San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) for BART’S Train Control Modernization Program (TCMP)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART) for BART’S Train Control Modernization Program (TCMP) SCCP-P-2021-04B May 13, 2021 4/1/2021 ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C VWDXYWDX`8abcdbefÿghipqdC r wdp IRsItsPIPQÿQRuIHuIv ExyxW 5 5 dpg bcdgbqd ghipqdÿ hbewdbefÿfpeq IR PIQI `xXÿ hped hpdp ÿqwqr ÿpwk h5hbewdbefÿfpeq yX`xÿ y` D`xyy`XÿxXyx``yXÿ yWWyX sXÿdxXooy pped VWDY ÿxX`ÿ ghipqdÿwewfpgAhedwqd hep wbÿkkgpcc ÿdyD`` eQIGtfRGfURH XgyD``hix`jyT ghipqdÿbdp lVFÿxXÿ yX`xyÿyYDxXm`yXÿExyxWÿGÿ yWWnXo`yXÿlDYÿxXÿ yX`xyÿ l ÿ yX`xo` hqwdbheÿ8ghipqdÿ bbdcC{ÿpcqgb|dbheÿ8qh|pÿh}ÿ~hgrC tXÿVWDYÿXYÿsXÿdxXooyÿoynX`DjÿuDÿ l ÿ yX`xo`ÿvÿiDÿWDWDX`DYÿ`uxynuÿ`uDÿxXiwÿ yxxYyxÿDWDX`ÿoyXXDo`Xÿ xXYÿXYÿsXÿdxXooyÿXYÿÿyo`DYÿXÿVWDYÿXYÿsXÿdxXooyÿoynX`DjÿuDÿ l ÿ yX`xo`ÿvÿxDoDÿ`uDÿDy`Xÿ`xXÿoyX`xyÿ w`DWÿv`uÿÿXDvÿoyWWnXo`yXGiDYÿ`xXÿoyX`xyÿw`DWzÿyvXÿlVFÿ`yÿouDTDÿ`uDÿuyx`DxÿuDYvwÿXDDYDYÿ`yÿyDx`DÿWyxDÿ xDnxwÿouDYnDYÿ`xXÿ`uxynuÿ`uDÿxXiwÿ yxxYyxjÿuÿoyDÿDDWDX`ÿÿXÿX`Dxÿx`ÿygÿ`uDÿyTDxÿiDXDg`ÿgxyWÿWDWDX`Xÿ`uDÿ Eÿ`uxynuÿ`uDÿxXiwÿ yxxYyxj h|heped |ppedbefÿfpeq sXÿdxXooyÿlwÿVxDÿFYÿxX`ÿ`xo` sXÿdxXooyÿlwÿVxDÿFYÿxX`ÿ`xo` bfdÿh}ÿ~w sXÿdxXooyÿlwÿVxDÿFYÿxX`ÿ`xo` hecdgpqdbhe sXÿdxXooyÿlwÿVxDÿFYÿxX`ÿ`xo` D`TDÿ`xo` ccp QHzQfzQtzQvzPIzPPzPezQRzQe pewdp fzvzQIzQQzQU hefgpccbhew QfzQtzQvzezvzQQzQPzQUzQRzQe ghipqdÿbpcdhep abcdbef gh|hcpk ghipqdÿdpkÿp|hgdÿ||ghpk qpfbeÿebghepedwÿ8Cÿwcp ItsIQsPIQe ItsIQsPIQe bgqpwdpÿgw}dÿebghepedwÿhqppedÿhqppedÿ|p gw}dÿghipqdÿp|hgd ItsIQsPIQe ItsIQsPIQe ekÿebghepedwÿwcpÿ8ÿbpcdhepC IvsIQsPIQf IvsIQsPIQf qpfbeÿpcbfeÿ8Cÿwcp IvsIQsPIQf IvsIQsPIQf ekÿpcbfeÿwcpÿ8pwkÿdhÿ bcdÿ}hgÿkpgdbcppedÿbpcdhepC IvsIQsPIQf IvsIQsPIQf qpfbeÿbfdÿh}ÿ~wÿwcp IvsIQsPIQf IvsIQsPIQf ekÿbfdÿh}ÿ~wÿwcpÿ8bfdÿh}ÿ~wÿpgdb}bqwdbheÿbpcdhepC IvsIQsPIQf IvsIQsPIQf qpfbeÿhecdgpqdbheÿwcpÿ8hedgwqdÿwgkÿbpcdhepC ItsIQsPIPI ItsIQsPIPI ekÿhecdgpqdbheÿwcpÿ8hecdgpqdbheÿhedgwqdÿqqp|dweqpÿbpcdhepC ItsIQsPIUQ ItsIQsPIUQ qpfbeÿhcphpdÿwcp IvsIQsPIUQ IvsIQsPIUQ ekÿhcphpdÿwcpÿ8hcphpdÿp|hgdC QPsIQsPIUQ QPsIQsPIUQ ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C `abIRVIWVPIPQÿQRXIHXIY bÿ`deÿbbe cdFefgÿehipqÿrsqthsuÿvswDhqpxitpsqÿEhsyhiÿpuuÿDqiuDÿcdFeÿtsÿpqhDigDÿtDÿq DhÿsÿthipqgÿsDhitpqyÿths yÿtDÿehiqgiÿrshhpwshÿiqwÿ e DÿsqyÿtDhÿhpwDhgpÿthDqwgÿitÿcdFeÿhD phDÿiwwptpsqiuÿiiptÿpÿigÿusqyÿDDqÿhDsyqpxDwÿihsggÿtDÿhDypsqÿiqwÿws DqtDwÿpqÿ gt wpDgÿpqu wpqyÿtDÿverÿrshDÿriiptÿehiqgptÿt wÿeDÿehipqÿrsqthsuÿvswDhqpxitpsqÿEhsyhiÿpuuÿDqiuDÿcdFeÿtsÿsDhitDÿthipqgÿptÿtDÿ gshtDhÿDiwigÿqDDggihÿtsÿwDupTDhÿshDÿthipqgÿDhÿs hÿiqwÿDDÿtDÿciÿdhDiÿsTpqy fÿ ghbgbda i `ek`lÿm`jd FDTDhgpuDÿiqDÿdqiugpg i dnoÿa`pd`qmbÿggdpapbÿa`abrlÿ4`m i