20110912-NEWS--0001-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/20115:58PMPage1 ©Entire contentscopyright2011byCrainCommunicationsInc.Allrightsreserved Southeast Michigan’stop- academic andclinicalaffairs will becomevicepresidentof takes shotsatBeaumont Cardiologist movestoDMC, Grines businesses, Page23 Largest woman-owned companies, Page19 Largest statewidepublic Page 25 2011 HealthCareHeroes, time, thankVCfirm,Page11 If thisgetsyoutothebuson at aratethatsurprises Birmingham buildingfillsup tackle videogameincentives Courts,Senate Next level: NEWSPAPER www.crainsdetroit.com Vol.27,No.38 This JustIn Crain’s Crain’s Health CareExtra Page 3 MICHIGAN BUSINESS Cindy Grines See ThisJustIn,Page2 Lists CRAIN’S H , M.D.,oneof where she Center Medical Detroit a jobatthe al Oakfor tal mont Hospi- left gists, has cardiolo- producing in Roy- Beau- , state director.ShealsoisaformerconsultanttoWayne Bing twiceaboutpossiblelocations,whichinclude chairman, saidhehasmetwithDetroitMayorDave cluding atleastathirdnewbranchinthecity. add 30branchesintheareaovernextfiveyears,in- two inDetroit,andfivemore2013.Inall,itwantsto pansion inSoutheastMichigan. Bank Flagstar in GeorgiaandIndiana,thelong-troubledTroy-based thing: There’sawargoingon. Detroit mayDetroit get 2in’12 branches in5years Flagstar plans30 Gaffney person tolead AFL-CIO UAW picksitsown burn Gaffney? Snyder win Did heatafter Page 11 middle ground, represents Column: M Joseph Campanelli,Flagstar’spresident,CEOand It planstoopenfivebranchesnextyear,including Having recentlyannouncedthesaleofitsbranches Michigan’s politicalrightandleftagreeonone ARY K Gaffney RAMER is abouttoembarkonanaggressiveex- CRAIN’S DETROITBUSINESS CRAIN’S DETROITBUSINESS B B Y serves as its Oct.3-4convention.Swiftnow in 2008,asGaffney’sreplacementat an organizingdirectorfortheUAW to backKarlaSwift,whoretiredas the year’s gubernatorialelection. candidate VirgBerneroinlast landslide victoryoverDemocratic as ascapegoatafterRickSnyder’s ry isthatthe Gaffney’s exit—theprevailingtheo- zation’s conventioninOctober. the Michigan not seekre-electionaspresidentof ty. Heannouncedlastweekhewill Y T D The union,the800-poundgorillaof Controversy swirlsaround Mark Gaffneyisthelatestcasual- OM USTIN Michigan DemocraticParty H ENDERSON eAeTePol Michigan We AreThePeople W ALSH UAW AFL-CIO SEPTEMBER 12–18,2011 See Flagstar,Page43 See Gaffney,Page45 is usingGaffney at theorgani- , plans more than1,500victims. that helpedofficialsidentify sulting servicesinNewYork velopment, supervisionandcon- company providedsoftwarede- to supplythoseIDservices.The Identification Systemsoftware and launcheditsMassFatality sidiary million, GeneCodesformedsub- which grewtomorethan$13 missing people. tacks witharosterofabout2,700 of theWorldTradeCenterat- human remainsfromtherubble 22,000 samplesofunidentified examiner tomatchmorethan York officeofthechiefmedical ceived acontractfromtheNew dent-CEO HowardCash,re- assignment inhistory. largest DNAforensicanalysis had 16employeestotacklethe Arbor-based the companygrewindecadesinceSept.11,2001. shifted fromtraditionaldefensetohomelandsecurityas surveillance systems.CEOEricSieczkasaysthefocus Pixel VelocityInc.ofAnnArbordevelopssmart Gene Codesisoneofseveral To completethecontract, The company,ledbyPresi- In lateSeptember2001,Ann CRAIN’S DETROITBUSINESS B Y Gene CodesForensicsInc. C HAD Gene CodesCorp. H ALCOM predominantly touristsvisiting al countriesinDecember2004— more than200,000livesinsever- Ocean tsunamithatclaimed remains ofvictimstheIndian ny hadbegunhelpingidentify in early2005;bythenthecompa- Trade Centereffortwrappedup Arbor. CEO of Eric Sieczka,co-founderand need todoprotectthem,”said in thecountryandwhatpeople critical assetswithtargetvalue create alotmoreawarenessof tractors growimportantniches. or helpedexistingdefensecon- years spawnednewcompanies 11 attacksandoverseveral was createdinresponsetothe9- partment ofHomelandSecurity lives adecadeago.The from thedisasterthattook2,996 ment contractingmarketborn grew tofillanall-newgovern- that builtanationalprofileor Southeast Michiganbusinesses For GeneCodes,theWorld “What (9-11has)reallydoneis Pixel VelocityInc See Adapt,Page44 . inAnn U.S. De- $2 acopy;$59year ON .com crainsdetroit Snyder, capitalist Rick venture for then- costly debacle averted a from 9-11 blog: Henderson’s Page 44 coordination, is education, Detroit: ties, metro Detroit victims with Six 9-11 memoriam: O M THE N ORE Tom Defending In 9-11 Page 44 Fallout Focus W EB ®
BOB CHASE 20110912-NEWS--0001-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 6:13 PM Page 1
CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS A special edition of
® Cwww.crainsdetroit.comRAIN Vol. 27, No. 38 ’SDETROITSEPTEMBER 2011 BUSINESS$2 a copy; $59 a year ©Entire contents copyright 2011 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved
Inside Michigan Pixel Velocity Inc. of Ann Arbor develops smart Did heat after surveillance systems. CEO Eric Sieczka says the focus BOB CHASE shifted from traditional defense to homeland security as Snyder win the company grew in the decade since Sept. 11, 2001.
If this gets you to the bus on time, thank VC firm, Page 11 burn Gaffney? ULI Michigan: Urban Land UAW picks its own Institute goes statewide, Page 15 person to lead AFL-CIO BY DUSTIN WALSH Success is in the cards CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Michigan’s political right and left agree on one for nonprofit that employs thing: There’s a war going on. the disabled, Page 18 Mark Gaffney is the latest casual- ty. He announced last week he will not seek re-election as president of World Watch: the Michigan AFL-CIO at the organi- zation’s convention in October. Spotlight on Controversy swirls around Michigan Gaffney’s exit — the prevailing theo- ry is that the UAW is using Gaffney business in India, Page 21 as a scapegoat after Rick Snyder’s landslide victory over Democratic candidate Virg Bernero in last Gaffney Health Care Extra year’s gubernatorial election. 2011 Health Care Heroes, The union, the 800-pound gorilla of MARY KRAMER the Michigan Democratic Party, plans Page 25 to back Karla Swift, who retired as Column: Gaffney an organizing director for the UAW represents middle ground, in 2008, as Gaffney’s replacement at Crain’s Lists Page 11 its Oct. 3-4 convention. Swift now Largest statewide public serves as We Are The People Michigan state director. She also is a former consultant to Wayne BY CHAD HALCOM Southeast Michigan businesses companies, Page 19 See Gaffney, Page 45 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS that built a national profile or MORE grew to fill an all-new govern- In late September 2001, Ann ment contracting market born ON 9-11 Largest woman-owned Arbor-based Gene Codes Corp. from the disaster that took 2,996 In businesses, Page 23 had 16 employees to tackle the lives a decade ago. The U.S. De- memoriam: largest DNA forensic analysis partment of Homeland Security Six 9-11 Flagstar plans 30 assignment in history. was created in response to the 9- victims with The company, led by Presi- 11 attacks and over several metro Detroit This Just In dent-CEO Howard Cash, re- years spawned new companies ties, Page 44 ceived a contract from the New or helped existing defense con- Defending Cardiologist moves to DMC, branches in 5 years York office of the chief medical tractors grow important niches. Detroit: Focus examiner to match more than “What (9-11 has) really done is is education, takes shots at Beaumont 22,000 samples of unidentified create a lot more awareness of coordination, Page 44 Cindy Grines, M.D., one of Detroit may get 2 in ’12 human remains from the rubble critical assets with target value Southeast Michigan’s top- of the World Trade Center at- in the country and what people producing BY TOM HENDERSON tacks with a roster of about 2,700 need to do to protect them,” said ON THE WEB missing people. Eric Sieczka, co-founder and cardiolo- CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Tom To complete the contract, CEO of Pixel Velocity Inc. in Ann gists, has Henderson’s left Beau- Having recently announced the sale of its branches which grew to more than $13 Arbor. blog: Fallout mont Hospi- in Georgia and Indiana, the long-troubled Troy-based million, Gene Codes formed sub- For Gene Codes, the World from 9-11 tal in Roy- Flagstar Bank is about to embark on an aggressive ex- sidiary Gene Codes Forensics Inc. Trade Center effort wrapped up averted a al Oak for pansion in Southeast Michigan. and launched its Mass Fatality in early 2005; by then the compa- costly debacle a job at the It plans to open five branches next year, including Identification System software ny had begun helping identify for then- Detroit two in Detroit, and five more in 2013. In all, it wants to to supply those ID services. The remains of victims of the Indian venture Medical add 30 branches in the area over the next five years, in- company provided software de- Ocean tsunami that claimed capitalist Rick cluding at least a third new branch in the city. velopment, supervision and con- more than 200,000 lives in sever- Snyder, Center, crainsdetroit Grines Joseph Campanelli, Flagstar’s president, CEO and sulting services in New York al countries in December 2004 — where she .com will become vice president of chairman, said he has met with Detroit Mayor Dave that helped officials identify predominantly tourists visiting academic and clinical affairs Bing twice about possible locations, which include more than 1,500 victims. Gene Codes is one of several See Adapt, Page 44 See This Just In, Page 2 See Flagstar, Page 43 1 NEWSPAPER 71486 02858 0 20110912-NEWS--0002-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 5:49 PM Page 1
Page 2 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011
mont. She was instrumental in panies in the fourth year of a sim- thony said. Under IRS require- rant’s aim is to train workers for THIS JUST IN bringing Beaumont to the fore- ilar five-year, $100 million con- ments, each hospital must con- living-wage jobs, promote access front for heart attack treatment,” tract awarded by a contract at duct an assessment as part of to fresh and healthy foods, and in- ■ From Page 1 Dixon said. Fort Jackson, South Carolina, for Form 990 annual financial filings. cubate worker-owned food busi- Grines, who was Beaumont’s bases across the Southeast. GDAHC includes hospitals, nesses. at the DMC Cardiovascular academic affairs vice chief of car- President and CEO Perry Mehta physicians and large businesses. — Nancy Kaffer Institute. diovascular medicine, said in the said he expects some work to get The council discusses and issues Upon leaving Beaumont, article another reason she moved under way by early October in reports on health care quality, ac- Garden Fresh buys building Grines leveled some illuminating to DMC is because Vanguard the Fort Bragg contract, and Fu- cess and costs in Southeast parting shots at her old employer, Health Systems, DMC’s for-profit tureNet could capture more than Michigan. Ferndale-based Garden Fresh where she practiced for 21 years. parent, is building a new cardio- $20 million worth of the projects. — Jay Greene Gourmet LLC has purchased a “When I first went (to Beau- vascular heart hospital. She also — Chad Halcom 20,000-square-foot industrial mont), it was cutting-edge, and will conduct more research Restaurant opens building in Ferndale for $440,000, innovative, and wild, and fun, but through Wayne State University Health care council drafts new according to the Washington, it’s a bit slower-paced, extremely Medical School. Former World Trade Center D.C.-based CoStar Group. conservative, and very bureau- She will be working with sever- plan to go with new CEO restaurant workers are joining The building, at 1220 E. Nine with Detroit restaurant workers Mile Road, is less than a half-mile cratic,” Grines said in a state- al former Beaumont cardiologists, The Greater Detroit Area Health ment to TheHeart.Org, an online including Joel Kahn, M.D., and Ted to promote job opportunities at a from the company’s current Council is developing a strategic training center in the city. headquarters at 1505 Bonner. publication by WebMD. Schreiber, M.D., president of the plan that it hopes will be in place “It’s all about corporate com- DMC Cardiovascular Institute. Both sets of workers were dis- Two messages left by Crain’s by next January, giving its new placed by crisis, the former by for CEO Jack Aronson were not re- pliance now. Meanwhile, DMC, — Jay Greene CEO time to implement a work which was having a bunch of fi- the terrorist attacks of 9-11, the turned. plan by the end of the year. latter by the economic crisis. Birmingham-based Core Part- nancial difficulties, has made FutureNet wins Army work Last month, Vernice Davis Antho- some major headway in the last The Restaurant Opportunities ners LLC was broker in the deal. ny, GDAHC’s CEO the past 10 Center of Michigan is opening COL- The building was last owned by years,” Grines said. Detroit-based FutureNet Group years, announced she will retire At Beaumont, Grines earned Inc. will share up to $100 million ORS-Detroit today, a locally Ferndale-based EPG Properties by the end of the year. GDAHC LLC, $743,151 in total compensation in of work with six other companies sourced restaurant on Grand Riv- though the sale was coordi- has been interviewing candidates er in downtown Detroit. The nated by Bloomfield Hills-based 2009 as director of cardiac cather- for construction and mainte- and is expected to hire someone restaurant is an affiliate of O’Keefe and Associates LLC as ization services, according to nance at military bases across by the end of September, she said. Restaurant Opportunities Centers court-appointed receiver for the Beaumont’s IRS 990 report. It is North Carolina, under a contract The GDAHC board is sched- United. lender, Comerica Bank. unknown what salary DMC of- awarded last week by the U.S. uled to vote on the new plan in its The worker-owned restau- — Daniel Duggan fered her. Army Mission Contracting Office at January meeting. In a statement from Simon Fort Bragg. In planning meetings, GDAHC Dixon, M.D., Beaumont’s chair of The seven companies were se- executive committee members CORRECTIONS cardiovascular medicine, Beau- lected among 55 competitive bids have discussed adding programs Ⅲ In a Sept. 5 story on Page 6, Altair ProductDesign Inc.’s hydraulic hy- mont has hired six of the seven submitted for work at up to half a to help providers and businesses brid bus was incorrectly described as a hybrid electric bus. cardiologists in the Royal Oak- prepare for changes coming under dozen bases, including Fort Ⅲ A story on Page 25 of the Sept. 5 issue, “Speculators may use auc- based Academic Heart & Vascular health care reform, Anthony said. Bragg, through August 2016. tions to tie up land essential to Bing plan,” said University of Michigan Another new program will help Group, except for Grines. FutureNet, a construction com- professor Margaret Dewar was an author of a report on tax-reverted hospitals develop a regional com- “We thank Dr. Grines for her pany that caters to government properties in Detroit. Dewar was not an author; she was one of the fac- munity health assessment, An- many years of service to Beau- clients, is also one of three com- ulty members who oversaw the report’s creation. 20110912-NEWS--0003-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 5:27 PM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 3
Inside Video game developers Heat assistance freeze sends chill through agencies, Page 6 on brink of film credit win House OKs new rules on teen workers’ hours. Capitol Legislation, court ruling may score incentives Briefings, Page 41
BY NATHAN SKID video game developers were shut out unless CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS they owned the intellectual property and distri- bution rights. Company index A win in court and friendly legislation soon Senate Majority Leader Randy Richardville, These organizations appear in this week’s Crain’s may make it easier for video game developers R-Monroe, has introduced Senate Bill 569, Detroit Business: to become eligible for film incentives. which would drop the requirement. And a Ajax Paving Industries ...... 10 Most of the at- game developer, Scientifically Proven Entertain- Association of Businesses Advocating Tariff Equity . . . 6 tention surround- ET GAMES BEGIN ment LLC, has won a court order against the re- Bailey Schmidt ...... 3 ing film incentives L quirement, although the decision is being ap- Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute ...... 27 has focused on Video: Behind the pealed by the state. Beaumont Hospitals ...... 29 movies, but video scenes at game maker, crainsdetroit.com/video “Michigan needs to be competitive with oth- Center for Michigan ...... 45 game production er states in retaining and attracting new indus- Coalition to Keep Michigan Warm ...... 6 was among the in- try,” Richardville wrote in an email to Crain’s. Consumers Energy ...... 6 NATHAN SKID/CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS dustries Michigan wanted to draw when the in- “It is important that we work to attract and re- Crittenton Hospital Medical Center ...... 37 Nathaniel McClure moved Scientifically Proven centives were created in 2008. tain new and technologically focused industry DeNovo Sciences ...... 7 Entertainment LLC from California to Farmington But when the Michigan Department of Treasury Detroit Department of Homeland Security ...... 44 Hills, hoping to make use of Michigan tax credits. drew up rules to implement the incentives, See Games, Page 42 Detroit Department of Transportation ...... 4 Detroit Edison ...... 6 Federal-Mogul ...... 21 Flagstar Bank ...... 1 Ford Motor ...... 21 Fuller Central Park Properties ...... 42 Gene Codes ...... 1 General Motors ...... 21 Greenleaf Trust ...... 3 Henry Ford Center for Integrative Wellness ...... 34 Huron River Ventures ...... 11 International Automotive Components Group . . . . . 21 Kellogg ...... 21 Mercy Place Clinic ...... 28 Michigan Accelerator Fund I ...... 11 Michigan AFL-CIO ...... 1 Michigan Department of Transportation ...... 10 Michigan Film Office ...... 42 Michigan Hematology Oncology ...... 29 Team Detroit CEO Satish Korde expects to apply to Ford lessons he Michigan Infrastructure & Transportation Assoc. . . 10 learned in the real and virtual worlds. Michigan Public Service Commission ...... 6 Michigan Restaurant Association ...... 41 Napoleon B. Jordan Center for Health Care ...... 34 National Network of Depression Centers ...... 26 Adman has Patriot Services ...... 45 Perrigo ...... 21 Pixel Velocity ...... 44 Pixofactor Entertainment ...... 42 RPM Ventures ...... 13 Ford’s world Scientifically Proven Entertainment ...... 3 Shepherd Intelligent Systems ...... 11 St. Joseph Mercy Health System ...... 32 St. Joseph Mercy Oakland ...... 28 in his hands Strive Recreational Therapy Services ...... 31 Stryker ...... 21 JOHN SOBCZAK Drew Schmidt (left) and Peter Noonan of Bailey Schmidt Inc. handled leasing at the Greenleaf Trust Building in BY JAMIE LAREAU Surnow ...... 42 Birmingham, now fully leased at rental rates near $36 a square foot — double the average for metro Detroit. CRAIN NEWS SERVICE Synova ...... 21 Team Detroit ...... 3 Satish Korde is a Renaissance The Heath and Warmth Fund ...... 6 man charged with helping Ford Mo- TI Automotive ...... 21 tor Co. complete a renaissance of UAW Retiree Medical Benefit Trust ...... 