CONCLUSION This Study of the Interactions Between the VOC

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

CONCLUSION This Study of the Interactions Between the VOC CONCLUSION This study of the interactions between the VOC employees and the mem- bers of the court of Ayutthaya shows how over the years ‘fixed Dutch/European categories’ of the Siamese court elite were created. The Dutch perceptions of the Siamese court in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries generally agreed with contemporary European views of the ‘absolute power’ of the Siamese king and the ‘splendour’ of his court, which both in Dutch/European and in Thai terms served to manifest his power. To a large extent, Dutch accounts, such as the work of Schouten, were even the main source of European perceptions of Siam. Although these few ‘fixed categories’ did not change dramatically over time, it is possible to see how the Dutch adapted themselves to an envi- ronment which, if it were to allow them their trade, needed to be under- stood at various cultural and political levels. To show and understand the Dutch awareness of this cultural-political situation, this study has analysed the nearly two centuries of Dutch-Thai interaction under the aegis of the VOC. From the beginning, the Dutch were awed by the ‘absolute power’ and ‘splendour’ of the Siamese King, which they sometimes regarded as unjust and wasteful. Despite such misgivings, they quickly recognized the centripetal force of the Ayutthayan court, into which they them- selves were drawn, as they were dependent on the King’s favour, as were all other court members. To communicate with the King more effectively, the Dutch mastered the Siamese ‘language of ritual’. They also learnt to recognize the general and personal needs of each Siamese ruler and his entourage and made use of that understanding. Through all this, they also gained a working knowledge of the political reality of the kingdom. This knowledge of things Thai—their ‘cultural capital’, so to say—was essential if they were to realize their prime goal, namely the establishment and operation of trading relations with the Ayutthaya Kingdom. Undoubtedly, many Europeans deemed accepting Siamese court etiquette to be a gesture of submission to this oriental King. Even so, the VOC men, known for their pragmatism, were more often than not flexible enough to observe the many intricacies of local custom. They often did follow local protocol because they genuinely understood the sig- nificance of ceremony and deference. They only tried to resist when a cer- emony or a contribution implied that they were bowing to a non- Christian religion and jarred their religious conscience. Even so, the 222 CONCLUSION Dutch and the Siamese often reached a compromise, especially because this would please the Siamese King. The Dutch were aware of the vicissitudes at court and tried to adjust to them, above all by re-inventing their own functions to suit the specif- ic needs of each Siamese King. Having established themselves in the commercial and diplomatic order of Siam during the reigns of Kings Ekathotsarot and Songtham, the Dutch further strengthened their posi- tion by forging a political and military alliance with King Prasatthong. After diplomacy and military alliance had lost their prominence or prac- ticability, the Dutch retained King Narai’s favour by supporting the expansion of his personal world to meet the wider one. More serious problems occurred when the following Kings Phetracha and Süa con- sidered neither Europeans trustworthy allies nor European culture a prominent element in court prestige. Nevertheless, for the rest of the time, the Dutch remained Siam’s most important European trade partner and the Kings’ indispensable link to the outside world. Not only the political and economic conditions but also the social and cultural life of each reign was defined to a large extent by the person- al strengths, or weaknesses, and personal interests of each ruler. The history of the Ayutthayan court as seen through Dutch eyes shows a constant power struggle between individuals and between interest groups. In the reality of Siamese politics, the Dutch also saw that the ‘absolute power’ of its King had its limits, as proven by the recurrent succession conflicts and the increasing need for power-sharing experienced by the Kings of the eighteenth century. What the Dutch observed even more clearly in their daily experience was that the khunnang—who were both partners and competitors of the Dutch—protected their interests by try- ing to manipulate the King’s knowledge of the precise circumstances of politics and trade. The Kings responded by tolerating this manipulation; sometimes fighting back to reclaim control; sometimes feeling powerless against it. Dutch understanding of the power relations among the Siamese elite did not always help them out. Especially in the seventeenth century, the Dutch often felt that the Kings were kept blind by their officials to the injustices done to them. However, studying Dutch sources, it is fairly obvious that Kings may have chosen deliberately to turn a blind eye to these injustices every now and again. Consequently, the claim by the VOC employees that the ruler had no knowledge of the miseries his ser- vants caused them seemed in a way a strategy which helped the Dutch to survive in Siam rather than to reflect reality. Notably, the tendency to stress the role of the King as the ‘last instance’ to whom the Dutch looked for succour1 grew less from the last decade of the seventeenth century; the disappearance of this ‘topos’ also reflected the fact that, gradually, the.
