The Case of a Rising Coffee Culture in China 3
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BUSHOR-1499; No. of Pages 14 Business Horizons (2018) xxx, xxx—xxx Available online at www.sciencedirect.com ScienceDirect www.elsevier.com/locate/bushor Challenges and opportunities of new retail horizons in emerging markets: The case of a rising coffee culture in China Jennifer Ferreira *, Carlos Ferreira Centre for Business in Society, Coventry University, Priory Street, Coventry CV1 5FB, U.K. KEYWORDS Abstract Economic growth and a rising middle class consumer base make emerging Emerging markets; markets an attractive prospect for many international businesses. Changing patterns Retail business of retail in these countries present opportunities for business expansion that many development; are keen to capitalize on, but also present challenges for reaching their ambitions. –— Consumer culture; This article examines the growth of the coffee shop industry in China considering its –— Chinese consumer key dynamics and drivers in order to address questions about successful retail behavior; expansion in emerging markets. We aim to explore how changing consumer cultures Coffee industry have contributed to a rapidly growing industry and what strategies businesses have used to enter the market and maintain growth, as well as considerations for potential retail success in the future. # 2018 Kelley School of Business, Indiana University. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. 1. Opportunities brewing in emerging and rising middle classes in emerging markets, markets many international businesses are turning their attention to emerging markets for future growth plans in order to exploit the potential of these Due to market saturation for some areas of retail in rapidly transforming markets (Kardes, 2016). mature markets, combined with economic growth Expansion into these markets requires careful consideration. As multiple cases have shown, there are many challenges surrounding different national cultures as well as institutional arrange- * Corresponding author ments and existing domestic competition (Miotto & E-mail addresses: [email protected] (J. Ferreira), [email protected] (C. Ferreira) Parente, 2015). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bushor.2018.06.001 0007-6813/# 2018 Kelley School of Business, Indiana University. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. BUSHOR-1499; No. of Pages 14 2 J. Ferreira, C. Ferreira The coffee shop industry in China represents a retailers; (2) abandonment of state monopolies fast emerging area of retail, reaching $3 billion in and subsequent opening to private businesses; and revenue in 2016; forecasts predict continued pos- (3) introduction of new sources of capital in the itive growth for many years (Euromonitor, 2017). retail sector such as foreign direct investment. The Largely situated in cities, coffee shops in China latter was made possible in part by the opening are becoming an ever-present feature of the of the Chinese market for foreign retailers in the urban landscape. In 2017, Starbucks opened its 1990s, which brought in new retail formats that first international reserve roastery in China, a were quickly copied by local retailers (Wang, 2011). 30,000 square foot roastery and coffee shop de- The other side of retail transformation in China is scribed in the media as a “coffee wonderland” changing consumer preferences and demand. Chi- (Dwyer, 2017). The roastery is located in Shang- nese consumers are part of a growing Asian mod- hai, a city with 600 existing Starbucks stores; by ernism; they are seeking novelty and hungry for opening this style and size of store, Starbucks experiences (Uncles, 2010). Rising incomes–— demonstrated the importance of the Chinese mar- associated with changes such as increased access ket in its operations. However, the factors behind to information and communications technology, in- the growth of coffee shops are multifaceted, ternational media, products, and brands–— are driv- driven by the ambitions of coffee shop chains to ing the growth of a new generation of middle-class expand into new markets as well as changing consumers (Kardes, 2016). These individuals are consumer cultures. often more familiar with Western lifestyles and This article explores the growth of the coffee brands than traditional consumers in these coun- shop industry in China and considers both the op- tries and tend to hold aspirations for improving their portunities and challenges experienced in an lifestyle, often using purchasing choices as emerging market. We utilize the example of China indications of both aspirations and status (Eyring, in an effort to demonstrate how some businesses Johnson, & Nair, 2011; Kardes, 2016; Kharas, 2010; are navigating the new retail landscapes and