benbÿ4bbdsbÿ4`ÿgppd i tuvwxyÿzy{zy| `abrl aa }dpa a`m ~DhitpsqiuÿhsTDDqt qtDhgDtpsqÿVÿpyqiuÿphsTDDqtg d Q ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C `abIRVIWVPIPQÿQRXIHXIY a`ÿ def`a cdeefghipqhdgÿrpsDtÿuvphgÿcdgqvdwÿxcrucyÿidgqvpiqÿhsÿpÿtDshgGfhwtÿidgqvpiqÿ EvdDiqÿhwDsqdgDsXÿFh qGdGpÿpifhshqhdgÿehwDsqdgDsÿpvDÿgdqÿpwhipqhdgÿqdÿq DÿucEÿÿ EDvdvepgiDÿgthipqdvsÿpgtÿDpsfvDsXÿsÿpÿqvpgshqÿvdDiqÿsdeDÿhgthipqdvsÿpgtÿeDqvhisÿwhsqDtÿpvDÿgdqÿpwhipwDÿDDÿq DÿccEÿgpvvpqhTDÿdvÿ edvDÿhgdvepqhdgÿdgÿEDvdvepgiDÿgthipqdvsÿpgtÿDpsfvDs ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C EDVWXVY`abDÿcadeb`fXVgÿ`adÿhD`giVDg &pqrstp pusvtpwÿxytÿ 'wvqyt&pqrstp 0v sv w xsstpÿ(yÿsv w !qp XaDgfeXaÿ EEÿEEÿEVXDbfÿVD`ÿXVVedXVÿXiafÿXVÿ Xf`eÿheeDg I QIIIIIIIIII GQIIIIIIIIII FDdibfeXa FDeXaedDÿhÿdDVÿ`def`ÿ`adÿXf`eÿ E h hÿdDVÿ`def` I QUfg GQUfg EDVgXaÿhXiVg I I I EEÿEEÿEDVgXaÿhXiVgÿXWÿV`TDeÿeYDÿ`TDd E hXiVgÿdDVÿ`def` HUiRUIHi I HUiRUIHi EEÿEEÿ E j`eeÿDkebeDÿhXiVgÿXWÿjDe` hXiVg I I I gfDYÿ EEÿEEÿED`mÿEDVeXdÿV`TDeÿeYDÿFDee`leeefÿ cadDn I I I FDee`leeef E cadDn EEÿEEÿ E V`agefÿDVTebDÿoaGeYDÿEDVWXVY`abD pÿqoaGfeYDq rQfP sr PfP eVÿti`eefÿuÿ EhÿPfiÿXag QifRH QsfQQ GPfHi EEÿEEÿE`Vfebie`fDÿh`ffDV vhv EÿwE EhÿQIÿXag I QHfRR GQHfRR EEÿEEÿ EÿwE `VlXaÿjeXnedDÿxoPy Xag I UUUIRrR GUUUIRrR EEÿEEÿ EÿwE Xe`feeDÿoV`aebÿXYdXiadgÿxoy Xag gfPr iIRfIi GRrHfgH EEÿEEÿ EÿwE iedkiVÿjeXnedDgÿxony Xag I UPfrQ GUPfrQ EEÿEEÿ EÿwE `VlXaÿhXaXnedDÿxoy Xag QHfsH QPIRH GQPIPrfQR EEÿEEÿ EÿwE zefVXDaÿonedDgÿxzony Xag QUifRi gRPfRH GHIgfIQ `WDf EEÿEEÿziYlDVÿXWÿzXaGhXfXVe{Ddÿ`f`eefeDgÿ EÿwE `adÿzXaGhXfXVe{DdÿDVeXigÿcaiVeDg ziYlDV I I I EEÿEEÿ EÿwE ziYlDVÿXWÿ`f`eefeDg ziYlDV QRfg gHfr GHPfP EEÿEEÿ EÿwE `f`eefeDgÿdDVÿQIIÿheeeeXaÿh ziYlDV IfIIIIH IfIIIIH I EEÿEEÿ EÿwE ziYlDVÿXWÿDVeXigÿcaiVeDg ziYlDV HHfg UQHPfs GUIrHfQ EEÿEEÿziYlDVÿXWÿDVeXigÿcaiVeDgÿdDVÿQIIÿ EÿwE heeeeXaÿh ziYlDV IfIIPr IfIIPr I bbDggeleeef EEÿEEÿ E ziYlDVÿXWÿ|XlgÿbbDggeleDÿlÿhXdD ziYlDV UUUH QrPR QRQP EEÿEEÿziYlDVÿXWÿjDgfea`feXagÿbbDggeleDÿlÿ E hXdD ziYlDV I I I EDVbDafÿXWÿEXdie`feXaÿjDWeaDdÿ`gÿXÿ EEÿEEÿcabXYDÿXVÿjeg`dT`af`Ddÿ}efkeaÿQ~Pÿ E heeDÿXWÿF`eeÿf`feXaÿDVVÿDVYea`eÿXVÿ p UU UU I hekGVDiDabÿigÿfXd wbXaXYebÿ EEÿEEÿ|XlgÿVD`fDdÿxjeVDbfÿ`adÿcadeVDbfy ziYlDV QPiRI I QPiRI jDTDeXdYDaf EÿwE Xgfÿ EEÿEEÿXgfÿDaDWefÿF`feX F`feX QfH I QfH wWWDbfeTDaDgg EÿwE ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C VWXYV`X aX aXc Yabc`Xÿ IR efghipÿefqhprÿspgÿtipguvqufrÿwxpyDp PIQId Yabc`XÿVXc wF ÿ ipvgÿefghifxÿfDigvphvfgÿEifipyÿGÿefyygvuphvfgÿpqDÿ ipvgÿefghifxÿe eÿefghipuh VWXVÿaXÿYabc`XÿaWXÿ87666WCÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ aacX Eivfi PQGPP PPGPU PUGPR PRGPd PdGPH PHGPef aX ccXVÿc` gÿ8gC spgÿtipguvqufÿphÿwiDpÿFpivÿ ipgq g QPrQPj QPrQPjspgÿtipguvqufÿphÿwiDpÿFpivÿ ipgq Akÿlÿ8C spgÿtipguvqufÿphÿwiDpÿFpivÿ ipgq ÿlÿ8C spgÿtipguvqufÿphÿwiDpÿFpivÿ ipgq Ak spgÿtipguvqufÿphÿwiDpÿFpivÿ ipgq QrIHdrmeQ QrIHdrmeQspgÿtipguvqufÿphÿwiDpÿFpivÿ ipgq QPrQPjQrIHdrmeQ QrIemrIII YaaWcnÿaXÿYabc`XÿaWXÿ87666WC aXcW gÿ8gC g QPrQPj QPrQPj Akÿlÿ8C ÿlÿ8C Ak QrIHdrmeQ QrIHdrmeQ QPrQPjQrIHdrmeQ QrIemrIII tgÿoQp qhrDiÿshphDÿGÿ ipgqvhÿpgÿsghDiuvhhÿFpvxÿepivhpxÿEifipyÿ sFeEÿefyyvhhD YaYÿanc VWXVÿnVÿ87666WCÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ PItUItPIetmQQ aacX Eivfi PQGPP PPGPU PUGPR PRGPd PdGPH PHGPef aX nVÿc` gÿ8gC g Akÿlÿ8C ÿlÿ8C Ak UQmrHII UQmrHII UQmrHII UQmrHII YaaWcnÿnVÿ87666WC aXcW gÿ8gC g Akÿlÿ8C ÿlÿ8C Ak UQmrHII UQmrHII UQmrHII UQmrHII ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C VWXYÿ`Pa bcdefÿVWXYgÿGÿheipÿFDTDXWDÿqrcsstppDYu wxywÿx yÿ yÿ87666Cÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ PIvQIvRIIvQII xx Eitci PQGPP PPGPU PUGPR PRGP PGPH PHGP x yÿyfg ÿ8C QPQP QPQP Adÿeÿ8C ÿeÿ8C Ad RI RI QPQP RI PPH wxxÿ yÿ87666C x ÿ8C QPQP QPQP Adÿeÿ8C ÿeÿ8C Ad RI RI QPQP RI PPH VWXYÿ`Ua bcdefÿVWXYgÿGÿbcdefÿhieXgicipeptcXÿVWXYgÿqrcsstppDYu wxywÿx yÿ yÿ87666Cÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ PIvQIvRIIvQII xx Eitci PQGPP PPGPU PUGPR PRGP PGPH PHGP x yÿyfg ÿ8C Adÿeÿ8C ÿeÿ8C Ad UIPUR UIPUR UIPUR UIPUR wxxÿ yÿ87666C x ÿ8C Adÿeÿ8C ÿeÿ8C Ad UIPUR UIPUR UIPUR UIPUR ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C VWXYÿ`Ra VbcÿVWXYdÿGÿVbcÿGÿeUIfghiÿÿGÿpDqÿrstusdÿrvtwwÿrstusdÿtXYÿxyuDÿgxyvvssDYi ÿ ÿÿ87666Cÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ VbcGbFcprb Euyu PQGPP PPGPU PUGPR PRGPe PeGPH PHGP d ÿij eÿ8eC e Afÿgÿ8C ÿgÿ8C Af UfhPRI UfhPRI UfhPRI UfhPRI ÿÿ87666C eÿ8eC e Afÿgÿ8C ÿgÿ8C Af UfhPRI UfhPRI UfhPRI UfhPRI VWXYÿ`ea rstsDÿrkQÿrxxEÿGÿrywWsyXÿlyuÿxyXmDdsDYÿxyuuYyudÿEuymutvÿgxyvvssDYi ÿ ÿÿ87666Cÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ UInQInIUInQII Euyu PQGPP PPGPU PUGPR PRGPe PeGPH PHGP d ÿij eÿ8eC e Afÿgÿ8C ÿgÿ8C Af ÿÿ87666C eÿ8eC e Afÿgÿ8C ÿgÿ8C Af ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTU 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿÿ!`abcdedÿefghÿbipdÿq`rÿiadstadsehÿ`scuÿvwxIRVIWVPIPQÿQRXIHXIY ywyw gwh wx xwÿ IR ÿÿÿÿdeDf PIQI ÿ7ÿ5ÿiiÿxw xwÿnvopgq EÿDEEFÿjÿkDdDÿlDDeDm pvrrygpÿsvgpxÿxtxwxq EÿDEEFÿjÿkDdDÿlDDeDm xvgÿuÿvxqÿsvgpx EÿDEEFÿjÿkDdDÿlDDeDm uÿvvxqÿsvgpxÿwyiiÿqxivhÿgxÿÿrxÿrvgxgwxÿixvihÿxyvivygÿ7CÿxvgÿuÿwsxÿqxivhxÿBCÿwÿygxvxÿxivwxqÿwÿwsxÿqxivhxÿvgqÿzCÿswÿ wÿygxvxÿwyiiÿ{xÿugqxq wsxÿypgyuyvgwÿ gurvwyg ÿBÿ5ÿÿn7ÿxwÿgih xwÿrxgqrxgwÿxtxwÿ8ixvxÿuiiwÿwsxÿygqy|yqviÿn7ÿvpvrÿpyqxiygxÿuÿvxyuyÿywxyvC EÿDEEFÿjÿkDdDÿlDDeDm vv|vi }ÿ~DDkÿDjÿ~ÿ~DÿkTDÿjeÿÿedDDÿfÿDÿfÿddÿTdÿ~TDÿkDDÿkDfÿjÿ~DÿDlÿjÿ~ÿeDfeDÿ DDm vrxÿ8ygwÿÿhvxC ypgvwx ywix vwx ÿzÿ5ÿiiÿxw wwvsrxgwÿ 7Cÿgxgxÿurÿ rvixrxgwygpÿpxghÿvgqAÿxpygviÿvgvwvwygÿivggygpÿpxghÿ BCÿxwÿ vwygÿvv ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !"