American Experience with Low-Dose Thalidomide Therapy for Severe Cutaneous Lupus Erythematosus
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
OBSERVATION American Experience With Low-Dose Thalidomide Therapy for Severe Cutaneous Lupus Erythematosus Daihung Jay Duong; G. Thomas Spigel, MD; Richard T. Moxley III, MD; Anthony A. Gaspari, MD Background: There is a renewed interest in thalidomide effects were sedation, constipation, and weight gain. Two therapy after its surprising effectiveness in treating erythema patients reported experiencing intermittent shaking epi- nodosum leprosum was first published. Thalidomide has sodes, an adverse effect not previously reported in the subsequently been reported to be effective in treating a num- literature. Four patients reported symptoms of paresthe- ber of dermatoses, including cutaneous lupus erythema- sia, but none was found to be caused by thalidomide- tosus. We examined the efficacy and adverse effects of low- induced peripheral neuropathy. dose, long-term thalidomide monotherapy in 7 patients with various forms of cutaneous lupus erythematosus that were Conclusions: A low starting dose of thalidomide as a unresponsive to traditional systemic treatments. monotherapy with continued sun avoidance is a safe and effective treatment for the various cutaneous manifesta- Observations: Six of the 7 patients treated with tha- tions of lupus erythematosus after traditional therapeu- lidomide after discontinuation of other oral agents had tic options have failed to control disease. Our experi- complete or marked resolution of their previously treat- ence with low-dose, long-term thalidomide therapy ment-resistant cutaneous lesions, with an average re- suggests that peripheral neuropathy is not as common sponse time of 2.2 ± 0.8 months. Our cohort of 7 pa- as suggested by other studies (up to 50% of patients treated tients with cutaneous lupus erythematosus was treated with thalidomide in some series). with thalidomide therapy for an average of 2.4 ± 3.1 years (range, 1 month to 9 years). The most common adverse Arch Dermatol. 1999;135:1079-1087 HALIDOMIDE (a-N-phthalyl- ministration for the treatment of ery- glutamic-acid-imide), a glu- thema nodosum leprosum. However, it re- tamic acid derivative, was mains an experimental treatment for a first synthesized in 1956 by variety of inflammatory skin disorders.18 Kunz and his coworkers in Among those reported included actinic West Germany.1,2 Thalidomide became prurigo,19,20 orogenital ulcerations,21-23 T 24 widely used as a sleeping aid but was re- Weber-Christian disease, graft-vs-host moved from the market after teratogenic disease,25-28 and chronic cutaneous lupus and neurologic effects were estab- erythematosus (CCLE).29,30 lished.3-12 Subsequently, thalidomide be- Many European studies have docu- came available only for experimental pur- mented that thalidomide is an effective poses. There was renewed interest in the treatment for various inflammatory der- clinical uses of thalidomide after She- matoses, such as cutaneous lupus ery- 13 From the Olean Medical Group, skin reported in 1965 the effectiveness thematosus (CLE), that are unresponsive 31 Olean, NY (Dr Spigel); and of thalidomide in treating erythema no- to standard therapy. Knop et al, in a study Departments of Neurology dosum leprosum. Sheskin, after giving of 60 cases of CCLE, reported that 90% of (Dr Moxley), Dermatology thalidomide to patients with leprosy for the patients had a complete or marked re- (Dr Gaspari), and sedative purposes, made a serendipitous sponse to treatment with thalidomide, 400 Microbiology/Immunology discovery that the treatment resulted in im- mg/d, and that 71% had relapses when tha- (Dr Gaspari) and Cancer mediate improvement in symptoms, and lidomide was withdrawn. Stevens et al32 Center (Dr Gaspari), that the patients’ cutaneous erythema- had similar findings with thalidomide, 50 University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry, tous lesions resolved in as little as 3 days. to 100 mg/d, with various adjustments, if Rochester, NY. Mr Duong is a His findings were confirmed by other re- any, in the doses of other oral medica- 14-16 17 medical student at the ports and by his follow-up study. tions already being used to treat CLE. Im- University of Rochester School Recently, thalidomide therapy has provements were observed within 2 weeks of Medicine and Dentistry. been approved by the Food and Drug Ad- of treatment, and maximum benefits were ARCH DERMATOL / VOL 135, SEP 1999 1079 ©1999 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 09/28/2021 PATIENTS AND METHODS All 7 patients were treated according to the pub- lished guidelines for thalidomide use.39 All other systemic medications for controlling CLE were discon- We reviewed the medical records of 7 women with disfig- tinued. The