Political Party System in Province the End of Accommodation? Roger Ouellette Commentary

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Political Party System in Province the End of Accommodation? Roger Ouellette Commentary 29 oct. 2016 – Telegraph Journal Political party system in province the end of accommodation? ROgeR Ouellette commentary In his 1963 book, Politics in New Brunswick, Hugh G. Thorburn concluded that New Brunswick had a two-party system composed of the Liberals and the Progressive Conservative party. The first could depend on the Acadian and Irish Catholic votes while the latter benefited from the massive support of the Anglo-Protestants. Jean-Guy Finn demonstrated in his political science master’s thesis for the University of Ottawa that there was an Acadian ethnic vote in New Brunswick. It was not before the 1970 election of Richard Hatfield’s Progressive Conservative government that we witnessed for the first time in the history of this province a premier from that political party actively wooing the Acadian vote that, until then, had been the preserve of the Liberal party. With the help of his francophone lieutenant, Jean-Maurice Simard, he undertook a systematic charm offensive that would be highly successful in the 1982 election. The Progressive Conservative troops made a historic breakthrough in ridings that were either predominantly or mixed francophone ridings that gave a strong majority to the government. It was by means of specific actions that Richard Hatfield’s government was able to get its candidates elected in francophone areas of the province. Among those actions mention can be made of the creation of educational and community centres in Fredericton, Saint John and Miramichi, implementing full duality in the Department of Education, followed by the adoption of Bill 88 that recognized the full equality of both official languages communities in the province. The heavy defeat of the Richard Hatfield government in 1987 after 17 years in office, but with a premier that had become highly unpopular in the wake of several scandals in his personal life, would be marked by the arrival on the political scene of CoR, an anti-bilinguism party that formed the official opposition in 1991. With a Progressive Conservative party in tatters, the francophone electorate once again gave its overwhelming support to the Liberal party. The choice of new francophone leader by the Progressive Conservative party, Bernard Lord, allowed a strong comeback to power with a healthy majority in the 1999 election. Having rebuilt unity within his party, Bernard Lord was able to recapture the votes of the francophones. The adoption of a new official languages law in 2002 that included the creation of the post of commissioner of official languages would become the hallmark the Bernard Lord government insofar as the francophone community was concerned. The 2014 election gave a small majority to the Liberal party, thanks to the large support of the francophone regions. It was the signal of a return to a party system in this province evidenced by an electoral split on a linguistic basis. Acadians and the Irish Catholics returned to the Liberal fold and the Progressive Conservative party was able to depend on its traditional electoral base, that is to say the Anglo-Protestants. The selection of a new leader of the Progressive Conservative party,a former member of CoR and a unilingual anglophone last Saturday in Fredericton, without the support of francophones, represents a setback for all those in his political party who believe in a party system that can accommodate both linguistic communities. The offhand remarks by Blaine Higgs about bilingual buses and the pointlessness of having a really bilingual paramedic service to accommodate the provincial population in both official languages revealed a leader insensitive to the fundamental rights of francophones to have access to services in their language. Contrary to what Blaine Higgs believes, to get access to essential services, such as ambulances at any time in French or in English is not a whim of the francophone community. It is not Blaine Higgs’improvised promise to become bilingual in record time for the 2018 election that will gain him the respect, and eventually the francophone votes in this province. Like Richard Hatfield and Bernard Lord, he will have to take specific actions in order to deserve the support of francophones. The Progressive Conservative party has lost all its seats in francophone areas, with the exception of Madeleine Dubé in Madawaska in the 2014 election. One is justified in thinking that Madeleine Dubé has kept her seat because of her huge personal popularity. Will Blaine Higgs be able to convince other Madeleine Dubé to climb aboard his bus in 2018? He will have to truly extend the hand of friendship to the francophone community, showing respect for duality and a bilingualism that is not mere window dressing in this province. If not, linguistic tensions only increase and our party system will become forever flawed by linguistic barriers very similar to a real wall of intolerance. Faced with the innumerable challenges that beset the province, struggling with a galloping debt, a sluggish economic growth, an aging population, we cannot afford the luxury of feeding toxic linguistic quarrels. Roger Ouellette is professor of political science and Fellow at the Donald J. Savoie institute at l’université de Moncton .