ÿ$%&&'($ÿ )0 1"ÿ23ÿ DEEFGHIIIGPIPQGIIIRÿTR 456676ÿ89ÿ6@AB6B6C UVDWXVDWY8`abcadeÿfghipcC q wci IrsItsPIPQÿQRurvuIv ExyxV 5 5 cif abcfapc fghipcÿ gadwcadeÿeidp Ir PIQI YxWÿ gtdc gtci ÿuwpv ÿiwi g5gadwcadeÿeidp yWYxÿ yY DYxyyYWÿxWyxYYyWÿ yVVyW wWÿxWlly iidc UVDX ÿxWYÿ fghipcÿwdweifAgdcwpc gdi waÿiifibb ÿyDYY dQIGtvrGvRrH WeyDYYfgxYhyT fghipcÿaci jUFÿxWÿ yWYxyÿyXDxWkYyWÿExyxVÿGÿlUxYmnxsoypWYypWÿqWXÿrWYDxylÿ gWÿsxXDÿ yWYxlY gpwcagdÿ8fghipcÿ aacbC|ÿibpfa}cagdÿ8pg}iÿg~ÿgfvC rWÿYmDÿlYxÿyeÿqWXhÿmDÿoypWYypWÿqWXÿrWYDxylÿsxXDÿ yWYxlYÿpÿgDÿVDVDWYDXÿYÿlUxYmnxÿWXÿoypWYypWÿqWXÿjUFÿ YYyWyÿWXÿpÿeeDlYÿDxTlDÿYmxynmÿYmDÿxWgxÿ yxxXyxÿDVDWYÿlyWWDlYWÿqWXÿWXÿwWÿxWllyÿWXÿÿWÿUVDXÿWXÿwWÿ xWllyÿlynWYDhÿmDÿoypWYypWÿqWXÿrWYDxylÿsxXDÿ yWYxlYÿWlnXDÿWYYyWÿyeÿWDpÿnxelDÿVynWYDXÿYxWÿlyWYxyÿxlDpxÿ WXÿylYDXÿlgDÿYyÿWDpÿwpYlmÿEypDxÿwnxÿ gWDYÿwEw ÿWXÿylYDXÿWYDxylÿpYlmDÿpÿgDÿXDWDXÿyWÿYmDÿzÿ{WDÿexyVÿ lUxYmnxÿxWÿ yWYxyÿFyyVÿYyÿrWYDxylWÿzPRyÿzPdÿWXÿzRdhÿmÿlyDÿDDVDWYÿÿWÿWYDxÿxYÿyeÿYmDÿyTDxÿgDWDeYÿexyVÿ VDVDWYWÿYmDÿ EÿYmxynmÿYmDÿxWgxÿ yxxXyxh g}gdidc }iidcadeÿeidp wWÿxWllyÿjxÿUxDÿFXÿxWYÿoYxlY wWÿxWllyÿjxÿUxDÿFXÿxWYÿoYxlY aecÿg~ÿw wWÿxWllyÿjxÿUxDÿFXÿxWYÿoYxlY gdbcftpcagd wWÿxWllyÿjxÿUxDÿFXÿxWYÿoYxlY {DYTDÿoYxlY bbi QHyQvyQtyQyPIyPPyPdyQryQd idwci vyyQIyQQyQR gdefibbagdw QvyQtyQydyyQQyQPyQRyQryQd fghipcÿaibcgdi `abcade fg}gbii fghipcÿctiÿi}gfcÿ}}fgii uieadÿdafgdidcwÿ8Cÿwbi ItsIQsPIQd ItsIQsPIQd afptwciÿfw~cÿdafgdidcwÿgptidcÿgptidcÿ}i fw~cÿfghipcÿi}gfc ItsIQsPIQd ItsIQsPIQd diÿdafgdidcwÿwbiÿ8ÿaibcgdiC IsIQsPIQv IsIQsPIQv uieadÿibaedÿ8Cÿwbi IQsIQsPIPI IQsIQsPIPI diÿibaedÿwbiÿ8iwiÿcgÿ abcÿ~gfÿiifcabiidcÿaibcgdiC
Recommended publications
  • The Third Crossing
    The Third Crossing A Megaproject in a Megaregion www.thirdcrossing.org Final Report, February 2017 Transportation Planning Studio Department of City and Regional Planning, University of California, Berkeley Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the Department of City and Regional Planning (DCRP) at the College of Environmental Design (CED) at UC Berkeley, the University of California Transportation Center and Institute of Transportation Studies (ITS), UC Berkeley for support. A special thanks also goes to the helpful feedback from studio instructor Karen Trapenberg Frick and UC Berkeley faculty and researchers including Jesus Barajas and Jason Corburn. We also acknowledge the tremendous support and insights from colleagues at numerous public agencies and non-profit organizations throughout California. A very special thanks goes to David Ory, Michael Reilly, and Fletcher Foti of MTC for their gracious support