Development of cutoff-related knickpoints during early evolution of submarine channels Zoltán Sylvester1 and Jacob A. Covault2 1Chevron Energy Technology Company, 1500 Louisiana Street, Houston, Texas 77002, USA 2Bureau of Economic Geology, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78758, USA ABSTRACT shape them and limited documentation of their Submarine channels are often thought of as having relatively simple geometries, with longer term morphodynamic evolution (Talling significant along-channel morphologic and stratigraphic continuity. Using high-resolution et al., 2015). Instances of highly sinuous chan- seismic reflection data from offshore Angola and a kinematic model of channel evolution, nels are especially puzzling where, in contrast we present evidence that channels on the seafloor can develop slope variability as a result of with rivers, there is no obvious evidence of bend meander cutoff events. When cutoffs develop, the shortened flow paths produce locally steep expansion and sinuosity development (e.g., Kolla gradients, thus initiating knickpoints. Waves of knickpoint retreat and the related channel et al., 2001; Deptuck et al., 2012, their figure incision explain the occurrence of terraces and associated remnant channel deposits above 13b). In addition, submarine channels are often the youngest channel thalweg. The simple processes of meander cutoff followed by knickpoint assumed to have relatively smooth profiles and retreat are intrinsic to submarine channels and result in significant morphologic variability, axial deposits with significant downslope continu- erosion, and stratigraphic complexity, without any external forcing. These insights highlight ity (e.g., McHargue et al., 2011; Sylvester et al., the early evolution of submarine channels, a phase with a record that is commonly fragmented 2011; although, see also Snedden, 2013), unless or completely absent as a result of subsequent erosion, and allow a better understanding of avulsions (Pirmez et al., 2000) or slope deforma- the autogenic controls on deep-marine stratigraphy. tion affect them. Here we show how channels with large slope variability and limited inner bank INTRODUCTION (Clift and Gaedicke, 2002; Covault et al., 2010). deposition can form without any external influ- Submarine channels are conduits through Submarine channel deposits also form important ence, by combining interpretations of submarine which sediment and organic matter are trans- petroleum reservoirs. A clear understanding of channel evolution from seismic reflection data of ported to deep-sea basins by sediment gravity the controls and processes that create submarine the subsurface offshore West Africa with a numer- flows, and they are important components of the channels remains elusive, because there are few ical model of channel meandering and incision. stratigraphic record of environmental change direct measurements of turbidity currents that DATA AND METHODS A B + C 1 km Seismic Reflection Data flow Fig. 1A We interpret the seismic stratigraphy of a e d tu AA’ structurally undeformed reach of an upper Mio- mpli a cene (calcareous nannofossil zone CN7, 10.55– 9.53 Ma; Gradstein et al., 2012) submarine chan- _ 100 ms nel system in the Lower Congo Basin, offshore Angola (Da Costa et al., 2001; Fig. 1). The seis- mic reflection volume has a dominant frequency of 30 Hz, 12.5 m horizontal sampling rate, and is location of horizon slice zero-phase. Two-way traveltime (TWTT) is con- verted to depth assuming an average velocity of 1 km 2700 m/s based on well to seismic ties. We inter- TWT (ms) A’ D 2020 preted seismic horizons on the 5°–20° angle stack. BB’ 2110 A Numerical Modeling 2200 The prominent geomorphologic and strati- 100 ms graphic features of the submarine channel off- 2290 shore Angola are captured in a numerical model B’ that we developed based on the Howard and 2380 B location of horizon slice Knutson (1984) meandering model (HK; for 1 km details of model implementation, see the GSA 1 C.I. = 5 ms 2 km Data Repository ). This model assumes constant Figure 1. A: Topography of basal erosional surface of submarine channel offshore Angola. 1 GSA Data Repository item 2016273, Movies Area is located between 5°24′S and 6°01′S, and 10°56′E and 11°37′E. TWTT—two-way trav- DR1 and DR2, animations of channel evolution, and eltime; c.i.—contour interval. B: Seismic horizon slice showing high-amplitude channel additional details on the numerical model, is available remnants on the valley sides, above the continuous channel thread. C, D: Cross sections online at www.geosociety.org/pubs/ft2016.htm, or on illustrating the typical distribution of sand bodies in the valley. request from [email protected]. GEOLOGY, October 2016; v. 44; no. 10; p. 1–4 | Data Repository item 2016273 | doi:10.1130/G38397.1 | Published online XX Month 2016 GEOLOGY© 2016 Geological | Volume Society 44 | ofNumber America. 10 For | www.gsapubs.orgpermission to copy, contact [email protected]. 