Recommended publications
  • Provincial Solidarities: a History of the New Brunswick Federation of Labour
    provincial solidarities Working Canadians: Books from the cclh Series editors: Alvin Finkel and Greg Kealey The Canadian Committee on Labour History is Canada’s organization of historians and other scholars interested in the study of the lives and struggles of working people throughout Canada’s past. Since 1976, the cclh has published Labour / Le Travail, Canada’s pre-eminent scholarly journal of labour studies. It also publishes books, now in conjunction with AU Press, that focus on the history of Canada’s working people and their organizations. The emphasis in this series is on materials that are accessible to labour audiences as well as university audiences rather than simply on scholarly studies in the labour area. This includes documentary collections, oral histories, autobiographies, biographies, and provincial and local labour movement histories with a popular bent. series titles Champagne and Meatballs: Adventures of a Canadian Communist Bert Whyte, edited and with an introduction by Larry Hannant Working People in Alberta: A History Alvin Finkel, with contributions by Jason Foster, Winston Gereluk, Jennifer Kelly and Dan Cui, James Muir, Joan Schiebelbein, Jim Selby, and Eric Strikwerda Union Power: Solidarity and Struggle in Niagara Carmela Patrias and Larry Savage The Wages of Relief: Cities and the Unemployed in Prairie Canada, 1929–39 Eric Strikwerda Provincial Solidarities: A History of the New Brunswick Federation of Labour / Solidarités provinciales: Histoire de la Fédération des travailleurs et travailleuses du Nouveau-Brunswick David Frank A History of the New Brunswick Federation of Labour david fra nk canadian committee on labour history Copyright © 2013 David Frank Published by AU Press, Athabasca University 1200, 10011 – 109 Street, Edmonton, ab t5j 3s8 isbn 978-1-927356-23-4 (print) 978-1-927356-24-1 (pdf) 978-1-927356-25-8 (epub) A volume in Working Canadians: Books from the cclh issn 1925-1831 (print) 1925-184x (digital) Cover and interior design by Natalie Olsen, Kisscut Design.
    [Show full text]
  • Print This Article
    Fixing What Ain’t Broke The New Norm of Fixed-Date Elections in Canada GRIFFYN G. CHEZENKO, Memorial University of Newfoundland Abstract. Since 2001, legislation implementing fixed dates for general elections has been passed by the federal government, and most provincial and territorial governments. The notion that general election dates are now fixed, however, is flawed. In my submission to Changing Political Landscapes, I will explore the fledgling norm of fixed date elections in Canada and examine the aspects of the legislation which call into doubt the fixedness of these elections. With a review of the literature on the subject, I begin by inquiring into the emergence of this foreign phenomenon into Canadian electoral politics and the justification for its extensive adoption. Comparing the legislation across jurisdictions, I analyze the basic construct of fixed date election legislation in Canada, survey similarities and differences, and discover how fixed dates for elections are ultimately avoidable. As a result, I find that election dates are not truly fixed in Canadian jurisdictions where fixed date election legislation has been enacted. Introduction Since the dawn of the 21st century, fixed dates for general elections in Canada have become a widely adopted norm. Bernard Lord, the former New Brunswick premier, once opined that folks “like to know when the elections are going to be” (as cited in Desserud, 2007: 204). This is a familiar concept to Canadian voters because we are inundated with information about what goes on with our southern neighbours. It is rather comforting, as Premier Lord knows, knowing when an election will be, and that there is nothing those rascally politicians can do about it.