in running regional travel and land use models, and to Professor Paul Waddell and Sam Blanchard of UrbanSim, Inc. for lending their resources and expertise in land use modeling. We also thank our classmates Joseph Poirier and Lee Reis; as well as David Eifler, Teresa Caldeira, Jennifer Wolch, Robert Cervero, Elizabeth Deakin, Malla Hadley, Leslie Huang and other colleagues at CED; and, Alexandre Bayen, Laura Melendy and Jeanne Marie Acceturo of ITS Berkeley. About Us We are a team of 15 graduate students in City Planning, Transportation Engineering, and Public Health. This project aims to facilitate a conversation about the future of transportation between the East Bay and San Francisco and in the larger Northern California megaregion. We are part of the Department of City and Regional Planning in the UC Berkeley College of Environmental Design, with support from the University of California Transportation Center and The Institute of Transportation Studies at the University of California, Berkeley.
    [Show full text]
  • Bay Area Air Quality Management District Board of Directors Will Be Held at 9:00 A.M
    BOARD OF DIRECTORS’ REGULAR MEETING March 3, 2004 A meeting of the Bay Area Air Quality Management District Board of Directors will be held at 9:00 a.m. at the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District’s (BART) Lake Merritt Headquarters, located at 800 Madison in the First Floor Board Room, Oakland, California. Questions About an Agenda Item The name, telephone number and e-mail of the appropriate staff person to contact for additional information or to resolve concerns is listed for each agenda item. Meeting Procedures The public meeting of the Air District Board of Directors begins at 9:00 a.m. The Board of Directors generally will consider items in the order listed on the agenda. However, any item may be considered in any order. After action on any agenda item not requiring a public hearing, the Board may reconsider or amend the item at any time during the meeting. Telegraph San Pablo To I-580 To I-580 18th 17th Lake 17th Merritt 16th 15th 15th 980 14th Lakeside 13th 12th P 11th 10th 9th Martin Luther King, Jr. Way Castro 8th 7th 6th To San Francisco880 To San José 5th 4th Oak Clay I-880 freeway Alice Franklin Jackson Webster Harrison to Bay Bridge 3rd Madison Jefferson and Broadway San Francisco 2nd Washington C.L. Dellums (Oakland) Amtrak Station Embarcadero N Oakland Inner Harbor Berkeley Amtrak Station Public Transit Access 80 (Emeryville) 24 BART: Lake Merritt Station on the Fremont Line 580 13 AC Transit: Lines 59, 59A, 62 (weekends) San Francisco Bay Bridge 880 Oakland Lines 11, 59, 59A, 62, 35X, 36X (weekdays) 980 Amtrak: C.L.