Recommended publications
  • Unit 1 Is the Introduction. No Lecture Note Unit 2 Thai Architecture
    1 Unit 1 is the introduction. No lecture note Unit 2 Thai Architecture Composition General concept of architecture- the art of shaping of space (physical, perceptual / conceptual and behavioral space) Outstanding characteristics of Thai arts/ architecture Influential factors and design concept of Thai architecture General Concept of Architecture Outstanding Characteristics of Thai Arts/ Architecture Thai art is very much influenced by nature and environment of Thai society. It’s outstanding characteristics include: - Its delicate beauty; this character reflects the character and mind of Thai people which can be perceived in created arts. - Most traditional arts in Thailand are created to promote Buddhism or are created from Buddhist faiths and beliefs. Thai architecture Thai architecture is defined as art of building or construction. In Thai context, buildings include houses and residences, buildings in monastery or temples such as Ubosot, Vihara, Stupa and Chedi, palatial buildings or palaces, halls, pavilions, and others. Architectural designs and functions vary by geographies and can be categorized by functions: (1) residences (e.g. houses, mansions, royal residences, palaces, grand palaces); and (2) monasteries or architecture that relates to religion (e.g. Ubosot, Vihara, monk’s residences, scripture halls, bell towers, drum towers, Stupa, Chedi). Background of architectural development of uumanity Architecture is not just a science of construction but it is a kind of ―Visual Art‖ Visual art is defined as plastic or tangible art which means that it has the following compositions: - stable form and size - ordered and well- planned structure - mass as well as massive 2 - space - proportion - unity - purpose - creativity - artistic value - serving human desires, physically and mentally (mind & imagination) Development of humanity architecture Human had been living in caves, cliffs, mountains, or other kinds of natural protecting areas.
    [Show full text]
  • Sports in Pre-Modern and Early Modern Siam: Aggressive and Civilised Masculinities
    Sports in Pre-Modern and Early Modern Siam: Aggressive and Civilised Masculinities Charn Panarut A thesis submitted in fulfilment of The requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Sociology and Social Policy Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences The University of Sydney 2018 Statement of Authorship This dissertation is the copyrighted work of the author, Charn Panarut, and the University of Sydney. This thesis has not been previously submitted for any degree or other objectives. I certify that this thesis contains no documents previously written or published by anyone except where due reference is referenced in the dissertation itself. i Abstract This thesis is a contribution to two bodies of scholarship: first, the historical understanding of the modernisation process in Siam, and in particular the role of sport in the gradual pacification of violent forms of behaviour; second, one of the central bodies of scholarship used to analyse sport sociologically, the work of Norbert Elias and Eric Dunning on sport and the civilising process. Previous studies of the emergence of a more civilised form of behaviour in modern Siam highlight the imitation of Western civilised conducts in political and sporting contexts, largely overlooking the continued role of violence in this change in Siamese behaviour from the pre- modern to modern periods. This thesis examines the historical evidence which shows that, from around the 1900s, Siamese elites engaged in deliberate projects to civilise prevalent non-elites’ aggressive conducts. This in turn has implications for the Eliasian understanding of sports and civilising process, which emphasises their unplanned development alongside political and economic changes in Europe, at the expense of grasping the deliberate interventions of the Siamese elites.
