be turned off and the quality of the wastewater in cooling holding pond must be improved. If this cannot be solved, such water will be sent to the company licensed by the government for disposal. − Inspect and maintain the condenser and the cooling tower regularly in order to help controlling the quality of cooling blowdown before draining outside the project. Measures to Manage Wastewater from the Process − Ensure that the properties of the wastewater to be delivered to the central wastewater treatment system of the estate meets the requirements of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. − Provide Oil Separator to separate oil from wastewater that is contaminated with oil and then send to Wastewater holding pond for quality inspection before draining it to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. − Provide sufficient toilets under proper hygienic principle for the workers as required by law. Construct septic tanks or ready-made wastewater treatment tanks to treat wastewater from the consumption of the workers before draining it to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-17 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 3. Surface Water − Provide a Neutralization Pit to adjust the water condition to neutral condition before draining it to the Quality and pro∑ect’s wastewater holding pond and then to the central wastewater treatment system of Hemara∑ Groundwater Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. Quality (Cont’d) − Provide a wastewater holding pond capable of holding wastewater for at least 24-hour in order to inspect the quality prior to draining into the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. − Install an Online Monitoring System to check temperature, pH value and conductivity at the wastewater holding pond and report the results to the Wastewater Control Centre of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. − Deliver the water which has passed through the quality inspection from the wastewater holding pond through the discharged water gutters for treatment at the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. 4. Water Use Water shortage − Consider ways to increase the efficiency of water usage, such as, reduction of water draining from the - Water is sufficient for use during Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in cooling system or recycling water within the project for maximum benefits. operation period. operation cost − Inspect condition of water pipes and repair leakages immediately to prevent loss of water. − Reduce power production or halt operation in case of water shortage when the estate cannot supply water to the project. − Many streams of water are reused in the process as much as possible. Storm water collected in the storm water holding pond can be used as raw water supply for the project, if its quality allows. 5. Transport Traffic congestion and − Require all drivers to strictly follow traffic rules - Record of daily traffic accident occurred Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in accidents from the − Establish rules of transportation and rules of safety for vehicles entering and exiting the project to during the project construction phase operation cost project transportation. prevent accidents. and produce a monthly report. − Provide sufficient parking spaces within the project at the suitable locations. Install various traffic signs in the area of construction and along the route leading to the project. − Install signs limiting speed in the project area at 20 kilometers/hour. − Limit the vehicles entering the production units to reduce accident in the production units. − Record the type and number of cars entering the project area and use such information to manage traffic within the project area. Strictly prohibit parking outside the designated areas. − Inspect the condition of the transportation vehicles regularly. − Display of the telephone number of the person in charge of the delivery vehicles as a channel to notify or complain to the project. − Require trucks transporting chemicals and trucks transporting solid waste to show warning signs. The signs must be clear and easy to understanding specify the name and details of the chemicals in accordance with the international standards, such as, UN Suggestions and HAZCHEM codes. − Ensure that the companies delivering chemicals and companies approved for transportation of solid waste comply with the relevant laws (e.g. Ministry of Industry’s Notification re: Delivery Documentary System for Transportation of Hazardous Substances B.E.2547 , Ministry of Industry’s Notification re: Land Transportation of Hazardous Substances B.E.2546, and the Land Transportation Department’s Notification re: Installation of Signs of Characters, Pictures and Symbols on Trucks Transporting Hazardous Substances).
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-18 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 6. Waste Management Hygiene problem − Provide collection bins for refuse with secure lids in sufficient number for collection of solid waste - Record of type and volume of general Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in from the project for delivery to the company licensed by the government for disposal by mean garbage and waste from construction operation cost specified by law. activities. − Provide the place for collection of refuse and solid waste which is covered by a roof and has concrete floor. Separate the types of the waste and install clear sign boards. − Recyclable waste should be collected and sorted for reuse to maximize utilization or collected and resold to waste buying company. After sorting, contact licensed waste disposal company to collect the remaining waste. − Collect and use recyclable refuses from the project as much as possible or sell them to the buying companies. Deliver the remainder to the company licensed by the government for disposal in accordance with Ministry of Industry’s Notification re: Disposal of Refuse or Discarded Materials B.E.2548. − Separate hazardous solid waste of characteristics prescribed with Ministry of Industry’s Notification re: Disposal of Refuse and Discarded Materials B.E.2548 such as lubricant and solvent from cleaning tools from general refuses for disposal by the company licensed by the government. − Provide enclosed container/tank to collect waste generated from production process i.e. resin and oil prior to proper disposal process stipulated by the announcement of Ministry of Industrial Waste Management and Disposal B.E.2548 (2005). − Record type, and quantity of solid waste produced and the destination to which they are transported for sale or disposal. 7. Drainage and Flood - Flooding in the − Connect rainwater drainage gutters in the project areas to the rainwater draining systems of Hemaraj - No flood in the project area. Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in Control project area Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. operation cost − Provide Storm Water Pond with total holding capacity of not less than 86,592 m³ capable of holding rainwater for three hours in order to control the rate of water flowing out of the project area to a suitable level to prevent flooding in the project area. − Drain contaminated rainwater to the Oil Separator pond to separate oil from water. Then drain uncontaminated water into the waste pond for inspection of the discharged water quality to ensure it meets the standard established by the estate before draining into the central wastewater treatment system of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate. − Inspect water drainage gutters in the project area regularly to prevent any clogging. − Clean water drainage gutters during the dry season each year to increase efficiency of the water drainage system. − Support the responsible agency of Khlong Kram and Khlong Rawoeng in the dredging of those canals. -
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-19 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 8. Socio-economic - During the General Measures - Results from socio-economic survey and Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in operation period, − Establish measures for hiring qualified local people first to reduce impacts on the relationship with the opinion interview with households, operation cost people in the people in the communities. Publicizing job opportunity in the communities when job vacancies are available. people, community leader/local leader, communities might − The project will request the Contractor to consider hiring local people first. During project execution, representatives of relevant agencies, still have some the pro∑ect will monitor Contractor’s hiring process to ensure that the Contractor will hire local local organization and sensitive opinion conflicts workers as much as possible and available. In addition, the Contractor will report the numbers of receptors around the project site i.e. regarding concerns workers to the project every month. hospital, temple, school and measurement stations of environmental about the project. − Establish measures to return benefits to the communities, such as, supports for local education, local public health, religion promotion and supports for other public benefits. quality. − Those affected by the project can complain about the impacts or the problems through the channels in any manners or as deem appropriate, e.g. verbal complaints, telephone, memorandum, letter, Email, fax, etc. as in Figure 9-2 and in case of emergency as in Figure 9-3. Complaints could be able to be anonymous as well. − The compensation for damages, in case it is proved that the impacts are caused by the project implementation, the project will propose preliminary compensation cost to the committee for consideration. This committee would consist of representatives from 3 parties i.e., government agencies, communities within 5 km radius and the project proponent. − Organize a power plant visit for communities to reduce their concerns. − Establish a policy for life quality promotion. Support and promote community business for sustainable socio-economic development of the communities. − Support activities for the conservation of marine life or environment such as, the fish releasing by relevant agencies at Nong Pla Lai Reservoir, the canals or at other water resources. − Follow the steps specified in the action plans strictly to reduce accidents and impacts to the project and to the communities. − Take corrective action urgently where it is proved that the power plant is the cause of such impacts. Set up a register of individuals or groups being affected and use the data to implement stricter measures to prevent the problems. − Prepare a register of people affected, recording issues from the complaints or from the event as evidence. Record information related to proof of facts, solutions, negotiations, and arrangements as evidence of the power plant operation. − Publicize and clarify facts to the public urgently, in case of misunderstanding between the power plant, and the community through various channels or media so people receive factual information. Be prepared to demonstrate that the pro∑ect will ta−e responsibility and care about people’s feeling.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-20 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities
9. Public Participation - During the − Disseminate information and news and publicize details of the project to the local communities in various − Record of activities that the project Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in and Relation operation period, channels and forms, such as, brochure, media or other activities consistent with the objectives of such arranges for local communities. operation cost
people in the measures. Be open for the community to participate in the monitoring of the project throughout the − Record of activities of the communities might project duration; Environmental Impacts Monitoring still have some − Allow people to give idea, information and suggestions. Committee are occurred every 6 opinion conflicts • conduct a focus group once during the first 3 years of the operation phase as follows: months regarding concerns ➢ coordinate with the local government agencies and the administrative agencies; ➢ conduct a focus group at the sub-district/district level to emphasize with priority to the groups that about the project. had given information during the pre-construction Phase and the construction phase of Sriracha Power Plant. ➢ Focus the meeting on comparisons of the situation before and after the project development and changes in the social, livelihood, economic and environmental condition. ➢ Prepare questionnaires after the meeting, trying to get opinions of the community on the project. ➢ Summarize the outcomes of the focus group. • Establish good relationship with local government agencies and people in the community by visiting regularly. Be prepared to solve problems and disturbance that may be caused by the project. • Be open to feedback from the communities regularly and continuously. • Appoint persons in charge of receiving complaints in order to publicize the project as well as to listen to the opinions and suggestions from those affected. Affected persons may lodge complaints as to the characteristics of the impacts or the problems through various channel, such as, verbal complaints, telephone, memorandum, letter, email, fax, etc. As shown in Figure 9-2 is the Complaints Procedure. • Support activities for the conservation of marine life or environment such as, the fingering releasing by relevant agencies at Nong Pla Lai Reservoir, the canals or at other local water resources. • Establish the Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee to commence the mission from the pre- construction phase up to the operation phase, serving no more than two 4 years terms.
