Modeling the Point-To-Point Wireless Communication Channel Under the Adverse Weather Conditions
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IEICE TRANS. ELECTRON., VOL.E87–C, NO.9 SEPTEMBER 2004 1455 PAPER Special Section on Wave Technologies for Wireless and Optical Communications Modeling the Point-to-Point Wireless Communication Channel under the Adverse Weather Conditions Sermsak JARUWATANADILOK†a), Urachada KETPROM†, Yasuo KUGA†, Nonmembers, and Akira ISHIMARU†, Member SUMMARY Point-to-point optical and millimeter wave communica- the optical frequency range, and the common wavelengths tion has recently been of interest, especially in urban areas. Its benefits are around 0.85 µm and 1.5 µm. Therefore, fog and clouds include simpler and easier installation compared with a land-based line. ff which have particle sizes in the same range have a strong However, this technology su ers when adverse weather conditions are ff present, such as rain, fog and clouds, which induce scattering and absorp- e ect on FSO. However, for the MMW system with a wave- tion of the optical wave. The effects of scattering and absorption degrade length of few millimeters, rain will be the major problem. In the quality of the communication link resulting in increase of bit-error-rate. both cases, scattering and absorption of the wave by discrete Therefore, there exists a need for accurate channel characterization in or- particles results in deterioration of the communication link. der to understand and mitigate the problem. In this paper, radiative transfer theory is employed to study the behavior of amplitude modulated signal One of the most accurate ways to characterize wave propagating through a random medium. We show the effect of the medium propagation through random media is the exact numerical to a modulated signal and relate the outcome on the quality of the commu- solution for the radiative transfer theory. Although the ra- nication link. diative transfer theory is based on the conservation of en- key words: multiple scattering, radiative transfer theory, random media, ergy and is less strict than the solutions of the fundamental optical wave propagation, free space optics, millimeter-wave Maxwell’s equation, we are only interested in the modulated intensity (or power), and the full wave solution which is very 1. Introduction difficult to obtain is not required in our case. The ON-OFF keying imposed on a carrier frequency, such as a digitally Point-to-point optical (free space optics or FSO) and modulated optical beam, can be viewed as an amplitude millimeter-wave (MMW) communication has been of inter- modulation on carrier frequency. Because the square wave est in recent years due to the increase in demand for high- can be decomposed into Fourier components, if we solve the speed data links, especially in urban areas. FSO and MMW radiative transfer equation for different modulation frequen- links provide simple and fast installation. Both systems re- cies and combine all the frequency responses, we should be quire a line-of-sight propagation channel and are affected able to simulate the ON-OFF keying modulation. The fun- by adverse weather conditions such as fog, clouds, and rain. damental radiative transfer equation is modified to include The maximum data rate is often limited by the channel con- the frequency modulation, which we explained in details in dition. Therefore, an accurate model of the communication our previous papers [2], [3]. The frequency modulated wave channel is required in order to characterize and improve the or photon density wave has been used in several applications quality of the communication link. because it is believed to better sustain the scattering effect in The deterioration of the propagation channel can be turbid media [4], [5]. classified into two cases: (i) due to fluctuation of index of In this paper, we explain the limitation and the justi- refraction and (ii) due to volume scattering by atmospheric fication of using the radiative transfer theory for FSO and particulates. For a short distance communication link, the MMW communication channels. Then, we express the vec- dominant effect usually comes from the volume scattering tor radiative transfer equation with frequency modulation and we will focus on it in this paper. This is particularly true and obtain its solution. The numerical results for different for the MMW link. cases will be discussed. When the size parameter ka,wherek is the wave num- ber and a is a radius of the particle, is much smaller than 2. Channel Characterization Using Radiative Transfer 1, the scattering is almost isotropic, and we can apply the Theory Rayleigh approximation. On the other hand, when ka is greater than 1 which happens when the particle size be- In classical communication theory, the channel can be char- comes comparable to the wavelength, the Mie scattering so- acterized in the time domain or in the frequency