    [Show full text]
  • Ayutthaya Wat Phra Si Sanphet Saraburi • Ang Thong • Suphan Buri Pathum Thani • Nonthaburi Contents Ayutthaya 8 Pathum Thani 44
    Ayutthaya Wat Phra Si Sanphet Saraburi • Ang Thong • Suphan Buri Pathum Thani • Nonthaburi Contents Ayutthaya 8 Pathum Thani 44 Saraburi 24 Nonthaburi 50 Ang Thong 32 Suphan Buri 38 8 Wat Mahathat Ayutthaya The ancient city of Ayutthaya, formally designated Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya was the Thai capital for 417 years, and is one of Thailand’s major tourist attractions. 8 9 Ayutthaya province is relatively small at 2,557 sq. km. and is easily accessible due to good road, rail and river connections and its proximity to Bangkok. Straddling the Chao Phraya River, the nation’s principal waterway, the province is extremely important, as it was the Siamese capital for four centuries. The city of Ayutthaya is 76 km. north of Bangkok and boasts numerous magnificent ruins from its days as the capital. Just to the south, in perfect condition, stands the royal palace of Bang Pa-in set in splendid gardens. The province is also noted for H.M. the Queen’s Bang Sai Arts and Crafts Centre. The ancient city of Ayutthaya, formally designated Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya was the Thai capital for 417 years, and is one of Thailand’s major tourist attractions. Many ancient ruins and art works can be seen in a city that was founded in 1350 by King U-Thong when the Thais were forced southwards by northern neighbours. During the period when Ayutthaya was capital, 33 kings and several dynasties ruled the kingdom, until the glittering city was sacked by the Burmese in 1767, ruined and abandoned. The extensive ruins and the historical records demonstrate that Ayutthaya was one of Southeast Asia’s most prosperous cities.
    [Show full text]
  • Ayutthaya Tourist Information Division (Tel
    Information by: TAT Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya Tourist Information Division (Tel. 0 2250 5500 ext. 2141-5) Designed & Printed by: Promotional Material Production Division, Marketing Services Department. The contents of this publication are subject to change without notice. 2010 Copyright. No commercial reprinting of this material allowed Ayutthaya April 2010 Free Copy Wat Phra Si Sanphet 08.00-20.00 hrs. Everyday Tourist information by fax available 24 hrs. E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.tourismthailand.org Cover Ayutthaya Eng jai.indd 1 6/22/11 11:18 AM 71 TAT Tourist Information Centres Tourism Authority of Thailand Head Office 1600 Phetchaburi Road, Makkasan, Ratchathewi, Bangkok 10400 Tel: 0 2250 5500 Fax: 0 2250 5511 E-mail: [email protected] www.tourismthailand.org Ministry of Tourism and Sports 4 Ratchadamnoen Nok Avenue, Bangkok 10100 Open daily from 8.30-16.30 hrs. TAT Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya 108/22 Mu 4 Tambon Pratuchai, Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya, Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya 13000 Tel : 0 3524 6076-7 Fax : 0 3524 6078 E-mail : [email protected] Area of Responsibility : Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya Ayutthaya Tourist Centre The former municipal building Phra Sisanphet Road, Tambon Pratuchai Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya, Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya 13000 Ayutthaya Elephant Kraal Tel: 0 3532 2730-1 Fax: 0 3532 2350 Transportation 6 Tourist Attractions 8 Amphoe Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya 8 Amphoe Bang Sai 29 Amphoe Bang Pa-in 34 Amphoe Bang Pa Han 41 Amphoe Nakhon Luang 41 Interesting Activities 44 Events and Festivals 49 Cover Ayutthaya Eng jai.indd 2 6/16/11 2:20 PM Contents Local Products 51 Local Product & Souvenir Shops 53 Suggested Itinerary 56 Accommodations in Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya 58 Accommodation 58 Restaurants 62 Travel Agent 69 Useful Calls 70 4 Wat Yai Chaimongkhon Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya 5 The ancient city of Ayutthaya, or Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya, the Thai capital for 417 years, is one of Thailand’s major tourist attractions.