1 channel width, and bank erosion is driven by Fig. 2B channel curvature, integrated over a segment A upstream from the point where the calculation is performed. The HK model has been successfully 5 km used in modeling subaerial meander develop- ment (e.g., Finnegan and Dietrich, 2011; Limaye B and Lamb, 2014). More sophisticated physics- based models have been developed for turbid- ity currents that shape submarine channels (e.g., cf Das et al., 2004); however, the HK model has kp A A’ the advantage of simpler input parameter choice and lower computational complexity. The HK model does not cover the full spectrum of sub- marine channel behavior. For example, turbidity currents that are not in equilibrium with their kp kp containing channel can deposit sediment closer cf to the outer bank (Kane et al., 2008; Jobe et al., 2015). Our goal here is to investigate the cf larger scale stratigraphic implications of rela- tively simple early sinuosity development that is coupled with incision. Many models of channel meandering assume constant slope along the centerline (Ikeda et al., 1981; Howard and Knutson, 1984; Sun et al., B B’ 1996). However, channel slope variability and knickpoint dynamics are likely to be important factors in the long-term evolution of submarine 1 km channels (Pirmez et al., 2000; Mitchell, 2006; c.i. = 5 m Heiniö and Davies, 2007). Therefore, in a manner C D similar to that of Finnegan and Dietrich (2011), AA’ BB’ we track the vertical coordinate of the channel centerline. Incision is modeled as a function of the boundary shear stress (Howard and Kerby, 100 m 100 m 1983), which varies with the channel gradient. 3. mud deposition The channel centerlines generated with the HK model provide the framework for our simu- 1. erosional surface 2. sand deposition lations. To examine the resulting geomorphol- ogy we created geomorphic surfaces that mimic Figure 2. Results from the modified Howard and Knutson (1984) model. A: Planform expres- realistic channel morphologies at each time step sion of channel system; the most recent channel location is highlighted in blue and cutoffs are shown in brown. B: Topographic surface through time. A few cutoffs (cf) and the related (e.g., Sylvester et al., 2011). To simulate ero- knickpoints (kp) are highlighted (c.i.—contour interval). C, D: Cross sections illustrating the sion, we used a cross section with a quadratic distribution of sand in the model and the disconnect between hanging cutoffs and basal shape; then coarse-grained channel deposition channel thread. Inset below C and D shows how surfaces (erosion, sand deposition, and is modeled with partially filling the channel to a mud deposition) were created around each centerline. fraction of the channel depth (Fig. 2). Although real-world channel deposits have significantly mapped for more than 23 km (Fig. 1). These this sandstone corresponds to peaks. The discon- more complicated geometries, it is likely that high-amplitude seismic reflections are over- nected loops are remnant channel deposits in this detail does not affect the large-scale struc- lain by lower amplitude sheets, which drape or terraces that were cut off and truncated against ture of the resulting stratigraphy. The third and lap onto a large-scale (<200 ms TWTT relief) the more continuous channel deposits; the latter final surface corresponds to overbank deposi- erosional surface. The high-amplitude, dis- correspond to a single ribbon in the thalweg of tion; it is generated as a muddy layer that lin- continuous loops also terminate against this the youngest large-scale channel-form surface. early thins away from the channel (Fig. 2). erosional surface, and they are located in an The width and sinuosity of individual ribbons elevated position, above the high-amplitude of high-amplitude seismic reflections, showing RESULTS ribbon at the base of the system. Gamma-ray cutoff meanders similar to features of subaerial wireline logs that penetrate the high-amplitude floodplains, are consistent with other seismically Seismic Stratigraphy and Channel seismic reflections exhibit low values, suggest- imaged submarine channel deposits (Normark Morphology ing high sand content; high gamma-ray values et al., 1993; Deptuck et al., 2003). The lower The seismic stratigraphy of the studied chan- from the lower amplitude sheets are evidence amplitude reflections represent hemipelagic nel system comprises high-amplitude seismic for their predominantly muddy character. The mud drape and overbank deposits adjacent to reflections organized into discontinuous loops sands deposited in the most recent and best- channel forms. (<1000 m long, <400 m wide), and a single high- preserved channel thalweg are coarse grained This stratigraphic structure suggests an early amplitude, sinuous ribbon with similar widths and poorly sorted, and therefore have a high channel evolution dominated by the develop- and a mean half-wavelength sinuosity of 1.5 impedance compared to the surrounding mud- ment of an actively meandering channel that that is continuous downstream and has been stones. Based on well to seismic ties, the top of carves a broad erosional valley and truncates 2 www.gsapubs.org | Volume 44 | Number 10 | GEOLOGY its own cutoff deposits as it incises.