2521 Dandakaranya [ RAJYA SABHA ] Project 2522 Clauses 2 and 3 and the Schedule Were Added to the Bill
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
2521 Dandakaranya [ RAJYA SABHA ] Project 2522 Clauses 2 and 3 and the Schedule were added to the Bill. Clause 1, the Enacting Formula and the Title were added to the Bill. SHRI B. R. BHAGAT: Sir, I move: "That the Bill be returned." MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: The question is: "That the Bill be returned." The motion was adopted. MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: We will now go to Dandakaranya. MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: An; reply? SHRI B. R. BHAGAT: The reply tc the last 3 P.M. point raised by the hon Member is that each item is mentionec in the Supplementary MOTION RE. THE DANDAKAR- Demands foi Grants. They have all been ANYA PROJECT due tc post-budget decision about SHRI BHUPESH GUPTA (West certair matters like relief and rehabilitation, Bengal): Sir, I beg to move: floating of a new Government-owned company or expenditure on Tibetan "That the Dandakaranya Project for the refugees. All the items are those which rehabilitation of displaced persons from could not be anticipated when the budget was East Pakistan and its implementation be framed. The Government however is living taken into consideration." in a dynamic situation and after the budget Sir, my purpose in sponsoring this particular estimates are made if any more decisions are motion is to afford to ourselves an taken, naturally it results in supplementary opportunity to discuss an important demands. I think there is nothing unusual project in the country. Somehow or or undesirable in this. other we have passed over it somewhat in silence. Sometimes we have made MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: The occasional and casual remarks, but beyond question is: that we have not done anything. I think, Sir, we should consider the project and look "That tiie Bill to authorise payment and into its problems a little more deeply for appropriation of certain further sums from two reasons: firstly, it is an important and out of the Consolidated Fund of India project involving in the long run, we are told, for the services of the financial year 1959- Rs. IOO crores and in the short run Rs. 60, as passed by the Lok Sabha, be taken 30 crores. Secondly, it is also a matter into consideration." of rehabilitation of displaced persons which again is to be viewed from the point The motion was adopted. of view of human compassion apart from other economic factors. MR. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN: We shall now take up clause by clause consideration Sir, I think the Government of India has of the Bill. not been very very open-hearted in this matter. We have not been told 2523 Dandakaranya [ 1 SEP. 1959 ] Project 2524 how things are progressing, and Irom time to as far as the bigger aspect is concerned, time we have been supplied with some you know that this will require not only documents. So I would request the hon. efforts iy the field of agriculture but also efforts Members of the House to consider what I in the fields of industry, mining, transport say on the subject. Rarely, Sir, has so much and communications, and so on. It is a vast of tall talk been matched by so little of problem, and I think that it is wrong to view performance, and if it were only a question this only from the point of view of the of bad performance, we would have perhaps Rehabilitation Ministry. If we are to develop excused the authorities responsible for it. I these underdeveloped areas of Andhra, say that there has been a lot of bungling, a Orissa and Madhya Pradesh embracing some lot of maladministration and many other 80,000 square miles, then naturally it is not things which require the attention of a task for the particular Rehabilitation Parliament. Ministry. It is the task of the Planning Commission, the National Development Now, Sir, the Dandakaranya project has Council, to formulate policies and supervise two aspects. One is the bigger aspect of the the operations, and then many Ministries and development of an undeveloped area. As far States have to co-ordinate their activities. as that aspect is concerned, namely the deve- That is not at all being done. On the lopment of an undeveloped area, there contrary we find that this Dandakaranya cannot be two opinions that in a developing Development project authority is being economy when we are making the nation, steadily, if surreptitiously, transformed into such ventures should be undertaken, and we an appendage of the Rehabilitation Ministry, a want such areas to be developed. Then, Sir, kind of branch of the