high- Sheth, 2011). This new consumer class–— with a light potential strategies for operating in these greater disposable income and growing awareness regions. We conclude by outlining a series of rec- and interest in imported brands and trends–— is an ommendations for developing a business in the attractive prospect for many international coffee shop industry in an emerging market–— and businesses and presents new internationalization retail more broadly. opportunities. For many industries, it is not sufficient to trans- fer existing business models and practices used in Western markets into these new emerging markets 2. Emerging markets opportunities: that require greater local knowledge of the mar- The transformation of retail and ket, its particularities, and consumer behavior consumption in China (Gamble, 2010). While rapid economic growth may present opportunities for expansion into in- Emerging markets such as China, India, and Brazil ternational businesses, in many cases, it also have been experiencing economic growth, chang- means growing domestic competition which has ing demographics, and cultural transformations the advantage of a greater understanding of the with consequent changes to the urban retail land- national market, its consumer base, and consumer scape (Javalgi & Grossman, 2016; Wang, 2011). The cultures (He & Wang, 2015; Talay, Townsend, & evolution of the Chinese retail sector since the Yeniyurt, 2015). There are complexities to many fi 1990s is one example of this. In rst-tier Chinese of these emerging markets and different processes cities, in particular, there is evidence of conver- of business hybridization must take place (Gamble, gence with international norms and trends, making 2010). Some international businesses recognized Chinese retailing less distinguishable from what is this and engaged in partnerships with local compa- available elsewhere (Uncles, 2010). New retail nies in order to break into a market, thereby –— formats particularly super- and hypermarkets acquiring an existing local knowledge base. In some –— and shopping centers have expanded, while tra- cases, complexities of the market restrict busi- ditional retailing (i.e., general merchandise nesses development and do not allow enough au- stores, family-owned shops, and urban markets) tonomy, and in other cases this strategy has not led has declined (Wang, 2011). Wang and Zhang (2005) to the success that was hoped for (Doherty, 2009; fi identi ed three drivers of transformation in the Khan, Lew, & Sinkovics, 2015). –— Chinese retail sector: (1) retail deregulation Some view emerging markets as unsaturated especially lower state control over individual and poised for growth and the middle-class BUSHOR-1499; No. of Pages 14 The case of a rising coffee culture in China 3 consumers therein a viable target for business 3. A growing coffee culture operations (Javalgi & Grossman, 2016; Welsh, Alon, & Falbe, 2006). While this may be the case 3.1. Coffee consumption and the growth in some sectors and places, there is a range of of coffee shops in China challenges associated with attempting to estab- lish a presence in these markets. These countries According to the International Coffee Organization contain substantial diversity: While much eco- (ICO, 2015), the average person in China drinks only nomic growth may be concentrated in urban cen- four cups of coffee a year compared with 300 in ters (Sheth, 2011) there are also distinct regional South Korea and 150 in Hong Kong, although this differences (Peng, Wang, & Jiang, 2008; Schlager number is growing. The per capita data for China is & Maas, 2013), which can be associated with heavily affected by the fact that coffee consump- different consumption behaviors (Miotto & tion is concentrated in cities and almost nonexis- Parente, 2015). Furthermore, there is potential tent in rural areas (Han & Zhang, 2009). The growth for greater diversity in the consumer base in terms in coffee consumption and the growth of coffee of price sensitivity. While there may be a growing shop spaces as business development opportunities –— middle class, much of the country particularly has been recognized by the wider coffee and busi- –— outside the urban centers may still operate at ness community in China. In 2014, a strategic co- much lower price points; this may present a bar- operation agreement was struck between the Food rier for future growth unless it is taken into ac- Hospitality World China (FHW) and ACA (Asia Coffee count in the creation of new business models Association) to facilitate the promotion of coffee (Reinatz, Dellaert, Kraft, Kumar, & Varadarajan, culture through FHW, one of the largest professional 2011). As such, businesses consider some of these food associations in South China (WorldEx, 2014). fi markets not as a homogenous playing