    [Show full text]
  • New Brunswick PC Government Under Pressure from Provincial Liberals: Liberal Party Enjoys 11 Point Lead in Decided Vote, Time for a Change Sentiment at 56%
    New Brunswick PC Government under pressure from Provincial Liberals: Liberal Party enjoys 11 point lead in decided vote, time for a change sentiment at 56% Toronto – June 28, 2005 – Liberals are leading the Progressive Conservatives by 11 points among New Brunswick decided voters (46% Liberals – 35% PC – 17% NDP). Voters appear to be choosing the Liberal Party because they feel it is time for a change. Voters say they are not choosing the Progressive Conservative party because of the party’s policies (particularly healthcare) and its leader. The majority of people in New Brunswick want a change, saying that it is time to give a new person and party a chance (56%). Fifty-two per cent of the public also support a provincial election this fall to either confirm Lord’s government or elect a new one. Despite the mood for a change, PC Premier Bernard Lord enjoys a 6 point lead as Best Premier. Looking at leadership favourables, outgoing NDP leader Elizabeth Weir has the strongest favourable rating at 57%. Lord edges out Graham by 6 points in favourables, the same margin as on best Premier. However, Lord also leads in unfavourables with 38%, 21 points higher than Liberal leader Graham. A second finding that conflicts with the desire of change is the mood of the province. People in New Brunswick feel positively on the direction the province is heading. However, when it comes to issues of concern, health care, jobs and education are the most important to them personally. New Brunswick clearly appears poised for a close provincial election whenever it comes.
    [Show full text]
  • If We Could All Be Peter Lougheed” Provincial Premiers and Their Legacies, 1967-2007 1
    “If we could all be Peter Lougheed” Provincial premiers and their legacies, 1967-2007 1 J.P. Lewis Carleton University [email protected] Paper for Presentation at The Annual Meeting of the Canadian Political Science Association Concordia University, Montreal June 2010 Introduction For a variety of reasons, the careers of Canadian provincial premiers have escaped explicit academic attention. Premiers are found frequently in Canadian political science literature, but more for direct roles and actions – in questions of the constitution, federalism, public policy and electoral and legislative studies – instead of longitudinal study and analysis. This fits a pattern of neglect in the field; some academics have lamented the lack of direct attention to provincial politics and history (Brownsey and Howlett 2001). The aggregate imprints of premiers are relatively ignored outside of regional and provincial treatments. No pan- Canadian assessment of premiers exists, and probably for good reason. The theoretical and methodological concerns with asking general research questions about premiers are plenty; leadership theory and historical approaches provide some foundations but any approach is going to confront conceptual challenges. This is where this study is found – in a void of precedents but a plethora of qualitative data. 2 Regardless of methodological challenges, some historians, political scientists and members of the media have not shied away from ranking and assessing national leaders. Some of the more popular treatments (from the popular culture version to the more academic approach) include Ferguson’s Bastards and Boneheads , Granatstein and Hillmer’s Prime Ministers: Ranking Canada’s Leaders , and Bliss’s Right Honourable Men . Bliss (xiv), the esteemed historian, is skeptical of such endeavours, “While this is Canadian history from Parliament Hill, I am not a Hegelian and I do not believe that political leaders, least of all prime ministers of Canada, are personifications of the world spirit.
    [Show full text]
  • Contact List
    CONSULTING PROVINCE CONTACT PHONE/FAX/E-MAIL LOGO BRITISH COLUMBIA Encorp Pacific (Canada) Phone: (604) 473-2400 Neil Hastie Fax: (604) 473-2411 Executive Director E-mail: [email protected] 206 – 2250 Boundary Rd. Burnaby, BC V5M 3Z3 www.return-it.ca BRITISH COLUMBIA Canadian Electrical Stewardship Phone: (710) 410-5070 Association E-mail: [email protected] or Julie Robertson [email protected] Member Inquiries 1321 Blanshard St. , Suite 301 www.cesarecycling.ca Victoria, BC V8W 0B6 BRITISH COLUMBIA Product Care Association Phone: (604) 592-2972 Mark Kurschner Toll Free: 1-888-252-4621 President E-mail: [email protected] or 105 West 3rd Ave. [email protected] Vancouver, BC www.productcare.org V5Y 1E6 The Product Care Association is contracted to manage the MARR www.marrbc.ca stewardship plan in BC. ALBERTA Alberta Recycling Management Phone: (780) 990-1111 Authority Toll Free: 1-888-999-8762 Doug Wright, CEO Fax: (780) 990-1122 1310 Scotia Tower 1 Toll Free Fax: 1-866-990-1122 10060 Jasper Ave. E-mail: [email protected] www.albertarecycling.ca Edmonton, AB T5J 3R8 SASKATCHEWAN SARCAN Recycling Phone: (306) 933-0616 Kevin Acton Fax: (306) 653-3932 Director of Operations E-mail: [email protected] 111 Cardinal Crescent www.sarcan.ca Saskatoon, SK S7L 6H5 SASKATCHEWAN SWEEP/EPRA Saskatchewan Phone: (306) 781-9337 Carl Flis E-mail: [email protected] Executive Director 2366 Ave C North Saskatoon, SK www.sweepit.ca S7L 5X5 MANITOBA Electronic Products Recycling Toll Free : 1-888-527-9382 Association E-mail: [email protected] Dennis Neufeld Program Director 210 – 1600 Kenaston Blvd www.recyclemyelectroni Suite 315 cs.ca/mb Winnipeg, MB R3P 0Y4 57 CONSULTING PROVINCE CONTACT PHONE/FAX/E-MAIL LOGO ONTARIO Ontario Electronic Stewardship Phone: (416) 380-4545 Jonathan Spencer Executive Director Fax: (416) 380-4154 885 Don Mills Rd.