patients returned every 3 months for follow- uring CLE who were treated with thalidomide in a 100- up, and the efficacy and adverse effects of their thalido- mg/d starting dose after exhausting the other therapeutic mide treatment were documented. Nerve conduction options, including glucocorticosteroids, antimalarials, studies, complete blood cell counts, 12-factor automated immunosuppressants, dapsone, clofazimine, and retinoids. blood chemistry studies, and thyroid studies (free thy- These patients continue to receive thalidomide therapy. roxine, thyrotropin) were done every 6 months or Candidates for thalidomide therapy were selected by the sooner as needed for baseline comparison. Any change presence of severe CLE that had previously been treated in blood cell count or results of serum chemistry studies with first- and second-line therapies.38 This treatment was was followed up closely to determine if it was thalido- offered on a compassionate basis by the Department of mide related. All patients were examined at baseline Dermatology, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY, for with a complete neurologic examination, with a focus on patients who had been referred by community dermatolo- clinical assessment of touch, scratch, vibratory, and gists. Table 1 lists their conditions and Table 2 position sensations. These examinations were repeated describes the therapeutic modalities that failed. Candidates at 6-month intervals during thalidomide therapy. Nerve were further selected by their ability to understand the conduction studies were done in all patients at baseline risks and benefits of thalidomide therapy. Further require- and at 6-month intervals to detect evidence of drug- ments included a willingness to comply with the monitor- induced sensory or motor loss in the extremities. The ing requirements, and to sign an informed consent (re- nerve conduction studies included unilateral examina- viewed and approved by the University of Rochester tion of the arm and leg. Standard techniques of percuta- Research Subjects Review Board). After a candidate for neous stimulation and surface recording were used. thalidomide therapy was identified, a single-patient inves- Motor conduction velocity, distal motor latency, and the tigational new drug application was submitted to the Food amplitude of the compound muscle action potential and Drug Administration. After this application was sub- were measured from the common peroneal, tibial, ulnar, mitted and approved (usually 3-6 months after submis- and/or median motor nerves. Sensory conduction veloc- sion), the Food and Drug Administration issued an inves- ity, sensory distal latency, and the amplitude (baseline to tigational new drug number (see Table 3). Contraception negative peak) of the sensory nerve action potential was initiated in women of childbearing age. A prescription (SNAP) were obtained from the sural, superficial pero- with payment and IND number were mailed to the sup- neal, ulnar, and/or median sensory nerves. The patients plier of thalidomide. This drug was then mailed to the pre- understood that they must stop taking thalidomide scribing physician, who dispensed the thalidomide to the should they begin to experience paresthesia. All patients patient. continued sun avoidance and use of sunscreen. Table 1. Patient Histories* Duration of Patient No./ Cutaneous 1982 ARA Sex/Age, y LE, y Lesion Sites Diagnosis Criteria for SLE Autoantibodies Contraception 1/F/46 25 Scalp CCLE ANA ANA Tubal ligation 2/F/48 7 Scalp, face, trunk, CCLE, SLE Malar rash, discoid rash, ND Tubal ligation extremities photosensitivity, ANA 3/F/49 33 Face, trunk, extremities SCLE, SLE Malar rash, discoid rash, ANA, anti-La Tubal ligation photosensitivity, ANA 4/F/28 11 Scalp, face, CCLE ND ND Oral, barrier 5/F/28 9 Scalp, face, trunk, CCLE, SLE Malar rash, discoid rash, ANA, anti-RNP, Oral, barrier extremities photosensitivity, anti-Ro arthritis, ANA, leukopenia 6/F/64 18 Face, mouth, trunk, Scleroderma with ANA ANA, anti-Ro None extremities LE, LP overlap (postmenopausal) 7/F/43 28 Face, mouth CCLE ND ND Hysterectomy *LE indicates lupus erythematosus; ARA, American Rheumatism Association; SLE, systemic lupus erythematosus; CCLE, chronic cutaneous lupus erythematosus; SCLE, subacute cutaneous lupus erythematosus; LP, lichen planus; ANA, antinuclear antibody; ND, not determined; anti-La, Sjögren syndrome B antigen; anti-RNP, antiribonuclear proteins; and anti-Ro, Sjögren syndrome A antigen. achieved within 16 weeks. Another study involving 11 in the cutaneous treatment of various forms of lupus ery- patients reported that a maintenance dose of 25 to 50 mg thematosus (LE).34-37 The reported adverse effects in these every night or every other night was necessary to pre- studies included paresthesia, drowsiness, abdominal dis-