10. Public Health / Health/ Occupational Public Health − Statistical record of accidents Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in
Occupational Health Health and Safety − Provide a first-aid unit, basic medication, and transporting vehicle in case of emergency in the − Minute of meeting of Occupational operation cost and Safety impact on project staffs construction area in accordance with Ministry of Labour’s Notification re: Provision for Welfare in the Health, Safety and Environment Business Premises, B.E.2548. Committee − Provide pre-employment physical check-up and annual physical check-up. − Organize activities to promote good health and educate communities on environment and good health. − 2 health awareness raising events per year are held for local community members, including, if possible targeted measures for girl's education in WASH practices, HIV/AIDS and safety − Support public health agencies in the area in promotion, rehabilitation, prevention and health care for the community. − Survey the statistic of illness of the people within 5 km radius from the project. Occupational Health, Safety and Environment − Establish an Occupational Health, Safety Committee to oversee the work. Organize OHS meetings at least once a month to evaluate and make suggestions to correct problems, improve and promote activities concerning occupational health, safety.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-21 Environm en tal Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plan t Project Environm en tal Man agem en t Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Impact or Risk to be Project Componen t or Institutional Activity Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performan ce Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Responsibilities 10. Public Health / / Provide a Safety Procedure for reference an d train employees on this procedure. The procedure will Occupational Health be consistent with the details of various machines and equipment being installed in the Power Plan t and Safety (Cont’d) an d the laws on occupation health an d safety. Provide work safety training to all new employees. / Provide sufficient number of personal protective equipment (PPE) appropriate to the working condition to all employees. / Provide a first-aid un it, basic medication, an d tran sporting vehicle in case of emergency in the construction area in accordance with Ministry of Labour’s Notification re: Provision for Welfare in the Business Premises, B.E.2548. / Specify the type an d quantity of safety equipment to comply with the standard. Inspect the conditions of the equipment regularly. / Provide backup electrical system in case of emergen cy. Design safe an d adequate lighting for working. / Provide pre-employment physical checkup and an nual physical checkup. / Organ ize a Safety Week to stimulate an d train the skills in safe work practice / Ensure that the fire prevention system and fire suppression system of the Power Plan t meet the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) stan dard an d related stan dards. / Inspection protective equipment regularly as specified in the Safety Procedure. / Establish an emergency plan classifying into two levels to be use as guideline in practice in case of emergency (as shown in Figure 9-4) as follows: Emergency Level One: Emergency Level One is the even t occurs in the power plan t which the coordinator of emergency can control the situation and limit the damage using the employees, workers an d equipment available in the Plan t un til the event returns to normal. Emergency Level Two: Emergency Level Two is the event occurs both inside and outside the power plant which the coordinator of emergency has evaluated the situation that the pre-set plan dealing with Emergency Level One cann ot be used and must request for man power an d equipment support from Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate to control the situation. / Arran ge an n ual drills of the emergency plan both on the part of the power plan t itself an d to drill the emergency plan jointly with Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate and external organ izations. Give training to employees at least once a year so that they are equipped with skills an d expertise in relieving emergency. / Appoint a safety officer to organ ize activities to promote kn owledge and un derstanding about occupational health, safety in conjun ction with schools in the vicinity, such as the Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan -aok School, at least once a year. Measures on tran sportation an d un loading of Diesel / Training on the practice according to the emergency plan Environmental Health & Safety (EH&S) an d the Safety Committee are responsible for training for all employees to possess fun damental kn owledge regarding the work rules, the conduct at work an d related documents. In the cases of changes of details of the work rules/ supporting document involving preparation for emergency, the prevention and suppression of emergency, EH&S must notify all employees of details of the chan ges.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-22 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 10. Public Health / − Measures to prevent oil leakage. Occupational Health • Department/Section working with oil must act in accordance with the work method re: Fuel Oil and Safety (Cont’d) Unloading Procedure. • Employee working with oil must perform their work carefully in order to prevent spillage outside environment by complying to Fuel Oil Unloading Procedure and related MSDS. − Prepare/inspect emergency equipment for emergency situation at all time as follows: • Appropriate PPE such as, rubber gloves, air filtering face mask or other appropriate material for absorption, such as, sand, saw dust, cloth, or other materials with absorbing property or prevention of dispersion of oil for employees working with oil to prevent spillage to outside environment by following Fuel Oil Unloading Procedure and related MSDS. • Appropriate PPE such as, rubber gloves, mask, air filtering mask and other equipment as deem appropriate. • Containers for waste material contaminated with oil with monthly inspection of bins, valves, and safety valves every month by competent person as specified by law. − Emergency equipment in response of oil leakage must be as follows: • In case of minor oil leakage ➢ The person encountering the incident must take corrective action immediately. ➢ Sprinkle sand, saw dust or other materials prepared by the work unit around the oil leakage to prevent leakage expanding. ➢ Immediately notify the supervisors and the employee responsible for the area which oil spill occurs to jointly suppress the situation. ➢ Use scrap cloth or absorbent material to clean up the oil and the area of the oil leakage. ➢ Collect and discard all the materials used for suppression of the leakage in the container prepared for hazardous waste (in accordance with the waste management practice). ➢ Clean up the area of oil leak thoroughly to prevent any impacts on the environment. ➢ The supervisor and the employee responsible for the area where the spilling or leakage takes place hold a meeting to find measures to prevent any recurrence. • In case of major oil leakage ➢ The person encountering the spill or leakage immediately reports it to the supervisor or the employee responsible for the area and relevant persons in order to correct the emergency. ➢ Fence off the area of large quantity oil spill or leakage to prevent dispersion and for the convenience in correcting and suppressing the emergency. ➢ The person who tries to control the situation should be in the direction of upwind in order to avoid the oil vapour and must wear safety equipment such as, mask to prevent vapor. ➢ Follow the prevention and response to oil spill or leakage plan. Chemical transportation safety measures Transportation of hazardous chemicals must be operated with utmost emphasis on the safety of communities, assets and environment. Operators of hazardous chemical transportation must fully comply with the project safety procedure, applicable laws and regulations such as Department of Pollution Control Hazardous Materials Transportation Manual of September 2011, Manual on Hazardous Chemicals
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-23 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 10. Public Health / Management in Workplace, July 2003, and the Notification of Department of Industrial Works re: Hazardous Occupational Health Chemicals and Storage Manual B.E.2550 such as: and Safety (Cont’d) − Chemical transportation operation permit Correctly marked chemical transporters as per Department of Land Transport regulations.. − Proper and safe sorting and transportation of chemicals. − Shipping paper administration − Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) is to be made available for all chemicals being shipped in both Thai and English languages. − Personal Protective Equipment equipped on board each chemical transport. − Provide training for drivers of chemical transports, making sure that the drivers understand the hazards of chemicals being shipped. Drivers must also be trained for safe driving skills and emergency mitigation procedures. Chemical storage safety measures The Sriracha power plant chemical storage safety measures will comply with the Notification of Department of Industrial Works re: Hazardous Chemicals and Storage Manual (B.E.2550) and the Hazardous Chemicals Management and Administration in Work Places Manual, April 2011 such as: − Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) is to be made available for all chemicals being stored in both Thai and English languages. − Hazardous substances must be stored and handled as appropriate to the 4 types according to the degree of hazard as follows: type 1 – business operator to comply with specified criteria and procedures, type 2 – as with type 1 and must obtain registration certificate from the authority, type 3 – as with type 2 and obtain permit, and type 4 – prohibited from production, distribution or possession. − Hazardous chemical storage must be in a safe condition or suitable to hazardous chemicals being stored. Safety Measures for Use of Chemicals