30 Greenleaf fills quickly at top rates its own. UM Comprehensive Depression Center ...... 26, 31 Korde, 61, the new CEO of Team United Auto Workers ...... 1 Detroit, Ford’s advertising agency, University of Michigan-Dearborn ...... 45 Birmingham success gives hope for similar projects is a chemical engineer by training. Urban Land Institute ...... 15 Yet he has spent 30 years in the ad- Visteon ...... 21 BY DANIEL DUGGAN “It sends a message that there’s demand for high- vertising world, mainly in re- Warm Training Center ...... 6 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS quality office space, and tenants will pay a premium search and marketing. He has Whirlpool ...... 21 for it.” traveled the world and is at home Just over one year after the Greenleaf Trust Greenville, S.C.-based Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, in the virtual world of social me- Building in Birmingham was completed, the office Smoak & Stewart PC and Finnea Group LLC have dia. and retail space is completely leased. signed leases for office space in the building, joining Ford needs all areas of Korde’s Department index And not only does the building hold the honor as the building’s anchor tenant, Greenleaf Trust, to fully expertise. The automaker has re- the only speculative office building developed dur- occupy the 27,000 square feet. bounded in the United States from BUSINESS DIARY ...... 40 ing the recession, it also has set the bar for rental With an asking rental rate of $36 per square foot, financial trials of the past decade, CALENDAR ...... 38 rates — commanding double the average rate for the according to Washington, D.C.-based CoStar Group, but it trails rivals in China and CAPITOL BRIEFINGS...... 41 region. the building is among the most expensive office several other markets. Ford will CAREERWORKS ...... 39 “This is something that will give some hope for spaces in metro Detroit. seek to draw on Korde’s knowl- CLASSIFIED ADS ...... 41 the idea of new construction in the region,” said Pe- CoStar lists the average rental rate for Class A of- edge of mature markets and key ter Noonan, vice president of brokerage services for fice space in metro Detroit at $21 a square foot, and growth markets in the Asia-Pacific KEITH CRAIN...... 8 Birmingham-based Bailey Schmidt Inc., the real estate LETTERS...... 8 firm representing the landlord in the leasing work. See Greenleaf, Page 42 See Korde, Page 43 MARY KRAMER ...... 11 OPINION ...... 8 Cool Places online Small-business webinars OTHER VOICES ...... 8 See profiles of 10 winners of Crain’s Cool Places Part one of a Comcast-sponsored series is THIS WEEK @ PEOPLE ...... 39 to Work 2011 and info about the November Sept. 27, focusing on disaster preparedness, WWW.CRAINSDETROIT.COM awards ceremony, crainsdetroit.com/cool crainsdetroit.com/smallbizwebinars RUMBLINGS ...... 46 WEEK ON THE WEB ...... 46 20110912-NEWS--0004-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 3:28 PM Page 1
Page 4 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 Feds push for regional transit authority to run light rail FTA: Funding could start before an agency does DDOT federal funding BY BILL SHEA Wayne, Oakland and Macomb volved early in the process,” Ro- CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS counties. goff said. “That said, we all recog- Federal officials have had RTA nize we can’t just click our fingers The head of the Federal Transit discussions with city and subur- and have a new governance struc- source could get axed Administration wants Detroit’s ban leaders, including with the ture in place.” Woodward Avenue light rail pro- suburban bus system and with State Rep. Bert Johnson, D-De- Detroit isn’t expected to submit pected to extend beyond that. ject to be operated by a regional Gov. Rick Snyder’s office. troit, introduced RTA legislation a request for federal money to About $1.6 billion was ap- transit authority — a governance Snyder earlier this year appoint- in 2010, but the bills got no trac- build a $528 million light-rail line proved in New Starts spending system that’s proved elusive here ed Dennis Schornack, a former se- tion in Lansing because of what on Woodward Avenue until next last year. — but he won’t say the lack of an nior policy adviser to Gov. John insiders say was over-emphasis year — if Washington doesn’t Under the New Starts program, RTA will jeopardize the proposed Engler, to be his special adviser on on labor protection and prohibi- eliminate the funding program federal funding wouldn’t be pro- line. regional transit. tions on private-sector involve- before then. vided until the project is ready “Many people have viewed an Hanging over the effort to create ment. The Detroit Department of Trans- for construction, when the FTA RTA as the ideal operator for the a regional authority is a history of No new or replacement bills portation needs an estimated $318 and the project organizer would system,” FTA Administrator Peter high-profile past failures and city- have been introduced. million in capital funding from sign what’s called a Full Funding Rogoff said, adding that it isn’t in suburb squabbling over funding The man who spearheaded cre- the Federal Transit Administration’s Grant Agreement. Detroit Department of Transporta- formulas and labor issues. ation of the Woodward project New Starts program that’s aimed DDOT’s project is just entering tion’s best interest to have the The most recent effort was the and a proposed regional transit at new surface transportation the preliminary engineering “added burden” of operating a rail Detroit Area Regional Transportation system, John Hertel, now runs the projects, such as commuter and phase of the project. This fall, it’s line. Authority, which died at the 11th Suburban Mobility Authority for Re- light rail. expected to move into the next The $528 million, nine-mile hour after legal challenges by lo- gional Transportation bus system. However, New Starts has been phase, called final design. route from downtown to the city cal transit unions. The Michigan “There can be no major targeted by some for the budget If the first two phases meet limit at Eight Mile Supreme Court progress on anything without a chopping block, including Rep. FTA approval — they’re expected Road is currently a in May 2006 regional transit authority,” he John Mica, R-Fla., chairman of to because the FTA has staff on- DDOT project, and it The strongest declined to said, adding that Wayne County the House Transportation Com- site in Detroit working with needs $318 million of “ hear an ap- Executive Robert Ficano, Oak- mittee. DDOT to expedite the process — that cost to peal of a 2005 land County Executive L. Brooks Mica has said he wants to cut then the project moves to the full operating surface transportation project come from Michigan Patterson and Macomb County funding agreement. spending by 35 percent as part of the FTA. plans are Court of Ap- Executive Mark Hackel, Snyder If Washington and Detroit the next transportation bill. “(An RTA) peals ruling and lawmakers are prepared to reach an agreement, it then House GOP members in Janu- has to happen those that that found support an RTA. would be included in the FTA ary proposed eliminating New for the pro- DARTA was Hertel blames the city on the budget that the president submits Starts as part of a larger $2.5 tril- ject to have a not legally es- lack of action. to Congress. achieve its lion set of cuts across the entire tablished. “There’s been one thing miss- New Starts is a 60-40 match pro- federal budget. broader utili- designated, The re- ing: Activity on the part of the Also, a 12-member bipartisan gram. ty,” Rogoff gion’s history Bing administration to get this congressional deficit reduction The federally required $210 mil- said. Wash- consistent of transit fail- done.” committee by November will pro- lion local funding match is com- ington typically ure isn’t lost Messages were left seeking and reliable pose at least $1.2 trillion in deficit ing from several sources, includ- funds large or region- on Rogoff, comment from Mayor Dave Bing cuts over the next decade, and it’s ing $74 million from the sale of al transit projects which is why and Norm White, who is oversee- funding source. unknown if the panel will target $125 million in Capital Grant Re- rather than small, not having an ing the Woodward project for ” New Starts. ceipts Revenue Bonds by DDOT; one-off efforts RTA in place DDOT. Peter Rogoff, The FTA currently is seeking $12 million from previously re- through the FTA pro- isn’t a deal- White has said the city prefers Federal Transit Administration $3.2 billion in funding for 28 tran- ceived federal transportation gram that DDOT is breaker for to build the Woodward line first, sit construction projects in the grants; $25 million from a federal working through. federal fund- then establish an RTA once other fiscal 2012 federal budget. Transportation Investment Gen- If approved for the money, ing. communities see the value of the DDOT would commence construc- The New Starts funding is part erating Economic Recovery “Folks generally recognize es- system. tion in the spring, and the line tablishing an RTA is going to take of the president’s $3.7 trillion 2012 grant; and $100 million in cash do- Marie Donigan, a former Royal could be running by 2015. It ex- time,” he said. “It can be a multi- budget request to Congress, nations and tax breaks (such as Oak state representative who does pects to apply later this year or step process.” which remains under debate as federal New Markets Tax Credits) private-sector transit advocacy early in 2012 for the federal money. That doesn’t mean the feds don’t part of the wider government assembled by a consortium of lo- and consulting, said a way can be (See story, right.) want it to happen as soon as possi- debt crisis. cal private backers and founda- found to make an RTA work, but In the meantime, there has been ble. The federal budget year begins tions, called M1 Rail. there is a lack of leadership and closed-door discussion of reviving “It’s always a good business Oct. 1, but the budget debate is ex- — Bill Shea will to get it done. efforts to establish a regional practice when establishing a new “There isn’t an overriding (po- transit authority that would gov- transit system that the agency current discussion of putting a re- feds appear to look favorably on litical) demand to have a regional ern the rail and bus systems in that’s going to operate it is in- gional transportation tax on a bal- the Woodward project. transit system,” she said. “Some- lot, but the FTA is helping DDOT Transportation Secretary Ray body has to be in charge. Nobody and regional leaders discuss fund- LaHood — Rogoff’s boss — has here is in charge — which is why ing mechanisms, Rogoff said. been to Detroit to announce plan- we don’t have one.” “Was Detroit’s initial operating ning grants for it, and the Obama funding plan (the most ideal) that administration has made the city Other worries we’ve seen? No,” he said. “We’re part of its “Strong Cities, Strong working with them to strengthen Communities” initiative aimed at The missing RTA isn’t Rogoff’s it. They have to show realistic helping distressed cities make bet- only concern about the light rail plans at each stage (of the federal ter use of federal funding and ex- proposal. funding process).” pertise. He has expressed skepticism The only current regional trans- Also, the FTA last week said the about DDOT’s plan to fund the portation levy is a .059 mills prop- project satisfies the requirements system’s operational costs erty tax in Wayne, Oakland and of the National Environmental through a $17.5 million annual Macomb counties that supports Protection Act. mishmash of state and federal the SMART bus system. It was re- The decision doesn’t mean grants along with city general newed in August 2010, but allows the project is green-lighted for funds and rider fares. communities to opt out of partici- funding, but that it has met the “The strongest operating plans pating — something regional sys- smell test of major regulatory con- are those that have a designated, tem backers say cannot be allowed cerns. consistent and reliable funding for a new system. “We’re making good progress. source,” he said. Rogoff also has About 40,000 people in Wayne, said that there is concern that Oakland and Macomb counties use This, like others across the coun- DDOT could end up cannibalizing the system’s 640 buses serving try, will have stutter steps and bus funding for the rail project, 1,200 square miles daily. The sys- naysayers along the way. After the which is forbidden under FTA’s tem connects to Detroit’s bus sys- first segment is built, even some of funding rules. tem, which is funded through the the naysayers want to know when A dedicated funding source for a city’s budget and federal grants. the next one is coming to their multi-jurisdiction transit system is community,” Rogoff said. typically some type of regional tax Bill Shea: (313) 446-1626, — something often administered Making progress [email protected]. Twitter: by a regional authority. There is no Even without an authority, the @bill_shea19 DBpageAD.qxp 8/26/2011 10:35 AM Page 1 20110912-NEWS--0006-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 5:03 PM Page 1
Page 6 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 Heat assistance freeze sends chills through agencies
BY SHERRI WELCH from them and eight hard-hit cities that rates,” said Robert Strong, member, Clark The nonprofit is soliciting donations to CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS were midstream in energy efficiency retro- Hill PLC and general counsel for ABATE, try to make up the gap, she said. fits to municipal buildings, among others. which counts the automakers, chemical and Warm Training Center expects the state Cuts of more than $200 million in state The cuts are “very concerning for the steel companies among its members. cuts to decrease its $2.3 million budget for and federal funding to emergency energy as- agencies (and) very concerning for Con- Following the appeals court’s ruling, the this year by $500,000, Chapman said. sistance and energy efficiency programs — sumers Energy,” said Whitney Skeans, cus- PSC directed Consumers Energy to continue “We partner with THAW, the Salvation Army and to the nonprofits that administer them tomer assistance coordinator for the Jack- collecting money for the state fund in rates and the City of Detroit Department of Human Ser- — are expected beginning in October, just as son-based utility, who is co-chair of the but to hold it in escrow. vices so that people who received crisis fuel the cold weather begins. Coalition to Keep Michigan Warm, a group of Detroit Edison and MichCon are continu- assistance also got some solutions-based help At the state level, the cuts stem from a late energy providers, nonprofit assistance ing to collect the money and escrow it as so they could immediately do something to July decision by the Michigan Court of Appeals, agencies, state departments and others. well, said Judy Palnau, media and public in- bring their bills down,” he said. which ruled the Michigan Public Service Com- More than 615,000 people in Michigan re- formation specialist at the PSC. Chapman said he expects the organiza- mission does not have the authority to collect ceived assistance through the federal fund- The PSC submitted a request to appeal the tion will have to lay off four to six of its 24 roughly $90 million from customers of Detroit ing last year, according to the coalition. Michigan Appeals Court decision to the employees. Edison Co., Consumers Energy Co. and Michigan About 100,000 received energy assistance Michigan Supreme Court on Sept. 1. Cuts to the Clean Energy Coalition’s funding Consolidated Gas Co. to fund energy assistance and weatherization services through the But for now, $90 million sits with the utili- will mean the loss of $2.5 million of its and efficiency programs through the Low-In- state fund, said Bob Chapman, executive di- ties, which were to transfer it to the state $4.4 million grant for the Cities of Promise come and Energy Efficiency Fund. rector of the Warm Training Center, one of the fund as of Oct. 1, Palnau said. program and another $5 million grant to ex- That decision has frozen about $90 million coalition’s members. Of that amount, $72 million was awarded pand its work with more cities. while the PSC figures out what to do with Skeans said there are discussions at the by the PSC, with $35 million to go to the In its third year, the program was funding funds collected previously by utilities to PSC and in the Legislature on how the state Michigan Department of Human Services and energy efficiency audits and retrofits to mu- fund assistance programs through the De- situation can be remedied in the short term the remainder to agencies nicipal buildings, said Sean Reed, founder partment of Human Services and nonprofits. for the upcoming heating season. around the state. and executive director of the coalition, At the federal level, President Obama is At Consumers, the state charge is built For nonprofits like The which expects to close out this year with a calling for a 50 percent cut in the $5.1 billion into the rates for all customer classes: com- Heat and Warmth Fund, a total budget of about $3 million. Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Pro- mercial, industrial and residential. decision by the Michigan Those projects were expected to save up to gram fund. In Michigan, that fund supports Skeans said the charge is about $7 a year Supreme Court — or a $1 million over the next decade, in each of state emergency energy assistance, home for an average electric residential customer legislative solution to re- eight initial cities: Benton Harbor, Detroit, energy conservation services for low-in- and about $10 a year for an average natural assert PSC’s authority to Flint, Hamtramck, Highland Park, come residents, energy-efficiency projects gas customer, but she did not have figures collect and distribute the Muskegon Heights, Pontiac and Saginaw. and the Home Heating Credit. for commercial and industrial customers. money — can’t come soon The original eight cities expected to each The cuts would decrease Michigan’s allo- The Association of Businesses Advocating enough. save up to $1 million over the next decade Sherer cation by 46 percent to a projected $106 mil- Tariff Equity, a group of large industrial ener- CEO Susan Sherer said and to reinvest those savings back into a lion in the coming fiscal year, down from gy users, and former attorney general THAW’s budget for fiscal 2012, which began city-managed fund that would fund similar $227 million in fiscal 2011. Michael Cox filed separate appeals of a PSC July 1, will plummet 63 percent from $24 mil- efforts in the future in each of the cities, The reductions are expected to hurt the ruling on a Michigan Consolidated Gas rate lion to $9 million as of Oct. 1. Reed said. budgets and staff levels at nonprofits that case with the Michigan Court of Appeals The nonprofit has tabled its plans to hire Sherri Welch: (313) 446-1694, provide those programs, hundreds of thou- last summer, which led to the July decision. more employees but doesn’t immediately ex- [email protected]. Twitter: @sherriwelch sands of low-income residents who benefit “This is not something that belongs in pect layoffs of any of its 17 employees. Amy Lane contributed to this report.