    [Show full text]
  • Famous New Brunswickers A
    FAMOUS NEW BRUNSWICKERS A - C James H. Ganong co-founder ganong bros. chocolate Joseph M. Augustine native leader, historian Charles Gorman speed skater Julia Catherine Beckwith author Shawn Graham former premier Richard Bedford Bennett politician, Phyllis Grant artist philanthropist Julia Catherine Hart author Andrew Blair politician Richard Hatfield politician Winnifred Blair first miss canada Sir John Douglas Hazen politician Miller Brittain artist Jack Humphrey artist Edith Butler singer, songwriter John Peters Humphrey jurist, human Dalton Camp journalist, political rights advocate strategist I - L William "Bliss" Carman poet Kenneth Cohn Irving industrialist Hermenegilde Chiasson poet, playwright George Edwin King jurist, politician Nathan Cummings founder Pierre-Amand Landry lawyer, jurist consolidated foods (sara lee) Andrew Bonar Law statesman, british D - H prime minister Samuel "Sam" De Grasse actor Arthur LeBlanc violinist, composer Gordon "Gordie" Drillon hockey player Romeo LeBlanc politician, statesman Yvon Durelle boxing champion M Sarah Emma Edmonds union army spy Antonine Maillet author, playwright Muriel McQueen Fergusson first Anna Malenfant opera singer, woman speaker of the canadian senate composer, teacher Gilbert Finn politician Louis B. Mayer producer, co-founder Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (born in Russia) Gilbert Ganong co-founder ganong bros. chocolate Harrison McCain co-founder mccain Louis Robichaud politician foods Daniel "Dan" Ross author Wallace McCain co-founder mccain foods
    [Show full text]
  • Opening Ceremonies
    Opening Ceremonies Second Session Fifty-Fifth Legislature Province of New Brunswick Thursday, December 2, 2004 3 o’clock p.m. PROCLAMATION WHEREAS I have proclaimed that the first session of the fifty-fifth Legislative Assembly of this Province be prorogued on the second day of December, 2004, in the forenoon; AND WHEREAS I have thought fit to call the second session of the fifty- fifth Legislative Assembly of this Province into session, I hereby issue a Proclamation that the same be called to meet on the second day of December, 2004, at 3:00 o'clock in the afternoon. Given under my hand and the Great Seal of the Province at Fredericton this 19 day of November, 2004, in the fifty- third year of Her Majesty’s Reign. BY COMMAND OF THE LIEUTENANT-GOVERNOR Bradley Green, Q.C. Herménégilde Chiasson Attorney General Lieutenant-Governor i Officers of the House Speaker of the Assembly Hon. Bev Harrison Premier Hon. Bernard Lord Leader of the Opposition Shawn Graham Permanent Officers of the House Clerk of the Assembly Loredana Catalli Sonier Clerk Assistant and Clerk of Committees Donald Forestell Clerk Assistant and Committee Clerk Shayne Davies Sergeant-at-Arms Daniel Bussières ii Proceedings 2:15 p.m. His Honour, the Honourable Herménégilde Chiasson, Lieutenant-Governor of New Brunswick representing Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, arrives at the Legislative Building. His Honour’s arrival at Parliament Square is sig- nalized by the firing of a fifteen-gun Royal Salute. His Honour receives the military honours in front of the Legislative Buildings. 2:30 p.m.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Calgary Press