− The project will devise chemicals safety measures as per US Occupational Safety and Health Agency (OSHA) and Ministerial Regulations re: Management, Administration, and Implementation of Occupational Health and Safety in Hazardous Chemicals Working Environment (B.E. 2556). Details of the safety measures will also be included in the project safety procedure. − Prepare Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) about the hazard characteristics of the substance’s property in Thai and English and place it at the point of work. − Install warning/ instructional/ caution signs for hazardous chemicals work in clear view at the work area. − Allocate area and equipment for safety protection in the area of work concerning hazardous substances, such as, the place for eye wash, hand and face wash, and the shower for washing off hazardous substances from body. − Provide appropriate Personal Protective Equipment to employees working with hazardous chemicals suitable to the nature of the hazard and hazard level to protect employees from possible harm.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-24 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 10. Public − Establish preventive measures for protection against hazardous chemicals at the hazardous chemical Health/Occupational storage areas. Preliminary mitigation measures include proper ventilation system, fire prevention Health and Safety system, spill retention dike to prevent chemical leaking out of the hazardous substance storage area (Cont’d) and dedicated spill drainages unconnected to water drainage system. − Provide a hazardous chemical detection equipment to monitor traces of chemicals in the atmosphere of work places and chemical storage areas. An alarm would go off when these chemical traces exceed safe limit. − Conduct regular monitoring and analyses of chemicals in the atmosphere of work places and hazardous chemical storage areas. − Provide appropriate fire extinguishers and emergency medical supplies. − Assign responsibility for chemists to improve chemical administration safety plan. − Chemists and safety officer shall audit and devise hazardous chemical audit system in each work area requiring use of chemicals with annual review and revision. − Provide training for all employees who work with chemicals on safe handling of chemicals, preventive measures and leak detection. Preventative Measures of the System of Natural Gas Pipeline and the Diesel Pipelines in the project area. − Designate natural gas control stations as restricted areas , in which wor−ing related to heat and sparking is prohibited by putting signs of danger warning around natural gas control stations and diesel oil tank areas. In case it is necessary to work in the areas, checking and controlling must be strict and work permit system must be conducted. − Maintain natural gas and diesel oil pipeline systems together with equipment to be ready for working - and to keep watching for safety. − Check the thickness of the gas pipeline route and the level of erosion of pipelines, regularly. − Conduct leakage survey of natural gas and diesel oil pipeline systems in accordance with related standards − Mark hazard zone and establish control and prevention measure for safety e.g. No Smoking Zone, Hot Work Zone, where access permission is required, etc. 11. Major Hazard Explosion/fire during − Inspect the leakage of the natural gas, using the gas measurement equipment to detect the main - No explosion/fire during operation Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in operation period leakage above the ground at the MRS regularly as specified in the Safety Procedure. period operation cost − Install warning signs along the pipeline route with warning to prevent any action in the area above the pipeline route which may affect the pipeline and so that people finding abnormalities may report to the person in charge. − Establish and enforce the regulation and methods of work for the safety of work concerning natural gas pipeline. − Configure the system of control of the shutdown and a system of relief valves to enable detection of abnormalities of the pressures within the pipeline correctly and promptly. − Diesel oil tanks must be surrounded by concrete dike, which can carry 110% of the biggest tank capacity in case of broken or leak, according to the ministerial law on oil storage regulation, B.E.2551 (2008) of Ministry of Energy. − The area of the station for unloading of the truc−’s oils must have di−es surrounding it so that the rain can flow through and clean up the oil stains which may have spilt or leaked in the area into the waste water collection pipe to be sent to the Oil Separator.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-25 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 11. Major Hazard Control and Monitoring Measures (Cont’d) Establish hazard zones where persons entering the hazard zone must strictly follow the control and preventive measures for the safety such as: − Prohibit Smoking − Prohibit bringing cigarette lighters, matches or anything that may cause spark into the hazard zone established. Prohibit bringing or storing flammable substance in the hazard zone. − Prohibit bringing or storing self- combustion substance, such as the yellow phosphorus, the white phosphorus, and Magnesium Alloys, etc. − Work with heat, such as, welding, metal cutting, etc. must obtain prior permission from the authoritative person. − Safety measures must be in place before work starts. − Prohibit persons without related function to the work to enter the hazard zone. Plan for Prevention and Containing Emergency and Fire from Natural Gas 1. Objectives • Prevent fire from Natural Gas • Be prepared for and to take appropriate action in case of fire. 2. The essential fundamental information To ensure safety in working with natural gas, we must know about the characteristics that may cause danger from natural gas and the general method to deal with them, as follow: • Fundamental property and property which may cause danger from natural gas. ➢ The natural gas being used by the power generation unit is mainly Methane gas known as Dry Gas. ➢ It is a natural gas having vapor density equals to 0.6 when comparing with the air by weight (the air being equal to 1). ➢ Methane gas is in the form of vapor at the normal temperature and pressure. ➢ Liquid Methane gas can expand many times in the form of vapor when comparing with other gases. ➢ Flammable and Explosive Limit of Methane is between 5.0 to 14% (Low to High Limit). • Danger from using natural gas ➢ It can flow and emit through the atmosphere (methane gas is hazard when mix with suitable level of air) ➢ Natural gas is colorless harmless to the body but if enters into the gas mass, a person can lose consciousness and short of breathing air. • Action in case of Gas Leakage ➢ Approaching to or coming near the fire or the position of gas leakage must be from the upwind direction. ➢ Make everyone leave the area which the gas mass float through. Get rid of things that may ignite the gas and this must be done immediately. ➢ Assign persons to station at the area of gas leakage to prohibit people from coming near the area within 200 ft from gas leakage, except for persons needing to enter to carry out their duties.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-26 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 11. Major Hazard ➢ Gas leaked but not ignited (Cont’d) : Shut the Valves to stop the flow of gas. : Spray water in fine sprinkles to reduce gas vapor in the cross directions to the direction which the gas emerges or other direction to a safe direction. : If the leakage or the gas mass cannot be put out, measures must be taken to control combustion by spraying large quantity of water to the hot metal parts, e.g. the pipe or the hot metal surface. : Avoid the sources that may cause fire. ➢ Gas leaked and ignited : Shut the Valve to stop the flow of gas. : Prohibit the use of fire extinguishers until the gas leakage is stopped. : Spray water to the extreme hot area such as concrete, pipe, metal surface and allow the fire to burn at the draining pipe. : If there is a combustion at the valve that is the key to stopping the gas leakage, spray water with fine sprinkles and get someone wearing a fire protection suit to shut the valve. : Dry chemical can be used to extinguish minor gas fire by spraying directly at the point of gas leakage. Use CO2 to extinguish fire for gas which has very low pressure. : If the gas leakage cannot be controlled, control the gas vapor bursting out by spraying water to protect equipment around the area of leakage. ➢ Prevention of Danger in case of Gas Leakage : Upon occurrence of gas leakage, stop using all electrical equipment that are not explosion proof type in the area of leakage. : Shut the valves to stop the flow of gas. : Control the sources that may cause combustion, e.g. flame, hot surface spark, etc. : Inspect the proportion of gas and air at the point of leakage to find the hazard points and to ventilate to expel the gas. : Persons working without the protective suit while functioning should inspect their own clothing because gas might have been trapped inside the clothing and may be released later after the incident which may cause danger. • Inspect to find the location of gas leakage ➢ Determine point of measurement of quantity of gas leak ➢ Prepare a table of inspection, specifying time of the inspection. ➢ Carry out the inspection using gas inspection equipment. • Repair or maintenance of equipment of pipelines which the gas flows through. : Shut down or block off the section of equipment or pipe which the gas flows through before repairing. : Ventilate the air adequately in the area before working on the repair. : Inspect the proportion of gas and air before working and periodically while working on the repairing. : Use Non-Sparking Type equipment for repair. : Maintain equipment e.g. inspect facilities regularly and check thickness of the pipe which may be the point causing leakage, etc. • Conduct annual emergency drill both in the part of the Power Plant itself and the joint drill of emergency plan with Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate and external agencies. Give training to personnel on the skill and expertise in relieving emergency, at least once a year. Plan of Preparedness in Cases of Emergency from Oil Leak. Follow the Measure on Unloading of Diesel, the Public Health Action Plan, the OHS Plan, during the operation phase
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-27 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-1 (CONT’D) PREVENTION AND MITIGATION MEASURES FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Project Component or Impact or Risk to be Institutional Mitigated Mitigation Measures(s) including legislation/IFC EHS Guidelines Performance Indicator(s) Cost Estimates Activity Responsibilities 12. Green Area Aesthetic impact − Arrange to have green area in the project area of no less than 5% of the project area by planting of - Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Included in the perennial plants, the shrubs and grass in three rows zigzagging between the perennial plants and operation cost the tall shrubs as shown in Figure 9-5. Examples of the perennial plants to be brought in are such as, the Indian mast tree, leguminosae, d.longissima schum, yellow silk cotton or other kind of plants as appropriate having the diameters of not less than 5 inches and to grow at suitable interval between plants in consideration of the shrub’s formation when they are fully grown. − The perennials trees to be planted in the project area must have a minimum height of 1.50 m in proportion with the area but no less than 450 trees as prescribed in the Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand’s Notification No. 103/2556 re: Land Development for business operators in the Industrial Estate, Section 27 which prescribes that, The business operators must plant perennial trees in proportion with the area but no less than 1 tree per 1 rai of land and the tree’s height must not be under แ.5เ m. The trees must be indicated in the site’s layout submitted for construction permit with the Industrial Estate Authority of Thailand.” − The green area of the project must be improved to make it suitable for plant growing. − In case trees die or are damaged, the project will replace them within one month to maintain the ratio of green area as required. − Take care of the green area to keep it beautiful, neat and order at all times. Use automatic watering systems to cover the green area. Allocate budget for caring and management of the green area adequately every year. 12. Heat Generated - from power plant 13. Green Area - 14. pH of Rainwater - and Sulfate Radicals in soil
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-28 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
FIGURE 9-1 : NOISE BARRIER IN CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION PERIOD
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-29 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
FIGURE 9-2 : SCHEME OF OPERATION ON GSRC POWER PLANT PROJECT’S COMPLAINT RECEIVING
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-30 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
Complainant
Sriracha Power Plant Complaint Center
Forward to management to assign personnel to undertake corrective action
Corrective action in 24 Hrs.