Working together magnifies the impact
and value of individual ideas and efforts.
When you’re serious about intellectual property law…
As one of the largest firms in the United States dedicated exclusively to intellectual property, Brinks has grown and evolved with the companies and technologies that shape the way we live and work. With 150 attorneys, most with technical or scientific degrees, Brinks has the insight and skill to partner with your company 866.222.0112 on its next generation of intellectual property challenges. usebrinks.com
Ann Arbor Office: Suite 200 | 524 South Main Street | Ann Arbor, MI 48104-2921 | 734.302.6000 20110912-NEWS--0007-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 3:27 PM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 7 Newton, Handique raise profile of med device startup
BY TOM HENDERSON end of July and recently agreed to “This is a great story, a perfect of $140 million. CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS join DeNovo after helping advise example of a successful entrepre- The firm had been seeking $125 the co-founders for much of the neur with a very good reputation million, but based on returns from DeNovo Sciences LLC, a tiny med- past year. taking his talents to help another the sales of HandyLab, HealthMedia ical device startup in Plymouth “At big companies, things move company grow,” Kinnear said. Inc. and Accuri Cytometers Inc., the Township, has joined forces with so slowly. I am really enjoying be- And Jan Garfinkle, managing fund was oversubscribed. two big names: Roger Newton and ing back at a startup,” said Hand- director of Ann Arbor-based Ar- Mahendra Ramsinghani, man- Kalyan Handique. ique. His first mission is to make boretum Ventures, a HandyLab in- aging director of the First Step Handique, co-founder of Handy- the rounds of the local angel in- vestor, looks forward to hearing Fund, a $5 million Detroit-based Lab Inc., will serve as CEO and vestor community. from Handique. fund that typically invests $50,000 Newton, founder of Esperion Thera- Newton Handique Tom Kinnear — executive direc- “I’m excited to hear the news,” in new companies, met with Hand- peutics Inc., as scientific adviser. tor of the Zell Lurie Institute for Entre- Garfinkle said. “His strength is ique and DeNovo’s founders last Both men also will be investors. In October 2009, HandyLab was preneurial Studies at the Ross School building a team and a culture.” week. DeNovo, which rents literally sold for $275 million to New Jer- of Business at UM, chairman and The timing of a pitch to Garfin- He said he will recommend an just a few square feet of lab space sey-based Becton, Dickinson & Co. president of the state’s Venture kle is particularly fortunate for investment in the company. at the Michigan Life Science and In- Handique, known as Handy, Michigan Fund and an avid local an- Handique because Arboretum an- Tom Henderson: (313) 446-0337, novation Center, was founded by joined Becton, Dickinson & Co. gel investor — will be happy to nounced last Thursday that it has [email protected]. Twitter: Chris Siemer, Saedeh Sepehri and He left Becton Dickinson at the hear Handique’s pitch. closed on its third and largest fund @tomhenderson2 Priya Gogoi, young biologists whose biggest accomplishment to date was their business plan win at the Great Lakes Entrepreneurs Quest in June. “HealthPlus takes care of my employees Their product is a small mi- crofluidic chip about an inch square that they hope will analyze so I can take care of business. That’s a blood samples to detect a wide range of very early-stage cancers. The company has a prototype that has passed early tests at the big Plus.” Karmanos Cancer Institute to see if the design works to capture cells. Blood flows in one end and out the other, with 10,000 tiny chambers in between to, in theory, capture can- cer cells circulating from very ear- ly-stage tumors. The company hopes to start hu- man trials soon and applied in Au- gust for a broad-based patent. It also is trying to raise a seed round of up to $1 million this year and a Series A venture capital round of $7 million next year. The technology, if it works as planned, could also be used by re- searchers to see how well drugs at- tack cancer cells. The market is huge, the need great. Such a chip could save tens of thousands of lives a year and many millions of dollars in biopsy costs, said Ramzi Mohammad, the director of gastrointestinal cancer research in the Department of On- cology at Karmanos. But good ideas and big markets are par for the course for entrepre- neurs. What’s not par for the course is landing the likes of Hand- ique and Newton. Newton founded Esperion in 1998 to make a drug to treat high cholesterol. He raised $200 million to fund drug development, took the com- pany public in a $54 million offer- ing in 2000, then sold it to Pfizer Inc. in 2002 for $1.3 billion. In 2008, backed by nearly $23 million in venture capital, Newton HealthPlus goes above and beyond for employers. relaunched Esperion, buying back from Pfizer the rights to a choles- terol-fighting molecule. It is cur- džƚĞŶƐŝǀĞƐƚĂƚĞǁŝĚĞĂŶĚŶĂƟŽŶĂůƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƌŶĞƚǁŽƌŬƐ rently in trials. Siemer and Gogoi were interns Worldwide emergency coverage at Esperion before deciding to found DeNovo last year. WĞƌƐŽŶĂůĂƩĞŶƟŽŶďLJĂĚĞĚŝĐĂƚĞĚƵƐƚŽŵĞƌ^ĞƌǀŝĐĞƚĞĂŵ “Their flexibility in taking on projects impressed me,” said New- ĂƐLJƚƌĂŶƐŝƟŽŶĨƌŽŵŽƚŚĞƌŚĞĂůƚŚƉůĂŶƐ ton. “And their technology is fasci- nating. It has legs.” Customizable HMO, PPO and self-funded health plans In 2000, Handique and Sun- daresh Brahmasandra, engineer- To enroll, contact your independent agent or call: ing students at the University of Michigan, founded HandyLab, 1-800-530-9071 which used microfluidic technolo- gy to quickly and cheaply diagnose www.healthplus.org diseases. The company raised more than $46 million over the HealthPlus HMO is a product of HealthPlus of Michigan, Inc. HealthPlus PPO is a product of HealthPlus Insurance Company. © 2011 HealthPlus of Michigan next nine years. 20110912-NEWS--0008-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 3:26 PM Page 1
Page 8 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 OPINION OTHER VOICES Give game developers Extend region to Windsor-Essex Why is a new bridge be- with Tourism Windsor- gan’s film industry, Windsor-Es- tween Detroit and Wind- Essex-Pelee Island to pro- sex may just become Hollywood’s sor so important? What mote. next big thing as Ontario has a per- access to incentives does it really mean for Just 45 minutes from manent film and television tax Michigan? the border in Harrow, On- credit, with an additional 10 per- It is time we consider tario, the Canadian gov- cent for productions outside of the hen Michigan’s film incentives were created in 2008, Windsor-Essex part of our ernment created the greater Toronto area. Regardless video game developers largely were left out in the region, recognizing our Greenhouse and Process- of what happens with film credits W cold. (See story, Page 3.) neighbors as our business ing Crops Research Cen- in Michigan, we should promote The Michigan Department of Treasury’s interpretation of partners and welcome tre where new technolo- Detroit and Windsor-Essex to the them into our community. gies are created affecting entertainment industry and con- incentive eligibility required developers to own intellectual Despite the collapse of Daniel Cherrin the agricultural industry. tinue to build upon the existing property and distribution rights — something not common in the auto industry, the Windsor-Es- Why can’t we link that with all the film industry in Detroit while al- an industry where games are often based on movies, toys and sex region remains strong in man- food technologies being created in lowing it to expand into Windsor- other copyrighted products. ufacturing, renewable energy, lo- and around Battle Creek? We Essex. That may be about to change. gistics/warehousing and can’t, in part, because we are not The University of Windsor is agribusiness. It has the longest taking the time to develop partner- working with TechTown and has Senate Majority Leader Randy Richardville, R-Monroe, has growing season in Canada, averag- ships across the border to benefit joint programs with the Universi- introduced legislation that would drop the requirement for ing 212 days, and the largest green- both economies and both nations. ty of Detroit, the University of video game developers, and a court also has ruled in develop- house industry in North America We are too focused on ourselves. Michigan-Dearborn and Wayne ers’ favor, although that is being appealed by the state. for vegetables and exotic flowers. Windsor-Essex is investing in State University. (The University Game developers often set up deeper roots and offer more Why can’t we move quicker on ur- the creative industries including of Windsor is a client of mine). ban farm initiatives or build just digital media and working with Windsor Regional Hospital and long-term employment in a community than the nomadic as many greenhouses on this side their universities and colleges to Hôtel-Dieu Grace Hospital have a movie industry. They should not have unreasonable barriers of the border? keep rising talent in the region. strong partnership with Henry to be eligible for incentives. There are 14 commercial winer- Why can’t we work together to Ford Hospital in Detroit for pa- ies with internationally recog- keep rising talent in the region? Solution needed to heating aid hit nized wine that we could work Given the uncertainty of Michi- See Voices, Page 9 Funding for heating assistance for low-income residents is taking a hit. As Sherri Welch reports on Page 6, funding is getting re- LETTERS TALK ON THE WEB duced on two fronts. President Obama is calling for a 50 per- From www.crainsdetroit.com cent cut in the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program. Bogus suits hurt biz And, at the state level, the Michigan Court of Appeals has Editor: Re: Kilpatrick at Philander Smith Reader responses to stories and ruled that it is illegal for the Michigan Public Service Commis- I could not agree with Michael When I saw your blog, the first blogs that appeared on Crain’s sion to distribute roughly $90 million collected by state utili- Bates more (“No windfall from thing I did was check to make Web site. Comments may be sure it wasn’t a college we have ties for various energy assistance and efficiency programs. Irene,” Sept. 5 Letters). As a busi- edited for length and clarity. ness owner going on 20 years of under consideration for my son. The decision is being appealed. growth, I find my defense of a friv- Is white-collar crime now accept- The need for heating assistance as we head into the cold- olous lawsuit highly detrimental able? Perhaps the college should Re: Pure Michigan marketing shifted weather months is critical. to my growth. invite him to speak on ethics as The Michigan Economic Devel- Gov. Rick Snyder in early August sent a letter to the leader- Although the funds paid to well. This is just what we need — opment Corp. uses money confis- Kilpatrick teaching our young ship of a key congressional committee urging for sustained lawyers, expert witness and my cated from citizens in the form of own employees (who still get paid people that crime pays. funding through the federal energy-assistance/weatherization higher taxes. Gov. Snyder and his by me while being deposed) can go Compass Commerical political friends at MEDC social- program. And, the Coalition to Keep Michigan Warm, a group toward new cars, clothing and wid- ize capital and privatize profit. of energy providers, nonprofit assistance agencies, state de- gets, it chokes my funding for new Re: No-fault insurance proposals P. Lester Diddy partments and others, also is lobbying Michigan’s congres- employees, IT, telecom, equip- There is nothing in these bills sional delegation. ment, etc. that states I can continue my un- Pure Michigan is simply state The creator of wealth is pun- limited coverage at the same welfare for chamber of com- And, Rep. Ken Horn, R-Frankenmuth, chair of the House ished while the system effectively merce types who would rather Energy and Technology Committee, said he plans to find a leg- price I pay now. The fact of the redistributes the wealth to the matter is that the insurance com- buy lobbyists and corrupt politi- islative solution to get money already collected and being held sycophants. panies will not be required to pass cians instead of paying their own in escrow to people in need as winter approaches. This is no way to serve as a cata- any savings on to their customers. advertising and promotions. It is Sen. Michael Nofs, R-Battle Creek, chair of the Senate En- lyst of economic growth. This is a The only ones I can see who are time for chamber of commerce much broader expansion of the ex- sure to gain will be the insurance members to pay for their own adver- ergy and Technology Committee, also plans to hold hearings ample, but the same principal ap- tising, just as our Michigan busi- on both state and federal funding issues in the coming weeks, companies. Even taxpayers will plies. lose on this deal because the un- ness has done successfully for his legislative director, Greg Moore, said. Michael T. Kulka covered injuries will end up in over 25 years. Co-founder and CEO Accommodator Hopefully, their combined efforts will yield results at both PM Environmental Inc. the Medicaid system. the state and federal levels. Berkley Mynsbem See Talk, Page 9 KEITH CRAIN: Sept. 11: A day that no one will ever forget Anyone who is old enough well Ten years ago I was in er tower. ed, we really didn’t expect anyone. when you simply were not able to remembers where they were when Frankfurt for the bien- I found a friend at the To our surprise, we had hun- return to Detroit. It took several they heard about the assassination nial auto show, and Mercedes stand and we dreds of people show up for our re- more days before the airlines got of John F. Kennedy. around three in the af- went into his office and ception. Everyone wanted to be to- back to something resembling nor- I had just taken off on a plane ternoon Germany time watched the event un- gether and, for many, they said malcy. from Denver heading for Chicago, had just left an inter- fold on CNN in the Ger- that they had come to support the I can only imagine that after Pearl and 20 minutes after takeoff the pi- view with the head of man language for a cou- United States. Harbor, everyone knew what to do. lot clicked on the intercom and an- Renault. I stopped in the ple of hours. It didn’t For several days we were all After 9-11, no one had any idea as nounced that the president of the middle of their stand to matter what language locked out of returning to the Unit- to what to do. There was no clearly United States had been assassinat- call the office in Detroit. was on the television, it ed States. No flights were allowed defined enemy, and there still isn’t. ed. That was it. For the next two It was then that I was simply horrifying. to fly inside our country, and most It made traveling more difficult hours we were left to our imagina- learned about a plane We had plans for a re- of us in Frankfurt just hung than ever. tions as to what had happened. that had flown into one ception where we around waiting to get home. A few terrorists changed the way Many of us were afraid that there of the towers of the World Trade would be announcing the intro- Eventually some of us flew to we all lived then and now. Perhaps would be no O’Hare airport when Center. While I was on the phone, duction of a new German-language Canada and Windsor and then forever. So on 9-11 a decade later, I we got there. It was a very strange my secretary told me that she just trade paper we were launching. Al- drove over the bridge into Detroit. am in Germany once again. Let’s experience. saw another plane fly into the oth- though hundreds had been invit- It was a very strange feeling hope the week is peaceful. 20110912-NEWS--0009-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 10:18 AM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 9 OTHER VOICES: Small biz can help lure young talent to state
It is important for recognize that the young growth over security, excitement a richer ecosystem than our lead- discuss college options. Talk to col- Michigan to retain and at- talent we are trying to re- over consistency. They won’t ers normally portray. Point out lege students in your field. Ask tract young talent, espe- cruit has different ideas spend their career with a single not just our own companies, but who is staying in Michigan. Ask cially in technical fields. about what makes a great company. They want to change the the many other opportunities for who is leaving. Ask why. Press the Companies locate where career in a great place. The world and create new enterprises. those who locate here. People can MEDC to produce a Pure Michigan there is a strong talent Pure Michigan campaign, People say: “Go to Silicon Val- continue their education at our campaign for young talent that is pool, and business growth in particular, focuses on ley, or Route 128.” Those regions graduate schools. Even the exodus every bit as inspiring as the cam- is dependent on it. We the desires of an older gen- have multiple opportunities. The can be an advantage. Young people paigns for our tourism industry. need talent to migrate to eration. Small businesses strength of the overall economy making a difference here are spe- If everyone does small, simple Michigan. Companies can extend Pure Michigan, minimizes the risk of any one job. cial: Even the governor mentions things, Michigan will become a will follow and put the highlighting the assets If your first Silicon Valley startup young people in almost every destination for talented young peo- economy on a growth Bill Wagner that attract the younger fails, just join another one. There’s speech. In Silicon Valley, or on ple. Once it starts, it will drive fur- track. generation: nightlife, a large com- always more opportunity. Route 128, you are just another ther change. Small businesses don’t have the munity of people their age, career We must tell this audience that nameless face in the crowd. Young Bill Wagner is CEO of Ann Ar- resources to implement high-speed opportunities with many different life in Michigan is much better people here have an amplified bor-based SRT Solutions, which rail, shrink Detroit to its urban companies, and the chance to than the perception. Washtenaw voice by choosing to be here. writes software for mobile, tablets, core, or hire by the thousands. But make a real mark on the future. County has more than 100 software Talk to people making life deci- web, desktop, and enterprise sys- when we do something, we can do The target audience values companies. That statistic points to sions. Go to area high schools and tems. it quickly. From that perspective, small businesses can play an effec- tive role in attracting and retain- ing the young talent that’s critical to growth and prosperity. The people who promote our state are not the target audience of their promotion efforts. They don’t