    [Show full text]
  • Transit-Oriented Development and Joint Development in the United States: a Literature Review
    Transit Cooperative Research Program Sponsored by the Federal Transit Administration RESEARCH RESULTS DIGEST October 2002—Number 52 Subject Area: VI Public Transit Responsible Senior Program Officer: Gwen Chisholm Transit-Oriented Development and Joint Development in the United States: A Literature Review This digest summarizes the literature review of TCRP Project H-27, “Transit-Oriented Development: State of the Practice and Future Benefits.” This digest provides definitions of transit-oriented development (TOD) and transit joint development (TJD), describes the institutional issues related to TOD and TJD, and provides examples of the impacts and benefits of TOD and TJD. References and an annotated bibliography are included. This digest was written by Robert Cervero, Christopher Ferrell, and Steven Murphy, from the Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California, Berkeley. CONTENTS IV.2 Supportive Public Policies: Finance and Tax Policies, 46 I INTRODUCTION, 2 IV.3 Supportive Public Policies: Land-Based I.1 Defining Transit-Oriented Development, 5 Initiatives, 54 I.2 Defining Transit Joint Development, 7 IV.4 Supportive Public Policies: Zoning and I.3 Literature Review, 9 Regulations, 57 IV.5 Supportive Public Policies: Complementary II INSTITUTIONAL ISSUES, 10 Infrastructure, 61 II.1 The Need for Collaboration, 10 IV.6 Supportive Public Policies: Procedural and II.2 Collaboration and Partnerships, 12 Programmatic Approaches, 61 II.3 Community Outreach, 12 IV.7 Use of Value Capture, 66 II.4 Government Roles, 14
    [Show full text]
  • 2015 Station Profiles
    2015 BART Station Profile Study Station Profiles – Non-Home Origins STATION PROFILES – NON-HOME ORIGINS This section contains a summary sheet for selected BART stations, based on data from customers who travel to the station from non-home origins, like work, school, etc. The selected stations listed below have a sample size of at least 200 non-home origin trips: • 12th St. / Oakland City Center • Glen Park • 16th St. Mission • Hayward • 19th St. / Oakland • Lake Merritt • 24th St. Mission • MacArthur • Ashby • Millbrae • Balboa Park • Montgomery St. • Civic Center / UN Plaza • North Berkeley • Coliseum • Oakland International Airport (OAK) • Concord • Powell St. • Daly City • Rockridge • Downtown Berkeley • San Bruno • Dublin / Pleasanton • San Francisco International Airport (SFO) • Embarcadero • San Leandro • Fremont • Walnut Creek • Fruitvale • West Dublin / Pleasanton Maps for these stations are contained in separate PDF files at www.bart.gov/stationprofile. The maps depict non-home origin points of customers who use each station, and the points are color coded by mode of access. The points are weighted to reflect average weekday ridership at the station. For example, an origin point with a weight of seven will appear on the map as seven points, scattered around the actual point of origin. Note that the number of trips may appear underrepresented in cases where multiple trips originate at the same location. The following summary sheets contain basic information about each station’s weekday non-home origin trips, such as: • absolute number of entries and estimated non-home origin entries • access mode share • trip origin types • customer demographics. Additionally, the total number of car and bicycle parking spaces at each station are included for context.
    [Show full text]
  • San Francisco Bay Area Regional Rail Plan, Chapter 7
    7.0 ALTERNATIVES DEFINITION & Fig. 7 Resolution 3434 EVALUATION — STEP-BY-STEP Step One: Base Network Healdsburg Sonoma Recognizing that Resolution 3434 represents County 8 MTC’s regional rail investment over the next 25 Santa years as adopted first in the 2001 Regional Trans- Rosa Napa portation Plan and reaffirmed in the subsequent County Vacaville 9 plan update, Resolution 3434 is included as part Napa of the “base case” network. Therefore, the study Petaluma Solano effort focuses on defining options for rail improve- County ments and expansions beyond Resolution 3434. Vallejo Resolution 3434 rail projects include: Marin County 8 9 Pittsburg 1. BART/East Contra Costa Rail (eBART) San Antioch 1 Rafael Concord Richmond 2. ACE/Increased Services Walnut Berkeley Creek MTC Resolution 3434 Contra Costa 3. BART/I-580 Rail Right-of-Way Preservation County Rail Projects Oakland 4. Dumbarton Bridge Rail Service San 1 BART: East Contra Costa Extension Francisco 10 6 3 2 ACE: Increased Service 5. BART/Fremont-Warm Springs to San Jose Daly City 2 Pleasanton Livermore 3 South Extension BART: Rail Right-of-Way Preservation San Francisco Hayward Union City 4 Dumbarton Rail Alameda 6. Caltrain/Rapid Rail/Electrification & Extension San Mateo Fremont County 5 BART: Fremont/Warm Springs 4 to Downtown San Francisco/Transbay Transit to San Jose Extension 7 Redwood City 5 Center 6 & Extension to Downtown SF/ Mountain Milpitas Transbay Transit Center View Palo Alto 7. Caltrain/Express Service 7 Caltrain: Express Service Sunnyvale Santa Clara San San Santa Clara 8 Jose 8. SMART (Sonoma-Marin Rail) SMART (Sonoma-Marin Rail) Mateo Cupertino County 9 County 9.