Inform Complainant of Progress
Monitor progress and report to local administrative organization
FIGURE 9-3 : EMERGENCY COMPLAINT PROCEDURE
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-31 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
IIn Case of a Fire in the Power Plant
The First Person Discovering a Fire
Attempt Preliminary Fire Extinguishing Emergency Level 1 Director of Emergency Orders Setting Off Alarm and Declare Whether the Fire No Report the Fire to the A State of Emergency and Evacuation Can Be Controlled Director of Emergency
Yes Proceed to Extinguish the Fire by Report to Persons in Charge According to the Plan Respective Superiors
Yes Whether the Fire No Can Be Controlled
Emergency Level 2
Director of Emergency Cancels Emergency and Evacuation Enter Emergency Plan of In order to Investigate and Enter Recuperation Plan Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard After the Fire Industrial Estate
Note : The Emergency Plan of Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate
FIGURE 9-4 : EMERGENCY CONTROL CHART
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-32
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 9 Chapter Management EnvironmentalPlan PlantPower Project Sriracha for submittalADB to Report Environmental RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2
Page
9- 33 FIGURE 9-5 : GREEN AREA
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9
Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2
MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE
Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate Construction Period 1. Air Quality Pre-construction Phase Applicable ambient air quality - TSP (24 hr) Areas for monitoring at 5 stations, comprising Once, before construction - TSP by Gravimetric-High Volume Contractor to 550,000 Baht/ time standards related to fugitive dust - PM-10 (24 hr) (Figure 9-6) activities, with 7 consecutive - PM-10 by Gravimetric-High Volume monitor under
and exhaust emissions are as - NO2 (1 hr) - Station 1 Project Area days covering holidays and or U.S. EPA or governmental offices supervision of Gulf
follows: - SO2 (1 and 24 hr) - Station 2 Child Development Center of workdays - NO2 by Chemiluminescence SRC Co., Ltd
Pollutant National WHO - Wind speed and direction Chomphon Chao Phraya Sub-district Municipality - SO2 by UV-Fluorescence Standard Standard - Temperature - Station 3 Ban Khlong Kram School - Temperature, speed and direction 3 3 (mg/m ) (mg/m ) - Station 4 Rawoeng Rangsan Temple of wind, sampling by using an TSP (24 330 - - Station 5 Ban Nong Klang Pla aerovane hrs) Construction Phase
PM-10 120 50 - TSP (24 hr) Areas for monitoring at 5 stations, comprising Six month time, each - TSP by Gravimetric-High Volume Contractor to 550,000 Baht/ time (24 hrs) - PM-10 (24 hr) (Figure 9-6) measurement takes 7 - PM-10 by Gravimetric-High Volume or monitor under
NO2 (1 hr) 320 200 - NO2 (1 hr) - Station 1 Project Area consecutive days covering U.S. EPA or governmental offices supervision of Gulf - - - SO2 (1 780 - SO2 (1 and 24 hr) Station 2 Child Development Center of holidays and workdays for the NO2 by Chemiluminescence SRC Co., Ltd
hrs) - Wind speed and direction Chomphon Chao Phraya Sub-district Municipality entire construction period, - SO2 by UV-Fluorescence - Temperature - Station 3 Ban Khlong Kram School especially activities generated - Temperature, speed and direction SO2 (24 300 20 hrs) - Station 4 Rawoeng Rangsan Temple dust such as area adjustment. of wind, sampling by using an aero - Station 5 Ban Nong Klang Pla vane
- Monitoring will be performed using - Monitoring of potential impacts on forest Once, during construction - Contractor to 50,000 Baht/ time satellite imagery, and/or other habitats at the location of the maximum air period. monitor under monitoring arrangements that will be quality concentration (At least area of 1x1 supervision of Gulf 2 explored and implemented as Km , covering maximum concentration of NO2 SRC Co., Ltd practically required and agreed by (728878E, 1456011N)) GSRC 2. Noise Pre-construction Phase
Noise performance will be - Leq 24 hrs. Measurement areas close the project site, at 3 Once, before the start of - Application of International Contractor to 90,000 Baht/ time
evaluated against the following - Leq 1 hr. stations (Figure 9-7) of: construction activities, by Organization for Standardization monitor under standards: - Leq 5 min - Station 1 project area continuous measurement for 7 (ISO1996) or methods assigned by supervision of Gulf
- Standard as prescribed in the - Ldn - Station 2 Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan- days, covering work days and governmental offices SRC Co., Ltd
National Environment Board’s - Lmax aok School holidays.
Notification No. 15 re: Prescribing - L90 - Station 3 Chompon Chaophraya Temple or Noise Level Standard, B.E. 2540. The Prod Housing Estate (Leq 24 hrs not exceed 70 dB(A)) Construction Phase
- Guidelines for Community Noise, - Leq 24 hrs. Measurement areas close the project site, at 3 - Twice a year. It must cover - Application of International Contractor to 90,000 Baht/ time World Health Organization (WHO), - Leq 1 hr. stations (Figure 9-7) of : noisy activities, such as Organization for Standardization monitor under 1999. - Leq 5 min - Station 1 project area foundation piling, by (ISO1996) or methods assigned by supervision of Gulf
Landuse Laeq 1 hr - Ldn - Station 2 Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan- continuous measurement governmental offices SRC Co., Ltd
Daytime Nighttime - Lmax aok School for 7 days, covering work
(07.00- (22.00- - L90 - Station 3 Chompon Chaophraya Temple or days and holidays. 22.00) 07.00) The Prod Housing Estate Residential; institutional; 55 45 education Industrial; 70 70 commercial
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2.docx Page 9-34 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate 3. Surface water quality and Construction Phase At the end of the drain of the wastewater from the − Once before drainage of − Application of Standard Methods Contractor to 8,000 Baht/time groundwater quality • Wastewater from Hydrostatic Test hydrostatic test the wastewater from the for the Examination of Water and monitor under Qualities of the treated effluent − Temperature hydrostatic test Wastewater supervision of Gulf compared with the applicable − pH SRC Co., Ltd effluent quality standards. − Suspended Solid (SS) − Oil & Grease • Wastewater from worker’s Retention pond at wor−er’s camp/office building − Once a month throughout − Application of Standard Methods Contractor to 5,000 Baht/time/station camp/office building area the construction period for the Examination of Water and monitor under
− pH Wastewater supervision of Gulf
− BOD5 SRC Co., Ltd
− Suspended Solid
− Sulfide
− Total Dissolved Solid
− Settleable Solids
− Oil & Grease
− TKN
− Fecal Coliform Bacteria 4. Water Use - 5. Transportation Construction Phase Construction area − Everyday throughout the − Record volume of daily traffic Contractor to Included in total
Number of complaints filed − Daily record the number of type of construction period accident occurred during the monitor under construction contract through the complaint response vehicle and time to enter the project project construction phase and supervision of Gulf cost channel construction area produce a monthly report. SRC Co., Ltd
− Record the number of truck transporting material and equipment
− Statistical record of accidents occurred from transportation including cause, location, time, and preventive measures for every accident.
6. Waste Management - − −
7. Drainage and Flood Control - − − 8. Socio-Economic Pre-Construction and Construction Representative of households within a 5 km radius − Once, 3 months before − In-depth interviews using Contractor to 720,000 Baht/time Number of complaints filed Phases of the project location cover 4 district and 6 sub- construction activities questionnaires monitor under through the complaint response − Socio-economic survey and opinion district in study area. (Figure 9-8) − Once a year throughout − Sample size (household) in supervision of Gulf channel interview with households, people, − Representative of households within measurement the construction accordance with statistical calculation SRC Co., Ltd community leader/local leader, and stations of environmental quality at the confidence level of 95%
representatives of relevant agencies. − Community leaders/local leaders within a 5 − Sample size will be classified
− Sensitive receptors around the project km radius of the project site following the radius of impacts site i.e. hospital, temple, school and − Sensitive area within a 5 km radius of the occurred (0-3 km and 3-5 km) measurement stations of environmental project site i.e. hospital, temple, and school. within a 5 km radius of the project quality including impacts occurred,
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-35 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate 8. Socio-Economic (Cont’d) problems, community and household site including distribution map to needed, and community satisfaction explain the survey activities. index by using systematic random sampling and distribution map for in- depth interview.
9. Public Relations and Pre-Construction and Construction Communities within a 5 km radius of the Throughout the Record activities that the project Gulf SRC Co., Ltd Included in total CSR Community Participation Phases project site construction period arranges for local communities cost Number of complaints filed Activities that the project arranges for Every 6 month, Record summary’s through the complaint response local communities activities of Environmental Impacts
channel Activities of the Environmental Monitoring Committee. Impacts Monitoring Committee are occurred every 6 months 10. Public Health/ Occupational Pre-construction Phase Health and Safety Public Health
Number of complaints filed Illness statistics of people within a 5 Communities around the project site Once, before start Once a year for Interview local Contractor to Included in total through the complaint response km radius of the project site construction activities people living in communities, monitor under construction contract channel designated for the project supervision of Gulf cost environmental quality SRC Co., Ltd measurement.
Gather health status data of local people from local public health services as well as analyze and compare the data between before and after project development. Construction Phase Construction area Worker
Statistical record of accidents Once a year, throughout Statistical record of accidents, Contractor to Included in total the construction period specifying causes and monitor under construction contract characteristics of the accidents, supervision of Gulf cost impacts on health and the number SRC Co., Ltd of persons injured. Specify the method of correction of the problems and the suggestions.
The meeting of Occupational Health, Throughout the Record the minutes of safety Safety and Environment Committee construction period officer meetings
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-36 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate
10. Public Health/ Occupational • Occupational Health and Safety − Construction area − Once a year, throughout − Keep a record of the accidents, Health and Safety (Cont’d) − Statistical record of accidents the construction period specifying causes and characteristics of the accidents, impacts on health and the number of persons injured. Specify the method of correction of the problems and the suggestions.