VOICES CONTINUED ■ From Page 8 tients in need of emergency car- diac care. To enrich our region with culture and business acumen on both sides of the border, more partnerships around culture and business must matriculate. Our relationship is more than just a border crossing, an annual freedom festival, air races or a visit to Erie Street. It is about jobs and commerce, history and culture and the unique geography we share with each other. While Detroit and Southeast Michigan’s population may have declined over the past 10 years, if we include Windsor and southwestern Ontario, we have a much stronger story to tell. We should build a bridge between our cities that will be used to enhance one regional economy. Daniel Cherrin is an attorney, mediator, public relations executive and lobbyist with Fraser Trebil- cock in Detroit and Lansing.
TALK CONTINUED ■ From Page 8 Re: Jim Hiller’s grocery gospel I love his passion, but I have to wonder why his stores are supplied by a grocery wholesaler that is based in Minneapolis, rather than buying from Spartan Stores, which is If you have an opportunity, we’re ready. This is no time to wait. And based here in Michigan. we’re not. In fact, so far this year, we’ve extended nearly 10 billion dollars in SayYesToMich credit to business customers, and we plan to lend another 28 billion dollars If Mr. Hiller wants his children to stay in Michigan, he needs to in the year to come. In addition to lending, we will keep supporting local think about how we can all work businesses with financial solutions and services that can improve productivity together to make our urban areas work again. and, ultimately, help them succeed. Find out how we can help you drive results David Waymire at 53.com/drivingresults or call 1-877-804-2091. Hiller’s approach to servicing customers and providing quality prod- ucts is a breath of fresh air in an in- dustry that continues to reduce cost to drive their bottom line. mlarue
Not many stories about busi- Loans subject to credit review and approval. Rates may vary based on credit qualifications. Fifth Third Bank, Member FDIC. Equal Housing Lender. nesses make me smile. I smiled through this entire article. … Can we clone Jim? Healthcare consultant 20110912-NEWS--0010-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 11:07 AM Page 1
Page 10 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 Road projects at risk if Congress misses funding date
BY AMY LANE thorization, the lapse in funding highway projects moving forward tension through January. Then the CAPITOL CORRESPONDENT could affect road projects statewide. for about a month. task is for them to sit down and de- I’m pretty hopeful The extent of the impact is un- The department would likely velop a reauthorization bill, and LANSING — Around Michigan, “ clear: Some projects may already have to delay putting out in Octo- that’s a more difficult task.” road builders are pushing to com- that they will do the be paid for or may wrap up before ber bids for some $22 million in President Barack Obama has plete more than a thousand high- a federal funding lapse would be- new work, and it also would not called for an extension of existing way projects before Michigan’s right thing. come an issue, and the Michigan De- award any new contracts until fed- law, and a four-month extension construction season ends and un- ” partment of Transportation says it eral funding reauthorization is ex- for highway spending has started favorable weather sets in. Polly Kent, MDOT would do all it could to avoid ulti- tended. There are currently nearly to move in the Democrat-led U.S. But some of those projects could mately shutting down highway $100 million in contracts ready to Senate. The Republican-controlled be put at risk if Congress doesn’t Authorization for most of the projects. be awarded by MDOT. U.S. House has indicated support act on key highway funding mea- 18.4-cent per gallon federal gas tax, MDOT hasn’t determined what Polly Kent, intermodal policy for some form of extension. sures by Sept. 30. and for spending from the federal projects could be affected and is administrator at MDOT, said “if If an extension is not approved Riding on Washington over the Highway Trust Fund, expires Sept. optimistic that at least an exten- there’s not at least an extension, and road projects start to be affect- next few weeks is the federal gov- 30. If Congress fails to act either on sion will be made. that would be devastating.” ed, even short delays in construc- ernment’s authority to spend mon- an extension or on a compromise If federal funding is not extend- “I don’t want to be too Pollyanna, tion can cause problems, said ey on highways and transit and to between House and Senate propos- ed by Sept. 30, MDOT would have but I’m pretty hopeful that they will Mark Johnston, president of Ajax collect federal fuel taxes. als for transportation funding reau- enough money to keep current do the right thing and do a clean ex- Paving Industries Inc. in Troy. “Michigan is a short construc- tion season. Our paving season ba- sically ends around Thanksgiving, if not sooner, and any type of de- lay, a week, two weeks, could put us into paving weather we’re not supposed to be in.” Beyond the question of a short- term extension lies the bigger is- sue of future federal road funding. A six-year, $230 billion proposal unveiled by U.S. Rep. John Mica, R-Fla., would reduce federal trans- portation funding by about 30 per- cent, setting a level of spending from the Highway Trust Fund that is in line with the amount of taxes the fund receives. MDOT esti- mates the House plan would mean a $175 million to $365 million annu- al reduction in Michigan’s federal funding. In the Senate, a $109 billion pro- posal from U.S. Sen. Barbara Box- er, D-Calif., would authorize trans- portation funding at approximately current levels plus inflation for two years. But the proposal would allocate more mon- ey than is available in the trust fund and $12 billion would need to be found elsewhere. Ajax Paving’s Johnston said Charlotte such uncertainty over future fund- Motown Expands to ing makes it difficult to plan capital investments, such as in equipment that is both costly and requires em- ployee training. “It’s tough to make capital investment decisions on the long term,” he said. Dykema is pleased to announce the opening of our 11th Mike Nystrom, executive vice president of the Michigan Infrastruc- office, in Charlotte, North Carolina. ture and Transportation Association, said that “with a questionable fu- As a leading law firm for banks and financial institutions, ture, construction firms are not doing any additional hiring, there’s no better place to expand our national footprint they’re doing very little training; than Charlotte, a top U.S. banking center. they don’t want to invest in em- ployees that they aren’t going to have eight to 12 months from now. Dykema’s automotive practice — which has existed since They aren’t buying any new equip- ment because of questions with re- 1926 — also has reason to celebrate our Charlotte office gards to the future. opening: a host of auto and truck manufacturers have “Uncertainty equates to inaction on planning, because you can’t significant operations in North Carolina or one of its plan on expansion when there’s no adjoining states. revenue to expand with.” But it’s also a picture that’s not new. The federal surface trans- Throughout the years, Dykema’s expansion into new markets Michigan portation law known as SAFETE- has been focused and purposeful, designed to meet the California LU originally expired in Novem- Illinois ber 2009 and is on its seventh needs of our clients while staying true to those values that North Carolina extension; its predecessor was also extended more than a dozen times, distinguish us from other law firms: Outstanding results. Texas Nystrom said. Unparalleled service. And exceptional value. Washington, D.C. “It has become almost a routine way of doing business, expecting www.dykema.com Congress to not actually do their To learn more, we invite you to visit www.dykema.com. duty until they debate it for far too
© 2011 Dykema Gossett PLLC Attorney Advertising long,” he said. Amy Lane: (517) 371-5355, [email protected]. Twitter: @alanecdb 20110912-NEWS--0011-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 11:26 AM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 11
PUBLISHER’S NOTEBOOK
Contact Mary Kramer at [email protected] CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Mary Kramer Middle ground in Michigan
Our country (read: Washington, D.C.) seems so politically polarized that it’s Filling the VC void hard to find the middle. Two exceptions are worth noting. On the left, it’s Michigan AFL-CIO Small funds President Mark Gaffney, who said last week he would meet big need not run for re- election. If you read the political for startups tea leaves, he is taking the fall for BY MATTHEW GRYCZAN the election last CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Gaffney fall of Republican Rick Snyder as governor over the drian Fortino counts him- anointed UAW candidate, Virg Bernero. self lucky he didn’t have to (So why wouldn’t the state Democratic A scrounge for money from Party chairman fall on his sword first, family and friends to launch Shep- inquiring minds might ask?) herd Intelligent Systems LLC in Ann On the right, it’s Paul Hillegonds, Arbor. And so far he hasn’t had to senior vice deal with the third traditional president of “F” source of funds for a startup corporate affairs company: fools. for DTE Energy. On On the contrary, Fortino Oct. 13, speaks highly of the advice he Hillegonds will has received from the principals receive one of of Huron River Ventures — who, four regional with a syndicate of other in- “Shining Light” vestors, closed on an agreement awards, sponsored by the with his company three weeks Hillegonds LON HORWEDEL Metropolitan ago to provide $1.25 million in exchange for an equity stake. A cellphone can check on University of Michigan bus arrival times through Shepherd Intelligent Systems’ tracking Affairs Coalition and the Detroit Free system. Adrian Fortino is Shepherd’s CEO and co-founder. Press. (For information, check The commitment “means the www.shininglightawards.com.) world to us,” said Fortino, 34, Hillegonds was a Republican state who with partner Jahan Khanna lawmaker from Holland for 18 years co-founded a business that al- Shepherd leads riders to buses on time when he made a dramatic decision to lows cellphone users to time move from the largely nonunion West their arrival at bus stations to With an infusion of $1.25 mil- Shepherd, created two years port in Boston. Michigan area to Detroit as CEO of meet the bus. lion, Shepherd Intelligent Systems ago from research at the Univer- About 85 percent of UM bus Detroit Renaissance Inc., the council That sort of funding can mean LLC in Ann Arbor is aggressive- sity of Michigan, posted about riders have used the Shepherd of CEOs (now the statewide Business the world to perhaps two dozen ly rolling out its proprietary $250,000 in revenue last year Intelligent system in some form Leaders for Michigan). DTE Chairman other startup companies in software system that uses GPS- from fixed fees it charges busi- over the past year, Fortino said. Tony Earley recruited him to his Michigan as well. enabled smartphones as track- nesses based on their fleet sizes. Riders do not need smartphones company from there. The recently capitalized Huron ing devices for bus systems, lim- The company to access the system — arrival Hillegonds understands the dominant River in Ann Arbor and Michigan ousine services and taxicab and has seven full- times can be sent by text mes- political, social and business cultures Accelerator Fund I in Grand shuttle service companies time employ- sage to any cellphone automati- that exist in our state better than Rapids invest in Michigan com- across the country. ees including cally. most. He dove into knotty problems panies only, providing cash com- Shepherd’s software allows Fortino’s An average of about 16,000 — including how best to fix Detroit’s mitments that they say can reach riders using any type of cell- partner and text messages have been sent ailing schools. He has created strong $1.5 million — the no man’s land phone to get predictions as ac- the compa- weekly at UM, Fortino said. relationships with people of all between the “three F’s” and the curate as 30 seconds from the ny’s chief He said his company’s system ethnicities, races and political stripes. more established venture funds actual arrival time of the bus or technology of- differs significantly from fleet I think the word for what he has that usually consider deals in the earned is “trust.” taxi. ficer, Jahan management such as C.J. Hood tens of millions of dollars. Transportation services can Khanna. Co. Inc.’s automatic vehicle loca- Gaffney has done the same. As a Khanna If all goes according to plan, use smartphones as inexpensive Fortino ex- tion system, because Shepherd’s member of the MAC board that is Huron River and Michigan Ac- giving out the leadership awards, tracking systems for their pects to hire this year to expand does not rely on dedicated hard- celerator each will raise about fleets, updating vehicle location the sales and marketing force. ware to track vehicles. Shep- Gaffney had a platform to represent $15 million by the end of 2012 to union views to a group of business data every two seconds to help Shepherd’s software is used herd uses GPS-enabled smart- invest in startups over the next leaders who might not always hear plan routes better and train dri- by customers including UM and phones running the Google few years. But both funds have them straight from the union mouth. vers how to conserve fuel, said Golden Limousine in Ann Arbor, Android platform as the track- sufficient capital now to make a Shepherd CEO and co-founder Indiana University-Purdue Universi- ing mechanisms. Plenty of knowledgeable politicos in difference for companies such as the “Michigan middle” mourned the Adrian Fortino. ty Indianapolis and Crystal Trans- — Matthew Gryczan Shepherd. loss of his pragmatic voice and The duo hope to spawn more perspective. You may not have always agreed with Gaffney on big issues, but small VC firms in Michigan as that have proved their business commitment — to market its pro- tiny funds can be very important you would respect his solid they themselves mature into concepts using money from in- prietary software aggressively to to a state like Michigan,” said representation of organized labor and midsize funds. vestors who know the company university bus systems, limou- Erik Gordon, a professor of entre- not feel polarized from it. “It’s the most important type founders personally but that now sine services, taxicab companies preneurial studies at the Universi- So even though it’s a year from now, I of funding that we need in Michi- need additional capital to com- and shuttle service companies ty of Michigan and associate direc- nominate Gaffney today for next gan,” Fortino said. “We have all pete in bigger leagues or tackle across the country. tor of the Zell-Lurie Institute at the year’s Shining Light awards. We need kinds of good companies out the next milestone. university’s Stephen M. Ross to celebrate more often integrity, there that are looking for growth For instance, Fortino said, The farm club system School of Business. “There’s a real dignity and thoughtfulness — and the capital money right now.” Shepherd will use its first need for relatively small ability to find the elusive middle. Huron River and Michigan Ac- “tranche” — VC-speak for draw- Huron River and Michigan Ac- celerator fill a need for startups ing some funds from the overall celerator “are tiny funds, but See Funds, Page 12 20110912-NEWS--0012-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 10:15 AM Page 1
Page 12 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Funds: Filling a VC void ■ From Page 11 amounts of money going to early- stage companies to help them de- velop their idea to the point they can attract bigger money.” To some extent, Gordon, 58, oversees his own tiny fiefdom as adviser to the university’s Wolver- ine Venture Fund, a $5.5 million fund that serves as a laboratory for MBA students learning to be to- morrow’s venture capitalists. But where Wolverine Venture can invest in a startup regardless of its location, Huron River and Michigan Accelerator can invest only in Michigan companies be- cause of a patron investor: the Michigan Economic Development Corp. The MEDC has committed $6 million to each fund, with some stipulations that essentially try to JON BROUWER foster job creation in the state, Dale Grogan (left) and John Kerschen Gordon said. manage Michigan Accelerator Fund 1 in Grand Rapids. Michigan is far from unique in using taxpayer money for venture to crawl before it can run the capital. Florida and Maryland are marathon of the business world.” just two examples of states that Definitions in the venture capi- Gordon said are active in venture tal industry are somewhat loose at funding. the first stage, A venture capi- but pre-seed tal firm won’t all of A startup needs money usually a sudden “move “ comes from here or just to crawl those who are spring up,” well-acquainted Gordon said. before it can with company “The typical founders, and way it works run the seed money usu- is a venture ally comes from capitalist or marathon of high-net-worth group of ven- individuals who ture capital- the business serve as angel ists start investors. In with a very world. both cases, the small fund, and ” investors put up they create a track Erik Gordon, University of Michigan their own mon- record.” ey. At the same time, when first- After founders have reached time entrepreneurs need startup proof-of-concept with the initial capital, they need to understand funding, they usually seek early- they are entering a VC farm club stage VC funds such as Huron Riv- system. er and Michigan Accelerator, “You can’t start with, ‘Well, I’ve which are managed by profession- got this great idea from the Uni- als who handle money from other versity of Michigan laboratories investors. or Michigan State lab or Grand “Hopefully, the company needs Valley lab, and you just give me more money yet: It’s at a stage $20 million and I will get going on it,’ ” Gordon said. “A startup needs See Next Page 20110912-NEWS--0013-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 10:14 AM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 13 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS
