O.No. MIDO Tpb -2T 1267 T20tc)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division , Oros jSindhudurganagari Main Adn-rinistrative Building, C-Wing , Block No- 312 Phone : 023 6212287 1 7 (Offi ce) Fax -023 6212287 17 E- Mai l- eemido@,redi ffmail.com, eemido@smai1. com. O.No. MIDO tPB -2t 1267 t20tc) Date:- ?J t 04 l20te To, The Member Secretary, Expert Appraisal Comrnittee (EAC) for River Valley & Hydroelectric Projects Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change Indira Paryavaran Bhavan, Jor Bagh Road, New Delhi -110003 Subject : Nardave Medir-rm Irrigation Project, Tal- Kankavali, Dist-Sindhudurg, S ubmission of Additional Information. Reference: Mir-rutes of the 21st Meeting of the Experl Appraisal Committee for River Valley and Hydroelectric Projects held on 28.01.2019. Item No. 21.5. Project: Nardave Medium Irrigation Project at Nardave, Tal: Kankavali, Dist.: Sindhudurg by Water Resources Department, Konkan Irrigation Development Corporation, Maharashtra. File No. l- 110201712017-IA.I(R) Proposal No. IA/MH I RM 62328 120 1l Respected Sir, With reference to the above said subject, we are herewith submitting the additional information sought as per Minutes of tl-re 21st Meeting of the Expert Appraisal Conrnrittee for River Valley and Hydroelectric Projects held on 28.01.2019 Item No. Item No.21.5. You are requested to consider the project as early as possible and kindly issue the environmental clearance for the above said project. This is for your information and further action please. Minor Irri sation Division Oros-Sindhudurs Copy to: Hon.E,xecutive Director, Konkan Irrigation Development Corporation, Thane. for inforrnation please. Copy to: Hon.Chief Engineer, Konkan Region, Water Resources Department, Mumbai. for information please. Copy to: Hon.Superintending Engineer (SKIPC), Oros Sindhudurg for information please. Copy to: Assistant Executive Engineer, Nardave Proj6ct SLrbclivision, Arnbadpal for information. Copy to: Assistant Executive E,ngineer, Talarnba Major Irrigation Project SLrbdivision No-3, Ambadpal for inforrnation. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Executive Engineer Nardave Medium Irrigation Project Additional Minor Irrigation Division, Village Nardave, Tal - Kankavali, Dist – Sindhudurg Maharashtra Information Oras - SindhudurganagariNardave Medium Irrigation Project Village Nardave, Tal - Kankavali, Dist – Sindhudurg Maharashtra Executive Engineer Minor Irrigation Division, Oras - Sindhudurganagari Main Administrative Building, C-Wing, Block No- 312 Phone: 02362/228717 (Office) Fax -02362/228717 Water Resources Department Konkan Irrigation Development Corporation (KIDC), Thane E-Mail- [email protected], [email protected] Phone officeReference: 02362-244241 Minutes Email of the ID 21 -st [email protected] Meeting of the Expert Appraisal Committee for River Valley and Hydroelectric Projects held on 28.01.2019 Item No. 21.5 Prepared By MITCON Consultancy and Engineering Services Ltd Agriculture College Campus, Next to D.I.C Office, Shivajinagar, Pune – 411005 Maharashtra Tel: +91-20-66289400 (Direct), 404, 406 Website:http://www.mitconindia.com Mitcon Consultancy Fileand Engineering No. JServices- 11020/7/2017 Ltd., Pune –IA.I(R), Proposal No. IA/MH/RIV/62328/2017 Executive Engineer Nardave Medium Irrigation Project Additional Minor Irrigation Division, Village Nardave, Tal - Kankavali, Dist – Sindhudurg Maharashtra Information Oras - Sindhudurganagari INDEX 1. DETAIL ABOUT COMMENCEMENT OF WORK AND YEAR WISE COMPLETION OF DIFFERENT COMPONENTS OF THE PROJECT TILL DATE ........... 1 2. TOTAL SUBMERGENCE AREA IN TOR DATED 10.10.2017 IS 627.14 HA WHEREAS AS PER THE DETAILS PRESENTED IT IS 356.352 HA. PP IS REQUIRED TO SUBMIT THE EXACT SUBMERGENCE AND CULTURAL COMMAND AREA. ..... 2 3. THE PROJECT SUBMERGENCE AREA IS ABOUT 0.7-2 KM AWAY FROM THE RADHANAGARI WILDLIFE SANCTUARY, WHEREAS FROM GOOGLE IMAGE IT APPEARS THAT SUBMERGENCE/CATCHMENT AREA IS FALLING INSIDE THE WILDLIFE SANCTUARY. CLARIFICATION IN THIS REGARD IS TO BE SUBMITTED .................................................................................................................................... 3 4. AS THE BASELINE DATA WAS COLLECTED AFTER 60% OF COMPLETION OF WORK, THEREFORE, DATA COLLECTED DOES NOT REPRESENT THE ACTUAL SCENARIO OF PRECONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENT. COMPUTATION OF SUCH DATA FOR ASSESSMENT OF FUTURE IMPACTS OF PROPOSED PROJECT MAY NOT BE ACCURATE IN ASCERTAINING MITIGATION MEASURES AND FURTHER MANAGEMENT PLAN. PP SHALL SUBMIT THE DETAILED CLARIFICATION IN THIS REGARD. ............................................................................................................................... 5 5 SEASON WISE (PRE MONSOON, MONSOON AND POST MONSOON) BASE LINE DATA OF ALL THE ENVIRONMENTAL ATTRIBUTES IS TO BE SUBMITTED ........... 