− Keep record accidents, causes, loss, corrective actions and methods to prevent recurrence
11. Major Hazard - − − −
12. Green Area - − − −
13. Heat Generated from the Pre-Construction and Construction − Covering the project construction site and air − Three times before project − Study and analysis of ground Contractor to 90,000 Baht/time Power Plant Phases quality measurement stations commissioning, covering temperature based on data monitor under
− Spot imagery, showing temperature all seasons: Hot season derived from the spot imagery, by supervision of Gulf data (mid February – mid May), Geo-Informatics and Space SRC Co., Ltd Rainy season (mid May – Technology Development Agency mid October) and cool (Public Organization) (GISTDA) or season (mid October – capable agencies/ companies. mid February) (refer Meteorological Department of Thailand, www.tmd.go.th)
14. pH of Rainwater and Sulfate - − − − Radicals in Soil Monitoring Operation Period 1. Air Quality Operation Phase Applicable air emission from • Air Quality from Emission Stacks 4 emission stacks of the project − CEMs measures − Installation of CEMs at stack of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd − Installation of CEMs, power plant standards are as − CEMs: TSP, NOx, SO2, O2 and flow rate continuously over the project. Measuring NOx, O2, SO2, about 2,000,000 Baht follows: − Random sampling: TSP, NOx, SO2, and entire power generation TSP, and flow rate continuously − Maintenance 100,000 Pollutant National IFC Standard Standard O2 period for the entire period of power Baht/year Gas − Audit the CEMs (Audit/RAA/ RATA): − Random sampling of NOx, generation − Air sampling from TSP 60 - (ppm) TSP, NOx, SO2, O2 SO2, TSP and O2 at the Audit the CEMs to confirm that the stack 200,000 NO2 120 25 stack ends, every 6 month, measurement results from the Baht/year SO2 20 - Diesel which measure CEMs are accurate. Measurement TSP 120 50 simultaneously with method following the U.S.EPA or (ppm) ambient air quality as well governmental offices will be used NO2 180 74 (ppm) as specify % load operation for examination. The audit is SO2 260 Use of 1 and wind direction when divided into 2 parts; (ppm) % or less S fuel measurements are being
conducted.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-37 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9
Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate 1. Air Quality (Cont’d) - Examine the accuracy of 1. System Audit is the CEMs audit, at least once examination for accuracy of a year CEMs working, by review qualitative evaluation and investigating CEMs working status. 2. Performance Audit is the examination of CEMs working accuracy by quantitative evaluation. Measurement
accuracy of NOx, O2 and SO2 employs relative test audit (RATA), based on reading the
value of NOx, O2 and SO2 from CEMs and compare with the measurement results of air sampling from stack at the same time as reading. The comparison gives relative accuracy. The results will then be compared with the criteria for accuracy test.
Applicable ambient air quality · Ambient Air Quality - Areas for monitoring at 4 stations, comprising Six month time, each - TSP by Gravimetric-High Volume Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 400,000 Baht/ time standards related to fugitive - TSP (24 hr) (Figure 9-6) measurement takes 7 - PM-10 by Gravimetric-High Volume or dust and exhaust emissions are - PM-10 (24 hr) - Station 1 Child Development Center of consecutive days covering U.S. EPA or governmental offices
as follows: - NO2 (1 hr) Chomphon Chao Phraya Sub-district Municipality holidays and workdays for the - NO2 by Chemiluminescence
Pollutant National WHO - SO2 (1 and 24 hr) - Station 2 Ban Khlong Kram School entire operation period. - SO2 by UV-Fluorescence Standard Standard - Wind speed and direction - Station 3 Rawoeng Rangsan Temple - Temperature, speed and direction 3 3 (mg/m ) (mg/m ) - Temperature - Station 4 Ban Nong Klang Pla of wind, sampling by using an aero TSP (24 330 - vane hrs) PM-10 120 50 (24 hrs)
NO2 (1 hr) 320 200
SO2 (1 780 - hrs)
SO2 (24 300 20 hrs)
- Monitoring will be performed using - Monitoring of potential impacts on forest Once a year, during operation - Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 50,000 Baht/ time satellite imagery, and/or other habitats at the location of the maximum air period. monitoring arrangements that will be quality concentration (At least area of 1x1 2 explored and implemented as Km , covering maximum concentration of NO2 practically required and agreed by (728878E, 1456011N)) GSRC
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2.docx Page 9-38 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate 2. Noise Operation Phase − Measure Leq 24 hrs. Leq 1 hr. Leq 5 min and − Continuous measurement − Application of International Gulf SRC Co., Ltd − Measurement of Leq Noise performance will be − Leq 24 hrs. L90 in the areas close to the project site, at 6 for 7 days covering work Organization for Standardization 24 hrs., Leq 1 hr, Leq evaluated against the following − Leq 8 hrs. stations of (Figure 9-7) : days and holidays for Leq (ISO1996) or methods assigned by 5 min and L90 costs standards: − Leq 1 hr. • Station 1.1-1.4 : At fence of the project 24 hrs, Leq 1 hr, Leq 5 governmental offices about 150,000 Baht/ - Standard as prescribed in the − Leq 5 min (4 sides) min every 6 months, time (2 time/year for National Environment Board’s Notification No. 15 re: Prescribing − Ldn • Station 2: Chumchon Borisat Namtan throughout the operation the entire operation Noise Level Standard, B.E. 2540. − Lmax Tawan-ao− School Co., Ltd.’s period. period) (Leq 24 hrs not exceed 70 dB(A)) − L90 community school − Prepare a Noise Mapping/ − Measurement of Leq - Guidelines for Community Noise, Station 3: Chompon Chaophraya Temple Noise Contour Map of the hrs. cost about World Health Organization (WHO), • 8 1999. or The Prod housing estate project by identified noise 10,000 Baht/time/ Landuse Laeq 1 hr − Prepare a noise mapping/noise contour map sources, loud noise level, station (2 time/year Daytime Nighttime (07.00- (22.00- of the project by identified noise sources, loud frequency and disturbed for the entire 22.00) 07.00) noise level, frequency and disturbed noise noise within the first year operation period) Residential; institutional; 55 45 − Measure Leq 8 hrs in the power block area i.e. of operation and to carry − Noise contour map education combustion chamber of gas turbine on continuously every 3 preparation costs Industrial; years. about 150,000 Baht/ commercial 70 70
− Twice a year, continuous time (the first year of measurement for Leq 8 operation and to carry hrs for 72 hrs throughout on continuously every the operation period 3 years.) 3. Surface water quality and Operation Phase
groundwater quality 1. The discharge water quality from − Cooling water holding pond No. 2 or 3 in which − Throughout operation − Installation of water quality online Gulf SRC Co., Ltd include in operation cooling tower has wastewater (Figure 9-9) period monitoring system cost • Water quality online Monitoring
− Temperature
− pH
− Conductivity
− Dissolved Oxygen • Measurement by sampling − Cooling Water Holding Pond No. 2 or 3 in − monthly throughout the − Use methods identified in water Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 10,000 Baht/time − Temperature which has wastewater (Figure 9-9) operation period quality standards of surface water − pH sources in accordance with the − Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) notification of NEB, No. 8 (1994), − Suspended Solids (SS) and Standard Methods for the − BOD5 Examination of Water and − Dissolved Oxygen (DO) Wastewater, regulated by APHA, - − Chlorite (ClO 2) AWWA and WEF, or methods − Sodium (Na) (millimole/liter) identified by governmental (for SAR calculation) agencies. − Calcium (Ca) (millimole/liter) (for SAR calculation)
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-39 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate
3. Surface water quality and − Magnesium (Mg) groundwater quality (Cond’t) (millimole/liter) (for SAR calculation) Na − SAR = (ca+ M) • Annual Measurement − Cooling Water Holding Pond No. 2 or 3 in − Once a year throughout − Use methods identified in water Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 6,000 Baht/time Follow Ministry of Industrial’s which has wastewater (Figure 9-9) the operation period quality standards of surface water Notification No. 2 (B.E2539) re: sources in accordance with the Prescribing Standards of Quality notification of NEB, No. 8 (1994), of Discharged Water Drain from and Standard Methods for the Factories and the level of Total Examination of Water and Dissolved Solid must be within Wastewater, regulated by APHA, the standards of the quality of AWWA and WEF, or methods water discharged into the identified by governmental Irrigation waterway of the agencies. Department of Royal Irrigation 2. Wastewater Quality from the Process − Wastewater holding pond (Figure 9-9) − Throughout operation − Installation of water quality online Gulf SRC Co., Ltd • Water quality online Monitoring period monitoring system − Temperature − pH − Conductivity • Measurement by sampling − Wastewater holding pond (Figure 9-9) − monthly throughout the − Use methods identified in water Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 6,000 Baht/time − Temperature operation period quality standards of surface water − pH sources in accordance with the − Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) notification of NEB, No. 8 (1994), − Suspended Solids (SS) and Standard Methods for the − Oil & Grease Examination of Water and Wastewater, − BOD5 regulated by APHA, AWWA and WEF, or methods identified by governmental agencies. • Annual Measurement − Wastewater Holding Pond (Figure 9-9) − Once a year throughout − Use methods identified in water Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 40,000 Baht/time All parameters follow’s Industrial the operation period quality standards of surface water Estate Authority of Thailand sources in accordance with the Notification No. 76/2560 (B.E.2017) notification of NEB, No. 8 (1994), re: General Guidelines for and Standard Methods for the Wastewater Drainage to the Examination of Water and central wastewater treatment Wastewater, regulated by APHA, system of industrial estate. AWWA and WEF, or methods identified by governmental agencies.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-40 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate 3. Surface water quality and 3. Surface water quality 8 Station (Figure 9-10) − Twice a year throughout − Use methods identified in water Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 150,000 Baht/time groundwater quality (Cond’t) − Temperature − Khlong Kram, 200 meters before flow through the operation period quality standards of surface water − pH the estate. sources in accordance with the − Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) − Khlong Kram at water discharged point of the notification of NEB, No. 8 (1994), − Suspended Solids (SS) estate. and Standard Methods for the − BOD5 − Khlong Kram, 200 meters after water Examination of Water and − Dissolved Oxygen (DO) discharged point of the Industrial Estate. Wastewater, regulated by APHA, - − Chlorite (ClO 2) − Khlong Rawoeng, 200 meters before flow AWWA and WEF, or methods − Chlorophyll a (for monitoring through the Industrial Estate. identified by governmental occurrence of eutrophication − The confluence point between Khlong agencies. which will occur when chlorophyll Rawoeng and Khlong Kram.
a in water is between 8-25 mg/l as − Khlong Rawoeng, 200 meters after Ban Wang specified in Water Quality Criteria Ka Yang weir. for Aquatic Life (EPA, 1986) − Nong Pla Lai Reservoir, 2 km. from mouth of − Sodium (Na) (millimole/liter) (for Khlong Rawoeng. SAR calculation) − Nong Pla Lai Reservoir, 4 km. from mouth of − Calcium (Ca) (millimole/liter) (for Khlong Rawoeng. SAR calculation)
− Magnesium (Mg) (millimole/liter) (for SAR calculation) Na − SAR = (ca+ M) 4. Groundwater quality − Monitoring Well (Figure 2-11) − Twice a year throughout − Use methods identified in Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 15,000 Baht/time − Temperature the operation period Standard Methods for the − pH Examination of Water and − Dissolved Oxygen (DO) Wastewater − BOD5 − Total Dissolved Solid (TDS) − Suspended Solid (SS) − Oil and Grease - − Chlorite (ClO 2) 4 Water Use − −
5. Transportation Operation Phase Project area − Everyday throughout the − Record volume of daily traffic Gulf SRC Co., Ltd
− Daily record the number of type of construction period accident occurred during the vehicle and time to enter the project project operation phase and construction area produce a monthly report.