From Previous Page fund’s other managing director, January, Grogan said, ranging where they have a more advanced Ryan Waddington, 40. from ideas that don’t stand a story to tell,” Gordon said. “Now chance to well-developed business they will need between $2 million The law of averages plans “that almost immediately and $5 million, and someone like they have everyone circling around Huron River will get together with Like other small firms trying to them.” a bigger VC firm to syndicate the establish themselves, Huron River For instance, Michigan Accelera- next round of funding.” and Michigan Accelerator have to tor has made two investments in Fortino said he has gotten much break into the VC industry by tak- Metabolic Solutions Development Co. more than just cash from Huron ing on deals that are too small for in Kalamazoo (featured in the Aug. River and another VC firm, RPM more established funds to consider. 8 issue of Crain’s Michigan Busi- Ventures in Ann Arbor, which “If you’re a midsized venture ness) in what was considered a later started in 2000 as Waypoint Ventures capital fund managing $400 mil- and more mature round of financ- and has invested in more than 20 lion to $500 million, you can’t ing. Grogan said the Metabolic So- companies. Huron River and RPM make investments of $250,000,” lutions investment isn’t typical for share offices in Ann Arbor and Gordon said. “You’d have to make Michigan Accelerator, but he is collaborate closely on opportuni- hundreds of investments that size elated to have been part of the syn- ties. just to deploy your fund.” dicate — a result of relationships in “My partner and I were intro- Michigan Accelerator already DAVID EGGERICHS duced to one another by RPM,” has assessed at least 150 deals since See Next Page Tim Streit (left) and Ryan Waddington of Huron River Ventures in Ann Arbor. Fortino said. “Jahan was a math graduate student working on the Magic Bus system — the precursor to our system — and he knew there was something there, but he need- ed help on the business side.” Khanna, 24, is chief technology of- Business & Warner ficer of Shepherd, and Fortino is CEO. Early VC firms have relation- ships with larger funds that be- come essential as a startup needs more capital, Gordon said. “A fund like Huron River will use its credibility and connections to syndicate the next deal,” he said. That syndication can occur at an early stage, said Tim Streit, a managing director of Huron River. The fund’s first investment was in Ambiq Micro Inc. late last year as part of a $2.4 million syndication that included investments from Draper Fisher Jurvetson and Cisco Inc. Ambiq Micro is a UM spinoff that claims to have created the world’s most energy-efficient mi- crocontrollers, which operate for long periods on very small batter- ies. Ambiq Micro was based in Michigan when it received its funding. The company has since moved its headquarters to Austin, Texas, because that city is home to a number of computer companies. But several Ambiq principals still live in Michigan. Streit, 33, said his fund usually expects to take an equity stake of one-third to one-half of the value of the company, either by itself or as part of a syndicate. One of the most difficult tasks that all the parties face during negotiations is to de- termine a reasonable value for the company before the cash invest- ment. Dale Grogan, who manages Michigan Accelerator along with his partner, John Kerschen, said his fund expects to take similar eq- uity stakes in the companies it ® backs. A Better Partnership That scale of investment pro- vides enough capital for the start- up to grow and keep the entrepre- neurs motivated to persevere, but also gives the VC investors a sig- nificant say in how the company is run. “I don’t look at it as if I am losing a slice of the pie,” said Fortino, who would not disclose the per- centage stake sold. “I look at it as I may have a smaller slice, but they SOUTHFIELD | STERLING HEIGHTS | GRAND RAPIDS | MUSKEGON | LANSING | HOLLAND will help create a much, much big- ger pie. On an absolute basis, I’m going to have a much greater over- all equity in the venture.” wnj.com With its investment, Huron Riv- er was given a seat on Shepherd’s board that will be filled by the 20110912-NEWS--0014-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 10:13 AM Page 1
Page 14 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS
From Previous Page to be zero for the funds, but the re- versities to instruct them on how to the West Michigan monied commu- turn for the state of Michigan will build businesses from their ideas. nity. not be zero,” he said. “About five The fund’s investment advisory where the Waddington said he and Streit (of 10 investments) may be worth committee consists of Marc Weiser probably have reviewed more than nothing — it’ll be a great idea, but and Tony Grover from RPM Ven- Party when you scale it up, it will fail. tures, Jim Adox from Venture In- Red Wings play! 250 proposals during the past two years. But the people who launched the vestors and Peter Mills from @Ven- Both funds say they see good deal companies have learned a lot tures. flow — the term assigned to propos- along the way, and they may go on Starting with a $6 million com- als being brought to them for in- to create other companies in mitment from the state, Michigan vestment. Out of the raft of propos- Michigan that succeed.” Accelerator has reached its initial als, each fund aims to select three goal of $10 million and hopes to to four deals a year for investment. Staying with what you know reach perhaps $15 million, Grogan The funds apply standard aver- said. ages in the industry for failure and Starting with a $6 million com- Michigan Accelerator has a close success rates. Probably one-third mitment from the Michigan Strate- relationship with Grand Valley State of the deals will be entire losses, gic Economic Investment & Commer- University and Hopen Life Science Ven- the second third may preserve the cialization Board, Huron River has tures, a Grand Rapids-based ven- initial investment with a loss or attracted an addi- ture capital firm gain of perhaps 20 percent, and the tional $3 million to- that recently last third will provide a return of ward its goal of man- For us to be launched its second at least five times the original in- aging a fund that it “ fund with a target of Õ'LQQHU *DPH*URXS3DFNDJHV$YDLODEOH vestments. The funds typically hopes will top $15 successful, we amassing $50 mil- Õ%RRN\RXU3ULYDWH3DUW\DWÐ7KH-RHÑ hold their equity stakes more than million by the end of lion by the begin- Õ&RUSRUDWH 6RFLDO3ULYDWH,FH6NDWLQJ(YHQWV five years before selling. next year. need to be very ning of next year for Even in a case of the failures, Both Shepherd investment in early 313.471.3333 the state gets something for its in- and Ambiq Micro capital-efficient to midstage life sci- vestment, said Gordon, the UM are sweet spots for ence businesses in- professor who oversees the Wol- Huron River, which and have a volving pharmaceu- verine Venture Fund. looks to invest in ticals, medical “The investment may turn out technology compa- relatively short devices and diagnos- nies that conserve or tics. extend energy and cycle time. Besides life sci- natural resources. ” ences, Michigan Ac- But Waddington said Ryan Waddington, celerator looks to in- the fund’s emphasis Huron River Ventures vest in homeland on clean technology security, informa- with a positive environmental im- tion technology, advanced manu- pact doesn’t include development facturing, agriculture and biofuels, of alternative-energy devices such and possibly alternative energy, as photovoltaic cells, wind turbines “although we don’t claim expertise Working Capital and battery storage. Commercial- in that space,” Grogan said. ization of those technologies takes Grogan said he gained some of investments of hundreds of mil- his experience in finance as presi- lions of dollars and years of work. dent of Leapfrog Smart Products Inc., To be successful, a fledgling a Florida company that developed fund such as Huron River must se- and marketed smart cards — wal- IN ACTION lect a few companies that are high- let-size plastic cards with embed- ly efficient with capital and can ded integrated circuits for identifi- bring a moneymaking product to cation and authentication. market in a few years. About three years ago, Grogan Waddington cut his teeth on as- joined Kerschen at The Charter sessing energy technology while Group, originally a business bro- he worked in the late 1990s in the kerage in Grand Rapids that corporate business development evolved into an adviser on merg- office of DTE Energy Co., where he ers and acquisitions with a sub- was involved in about 19 venture sidiary, Charter Capital Partners, capital transactions. He also did that invests in businesses and stints as director of venture ser- forms syndicates. Charter has vices with NEXTEnergy, a Detroit- been involved in investments in Al- based nonprofit that channels fed- liant Health Care Products in Rich- eral grants to energy companies land, Intervention Insights in Grand and incubates emerging clean-tech Rapids and Grand River Aseptic Man- companies, and as a director of ZBI ufacturing in Grand Rapids. Ker- Ventures, the venture capital group schen, 44, is managing director of within New York City-based Ziff The Charter Group. Bros. Investments. The investment review board of “The energy industry is very Michigan Accelerator is Ker- capital-intensive and very slow- schen; Mark Olesnavage, chair- moving,” Waddington said. “For man of Hopen; Mahendra Rams- us to be successful, we need to be inghani, who is managing director very capital-efficient and have a of the First Step Fund in Detroit; relatively short cycle time — yet and serial entrepreneur Craig We partner with business owners across Michigan to help their second stage still have technology that has a Hall in Grand Rapids. Hall also ad- positive environmental impact. As vises Huron River on day-to-day companies succeed beyond expectations. Our working capital options increase it turns out, companies like Shep- activities. herd are a very good fit for us.” The hope is that the state will cash flow and our network capital connects entrepreneurs with the Streit said he owes some of his continue backing first-round ven- venture capital connections to ture funds such as Huron River people and resources they need to expand. stints at Hongkong and Shanghai and Michigan Accelerator. Banking Corp. in Chicago and JP- “We have a lot of smart people in Morgan Chase & Co. in New York Michigan,” Gordon said. “We have City. He holds a bachelor’s degree lots of engineering people, we have Let us put our growth capital and financial in mechanical engineering from lots of life science people — we are UM and an MBA from the Universi- a state that is rich in potential new wisdom to work for your business! ty of Chicago. companies. To make that happen, One of Huron River’s strategies is we have to be rich in sort of a ven- to commercialize research being ture capital ecology. done at UM, Michigan State University “The reason that these little and other state institutions. Last guys, even though they’re little, month, Huron River and other orga- are important is they become the 248.658.1100 HennesseyCap.com nizations sponsored a five-day big guys.” course in Grand Rapids that drew 21 Matthew Gryczan: (616) 916-8158, researchers from 10 Michigan uni- [email protected] 20110912-NEWS--0015-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 10:12 AM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 15
CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Advertisement
Name change makes ULI “ Neighborhoods, cities and regions are awakening to statewide focus official the importance of ‘place’ BY DANIEL DUGGAN in economic development. CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS ULI REAL ESTATE FORUM The University of Michigan/Urban They are planning for a future that recognizes The Urban Land Institute is mov- Land Institute Real Estate ing toward a statewide presence. Forum’s 25th annual event will be the critical importance of quality of life to attracting After founding a Detroit chapter Nov. 9-10 in Cobo Center in talent, entrepreneurship and encouraging local businesses. … A community in 1999, the Washington, D.C.-based Detroit. This year’s theme is urban planning and real estate edu- “Forged by Innovation.” Crain’s without place amenities will have a difficult time attracting and retaining talented cation group is expanding and re- Detroit Business is a sponsor. workers and entrepreneurs, or being attractive to business.” – Gov. Rick Snyder branding to become ULI Michigan in- For information: umuliforum.com stead of ULI Detroit. The move comes after the group Grand Rapids. It’s expected that the statewide move will boost member- spent several years building a base We understand the importance of “place” in Michigan. in Grand Rapids, Lansing, Kalama- ship, which has been roughly 250 zoo and Flint, said William Watch, people, said Shannon Sclafani, The Michigan State Housing Development Authority (MSHDA) and the Small manager of ULI Michigan. chairman of ULI Michigan. Business Association of Michigan (SBAM) believe that in order to restore Michigan “It’s going to be a great opportu- ULI’s move is also recognition nity for our membership to have for the west side, said Rick Chapla, to a prosperous state, we must focus on what really matters: creating dynamic, the option of looking vice president of walkable, sustainable communities and regions where people want to live. at, and studying, the business attrac- That’s why we celebrate the release of “The Economics of urban areas around We’ll be sharing tion for The Right the state,” said “ Place, a Grand Place: The Value of Building Communities Around People,” Watch, who the best Rapids-based a new book published by the Michigan Municipal League is also presi- economic devel- that examines the importance of “place” as an economic dent of practices of opment group fo- development strategy that will create a positive, dynamic Southfield- cused on the future for Michigan. based First the west side west side. “It Commercial symbolizes that Lavishly illustrated with scenes of some of our state’s best Realty & De- with the east West Michigan placemaking triumphs, “The Economics of Place” includes is a strong play- velopment essays from urbanists, researchers, practitioners and Co. “We’ll be side and the er in the overall sharing the economic health entrepreneurs as they share their stories and unique perspectives best prac- east side with of Michigan,” he on the importance of “place” and its vital role as an economic spur. tices of the west side said. with the east side the west side. The expanded You will not only read about specific Michigan challenges and the state’s and the east side ” ULI works to- potential, but you will also discover lessons learned in other places around with the west side.” William Watch, ULI Michigan ward a larger A rebranding will goal of market- the country. occur in the next month as the ing the state’s to companies around name is changed on the group’s the country, said Eric “Dusty” Some of the highlights include: website, letterhead and emails. A Duistermars, a member of the na- series of real estate events will be tional attraction unit of the Michi- tThe importance of our young people and what it will take to keep them here held in cities around the state, gan Economic Development Corp. who tHow the changing demographics are driving a different path to economic viability starting in March in Lansing, and works on projects around the state. tWhat economics of place means in the New Economy vs. the Old Economy a West Michigan committee will be “The more we can do to identify formed to oversee future events. the entire state as one area, as a tTo design around people changes the way we look at a community Discussions have been in the larger region, the more it will help tCitizen engagement is a key component in building sustainable, vibrant works since ULI’s flagship event, us to tell its story to the rest of the communities country,” said Duistermars, based the University of Michigan/ULI Real tHow “social entrepreneurs” are driving change in Detroit Estate Forum, was held in Grand in Holland. “Regional collabora- Rapids in 2008. tion will do nothing but help the tHow federal policy has affected Michigan This year’s event will be Nov. 9- entire state.” 10 at Cobo Center in downtown De- Daniel Duggan: (313) 446-0414, Contributing authors include: troit. To cement the new statewide [email protected]. Twitter: presence, the 2012 event will be in @d_duggan
THE MILLER LAW FIRM a professional corporation
Christopher Carol Coletta Dr. Soji Adelaja John Norquist Leinberger President, Coletta & Co. Founder and Director President Founding director Former Executive Land Policy Institute Congress for the Graduate Real Estate Director Michigan State University New Urbanism Development Program Mayors’ Institute Author, “The Wealth University of Michigan on City Design of Cities”
To learn more about the “The Economics of Place,” go to: mml.org/home.html.