    [Show full text]
  • THE STORY of OSCAR GRANT Preview
    DARE TO BE KING: PreviewWHAT IF THE PRINCE LIVES? A Survival Workbook for Adolescent African American Males Purposes Only By David Miller Introduction by Cephus Johnson, Executive Director of the Oscar Grant Foundation Table of Contents “No matter the circumstances that you may be going through, just push through it” Preview Ray Lewis, Former NFL Line Backer- Baltimore Ravens INTRODUCTION Open Letter to Organizations ............................................................................11 Getting Started ..................................................................................................13 Using Dare To Be King ......................................................................................17 Facilitator’s Guide ..............................................................................................18 Evaluation & Documenting the Work ...............................................................34 Dare To Be King Book Club Project ...................................................................37 SESSIONSPurposes Session 1. Orientation .......................................................................................42 Session 2. Art of War .........................................................................................48 Session 3. Confronting the School Bully ............................................................53 Session 4 & 5. The Oscar Grant Story ...............................................................60 Session 6. Whose the Greatest ...........................................................................67
    [Show full text]
  • Weekly Update
    City Manager’s 3 Weekly Update March 9, 2016 U P C O M I N G To: City Council M EETINGS From: Chris Zapata, City Manager 2016 Mark Your Calendar 3/14 City Council Work Session, 7:00 p.m., Council Chambers “Big Read” Guest Speaker Featuring Julie M. Rivett (Attached) th 3/21 City Council Meeting Sat., Mar. 12 , 2:00 p.m. – 4:30 p.m., Main Library, 300 Estudillo 7:00 p.m., Council Ave. Chambers Join Julie M. Rivett, a Dashiell Hammett Scholar and 3/28 State of the City, 6:30 granddaughter to Samuel Dashiell Hammett, for a lively discussion that p.m., Senior Community Center explores the links between her grandfather and his most famous fictional creation. The event is free and open to the public and no prior registration 4/4 City Council Meeting 7:00p.m., Council is required. Chambers 4/11 Water Pollution Control Plant Open House, 4:00 Color Up San Leandro: A Run for Fun (Attached) p.m.- 6:00 p.m. Sat., Mar. 12th, 10:00 a.m., San Leandro Marina, 14001 Monarch 4/18 City Council Meeting Bay Dr. 7:00 p.m., Council The Youth Advisory Commission (YAC) will host its annual Chambers “Color Up San Leandro: A Run for Fun” at the San Leandro Marina. 4/25 Informal Gathering 6:15 Participants will be showered in non-toxic, vibrant colored powder as p.m. they complete a lap around the marina. People of all ages and fitness City/SLUSD/SLUZD Joint Work Session, levels are encouraged to attend.
    [Show full text]
  • Bart at Twenty: Land Use and Development Impacts
    ffional Development BART@20: Land Use and Development Impacts Robert Cervero with research assistance by Carlos Castellanos, Wicaksono Sarosa, and Kenneth Rich July 1995 University of California at Berkeley - 1 BART@20: Land Use and Development Impacts Robert Cervero with Research Assistance by Carlos Castellanos, Wicaksono Sarosa, and Kenneth Rich This paper was produced with support provided by the U.S. Department of Transportation and the California State Department of Transportation (Caltrans) through the University of California Transportation Center. University of California at Berkeley Institute of Urban and Regional Development Table of Contents ONE: BART at 20: An Analysis of Land Use Impacts 1 1. INTRODUCTION 1 TWO: Research Approach and Data Sources 3 THREE: Employment and Population Changes in BART and Non-BART Areas 6 3.1. Population Changes 6 3.2. Employment Changes 3.3. Population Densities 15 3.4. Employment Densities 15 3.5. Summary 20 FOUR: Land Use Changes Over Time and by Corridor 21 4.1. General Land-Use Trends 23 4.2. Pre-BART versus Post-BART 25 4.3. Early versus Later BART 30 4.4. Trends in Non-Residential Densities 33 4.4. Summary 37 FIVE: Land-Use Changes by Station Classes 38 5.1. Grouping Variables 38 5.2. Classification 38 5.3. Station Classes 41 5.4. Trends in Residential and Non-Residential Growth Among Station Classes 44 5.5. Percent Growth in Early- versus Later-BART Years Among Station Classes 46 5.6. Trends in Non-Residential Densities Among Station Classes 46 SLX: Matched-Pair Comparisons of Land-Use Changes near BART Stations Versus Freeway Interchanges 51 6.1.
    [Show full text]
  • Bart Core System Parking Analysis
    Silicon Valley Rapid Transit Corridor Final EIR CHAPTER 5.0: BART CORE SYSTEM PARKING ANALYSIS 5.1 INTRODUCTION The “core system” represents those stations on the existing BART system outside of Santa Clara County. The 16 existing stations include South Alameda County – San Leandro, Bay Fair, Hayward, South Hayward, Union City, and Fremont; East Alameda County – Castro Valley and Dublin/Pleasanton; Oakland/Central Alameda County – MacArthur; North Alameda County/West Contra Costa County – El Cerrito Plaza and El Cerrito Del Norte; and Central and East Contra Costa County – Lafayette, Concord, North Concord/Martinez and Pittsburg/Bay Point. New riders of the BART Alternative may walk, bicycle, use another transit mode, or park and board at one of the BART core system stations and take the train from there to a station along the BART Alternative within Santa Clara County. The number of potential new riders of the BART Alternative would be somewhat limited by the ability of those riders to park and board at core system stations. To achieve the anticipated ridership for the BART Alternative as described in this document, the additional parking demand that would be generated by those new riders must be accommodated. The regional transportation model shows that providing parking for riders who may board at core system stations would require approximately 3,200 spaces in 2025. Parking expansion at the BART core system stations to meet this additional parking demand is an integral part of the BART Alternative. To avoid displacing other users or diverting riders from using the BART system to travel to and from Santa Clara County, VTA will financially support BART in the expansion of parking in the core system by the number of spaces necessary to meet the demand generated by the BART Alternative.