− Statistical record of accidents occurred from transportation including cause, location, time, and preventive measures for every accident.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-41 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate
6. Solid Waste Management Operation Phase Project area − Monthly throughout the − Survey and record Gulf SRC Co., Ltd
− Type and volume of general garbage operation period and waste from production process. 7. Drainage and Flood Control - 8. Socio-economic Operation Phase − Representative of households within a 5 km − Once a year throughout − In-depth interviews using Gulf SRC Co., Ltd 720,000 Baht/time − Socio-economic survey and opinion radius of the project site cover 4 district and 6 the operation period questionnaires interview with households, people, sub-district in study area. − Sample size (household) in community leader/local leader, − Representative of households within accordance with statistical representatives of relevant agencies, measurement stations of environmental calculation at the confidence level local organization and sensitive quality of 95%
receptors around the project site i.e. − Community leaders/local leaders within a 5 − Sample size will be classified hospital, temple, school and km radius of the project site following the radius of impacts measurement stations of environmental − Sensitive area within a 5 km radius of the occurred (0-3 km and 3-5 km) quality including impacts occurred, project site i.e. hospital, temple, and school. within a 5 km radius of the project problems, community and household site including distribution map to needed, and community satisfaction explain the survey activities. index by using systematic random sampling and distribution map for in- depth interview.
− Record compliant issues − Representative of households within a 5 km − Twice a year throughout − Record compliant issues of Gulf SRC Co., Ltd radius of the project site cover 4 district and 6 the operation period community including resolution sub-district in the study area. approaches and timeframe to
− Representative of households within resolve the problems measurement stations of environmental quality
− Community leaders/local leaders within a 5 km radius of the project site
− Relevant government agencies within a 5 km radius of the project site
− Sensitive area within a 5 km radius of the project site i.e. hospital, temple, and school.
9. Public Relations and Operation Phase − Communities within a 5 km radius of the − Throughout the operation − Record activities that the project Gulf SRC Co., Ltd.
Community Participation − Public Participation and Relation Plan project site period arranges for local communities. and Environmental
− Establish Environmental Impact − − Every 6 month, Record − Impacts Monitoring Monitoring Committee summary’s activities of Committee Environmental Impacts Monitoring Committee.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-42 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate
10. Public Health/ Occupational Operation Phase Communities around the project site Once a year for compiling Once a year for Interview local Gulf SRC Co., Ltd Health and Safety Public Health data on people health people living in communities,
Illness statistics of people within a 5 conditions, from public designated for the project km radius of the project site health service centers in environmental quality the area measurement.
Gather health status data of local people from local public health services as well as analyze and compare the data between before and after project development. Worker Project area Health check-up for Produce monthly report and once Gulf SRC Co., Ltd Statistical record of accidents, illness, workers in the project a year for health check-up of injury of workers, public health (Once a year) workers problem, and worker health Occupational Health and Safety Project area Operation period Keep a record of the accidents, Gulf SRC Co., Ltd Statistical record of accidents (Once a year) specifying causes and characteristics of the accidents, impacts on health and the number of persons injured. Specify the method of correction of the problems and the suggestions.
Keep record accidents, causes, loss, corrective actions and methods to prevent recurrence Meeting of OHS Committees Project area Operation period Minutes of Meeting Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Results of Emergency Plan Project area Operation period Evaluate the drills of the Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Emergency Plan in order to adjust the plan and the employees’ working skills. Noise in the workplace Loud noise area i.e. 4 times a year International Organization for Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. 10,000 Baht/time Leq 8 hrs Cooling Tower area Standardization (ISO 1996) or Gas Compressor area method assigned by government
Boiler Feed Pump area offices
Gas Turbine area
Steam Turbine area
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-43 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate
10. Public Health/ Occupational − Noise Mapping/Noise Contour in order − The production areas of loud noise − The first year of operation − Integrated Sound Level or method Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Health and Safety (Cont’d) to mark the areas of loud noise and to carry on assigned by governmental offices continuously every 3 years • Heat − Condenser Exhaust Unit area − 4 times a year − WBGT Method or method assigned Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. 5,000 Baht/time − Wet Bulb Globe Temperature: WBGT − Steam pipeline area by governmental offices
− Steam turbine area
− Gas turbine area • Light − Electrical and Control Building − 4 times a year − Lux Meter or method assigned by Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. 10,000 Baht/time − Light Intensive Level − Administration Building governmental offices
− Workshop
• Health − New workers − Prior to work − Physical exam Gulf SRC Co., Ltd.
− General health check-up for new commencement following − Lung X-ray
workers time requirement of Law − Blood test for complete blood o Physical check-up by physician count, blood group, Hepatitis B o Lung x-ray o Blood test: complete blood count, blood group, Hepatitis B
− General Health check-up for Full Time − Full Time workers − Once a year − Health check-up Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. workers o Lung x-ray o Vision Test o Hearing Test o Physical check-up by physician o Lung Function Test o Blood test: complete blood count, blood group, Hepatitis B
11. Major Hazard Operation Phase − Project area − As specified in the − Record examination of leak Gulf SRC Co., Ltd.
− Leak protection system for natural gas emergency plan protection system for natural gas and diesel oil and diesel oil
− Practices following emergency plan − Examine the practice following emergency plan
12. Green Area - − − −
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-44 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
TABLE 9-2 (COND’T) MONITORING PROGRAM FOR SRIRACHA POWER PLANT OF GULF SRC CO., LTD. SRIRACHA DISTRICT, CHON BURI PROVINCE Performance Indicator and Monitoring Parameters Monitoring Locations Frequency and duration Methods of measurement and Responsibilities Equipment/ Laboratory Purpose detection limits Tests Cost Estimate
13. Heat Generated from the Operation Phase − Covering the project construction site and air − Hot season (mid February − Study and analysis of ground Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. Power Plant − Spot imagery, showing temperature quality measurement stations – mid May), Rainy season temperature based on data data (mid May – mid October) derived from the spot imagery, by and cool season (mid Geo-Informatics and Space October – mid February), Technology Development Agency the first year of operation (Public Organization) (GISTDA) or and to carry on all season capable agencies/ companies. every 3 years (refer Meteorological Department of Thailand, www.tmd.go.th)
14. pH of Rain Water and Sulfate Operation Phase − Rain water in the project area − Twice a month during − Using pH Meter in accordance with Gulf SRC Co., Ltd Radicals in the Soil Monitoring − pH value of rain water rainy season (May- the Standard Methods for the October) Measurement of Water and Wastewater and calibrate the pH Meter by the agencies registered with the government agency, regularly at least, once a year and to attach details of each calibration in the Impact Monitoring Report
− Measurement of Sulfate Radicals in − Station No. 1 Chumchon Borisat Namtan − Twice a year − Leachate Extraction, Turbid metric Gulf SRC Co., Ltd the Soil (at the depth of 15 cm) Tawan-aok School Method or measurement method
− Station No. 2 Wat Chompon Chaophraya as specified by the authority
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-45 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
FIGURE 9-6 : AIR QUALITY MONITORING STATION
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-46 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
FIGURE 9-7 : THE PROJECT’S NOISE MONITORING STATION
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-47 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
FIGURE 9-8 : SOCIO-ECONOMIC LOCATION
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-48
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 9 Chapter Management EnvironmentalPlan PlantPower Project Sriracha for submittalADB to Report Environmental RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2
Page FIGURE 9-9 : WASTEWATER QUALITY MONITORING STATION OF PROJECT
9- 49
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 Sriracha Power Plant Project Environmental Management Plan
FIGURE 9-10 :WATER QUALITY MONITORING STATION OF PROJECT
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2 Page 9-50
Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 9 9 Chapter Management EnvironmentalPlan PlantPower Project Sriracha for submittalADB to Report Environmental RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61025-chap 9_rev2
Page
9-
51 FIGURE 9-11 : MONITORING WELL LOCATION OF PROJECT
CHAPTER 10 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation
CHAPTER 10 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
10.1 CONCLUSION FROM THE IMPACT ASSESSMENT As the Sriracha Power Plant is located in the Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate (HESIE), the potential impacts, therefore, are related to pollution from the project rather than from the project location and infrastructure of the project. The impacts related to the pollution from project operation are summarizied as follow;
10.1.1 Air Quality The potential air quality impacts from the Sriracha Power Plant Project during the construction and operation periods will be from dust dispersion during the construction phase and stack emissions during the operation phase. The assessment of impact on air quality has conducted by using AERMOD model with the input data of meteorological data from the nearest meteorological station by Pollution Control Department and Thai Meteorological Department, and continuous air quality monitoring results of the year 2015-2017. Continuous monitoring data from AQMS in Hemaraj ESIE during 2015-2017 compares with the National standard show that all of air quality parameters from Hemaraj ESIE AQMS were in accordance with the National standard. It can be concluded that the airshed is non-degraded. The considered sensitive receptors are the places where the occupants are more susceptible to the adverse effects of exposure to pollutants such as hospital and school. The assessment reults are as follows: During the project construction, the main activities leading to the dispersion of suspended particulate are the activities in the preparation of the ground for foundation works and the building works. According to the forecast of the impacts from the project construction on 21 sensitive areas, the highest 24-hr average TSP is found at the construction area with the concentration of 190.46 µg/m³. When it is added to the highest concentration measured from the field study (135 µg/m³), the result was 325.46 µg/m³. Nevertheless, the project has established environmental impact mitigation and preventive measures on air quality during the construction period by spraying water in the construction area, the soil mounds or where project construction activities causes the dispersion of suspended particulate, such as the road, the area undergoing filling and grading, etc. to reduce the dispersion of the suspended particulate, at least two times/day (morning and afternoon). When the weather is hot, dry or windy, it is estimated that the sprayed area getting dried and there is a tendency to caused dust dispersion the project will consider to increase frequency on spraying water at the area; and Install shading nets or fences with the height of 3 meters from the ground around the project. Those mitigation
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-1 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation measures could reduce the total suspended particulate (TSP) to 95.23 µg/m³. When this is added to the highest concentration measured from the field study (135 µg/m³), the result was 230.23 µg/m³ or 73.83 % of the standard level. The maximum incremental TSP is 95.23 µg/m³ at the construction site over 25 percent of national ambient air standard (330 µg/m³), it takes place at the project area. In addition, the incremental TSP at the sensitive receptors are 1.10-11.82 µg/m³ approximately 0.33-3.58 percent of national standard. During the operation period, the air quality impact will be from the use of natural gas as main fuel and diesel oil as backup fuel to generate the electricity. The combustion of these fuels will generate major air pollutants including primary oxides of nitrogen (NOx), sulfur dioxide (SO2), and particulate matters (PM). However, there will be small amount of SO2 emission and PM because of the composition of selected fuel of the project. Results from forecating model showed that the operation of 100% load produces the incremental concentration of nitrogen dioxide (NO2), sulfur dioxide (SO2) and total suspended particulate (TSP) in the atmosphere at the sensitive receptors below 25 percent of WHO ambient air quality guidelines and national ambient air quality standard. There is only the maximum 1-hour average concentrations of NO2 taking place at the Khang Phu and Chomphu Mountain with distance of about 13-15 kilometers from the project site, which are part of Khao Khiao-Khao Chomphu wildlife sanctuary and has no residents. Comparing those maximum concentrations with WHO guidelines for the effects of NO2 on vegetation (critical level), they are far below the critical level. Accordingingly, the potential impact is considered to be not significant.