Our firm specializes in litigation: We congratulate the Michigan Municipal League on its accomplishment • Complex Commercial and Business and for working to make Michigan a great place to live. • Shareholder and Partnership • Automotive Supplier • Class Actions SMALL BUSINESS AssociationA of MICHIGAN • Employment Focusing the power of small business. • Family Law and Probate Litigation (248) 841-2200 950 West University Drive, Suite 300 Photos courtesy of the Michigan Municipal League. millerlawpc.com Rochester, Michigan 48307 20110912-NEWS--0016,0017-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/9/2011 10:08 AM Page 1
Page 16 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS MICHIGAN BRIEFS Truck suppliers seek boost from Emphasis on fuel performance in largest auto and home owner’s in- months of last year. to purchase energy from a wind the industry, even before the new surer in the U.S. The index dropped to 90.9 points farm in Michigan’s Thumb area. new fuel, emissions standards standards were announced, had — Matthew Gryczan from 94.4 in the fourth quarter of The contract is with Tuscola Bay DETROIT — Suppliers to the prompted increased sales for CK 2010. The dip still puts the index Wind LLC, a subsidiary of NextEra commercial truck and bus indus- Technologies, which is building a Business Leaders for Michigan well above the third quarter of Energy Inc., which will own the try throughout Michigan are wait- $20 million plant to handle new 2010, when it was 85.3. The index 9,000-acre wind farm in Tuscola, ing to see how new fuel and emis- business in Brownsville, Texas. plans CEO Summit for March also is above the 2010 first-quarter Bay and Saginaw counties. Juno sions standards in the U.S. will — Plastics News reading of 89. Beach, Fla.-based NextEra Energy The nonprofit Business Leaders The index uses six indicators to is the largest wind energy develop- affect them. for Michigan will host its first New rules announced last month measure innovation in the state: er in the country. Farmers Insurance to open Michigan CEO Summit next filings for incorporations and lim- The wind farm is expected to be- by the U.S. Department of Transporta- spring in Detroit. tion and the Environmental Protection new service center in Caledonia ited-liability companies, trade- gin operating late next year and “Attendees will be able to hear mark applications, percentage of will produce enough power for Agency should lead to lighter- Farmers Insurance Group is hold- firsthand how industry leaders are weight parts and more parts that innovation workers, venture capi- more than 30,000 homes. It is cur- ing an opening celebration this paving the path toward a new tal funding, gross job creation and improve aerodynamics, said Mark rently in the engineering phase, month for its $84 million training Michigan,” Business Leaders Pres- loans from the U.S. Small Business Miller, president of plastics injec- with construction expected to start and service center in the Grand ident and CEO Doug Rothwell said Administration. tion molder CK Technologies LLC. late next year and take six to nine Rapids suburb of Caledonia — its in a statement. Lee Redding, associate dean of The thing Miller said he does months. largest business campus in North The event is scheduled for academic affairs and an associate not know is how specific cus- The 20-year renewable-energy America — in preparation to ex- March 15 at the Westin Book Cadillac professor of business economics at tomers will approach the stan- contract, for 120 megawatts of pand the insurer’s business in the Hotel in Detroit. Registration will UM-Dearborn’s College of Busi- dards. “Here’s the difficulty,” wind-generated electricity, was ap- eastern section of the country. begin this fall through the Busi- ness, said the Small Business Jobs Miller said last month in an inter- proved by the Michigan Public Ser- Farmers Insurance said it ex- ness Leaders website, www. Act of 2010 contributed to 2010’s view. “There are a whole spectrum vice Commission. pects to add about 1,600 employees businessleadersformichigan.com. fourth-quarter spike in SBA loans. of issues and ways that they could DTE also announced it has se- over the next five years at the CEOs at the event will discuss A total of 720 SBA loans were is- approach this.” lected Southfield-based Barton Mal- 365,000-square-foot center, which issues facing Michigan’s economy, sued in the fourth quarter, com- An emphasis on engines or trail- ow Co. to build three wind farms in has been under construction since including private sector invest- pared with 437 in the first quarter ers, for instance, would not neces- Huron and Sanilac counties next 2009. The project is at the compa- ment and innovation. The public of this year. Without this unusually sarily be the same boon for CK year. General Electric Co. will pro- ny’s 600-acre Kraft Lake Office Park will be invited to attend for a fee high number, the overall reading Technologies — part of Grand vide the nearly 70 turbines for campus. that has not been set. would have been up slightly, Red- Rapids-based Cascade Engineering those wind farms, which will pro- Farmers said it hired more than Business Leaders’ vice presi- ding said. Inc. — as would be decisions to re- duce about 110 megawatts of elec- 25 companies to build the project, dent of marketing and communi- Venture capital funding fell place metal parts with plastics, he tricity. with about 95 percent of the sub- cations, Kelly Chesney, said the from $25 million to $4 million. This said. — Amy Lane contracting work performed by event is expected to draw 300 peo- continues a trend of declining ven- The commercial truck industry West Michigan businesses. ple or more. ture capital funding in the state. In has had generally positive response Farmers facilities manager Pete — Michelle Muñoz the second quarter of 2010, fun ding Grand Haven injection molder to the standards. The rules cover Murray said one of the reasons for totaled $70 million. It fell to $40 mil- expands for ‘growth spurt’ everything from delivery vans and selecting the site was the availabil- lion in the third quarter. school buses to large semitrailer ity and skill level of workers in UM-Dearborn Innovation Index The percentage of innovation GRAND HAVEN — An injection- trucks, with improvement targets Kent County. The company em- slips in 1st quarter workers in the state fell from 4.9 molding company plans $4 million of 10 percent to 15 percent. ploys more than 2,250 on the cam- percent to 4.5 percent, lowering worth of new equipment for a “sig- The federal government esti- pus, making Farmers one of West The Innovation Index compiled the index 0.6 points. nificant growth spurt” it expects in mates improvements on fuel effi- Michigan’s top employers. by the Center for Innovation Re- The index’s gross job creation the second half of the year. ciency for those vehicles could Farmers Insurance, a sub- search at the University of Michigan- numbers are always one quarter Grand Haven Custom Molding LLC lead to $50 billion in fuel cost sav- sidiary of the Zurich Financial Ser- Dearborn fell in the first quarter of behind. The third quarter of 2010 opened in 2010 in the West Michi- ings for fleet operators. vices Group in Zurich, is the third- the year from the final three saw 217,000 gross jobs created, gan city. Owner Karl Chapel is the compared with fourth-quarter son of Al Chapel, who founded in- gross job creation of 207,000. jection molder Grand Haven Plastics The two indicators that boosted in 1983. Karl Chapel was vice presi- the index were incorporation and dent and general manager of that filings for limited-liability compa- company before launching the new nies and trademark applications. business in an industrial building. — Michelle Muñoz In paperwork filed with the city requesting a tax break, Chapel said the company expects to grow from DTE to buy $485 million worth annual sales of $4.5 million to a $30 of energy from Thumb wind farm million operation by 2013. Grand Haven Custom Molding also ex- State regulators have approved a pects to have 65 full-time employ- $485 million DTE Energy Co. contract See Next Page
Leaders in the Making Today, more than ever, global competition and corporate streamlining require innovative thinking and leadership abilities. Continuing your education can be key to ensuring your success. From biomedical engineering to health information technology management, Lawrence Technological University offers innovative degrees and fast-track certificate programs to prepare you for the jobs of the future.
Waive your application fee at www.ltu.edu/applyfree
01 01 1 Explore over 100 undergraduate, master’s, and doctoral 2 1 2 2 20 2 AMERICA’S BEST BEST COLLEGES MILITARY programs in Colleges of Architecture and Design, UNIVERSITIES in the Midwest FRIENDLY U.S. News & Princeton SCHOOL Arts and Sciences, Engineering, and Management. World Report® Review® G.I. Jobs®
Lawrence Technological University | 21000 West Ten Mile Road, Southfield, MI 48075-1058 | 800.225.5588 | [email protected] | www.ltu.edu 20110912-NEWS--0017-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/8/2011 4:30 PM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 17 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS MICHIGAN BRIEFS Presented by From Previous Page sued official notice that the current tegrated photovoltaic application. ees with the expansion, compared funding system must be changed. Ⅲ UM was awarded $1.5 million with 15 now. The City Council ap- Said Kurt Weiss, public informa- for an organic photovoltaic tech- proved an industrial facility tax ex- tion officer for the state budget of- nology. 4FQUFNCFS emption, which will reduce the fice: “While we have not received The SunShot Initiative has dis- QNoQN company’s taxes for 12 years. any formal notice in writing, we bursed $59 million since 2007 to en- .46,FMMPHH)PUFM$POGFSFODF — Plastics News have had verbal conversations courage a widespread adoption of with the federal government indi- solar energy systems. This year $FOUFS &BTU-BOTJOH Legislature passes cating that we can expect a formal Michigan received the third-largest notice.” dollar amount out of 50 states. health care claims tax — Amy Lane The goal of the SunShot Initia- Michigan in 2050 A new 1 percent tax on paid tive is to make solar energy more Joel Kotkin health care claims, designed to 3 state firms, UM get solar economical. It seeks to lower the Author of THE NEXT HUNDRED MILLION: generate about $1.2 billion in fund- costs of solar energy systems 75 America in 2050 ing for the state Medicaid pro- energy grants totaling $16.5M percent by the end of the decade. gram, is on its way for Gov. Rick Three Michigan businesses and — Michelle Muñoz Internationally-recognized speaker and writer Joel Kotkin Snyder’s expected signature. the University of Michigan in Ann will examine Michigan’s future economy and demography The Legislature last month gave Arbor have been awarded grants Whirlpool loses bid for U.S. including changes to our state’s population, its cities and small final approval to the tax, the biggest totaling more than $16.5 million communities, and the opportunities for new jobs and industries unfinished piece of the state budget from the U.S. Department of Energy’s duties on Korean refrigerators as America reaches new heights in the coming decades. that starts Oct. 1. It would be paid Office of Energy Efficiency and Renew- The U.S. Department of Commerce by health insurers, including self- able Energy. rejected a bid by Benton Harbor- funded employer plans, and third The projects included in the de- based Whirlpool Corp. for counter- party administrators. Annual Dinner partment’s SunShot Initiative must vailing duties on imports of cer- It is targeted to generate about Al Sharpton and Pat Buchanan improve the materials, manufac- tain refrigerators from South $400 million, which would lever- turing processes and supply chains Korea, saying the Asian producers Debate the Big Issues age an additional $800 million in received minimal subsidies. federal matching funds. of solar energy systems. Political analysts and former Presidential Candidates Sharpton Countervailing duties are meant The new tax in Senate Bill 348 The following received SunShot to offset government subsidies pro- and Buchanan share their thoughts on national issues and their replaces a 6 percent use tax on grants: vided to a manufacturer. impact on Michigan. Topics include an outlook on the 2012 Medicaid health maintenance or- Ⅲ Cascade Engineering Inc. of Samsung Electronics Co., LG Elec- national elections and Michigan’s congressional candidates. ganizations. Federal officials are Grand Rapids, $602,623 for a rack- tronics Inc. and Seoul-based Daewoo expected to no longer allow the use ing system for commercial roof- Electronics Corp. received aid worth tax as a mechanism to receive fed- tops that uses polymers. “below 1 percent overall” of the Register at www.michamber.com/futureforum eral Medicaid matching dollars. Ⅲ Raymond Tinnerman Manufactur- But in a statement, House Demo- ing of Rochester Hills, $1.67 mil- product’s price, below the thresh- .JDIJHBO$IBNCFS'PVOEBUJPOt48BMOVU4U -BOTJOH .* cratic Leader Richard Hammel, D- lion for a bracket system for com- old for the imposition of tariffs, the tXXXNJDIBNCFSDPN Mt. Morris Township, said the mercial rooftop installations. International Trade Administration claims tax was not needed because Ⅲ Midland-based Dow Chemical said last month. the federal government has not is- Co., $12.8 million for a building-in- The ruling is a preliminary de- termination, and the Commerce Department is to make its final de- cision by Jan. 9. South Korean companies sent refrigerators val- ued at $881 million to the U.S. in 2010, according to the department. Whirlpool said it wasn’t sur- prised because the Asian nation’s producers resisted answering U.S. investigators’ questions. — Bloomberg News July brings higher jobless rates, but nothing like years past LANSING — It used to be that July brought significant layoffs be- “Clarkston State Bank is one of cause of shutdowns and retooling in the first banks in Michigan to the auto industry. But for a second year, revamped automaker produc- recapitalize on its own. tion has meant fewer July layoffs in Michigan manufacturing. Their local board members stayed committed to Seasonally unadjusted manufac- their community and mission in the toughest of turing jobs dropped 11,000 from June to July, but that was well be- economic times.” low the retooling-related layoffs of MICHIGAN REPRESENTATIVE MARTY KNOLLENBERG (R) nearly 35,000 that occurred in past Standing Committee Chair for Banking and Financial Services Julys at automakers and suppliers. Overall, seasonally unadjusted unemployment rates rose in 14 of eadership is exactly what’s behind Clarkston State Bank’s success Michigan’s 17 major labor market L in the face of a crushing economic climate and bailouts. CEO Grant areas in July. The largest increases Smith and the bank’s board made some tough calls. The bank survived were in the Detroit metropolitan and will be here to serve the community for many years to come. statistical area, up 1.6 percentage points; the Flint MSA, up 1 percent- age point; and the Battle Creek and Monroe MSAs, each up 0.7 points. Minor rate declines of 0.1 percent- age point occurred in the Holland MSA, northwest lower Michigan That’s strength. That’s leadership. and the Upper Peninsula MSA. And that’s why more people are banking on Clarkston State Bank. Compared with a year ago, un- Main Office Clarkston Waterford Sashabaw employment rates in most regions 15 S. Main St. 5800 S. Main St. 6600 Highland Rd. 6461 Sashabaw Rd. throughout the state remained sig- Clarkston 48346 Clarkston 48346 Suite 2 Clarkston 48346 (248) 625-8585 (248) 922-6970 Waterford 48327 (248) 625-0887 nificantly lower. Sixteen of the 17 (248) 886-0086 regions posted year-over-year rate declines of 1.6 percentage points or www.clarkstonstatebank.com more, with a median reduction of 2.1 percentage points. — Amy Lane 20110912-NEWS--0018-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/8/2011 4:01 PM Page 1