6 5.1 Ambient Air Quality ................................................................................................... 6 5.2 Ambient Noise Level .................................................................................................. 9 5.3 Water Quality Study ................................................................................................. 12 5.4 Soil Quality ............................................................................................................... 28 5.5 Ecology and Biodiversity .......................................................................................... 37 5.5.1 Ephemeral Plant .................................................................................................................... 37 5.5.2 Phytosociological Study ....................................................................................................... 41 5.5.3 Vegetation survey in Command area .................................................................................... 52 5.5.4 Conclusion Vegetation Study ............................................................................................... 54 5.5.5 Faunal Study ......................................................................................................................... 57 5.5.6 Radhanagari Wildlife Sanctuary ........................................................................................... 66 5.5.7 Wetland Ecology .................................................................................................................. 72 6. COST ESTIMATE OF MUCK MANAGEMENT PLAN, LANDSCAPE AND RESTORATION PLAN, ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES, ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PLAN, WATER, AIR AND NOISE MANAGEMENT PLAN UNDER REVISED EMP IS TO BE SUBMITTED. .................... 86 6.1 Muck Management Plan ........................................................................................... 86 6.2 Landscape Plan .......................................................................................................... 89 6.3 Energy Conservation Measures ................................................................................. 92 6.4 Environmental Monitoring Plan ................................................................................ 92 Mitcon Consultancy and Engineering Services Ltd., Pune i Executive Engineer Nardave Medium Irrigation Project Additional Minor Irrigation Division, Village Nardave, Tal - Kankavali, Dist – Sindhudurg Maharashtra Information Oras - Sindhudurganagari 6.5 Water, Air and Noise Management Plan under revised EMP ................................... 93 7. PP OBTAINED NBWL CLEARANCE ON 21.01.2015 WHEREAS THE SAID WILDLIFE SANCTUARY WAS DECLARED AS TIGER RESERVE IN 2017. THEREFORE, A LETTER IS NEEDED FROM LOCAL DFO STATING THAT STATE FOREST DEPARTMENT IS AWARE OF SUCH PROPOSED PROJECT IN THE VICINITY OF TIGER RESERVE .............................................. 94 8. THE ENVIRONMENTAL MATRICES FOR BOTH CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION PHASES IS TO BE REVISITED. UPDATED MATRIX SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE MINISTRY FOR RECONSIDERATION ......................................................................................................................... 96 9. LIST OF FISH SPECIES TO BE REVISITED FROM THE SECONDARY SOURCES AND ACCORDINGLY BE UPDATED IN THE EIA/EMP REPORT ............................................................ 98 10. DETAIL PRESENT STATUS OF R&R TO BE IMPLEMENTED ................................................. 100 TABLE Table No.5.1. Techniques Used for the Analysis of Ambient Air Quality Parameters ............ 6 Table No.5.2. Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Locations ...................................................... 8 Table No.5.3. Test Methods Used for Analysis of Ambient Air Parameter ............................. 8 Table No.5.4. Results of Analysis of Ambient Air Parameter (µg/m3) (Post Monsoon October to December 2017) ....................................................................................................... 8 Table No.5.5. Results of Analysis of Ambient Air Parameter (µg/m3) (Pre monsoon March to May 2018) .......................................................................................................................... 9 Table No.5.6. Ambient Noise Level Monitoring Locations ................................................... 10 Table No.5.7. Test Methods Used for Ambient Noise Level Monitoring .............................. 10 Table No.5.8. Ambient Air Quality standards in respect of Noise ......................................... 11 Table No.5.9. Results of Analysis of Ambient Noise Level data various locations ............... 11 Table No.5.10.Surface Water Sampling Locations ................................................................