"Youth Employment Initiative" Programme 2015
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STUDY Evaluation of the impact of the European "Youth Employment Initiative" programme 2015 April 2016 Summary of the national evaluation report of the YEI This document is a synopsis of the national evaluation report of the Youth Employment Initiative in France. The Youth Employment Initiative (YEI) was set up by the European Union to combat youth Key figures unemployment and to speed up delivery of the European Youth Guarantee. This specific fund The YEI in France: receives matching funding from the European Social Fund (ESF) and is intended for Member State regions with youth unemployment rates in excess of 25%. It is intended to fund €622 million YEI + ESF initiatives to help "NEETs", young people Not in Education, Employment or Training.. In 2012, 16 territories in France qualify (13 the baseline year for YEI eligibility, the NEET rate in France was 12.5% - more than 900 000 Regions and 3 Departments) young people - and the youth unemployment rate for young people aged 15-24 was 24.5%. 1 Specific YEI National Operational 16 territories are eligible for YEI funding: 13 regions (Aquitaine, Auvergne, Centre, Programme, administered by the Champagne -Ardennes, Guadeloupe, Guyana, Upper Normandy, Languedoc-Roussillon, central government Martinique, Mayotte, Nord Pas-de-Calais, Picardy and Reunion) and 3 departments 12 multi-funded ERDF-ESF-YEI (Bouches-du-Rhône, Haute-Garonne and Seine Saint-Denis). Regional Operational Programmes, administered by the Regional France received funding of €310.2 million specifically from the YEI fund, with a matching Councils €312 million coming from the ESF This package of €622 million was split between the specific YEI National Operational Programme (70% of the funds), administered by the French General Delegation for Employment and Vocational Training (DGEFP), and 12 multi-funded ERDF-ESF-YEI Regional Operational Programmes (30% of the funds), administered by the Regional Councils of the territories qualifying for YEI funding. The specific YEI National Operational Programme also covers two components: a "central" package administered by the French General Delegation for Employment and Vocational Training (DGEFP) to fund national schemes, and a "decentralised" package managed by Direccte-Dieccte (territorial delegated management authorities). €188 million YEI -ESF funding €434 million YEI-ESF funding administered by the Regional administered by the DGEFP Councils National Regional YEI ESF YEI ESF contribution contribution €216 €218 €38 million €94 €94 ~ €70 million 58% million million million million €622 millionRegion YEI+ESF funding This study is co-financed by the European Social Fund as part of the "Youth Employment Initiative" national 1 operational programme EUROPEAN UNION Focus on the evaluation methodology This YEI evaluation is one of the statutory obligations in the area of evaluation of European funds. Throughout the programme period (2014-2020), the management authorities are actually responsible for evaluating the efficacy, efficiency and impact of their programme schemes. In France, the 13 management authorities involved in the YEI decided to join forces to produce a single study in 2015. The Delegation for Employment and Vocational Training (DGEFP) has full financial responsibility for this evaluation, while the 12 Regional Councils that manage the YEI were members of the steering committees of the study and were involved in the validation of all its stages. Given the progress of the YEI and the data available, the 2015 evaluation is a theory-based impact assessment: it must enable the intervention approach, implementation and expected impacts of the YEI in France to be analysed. This theory-based approach is complementary to the so-called "counterfactual" approach, and seeks to understand "why, how, for whom and under what conditions the YEI may have an intentional or unintentional impact". This 2015 evaluation must also contribute to the preparation of the evaluation of the YEI's impact on young people, planned for 2018. The evaluation is organised around 3 major stages: . A work preparation stage (September-October 2015), with scoping interviews at national level with the different departments of the DGEFP and national partners and operators. A first work seminar with the management authorities was held in October 2015. A "field" stage in 12 territories (October-December 2015), covered by the YEI National Operational Programme and a Regional Operational Programme. During this phase, interviews were held with the Regional Councils, regional government, and operators involved in the implementation of the YEI. A second work seminar was held in January 2016, to discuss the lessons of the evaluation and to develop recommendations. A work finalisation and deliverables preparation stage (December 2015-May 2016). A symposium in May 2016 provided the occasion for release of the evaluation results. This evaluation is based on qualitative and quantitative data collection. Interviews held at national level and in the territories were used to analyse the different approaches of the management authorities, partners and operators in the implementation of the YEI. In all, over 140 interviews took place: 74 beneficiary operators; 23 Regional Council departments or services; 26 DIRECCTE departments or services; 16 central government departments or services and 2 European Commission services. The objective elements were based primarily on data from "Ma démarche FSE" (the software used to monitor the initiatives of the national operational programme). There was, however, no reliable and consistent data source for the regional operational programmes in late 2015. The analysis of the first pathways of the young people involved Data collectionData in the YEI is highly fragmented and is mentioned for information only: YEI funded initiatives have been set up but some will not begin until 2016 and data entry in "Ma Démarche FSE" may also be subject to delay for some operations. The data in this document should therefore be interpreted with caution. More generally, as the programme schemes were only partly under way, much of the data was not yet available or was incomplete as at 31/12/2015. 2 By the end of 2015, most of the French YEI-ESF funding package was allocated To help its many young NEETs swiftly, France undertook to apply the whole YEI-ESF package allocated to it before 31 December 2015. To date, almost all the funds have allocated (84% of the French YEI-ESF package). In the national YEI operational programme, the package was quickly allocated - 94% of the central component package was allocated to major national schemes while 71% of the decentralised component package was allocated via the involvement of operators through calls for projects. However, programme progress varies from one Direccte to another: while most territories have managed to allocate the funds, some Direcctes have experienced more difficulties, because of the tight schedule, the restrictions of the IEJ funding tool (resulting in difficulties mobilising operators) and a risk of service "saturation". For the regional operational programmes, implementation is also at an advanced stage, particularly for Regions that chose to allocate all (or a significant portion) of their funding package to Regional Training Programme initiatives or other pre-existing schemes. 97% of the YEI-ESF package allocated to the Regional Councils was therefore used by the end of 2015. The majority of the YEI-ESF funding package was used for enhanced support initiatives (48% of the French package), mainly funded by the national YEI operational programme. These enhanced support measures are largely sponsored by local youth centres (Youth Guarantee and support schemes funded by Direccte), but also by community associations, local authorities, public/private industry organisations. The next largest amount was allocated to training expenses (31% of the French package), mainly funded by the Regional Councils (Regional Training Programme initiatives, qualification pathway schemes, etc.), but to an extent also by the Delegation for Employment and Vocational Training (funding of Emplois d'Avenir training at national level). The proportion of the packages assigned to initiatives for the identification of young NEETs was lower (less than 3% of the French package). Ultimately, in the French Overseas Territories, the YEI funding has mainly been for specific pathway and qualification access schemes: the French/Overseas territories school leaver support bodies. Key figures Key figures The programme of schemes of the national YEI operational programme The programme of schemes of the Central Decentralised regional operational programmes component component €182 €154 €193 million million million YEI+ESF YEI+ESF YEI+ESF €108 million (59% of the funding package) on (70% of the funding package) allocated to enhanced support initiatives €241 million Regional Training Programme initiatives €41 million (12% of the funding package) allocated to the Adapted Military Service €28 million (15% of the funding package) €29 million (8% of the funding package) on Emplois d'Avenir training allocated to "apprenticeship" type initiatives €7 million (2% of the funding package) on initiatives for the identification and support of €28 million (15% of the funding package) unqualified school leavers (enhancement of Unqualified School Leaver Monitoring and Support allocated to integrated pathway initiatives (long- Platforms) term qualification preparation schemes) €6 million (2% of the