Page 18 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Success is in the cards for nonprofit that employs disabled
BY HOWARD LOVY can see what we do, they fall in really green.” State Farm, plus Paperworks has SPECIAL TO CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS love with us,” Lewis said. “Social Initially, Burns said, she was seen “big growth in retail and in- Social media is an media is an integral part of our unsure what baabaazuzu’s cus- dividual orders,” Lewis said. In a nondescript commercial “ ‘falling in love strategy.’ ” tomers would think about the com- Lauren Lawson, media rela- park near Cherry Capital Airport in integral part of our What does Lee get out of the pany’s hawking Paperworks’ tions manager at the national of- otherwise scenic Traverse City, partnership? cards. But her customers expect fice of Goodwill Industries Interna- workers with disabilities trans- ‘falling in love First, it’s a great way to build re- products that are handmade, tional, said revenue from local form bits of flowers, blue jeans — lationships with customers and unique and recycled, so Paper- Goodwill initiatives such as Pa- even hops for beer and coffee strategy.’ partners using social media, said works appears to perworks is key grounds — into handcrafted sta- ” Nancy White, Lee’s manager of be a good fit. to the organiza- tionery. Brian Lewis, marketing communications. So far, word tion’s survival. Scrap by scrap, the employees at Paperworks Studio Second, it helps Lee maintain its has spread via “Unlike oth- Paperworks Studio also are building sustainability goals by eliminat- social media, er nonprofits, a livelihood in a job market that is sales from last year. Next year, he ing waste and finding creative and we don’t have to tough even for someone without a said, the company forecasts 300,000 ways to reuse its denim scraps. baabaazuzu’s fundraise be- disability. cards sold at the same price, “When we first heard about it, customers cause our busi- Brian Lewis, Paperworks’ di- “though it wouldn’t surprise us if we thought it was a great way to seem eager to ness model is rector of sales and business devel- we grew faster,” he said. recycle the denim,” White said. get their cards. based on online opment, thinks they are building Lewis pointed to Paperworks “But then when we heard that Pa- “We’re real- sales and unique what will become a multimillion- Studio’s first national partner: Lee perworks Studio employs special- ly excited to business models dollar company as it partners Jeans. Kansas-based Lee supplies needs employees, we were really be working like Paperworks,” with major corporations world- scraps of denim that the workers inspired by that.” with these Lawson said. “So wide. turn into cards. Another natural partnership guys, and I’m revenue is key, In the past seven months, this The partnership with Lee is a Lewis points to is one with really excit- and it’s really 180-worker nonprofit — which be- testament to the strength of social baabaazuzu, based in Lake Lee- ed about what funds our job- came a program run by Goodwill In- media. Lee found out about Paper- lanau on the pinkie of Michigan’s where it training and sup- dustries of Northern Michigan three work’s plans for blue jean cards mitten. Baabaazuzu supplies cloth- might take port programs. years ago — has pursued an ag- when the Traverse City company ing to around 900 retailers across us,” Burns said. “Goodwill wants gressive plan to go national “friended” Lee on Facebook. the country. The clothing itself is Lewis said the to be unique and through partnerships with corpo- Lewis launched the social media made from scraps of larger items most popular cards A Facebook friendship find different ways rations and businesses that share campaign shortly after he began at that ordinarily would just be are holiday cards helped Paperworks Studio in to fund the mission, Paperworks’ vision of creating Paperworks, to spread the news tossed out. and cards made Traverse City partner with Lee and Paperworks is jobs for people with disabilities by about what it is doing and to at- “A lot of our product is byprod- from scraps of blue Jeans get denim scraps to just one example of crafting green products from tract potential partners. Paper- uct of larger pieces in our line,” jeans and coffee use in making cards like this. being able to do scraps that otherwise would be works has a social media coordina- said baabaazuzu founder and lead grounds, followed that. They’re mak- thrown away. tor who also puts together videos designer Sue Burns. So giving the by tie-dyed patterns and the ing products and they’re making a Lewis said Paperworks sold to post on YouTube. smallest scraps to Paperworks baabaazuzu cards. Companies difference in someone’s life at the more than 150,000 cards in the past “We knew from the experience “is really getting down there as that have ordered the cards in- same time.” year at around $2 per card, double of giving tours that when people far as using our scraps, so it’s clude Merrill Lynch, Yoplait and As for those employees, Kim Henderson, who is in charge of hir- ing at Paperworks, said she looks for somebody who can come in, have a sense of humor and “just love what they’re doing.” “Just because they’re disadvan- Make an Executive Decision. taged and disabled doesn’t mean that they can get away with any and everything,” Henderson said. “This is a place of employment. Choose Sommers Schwartz This is your job. You are treated here just like you would be in a fac- To Protect your career tory, in a grocery store. We expect the same things.” Lawson at the national office and your Family said that Goodwill International perhaps will want to expand the Paperworks concept, “but I don’t know if we’re at that point yet.” Decisions… decisions. This does not deter Lewis from making big plans. He said he Choosing the right law firm to handle your wants other production opera- employment law dispute can be difficult. Fortunately, tions around the country to do we at Sommers Schwartz can make your choice much easier. what the Traverse City workshop Why? Simple. We offer you our vast experience with both does. business and individual cases, handle a diverse clientele, The goal is to “be a multimillion- dollar greeting card company, ab- resolve cases quickly, customize fee arrangements and offer solutely,” Lewis said. you the clout of a big law firm combined with highly Paperworks began with Tra- personalized service. verse City teacher Tim Coffey, who started it to help children So make an executive decision. Choose Sommers Schwartz with special needs build self- for all your employment law needs. esteem and become more indepen- dent after they left school. The big push to go national can be traced to Lewis’ involvement. The former owner of Sleeping Bear Press in Chelsea sold the publish- ing company in 2002 and decided to move north and try something new. “Many entrepreneurial aspects of business have applied here,” yhd/s ^WZd/KE /^Whd^ ͻ /^Z/D/Ed/KE ͻ ,Z^^DEd ͻ KsZd/D >/D^ ͻ t,/^d>ͳ>KtZ Lewis said. “I also believe that if you are passionate about what you SOMMERS SCHWARTZ | 248-415-3205 | 1-800-285-0048 | 2000 Town Center, Suite 900, Southfield, MI 48075 do, it has a big impact on your suc- www.sommerspc.com cess. It is impossible not to be pas- sionate about Paperworks Studio and the talented people who make our beautiful cards.” 20110912-NEWS--0019-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/8/2011 4:05 PM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 19
CRAIN'S LIST: LARGEST OUTSTATE PUBLICLY HELD COMPANIES Ranked by 2010 revenue
Company; fiscal year end Revenue Revenue Net income Exchange/ Stock price Phone; website ($000,000) ($000,000) Percent ($000,000) Ticker 52-week Rank Location Top executive 2010 2009 change 2010/2009 symbol high/low Type of industry Dow Chemical Co., (12/2010) Andrew Liveris $53,674.0 $44,875.0 19.6% $2,321.0 NYSE 26.95 Chemical manufacturer 1. (989) 636-1000; www.dow.com chairman, president and CEO $648.0 DOW 26.53 Midland Whirlpool Corp., (12/2010) Jeff Fettig 18,366.0 17,099.0 7.4 619.0 NYSE 56.60 Home appliance 2. (269) 923-5000; whirlpool.com chairman and CEO 328.0 WHR 54.94 manufacturer and sales Benton Harbor Kellogg Co., (01/2011) John Bryant 12,397.0 12,575.0 -1.4 1,247.0 NYSE 54.50 Food processing 3. (269) 961-2000; www.kelloggcompany.com president and CEO 1,212.0 K 54.01 Battle Creek Stryker Corp., (12/2010) Stephen MacMillan 7,320.0 6,723.1 8.9 1,273.4 NYSE 49.44 Medical technology 4. (269) 385-2600; www.stryker.com chairman of the board, president 1,107.4 SYK 48.73 Kalamazoo and CEO CMS Energy Corp., (12/2010) John Russell 6,432.0 6,205.0 3.7 340.0 NYSE 19.41 Utility 5. (517) 788-0550; www.cmsenergy.com president and CEO 229.0 CMS 19.14 Jackson Perrigo Co., (06/2011) Joseph Papa 2,755.0 2,268.2 21.5 339.2 Nasdaq 92.79 Pharmaceuticals 6. (269) 673-8451; www.perrigo.com chairman, president and CEO 223.8 PRGO 91.66 Allegan Spartan Stores Inc., (03/2011) Dennis Eidson 2,533.1 2,552.0 -0.7 32.3 NASDAQ 15.84 Grocery retail 7. (616) 878-2000; www.spartanstores.com president and CEO 25.6 SPTN 15.74 Grand Rapids Steelcase Inc., (02/2011) James Hackett 2,437.1 2,291.7 6.3 20.4 NYSE 7.53 Office furniture 8. (616) 247-2710; www.steelcase.com president and CEO (13.6) SCS 7.40 Grand Rapids Universal Forest Products Inc., (12/2010) Matthew Missad 1,890.9 1,673.0 13.0 17.4 NASDAQ 28.99 Wood and wood-alternative 9. (800) 598-9663; www.ufpi.com CEO 24.3 UFPI 28.03 products Grand Rapids Herman Miller Inc., (05/2011) Brian Walker 1,649.2 1,630.0 1.2 70.8 NASDAQ 19.34 Furniture manufacturing and 10. (616) 654-3000; www.hermanmiller.com president and CEO 68.0 MLHR 18.84 interior systems design Zeeland Wolverine World Wide Inc., (01/2011) Blake Krueger 1,248.5 1,101.1 13.4 104.5 NYSE 36.01 Footwear manufacturer 11. (616) 866-5500; www.wolverineworldwide.com chairman, president and CEO 61.9 WWW 35.44 Rockford La-Z-Boy Inc., (04/2011) Kurt Darrow 1,187.1 1,179.2 0.7 24.0 NYSE 8.43 Home furniture 12. (734) 242-1444; www.la-z-boy.com president and CEO 32.7 LZB 8.13 manufacturer Monroe
This is a list of publicly held companies outside of Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, Washtenaw and Livingston counties. 52-week highs and lows for period ending Aug. 31, 2011. LIST RESEARCHED BY BRIANNA REILLY
WeW hear you, Pata . Which is the reason Priorityt Heaaltth offerss flexe ibblee funndid ngng opoptit ono s and a fuulll range of plana s to meeet yoour buddgeget.t Pluus wew ’ve exxpap ndnded ouour wewellnen ss planss so you’’ll havve healththieer ememplp oyyeeees—s—annd a heala thier bob tttom linne. For more innformation, conntacct youour locacal inndedependdent agene t or visitt us at prriorityheallth.com. Share your ideas for immprovinng heh alth care at abete terhr eae ltl hph lalan.oro g. 20110912-NEWS--0020-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/8/2011 3:59 PM Page 1
Page 20 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS September 12, 2011
CRAIN’S HOSTS WORKSHOP ABOUT PURE MICHIGAN CONNECT Companies interested in learning hear from leading private-sector more about the Pure Michigan purchasing managers on how to get Meet with Connect plan to create more into their vendor systems and procurement participate in opportunities for in- roundtables with buyers companies all state businesses will from the companies or have access to top industries they choose. purchasing managers at The event will feature over the world an upcoming Crain’s speakers Jeff Brownlee, event. purchasing director for the state of Crain’s is hosting Buy Michigan, Michigan; John Eley Jr., senior before your a Second Stage workshop, on Sept. supply chain manager for DTE 22. The event is planned in Energy Co.; Mike Finney, president partnership with the Small Business and CEO of MEDC; Brian Smith, competition Association of Michigan and the president of the Institute for Supply Michigan Economic Development Management; and Cynthia Kay, Corp. Huntington Bank is the title owner and president of Cynthia Kay boards the plane. sponsor. and Co. Participants at the 7:30-11:30 Tickets purchased in advance a.m. session at the MSU are $35 each, $30 for groups of 10 Management Education Center in or more, or $40 at the door. Troy can learn how the Pure For more information, visit Michigan Connect program works, www.crainsdetroit.com/events.