    [Show full text]
  • The Grand Palace in the Description of Ayutthaya: Translation and Commentary
    The Grand Palace in the Description of Ayutthaya: Translation and Commentary Chris Baker1 “The Kings Palace is seated upon the River, resembling a little Town apart, great and magnificent, many of its Buildings and Towers being entirely gilded.” (Caron and Schouten, True Description, 125) The only significant account of the Ayutthaya Grand Palace2 appears in the Description of Ayutthaya, a document probably compiled in early Bangkok from the memories of residents of the city prior to its sack in 1767 (see details at the head of the translation below). Here I present a translation from the document along with some analysis of what the palace tells us about Siamese kingship in the late Ayutthaya era. This account of the palace is important because no other historical source offers much information. All that can be gleaned from the Palace Law are the names of a few buildings and arrangements for guarding the walls. Most European accounts comment on the size of the complex but have almost nothing on the interior because the authors had not seen it. At the visit of the French embassy in 1685, Chaumont, de Choisy, Forbin, and Tachard were among the party that went inside and all wrote accounts of the experience. However, each was intent on recording the process of the audience rather than its surroundings. All describe the spectacle of elephants, horses, soldiers, and “mandarins” amassed in the courtyards as they walked to the audience hall, but have little to say about the layout and architecture of the palace other than some vague (and mutually conflicting) accounts of the number of gates and courtyards they traversed.
    [Show full text]
  • SEVENTEENTH CENTURY JAPANESE DOCUMENTS ABOUT SIAM* by Yoneo Ishii
    SEVENTEENTH CENTURY JAPANESE DOCUMENTS ABOUT SIAM* by Yoneo Ishii The Cabinet Library (Naikaku Bunko, P'] ~"'l Jt Jll) in Tokyo has collections of documents called Ti.isen Fiisetsusho ( ~ Aa )§\, ~ W ), "Reports and Tales from the Chinese Ships." These are subdivided into two categories, Kaihentai ( ~ 1f,_ &: !!j) and Kikoshosetsu (~~tit ~ ~ m). The Tosen Fusetsusho papers record a great deal of varied informa­ tion which was all collected from crewmen and passengers on board the "Chinese" junks (Tosen, ~ A!j) that called at Nagasaki in the mid-Toku­ gawa period. These documents were kept strictly secret by the Toku­ gawa government, and even now they are little known outside Japan. Thanks to the Oriental Library (Tuyu Bunko) many Tosen Fii.~etsusho have now been published and they await much wider use by historians.l The aim of this short paper is to show that they can add to our information about 17th century Siam. But before moving directly into that topic, we shall give a brief history of the earliest relations between Siam and Japan to show the background of the trade of the two countries against which the Tosen Fu.1etsusho can be appropriately evaluated. Curiously, the first account of Thai-Japanese relations is found in neither a Siamese nor a Japanese source, but in a Korean one. The Koryu-si ( ;ij H ~),History of Korea, states that as early as 1388, the king of Sien Lo Hok Kok ( i.l .'li. M @ , the name under which Siam was then known in the Easq dispatched an envoy of eight members headed by a man called Nai Kung ( 1ft IJ to tbe court of Korea to pay tribute.
    [Show full text]
  • Ayutthaya Saraburi Ang Thong Suphan Buri Pathum Thani Nonthaburi Wat Phukhao Thong CONTENTS
    Ayutthaya Saraburi Ang Thong Suphan Buri Pathum Thani Nonthaburi Wat Phukhao Thong CONTENTS AYUTTHAYA 8 City Attractions 9 Out-Of-City Attractions 14 Special Events 17 Interesting Activities 18 How to Get There 19 Local Transportation 19 SARABURI 20 City Attractions 21 Out-Of-City Attractions 21 Special Events 25 Local Products 27 How to Get There 27 ANG THONG 28 City Attractions 29 Out-Of-City Attractions 29 Local Products 32 Special Event 33 How to Get There 33 SUPHAN BURI 34 City Attractions 35 Out-Of-City Attractions 37 Special Event 39 Local Products 39 How to Get There 39 PATHUM THANI 40 City Attractions 41 Local Products 45 How to Get There 45 NONTHABURI 46 City Attractions 47 Special Events 50 Local Products 51 How to Get There 51 AYUTHAYA AYUTTHAYA Saraburi Ang Thong Suphan Buri Pathum Thani Nonthaburi Bangkok Wat Yai Chaimongkhon AYUTTHAYA Straddling the Chao Phraya River, the nation’s The centre provides information services and principal waterway, the province is extremely a library containing historical materials about important, as it was the Siamese capital for Ayutthaya. Open on Tuesday - Saturday at 9.00 four centuries. This province is relatively small a.m.- 4.30 p.m. (Closing on Sunday and Monday) at 2,557 sq. kms. and is easily accessible due to For more information, contact Tel. +66 3524 good road, rail, and river connections and its 5123. proximity to Bangkok. Chao Sam Phraya National Museum The city of Ayutthaya is 76 kilometres north of Located on Rochana Road, opposite the city wall, Bangkok and boasts numerous magnificent the Museum houses antique bronze Buddha ruins from its days as the capital.
