Federal Register/Vol. 80, No. 212/Tuesday, November 3, 2015/Notices
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
67742 Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 212 / Tuesday, November 3, 2015 / Notices reason, the Commission treats such implementing, enforcing, inviting, Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust conduct as ‘‘inherently suspect’’ (that is, offering, or soliciting an agreement with Improvements Act of 1976, requires presumptively anticompetitive).6 This any competitor to divide markets, to persons contemplating certain mergers means that an invitation to collude can allocate customers, or to fix prices. or acquisitions to give the Federal Trade be condemned under Section 5 without Section II, Paragraph C bars Step N Commission and the Assistant Attorney a showing that the respondent possesses Grip from urging any competitor to General advance notice and to wait market power.7 raise, fix or maintain its price or rate designated periods before The Commission has long held that an levels or to limit or reduce service terms consummation of such plans. Section or levels. invitation to collude violates Section 5 7A(b)(2) of the Act permits the agencies, of the FTC Act even where there is no Section II, Paragraph D forbids Step N Grip from instructing or encouraging a in individual cases, to terminate this proof that the competitor accepted the waiting period prior to its expiration invitation.8 There are various reasons distributor or seller to engage in the conduct proscribed in Section II, and requires that notice of this action be for this. First, unaccepted solicitations published in the Federal Register. may facilitate coordination between Paragraphs A through C. competitors because they reveal Sections III–VI of the Proposed Order The following transactions were information about the solicitor’s impose certain standard reporting and granted early termination—on the dates compliance requirements on Step N intentions or preferences. Second, it can indicated—of the waiting period Grip. be difficult to discern whether a provided by law and the premerger The Proposed Order will expire in 20 notification rules. The listing for each competitor has accepted a solicitation. years. Third, finding a violation may deter transaction includes the transaction similar conduct—conduct that has no By direction of the Commission. number and the parties to the legitimate business purpose.9 Donald S. Clark, transaction. The grants were made by Secretary. the Federal Trade Commission and the III. The Proposed Consent Order [FR Doc. 2015–27934 Filed 11–2–15; 8:45 am] Assistant Attorney General for the The Proposed Order contains the BILLING CODE 6750–01–P Antitrust Division of the Department of following substantive provisions: Justice. Neither agency intends to take Section II, Paragraph A of the any action with respect to these Proposed Order enjoins Step N Grip FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION proposed acquisitions during the from communicating with its Granting of Request for Early applicable waiting period. competitors about rates or prices, with Termination of the Waiting Period a proviso permitting public posting of Under the Premerger Notification rates. Rules Section II, Paragraph B prohibits Step N Grip from entering into, participating Section 7A of the Clayton Act, 15 in, maintaining, organizing, U.S.C. 18a, as added by Title II of the EARLY TERMINATIONS GRANTED MARCH 1, 2015 THRU SEPTEMBER 30, 2015 03/03/2015 20150580 ...... G FMR LLC; The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America; FMR LLC. 03/06/2015 20150597 ...... G Accenture plc; Robert E LaRose Revocable Trust; Accenture plc. 20150614 ...... G Hitachi Ltd.; Pentaho Corporation; Hitachi Ltd. 20150628 ...... G Healthstream, Inc.; Dan Littrell; Healthstream, Inc. 20150637 ...... G Elliott International Limited; Informatica Corporation; Elliott International Limited. 20150638 ...... G 3M Company; Ivera Medical Corporation; 3M Company. 20150639 ...... G Elliott Associates, L.P.; Informatica Corporation; Elliott Associates, L.P. 20150648 ...... G Fir Tree Value Master Fund, L.P.; CDK Global, Inc.; Fir Tree Value Master Fund, L.P. 20150651 ...... G Harbour Group Investments VI, L.P.; Audax Private Equity Fund III, L.P.; Harbour Group Investments VI, L.P. 20150655 ...... G Berwind Corporation; Windjammer Senior Equity Fund III, L.P.; Berwind Corporation. 