10.1.2 Noise Level The construction activity causing the highest level of noise is the foundation work. During that activity, the predicted 1-hour equivalent sound pressure level (Leq 1 hr) at the four Sensitive areas namely Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok School, the Child Development Center of Chomphon Chao Phraya Sub-district Municipality, Wat Chomphon Chao Phraya and The Proud house estate is increase in background below 3 dB(A). As for disturbed noise, all four sensitive receptors have higher level of disturbed noise than the standard level. Therefore, the project set up measure to reduce that disturbed noise by installing temporary noise barrier at the site of the foundation piling in the northeast and south sides. The noise barrier is made from 1.27-mm metal materials (steel 18 ga) or thicker having sound transmission loss (TL) of 25 dB(A). The height of the noise barrier is approximately 5 m in the northeast side and approximately 3 m in the south side which will bring the specific noise to a level lower than the standard. It is anticipated that the noise from the pro∑ect’s construction activities will have temporary and low impact on the everyday life of the nearby receptors.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-2 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation
During the operation period, the major noise source will be an electricity generator. The standard engineering design specifies that the noise level at 1 m away from the generator and 1.2 m above the ground (level of hearing) must not exceed 85 dB(A). Regarding the pro∑ect’s design, equipment generating loud noise will be installed in buildings that are equipped with acoustic walls to absorb noise. Silencers will be installed to reduce the noise level during operations of equipment that may generate loud noise, such as safety valves and start up vent valves. The Project will control general noise level at the Pro∑ect’s fence areas not to exceed 7เ dB(A). Sensitive receptors in the vicinity will expose to the noise level from the project 65.2-68.2 dB(A) or equivalent to 93.แ4-97.43 % of the 24-hr average noise level standard. Regarding the prediction of noise using the 1-hr average specific noise level during เ6.เเ a.m. to 22.เเ p.m. and using the 5-min average noise level during 22.เเ p.m. to เ6.เเ a.m. to identify the disturb level, the value ranges from non-disturbing level up to 13.5 dB(A) at night which is higher than the national annoyance noise standard level limiting the maximum noise level at 10 dB(A). The annoyance noise occurs at Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok School. Therefore, noise barrier will be install at northeast fence of the project that is adjacent to the Chumchon Borisat Namtan Tawan-aok School. The fence height is at a 10-meters minimum. This results in the reduction of annoyance level to be within the standard. Also, the noise level monitoring at the vicinity will be monitored entire the project lifetime.
10.1.3 Surface Water Quality The Pro∑ect’s primary source of wastewater during the construction period comes from workers' wash rooms and toilets. The rest is wastewater from construction activities. The uncontaminated volume is sent to wastewater holding ponds for quality checking according to the requirements of Hemaraj ESIE prior to discharging into Hemaraj ESIE's central wastewater treatment system. Wastewater from wash rooms and toilets is drained into the septic tanks. During the construction period, it is estimated that there will be 1,377 m3 of wastewater per day. With this regard, the Project requires that the contractors provide bathrooms and toilets to their workers and staff with the ratio of 15 persons to one room. As for the hydrostatic test water discharge of about 150 m3 will be measured for pH, temperature, and volume of suspended solids, oil and grease to ensure that the values of these indices are within Hemaraj ESIE's specified criteria prior to discharging into Hemaraj ESIE's central wastewater treatment system. In terms of rainwater, it is likely to be contaminated with deposits of soil, sand or debris from the construction so it will be drained into temporary sedimentation pond for soil or sand sedimentation before draining clear water into rain gutter drainage system of Hemaraj ESIE later. As a result, the impact level on surface hydrology during the construction period of the project is low while there is no impact on surface water quality.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-3 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation
During the operation period, discharged water will come from two sources: 1) the electricity generating process and 2) the cooling system. The wastewater discharged from the process consists of wastewater from the water treatment system, the operation room and the office building at the maximum volume of 48 m³/day. This discharged water will be initially treated before sending to the pro∑ect’s wastewater holding pond which has the capacity to retain the discharged water for at least one day. The pond will be equipped with online monitoring of water quality to check the temperature, pH and conductivity (to find Total Dissolved Solid) in accordance with the requirement of the industrial estate before sending it for treatment in Hemara∑ ESIE’s central wastewater treatment system. Water discharged from the cooling tower of 11,660 m³/day maximum is uncontaminated and free from substances from the production process, and it will be retained at the pro∑ect’s two cooling water holding ponds with the holding capacity of 19,000 m³ each. Each pond can retain the water for at least one day. While one of the ponds is being used, the other pond will serve as the emergency pond. The discharged water is retained here before being released into the cooling water holding pond of Hemaraj ESIE which can take in the water for another one day. The project has installed a water quality online monitoring system to check temperature, pH and conductivity (for the purpose of the detection of the total dissolved solid (TDS)) in the cooling water holding pond in accordance with Ministry of Industry’s Quality Standards of Discharged Water where the level of total dissolved solid must be within the standards of the Royal Irrigation Department on the quality of discharged water in the waterways and temperature not exceeding 34 oC. The cooling water is finally drained into Kram canal flowing through Hemaraj ESIE. The difference between temperature of mixing water (drained cooling water and water in Kram canal) and that of Kram canal is lower than 3 oC. Moreover, the water quality in Kram canal, Rawoeng canal and Nong Pla Lai reservoir, which connect to each other, was forecasted to evaluate the impact from the cooling water drained from the cooling water holding pond of Hemaraj ESIE into Kram canal. The water quality forecast was conducted by calculation of SAR, and BOD and TDS concentration in (1) Kram canal after receiving the cooling water, (2) Rawoeng canal after meeting Kram canal, and (3) Nong Pla Lai reservoir after receiving water from Rawoeng canal. The quality of the cooling water was taken from that of Kaeng Khoi power plant 2 which is IPP power plant of Gulf Group and currently operating. The results show that SAR, and BOD and TDS concentration in Kram canal, Rawoeng canal (during wet season) and Nong Pla Lai reservoir do not change significantly while those in Rawoeng canal during dry season, considering BOD, the water quality has changed the classification from class 3 to class 4. However, the water in those water resources after receiving the pro∑ect’s cooling water still could be used for water use for agriculture and production of tap water.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-4 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation
Therefore, the impacts from the discharged cooling water on Kram canal, Rawoeng canal, and Nong Pla Lai reservoir are low to moderate. Nevertheless, to monitor the water quality in the water sources adjacent to the project and Hemaraj ESIE, the project will continue with examination of the level of SAR and Chlorophyll A to monitor the environmental impacts throughout the duration of the project.