    [Show full text]
  • Final Part of the Description of Ayutthaya with Remarks on Defence, Policing, Infrastructure, and Sacred Sites
    Final Part of the Description of Ayutthaya with Remarks on Defence, Policing, Infrastructure, and Sacred Sites Chris Baker1 The Description of Ayutthaya is a verbal description of the old capital, probably compiled from the memories of survivors after its destruction in 1767. I have published translations of two extracts from the document in JSS99 (2011) and JSS101 (2013). This article has a translation of the remaining portions. These deal with three subjects: the infrastructure of gates, roads, bridges, and ferries; security arrangements including customs and guard posts, checkpoints, jails, and a watch tower; and a listing of major royal and religious places inside and outside the city. This brief introduction draws attention to some implications of these sections of the text. Gates and defence After the first sack of the city by the Burmese in 1568-9, the walls and moats were improved. In 1586, these defences held against another siege by the Burmese armies. For the next 173 years, until 1759, no army threatened Ayutthaya. The sheer number of gates betrays the city’s sense of security in this era. There are twenty-three gates listed in the section of the document translated here, plus another six in the northern wall of the palace, which also forms part of the city wall. In addition, there were over sixty “tunnel gates,” apertures big enough for people or pack animals to pass. All illustrations of the city show that the water gates were large and flamboyant. The most reliable representation is a sketch made in his notebook by Kaempfer while mapping the city in 1690 (Figure 1).
    [Show full text]
  • Ayutthaya Saraburi Ang Thong Suphan Buri Pathum Thani Nonthaburi
    Ayutthaya Saraburi Ang Thong Suphan Buri Pathum Thani Nonthaburi Muay Thai (Thai Boxing) at Borom Phuttharam Temple is located in Ayutthaya Historical Park Printed in Thailand by Promotional Material Production Division, Marketing Services Department, Tourism Authority of Thailand for free distribution. www.tourismthailand.org E/FEB 2020 The contents of this publication are subject to change without notice. riding a chariot surrounded by floral patterns. Nonthaburi Fruit Fair The base is in the shape of a junk’s hull. April-June Wat Phai Lom This is an annual fair held to celebrate the Built in the late Ayutthaya period, this temple has abundance of such local fruits; such as, durian, a magnificent chapel featuring wood flower mangosteen, mango and star fruit, beside the patterns and two small carambola-shaped dam in front of the old city hall in Amphoe chedis. The Mons called the temple “Phia To”. Mueang. Ornamental flowers are also sold during the fair. Kwan A Man This is a Mon cultural centre featuring Giving Offerings to 108 Monks Festival traditional Mon earthen pottery, whose October distinctive beauty is now part of the provincial emblem. Some island homes make pottery This decades-old merit-making festival is held items for daily use like flowerpots, mortars and along Khlong Bangkok Noi at many temples jars in which visitors can go inside and browse. including Wat Thai Charoen, Wat Bang Krai Nok, Khlong Khanom Wan is canalside homes Wat Utthayan, and Wat Bang Krai Nai, on the specialising in sweet-making and give eighth day of the waning moon in the twelfth demonstrations to tourists.