2015), available at https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ Commission can condemn it ‘‘without proof of has been endorsed by leading antitrust scholars. See documents/public_statements/735411/150813 market power or actual effects’’). P. Areeda & H. Hovenkamp, VI ANTITRUST LAW section5speech.pdf. 8 See, e.g., In re Valassis Commc’ns, Inc., 141 ¶ 1419 (2003); Stephen Calkins, Counterpoint: The 6 See, e.g., In re North Carolina Bd. of Dental F.T.C. 247 (2006); In re Stone Container, 125 F.T.C. Legal Foundation of the Commission’s Use of Examiners, 152 F.T.C. 640, 668 (2011) (noting that 853 (1998); In re Precision Moulding, 122 F.T.C. 104 Section 5 to Challenge Invitations to Collude is inherently suspect conduct is such that be (1996). See also In re McWane, Inc., Docket No. Secure, ANTITRUST Spring 2000, at 69. In a case ‘‘reasonably characterized as ‘giv[ing] rise to an 9351, Opinion of the Commission on Motions for brought under a state’s version of Section 5, the intuitively obviously inference of anticompetitive Summary Decision at 20–21 (F.T.C. Aug. 9, 2012) First Circuit expressed support for the effect.’’’ (citation omitted)). (‘‘an invitation to collude is ‘the quintessential Commission’s application of Section 5 to 7 See, e.g., In re Realcomp II, Ltd., 148 F.T.C. example of the kind of conduct that should be . invitations to collude. Liu v. Amerco, 677 F.3d 489 ___, No. 9320, 2009 FTC LEXIS 250 at *51 (Oct. 30, challenged as a violation of Section 5’ ’’) (citing the (1st Cir. 2012). 2009) (Comm’n Op.) (explaining that if conduct is Statement of Chairman Leibowitz and 9 In re Valassis Comm’c, Inc., 141 F.T.C. 247, 283 ‘‘inherently suspect’’ in nature, and there are no Commissioners Kovacic and Rosch, In re U-Haul (2006) (Analysis of Agreement Containing Consent cognizable procompetitive justifications, the Int’l, Inc., 150 F.T.C. 1, 53 (2010)). This conclusion Order to Aid Public Comment). VerDate Sep<11>2014 19:22 Nov 02, 2015 Jkt 238001 PO 00000 Frm 00045 Fmt 4703 Sfmt 4703 E:\FR\FM\03NON1.SGM 03NON1 mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 212 / Tuesday, November 3, 2015 / Notices 67743 EARLY TERMINATIONS GRANTED—Continued MARCH 1, 2015 THRU SEPTEMBER 30, 2015 03/09/2015 20150117 ...... G Ingredion Incorporated; Penford Corporation; Ingredion Incorporated. 20150664 ...... G Rite Aid Corporation; TPG VI DE AIV II, L.P.; Rite Aid Corporation. 20150671 ...... G WPP plc; comScore, Inc.; WPP plc. 20150675 ...... G WPP plc; comScore, Inc.; WPP plc. 20150685 ...... G Heinz Hermann Thiele; Vossloh AG; Heinz Hermann Thiele. 03/11/2015 20150656 ...... G LLR Equity Partners IV, L.P.; Generation Capital Partners II LP; LLR Equity Partners IV, L.P. 20150676 ...... G TPG Magnate Holdings, L.P.; Mossi & Ghisolfi S.p.A.; TPG Magnate Holdings, L.P. 03/12/2015 20150594 ...... G Providence Equity Partners VI L.P.; Schoolwires, Inc.; Providence Equity Partners VI L.P. 20150608 ...... G Kevin A. Plank; MyFitnessPal, Inc.; Kevin A. Plank. 20150649 ...... G TA XI L.P.; Michael Miola; TA XI L.P. 20150654 ...... G The Pennsylvania State University; Catholic Health Initiatives; The Pennsylvania State University. 20150682 ...... G Arrow Electronics, Inc.; immixGroup, Inc.; Arrow Electronics, Inc. 03/13/2015 20150684 ...... G Valeant Pharmaceuticals International, Inc.; Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd.; Valeant Pharmaceuticals International, Inc. 20150697 ...... G BDT Capital Partners Fund I AIV, L.P.; Marquette Transportation Company Holding; BDT Capital Partners Fund I AIV, L.P. 20150702 ...... G Michael J. Cantanucci; Wiesenthal Holding GmbH; Michael J. Cantanucci. 20150704 ...... G JLL Patheon Co-Investment Fund, L.P. (Cayman); IRIX Pharmaceuticals, Inc.; JLL Patheon Co-Investment Fund, L.P. (Cayman). 20150707 ...... G Todd L. Boehly; Eldridge Investors, LLC; Todd L. Boehly. 03/16/2015 20150647 ...... G New Media Investment Group Inc.; SF Holding Corp.; New Media Investment Group Inc. 20150712 ...... G Berkshire Hathaway Inc.; The Procter & Gamble Company; Berkshire Hathaway Inc. 20150714 ...... G Stifel Financial Corp.; Sterne Agee Group, Inc.; Stifel Financial Corp. 03/17/2015 20150674 ...... G Hanesbrands Inc.; Merit Mezzanine Fund V, L.P.; Hanesbrands Inc. 20150680 ...... G Merck & Co., Inc.; NGM Biopharmaceuticals, Inc.; Merck & Co., Inc. 20150708 ...... G Pacolet Milliken Enterprises, Inc.; Metalmark Capital Partners, L.P.; Pacolet Milliken Enterprises, Inc. 03/18/2015 20150657 ...... G JANA Offshore Partners, Ltd.; Computer Sciences Corporation; JANA Offshore Partners, Ltd. 20150658 ...... G JANA Nirvana Offshore Fund, Ltd.; Computer Sciences Corporation; JANA Nirvana Offshore Fund, Ltd. 20150699 ...... G Deutsche Telekom AG; Verizon Communications Inc.; Deutsche Telekom AG. 20150700 ...... G Verizon Communications Inc.; Deutsche Telekom AG; Verizon Communications Inc. 20150710 ...... G Philip and Jocelyn Hagerman; BioRx, LLC; Philip and Jocelyn Hagerman. 20150715 ...... G Catamaran Corporation; Brazos Equity Fund II, L.P.; Catamaran Corporation. 20150716 ...... G Warburg Pincus Private Equity X O&G, L.P.; Laredo Petroleum, Inc.; Warburg Pincus Private Equity X O&G, L.P. 03/19/2015 20150006 ...... G Waste Management Inc.; Deffenbaugh Disposal, Inc.; Waste Management Inc. 20150636 ...... G Hospira, Inc.; Pfenex Inc.; Hospira, Inc. 20150662