Lufkin and Jefferson Pool Assessments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
2013 FACILITY EVALUATION Date: 24 September 2013 TO: Village of Villa Park Greg Gola, CPRP Director of Parks and Recreation Marlon Hummell Superintendent of Parks, Buildings & Grounds PROJECT NAME: Facility Evaluation Lufkin & Jefferson Pools WA PROJECT NUMBER: 2013-010 ____ Village of Villa Park Parks & Recreation / Outdoor Aquatics Facility Evaluation / 24 September 2013 / Page 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS FACILITY EVALUTION EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................................... 3 SCOPE ........................................................................................................... 3 HISTORY ....................................................................................................... 3 METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................... 3 OBSERVATIONS ........................................................................................... 4 CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................. 4 LUFKIN POOL OBSERVATIONS ........................................................................ 7 MAIN POOL ................................................................................................... 7 SPRAY AREA ............................................................................................... 13 MAIN POOL MECHANICAL .......................................................................... 14 SITE ......................................................................................................... 17 BUILDINGS .................................................................................................. 18 MECHANICAL ............................................................................................. 31 PLUMBING .................................................................................................. 33 ELECTRICAL .............................................................................................. 42 RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................ 47 JEFFERSON POOL OBSERVATIONS ............................................................. 53 MAIN POOL ................................................................................................. 53 WADING POOL ........................................................................................... 57 MAIN POOL MECHANICAL ......................................................................... 57 WADING POOL MECHANICAL .................................................................... 58 SITE ......................................................................................................... 58 BUILDINGS .................................................................................................. 60 MECHANICAL ............................................................................................. 71 PLUMBING .................................................................................................. 75 ELECTRICAL .............................................................................................. 87 RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................ 92 DETERIORATION MECHANISMS .................................................................... 97 Village of Villa Park Parks & Recreation / Outdoor Aquatics Facility Evaluation / 24 September 2013 / Page 3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY SCOPE The Villa Park Parks and Recreation Department commissioned Williams Architects/Aquatics to provide an audit of Lufkin Pool and Jefferson Pool. The intent of the evaluation was to determine the present condition of the facilities in order to assist with the planning for future repairs/replacements. TIME OF STUDY The site investigation for this study was conducted in the spring of 2013, prior to the pools being prepared by staff for the upcoming swim season. Therefore, some of the noted deficiencies and associated photographs may not be representative of current conditions as they may have been corrected by staff. HISTORY Lufkin Pool The pool opened in 1954. The original filtration system was a vacuum sand filter. In the late 1960’s to early 1970’s the filter system was converted to a vacuum DE filter. In 1997 the pool received a significant renovation which included a new stainless steel perimeter gutter system, a new PVC pool liner to address the deteriorating leaking pool vessel and new site amenities including: water slide, drop slide, spray features and a sand play area with a playground. Jefferson Pool The pool opened in 1966. The original filter system, a vacuum DE filter, is still in use today. In 1997 a new body flume slide and drop slide were added to the main pool and a new zero depth entry wading pool was constructed, with its own filter building, a new playground was also added adjacent to the new wading pool. METHODOLOGY The evaluation consisted of an on-site visual inspection of the facilities and discussions with the staff regarding areas of specific concerns. The investigation included a visual examination of the buildings, mechanical, plumbing and electric systems, structure and finish for the pools, pool gutter systems, exposed piping, pool filtration systems, chemical control and feed systems, deck areas and related equipment. This report will help identify items that require ongoing maintenance or repair and items that do not meet the current codes and regulations including the Illinois Department of Public Health Swimming Pool and Bathing Beach Code and current industry design standards. Reference to violations of the current Codes, in the body of this report, should not necessarily be construed as grounds for pool closure. The state administrative code referred to in this pool audit report is: State of Illinois Administrative Code Title 77: Public Health Chapter 1: Department of Public Health (IDPH) Subchapter n: Recreational Facilities Part 820 Illinois Swimming Pool and Bathing Beach Code Village of Villa Park Parks & Recreation / Outdoor Aquatics Facility Evaluation / 24 September 2013 / Page 4 OBSERVATIONS Both Lufkin and Jefferson pool facilities have serviced the community well for many years. Over the years staff has done a commendable job of maintaining and repairing the pools. However, with age come problems and both pools currently have significant physical issues that require major repairs or complete replacement. The pools are not compliant with current codes, state swimming pool regulations and in some areas may pose hazards to patrons. Facilities such as these were built under previous codes and therefore are allowed to continue operation without improvements to bring them into compliance with current codes (referred to as grandfathering). The exception would be a hazardous or unsafe condition or when renovations are made. CONCLUSION Lufkin Pool Pool / Decks - The findings of our facility assessment indicate that the pool and associated decks have a number of deficiencies that require major repairs. The primary deficiencies include: • Severe deterioration of existing concrete pool structure • Existing PVC pool liner has exceeded its useful life and requires replacement • Extensive issues/conditions that do not meet current IDPH code requirements • The concrete DE filter requires continual repair to stop it from leaking. • Poor condition of decks and associated deck drainage. Deck drainage does not meet current IDPH code requirements. • Age of original underground main drain piping Repairs/replacements of the deficient items listed in this report could be done and the Village could continue to operate the facility. However, with a pool that is nearly 50 years old, it is not advisable or a suitable long term investment solution to make major repairs to the pool. It is our opinion that the facility has reached the end of its useful life and it is our recommendation that it should be replaced in the near future. Site (Outside pool fence) – The parking lot is in generally good condition however requires some crack repair and should be seal-coated and restriped. Missing and / or damaged wheel stops should be replaced and damaged concrete apron and walks should be repaired. Buildings - Bathhouse - the Bathhouse is in fair condition and with proper maintenance can continue to support the pool use. The building layout adequately serves the public’s needs; however, has a cramped, outdated staff area. Current trends suggest you may want to consider a renovation to include improvements to the staff areas and the addition of Village of Villa Park Parks & Recreation / Outdoor Aquatics Facility Evaluation / 24 September 2013 / Page 5 family changing rooms. As part of these improvements you should include ADA upgrades and mechanical, plumbing, electrical and energy code improvements. Filtration / Concessions Building - When the pool undergoes major renovation or replacement, we recommend demolition and replacement of this building. This will not only provide an improved, code updated space for the new pool filtration equipment, but also an opportunity to provide a state-of-the-art concessions operation. Jefferson Pool Pool / Decks- The findings of our facility assessment indicate that the pool and associated decks have a number of deficiencies that require major repairs. The primary deficiencies include: • Deterioration of existing concrete pool structure • Severe deterioration of existing painted pool finish • Major water loss