    [Show full text]
  • The Organization of Thai Society in the Early Bangkok Period, 1782-1873 the Cornell University Southeast Asia Program
    THE ORGANIZATION OF THAI SOCIETY IN THE EARLY BANGKOK PERIOD, 1782-1873 THE CORNELL UNIVERSITY SOUTHEAST ASIA PROGRAM The Southeast Asia Program was organized at Cornell University in the Department of Far Eastern Studies in 1950. It is a teaching and research program of interdisci­ plinary studies in the humanities, social sciences and some natural sciences. It deals with Southeast Asia as a region, and with the individual countries of the area: Brunei, Burma, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam. The activities of the Program are carried on both at Cor­ nell and in Southeast Asia. They include an undergraduate and graduate curriculum at Cornell which provides instruct­ ion by specialists in Southeast Asian cultural history and present-day affairs and offers intensive training in each of the major languages of the area. The Program sponsors group research projects on Thailand, on Indonesia, on the Philippines, and on the area• s relations with China. At the same time, individual staff and students of the Pro­ gram have done field research in every Southeast Asian country. A 1 ist of publications relating to Southeast Asia which may b e obtained on prepaid order directly from the Program is given at the end of this volume. Information on Program staff, fellowships, requirements f o r degrees, and current course offerings will be found in the Announce­ ment o f the Department of Asian Studies, obtainable from the Director, Southeast Asia Program, Franklin Hall, Cor­ nell University, Ithaca, New York, 14850. THE ORGANIZATION OF THAI SOCIETY IN THE EARLY BANGKOK PERIOD, 1782-1873 by Akin Rabibhadana Data Paper: Number 74 Southeast Asia Program Department of Asian Studies Cornell University, Ithaca, New York July, 1969 Price: $3.
    [Show full text]
  • Section I: History If Islam in Thailand
    History and Politics of the Muslims in Thailand Thanet Aphornsuvan THAMMASAT UNIVERSITY Revised 12/2/03 History and Politics of the Muslims in Thailand/Thanet 1 Table of Contents Section 1: History of Islam in Thailand 1. Introduction 2. Characteristics of Muslims in Thai Society 3. History of Islam in Thailand 4. Patterns of Islamization Section II: The Malay-Muslims in the Formation of the Modern Thai State 1. The Malay-Muslims and the Pre-modern Thai state 2. Islam in an Era of Nation-States Section III: Politics of a Cultural Assimilation 1. Political Assimilation or Coercion? 2. The Muslim South in an era of modernization 3. Towards a more peaceful Muslim identity? Illustrations Suggestions for Further Reading Appendices Appendix I: Chronology of Thai History Appendix II: Structure of Patani under Thai rule Appendix III: The Structure of the Thai-Islam Socio-religious Bureaucracy in Thailand Appendix IV: Ratthaniyom or State Preference Policy Appendix V: The Patronage of Islam Act of 1945 History and Politics of the Muslims in Thailand/Thanet 2 Section I: History of Islam in Thailand 1: Introduction The Muslims are a significant minority group in Thailand. They are the second largest minority next to the Chinese. Unlike other groups of minorities, the Muslims had their own kingdom in the southernmost Thailand from which the living history and culture of its people still lives. The history of the Muslims in the Greater Patani Region,1 which comprises the four provinces of Satun, Yala, Pattani and Narathiwat, has been one of independence followed by subordination to Siam’s domination and annexation.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of Entertainment Culture in Thai Society
    THE EVOLUTION OF witnessed significant changes from ENTERTAINMENT sacredness to publicity, while the theme have been based so much on daily life activities CULTURE IN THAI that performing artists could really earn their SOCIETY: FROM own livings using their skills and diversify the SACREDNESS TO forms ofperformances more than in the past. POPULARITY1 The critical change in entertainment culture 2 occurred during the reign of King Rama V, ~atarawdee Puchadapirom when the general public began to be able to select and pay for its entertainment. Abstract Consumer behavior has dictated the creation of the modern musical and performing arts. Associated with the religious, The royal court and high dignitaries played animistic, and ritual aspects in an important role in assimilating European everyone's lifestyle, entertainment culture in Thai performances, resulting in culture has evolved to meet the lakom duk-damban (song and dance drama audience's changing preferences and with soft music) and piphat duk-damban different social status in each era. (orchestra with pipes). The standard practice Whether for the royal court or the of royal court entertainment was established commoners, both forms of entertain­ and handed down. ment were found complementing each other, resulting in its legacy and Introduction creation ofa new variety. Wathanatham kwam banthoeng 1s a Economic growth not only conveyed compound word combining the terms wealth to people but also produced an 'entertainment' and 'culture'. It refers to increase in entertainment entertainment customs and civilization for performances. In the present public enjoyment. Ratanakosin period, entertainment has Coined in the era of Field Marshal Pibulsongkram, the term wathanatham, 1 As part of my Ph.D.
    [Show full text]