To learn how Automation Alley CRAIN’S HOSTS ANNUAL HOUSE PARTY SEPT. 28 can help you expand your Those interested in residential apartments, followed by a living in Detroit can get a taste later combined afterglow party. The business globally, contact us this month with the Crain’s House afterglow will be held at The at www.automationalley.com Party. Roostertail. Last Crain’s Detroit year’s party attracted or call 1-800-427-5100. Business and more than 1,000 sponsors including the attendees.Tickets to Michigan State the Sept. 28 event are Housing and $60 each, $50 for Development Authority throw the groups of 20 or more. annual event consisting of 29 See www.crainsdetroit.com cocktail parties at historic Detroit /events for more information or to homes, lofts, condominiums and register. 20110912-NEWS--0021-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/8/2011 4:55 PM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 21
Monthly India WHERE MICHIGAN DOES BUSINESS
Federal-Mogul Corp. elcome to the fourth when accounting for pur- Based: Southfield edition of Crain’s chasing power parity — is ex- AROUND THE WORLD W monthly World pected to cross the $4 trillion India operations: A corporate office in Each World Watch Watch report, which exam- mark this year. New Delhi New Delhi, four regional aftermarket of- Monthly will feature a Manesar Gurgaon NEPAL fices, 17 aftermarket distribution centers ines how Michigan compa- India has 10 of the 30 different country. If you Bhiwadi across India and seven manufacturing facil- nies are going global with fastest-growing urban areas know of a Michigan ities including two in Bangalore, two in Bhi- manufacturing, research and in the world and is growing company that exports, INDIA wadi, one in Parwanoo, one in Patiala and other operations. the high-tech and industrial manufactures abroad Vadodara Kolkata one in Uttarakhand. World Watch showcases portions of its economy, or has facilities abroad, Ankleshwar email Jennette Smith, Mumbai BANGLADESH Employees: 6,660 Michigan companies that are which traditionally has been Talegaon deputy managing Chakan Products: Pistons and piston rings, already international busi- dominated by agriculture. Dabhade Pune editor, at Hyderabad ness leaders in growing glob- Examples of major indus- spark plugs, engine bearings, valve seats [email protected]. and guides. al markets — and those that tries include telecommunica- Upcoming reports: are expanding operations. tions, textiles, chemicals, Bangalore Industries served: Automotive, heavy- October: Great Chennai duty vehicles, motorcycles, railway, indus- This month’s report cen- food processing, pharmaceu- Britain Maraimalai Nagar ters on India, a big world ticals steel, transportation Puducherry trial, energy and power generation. November: Israel economy growing at hyper equipment, mining, petrole- Top executive: Jean de Montlaur, presi- December: Canada dent and managing director of India opera- speed. The GDP for 2010 was um, machinery, and IT - tions. $1.53 trillion, but GDP — based services. More information: Building a brake ma- India operations: TI India operates as two terial manufacturing plant in Chennai legal entities, Bundy India Ltd. and Hanil Tube and Tavera for sale nationwide. More information: Kellogg India prod- scheduled to begin operations by the end of India Private Ltd., and has a corporate office Top executive: Karl Slym, president and ucts are exported to Sri Lanka, Nepal, this year. and facility in Manesar and facilities in managing director, GM India. Bangladesh, Bhutan and Maldives. Chennai, Vadodara and Bangalore. More information: GM and its Chinese Employees: 641 Ford Motor Co. partner Shanghai Automotive Industry Corp. Products: Brake and fuel components, are expected to begin selling minivans un- Perrigo Co. Based: Dearborn high pressure diesel components, com- der the Chevrolet brand in India by 2012. Based: Allegan India operations: Ford India Private Ltd. pressed natural gas and liquefied petrole- India operations: The over-the-counter has an assembly plant and an engine plant um gas parts and plastic fuel tanks and pharmaceutical producer acquired an 85 per- in Maraimalai Nagar and 190 sales and ser- tubes. cent stake in Mumbai-based Vedants Drugs vice offices in 109 cities. Top executive: T. Ravi Babu, managing and Fine Chemicals in August 2009. Perrigo Employees: More than 10,000 director. plans to make India a major global produc- Products: The Ford Fusion, Ikon, Figo, More information: Plans to open a facili- tion base for the company and is converting Fiesta, Endeavour and diesel engines. ty in Chennai to support Nissan India plat- the Vedants facility in Hyderabad to be on- Top executive: Michael Boneham, presi- forms and set up operations for supply of One of IAC India’s two plants in Chakan. line and begin production by the end of 2011. dent and managing director, Ford India. engine parts. Employees:50 More information: Ford India is invest- Products: Certain specialty active phar- ing about $1 billion to build two new manu- International Automotive maceutical ingredients as well as prescrip- Visteon Corp. facturing fa- Components Group tion and future prescription to over-the- cilities in Based: Van Buren Township counter products. western In- Based: Southfield India operations: One manufacturing Top executive: Joseph Papa, chief execu- dia in Gu- India operations: IAC India engineers and plant in Bhiwadi, one in Chennai and two tive and chairman, Perrigo Co. jarat for manufactures interior and exterior compo- in Pune; operates a technical and services stamping, nents for passenger vehicles and heavy center in Chennai and a major engineer- body, paint trucks around the globe. Its engineering Stryker Corp. ing center in Pune. Visteon offers products and vehicle and regional headquarters is in Pune; two to India-based and global vehicle manufac- assembly plants are in Chakan and one in Manesar, Based: Kalamazoo turers and engineering support and soft- and machin- New Delhi. India operations: Medical technology ware for domestic and global product pro- Checkpoint at the end of the line company Stryker India Private Ltd. has a sales grams. in Ford India’s assembly plant. ing and en- Employees: About 500 gine assem- Products: Components including instru- and marketing presence in India, with sales Employees: 3,000 bly. The facilities will employ close to 5,000 ment panel assemblies, glove box assem- offices in New Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai and Products: Heating, ventilation and air people. Ford India also will invest $72 mil- blies, front grills, doors, door trim, floor Kolkata. Stryker established the Stryker conditioning systems, powertrain cooling lion to expand its engine plant in Chennai consoles, mud guards, wiper panels, aero Global Technology Centre in Gurgaon in systems and controls, air induction sys- to support its sales and export growth plans corners, wheel liners, foot steps and wind- 2006 to help accelerate global innovation. tems, exhaust gas recirculation coolers, au- in India. shield access handles. The company’s presence in India is in re- dio and infotainment, control panels, in- Industries served: Automotive search and development and sales. strument panels, cockpit modules, and front Top executive: Gajanan Gandhe, senior Employees: 400 and rear lighting products. General Motors Co. vice president of Asia. Industries served: Medical Customers: Hyundai Motor Co., Maruti Based: Detroit More information: In January, IAC ac- Top executive: Yashdeep Kumar, manag- Suzuki, Ford Motor Co., Tata Motors Ltd., Mahin- India operations: General Motors India has quired Manesar-based Multivac India Private ing director, India dra & Mahindra Ltd., General Motors Co. and Ltd., a supplier of vehicle headliners, instru- Volkswagen. 209 sales points and 205 service outlets in 178 cities across India. It has a vehicle man- ment panels, interior trim and door panels Synova Inc. Top executive: A. “Vish” Viswanathan, ufacturing facility in Talegaon Dabhade for to vehicle manufacturers. In March, IAC managing director, India operations. Group opened its second manufacturing fa- Based: Southfield the Chevrolet Spark and Beat, cility in Chakan. India operations: Headquartered in Elec- Whirlpool Corp. a vehicle manu- tronic City, Bangalore, Synova Innovative facturing facili- Kellogg Co. Technologies Private Ltd. provides informa- Based: Benton Harbor ty in Halol, and tion technology and software services with India operations: Three plants, including a powertrain Based: Battle Creek offices in Chennai, Gurgaon, Hyderabad, a washer plant in Puducherry and a refrig- plant in Tale- India operations: Kellogg India produces Noida, Pune and Kolkata. erator plant in Faridabad, a corporate office gaon Dabhade and markets several cereal products in In- Employees: 750 in Gurgaon, 21 sales offices and one global Installing glass at GM dia with one manufacturing facility in Talo- Services: Staff augmentation, resource technology center. that produces India’s Talegaon Dabhade ja, an office in Mumbai and sales offices in requirement fulfillment, virtual staffing, Employees: 2,350 engines for plant. small passenger New Delhi, Kolkata and Chennai. multiple location fulfillment and project Products: Refrigerators, washing ma- cars. GM India also has a technical center Employees: 2,500 employees in all of management. chines, air conditioners, microwaves and in Bangalore that houses engineering, de- Asia Pacific region. Industries served: Finance, government, water purifiers. sign and R&D activities, a corporate office Products: Special K, All-Bran Wheat technology, automotive and health care. Top executive: Arvind Uppal, president, in Gurgaon and regional offices in Gurgaon, Flakes, Corn Flakes, Extra Muesli and Hon- Top executive: Tim Manney, president. Asia South and Asia Pacific and chairman Mumbai, Chennai and Kolkata. ey Loops. and managing director, India. Employees: 4,000 Top executive: Paul Norman, president, TI Automotive Ltd. More information: Exports about 200,000 Products: The Chevrolet Spark, Beat, Kellogg International; and Sangeeta Pen- units from India annually. Captiva, Optra, Cruze, Aveo, Aveo U-VA, durkar, managing director, India. Based: Auburn Hills — Ellen Mitchell DBpageAD.qxp 3/17/2011 10:31 AM Page 1 20110912-NEWS--0023-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/8/2011 3:58 PM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 23
CRAIN'S LIST: LARGEST WOMAN-OWNED BUSINESSES Ranked by 2010 revenue
Company Revenue Revenue Local Local Percent Address ($000,000) ($000,000) Percent employees employees woman- Rank Phone; website Majority owner 2010 2009 change Jan. 2011 Jan. 2010 owned Type of business RKA Petroleum Cos. Inc. Kay Albertie $492.6 $406.7 21% 83 82 100% Petroleum wholesaler, biodiesel, ethanol, E-85, jet A and 28340 Wick Road, Romulus 48174 majority jet A1 products 1. (734) 946-2199; www.rkapetroleum.com shareholder
Detroit Entertainment LLC (MotorCity Casino- Marian Ilitch 446.4 445.8 0 2,040 2,087 100 Casino, hotel, dining and theater Hotel) owner 2. 2901 Grand River Ave., Detroit 48201 (313) 237-1589; www.motorcitycasino.com
Troy Motors Inc. (Elder Automotive Group) Irma Elder 376.6 296.7 27 300 247 100 Automobile dealerships 777 John R Road, Troy 48084 CEO 3. (248) 585-4000; www.elderautomotivegroup.com
Strategic Staffing Solutions Inc. Cynthia Pasky 205.0 171.0 20 497 250 74 Pprovides consulting and staff augmentation services, 645 Griswold St., Suite 2900, Detroit 48226 president and vendor management programs, executive search 4. (313) 596-6900; www.strategicstaff.com CEO services, call center technology and a Detroit-based IT development center
Rush Trucking Corp. Andra Rush 100.0 90.0 11 311 316 100 Motor carrier 38500 Van Born Road, Wayne 48184 chairman and 5. (734) 641-4354; www.rushtrucking.com CEO
Vendor Managed Solutions Inc. Rumia Ambrose- 89.5 85.0 5 65 NA 100 Integrated maintenance, repair, and operations and 850 Stephenson Highway, Suite 600, Troy 48083 Burbank vendor management services, procurement, supply chain 6. (248) 658-4600; www.vmsglobal.com president
Iconma LLC. Claudine George 88.6 53.2 67 28 NA 100 Professional staffing and project-based services 850 Stephenson Highway, Troy 48083 managing 7. (888) 451-2519 member and CEO
Technical Training Inc. (TTi Global) Shirley Brzezinski 63.5 45.0 41 163 120 100 Staffing, outsourcing and training 2750 Product Drive, Rochester Hills 48309 shareholder 8. (248) 853-5550; www.ttinao.com
Unibar Services Inc. G. Jean Davis 60.0 55.0 9 400 NA 81 Utility support and meter services, damage prevention, 4325 Concourse Drive, Ann Arbor 48108 president and facilities locating and asset protection 9. (734) 769-2600; www.unibarinc.com CEO
Rodgers Chevrolet Inc. Pamela Rodgers 54.2 40.0 35 62 57 85 Automobile dealership 23755 Allen Road, Woodhaven 48183 president 10. (734) 676-9600; www.rodgerschevrolet.com
Motor City Stampings Inc. Judy Kucway 49.0 32.0 53 260 175 NA Stamping plant; automotive welding, assembly, dies and 47783 N. Gratiot Ave., Chesterfield Township 48051 CEO and CFO prototypes 11. (586) 949-8420; www.mcstamp.com
G-Tech Services Inc. Mara Ghafari 43.4 31.6 37 435 340 100 Recruitment and placement of engineers, technical 17101 Michigan Ave., Dearborn 48126 chairman and support, information technology, and finance and 12. (313) 441-3600; www.gogtech.com corporate counsel accounting professionals on a contract and direct-hire basis
Wolverine Truck Sales Inc. Lynn Terry 40.4 36.0 12 99 97 100 Truck sales, parts and service 3550 Wyoming Ave., Dearborn 48120 president 13. (313) 849-0800; www.wolverinetruckgroup.com
Systrand Manufacturing Corp. Sharon Cannarsa 40.0 27.5 45 113 163 100 Precision machining and assembly of automotive 19050 Allen Road, Brownstown Township 48183 president and products 14. (734) 479-8100; www.systrand.com CEO
Mars Advertising Inc. Marilyn Barnett 35.5 34.3 4 348 335 50 Advertising agency 25200 Telegraph Road, Fifth Floor, Southfield 48033-7496 president and 15. (248) 936-2267; www.marsusa.com chairman of the board
Rapid Global Business Solutions Inc. Bati Devi 35.5 18.5 92 624 295 80 Engineering design, staff augmentation, vendor 31791 Sherman Drive, Madison Heights 48071 chairman management services, payroll 15. (248) 589-1135; www.rgbsi.com
Jawood Holding Inc. Lynn Mustazza 35.5 30.7 16 344 204 70 Information-technology consulting and staffing 32270 Telegraph Road, Suite 200, Bingham Farms 48025 president and 15. (248) 833-8000; www.jawood.com CEO
Seko Worldwide Detroit Tanya Bartelo 31.0 28.1 10 22 25 51 Global logistics provider, including air, ocean and 6800 S. Cypress, Romulus 48174 owner and domestic transportation, as well as customs brokerage 18. (734) 641-2100; www.sekologistics.com/detroit managing director services and export crating
The WW Group Inc. (Weight Watchers) Florine Mark 25.0 25.0 0 850 850 60 Weight-loss products and services 28555 Orchard Lake Road, Farmington Hills 48334 chairman and 19. (248) 553-8555; www.8883florine.com president www.florineonline.com
ASG Renaissance LLC Lizabeth Ardisana 22.9 21.3 8 227 205 51 Marketing communications, public relations, staffing, 22226 Garrison, Dearborn 48124 CEO performance management and diversity services 20. (313) 565-4700; www.asgren.com
This list of woman-owned businesses is an approximate compilation of the largest such businesses based in Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, Washtenaw and Livingston counties. It is not a complete listing but the most comprehensive available. Unless otherwise noted, the companies provided the information. Percentage of the company that is woman-owned may not be solely held by the leading shareholder. NA = not available. LIST RESEARCHED BY BRIANNA REILLY DBpageAD.qxp 9/7/2011 12:15 PM Page 1
YOUR BUSINESS FUTURE IS BUILT ON BORROWING DECISIONS YOU MAKE RIGHT ABOUT...NOW.
As a business owner, you face tough decisions every day. Like deciding if and when you should borrow. A Huntington Business banker can help.
Now is the time to reach out. At Huntington Business Banking, we take the time to understand your specific business needs and help you make borrowing decisions that are right for you. In 2010, we committed to lending $4 billion to local businesses over a three-year period, so if you decide you’re ready, we’ll be there to support you every step of the way. It’s what you’d expect from the #1 SBA lender.1
To learn more or speak with a Business Banker, stop by your local Huntington branch or call 1-866-808-8913.
1Huntington is the #1 SBA 7(a) lender in the region made up of Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, Michigan, West Virginia and Western PA. Source: U.S. SBA from October 1, 2007, through June 30, 2011.
Member FDIC. ® and Huntington® are federally registered service marks of Huntington Bancshares Incorporated. Huntington.® Welcome.™ is a service mark of Huntington Bancshares Incorporated. ©2011 Huntington Bancshares Incorporated. 20110912-NEWS--0025-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 9/8/2011 4:25 PM Page 1
September 12, 2011 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 25 Extra
People