    [Show full text]
  • San Francisco East
    San Francisco-East Bay Rail Lines, 1939-1941 calurbanist.com Key System SP IER (Southern Pacific Interurban Electric Railway) Thousand Oaks Station Transbay Colusa & Solano Albany Solano A Downtown Oakland/12th St 5 3 9 2 7 Oakland/7th St/Dutton East H B Trestle Glen/Grand Ave (Local & Express) Santa Fe & Key Route Blvd Bay C Piedmont/40th St 3 9 Berkeley/Shattuck G (Local & Express) University of E Claremont G California 4 6 Shattuck Alameda/Encinal Sacramento & Telegraph & F South Berkeley/Adeline (4 EB, 6 WB) Delaware Bancroft H Alameda/Lincoln Berkeley K Berkeley/Sacramento (4 WB, 6 EB) 9th St 5 Shuttles Berkeley/9th St G Westbrae Dinky Claremont Hotel S College Ashby & Claremont Sacramento Northern Sacramento K College Ave E Alcatraz F K Adeline & Alcatraz Stanford Claremont Adeline 55th St Transbay Terminal Mission & 1st St Emeryville A B C E F H S 2 3 4 5 6 7 9 Shafter 40th St BRIDGE Piedmont Ave S BAY C Oakland Ave 16th St Station & Latham to Sacramento San 16th & Wood Oakland via Walnut Creek Poplar & Concord Piedmont Francisco Grand 12th St Lakeshore 7th St B Underhills Station Underhills Rd A 2nd Ave A Brief History of Transbay Trains & 16th St 4 West Alameda 6 Station 1851-1939 Transbay transit service is limited 1941 The SP IER, Sacramento Northern to ferries. Starting in 1869, “moles” or Railway, and Key System G and H lines are causeways are extended from the East Bay abandoned. At the same time, the Key System shore to rail/ferry terminals miles out.
    [Show full text]
  • BART FY19 Short Range Transit Plan/Capital Improvement Program
    BUILDING A BETTER BART BUILDING A BETTER BART FY19 SHORT RANGE TRANSIT PLAN AND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM OCTOBER 2018 San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Robert Raburn, President, Board of Directors Grace Crunican, General Manager Short Range Transit Plan and Capital Improvement Program Federal transportation statutes require that the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC), in partnership with state and local agencies, develop and periodically update a long-range Regional Transportation Plan (RTP) and a Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) that implements the RTP by programming federal funds to transportation projects contained in the RTP. To effectively execute these planning and programming responsibilities, MTC requires that each transit operator in its region that receives federal funding through the TIP prepare, adopt, and submit to MTC a Short Range Transit Plan (SRTP) that includes a Capital Improvement Program (CIP). Schedule, cost, and performance data used to generate this SRTP/CIP were based upon the most current information available as of October 2018. July 2018 Table of Contents Page 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 1-1 2 Overview of the BART System ...................................................................................... 2-1 2.1 History ....................................................................................................................... 2-1 2.2 Governance ..............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 18-311 ,:/1 Meeting Date: December 12, 2018 Alameda-Contracosta Transit District
    ReportNo: 18-311 ,:/1 Meeting Date: December 12, 2018 Alameda-ContraCosta Transit District STAFF RE PO RT TO: ACTransit Board of Directors FROM: Michael A. Hursh, General Manager SUBJECT: Operator Restroomsat BARTStations ACTION ITEM RECOMMENDED ACTION(S) Consider authorizing the GeneraIManager to negotiate and execute an agreement with the Bay Area RapidTransit District (BART)for the design, construction, operation, and maintenance of Operator restrooms. BUDGETARY/FISCAL IMPACT This project will be added to the current fiscal year Capital Budget and Capital Improvement Planwith $638,826 in District Capital funds. Capital Planning and Grants will continue to seek externalfunding to support this project. BACKGROUND/RATIONALE AC Transit provides fixed route serviceto and from many Bay Area RapidTransit District IBART) stations located in the East Bay.AC Transit Operators and Road Supervisors rely on the ability to utilize BART station restroom facilities during a scheduled break. On several occasions, employees were not able to use the public restrooms because of long lines or the restroom being closed for repairs. At the April 4, 2018 BART/AC Transit Interagency Liaison Committee jtLC) both agencies agreed to collaborate on developing a process to provide restroom access for AC Transit personnelat BARTstations. Station Restroom Assessment Staff conducted an assessmentof fourteen BART stations where AC Transit buses have scheduled layovers and are utilized by District employees for restroom breaks during the peak period between 3:00pm and 9:00pm. Listed on the table below are the BARTstations with the highest amount of buses scheduled for layover during the evening: 1 of 23 Report No. 18-311 Page2 of4 BARTStation LayoversPerPeak Period Fruitvale fremont Bay Fair West Oakland Coliseum EI Cerrito Plaza SanLeandro The following BARTstations were determined to be least utilized with lessthan 25 scheduled busesthat layover: DeINorte, South Hayward, Castro Valley, Richmond and North Berkeley.
    [Show full text]