    University of Calgary Press www.uofcpress.com A CENTURY OF PARKS CANADA 1911-2011 A CENTURY of Edited by Claire Elizabeth Campbell Parks ISBN 978-1-55238-557-9 Canada 1911–2011 THIS BOOK IS AN OPEN ACCESS E-BOOK. It is an electronic version of a book that can be purchased in physical form through any bookseller or on-line retailer, or from our distributors. Please support this open access publication by requesting that your university purchase a print copy of this book, or by purchasing a copy yourself. If you have any questions, please contact us at edited by claire elizabeth campbell [email protected] Cover Art: The artwork on the cover of this book is not open access and falls under traditional copyright provisions; it cannot be reproduced in any way without written permission of the artists and their agents. The cover can be displayed as a complete cover image for the purposes of publicizing this work, but the artwork cannot be extracted from the context of the cover of this specific work without breaching the artist’s copyright. COPYRIGHT NOTICE: This open-access work is published under a Creative Commons licence. This means that you are free to copy, distribute, display or perform the work as long as you clearly attribute the work to its authors and publisher, that you do not use this work for any commercial gain in any form, and that you in no way alter, transform, or build on the work outside of its use in normal academic scholarship without our express permission.
    [Show full text]
  • This Week in New Brunswick History
    This Week in New Brunswick History In Fredericton, Lieutenant-Governor Sir Howard Douglas officially opens Kings January 1, 1829 College (University of New Brunswick), and the Old Arts building (Sir Howard Douglas Hall) – Canada’s oldest university building. The first Baptist seminary in New Brunswick is opened on York Street in January 1, 1836 Fredericton, with the Rev. Frederick W. Miles appointed Principal. Canadian Pacific Railway (CPR) becomes responsible for all lines formerly January 1, 1912 operated by the Dominion Atlantic Railway (DAR) - according to a 999 year lease arrangement. January 1, 1952 The town of Dieppe is incorporated. January 1, 1958 The city of Campbellton and town of Shippagan become incorporated January 1, 1966 The city of Bathurst and town of Tracadie become incorporated. Louis B. Mayer, one of the founders of MGM Studios (Hollywood, California), January 2, 1904 leaves his family home in Saint John, destined for Boston (Massachusetts). New Brunswick is officially divided into eight counties of Saint John, Westmorland, Charlotte, Northumberland, King’s, Queen’s, York and Sunbury. January 3, 1786 Within each county a Shire Town is designated, and civil parishes are also established. The first meeting of the New Brunswick Legislature is held at the Mallard House January 3, 1786 on King Street in Saint John. The historic opening marks the official business of developing the new province of New Brunswick. Lévite Thériault is elected to the House of Assembly representing Victoria January 3, 1868 County. In 1871 he is appointed a Minister without Portfolio in the administration of the Honourable George L. Hatheway.