domain. lution should be used [1]. FSO communication operates in In the time domain, the impulse response exhibits the time characteristic of the channel. On the other hand, in the fre- Manuscript received January 20, 2004. quency domain, the frequency response which is the Fourier Manuscript revised March 11, 2004. †The authors are with the Department of Electrical Engineer- transform of the impulse response, shows the characteristics ing, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA. of the channel as a function of frequency. For a frequency a) E-mail: [email protected] limited signal, the frequency response is a more compact IEICE TRANS. ELECTRON., VOL.E87–C, NO.9 SEPTEMBER 2004 1456 way to evaluate the channel characteristics. We want to Table 1 Particle size distribution of fog. investigate the response to an information carrying optical Diameter of Particle (µm) Number of particles wave. In this investigation, we consider the ON-OFF keying 0.4 3 modulation. We assume that the data transmitted through 0.6 10 the channel is a square wave which represents alternating 0.7 40 zero digits and one digits. The frequency spectrum of the 1.4 50 input wave is easily realized as a Fourier series with a funda- 2.0 7 mental frequency of half of the bit rate. Frequency compo- 3.6 1 nents of the input pulse is an infinite series of odd harmonics 5.4 9 of the fundamental frequency. However, at higher harmon- ics the amplitude is reduced by a factor 1/N where N is the 8.0 2 harmonic order. Therefore, we can ignore the contribution from a higher order. As a result, characterizing of the chan- nel using the ON-OFF keying signal in the frequency do- main will reduce the computational resource required and provide adequate information. To characterize the propagation channel, the scattering and absorption effect from the medium have to be accounted for. One way is to start with analytical theory involving Maxwell’s equations. This method is complete in the sense that all wave phenomena are included, but it poses a mathe- matical challenge and, in practice, is nearly impossible to solved [6]. The radiative transfer equation, on the other hand, starts with statement of energy conservation. Thus, it relaxes the rigorous mathematics which exists in Maxwell’s equations. However, it does not include some of the wave phenomenon. It also assumes there is no correlation be- tween fields. In this particular problem where only the in- Fig. 1 Size distribution of rain droplets. tensity is of consideration, radiative transfer theory can be applied to explain the behavior of the intensity of the wave propagating through a random scattering medium. rain (100 mm/hr). Figure 1 shows the volume distribution We model both the FSO and MMW channels with the for several rain rates. following assumptions. The medium is a slab of a homo- The signal is an ON-OFF keying modulation with a geneous background of air with suspended particles. The modulation frequency of 50 MHz and 500 MHz correspond- particles are assumed to be spherical water droplets. The ing to the bit rate of 100 Mbit/sec and 1 Gbit/sec. The ON- distribution of the particles throughout the slab is uniform. OFF keying signal can be decomposed in the Fourier series An important parameter indicating the randomness of the with odd harmonics with respect to the fundamental fre- medium is the optical depth τo defined by τo = ρσtL where quency. We are able to calculate the intensity of the wave L is the length of medium. In our calculation, we use at particular frequencies using the radiative transfer and re- L = 200 m. The concentration of particles ρ depends on combine them to construct the response of the input opti- the condition of the weather. This parameter should be care- cal wave. As Fig. 2 shows, the FSO signal consists of the fully considered since radiative transfer theory works only DC term and the AC term. Both have to be considered to in the case where the particles are not too dense. The total complete the reconstruction of the output signal. Each term scattering cross section of a single particle σt can be cal- creates the coherent and incoherent contribution to the sig- culated using the Mie solution with assumption of spherical nal after propagation through the medium. Therefore, there shape. are four terms that contribute to the output signal. Coherent In the FSO channel, we employ data from reference [7] components are the result of waves that are no affected by which give the distribution of fog particles in Table 1. The scattering and absorption. The amplitude of this component wavelength used in the calculation is 0.8 micron. We con- dramatically drops as a function of the optical length ρσtz sider cases of weather varying from light fog with visibility where z is the distance in meters. As a result, at the other about 1–5 km corresponding to optical depth of about 0.8 to end of the medium (z = L), the reduction is exp(−τo).