10.1.4 Aquatic Ecology During the construction period the Project will produce scraps that can be washed out of the Project site and affecting the ecology of water resources in the surrounding areas. The Project, thus, has established mitigation measures, such as washing tire of the trucks leaving the construction area or construction-related areas to prevent dirt and sand from potential stains on the roads both inside and outside of the Project area. This will eventually avert the dirt and debris from various construction projects, from being washed directly into the public waterways. Storm water within the construction site will be collected in the rain gutter drainage system and drained into temporary sedimentation pond for retention and sedimentation inside the Project site. The solid sediments are separated from the rainwater and the clear water is recirculated for use to spray roads to reduce suspended particulate levels in the Project site. The remaining volume will be drained into Hemaraj ESIE's rain gutter drainage system. Therefore, it can be estimated that the construction activities of the Project will have low impact on an aquatic ecology in the areas surrounding the Project site. During operation period, the impact assessment on aquatic ecology is not only considered wastewater treatment of the project and Hemaraj ESIE, but also considered the use of chemical substances in the process. The chemical substances are considered to affect the aquatic ecology, namely, chlorine dioxide (ClO2), ammonia (NH3) and 3- phosphate (PO4 ). The project has selected the ClO2, the substance that will not generate Trihalomethane (THMs), or other compounds that have been studied or confirmed not to cause any environmental impact, to dispose biofilms and microorganisms in the cooling blowdown. However, there may be some impacts on aquatic ecology that may affect - aquatic lives because ClO2 will change to chlorite (ClO2 ). From the calculation showed that Kram canal, Rawoeng canal and Nong Pla Lai reservoir after receiving the cooling water from the project, which yields the concentration of chlorite of less than 1 mg/l, will have chlorite with concentration of 0.23, เ.แเ and 0.เ9 mg/l. This concentration of chlorite is too low to cause the impact on fish, mysid shrimp and phytoplankton as relevant reference document.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-5 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation
Sriracha Power Plant uses trisodium phosphate (Na3PO4) in its boilers to prevent slag formation. The remaining water in the boilers will be blowdown and mix with the cooling blowdown. Regarding the rate of phosphate use of the 10 % concentration substrate, the annual use is 3เ m3. If phosphate dissolution from the heat does not occur, the boiler blowdown when mixing with the cooling blowdown will produce phosphate of the concentration of 0.38 mg/l to be discharged into the canal. The concentration of phosphate will be diluted when mixing with Kram canal, when Kram canal meets Rawoeng canal, and when water in Rawoeng canal flows into Nong Pla Lai reservoir. Whereas the concentration of phosphate that will cause eutrophication is เ.แ3 mg/l with the nitrogen (TKN) concentration in water of about 9.1 mg/l. As the result, the assessment of phosphate can be concluded that the concentration of phosphate and nitrogen were not at the levels that may pose a problem of eutrophication. Ammonia used in the project is to (1) control nitrogen oxides produced by the fuel firing and (2) control water quality in the boilers/boiler pipeline system, which later will be the blowdown mixing with the cooling blowdown. From calculation ammonia concentration in the cooling blowdown of Siracha Power Plants and other power plants in Hemaraj ESIE will be equal to 0.51 mg/l. After cooling blowdown from Sriracha Power Plant is discharged into Kram canal the average of ammonia concentration in Kram canal will be 0.22 mg/l. When the mixing water from Kram canal merging with Rawoeng canal ammonia concentration will be 0.13 mg/l. In light of the standard of non-marine surface water quality as prescribed in the National Environment Board’s Notification No. 8 B.E. 2537 re: Prescribing Ammonia Values of Surface Water Classes 1 – 3 for the clean water suitable for the living of aquatic lives with the limitation of ammonia value of not exceeding เ.5 mg/L, it can be concluded that ammonia as a result from the operation activities of Sriracha Power Plant, together with other power plants in Hemaraj ESIE will not have an impact on the aquatic ecology.
10.1.5 Infomration Disclosure, Public Consulations and Participations Public consultations were held three times. The participants consist of agencies at provincial, district and sub-district level, community leaders, local people, representatives of local educational institutes and environmental NGOs, local mass media, fisherman group utilizing the Nong Pla Lai reservoir, and interested general public with the total of 1,452, 1,710 and 598 in the first, the second and the third public consultation, respectively. The concerns and recommendations expressed in the public consultations can be categorized into main 7 aspects: cumulative impact from air pollution on long term agricultural sector and people’s health, impact on water quality in Kram canal and Nong Pla Lai reservoir, traffic accident and inconvenient transportation, safety system of the project, water use, fishery, benefit to the community and public participation to monitor
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-6 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation the project implementation. All of the concerned were considered and incorporated in the pro∑ect’s environmental impact mitigation measures. In addition, power plant visit was arranged to create the learning process from a direct personal experience of the public target group and to create the understanding with one another which would be beneficial to the coexistence between the community and the Project. The participants were community headmen and local people within the study area. For this reason, a power plant visit was arranged for the public in the vicinity of the Project and within the study area with the objective of creating knowledge and understanding about the operation of power plant. A group of 648 participants were taken to visit Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2, Kaeng Khoi District, Saraburi Province. To ensure the representatives of communities receive sufficient knowledge from the field trip, Gulf SRC Co., Ltd. arranged activities during the visit to the power plant and the natural gas pipeline system within the power plant. The participants viewed a video presentation and listened to briefing from the personnel of the Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2. The briefing included the information on background of Kaeng Koi Power Plant 2, the power generating process, the pollutant and water controls followed the generating process, the policy on the supervision of the environment and the conduct of the community relations activity. Additionally, stage was opened for participants to ask questions and the representatives of the Project including environment unit, community relations unit, personnel of Kaeng Khoi Power Plant 2 jointly answered all questions.
10.1.6 Public Health The health impact assessment was conducted within the concentration on local people in sensitive receptors within 5 km radius around the project site, including the project staff and workers. The study was conducted in accordance with Guidelines for HIA in Thailand’s EIA Report and Thailand’s EIA Manual by Environmental Impact Evaluation Bureau, Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (ONEP), Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (June 2008) and carried out according to the notification of Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment prescribing rule, method, regulations and EIA guideline for project may cause severe impact to communities, environmental quality and health B.E.2552 (2009), 29 December 2009). According to the public health personnel survey from 18 medical centers in the study area, 94.4% of public health officers indicate that public health personnel is inadequate while 77.8% think that medical equipment is insufficient. 72.7% of interviewees indicate that people’s illness is an impact resulting from the current environmental condition (air quality, water quality, solid waste, etc.). 72.2% of interviewees indicate that social problems in the study area are crimes involving thief/robbry, drug abuse, violence and teenage pregnancy.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-7 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation
Pro and cons, concerns and suggestions of project during construction period: 94.4% of interviwees indicate that project development leads to improvement of socio- economic in the area. However, concern issues are project may cause impact of health, environment, social, traffic, etc. Pro and cons, concerns and suggestions of project during operation period: 77.8% of interviwees indicate that project development leads to improvement of socio- economic in the area as well as may cause impact of health environment, traffic, social, safety, etc. The resulting of the mentioned agencies consist of 6 sub-district health promoting hospitals which can provide only the primary medical care. In case that public health agencies cannot provide medical care, the patient will be transferred to other local hospitals such as Laem Chabung Hospital, Nong Yai Hospial, Ban Bueng Hospital and Pluak Daeng Hospital. In addition, collection of cause and mobidity of out-patient (ROR NGOR.504) found that respiratory diseases are common disorder among the local people. The project development both during construction and operation periods may increase number of patients and severity of diseases. However, the project has air pollution control measures to mitigate the impact on local’s health for both natural gas fired and diesel oil fired operation such as using Dry Low NOx and Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) and water injection to control the formation of the oxides of nitrogen. In addition, air quality at sensitive area will be monitored throughout the project lifetime. As the Project has already proposed environmental prevention and mitigation measures and environmental monitoring measured, health impacts on local are reduced at low level. Since the project site is located in Hemaraj Eastern Seaboard Industrial Estate with all facilities and utilities for industries, the project development will therefore not affect the local food, utility sources for surrounding communities.
10.1.7 Major Hazard Assessment The simulation of any leak and flammable of chemical substances such as natural gas, diesel oil and aqueous ammonia by BREEZE HAZ model, consideration is taken on leak characters (instantaneously or slowly) and ignition characters (instantaneous ignition or delay ignition). For the studied results of impacts to be occurred to adjacent areas including natural gas transmission pipeline system, diesel transportation pipeline system, diesel and aqueous ammonia storage tank, consideration was taken on areas with any leakages and ignition. It is found that when natural gas/diesel oil/ aqueous ammonia is assumed to be leaked and ignited, the radius of heat radiation is mostly in the power plant site. From risk probability, it is found that the project risk is at a low level.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-8 Environmental Report for submittal to ADB Chapter 10 Sriracha Power Plant Project Conclusion and Recommendation
For the chemicals and boiler explosion hazard, it is found that the probability is at a low level. In addition, the project has prepared safety management measure from the design period through installation to operation and annual examination for maximum safety benefit will be regularly conducted. Although the risk analysis indicated that the project has low level risk, the project development will strictly follow international standards for the design, construction, operation and maintenance. In addition, the project has prepared emergency plans and training program to be able to handle the emergency situation at all time.
10.2 RECOMMENDATIONS Based on the results of the EIA study, the necessary recommendations can be emphasized as follows: (1) The project shall be under all conditions, strictly enforce the implementation of the proposed environmental measures designed for the construction and operation phases in order to avoid or minimize both environmental and social impacts on the surrounding communities and general public. (2) The project shall always conduct an environmental study for any modification of the project design and/or the environmental action plan to find out the environmental feasibility before making the decision. (3) The public praticipations are the ongoing activities throughout the project implementation. The comments, concerns and suggestions from concerned stakeholders shall be considered and incorporated into the project environmental management plan as appropriate.
RNP/ENV-P/P2810/FR (ADB)/RE61026-Chap 10-final Page 10-9