    [Show full text]
  • Strengthening New Brunswick's Democracy
    Strengthening New Brunswick’s Democracy Select Committee Discussion Paper on Electoral Reform July 2016 Strengthening New Brunswick’s Democracy Discussion Paper July 2016 Published by: Government of New Brunswick PO Box 6000 Fredericton, New Brunswick E3B 5H1 Canada Printed in New Brunswick ISBN 978-1- 4605-1033-9 (Print Bilingual) ISBN 978-1- 4605-1034-6 (PDF English) ISBN 978-1- 4605-1035-3 (PDF French) 10744 Table of Contents Select Committee on Electoral Reform 1 Message from the Government House Leader 2 How to use this discussion paper 3 Part 1: Introduction 4 Part 2: Making a more effective Legislature 8 Chapter 1: Eliminating barriers to entering politics for underrepresented groups 8 Chapter 2: Investigating means to improve participation in democracy 12 Internet voting 18 Part 3: Other electoral reform matters 20 Chapter 1: Election dates 20 Chapter 2: Election financing 21 Part 4: Conclusion 24 Part 5 : Appendices 25 Appendix A - Families of electoral systems 25 Appendix B - Voting systems 26 Appendix C - First-Past-the-Post 31 Appendix D - Preferential ballot voting: How does it work? 32 Appendix E- Election dates in New Brunswick 34 Appendix F - Fixed election dates: jurisdictional scan 36 Appendix G- Limits and expenses: Adjustments for inflation 37 Appendix H - Contributions: Limits and allowable sources jurisdictional scan 38 Appendix I - Mandate of the Parliamentary Special Committee on Electoral Reform 41 Appendix J - Glossary 42 Appendix K - Additional reading 45 Select Committee on Electoral Reform The Legislature’s Select Committee on Electoral Reform The committee is to table its final report at the Legislative is being established to examine democratic reform in the Assembly in January 2017.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Acadians' Electoral Weight in N.B.?
    5 octobre 2018 – Telegraph Journal What is Acadians’ electoral weight in N.B.? GABRIEL ARSENEAULT & ROGER OUELLETTE COMMENTARY Acadian Day festivities take place along Water Street in Miramichi. Scholars Gabriel Arseneault and Roger Ouellette write: ‘Since Acadians do not have enough clout in enough ridings to be indispensable to political parties, they must avoid being taken for granted or ignored by political parties.’ PHOTO: JEREMY TREVORS/MIRAMICHI LEADER Francophones now represent about one-third of New Brunswick’s population. How does this demographic weight translate into electoral clout? In which ridings do Acadians have the most influence? And for whom do Acadians vote? This demographic importance is fairly accurately reflected in the electoral boundaries, as shown by the most recent data from the Electoral Boundaries and Representation Commission of New Brunswick. Of the 49 ridings represented in the Legislative Assembly, 16, or 32.7 per cent of the total, have a majority of registered voters whose only mother tongue is French. Francophones also account for more than 20 per cent of the electorate in seven other ridings. In other words, the Acadian vote appears unavoidable in just under half of the ridings, or 23 out of 49. On the other hand, a clear majority of the ridings, 26 out of 49, contain less than 15 per cent francophones. In principle, it would therefore be possible for a party 5 octobre 2018 – Telegraph Journal to obtain a majority of seats without being overly concerned about the French- speaking vote. Over the past 100 years, Acadians have mainly supported the Liberal party.
    [Show full text]
  • Court File No. 01-CV-208141 BE TW E E N: ONTARIO SUPERIOR
    Court File No. 01-CV-208141 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BE TW E E N: THE COUNCIL OF CANADIANS, and DALE CLARK, DEBORAH BOURQUE, and GEORGE KUEHNBAUM on their own behalf and on behalf of all members of the CANADIAN UNION OF POSTAL WORKERS, and BRUCE PORTER and SARAH SHARPE, on their own behalf and on behalf of all members of the CHARTER COMMITTEE ON POVERTY ISSUES Applicants - and- HER MAJESTY IN RIGHT OF CANADA, AS REPRESENTED BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CANADA Respondents AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID SCHNEIDERMAN I, DAVID SCHNEIDERMAN, of the City of Toronto, in the Province of Ontario, HEREBY AFFIRM THAT: 1. I have been since 1999, and continue to be, an Associate Professor at the Faculty of Law, University of Toronto. 2. Prior to that, I was Executive Director of the Centre for Constitutional Studies at the University of Alberta from 1989 to 1999. This is an interdisciplinary research institute housed in the Faculty of Law concerned with constitutional developments in Canada and elsewhere in the world. 3. I have attached As Exhibit "A" to this Affidavit a copy of my curriculum vitae. My research and teaching subjects concern constitutional law in Canada, both as regards the division of legislative authority between the federal government and the provinces and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. A body of research undertaken over the last ten years concerns the implications of - 2 - investment treaties, such as the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), on Canada's constitutional order. 4. The purpose of this Affidavit is to join issue with several points made by Professor James Crawford in his Affidavit dated July 15, 2004.
    [Show full text]