Rehabilitation Ministry there is another aspect, a somewhat narrower and that rules out the consideration that they aspect, and that is that we are trying to should bring about an all-sided development of rehabilitate the displaced persons from East the whole area. I take it therefore that they Pakistan whose resettlement in life are more concerned with the rehabilitation according to the Government has become of the displaced persons there. Sir, here I difficult within the State of West Bengal, but would like only to add before I pass on to the which is not so according to us. I shall come narrower aspect that nobody believed it when to that aspect later. Therefore, roughly there the Government said that they were going to are two aspects: one is the broad and.general develop these 80,000 square miles under that aspect, and the other is more in the focus, the project by spending Rs. 100 crores. It was all immediate aspect of the project. I would like moonshine, because we know that it is not a the House not to confuse the two issues. small job. It is a big job and it could not be undertaken in that cavalier fashion, in that light-hearted manner in which it was Either we look at it from the angle of announced earlier. But people did take development of a vast area of 80,000 square seriously their proposal in respect of the miles, 30,000 square miles to begin with, or smaller aspect of the matter, that is to say the we look at it from the point of view of the project for the rehabilitation of the rehabilitation of the displaced persons in that displaced persons. area. It is also understandable that we view it from both the angles, namely that we rehabilitate these persons to develop this Now, Sir, as I said, Rs. 30 crores had been area, and also in the process of development sanctioned for a period of ten years, Rs. 10 of that particular area we rehabilitate the crores for a period of the first three years. A displaced persons from East Pakistan. I can blue print of this thing was prepared in 1957. understand all that. Now, Sir, I asked for a eopy of it from tha 2525 Dandakaranya t RAJYA SABHA ] Project 2526 [Shri Bhupesh Gupta.] Ministry in June that there were 50,000 families of displaced 1957 and I was supplied with it, and from that persons in the camps of West Bengal out of I gathered that a high level Committee other- whom 30,000 would be taken in March 1959, wise called A.M.P.O., under the chairmanship this year, to Dandakaranya. Dandakaranya will of Mr. H. M. Patel, former Principal Finance be so equipped and developed that it will be in Secretary, was appointed in January 1957. The a position to receive 30,000 families of Com-riaittee consisted of representatives of displaced persons out of 50,000 families living the Planning Commission, the Union in the camps. Then his counter part— Ministries of Agriculture, Rehabilitation and miniature counter-part, if I may say so—in the Home Affairs, and so on, and it submitted its State, Mr. Tarun Kanti Ghosh, Rehabilitation report. Its suggestions fall under five broad Minister, promised that he would give 21 categories: balanced utilisation of available bighas of land to each family going to land; establishment of industries; educational Dandakaranya, that is to say, seven acres to training facilities; transport and each family. Then the services of Mr. Ashoke communications; and exploration and Sen, the Law Minister— I do not see him development of the mineral resources. These here—were requisitioned, and he went to the were the broad lines of recommendations by camp and said, "I have come here. I shall stand that A.M.P.O., that high power committee. or fall with you. I shall go to Dandakaranya". Money was also sanctioned on the basis of Rs. Almost heaven was promised down on earth. IOO crores for the entire period of thirty years These displaced persons were to get heaven on and Rs. 30 crores for ten years. Every year we earth That is how they talked. Mr. Khanna sanction money in the budget. declared on January 23, this year, that 2,25,000 acres of land would be reclaimed. He The A.M.P.O. also recommended that the made an announcement like that. Dandakaranya Development Authority be THE MINISTER OF REHABILITATION invested with sufficient powers to enable it to AND MINORITY AFFAIRS (SHRI; MEHR function autonomously. I mention this fact because it is not functioning, so to say, auto- CHAND KHANNA): When was this nomously now. More and more it is being announcement made'" swallowed up by the Rehabilitation Ministry, SHRI BHUPESH GUPTA: According to the and much of its autonomy is gone. Why it has gone, you will hear from the hon. Minister. Statesman, you did it on January 23, 1959. That is how the plan came.